CLARK v. BRITT et al, No. 1:2018cv00493 - Document 126 (M.D.N.C. 2021)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION, ORDER AND RECOMMENDATION OF UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Plaintiff's Motion [Doc. #119] seeking leave to file a Response brief in excess of the Court's pag e limits is granted, Plaintiff's Motion to Exercise Jurisdiction [Soc. #103] is granted to the extent that all of the claims have been addressed, and Plaintiff's Motion for Leave to Subpoena North Carolina's Commissioner of Prisons [Do c. #102], Motion [Doc. #112] seeking sanctions, and Motion for Appropriate Relief [Doc. #118] are denied. IT IS RECOMMENDED that Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment [Doc. #97] be denied, that the Motion for Summary Judgment [Doc. #108] file d by a Defendants Bartee, Britt, Covington, Gerald, Hammonds, Lochlear, Locklear, McClean, Mewborn, Poole, and Wallace be granted, and that the action be dismissed as to these Defendants. IT IS FURTHER RECOMMENDED that Plaintiff's claims agains t Defendants Almodovar, Collins, and Chavis be dismissed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1915(e)(2) for failing to state a claim upon which relief may be granted except for the remaining claims as to Defendant Almodovar alleging malicious prosecution under sta te and federal law. IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiff's Motion for Default Judgment [Doc. #86] is treated as a Motion for Entry of Default and granted as to those remaining claims against Defendant Almodovar in light of her failure to respond, and t hat the Clerk enter default and provide notice to Defendant Almodovar. IT IS RECOMMENDED that if Defendant Almodovar does not move to set aside the default and for appointment of pro bono counsel, or otherwise object this Order and Recommendation by April 15, 2021, that Plaintiff's second Motion for Default Summary Judgment [Doc. #100] be granted with an award to Plaintiff of nominal damages of $1.00 and no punitive damages. IT IS FURTHER RECOMMENDED that the Motion for Temporary Res training Order and Preliminary Injunction [Doc. #123] be denied. FINALLY, IT IS ORDERED that this case is STAYED until April 15, 2021, in light of the Covid-19 pandemic and related lock-downs and restrictions at state correctional facilities, in order to allow Defendant sufficient time to receive the Recommendations and present objections. Objections must be filed by April 15, 2021. Signed by MAG/JUDGE JOI ELIZABETH PEAKE on 2/22/21. (Garrett, Kim)

Download PDF
CLARK v. BRITT et al Doc. 126 FILED in the Middle District of North Carolina May 21,22, 2020 February 2021 6:05 pm 2:29 pm Clerk, US District Court kg By: __________ KM "g+ g." + g)+ + )g )+& +g $.&+g $&g+ g g )+& ,g$ g"$&- g &$ " g $) % g (g & g g %O4JU^J> g ) 0g " ) 1g & ++ g:^g4O g :=U84U^] g / g ! $& " . g$% " $" g$& & g " g' $ " + $"g$ g .# + g)+ + )g )+& + g . g +I]gJ]g4g 6K`JOg[JFH^]g46^LWUg BO:8g_U8:\g g. * gfg g 5dg%O4JU^J?g W]:XHg 4[Og O4[N g g4VgJUS4^:gJVg^H:g"W\^Hg 4\WOJU4g :X4[^S:U^gW;g W\\:6^JWU g +H:g WSXO4JU^g 2W6 g 3g \:O4^:]g^Wg:a:U^]gbHJ6HgW66_[\:8g4^g)7W^O4U8g W[\:7^JWU4Og U]^J^_^JWUg5:FJUUJUFgWVg _U:g g g 4V8gbHJ6HgO:8g^Wg5W^HgY\J]WUg8J]7JXQU4\eg6H4\F:]g4U8g]^4^:g6W_\^g6[JSJU4Og7H4[F:]g 4F4JU]^g%O4JV^J@g :gb4]gC_U8gF_JO^dgW;g^H:g8J]6JXOJU4\dg7H4[F:] g5_^g^H:g6\JTJU4Og6H4\F:]gb:[:g O4^:\g8J]SJ]]:8g5dg^H:g)^4^: g %O4JU^J?g]_5]:Z_:U^Pdg BO:8g4Ug_U]_66:]]EOgX:^J^JWUgC\gH45:4]g 6W\X_]gJUg^HJ]g W_\^g6H4R:UGJUFg^H:gX[J]WUg8J]6JXOJU4\dg7WUaJ7^JWU]gJUg64]:g g g /g g g D:\g ^H:g W_\^gF\4U^:8g]_SS4[dgM_8 :U^gJUg <aW\gW;g^H:g&:]XWU8:U^gJUg^H4^g64]: g %O4JU^J?gBO:8g ^H:g 6_[[:U^g 46^JWUg U4SLUFg C_\^::Ug 6_\\:U^g 4U8g C\S:\g X\J]WUg WA6J4O]g 4]g :=U84V^] g g U_S5:\gW;gSW^JWU]g BO:8g5dg^H:g%4[^L:] g JU6O_8JVFg6\W]]gSW^JWU]gC[g]_SS4[dgM_8 :U^ g4\:g 6_[\:U^OdgX:U9JUFg5:C\:g^H:g W_[^g4U8gcOOg5:g8J]6_]]:8gJUg^_\Ug5:OWb g g Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 1 of 40 Dockets.Justia.com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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 2 of 40 'YAKDP$Gj'$[+ j #?+j SKVG$AP^j$GG+<+[j^?$^j +-+P)$Q^j GKS)Sd$Yj^SG)j^?+j"?+YA3[j .8'+j^?$^j +1P)$P^j $^ij SSG+j ?$)j f$^'@+)j dA)+Sj S-j ^?+j AP'A),P^ j &a^j ^?$^j +1P)$P^j SSG+j $G[Sj fSaG)jPS^j^bYPjSe+Yj^?,jdA)+S j SKVG$AP^j$^j j G$AP^D3[j$^^SYQ+ijAPj^?,j'YEP$Gj'$[+j9G+)j $j KS^ASPj ^Sj *C[KA[[j ^?+j 'YANAP$Gj (?$Y<+[j $P)j ^?+j A[^ZA'^j ^^SYP+ij 9G+)j $j )A[KA\[$Gj $-^+Yj G+$YPAP<j^?$^j$GGjS-j^?+j+dA)+P'+j?$)j&++Qj)+\^YSi+) j$GG+=+)GijAPjdASG$^ASPjS-j SY^?j $YSGAP$j [^$^a^SYijG$gj$P)jVYA[SPjY+<aG$^DSQ[ j [jPS^+)j$&Sd+ j ^?+j VYA[SPj$G[Sj'SP)a'_+)j)A['AVIAP$YijVYT'++)AP<[ j #?+j SLVG$AP^j 'H$AK[j ^?$^j +1P)$P^[j b[^APj ?$dA[j $P)j YA^^j 'SP)a(^+)j ^?+j )A['AVGAP$Yij AQd+[^A<$^ATPj $P)j ^?$^j +-+Q)$P^j $K+G$j S'FG+$Yj f$[j ^?,j ?+$YAP<j T6'+Y j ) j $^j j +1P)$P^]j $MA+j $KLSP)[j$P)j#Si$j SGGAP\j 'SP)a'^+)j $Pj$)OPD[^Y$^Dd+j APd+[^A<$^DSP j f?A'?j +2P)$P^[j !SP$G)j SdBP<^SPj$P)j +$Pj S'?H+$YjY+dA+f+) j ) j$^j j +1P)$P^j a+,Pj +Y$G)j$GH,=+)Gij W$Y^A'AV$^+)jAPj^?+j)D['AVJP$YijVYS'+[[j$P)jY,dA+f+)j^?+jdA)+SjAPjXa+[^ASP j ) j$^j j G$AP^A4j 9G,)j ^?+j VY+dASa[Gij K+P^ASP+)j ?%&+$[j $'^ASPj (?$HG+P>P<j ?A[j 'SQdA'`SPj SPj ^?,j )A['BVGDP$Yij '@$Y<+[ j &a^jGS[^j^?$^j'$[+ j f?A'?j ?+j 'SP_+P)[j f$[j &+'$b[+j ?+j *B)jPS^j?$d,j ^?,j+dA),P'+j ^Sj VYSd+j&A$[jSPj^?+jV$Y^jS-j^?+j?+$YAP<jT7'+Y j ) j $[,)j TPj ^?+\+j $GG+<$^AUP[ j G$AP^A4j'H$AM[j ^?$^j ?+j [a5+Y,)j )A[^Y+[[j )a+j ^Sj /'AP=j $j VS[[A&G+j:cZj$)*A^ASP$Gji+$Y[jAPjVYA[SPj$P)j$jGS[[jS-j0KAGij`+[ j +j[++F[j'SKV+P[$^SYij$Q)j VaRA^Ad+j )$K$<+[j $P)j ^?+j +hVaP<+K+P^j S-j ^?+j )A[NA[[+)j 'YAKAP$Gj '?