Walker v. Davis, No. 4:2017cv03133 - Document 21 (S.D. Tex. 2018)
Court Description: ORDER granting 19 Motion for Summary Judgment. No COA is issued. (Signed by Chief Judge Lee H Rosenthal) Parties notified.(gclair, 4)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Walker v. Davis Doc. 21 United States District Court Southern District of Texas ENTERED I TH E UN I N TED STA TE S D I STR I CO UR T CT FO R TH E SO U TH ER N DI STRI T O F TEU S C H O U STO N DI I O N V SI July 27, 2018 David J. Bradley, Clerk STEVEN D . ALK ER , W TD CJ N o. 927071 01 , Pe ii r ttone , CI L ACTI NO. 1 1 31 VI ON 1 - 7- 33 LORI DAVI Die t r E S, r c o , Te D e r m e ofCrm i lJ tc xas pa t nt i na us i e, Co r c i ll tt i D i s on, r e tona ns iutons vi i Res pondent . O R D ER G R AN TI G M O TI N FO R SU M M A R Y JUD GM EN T N O St ve D . a ker a Te s sa e pr s r brngst sha a c pusa ton unde 28 U . C. e n W l , xa t t i one , i hi be s or ci r S. jj22 and2254.W al rc l sadicplna yco ci f bei d ofplce'( 41 ke halenge s i i r nviton or ng ' out a .'DHR a t The r ponde ,Lore D a s D ie t oft Te s De rm e ofCrm i J tc m ove es nt i vi , r c or he xa pa t nt i nal us i e, s t ds s W ak rssc n cam wi prj d c b c us W ake f i dt e h u t i saec u t o imis le ' e o d li t eu ie e a e l r al o x a s h s tt-o r h e r medi a hi c am i now pr dur ly ba r d. Davi a tr tvey m ove t dim is wih e es nd s l i s oce a l r e s le nai l so s s t p eu ieb c u eW ak rscamslc me i. rj d c e a s le ' li a k rt W al r s c pl i a l gest t ke ' om a nt le ha : 1 hel c t r qui iei e t commi t dici i r ofe ebec us he was . a ked he e st nt nt o t he s plna y f ns a e una et he rt or soft c r c i ofi rduet ane ra t oa i e ton; bl o a he der he ore tonal fce o a nd hr t nf c i a nd 2. hi r g s w er vi a e due t t une s i ht e ol t d o he qual te m ent of s m ia l s t t r at i l ry iua ed of e r . f nde s Fe W rtPe . t5-7. d. i t a P. Espio e-a es' lh le,See ( l -l 3 Ore MS 72 -0 8a 4wp h cAs ïrsnrh bato 7Wak r tv n H-73 3 ) dr J -72 l 0 d l Dockets.Justia.com W ake i i c t unde t convitonands e f t t r de e f l ofdrvi l r s n usody r he ci entnce or he hid- gr e eony i ng unde t i l nc ( us Numbe 1 2488 01 339t DititCour,HarsCouny, xa ) r he ntue e. Ca e r 41 01 0, h src t ri t Te s. He r c i d a 8- arprs t l . 1 W a ke doe notc le hi c c i or s nt nc but e e ve n ye i on e' d. l r s m ha l nge s onvi ton e e e, i t a c lenge hi 201 pr s di ci i r c cton. Fed.W rtPe . 