Thomas v. United States of America, No. 1:2019cv05675 - Document 7 (S.D.N.Y. 2020)
Court Description: OPINION & ORDER: For the foregoing reasons, the Court denies Thomas's Petition for a writ of error coram nobis. The Court declines to issue a certificate of appealability and certifies that any appeal from this order would not be taken in good faith; therefore, in forma pauperis status is denied for the purpose of an appeal. Coppedge v. United States, 369 U.S. 438, 445 (1962). The Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to terminate the motion pending at docket one and to close this case. The Clerk of Court is further instructed to mail a copy of this order to Thomas. (Signed by Judge Paul A. Engelmayer on 6/23/2020) (jwh) Transmission to Docket Assistant Clerk for processing.
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Thomas v. United States of America Doc. 7 IB=H98 GH5H9G 8=GHF=7H 7CIFH GCIH<9FB 8=GHF=7H C: B9K LCF? ?9BB9H< H<CA5G& DTcXcX^]Ta& 'e' *2'7J'./0. #D59$ )*'7F'.02 #D59$ CD=B=CB " CF89F IB=H98 GH5H9G C: 5A9F=75& FTb_^]ST]c( D5I@ 5( 9B;9@A5L9F& 8XbcaXRc >dSVT3 DTcXcX^]Ta ?T]]TcW HW^¥Pb& _a^RTTSX]V AB@ C7& bTTZb P faXc ^U Taa^a 5@B3> ?@4;C c^ ePRPcT WXb B^eT¥QTa *,& +))* VdX[ch _[TP c^ ^]T R^d]c ^U PRRTbb STeXRT UaPdS X] eX^[PcX^] ^U *1 I(G(7( jj *)+2#P$#+$ P]S +( HWT DTcXcX^] R[PX¥b cWPc HW^¥Pbqb VdX[ch _[TP bW^d[S QT ePRPcTS QTRPdbT WXb R^d]bT[ fPb X]TUUTRcXeT Qh& ;?D7B 3=;3& UPX[X]V c^ bdUUXRXT]c[h X]U^a¥ HW^¥Pb ^U cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb _[TP( :^a cWT U^[[^fX]V aTPb^]b& cWT 7^dac SXb¥XbbTb HW^¥Pbqb _TcXcX^]( )! %24<8A@D?5 HW^¥Pb Xb P RXcXiT] ^U cWT I]XcTS ?X]VS^¥ P]S WPb QTT] P [PfUd[ _Ta¥P]T]c aTbXST]c ^U cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb& WPeX]V [TVP[[h T]cTaTS cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb X] ^a PQ^dc *21+( 077 8Zc( / #nDTc( FT_[ho$ Pc *& ,( C] APh *0& +))*& HW^¥Pb fPb RWPaVTS Qh 7^¥_[PX]c fXcW QP]Z UaPdS& X] eX^[PcX^] ^U *1 I(G(7( jj *,-- P]S +( B^( )* 7a( .02& 8Zc( * #n7^¥_[(o$( HWT 7^¥_[PX]c P[[TVTS cWPc HW^¥Pb WPS STUaPdSTS 7WPbT AP]WPccP] 6P]Z #n7WPbTo$ Qh fXcWSaPfX]V P__a^gX¥PcT[h !*,&+.) Ua^¥ cWT PRR^d]cb ^U U^da PRR^d]cW^[STab fXcW^dc PdcW^aXiPcX^] P]S I][Tbb ^cWTafXbT X]SXRPcTS& P S^RZTc RXcPcX^] aTUTab c^ cWT S^RZTc ^U B^( *2 7Xe( ./0.& X] fWXRW HW^¥Pbqb 5@B3> ?@4;C _TcXcX^] fPb UX[TS( * Dockets.Justia.com caP]bUTaaX]V cW^bT Ud]Sb X]c^ DPhDP[ PRR^d]cb RaTPcTS d]STa ePaX^db ]P¥Tb X]R[dSX]V n?T]]TcW HW^¥Pb(o )6" Pc *l+( HW^¥Pb WPS QTT] T¥_[^hTS Pb P R^¥_dcTa R^]bd[cP]c Qh cWT bP¥T R^¥_P]h fWTaT cWT U^da PRR^d]cW^[STab f^aZTS( )6" Pc ,( 5c [TPbc ^]T RWTRZ& cWT 7^¥_[PX]c P[[TVTS& WPS QTT] SaPf] ^] cWTbT DPhDP[ PRR^d]cb& ¥PST _PhPQ[T c^ n?T]]TcW HW^¥Pb&o P]S ST_^bXcTS X]c^ P] PRR^d]c X] cWT ]P¥T ^U n?T]]TcW HW^¥Pbo Pc 7WPbT( )6" Pc +l,( =] bd__^ac ^U cWTbT RWPaVTb& cWT 7^¥_[PX]c P[[TVTS cWPc& ^] APh 1& +))*& P I]XcTS GcPcTb GTRaTc GTaeXRT PVT]c WPS TgP¥X]TS HW^¥Pbqb W^¥T R^¥_dcTa fXcW WXb R^]bT]c P]S U^d]S cWPc cWT =D PSSaTbb ^U HW^¥Pbqb R^¥_dcTa ¥PcRWTS cWT =D PSSaTbb dbTS c^ PRRTbb cWT DPhDP[ PRR^d]cb( )6" Pc ,( 5 fPaaP]cTS bTPaRW ^U HW^¥Pbqb W^¥T ^] APh 2& +))* aTeTP[TS bTeTaP[ RWTRZb cWPc WPS QTT] _aX]cTS Qh P R^¥_dcTa& P__TPaTS R^d]cTaUTXc& P]S