Adkins v. McGlothlin, No. 1:2011cv00087 - Document 41 (W.D. Va. 2012)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/29/2012. (lmh)
Download PDF
.' '.. * ' e. ' ' e x -iù-leu. :: o r a t , lm x A m- : i: R A o u lv Mt zn I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STRI T C O U RT C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F V I G I A C R NI ABIN G D O N DIVISIO N û 2 22 I tl . ./ c ) u rk . Dt A cutàh . ; H ER M A N R ALPH AD M N S, D K Ci lA c i N o.1: v00087 vi ton 11c Pl ntf ai if, V. W O O DR O W M C G LO T H LI , N By: M i hae F.U r c l bans ki U ni e St e Di t i Judge t d at s s r ct D ef endant . M EM O M N DU M O PI O N NI Thi m a tri bef et cour on t moton t dim isfld b de e ntW oodr w s te s or he t he i o s s ie y f nda o M c ot i ( . 30 .Themotonwa r fn'dt t Honorbl RobetS. l Unie Gl hln Dkt# ) i s ee e o he a e r Balou, td SttsM a srt J ae gitae udge,purua t 28U. C.j636( ( )B) f pr pos dtndi off ta s nt o S. b)1( ,or o e i ngs ac nd ar omm e d diposton oft moton. OnAugus 6,201 t M a sr t J ec nde s ii he i t 2, he gitae udgeis a s ued Re ta Rec por nd omm e i n r c me ngt tM c o hln' moton t dimisbegr nt a ndato e om ndi ha Glt i s i o s s a ed nd t motonf dicoveyfldbypli it Hema RaphAdki ,( .#33) bedenidas he i or s r ie antfl r n l ns Dkt , e m oot. Afe r ve o t eRe o t n Re o n ain, k n 'o j cinst eeoa d tr e iw f h p r a d c mme d to Ad i s be to h rt n M c l hln' r pons i i cl rt tt R e ta Re om m e i m us be a ed a t s G ot i s es e, t s ea ha he por nd c ndaton t dopt nd hi ca e di m i s d. I s t a a m a t rofl w , ne oft a l ge f lngs l vel a i t s s s e n hor , s te a no he le d aii e ed ga ns M cGl t i i hi r e a D e y Unie St esM a s lgi rs t a c vi rght c a m o hln n s ol s put t d at r ha ve i e o i l i s l i a tona ea i thi unde Bi nsv.Si Unknown Fe r lNa c isAge s 403U . 388 c i bl ga ns m r ve x de a r otc nt , S. ( 971. 1 ) 1. A dki f r tc pl ns t tM c l hln vi a ed hi c vi r g s by a r tng hi' on a ns i s onl ai ha G ot i ol t s i l i ht r es i l n f de alf l ny g c ge i 1 e r e o un hr n 999,ast w hi h he c a m she w as( a loa d' i t pl a ng o c li G ir de ' n o e di r guit Re e oft c t e or as oc aedwihA d ns a r s and pr e ton m a i cea ly. vi w he our r c ds s i t t ki ' re t os cu i ke t l r t tAdki ha no vibl cai t tM cGl t i sa r tofhi vi at hi cvi rg s ha ns s a e l m ha o hln' res m ol ed s i l iht . I Un td S ae v Hema Rap Ad i , .19 - - 0 6 , Co lita dAre t n ie tts . r n lh kns No :9 mj0 0 0 a mp an n r s W a r ntwe e is on Se e ra r s ued pt mber9,1 ont f ony wea 999 he el ponsc r Folowi Ad ns ha ge. l ng ki ' a r s by M c ot i a i ta a re t Gl hln, n niil ppea a e wa conduce on Se e be 20,1 r nc s td ptm r 999,a whih tm e t c i t U nie St t s m ove f a c pe e y e ua i A f ens c eva ua i w a c he t d a e d or om t nc val ton. or i l ton s onduc e a t d nd a r por r ce ved o J nua y 5,2000.A d nsw asf e te i n a r ki ound c pe entt s a t