Goepper v. Colvin, No. 3:2014cv00020 - Document 15 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/19/2014. (ssm)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Goepper v. Colvin Doc. 15 L..cx,. ' '.. ,' 1 . .( .-) . Cti t uu, 4 w - --. : .( . 2 r C . )x ? . . . p. .) ) z iM'j......a Yr , k z x. >. : : 4 - & k. v . C 'f- ' .I xr' 1 : jOy jj L j jf . ' )j g I TH E UN I N TED STA TES DI STRI CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRJ OF V I GI A CT R NI CHA RLO TTESV I LLE D I I O N V SI JJ tI BK : t . ) . ' DL , L K EY E DEPU' CL K W DI ANNA ROBERTS GOEPPER, Ci lAc i No. 3:4CV00020 vi ton 1 Pl ntf , ai i f M EM OR ANR UM OPI ON M CAR OLY N W . LV I ,A c i CO N tng Comm isone ofSocalSe urt si r i c iy, By: Hon. e E. Gln Conr ad Chi U nie St t D i ti tJ ef t d a es s r c udge De e nt f nda . Pl ntf ha fl d t sa ton c le ng t tna decson oft Com mi so rofSoc a ai if s ie hi c i hal ngi he i l ii he s i ne il Sec iy de ng pli ifsc am f ape i ofdia lt a dia lt i ur ncebe ksunde urt nyi antf l i or rod s biiy nd s biiy ns a net r t SocalSe urt Ac,a a nde 42 U. C.jj41 i a 423. J iditon oft sc ti he i c iy t s me d, S. 6() nd urs ci hi our s pt s tt j205()oft Ac, U. C.j405g) Asrte tdbyt me a andar nt l uan o r g he t42 S. ( . el ce he mornda gume s itd by t pa tes t is now be or t cour ar whehert Comm isoners fnal ubm te he ri , he s ues f e he t e t he si ' i de son i s cii s uppore b s t tale de e,orwhe he t r i ' td y ubsan i vi nc t r he e s ' good c us 'ast ne s ia e a e' o ce stt rma ngt c et t Commisone f f t rco i rton.Se 42U. C.j405( . e ndi he as o he si r or urhe nsdeai e S. g) Thepl ntf, a RobersGoe r wa bo nonM a c ai if Dinna t ppe , s r r hzl, 976.M r . ppe at nded 1 s Goe r te c l a r e ve aba he orofs inc de e i ntr i The e fe ,s wor d asanur e olege nd ec i d c l ce e gr e n lsng. r a tr he ke s e a or She l s w or d on a r ara s t i ba i i Se e be of201 On M a ch 11 duc t . a t ke egul nd us a ned s s n pt m r 0. r , 2011 M r . ppe fl d a a ia i f ape i ofdia lt a dia lt i tr ebe is , s Goe r ie n pplc ton or rod s biiy nd s biiy nszanc neft . She a l ge t ts bec m edi a e f a 1f m sofs bs a i lga nf le pl e on Se em be le d ha he a s bl d or 1 or u t nta i ' m oym nt u pt r 1 201 due t Gbr ya gi c o cf tgue s om e de e s on; a t pia i ,orhosa i 7, 0, o om l a; k ni a i yndr ' pr s i he r pal t tons t t tc , ' hypot i w ea s ' em or l s pos -r um a i sr sdi or r i rt bl bowels om e; nd ens on; kne s m , y os ; tt a tc tes s de ; r ia e yndr a Dockets.Justia.com i omni Pl i ifnow mai ai t ts hasr m aned dia e t t pr en tme.The r c d ns a. antf nt ns ha he e i s bl d o he es t i e or r al ha M r . pper e t i ur d sausr quie e soft Ac a alr e nttm e c r d eve st t s Goe m t he ns e t t e r m nt he t t 1 elva i s ove e byt fnalde sonoft Commisone .Se g nerly42U. C.jj41 i a 423() he i cii he si r e e al S. 6() nd a . M r . ppe ' a ia i wasde e upo i ta c i r ton a r onsde a i She s Goe rs pplc ton ni d n nii l onsde a i nd ec i r ton. t r uetda rcevedad novohe rnga rvi beor a Admi srtveLaw J hen eq se nd e i ai nd e ew f e n nitai udge.l n an opi o da e Fe u r 28,201 t La J e a s dee m i d t tpl i ifi notdiabl ni n