WPS QTT] SaPf] ^] cWT QP]Z PRR^d]cb ^U cWT U^da T¥_[^hTTb( )6" 9PRW T¥_[^hTTqb PRR^d]c WPS QTT] STQXcTS PUcTa P RWTRZ ¥PST _PhPQ[T c^ HW^¥Pb WPS QTT] _aTbT]cTS P]S ST_^bXcTS Pc 7WPbT( )6" B^]T ^U cWT RWTRZb WPS QTT] faXccT] ^a PdcW^aXiTS Qh cWT T¥_[^hTTb( )6" 5 [PcTa bTPaRW ^U HW^¥Pbqb U^a¥Ta R^¥_P]h ^] APh */& +))*& aTeTP[TS cWPc b^¥T^]T WPS Qa^ZT] X]c^ cWT R^¥_P]hqb _Tab^]]T[ UX[Tb& fWXRW R^]cPX]TS b^RXP[ bTRdaXch ]d¥QTab P]S QP]Z PRR^d]c X]U^a¥PcX^] ^U T¥_[^hTTb( )6" Pc -( C] >d]T *.& +))*& HW^¥Pb fPb X]SXRcTS ^] cWaTT RWPaVTb3 #*$ QP]Z UaPdS& #+$ fXaT UaPdS X] eX^[PcX^] ^U *1 I(G(7( jj *,-, P]S +& P]S #,$ UaPdS X] R^]]TRcX^] fXcW P] d]PdcW^aXiTS PRRTbb STeXRT& X] eX^[PcX^] ^U *1 I(G(7( jj *)+2#P$#+$ P]S +( B^( )* 7a( .02& 8Zc( 1( 5b c^ cWXb [PccTa RWPaVT& cWT =]SXRc¥T]c P[[TVTS cWPc HW^¥Pb WPS UaPdSd[T]c[h dbTS cWT QP]Z PRR^d]c P]S a^dcX]V ]d¥QTab ^U PRR^d]cW^[STab c^ caP]bUTa Ud]Sb& fXcW^dc PdcW^aXiPcX^]& Ua^¥ cW^bT PRR^d]cb c^ DPhDP[ PRR^d]cb d]STa WXb R^]ca^[( )6" k ,( C] B^eT¥QTa *,& +))*& HW^¥Pb _[TS VdX[ch QTU^aT cWT <^]( AXRWPT[ 6( AdZPbTh& _dabdP]c c^ P _[TP PVaTT¥T]c& c^ 7^d]c HWaTT& RWPaVX]V PRRTbb STeXRT UaPdS( 077 B^( )* 7a( .02& + 8Zc( *0 #nD[TP Ha(o$ Pc +& *.( 5c cWT _[TP WTPaX]V& HW^¥Pb bcPcTS& d]STa ^PcW& cWPc WT WPS SXbRdbbTS cWT RPbT P]S _^cT]cXP[ STUT]bTb fXcW WXb R^d]bT[ P]S fPb bPcXbUXTS fXcW WXb R^d]bT[qb aT_aTbT]cPcX^]4 cWPc ]TXcWTa WT ]^a P]h^]T T[bT WPS QTT] cWaTPcT]TS X] R^]]TRcX^] fXcW cWT _[TP4 P]S cWPc WT WPS ]^c QTT] U^aRTS c^ _[TPS VdX[ch( )6" Pc -l.& *)l**( HWT ;^eTa]¥T]c _a^UUTaTS TeXST]RT TbcPQ[XbWX]V cWT ^UUT]bT& X]R[dSX]V TeXST]RT U^d]S ^] HW^¥Pbqb R^¥_dcTa& bcPcT¥T]cb Ua^¥ fXc]TbbTb& P]S X]Rd[_Pc^ah bcPcT¥T]cb Qh HW^¥Pb( 077 ;6" Pc *,l*-( HWT TeXST]RT& cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c bcPcTS& bW^fTS cWPc HW^¥Pb WPS dbTS WXb R^¥_dcTa c^ ^_T] DPhDP[ PRR^d]cb& fWXRWlldbX]V PRR^d]c P]S a^dcX]V X]U^a¥PcX^] ^U ^cWTab fXcW^dc cWTXa _Ta¥XbbX^]llWT WPS dbTS c^ ^QcPX] P__a^gX¥PcT[h !*,&))) QT[^]VX]V c^ cWT PRR^d]cW^[STab QTcfTT] 5_aX[ P]S APh +))*( 077 ;6" C] :TQadPah *.& +))+& >dSVT AdZPbTh bT]cT]RTS HW^¥Pb c^ P cTa¥ ^U ,/ ¥^]cWbq _a^QPcX^]& bdQYTRc c^ b_TRXP[ R^]SXcX^]b cWPc WT bTaeT bXg ¥^]cWb X] W^¥T R^]UX]T¥T]c P]S _Ph !*+&))) X] aTbcXcdcX^]( B^( )* 7a( .02& 8Zc( +) #nGT]cT]RX]V Ha(o$ Pc -( C] cWT ;^eTa]¥T]cqb ¥^cX^]& >dSVT AdZPbTh SXb¥XbbTS cWT aT¥PX]X]V R^d]cb( 077 ;6" Pc .( HW^¥Pb SXS ]^c UX[T P] P__TP[( 077 8Zc( * #nDTc(o$ Pc ,( I]cX[ CRc^QTa *,& +)).& HW^¥Pb _PXS ¥^]Th c^fPaSb aTbcXcdcX^]( 077 B^( )* 7a( .02& 8Zc( +. #n;^e( C__(o$ Pc +( C] B^eT¥QTa +*& +)*1& HW^¥Pb PaaXeTS Pc >^W] :( ?T]]TSh =]cTa]PcX^]P[ 5Xa_^ac X] BTf L^aZ Ua^¥ P caX_ PQa^PS P]S fPb P__aTWT]STS Qh X¥¥XVaPcX^] ^UUXRXP[b& PUcTa Rdbc^¥b ^UUXRXP[b WPS P[TacTS c^ WXb +))* R^]eXRcX^]( 077 DTc( FT_[h Pc *l+4 ;^e( C__( Pc +l,( HW^¥Pb fPb X]bcadRcTS c^ P__TPa fXcW S^Rd¥T]cPcX^] U^a X]b_TRcX^] Pc P [PcTa SPcT( 077 ;6" C] APh 0& +)*2& HW^¥Pb aTcda]TS P]S fPb bTaeTS P ]^cXRT c^ P__TPa U^a eX^[PcX^] ^U 1 I(G(7( j **1+#P$#+$#5$#X$#=$( 077 DTc( FT_[h Pc +4 ;^e( C__( Pc ,( HW^¥Pb fPb STcPX]TS _T]SX]V WXb aT¥^eP[ _a^RTTSX]V& , _dabdP]c c^ 1 I(G(7( j *++/#R$( )6" <T Xb RdaaT]c[h STcPX]TS Pc cWT <dSb^] 7^d]ch 7^aaTRcX^]P[ :PRX[Xch X] ?TPa]h& BTf >TabTh(! DTc( FT_[h