5. ns e d ha l s s 7 i on s plna y onvi i i t at O n M a 1 201 TD CJnotf e W a kert the wasc r d w ih vi a i t TD CJ CI y 7, 7, ii d l ha ha ge t ol tng he - D Dicpl a yRu e a dpr c d r s o O fn es f r en o t pa e DHR a 1 2.OnM a 1 , s i i r ls n o e u e f r fe d r ,o b ig u of lc . n ty7 201 W ake sg dt s c i oft Fi Hea i Re tsa i t thewaved hi rgh t t 7, l r i ne he e ton he nal rng por t tng ha i s i t o he 2 ho he rng no i and i ut i d t hea i ofi e t pr e wih t he rng. 1 a 1 4- ur a i tce i horze he rng fc r o oce d t he a i ' d. t . a ' Att M a 1 201 he rng,t he rng ofi rf und W al rguit ofbei outofplc Hi he y 8, 7 a i he a i fce o ke ly ng a e. s pu s e w a t l e 45 da ofr cr a i prvie ,45 da ofc m i s r prviege , nd 30 ni hm nt s o os ys e e ton i l ges ys om s a y i l s a da ofgoodtm e.1 a 1 6.W a ke s it d aSt p 1a St p 2of e rg iva ef r .The ys i d. t , l r ubm te e nd e f nde re nc o m TD CJ de e bot g i va s. 1 a 2,4. ni d h r e nce d. t W al rf l d t sf r lha as pe ii on Oc obe 13,201 1 Fe . W rtPet.at 10. The ke ie hi ede a be tton t r 7. d i rc d i l e or ncudes t Dicplna y Hea i Re d,t Dici i r Gre nc Rec d,a t he s i i r rng cor he s plna y iva e or nd he Dicplna y Hea i Audi Re di wih a ompa ng busncs r c dsafi vis a we la si i r rng o cor ng, t cc nyi i s e or fda t , s l s ac ofW al rsc mime i l s r n,wih e a tons opy ke ' om t nt nqui c ee y t xplna i . 1 . The Sum m ar Judgm e St y nt andard t mma yj me i fdea ha asi difr t ni t a a ci lcae.' r c v d su r udg nt n e rl be s feentha n he verge vi s 'To r s . Th e ,395Fe App' l ,106( hCi.201 ( tngSmihv Coc r l, 11F. 661 668( h alr d. x. 01 5t r 0) cii t . k el3 3d , 5t Ci. r 2002) abr gatd onot rgr , o e he oundsb Te dv Dr t ,542U. 27 284( y nnar . eke S. 4, 2004:.$ a i As te S tiev Can l 9F.d3 4 3 8(t Ci.1 98 (o p ro e o d tnni n tea pia lyo AEDP a s e povl . i, 4 3 7 , 7 5h r 9 ) fr up s s f ee nig h p lcbit f l i A, fd rl eio itldo ted t ii pa e i tepio mal y tm) e ea p tin s 'e n h ae t s lc d n h rs n is se . t i g n rl rn i e Rul 5 o teFe ea Rue o Cii Pr c d r , eai t s mmayj d me t e ea p i cpl, e 6 f h d r l ls f v l o e u e rltng o u r u g n , a i swihequa f cei t c e ofhabe cor c e .' ar v John on, 2 F.d 760, pple t l or n he ontxt as pus as s'Cl k . s 20 3 764 ( hCi. ) TheFe a RulsofCi l oc ea yt ha asc esonl asc it twih 5t r 2000 . derl e viPr edur ppl o be as y onssen t e tbls ha aspr c iea pr dur Se Rul 11oft Rul Gove ni Se i 2254Ca e . sa ihed be a tc nd oce e. e e he es r ng cton ss ( tonl2254()1 -whihma tst ttndi offc ma b asaec tae Seci e( ) c ndae ha i ngs a t de y tt our r ûr s me t b c re t -o erd steo dnaynl t a,nas mmayj d me t p e u d o e o rc ' v rie h r i r l h t i u r u g n e pr e di a1 dipu e f c smus be c tue i t lghtm os f vor bl t t oc e ng, 1 s t d a t t onsr d n he i t a a e o he n n vn p ry Une s g p tto e) c n te u ( 1 t e prs mpi n o o mo ig a t. ls t ei n r a r b t he i h e u to f c r c ne sby c e ra co nc ng e de e'a t t s a e oft c ts fndi or e t s l a nd nvi i vi nc s o he t t he our ' i ngs off c , he m us be a ce t a c r c . a tt y t c p ed s or e t Smih,311F. a 668. t 3d t Pl a ngsb as fr pr e e