JOHNSON v. PALMS ASSOCIATES, LLC et al, No. 1:2020cv01049 - Document 70 (M.D.N.C. 2023)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER signed by JUDGE WILLIAM L. OSTEEN, JR. on 08/16/2023, that Plaintiff's Unopposed Motion for Final Approval of Class Action Settlement, for Award of Attorneys' Fees and Expenses , and for Service Award to Class Representative, (Doc. 63 ), is GRANTED, and the Class Action Settlement is Approved. FURTHER ORDERED that payment of attorney's fees in the amount of $112,000 to Class Counsel is approved, and Class Coun sel shall be paid $112,000 in the manner set forth in the Settlement Agreement. FURTHER ORDERED that payment of expenses in the amount of $3,725.77 to Class Counsel for reimbursement is approved and shall be paid as set forth in the Set tlement Agreement. FURTHER ORDERED Jessica Johnson shall be paid a service award of $2,500 as set forth in the Settlement Agreement. FURTHER ORDERED that the Claims Administrator is awarded its expenses and those expenses shall be paid as set forth in the Settlement Agreement. FURTHER ORDERED that funds remaining in the Cash Fund more than six months after checks are mailed to class members shall be distributed as set forth in the Settlement Agreement. FURTHER ORDERED that this court re tains jurisdiction over this case for purposes of resolving any issues pertaining to settlement administration. FURTHER ORDERED that the above-captioned action is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. A Judgment is filed contemporaneously herewith. (Taylor, Abby)

Download PDF
JOHNSON v. PALMS ASSOCIATES, LLC et al Doc. 70 ÿ 12ÿ345ÿ621357ÿ839358ÿ7183 1 3ÿ 6 3ÿ ÿ ÿ345ÿ 177 5ÿ7183 1 3ÿ ÿ2 34ÿ 9 129ÿ ÿ ÿ 5881 9ÿ 428 2 ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ " ÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿ # ÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿ $%ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿ&'()*+$*&),-ÿ ÿÿ ÿ #9 8ÿ988 19358 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿ 76 49 ÿ 5.8 ÿ ÿ /0/ ÿ76 49 ÿÿÿ ÿ 85 31 2ÿ&ÿ988 19358 ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿÿ ÿ 7 %ÿÿ ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 1213456781ÿ3:;6;36ÿ567ÿ34724ÿ 3<=226>ÿ?4@>ÿ7ABCDAECÿ?FGHIÿÿÿ ÿ J ÿ ÿKLMNOÿQRÿSTUQVOQWWXRÿYVLZZLR[\ÿ]LOQLVÿ ÿ ÿ9^^ $ ÿ ÿ ÿ9+ ÿ8 ÿ ÿ9_ ÿ ÿ `OOLNV[aRXÿb[[Rÿ ÿ5c^ ÿ ÿ ÿ8 $ + ÿ9_ ÿ ÿ ÿ ^ $ %ÿd7 +%ÿef% ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ gLMNOÿhQTTÿiNUVOÿSTUQVOQWWXRÿjLOQL %ÿ ;@ÿ l5mno43867ÿ 5@ÿ pqECFqrÿqsGÿ:DtEIGFDqrÿuABCtDvÿ 3 ÿ ÿ_ ÿ w !ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿx ÿ " ÿ ÿ " + ÿ8"^ ÿ " ÿ7 $ ÿ " !ÿ ÿ7" ÿ2 ÿ ÿ !