i a a he i om t o t nd ral t arng c n u tdo J n a y7 2 0 a drla e o b n Tha c s , .19 - - 00 0 wa o d ce n a u r , 0 0 n ee s d n o d. t a e No :9 mj0 6 , s tr i t d wih t tlng ofaf ony i cm e agans Adki on J nua y 26, e m na e t he ii el ndit nt i t ns a r 2000. The doc toft e ui a ton, nied St t v. e m a Ral A t ns N o.1: c ke he ns ng c i U t a es H r n ph ki , 00- r 00009, e l c st tAdki wa r pr e e by co eli t tca e.A pl ag ee e wa r fe t ha ns s e es nt d uns n ha s ea r m nt s e e e on J y 7, nt r d ul 2000,r l c i Adki 'ag ee tt pl a g lyt a mideme no .A efe tng ns r men o e d uit o s a r s r e ng i or a i was fl on J y 20,2000,a guit pl a hea i w a he d t tda upe s di nf m ton ied ul nd ly e rng s l ha y. Puruantt t s r e ng i o m a i a plaag e m e , s o he upe s di nf r ton nd e r e nt Adki pl ade guit t a ns e d ly o mide norvi ai of18U. C.j1 whihma siunlwf lt pi to paa i a s mea olton S. 507, c ke t a u o cke r rde n n atmp t itreewih o sr c o i e et ea miitain o j sieo itu n eaj d e te t o ne fr t , b tu t r mp d h d n sr t f u tc r nl e c u g . o Pur ua t t pl a a e en ,t f l ny w ea s nt o he e gr em t he e o pons c r aga ns A d ns w a di m i s d on ha ge i t ki s s se m oton oft go r m e . Adki w a s nt nc t s x m o hs i ar e aton,w ih c e tf r i he ve n nt ns s e e ed o i nt nc c r i t r di o tm e s n 'd durng t pende ofhi c pe e e l ton. A dki w a pl e on hom e i e e i he ncy s om t ncy va ua i ns s ac d c nfn me t o t rman e o tej i tr i o e S g fc nl , kisddn ta p a ti o i e n f r he e id r f h alem mp s d. iniia ty Ad n i o p e lh s ci n lu g n , o ddh fl ah be sc r u pei o u d r28U. C. 2 5 Ass c t rmia j d me tn r i e ie a a o p s tt n n e i S. j 2 5. u h,he c tsOcobe 5,2000,udgme i t sc eha l be n fna. our' t r j ntn hi as s ong e i l A sbes a t cour c n di c r M c l hln' onl r e i t s pr e uton w a t a r t t s he t a s e n, G ot i s y ol n hi os c i s o r es A dki i Se e ber 1 ns n pt m , 999. A st M ag s r t J he i t a e udge c r c l conc ude a A dki pl d g ly or e ty l d, s ns e uit i 2000 pur ua t a pl ag ee e r ol ng t wea n s nt o ea r m nt es vi he pons c r e f w hi h he w a a r t ha g or c s r esed, t ei no ba i f a c am ofmalcouspr ec i a ii outofhi a r s nora ot r her s s s or ny l i ii os uton rsng s ret ny he c ogni a e c tt i z bl ons iutonalc a m . ç ti wel s tl d unde V igi a 1 w t tc i i lco c i n l i ç s l e te l r r ni a ha r m na nvi to esa i he ,w iho t ne s iy ofot rpr ,t e s e e oft el m e ofpr bl c us t bls s t ut he ce s t he oof he xi t nc he e nt oba e a e t a r s a pr e ut whi h i ac o r e t nd os c e, c s omplt de e et a tonsf malci pr e uton, a s e e f ns o c i or i ous os c i f le ar t a de n ton. Brwse v.W oodwad& Lot op.I ,530F. 1 6,1 7( C. r res, nd f mai ' e tr ' r hr nc. 2d 01 01 D. Ci. 1 ;J nne v. ln' De .St e, F. 976) a v Ara s pt or 247 Supp.306,308( . Va.1 ) Ri tsv. G. W D. 965 ; cket J. M c or Co. 1 Va. 554,1 S. 91 91 ( 924) cr v , 38 548, 21 