ltg nt r r viwe t ral ssrnge sa r t nt e e di y el-e es nt d ii a a e e e d mde es ti nt t nda d ha hos drfe byatr ys Se Hai v Ker , 4U. 51 520( 972)The epla ngsaee il atd tone . e nes . ner 40 S. 9, 1 . s e di r ntted t albe al onsr ton g vi a1r s bl i e e e whihc bedr wnfom t m . Hai s o i r c tuc i i ng 1 ea ona e nf r nc s c an a r he See ne , 404 U . a 5 1. k lho h t pl a ngstl d by pr s pa te ar he d t tes s rnge s a r S. t 2 l t ug he e di i e A o e r i s e l o l s t i nt t nda ds t n f m a pla ngs dr fed by l wy r , pr s pa tes mus silc pl wih t r es of ha or l e di at a e s' o e ri t tl om y t he ul p o e u ea dma ea g me t c p bl o wih tn i gs mma yj d me t'M a tnv Ha rs n r c d r n k r u n s a a e f t sa d n u r u g n . ri . rio ' Ct?z/ Jai,975F. 1 1 ( t Ci.1 )s ealo Ogbodigwuv Wack nhu Cor e ton )/7 l ,y 2d 92, 93 5h r 992) e s e . e t r ci s Cor ,202F. 265( t Ci.1 ( p. 3d 5h r 999) unpubls dtbl o nin) ihe a e pi o . Il. The ls ofExhaus on sue ti W al rc am st thel c d t r quiiei e t c ke l i ha a ke he e st nt nt o omm i t dici i r ofe ebe a e t he s plna y f ns c us hew a una et he rt or r oft c r c i of i e duet a e ra tloa i e ton, nd t t s bl o a he de s he or e tonal f c r o n a nd lr t nf c i a ha hi rght weevi ae byt uneq lte t ntofsmial st tdofe r.( d.W rtPe.a s i s r oltd he ua r ame i lry iuae fndes Fe i t t 5 .An i t c l ng a prs dici i r c cton mus e us hi a nitai -7) nmae halengi ion s plnay onvi i t xha t s dmi srtve rme isb f r tl gaf d r lj2 4 p tto Le mav Esel, 8 F.d 1 7 1 9 (t Ci. e d e eo e si n e ea 25 eiin. r . tle 5 5 2 29 , 2 9 5h r 1 ) Br s d v.Wal r 91 F. 978 ) ous ar ke , 8 supp.1 040,1 ( D.Te 1 ) Exha ton rquie 043 E. x. 996 . usi e r s f l ngt TDCJi ena gre ncepr e es i a 1 (ii Gartelv.Ga or 981F. olowi he ntr l iva oc dur ,d. t 043 ctng r l yl , 2d 254,258n.3)(t Ci.1 ) A peii rmus pr s nthi cli a or ngt t pr durl 5h r 993). ttone t e e s ams cc di o he oce a r esoft a nitai bod Casil v Peo e , U. 3 351( 989) TheTDCJgre nc ul he dmi srtve y. tle . pls 489 S. 46, 1 . iva e pr edu ehast se t tapeiine mus e us.Wal rv oc r wo tps ha tto r t xha t ke .Wale ,385F. 5 515( t kr 3d 03, 5h Ci. 4)( tng Wrghtv Holigs t 260F. 357,358( h Ci.2001) Eve i acai i r 200 cii i . ln worh, 3d 5t r ). n f l m s u e ha se ,h c u t yd n io t meis 2 U. C. 22 4 b 4 ) W et 01 ) Me c d l . n x u td t e o rma e y t n he rt. 8 S. j 5 ( )2 ( s 2 8 ; r a e v Cai 179F. 271 276-78( t Ci.1 . n, 3d , 5h r 999) W ake f ie t m e i hi s ondcli i et rofhi gre nc f l r al d o nton s ec am n ihe s i va e onns DGR a 1 He . t -4. di not c pl w ih t TD CJ S i e nalgr e nc pr edur as t t s cond c a m ,whi h i d om y t he ' nt r i va e oc e o he e li c s u e h use . Dimis lma be wih p eu ie h we e ,b c u e t cam i p o e u al n x a td s sa y t rj dc , o v r e a s he li s