Scott v. Gutierrez et al, No. 4:2021cv01145 - Document 20 (S.D. Tex. 2022)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER GRANTING 14 MOTION to Seal, DISMISSING with prejudice 1 Complaint. Email sent to Manager of Three Strikes List. (Signed by Judge Sim Lake) Parties notified.(rkonieczny, 4)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Scott v. Gutierrez et al Doc. 20 Case 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 1 of 8 United States District Court Southern District of Texas ENTERED January 10, 2022 %*Q /$!Q 0*%/! Q ./ /!.Q %./-% /Q +0-/Q "+-Q /$!Q .+0/$!-*Q %./-% /Q +"Q /!2 .Q $+0./+*Q %1%.%+*Q '!1%*Q ! -(Q . +// Q / &Q Q ,>4<@H<99 Q J Q 1% Q #0/%!--!3 Q 8HQ 4> Q 898@74@HG Q Nathan Ochsner, Clerk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ockets.Justia.com Case 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 2 of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ase 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 3 of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ase 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 4 of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ase 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 5 of 8 F72O 1242>1.>FEO 7.H2O H9@<.F21O 79EO D967FO F@O 1G2O AD@02EEO .>1O 2CG.<O AD@F20F9@> (0@FFO E22;EO 120<.D.F@DKO .>1O 9>:G>0F9H2O D2<924O 4D@=O F72O .1H2DE2O 1209E9@>O F7.FO 12>921O 79=O 2.D<KO D2<2.E2O .>1O 7.EO D2EG<F21O 9>O 79EO 0@>F9>G21O 9>0.D02D.F9@> (0@FF EO .<<26.F9@>E O I7907O 0.<<O 9>F@O CG2EF9@>O F72O H.<919FKO @4O .>O .1H2DE2O 1209E9@>O D2>12D21O /KO F72O '.D@<2O @.D1O @>O &.D07O O O 4.9<O F@O EF.F2O .O 0<.9=O G>12DO O * ( O NO O *>12DO F72O DG<2O 9>O "20;O H O "G=B7D2L O O ( O F O O O O .O 09H9<O D967FEO A<.9>F944O 0.>>@FO @/F.9>O =@>2KO 1.=.62EO /.E21O @>O .<<26.F9@>EO @4O G>0@>EF9FGF9@>.<O 0@>H90F9@>O @DO 9=AD9E@>=2>F O @DO 5@DO @F72DO 7.D=O 0.GE21O /KO .0F9@>EO I7@E2O G><.I4G<>2EEO I@G<1O D2>12DO .O 0@>H90F9@>O @DO E2>F2>02O 9>H.<91 ?O I9F7@GFO 49DEFO AD@H9>6O F7.FO F72O 07.<<2>621O 0@>H90F9@>O @DO E2>F2>02O 7.EO /22>O D2H2DE21O @>O 19D20FO .AA2.< O 2JAG>621O /KO 2J20GF9H2O @D12D O 120<.D21O 9>H.<91O /KO .O EF.F2O FD9/G>.<O .GF7@D9M21O F@O =.;2O EG07O 12F2D=9>.F9@>E O @DO 0.<<21O 9>F@O CG2EF9@>O /KO .O 5212D.<O 0@GDF EO 9EEG.>02O @5O .O ID9FO @4O 7./2.EO 0@DAGEO ,G>12D-O O * ( O NO O )72O DG<2O 9>O "20;O .AA<92EO F@O 0@=A<.9>FEO ./@GFO F72O 5.0FO @DO 1GD.F9@>O @4O A.D@<2 O (22O %9FF<2EO H O @.D1O @4O '.D1@>EO .