Adkins v. McGlothlin, No. 1:2011cv00087 - Document 41 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/29/2012. (lmh)

Download PDF

.' '.. * ' e. ' ' e x -iÃ¹-leu. :: o r a t , lm x A m- : i: R A o u lv Mt zn I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STRI T C O U RT C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI ABIN G D O N DIVISIO N Ã» 2 22 I tl . ./ c ) u rk . Dt A cutÃ h . ; H ER M A N R ALPH AD M N S, D K Ci lA c i N o.1: v00087 vi ton 11c Pl ntf ai if, V. W O O DR O W M C G LO T H LI , N By: M i hae F.U r c l bans ki U ni e St e Di t i Judge t d at s s r ct D ef endant . M EM O M N DU M O PI O N NI Thi m a tri bef et cour on t moton t dim isfld b de e ntW oodr w s te s or he t he i o s s ie y f nda o M c ot i ( . 30 .Themotonwa r fn'dt t Honorbl RobetS. l Unie Gl hln Dkt# ) i s ee e o he a e r Balou, td SttsM a srt J ae gitae udge,purua t 28U. C.j636( ( )B) f pr pos dtndi off ta s nt o S. b)1( ,or o e i ngs ac nd ar omm e d diposton oft moton. OnAugus 6,201 t M a sr t J ec nde s ii he i t 2, he gitae udgeis a s ued Re ta Rec por nd omm e i n r c me ngt tM c o hln' moton t dimisbegr nt a ndato e om ndi ha Glt i s i o s s a ed nd t motonf dicoveyfldbypli it Hema RaphAdki ,( .#33) bedenidas he i or s r ie antfl r n l ns Dkt , e m oot. Afe r ve o t eRe o t n Re o n ain, k n 'o j cinst eeoa d tr e iw f h p r a d c mme d to Ad i s be to h rt n M c l hln' r pons i i cl rt tt R e ta Re om m e i m us be a ed a t s G ot i s es e, t s ea ha he por nd c ndaton t dopt nd hi ca e di m i s d. I s t a a m a t rofl w , ne oft a l ge f lngs l vel a i t s s s e n hor , s te a no he le d aii e ed ga ns M cGl t i i hi r e a D e y Unie St esM a s lgi rs t a c vi rght c a m o hln n s ol s put t d at r ha ve i e o i l i s l i a tona ea i thi unde Bi nsv.Si Unknown Fe r lNa c isAge s 403U . 388 c i bl ga ns m r ve x de a r otc nt , S. ( 971. 1 ) 1. A dki f r tc pl ns t tM c l hln vi a ed hi c vi r g s by a r tng hi' on a ns i s onl ai ha G ot i ol t s i l i ht r es i l n f de alf l ny g c ge i 1 e r e o un hr n 999,ast w hi h he c a m she w as( a loa d' i t pl a ng o c li G ir de ' n o e di r guit Re e oft c t e or as oc aedwihA d ns a r s and pr e ton m a i cea ly. vi w he our r c ds s i t t ki ' re t os cu i ke t l r t tAdki ha no vibl cai t tM cGl t i sa r tofhi vi at hi cvi rg s ha ns s a e l m ha o hln' res m ol ed s i l iht . I Un td S ae v Hema Rap Ad i , .19 - - 0 6 , Co lita dAre t n ie tts . r n lh kns No :9 mj0 0 0 a mp an n r s W a r ntwe e is on Se e ra r s ued pt mber9,1 ont f ony wea 999 he el ponsc r Folowi Ad ns ha ge. l ng ki ' a r s by M c ot i a i ta a re t Gl hln, n niil ppea a e wa conduce on Se e be 20,1 r nc s td ptm r 999,a whih tm e t c i t U nie St t s m ove f a c pe e y e ua i A f ens c eva ua i w a c he t d a e d or om t nc val ton. or i l ton s onduc e a t d nd a r por r ce ved o J nua y 5,2000.A d nsw asf e te i n a r ki ound c pe entt s a t i a a he i om t o t nd ral t arng c