ÿ# ÿ + ÿ ÿ_ ÿ "w ÿ ÿ^" $ ÿ + ÿ + ÿ w ÿ7 ÿ# ÿ9 + ÿ ÿ ÿ7" ÿ _ ÿ ÿ /0/ ÿ7" ÿ8 + ÿ1ÿ9 + %ÿd7 +%ÿ&*&ÿ ÿ& ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 1 of 16 Dockets.Justia.com 345ÿ6789 9 ÿ877 ÿ 8 ÿ 8 ÿ 78 77 ÿ 8 ÿ 9 9 0 78 ÿ ÿ8 ÿ 78 77 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ 9 9 0 78 ÿ ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ7 ÿ 9 ÿ 78 77 ÿ 9 ÿ 9 ÿ 8 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ 9 ÿ8 ÿ 9 9 ÿ8 9 ÿ 8 ÿ 97 4ÿ 4ÿ8 ÿ3 !ÿ" #45ÿ6789 9 ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ8 ÿ 78 8 ÿ 79 ÿ ÿ 9 78 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ $ ÿ%8 79 8ÿ& 9 987ÿ& 87ÿ' ÿ' !ÿ$ ÿ%8 79 8ÿ ÿ% 77 9 ÿ' !ÿ8 ÿ$ ÿ%8 79 8ÿ( 89 ÿ8 ÿ 9 ÿ ) 8 ÿ6 8 9 ÿ' 4ÿ 4ÿ8 ÿ** * 45ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ 87ÿ !ÿ 4ÿ*5!ÿ 8 ÿ8 ÿ6+,-./-0012ÿ4567+,-./!ÿ 4ÿ*254ÿ6789 9 ÿ 8 7 ÿ 97 ÿ8ÿ9 9 ÿ ÿ68 987ÿ: ÿ ÿ ÿ 67 8 9 4ÿ 4ÿ*#45ÿ) ÿ 8 9 ÿ87 ÿ 97 ÿ8ÿ: 9 ÿ9 9 ÿ ÿ 2/,;ÿ7<.=-.>ÿ=</<?6-.,/-5.ÿ50ÿ@+,-./-0012ÿA5/-5.ÿ05?ÿ@,?/-,+ÿ :B=>6<./ÿ5.ÿ/C<ÿ@+<,=-.>2ÿ,.=ÿD<0<.=,./21ÿ05?/C456-.>ÿA5/-5.ÿ05?ÿ 68 987ÿ: ÿ ÿ ÿ67 8 9 4ÿ 4ÿ3E45ÿ) 9 ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ @+,-./-0012ÿA5/-5.ÿ05?ÿFB=>6<./ÿ5.ÿ/C<ÿ@+<,=-.>2ÿ,.=ÿD<0<.=,./21ÿ 9 9 ÿ ÿG 8 4ÿ 4ÿ3H45ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ 97 ÿ8ÿ9 9 ÿ ÿ : ÿ ÿ ÿ67 8 9 4ÿ 4ÿ3I45ÿ' ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ 8 ÿ 77 ÿ 9 !ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ9 ÿ8ÿ 8 ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ J5B?/CÿK-?4B-/12ÿ=<4-2-5.ÿ-.ÿL8 ÿ 4ÿM 9 9 ÿ9 4ÿ% 4ÿ 4ÿN345ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 2 of 16 345678ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 5 6 ÿ 78 8 ÿ67ÿ 7 6 ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ ÿ! !" ÿ ÿ # ÿ $ÿ ÿ%& 'ÿ "ÿ()ÿ ÿ! * & "ÿ# " !+ÿ,- !! ÿ "ÿ. ÿ/ ÿ 0 & +ÿ,0 &+ÿ12023ÿ44ÿ25677+3ÿ8 ÿ ÿ# !ÿ" "ÿ ÿ! 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ# " 'ÿ$ : ÿ ÿ# " 'ÿ ÿ* ! ÿ& ; "ÿ " &; ÿ "ÿ; # )ÿ ! "ÿ ÿ ÿ< # ÿ% ! # +ÿ ,="+ÿ44ÿ7>677+3ÿ ? ÿ& ;! ÿ*! # ! )ÿ **! 9 "ÿ ÿ< # ÿ% ! # 'ÿ *! * "ÿ & ÿ* 'ÿ "ÿ ÿ< # ÿ@ +ÿ,0 &+ÿ17+3ÿ A;! ; ÿ ÿ ÿ* ÿ **! 9 "ÿ()ÿ ÿ& ;! 'ÿ & ÿ: ÿ " # "ÿ ÿ ÿ& +ÿ? ÿB!" !ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ" " ÿ $ÿ %*! ÿ2C'ÿ7>72ÿ ÿ * ÿ ; ÿ !ÿ (D & ÿ ÿ ÿ # +ÿ,="+ÿ ÿ22+3ÿE ÿ ÿ ÿ * "ÿ ; ÿ $ÿ ÿ # 'ÿ "ÿ ÿ < # ÿ@ ÿ. #( !ÿ ÿ (D & "ÿ ÿ ÿ # 'ÿ ÿ *! * "ÿ : !"ÿ $ÿ$ ÿ "ÿ F* ÿ ÿ@ ÿ@ ; 'ÿ !ÿ ÿ *! * "ÿ !9 & ÿ : !"ÿ ÿ ÿ& ÿ! *! 9 +ÿ,- !! ÿ "ÿ . ÿ/ ÿ0 & +ÿ,0 &+ÿ12023ÿ4ÿC>+3ÿÿ GHÿ JKLLMKNKOLÿQKRNSÿ ? ÿ< # ÿ% ! # ÿ*! 9 " ÿ# !)ÿ! $ÿ $ÿ T5UV'57U+22'ÿ: & ÿ ÿ& #* "ÿ $ÿ ÿ@ ÿW; "ÿ $ÿT77X'>>>+>>'ÿ "ÿ0 ( ÿY $ÿ $ÿ **! F # )ÿT1XC'57U+22+ÿ,="+ÿ4ÿ2>+3ÿZ & ÿ < # ÿ@ ÿ# #( !ÿ ÿ ÿ# #( !ÿ $ÿ ÿ !ÿ : ÿ& +ÿÿ [\MMK]L^\Oÿ_KLLKRÿ[M`SSaÿ% ÿ ;! ÿ* ! ÿ: ÿ , 3ÿ ÿ )ÿ* ÿ( : ÿB& ( !