Securities and Exchange Commission v. Sugarman, No. 1:2019cv05998 - Document 55 (S.D.N.Y. 2020)
Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER re: 38 MOTION to Dismiss Complaint. filed by Jason Sugarman. For the foregoing reasons, Sugarman's motion to dismiss is denied. The Clerk of Court is directed to terminate the motion pending at ECF No. 38. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge William H. Pauley, III on 9/30/2020) (kv)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Securities and Exchange Commission v. Sugarman Doc. 55 JC>I:9 HI6I:H 9>HIG>8I 8DJGI HDJI=:GC 9>HIG>8I D; C:L NDG@ 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 H:8JG>I>:H 6C9 :M8=6C<: 8DBB>HH>DC E]RZ_eZWW& 'RXRZ_de' ?6HDC HJ<6GB6C& 9VWV_UR_e( +3Tg/332 DE>C>DC " DG9:G L>AA>6B =( E6JA:N >>>& HV_Z`c J_ZeVU HeReVd 9ZdecZTe ?fUXV4 IYV HVTfcZeZVd R_U :iTYR_XV 8`^^ZddZ`_ #pH:8q$ ScZ_Xd eYZd V_W`cTV^V_e RTeZ`_ RXRZ_de 9VWV_UR_e ?Rd`_ HfXRc^R_ W`c gZ`]ReZ`_d `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te `W +3-- #eYV pHVTfcZeZVd 6Teq$& eYV HVTfcZeZVd :iTYR_XV 6Te `W +3-. #eYV p:iTYR_XV 6Teq$& R_U eYV cf]Vd ac`^f]XReVU eYVcVf_UVc( IYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U YZd SfdZ_Vdd aRce_Vc& ?Rd`_ <R]R_Zd& aRceZTZaReVU Z_ R dTYV^V e` UVWcRfU Z_gVde`cd hZeY S`_Ud ZddfVU Sj eYV LR¥aR^_Z AR¥V 8`^^f_Zej 8`ca`cReZ`_ #pLA88q$& RWWZ]ZReVU hZeY eYV LR¥aR^_Z 9ZdecZTe `W eYV DX]R]R HZ`fi CReZ`_( HfXRc^R_ ^`gVd e` UZd^Zdd eYV H:8sd 8`^a]RZ_e afcdfR_e e` ;VUVcR] Gf]V `W 8ZgZ] Ec`TVUfcV +,#S$#0$( ;`c eYV W`]]`hZ_X cVRd`_d& HfXRc^R_sd ^`eZ`_ Zd UV_ZVU( 768@<GDJC9 J_]Vdd `eYVchZdV _`eVU& eYV W`]]`hZ_X WRTed RcV UVcZgVU Wc`^ eYV H:8sd 8`^a]RZ_e R_U RcV RTTVaeVU Rd ecfV W`c afca`dVd `W eYZd ^`eZ`_( Dockets.Justia.com >( DgVcgZVh DgVc R eYcVV'jVRc aVcZ`U SVXZ__Z_X Z_ ]ReV ,*+-& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd&! R]`_X hZeY eYVZc Rdd`TZReVd& aVcaVefReVU R ^RddZgV WcRfU Z_ hYZTY eYVj de`]V Raac`iZ^ReV]j !.- ^Z]]Z`_ Wc`^ Z_gVde`cd e` WZ_R_TV eYV RTbfZdZeZ`_ `W R X]`SR] WZ_R_TZR] T`_X]`^VcReV( #8`^a](& :8; C`( 0 #p8`^a](q$& m +($ 6]`_X eYV hRj& eYVj UVTVZgVU R CReZgV 6^VcZTR_ ecZSR] V_eZej Sj T`_gZ_TZ_X eYV LA88 e` ZddfV Raac`iZ^ReV]j !0* ^Z]]Z`_ Z_ ]Z^ZeVU cVT`fcdV S`_Ud #eYV pIcZSR] 7`_Udq$ #8`^a]( mm ,& .($ IYc`fXY R dVcZVd `W T`^a]Vi ecR_dRTeZ`_d& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd `SeRZ_VU T`_ec`] `gVc eh` Z_gVde^V_e RUgZdVcd& hY`dV T]ZV_eds Wf_Ud hVcV fdVU e` afcTYRdV eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud( #8`^a]( m 0($ >_deVRU `W fdZ_X eYV S`_U ac`TVVUd W`c eYV SV_VWZe `W eYV LA88& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd ^ZdRaac`acZReVU eYV^( #8`^a]( mm 3n+*($ >_ ,*+0& eYV H:8 WZ]VU dfZe RXRZ_de VZXYe Z_UZgZUfR]d R]]VXZ_X R WcRfUf]V_e dTYV^V Z_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud4 <R]R_Zd& 9Vg`_ 6cTYVc& 7VgR_ 8``_Vj& =fXY 9f_¥Vc]Vj& ?`Y_ <R]R_Zd& <Rcj =Zcde& ;cR_TZdT` BRceZ_& R_U BZTYV]]V B`ce`_( HVV H:8 g( 6cTYVc& C`( +0' Tg'-/*/ #H(9(C(N($( 8`_TfccV_e]j& eYV J_ZeVU HeReVd 6ee`c_Vjsd DWWZTV W`c eYV H`feYVc_ 9ZdecZTe `W CVh N`c¥ WZ]VU aRcR]]V] TcZ^Z_R] TYRcXVd RXRZ_de R]] `W eY`dV UVWV_UR_ed& ViTVae BRceZ_( HVV J_ZeVU HeReVd g( <R]R_Zd& C`( +0'Tc'-1+ #H(9C(N($( ;`fc UVWV_UR_edo<R]R_Zd& 9f_¥Vc]Vj& =Zcde& R_U B`ce`_oa]VU XfZ]ej( ;`]]`hZ_X R dZi'hVV¥ TcZ^Z_R] ecZR]& R [fcj T`_gZTeVU eYV `eYVc eYcVVo ?`Y_ <R]R_Zd& 6cTYVc& R_U 8``_Vjo`W dVTfcZeZVd WcRfU R_U T`_daZcRTj e` T`^^Ze dVTfcZeZVd WcRfU( IYVcVRWeVc& ?fUXV 6ScR^d XcR_eVU 6cTYVcsd ^`eZ`_ W`c R _Vh ecZR] f_UVc ;VUVcR] Gf]V `W ! FWUO¥¥ X]RO[`S¥O ¥YOMSPSON% h9KUKWS¥i [OPO[¥ ]X <K¥XW 9KUKWS¥' , 8cZ^Z_R] Ec`TVUfcV --( J_ZeVU HeReVd g( <R]R_Zd& -00 ;( Hfaa( -U .11& .2* #H(9(C(N( ,*+2$( IYRe UVTZdZ`_ Zd `_ RaaVR] e` eYV HVT`_U 8ZcTfZe(" ;`]]`hZ_X eYV TcZ^Z_R] ecZR]& eYZd 8`fce V_eVcVU T`_dV_e [fUX^V_ed RXRZ_de <R]R_Zd& 8``_Vj& 9f_¥Vc]Vj& ?`Y_ <R]R_Zd& =Zcde& BRceZ_& R_U B`ce`_ Z_ eYV aV_UZ_X H:8 ^ReeVc( 6cTYVc& C`( +0'Tg'-/*/& :8; C`d( ,,+& ,.,n./& ,/.& ,/3( >_ ?f_V ,*+3& eYV H:8 WZ]VU eYZd RTeZ`_ RXRZ_de HfXRc^R_( >>( HfXRc^R_sd 7fdZ_VddVd R_U GV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY <R]R_Zd IYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd hVcV SfdZ_Vdd aRce_Vcd Z_ eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V( #8`^a]( m +3($ IYV eh` ^RZ_eRZ_VU R T]`dV cV]ReZ`_dYZa& R_U `eYVc dTYV^V aRceZTZaR_ed cVWVccVU e` eYV^ Rd eYV peh` ?Rd`_dq R_U p/*)/* aRce_Vcd(q #8`^a]( m +3($ 7VW`cVo R_U UfcZ_XoeYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V& HfXRc^R_ hRd R_ `WWZTVc& UZcVTe`c& R_U Z_UZcVTe `h_Vc `W LVR]eY 6ddfcR_TV =`]UZ_Xd AeU( #pL6=q$& R 7Vc^fUR'SRdVU Z_dfcR_TV T`^aR_j(# #8`^a]( mm +.& +1($ =V hRd R]d` R UZcVTe`c& Z_UZcVTe `h_Vc& R_U ^V^SVc `W eYV Z_gVde^V_e T`^^ZeeVV `W 7fc_YR^ HVTfcZeZVd #p7fc_YR^q$& R eYV_'H:8'cVXZdeVcVU Sc`¥Vc'UVR]Vc R_U Z_gVde^V_e RUgZdVc( #8`^a]( mm +.& +0($ EcZ`c e` eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd YV]aVU L6= RTbfZcV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV 6< #pLVR]eY'6ddfcR_TVq$& R AZVTYeV_deVZ_'SRdVU Z_dfcR_TV T`^aR_j& eYc`fXY R]]VXVU]j WcRfUf]V_e ^VR_d( #8`^a]( mm +1#+$& ,+n,3($ D_ ?R_fRcj 1& ,*+.& W`]]`hZ_X HfXRc^R_ R_U 9f_¥Vc]Vjsd acVdV_eReZ`_ e` eYV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd #`_ hYZTY eYVj S`eY dRe$& eYV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV S`RcU Raac`gVU R t. ^Z]]Z`_ Z_gVde^V_e #!/(. ^Z]]Z`_$ `W eYV T`^aR_jsd TRaZeR] Z_ R_ >cV]R_U'SRdVU Wf_U TR]]VU 7R]]jSf_Z`_ 8Ra]RZ_ J@ ;`Tfd <c`heY " 3NNS]SXWKUUb% ?X[]XW PSUON K VX]SXW ]X `S]RN[K` RO[ Q^SU]b YUOK% `RSMR S¥ M^[[OW]Ub YOWNSWQ' ;W 6OMOVLO[ *(),% H3: MRKWQON S]¥ WKVO ]X GKUX[ 9[X^Y >]N' #5XVYU' ee ),% )/'$ 8X[ MUK[S]b% ]RS¥ AYSWSXW " A[NO[ `SUU [OPO[ ]X LX]R K¥ hH3:'i # - ;f_U #p7R]]jSf_Z`_q$ W`c eYV Wf_U e` ^R_RXV( #8`^a]( m ,.($ HfXRc^R_ eYV_ UZcVTeVU YZd RddZdeR_e e` Z_T`ca`cReV R ]Z^ZeVU ]ZRSZ]Zej T`^aR_j Z_ CVgRUR SVRcZ_X eYV 7R]]jSf_Z`_ _R^V& VgV_ eY`fXY eYRe V_eZej YRU _` T`__VTeZ`_ e` eYV 7R]]jSf_Z`_ Wf_U Z_ >cV]R_U( #8`^a]( m ,/($ LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV hZcVU eYV t. ^Z]]Z`_ Z_gVde^V_e e` eYV pWR¥Vq 7R]]jSf_Z`_ T`^aR_j Z_ CVgRUR( #8`^a]( mm ,0n,1($ 6WeVc gRcZ`fd Z_eVc^VUZRcj ecR_dRTeZ`_d& eYV Sf]¥ `W eYRe ^`_Vj hRd ecR_dWVccVU e` L6= e` afcTYRdV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV($ #8`^a]( m ,1($ Efe dZ^a]j& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd UZcVTeVU L6= e` RTbfZcV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV fdZ_X LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TVsd `h_ TRaZeR]( >_ eYV W`]]`hZ_X ^`_eYd& <R]R_Zd T`gVcVU fa eYVdV ecR_dRTeZ`_dohZeY pHfXRc^R_sd ¥_`h]VUXV R_U Raac`gR]qoSj eR¥Z_X deVad e` UVTVZgV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV V^a]`jVVd RS`fe eYV deRefd `W hYRe eYVj T`_dZUVcVU R ]VXZeZ^ReV Z_gVde^V_e( #8`^a]( mm -*n-+($ >>>( IcZSR] 7`_Ud HTYV^V 7VXZ__Z_X Z_ BRcTY ,*+.