Pc +( C] >d]T *0& +)*2& HW^¥Pb UX[TS cWT X]bcP]c DTcXcX^]& PaVdX]V cWPc WT Xb T]cXc[TS c^ WPeT WXb R^]eXRcX^] ePRPcTS QTRPdbT3 #*$ ]TXcWTa WXb Pcc^a]Th& cWT 5IG5& ]^a >dSVT AdZPbTh PSeXbTS WX¥ ^U cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb VdX[ch _[TP4 #+$ WXb Pcc^a]Th SXS ]^c PSeXbT WX¥ ^U cWT TeXST]RT PVPX]bc WX¥ ^a WXb STUT]bTb4 P]S #,$ cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c WPS cWaTPcT]TS WX¥ P]S WXb UP¥X[h b^¥TcX¥T QTU^aT WXb _[TP( 077 DTc( Pc .( C] >d]T +.& +)*2& cWT 7^dac R^]bcadTS cWT DTcXcX^] Pb P faXc ^U Taa^a 5@B3> ?@4;C P]S ^aSTaTS cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c c^ aTb_^]S( 8Zc( ,( C] 5dVdbc ++& +)*2& cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c UX[TS P ¥T¥^aP]Sd¥ ^U [Pf X] ^__^bXcX^]( ;^e( C__( C] GT_cT¥QTa *2& +)*2& HW^¥Pb UX[TS P aT_[h( DTc( FT_[h( ))! ':B4DBB:@? 5 faXc ^U Taa^a 5@B3> ?@4;C bW^d[S XbbdT ^][h fWTaT nTgcaP^aSX]Pah RXaRd¥bcP]RTb PaT _aTbT]c(o '@@?D F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& 2, :(,S 0/& 01 #+S 7Xa( *22/$ #`d^cX]V -;5<C F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& 2.. :(+S */*& */0 #+S 7Xa( *22+$$( HWT faXc Xb P naT¥TSh ^U [Pbc aTb^ac& bcaXRc[h [X¥XcTS c^ cW^bT RPbTb X] fWXRW Taa^ab ( ( ( ^U cWT ¥^bc Ud]SP¥T]cP[ RWPaPRcTa WPeT aT]STaTS cWT _a^RTTSX]V XcbT[U XaaTVd[Pa P]S X]eP[XS(o 1?;D76 0D3D7C F" /ED;9=;3?@& 110 :(,S 21& *)1 #+S 7Xa( +)*1$ #X]cTa]P[ 9eT] cW^dVW HW^¥Pb Xb QTX]V WT[S _aTbT]c[h X] BTf >TabTh& eT]dT Xb _a^_Ta X] cWXb 8XbcaXRc QTRPdbT Xc Xb cWT bXcT ^U HW^¥Pbqb RWP[[T]VTS _[TPllfWTaT ncWT P[[TVTS Taa^ab ^RRdaaTS(o ,ECD3;? F" .73BC@?& .2+ :(+S *)*1& *)+* #1cW 7Xa( *202$ #nM5N faXc M^U 5@B3> ?@4;CN RP] QT UX[TS ^][h X] cWT R^dac fWTaT cWT P[[TVTS Taa^ab ^RRdaaTS(o$4 58" 1?;D76 0D3D7C F" ,@B93?& ,-/ I(G( .)+& .*+ #*2.-$ #_TcXcX^] U^a faXc ^U 5@B3> ?@4;C R^]RTa]X]V fWTcWTa STUT]SP]c _a^_Ta[h fPXeTS WXb aXVWc c^ R^d]bT[ U^a P caXP[ ¥dbc QT WTPaS Qh caXP[ R^dac$4 1?;D76 0D3D7C F" 03?6=7C& -/2 :(,S .)1& .*0 #/cW 7Xa( +))/$ #caP]bUTaaX]V _TcXcX^] U^a faXc ^U 5@B3> ?@4;C c^ R^dac X] fWXRW STUT]SP]c fPb UXabc R^]eXRcTS& fWTaT ncWT P[[TVTS Taa^ab ^RRdaaTSo$4 1?;D76 0D3D7C 7H B7= +3F7==7 F" '3I& +). :(+S +2-& +2. #+S 7Xa( *2.,$ #_TcXcX^] U^a faXc ^U 5@B3> ?@4;C RWP[[T]VX]V R^]eXRcX^] ¥dbc QT WTPaS nQTU^aT cWT bT]cT]RX]V R^dac X] cWT SXbcaXRc fWTaT cWT aTR^aSb P]S V^eTa]¥T]c ^UUXRXP[b X]e^[eTS PaT [^RPcTSo$4 $@I?D@? F" (;5<C& B^( )+ 7Xe( *-,2 #87$& +)), K@ ++)10/,-& Pc %, #G(8(B(L( GT_c( 2& +)),$ #nMHNWT _a^_Ta eT]dT U^a P R^aP¥ ]^QXb aTeXTf ^U X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U P__T[[PcT R^d]bT[ R[PX¥b ( ( ( Xb X] cWT P__T[[PcT caXQd]P[ fWTaT cWT P[[TVTS[h STUXRXT]c aT_aTbT]cPcX^] ^RRdaaTS(o #X]cTa]P[ `d^cPcX^] ¥PaZb& RXcPcX^]& P]S T¥_WPbXb ^¥XccTS$$( ! - `d^cPcX^] ¥PaZb P]S RXcPcX^]b ^¥XccTS$( H^ bTRdaT 5@B3> ?