ÿU'ÿ7>21ÿ "ÿ/; ÿ7X'ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 3 of 16 34567ÿ89 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ ! ÿ ÿ ÿ" #ÿÿ ÿ $%&'(&)*ÿ,--ÿ./0112ÿ3 ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ8 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ5 9 ÿ67ÿ3457ÿ ÿ84 ÿ397ÿ34567ÿ 89 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ ÿ8 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ8 ÿ ÿ:! ÿ; #ÿÿ ÿ 8< #ÿ=ÿ>5# ÿ ÿ" ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ ! ÿ?39ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ4 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ?69#ÿ 8< #ÿ=ÿ>3# ÿ@ ÿ ÿ; ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ?547444#44ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ;4 7ÿ ÿ ÿ4 ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ:! ÿ; ÿ #ÿ8< #ÿ=ÿ>># ÿ:! ÿ; ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ÿ ÿ?5A4#44ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 49B ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ ÿ" ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ #ÿ8< #ÿ=ÿ>9C>6# ÿ:! ÿ ; ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ" ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ9 #ÿ ÿ @ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿD ÿE ÿ ÿ 9 ÿF ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ9 ÿ ÿ ÿ #ÿ@ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿE ÿ3 ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ 4 ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ D 9 ÿ ÿ #ÿ8< #ÿ=ÿ>6# ÿÿÿ G ÿ ÿ 7ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ9 ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ #ÿ 4 0 ! ÿ ÿ ÿ H ÿ ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 4 of 16 3456784ÿ9 95 ÿ 5ÿ 4ÿ 933ÿ 4 5434 9 764ÿ 7 ÿ 4ÿ 97 ÿ ÿ 4 4 9 3ÿ ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 93 ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ2 0 ÿ9 ÿ ÿÿ !!"ÿ $%$&'(!(ÿ $"ÿ $**+,-./ÿ,0ÿ1/.22ÿ%,3456ÿ 7 4ÿ84 494 ÿ 93343ÿ 964ÿ 44 ÿ 7 74 ÿ ÿ 4ÿ34 494 ÿ 53 9 ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 9 ÿ9 5 64 ÿ ÿ 73ÿ8 5 ÿ: 45ÿ 967 ;ÿ 54674 4 ÿ 4ÿ< 3 0= 784ÿ 48 959 7 3ÿ ÿ 4ÿ84 494 ÿ : 97 73 59 5>ÿ ? 54 @9 ÿ 48 ÿ 8 ÿ A0B >ÿ 78 ÿ 93ÿ 543 37 4ÿ 5ÿ8955 7 ;ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 784ÿ 5 ;599>ÿ 73ÿ8 5 ÿ 454 ÿ 7 3ÿ 9 ÿ 4ÿ 784ÿ 93ÿ988 9 73 4 ÿ7 ÿ988 5 9 84ÿ 7 ÿ 73ÿ8CDEFGHÿ 57 5ÿJ5 45 ÿ7 73ÿ8 5 ÿ 5 45ÿ 7 3ÿ 9 ÿ 4ÿ 784ÿ 5 ;599ÿ8 3 7 4 ÿ 4ÿ 43 ÿ 598 789 4ÿ 784ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 84 494 ÿ 93343ÿ 45ÿ 4ÿ8758 93 9 843ÿ9 ÿ ÿ39 73 743ÿ 4ÿ54K 75494 3ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 5 8433>ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ 76 ÿ< ÿBA>ÿ9 ÿBLÿ M 8 ÿNÿ O 2 ÿ P"ÿ $**+,-./ÿ,0ÿ3Q6ÿ(633/6R6S3ÿ 7 73ÿ8CDEFÿTUVWHÿFXYFÿFXZÿ[YEFUZHGÿHZFF\Z]ZVFÿUHÿTYUE^ÿ 5493 9 4ÿ9 ÿ9 4K 9 4ÿ7 ÿ988 5 9 84ÿ 7 ÿ 4ÿBA_ÿ 93ÿ5498 4 ÿ YFÿYE]GHÿ\ZV`FXÿaUFXCDFÿbC\\DHUCVÿCEÿTEYDWcÿYVWÿHYFUHTUZHÿY\\ÿCTÿ 4ÿ54K 75494 3ÿ 5ÿ 7 9 ÿ9 5 69 ÿ7 73ÿ8 5 ÿ 93ÿ8 37 454 ÿ 4ÿ8 9 4d7 >ÿ4d 4 34ÿ9 ÿ 7e4 ÿ 59 7 ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 7 7;9 7 ÿ7 ÿ 4ÿ34 494 ÿ73ÿ ÿ9 5 64 _ÿ 4ÿ 3ÿ ÿ 4ÿ 97 7 ÿ 3 8844 7 ;ÿ9 ÿ 579 ÿ 9 9 84 ÿ ÿ 4ÿ573e3ÿ ÿ8 7 4 ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 5 of 16 3454675489 ÿ5 ÿ 796 ÿ8 ÿ 8 4 3 ÿ 8 ÿ4 ÿ5 ÿ 7 ÿ4 ÿ5 4 ÿ 5 ÿ8 49489 ÿ8 ÿ 37 ÿ 8 9 3ÿ79 ÿ5 ÿ 37 ÿ 95754 ÿ79 ÿ 5 ÿ 6 ÿ8 ÿ8 8 45489ÿ58ÿ5 ÿ 553 95 ÿ 4 ÿ 8 5ÿ 8694 ÿ5 75ÿ98ÿ 553 95ÿ 37 ÿ ÿ 8 5 ÿ58ÿ5 ÿ 553 95 ÿ98ÿ89 ÿ 7 ÿ 8 9ÿ58ÿ8 508 5ÿ8 ÿ5 ÿ 553 95 ÿ79 ÿ98ÿ89 ÿ 7 ÿ 43 ÿ7ÿ 734 ÿ79 ÿ54 3 ÿ 5ÿ 8 ÿ 3 489 ÿ !9ÿ 8 5 ÿ5 ÿ 553 95ÿ4 ÿ 49733 ÿ7 8 ÿ79 ÿ5 ÿ 7 54 ÿ7 ÿ 4 5 ÿ58ÿ 89 75 ÿ5 ÿ 553 95ÿ49ÿ7 8 79 ÿ "45 ÿ45 ÿ5 ÿ #$ÿ #&'()*)+,()-.ÿ-*ÿ(0&ÿ1&((2&3&.(ÿ#2,44&4ÿÿ 4 ÿ 8 5ÿ ÿ 49733 ÿ 54 4 ÿ5 ÿ 833 5489ÿ5 55 ÿ 37 ÿ79 ÿ5 ÿ6 4 5489ÿ7 ÿ 37 ÿ7 ÿ 8338" 8ÿ #-22&+()-.ÿ9&((&'ÿ#2,448ÿ:33ÿ975 73ÿ 89 ÿ" 8ÿ ;7<ÿ75ÿ79 ÿ 8495ÿ 5" 9ÿ= 58 ÿ> ÿ?@A2ÿ79 ÿB 9 ÿ?C ÿ ?@AD ÿ; <ÿ 4 ÿ49ÿ79 ÿ8 ÿ5 ÿ 8 54 ÿ49ÿE8 5 ÿ 7 83497ÿ8"9 ÿ79 F8 ÿ 7976 ÿ ÿG 9 795 ÿ79 ÿ ; <ÿ 4 ÿ7ÿ 833 5489ÿ5 55 ÿÿ ÿ HI)+()-.ÿJ&&ÿ#2,448ÿ:33ÿ975 73ÿ 89 ÿ" 8ÿ;7<ÿ75ÿ79 ÿ 8495ÿ 5" 9ÿ= 58 ÿ> ÿ?@A2ÿ79 ÿB 9 ÿ?C ÿ?@AD ÿ ; <ÿ 4 ÿ49ÿ79 ÿ8 ÿ5 ÿ 8 54 ÿ49ÿE8 5 ÿ 7 83497ÿ 8"9 ÿ79 F8 ÿ 7976 ÿ ÿG 9 795 ÿ79 ÿ; <ÿ" ÿ 7 6 ÿ79 ÿ; <ÿ 74 ÿ6 4 5489ÿ7 ÿÿ ÿ 6 3 ÿ 8 ÿ5 ÿ 553 95ÿ 37 ÿ7 ÿ;A<ÿ 89 ÿ" 8ÿ 7 ÿ 38 ÿ 4 58 ÿ8 4 ÿ79 ÿ76 95 ÿ8 ÿG 9 795 ÿ ;?<ÿ 89 ÿ" 8ÿ54 3 ÿ79 ÿ 8 3 ÿ 3 ÿ5 3 ÿ 8 ÿ5 ÿ 553 95ÿ 37 ÿ7 ÿ 8 4 ÿ49ÿ5 4 ÿ:6 95 ÿ;K<ÿ79 89 ÿ" 8ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 6 of 16 345ÿ6789 5 ÿ8 8 8 ÿ4ÿ 7 8 ÿ78 8458ÿ ÿ4 ÿ 4 5ÿ4 4 5 ÿ 8 8 4 5ÿ78 4 8 ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ 885ÿ4 ÿ ÿ 387 58ÿ 8ÿ4ÿ 8 87ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 455 ÿ4 ÿ !ÿ 38ÿ 7 "ÿ 38ÿ #$%&'(ÿ*++,-*.&,ÿ/.+*012ÿ.3-ÿ 7 ÿ5 4 4ÿ 5458 ÿ ÿ 38ÿ78 7 ÿ 8 78ÿ 3 5ÿ 7 "ÿ 3 5ÿ 7 ÿ3878 ÿ 5ÿ 34 ÿ 38ÿ678786 5 85ÿ ÿ7 8ÿ89 4!ÿ4 ÿ ! 9!ÿ3498ÿ 88 ÿ 54 5 8 ÿ 7ÿ 87 4 ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 45585ÿ 7ÿ 58 8 8 ÿ6 76 585ÿ :ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 45585"ÿ 3 3ÿ 4 ÿ 3 78 5ÿ ÿ 8 875"ÿ478ÿ5 ÿ 87 5ÿ 34 ÿ; 87ÿ ÿ4 ÿ 8 875ÿ 5ÿ 674 4 8 ÿ 3878ÿ478ÿ6 85 5ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 45585 ÿ 38ÿ 4 5ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 455ÿ7867858 4 98ÿ 478ÿ 6 4 ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 4 5ÿ ÿ 38ÿ4 58 ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 455ÿ 8 875 ÿ 38ÿ 455ÿ7867858 4 98ÿ4 ÿ 455ÿ 58 ÿ3498ÿ4 ÿ ÿ4 86 4 8 ÿ4 ÿ 4 7 ÿ67 8 ÿ 38ÿ 8785 5ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 45585ÿ 3ÿ78 47 ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 4 5ÿ ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 45585 ÿ4 ÿ ÿ6 85 5ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿ 4 ÿ678 4 8ÿ 987ÿ 6 85 5ÿ4 8 ÿ ÿ 9 4 ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 455ÿ 8 875"ÿ 78 87 ÿ 38ÿ 8 8 8 ÿ 45585ÿ5 8 ÿ 385 98ÿ ÿ 4774 ÿ4ÿ 455ÿ58 8 8 4ÿ <=ÿ ?