t d br a y 3, he w udg lo tr ne ha antf s s ed. TheLa J ef m dt tM r . w udg ol ha s Goeppe s f r fom fbr r ufe s r i omyal a; hr cpai s ome, hr c gi c oni n yndr c oni f tgue'c r a a r hm i irtbl bowe s om e'orhosai hypot nson'mood dior ; a i , a dic rhyt a; ria e l yndr , t t tc e i , s der de es i a a eydior r Be a eoft s pr e st La l pr son; nd nxit s de . c us he e obl m ,he w udger l dt t r . ppe u e ha M s Goe r i diabld f he pa tr e twor a tviy. Howe r t Law J ehe d t tpl i ifr t i s s e or r s elvan k ci t ve , he udg l ha antf e ans s fc e r sdua f tona c pact f r lghtwor The La J e as e s d M r .Goe rs ufii nt e i l unc i l a iy o i k. w udg s s e s ppe ' r i lf tonalc pa iy a f l : esdua unc i a ct s olows Af e ca e ul c i r ton of t e i e r cor t t de s gned fnds t t t t r r f ons de a i he ntr e d, he m r i i ha he cama thast r i l u tonal a ciyt pef m lgh k(oot eomit l li n he esdua f nci c pa t o ror i twor f not ted a d fn di 2 C. R. 0 1 6 (9 e c p t a t ecama tc no c so al ci s ei e n 0 F. 4 4.5 7 1 x e t h th li n a c a in ly l mb ldder ,r s s fol ,sais a r mps oc aso ly soo knee ,c ouch,a a s ope , ca f ds t r , nd a ; c i nal t p, l r nd c a ; r que l ba a e;a s da dexposlet ha r s h a unpr e t r wl fe nty l nc nd houl voi tr o zads uc s ot ced he g sand ha r i ht za dousm a hi r Des t t cai ntsm e allmia i ,s i c ne y. pie he l ma ' nt i t tons he s c pa e ofpe f mi sm pl r i r peii t ks a bl ror ng i e, outne, e ttve as . ( 23) Gi ns har iua f tona c pact,a afe c i rngpli ifsage e ai TR . ve uc esd lunci l a iy nd tr onsdei antf , duc ton, andprorwor e re , wel ast si onyfom avoc tona e i k xpe ince as l e tm r a i l xper,heLa J tt w udgef oundt t ha M r .Goe rr t i s tc e f tonalc pa iyt peror s ve als cii lghta s de a y s ppe e ans ufi i nt unc i a ct o f m e r pe fc i nd e nt r wor r ese si i sg t a numberi t na i lec k ol xitng n i nik nt n he tona onomy.Ac di y,t Law J cor ngl he udge uli ael c ude t tM r .Goe ri no dia e and t s i note il d t aperod of tm t y oncl d ha s ppe s t s bld, hat he s ntte o i dia lt ordia lt i ux nc beneis Seege rly, C. R. 404.520( .TheLa J s biiy sbiiy ns a e ft. neal 20 F. j 1 g) w udge' s he si r he a c iy opi o wa ado e a t fna de ii of t Com misone by t Socil Se urt ni n s pt d s he i l c son Adm i sr to sAppe sCot l Ha ng e used a 1aval bl a i sr tver m e e ,M r . nita i n' al mci. vi xha t l ia e dm nita i e di s s Goe pperha no a a e t t sc t s w ppe l d o hi our. W hie pli if ma be dia e f c ran f r s of e pl e ,t c u a f c ua l antf y s bld or e ti o m m oym nt he r cil a t l dee mi to i whe he pl i ifwa dia e f ralf r sofs t i gai ul tr nai n s t r antf s s bl d o l o m ubsantal nf empl ym e .See o nt 4 U.. j4 ()2 .Th r a eft ee n so p o f ihmu t ec n i ee i ma i s c 2 SC. 23d () ee r o l lme t f r o whc s b o sd r d n kng u h r a a ay i.Th s ee n saes mmaie a f l ws 1 o j ci eme ia fcsa d ciia n n l ss e e lme t r u rz d s ol :( ) be tv d c l a t n lnc l o fndn s ( )h o ii n a dc n l so s f raigp y iins ( ) u j ciee i e c o ph ia i ig ;2 te pn o s n o cu i n o te tn h sca ;3 s b e tv v d n e f ysc l ma f ttonsofi ime s asdesrbedt oughacama ' t tmony; ( t cli nts niesai mpar