>1O '.D@<2EO 9OH9E9@> O O ! O 1O O O O F8O 9D O O O E22O .<E@O $.0;E@>O H O +.>>@L O O ! 1O O O F7O 9D O O )72O DG<3O .<E@O #1 O .FO O O .FO O Case 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 6 of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ase 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 7 of 8 =;HHEMBa EMWPa SY?VWEPNa WC?a I;[@YHM?VVa P@a CEVa =PMWEMY?>a =PM@EM?K?NW a CEVa =H;ELVa ;T?a <;TT?>a @TPKa U?ZE?[a YM>?Ta a 9 6 " a `a a ;<V?MWa ;a VDP[EMBa XD;Wa WD?a ;>Z?TV?a >?=EVEPMa D;Va <??Na V?Wa ;VE>? a 6??a 0=(T?[a Z 7?\;Va !> a P@a 3;T>PMVa ;M>a 4;UPH?V a a ' >a a a WDa "ET a VE@a Z a 6=PWW a a ' >a a a :.a a ;Xa a WDa "ET a a YMQY<HEVD?> a a "PYUWa T?=PT>Va T?@H?=Wa WD;Wa 6=PWWa D;Va @EH?>a ;a @?>?T;Ha D;<?;Va =PTQYVa QTP=??>EMBa WPa =D;HH?MB?a 4;TPH?a !P;U> Va >?=EVEPMa XPa >?N]a DEKa ?;TH]a T?H?;V?a ATPLa QTEVPNa PMa 0;T=Da a a 6??a 6=PWWa Z a #ET?=WPT a 7#", "+$ a "EZEHa 2P a J =Z )a 2 # a 8?\ a 7Pa >;X? a DP[?Z?U a WD?T?a D;Va <??Ma MPa TYHEMBa EMa WD;Xa =;V?a ;M>a WD?a 4;TPH?a !P;T> Va >?=EVEPNa D;Va NPWa <??Na V?Wa ;VE>? a !?=;YV?a 6=PWW Va =H;EKVa ;U?a NPWa =YTT?MXH]a =PBME_;<H?a YM>?Ta a 9 6 " a ` a WDEVa ;=WEPMa LYVWa <?a >EVKEVV?>a [EWDa QT?FY>E=?a WPa <?EMB T?;VV?TW?>a ;B;EMa YMWEHa WC?a =PN>EWEPMVa EMa )?=Ga ;T?a L?X a 6??a "PPGa Z a "EW^a PAa 7^H?T a 7?\ a a ' >a a a WDa "ET a a ,PDMVPMa Z a 0=%HZ??M a a ' >a a a WDa "EU a a !;V?>a PNa WD?a @PT?BPEMB a WD?a =PYTWa ;Va APIHP[V a 7D?a 3UEVPM?T Va "EZEIa 5EBDWVa "PKQH;EMWa @EH?>a <] -?ZENa %;THa 6=PWWa $P=G?Xa &MWT]a 2P a a EVa 6=PXWa C;Va QTPZE>?>a ;a =PQ]a PAa 5?VQPM>?MW Va MV[?Ua [EXDa !TE?@a ENa 6YQQPUWa EMa 6=PWXa Z a /YKRGEN a ";YV?a 2P a =Z * a &\DE<EWa 2a WPa 3I;EOXEAA Va 6YQQH?K?NW;Ha 1$6 a $P=G?Wa &MWT]a 2P a a QQ a a Case 4:21-cv-01145 Document 20 Filed on 01/10/22 in TXSD Page 8 of 8 &.+> */83088> )5:49> (8> ( 1+ > ,57> 6:7658+8> 5,> > ' % > => - > "2(/490,, 8> %:662+3+49(2> 59/54> 95> %+(2> > 5)1+9 497<> 5 > > /8> . $ . %. $ & . &". #$"* . . "#-. " . ' %. "$ ! ). ! "!. ! . $ $. &". & . # !& . . $ . + . %". % ! . . "#-. " . & %. $ $. &". & . ! $. " . $ . &$ %. %&. &. $ &$ % &,% (% "($&% "* . . (9> 5:8954 > &+;(8 > 54> 9./8> 9.> *(<> 5,> (4:(7< > > % > > % !#> ' & > %& & %> %&$ &> ' >
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