& <R]R_Zd R_U YZd WReYVc& ?`Y_ <R]R_Zd& Z_ZeZReVU eYV ]RcXVc dTYV^V Sj T`_gZ_TZ_X eYV LA88 e` ZddfV eYcVV ecR_TYVd `W ]Z^ZeVU cVT`fcdV S`_Ud e`eR]Z_X Raac`iZ^ReV]j !0* ^Z]]Z`_( #8`^a]( mm -,n--($ 6TT`cUZ_X e` eYV ZddfZ_X U`Tf^V_ed& eYV LA88 a]R__VU e` fdV eYV ac`TVVUd Wc`^ eYV S`_U dR]Vd e` afcTYRdV R_ R__fZej Wc`^ LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV( #8`^a]( m --($ =`hVgVc& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd Z_eV_UVU e` XRZ_ T`_ec`] `gVc eYV S`_Ud W`c eYVZc `h_ SV_VWZe( #8`^a]( mm -.n-/($ 6d aRce `W eYV dTYV^V& HfXRc^R_ YV]aVU WZ_R_TV eYV afcTYRdV `W =fXYVd 8RaZeR] BR_RXV^V_e& AA8 #p=fXYVdq$& R KZcXZ_ZR'SRdVU Z_gVde^V_e RUgZdVc hZeY Raac`iZ^ReV]j !3** ^Z]]Z`_ f_UVc ^R_RXV^V_e( #8`^a]( mm 1& -0n-1($ >_ ?f_V ,*+.& B`ce`_ acVdV_eVU =fXYVdsd eYV_'`h_Vc hZeY R U`Tf^V_e eZe]VU p>_ec`UfTeZ`_ e` 8DG 8RaZeR]&q hYZTY hRd RfeY`cVU Sj <R]R_Zd( #8`^a]( m -2($ >e ]ZdeVU dVgVcR] SfdZ_VddVd eYRe 8DG 8RaZeR] afca`ceVU]j `h_VU& dfTY D^QK[VKW KU¥X NS[OM]ON !0((%((( P[XV ]RO 4KUUbL^WSXW KMMX^W] ]X KW SW_O¥]VOW] SW 5AC 8SWKWMSKU #:=$g K ¥XUK[ MXVYKWb SW `RSMR RO RKN KW SW]O[O¥]gKWN X]RO[ VXWOb ]X K ]OMRWXUXQb SW_O¥]VOW]' #5XVYU' e *1'$ $ . Rd LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV R_U 7fc_YR^ HVTfcZeZVd( #8`^a]( m -2($ HfXRc^R_ YV]U YZ^dV]W `fe Rd R ^V^SVc R_U ^R_RXVc `W 8DG 8RaZeR]& R_U Raac`gVU eYV Z_ec`UfTe`cj U`Tf^V_e( #8`^a]( m -3($ 6 ^`_eY ]ReVc& <R]R_Zd dV_e HfXRc^R_ R T`aj `W eYV ViVTfeVU eVc^ dYVVe W`c eYV =fXYVd RTbfZdZeZ`_ R_U _`eVU4 pPLQV XVe UZdTcVeZ`_ `gVc !3** ^Z]]Z`_(q #8`^a]( m .* #R]eVcReZ`_ Z_ `cZXZ_R]$($ 6TT`cUZ_X e` eYV H:8& HfXRc^R_ YRU <R]R_Zd XY`dehcZeV R ^V^` e` eYV S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd `W LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV cVT`^^V_UZ_X eYV RTbfZdZeZ`_( #8`^a]( m .+($ IYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ d`fXYe e` T`_TVR] <R]R_Zdsd Z_g`]gV^V_e SVTRfdV `W <R]R_Zdsd acZ`c dVTfcZeZVd gZ`]ReZ`_d( #8`^a]( m .+ " _(-($ >_ 6fXfde ,*+.& eYV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd #hYZTY Z_T]fUVU HfXRc^R_$ UZdTfddVU eYV ^V^` R_U Raac`gVU eYV afcTYRdV `W =fXYVd eYc`fXY Zed dfSdZUZRcj& 7;< >_gVde^V_ed(% #8`^a]( mm .-n..($ H``_ RWeVc eYV RTbfZdZeZ`_ `W =fXYVd& <R]R_Zd W`chRcUVU HfXRc^R_ R dacVRUdYVVe R_U ecRUV S]`eeVc Z_UZTReZ_X eYRe _Z_V `W =fXYVdsd T]ZV_ed afcTYRdVU Raac`iZ^ReV]j !,1 ^Z]]Z`_ `W eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud( #8`^a]( m ./($ 7fc_YR^ dVcgVU Rd eYV a]RTV^V_e RXV_e W`c eYZd ecR_dRTeZ`_( #8`^a]( m ./($ 6TT`cUZ_X e` eYV H:8& HfXRc^R_ ¥_Vh Wc`^ <R]R_Zd eYRe eYV ac`TVVUd Wc`^ eYV IcZSR] 7`_U dR]Vd hVcV ^VR_e e` SV fdVU e` afcTYRdV R_ R__fZej Wc`^ LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV( #8`^a]( m .0($ I` dfaa]V^V_e eYZd R]]VXReZ`_& eYV H:8 R]d` T`_eV_Ud eYRe HfXRc^R_ ¥_Vh #`c hRd cVT¥]Vdd Z_ _`e ¥_`hZ_X$ eYZd Z_W`c^ReZ`_ SVTRfdV YV hRd R ^V^SVc `W 7fc_YR^sd Z_gVde^V_e T`^^ZeeVV( #8`^a]( m .0($ <R]R_Zd eYV_ dV_e HfXRc^R_ R dacVRUdYVVe UVdTcZSZ_X eYV ac`a`dVU R]]`TReZ`_ `W eYV IcZSR] 7`_U ac`TVVUd& hZeY`fe R_j cVWVcV_TV e` R_ R_eZTZaReVU R__fZej( #8`^a]( m .1($ 6d UVdTcZSVU SV]`h& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd eYV_ XRZ_VU RTTVdd e` R_U ^ZdRaac`acZReVU eYV ac`TVVUd Wc`^ eYV dR]V `W IcZSR] 7`_Ud e` =fXYVdsd T]ZV_ed( #8`^a]( m 2($ DYOMSPSMKUUb% 489 ;W_O¥]VOW]¥ VKNO K MKYS]KU MXW][SL^]SXW ]X 9?E 6^WMKW >>5 #h9?Ei$% `RX ]ROW Y^[MRK¥ON :^QRO¥' #5XVYU' ee )/#)$% ,,'$ 9?E `K¥ :^QRO¥k¥ KWN 33?k¥ YK[OW] MXVYKWb' #5XVYU' e )0'$ % / HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd cVa]ZTReVU eYV =fXYVd dTYV^V hZeY eYVZc RTbfZdZeZ`_ `W 6e]R_eZT 6ddVe BR_RXV^V_e AA8 #p66Bq$& R_ Z_gVde^V_e ^R_RXVc hZeY !++ SZ]]Z`_ Z_ RddVed f_UVc ^R_RXV^V_e( #8`^a]( mm 1& /.($ >_ C`gV^SVc ,*+.& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd RccR_XVU W`c LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV e` afcTYRdV KR]`c]ZWV AVSV_dgVcdZTYVcf_Xd 6< #pKR]`c]ZWVq$& R AZTYeV_deVZ_' SRdVU Z_dfcVc& fdZ_X !++ ^Z]]Z`_ Z_ IcZSR] 7`_U ac`TVVUd( #8`^a]( m +1#,$($ 6e HfXRc^R_sd UZcVTeZ`_& 9f_¥Vc]Vj ac`gZUVU 66Bsd XV_VcR] T`f_dV] hZeY R ]VeeVc `_ SVYR]W `W eYV p8DG <c`fa `W 8`^aR_ZVd& >_T(q cVXRcUZ_X WZ_R_TZ_X( #8`^a]( m /1($ >_ 6acZ] ,*+/& HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd `SeRZ_VU RfeY`cZkReZ`_ Wc`^ KR]`c]ZWVsd S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd e` WZ_R_TV eYV afcTYRdV `W 66B( #8`^a]( m /2($ 6WeVc eYV afcTYRdV& <R]R_Zd ¥Vae HfXRc^R_ RaacZdVU Sj V^RZ] RS`fe a`ddZS]V Z_gVde^V_e UVTZdZ`_d( #8`^a]( mm 0,n0-($ IYVcVRWeVc& 7fc_YR^ RTeVU Rd eYV a]RTV^V_e RXV_e `W eYV _Vh !+0(, ^Z]]Z`_ ZddfR_TV `W IcZSR] 7`_Ud( #8`^a]( m 0/($ >K( BZdRaac`acZReZ`_ IYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ UZcVTe]j R_U Z_UZcVTe]j ^ZdRaac`acZReVU S`_U ac`TVVUd ^VR_e W`c eYV LA88( <R]R_Zd dVe fa R dYR^ V_eZej& LVR]eY 6ddfcR_TV EcZgReV 8]ZV_e 8`ca`cReZ`_ #pL6E88q$& Rd R afca`ceVU R__fZej ac`gZUVc VgV_ eY`fXY Ze YRU _` cV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV( #8`^a]( m .2($ B`de `W eYV IcZSR] 7`_U ac`TVVUd hVcV UZgVceVU Wc`^ L6E88 e` IY`cdUR]V ;ZUfTZRcj R_U <fRcR_ej 8`^aR_j AeU( #pIY`cdUR]Vq$& R <R]R_Zd T`^aR_j( #8`^a]( mm +/& .3($ IYV ac`TVVUd hVcV eYV_ dV_e UZcVTe]j e` gRcZ`fd dTYV^V aRceZTZaR_ed `c eYVZc cV]ReVU V_eZeZVd& dfTY Rd LVR]eY 6ddfcR_TV =`]UZ_Xd& AeU( #pL6= CKq$( #8`^a]( mm 01n02($ 6_U Rd hRd ejaZTR] Z_ eYZd dTYV^V& L6= CK S`cV R dZ^Z]Rc _R^V e` L6=& Sfe ^RZ_eRZ_VU _` cVR] cV]ReZ`_dYZa hZeY eYV T`^aR_j( #8`^a]( m 02($ DgVcR]]& HfXRc^R_ _VeeVU Raac`iZ^ReV]j !3 0 ^Z]]Z`_ eYc`fXY eYZd dTYV^V& Z_T]fUZ_X !/,.&/** UZcVTe]j Wc`^ eYV IcZSR] 7`_U ac`TVVUd Z_ WZgV ecR_dWVcd e` YZ^ `c YZd hZWV& Z_T]fUZ_X `_V UZcVTe]j Wc`^ L6E88( #8`^a]( mm ,& 1*($ IYV 8`^a]RZ_e UVdTcZSVd R ]Rf_Ucj ]Zde `W cV]ReVU ecR_dRTeZ`_d f_UVc eYV f^ScV]]R `W ^ZdRaac`acZReZ`_& dfTY Rd4 #+$ HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd fdZ_X S`_U ac`TVVUd e` afcTYRdV _Vh ecR_TYVd `W IcZSR] 7`_Ud #eYV pG`dV^`_e 7`_Uq R_U p8``_Vj 7`_Uq$ e` RTbfZcV T`^aR_ZVd ]Z¥V KR]`c]ZWV& R_U ^VVe 7fc_YR^sd _Ve TRaZeR] cVbfZcV^V_ed& #8`^a]( mm /+n/,& 1+n3+$5 #,$ cVaRjZ_X R !+(- ^Z]]Z`_ UVSe eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd `hVU e` =Zcde Rd aRce `W eYVZc afcTYRdV `W LVR]eY' 6ddfcR_TV& #8`^a]( mm 3,n3.$5 #-$ Z_[VTeZ_X =fXYVd R_U 66B hZeY TRdY& Z_T]fUZ_X R a`ceZ`_ `W eYV S`_U ac`TVVUd eYRe hVcV dfaa`dVU e` SV Z_gVdeVU Z_ R__fZeZVd& #8`^a]( mm 3/n33$5 #.