@4;C aT[XTU& nP _TcXcX^]Ta ¥dbc bW^f cWPc #*$ pcWTaT PaT RXaRd¥bcP]RTb R^¥_T[[X]V bdRW PRcX^] c^ PRWXTeT YdbcXRT&q #+$ pb^d]S aTPb^]b TgXbc U^a UPX[daT c^ bTTZ P__a^_aXPcT TPa[XTa aT[XTU&q P]S #,$ pcWT _TcXcX^]Ta R^]cX]dTb c^ bdUUTa [TVP[ R^]bT`dT]RTb Ua^¥ WXb R^]eXRcX^] cWPc ¥Ph QT aT¥TSXTS Qh VaP]cX]V ^U cWT faXc(qo )6" #`d^cX]V '@@?D& 2, :(,S Pc 02$( HW^¥Pb bPcXbUXTb cWT cWXaS _a^]V ^U cWT '@@?D cTbc3 HWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb U^a HW^¥Pb bcT¥¥X]V Ua^¥ WXb +))* R^]eXRcX^] R^]bcXcdcT R^]cX]dX]V [TVP[ R^]bT`dT]RTb Ua^¥ cWPc R^]eXRcX^]( 077 *@F35C F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& 0-- :(,S --& -2 #+S 7Xa( +)*-$( HW^¥Pb& W^fTeTa& RP]]^c bPcXbUh cWT UXabc ^a cWT bTR^]S _a^]Vb( 5b c^ cWT UXabc& P _TcXcX^]Ta RP] bPcXbUh cWXb Qh bW^fX]V WT aTRTXeTS X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U R^d]bT[ X] WXb d]STa[hX]V RaX¥X]P[ RPbT( 077 ;6(4 C77 3=C@ &@7 F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& 2*. :(,S 2).& 2*) #+S 7Xa( +)*2$ #n=]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U R^d]bT[& X]R[dSX]V SdaX]V cWT _[TP'QPaVPX]X]V _a^RTbb& Xb P RXaRd¥bcP]RT R^¥_T[[X]V cWT VaP]c ^U P cX¥T[h P__[XRPcX^] U^a 5@B3> ?@4;C aT[XTU(o$( 6dc fWT] P _TcXcX^] QPbTS ^] P R[PX¥ ^U X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT UPX[b& cWT faXc RP]]^c QT VaP]cTS( 077 0:3G F" #BDEJ& B^( 22 7Xe( 20.#F@9$& +))* K@ *,)*0,.& %1 #G(8(B(L( CRc( *2& +))*$ #W^[SX]V bcPcT R^dacqb ST]XP[ ^U faXc ^U 5@B3> ?@4;C _a^_Ta& VXeT] _TcXcX^]Taqb UPX[daT c^ bW^f X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT$( :^a cWT aTPb^]b cWPc U^[[^f& bdRW Xb cWT RPbT WTaT& X] cWPc HW^¥Pbqb _aX]RX_P[ QPbXb U^a R[PX¥X]V X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U R^d]bT[llWXb R^d]bT[qb PbbTacTS UPX[daT c^ ]^cXUh WX¥ ^U cWT _^cT]cXP[ X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb _[TPllUPX[b c^ ¥PZT ^dc P R[PX¥ ^U X]TUUTRcXeT]Tbb( 5]S c^ cWT TgcT]c cWPc HW^¥Pb ]^f aPXbTb ^cWTa RWP[[T]VTb c^ WXb VdX[ch _[TP& WT UPX[b c^ YdbcXUh WXb _a^caPRcTS ST[Ph X] S^X]V b^( $! )?67764C:E6 $BB:BC2?46 @7 &@D?B6= %2B65 @? *24< @7 )>>:8A2C:@? (D:52?46 HWT DTcXcX^] _aX¥PaX[h PaVdTb cWPc HW^¥Pb aTRTXeTS X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U R^d]bT[ d]STa cWT GXgcW 5¥T]S¥T]c QTRPdbT WXb R^d]bT[ ^bcT]bXQ[h SXS ]^c X]U^a¥ WX¥ ^U cWT _^cT]cXP[ . X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb _[TP& RPdbX]V WX¥ c^ PRRT_c P] d]UPXa _[TP STP[(" DTc( Pc .( <T R[PX¥b cWPc WT f^d[S WPeT V^]T c^ caXP[ XU WT WPS QTT] X]U^a¥TS ^U bdRW R^]bT`dT]RTb( 077 DTc( FT_[h Pc .( 5 R^dac P]P[hiTb P R[PX¥ ^U X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U R^d]bT[ d]STa cWT cf^'_a^]VTS cTbc bTc U^acW X] 0DB;5<=3?6 F" 23C:;?9D@?& -// I(G( //1 #*21-$& d]STa fWXRW P ¥^eP]c ¥dbc bW^f cWPc #*$ WXb R^d]bT[qb _TaU^a¥P]RT fPb STUXRXT]c X] cWPc Xc UT[[ QT[^f P] ^QYTRcXeT bcP]SPaS ^U aTPb^]PQ[T]Tbb P]S #+$ cWT STUXRXT]c _TaU^a¥P]RT _aTYdSXRTS cWT STUT]bT( &@7& 2*. :(,S Pc 2*)( HW^¥Pb RP]]^c TbcPQ[XbW TXcWTa( "! ,3;64C:E6 /C2?52A5 @7 .62B@?23=6?6BB HW^¥Pbqb R^d]bT[qb _TaU^a¥P]RT fPb ]^c STUXRXT]c U^a UPX[daT c^ ]^cXUh HW^¥Pb ^U cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb VdX[ch _[TP& QTRPdbT Pc cWT cX¥T& R^d]bT[ SXS ]^c WPeT P [TVP[ ^Q[XVPcX^] c^ S^ b^( B^c [^]V PUcTa HW^¥Pbqb _[TP& cWT GTR^]S 7XaRdXc WT[S& R^]bXbcT]c fXcW cWT [Pf Pc cWT cX¥T& cWPc nP] Pcc^a]Thqb UPX[daT c^ X]U^a¥ P R[XT]c ^U cWT ST_^acPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U P VdX[ch _[TP& fXcW^dc ¥^aT& S^Tb ]^c UP[[ QT[^f P] ^QYTRcXeT bcP]SPaS ^U aTPb^]PQ[T]Tbb(o 1?;D76 0D3D7C F" %E@D@& ,** :(,S *02& *10 #+))+$( H^ QT bdaT& TXVWc hTPab [PcTa& cWT