Barnes v. Johnson et al, No. 3:2012cv00053 - Document 192 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/03/2014. (ssm)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL SOFFI U.S. ST ERK' CE DI . COURT ATRDA NOKE, VA FI ED L I TH E UN I N TED STATES D I STRI COU RT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STRI OF V I I I CT RG N A CH AR LOTTESVI LLE D I I ON V SI J 23 2 1 UL 2# J A BKULI C. D Ci lA cton N o.3: vi i 12CV00053 Pl ntf , ai if M EM O R AN DU M O PIN I N O By: on, e E. H Gl n Conr d a Chi Unied St es D it i J ef t at s rct udge D ef endant s. Fa Ba ne , af ye r s onne i a e oft Fl r nm t he uvanna Co r c i lCent r f W om e r e tona e or n l j i (s uva ' ,ie t scvi rg sa tonpurua t 42U. C.j 1 algi t tt 1 i Fl nna' tld hi i l iht ci ) s nt o S. 983, le ng ha he I i dfnatfr r orcin Letnn JhahnBadue ecsieoc aantj eedn,omeC ret s i eatonta l ,sd xes fre gislr o u n v ! Whi s ewa ic r eae ,nvolto of h panifsEih hAme d n rg t. Th l te l h s n ac rtd i i ai n t e litf g t e n me t ih sl ematr 1 I i p e e tyb f r t ec u t nt ed fn a tsmo inf rs mmayj dg n .Th mo in s rs n l eo e h o r o h e e d n ' to o u r u me t e ts ha ng be n f l bref d a t pa te ha ng ag e t s i t m oton w ihou a he rng, vi e uly i e nd he ri s vi r ed o ubm t he i t t i t m a t ri now rpe f r diposton. Fort f l w i r s ,t m oton wilbe de d. he te s i o s ii he olo ng ea ons he i l ni Bac ound kar I i i I T ercr rvash fl wigrlvn fcs rsne i tel h motaoast h eod e elte ol n eeatatpeetd n h i t sfv rbe o o g I ! t pli if Se Anderonv.Li ryLobby,nc, U. 242,261n. ( 986) Thepl ntf, he antf. e s bet I .477 S. 21 . ai if FayeBane , a i t a Fl nnabewe nFebr r 2009a Fe uay201 Unil r s was n nmae t uva t e uay nd br r 2. i I Novembe 201 t de e nt J t Blnd,wa e pl d asaCore tonsLi t nà a r 0, he f nda , ohnahan a s m oye rci eu e 1nt t Fl nna. I Se e be 201 w hie a tng ast ofi e i c r oft pl i if sho ng uva n pt m r 0, l c i he t c r n ha ge he a ntf ' us uni,Bl charged t pl ntf w ih Cgat i and appr t and he ai if t t her ng oachi i a t eat ng w ay.' hid ng n hr eni ' r 1 CLE é' FA Y E BA RN ES, GEN E JOHN SON ,etal, . , I Thepl ntf alo na e t ot rdefndant,i udi addii c r ctonalofi r a m e be sof ai if s m d en he e s ncl ng tonal ore i fce s nd r Fl nna' m edi saf . The cl m saga ns t e de enda sha bee f l r ol a J t n Bl d i t uva s cal t f ai i t hos f nt ve n uly es ved, nd ohna ha a s he onl de enda r ni i t c e y f nt emai ng n he as . I Sum m . .2,Doc tN o.1 Shes ksdnma i t a o of$1 000, 2 Thi d A m . J ke 87. ee ges n he m unt 0, 000. r Complj21 .f 9. The de e ntde est the r s r i d t pl i ifi ha cuf son Se e be 30,201 f nda ni ha e ta ne he a ntf n nd f pt m r 0, a s kss nd ee ummayj r udgme i hi fvoront meis Bl pr fr t tkl r lwa nt n s a he rt. and ofes ha iBanes s t a por e t s r ga i by t o ya d of i er and wasunr s r i d untls r ac d t r ns t d o eg e ton w r fc s e ta ne i he e he he s gr to buidi ' De.sM ott Se Asd Enr ofDea t6, 15, ke No.1 The e egain l ng. f' .o t ie ty ' ful ! Doc t 76. de e ntù ns r t d t ya d of i r nott r s r n Pl i ifdurng t a por be a e t r w as f nda t tuc e he r fce s i o e tai a ntf i r ns t c us he e move ntont yad.'J sThedee nte ai t ttft ofiesha rsr i dBane t me he r ' ê fnda xpl ns ha s he fc r d e tane r s o i ta por he ... o t s gr ga i buidi t entr yar w oul ha bee r qui e t go on r ns t r t he e e ton l ng, he ie d d ve n e r d o l kdown. L= tv boo fom t buidi s dpr dee de es oc ' d sog ks r he l ng houl ovi vi nc uppori Blnd' ' l tng a s de ens t the di no ta por Pl ntf on Se e be 30,201 ' l a 8. A lhough C ai i f f e ha d t r ns t ai if pt m r 0. d. t ' t d ntf pl s d ha bee r tai be o e s e er d t s gr a i buidi ' Bl nd idi not houl ve n esr ned f r he nt e he e eg ton l ng, a d d ' pe s ly wines Pl i ifbe ng r s r i a he di notac om pa he t t buidi ' I r ona l t s a ntf i e t a ned s d c ny r o he l ng. d. ' M or r e n i Bl nd ha ha uf ed t pl ntf o Se e be 30,201 a a l ge eove , ve f a d ndc f he ai i f n pt m r 0, s le d i t c pl i ,he a guest thi co n he om a nt r ha s nduc w o d notha vi a e he r gh s unde t Ei h t