E. 6, 8 1 . I l. A dki ne c pl ns t tM c l hln s e ns xt om ai ha G ot i om how vi a ed hi c tt i lrght by no ol t s ons iutona i s t i si tngcli ofpej ybywine s a ti sc nvetgai ams rur t ses t ral onduce durngt prc ngdec dei td i he e edi a n s a e and f de alc t A dki hasno c tt i lr ghtac i bl unde Bi nst r uie a tt e r our . ns ons iutona i tona e r ve o eq r De y Unie Stt M a s t i tgae a purueAdki 'cai st tW as ng on Co y put t d a es r hal o nvesi t nd s ns l m ha hi t unt She if sD e y La r M oor a ot r le unde oa h i e r i rt i s A dki obvi usy rf put r y e nd he s i d r t n a le ral . ns o l bele st thewa m onge by f le ive ha s d as hoodshecon e we epe er t i t ec t by t nds r m taed n hos ours M oor a o he s Butt r i no bas si t 1 w f A dki t brng a l w s ta ns e nd t r . he e s i n he a or ns o i a ui gai t M c l hln f notpr s ng A dki 'cl i s G ot i or es i ns a m . 1 11. Fi l A dki cl m s t thi r ght ha bee vi a ed be us M cGl hln c m e on naly, ns ai ha s i s ve n ol t ca e ot i n A dki z ope t l f hi busnes ca d,a t r fe di notr t n A dki z e e ns pr r y, e t s i s r nd he ea t r d e ur nst l phone c l A s als. t M a sr t J he gi ta e udge a l not d,t e f c sdo nots pty e hes a t uppor a c tt i lvi a i l t ny ons iutona ol ton. n s t t r ca beno a tonabl cvi rg scli a ns M c ot i t onl de e nti t s hor,he e n ci e i l i ht am gai t Gl hln, he y f nda n hi ca e,a t sc em us be dim is s nd hi as t s s ed. lV . Ad i h sfld awrte o j cint teRe o t n Re o n ain, c tec u t kns a ie itn be to o h p r a d c mme d t whih h o r o h srviwe l i ce rfo t eo j cinta Ad n p icpal i c n en d wihalg dy a e e d. t s la r m h b e to h t kis rn i ly s o c r e t le e l f s t tmony fom M oor a ot r a til hel i sa eand f de a cour m or t n ade de ale esi r e nd he s t ra s d n tt e rl t e ha ca a o I d e Ad i akst i c u tor s o dt t q sinso t els p g o hso jcin, g . n e d, kns s h s o r t e p n o wo ueto n h at a e f i be to ea h ofwhi h c c c once st ve iy oft si o t ke i ti l c m he rt e tm ny a n n ra s onduct l ago. Butt c t ed ong he our h sn a ii n rfa ky a yj rs ito t a s rt o eq eto sa t e ha en t iga al a o b ly, o r n l n u idcin,o n we h s u si n s h y v o hn t l t t do wiht def nda i t sca e W oodr M c ot i nort c am sr ie a i thi i o t he e nt n hi s , ow Gl hln, he l i a s d gans m n t c s pe ng be or t c t Si yput as ta i tM cGl hln ca pr deno r medy he a e ndi f e he our. mpl , ui gans ot i n ovi e t Adki f t wr o ns or he ongshecli soc ur e a o he ïha i ot rca e ye r ago.A st r i am c r d t t r nds n he s s a s he e s no a tona ec tt i lvi a i alege i t sc s ,i mus be dim is c i bl onsiutona olton l d n hi a e t t s s ed. A n Or ra de doptng t R e ta Re om m e ton i isen iel a di m i s ng t s i he por nd c nda i n t tr y nd s s i hi a to wihp eudc wil ee tr dti d y cin t rj ie l b n ee h s a . E trd: /& -A. - Z 4 i2n ee @ - 4/- * / WG Mi chaelF.U r ki bans Unie St t D i ti tJ t d a es s r c udge 4