$Y<+[j ;SKj ?A[j Y+'SY) j ) j$^j j j Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 3 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 4 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 5 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 6 of 40 L+S9+W+)]P8+]S9)+J]J,]P8+]9H(9)+HP ]%H)]%CCJW+)]P8+]S9)+J]PJ]'+]RO+)]9H]P8+]KL9OJH]):O(9KC9H%L\] 8+%L9H6 ] 'RP] %OO9OP+)]9H] (JS+L9H6]RK]P8+] S9)+J] 9H]P8+] (L9GH%C]KLJ(++*9H6O ] ) ] %P] ] 8+] F+H)+)] JFKC%9HP] %COJ] %((RO+O] +,+H)%HP] "+LL%HP;] ( C+%H] J,] L+5O9H6] PJ] OK+%B] JRP] JL] (JJK+L%P+] 9H] ORKKJLP]J,] C%9HP:/]%H)] %PP+FKPO] PJ] 8JC)] +,+H)%HPO] %FFJH)O ] %LP++ ] %H)] +L%C)] C:%'C+] '+(%RO+] P8+Z] W+L+] P8+] ORK+LS9OJLO] J,] P8+] RI<P] W8+L+] P8+] 9H(9)+HP] J((RLL+) ] ORK+LV9O+)] +,+H)%HP] CFJ)JT%L ]%H)]X+L+]%W%L+]J,]P8+]9H(9)+HP ] ) ]%P] ] %O+)]JH]P8+O+]%CC+6%P:JHO ] C%9HP:/](JHP+H)O]P8%P] +.H)%HPO]S9JC%P+)]89O]L968PO]RH)+L] P8+] JRLP8] F+H)F+HP] J,] P8+] !H9P+)] P%P+O] JHOP=PRP9JH ] )+H9+)] 89O] L968P] PJ] )R+] KLJ(+OO ] +H6%6+)]9H])+C:'+L%P+]9H*90+L+H(+]%H)](LR+C]%H)]RHROR%C]KRH9O8F+HP ]%H)](JFF:PP+)]P8+]OP%P+] C%W] PJMPO] J,] F%D9(9JRO] KLJO+(RP9JH ] J'OPLR(P:JH] J,] AROP:(+ ] %H)] 9HP+HQ;JH%C] 9H39(P:JH] J,] +FJP:JH%C]*9OPL+OO ] ) ]%P] ] +]O++BO](JFK+HO%PJL\]%H)]KRH:P>U+])%F%6+O]J,] ] ) ] %P] ] C%9HP9/]L+ OP%P+O]P8+O+](C%:FO]%H)]L+K+%PO]P8+O+]%CC+6%P9JHO]9H]89O]RHOWJLH] RKKC+F+HP] #J( ] $ ] H]P8+] RKKC+F+HP ]8+]O+PO]JRP]89O](C%9FO]4L]F%C9(9JRO]KLJO+(RP:JH]9H]T9JC%P9JH]J,] P8+] JRLP8] F+H)F+HP] %H)] OP%P+] C%W ] %O] W+DE] %O] S9JC%P:JH] J,] P8+] 968P8 ] 9,P8 ] @P8 ] %H)] JRLP++HP8] F+H)F+HPO ]%6%9HOP] +.H)%HP] CFJ)JT%L]'%O+)]JH]8+L]2E9H6]%](JFKC%9HP]Y?P8] P8+] (JPC%H)] JRHP\] 8+L91O] +K%LPF+HP] P8%P] L+ORCP+)] 9H] P8+] (L9F;H%C] (8%L6+O ] O] PJ] P8+] L+F%9H9H6] +,+H)%HPO ] P8+] RKKC+F+HP] %CC+6+O] 6+H+L%CC[] P8%P] P8+Z] -&9C+)] PJ] KLJP+(P] P8+] +T9)+H(+ ] K%LP9(RC%LCZ]P8+]S9)+JO]%H)] K8JPJ7L%K8O ] %H)] -&:C+)] PJ]KLJS9)+]P8+]+S9)+H(+] PJ]P8+] (JPC%H)] JRHP\] 8+L91O] +K%LPF+HP])RL9H6]P8+](L9F;H%C]KLJ(++)9H6O]%6%9HOP]89F ] C%9HP9/] %COJ] %6%9H] L%9O+O] (C%9FO] L+6%L)9H6] P8+] KN9OJH] ):O(9KC:H%LZ] KLJ(++):H6 ] K%LQ;(RC%LCZ] P8+] CJOO] J,] Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 7 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 8 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 9 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 10 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 11 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 12 of 40 # )/ 93 .9+# 9 )9 9.*# / ,79 ##9 ,9/ , 9 7.93 , 9 9 ## .9 9 9)*9% //- .. 9 )*9 #*/ .9 7*) 9 .9 *6 ,9. *,/. 9 )*9# ) ). 9 )*9/* # /9/ ..0 9 )*9 # )" / 9 ) 9)*9.* + 9 9 9 *, ) 9 /*9 # )/ 9 / . 9 /8+ .9 * 9 , ./- / *).9 , 9 &+*. 9 )*,% $#79 3 )9 % . 1 *,9* 0,.9 )9.*# / ,79 *) ) % )/ 9)*/93 )9 /9* 0,.9 )9 ) , #9+*+0# / *) 9 9 *./9* 9/ 9, ./9* 9 # )/ .9 # , / *)9 ##*3.9%*, 9 #*. #795/ 9/ 9 *%+# )/9 ) 9 % ) 9 *%+# )/9 ) 9 / #.9/ 9+, .*)9 . +# ) ,89+,* .. 9 .9 // %+/.9/*9+, . ,2 9 ) 9 , 1 9 / 9 + */* , + 9 ) 9 1 *9 1 ) 9 ) 9 / 9 , () #9 +,* ) .9 )9 ./ / 9 *0,/ 9 , , 9/ 9 *0,/94!##9)*/9, + /9 / 9 0/9% 79)*/ 9 /9 #*393 , 9) .. ,89 ,9/ 9+0,+*. .9 * 9 . 0.. *) 9)0% ,9* 9 ) )/.9 #.*9.0 ' // 9 # , / *). 9 *,9/ 9%*./9+ ,/9/ 79 )79 # )/ .9 ## / *).9 *) ,) ) 9 #. 9./ / % )/.9*,9/ 9 )/ )/ *) #9 ) 9*,9 ./,0 / *)9 H.x ^kahx,^.gx\^h.xhH)hxthHxa.g_.+hxh^xhH.x)TU.D.,xoN,.^x.mJ,.\+. xJhxJgxk\,Jg_kh.,xhH)hxhH.a.xJgx\^xmJ,.^x^/x hH.x)+hl)TxJ\+J,.\hxpHJT.x T)L]hJ3xp)gxg.)h.,xJ\x TY^,^m)a gx^;+. x*.+)kg.x)gx U)J\hJ3x\^h.gxJ\xIJgx .+U)a)hJ^\ x H.xp)gxJ\x)x *TJ\,xg_^h x^3x+)Y.a) x H.xmJ,.^xhHkgxa.?.+h.,x^\UvxhH.x_.bJ^,xJYY.,J)h.Uvx*.@a.x)\,x)/h.axhH.x J\+J,.\h x kcPDxhH.x_aJg^\x-Jg+J_UJ\)avx_a^+..,J\Dg xhH.xmJ,.^xp)gxmJ.p.,x)\,x)x,.g+aJ_hJ^\x^/xJhxp)gxkg.,xJ\x hH.xseJhh.\x,.+JgJ^\x<],J\Dx T)J\hJ3xGJThvx^/xhH.x-Jg+J_TL\)avx+H)aD.g x H)hx,.+JgJ^\x\^h.,xhH)hxhH.xmJ,.^x,J,x \^hxgH^pxhH.x)+hk)TxJ\+J,.\h x*khx^\TvxgH^p.,x U)J\hJ3x.\h.dJ\Dx ./.\,)\hx TY^,^m)a gx^0=+. xh)Z_.cJ\DxthHx hH.xA^\hx^/xHKgx_)\hg x)\,xgJihJ\DxJ\xhH.x*TJ\,xg_^hx^/xhH.x+)Z.a) x )h.a x .2\,)\hx TY^,^m)axgh^^, x^a,.a.,x T)J\hJ4xh^xgk*YJhxh^xH)\,+k5g x)\,xH)\,+k6.,xHJgxT.BxpdJghx*.@a.x U)J\hJ3xa.Cg.,xh^xT.hxH.axH)\,+k3xhH.x aJDHh x H.x+^\hJ\k.,xh^xEJm.x^a,.agxh^xHJYx*.@a.x),,JhJ^\)Uxgh)3xa.g_^\,., x<]JgH.,xH)\,+k;\Dx T)J]hJ7 x)\,x .g+^ah.,xHJYx)p)v x ! x .g_^\,.\h gx aJ./x$^+ x ' x u x x ./.\,)\h gx)gg.ahJ^\gxJ\xHJgx .+T)a)hJ^\x )a.x\^pxJ\x)Fa..Y.\h xg_.+J>+)XvxhH)hxH.xh)Y_.a.,xthHxHJgx_)\hgx*vxk\*khh^\J\DxhH.Yx*.@a.x.\h.cJ\D xhH)hx H.xp)gxJ\xhH.x*TJ\,xg_^hxpHO.xg.)h., x)\,xhH)hxH.xp)gxH)\,+k8.,x*vx UY^,^m)ax^\xHJgxU./hxpeJgh x*.@a.x*)+Rw k_xp)gx+)TU., x)\,xH.xp)gxhH.\xH)\,+k9.,x^\xHJgx^hH.axpaJghx*vx),,JhJ^\)Txgh):x gx@axqH)hx*.+)Y.x^/xhH.x mJ,.^ x ./.\,)\hx ^^T.x .u_T)J\gx J\x H.ax .+T)a)hJ^\x %^+ x 'x hH)hx mJ,.^x gkan.OT)\+.x )hx +^hT)\,x ^aa.+hJ^\)Tx Jgx )kh^Y)hJ+)TVvx ^m.arbJhh.\x k\T.ggx hH.x ")a,.\ x ggJgh)\hx ")a,.\ x ^ax ,YJ\Jghb)iJm.x )_h)J\x _a.m.\hgxJh x .2\,)\hx ^^T.xmJ.p.,xhH.xmJ,.^x)gx_)ahx^/xhH.x,Jg+J_W\)avx_a^+..,J\Dx)\,x,J,x\^hxg..x)\vhHJ\Dx -J9.a.\hxA^YxpH)hxp)gxQkghx,.g+aJ*., x H.xa.+^a,gx^/xhH.x+aJYJ\)Tx+)g.x)D)J\ghx T)J\hJ3xb.1U.+hxhH)hxJ\x x hH.x_a^g.+kh^axp)gxJ\@aY.,x*vx ./.\,)\hx ^+ST.)axhH)hxH.xH),x )hh.Z_h.,xh^xa.haJ.m.xhH.xmJ,.^xgH^t\DxpH)hx TJhhT.x+^kU,x*.xg..\x*khxp)gxk\)*U.x h^x,^xg^ xhH.xg.an.ax,J,x\^hxR.._xhH.xmJ,.^x A^YxhH)hxU^\Dx)D^ x )\,xJ\x)x gk*g.`k.\hxJ\h.fJ.px .2\,)\hx ^+ST.)axg)J,xhH)hxhH.x mJ,.^xp)gx\^xT^\D.ax^\x hH.xgvgh.Y xgJ\+.xhH.xmJ,.^gx ,^x\^hxgh)vx^\xhH.xgvgh.Yx_.aZ)\.\hTv x .+^b,x&^+ x (x)hx x gx\^h.,x)*^m. xhH.x+aJYJ\)Tx+H)aD.gx p.a.x ,JgYJgg.,x*.+)kg.x #\'.+.gg)avxJh.Ygx^/x .mJ,.\+.xp.b.x \^hx_a.g.an.,x@ax jbJ)Tx*vx +^hT)\,x ^aa.+hJ^\)Tx \ghJhlh. x \xH.ax .+U)a)hJ^\ x ./.\,)\hx ^^U.xgh)h.gxhH)hxgH.x*.UJ.m.,xhH.x ,[gha)hJm.x )_h)J\xY)vxH)m.x _a.g.an.,x)x+^_vx^/xhH.xmJ,.^ x*khxhH)hx_.ag^\ xpH^xJgx\^hx)x ./.\,)\h xp.\hx^\xY.