nt, ci hr li nt esi s and 4) he ama ' e u ain vo ain l itr ,e iu l kls a da e Vie v. n h, 3 F.d 1 5 ,1 5 - 0( t d c to , c to a h so y rsd a s il, n g . tk Fic 4 8 2 1 7 1 9 6 4h Ci.1 ) Unde oodv. biof, F. 850,851( hCi.1 . r 971 ; m Ri e f 298 2d 4t r 962) Afer a r viw of t r c d i t s ca e, t c t i una e t c l t t t t e e he e or n hi s he our s bl o oncude ha he Com misone ' fnaldec son i s ppore by s t nta e de e. As r lc ed a s i rs i ii s u td ubsa il vi nc efe t bove,t he Admi sr tve La J nita i w udge f ound t tM r .Goe rs f r fom a combi ton ofphysca a ha s ppe ufe s r nai i l nd emotona i im e swhi hr nde he dia edf he pa tr l ntwor a anur ee a or l i l mpar nt c e r r s bl or r s eeva k s s duc t . n s h cr um sa s t btr n ofgoi f wa d wih t evi nces hst t Comm isonert uc ic t nce , he lde ng or r t he de hi o he si o e t bls t a l lt ofa t r t w or r es whi h t cl i a coul be e c e t pe f m . s a ih he vaiabiiy le na e k ol , c he a m nt d xpe t d o r or Gr tv. hweke , F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) Ta orv. enber r51 F. 664, (t an Sc i r 699 2d 89, 92 4t r 983 ; yl W i ze, 2 2d 666 4h Ci. 1 7 ) S e as ,2 C. R.j 4 4 1 6 ()2) l o d r t d shag t s b zd n t r 9 5 . e lo 0 F. 0 .5 0 c( . n r e o ic r e hi t e , he r Comm isone ofe r lesont si on fom avoc tona expe t Gr nt 699F. a 1 Asnot d s i r tn e i e tm y r ai l r. a , 2d t 92. e a ve i t i t nt c e,t A d i sr tve La J bo , n he nsa as he m ni t a i w udge r le on t s i on f o a voca i na ei d e tm y r m to l e r i de e m i ng t tM r .Goe rc dbee c e t pe f m at r t lghtwor r e xpe t n t r ni ha s ppe oul xpe t d o ror le na e, i k ol s e si i t nai lec xitng n he tona onomy.Att tme oft a nita i he rngon Fe ta y 21 201 he i he dmi sr tve a i brz r , 3, t La J e pos t f l ng hy t tc que ton t t voc tona e r : he w udg ed he olowi po he ial si o he a i l xpe t I t fr thypot i lld a k t ty as umea i vi ua oft Cl ma ' a , n he is hetca ' s ha ou s n ndi d l he ai nts ge e ai a wor e re elm ie t wor a t lg e ri lve ast t duc ton nd k xpe inc i t d o k t he i ht xe tonal e l ha ' s detne i her gul tonswiho yocc sona clm bi whihwoul i l r mps i d nt e ai t nl a i l i ng c d ncude n , sar , a r , ope ,s a f ds lm ie t fe ntbaa i lmie t oc aso l t is l dde s r s c fol , i t d o r que lncng, i t d o c i na soo ng, e i c o hi a cr wlng,lm ie t smpl r i a r pe ii t pi kne lng, r uc ng nd a i i t d o i e outne nd e ttve t ks. as ( 5 - 4 .I r s n e t ev c to l x r tsiidta, iet ep an ifc ul n t ef r TR 3 5 ) n epo s ,h o aina e pe tetfe h t wh l h litf o d o p ro m pa tr l va wor s coul bee c e t pe f m ce t n lg a s de a ywor r e whi h s e e nt k, he d xpe t d o ror rai i ht nd e nt r k ol s c e s i sgniia numbe i t nai lec xit n i fc nt r n he tona onomy.