Gd_aT¥T 7^dac WT[S c^ cWT R^]caPah X] .36;==3 F" *7?DE5<I& ..2 I(G( ,./ #+)*)$( 6dc cWT 7^dac WPb P[b^ WT[S cWPc n.36;==3 S^Tb ]^c WPeT P aTca^PRcXeT TUUTRc(o %:3;67J F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& ./1 I(G( ,-+& ,-- #+)*,$( 6TRPdbT d]STa cWT [Pf Pc cWT cX¥T ^U cWT _[TP& HW^¥Pbqb R^d]bT[ fPb ]^c d]STa P [TVP[ ^Q[XVPcX^] c^ X]U^a¥ WXb R[XT]c ^U cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb& WXb #P[[TVTS$ UPX[daT c^ S^ b^ SXS ]^c ¥PZT WXb aT_aTbT]cPcX^] X]TUUTRcXeT P]S WT]RT S^Tb ]^c _a^eXST P QPbXb U^a 5@B3> ?@4;C aT[XTU( HW^¥Pb ¥PZTb cf^ ^cWTa R[PX¥b3 cWPc WXb Pcc^a]Th SXS ]^c aTeXTf cWT TeXST]RT P]S WXb STUT]bTb fXcW WX¥ P]S cWPc cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c cWaTPcT]TS WXb UP¥X[h( HWTbT R[PX¥b PaT TPRW SdQX^db X]b^UPa Pb TPRW Xb X]R^]bXbcT]c fXcW HW^¥Pbqb _[TP P[[^RdcX^]( 077 D[TP Ha( Pc -l.& *)l**( BTeTacWT[Tbb& QTRPdbT cWT 7^dac SXb_^bTb ^U cWTbT R[PX¥b ^] cWT Va^d]Sb cWPc HW^¥Pb d]aTPb^]PQ[h ST[PhTS X] QaX]VX]V cWT¥& C77 ;?8B3 __( *)l*+& Xc WPb ]^ ^RRPbX^] c^ aTb^[eT cWTbT R[PX¥b ^] cWT ¥TaXcb( " / HW^¥Pbqb R^d]bT[ SXS& cW^dVW& WPeT P Sdch ]^c c^ ¥PZT PUUXa¥PcXeT ¥XbaT_aTbT]cPcX^]b c^ HW^¥Pb aTVPaSX]V cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U P VdX[ch _[TP( %E@D@& ,** :(,S Pc *11 #W^[SX]V cWPc P] nPUUXa¥PcXeT ¥XbaT_aTbT]cPcX^] Qh R^d]bT[ Pb c^ cWT ST_^acPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U P VdX[ch _[TP Xb ( ( ( ^QYTRcXeT[h d]aTPb^]PQ[To$4 C77 3=C@ &@7& 2*. :(,S Pc 2*)l** #UX]SX]V R^d]bT[ PRcTS d]aTPb^]PQ[h fWTaT R^d]bT[& X] aTb_^]bT c^ `dTbcX^]& fa^]V[h PSeXbTS WXb R[XT]c cWPc WT nbW^d[S ]^c WPeT P _a^Q[T¥ fXcW cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] PdcW^aXcXTb P]S bW^d[S ]^c UPRT ST_^acPcX^]o P]S fWTaT R^d]bT[ R^]RTSTS ¥XbX]U^a¥X]V R[XT]c PQ^dc ¥P]SPc^ah ST_^acPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb$( 6dc HW^¥Pb S^Tb ]^c R[PX¥& P]S cWT aTR^aS S^Tb ]^c bdVVTbc& cWPc PUUXa¥PcXeT ¥XbaT_aTbT]cPcX^]b fTaT ¥PST X] cWXb RPbT( FPcWTa& cWT DTcXcX^] aT_TPcTS[h UPd[cb HW^¥Pbqb caXP[ R^d]bT[ U^a ]^c PSeXbX]V WX¥ PQ^dc cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb _[TP( 077 DTc( Pc .& *,4 C77 3=C@ DTc( FT_[h Pc . #PaVdX]V R^d]bT[ nWPS P aTb_^]bXQX[Xch c^ SXbRdbb cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb fXcW HW^¥Pbo$( HWT DTcXcX^] cWTaTU^aT UPX[b c^ P[[TVT ^QYTRcXeT[h d]aTPb^]PQ[T QTWPeX^a Qh R^d]bT[( #! -A6;D5:46 H^ bPcXbUh 0DB;5<=3?6qb bTR^]S& n_aTYdSXRT&o _a^]V& HW^¥Pb ¥dbc bW^f cWPc #*$ nWT _[PRTS _PacXRd[Pa T¥_WPbXb ^] X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb X] STRXSX]V fWTcWTa ^a ]^c c^ _[TPS VdX[ch&o P]S #+$ nQdc U^a R^d]bT[qb d]_a^UTbbX^]P[ Taa^ab& cWTaT fPb P aTPb^]PQ[T _a^QPQX[Xch cWPc MWTN R^d[S WPeT ]TV^cXPcTS P _[TP cWPc SXS ]^c X¥_PRc X¥¥XVaPcX^] bcPcdb ^a cWPc WT f^d[S WPeT [XcXVPcTS P] PePX[PQ[T STUT]bT(o 077 &@7& 2*. :(,S Pc 2** #QaPRZTcb P]S RXcPcX^]b ^¥XccTS$( HW^¥Pb WPb ]^c ST¥^]bcaPcTS TXcWTa ^U cWTbT( :Xabc& P[cW^dVW HW^¥Pb ]^f R[PX¥b cWPc WT f^d[S ]^c WPeT _[TS VdX[ch P]S X]bcTPS f^d[S WPeT ncPZTM]N WXb RWP]RTb Qh V^X]V c^ caXP[&o DTc( FT_[h Pc .