$ afcTYRdZ_X dVTfcZeZVd Z_ 8`UV GVSV] 8`ca`cReZ`_& R T`^aR_j eYRe hRd V_XRXZ_X Z_ R_ >ED& R_U Z_ hYZTY HfXRc^R_ YRU Z_gVde^V_ed& #8`^a]( mm +**n*3$5 R_U #/$ Z_ HVaeV^SVc ,*+/ W`]]`hZ_X <R]R_Zdsd RccVde& hZcZ_X ^`_Vj e` L6E88oeYV WR¥V R__fZej ac`gZUVcoe` T`gVc Zed Z_eVcVde `S]ZXReZ`_d UfV e` S`_UY`]UVcd& #8`^a]( mm ++*n+,$( IYV H:8 R]]VXVd acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_d f_UVc4 HVTeZ`_d +1#R$#+$ R_U #-$ `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te& +/ J(H(8( ll 11b#R$#+$ R_U #-$5 HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ `W eYV :iTYR_XV 6Te& +/ J(H(8( l 12[#S$5 R_U Gf]Vd ]*S'/#R$ R_U #T$& +1 8(;(G( ll ,.*(+*S'/#R$ R_U #T$( 6UUZeZ`_R]]j& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd dVT`_URcj gZ`]ReZ`_d f_UVc4 HVTeZ`_ +/#S$ `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te& +/ J(H(8( l 11`#S$5 R_U HVTeZ`_ ,*#V$ `W eYV :iTYR_XV 6Te& +/ J(H(8( l 12e#V$& W`c RZUZ_X R_U RSVeeZ_X <R]R_Zdsd acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_d( 9>H8JHH>DC >( AVXR] HeR_URcU D_ R ^`eZ`_ e` UZd^Zdd& R T`fce RTTVaed R]] WRTed R]]VXVU Z_ eYV T`^a]RZ_e Rd ecfV R_U T`_decfVd R]] cVRd`_RS]V Z_WVcV_TVd Z_ R a]RZ_eZWWsd WRg`c( :86& A`TR] +-. >7:L ?`Z_e 1 EV_dZ`_ Ic( `W 8YZ( g( ?E B`cXR_ 8YRdV 8`(& //- ;(-U +21& +30 #,U 8Zc( ,**3$( CVgVceYV]Vdd& R T`^a]RZ_e ^fde pT`_eRZ_ dfWWZTZV_e WRTefR] ^ReeVc& RTTVaeVU Rd ecfV& e` deReV R T]RZ^ e` cV]ZVW eYRe Zd a]RfdZS]V `_ Zed WRTV(q 6dYTc`We g( >bSR]& //0 J(H( 00,& 012 #,**3$ #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$( I` dfcgZgV R ^`eZ`_ e` UZd^Zdd& eYV T`fce ^fde WZ_U eYV T]RZ^ cVded `_ WRTefR] R]]VXReZ`_d eYRe pcRZdV R cZXYe e` cV]ZVW RS`gV eYV daVTf]ReZgV ]VgV](q 7V]] 6e]( 8`ca( g( Ih`^S]j& //* J(H( /..& /// #,**1$5 dVV R]d` >bSR]& //0 J(H( Re 012 #pIYV a]RfdZSZ]Zej deR_URcU Zd _`e R¥Z_ e` R ac`SRSZ]Zej cVbfZcV^V_e& Sfe Ze Rd¥d W`c ^`cV eYR_ R dYVVc a`ddZSZ]Zej eYRe R UVWV_UR_e YRd RTeVU f_]RhWf]]j(q #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$$( p9VeVc^Z_Z_X hYVeYVc R T`^a]RZ_e deReVd R a]RfdZS]V T]RZ^ W`c cV]ZVW hZ]] ( ( ( SV R T`_eVie'daVTZWZT eRd¥ eYRe cVbfZcVd eYV cVgZVhZ_X T`fce e` UcRh `_ Zed [fUZTZR] ViaVcZV_TV R_U T`^^`_ dV_dV(q >bSR]& //0 J(H( Re 013( B`cV`gVc& T]RZ^d d`f_UZ_X Z_ dVTfcZeZVd WcRfU ^fde ^VVe eYV YVZXYeV_VU a]VRUZ_X cVbfZcV^V_ed `W ;VUVcR] Gf]V `W 8ZgZ] Ec`TVUfcV 3#S$( @R]_Ze g( :ZTY]Vc& ,0. ;(-U +-+& +-2 #,U 8Zc( ,**+$5 HYZV]Ud g( 8Zejecfde 7R_T`ca& >_T(& ,/ ;(-U ++,.& ++,1n,2 #,U 8Zc( +33.$( p7VTRfdV Gf]V 3#S$ `WWVcd UVWV_UR_ed Z^a`ceR_e ac`eVTeZ`_d& eYV HVT`_U 8ZcTfZe Raa]ZVd Gf]V 3#S$sd YVZXYeV_VU deR_URcU _`e `_]j e` T]RZ^d Via]ZTZe]j R]]VXZ_X WcRfU& Sfe R]d` e` T]RZ^d d`f_UZ_X Z_ WcRfU& dfTY Rd hYVcV reYV h`cUZ_X R_U Z^afeReZ`_d `W eYV T`^a]RZ_e RcV T]RddZTR]]j Rdd`TZReVU hZeY WcRfU(sq H:8 g( :XR_& 33. ;( Hfaa( ,U //2& /0/ #H(9(C(N( ,*+.$ #bf`eZ_X G`^SRTY g( 8YR_X& -// ;(-U +0.& +1, #,U 8Zc( ,**.$$( =`hVgVc& eYV H:8 _VVU _`e dReZdWj eYV a]VRUZ_X cVbfZcV^V_ed f_UVc eYV EcZgReV HVTfcZeZVd AZeZXReZ`_ GVW`c^ 6Te #pEHAG6q$( H:8 g( 8YZ_R CV( EVec`]Vf^ =`]UZ_Xd AeU(& ,1 ;( Hfaa( -U -13& -21 #H(9(C(N( ,*+.$5 dVV R]d` +/ J(H(8( l 12f' .#R$#+$( C`_VeYV]Vdd& Z_ RUUZeZ`_ e` ac`gZUZ_X R WRTZR]]j a]RfdZS]V T]RZ^ e` cV]ZVW& eYV H:8 p^fde deReV hZeY aRceZTf]RcZej eYV TZcTf^deR_TVd T`_deZefeZ_X WcRfU `c ^ZdeR¥V(q ;VU( G( 8Zg( E( 2 3#S$( 6]eY`fXY pP^QR]ZTV& Z_eV_e& ¥_`h]VUXV& R_U `eYVc T`_UZeZ`_d `W R aVcd`_sd ^Z_U ^Rj SV R]]VXVU XV_VcR]]j&q ;VU( G( 8Zg( E( 3#S$& eYV cV]RiReZ`_ `W eYV aRceZTf]RcZej cVbfZcV^V_e W`c T`_UZeZ`_d `W ^Z_U ^fde _`e SV ^ZdeR¥V_ W`c R p]ZTV_dV e` SRdV T]RZ^d `W WcRfU `_ daVTf]ReZ`_ R_U T`_T]fd`cj R]]VXReZ`_d&q 6TZe` g( >B8:G6 <ca(& >_T(& .1 ;(-U .1& /, #,U 8Zc( +33/$ #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$( IYV H:8 ^fde pR]]VXV WRTed eYRe XZgV cZdV e` R dec`_X Z_WVcV_TV `W WcRfUf]V_e Z_eV_e(q 8YZ]] g( <V_( :]VTecZT 8`(& +*+ ;(-U ,0-& ,01 #,U 8Zc( +330$ #V^aYRdZd `^ZeeVU$ #bf`eZ_X 6TZe`& .1 ;(-U Re /,$( IYZd Z_WVcV_TV TR_ SV VdeRS]ZdYVU pVZeYVc #R$ Sj R]]VXZ_X WRTed e` dY`h eYRe UVWV_UR_ed YRU S`eY ^`eZgV R_U `aa`cef_Zej e` T`^^Ze WcRfU& `c #S$ Sj R]]VXZ_X WRTed eYRe T`_deZefeV dec`_X TZcTf^deR_eZR] VgZUV_TV `W T`_dTZ`fd ^ZdSVYRgZ`c `c cVT¥]Vdd_Vdd(q 6TZe`& .1 ;(-U Re /, #bf`eZ_X HYZV]Ud& ,/ ;(-U Re ++,2$( >>( EcZ^Rcj AZRSZ]Zej HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ `W eYV :iTYR_XV 6Te& Z_ cV]VgR_e aRce& ^R¥Vd Ze f_]RhWf] pW`c R_j aVcd`_& UZcVTe]j `c Z_UZcVTe]j ( ( ( PeQ` fdV `c V^a]`j& Z_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]V `W R_j dVTfcZej ( ( ( R_j ^R_Zaf]ReZgV `c UVTVaeZgV UVgZTV `c T`_ecZgR_TV Z_ T`_ecRgV_eZ`_ `W dfTY cf]Vd R_U cVXf]ReZ`_d Rd eYV PH:8Q ^Rj acVdTcZSV(q +/ J(H(8( l 12[#S$( >_ efc_& Gf]V +*S'/ ^R¥Vd Ze f_]RhWf] e`4 #R$ pV^a]`j R_j UVgZTV& dTYV^V& `c RceZWZTV e` UVWcRfUq5 #S$ p^R¥V R_j f_ecfV deReV^V_e `W R ^ReVcZR] WRTe `c `^Ze e` deReV R ^ReVcZR] WRTe _VTVddRcj Z_ `cUVc e` ^R¥V eYV deReV^V_ed ^RUV ( ( ( _`e ^Zd]VRUZ_Xq5 `c #T$ pV_XRXV Z_ R_j RTe& acRTeZTV& `c T`fcdV `W SfdZ_Vdd hYZTY `aVcReVd `c h`f]U `aVcReV Rd R WcRfU `c UVTVZe fa`_ R_j aVcd`_q Z_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]V `W dVTfcZeZVd( +1 8(;(G( l ,.*(+*S'/( HVTeZ`_ +1#R$#+$ `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te ^R¥Vd Ze f_]RhWf] e` pV^a]`j R_j UVgZTV& dTYV^V& `c RceZWZTV e` UVWcRfUq Z_ eYV `WWVc `c dR]V `W dVTfcZeZVd( +/ J(H(8( l 11b#R$#+$( pr:ddV_eZR]]j eYV dR^V V]V^V_ed RcV cVbfZcVU f_UVc HVTeZ`_ +1#R$#+$s Rd f_UVc HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ R_U 3 Gf]V +*S'/& ViTVae eYRe HVTeZ`_ +1#R$#+$ cVbfZcVd ac``W `W R T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV r`WWVc `c dR]Vs `W dVTfcZeZVd& Z_deVRU `W eYV rafcTYRdV `c dR]Vs `W dVTfcZeZVd(q H:8 g( IY`^ad`_& ,-2 ;( Hfaa( -U /1/& /3+ #H(9(C(N( ,*+1$ #bf`eZ_X H:8( g( B`_RcTY ;f_UZ_X 8`ca(& +3, ;(-U ,3/& -*2 #,U 8Zc( +333$$( 6_U HVTeZ`_ +1#R$#-$ `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te ac`YZSZed UVWV_UR_ed Wc`^ V_XRXZ_X pZ_ R_j ecR_dRTeZ`_& acRTeZTV& `c T`fcdV `W SfdZ_Vdd hYZTY `aVcReVd `c h`f]U `aVcReV Rd R WcRfU `c UVTVZe fa`_ eYV afcTYRdVc(q +/ J(H(8( l 11b#R$#-$( IYZd ac`gZdZ`_ YRd R]^`de ZUV_eZTR] V]V^V_ed Rd HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ R_U HVTeZ`_ +1#R$#+$& ViTVae eYRe pPdQTZV_eVc Zd _`e cVbfZcVU e` ac`gV R UVWV_UR_e gZ`]ReVUq eYV deRefeV( H:8 g( <Z_UVc& 1/, ;(-U /03& /1. #,U 8Zc( ,*+.$ #TZeZ_X 6Rc`_ g( H:8& ..0 J(H( 02*& 030n31 #+32*$$( GReYVc& pPRQ dY`hZ_X `W _VX]ZXV_TV Zd dfWWZTZV_e(q <Z_UVc& 1/, ;(-U Re /1.