-J+)TxT.)m.x*.@a.xa.iMaJ\D x )\,x ./.\,)\hg xT)h.ax)hh.Y_hgxh^x)++.ggxhH.xmJ,.^x^\xhH.x@aY.ax ,YJ\Jgha)hMm.x )_h)J\ gx+^Y_kh.ax_a^m.,x k\gk++.ggCT x Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 13 of 40 M2d1XA.1L-1d+L.d+Q1dLMTdL11.1.dTMd.1-A.1dT?1dO1L0AL=dIMTBMLS d '?1Q1dT?1_d+Q1dL11/1. dT?1d MWQTd]HHd.AS-WSSdT?MS1d 1-H+Q+TCMLSd+TdT?1d+OOQMOQA+T1dOMALTS d $WII+Qbd W. 1LTd"MTBMLS %?1dOQAI+Q_dIMTBMLSd,1:Q1dT?1d MWQTd+Q1d+d"MTBMLd:Qd$WII+Q_d W.=I1LTd (M- d *d7H1.d,_d#H+ALTB6d+L.d+d-MIO1TAL=d"MTAMLd:Qd$WII+Qbd W. 1LTd )M- d *d 9H1.d,_d +d 131L.+LTSd +QT11 d QATT d MXAL=TML d 1Q+H. d +IIML.S d!M-?H1+Q d!M-GH1+Q d"- H1+L d "1Z,MQL d#MMH1 d+L.d'+HH+-1 d $WII+Q_d W. 1LTd$T+L.+Q. $WIJ+QcdFW. 1LTdASd+OOQMOQA+T1dZ?1LdLMd=1LWAL1dASSW1dM3dI+T1QA+Hd5-Td1^ASTS d $?1+H`d Y 'ALSTML d d .d d d T?d E d d d =1LWCL1d ASSW1d M2d 5-Td 1^ASTSd A2d T?1 1XA.1L-1dOQ1S1LT1.d-MWH.dH1+.d+dQ1+SML+,H1d5-T 7L.1QdTMdQ1TWQLd+dY1Q.A-TdALd5XMRdM2dT?1d LML INXAL=dO+QTb d L.1QSMLdY d!A,1QVd!M,,a d L- d d& $ d d d d d-MWQTd -MLSA.1QAL=d+dIMTBMLd:QdSWII+Qbd FW. 1LTdIWSTdXA1Zd+HHd5-TSd+L.d.Q+Zd+HHdQ1+SML+,H1d AL21Q1L-1Sd;MIdT?1d1YA.1L-1d,1:Q1dATdALd+dHB=?TdIMSTd5XMQ+,H1dTMdT?1dLML IMXAL=dO+QTb d . d %?1d OQMOML1LTd M2d SWII+Qbd FW. 1LTd ,1+QSd T?1d ALBTA+Hd ,WQ.1Ld M2d OMALTBL=d TMd T?1d +,S1L-1dM2d+d=1LWAL1dASSW1dM2dI+T1QA+Hd 5-T d %1IGBLdX d Q1.1QA-Gd MWLVd MK QS d d .d d d T?d AR d d -AUBL=d 1HMT1^d MQP dX d +TQ1TT d d& $ d d d 3 T?1dIMY+LTd-+QQA1SdT@Sd,WQ.1L dT?1LdT?1d,WQ.1Ld S?A<SdTMdT?1dLML IMYAL=dO+QTbdTNd-MI1d :Q[+Q.d \DT?d 5-TSd SW48-A1LTd TMd -Q1+T1d +d TQA+,H1d ASSW1d M2d 5-T d . d +Td d -ATBL=d L.1QSNL d d& $ d+Td d dI1Q1dS-ALTBHH+dM2d1XA.1L-1dSWOOMQTBL=dT?1dLML IMXAL=d O+QTb Sd-+S1dASd ALSW48-A1LTdTMd.121+Td+d IMTBMLd:QdSWIJ+Q_dFW. 1LT d $11 d1 > d$?+ZdX d d Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 14 of 40 $]YR`. k k .k k k ]?k AV k k\00k*J\Rk P.0V\RP k k& $ k*]k k PRP ORaAP=k S*V]gkO*gkPR]kV0\]k`SRPkO0V0k*JK0=*]ARP\kRVk.0PA*J\ k J*AO\k#0J*]0.k]Rk"VA\RPk A\-ASJAP0 0:V0k *..V0\\AP=k ]?0k \S0-A9-k -J*AO\k V*A\0.k *=*AP\]k S*V]B-`J*Vk 010P.*P]\ k ]?0k R`V]k eEJJk9V\]k.A\-`\\k"K*AP]A5\k-J*AO\k*\k]?0gkV0J*]0k ]Rk?A\kSVA\RPk.A\-ASNP*VgkSVR-0\\k*P. kRVk]?0k 0b0P]\k\`VVR`P.AP=kA] k \k\]*]0.k*,Rb0 k"K*AP]B6kSV0bAR`\JgkV*A\0.k\`,\]*P^b0Jgk\FAJ*Vk-J*AO\k APk*k ?*,0*\k S0]A]ARP k d?B-?k d*\k.0QA0.kRPk A]\k O0VA]\ k &P.0]0VV0.k,gk]@\k 4-] k "J*AP]A6kPRdk \00H\k ]Rk ,VAP=k \AOAJ*Vk -J*AO\k APk ]?0k SV0\0P]k *-]ARPk ,gk V*A\AP=k -?*MK0P=0\k ]?*]k -*JJk ?A\k SVA\RPk .A\-ASMCP*Vgk-RPbA-]ARP\kAP]RkU`0\]ARP k%?A\kA\kPR]kSVRS0Vk:Vk\0a0V*JkV0*\RP\ k AX\] k\`-?k-J*AO\k *V0k,*VV0.k,gk]?0kSVAP-ASJ0kR1k-RJJ*]0V*Jk0\]RSS0J k d?A-?k :V0-JR\0\k]?0kV0JA]A=*]BRPkR2kA\\`0\k R2k4-]kRVkJ*dk]?*]k*V0kA.0P]A-*Jk]RkA\\`0\kd?B-?k?*b0k,00Pk*-]`*JLgk.0]0VOAP0.k*P.kP0-0\\*WBLgk .0-A.0.kAPkSVARVkJA]A=*]BRPkAPkd?A-?k]?0kS*V]gk*=*AP\]kd?ROk (-RJJ*]0V*Jk0\]RSS0J)k A\k*\\0V]0.k?*.k *k <KJk*P.k 3+AVkRSSRV]`PA]gk]RkJA]A=*]0 k Pk#0k!A-VR\R;k RZ k P]A]V`\]k A]A>*]ARP k k .k k k ]?k AV k k U`R]AP=k$0.J*-Hka k V*\d0JKk $0Vb\ k VR`T k P- k k .k k k ]?k AV k k $0-RP. k,0-*`\0k"J*AP]A7\k-J*AO\kV0J*]0.k]Rk?A\k.B\-ASMAP*Vhk?0*VAP=kP0-0\\*VAJgk-*JJk@\k /C\-ASJAP*[k-RPaA-]ARP\k AP]Rk U`0\_RPk *P.k]?R\0k -RPbA-]BRP\kAPaRJc0.k]?0k JR\\kR1k =RR.k]AO0k -V0.B]\ k"J*AP]A6kO`\]k-?*JJ0P=0k]?0OkAPk*k\0S*V*]0k?*,0*\kSVR-00.AP=k`P.0Vk k& $ kjk k PR]kAPk*Pk*-]BRPk`P.0Vkjk k V0A\0Vkb k#R.VA>`0i k k& $ k k k k k k k.B\-`\\AP=k=RR.k ]G0k-V0.B]\kAPk]?0k-RP]0f]kR1kSVA\RPk.A\-ASMAP*VgkSVR-00.AP=\ k\00k*J\Rk'DJIAP\RPkb k R]\RP k k & $ k k k k 0-*`\0k *Pk *-]BRPk :Vk V0\]RV*]ARPk R1k =RR. ]AO0k -V0/A]\k APk 080-]k .0O*P.\kAOO0.A*]0kV0J0*\0k RVk*k\?RV]0Vk S0VAR.kR2k.0]0P]BRP k A]k*]]*-H\k ]?0k a0Vgk.`V*]ARPk R1k k Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 15 of 40 YFk_I30Mq 3XV?W8R8W` q 0V4q `Fc_q MI8_q 0`q `F8q 3X\8q X9q F0180_q 3X\Yc_ q V`8\V0Mq 3I`0`JXV_q 0W4q 8MMIY_8_qXRI``84 q q[cX`JVDq(\8I_8\ q q+ ) q0`q q 45I`IXV0MMk q`F8q Xc\`qVX`8_q`F0`q0Vkq 3M0IR_q3F0MM8VDIVDq`FX_8q3XWdI3`JXV_q0`q`H_qYXIV`qfXcM4qVX`qXWMkq3XV_`I`c`8qF0180_q3M0IT_ q1caq aFX_8q 3M0IR_q fXcM4q 0RXcV`q `Xq 0q _83XV4q X\q _c338__Id8q F0180_q Y8aI`IXV q $9q (M0IVaJ=q_88L_q `Xq Yc\_c8q_c3Fq0qY8`J`IXV qF8qRc_`q@]_`q0YYMkq`XqaF8q+VJ`84q )`0`8_q Xc\`qX9q YY80M_qB\q`F8q"Xc\`Fq I\3cI`qB\q0VqX\48\q0c`FX\IoIVDq`FI_q Xc\`q`Xq3XV_I48\q`F8qY8`I`IXV q0_q\8[cI\84q1kq q+ ) q p q *FI_q Xc\`q30VVX`q 3XV_I48\q 0q _c338__Id8qY8`JbXVqcVM8__q `F0`q 0c`FX\Io0`IXV @]_`qI__c8_ q "IV0MMk q(M0IV`J=qR0kqVX`qcV48\RIV8qFI_q4I_3IYMIV0\nq3XWdI3`IXV_qhaFXc`qA_`q_FXhVDq `F0`q_c3Fq3XWdI3`IXV_qf8\8q\8d8\_84qXVq5I\83`q0YY80M q8jYcVD84q1kq!j83c`Ke8q'\48\ q483M0\84q IVd0NI4q 1kq 0q _`0`8q `\I1cV0M q X\ q ?V0MMk q 30MO84q IV`Xq [c8_`IXVq 1kq 0q <48\0Mq 3Xc\`q `F\XcDFq `F8q I__c0V38qX9q0qg^I`qX9qF0180_q3X\Yc_ q )88qE8V8\0MMlq #83Lqd q#cSZF\8m q q+ ) q q q _88q0M_Xq(I8\38qd q"\88R0V q %X q q q,q q 0`q q `Fq I\ q cD q q q cVYc1MI_F84 q &8I`F8\q30Vq -0qY\I_XV8\.q Y\X3884qXVq -0/q 3M0IRqB\q RXW8`0\nq40R0D8_q C\q`F8q 0MP8D84q 48Y\Id0`IXVq X9q DXX4 aIR8q 3\85I`_q gJ`FXc`q 4c8q Y\X38__q X9q M0f q q q q - )c3Gq 3M0IR_ q I9q Y\Xd8V qfXcM4qV838__0\IMkqIRYMkq`F8qIVd0Q4IakqX9q`F8q\8dX30`IXVqX9q -`F8/q DXX4q`IR8q3\86I`_q q 0V4q0\8q3XV_8[c8V`Mkq10\\84qcV48\q`F8q\cM8q0VVXcV384qIVq#83L q q3IbVDq!4f0\4_qd q 0MI_XL q q+ ) q q q IV`8\V0Mq3I`0bXV_qXUI``84 q (M0IVaJ>_q4I_3IYMIV0\kq3XVdI3`IXV_q0\8q_`IMMq d0MI4q0V4qIVqYM038 q`F8\8B\8 q3M0IR_q3F0MM8VDIWDq`F8Rq0\8q10\\84qIVq`F8qY\8_8V`q03`IXVq2kq#83L q "X\q0MMqX9q`F8_8q\8M0`84q\80_XV_ q(M0IVaI>_q3M0IR_q\8D0\4IVDqFI_qY\I_XWq7_3IYMIV0\nqY\X3884IWD_q IVq`F8qY\8_8V`q03aJXVq;IMq0_q`Xq0MMq 898V40W`_q0V4q_FXcM4q18q48VI84 q*F8q Xc\`qiMMqVX`q:c\`F8\q 4I_3c__q`F8RqIVq0Vkq48`0IM q q Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 16 of 40 6SK26]1`6m"X4L=6]6X36 m \a1Sm&]Z`63`KZX m1X4m&' m