& bdRW nA@CD :@5 PbbTacX^]b Ua^¥ P STUT]SP]c PQ^dc W^f WT f^d[S WPeT _[TPSTS Qdc U^a WXb Pcc^a]Thqb STUXRXT]RXTbo PaT X]bdUUXRXT]c c^ bPcXbUh cWXb aT`dXaT¥T]c& +77 F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& *,0 G( 7c( *2.1& *2/0 #+)*0$( 5 R^dac X]bcTPS 0 ¥dbc n[^^Z c^ R^]cT¥_^aP]T^db TeXST]RT c^ bdQbcP]cXPcT P STUT]SP]cqb Tg_aTbbTS _aTUTaT]RTb(o )6" :^a TgP¥_[T& P _TcXcX^]Ta ¥Ph _^X]c c^ TeXST]RT cWPc WT PbZTS PQ^dc bdRW R^]bT`dT]RTb QTU^aT _[TPSX]V VdX[ch( =] +77& U^a X]bcP]RT& cWT Gd_aT¥T 7^dac U^d]S cWPc bdRW R^]bT`dT]RTb WPS QTT] P nSTcTa¥X]PcXeT XbbdTo X] cWT STRXbX^] c^ _[TP QTRPdbT cWT _TcXcX^]Ta WPS nPbZTS WXb Pcc^a]Th aT_TPcTS[h fWTcWTa cWTaT fPb P]h aXbZ ^U ST_^acPcX^]&o Q^cW _TcXcX^]Ta P]S WXb R^d]bT[ cTbcXUXTS cWPc WT f^d[S WPeT V^]T c^ caXP[ WPS WT Z]^f] ^U cWT aXbZ ^U ST_^acPcX^]& P]S _TcXcX^]Ta ^][h _[TS PUcTa WXb R^d]bT[ PbbdaTS WX¥ cWPc cWT YdSVTqb fPa]X]V PQ^dc X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb fPb P nbcP]SPaS fPa]X]V(o# )6" Pc *2/0l/14 C77 3=C@ &@7& 2*. :(,S Pc 2**l*+ #]^cX]V ¥d[cX_[T X]bcP]RTb X] fWXRW _TcXcX^]Ta WPS PbZTS PQ^dc WXb X¥¥XVaPcX^] bXcdPcX^] _aX^a c^ _[TP$4 2:ID7 F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& B^b( )1 7a( *,,)& *- 7Xe( ,.21 #J97$& +)*. K@ -//)2)-& Pc %0 #G(8(B(L( 5dV( /& +)*.$ #_TcXcX^]Ta WPS naT_TPcTS[h PbZTS WXb Pcc^a]Th fWTcWTa cWT _[TP f^d[S PUUTRc WXb X¥¥XVaPcX^] bcPcdbo #X]cTa]P[ `d^cPcX^] ¥PaZb P]S RXcPcX^] ^¥XccTS$$( HW^¥Pb& X] R^]caPbc& S^Tb ]^c R[PX¥ cWPc WT TeTa PbZTS WXb R^d]bT[ PQ^dc cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U P VdX[ch _[TP& ^a TeXST]RTS R^]RTa] PQ^dc cWXb bdQYTRc X] P]h ^cWTa UPbWX^] Pc cWT cX¥T( =] UX]SX]V cWPc cWT _TcXcX^]Ta _[PRTS T¥_WPbXb ^] cWT [PRZ ^U X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb& cWT Gd_aT¥T 7^dac X] +77 ]^cTS& Pb R^aa^Q^aPcXeT TeXST]RT& @TTqb STT_ cXTb c^ cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb3 @TT fPb P [PfUd[ _Ta¥P]T]c aTbXST]c fW^ WPS [XeTS X] cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb U^a cWaTT STRPSTb& WPS cf^ QdbX]TbbTb WTaT& P]S fPb cWT ^][h UP¥X[h ¥T¥QTa fW^ R^d[S RPaT U^a WXb T[STa[h _PaT]cb [XeX]V WTaT( *,0 G( 7c( Pc *2/1( @TT WPS ¥^eTS c^ cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb Ua^¥ G^dcW ?^aTP Pc cWT PVT ^U *, P]S WPS ]TeTa aTcda]TS( 077 ;6" Pc *2/+l/,& *2/1( HW^¥Pb RP] P[b^ PbbTac b^¥T bca^]V cXTb c^ cWXb R^d]cah3 <T bcPcTb cWPc& P[cW^dVW Q^a] X] cWT I]XcTS ?X]VS^¥& WT WPb ]^ cXTb cWTaT4 WT T]cTaTS cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb Pb P [PfUd[ _Ta¥P]T]c aTbXST]c Pa^d]S *21+4 P]S WXb UP¥X[h [XeTb WTaT( 077 DTc( FT_[h Pc *& ,( 6dc fXcW^dc P]h TeXST]RT cWPc WT _[PRTS T¥_WPbXb ^] X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb Pc cWT cX¥T ^U cWT _[TP& HW^¥Pbqb I(G( cXTb PaT X]bdUUXRXT]c c^ RPaah WXb QdaST]( 077! 7"9"& /@6B;9E7J F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& 0,) :( 5__qg ,2& -,l-- #+S 7Xa( +)*1$ #]^cX]V cWPc& X] PSSXcX^] c^ _TcXcX^]Taqb R^]]TRcX^]b c^ cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb& R^d]bT[ WPS VXeT] WX¥ nTPa[h P]S R^]cX]dTS PbbdaP]RTb cWPc cWTaT fTaT ?