( 54- . TR 55) The dif c t i t s c s i t tt hypot tc ques i putt t voc i f i uly n hi a e s ha he he i al ton o he atonalexpe tdi r d noti ude a 1t lm ia i uli ael f ncl l he i ttons tm t y ound t e s by t Admi sr tve La J o xit he nita i w udge i hi n s opi on.TheAdmi sr tveLa J ni nita i w udgeg ve'itewei 't ac ulai ps hol ca r por a ' tl l ght'o ons t tve yc ogi l e t i whihMr . ppe wass dt e incesrouse tonals oms ( 31 .I tad,he n c s Goe r ai o xpere ei moi ympt . TR ) nse t La J w udge c e t d t r por fom a no xa ni sa e a nc ps hol s who f md t t r die he e t r ne mi ng tt ge y yc ogit ot ha pl ntf expei es' ai if renc ' rt lmiai i c enrton,pesse e a pa e. ( 30) The modeae i ttons n onc tai ritnc , nd c ' TR . ' La J w udgee i tyf xplcil ound t tpli tf expe i esmode ae lm iai , hough t La J ha a n if renc r t i t tons t he w udge 4 di noti l s h wo k-ea e ma f sa i i hi a s s ntofpl ntf sr i ua f tona d ncude uc r r lt d nie t tons n s s es me ai if esd l unc i l c pact ( 23,30) Thus whiet voc tonale r pr e atmaewor r e s h a a iy. TR . , l he ai xpe t opos d le t k ols uc s ofi hepe ,ofk e m e s ng ,r t lma ke ,i or ton c e k,and or rclr t voc tonal fce l r t s e er eai r r nf ma i l r de e k, he a i e r wa not as d t co i r t de e t whi h s h wor r es r quie s t ne xpe t s ke o nsde he gr e o c uc k ol e r usai d c nc ntai n, e ulzpr uci n o put a a tnda et t k. o e r to r g a od to ut , nd te nc o as I W al rv. n ke Bowe 889F. 47, 0( hCi.1 ,heUniedSttsCo t Appeasfr n, 2d 5 4t r 989)t t ae ur of l o t Fourh Cic tc he t r ui omm e ed a f l nt s olows: The pur e ofbrngng i a voc tona e r i t a ss t ALJ i deer ni pos i i n a i l xpe t s o s it he n t mi ng whehe t e i wor a ia e i t na i t r her s k va lbl n he tonalec onomy whi t s pa tc a ch hi riulr cli a c n pe f m . I or rf a voc tona e r ' opi on t be r l va or am nt a ror n de or a i l xpe ts ni o e e nt hel ul i mus beba e upon ac i r tonofalot re de ei t r co d, nd pf ,t t sd onsde ai l he vi nc n he e r a i mus be i r pons t pr rhy hei a quesi whi f ry s touta 1of t t n es e o ope pot tc l tons ch ail e l cama tsi ar n s (iainso te ) li n ' mp ime t. ctto mi d . l I t i t ntca e t co ti smpl una e t c ude t t t as es men ofe e by t n he nsa s , he ur s i y bl o oncl ha he s s t f r d he voc tona e r, c wa ado e byt Adm i sr tveLa J a i l xpe twhi h s pt d he nita i w udge, sbas d ona1 t wor wa e 1 he kr l e lm iai nswhi h t La J eatd i t to c he w udgeuli e y f und t e s. St td dif r nty,whieM r . tmatl o o xit ae fe e l l s Go p e wa u tmaey fu d t b c pa l o u s le o fc a rti makeigj bs whih e p r s li tl o n o e a be f n ki d, fie nd eal r tn o , c l ofe r quiecos a t ncet t k a s tsa ton o da l quot s t voc tona e r w a no tn e r l e tenda o as nd a if c i f iy a ,he a i l xpe t s t as d t c i rt i e l y ofm ode a e lm ia i i c ke o ons de he nt m a r t i t tons n once r t o pe s s e nt a i n, r it nce, nd pa e. I a c n s h c r um sanc ,he c tbeleve t tt La J uc ic t es t our i s ha he w udgedi notpr ry i ntf at r t wor d ope l de iy le na e k r e whi t ke i o ac ount pl i ifs pa tc a co bi ton of physca a emotona ols ch a nt c antf riul r m na i i l nd i l 5 i mpaime s Thus t cou tfndsç r nt . , he r i t good ca e'f r mand oft sc et t Comm isone f us ' or e hi as o he s i r or f t rde l e a c i r ton. urhe veopm nt nd onsde a i l hi opi o t La J e di note ai hi decson nott i l hi fndi of n s ni n, he w udg d xpl n s ii o nc ude s i ng moder t lm ia i i c e r ton,pe sse ,a pa ei hi as e s nto pl n ifsr i ua ae i tton n onc nta i r it nce nd c n s s s me f aitf esd l f tonal e pa iy. H owe r