Thornhill v. Aylor et al, No. 3:2015cv00024 - Document 65 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/20/2016. (mab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STY CT OF VI NI RGI A CHARLOTTESVI LLE DI SI VI ON J Q 02 1 Ay - 95 Juu BY SHERRY LYN N THORNHI LL, f rhe s fa asAdmi sr t roft o r el nd nita o he Esae ofhe s Sha Chrso rBeny, tt r on, wn it phe de a e S vi ly a o be l of ce s d, ndi dua l nd n haf CLERK' OF CEU.S.DI COURT S FI SX ATFO.IiKS, L A .) VA I : FI LED a : j oinu rcu RK i us . . PUW CLERK Ci lAc i No. 15- 00024 vi ton 3: CV- a 1ot r sm ia l st t d, l he s i lry iua e Pli if a ntf, M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By:Ho Gl n E.Cozr d n. e la Chi fU nie S a e D it i tJ e t d t t s s rc udge F. GLENN AYLOR,e al, t . D e e nt . f nda s Pl ntf She y Lyhn Thor l,on be fofhe s l a a a i sr t oft e t t of ai if n' nhil hal r ef nd s dm nita or he sae h rs n Sh wn Ch it p e Ber ,ie t sa to pzs n t 42U. C. 1 3a Va Co e e o, a rso h r ry fld hi cin l ua t o r S. j 98 nd . d Ann j8015 ,. sc.a an theCe sa Vign aRç ina J i Auh r' (h d t rt ), . . - 0 # el g is t nr l r ii g o l al to iy t e t ho i 1 , t Au y' Supe i t nda F.Glz Ayl r a s ve alofi r a n s a Ce r lVigi a Re onalJ i rn e nt em o , nd e r fce s nd ures t nta r ni gi al (CVRJ'a trBer de whl i c t d Thec s i p ee t beo et c u t n t I ' fe ry id ie n uso y. ) a e s r s nl f r he o r o y de e nt 'm o i t srkepori oft n e f nda s ton o ti tons he m nded c m pl i . t f l wi r a o , he o ant For he olo ng e s ns t c twilde t m oton. our l ny he i B ackaround On Aug t7, 4,Bery wa a r se by de i fom t Or nge Cot y She ifs us 201 r s retd putes r he a mt rf' De rm e on outt ndi wa r nt . t tm eofhi a r t Be r ha bee a c e t pa t nt sa ng ra s At he i s res, ry d n ddi t d o Thornhill v. Aylor et al Doc. 65 aco f ro rt nt ye r a he oi f a tt n ye r ,a hei or e t de i st the l hol o ve we y a s nd r n or bou e a s nd nf m d he pute ha wo l e p re es v r wih rwa i alBer sgrfindas t l t ed p te t t n' u d x einc e ee t d a l nj i. ry' ilre lo o d h e u is ha Be y wo l e p re ewi d a l y tmsi j i, n t t eh dt b p a e i itnsv c z t e ud x einc t r wa s mpo n ala d ha h a o e lc d n ne ie ae h h ls tmeh we tt j i.W hl i c t d a CVRJ Ber be a t e p re c wih rwa a t i e n o al ie n uso y t , ry g n o x ein e t d a l Dockets.Justia.com , s ympt .M edialsa fa CVRJpr vi d Be r wih m e c ton a Ga or de t k hi vial, oms c tf t o de ry t di a i nd t a , oo s t s a monio e hi c ton. fc r a CVRJas a sse Be y on s ver loc aso ,nn ey nd t r d s ondii Ofie s t lo s it d n' e a c i ns m l wh nhefl o to hsb n , o l n tsa di t es o r a ds i dhi j mps t Ov rte e el u f i u k c u d o tn n h h we, n ol s u ui e h e . c zs oft da , ry' he lh de e i a e a hepa s a y on Aug t9,201 olr e wo ys Be r s at t ror t d, nd s ed wa us 4. lt n n he mende c pls , r hilal ge t tt Au hort Ayl ,a s ve a d om a nt Tho n l le s ha he t iy, or nd e r l ofi e sa ntr e a CVRJwe edelbe a ey i fe e t Be r ss i media ne ds fc r nd ls s t r i r t l ndif r nt o ry' efous cl e , s e i al ac ho a dh r i wi d a l,nvo aino j 1 8 a dVign aswr n f l ah p csc ly lo l n e on t rwas i ilto f 9 3 n r ii' o g u de t h saut .l s ve a par gr phsi t n e d compl nt Tho n l a s rst tde e n s tt e n e r l a a n he m nde ai , r hil s e t ha f nda t ço tr d' n ç le 'Be y Am. mp . ! 