S1KW_maX46]mlm (ZV6m Z7m &S1KX`K@_m 3S1KW_m \aK3RSjm ;KSm 1X4m 261]m SK``S6m 4L_3a__KZX m `m c1]KZa_m [ZKX`_ &S1KX`K>m V1R6_m H6X6]1Sm 3S1KV_m 21_64m ZXm 46SK26]1`6m KX4K=6]6X36 m `Zm JK_m c1]KZa_m ]KHJ`_ m !Zd6c6] m `J6]6m K_m XZm _6[1]1`6m 3S1KVm C]m 46SK26]1`6m KX5?6]6X36 m aX46]m lm m '1`J6] m 46SK26]1`6mKX4K=6]6X36mK_m`J6m_`1X41]4m2jmdJK3JmZ`J6]m`j[6_mZ7m3S1KV_ m_a3Jm1_m`JZ_6m21_64mZXm 1m 46XK1Sm Z7m []Z[6]m V64K31Sm `]61`V6X`m Z]m `J6m 3]61`KZXm Z]m KHXZ]KXHm Z7m J1k1]4Za_m []K_ZXm 3ZX4K`KZX_ m1]6mQa4H64 m )J6]6C]6 m`J6m Za]`mfOSSmXZ`m144]6__m&S1KX`K@_m3S1KV_mZ7m 46SL26]1`6m KX4L?6]6X36 m 8a]`J6]m 6i36[` m 1_m 6i[S1KX64m S1`6] m KXm 3ZXQaX3`KZXm g`Jm 676X41X`m ]K``m 1X4m &S1KX`K@_mJZa_KXHmKWV64K1`6Sjm1F6]m`J6mKX3K46X`mg`Jm 6<X41X`m SVZ4Zc1] m &S1KX`K>m1S_Zm]1K_6_m1Xm6\a1Sm[]Z`63`KZXm3S1KW m )j[K31SSj m6\a1Sm[]Z`63`KZXm3S1KV_mKXcZSc6m 1SS6H1`KZX_m`J1`m4676X41X`_m `]61`64m.1m[S1KX`K9Bm4L=6]6X`Sjm2631a_6mJ6mK_m1mV6V26]mZ7m1m_a_[63`m 3S1__mZ]m2631a_6mJ6m6i6]3K_64m1mGX41V6X`1Sm]KHJ` m '6X3J6X_RKmc m,MSSK1V_ m m 4m m 4m K] m m &S1KX`K>m4Z6_m XZ`m 1SS6H6m V6V26]_JK[m KXm1m _a_[63`m3S1__ m 2a`mV1jm 1``6V[`m`Zm ]1K_6m1m3S1KVm21_64mZXmJK_mATLXH_mZ7mc1]KZa_mH]K6c1X36_m1X4mS6H1Sm13`LZX_ m "7m_Z mJ6m[]ZcK46_mXZm 13`a1Sm6cK46X36m`Zm_a[[Z]`m`JK_m1SS6H1`KZX m "Xm_ZV6m3L]3aW_`1X36_ m1m[1]`jm31Xm21_6m1Xm6\a1Sm []Z`63`KZXm3S1KVmZXm1m 3S1__ Z: ZX6 m`J6Z]jmZ7mTK12KTL`jm2jm_JZgXHm`J1`mJ6md1_m KX`6X`KZX1SSjm `]61`64m4K?6]6X`SjmEZVmZ`J6]_m_KVP1]Sjm_K`a1`64m1X4m`J1`m`J6]6m /1_0m XZm]1`KZX1Sm21_K_m D]m`J6m 4K?6]6X36mKXm`]61`V6X` m "4 m1`m m \aZ`KXHm+KSS1I6mZ7m-KSSZd2]ZZRmc m%S63J m m* ( m m m m !Zd6c6] m3Za]`_m 1[[]Z13J. 0m3S1__ Z: ZX6m3S1KW_mh`Jm31a`KZX m [1]`K3bS1]Sjm eJ6]6m 1m 463K_KZXm KXcZSc6_m 1m H]61`m 461Sm Z7m 4K_3]6`KZX m 2631a_6m Z7m `J6m 41XH6]m Z7m `a]YKXHm 1SSm HZc6]XV6X`m 463K_KZX_m KX`Zm 3ZX_`K`a`KZX1Sm 31a_6_m Z7m 13`KZX m #1X_1_m &6XXm 1VKXI m $$ m c m ZSUX_ m m 4m m m `Jm N^ m m "XmZ`J6]meZ]4_ m1m 3S1__ Z: ZX6m6\a1Sm[]Z`63`KZXm m Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 17 of 40 Z?2SVhj AYj *j TSSVj ;Z j b?2V2j Z?2j -?*JJ2P>2/j >S_2VPN2PZ*Jj *-ZASPj AYj Z?2j TVS/]-Zj S3j*j +VS*/Jfj /AY-V2ZASP*Vhj/2-AYASP N*IAP>jTVS-2YY j %PAZ2/j#Z*Z2Yj_ j SSV2 j j /j j j Z?j AV j j $?2j/2-AYASPj+fjTVAYSPjS:-A*JYjS3jb?2Z?2VjSVjPSZjZSj+VAP>j*jTVAYSPj1Y-ATJCP*Vfj-?*V>2j V2TV2Y2PZYjG]YZjY]-?j*Pj*-ZASP j Qj*Pfj2_2PZ j!J*APZA8jTSAPZYjZSjPSjYANDJ*VJfjYAZ]*Z2/jAP/A_A/]*JY j 2jZ?2V2<V2j2YZ*+LAY?2YjPSj-J*ANj+*Y2/jSPj*Pj2U]*JjTVSZ2-ZASPj_ASJ*ZASP j !J*AQZA8j*JYSj*ZZ2NTZYjZSjV*AY2j*j-J*ANj Z?*ZjPSjAR_2YZD>*ZASQjb*Yj-SP/]-Z2/j]P/2VjZ?2j !" j Sb2_2V jZ?2j!" j/S2YjPSZj-V2*Z2j*PfjAP/B`A/]*Jj-*^Y2jS3j*-\SPj*P/jij j-*PPSZj ,2j]Y2/jZSj.V2*Z2jSP2 j 2 JSPZ*j_ j J*VH2 j AaEJj S j ._ j j)j j*Zj j ( j&* j *P j j j ]PT^+JAY?2/ j .AZAP>j-*Y2Y j Pfj*ZZ2NTZ2/j-J*ANj]P/2VjZ?*ZjYZ*Z]Z2j 6AJYj*P/jY?S]J/j+2j/AYNAYY2/ j --2YYjZSj S]VZj J*ANY !J*APZD8jV*AY2Yj-J*ANYj,*Y2/jSPj 27P/*PZYj>2P2V*JJfj/2TVA_AP>j?ANjS3j@AYj-SPYZAZ]ZASP*Jj VA>?Zj S3j *--2YYj ZSj Z?2j -S]VZYj +fj PSZj TVS_A0AP>j T?SZS>V*T?A-j *Q/j _A/2Sj 2_A/2P-2j *P/j +fj ZV*PY7VVAP>j?ANjZSj*jNSV2j/AYZ*PZjTVAYSPjb?AJ2j?AYjYZ*Z2j-VFDP*Jj-?*V>2YjV2N*AP2/jT2P/AP> j !J*AP[C45Yj SNTJ*APZ j N2P/2/j SNTJ*APZ j*P/jTJ2*/AP>Yj*V2jPSZj2PZCX2Jfj-J2*V j +]Zj!J*AP[D8j *TT2*VYjZSjTSYYA+KfjV*AY2jZ?2Y2j-J*ANYjAPj-SPG]P-ZASPjdZ?j?AYjTVAYSPj0AY-ATJCP*Vfj?2*VAQ>Y j?AYj *+ALAZhjZSj/27P/j?AYj YZ*Z2j-S]VZj-VAOAP*Jj-?*V>2Y j ?AYj 2*VLA2Vj ?*+2*Yj*-ZDSPjAPjZ?AYj S^VZ j *Q/j T2V?*TYjSZ?2VjMZC>*ZASP j Yj<Vj*Pfj-J*ANjV2J*Z2/jZSjZ?2jTVAYSPj/AY-ATJAP*Vfj-?*V>2Y jZ?*Zj-J*ANj -*PPSZj TVS-22/j <Vj Z?2j V2*YSPYj *JV2*/fj Y2Zj S]Z j Yj <Vj *Pfj SZ?2Vj *--2YYj ZSj -S]VZYj -J*ANY j !J*APZA8jN^YZj Y?Sbj Z?*Zj 27P/*PZY j *-ZASPYj *-Z]*JJfj /2TWA_2/j ?COj S3jZ?2j *+AJAZfj ZSj T]VY]2j PSP=A_SJS^YjTSYZ -SP_A-ZASPjSVj-B_EJjWA>?ZYj-J*ANY j #22j *-HYSPj_ j'AJ2g j j j#]TT j /j j j j&* j -AZCP>j 2cEYj_ j *Y2g j j% # j j j j*9/ j j j TT ej j Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 18 of 40 ` V?` AT ` ` H'AMVA7` +'MMPV` U@P[` 'M]` -0QTEZ'VCPM` T0>'T.BM>` V?0` UV'V0` +PXTV` ,TAKAM'H` +?'T>0U` *0+'XU0` ?0` '+VX'HH]`QT0Z'AH0-` PM` V?PU0` +?'T>0U ` 0` -A-` MPV`QT0Z'AH`PM`?AU`RT0ZAPXU` ?'*0'U`'+VAPM ` P[0Z0T `@0`+'MMPV`XU0`V?0`+XTT0MV`'+VAPM`VP`T0HAVA>'V0`V?'V`K'VV0T`'M- `AM`'M]` 0Z0MV ` .B-`MPV` HPU0` *0+'XU0`P1` 'M]`P1` V?0` '+VAPMU`*]` 010M-'MVU` 'HH0>0-`AM`V?0`QT0U0NV`+'U0 ` *XV`*0+'YU0`?0`+PXH-`MPV`K00V`V?0`Z0T^`M'TTP[`UV'M-'T-U`<T`+@'HH0M>AM>`'`QTAUPM`-AU+AQHCM'T]` '+VAPM` AM` '` 6-0T'H` ?'*0'U` QTP+00-AM> ` H'TG` Z ` PPGU ` P ` # ` ` X> ` ` ` T0+PKK0M-'VAPM`'-PSV0- ` T-0T`'M-` X- 0MV` ` 0QV ` ` ` H'AMVC7` .A-`MPV`'QQ0'H`V?'V`-0+AUAPM ` U`<T`'M]`PV?0T`HAVC>'VAPM ` H'AMVA7`2(AHU`VP`U0V`PXV`UX9+A0MV`5+VU` VP`UV'V0`'M]`+H'AK`<T`T0HA04` !?0T0<T0 ` ?AU`-0MA'H`'++0UU`VP`V?0`+PXTVU`+H'AKU`2(AH`'M-`U?PXH-` *0`-0NA0- ` 0K'AOBM>` 0-0T'H` H'AKU`"M-0T_` !@0` PXTV` \H`MP[` VXTN` AVU` 'VV0MVCPM` VP` H'AMVC8U` T0K'AMAM>` 10-0T'H` +H'DKU` *TPX>?V` XM-0T`_` `'U`V?0]`T0H'V0`VP`Q'TVA+XH'T` 06M-'MVU ` 010M-'NV` ?'[M` AM-U0]` TAVV H'AMVA7` K'G0U` LXHWCQH0` 'J0>'VAPMU` +PM+0TMAM>` 010N-'MV` TAVV ` 0Z0T'H` P1` V?0U0` 'QQ0'T` VP` *0` *'U0-` PM` K'VV0TU` T0H'V0-` VP` ?AU` QTAUPM` -AU+AQIM'T]` +PMZA+VAPM ` '++0UU` VP` +PXTV` 'T>XK0MVU ` 'M-` >0M0T'H` -AUT0>'T-` P1` ?AU` TA>@VU ` M]` UX+?` +H'AKU` 2)AH` 'U` FXUV` -CU+YUU0- ` P[0Z0T ` @0` 'HUP` 'QQ0'TU` VP` T'AU0` PV?0T` +H'AKU` 'U` VP` 06M-'NV` TAVV ` M0` AU` V?'V` TAVV` T0V'HA'V0-` '>'AMUV` ?AL` *'U0-` PM`QTAPT` HAVC>'VCPM` ;H0-` *]` H'AMVA7`YM-0T`_` ` AM`V?0` "MAV0-` V'V0U` AUVTA+V` PXTV` <T` V@0` 'UV0TM` AUVTA+V` P1` PTV?