@@ABCDEFCDÿAHÿIJKLLÿIAMCLFJÿKCNÿIJKLLÿOF@PFLFCDKDBQFÿ R3 5ÿ 7 ÿ466 5ÿ ÿ 4ÿS477 5ÿ4 ÿT4 7 UÿV4ÿW4 4 8ÿ ÿV 87 ÿ 8 4 ÿ57 5 ÿT3 65ÿX7 55 4 "ÿTYY "ÿ4 ÿ 47 ÿS4ÿ V4 5ÿ4 ÿZ47 ÿ 4ÿX 4 8 ÿ ÿV4 5ÿS 47 "ÿ45ÿ 455ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 7 of 16 3456789 ÿ 7ÿ345 ÿ 4 6 7ÿ 877 3 ÿ 4 6746ÿ 7ÿ 9 77ÿ 8 8786 8 ÿ ÿ !ÿ# ÿ 8ÿ%8 98&86 ÿ'( 88&86 ÿ 974ÿ 4 )87ÿ ÿ*8+86) 6 7ÿ, 99ÿ -./ÿ1.-/23/ÿ42//5262-/ÿ75833ÿ7.9-325:3ÿ 9 3 46ÿ 4ÿ 7ÿ345 ÿ ;.<ÿ=8>62-/ÿ.;ÿ8//.<-2>3:ÿ;223ÿ9=ÿ/.ÿ/?2ÿ86.9-/ÿ.;ÿ@AABCDDDEDDCÿ 957ÿ 8 &F5 78&86 ÿ4+ÿ8G 86787ÿ 6)ÿ347 7ÿ+ 4&ÿ 8ÿ 7 ÿH56)ÿ4+ÿ /?2ÿ42//5262-/EÿI?2ÿ<2J923/2Kÿ8//.<-2>3:ÿ;223ÿ86.9-/ÿ/.ÿ 4G & 89LÿMNOÿ4+ÿ 8ÿ 4 9ÿP468 Lÿ 89 8+ÿ 4 )8)ÿ56)8 ÿ /?2ÿ42//5262-/EÿQ//.<-2>3:ÿ;223ÿ8-Kÿ<2R6S9<3262-/ÿ.;ÿ2T=2-323ÿ 6)ÿ347 7ÿ,8 8ÿ68(4 8)ÿ469Lÿ + 8 ÿ 8ÿ75F7 6 8ÿ 8 &7ÿ4+ÿ 8ÿ%8 98&86 ÿ,8 8ÿ ( 88)ÿ5 46 ÿUV 7ÿ 6)ÿP ( 66 7ÿ 4 6 ÿ *839 ÿU*43 ÿWN0MXÿYÿZN Xÿÿ 8 8ÿ 8ÿ ,4ÿ & Lÿ&8 4)7ÿ+4 ÿ3 9359 6(ÿ 4 68L7:ÿ +887ÿ 6ÿ 8ÿH45 ÿ 35 [ÿ 8ÿ 8 386 (8ÿ4+ÿ 8ÿ+56)ÿ&8 4)ÿ 6)ÿ 8ÿ94)87 ÿ&8 4) ÿ\ 99 7ÿ ÿ )ÿ]5 6 Lÿ^63 _ÿ`4 ÿ M[ab3 cM_ÿZaMWÿdeÿZWNWZ2b_ÿ ÿfZÿUP * ` ÿP Lÿb_ÿZaMWXgÿV 99ÿ ÿ V ( 8 ÿh68ÿP 3 687_ÿ^63 _ÿ`4 ÿi0Mi0 j0Wca0H_ÿZaMWÿdeÿikMWi2Z_ÿ ÿfcÿUl * ` ÿ%8 ÿZW_ÿZaMWXÿmnIo?2ÿ=2<12-/8p2ÿ.;ÿ;9-Kÿ62/?.Kÿ 4 )87ÿ ÿ 8ÿ345 ÿ , )ÿ 4 68L7qÿ+887ÿ 7ÿ ÿ 8 386 (8ÿ4+ÿ /?2ÿ1.66.-ÿ;9-KCrÿs?R52ÿmn/o?2ÿ5.K23/8<ÿ62/?.Kÿ<2J9R<23ÿ/?2ÿ 345 ÿ 4ÿ)8 8 & 68ÿ 8ÿ 45 7ÿ 8 746 F9Lÿ8G 86)8)ÿFLÿ3456789ÿ ÿ 3 8 8)_ÿ 4 83 8)_ÿ4 ÿ 878 8)ÿ 8ÿ+56)t_uÿ 86ÿ 4ÿ&59 9Lÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 8 of 16 3453ÿ789 ÿ ÿ5ÿ 5 5 ÿ4 ÿ 53 ÿ ÿ ÿ !ÿ " #2 ÿ$%ÿ& ÿ'$ %()$% *+ÿ +ÿ*) , +$ -ÿ'./*%$% *+ÿ0$)1 ÿ *0 %%(2-3ÿ4 (ÿ *2( %$)ÿ0(% *2ÿ +5* 5( ÿ0/ % 6 +,ÿ% (ÿ $33 7 ÿ 5 5 ÿ4 ÿ 53 ÿ ÿ34 ÿ 8 ÿ 7ÿ4 ÿ )($ *+$9 6ÿ(: (+2(2 ÿ$;%()ÿ<*+ 2() +,ÿ% (ÿ=* + *+ÿ;$<%*) >ÿ ' -ÿ% (ÿ% 0(ÿ$+2ÿ $9*)ÿ(: (+2(2?ÿ' -ÿ% (ÿ+*5( %6ÿ$+2ÿ 2 ;; </ %6ÿ*;ÿ% (ÿ./( % *+ ÿ)$ (2?ÿ'"-ÿ% (ÿ 1 ÿ )(./ )(2ÿ%*ÿ )* () 6ÿ ();*)0ÿ% (ÿ (,$ ÿ ()5 <( ÿ @ @AÿBCDÿ34 ÿ533 7 ÿ EE 3 83 ÿF 3 ÿ8 ÿ )( +,ÿ% (ÿ + %$+%ÿ % ,$% *+?ÿ'G-ÿ% (ÿ</ %*0$)6ÿ;((ÿ 7 ÿ 8H ÿI HAÿBJDÿ34 ÿ533 7 ÿ KE F3538 ÿ53ÿ34 ÿ */% (%ÿ*;ÿ% (ÿ % ,$% *+?ÿ'L-ÿ% (ÿ% 0(ÿ 0 %$% *+ ÿ 0 * (2ÿ96ÿ% (ÿ< (+%ÿ*)ÿ< )</0 %$+<( ?ÿ'#-ÿ% (ÿ$0*/+%ÿ +ÿ<*+%)*5() 6ÿ$+2ÿ% (ÿ)( / % ÿ*9%$ +(2?ÿ'2-ÿ% (ÿ (: () (+<( ÿ)( /%$% *+ÿ$+2ÿ$9 %6ÿ*;ÿ% (ÿ$%%*)+(6?ÿ ' -ÿ% (ÿ/+2( )$9 %6ÿ*;ÿ% (ÿ<$ (ÿM % +ÿ% (ÿ (,$ ÿ <*00/+ %6ÿ +ÿM < ÿ% (ÿ / %ÿ$)* (?ÿ' -ÿ% (ÿ+$%/)(ÿ$+2ÿ (+,% ÿ*;ÿ% (ÿ )*;( *+$ ÿ)( $% *+ ÿ9(%M((+ÿ 533 ÿ5 @ÿF 8 3Aÿ5 @ÿBNODÿ533 7ÿ7 ÿ5I5 @ ÿ +ÿ 0 $)ÿ<$ ( 3ÿ ÿ P) *0ÿ53ÿQ ÿR*) 3 ÿGS2ÿT3"2ÿ" " ÿ" ÿ'S% ÿR )3ÿ #-ÿ './*% +,ÿU ( ÿ53ÿQ<V$+ ( ÿ# SÿT3 2ÿ "# ÿ S ÿ+3 #ÿ'S% ÿR )3ÿ 2#L--3ÿ4 ( (ÿ;$<%*) ÿ;)*0ÿ=* + *+ÿW5 ÿ3 ÿ ÿF 8@ @ÿ5 ÿE5 3ÿ 7ÿ34 ÿX 37 ÿ@ 3 88 538 ÿ 7ÿ34 ÿ 5 5 ÿ 8 ÿ 7ÿ4 ÿ $+2ÿ% (ÿ)($ *+$9 (ÿ)$%(ÿ3 ÿ ÿ @ÿ8 ÿ348 ÿF5 ÿV$M *+ ÿ Sÿ !ÿSLS#G ÿ$%ÿ&"?ÿ ((ÿ$ *ÿY5 ÿZ ÿ[88 7 \ÿ] F ÿGLLÿT3 2ÿ ÿ ÿ'S% ÿR )3ÿ 2L#-?