1 7 1 . mial , o n il lo sae ta ç al ç rt e 'a d ç ld' n'. Co l! , - 6 Si lry Th r hl as tts h t t i t t ki aj sn e c s o l no b ad ahsn e c , 1 a !3 a t a t eCVRJsafp ro me n n o e tn e h u d t e e t e tn e' d. t , nd h t h ' tf ef r d o e f t m e c pr ed esa r quiedby CVRJ Spolc e orpe f medt m i awa ç s g t he dial oc ur s e r ' ii s ror he n y ç i ned o de ifit xml pana s fe igt Ber , J.a !4 . c r i t tec mp an ,h n lc ma i l i nd u f rn o ry' ., t ( 0 Ac o dng o h o lit te m '1 . J c i st tco r a s ounte ha ntol nd uppo tCVRJt us pr vi a qua er s c t al w f pr r r t t o de de t e our es o lo or ope m me ia c r a CVRJ'I . t 2 F n ly t ec mpan d srb stec mml iainsb t e d c l ae t . d a ! . i al ,h o lit e ci e h o l c to ewe n ' n Ber , i grfin , n t ed p te p irt hi ta se t CVRJ S ei . !21 2 . f n a t ry h s ilre d a d h e u is ro o s rn fr o . e d ! - 4 De e d n s movet srket s pori fom t a e o ti he e tons ' he m ndedco pl i . pa tesha wavedor l r m ant The ri ve i a a gum e ont m o i n.Them o i ha be n f ly bref d a i dpef diposton. r nt he to ton s e u l i e nd s or s ii Di scuss on i 1 . Pr e alBar t M oton t St i oc dur o i o r ke As a i ta m a t r t c tm us fr tde e m i whe he def nda s m oto t s rke i n nii l te , he our t i s t r ne t r e nt ' i n o ti s pr c d r l b re . l 1 ( )o t Fe ea Rue o Cii Pr c dzepr vd st tG p ry o e u al ar d Rue 2 g f he d r l ls f v l o e l o ie ha & at y r a t tm a sa m oto unde t sr l m us notm a a t rm o i unde t sl e r i i a ha ke in r hi u e t ke no he ton r hi ' a s ng ul d fn eo o j cint a wa a alb et t p ryb to te o ise rirmoin. Fe . ee s r b e to h t s v ia l o he a t u mitd m t a le to ' d R. ' Ci P.1 ()2 . eeaee e to t ti nz , o ve, o d fns sba e o fil et sae v. 2 g () Th r r xc p ins o h s l h we r f r ee e s d n alr o tt e z acam f r ihrlç c nb g a td fiu et j i a id s e sbl p ry fi et saea li o wh c eif a e rn e , alr o on n n ip n i e a t, al o tt ur lg l e e s t acam, n lc ö s be t te j s ito Fe . Ci P.1 ( ()() e a d fn e o li a d a k f u jc matr mi d cin. d R. v 2h)2 -3 . Tho n il r zst a d fn a t' to t srk i b n'dp ts n t Rul 1 ( )2 b c u e r h lagt h t ee d n s moin o tie s a e t ua to e 2 g( ) e a s e r d fnd nsddn t as t s o j cin i t i e rirRue1 b ()moinst ds s.n ee a t i o r ie he e be to s n her ale l 2()6 to o imis I rs o s , ee d nsc n e dt a t e p e e v dt ero j cinsi t ermoinst ds s a d e p n e d fn a t o tn h t h y r sr e h i be to n h i to o imis n , i t eatmaie t t e1 ( )2 d e n ta pyt moin t srkep rua t oRue1 9 n h le tv ,ha Rul 2 g ( ) o s o p l o to s o ti u s n t l 