Draper v. Charlottesville General District Court, No. 3:2018cv00022 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/16/18. (jcj)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OF CE U.. DI COUFF S FI S ST. ATROANOKE, ' VA FI LED MA 6 2 1 t 28 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI UCT COURT STI FOR TH E W ESTERN D I STRI O F VI I I CT RG N A CHA RLOTTESV I LLE D I I ON V SI JU DL CLE EY BK . W CLE CED RI EU RON D RA PER, CK Ci lAc i N o.3: CV00022 vi ton 18 Pli i: antf M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON NI Hon.Gln E.Co a e nr d Se o Unie St esDititJ ni r t d at src udge CHA RLO TTESV I LLE G EN ER AL DI STRI CO URT, CT D e e nt f nda . Pl ntf Ce ik Eur Dr pe ,pr ee ng pr K ,fl d t s a ton on Aprl2,2018, ai if drc on a r oc di o ie hi c i i nn ng t Cha lte vil Ge r Ditit Cour a t de e nt Thi m a tr i c r nty mi he ro ts le ne al src t s he f nda . s te s ure l beo et c to t pli ifsmoi f la t pr e L f mapa rs Alhought fr he our n he antf' ton or e ve o oce d q or upe i. t he c ' g an st m oto f t r as nst tf l t co tc l st tt co pl ntmus oul r t he i n, or he e o ha olow, he ur oncude ha hb m ai t t ' . ' q be ds se u d r Rue 1 49( ) o t Fe ia Ru e o Cii Pr c d r a d 2 U. C. imisd n e l 2 1 3 f he d r l ls f v l o e u e n 8 S. j 1 5 e()B) 91 ()2 ( . B ackeround Thepl i if s c pl i s a e a f l s a ntf ' om a nt t t s s olow : Cas N o. GV18000089- AND GV 1 e : 00 80000 00 wa dim is d and ta f r e 43s s se r ns er d t Fe r Coul a t ca ehad t s m edef nda ,t r cor waswihhed by o de al ' s he s t he n e nt he e d t l rq e to 2232 8 u o o s cfc c s a d t a t rc s a aa l (i) e u s n / / 01 p n ne pe ii a e n he nohe a e v ibe sc ha i ufi i p pr fofs r c whe t a e swa va i by 1 Br Roa d ns fc e t oo e vj e n he ddr s s ld 801 ook d Ri hmond Vigi a23232 beng amai ofi eno a s t c r ni i n fc t uie. Draper v. Charlottesville General District Court Doc. 3 Com pl 4, kt N o. The pl i i fçs ks f m o u a ton upon t c vi pr e ng by t . D . 2. a ntf 'ee or ngf l c i he i l oce di he de a d n ot of3500. ort no i dn a obs l ton oft c tde em i ton of m nde m mt 00 he m nal m ge ewa i he our t r nai sa e c am . 1 t t d l i ' d. ' Dockets.Justia.com St andar ofR e e d vi w Rul 1 h)3 oft Fe rlRuls ofCi lPr ed e rquie a c tt ds s a e 2( () he dea e vi oc ur e rs our o imis n a to tift ec u td tr n s a a y tme ta i lc ss be tmatrj rs ito ' Fe R. cin t q h o r eemie t n i h t t a k u j c- te u idcin. d. r ' Ci P.1 ( )3 . t ol e to so s b e tmatrj idcin ma b r ie a a pon d rn v. 2 h ( ) t u sin f u j c- te urs ito y e as d t ny it u i g g te p o e dn s a d ma (r mo e p e iey mu t be rie s a s o t b t c ut' h r c e ig n y o , r r cs l, s) as d u p ne y he o l ' Brc wo dCo ta trs n . Daa e En g I .3 9F.d3 5 3 0( t Ci. 0 4 . ik o nr cos I c v. tn t g'.nc, 6 3 8 , 9 4h r 2 0 ) Ad iinal t e 2 U. C.j1 5e , ih g ven L f r p u rsp o e dn s dto l md r 8 S. y, 91 () wh c o r s q o ma a pei r c e ig , t c thas<a d y t s r n i ta flngs' Erlne Co.S. v.J he our ç ut o c ee nii l ii .' ii A. ohns n,440 F. 648,656 o 3d ( t Ci. 0 ) The c u tmu tds s a c s G ta y tme'i te c ur d tr n st a t 4h r 20 6 . o r s imis a e d n i ' f h o t ee mie h t he a c mp an d al t saeacam o whihr le ma b g a td' U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i) o lit t i o tt li n c eif y e rne . f s '28 S. j 91 ()2 ( (i. I r ve n a c mplit fr ds sa u d r j1 1 ()2 ( (i,t e c u ta p is t e sme n e iwig o an o imis l n e 9 5 e()B)i) h o r p le h n sa d r u e t r ve amoin frds sa t e Ru e1 b ()o t Fe e a Rue o Cii tn ad s d o e iw to o imis l md r l 2()6 f he d rl ls f vl Pr c d r . DeLo t v At lne 3 F.d 6 0 6 3 ( t Ci.20 3 . Alh u h a p o . o e ue ' n a . meo , 30 3 3 , 3 4h r 0 ) t o g r K pl ntf pl a ngs a e lbe a l co tue t compl nt m us c an s fcen f t l ai ifs e di r i r ly nsr d, he ai t ont i ufi i t acua al ga i Co r s a rghtt r le a le tons ç aie i o e if bove t s ultve lve ' and t ( t t a cli t r i t he pec a i e l' o E a e am o elef s ta i pa i eo isf c . Bel lCo n v Two l 5 0U. 5 4 5 5 5 0( 0 7 . h t s lusbl n t a e' lAt. r . . mby, 5 S. 4 , 5 , 7 2 0 ) ' D i c s on s us i Fe ea c urs ha e lmie j rs ito a d i o s s o l t tp we a t o ie b d rl o t v i td u idci n n i s e s ny ha o r u h rz d y p Cons iuton a s a ut ' K okkone v. Gua di n Li e l Co. of A m . 