Nautilus Insurance Company v. Strongwell Corporation, No. 1:2013cv00066 - Document 25 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/23/2014. (ssm)

Download PDF
CL ERKS OFFI U.S.DI .COURT CE ST AT ROANOKE,VA FI LED I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STRI C OU RT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I I O F V I I I STR CT RG N A A BI G D ON D I I ON N V SI J 23 2 1 UL 29 JULI . A BY: LEY C 'c ï' 'îF . 's ' . ;.rr) .j .: f . Jy: : N A U TI S I SU RAN CE CO M PAN Y , LU N Ci lA c i N o.1: 3CV00066 vi ton 1 Pl i i f a ntf , M EM O R AN DU M O PIN IO N V. STR ON G W ELL CO RPO RA TI , ON By:H on. l n E.Conr d Ge a Chi Unie St t D i ti tJ ef t d a es s r c udge Def nda . e nt l t si ur nc cove ag di put w hi h ha be c olda e w ih Ci lA c i N o. n hi ns a e r e s e, c s en ons i t d t vi ton ll CV0 0 , u i l s r n eCo a y(û u iu ' s e sad caao yj dg n t a ih s :2 0 38 Na tl n u a c mp n C tl s' e k e lrt r u me t h t t a us Na ) nooblgai t defndori mniy StongwelCoporton(k r i ton o e nde f r l ai tstongwel')i c ci wiha l' n onne ton t lws tt tBl k& Ve thCo porton(t a k& Ve th' orgi l fl agans Stongweli a ui ha ac ac r ai iBlc ac ' i naly ied i t r ) ln t U nie St t s Di t i tCour f t Sou he n D i ti tofA l m a. The ca e i pr e l he t d a e s rc t or he t r sr c aba s s es nty bef e t c to St ongw e l sm o i n t di m i s Fort r as t tf l , he m o i w il or he our n r l' t o o s s . he e ons ha olow t ton l be gr nt d i par a de ed i pa t a e n t nd ni n r . 1. D ut to D efend v O n M a c 29, rh 2013, a & V e t h fl s taga ns St o w el i t Sout n D it i t Bl ck a c ied ui i t r ng l n he her s rc ofAlba (heC a mas f'. Blc & Ve th' camsrlt t wor a maerast t a ma t s ba ui ) a k Al ac s li eae o k nd t il ha Sto g l p o ie a p r o ap o e t oc n tu tajtb b ln ra trf rt eCh re L. r n wel r vd d s a t f rj c t o sr c e u b ig e co o h a ls Low m a PowerPl nti Le oy,A l ba a. On Se e be 30,201 t A l ba a s tw as n a n r a m pt m r 3, he a m ui t a f r ed t t W e t r D it i tofM i s i whe e i w ascons i t d w ih Bl ck & V e t h r ns e r o he s e n s rc s our , r t olda e t a ac Cop. Stongwel Co'.4:2CV0011 (heS sour s f',n whihBlc & Veacha s t r v. r l l, 1 p 9 t d s i ui ) i Mi c ak t sers smia camsr ai t t de i a c tuci ofjtbubblngra t si Ohi a I a i lr li eltng o he sgn nd onsr ton e i e cor n o nd ndina. Thi cour hasalea r edt tNa iushasa d y t def nd Stong l i t M is i s t r dy ul ha utl ut o e r we l n he s our s t Se Na iusl .Co. Stong l Cor , l:2CV00038,968F.Supp.2d807( . ui. e utl ns v. r wel p.No. 1 W D. Va. 3)(é utl 1'. A r e oft doc ti t M is is trve l t tt M is ur 201 s ius ') Na eviw he ke n he sour ui e as ha he so i s tand t Al ba a s tha be n f l c olda e f a 1 pos ,i udi ti l Se Bl ck ui he a m ui ve e uly ons i t d or l pur es ncl ng r a . e a & Ve thCor v. r ac p. StonawelNo. 