ÿ=* + *+ÿ53ÿP$3ÿ^ , M$6ÿ_: )( ÿ`+<3 ÿ Caaÿb O@ÿcNCÿBNdcCD ÿX ÿ8 ÿ KE F3 @ÿ3 ÿ K F8 ÿW 8 8 9ÿ e @98 3\ ÿ5 @ÿ@8 3 8F3ÿF 3 ÿ 4 @ÿ KF @ ÿ4 ÿ3453ÿ5 ÿ 0ÿ2ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 9 of 16 45675889 5 ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ 5 985ÿ 57588 ÿ ÿ !ÿ "#ÿ$%& '()'*+ÿ,-2ÿ.# #ÿ,/,+ÿ,0,ÿ122304#ÿ 5 ÿ 66797 ÿ8 ÿ759 7ÿ8558ÿ:5 8ÿ4 5ÿ: 5 ÿ 8ÿ 58 :798 9 9ÿ 5ÿ 5 8 :75 588 ÿ 8ÿ 59 ÿ 5 ;8ÿ 58ÿ ÿ 498ÿ :7995 ÿ ÿ8 ÿ ÿ 5ÿ 5< 58 5 ÿ 7 ÿ 58ÿ 5ÿ 7 898 5 ÿ 9 ÿ= 5ÿ6 5 979 9ÿ> ?5 ÿ 58ÿ9 ÿ 5ÿ 575 ÿ 7 >> 9 ÿ8 ÿ 5ÿ 65ÿ 8ÿ ?ÿ8 ÿ 97 ÿ 8 5ÿ855?8ÿ ÿ ; ÿ @%AB ÿ"#ÿCD%E)'+ÿF03ÿG#0Hÿ32+ÿ22ÿ1,*(ÿIJ'#ÿ/3204ÿ1) * ')*JD ÿJ ÿ 999 7KÿL79 9 ÿ >9 5 K ÿ4M 5ÿ 575 ÿ> ?5 ÿ8 ÿ H * 'NJ J Oÿ*( ÿP' ")J J Oÿ')* ÿJ ÿD'HJ )'J !ÿ*( ÿ%DNNQ J*!ÿJ ÿ R(J%(ÿ*(5ÿ7 ÿ 5 5ÿ 5ÿ 7 9 ÿ98ÿ6 857 5 ÿ89 8 ÿSQNÿI' &ÿ ID) ÿ ) +ÿT %#ÿ"#ÿI)P '*D +ÿ02ÿG#0Hÿ2-2+ÿ2FUÿ1,*(ÿIJ'#ÿ222,4ÿ 1%J*)*JD ÿDNJ** H4ÿ V7 9 988;8ÿ7 857ÿ 5ÿ6 9 5 ÿ 9>5ÿ 57 8ÿ 58757 9 9ÿ *( ÿ*JN ÿ P *ÿD ÿ*(J ÿN)** '#ÿ1 ÿWD% #ÿ-3X2Yÿ-2X2#4ÿZ(' ÿ )**D' ! +ÿ %D**ÿ )''J +ÿ@)'*()ÿ[ '+ÿ) Hÿ$HR)'Hÿ@)OJ J ÿ P *ÿ )ÿ%DN\J Hÿ2U3#FUÿ(DQ' ÿD ÿ*( ÿN)** 'ÿ)*ÿ)ÿ\J J Oÿ')* ÿDBÿ]F33#ÿ 1WD% #ÿ-3X2Yÿ-2X2#4ÿGJ" ÿD*( 'ÿ)**D' ! +ÿ^)*'J%&ÿ_) )% +ÿ @J%() ÿWQ +ÿ$'J ÿSQ\ +ÿ )')(ÿ P) O \Q'O+ÿ) Hÿ`)' ÿ[R) * !ÿ P *ÿ)ÿ%DN\J Hÿ/U,#-ÿ(DQ' ÿD ÿ*( ÿN)** 'ÿ)*ÿ)ÿ')* ÿDBÿ]UU3#ÿ 1WD% #ÿ-3X2Yÿ-2X2#4ÿaD'H) ÿ[DHRJ ÿ P *ÿ0-#3,ÿ(DQ' ÿD ÿ*( ÿ N)** 'ÿ)*ÿ)ÿ')* ÿDBÿ]0U3#ÿ1WD% #ÿ-3X2Yÿ-2X2#4ÿGJ ) !+ÿ*RDÿ QPPD'*ÿ *)BB+ÿAN) H)ÿ@&)N) O)ÿ) Hÿ %D**ÿ HN) ÿ P *ÿ)ÿ 0ÿ23ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 10 of 16 3456789 ÿ ÿ 4 ÿ48ÿ 9ÿ5 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ 9ÿ4 ÿ 2 ÿ 43 ÿ 2 ÿ 2 2ÿ!8ÿ 4 "#ÿ3" ÿ34 8 9"ÿ $98 ÿ ÿ3456789 ÿ % ÿ 4 ÿ48ÿ 9ÿ5 9 ÿ 4 ÿ ÿ3 5 " 7&9ÿ& " 9ÿ4 ÿ % # 2 ÿ 43 ÿ 2 ÿ 2 ÿ '()**ÿ,-./*0(ÿ*1)10*ÿ12)1ÿ12034ÿ54)10*ÿ)40ÿ63123/ÿ120ÿ 3 45 7ÿ 9 ÿ3 89 ÿ67ÿ 4 897 ÿ78ÿ 7 ÿ 7 73 ÿ 4 ÿ $9 4 5788ÿ 757" "7ÿ345$"99ÿ"7 78 748#ÿ783" 788ÿ3" ÿ ),13-/*:;ÿ<=-,:ÿ>?ÿ@ÿABÿ=-,:ÿ>Cÿ@ÿ>:DÿE 9 ÿ34 ÿ78ÿ 7 ÿ 7 73 ÿ &9ÿ 339$ 9 ÿ 9 ÿ4 ÿ ÿ$9 ÿ 4 ÿ 4 ÿ 4 897 ÿ78ÿ $ 73 " "7ÿ345$"99ÿ3 9 ÿF99ÿG78878 ÿ& ÿHIJKEÿI5 #ÿ!83 #ÿ % 2 ÿL F ÿ 7 ÿGJM!Fÿ2 #ÿN ?ÿ<)OO4-P3/Qÿ)11-4/0RS*ÿT00*ÿ-Tÿ ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ$9 ÿ 4 :ÿU2-.Q2ÿV()3/13TT*Sÿ,-./*0(S*ÿ4)10*ÿ $$9 ÿ 4ÿ69ÿ ÿ 9ÿ $$9 ÿ98 ÿ4 ÿW ÿ4 9 ÿ34 ÿ78ÿ 7 ÿ 7 73 ÿ &9ÿ 339$ 9 #ÿ 7 ÿ34 ÿ 49 ÿW7""ÿ84 ÿ5 X9ÿ ÿ 78 788ÿ ÿ 97ÿ 9ÿ 8 9 48 6"9ÿ 4 ÿ 8ÿ 4 897ÿ78ÿ 9ÿY7 "9ÿ 7 73 ÿ4 ÿZ4 ÿK 4"78 ÿ"7 78 788ÿ ÿ3" ÿ 3 748 ÿÿ [ 98ÿ348 7 9 788ÿ 9ÿ 4 897S ÿ 99 ÿ ÿ ÿ$9 398 89ÿ4 ÿ 9ÿ T./\]ÿ120Rÿ)OO0)4ÿ40)*-/)^(0:ÿV()3/13TT*Sÿ,-./*0(ÿ*00_ÿ 22%# ÿ 45ÿ ÿ 4 "ÿ5489 7ÿ 934&9 7ÿ4 ÿ # % 2ÿ4 ÿ $$ 4975 9"7ÿ2 `ÿ4 ÿ 9ÿ 4 "ÿ5489 7ÿ 934&9 7 ÿ 43 ÿ 0 ÿ aÿ22 ÿE 9 ÿ34 ÿ78ÿ 7 ÿ37 3 7 ÿ &9ÿ 339$ 9 ÿ" 89 ÿ ÿ 2ÿc 9 ÿ48ÿ 9ÿ67""788ÿ 9ÿ 8 ÿ 9ÿ X ÿY ÿYX 5 88 ÿ 8 ÿ Y ÿH9" 5 8ÿ345$"9 9 #ÿ 7 ÿ34 ÿ 59 ÿ 97ÿ 9ÿ $$4 ÿ ÿÿ 0ÿ22ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 11 of 16 4567589 5 ÿ 6 4 96 7 ÿ ÿ 6 8 ÿ 88 9 8 ÿ 5 9 7 65ÿ ÿ 3ÿ ÿ 44 ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ"# $ % ÿ3!2&'ÿ"7 579 8 ÿ ()*+*ÿ-.