r c d rl y def uled. Any s e nte f .t e us t sc am wo d be un i ey. Eve i W ake we e a t ubs que fol o xha t hi l i t ul tm l z nf l r r t pr e t s c ai t t Te s Co tofCr m i lA ppe l i a s a e ha a a plc ton, twoul o es nt hi l m o he xa ur i na a s n t t be s p i a i i d be di m i s d be a e pr s di c plna y cha l nge ca s s e c us i on s i i r le s nnotbe r vi w e o s a e ha as Se Ex e e d n t t be . e pareBr ge , S. . 46( x. i App.1 (heTexa Cour ofCrmi Appe l wil t a r 704 W 2d Te Crm. 986) t s t i nal as lnot rviw c le t prs dicplna yaci i asaeha asa iaton) e e halnges o ion s i i r tons n tt be pplc i . The r cor pr desno bas st c ude t tW al r sf iur t exha t sa i s r tve e d ovi i o oncl ha ke ' a l e o us hi dm ni ta i r m e eswasdue t S abs e ofa ia e St t co r c i pr es s' t an i f e tve p oc s e di oi an enc va l bl a e r e tve oc s ' or o ne f c i r e s lopr ec t rg soft a ia .28U. C. 2254( ( )B)i& (i ( es 201 .W ake ha s ot the iht he pplc nt' t ' S. j b)l( () i) W t 8) l r s Z - D, ye d rOre tto Ha d o k<h :- . c.tt. u/o u nsofe d rOre tt n Ha d o k TDCJCI O n e inain n b o e / / t jsaeW.sd c me t/ fn e inai n b o d o En ih.db a 7 - 5 ( sa ls n t a o f n e sh v fhe n d ysfo t ed t o t e icd n t r ie ase - n gl p t t 3 7 e t b ihig h t fe d r a e i e a r m h a e f h n ie t o a s tp o e s g iv n e a dtfend y fo ad na o ase o egiv n et fl ase t g iv n e. re a c , n 'te a s rm e il f tp-n re a c o ie tp-wo re a c ) i n td mo tae a a e u t c u ef rt ed f ut o t th wa a t al p eu ie Sat v o e nsrtd n d q ae a s o h e a l, r ha e s cu ly rj d c d. t e . Fule ,11F. 61 62( hCi.1 ;Wale v. n, 5F. 48 494( hCi. lr 3d , 5t r 994) k r Cai 21 3d 9, 5t r 2000) W ake' ; l rs sc ndcam i u e ha se a dpr c d r l b re , n i i d s se wihp eu ie e o li s n x u td n o e u al ar d a d t s imis d t rj dc . y 111 . The Is of a D ue Process V i aton sue ol i W ake ' dicplna y c s r ule i hi l i 45 da of r c e ton, 45 da of l r s s i i r a e es t d n m osng ys e r ai ys c mmis r , n 3 d yso g o tme S-l eDu Pr c s Clu ed e n t r tc e ey c a g o say a d 0 a f o d i .ilh e o e s a s o s o p o e t v l h n e gi t c tonsofc i entha ng a s t nta a n he ondii onfnem vi ubs a i l dver e i pa t on t pr s r ' Sandi v s m c he ione . ' n . Conne ,515U. 472,478( 995 .l i t qua iyoftmesr edt tce tsalbe t i ees, r S. 1 ) t s he ntt i e v ha rae i ry ntr t r t rt n t qua iy oftm e s r d. a he ha he lt i e ve Sandi 515U . a 483-84; adi v Par r 1 F. d 765, n, S. t M son . ke , 04 3 7 ( h Ci.1 7) Toi i t duepr es bas ont quaiyoft tmes r e rquie t 67 5t r 99 . mplcae oc s ed he lt he i e v d e rs he i aet s nm t o how a daypi a a sgnii a ha ds p i r a i t t or na yi i t ofprs n tt c l nd i fc nt r hi n elton o he di r ncden s ion lf ' Sandi 51 U. a 48 Thel sofr cr a i andco m is r prvie i nota C t ca ie. ' n, 5 S. t 4. os e e ton m s a y i lges s n s ypi l a a d sg iia th r s p. S e i Th s l se ae ç ha g si te c n i o so g ak rs n in fc n ad hi ' e d. e e o s s r s n e n h o dt n f W l e') ' c i c i me 't té noti i t duepr e sc ens' Madion,1 F. a 768(osng onfne nt'ha s do mplcae oc s onc r . 