( 6_R]jkZ_X eYVdV ac`gZdZ`_d e`XVeYVc& HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ `W eYV :iTYR_XV 6Te& Gf]Vd +*S'/#R$ R_U #T$& R_U HVTeZ`_d +1#R$#+$ R_U #-$ `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te pTcVReV hYRe T`fced YRgV TR]]VU rdTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zejs W`c eY`dV hY`& hZeY dTZV_eVc& V_XRXV Z_ UVTVZeWf] T`_UfTe(q H:8 g( ?VR_' EZVccV& ,*+/ LA +*/.3*/& Re %2 #H(9(C(N( BRc( 3& ,*+/$5 dVV R]d` >_ cV H^ZeY 7Rc_Vj IcR_dWVc 6XV_e AZeZX(& 22. ;( Hfaa( ,U +/,& +0* #H(9(C(N( ,*+,$ #_`eZ_X eYRe UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe ^Rj XZgV cZdV e` dTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zej f_UVc Gf]Vd +*S'/#R$ R_U #T$$( I` deReV R T]RZ^ W`c dTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zej& eYV H:8 ^fde R]]VXV eYRe eYV UVWV_UR_e p#+$ T`^^ZeeVU R ^R_Zaf]ReZgV `c UVTVaeZgV RTe #,$ Z_ WfceYVcR_TV `W eYV R]]VXVU dTYV^V e` UVWcRfU& #-$ PhZeYQ dTZV_eVc(q H:8 g( AVV& 1,* ;( Hfaa( ,U -*/& -,/ #H(9(C(N( ,*+*$ #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$( 6 p^R_Zaf]ReZgV `c UVTVaeZgV RTeq Zd pd`^V RTe eYRe XZgVd eYV gZTeZ^ R WR]dV Z^acVddZ`_(q J_ZeVU HeReVd g( ;Z__Vcej& /-- ;(-U +.-& +.2 #,U 8Zc( ,**2$( I` VdeRS]ZdY ]ZRSZ]Zej& UVWV_UR_ed p^fde YRgV aRceZTZaReVU Z_ R_ Z]]VXZeZ^ReV& dYR^ `c Z_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgV ecR_dRTeZ`_ hYVcV PeYVZcQ T`_UfTe `c c`]V YRPUQ eYV afca`dV R_U VWWVTe `W +* TcVReZ_X R WR]dV RaaVRcR_TV(q H:8 g( 8@7+02 =`]UZ_Xd& AeU(& ,+* ;( Hfaa( -U .,+& ../ #:(9(C(N( ,*+0$ #R]eVcReZ`_d Z_ `cZXZ_R]$ #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$5 RTT`cU <cfSVc g( <Z]SVced`_& ,*+2 LA +.+2+22& Re %+. #H(9(C(N( BRc( ,*& ,*+2$( R( ERceZTf]RcZej HeR_URcU 6d R_ Z_ZeZR] ^ReeVc& HfXRc^R_ T`_eV_Ud eYRe eYV 8`^a]RZ_e U`Vd _`e dReZdWj Gf]V 3#S$sd aRceZTf]RcZej deR_URcU SVTRfdV Ze4 #+$ WRZ]d e` UZdeZ_XfZdY SVehVV_ HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zdsd T`_UfTe Sj ]f^aZ_X R]]VXReZ`_d RXRZ_de eYV Z_UZgZUfR]d e`XVeYVc& R_U #,$ fdVd Z__fV_U` e` T`_dZdeV_e]j Rdd`TZReV HfXRc^R_ hZeY <R]R_Zd( #BV^( `W ARh Z_ Hfaa( `W ?Rd`_ HfXRc^R_sd B`e( e` 9Zd^Zdd eYV 8`^a](& :8; C`( -3 #p9VW(sd BV^(q$& Re +*n+/($ pLYVcV ^f]eZa]V UVWV_UR_ed RcV Rd¥VU e` cVda`_U e` R]]VXReZ`_d `W WcRfU& eYV T`^a]RZ_e dY`f]U Z_W`c^ VRTY UVWV_UR_e `W eYV _RefcV `W YZd R]]VXVU aRceZTZaReZ`_ Z_ eYV WcRfU(q 9ZKZee`cZ` g( :bfZUj_V :iecRTeZgV >_Ufd(& >_T(& 2,, ;(,U +,.,& +,.1 #,U 8Zc( +321$( Gf]V 3#S$ Zd _`e dReZdWZVU Sj R T`^a]RZ_e Z_ hYZTY pUVWV_UR_ed RcV T]f^aVU e`XVeYVc Z_ gRXfV R]]VXReZ`_d(q IYcVV 8c`h_ AeU( EsdYZa g( 8Rie`_ 8`ca(& 2+1 ;( Hfaa( +*--& +*.* #H(9(C(N( +33-$( pI` eYZd V_U& eYV T`^a]RZ_e ^Rj _`e cV]j fa`_ S]R_¥Ve cVWVcV_TVd e` RTed `c `^ZddZ`_d Sj R]] `W eYV UVWV_UR_ed& W`c VRTY UVWV_UR_e _R^VU Z_ eYV T`^a]RZ_e Zd V_eZe]VU e` SV RaacRZdVU `W eYV TZcTf^deR_TVd dfcc`f_UZ_X eYV WcRfUf]V_e T`_UfTe hZeY hYZTY YV Z_UZgZUfR]]j deR_Ud TYRcXVU(q GVU 7R]] >_eVcZ`c 9V^`]ZeZ`_ 8`ca( g( ER]^RUVddR& 21. ;( Hfaa( /10& /2. #H(9(C(N( +33/$5 RTT`cU >_ cV 7]VTY HVT( AZeZX(& 3,2 ;( Hfaa( +,13& +,3,n3- #H(9(C(N( +330$( =VcV& eYV H:8 WcVbfV_e]j T`^SZ_Vd eYV T`_UfTe `W HfXRc^R_ hZeY <R]R_Zd Sj cVWVccZ_X e` eYV aRZc e`XVeYVc Rd pHfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zdq eYc`fXY`fe eYV 8`^a]RZ_e( =`hVgVc& ^R_j `W eYVdV cVWVcV_TVd e` pHfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zdq Via]RZ_ eYVZc T`]]VTeZgV dTYV^V( #HVV& V(X(& 8`^a]( m 0 #pHfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd UVgZdVU R a]R_ e` `SeRZ_ T`_ec`] `gVc Z_gVde`cds Wf_Ud Sj ++ RTbfZcZ_X Z_gVde^V_e RUgZdVcd ( ( ( (q$& 8`^a]( m +* #pHfXRc^R_& <R]R_Zd& R_U PeYVZc Rdd`TZReVdQ UZggZVU fa eYV ^ZdRaac`acZReVU ac`TVVUd ( ( ( (q$5 dVV R]d`& V(X(& 8`^a]( mm 1& 3& ,+& -,& -0& /.($ B`cV`gVc& eYV ^R[`cZej `W eYV 8`^a]RZ_e daVTZWZVd VRTY `_Vsd T`_UfTe Z_ eYV dTYV^V( #HVV& V(X(& 8`^a]( mm -1n/- #HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zdsd cVdaVTeZgV c`]Vd Z_ eYV =fXYVd RTbfZdZeZ`_$& 8`^a]( mm /.n00 #HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zdsd cVdaVTeZgV c`]Vd Z_ eYV 66B RTbfZdZeZ`_$& 8`^a]( m 1* #TYRce dY`hZ_X S`_U ac`TVVUd dV_e e` HfXRc^R_$& 8`^a]( mm 2.n23 #HfXRc^R_sd RTbfZdZeZ`_ `W KA 6ddfcR_TV fdZ_X eYV G`dV^`_e 7`_U R_U UZcVTeZ`_ `W Zed Wf_Ud$& 8`^a]( mm ++*n+, #HfXRc^R_sd aRj^V_e `W L6E88sd Z_eVcVde `S]ZXReZ`_d$($ 6]eY`fXY ]f^aZ_X UVWV_UR_ed e`XVeYVc Z_ gRXfV R]]VXReZ`_d Zd XV_VcR]]j Z_Raac`acZReV& eYV TRdV ]Rh HfXRc^R_ TZeVd Zd UZdeZ_XfZdYRS]V( ;`c ViR^a]V& Z_ IYcVV 8c`h_& eYV T`^a]RZ_e T`_dZdeV_e]j ]RSV]VU ^f]eZa]V UVWV_UR_ed e`XVeYVc Rd pd`^V `c R]] `W eYV UVWV_UR_edq hZeY`fe ac`gZUZ_X aRceZTf]RcZkVU WRTed Rd e` hYj VRTY UVWV_UR_e dY`f]U SV Z^a]ZTReVU Z_ eYV R]]VXVU ^Rc¥Ve ^R_Zaf]ReZ`_ dTYV^V( 2+1 ;( Hfaa( Re +*.*( HZ^Z]Rc]j& Z_ ;Z]]Vc g( =R_gZe 7R_¥& eYV T`fce UZd^ZddVU WcRfU T]RZ^d SVTRfdV eYV pT`^a]RZ_ed PUZUQ _`e ^R¥V R]]VXReZ`_d hZeY cVdaVTe e` VRTY UVWV_UR_e& Sfe Z_deVRU cVWVcPcVUQ `_]j XV_VcR]]j e` eYV UVWV_UR_ed Rd reYV 7R_¥ds `c reYV @`cVR_ 7R_¥d(sq ,**- LA ,,++*11-& Re %- #H(9(C(N( HVae( +,& ,**-$( 7fe eYVdV TRdVd& R_U `eYVcd TZeVU Sj HfXRc^R_& U` _`e deR_U W`c eYV ac`a`dZeZ`_ eYRe R a]VRUZ_X ^fde WRZ] ZW ^`cV eYR_ `_V UVWV_UR_e R]]VXVU]j TRccZVU `fe eYVZc T`_UfTe Z_ eR_UV^( >_deVRU& eYVdV T]RZ^d hVcV UZd^ZddVU f_UVc Gf]V 3#S$ SVTRfdV eYV a]RZ_eZWWd UZU _`e pdaVTZWj PeYV UVWV_UR_edsQ cVdaVTeZgV c`]Vd Z_ eYV PdTYV^VQ(q IYcVV 8c`h_& 2+1 ;( Hfaa( Re +*.*( IYZd 8`fce TR_ YRcU]j WRf]e eYV H:8 W`c eYV WRTe eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd RTeVU Z_ T`_TVce( 6_U hYZ]V& Rd Via]RZ_VU SV]`h& _`e R]] `W eYV H:8sd R]]VXReZ`_d aRdd ^fdeVc f_UVc eYV dVTfcZeZVd ]Rhd& eYV 8`^a]RZ_e RUVbfReV]j afed HfXRc^R_ `_ _`eZTV `W YZd c`]V Z_ eYV R]]VXVU]j WcRfUf]V_e dTYV^V( +, GV]ReVU]j& HfXRc^R_ T`_eV_Ud eYRe eYV H:8 TR__`e dReZdWj Gf]V 3#S$ hZeY pT`_T]fd`cj RddVceZ`_d eYRe `_V UVWV_UR_e T`_ec`]]VU R_`eYVc& `c eYRe d`^V UVWV_UR_ed RcV XfZ]ej SVTRfdV `W eYVZc Rdd`TZReZ`_ hZeY `eYVcd(q @`]SVT¥ g( A>I 6^(& >_T(& 3,- ;( Hfaa( //1& /03 #H(9(C(N( +330$( IYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd hVcV SfdZ_Vdd aRce_Vcd Z_ eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V( #8`^a]( mm /& +3($ 6]eY`fXY dZ^a]j ]RSV]Z_X HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd p/*)/* aRce_Vcdq `c eYV peh` ?Rd`_dq Zd _`e& Z_ ZedV]W& V_`fXY e` VdeRS]ZdY ]ZRSZ]Zej& Ze Zd a]RfdZS]VoR_U eYV H:8 a]VRUdoeYRe eYV eh` RTeVU Z_ T`_TVce eYc`fXY`fe eYZd V_UVRg`c( HVV H:8 g( 8`]]Z_d " 6Z¥^R_ 8`ca(& /,. ;( Hfaa( ,U .11& .20 #H(9(C(N( ,**1$ #pHVgVcR] aVcd`_d ^Rj RTe Z_ T`_TVce e` T`^^Ze R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W dVTeZ`_ +*#S$ eYRe ^ZXYe _`e SV RTeZ`_RS]V hVcV Ze _`e W`c eYVZc T``aVcReZ`_(q$5 dVV R]d` H:8 g( :dafV]Rd& 032 ;( Hfaa( ,U .+/& .