1 l, 4:2CV0011 M i eEnr Doc tNo.111( . M o. i 9, nut ty, ke W D. Aprl 1 , 01 )( rni gtepa t s j itmo int a n t s h d ln o d ra ds tigt j r 1 2 4 g a tn h ri ' o n to o me d he c e u ig r e n etn he u y e tilf Aprl1 201 . l t r f ef l t tNa iusi oblgae t dee t e ie ra or i 3, 5) t he eor olows ha utl s i td o fnd he ntr c olda ed a ton,a N a t l is fa know l dgesi isbref Se N a ius sBr i Opp' a 8 ons i t c i s u ius t el c e n t i . e utl ' . n n t (e og zi t ti ma bede me t haveadut t dee Sto weli t Alba s ti t rc ni ng ha t y e do y o fnd rng l n he a ma ui f he s ti f l co oldae wiht Mis is t (ii AES Cor v.Stadfs l .Co.725 ui s uly ns i td t he sour ui) ctng p. e at ns , S. 2d 5 ( 201 ) s ealoCACII '-l v.St Pa Fiea M ai l .Co.566F. E. 32 Va. 2). e s , nt1 nc. . ul r nd rne ns , 3d 15 l ( hCi. 0, 55 4t r 2009)(t r ni a ot rsae rc z t C enilt r e, wheen in C gi a nd he tts e ognie he pot taiy ul ' ri a vi is rrsd t t d fn i tig r di t r i a ypo sb l yt a aj dg n a ans teis r d n u e ' uy o ee d s rg ee f hee s n siii h t u me t g i t h n u e t wilbec r undert i ur nc polc ''(uoi Bo e rv. i l . oup, F. l oveed he ns a e iy.' q tng hre Ere ns Gr 475 Supp. ) 2d 578,584( D, 2007); s v. lci l . ,61F. 238, ( hCi.1 (sW j r E. Va. ) Fuiz See tve ns Co. 3d 245 4t r 995) sl hee bot c r a e udeda t ar al edggans t i ur ,t duyt defndatc s' ; h oveed nd xcl cs e leg a i t he ns edl he t o e ta he .l ' Co c o l u a e3 j2 02 ( e ta 2 4 ($ t mao iyo j rs ito s a is rrs u h n ns rnc d 0 :5 W slw 01 ) kn he j rt f u id ci n , n n u e ' l dut t de end e e t t e i e a i w hi i ude c r pot ntaly cove e and y o f xt nds o he ntr cton, ch ncl s ove ed, e i l r d, unco rdalegai wihi t cli ' . Acc di l Nautl ' compli wilbedimis d vee l tons t n he am.) ' or ngy, iuss ant l s se i of r a i s eksa de a a i t ti hasno dut t de e St o w el. ns a s t e cl r ton ha t y o f nd r ng l I I. Dut t Indem niv v o f Stongwelha as movedt dimis wiho prj c t pori oft c an i r l s lo o s s , t ut eudie,he ton he omplit n whi h Nautl s ks a de a a i n t ti ha no du y t i m ni y St ongwel. A spr vi l c ius ee cl r to ha t s t o nde f r l e ous y e a ned i N a ius1 c t ha ge a l he d t ti w oul be pr m a ur t r l o a xpl i n utl , our s ve ner ly l ha t d e t e o ue n n i ur r sdut t i m niy w hie t unde l ng a ton r m a nspe ng. Se N a iusl .Co. ns e ' y o nde f l he ryi c i e i ndi e utl ns , 968F.Supp. a 821(ii ca e ) W hiet cou tfndsnor as t depa tfom t sge r l 2d t ctng s s. l he r i e on o r r hi ne a r e i t i tnta ton, heco tde i t di mist po ton oft c pli i whi h ul n he nsa c i t ur clnes o s s he ri he om a nt n c N a ius s e a de e m i i n ofis i m nii a i oblg i ns I t ad,c i t ntw ih utl e ks t r nato t nde f c ton i ato . ns e ons s e t N a ius1 t c twilr r i f o r i on t i s ofi m ni i ton un i t unde l ng utl , he our l ef a n r m ulng he s ue nde fca i t l he ryi ac i i r s ved. ton s e ol Fort r s sa e Stongw e lsm o i t di m i swilbe g a ed i pa ' a de ed i he ea ons t t d, r l ' ton o s s l r nt n l nd ni n t pa t The Cl r i die t d t s nd c e oft s m em or ndum opi on a t a co pa ng r. e k s r c e o e opi s hi a ni nd he c m nyi or rt a lc de o l ouns lofr or e ec d. ENTER: s J. Thi 3 a o J l 2 4. y f uy, 01 Chi fUnied St t D i t i tJ e t a es sr c udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.