@ X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb c^ f^aah PQ^dc&o P]S WPS aT_TPcTS[h T¥_WPbXiTS Pc cWT _[TP _a^RTTSX]V cWPc _TcXcX^]Taqb nb^[T R^]RTa]o fPb c^ T]bdaT cWPc bWT fPb PQ[T c^ R^]cX]dT c^ f^aZ X] cWT I]XcTS GcPcTb P]S bd__^ac WTa UP¥X[h #T¥_WPbXb X] ^aXVX]P[$$( # 1 HWT caP]bRaX_c ^U HW^¥Pbqb _[TP Xb bX¥X[Pa[h STe^XS ^U P]h X]SXRPcX^] ^U R^]RTa] U^a bdRW R^]bT`dT]RTb( 5]S cWT DaTbT]cT]RT =]eTbcXVPcX^] FT_^ac #nDGFo$ X]R[dSTS P b_TRXP[ R^]SXcX^] aT`dXaX]V HW^¥Pb c^ nR^¥_[h fXcW cWT SXaTRcXeTb ^U cWT =¥¥XVaPcX^] P]S BPcdaP[XiPcX^] GTaeXRT P]S cWT =¥¥XVaPcX^] @Pfb&o VXeT] nHW^¥Pbqb pX¥¥XVaPcX^] bcPcdb X] cWT I]XcTS GcPcTbq P]S cWT _^bbXQX[Xch ^U p_a^RTTSX]Vb aT[PcXeT c^ WXb bcPcdb(qo ;^e( AT¥( Pc 0 #`d^cX]V DGF$( HWTaT Xb ]^ X]SXRPcX^] cWPc HW^¥Pb P[TacTS c^ cWTbT _a^eXbX^]b ^a aPXbTS R^]RTa]b Pc cWT cX¥T ^U bT]cT]RX]V PQ^dc _^cT]cXP[ X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb( GTR^]S& cWT 7^dac RP]]^c UX]S P aTPb^]PQ[T _a^QPQX[Xch cWPc& WPS HW^¥Pbqb Pcc^a]Th PUUXa¥PcXeT[h P[TacTS WX¥ c^ _^cT]cXP[ X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U P VdX[ch _[TP& WT f^d[S WPeT ^QcPX]TS P] ^dcR^¥T [PRZX]V cW^bT R^]bT`dT]RTb( HWTaT Xb ]^ QPbXb c^ R^]YTRcdaT cWPc HW^¥Pb R^d[S WPeT ]TV^cXPcTS P VdX[ch _[TP STe^XS ^U _^cT]cXP[ PSeTabT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb( 5]S cWT VdX[ch _[TP WTaT VPeT HW^¥Pb P [PaVT QT]TUXc( 5QbT]c RaTSXc U^a PRRT_cX]V aTb_^]bXQX[Xch& HW^¥Pb UPRTS P cWT]'¥P]SPc^ah GT]cT]RX]V ;dXST[X]T aP]VT ^U *)l*/ ¥^]cWbq X¥_aXb^]¥T]c& fXcW ]^ ^__^acd]Xch U^a _a^QPcX^]( ;^e( AT¥( Pc 0( KXcW bdRW RaTSXc& W^fTeTa& HW^¥Pb QTRP¥T T[XVXQ[T U^allP]S aTRTXeTSllP ]^]'Rdbc^SXP[ bT]cT]RT( 077 GT]cT]RX]V Ha( Pc -( =] [XVWc ^U cWXb _P[_PQ[T QT]TUXc& Xc Xb ]^c RaTSXQ[T c^ R[PX¥ cWPc cWT nb^[T aTPb^]o U^a HW^¥Pbqb VdX[ch _[TP fPb R^d]bT[qb ¥XbcPZT] QT[XTU cWPc cWT _[TP f^d[S ]^c RPaah PSeTabT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb( 077 *@F35C& 0-- :(,S Pc ., #UX]SX]V _TcXcX^]Ta R^d[S WPeT ]TV^cXPcTS P[cTa]PcXeT _[TP fWTaT ^][h aTPb^] U^a _[TP fPb SXb_T[[X]V X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb$( HWTaT Xb TeTah aTPb^] c^ QT[XTeT& X]bcTPS& cWPc cWT _a^b_TRc ^U Pe^XSX]V X]RPaRTaPcX^] fPb P _aX]RX_P[ SaXeTa ^U HW^¥Pbq STRXbX^] c^ _[TPS VdX[ch( =] bW^ac& HW^¥Pb WPb T[XRXcTS n]^ TeXST]RT fWPcb^TeTam^cWTa cWP] b_TRd[PcX^]m cWPc bdRW P STP[ f^d[S WPeT QTT] PePX[PQ[T c^ WX¥(o 03?D3?3 F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& B^( *+ 7Xe( +*.) 2 #>GF$ #;K;$& +)*, K@ 0*0+1-& Pc %- #G(8(B(L( :TQ( +1& +)*,$& B7A@BD 3?6 B75@>>7?63D;@? 36@AD76& +)*, K@ *-22-)/ #G(8(B(L( 5_a( **& +)*,$( GT_PaPcT[h& HW^¥Pb WPb P[b^ UPX[TS c^ bW^f P aTPb^]PQ[T _a^QPQX[Xch cWPc WT WPS P STUT]bT PePX[PQ[T Pc caXP[( nM5N STUT]SP]c UPRX]V bdRW [^]V ^SSb fX[[ aPaT[h QT PQ[T c^ bW^f _aTYdSXRT Ua^¥ PRRT_cX]V P VdX[ch _[TP cWPc ^UUTab WX¥ P QTccTa aTb^[dcX^] cWP] f^d[S QT [XZT[h PUcTa caXP[(o +77& *,0 G( 7c( Pc *2//( <TaT& Pb aTRXcTS X] cWT 7^¥_[PX]c P]S _a^UUTaTS Pc cWT cX¥T ^U cWT _[TP& cWT ;^eTa]¥T]cqb TeXST]RT PVPX]bc HW^¥Pb fPb _^cT]c P]S ePaXTS( =c X]R[dSTS TeXST]RT V[TP]TS Ua^¥ HW^¥Pbqb R^¥_dcTa& TeXST]RT cWPc cWT =D PSSaTbb ^U cWPc R^¥_dcTa ¥PcRWTS cWT =D PSSaTbb dbTS c^ RaTPcT cWT UaPdSd[T]c PRR^d]cb& TeXST]RT ^QcPX]TS Ua^¥ HW^¥Pbqb U^a¥Ta T¥_[^hTa& fXc]Tbb bcPcT¥T]cb& P]S PS¥XbbX^]b Qh HW^¥Pb WX¥bT[U( 077 D[TP Ha( Pc *,l*-4 7^¥_[( Pc +l-( 5]S cWT DTcXcX^] S^Tb ]^c P[[TVT cWPc HW^¥Pb WPS P ]^]'UaXe^[^db STUT]bT PePX[PQ[T Pc caXP[( DTcXcX^]Tab X] bdRW RXaRd¥bcP]RTb& fW^ WPeT n]^ _[PdbXQ[T RWP]RT ^U PR`dXccP[ Pc caXP[o P]S cP]VXQ[T QT]TUXcb Ua^¥ _[TPSX]V VdX[ch& PaT UPXa[h nWXVW[h [XZT[h ( ( ( Mc^N PRRT_c MbdRWN P _[TP XU cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c ^UUTab ^]T(o +77& *,0 G( 7c( Pc *2//( HWT 7^dac cWTaTU^aT UX]Sb cWPc HW^¥Pb WPb ]^c ST¥^]bcaPcTS X]TUUTRcXeT PbbXbcP]RT ^U R^d]bT[ Pb c^ cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb _[TP( %! 