-/ #H(9(C(N( ,*+*$ #WZ_UZ_X eYRe eYV H:8 RUVbfReV]j a]VU WcRfUf]V_e T`_UfTe R_U dTZV_eVc R]eY`fXY eYV T`^a]RZ_e ^RUV pdfSdeR_eZR]]j dZ^Z]Rc R]]VXReZ`_dq RXRZ_de eh` UVWV_UR_ed$( C`_VeYV]Vdd& eYV 8`^a]RZ_e T`_eRZ_d R]]VXReZ`_d eYRe <R]R_Zd R_U `eYVc dTYV^V aRceZTZaR_ed TRccZVU `fe RTed eR¥V_ hZeY HfXRc^R_sd p¥_`h]VUXV R_U Raac`gR]q `c p¥_`h]VUXV R_U T`_dV_e(q #HVV& V(X(& 8`^a]( mm 2& 3& -*& 01& 2,& 3-& 31($ BR_j `W eYVdV RddVceZ`_d RcV T`_T]fd`cj& R_U eYZd 8`fce hZ]] UZdcVXRcU eYV^ f_]Vdd `eYVchZdV dfaa`ceVU Sj aRceZTf]RcZkVU WRTefR] R]]VXReZ`_d( HVV& V(X(& EVe:UXV& >_T( g( <RcX& ,-. ;( Hfaa( -U .11& .3- #H(9(C(N( ,*+1$ #UVdTcZSZ_X RddVceZ`_d eYRe Z_UZgZUfR]d RTeVU pRe PUVWV_UR_esdQ UZcVTeZ`_&q pRd aRce `W PUVWV_UR_esdQ dTYV^V e` UVWcRfU PeYV a]RZ_eZWWQ&q R_U phZeY YZd ¥_`h]VUXV R_U Raac`gR]q Rd T`_T]fd`cj R_U UZd^ZddZ_X eY`dV f_dfaa`ceVU Sj aRceZTf]RcZkVU WRTefR] R]]VXReZ`_d #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$$5 >_ cV CF B`SZ]V& >_T( HVT( AZeZX(& ,*+/ LA +/*+.0+& Re %, #H(9(C(N( BRc( ,1& ,*+/$ #WZ_UZ_X T]RZ^d eYRe R UVWV_UR_e aVcW`c^VU RfUZe dVcgZTVd p`_ eYV RfeY`cZej `W& Re eYV UZcVTeZ`_ `W& f_UVc eYV T`_ec`] `W& R_U W`c eYV d`]V SV_VWZe `Wq R_`eYVc UVWV_UR_e e` SV pT`_T]fd`cj R]]VXReZ`_dq hZeY +- p_` WRTed e` dfSdeR_eZReVq eYV^$( S( 9VTVaeZgV 6Ted HfXRc^R_ RcXfVd eYRe eYV H:8 YRd _`e RUVbfReV]j a]VU eYRe YV T`^^ZeeVU eYV cVbfZdZeV UVTVaeZgV `c ^R_Zaf]ReZgV RTed dfWWZTZV_e e` deReV R T]RZ^ W`c dTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zej(& #9VW(sd BV^(& Re +/($ >_ T`_ecRde& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ hRd eYV p^RdeVc^Z_Uq `c pRcTYZeVTeq `W eYV dTYV^V SRdVU `_ YZd UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe( #E]( H:8sd BV^( `W ARh Z_ Daas_ e` 9VWsd B`e( e` 9Zd^Zdd& :8; C`( ., #pH:8sd BV^(q$& Re ++($ IYVcVW`cV& eYV H:8 T`_eV_Ud eYRe HfXRc^R_ Zd Z_YVcV_e]j ]ZRS]V Rd R acZ^Rcj gZ`]Re`c( HVV& V(X(& KR_8``¥ g( H:8& 0/- ;(-U +-*& +-3 #,U 8Zc( ,*++$ #WZ_UZ_X pRcTYZeVTeq `W ecRUZ_X dTYV^V gZ`]ReVU dTYV^V ac`gZdZ`_d$5 dVV R]d` 8@7+02 =`]UZ_Xd& AeU(& ,+* ;( Hfaa( -U Re ..0 #p6aRce Wc`^ PUVWV_UR_esdQ UVTVaeZgV ac`^`eZ`_R] RTed& YZd c`]V Rd dTYV^V RcTYZeVTe ^R¥Vd YZ^ ]ZRS]V Rd R ^ReeVc `W ]Rh(q$5 >_ cV <]`S( 8c`ddZ_X& AeU( HVT( AZeZX(& -,, ;( Hfaa( ,U -+3& --0 #H(9(C(N( ,**.$ #pP9VWV_UR_esdQ R]]VXVU]j TV_ecR] c`]V Z_ eYVdV dTYV^Vd& Rd eYVZc TYZVW RcTYZeVTe R_U ViVTfe`c& ]VRgVd _` U`fSe Rd e` PYZdQ a`eV_eZR] ]ZRSZ]Zej Rd R acZ^Rcj gZ`]Re`c f_UVc dVTeZ`_ +*#S$(q$( =`hVgVc& ^VcV]j ]RSV]Z_X HfXRc^R_ R p^RdeVc^Z_Uq `c pRcTYZeVTeq `W eYV dTYV^V Zd Z_RUVbfReV e` VdeRS]ZdY ]ZRSZ]Zej( IYVcVW`cV& eYZd 8`fce ^fde R_R]jkV HfXRc^R_sd R]]VXVU]j UVTVaeZgV `c ^R_Zaf]ReZgV RTed eYRe T`_deZefeV YZd Z_g`]gV^V_e Z_ eYZd dTYV^V( Z( =fXYVd 6TbfZdZeZ`_ IYV =fXYVd RTbfZdZeZ`_ hRd R ¥Vj T`^a`_V_e `W eYV `gVcR]] IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V SVTRfdV eYV dTYV^V aRceZTZaR_ed feZ]ZkVU =fXYVdsd T]ZV_eds Wf_Ud e` afcTYRdV eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud( =`hVgVc& eYV aRceZVd daRc `gVc4 #+$ hYVeYVc HfXRc^R_sd T`_UfTe hRd Z_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgV5 R_U #,$ hYVeYVc YZd T`_UfTe hRd pZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]Vq `W dVTfcZeZVd& +/ J(H(8( l & D^QK[VKW NXO¥ WX] VX_O ]X NS¥VS¥¥ ]RO Y[SVK[b _SXUK]SXW¥ XW ¥MSOW]O[ Q[X^WN¥' #6OP'k¥ ?OV'% K] )( W'/'$ +. 12[#S$5 +1 8(;(G( l ,.*(+*S'/& `c pZ_ eYV `WWVc `c dR]Vq `W dVTfcZeZVd& +/ J(H(8( l 11b#R$( ;Zcde& eYVcV Zd ]Zee]V U`fSe eYRe HfXRc^R_ a]RjVU R TV_ecR] c`]V Z_ eYV =fXYVd RTbfZdZeZ`_( #8`^a]( mm -1n/-($ HaVTZWZTR]]j& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ acVdV_eVU R ^V^`oafca`ceVU]j hcZeeV_ Sj 9f_¥Vc]Vj Sfe XY`dehcZeeV_ Sj <R]R_Zdoe` eYV LVR]eY' 6ddfcR_TV S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd cVXRcUZ_X eYV afcTYRdV `W =fXYVd(' #8`^a]( mm .+n.-($ 6_U eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe eYV ^Z_feVd Wc`^ eYV S`RcU ^VVeZ_XoUfcZ_X hYZTY eYV ecR_dRTeZ`_ hRd T`_df^^ReVUocVW]VTe eYRe eYV Z_gVde^V_e hRd HfXRc^R_ R_U 9f_¥Vc]Vjsd ac`a`dR]( #8`^a]( m .-($ IYfd& HfXRc^R_sd pT`fcdV `W T`_UfTe ^Rj _`e YRgV SVV_ Z_YVcV_e]j f_]RhWf]& Sfe Ze hRd UVTVaeZgV(q H:8 g( LVj& ,.0 ;( Hfaa( -U 23.& 3+2 #H(9(C(N( ,*+1$5 RTT`cU H:8 g( =fZ ;V_X& 3-/ ;(-U 1,+& 1-1 #3eY 8Zc( ,*+3$ #pP9QVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe eYRe Zd _`e Z_YVcV_e]j f_]RhWf] ^Rj W`c^ eYV SRdZd `W R dTYV^V e` UVWcRfU(q #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$$( B`cV`gVc& eYV ^V^` hRd ^Zd]VRUZ_X( >e ^V_eZ`_VU eYRe L6= YRU pcVWVccVUq R_ Z_gVde^V_e ac`a`dR] e` LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV eYRe Z_T]fUVU R cVT`^^V_UReZ`_ eYRe eYV Z_gVde^V_e hRd T`_UZeZ`_VU `_ R !+, ^Z]]Z`_ afcTYRdV `W L6=sd 8]Rdd 7 dYRcVd( #8`^a]( mm .+n.,($ >_deVRU `W SfjZ_X L6=sd 8]Rdd 7 dYRcVd& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd cVTjT]VU eYV IcZSR] 7`_U ac`TVVUd e` Wf_U eYV G`dV^`_e 7`_U& eYV 8``_Vj 7`_U& R_U afcTYRdV `eYVc V_eZeZVd& dfTY Rd KR]`c]ZWV( #8`^a]( mm /*n/,& 1-n13($ 6_U RTT`cUZ_X e` eYV 8`^a]RZ_e& XRZ_Z_X UZdTcVeZ`_ `gVc =fXYVdsd T]ZV_eds Wf_Ud e` UZcVTe eYVZc Z_gVde^V_ed hRd eYV Z_ZeZR] afca`dV `W eYV ecR_dRTeZ`_(( #8`^a]( mm .*& .,($ 3U]RX^QR ]RO 5XVYUKSW] YUOKN¥ ]RK] hD^QK[VKW RKN 9KUKWS¥ N[KP] K VOVX%i S] S¥ YUK^¥SLUO ]RK] D^QK[VKW NS[OM]ON 9KUKWS¥k¥ MXWN^M] LOMK^¥O RO ¥OW] D^QK[VKW N[KP]¥ XP ]RO VOVX XW 3^Q^¥] - KWN 3^Q^¥] /% *(), PX[ D^QK[VKWk¥ MXVVOW]¥' #5XVYU' e ,) #OVYRK¥S¥ KNNON$'$ ' COMOW]Ub% SW >X[OWcX _' DOM^[S]SO¥ KWN 7aMRKWQO 5XVVS¥¥SXW% )+1 D' 5]' )(1, #*()1$% ]RO D^Y[OVO 5X^[] OaYKWNON ]RO ¥MXYO XP ¥MROVO USKLSUS]b MUKSV¥ ^WNO[ ]RO ¥OM^[S]SO¥ UK`¥' DYOMSPSMKUUb% ]RO D^Y[OVO 5X^[] ROUN ]RK] ]RO hNS¥¥OVSWK]SXW XP PKU¥O X[ VS¥UOKNSWQ ¥]K]OVOW]¥ `S]R SW]OW] ]X NOP[K^N MKW PKUU `S]RSW ]RO ¥MXYO XP ¥^L¥OM]SXW¥ #K$ KWN #M$ XP C^UO )(L&-% ' ' ' O_OW SP ]RO NS¥¥OVSWK]X[ NSN WX] jVKTOk ]RO ¥]K]OVOW]¥ KWN MXW¥OZ^OW]Ub PKUU¥ X^]¥SNO ¥^L¥OM]SXW #L$ XP ]RO C^UO'i >X[OWcX% )+1 D' 5]' K] ))((f()' @OS]RO[ YK[]b L[SOPON ]RS¥ S¥¥^O% KWN K] ]RS¥ ¥]KQO% ]RS¥ ( +/ I` T`f_eVc eYZd a`Z_e& HfXRc^R_ ReeRTYVd e` YZd ^`eZ`_ aRaVcd R_ ViYZSZe `W LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TVsd `WWZTZR] S`RcU ^Z_feVd Wc`^ ?R_fRcj 1& ,*+. eYRe cVWVcV_TVd <R]R_Zdsd c`]V Rd R a`eV_eZR] T`_df]eR_e W`c eYV S`RcU( #9VT]( `W 9RgZU B( OZ__ Z_ Hfaa( `W ?Rd`_ HfXRc^R_sd BV^( `W ARh Z_ Hfaa( `W YZd B`e( e` 9Zd^Zdd eYV 8`^a](& :8; C`( .*& :i( 7($ HfXRc^R_ T]RZ^d eYRe eYZd U`Tf^V_e dY`hd eYRe eYV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV S`RcU ¥_Vh <R]R_Zd hRd h`c¥Z_X W`c eYV T`^aR_j& R_U eYVcVW`cV& T`_TVR]Z_X YZd c`]V T`f]U _`e YRgV SVV_ Z_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgV( #9VW(sd BV^(& Re +0($ >_ UVeVc^Z_Z_X hYVeYVc UZd^ZddR] Zd hRccR_eVU& R T`fce ^Rj pT`_dZUVc R_j hcZeeV_ Z_decf^V_e ReeRTYVU e` eYV T`^a]RZ_e& deReV^V_ed `c U`Tf^V_ed Z_T`ca`cReVU Z_e` eYV T`^a]RZ_e Sj cVWVcV_TV& ]VXR]]j cVbfZcVU afS]ZT UZdT]`dfcV U`Tf^V_ed WZ]VU hZeY eYV H:8& R_U U`Tf^V_ed a`ddVddVU Sj `c ¥_`h_ e` eYV a]RZ_eZWW R_U fa`_ hYZTY Ze cV]ZVU Z_ ScZ_XZ_X eYV dfZe(q @]VZ_^R_ g( :]R_ 8`ca(& a]T& 1*0 ;(-U +./& +/, #,U 8Zc( ,*+-$( 6]eY`fXY eYV 8`^a]RZ_e cVWVcV_TVd eYV ?R_fRcj 1& ,*+. S`RcU ^VVeZ_X Z_ eYV T`_eVie `W eYV 7R]]jSf_Z`_ ecR_dRTeZ`_& #8`^a]( m ,.