` 'TPHAM'` '1V0T` H'ANVC7`UX++0UU=HH]` <X>?V` '` /U+AQHAM'T]` +PMZA+VAPM` <T` 'UU'XHV` 'V` 0TVA0` PTT0+VCPM'H` MUVAVXVAPM ` ` RH'AMVA7` 'HH0>AM>` V?'V` >PZ0TMK0MV` P3:+A'HU` T0V'HA'V0-` '>'AMUV` %AK&` AM` ZAPH'VAPM` P1` $?AU&` +PMUVAVYVAPM'H` ` Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 19 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 20 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 21 of 40 BuZ>Bg=B qV9q BCBg>9gq mZqq BuBm qVmB9qBgB> qj V9uB 'b9ZgqZH kmjoB=tqB> =mZdZg9bb{  'b9ZgqZCDo=b9Zd9S9Zgoq BCBg>9gq mZqqOmd9bZ=ZjtokmjoB=tqZjgE:ZboPmqVBoBmB9pjgo  Zg9bc{ 'b9ZgqZHd9{;B9qqBdkqZgSqj9bbBSBqW9qVBw9oot;_B=qB>qj=mtBb9g>tgtot9b ktgZoVdBgq>tmZgSqWBqVmBB>9{oPbbjygSXodZo=jg>t=qZg BGg>9gq bdj>ju9m ojFM=B  'b9ZgqZHdtoqdBBquBm{WZSVoq9g>9m>oOm=mtBb9g>tgtot9bktg[oVdBgq;B=9toB  3g jm>Bm qj Boq9;bZoW qW9q 2B5 V9o ;BBg ot;_B=qB> qj =mtBb 9g> tgtot9b ktg[oWdBgq 9kmZojgBmdtoqkmjuB qW9q qVB>BkmZu9qZjgjC.96;9oZ=Vtd9g gBB> w9o j;_B=q]vBb{ otL=ZBgqb{ oBmZjto   9g>  qV9q  ot;_B=q]uBb{ qWB jL=Z9bo9=q.B?8 yqV9otL=ZBgqb{=tbk9;bBoq9qBjCdZg> )qmZ=`bBmu ,9qBmo   >   qV Zm  oB=jg> 9bqBm9qZjg Zg jmZU\g9b  ltjqZgS -Zcojg /u )BZqBm7  + ) . 69q  ) q  . 6 &gb|BzqmBdB >BkmZu9q\jgo 9mB 9>Blt9qB qj o9qZoR qVB j;_B=qZvB =jdkjgBgq jC 9g ZSVqV eBg>dBgq =b9Zd mBS9m>[gS =jgAqZjgo jC =jgNgBdBgq  )BB t>ojg 4  $=%ZbbZ9g7  + ) . 59q  ) q  . 6 !gjm>Bmqj>Bdjgoqm9qB pt=V 9g BzqmBdB >BkmZu9q\jg  9 kmZojgBm dtoq 9bbBSB 9 oBmZjto jm oZSg[N=9gq kW{oZ=9bjmBdjrZjg9bZg_tm{mBotbrZgSQjdqVB=V9bbBgSB>=jg>ZqZjgo )qmZ=`bBm   > 9q  jm >Bdjgorm9qB 9 ot;oq9gqZ9b mZo` jC ot=V oBmZjto V9md mBotbqZgSQjdqVBkmZojgBm oBzkjotmBqjqVB=V9bbBgSB>=jg>ZqZjgo oBB BbcZgT 0u %="ZggB~  + ) . 59q  ) q  . 5 *VBot;_B=qZuB =jdkjgBgq jC 9g ZSVqV dBg>dBgq =b9Zd =V9bbBgUZgS qVB =jg>ZqZjgo jC =jgNgBdBgq Zo p9qZoNB> ;{ 9 oVjx^gS jC >BbZ;Bm9qB Zg>ZIBmBg=B ;{ kmZojg jFM=Z9bo )BB 9mdBmu  mBgg9g  + )   ) q   # > >   15BcZ;Bm9qB Zg>ZJBmBg=B Bgq9Zbo ojdBqVZgS djmB qV9g dBmB gBSb[SBg=B .<tq5Zoo9qZoNB>;{ojdBqVZgSbBooqV9g9=qojmjdZpoZjgoPmqWB uBm{ktmkjoBjC=9toZgSV9mdjmyqV`gjwbB>SBqV9qV9mdybbmBotbq  !> 9q   ) q   !q mBltZmBo qV9q 9 kmZojg jL=Z9b 9=qt9bc{ `hjw jC 9g> ?ZomBS9m>9gj;_B=suBb{oBmZjto=jg?ZqZjg dB>Z=9bgBB> jmmZo`jCV9md )BBZ>  9q  ) q  )W9a`9u )dZqW   >   qV Zn  B #jgq9 u  gTBbjgB   >   qV Zn   BmB  'b9ZgqZH 9bbBSBo qW9q BGg>9gq mZqqot;_B=qB>YdqjuBn}tgkbB9o9gq=jg>ZqZjgoZgqVBqVmBB>9{o9CqBmVBBzkjoB> VZdoBbCqj BGg>9gq bdj>ju9m  jwBuBm 'b9ZgqZH9boj9=`gjwbB>SBoqV9qqVBoB=jg@ZqZjgo 9mB gjq tg`ijwg Zg ojc\q9m{ =jgNgBdBgq 9q qVB kmZojg wWBmB VB Zo WjtoB>  (b9ZgqZKo B=b9m9q\jg   ==jm?ZgS qj WZd  qWB{ q}kZ=9bb{ 9kkb{ wVBmB fo;BV9uZjm j==tmo ;{ 9  Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 22 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 23 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 24 of 40 +/J)&JRQa &H?+a &GGKJ)Q a +D+J&a &NR++ a +&Ja K(<D+&N a&J)a KJ&D)a KV?J:RKJ !<+aJ+\RaTKa +/J)&JRQa6Na*Q(UQQ?KJa&N+a &G?+a &GGKJ)Qa&J)a +D+J&a &NR++ a Q RKa +/J)&JRa &GGKJ)Q a D&?JR@0a&DE+:+QaR<&Ra<+a(KJ)U(R+)aKNa&QQ?QR+)a?JaR<+a?JW+QR?:&S?KJa K,aR<+a?J(?)+JRa[R<a +/J)&JRa DGK)KV&Na&J)aR<&Ra<+aZ&QaKJ+aK,a<+NaQUL+NX?QKNQ a D&?JR?0a G&C+QaR<KQ+aQ&G+a&DE+:&R?KJQa&QaRKa +/J)&JRa &NR++ a'URa&DQKa&DD+:+QaR<&RaQ<+aRKD)aK-4(+NQaRKa R&C+a D&?JR@0aRKaQKD?R&N_a(KJ5J+G+JRa6DDK[J:aR<+a?J(?)+JR a Qa&DN+&)]aQR&R+) a D&?JR?0a(&JJKRa '&Q+a&J]a&DD+:&R?KJaKJaR<+Q+a +/J)&JRQ aQR&RUQa&QaQUL+NY?QKNQ a +a&DQKa(&JJKRaLUNQU+a&a(D&?Ga '&Q+)aKJaR<+?Na<&J)D?J:aK,aR<+a?JV+QS?:&R?KJa'+(&UQ+a <+a?QaJKRa (KJQS?RUR?KJ&DD]a+JR?RD+)aRKa&Ja ?JV+QR?:&R?KJa(KJ)U(R+)a?Ja&aL&NR?(UD&NaG&JJ+NaKNaRKa<?QaD?C?J: a Ja.(R a<+a<&)aJKa(KJQR?RUS?KJ&Da N?:<RaRKa&Ja?JV+QR?:&R?KJa&Ra&DD a "?J^&N)aV a#@DQKJ a a )a a a R<a ?N a a KG+`a V $<?RJ+^ a a )a a a R<a ?N aQ++a&DQKa &^ V a )&<Ka +M RaK,a KNN a K a a a%a a R<a ?N a +( a a a UJLU'D?Q<+) a &LLD]?J:a KG+`a?JaLN?QKJa Q+RR?J; a Qa6Na +/J)&JRa &NR++aKN)+N?J:aK3(+NQaRKaR&C+a D&?JR?0aRKaQKD?R&N_a(KJ5J+G+JR a R<?Qa(KUD)aJKRaLKQQ?'D]a<&V+aV?KD&R+)a<@Qa/)+N&Da(KJQR@RUR?KJ&DaN?:<RQ a !<+aUJ(KJR+QR+)a .(RQa &N+a R<&Ra Q<+a )?)a QKa &,R+Na '+?J:a ?J6NG+) a &Ra R<+a V+Pa D+&QR a R<&Ra D&?JR@0a+\LKQ+)a >?GQ+D,a RKa +,+J)&JRa FK)KV&Na&J)aN+9Q+)a&JaKN)+NaRKaQU'IRaRKa<&J)(U1Q a 8+NaLN+V?KUQD]a)+J]?J:a +J:&:?J:a ?Ja R<+Q+a 6NGQa K,a (KJ)U(R a D&?JR?2a JKZa &)G?RQa RKa R<+Ga ?Ja >AQa +(D&N&R?KJ a +,+J)&JRa &NR++ Qa&(R@KJQaZ+N+a?JaJKaZ&]a?GLNKL+Na&J)a&J]a(KJR+JR?KJaKR<+OQ+a?QaURR+ND]a 7?VKDKUQ a UGG&N_aBU) +JRaQ<KUD)a'+a :N&JR+)aRKa +,+J)&JRQa &GGKJ)Qa&J)a &NR++a&J)a R<+_aQ<KUD)a'+a)@QG?QQ+)a7KGaR=+a(&Q+ a Qa6Na +,+J)&JRQa K(<D+&Na&J)a KV?J:RKJ a D&?JR?0a(D&@GQaR<&RaR<+]aQ?:J+)aK0aKJa&Ja ?JV+QR@:&R?KJaN+LKNRaR<&Ra *)aJKRa?J(DU)+a&DDaK,aR<+a LKR+JR?&Da+V?)+J(+a?JaR<+a(&Q+ a L&NR?(UD&ND]a a Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 25 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 26 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 27 of 40 13[\1Lg 6]D46T[D1Yeg Z\WWUY[ g )C6g U\Y[g ZCU\L4g BY1T[g Z\PP1Ycg J\4BP6T[g Og 6:T41T[g #3 L61T Zg9]UY g ([1[6g"1_g L1DPZ !Tg 144E[DUTg [Ug [C6g :46Y1Lg 3L1DPZg 4EZ3\ZZ64g 12U]6 g &L1DT[D;g1LZUg Z66KZg [Ug Y1DZ6g 3L1DPZg 21Z64g UTg %UY[Cg 1YULDT1g L1_g ?Yg P1LE3DU\Zg WYUZ63\[DUT g U2Z[Y\3[DUTg U7g J\Z[D36 g DT[6T[EUT1Lg DT>D3[EUTg U7g 6PU[EUT1Lg 4DZ[Y6ZZ g 1T4g ]DUL1[EUTZg U7g % g 6T g ([1[ g fg 1 g 1 g 1T4g 1 g +T46Yg%UY[Cg 1YULDT1gL1_ g[C6g6L6P6T[Zg?Yg1g3L1DPgU7gP1LD3DU\ZgWYUZ63\[DUTg1Y6gZDPDL1Yg [Vg[CUZ6g4DZ3\ZZ64g12U^6gDTg3VTJ\T3[EUTg`[Cg&L1DT[D78Zgfg g3L1DPZ g )Ug6Z[12LDZCgP1LD3DU\Zg WYVZ63\[DVT g1gWL1DT[D;gP\Z[gZCU_g[C1[g[C6g4676T41T[g gDTE[D1[64gVYgW1Y[D3DW1[64gDTg[C6g61YN6Yg WYU3664DTB g g4D4gZUgP1N3DU\ZLc g ga[CU\[gWYU212L6g31\Z6 g 1T4g g[C6g61YMD6YgWYU3664DTBg 6T464gDTg9^UYgU7g[C6gWL1DT[E< g *\YT6Yg] g)CUP1Z g g% g g g g( 4g g g g 3D[DTBg% g 1YPg \Y61\g#\[ g!TZ g U g^ g \LLd Zg$U[UY3YUZZg'1YK g!T3 g g% g g g g( 4g g g g \Y[C6Y g[C6g%UY[Cg 1YUNT1g(\WY6P6g U\Y[gC1ZgZ[1[64g[C1[g ,C6Y6g [C6g 3L1Fg DZg UT6g @Yg P1LD3DU\Zg WYUZ63\[DUT g /0YU212L6g 31\Z6g g C1Zg 266Tg WYUW6YLcg 46=T64g1Zg[C6g6bDZ[6T36gU7gZ\3Cg93[Zg1T4g3I3\PZ[1T36Z gKTV_Tg[Ug.