+/+ÿ(01/2*ÿ)330-+4ÿ)220/5+67*ÿ8++ÿ)-)/4*ÿ9+2-++5ÿ:;ÿ 4567589ÿ9 ÿ 8509 6 ÿ <ÿ9 5ÿ9 9 ÿ657 56= 'ÿ 8ÿ7 8 56 8 ÿ9 5ÿ65 5 89ÿ> 6?56ÿ< 79 6 ÿ9 ÿ7 69ÿ @4 =ÿ8 95 ÿ9 9ÿ7 ÿ7 8 5 ÿ 8 5 95 ÿ 8 < 7 89ÿ9 @5ÿ 8 ÿ /+*01/(+*ÿA520ÿ2.A*ÿ()*+BÿC44A2A05)336Dÿ2.+ÿE01/2.ÿFA/(1A27*ÿ 657589ÿ 57 8ÿ 8ÿ> ÿ ÿG5 8 95 8ÿ# @9 ÿ ÿ46 5 ÿ ÿ 56 ÿ <ÿ8 9ÿ 8 6@ 89 ? 5 ÿ @45 @589ÿ9 ÿH3)A52A88*7ÿ ? 9=ÿ9 ÿ657 56ÿ 8=9 8 ÿ<6 @ÿ$5<58 89 ÿ Iÿ 9 ÿ ÿ I ÿ " 9 ÿ 6 ÿ3!33' ÿJ 565< 65 ÿ9 5ÿ 599 5@589ÿK 655@589 ÿL 7 ÿ 46 5 ÿ ÿ@ 859 6=ÿ657 56=ÿ <ÿM&N &3N 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ965@58 ÿ 65 9ÿ< 6ÿ9 5ÿ7 ÿ 8 = ÿ9 5ÿ 5 9 6ÿ76 07 57 ÿ7 8< 6@ ÿ9 5ÿ65O 5 95 ÿ )220/5+67*ÿ8++*ÿ)/+ÿ/+)*05)93+BÿJ 5ÿ 5 9 6ÿ 5ÿ< 6ÿ ÿ F015*+37*ÿL 6 ÿ 8ÿ9 ÿ@ 9956ÿL ÿM3I !2 ! ÿ" @4 65ÿ$ 7 ÿI&ÿ PÿI ÿL 9 ÿ$ 7 ÿI ÿPÿN 'ÿ ÿ 8 5 ÿ 65ÿ65O 5 9 8 ÿM223 !!!ÿ 8ÿ )220/5+67*ÿ8++* ÿ65 9 8 ÿ 8ÿ ÿ 5 9 6ÿ@ 9 4 56ÿ <ÿ 446 Q @ 95 =ÿ 3 ÿRF01/2*ÿ.)S+ÿ80154ÿ2.)2ÿ304+*2)/ÿT132AU3A+/*ÿ 6 8 8 ÿ<6 @ÿ3ÿ9 ÿ ÿ 5@ 8 96 95ÿ9 5ÿ65 8 ? 585 ÿ <ÿ ÿ /+V1+*2+4ÿU+/(+52)W+ÿ8++BXÿ 6 4 96 7 ÿ 3ÿ ÿ 44 ÿ ÿ 9ÿ !Nÿ 0ÿ23ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 12 of 16 45678769 ÿ9 677 ÿ 8 ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ 9 96 ÿ7 6 ÿ59 7ÿ 6 ÿ7 ÿ ÿ" ÿ # $ÿ "ÿ%&&'()))*))ÿ+ ÿ ,- ÿ+ ÿ .+ ÿ/ *0ÿ 12ÿ 45677ÿ49:;7<5=7ÿ>?@<;7<7ÿ BC8 ÿB9 Cÿ 8D ÿE 9D6 ÿ 5C8 8769 ÿ E 56 F6 ÿ7 87ÿ 7 Fÿ 8D ÿ6 5 ÿ GE ÿ6 ÿ7 ÿ8 9 7ÿ9 ÿH3 I0J IIÿ6 ÿ7 ÿ E 9 5 769 ÿ9 ÿ7 6 ÿC676 8769 ÿ9 ÿK 8C ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ5C8 ÿ4L8 6 ÿ 8 ÿM8 6 6 ÿN96 7ÿO 5C ÿ4O95 ÿP302 ÿQQÿP0RP3 ÿS 6 ÿ59 7ÿ 6 ÿ 7 6 ÿ GE ÿT ÿ 8 9 8KCFÿ8 ÿ 5 8 6CFÿ6 5 ÿ8 ÿ8 ÿ 8ÿ C7 ÿBC8 ÿB9 Cÿ8 ÿ 767C ÿ79ÿ 6 K 7ÿ 9 ÿ7 6 ÿ GE ÿ6 ÿ8 6769 ÿ79ÿ7 ÿ ÿ8T8 ÿ U2ÿ VWXYZ[Wÿ\]^X_ÿ S ÿ` 77C 7ÿa 7ÿE 9D6 ÿ7 87ÿO 8 7 ÿ Kb 57ÿ 79ÿ59 7ÿ8EE 9D8C ÿT6CCÿE8FÿH0 Jccÿ79ÿN 658ÿN9 9 ÿ 9 ÿ ÿ D65 ÿ8 ÿBC8 ÿd E 7876D ÿT67 ÿ 5 ÿE8F 7ÿ79ÿK ÿ 8 ÿ 9 ÿ7 ÿB8 ÿe ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ 77C 7ÿE8F 7 ÿ4O95 ÿJf0gÿ87ÿ2P ÿ ha7ÿ7 ÿ59 5C 69 ÿ9 ÿ8ÿ 55 Cÿ5C8 ÿ85769 ÿ58 ÿ67ÿ6 ÿ 59 9 ÿ 9 ÿ59 7 ÿ G 56 6 ÿ7 6 ÿ 6 5 769 ÿ79ÿ8T8 ÿ E 568Cÿ 59 E 8769 ÿ79ÿ7 ÿ5C8 ÿ E 7876D ÿ6 ÿ 59 6769 ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ 76 ÿ8 ÿ 9 7ÿ7 Fÿ 8D ÿ6 D 7 ÿ 9 ÿ7 ÿK 67ÿ9 ÿ7 ÿ ÿ 955 E6 ÿ87ÿM8 6 6 ÿL9T8 ÿ8 ÿ 6 ÿ6 9 8769 ÿT8 ÿ 97ÿ6 5C ÿ 9 ÿ7 ÿ 6 l ÿ ml *ÿn` ÿO95 ÿJf03 ÿL9T D ÿ D ÿ K7 8576 ÿ o $#+ ÿ/ +,m + ÿ" lÿ . ÿp $ ÿ/ -/m- + (ÿ . ÿ C76EC6 ÿT9 C ÿ9 CFÿ6 5 8 ÿ79ÿ gg ÿ7 ÿ7 6 ÿ 857 8Cÿ6 ÿ $ ÿ ÿ - ÿ .+ ÿ/ m ÿ/ /-m + *ÿÿ 0ÿ23ÿ0ÿ 0ÿj7ÿ6 ÿ 5C 8 ÿ79ÿ7 6 ÿ59 7ÿT 87ÿE9 6769 ÿN9 8 ÿk9 T6 ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 13 of 16 4567789ÿ ÿ 8ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ 8ÿ2 04 02!" ÿ # "ÿ$%ÿ22&2 " ÿ6 ÿ'3ÿ()8 8 8 8ÿ*6 8ÿ2 ÿ# "+8ÿ, 7ÿ4 ÿ- .7ÿ 6 ÿ 6 ÿ -ÿ ÿ7 4 ÿ6/6 .