24 be us t co thasa hort t srkepl a ngson iso ca e he ur ut iy o ti e di t wn. Alhough t r i ltl c ea on t sis t c t i m or pe s svet t he e s ite as lw hi s ue,he our fnds e r ua i he a t rte t a h vea p idRu e1 ( )2 t moin t srkeb s do tefmd rt sr l' uho i s h t a p le l 2 g ( ) o to s o ti a e n h t e hi ue' i t lng g i Ru e1 ( )2 a dt en ro e c pt nst t enze Se . ..Cha p lev. u tu t a ua e n l 2 g ( ) n h ar w x e i o h l. e eg, p el S nr s o M o t l c, .1 -v 0 7 r. n .No 4 c - 3 45YGR, 1 U. DitLEXI 1 3 0 , t* - ( D. lDe . , s 20 5 S. s. S 6 1 7 a 56 N. Ca. c 4 2 5 ; ie S ae e rlPo lv. Itr o tn n a Unv.l .7 6F. u p. 1 7 01 ) Untd tts x e. wel Am.n ec nie tl i .nc, 5 S p 2d 3 4, 1 0 81( D. . 01 ) Ci v. el on He l c r Newo k e n .No. 5 c - 27J 38 - N. Ga 2 0 ; ma W lp it at ae t r s I c, 0 -v 41 -PG, h l 2 0 W L 1 6 2 2 a * ( . 11Apr 6 2 0 ) 2J me W m. o r e a.M o r ' Fe e a 07 0 8 5 , t 3 SD. 1. . , 0 7 ; a s M o e t l, o e s d r l Prciej 1 21( de . 0 7 (& l 1 ( )sc ns ld to rq ie n a pl sn to yt Rue a tc 2. 3 d 2 0 ) ( e 2 g ' o o iain e u rme t p i o nl o l Ru e 1 b d f n e , u as t a .é to t srk u e Rue 1 9.) M oe v r t c u t md 2() ee s s b t lo o .moi n o tie nd r l 24 ' . r o e,he o r f s ' t a d f n a t' be to st teln u g i ten nd dc mp an weea ia l t te h t e e d ns o j ci n o h a g a e n h me e o lit r valbe o h m whe t y fl t i motonst dimis. co tnot t tt c e i uspo tonsoft n he ied her i o s s The ur es ha he ont nto ri he a e m nded co pl ntw e e a s i ude i Tho n l' i ta co pl nt Fi l t co ti no m ai r l o ncl d n r hil s nii l m ai . naly, he ur s t p ru d db d fn a t'ag me tta t e p ee v dtero j ci n b smpysaigta t e s a e y ee d n s r u n h t h y r sr e h i be to s y i l ttn h the c mplit( ansago sydso tdpcu eo wha h pp n dg 'CVRJ SM e i S p o o an t it r s l itre it r f t a e e .' p l ' m.n u p. f M ot t Dim is Doc tNo. a 2. no poi i t i m o i n di CVRJs c fc l t r t . o s s , ke 45 t At nt n l s to d l pe ii aly a ge t s pori oft n he e tons he mende co ant I t ad, he smpl sa e t rdia e me wih d mpli . nse t y i y t t d hei s gr e nt t Thom hilsalegai ns The e or t c t dst tde e ntsm otont srkei i oper l' l to . r f e,he our hol ha f nda ' i o ti s mpr he e , he o r ma ti o to f la ig n t wn md r t e Rue1 g ( )1N evert l ss t c u t ysrkep rinso ap e dn o iso t e md r l 2()2 . Rue1 9. e Fe R. v P.1 ( (ttn t thec u t ya tG n i o '. s c ,he l 2( S e d. Ci. 29 saig ha t o r ma c l t wn' As u h t o s ) c twilc i rwhe he t srket epo tonsoft n nded c our l onsde t r o ti hes ri he me ompli t an. I. I I m at ri ,I pe t ne ,or Sca m e al m r i nt ndal M at e s i t A m e d C o pl nt ous t r n he nde m ai Rul 1 ( alwst .o r t srk fo ape dngG n rd n a ti tra, e 2 9 lo hec u to tie r m la i c y e u d n,mmaeil a i rie t o s a d l u matr'Fe R. v. 1 ( I f r to i tmmaeil f rt mpet n , r c n ao s te . d. Ci P. 2 9. n o main s s tra' o he n ' i ' p r s so Ru e1 ( i i h s( oe s nil ri o tn rlto hpt tecam f rr l fo upo e f