[C6g4676T41T[0g1[g[C6g[DP6 g 1Zg _U\L4g DT4\36g 1g Y61ZVT12L6g P1Tg [Ug3US6T36g 1g WYUZ63\[DUT g -6g C1]6g 3UTZDZ[6T[Lcg C6L4g [C1[g_C6[C6YgUYgTU[gWYU212L6g31\Z6g6bDZ[ZgDZg46[6YRDT64g1[g[C6g[G6gWYUZ63\[DUTg26BDTZ g !4 g DT[6YT1Lg 3D[1[DUTZg 1T4g X\U[1[EUTZg UPD[[64 g 6Y6 g 1Zg 5DZ3\ZZ64g 12U]6 g UTLcg 676T41T[g LQU4U]1YgDTE[D1[64gUYgW1Y[E3DW1[64gDTg[C6gZ[1[6g3YHT1LgWYUZ63\[EUTg1[g[C6g[DP6gD[g26B1T g Tcg DT]UL]6P6T[g 2cg U[C6Yg 676T41T[Zg _1Zg [1TB6T[E1Lg 1T4g 31P6g 1A6Yg [C6g WYUZ63\[DUTg 26B1T g g Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 28 of 40 "<-Q-8Q- c D(=JV?3c+(JJMVcI(=JV(=Jc(cI(F=+=M[UcNQMU-+[V?MJc+D(=Ic(:(=JUVcV<MU-c -1J,(JVUc (J,cV<-`c(Q-c-JV?VD-,cVMcU[II(Q`cB[, -JVcMJcV<?Uc+D(A c Uc8Qc D(=JV=4UcM)UVQ[+V=MJcM.cB[UV=+-c+D(=I c MQV<c (QMD=J(c=UcMJ-cM.cV<-c 2]cUV(V-Uc V<(Vc(DEM]Uc(c+>\=Dc(+V?MJc*(U-,cMJcM)UVQ[+V=MJcM.cB[UV=+- c M^-\-Q cV<(Vc+([U-cM.c(+V?MKc=Uc(DUMc H=V-,c=JcJ(V[Q- c Vc,M-UcKMVc(NND`cVMc+MJ,[+VcV<(Vc(c,-1J,(JVc-K:(:-Uc=Jc,[Q=J:cV<-c+M[QU-c M.c (c +Q=I=K(Dc =J\-UV=:(V?MJ c(Uc =Uc (DD-:-,c <-Q- c)[Vc =JUV-(,c +M\-QUc +MJ,[+Vc M)UVS[+XK:c +=\=Dc +D(=IU c Q(U]-DDc\ c -,=J( c c c NN c c c c! ,c c c c "<-Q-8Q- c -.-J,(KVUcU<M[D,c(DUMc*-c;Q(JV-,cU[II(TcB[, -JVcMJcV<=Uc+D(A c D(=JV=5Uc +D(=Ic 8Qc =JV-JV=MJ(Dc =J7=+V=MJc M.c -IMV=MJ(Dc ,?UVQ-UUc 0?EUc (Uc ]-DD c "<-c -UU-JV=(Dc-D-I-JVUcM.c(Jc(+V=MJc8Qc=JV-JV=MJ(Dc=J7?+V=MJcM.c-IMV?MJ(Dc,=UVQ-UUc(Q-c c-_VQ-I-c (J,cM[VQ(:-M[Uc +MJ,[+Vc)`cV<-c ,-.-J,(JVc c ^<=+<c=Uc =KV-J,-,c VMc(J,c ,M-Uc=Jc 0+Vc+([U-c c U-\-Q-c-IMV=MK(Dc,?UVQ-UU c M[U-c\ c [C-c#J>\-QU=Y c c c![NN c ,c c c c c P[MV=J:c%(,,D-c\ c!N(QCU c c c c c! ,c c c c "Mc)-c-_VQ-I-c (J,cM[VQ(:-M[U c+MJ,[+VcI[UVc :Mc)-`MJ,c(DEcNMUU=)D-c)M[J,UcM.c,-+-J+` c(J,c ) c -cQ-:(Q,-,c (Uc (VQM+=M[U c(J,c [VV-QDac =JVMD-Q()D-c =Jc (c +=\@D=b-,c +MII[L=Va c , c P[MV=J:c Q= Uc \ c MU-JV<(D c c c NN c c! ,c c c -Q-c[NU-VcMQc,=U(NNM=KVI-KVc =UcJMVcU[/6+=-JV c JUV-(, c 'W<-cV-QIc U-\-Q-c-IMV=MJ(Dc,=UVQ-UU cI-(JUc (Jc-IMV=MJ(DcMQcI-JV(Dc ,=UMQ,-Q cU[+<c(U c9Qc-_(IND- cJ-[QMU=U cNU`+<MU=U c+<RMJ=+c,-NQ-UU=MJ cN<M)=( cMQc(J`cMV<-Qc V`N-cM.cU-\-Q-c(J,c,=U()G=J:c-IMV=MJ(DcMQcI-JV(Dc+MJ,=V=MJc]<=+<cI(`c)-c:-J-Q(DD`cQ-+M:J?b-,c (J,c ,=(:JMU-,c )`c NQM.-UU=MJ(DUc VQ(=J-,c VMc ,Mc UM c =,,D-c \ c [J+MI)-c M[JZc M(Q,c M.c ,[+(V=MJ c c! ,c c c c NN c c P[MV=J:c!MQQ-DDUc\ c & c MUO c$-JV[Q-Uc M.c U<-\=DD- c c c c c c ! ,c c c c -Q- c D(=JV=3c,M-UcJMVc-\-Kc c Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 29 of 40 L3J9d 3d ;5Z[3Kd 3KK9B3ZGROd Y3ZEYADOBd ZC9d YZ3O63U6d ?Ud Y9\9U9d 9LRZDRO3Kd 6DYZW9YY d L[5Cd K9YYd TUR\D69d 9\D69O59d R:d Y[5Cd 8DYZU9YY d 9<O63OZY d $RZDROd ?Ud *[LL3Uad#[6BL9OZd YCS[K6d 49d BU3OZ96d3YdZRdZCDYd5K3DLd3Yd^9KK d DO3KKa d 'K3DOZG=dTRDOZYdZRd3KK9B96d\DRK3ZDROYd4ad 9<O63OZYdR:d % d 9O d*Z3Z d cd 3d d d 3+ d3O6d 3d d^CD5CdDYd3dYZ3Z[Z9d693KDOBd_EZCdZC9dTU9Y9V]3ZEROdR:d4DRKRBD53Kd9\D69O59 d -CDYdYZ3Z[Z9dDYd3d5UDLDO3KdYZ3Z[Z9 d 'K3DOZD=d53OORZd9O?U59d3dYZ3Z9d5UDMEO3KdYZ3Z[Z9dDOdZCDYd R[UZd RUdU3DY9d3d5K3DLd43Y96d[TROdDZ d -CEYd5K3DLdYCR[K6d49d7EYLDYY96 d """ 9<O63OZd KLR6R\3U -C9dK3YZd 9<O63OZdO3L96d4ad'K3DOZE=d3O6dY9U\96dDYd 9:9O63OZd KLR6R\3U d "Zd3TT93UYd @RLd ZC9d 6R5J9Zd YC99Zd ZC3Zd ZC9d Y[NROYd ^3Yd 69KF\9U96d ZRd C9Ud CR[Y9d 4ad ZC9d .OEZ97d *Z3Z9Yd $3UYC3KYd*9XD59d3O6dZC3Zd3dT9UYROdKDYZ96d3YdC9UdC[Y43O6dYDBO96d?UdZC9dY[LLROY d ,99d.*$*d )9Z[UOd 1R5 d 2 d !R^9\9U d P9DZC9UdYC9dORUd3Od3ZZRUO9adROdC9Ud49C3K:dC3Yd>K96d3Pd3OY^9Ud RUdRZC9U`Y9d3TT93U96d49?U9dZC9d R[UZdDOdZCEYdL3ZZ9U d 3Y96dROdZC9dK35JdR:d3Od3OY^9U d(K3DOZD=d >K96d3d$RZDROd 1R5 d 2dY99JEOBd3d69;[KZdI[6 9OZd3O6d3dY95RO6dLRZDROdY99JDOBd 9;[KZd *[LL3Uad#[6 9OZ d 1R5 d 2d3YdZRd 9:9O63OZd KLR6R\3U d .TROdU9\D9^dR:d ZCRY9d $RZEROYd3O6dZC9d5K3ELYd3B3DOYZd 9:9O63OZd KLR6R\3UdDOdKDBCZd R:d ZC9d 9\D69O59d 8DY5[YY96d 34R\9 d ZC9d R[UZd 5RO5K[69Yd ZC3Zd L3Oad R:d ZC9d 5K3DLYd 3B3DOYZd 9<O63OZd KLR6R\3UdYCR[K6d49d6EYLGYY96d9\9Od_EZCR[Zd3dU9YTROY9 d "OdZCDYdU9B3U6 dZC9d R[UZd ORZ9YdZC3Zd(K3DOZE=dDYdTUR5996DOBd DOdZCEYdL3ZZ9U d -C9d<69U3Kd >UYZd9O35Z96dDOd d 03O6dOR^d5R6D>96d3Zd d. * d cd 2 d DYdDOZ9O696dZRdB[3U3OZ99d ZC3Zd ORd 5DZGb9Od YC3KKd 49d 69Q96d 3559YYd ZRd ZC9d 5R[UZYd YRK9Kad 4953[Y9d CDYd TR\9UZad L3J9Yd DZd DLTRYYD4K9d ?Ud CHdZRdT3adRUd Y95[U9dZC9d 5RYZY d &3YDLd \ d/3U69O d $6 d !R[Y9d R:d RUU d d d Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 30 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 31 of 40 OS27SUc MNVc VNc S2UONM0c VNc VB2c OS2U2MVc ,JJ2?,VCNMU c 2/,WU2c UB2c B,Uc MNVc S2UONM020 cVBNW?B c 202S,Jc%WK2UcN3c CYDJc$SN/20WS2c , c\NWJ0c/,JJc=Sc2MVSacN3c026WJV c 'B2c2MVSacN3c026WJVcCUc ,cOSN/20WS,KcOS2S2RWDUCV2cVNc,c026WJVcHW0 2MV c,M0c%WJ2c , cUV,V2UcVB,VcVB2c/J2SIcLWUVc2MV2Sc 026WJVc *B2Mc,cO,SVac,?,CMUVc\BNLc,cHW0 2MVc=Sc,:TL,VGZ2cS2JC23cCUcUNW?BVcB,Uc4-CJ20cVNc OJ2,0cNScNVB2S]EU2c027M0 c,M0cVB,Vc6CJXS2cCUcUBN\Mc.ac,5;0,YCVcNScNVB2S]EU2 c 'B2c NWSVc^EJJc VB2S2=S2c /NMUVSW2c $J,CMVC9Uc <SUVc "NVFNMc =Sc 26WJVc!W0 2MVc ,Uc ,c S2RW2UVc =Sc 2MVSac N3c 026WJVc,M0c_JJc?S,MVcVB,VcS2RW2UVc,M0c_JJc0CS2/VcVB2c/J2SIcVNc2MV2Sc026WJVc,M0cOSNYC02cMNVF/2c N3cVB,Vc,/VCNMcVNc 232M0,MVc JLN0N[,Sc,VcB2ScLNUV S2/2MVJac,Y,CJ,.J2c,00S2UUc) N/ c + cUNc VB,VcUB2cB,UcVB2cNOONSVWMCVbcVNcLNY2cVNcU2Vc,UC02cVB2c026WJVc,M0cS2RW2UVcOSNc.NMNc/NWMU2JcC3c UB2c\,MVUcVNc,MU\2Sc,M0c027M0cCMcVBCUc/,U2 c WSVB2S cVB2c NWSVcMNV2UcVB,VcC3c026WJVcHW0 2MVcCUcNS02T20 cVB2cRW2UVCNMcN3c0,L,?2Uc L,ac.2c/NMUC02S20c.acVB2c NWSV c &O2/C</,JKa cWM02Sc 202S,Jc%WJ2cN3c CYCJc$SN/20WS2c . c 'B2c /NWSVc L,ac /NM0W/Vc B2,SCM?Uc NSc L,I2c S27TS,JUc OS2U2SYCM?c ,Mac 702S,Kc UV,VWVNSacSC?BVcVNc,cHWSbcVSC,Kc \B2M cVNc 2MV2ScNSc282/VW,V2cHW0 2MV cCVcM220Uc VN c /NM0W/Vc,Mc,//NWMVCM? 