ul ve ol t d r i t r he ght Am e ndm e ,m uc l s a c e r y e t bls cons iutona r ght H a l v.Fizge a d,457 nt h es ny l a l s a i hed tt i l i . row t rl U. 8 ( 98 ( c i ngt t pr e quaiidi S. 00 1 2) desrbi he wo- ong d lfe mmuniyts) The eor,t dee an t et. r f e he fnd t ague ,hei e ildt s r s s ntte o ummayj r udgmentont bai ofqualfedi he ss ii mmuniy, wela ont t as l s he m ert is. 2Thepli ifdi notie i he pr ye f dama agans ea h i vi de e nt Rat r s m a antf d tm ze r a r or ges i t c ndi dual f nda . he , he de acoleci dema i t a l tve nd n he moun of$1 000, fom aldefnda s.Thec tnoest tt pl ntf s tld he t 0, 000 r l e nt our t ha he ai if e te r r a e cl m saga ns def ndant Be ry Ros era Corz He t I f a undi c os d a ount el t d ai i t e s ve l s nd i on aIh, nc, or n sl e m . 3 wa usd; 3 t ee tn o teij l ; 4 tet ra ra o a l p r eve b ter s nsbe s e ( ) h xe t f h nu' ( ) h h e t e s n by ec i d y h epo i l y ofiilbasd o t f t knownt hi a ( a ef t mad t t rt s ve iyofa tca e n he acs o m; nd 5) ny fors e o empe he e rt f c f lr s ns W hilv,475U. a 321,Theob e tvec ore u epo e. te S. t j ci ompo ntf us onçhenau eof ne oc es t tr t t f r e'whih mus beC ti a. W iki v. ddy,559U. 34,39( 0) dWhe he o c ,' c t ' rvil' l ns Ga non ' S. 201 . i n pr s ofi i l m alci l a s di tc l us f r e t ca e ha m ,c e por r sa ar of i on fc a s i ous y nd a s i aly e o c o us r ont m a y t nd ds de enc awa a evi ae ' Huds 503U. a 9.I s tt û or j ca i r gs ... c y l ys r oltd. ' on, S. t n hor,he t e udiilnquiy i) c t na ur oft f c s i ly, t ri wasnonti a a wasa i d ...ma ii l he t e he or e pecfcal whe he t rvil nd pple lc ousy a s ditc lyt ca eham. W iki ,559U. a 39(ntr lquottonmaksomitd) I nd a sial o us r ' l ns ' S. t i ena ai r te . f t c tfnds t tC he e de e, e e i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pl ntf ,wils he our i ha k vi nc vi w d n he i t t a a e o he ai i f l uppor t arla ei eenc ofwa onne si t i lci ofpanunde ghi t pa t tndadj' eibl nfr e nt s n he nfiton i r t s wo- r sa r ,' s ummayj me i t dee ntsfvo i i pprprae W hily, U. a 3 r udg nt n he fnda ' a r s na o it. te 475 S. t 22. A f lr vi w oft r co d r a fr st c m en s m a by t co ta t he i on ul e e he e r e f im he om t de he ur t he arng t motont sta i t e r ofdea t s he i o e sde he nty ful- ummayj r udgmen i i ppr praei t sc s t s na o it n hi a e bec us Ba ne pr s nt ge neis ofmae ilf twihr pec t boht s j ci a a e r s e e s nui sues tra ac t es t o t he ub e tve nd ob e tvecompone sofhe Ei hAme me exc s i f c cai ag ns Blnd.M os j ci nt r ght nd nt e sve ore l m ai t a t f unda nt ly,af t ldipu ee ssa t whe he t def nda ha ufedt pl i ifo me al acua s t xit s o t r he e nt ndc f he antf n Se e r30, 0.Co r ThidAm.Compl!44 (( ora Se e r30,...gj ptmbe 201 mpae r . (On bout ptmbe the pr dur Bl nd e pl d f s c i Pl i ifm ea tt the w r nc he a m sbe nd he oce e a m oye or ha klng a ntf n ha e hed r r hi r ba kt mee a t nc fdt m t t .) a BanesDe 49, ke No.1 1((was c o t nd he ufe he ogeher', nd r ' p. Doc t 87- dI s c e a handc f d by Li utna Bl nd,a Li u e ntBl us d t sngl ha uf f ha kl d nd ufe e e nt a nd e t na and e he i e ndc f or t wrs.)wihBl Af. 8,Docke No.1 4(6 as t d( antf sc eqt t1ha he it', t and f ! ' t 76- $1 lo ol pli if ouns l ha d no s c e Baneswhe s wa move t s r ton, Banesalgesi he c ant') t ha kld r n he s d o egegai as r le n r ompli . , ' u u u l u ih n ) eeo e t ed fnd n ' moi nfrs mmayj d me t s b d n e . n s a p n s me t.Th rf r ,h ee a ts to o u r u g n mu t e e id C oncl i uson Fo t ef r g igra o ,h moinf rs mmayj g n fldbyd fn n r h o e on e s ns te to o u r ud me t i e e e da t J ohna ha Bl nd w ilbe de e The c s w ilpr e d t a be h t i c r nty s hed e t t n a l ni d. a e l oc e o nc ral ur e l c ul d o be n on J y 1 201 gi ul 5, 4. The Cl r i diec e t s nd c r ii d c esoft sm e or nd opi on a t e k s r t d o e e tf e opi hi m a um ni nd he a c pa ng or rt al c c om nyi de o 1 ouns ofr c d. el e or ENTER:Ths 3*2 d yo J l, 01 . i a f uy 2 4 Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ e t d a e sr c udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