l 2 9 f t a s se ta o mp ra t eains i o h li o ei r n e t ed f n e b igpe d dl '5 Ch re Aln W rg t& Arh rR. le, d r l r cie& h ee s s en la e .' C als a ih q tu Milr Fe ea P a tc P o e u ej1 2( de 20 4 ; mal, 1 W L 71 2 7 , t* . (mp rie t' te d e r c d r 38 3 d. 0 ) S ls 20 5 6 9 0 a 3 An d e t n 'matr o s i n nott ran, (s notnec sar t t is i q si 'Smals 2015' L 71 i ti and ij pe e s y,o he sues n ueton. ' l, W 62970,a *3 t ( u tn Wrg t M ilr s p a . nal i f n to i E c n ao s'fi (mp o ryc ssa q oig i h & l , u r) Fi l n o nain s G a d lu 'i tt r pel a t e y, s i de oga o y lg on s e r t r i ht om one, os t pi ly on apa t t t aci n.' rgh & M ilr s a. t m t y cal ry o he to 'W i t le , upr I i n t no ht t h alg to t fe d t es n iii e o t eo j cigp ryi t c alng d s o e ug ha t e le ain t f n s h e sblt s f h b e tn a t f he h le e o i a lga i de c i a t o e nt t ta er lva tt t a ton. 1 le tons s rbe c s r ve s ha r ee n o he c i ' d. ' Th c u t ho du eRu e1 4 s a igy a mo in t srkeaeg n r l v e dwi e o r s ul s l 2 9 p rn l, s to s o ti r e eal iwe t y h d sa r W at M g . l ig .n . Gimo e 25 F.d31 , 4 ( t Ci. 0 ) Ass c , ifvo . se mtHo dn s lc v. l r , 2 3 6 3 7 4h r 2 01. u h a m o i t srkes d onl be g a t d whe t a lga i ha ç pos i er lton orl i a ton o ti houl y r ne n he le tons ve ç no sbl ea i og c l c r cint tes be t atro tec nr v ryal ma c us s mef r o sg t n ome to o h u j c ' te f h o to e s td y a e o o m f ini t m ka p eu iet o eo mo eo tepat st t ea to 'Balvv Fara Ct , .11 - v 0 , rj dc o n r r f h ri o h cin. ie . if x y.No :0 c -1 31 e ' 1 Dee a t as ag eta te weea t i g o fi byn tsaigt i o jcin e rir a te fnd ns lo ru h th y r ci n o d at o ttn her beto s al , s h y ng h e weewatn frted cso i Smal v Che o Poie No 41 - 0 01 , 01 WL 71 2 7 ( D. . v. r i g o h e iin n ls . if f lc , . :5CV-0 7 2 5 i 6 9 0 W. Va No 1 , 01 ) Th c m'f ss hag n u pes sv a d fn a t ct n a t rt ta rc g ie ag o fi 3 2 5. e o t md uc rume t n ruaie s ee d ns i o uhoiy h t e o nz s o d at e h e c pint 'ul l ()2 . x e to oR e 2g () 4 2 0W L 5 0 8 4 * ( D. . c 21 2 0 ( u tn W rg t& M i e, u r) s eas 01 3 0 7 , 4 E. Va De . , 01 ) q o ig ih l r s p a ; e lo l Au u tsv Bd o Pu I t cino Es n i Ct .Fl.3 6F.d 8 2 8 8(t Ci. 9 2 g su . . f b.nsnlto f c mb a y. a, 0 2 6 , 6 5h r 1 6 ) ( E moint srk ji ad atcr me yt b r s re t o l wh nr q ie frt ep r o e çA to o tie s rsi e d o e e o td o ny e e urd o h u p s s ç o j sie(n )s o l b g a tdo l wh nt pe dn t besrc e h sn p s il r lto f u tc a d h ud e rn e ny e he la ig o tik n a o o sbe eain t tec nr v ry' . rhemo e G a ds ue q sino fc c n o b d cde o moi nt o h o to es .) Fu t r r,$ ) ip td ueto f a t n n t e e i d n to o ' ( srke. I I s h cr um smwes t c ts d çde e aci o t m o i n and l vet ti ' d. n uc ic t ' , he our houl ç f r ton n he to ea he s fce y oft alegai f rde e mi ton ont m e is'1 Thus t m ova und Rul ufi inc he l tons o t r nai he rt . d. ' , he nt er e 1 ( f c saS ie beb r e 'Clr v. in 1 