'See s 04 3d t li 30 da ofc ys ommis y a 30 daysofc l r titonsdo noti i t duepr e s;s e alo sar nd el esrci mplcae oc s) e s Sandi 51 U. a 486(dmi srtvesgrgatondoesnoti iaealberyi ee t)W al rs n, 5 S. t a nitai e e i mplc t i t ntrs. ke ' cli t thi duepr s rg swer vi aedb t l sofhe eda of e r to a c a m ha s oce s i ht e ol t y he os t s ys r c eai n nd omm is r s ay p iie e i ds se , t p eu ie rvlg s s imis d wi rj d c . h T he I ssue ofG ood- m e R evocaton Ti i W a ke ' l sof3 da ofgood-i ec e tdoe i plca e albe t i e es .Se Te Gov' l r s os 0 ys tm r di s m i t i ry nt r t e x. t Codejj508.47,508.49( es 201 ; e Exhi tA; 1 1 W t 3)s e bi DHR a 1, Tos t t wa de i d t 8. how ha he s prve o duepr e sbyt spunihm e , ake f oc s hi s nt W l rmus s t how t tt c nduc oft dicplna ypr ee ng ha he o t he s i i r oc di PTAssroehb ato 'Wak rSe n( l- I3 Ore MS 72 -0I a4wp - 5Ehinrae sz lT le tve H-73 3 ) d r J -72 8 0 d ps h - di notme tduepr es r uie e s 418U. a 556 d e oc s eq r m nt. S. t -70.Thes r quie nt a et tt i ae e e r me s r ha he nm t be prvi d: 1 ad nc wrte notc oft dicplnay c r ;2)a opporuniy t cal o de ) va e itn ie he si i r hages n t t o l w ine s a pr e doc e s w he i i not undul ha r t s es nd es nt um nt n ts y za dous t i tt i o ns iutonal s f t a a e y nd coreci lg l;a 3)a wrte sae ntb t fc-i roft evi ncer i onandt r tona oas nd itn ttme y he a tfnde he de eled he r a o f rt ed s il r a to 1 a 5 3 6 e s ns o h icpi y cin. d. t 6 - 7.Theimaemus s w p eu iefo a yd e na n t t ho rj dc r m n u pr e svilton.Se Jaco'nv Cai 8 F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1989 . oc s oai e l o . n, 64 2d 235, 251 5t r ) The r or s st tW a ke r e ve wrt e no i e ofhi di ci i r c r s a oft ec d how ha l r ec i d it n t c s s plna y ha ge nd he hea i on M a c 1 201 a 2: p. .Alhough W a ke sg d o t ts daea wai dhi rng r h 7, 7, t 55 m t l r ine n ha ame t nd ve s r g t t 24i ht o he hournotc bef e t he r ng,DH R a l t he rng w a hel on M a 1 201 i e or he a i t , he a i s d y 8, 7. D H R at l D H A .W al r was i or ed of hi r g t c l a ques i w ine s a pr s nt ; ke nf m s i ht o al nd ton t s es nd e e d m e a y e de e,a hehad t opporu t t do s a hi hea i DHR a 1 4,6;DHA. ocu nt r vi nc nd he tniy o o t s rng. t , W ake sgnedadoc nta trt he rng i t s ton lbeld kofe rSi t ef Re i l ri ume fe he a i n he eci a e l f nde gnaur or cept ofFi Re t'sa i hehadr eve t TDCJDicplna yRe t Hea i Re or DHR nal por, ttng ' ec i d he s i i r por and rng c d. a l TheRe ts toutt e de