511 U . 375, 377 tt i nd t t e. ' n r a f ns. , S. ( 994 . Ge r ly,f rldititc t aea ho iedt he rca e aii outoffderllw 1 ) ne al edea src ours r ut rz o a s s rsng e a a o i vi di re pa tesa a s cfe nmot i co r ry. 28 U. C.jj1 ,1 r nvol ng ves ri nd pe iid mt n ntoves S. 331 332. U nde t w e lpl de c pl i r l ,(a s ta i e unde f de al1 w o y w he t pl i i s r he l- ea d om a nt u e : ui r s s r e r a nl n he a ntY sae e o hi own c us ofa ton s t tm nt f s a e c i howst ti i ba e upon f de a lw . Vade v. s ove ha t s s d e rl a ' ' n Dic r 2 Ba k 5 6U. 4 , 0( 09 ( l r to a ditr l u tto mak o te ) n . 5 S. 9 6 20 ) at ains n nena q o ain r s mitd . e Ha ng r viwe t c pli ,t c ti c ta ne t c l t t i mus be vi e e d he om a nt he our s onsr i d o oncude ha t t ds se f rlc o s b e tmatrj idcin.Drpe h sn tatmp e t iv k dv riy imis d o a k f u j c te urs ito a r a o te td o n o e ie st j rs ito a d heha fie t ie tf a y vilto o fd r l1w wh c mih s p r t u idci n n s ald o d niy n oain f e e a a ih g t u po t he e rieo fd r l u sinju s ito u d rj 1 31 xecs f e e a q e to ti dcin n e 3 . M or eover unde t Rooke - l a docti , f r l ditit co t do not ha r he rFedm n rne* ede a src urs ve , s be tmatrj rs ito t he rS a e b o g tb saec u tl sr c mp anig o ij re u j c te u idcih o a t s s r u h y tt-o r o es o li n f nu is c c us dby saec u t u g nsrn e e b f r t ed src c u tp o e dng c mme e a a e tt- o r j d me t e d r d eo e h itit o r r c e i s o nc d nd ivtn dsrc c u tr ve a d rj cin o t s j g ns' Ex o M o i Co p.v S u i n iig itit o r e iw n ee to f ho e ud me t. x n b l r . a d ' Ba i I d s Co p.5 4U. 28 , 4 ( 0 ) Ac o dngy t t ee tn p an ifse rv e sc n u . r , 4 S. 0 28 20 5 . c r i l, o h x e t litf e ks e iw o , rrle fo d cso sb t Ch ro ts il Ge rlDititCo r, sc mp an i s b e t f o eif r m, e ii n y he alte v l nea src u thi o lit s u j c e t d s sa u d rRue 1 ()3 . Th a p o it a e ue f rc n etng r mo a fo sae o imisl n e l 2h () e p r prae v n o o tsi e v l r m tt c tt f de a c ti t tm ey tl a moton t r m a i t r m ove ca e Se 28 U . C. our o e r l our s o i l ie i o e nd n he e d s. e S. j1 4 () 4 7c. PlitY s c mplit i as s be tt d s sa u e j1 1 ()2 ( (i. Lie al an i o an s lo u jc o imis l nd r 9 5e ()B)i ) b rl y c tung t c m pl nt tf is t alege s fc e f c s t sat a pl usbl c am f r r le onsr i he o ai ,i al o l uf i nt a t o t e a i e l i o e if a i tt de e nt The c gans he f nda . ompl i does noti ntf any c us of aci n unde whi h t ant dé iy a e to r c he pli ifs ksr le ,a nori onedi c m i e fo t c a ntf ee e if nd s s e bl r m he ompl i . A cc di y,t c pl i ant or ngl he om a nt f ist sat a c ai f r i f a l o t e l m or ele . C oncl on usi Fort r a o sae t co tgrnt t plitf smoi f la t pr ee L he e s ns ttd,he ur a s he anif ton or e ve o oc d q @TheRooke - dm a docti i na e a rt Su emeCou tca es Rooke v. dei Tr tCo.263 U. 41 rFel n rne s m d Re wo pr r s , r Fi lw us , S. 3 (9 3, n Ditit fCou aCo r o Ap asv. lma , 60U. 4 2(98 ) 1 2 )a d src o lmbi ut f pel Fed n 4 S. 6 1 3 . fr p u rs a d d s se t e c mpan pzs a t t Rul 1 h ( ) a d 2 U. C. oma a pei n imis s h o lit l u n o r e 2()3 n 8 S. j 1 5 e()B) Th Clr i drce t s n c ri e c p e o ti me rn u o iin a d 91 ()2 ( . e ek s ie td o e d e tid o is f h s mo a d m pn o n f t ac ompa i or rt t pl ntf. he c nyng de o he ai if y y 8 DATED: s G X da ofM a 201 Thi . Se orUnie St t sDititJ ni t d a e src udge 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