2F. D. 6 7 ( D. . .1 9 )Th 2 9 a e G z a l u d n. ak M lm, 5 R. 6 , 0 S. W Va 9 3 . e s ' dsa o e c a a tro Rue 1 ( ho v r i s me t ea e i tec n e t fs a d lu ifv rd h r ce f l 2 9, we e ,s o wha r lx d n h o tx o c n ao s ma tr a m aera so t st ofe wilbesrc n fo t pladi i or rt S get te , nd t il f hi ype tn l tike r m he e ngs n de o s pur he c u t slsa dprtc t p ro wh i t s b e to t ealg to s'W rg t& M ilr s p a o r' e n oe t he es n o s he u j c f h le ai n . ih s ' le, u r . I t sc e, e nt frta guet tt sa e nt t tt y de i r t l G o t e ' n hi as def nda s is r ha he t t me s ha he lbe ae y ç rur d' t a l led'Be'y a e i ri nta s a l .Fis,a t whehert al gai nsa e nd G l ' l r mpe tne nd c ndaous rt s o ki r t he le to r i ri nt t c r sndst ts h l pgedoe pe ti t t i s i q si ,n ey mpe tne , he ou t ha uc angt s ran o he s ues n ue ton, m l n whet rde enda swe edei r t y i f e e t Be ss rousme c ne I Ese l v. he f nt r lbe ael ndif r nt o ny' e i di al ed. n t le Gambl t Unie St t sSupr m eCour sa e t t whe i aes m e c lne dsa eno me , e, he t d a e e t tt d ha, n nm t ' di a e r t t s hfi r c np o u eç h sc l o t eo aln ei gd ah. 4 9U. 9 ,1 3( 9 6 uc al e a r d c ç y ia trur r ig rn e t ' 2 S. 7 0 1 7 ) u p ' (n en l u tto mak o te ) Th rhi ag e ta d fn nst ru e Ber b d n n itr a q oain r s mitd . o n l r u s h t ee da t o tr d ry y e yig l hi m e ca ca eashe s f r fo a c hola he oi wihd a a . co e t t m di l r ufe ed r m l o nd r n t r w l She nt nds ha de e nt pr vi d m e ca c e t Be r i a w a t tw o d i lc m a m um pa n a f nda s o de di l ar o r y n y ha ul nfi t xi i nd s f r ng on Be r A lho h a s i oft t e i no ne es a y f a c a m o de i r t uf e i r y. t ug how ng orur s t c s r or l i f lbe a e i fe e e, hec ti no pe s dedt ts h l ngua ha nopos i er a i t whehe ndif r nc t our s t r ua ha uc a ge s sbl elton o t r de e f ndan swe edei r t l i fe en t Be r ss ro m e ca nee Dei r t i fe e e t r lbe a ey ndif r t o r y' e i us di l d. lbe a e ndif r nc rq ie as b e tv s wi gt a ad fnd n k e o asro srs o ham t a imae a d e ur s u j ci e ho n h t ee a t n w f e iu ik f r o n n t, n t tli o hera tonswer i ppr pra ei lghtoft trs Ce ti y,i a de e ntwer t ha ts r ci e na o i t n i ha ik. ranl f f nda eo e ge i a tvet rur ofan i t by de ng hi m e c lca e, ha sm a i wo d s tsy nga n c i o t e nma e nyi m di a r t t i ton ul aif t ssa r asa wor tc s s e ro.Alhoug t c ti no pe s dedt ts as e ro i hi tnda d s a e c na i t h he our s t rua ha uch c na i s pr s nti t sc s t c tde lne t de des h quesi o amoton t srkea t ssag e e n hi a e,he our c i s o ci uc tons n i o ti t hi t e oft ltgai n. or ove ,Thor l' c m pl i al ge t tde e an s i to a f ilr s he ii to M e r nhils o ant le s ha f nd t ' naci n nd alze c us d Be r sdeah. a e ry' t Thus t c t i t tt wor S le ' ra nst t wr u de t , he our fnds ha he d t l d'pe ti o he ongf l ah ki cai i t c l m n he ompli t whih r quie as a n , c e r s howi ofGhe de t o ape s ..c e by t ng ' t ah f r on . aus d he wr n f l c, ge t o d fu t fa ypes ng 'Va Co eAn j8015 . s c ,hec u t o g u a t ne lc r ea l o n ro .' . d n. . - 0 As u h t o r l fndst ts h lnguag i pe tne t t is sr iedi t sltgai n. i ha uc a e s ri nt o he s ue a s n hi ii to Ne ,a t whehe t alegai nsa e s nda o ,t c tfndst ts h lng gedoes xt s o t r he l to r ca l us he our i ha uc a ua no c ta i ope lg ont def nda s Thi c s i i t e ry sag ,a t pa te have t as n mpr r i ht he e nt . s a e s n he a l t es nd he ri s no e t ngage i f l dic r ast wha de e nt kne a t tmeBe r wa goi t ough d n ul s ove y o t f nda s w t he i ry s ng hr acohola he oi wihdr wal W hiet s s i al ga i i t c l nd r n t a . l he e pecic le tons n he ompli m a be ant y i l mm aor a ofe i t t de e nt , heco ti una et fndt tt alegai nsha nfa t y nd f nsve o he f nda s t ur s bl o i ha he l to ve n p si erlto o lgc l o ne to t t a to , rc us sg fc n p eu iet o o sbl eain r o ia c n ci n o he cin o a e iniia t rj dc o de e nt .2 f nda s 2 hos t d n fnda s' if rt n Thec r ditnguihe t sca e9om t ecie i dee nt bre . Fis,i Smal v.ChifofPolc ou t si s s hi s ls e ie, t sc tsr kt tr S de' 9om t c hi our tuc he e m & mur r' he ompli bec us pl ntf' cli di notr quiepr of ant a e ai ifs ams d e r oof pr emedia i o i e t ca ede t 2015W L 71 tton r ntnt o us ah. 62970,a * I t sca e delbeae i fee et asrous t 3.n. ' s , i rt ndif rnc o e i hi me c ne ma c ea i t t bet tr d a kild.Be us dei r t i fe e r uie ab ng of dial ed y aus n nmae o oru e nd le ca e lbe ae ndifr nce eq r s howi wh tad fnd n s be t eyk e wh te ted fn a t o rda al imaei p ri n t sc a ee a t u jci l n w, eh r h ee d n t % e n ing n t s et to u h v i ne dee mi ton.Alo,s h l tr na i ' s uc angua i pe t ntt Thor l' cl m ofwr ulde t whihr quie adeah ge s ri ne o nhils ai ongf ah, c e r s t c us by t wr u a t negl t orde a tofa he .Sec a ed he ongf l c, ec, f ul not r ond,i EsaeofGol m e r l G ol r v. n tt dbe x e . dbe c N i oiyn,t dititc tsr k l m t he src our tuc angua 9om t c pli ,i l ngS ur r'ti e i kilng,'a ge he om ant ncudi i de y 'ntntonal li ' nd m ' iorur 'bec us s h al tonsha nof cualba i andwe enotpe i ntt whehe t defndmtwas s t ey a e uc legai t ' d at ss r rt ne o t r he e t n gie tNo 1 - 0 20 4WL 6 0 01 , t# 11 ( D. . c 8 2 4 .nt sc s, o n l' c mplit e lg n. . 498 , 1 9 8 3 a 1 -2 E. Pa De . ' 01) I hi ae Th rhi s o an , l doe no c ai ane i e cam. nse d,Tho nhilscai ofdelbert i feenc r quiesas ng be s t ont n glgenc li I t a r l' l m i ae ndif r e e r howi yond meeneglge ,a he cli ofwr ulde hma bes ts dby s ng awr ula t s h a t kilng of r i nce nd r am ongf at y aife howi ongf c, uc s he li a he . not r 6 Fi ly,de e nt a gu t tt co aitc anss ve alir lva tal s ns tona na l f nda s r e ha he mpl n ont i e r r ee n ld e a i l f c s Fis,de e nt a guet tt c ts d srkepa a a 2 oft c a t . r t f nda s r ha he our houl ti r gr ph he ompl i be a e ant c us t CVRJco i a e no na e a de e nt ,a be us t pa a a c ssade ogaor he