r le u n a t r as f t dicplnay a ton.DHR t. por e he vi nce ei d po nd he e ons or he s i i l c i a 1.Ther c d s t e or howst tW a ke r cevedt pr s hewa due. ha l r e i he oce s s Fi ly, ake ' c l nge t t me isa eund r i dbyt e r whi hde o ta e nal W l rs hale s o he rt r e m ne her co d, c m nsr t s t tt r wa s ee de t uphol t fndi ofg l.The Supr ha he e s om vi nce o d he i ng uit eme Cour ha hel t td t s d ha ue pr es i s tss d i a prs dici i r c ci n i s oc s s aite f ion s plna y onvito s uppore by d ome e de e. td t s vi nc ' ' Su i e perntndent Mas .Cor .I t .Hil 47 U. 445,455 6 ( 985) The S o e de e' , s r ns.v l, 2 S. -5 1 . t me vi nc ' s s a r i l sexa tng t n t pr ponde a e oft e de e s a r r rng o y t tt t nda d s es c i ha he e r nc he vi nc t nda d, equii nl ha he de s on notbe a bir r orwihouts ppor i t r c d. il 472 U . at cii r ta y t u t n he e or H l, S. 457.Thehea i ofi e rng t c r ba e hi fndi of guit on t cha gi of i e ' t s i ony a O f e e Re t D H R at 1 6; s d s i ng l he r ng f c r s e tm nd f ns por . , DHA . c r ng ofi e e a ne i de a lho he dee mi d t tW ake wa outofplce. The ha gi fc r xpli d n t i w tr ne ha l r s a DHA ;DHR a 1 5 W akerwa r pr s nt i t dici i r he i t ough a c t -2, -6. l s e e e ed n he s plna y arng hr ouns l e s tt e who ha t o ubsiut , d he pporuniy t c os - xa i t c r ngofi e .TheDHO r viwe t t t o r s e m ne he ha gi fc r e e d he e de e a c ude t tW al r ha be outofpl ce ascha ge D HA ;DH R a 1 6. Thi vi nc nd oncl d ha ke d en a r d. t , s r c d,w ih t cha gi of i r st s i ony, t nse e or t he r ng fce ' e tm con ai noug f c st s h a t o uppor t fndi ofguit t he i ng l. W al rcon e t thel c t i e t c ke t nds ha a ked he ntnt o omm i t dicplna y ofe ebe a ea e r t he s i i r f ns c us n a a t oa i e ton madehi una et he rt c r ci lofi ersor r .Fed.W rtPe . t6. nd hr t nf ci m bl o a he or e tona fc ' de s i ta W al r s cl i f isbe aus i e i no a e e e oft di c plna y of e e ofbei û of ke ' a m a l c e nt nt s t n l m nt he s i i r f ns ng k out plc . TDCJ CI Dic ia y Rue a d Pr c du e o O fn es a 3 ;s eAv l n d v a e' ' - D, s èl r ls n o e r sf r fe d r t 8 e el e a . n a Qu tr No. V. V- 1 2008W L 21 are man, CI A. 07- 9, 68346,a * ( D.Te M a 23, ) toutof t 4-5 S. x. y 2008 .s Pl ce 'i de i a t I a una hor z a e s a a c l or w i t w hi h one i no a ' s fned s: d n ny a. ut i ed r a, uch s el ng o c s t a sg s i ned;orb. iur t bea a de i t d a eaa as cii tm e, orexa e,he ofe rhas Fa l e o t sgna e r t pe fed i f mpl t f nde a l y-n f am e c la a i or di a ppoi m e , tg t t lbr r i t a ' TD CJ CI ,lk d ix , nt nt bu oes o he i a y ns e d. ' - D Lv pl n Roc , t Ae Gxr e l h :œ <m / / . c. a. d e ioFe d rœ e ué n Hrd o - si . t j tk. e œr n ds n e- n o - Y k En s e h a 38. Ofe eRe r sa est tW al rwaso ofplc afe