n u tdo J n a y7 2 0 a drla e o b n Tha c s , .19 - - 00 0 wa o d ce n a u r , 0 0 n ee s d n o d. t a e No :9 mj0 6 , s tr i t d wih t tlng ofaf ony i cm e agans Adki on J nua y 26, e m na e t he ii el ndit nt i t ns a r 2000. The doc toft e ui a ton, nied St t v. e m a Ral A t ns N o.1: c ke he ns ng c i U t a es H r n ph ki , 00- r 00009, e l c st tAdki wa r pr e e by co eli t tca e.A pl ag ee e wa r fe t ha ns s e es nt d uns n ha s ea r m nt s e e e on J y 7, nt r d ul 2000,r l c i Adki 'ag ee tt pl a g lyt a mideme no .A efe tng ns r men o e d uit o s a r s r e ng i or a i was fl on J y 20,2000,a guit pl a hea i w a he d t tda upe s di nf m ton ied ul nd ly e rng s l ha y. Puruantt t s r e ng i o m a i a plaag e m e , s o he upe s di nf r ton nd e r e nt Adki pl ade guit t a ns e d ly o mide norvi ai of18U. C.j1 whihma siunlwf lt pi to paa i a s mea olton S. 507, c ke t a u o cke r rde n n atmp t itreewih o sr c o i e et ea miitain o j sieo itu n eaj d e te t o ne fr t , b tu t r mp d h d n sr t f u tc r nl e c u g . o Pur ua t t pl a a e en ,t f l ny w ea s nt o he e gr em t he e o pons c r aga ns A d ns w a di m i s d on ha ge i t ki s s se m oton oft go r m e . Adki w a s nt nc t s x m o hs i ar e aton,w ih c e tf r i he ve n nt ns s e e ed o i nt nc c r i t r di o tm e s n 'd durng t pende ofhi c pe e e l ton. A dki w a pl e on hom e i e e i he ncy s om t ncy va ua i ns s ac d c nfn me t o t rman e o tej i tr i o e S g fc nl , kisddn ta p a ti o i e n f r he e id r f h alem mp s d. iniia ty Ad n i o p e lh s ci n lu g n , o ddh fl ah be sc r u pei o u d r28U. C. 2 5 Ass c t rmia j d me tn r i e ie a a o p s tt n n e i S. j 2 5. u h,he c tsOcobe 5,2000,udgme i t sc eha l be n fna. our' t r j ntn hi as s ong e i l A sbes a t cour c n di c r M c l hln' onl r e i t s pr e uton w a t a r t t s he t a s e n, G ot i s y ol n hi os c i s o r es A dki i Se e ber 1 ns n pt m , 999. A st M ag s r t J he i t a e udge c r c l conc ude a A dki pl d g ly or e ty l d, s ns e uit i 2000 pur ua t a pl ag ee e r ol ng t wea n s nt o ea r m nt es vi he pons c r e f w hi h he w a a r t ha g or c s r esed, t ei no ba i f a c am ofmalcouspr ec i a ii outofhi a r s nora ot r her s s s or ny l i ii os uton rsng s ret ny he c ogni a e c tt i z bl ons iutonalc a m . Ã§ ti wel s tl d unde V igi a 1 w t tc i i lco c i n l i Ã§ s l e te l r r ni a ha r m na nvi to esa i he ,w iho t ne s iy ofot rpr ,t e s e e oft el m e ofpr bl c us t bls s t ut he ce s t he oof he xi t nc he e nt oba e a e t a r s a pr e ut whi h i ac o r e t nd os c e, c s omplt de e et a tonsf malci pr e uton, a s e e f ns o c i or i ous os c i f le ar t a de n ton. Brwse v.W oodwad& Lot op.I ,530F. 1 6,1 7( C. r res, nd f mai ' e tr ' r hr nc. 2d 01 01 D. Ci. 1 ;J nne v. ln' De .St e, F. 976) a v Ara s pt or 247 Supp.306,308( . Va.1 ) Ri tsv. G. W D. 965 ; cket J. M c or Co. 1 Va. 554,1 S. 91 91 ( 924) cr v , 38 548, 21 E. 6, 8 1 . I l. A dki ne c pl ns t tM c l hln