$& pR XV_VcR] R]]fdZ`_ e` eYVdV U`Tf^V_ed Zd Z_dfWWZTZV_e e` UVV^ eYV^ Z_T`ca`cReVU Sj cVWVcV_TV&q D¥]RY`^R ;ZcVWZXYeVcd EV_dZ`_ " GVe( Hjd( g( AVi^Rc¥ >_es]& >_T(& -01 ;( Hfaa( -U +0& ,2 #H(9(C(N( ,*+3$( B`cV`gVc& VgV_ ZW eYV 8`^a]RZ_e cV]ZVU `_ eYVdV ^Z_feVd& eYV H:8 UZdRXcVVd hZeY HfXRc^R_sd WRTefR] Z_eVcacVeReZ`_ `W eYV^( #H:8sd BV^(& Re +- _(.($ 6_U Ze Zd ]`_X'dVee]VU Z_ eYZd 8ZcTfZe eYRe R T`fcesd Wf_TeZ`_ `_ R ^`eZ`_ e` UZd^Zdd Zd p_`e e` hVZXY eYV VgZUV_TV eYRe ^ZXYe SV acVdV_eVU Re R ecZR] Sfe ^VcV]j e` UVeVc^Z_V hYVeYVc eYV T`^a]RZ_e ZedV]W Zd ]VXR]]j dfWWZTZV_e(q HTYhRS g( :%IcRUV ;Z_( 8`ca(& ,2/ ;( Hfaa( -U 1./& 1.3 #H(9(C(N( ,*+2$ #bf`eZ_X <`]U^R_ g( 7V]UV_& 1/. ;(,U +*/3& +*01 #,U 8Zc( +32/$$( IYVcVW`cV& eYZd 8`fce UVT]Z_Vd e` 5X^[] WOON WX] NOU_O P^[]RO[ SW]X `RO]RO[ D^QK[VKWk¥ MXWN^M] SWMU^NO¥ ]RO hNS¥¥OVSWK]SXW XP PKU¥O X[ VS¥UOKNSWQ ¥]K]OVOW]¥ `S]R SW]OW] ]X NOP[K^Ni K¥ OW_S¥SXWON Lb >X[OWcX' :X`O_O[% ]RS¥ 5X^[] WX]O¥ ]RK] ^¥SWQ hPKU¥O [OY[O¥OW]K]SXW¥ ]X SWN^MO ]RO Y^[MRK¥O XP ¥OM^[S]SO¥ `X^UN ¥OOV K YK[KNSQVK]SM OaKVYUO XP ¥OM^[S]SO¥ P[K^N'i >X[OWcX% )+1 D' 5]' K] ))(+' +0 T`_dZUVc eYV S`RcU ^Z_feVd Z_ Zed VgR]fReZ`_ `W HfXRc^R_sd ^`eZ`_( HVT`_U& eYV H:8 RUVbfReV]j R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_sd T`_UfTe hRd pZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]Vq R_U pZ_ eYV `WWVc `c dR]Vq `W dVTfcZeZVd( HVV +/ J(H(8( ll 11b#R$& 12[#S$5 +1 8(;(G( l ,.*(+*S'/( p>_ Zed c`]V V_W`cTZ_X eYV 6Te& eYV H:8 YRd T`_dZdeV_e]j RU`aeVU R Sc`RU cVRUZ_X `W eYV aYcRdV rZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]V `W R_j dVTfcZej(sq H:8 g( OR_UW`cU& /-/ J(H( 2+-& 2+3 #,**,$( >_UVVU& pZe Zd V_`fXY eYRe eYV WcRfU R]]VXVU rT`Z_TZUVs hZeY R dVTfcZeZVd ecR_dRTeZ`_ohYVeYVc Sj eYV a]RZ_eZWW `c Sj d`^V`_V V]dV(q BVccZ]] Aj_TY& EZVcTV& ;V__Vc " H^ZeY >_T( g( 9RSZe& /.1 J(H( 1+& 2/ #,**0$5 RTT`cU LVj& ,.0 ;( Hfaa( -U Re 3+-n+.( 7fe pPTQ`_UfTe eYRe Zd ^VcV]j Z_TZUV_eR] `c eR_XV_eZR]]j cV]ReVU e` eYV dR]V `W dVTfcZeZVd hZ]] _`e ^VVe eYV rZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeYs cVbfZcV^V_e(q AVj¥Z_ g( 6I " I 8`ca(& .,- ;( Hfaa( ,U ,,3& ,.+ #H(9(C(N( ,**0$& RWWsU& ,+0 ;( 6aasi +. #,U 8Zc( ,**1$( =VcV& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe eYV afcTYRdV `W =fXYVd hRd R_ Z_eVXcR] deVa Z_ eYV ]RcXVc dTYV^V eYRe daVTZWZTR]]j V_eRZ]VU XRZ_Z_X RTTVdd e` T]ZV_e Wf_Ud e` dV]] eY`dV T]ZV_ed dYR^ dVTfcZeZVdoeYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud( 6]eY`fXY eYV afcTYRdV `W =fXYVd ^Rj YRgV RaaVRcVU p]VXZeZ^ReV&q AVj¥Z_& .,- ;( Hfaa( ,U Re ,.,& eYV RTbfZdZeZ`_ V^a]`jVU UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe _VTVddRcj e` ViVTfeV eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V() B`cV`gVc& eYV Z_gVde^V_e ^V^` Via]ZTZe]j Z_T]fUVU R cVT`^^V_UReZ`_ eYRe eYV =fXYVd Z_gVde^V_e SV T`_UZeZ`_VU `_ LR¥aR^_Z >_gVde^V_eds afcTYRdV `W !+, ^Z]]Z`_ `W L6=sd 8]Rdd 7 dYRcVd( #8`^a]( mm .,& /*($ IYVcVW`cV& HfXRc^R_sd UVTVaeZgV c`]V Z_ eYV RTbfZdZeZ`_ `W =fXYVd R_U eYV dfSdVbfV_e dR]V `W IcZSR] 7`_Ud ERO 5XVYUKSW] KUUOQO¥ ]RK] h9KUKWS¥% ?X[]XW KWN :S[¥]% KM]SWQ `S]R D^QK[VKWk¥ TWX`UONQO KWN MXW¥OW]% NS[OM]ON :^QRO¥k¥ MUSOW]¥k Y^[MRK¥O¥ XP ]RO PS[¥] !*/ VSUUSXW ][KWMRO XP LXWN¥'i #5XVYU' e 0 #OVYRK¥S¥ KNNON$'$ 3¥ VOW]SXWON% KUUOQK]SXW¥ ]RK] KW SWNS_SN^KU KM]ON `S]R KWX]RO[k¥ hTWX`UONQO KWN MXW¥OW]i K[O `RXUUb MXWMU^¥X[b' :O[O% ]RO D75 YUOKN¥ ]RK] 9KUKWS¥ PX[`K[NON D^QK[VKW K 5FD;B PX[ ]RO E[SLKU 4XWN¥% K¥ `OUU K¥ K ¥Y[OKN¥ROO] KWN ][KNO LUX]]O[ [OPUOM]SWQ :^QRO¥k¥ MUSOW]¥k Y^[MRK¥O XP ]RO LXWN¥' #5XVYU' e ,-'$ ERS¥ KUSQW¥ `S]R ]RO D75k¥ KUUOQK]SXW ]RK] D^QK[VKW KWN 9KUKWS¥ SW]OWNON ]X Y^[MRK¥O :^QRO¥ ]X NS[OM] ]ROS[ MUSOW]¥k P^WN¥ SW]X E[SLKU 4XWN¥' #5XVYU' e ,*'$ ERO[OPX[O% `RSUO D^QK[VKW VKb WX] RK_O KM]^KUUb Y^[MRK¥ON ]RO E[SLKU 4XWN¥ XW LORKUP XP :^QRO¥k¥ MUSOW]¥ RSV¥OUP% ]RO D75 KNOZ^K]OUb YUOKN¥ ]RK] D^QK[VKW TWO` KLX^] ]RO¥O YUKWWON ][KW¥KM]SXW¥ KWN ¥KUO¥' ) +1 e` =fXYVdsd T]ZV_edohYZTY HfXRc^R_ R]]VXVU]j ¥_Vh RS`fe Wc`^ eYV SVXZ__Z_XoT`^a`ced hZeY eYV pSc`RU Z_eVcacVeReZ`_q `W eYV aYcRdV pZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]Vq `W dVTfcZeZVd Z_ eYV T`_eVie `W HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ R_U Gf]V +*S'/( 9RSZe& /.1 J(H( Re 2/5 B`_RcTY ;f_UZ_X 8`ca(& +3, ;(-U Re -*2 #p:ddV_eZR]]j eYV dR^V V]V^V_ed RcV cVbfZcVU f_UVc HVTeZ`_ +1#R$#+$n#-$ Z_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV `WWVc `c dR]V `W R dVTfcZej(q$5 dVV R]d`& V(X(& H:8 g( HRjZU& ,*+2 LA -/1-,*& Re %1 #H(9(C(N( ?R_( +*& ,*+2$ #WZ_UZ_X Ree`c_Vjsd `aZ_Z`_ ]VeeVcd UV]ZgVcVU e` ecR_dWVc RXV_e hVcV R_ pZ_eVXcR] aRce `W PUVWV_UR_esdQ `gVcRcTYZ_X af^a R_U Uf^a dTYV^Vq R_U eYRe Ree`c_Vj p¥_Vh `c dY`f]U YRgV ¥_`h_ eYRe YZd WR]dV cVacVdV_eReZ`_d h`f]U SV fdVU e` Vcc`_V`fd]j ZddfV Pf_cVXZdeVcVUQ dYRcVd `W ( ( ( de`T¥q$5 LVj& ,.0 ;( Hfaa( -U Re 3+-n+.& 3+1 #T`_T]fUZ_X H:8 RUVbfReV]j R]]VXVU aRceZTZaReZ`_ Z_ R WcRfUf]V_e dTYV^V pZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY eYV afcTYRdV `c dR]Vq R_U pZ_ eYV `WWVc `c dR]Vq `W dVTfcZeZVd SRdVU `_ ^ZdcVacVdV_eReZ`_d e` RddZde R T`^aR_j Z_ `SeRZ_Z_X ]ZdeZ_Xd `_ C6H96F$( ZZ( 6UUZeZ`_R] 9VTVaeZgV 6Ted IYV H:8 Zd _`e cVbfZcVU e` R]]VXV eYRe HfXRc^R_ paRceZTZaReVU Z_ VRTY R_U VgVcj RdaVTe `W eYV WcRfUf]V_e dTYV^Vq e` VdeRS]ZdY dTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zej( LVj& ,.0 ;( Hfaa( -U Re 3+0( >_UVVU& Rd HfXRc^R_ a`Z_ed `fe& ^R_j `W eYV H:8sd R]]VXReZ`_d W`Tfd d`]V]j `_ <R]R_Zdsd daVTZWZT T`_UfTe( #HVV& V(X(& 8`^a]( mm .& ,3n-*& ./($ =`hVgVc& Re eYV ^`eZ`_ e` UZd^Zdd deRXV& eYV H:8 ^fde `_]j R]]VXV HfXRc^R_ pV_XRXVU Z_ UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe eYRe T`_ecZSfeVU e` eYV ]RcXVc dTYV^V(q H:8 g( HRd`_& .-- ;( Hfaa( -U .30& /*3 #H(9(C(N( ,*,*$( IYV H:8 YRd ^Ve eYRe SfcUV_( ;`c ViR^a]V& acZ`c e` eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud dTYV^V&! HfXRc^R_ T`_gZ_TVU LVR]eY' D^QK[VKW MXW]OWN¥ ]RK] ]RS¥ ][KW¥KM]SXW S¥ WX] YK[] XP ]RO X_O[KUU ¥MROVO% KWN ]RO[OPX[O ]RS¥ 5X^[] ¥RX^UN NS¥[OQK[N ]RS¥ ¥OYK[K]O% OK[USO[ O_OW]' #COYUb ?OV' SW D^YY' XP <K¥XW D^QK[VKWk¥ ?X]' ]X 6S¥VS¥¥ ]RO 5XVYU'% 758 @X' ,-% K] )'$ :X`O_O[% D^QK[VKW YXSW]¥ ]X WX MK¥O UK` ]RK] USVS]¥ ]RS¥ 5X^[]k¥ KLSUS]b ]X N[K` P[XV ]RO OW]S[O ! +2 6ddfcR_TVsd S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd e` Raac`gV R t. ^Z]]Z`_ Z_gVde^V_e `W eYV T`^aR_jsd TRaZeR] Z_ eYV 7R]]jSf_Z`_ Wf_U Z_ >cV]R_U( #8`^a]( m ,.