beng or r d ba k t hi c l o t The f ns po t tt ha ke ut a e tr i de e c o s elf r S a up' an k pe ilc t' DHR a.2. W ake was t tofplc 'whe he r mane i an t ck ' d t ca oun . r s ' t l r i ou a e' n e i d n t t ie a e a trhewaso d r dba kt li c l f ras ca c mt DHR a 2.Thehe rngofi r mauhorz d r a fe r e e c o ls el o pe il ot . t a i fce f t t tt r wass tc e te de et s por t c nviton,a t r c r s rst tr s t o md ha he e ufi i n vi nc o up t he o ci nd he e o d uppo t ha e ul. W al ra s cl i savi a i ofhi e l ot c i r gh .A pe ii ra s ri t sc a m ke l o a m ol ton s qua pr e ton i t ttone s e tng hi l i m us s t how t tpr s of i a s ac e w ih a S s r m i t y pum os ' a ç e t d t o or m or ha i on fci l t d t s c i na or di e ' nd û a e w cr e ca sfc tonsofsmial st ed prs r t twee te ed difrnty,...a ( t tt lsiiai i lry iuat iones ha r rat fee l nd 2) ha he ca sfc t nh dnor to a rlto t a ylg t t g v n ntl b e tv . S ea f . y lsiiai a o ain l eai n o n e ii e o e une a o j ci e' tf nofv Ha s ma ' PSAEsroehba oo! k r See ( (- I3 Ore MS.-72 l a 4wp - 7c sspinra es PWklrz tv n H-73 3 ) dr J72 -0 8 O . d s - Count 1 F. 523,5 ( hCi.1 ) Woo v.Edwar ,51F.d 577,580 (t Ci.1 ) y, 54 3d 27 5t r 998 ; ds ds 3 5h r 995 . é i c i i or pu pos ... m ple t tt de i i m a rs l t a pa tc a co s ofa ton i s r m nat y r e D i i s ha he c s on ke e ec ed r i ul r ur e c i a l a t i pr t be us of a not s m pl i s t of t adve s i pac i woul ha on a t e s n a ca e , nd i y n pie , he re m t t d ve n i ntfa egr p.' tdst esv Galowa 951F. 64, (t Ci.1 .W ake ague t t de iibl ou 'Unie at . l y, 2d 65 5h r 992) l r r s ha ot ri aeswho we e c r wih t s m e o smia di cplna y ofe esr c ve dif e he nm t r ha ged t he a r i lr s i i r f ns e ei d fer nt punihmen ,i t y we e punihe a al. Fed.W rt Pe .W hie W a ke ha m a e s t f he r s d t l i t l l r s de ondus y or a lga i t tot rsm ia l st t d i aeswe e punihed dif r nty,he hasnota lge or le tons ha he i lry iua e nm t r s fe e l le d i n ii d r or e de e t tw oul s de tf e ec d vi nc ha d uppor a i e e t tpr s of i al f t n nf r nce ha i on fci s ound hi g ly m uit be us ofpup os f dic i i to ori pe m isbl m otve. Norhas he s ca e e ul s rm nai n m r si e i hown t the was ha c ce wih i ufi i nte de ort thi punihme vi a e due pr es . Thi cai i onvi td t ns fc e vi nce ha s s nt olt d oc s s lm s di m i s d. s se V. C oncl i us on Themo inf rs mmayj d me t sg a td. n l u g n i e trdb sp rt od r to o u r u g n i rn e Fia j d me t s n ee y e a ae r e . No c rii t ofa albiiy i i s be a e W ake doe notm e tt r quieme s e tfcae ppe a lt s s ued c us l r s e he e r nt . SI ED on J y 27, 8, tH ous on,Te s GN ul 201 a t xa . Lee H .Ros hal ent Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ e t d a e s rc udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