i o he c es t Com m i s o r s e i e a gues t t s h unc i a ct ve , n t r as , he s i ne om tm s r ha uc m ode a elm ia i ae s umedt r t i t tons r ubs mdert fndi t tac am a ti c pa e ofpe f mi onl he i ng ha l i n s a bl ror ng y sm pl r i r ttve t ks. H ow e r t co t i una e t a e t s pr i e, outne, epe ii œs ve , he ur s bl o cc pt hi oposton. A ii lm iai t smpl uns led wor doesnotne es a iy i y,o t ke i o a count m ode a e i t ton o i e, kil k c s rl mpl r a nt c , rt lm ia i i c e r ton, r i t nc o pa e.Se Se on v. vi - F. i t tons n onc nt a i pe s s e e, r c e xt Col n, supp. - , 4 W L zd 201 2090647, t*3, ( . Va. a 1 201 .Asnot byt Unie Stt Cour ofAppeasf t a 4 W D. M y 9, 4) ed he td aes t l or he Tent Cic ti W idehol v. mhar,1 F. x 8 8 ( 0t Ci. ) h rui n e r t Bn t 21 App' 33, 39 1 h r 2005 : Ther a i ybr d, pe ii dnatr oft des rpto Csm pl ' nd é kild' eltvel oa uns c fe tle he c i i n ti e'a i uns le ' does no a uael i po ae t ALJ' a tonal m or s cii fndi t deq t y ncor r t he S ddii , e pe fc i ngs r ga di M r . i de hol' m e a i pa r e s Be us t A LJom it d, t e r ng s W e r t s nt l m im nt . ca e he te wihout e a ton, i nne s t t he f xpl na i mpai nt ha ound t e s,s h a m ode a e difculis o xit uc s r t fi te ma nt ni c e r ton, r it nc orpa ,t r uli h he ialque ton i ai ng onc nta i pe sse e, ce he es tng ypot tc si wa fa d. or ove ,he ei no e de et s s l we M e r t r s vi nc o ugges t tt VE he r t tmony t ha he a d esi or o he evi nc al ng he t m a a i vi lze a s s e t t t r de e lowi r o ke n ndi duai d s es m nt ha i o o aedt ALJ' s c t a to l i ngsa utM r W i r tsm e t l nc p r t he S pe ik ddii na fndi bo s. ede hol' n a i ime s ( ttonsomitd) mpar nt.ciai te . Se as M il ev. tue 2009W L763740, t*3( . Fl )(ttngt ti e lo lhous Asr , a M D. a. sai ha t modert lmiai ae i ttons i s a f nc i ng a c n ocil u toni nd once r ton,pe sse ,o pa consiut gr a e r srci t n a nta i r it nce r ce tt e e t r e ti tons ha lmiai ouns le wo k' ; va Asr e, 2W L4336205, t*9( . Fl.(notngt t i ttont kild r ' Cha nuv. tu 201 ) a M D. a) i ha tglve a cruisha f t trsrci ()VE' i r t smpl r i orrpeii t ks tse r l ic t ve ound ha e titng a s nquiy o i e,outne, e ttve as , 6 o u s ildwo kd e n ta c u t (i)f rapanifsmo eaed fce ce i c n e tain r n kle r o s o c o n s sc o li tf d rt eiin is n o c nrto , pe sse e, rpa e,'ndctngt t s ca e ) I e a noe a ritnc o c 'a ii o he e s s. nde d, s td bove,ts mst tpr e wih i ee ha oblms t conc ntai n a pa woul bee pe i lyc ii li tr sof ronnanc ofr i a r pe ii e r to nd ce d s c al rtca n e m pe f e outne nd e ttve t ks Stt d s i ty, t c t c l es t t t hy t tc q si n pos d by t as . a e uccncl he our oncud ha he pohe ial ue to e he Ad i sr tveLa J e, xcl ngpli ifsmode at lm ia i i c m nita i w udg e udi antf r e i ttons n once r to pe sse e ntai n, r it nc , orpac , snotc itntwiht e de eof e or Thecou t lr ma hi c ef a opra e ei onsse t he vi nc r c d. r wil e ndt s as or ppr it pr ee ngs oc di . Ona a t t sc qpl i ifma n a nst t hefna de sonoft Co mi so rs d ppe l o hi our antf i t i ha t i l cii he m s i ne houl ber ve s bas dons ve a de i inci i heAdmi sr tveLa l e r ed, e e r l fce es nt nita i w udgeso ni n.W iho