($ HfXRc^R_ eYV_ UZcVTeVU YZd RddZdeR_e e` Z_T`ca`cReV R ]Z^ZeVU ]ZRSZ]Zej T`^aR_j Z_ CVgRUR SVRcZ_X eYV dR^V 7R]]jSf_Z`_ _R^V& hYZTY YRU _` cVR] cV]ReZ`_dYZa e` eYV >cZdY Wf_U( #8`^a]( m ,/($ LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV f]eZ^ReV]j hZcVU eYV t. ^Z]]Z`_ e` eYV dYR^ 7R]]jSf_Z`_ T`^aR_j& R_U RWeVc gRcZ`fd ecR_dRTeZ`_d& eYV Wf_Ud hVcV fdVU Sj L6= e` afcTYRdV LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TV( #8`^a]( mm ,0n,1($ 7j UZcVTeZ_X YZd RddZdeR_e e` TcVReV eYZd dYR^ RTT`f_e R_U eYV_ YZUZ_X eYV d`fcTV `W LVR]eY'6ddfcR_TVsd afcTYRdV eYc`fXY R dVcZVd `W WcRfUf]V_e ecR_dRTeZ`_d& eYV 8`^a]RZ_e a]VRUd Z_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgV RTed( HVV H:8 g( EV__& ,,/ ;( Hfaa( -U ,,/& ,-0 #H(9(C(N( ,*+0$ #WZ_UZ_X eYRe Sj pUZdXfZdZ_X eYV f]eZ^ReV cVTZaZV_e `W ( ( ( Wf_Ud eYc`fXY dYR^ ecR_dRTeZ`_d& PUVWV_UR_eQ V_XRXVU Z_ R_ Z_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgV RTeq$5 >_ cV H^ZeY 7Rc_Vj IcR_dWVc 6XV_e AZeZX(& 22. ;( Hfaa( ,U Re +0+ #TcVReZ`_ R_U fdV `W Z_eVc^VUZRcj V_eZej e` T`_TVR] ZUV_eZej `W ecR_dRTeZ`_sd SV_VWZTZRcj Zd UVTVaeZgV$( HZ^Z]Rc]j& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd Z_deR]]VU 9f_¥Vc]Vj e` RTe Rd eYV d`]V UZcVTe`c R_U _`^Z_VV acVdZUV_e `W L6= CK& hYZTY YV]aVU afcTYRdV KR]`c]ZWV( #8`^a]( mm 02& 10n11($ pP@Q_`hZ_X]j dfaVcgZdZ_X V^a]`jVVd hY` RcV TRccjZ_X `fe R WcRfUf]V_e dTYV^V Zd ZedV]W eYV V^a]`j^V_e `W R UVTVaeZgV UVgZTV(q HVV 8`]]Z_d " 6Z¥^R_ 8`ca(& /,. ;( Hfaa( ,U Re .3/( B`cV`gVc& ]Z¥V eYV 7R]]jSf_Z`_ ecR_dRTeZ`_& eYV ^`_Vj W`c eYZd afcTYRdV e``¥ R TZcTfZe`fd c`feV& hYZTY eYV H:8 R]]VXVd hRd UVdZX_VU e` UZdXfZdV eYV d`fcTV `W eYV Wf_Ud fdZ_X eh` HfXRc^R_'RWWZ]ZReVU V_eZeZVd& L6= CK R_U 8R^UV_ :dTc`h( #8`^a]( mm 1-n11($ IYfd& eYV afcTYRdV `W KR]`c]ZWV hRd RTT`^a]ZdYVU eYc`fXY R]]VXVU]j UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe( 6_U Ze hRd dZ^Z]Rc]j UVTVaeZgV e` T`_TVR] eYVdV ecR_dRTeZ`_d UfcZ_X eYV afcTYRdV `W 66B& hYZTY R]]`hVU HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd e` dV]] RUUZeZ`_R] ecR_TYVd `W IcZSR] 7`_Ud( IYZd T`_UfTe Zd dfWWZTZV_e e` YUOKNSWQ ]X NO]O[VSWO `RO]RO[ ]RO D75k¥ 5XVYUKSW] hMXW]KSWI¥J ¥^PPSMSOW] PKM]^KU VK]]O[% KMMOY]ON K¥ ][^O% ]X ¥]K]O K MUKSV ]X [OUSOP ]RK] S¥ YUK^¥SLUO XW S]¥ PKMO'i ;ZLKU% --. F'D' K] ./0 #Z^X]K]SXW VK[T¥ XVS]]ON$' +3 deReV R T]RZ^ W`c R acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_( HVV& V(X(& EV__& ,,/ ;( Hfaa( -U Re ,-0 #pG`feZ_X eYV ^`_Vj e` Peh` UVWV_UR_e'T`_ec`]]VU V_eZeZVdQ eYc`fXY PR dVaRcReV V_eZejQ dVcgVU _` ]VXZeZ^ReV afca`dV R_U hRd R_ `SgZ`fd ReeV^ae e` dYZV]U PUVWV_UR_esdQ eYVWe Wc`^ eYV ;f_Usd RfUZe`cd R_U aRceZTZaR_ed(q$5 >_ cV ERc^R]Re HVT( AZeZX(& -10 ;( Hfaa( ,U .1,& .3- #H(9(C(N( ,**/$ #T`_T]fUZ_X eYRe ecR_dRTeZ`_d hVcV UVTVaeZgV SVTRfdV eYVj pTcVReVU R_ RaaVRcR_TV `W dfSdeR_TV hYVcV dfSdeR_TV hRd ]RT¥Z_Xq R_U eYVcVW`cV hVcV dfS[VTe e` Gf]Vd +*S'/#R$ R_U #T$$( 6]eY`fXY eYV 8`^a]RZ_e R]]VXVd eYRe S`eY pHfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zdq TRccZVU `fe eYV KR]`c]ZWV ecR_dRTeZ`_d e`XVeYVc& eYVdV R]]VXReZ`_d RcV dfWWZTZV_e f_UVc Gf]V 3#S$( >_ R dVaRcReV T`^a]RZ_e Z_ eYV 6cTYVc TZgZ] ^ReeVc& eYV H:8 R]]VXVU eYRe p?Rd`_ <R]R_Zd YRU dZX_Z_X RfeY`cZej `gVc IY`cdUR]Vsd SR_¥ RTT`f_e& YV]U Zed `_]j UVSZe TRcU& R_U UZcVTeVU R]] eYV hZcVd eYRe IY`cdUR]V dV_e eYRe hVcV Wf_UVU Sj S`_U ac`TVVUd Wc`^ eYV L6E88 6TT`f_e(q 6cTYVc& C`( +0'Tg'-/*/& :8; C`( 22& m 22( HfXRc^R_ TZeVd CVh =R^adYZcV g( BRZ_V& /-, J(H( 1., #,**+$& W`c eYV ac`a`dZeZ`_ eYRe `_TV R X`gVc_^V_e a]RZ_eZWW Rddf^Vd R_U SV_VWZed Wc`^ R TVceRZ_ WRTefR] a`dZeZ`_ Z_ ]ZeZXReZ`_& Ze hZ]] SV Vde`aaVU Wc`^ Rddf^Z_X R T`_ecRcj a`dZeZ`_ Z_ R _Vh T`^a]RZ_e( pIjaZTR]]j& [fUZTZR] Vde`aaV] hZ]] Raa]j ZW4 +$ R aRcejsd ]ReVc a`dZeZ`_ Zd rT]VRc]j Z_T`_dZdeV_es hZeY Zed VRc]ZVc a`dZeZ`_5 ,$ eYV aRcejsd W`c^Vc a`dZeZ`_ YRd SVV_ RU`aeVU Z_ d`^V hRj Sj eYV T`fce Z_ eYV VRc]ZVc ac`TVVUZ_X5 R_U -$ eYV aRcej RddVceZ_X eYV eh` a`dZeZ`_d h`f]U UVcZgV R_ f_WRZc RUgR_eRXV RXRZ_de eYV aRcej dVV¥Z_X Vde`aaV](q 9VG`dR g( CRes] :_gV]`aV 8`ca(& /3/ ;(-U 33& +*- #,U 8Zc( ,*+*$ #bf`eZ_X BRZ_V /-, J(H( Re 1/*n/+$( B`cV`gVc eYV HVT`_U 8ZcTfZe ]Z^Zed p[fUZTZR] Vde`aaV] e` dZefReZ`_d hYVcV eYV cZd¥ `W Z_T`_dZdeV_e cVdf]ed hZeY Zed Z^aRTe `_ [fUZTZR] Z_eVXcZej Zd TVceRZ_(q JkURgZ_Vd g( LVV¥d BRcZ_V& >_T(& .+2 ;(-U +-2& +.2 #,U 8Zc( ,**/$ #bf`eZ_X HZ^`_ g( HRWV]ZeV <]Rdd 8`ca(& +,2 ;(-U 02& 1, #,U 8Zc( +331$$( ,* =`hVgVc& eYV [fUZTZR] Vde`aaV] U`TecZ_V Zd Z_Raa]ZTRS]V( IYV H:8sd TfccV_e a`dZeZ`_ eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U <R]R_Zd UZcVTeVU R ]RcXV a`ceZ`_ `W eYV S`_U ac`TVVUd e` SV dV_e Wc`^ IY`cdUR]V Zd _`e pT]VRc]j Z_T`_dZdeV_e&q BRZ_V& /-, J(H( Re 1/*& hZeY Zed VRc]ZVc a`dZeZ`_ eYRe <R]R_Zd YRU dZX_Z_X RfeY`cZej `gVc IY`cdUR]Vsd SR_¥ RTT`f_e R_U UZcVTeVU Zed hZcVd( ;`c ViR^a]V& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe L6= CKsd SR_¥ RTT`f_e deReV^V_ed hVcV dV_e e` R_ `WWZTV Z_ 8R]ZW`c_ZR eYRe HfXRc^R_ R_U YZd Sc`eYVc fdVU Z_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeY gRcZ`fd SfdZ_VddVd( #8`^a]( m 02($ 8`_decfZ_X R]] cVRd`_RS]V Z_WVcV_TVd Z_ eYV a]RZ_eZWWsd WRg`c& Rd eYZd 8`fce ^fde& Ze Zd a]RfdZS]V eYRe HfXRc^R_ YRU R c`]V Z_ UZcVTeZ_X eYV ac`TVVUd Wc`^ IY`cdUR]V e` L6= CK& VgV_ ZW <R]R_Zd YRU RTefR] T`_ec`] `W eYV RTT`f_e( ZZZ( BZdRaac`acZReZ`_ IYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ Zd R]d` ]ZRS]V SVTRfdV p^ZdRaac`acZReZ`_ Zd Z_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgVq R_U Zd V_`fXY e` deReV R T]RZ^ W`c R gZ`]ReZ`_ `W eYV dVTfcZeZVd ]Rhd( #H:8sd BV^(& Re +-($ IYV H:8 Zd Z_T`ccVTe Rd R ^ReeVc `W ]Rh( LYZ]V pT`_UfTe ZedV]W TR_ SV UVTVaeZgV&q R_U ^Rj XZgV cZdV e` ]ZRSZ]Zej f_UVc HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ `c Gf]V +*S'/ hZeY`fe pR daVTZWZT `cR] `c hcZeeV_ deReV^V_e&q He`_VcZUXV >_g( ERce_Vcd& AA8 g( HTZ('6e]R_eR& //, J(H( +.2& +/2 #,**2$& UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe pZccVUfTZS]j V_eRZ]d d`^V RTe eYRe XZgVd eYV gZTeZ^ R WR]dV Z^acVddZ`_&q ;Z__Vcej& /-- ;(-U Re +.2( >_UVVU& Z_ ;Z__Vcej& eYV HVT`_U 8ZcTfZe Via]RZ_VU eYRe pPeQYVWe _`e RTT`^a]ZdYVU Sj UVTVaeZ`_ #V(X(& aYjdZTR]]j eR¥Z_X R_U TRccjZ_X RhRj R_`eYVcsd ac`aVcej$ Zd _`e WcRfU RSdV_e R WZUfTZRcj Ufej(q /-- ;(-U Re +.2 #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$( HZ^Z]Rc]j& Z_ OR_UW`cU& hYV_ UZdTfddZ_X eYV pZ_ T`__VTeZ`_ hZeYq cVbfZcV^V_e f_UVc HVTeZ`_ +*#S$ R_U Gf]V +*S'/& eYV HfacV^V 8`fce UZdeZ_XfZdYVU dVTfcZeZVd gZ`]ReZ`_d Wc`^ dZefReZ`_d Z_ hYZTY pR ]RhWf] ecR_dRTeZ`_ YRU SVV_ T`_df^^ReVU& PR_UQ R Sc`¥Vc UVTZUVU e` deVR] eYV ac`TVVUd R_U UZU d`(q OR_UW`cU& /-/ J(H( Re 2,*( AZ¥VhZdV& hYV_ pR eYZVW dZ^a]j Z_gVdePdQ eYV ac`TVVUd `W R c`feZ_V ,+ T`_gVcdZ`_ Z_ eYV de`T¥ ^Rc¥Ve&q eYRe U`Vd _`e Rfe`^ReZTR]]j daRh_ R dVTfcZeZVd gZ`]ReZ`_( OR_UW`cU& /-/ J(H( Re 2,*( IYVdV TRdVd ^R¥V T]VRc eYRe T`fced ^fde aRcdV WcRfU R]]VXReZ`_d e` UZdeZ_XfZdY SVehVV_ ^ZdRaac`acZReZ`_ eYRe Zd R ^Z_V'cf_ T`_gVcdZ`_& R_U ^ZdRaac`acZReZ`_ eYc`fXY UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe( IYVcVW`cV& hYZ]V eYVcV Zd _`eYZ_X pZ_YVcV_e]j UVTVaeZgVq RS`fe deVR]Z_X ^`_Vj& eYV ^ZdRaac`acZReZ`_ `W Wf_UdohYV_ RTT`^a]ZdYVU Sj UVTVaeZgV RTedo^Rj SV Z_UZTReZgV `W dTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zej( HVV& V(X(& <cfSVc& ,*+2 LA +.