untes r t m d s f nda s nd ca e he r gr ph a t r t y lghton t c i s Theco tc l st tde e nt ha nota qua ey s i he ounte . ur oncude ha f nda s ve de t l hown t ts h ha uc l ngua hasno pos i er lton orl i a c a ge sbl ea i og c l onne ton t t alegai nsi t i t ntaci n or c i o he l to n he nsa to c u e sg iia t eudc t o eo mo eo t ep rist t ea to I f c, u hlng a e a s s in fc n prj ie o n r r f h a t o h cin.n a t s c a u g e r f r t e ii st ta enotpa test t ltg tun, de enda sco e i t rmoton. e e s o ntte ha r ri o he ii a i as f nt nc de n hei i M or ove ,hec e r t ompli al gest tt Aut rt de e bascme c c r t i a e i or r ant le ha he ho iy ni d i di al a e o nm t s n de t c coss The e or ,whehe t CVRJwasade t l f ndedand orhad s t intr s c o ut t . r f e t r he qua ey u / ufk e e our es hasal c c ogial onne tont s h c am s Se ond, e nt a guet tt c ts d srkeas ci o uc l i . c def nda s r ha he our houl ti ir e ntm a t r t tr l t t Be r s c m t i t o pr o t hi i r e a i n a CV RJ The r el va te s ha e a e o r y' om m ca i ns i r o s nca c r t o t . co tdia e . a edelbe aei fe e er uie as ur s gr es Bec us i r t ndif r nc eq r s howi ofwha de e nt ng t f nda s s b e t l k e tesae n sma eb Ber a li grfin t t d p te a tetmeo u j ci y n w,h ttme t d y ry nd l ilre d o he e u is t h i f ve s t i a r ssa t sa e e smadeby t de te t CVRJa t tm eofBe r sta f rt her r e t nd he tt m nt he pu i s o t he i ry' r nse o CVRJa er e ntt t sq si r elva o hi ue ton. Ove al,hec t i t tdef nda sha no m e t i he btr n ofs r l t our fnds ha e nt ve t t her avy lde howi t t ng ha t s a lga i a ei ae i l i pe tne , s ndaous The e or t co tfndsno he e le tons r mm t ra ,m ri nt or ca l . r f e,he ur i pe s sveba i u whih t srkes h lng gefom t n e d c rua i ss pon c o ti uc a ua r he m nde ompl i a t ssa i ant t hi t ge n t ltgai n. Ac r ngl , t moton t srkewilbe de e he ii to 3 co di y he i o ti l ni d. 3 The c t es how e r t tt pa te a e9eet m a sm ia agum e spm s ntt t Fede a Rul our not , ve , ha he ris r o ke i lr r nt ua o he r l es ofEvi nc i t rpr kilmotons I i no a o it f t c utt decdet eis on amoto t srke. de e n hei e- a i . t s t ppr prae or he ot' o i hes sues in o ti S eSi v. e r. .1 -51 , 01 WL 5 1 3 5 a * ( D. . .1 , 5 (( ot e tn ta e t Trc e No 52 5 2 5 pe 0 2 7 , t 6 E. La Aug 9 201 ) fTj he xe th t d Pl ntf' cai ar f s orS sp'asase td byDefnda s t y wilhavet ber s vedatasa i t ai ifs l ms e ale, gos i s re e nt, he l o e ol tge n he poce n wh nteas sme to dsue q eto so fc i a p o rae n ti amoint sr .l r edig e h se s n f ip td u sin f a ts p rp it- o n to o tQe' . ' Co l in nc us o Fo t f eg ngr a o , heco twildeny de e n s m otont srke The Clr i r he or oi e s ns t ur l f nda t ' i o ti . ek s die t t s nd c rii c esoft sm e o a r ced o e e tfed opi hi m r ndmn opi on a t a co pa ng o de t al ni nd he c m nyi r r o l co ms lofr c d. t e e or DATED:Thi ;J da o J nua y, 2016. s y fa r ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