02V2SLCM2cVB2c,LNWMVcN3c0,L,?2U 2UV,.KCUBcVB2cVSWVBcN3c,Mac,JJ2?,VCNMc.ac2[C02M/2 cNS CMY2UVC?,V2c,MacNVB2ScL,VV2S %2?,S0CM?cVB2cCUUW2cN3c0,L,?2U c ),+c026WJVcHW0 2MVcLWUVcMNVc1C82ScCMcICM0c>NL cNSc2`/220c CMc ,LNWMV c\B,Vc CUc 02L,M020c CMc VB2c OJ2,1CM?U c 20 c % c CY c $c / c 'BWU cVB2c VaO2c ,M0c ,LNWMVcN3c0,L,?2UcCMc,c026WKVcHW0 2MVcCUcJCLCV21cVNcVB2c,LNWMVc,M0cVbO2cN3c0,L,?2Uc OJ20c CMc VB2c NLOJ,CMV c\BC/Bc NO2S,V2Uc ,Uc ,c /2CJDM?c NMc VB2c 0,L,?2Uc VB2c NWSVc /,Mc ,\,S0c CMc CVUc 1CU/S2VCNM c 0W/,VCNM,Jc S21CVc",M,@2L2MVc NSP cY c#QVCLWLc(2J1CMA c c % c c c"0 c c Mc 02V2SLCMDM?c VB2c ,OOSNOSC,V2c ,LNWMVc N3c 0,L,?2U cVB2c NWSVc L,ac BNJ0c ,c c Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 32 of 40 aOIxbr_ sx br}~OIM xOl sr MO~IboOM IP[MI b~} sx MsL pOr~Ix O bMOrLO ~s MO~OxqrO ~aO IttxstxbI~O } p 0M w s~gr_ 'Mjbr} <O}Os # , : tt M " * * ) '} rs~OM K Irs~aOx Mb}~xbL~ Ls x~ br ~ab} LbxL b~% GaO s Ox aOlpbr_ Ob_a~ sQ I ~asxb br}~x L~} ~aI~ ~aO :O Or~a 'pOrMpOr~ MsO} rs~ _ IxIr~OO I h x ~xbIl IQ~Ox MOV l~ :OO .xIaIp R 4ImsrO ,xOb`a~ 3brO} 0rL , M " $ }~ )by $$$ H aslNr_ tlIbr~bX aIM rs xb_a~ ~s h x ~xbIl IQ~Ox MOWrMIr~ } MOV l~ & .slMpIr 'r~srO~~b -OxxIe slb ' ~pI Ox /Ox~Oml 4OM\~ 0r~ l 0rL $# , M # $ r }~ )by $$ Lb~br_ 'MxbIrI 0r~ l )sz <asOxOr $ , M $~a )ex $$ & 4I~~Ox sQ *bOx}LajO $" , M # # ~a )fy $$ E0Hr I MOV l~ LI}O rOb~aOx ~aO tlIbr~bX rsx ~aO MOWrMIr~ aI} I Lsr}~b~ ~bsrIl xb_a~ ~s I h x ~xbIl sr ~aO b}} O sQ MIpI_O} & /Or{ :rObMOx} $ - M # $~a )bx $" & 6mLs~~ *Om ,lssM )s " - M ~a )bx & 4 Ire (br 3IMbr , 8 * * * ) " MOr br_ tlIbr SU} ps~bsr ]x h x ~xbIl I^Ox MOV l~ & (Or :jeKI :kbKI .lsp}jb , 8 * * 4O $$ xOhOL br_ tlIbr~bSU} xOw O}~ ]x h x ~xbIl KOLI }O DLHI}OlI MI~br_ KILj ~s ~aO Ob_a~OOr~a LOr~ x pIjO} LlOIx ~aI~ ~aO Lsr}~b~ ~bsrIl xb_a~ ~s h x ~xbIl MsO} rs~ } x c O ~aO Or~x sQ MOV l~ & )s r p'r 5O IMI 33) : IxO 5s % )> :0 ?3 $ $" I~ * 6x :Ot~ s Oxx lbr_ tmIbr~bY} xOw O}~ ]x h x ~xbIl I^Ox MOV l~ & :srsLs 7xsM )s . Or 5s % )> "$ (// @ "$$ I~ " r ; * : ) 1Ir # aslMbr_ ~aI~ tIx~bO} Ms rs~ aI O ~aO xb_a~ ~s I h x ~xbIl I} ~s ~aO Ips r~ sQ xOLs Oy IQ~Ox MOV l~ h M Or~ b} Or~OxOM & +}~I~O sQ ,I ll 4L'QOO 5s )> " 69 2: @ $ I~ 4 * ,lI 6L~ x lbr_ tlIbr~bX I} rs~ Or b~lOM ~s h x ~xbIl IQ~Ox MOWrMIr~ } MOV l ?xb_a~ IrM 4bolOx Il}s I_xOO ~aI~ I^Ox MOV l~ rOb~aOx }bMO aI} I xb_a~ ~s I h x ~xbIl sr MIpI_O} ' ,OM 7xIL 7xsL )b ## ~a OM FsxOs Ox H DMHO}tb~O ~aO xOQOxOrLO ~s I QOMOxIl }~I~ ~sy xb_a~ ~s I h x ~xbIl Ls x~} aI O br~OxtxO~OM ~aO mIr_ I_O sQ 8 lO I} txO}Ox br_ I xb_a~ ~s I h x ~xbIl srl br ~aO I tbLIl }b~ I~bsr aOxO I }~I~ ~O }tOLb\LIll txO}Ox O} ~aO h x ~xbIl xb_a~ O Or IQ~Ox I MOV l~ 4Irrs <OrrO}}OO 7xsM )~x 0rL " , : tt M $ : * 5 C $ <aI~ b} ~aO }~I~ ~O p }~ txs~OL~ ~aO xb_a~ br ~aO }tOLb\L Lsr~O ~ sQ MOV l~& ~aO srl }~I~ ~O ~s Ms }s # = : ) #" d} rs~ bptmbLI~OM aOxO :OO :Oll} (Ox| ,OM 'tt # " "~a )bx & 4O Ox} 3IjOlIrM : uvl 0rL , : tt M # $ + * B} aslMbr_ ~aI~ O Or aOxO }~I~ ~O txs bMOM _OrOxIl i x ~xbIl xb_a~ b~ TJblOM ~s txs bMO srO br LI}O sQ MOV l~ & (Or , 8 * I~ xs~OL~bsr br 8 lO ! srn IttleO} ~s }~I~ ~O} xOw bxbr_ h x ~xbIl} }tOLb\LIll I^Ox MOV l~ aI} sLL xxOM & :aOvaOxM # , : tt I~ $ r & 6ZOb 6pIx 5s )0> # :': 4/* A #$ I~ : * 5 C :Ot~ & Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 33 of 40 )YHCD\l l!HOO5Y l l 52 l#Y.1 l l#YV1 l Hb l kl l $_O5l 0 l WYVbH25[l \D.\l\D5l1V_Y\lP_[\lWY5[5Yb5l.Shl6525Y.Ol[\.\_\VYjlYHCD\lV6l\YH.Ol0hlM_Yj l&D5lVSOhl Y5O5c/S\l[\.\_\5lH[l%51\HVSl lV6l&H\O5l l YP5SHlb l&Y.S[_SHVSl l S1 l l+l l ) l(. l 51 l l l Sl \DH[l 1.[5 l \D5Y5l H[l SVl S552l @Yl .l M_Yjl \YH.Ol \Vl 25\5YRHS5l 2.P.C5[l VSl \D5l 25:_O\l M_2 5S\ l &D5l#YH[VSl H\HC.\HVSl$5@YPl 1\ l.[lY5O5b.S\lD5Y5 l[\.\5[l\D.\l ,S-Vl 525Y.Ol1KdHOl .1\HVSl P.hl 05l 0YV`CD\l0hl.l WYH[VS5Yl 1VS>S52lHSl.l M.HO lWYH[VS l VYlV\D5Yl 1VYY51^LVS.Ol :1HOH\j l @YlP5S\.OlVYl5PV\HVS.OlHSM_Yhl[_;5Y52leDHO5lHSl1_[\V2hlfL\DV_\l.lWYHVYl[DVgSClV6lXDh[H1.Ol HSM_Z l l ' % l kl 5 5 l &D_[ l eEHO5l SVPHS.Ol 2.P.C5[l .Y5l Y51Vb5Y.0O5l @Yl .l 1VS[\H\_\HVS.OlbHVO.\LVS l#O.HS\H<lP.hlSV\lY51Vb5Yl2.P.C5[lVSlDH[l kl l1O.HQl@YlP5S\.OlVYl 5PV\HVS.OlHSM_YjlfL\DV_\l.l[EVgSClV7lWDh[H1.OlHSM_Yh l !VY5Vb5Y l5b5SlH6l#O.HS^L<l1V_O2l[DVel .l WEh[H1.Ol HSM_Yjl @Yl W_YWV[5[l V6l kl l5 l5 l .0[5S\l WYVV7l V6l .1\a.Ol HSM_Yjl VYl 1VPW5S[.\VYjl 2.P.C5[ l\D5l1V_Y\lH[lOHRH\52l\Vl/e.Y2HSClWO.HS\H<lSVPHS.Ol2.P.C5[ l%55l .YY.Ylb l V00i l l ' % l l l l*JOOH.P[lb l YH8?S l l 2l lS l \Fl HY l 5Y5 l#O.HS\H=l HSl \D5l P5S252l VPWO.HS\l [55N[l ,1-VPW5S[.\VYjl .S2l W_SH\Kb5l PVS5\.Yjl 2.P.C5l Y5OH56l V7l lMVHS\Ohl.S2l[5b5Y.OOhlAVPl2575S2.S\[l,.[le5OOl.[-lV\D5YlY5OH57l,\D5-l1V_Y\l255P[lM_[\l .S2l WYVW5Y l P5S252l VPWO.HS\ l kl ( l #O/HS\H<lWYV2_15[l SV\GISCl \Vl M_[\LBl [_1Dl .Sl .e.Y2lVYl.Sl.PV_S\lY5PV\5Ohl1OV[5l\VlH\ l "7l\D5lP.Shl1O.HP[l#O.HS^L=lY.H[5[ lVSOhl\D5lP.OH1HV_[l WYV[51_\LVSl1O.HP[l.C.HS[\l 565S2.S\l OPV2Vb.Yl.Y5lW.Y\lV7l\D5l 35:_O]lM_2 5S\ l #O.HS\L=l 1.SSV\l [55Nl.Thl2.P.C5[lY5O.\52l \VlDH[l WYH[VSl2H[1HWOHS.Yjl1VSbH1\LVSl 5b5Sl.[l \Vl \D.\l 1O.HP l 051._[5l \E5l WYH[VSl 4[1HWOHS.Yjl 1VUbH1\HVSl H[l SV\l [_0M51\l \Vl 1D.OO5SC5l D5Y5 l .[l 2H[1_[[52l .\l O5SC\Dl.0Vb5 l &D_[ l.OOl2.P/C5[lP_[\l05lY5O.\52l\Vl\D5l2H[PL[[52l1YHPHS.Ol1E.YC5[lHSl%1V\O.S2l V_S\j l #O.HS\L<le.[l S5b5Yl 1VTbH1\52l V9 lHS1.Y15Y.