ÿ 7ÿ6 6 ÿ ÿ 7ÿ467 ÿ ÿ 5 ÿ -ÿ)78ÿ012341354ÿ/ 6ÿ ÿ7 65-ÿ -ÿ ÿ 5 ÿ 5677 7ÿ 6 .ÿ 6 ÿ ÿ 5 ÿ 5677ÿ 7 ÿ 67ÿ 78 4 .ÿ ÿ ÿ7 4 ÿ 6/6 .78ÿ, 7ÿ4 ÿ 7 ÿ6 7ÿ ÿ7 4 ÿ6/6 . ÿ/ 4 ÿ 429::ÿ;<ÿ=9>?ÿ@134>4A<3AÿB>A2ÿA2<ÿ=9CA><45ÿD<AA:<E<3AÿFGC<<E<3AHÿ IJÿ LMÿOPQRÿ S ÿ ÿ ÿ 6 ÿ 5 ÿ 5677ÿ 7 7ÿ-6 5ÿ ÿ467 ÿ ÿ4 467ÿ/ ÿ7 Tÿ 7ÿ -ÿ 6 5 ÿ7 4 ÿ 6 ÿ ÿ 67 ÿ U .ÿ 67ÿ6ÿ 7 ÿ7656 4 ÿ655ÿ 6 ÿ6 7ÿ ÿ ÿ 67 ÿ U .ÿ7 655ÿ7 ÿ V 655 ÿ. . .ÿ6 .ÿ. 77 7 .ÿ ÿ ÿ6 .ÿ4 ÿ 7ÿ 4 7ÿ6 .ÿ ÿ - .6 7ÿ67ÿ . .ÿ ÿ ÿ 5 ÿ W 8ÿ( ÿ 48ÿ 30&ÿ6 ÿ2XY2"8+ÿZ 0 65-ÿ -ÿ6 ÿ 6 ÿ 6 7ÿ ÿ ÿ 67 ÿU .ÿ/ 55ÿ7 ÿ V 655 ÿ. . .ÿ7 ÿ ÿ / ÿ4 ÿ 7ÿ 4 7 ÿ[6 ÿ[ 7 ÿ 4 7ÿ6 .ÿ 6- 5.ÿ ÿ 6 5 68ÿ(S.8+ÿ, ÿ ÿ 0 65-ÿ -ÿ6 ÿ 6 ÿ6 7ÿ ÿ ÿ 67 ÿU .ÿ/ 55ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ - .6 78ÿ(S.8+ÿ, ÿ 56 7ÿ W. 7 6 ÿ 7ÿ . .ÿ ÿ . ÿ6ÿ ÿ ÿ 5677ÿ 7 5ÿ 6 .ÿ - .6 7\ÿ 7 5ÿ -ÿ655ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 67 ÿU .ÿ5 - ÿ . 77 7 .ÿ/ ÿ- - ÿ465 .6 ÿ.6 7ÿ6- ÿ ÿ7 Tÿ ÿ .ÿ 67ÿ 56 7 .8ÿ ÿ 0ÿ23ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 14 of 16 4445ÿ7897 489ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿ8 ÿ ÿ !"#$"%%&'ÿ)#*++*',-ÿ.*$"*#ÿ ÿ /ÿ 011 2 /ÿ ÿ3/ ÿ04 ÿ5 / 6 ÿ ÿ07 8ÿ ÿ9$$*:#,;'&ÿ ÿ 8ÿ<=1 ÿ 8ÿ ÿ5 2 4 ÿ07 8ÿ ÿ3/ ÿ > 1 2 ÿ?@ 4AÿBCD ÿ ÿE F9 Gÿ 8ÿ ÿ3/ ÿ04 ÿ 5 / 6 ÿ ÿ011 2 8Aÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿH I ÿ8 ÿ$J!$ÿ+!;K,#$ÿ*%ÿ!$$*:#,;&'ÿ%,,'ÿ"#ÿ ÿ 6 L ÿ ÿM22N OOOÿ ÿ3/ ÿ3 L /ÿ ÿ 11 2 8 ÿ 8ÿ3/ ÿ 3 L /ÿ //ÿP ÿ1 8ÿM22N OOOÿ ÿ ÿ6 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 5 / 6 ÿ0 6 Aÿÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿH I ÿ8 ÿ ÿ1 Q6 ÿ ÿ =1 ÿ ÿ ÿ 6 L ÿ ÿMC RN3ARRÿ ÿ3/ ÿ3 L /ÿ ÿ 6PL 6 ÿ ÿ 11 2 8ÿ 8ÿ //ÿP ÿ1 8ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ5 / 6 ÿ 0 6 Aÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿH I ÿ8 ÿS 4 ÿS ÿ //ÿP ÿ1 8ÿ ÿ 2 4 ÿ 7 8ÿ ÿMN 3OOÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ5 / 6 ÿ 0 6 Aÿ 4 ÿ4 ÿH I ÿ8 ÿ ÿ ÿ3/ 6 ÿ086 ÿ ÿ 7 8 8ÿ ÿ =1 ÿ 8ÿ ÿ =1 ÿ //ÿP ÿ1 8ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ5 / 6 ÿ0 6 Aÿ 0ÿ23ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 15 of 16 45ÿ47ÿ89 5 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ! ÿ ÿ " ÿ ÿ " ÿ # ÿ ""ÿ# ÿ # ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ$ " ÿ% &ÿ 45ÿ47ÿ89 5 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ' ÿ ( ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ) ) ÿ ÿ "( ÿ *ÿ ÿ) ÿ ÿ " ÿ &ÿÿ 45ÿ47ÿ89 5 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ # ( 0 ) ÿ ÿ ÿ 47+477 ÿ,45 ÿ- .9 4/ &ÿ%ÿ0 ÿ ÿ " ÿ ) "*ÿ 1 &ÿ 2 ÿ ÿ23 ÿ *ÿ ÿ% 3ÿ4546&ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 7777777777777777777777777777777777ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿ8 ÿ$ ÿ9 ÿ0 ÿÿÿ 0ÿ23ÿ0ÿ Case 1:20-cv-01049-WO-JLW Document 70 Filed 08/16/23 Page 16 of 16

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.