s e ns xt om ai ha G ot i om how vi a ed hi c tt i lrght by no ol t s ons iutona i s t i si tngcli ofpej ybywine s a ti sc nvetgai ams rur t ses t ral onduce durngt prc ngdec dei td i he e edi a n s a e and f de alc t A dki hasno c tt i lr ghtac i bl unde Bi nst r uie a tt e r our . ns ons iutona i tona e r ve o eq r De y Unie Stt M a s t i tgae a purueAdki 'cai st tW as ng on Co y put t d a es r hal o nvesi t nd s ns l m ha hi t unt She if sD e y La r M oor a ot r le unde oa h i e r i rt i s A dki obvi usy rf put r y e nd he s i d r t n a le ral . ns o l bele st thewa m onge by f le ive ha s d as hoodshecon e we epe er t i t ec t by t nds r m taed n hos ours M oor a o he s Butt r i no bas si t 1 w f A dki t brng a l w s ta ns e nd t r . he e s i n he a or ns o i a ui gai t M c l hln f notpr s ng A dki 'cl i s G ot i or es i ns a m . 1 11. Fi l A dki cl m s t thi r ght ha bee vi a ed be us M cGl hln c m e on naly, ns ai ha s i s ve n ol t ca e ot i n A dki z ope t l f hi busnes ca d,a t r fe di notr t n A dki z e e ns pr r y, e t s i s r nd he ea t r d e ur nst l phone c l A s als. t M a sr t J he gi ta e udge a l not d,t e f c sdo nots pty e hes a t uppor a c tt i lvi a i l t ny ons iutona ol ton. n s t t r ca beno a tonabl cvi rg scli a ns M c ot i t onl de e nti t s hor,he e n ci e i l i ht am gai t Gl hln, he y f nda n hi ca e,a t sc em us be dim is s nd hi as t s s ed. lV . Ad i h sfld awrte o j cint teRe o t n Re o n ain, c tec u t kns a ie itn be to o h p r a d c mme d t whih h o r o h srviwe l i ce rfo t eo j cinta Ad n p icpal i c n en d wihalg dy a e e d. t s la r m h b e to h t kis rn i ly s o c r e t le e l f s t tmony fom M oor a ot r a til hel i sa eand f de a cour m or t n ade de ale esi r e nd he s t ra s d n tt e rl t e ha ca a o I d e Ad i akst i c u tor s o dt t q sinso t els p g o hso jcin, g . n e d, kns s h s o r t e p n o wo ueto n h at a e f i be to ea h ofwhi h c c c once st ve iy oft si o t ke i ti l c m he rt e tm ny a n n ra s onduct l ago. Butt c t ed ong he our h sn a ii n rfa ky a yj rs ito t a s rt o eq eto sa t e ha en t iga al a o b ly, o r n l n u idcin,o n we h s u si n s h y v o hn t l t t do wiht def nda i t sca e W oodr M c ot i nort c am sr ie a i thi i o t he e nt n hi s , ow Gl hln, he l i a s d gans m n t c s pe ng be or t c t Si yput as ta i tM cGl hln ca pr deno r medy he a e ndi f e he our. mpl , ui gans ot i n ovi e t Adki f t wr o ns or he ongshecli soc ur e a o he Ã¯ha i ot rca e ye r ago.A st r i am c r d t t r nds n he s s a s he e s no a tona ec tt i lvi a i alege i t sc s ,i mus be dim is c i bl onsiutona olton l d n hi a e t t s s ed. A n Or ra de doptng t R e ta Re om m e ton i isen iel a di m i s ng t s i he por nd c nda i n t tr y nd s s i hi a to wihp eudc wil ee tr dti d y cin t rj ie l b n ee h s a . E trd: /& -A. - Z 4 i2n ee @ - 4/- * / WG Mi chaelF.U r ki bans Unie St t D i ti tJ t d a es s r c udge 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.