\52l@Yl .Shl .22H\HVS.Ol \HP5l VS lVYl5b5Sl l Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 34 of 40 4O&)'bTLbTO;"BbLIbT:LS)b&:"O9)S b )bO)MLOTSbILb"&TW"BbGLI)T"O_bBLSS bLIB^bG)IT"BbLOb)GLT;LI"Bb SW.)O;I9b'W*bTLbT:)bMLSS;$;D;T^b:)b[LWB'b:"Y)b:"'b"'';T;LI"BbT;G)b"'')'bTLb:;Sb"BO)"'^bB)I9T:^b S)IT)I&)b ;+b :)b [)O)b &LIY;&T)' b "I'b MLSS;$B)b :"OGb TLb :;Sb O)MWT"T;LI b Sb "BO)"'^b ST"T)' b T:;Sb B"TT*Ob &LIT)IT;LIb ;Sb 6;YLBLWS b B";IT;/b :"Sb SM)ITb :;Sb ^)"OSb ;Ib MO;SLIb &O)"T<I9b "I'b 3PGB^b )ST"$B;S:;I9b :;Sb O)MWT"T;LIb "Sb LI)b [:Lb ')2)Sb "WT:LO;T_ b \BE;I9B^b "&&)MTSb LOb ;9ILO)Sb MWI;S:G)IT b"I'b)]MLS)Sb:<GS)B+bLOb[LOS)bTLb-G"B)bST"/bG)G$)OS b :)b';SG;SS)'b&O;G<I"Bb &:"O9)Sb ;Ib T:)b MO)S)ITb &"S)b ';'b ILTb &O)"T)b T:"Tb O)MWT"U;LIb "I' b ;Ib ,&T b &LWB'b ILTb )Y)Ib :"Y)b [LOS)I)'b;Tb9;Y)Ib B";IT;0SbBLI9b"I'bO)M)"T)'b:;STLO_bL+bS@C"Ob&LI'W&T b LObT:)S)bO)"SLIS b T:)bO)&LO'b%)5O)bT:)b LWOTb'L)SbILTbSWMMLOTbO)&LGG)I'<I9b"Ib"["O'bL+bGLO*bT:"IbILG;I"Bb '"G"9)Sb;IbT:)bSWGbL+b b LO)LY)O b B";IT;/b :"Sb ILTb S:L[Ib "I^b $"S;Sb 4Ob "Ib "["O'b L+b MWI;T>Z)b '"G"9)S b WI<T>Z)b '"G"9)Sb"O)b "Y";C"$B)b ;Ib"Ib"&T<LIb WI')Ob ab b [:)Ib T:)b ')+)I'"IT Sb &LI'W&Tb ;Sb S:L[Ib TLb %)b GLT>Z"T)'b $^b )Y;Bb GLU?Y)b LOb ;IT)IT b LOb [:)Ib ;Tb ;IYLBY)Sb O)&AB)SSb LOb &"BBLWSb ;I(;.)O)I&)bTLbT:)b-')O"CB^bMOLT)&T)'bO;9:TSbL+bLT:)OS b G;T:bY b "') b b b b b b WI;T;Y)b '"G"9)Sb "O)b ';S&O)T;LI"O^ b "I'b "O)b "["O')'b TLb MWK=S:b T:)b ')-I'"ITb 5Ob :;Sb LWTQ"9)LXSb&LI'W&Tb"I'bTLb')T)Ob:;Gb"I'bLT:)OSbB<A)b:;Gb6LGbS;G<B"Ob&LI'W&Tb;IbT:)b7TWO) b ' b"Tb b "BT)O"T;LISbLG;TT)' b :)b LWOTbG"^b&LIS;')ObT:)b'"G"9)bT:"Tb"&TW"CC^bL&&WOO)'b"Sb "b O)SWBTb L+b T:)b ')-I'"IT Sb $):"Y;LO b T:)b '"G"9)b T:"Tb &LWB'b :"Y)b L&&XOO)' b "I'b T:)b J))'b TLb ')T)Ob 8TXO)b S@B"Ob&LI'X&T b ! b OL'W&T;LIb LR bY b BF"I&)b )SLWO&)Sb LON b b b b b b Sb "BQ)"'^b ILT)' b ILb "&TW"Bb '"G"9)b L&&WOO)'b TLb B";IU;1b XOT:)O b #BT:LW9:b )]TO"b ;I&"O&)O"T;LIb &LWB'b :"Y)b O)SWBT)'b 6LGb T:)b &O;HI"Bb &:"O9)Sb $OLW9:Tb $^b )-I'"ITb BGL'LY"O bILbSW&:b&LIY;&T<LIbLOb)]V"b;I&"O&)O"T;LIbG"T)O;"D;`)' b Sb"bO)SWBTbL+b b Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 35 of 40 !@ @FS 3A AH D ESEF F ; @F S 8 4@F4"S S 0 D. ESA S; 96 4AGES A@ G FS PS SBD4EA@ DS G S FAS F0DAL@.S A S S A 48PS 96CG4 S EE G8FS A@S S !; 8 S @ S 4@ @FS OBAEGD S AJ H D S !@ @FS04;E 8 S D F SF0 SE4FG F4A@SF0 FS8 SFASF1AE S 0 D. E S ES 8 4@F4"S@AF E S 0 S4ES S H DRS 8 D. S ; 8 S BD4EA@ DS J0AS J ES 4@S S H DPS E; 88S @ S A@'@ S EB S LF0S @ @FS 3A AH D SJ0AS4ES;G 0SE; 88 DSF0 @S 8 4@F4%S 048 S4@SF0 FSEB S0 S4@F @F4A@ 88PS OBAE S 04<E 8 SFAS0 DS(DSF0 SBGDBAE ESA SE OG 8S.D F5' F4A@S @ SEG E CG @F8PSD ,E S0 DSAD DESFAS EG ;4FSFAS 0 @ G#E S G@ DS 04ES AJ@S H DE4A@S A S H @FE S 0 D (D S 04ES >4FF S A@ G FS FS 8 EFS D.G 8PSEG 7 F S05;SFASF0 S8 FF DSFKAS 0 D. ESF0 FS0 S S FSF0 SH DPS8 EF S SB DEA@S 4@S !@ @FS 3A AH D ESB8 S AG8 S0 H S 85 H SF04ESFAS SEA S 1 SA@8PS D 8S 4EBGF S4ES J0 F0 DS @ @FS 7 G8 F S J04 0SJAG8 SEGBBADFSF0 S; 84 4AGES A@ G FS 0 D. S FS4ES@AFS 8 DS 0AJS ;G 0S F4; S F04ES 0 D. S AG8 S 0 H S S FAS 04ES E @F @ S H DEGES F0 S AF1 DS FJAS 0 D. E S AJ H D S4@S @PS H @F S !@ @FS 8;A AH DS4ES@AS8A@. DS ;B8AQ S4@SF0 S ADF0S DA:@ S D4EA@S PEF ; S @ S @PS BAEE4 8 S E4;48 DS -FGD S4@ 4 @FES LF0S AF0 DSBD4EA@SA& 4 8ES B @ ES8 D. 8PSA@S 8 4@F4"S @ SJ0 F0 DSADS@AFS0 S A@F5@G ESFAS @. . S4@SE OG 8S;5E A@ G FS FAJ D S BD4EA@S ;B8AP E S S 0 S E ES A<;4FF4@.S BD4EA@S 4@+ F4A@ES )DS 04ES AJ@S E OG 8S /D F5' F4A@ SF0 SBAEE4 484FPSA S,FGD S 8E S 0 D. ES BB DESFASBD F4 88PS@A@ O4EF @F S ADS 88S A SF0 E SD EA@E S F0 S AGDFSL88S@AFSD A;; @ S @PS J D SA S BG@4F4H S ; . S GFSA@8PSF0 S @FDPSA S S G8FS7G @FS4@SF0 S ;AG@FSA S S E SA@S@A?@ 8S ; . E S 0 D (D S 4 S !@ @FS 3A AH DS A ES @AFS ;AH S FAS E FS E4 S F0 S G8FS @ S )DS BBA4@F; @FSA SBDAS A@AS AG@E 8 SADSAF0 DNE SA 7 FSF2ES D DS @ S A;; @ F4A@ SF0 S AGDFS D A;< @ ESF0 FS 8 4@F4$ESE A@ S AF4A@S *DS G8FS G @FS S .D @F SMF0S @S J D SFAS 8 4@F4"SA S@A=6@ 8S ; . ESA S S @ S@ASBG@4F5I S ; . E S S Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 36 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 37 of 40 6%XK%"FE#X FM8FEX F" X X K>KXM6%X FNHMXMFX%U%H"8K%XKNGG?%C%EM ?X=NH8L#8"M8FEX FO%HX ? 8EM;/KXLM M%X? RXF!KMJN"M;FEXF&X=NKM8"%X"? 8CK X 68KX FNHMX6 KX=NH8K#8"M8FEX8EXM68KX" K%X 8EX @856MX F&X M6%X -#%H ?X "? 9DK X R<M6X KNGG?%C%EM ?X =NH8K#8"M8FEX FO%HX M6%X KM M%X ? RX "? 8CK X ? 8EM;/KX FM8FEXMFX U%H"8K%X NH8K#8"M8FEXR<??XM6%H%2H%X!%X5H EM%#XMFXM6%X%UM%EMXM6 MX ??XF&XM6%X "? 9DKX6 O%X!%%EX ##H%KK%# X 6%X E%UMX H%C 8E8E5X FM8FEX F" X X K>KX M6%X FNHMX MFX K E"M8FEX %&%E# EMKX 2HX ??%5%#?VX C8KH%GH%K%EM8E5X ,"MKX H%? M%#XMFX M6%X %U8KM%E"%X FHX#%KMHN"M8FEX F&XM6%X O8#%FX %P8#%E"%X E#X2HX ??%5%#?VX' 8BE5XMFXM8C%?VXKNGG?%C%EMXH%KGFEK%KXMFX ? 8EM8/KX8EM%HHF5 MFH8%K X O8E5X H%O8%S%#XM6 MX FM8FE X8MX8KXH% ??VX=NKMX X(NHM6%HXH%6 K6XF&X8KKN%KXGH%O8FNK?WX#8K"NLK%#XH%5 H#8E5X M6%X O8#%F X TM6X ? 8EM8.X "? 9C8E5X M6 MX M6%X O8#%FX KM8??X %U:KMKX E#X M6 MX %&%E# EMKX 68#X E#X "FEM8EN%X MFX 68#%X M6 MX O8#%F X 6%K%X H%X EFM68E5X CFH%X M6 EX GF8EMKX F)X#8K 5H%%C%EMX 8EX M68KX ? RKN8M X EFMX5IFNE#KX2HXK E"M8FEKX E#XM6%X FM8FEXT??X!%X#%E:%#X ""FH#8E5?V X 6%X E%UMXCFM8FEX 0?%#X!VX ? 8EM8.X8KX X FM8FEX 3HX GGHFGH8 M%X %?8%)X F" X X 8EX R68"6X 6%X ??%5%KX M6 MX 6%X R KX EFMX GHFG%H?VX K%HQ%#X R<M6X %&%E# EMK X FM8FEX 2HX NCC HVX N# %EM X EX M6%X K C%X # W X 6%X ?KFX 0?%#X X M7HMV K8UX G 5%X %LGFEK%X F" X X MFX M6%X FM8FEX 2HX NCC HVX N# %EM X ?FE5X TM6X %U7!8MKX E#X X FM8FEX F" X X K%%>8E5X MFX %U"%%#XM6%X FNHM KXFH$:E JVXG 5%X?8C8MKX8EX0A:E5X68KX %KGFEK% X 6%X FNHMXT??X5H EMXM6%X FM8FEX MFX %U"%%#X M6%X G 5%X @9C8MKX E#X ""%GMX ? 8EM8*+KX 4??X %KGFEK% X !NMX #%EVX M6%X FM8FEX 2HX GGHFGH8 M%X H%B%&X 58O%EX M6 MX ? 8EM8.X"?% H?WX H%"%8O%#X %&%E# EMK X FM;FEX 2HX NCC HVX N# %EMX8EX XKN*1"8%EMXMFX2HCN? M%X X4??X E#X?%E5M6VX %KGFEK%XMFX8M X 8E ??V X ? 8EM8.X0?%#X X FM8FEX 2HX X %CGFH HVX %KMH 8E8E5X H#%HX E#X H%?8C8E HVX E=NE"M;FEX F" X X 8EX R68"6X 6%X !H8E5KX ??%5 M8FEKX F&X FE5F8E5X $:KGNM%KX E#X 8KKN%KX R<M6X X Case 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 38 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 39 of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ase 1:18-cv-00493-CCE-JEP Document 126 Filed 02/22/21 Page 40 of 40

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.