+2+22& Re %+. #pP9VWV_UR_edQ TRfdVU eYV 8`^aR_j e` RhRcU eYVZc WR^Z]j ^V^SVcd R dfSdeR_eZR] R^`f_e `W dYRcVd& hYZTY hVcV eYV_ ecR_dWVccVU e` eYV^oR eV]]eR]V dZX_ `W UVTVaeZgV T`_UfTe(q$5 8YZ_R CV( EVec`]Vf^ =`]UZ_Xd AeU(& ,1 ;( Hfaa( -U Re -3, #pPIQYV H:8 YRd T`^aVeV_e]j a]VU eYV ViZdeV_TV `W R ]RcXVc dTYV^V& `_V eYRe hV_e SVj`_U ^VcV ^ZdcVacVdV_eReZ`_d e` Z_gVde`cd& hYVcVSj UVWV_UR_ed V_cZTYVU eYV^dV]gVd R_U eYVZc WR^Z]ZVd Re dYRcVY`]UVcds ViaV_dV(q$( IYV 8`^a]RZ_e R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ #R_U <R]R_Zd$ hVcV Z_eZ^ReV]j Z_g`]gVU Z_ dVTfcZeZVd ecR_dRTeZ`_d R_U UZgVceVU Wf_Ud UZcVTe]j R_U Z_UZcVTe]j Wc`^ L6E88& Z_deVRU `W fdZ_X eYV Wf_Ud e` afcTYRdV R_ R__fZej W`c eYV LA88( #8`^a]( mm .0n/-& 00n1*($ HfXRc^R_ hRd _`e dZ^a]j YV]aZ_X <R]R_Zd deVR] Wc`^ Z_gVde`cd& Sfe RTeZgV]j aRceZTZaReZ_X Z_ R ]RcXVc dTYV^V Z_ hYZTY ^f]eZa]V `eYVc V_eZeZVd hVcV afcTYRdVU hZeY ^ZdRaac`acZReVU Wf_Ud& WRZ]Z_X e` UZdT]`dV eYV d`fcTV `W eYVdV Wf_Ud& R_U RTeZgV]j ecjZ_X e` T`gVc'fa eYVZc dTYV^V Sj UZgVceZ_X ^`_Vj SRT¥ e` =fXYVd R_U 66B( #8`^a]( mm 1+n++,($ 6_U eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ ac`WZeVU Wc`^ eYV dTYV^V Sj dZaY`_Z_X _VRc]j !3 ^Z]]Z`_& Z_T]fUZ_X UZcVTe aRj^V_ed Wc`^ eYV S`_U ac`TVVUd4 #+$ !,-0&*** Wc`^ L6E88 #eYV dYR^ R__fZej ac`gZUVc$5 #,$ RS`fe !,.*&*** Wc`^ L6= CK #YZd RWWZ]ZReVU V_eZej$5 R_U #-$ !.1&/** Wc`^ IY`cdUR]V #<R]R_Zdsd V_eZej$( #8`^a]( mm ,& 1*($ IYVcVW`cV& eYV H:8 YRd RUVbfReV]j a]VU acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_d f_UVc R eYV`cj `W dTYV^V ]ZRSZ]Zej( ,, >>>( HVT`_URcj AZRSZ]Zej HVTeZ`_ +/#S$ `W eYV HVTfcZeZVd 6Te ac`gZUVd eYRe Z_ RTeZ`_d Sc`fXYe Sj eYV H:8 pR_j aVcd`_ eYRe ¥_`hZ_X]j `c cVT¥]Vdd]j ac`gZUVd dfSdeR_eZR] RddZdeR_TV e` R_`eYVc aVcd`_ Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W R ac`gZdZ`_ `W eYZd dfSTYRaeVc& `c `W R_j cf]V `c cVXf]ReZ`_ ZddfVU f_UVc eYZd dfSTYRaeVc& dYR]] SV UVV^VU e` SV Z_ gZ`]ReZ`_ `W dfTY ac`gZdZ`_ e` eYV dR^V VieV_e Rd eYV aVcd`_ e` hY`^ dfTY RddZdeR_TV Zd ac`gZUVU(q +/ J(H(8( l 11`#S$( p7VTRfdV eYV `aVcReZgV ]R_XfRXV Z_ PHVTeZ`_Q +/#S$ Zd _VRc]j ZUV_eZTR] e` eYRe Z_ PHVTeZ`_Q ,*#V$& eYV deR_URcU W`c RZUZ_X R_U RSVeeZ_X ]ZRSZ]Zej Zd eYV dR^V f_UVc S`eY deRefeVd(q H:8 g( AV¥ HVT( 8`ca(& ,10 ;( Hfaa( -U .3& 0+ #H(9(C(N( ,*+1$5 +/ J(H(8( l 12e#V$( I` deReV R T]RZ^ W`c RZUZ_X R_U RSVeeZ_X& eYV H:8 ^fde R]]VXV4 p#+$ eYV ViZdeV_TV `W R dVTfcZeZVd ]Rh gZ`]ReZ`_ Sj eYV acZ^Rcj #Rd `aa`dVU e` eYV RZUZ_X R_U RSVeeZ_X$ aRcej5 #,$ ¥_`h]VUXV `W eYZd gZ`]ReZ`_ `_ eYV aRce `W eYV RZUVc R_U RSVee`c5 R_U #-$ dfSdeR_eZR] RddZdeR_TV Sj eYV RZUVc R_U RSVee`c Z_ eYV RTYZVgV^V_e `W eYV acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_(q H:8 g( 6afkk`& 023 ;(-U ,*.& ,++ #,U 8Zc( ,*+,$ #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$(!! HfXRc^R_ UZdafeVd _VZeYVc <R]R_Zdsd acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_d _`c eYV WRTe eYRe HfXRc^R_ ac`gZUVU dfSdeR_eZR] RddZdeR_TV( #9VW(sd BV^(& Re ,,n,-($ >_deVRU& YV T`_eV_Ud eYRe YV UZU _`e ¥_`h YV hRd ac`gZUZ_X dfSdeR_eZR] RddZdeR_TV e` R WcRfUf]V_e dTYV^V( =VcV& eYV 8`^a]RZ_e Zd cVa]VeV hZeY R]]VXReZ`_d `W HfXRc^R_sd ¥_`h]VUXV #`c Re ]VRde cVT¥]Vdd_Vdd$ R_U YZd YZXY UVXcVV `W dfSdeR_eZR] RddZdeR_TV e` eYV dTYV^V e` UVWcRfU( 6d R_ Z_ZeZR] ^ReeVc& eYV R]]VXReZ`_ eYRe pHfXRc^R_ ¥_Vh Wc`^ <R]R_Zd eYRe eYV ac`TVVUd Wc`^ eYV 7`_U dR]Vd hVcV dfaa`dVU e` SV fdVU Sj eYV PLA88Q e` afcTYRdV R_ R__fZej ( ( ( Wc`^ LVR]eY' ;W *()(% 5XWQ[O¥¥ KVOWNON KSNO[ KWN KLO]]X[ USKLSUS]b ]X SWMU^NO KWb YO[¥XW `RX hTWX`SWQUb X[ [OMTUO¥¥Ub Y[X_SNO¥ ¥^L¥]KW]SKU K¥¥S¥]KWMO ]X KWX]RO[ YO[¥XWIk¥Ji _SXUK]SXW' DOO )- F'D'5' d /0]#O$2 6XNN&8[KWT HKUU D][OO] COPX[V KWN 5XW¥^VO[ B[X]OM]SXW 3M]% B^L' >' @X' )))&*(+% ES]UO G;;% d 1*1(% )*, D]K]' )/.)% )0.*% )0.- #*()($ #OVYRK¥S¥ KNNON$' !! ,- 6ddfcR_TVq Zd a]RZ_]j T`_T]fd`cj R_U hZ]] SV UZdcVXRcUVU(!" #8`^a]( m .0($ IYRe SVZ_X dRZU& Z_ eYV dR^V aRcRXcRaY& eYV H:8 a]VRUd eYRe HfXRc^R_ ¥_Vh #`c hRd cVT¥]Vdd Z_ _`e ¥_`hZ_X$ eYRe eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud hVcV Z_eV_UVU e` SV Z_gVdeVU Z_ R_ R__fZej SVTRfdV `W YZd pcVgZVhq `W eYV ecR_dRTeZ`_ Rd R ^V^SVc `W 7fc_YR^sd Z_gVde^V_e T`^^ZeeVV( #8`^a]( m .0$ HfXRc^R_ R]d` Z_UZcVTe]j `h_VU R_ Z_eVcVde Z_ 7fc_YR^ R_U hRd R ^V^SVc `W Zed S`RcU `W UZcVTe`cd( #8`^a]( m +0($ IYVdV R]]VXReZ`_d RcV dfWWZTZV_e Re eYZd deRXV& VdaVTZR]]j Z_ ]ZXYe `W eYV WRTe eYRe pR YZXY UVXcVV `W dfSdeR_eZR] RddZdeR_TV ^Rj ]VddV_ eYV H:8sd SfcUV_ Z_ ac`gZ_X dTZV_eVc(q 6afkk`& 023 ;(-U Re ,+/ #V^aYRdZd Z_ `cZXZ_R]$( I` WfceYVc Z_UZTReV HfXRc^R_sd ¥_`h]VUXV `W eYV dTYV^V& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ cVTVZgVU R dacVRUdYVVe Wc`^ <R]R_Zd RS`fe eYV cVR] ac`a`dVU R]]`TReZ`_ `W eYV ac`TVVUd& hYZTY UZU _`e Z_T]fUV R_ R__fZej( #8`^a]( m .1($ IYV 8`^a]RZ_e T`_dZdeV_e]j RddVced eYRe HfXRc^R_ ¥_Vh eYRe eYV Wf_Ud YV cVTVZgVU hVcV Wc`^ L6E88 #eYV WR¥V R__fZej ac`gZUVc$ `c hVcV dV_e Wc`^ `eYVc cV]ReVU V_eZeZVd( #8`^a]( mm 00& 1*& 1/n11& +**($ =V R]d` R]]VXVU]j ¥_Vh eYV S`_Ud YRU _` Z_YVcV_e gR]fV& Rd VgZUV_TVU Sj YZd ecR_dWVc `W R a`ceZ`_ `W eYV G`dV^`_e 7`_U d` eYRe 7fc_YR^ T`f]U ^RZ_eRZ_ Zed _Ve TRaZeR] cVbfZcV^V_ed( #8`^a]( mm 1+& 3+($ B`cV`gVc& eYV H:8 R]]VXVd eYRe HfXRc^R_ dVTcVe]j Wf_UVU L6E88sd Z_eVcVde aRj^V_e `_ eYV IcZSR] 7`_Ud e` W`cVdeR]] UZdT`gVcj `W eYV dTYV^V Sj Z_decfTeZ_X YZd Ree`c_Vj e` hZcV !,/*&*** e` L6E88( #8`^a]( mm ++*n++($ HfXRc^R_ RcXfVd eYRe YZd aRj^V_e hRd _`e UVTVaeZgV& R_U eYV 8`^a]RZ_e UVdTcZSVd `eYVc `TTRdZ`_d hYV_ HfXRc^R_ RccR_XVU `c RUgR_TVU Wf_Ud W`c YZd R_U YZd Rdd`TZReVds SfdZ_Vdd gV_efcVd( #HVV& V(X(& 8`^a]( mm +3& 30($ 7fe Re eYV ^`eZ`_ e` UZd^Zdd deRXV& eYV H:8 Zd `_]j cVbfZcVU e` pdeReV R T]RZ^ e` cV]ZVW eYRe Zd a]RfdZS]V `_ Zed WRTV(q >bSR]& //0 J(H( Re 012 #bf`eReZ`_ ^Rc¥d `^ZeeVU$( =VcV& Ze Zd a]RfdZS]V eYRe HfXRc^R_ ERS¥ 5X^[] KU¥X WX]O¥ ]RK] ]RO ][KW¥KM]SXW LOSWQ KYY[X_ON hSW K VOO]SWQ K]]OWNON Lb K] UOK¥] 6^WTO[UObi NXO¥ WX] ¥YOKT ]X D^QK[VKWk¥ X`W MXWN^M]' #5XVYU' e ,.'$ !" ,. hZcVU eYV ^`_Vj e` L6E88 e` pUVW]VTe dTcfeZ_j `W eYVZc dTYV^Vq SVTRfdV L6E88 hRd R WR¥V R__fZej ac`gZUVc dVe fa Sj <R]R_Zd& R_U <R]R_Zd hRd RccVdeVU Z_ R dVaRcReV ^ReeVc Re eYV eZ^V( #8`^a]( mm ++*n++($ IYZd Z_eVcVde aRj^V_e& hYZTY hRd R]]VXVU]j UVdZX_VU e` T`gVc'fa eYV dTYV^V& YV]ad VdeRS]ZdY HfXRc^R_sd RddZdeR_TV Z_ WRTZ]ZeReZ_X <R]R_Zdsd acZ^Rcj gZ`]ReZ`_d( IYVcVW`cV& eYV H:8 YRd a]VU R T]RZ^ W`c dVT`_URcj ]ZRSZ]Zej( 8DC8AJH>DC ;`c eYV W`cVX`Z_X cVRd`_d& HfXRc^R_sd ^`eZ`_ e` UZd^Zdd Zd UV_ZVU( IYV 8]Vc¥ `W 8`fce Zd UZcVTeVU e` eVc^Z_ReV eYV ^`eZ`_ aV_UZ_X Re :8; C`( -2( 9ReVU4 HVaeV^SVc -*& ,*,* CVh N`c¥& CVh N`c¥ ,/
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