goi ' pi o t ut ng i o a g ea de ai,t c tnot t tM r .Goe ri c r c i as e tng t tt La J nt ny r t t l he our es ha s ppe s or e t n s ri ha he w udge a or d ltl weghtt t fndi a opi onsofs r lte tng physc a .Asnotd a cc de ite i o he i ngs nd ni eve a r a i ii ns e bove , t Law J e a s a cor d ltl wei t t fndi ofa c ulai ps he udg lo c de ite ght o he i ngs ons t tve ychol s who s ogit aw M r. s Goeppe a t be s oft sa edia lt age y.Asas r t a g e , a n ifur est t r t he he t he t t s biiy nc epa a e r um ntpli tf g ha t La J he w udgef ie t pr ry c e the t tmony r ga di t s ve iy a f tona i pa a ld o ope l r di r esi e r ng he e rt nd unc i l m d ofher s pt s Howe r t co tbeive t tt Admi sr tve La J ym om . ve , he ur le s ha he nita i w udge r s bl ea ona y de e m i d t tma oft as e s e sa r porsfo t teai m e ca s c we ebas d t r ne ha ny he s s m nt nd e t r m he r tng di l our es r e o p an if s b e tv s mp o t lg ,a wee no rltd t s e i c ci c lfn n s n litf s u j cie y tmaoo y nd r t eae o p ct l a idig . i ni Li wie t c ta e t tm uc ofpl ntf st si ke s , he our gr es ha h ai if e tmony s ugge t s ss ympt soutofpr to om opori n t t eo j ciefn i g icu e i t eme ia r c r .I ti c n e tt ec u t eiv st a t o h b e tv id n s n ld d n h d c l e o d n h s o tx ,h o r b le e h the La J epr pe l c i r i f om t s a e a nc w udg o ry ons de ed nput r he t t ge yphys c a w ho wer t a et doc z en i i ns e m bl o lm t c i ca fndi c it twih dia i physc la e o i na pr ems Gi n t f c t t lni l i ngs ons sen t s blng ia nd m to l obl . ve he a t ha pl i ifsfbr antf i omya gi s ndr l a y ome, r lt d emoto lpr blm s a e apr i f t e i t s and e ae i na o e , r om nent eaur n hi c s , t tt i e a tonofhe physc la e i ls a e and ha he nt r c i r ia nd motona ympt i c oms s omplx,hecour beleve e t t i s t t t f t fnde mi ht bene i fom t tmony of a m e ca a s a a s e ha he ac i r g ft r esi di l dvior t uppl mentl a a i sr tvehea i Howe r bas don t e si r or t c t suna et c udet t dm nita i rng. ve , e he xitng ec d, he our i bl o oncl ha M r . ppe ha me t bur n ofpr i esa ihi t a dia lt f al f s Goe r s t he de oof n t bls ng ot l s biiy or l onnsofs t nta ubsa i l g i ule pl anf m oyme . nt For t r s sa e t co t fnds tg he ea ons tt d, he ur i tood c us ' f r r nd of t s c s t t a e' o ema hi a e o he Co m iso rf f t rc i r tona de opme .I t Comm isone i una et de i m s i ne or urhe onsde a i nd vel nt f he s i r s bl o cde t sca ei pl i ifsf voron t bassoft e si r c d, he Comm isone wilc hi s n a ntf a he i he xitng e or t s i r l onduc a t s e t la i sr tve he rng,a whi h bot sdeswilbe alo upplmen a dm nitai ai t c h i l l wed t pr e addii o es nt tonal e de ea a gum e .Asnot d a vi nc nd r nt e bove t c t le t ti fom amedial s woul , he our be ives ha nput r c advior d bees i l hepf i t sc e.An a o i t o d ofr ma wilbee e e t sda pecaly l ul n hi as ppr prae r er e nd l nt r d hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd c rii d co e oft sopi on t a1c e k s r c e o e e tte pis hi ni o l ouns lofr c d. e e or DA'Eo: i ( & r Ths 4 da ofxove be , 2 4. y m r 01 Chi Unie St t sDititJ ef t d a e src udge 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