09@>2BGB '6=2F :? -DABD:?8 ,C96A &=2:>B 5_Pac Ua^¥ HW^¥Pbqb R[PX¥ cWPc WXb R^d]bT[ UPX[TS c^ ]^cXUh WX¥ ^U cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb VdX[ch _[TP& fWXRW cWT 7^dac Pbbd¥Tb 3B9E7?6@ fPb cX¥T[h ¥PST&$ cWT HWT DTcXcX^] aPXbTS HW^¥Pbqb X¥¥XVaPcX^]'aT[PcTS R^]RTa]b [Tbb cWP] P hTPa PUcTa HW^¥Pb fPb STcPX]TS ^] PRR^d]c ^U cWT +))* R^]eXRcX^]( HWT 7^dac Pbbd¥Tb cWPc& XU HW^¥Pb WPS cWTaTc^U^aT QTT] d]PfPaT ^U cWT X¥¥XVaPcX^] R^]bT`dT]RTb ^U WXb _[TP& WT fPb YdbcXUXTS X] ]^c QaX]VX]V cWPc _PacXRd[Pa R[PX¥ d]cX[ WXb X¥¥XVaPcX^] STcT]cX^]( 077 1?;D76 0D3D7C F" (7B?3?67J& +1, :( Gd__( ,S *--& *.,l.- #G(8(B(L( +)*1$ #P]P[hiX]V fWT] _TcXcX^]Ta UX[TS X¥¥XVaPcX^]' aT[PcTS 5@B3> ?@4;C X] R^¥_PaXb^] c^ fWT] bWT aTRTXeTS ST_^acPcX^] ^aSTa$( $ *) DTcXcX^] P[b^ UPd[cb HW^¥Pbqb R^d]bT[ U^a P[[TVTS[h UPX[X]V c^ SXbRdbb cWT TeXST]RT P]S _^cT]cXP[ caXP[ STUT]bTb fXcW WX¥ QTU^aT cWT _[TP& P]S R[PX¥b cWPc cWT ;^eTa]¥T]c WPS cWaTPcT]TS WXb UP¥X[h _aX^a c^ cWT _[TP(% 077 DTc( Pc .( HWT 7^dac UX]Sb cWPc cWTbT RWP[[T]VTb& fWXRW HW^¥Pb UXabc Qa^dVWc *0 hTPab PUcTa cWT _[TP& PaT d]cX¥T[h( n5 _TcXcX^] U^a faXc ^U 5@B3> ?@4;C ¥Ph QT pcX¥T QPaaTS XU cWT _TcXcX^]Ta RP]]^c _a^eXST P YdbcXUXTS aTPb^] U^a UPX[daT c^ bTTZ P__a^_aXPcT aT[XTU Pc P] TPa[XTa SPcT(qo (7B?3?67J& +1, :( Gd__( ,S Pc *., #RXcPcX^] ^¥XccTS$( nKWX[T ]^ bcPcdcT ^U [X¥XcPcX^]b V^eTa]b cWT UX[X]V ^U P 5@B3> ?@4;C _TcXcX^]& P _TcXcX^]Ta ¥dbc bcX[[ bW^f b^d]S aTPb^]b U^a cWT ST[Ph X] QaX]VX]V cWT _TcXcX^](o &@7& 2*. :(,S Pc 2*. #X]cTa]P[ `d^cPcX^]b& QaPRZTcb& P]S RXcPcX^] ^¥XccTS$( HWT R^dacqb cX¥T[X]Tbb X]`dXah Xb R^¥_[TcTS ^] P RPbT'Qh'RPbT QPbXb& fXcW cWT nRaXcXRP[ X]`dXaho QTX]V nfWTcWTa cWT _TcXcX^]Ta Z]Tf ^a bW^d[S WPeT Z]^f] TPa[XTa ^U UPRcb d]STa[hX]V cWT R[PX¥ U^a 5@B3> ?@4;C aT[XTU(o (7B?3?67J& +1, :( Gd__( ,S Pc *., #RXcPcX^] ^¥XccTS$( n=U _TcXcX^]Ta S^Tb ]^c _a^UUTa P b^d]S aTPb^] U^a ST[Ph& pR^dacb WPeT WT[S cWPc bdRW _TcXcX^] bW^d[S QT SXb¥XbbTS XU Xcb UX[X]V WPb QTT] ST[PhTS U^a ¥^aT cWP] bTeTaP[ hTPab(qo )6" #QaPRZTcb P]S RXcPcX^] ^¥XccTS$( =] WXb DTcXcX^] P]S WXb aT_[h QaXTU& HW^¥Pb& cT[[X]V[h& S^Tb ]^c ^UUTa P]h Tg_[P]PcX^] U^a WXb *0'hTPa ST[Ph X] QaX]VX]V cWTbT R[PX¥b( HWT DTcXcX^] P[[TVTb cWPc WXb R^d]bT[ UPX[TS c^ SXbRdbb cWT TeXST]RT P]S WXb STUT]bTb fXcW WX¥ P]S cWPc WXb UP¥X[h ¥T¥QTab WPS QTT] cWaTPcT]TS QTU^aT cWT VdX[ch _[TP& RPdbX]V WX¥ c^ STRXST c^ T]cTa cWPc _[TP( 6dc Pbbd¥X]V cWTbT R[PX¥b c^ QT cadT& HW^¥Pb fPb PfPaT ^U Q^cW RXaRd¥bcP]RTb Pc cWT cX¥T ^U WXb _[TP P]S ^U WXb bT]cT]RX]V& hTc UPX[TS HWT DTcXcX^] bT_PaPcT[h bcPcTb cWPc HW^¥Pb WPb RWP]VTS WXb [XUT U^a cWT QTccTa bX]RT cWT cX¥T ^U WXb _[TP& P]S PbbTacb cWPc WXb UP¥X[h f^d[S bdUUTa WPaSbWX_ Ua^¥ WXb ST_^acPcX^]( 077 DTc( Pc /& 1( HWTbT R^]bXSTaPcX^]b& P[cW^dVW bh¥_PcWTcXR& PaT ]^c VTa¥P]T c^ HW^¥Pbqb 5@B3> ?@4;C _TcXcX^]& fWXRW cda]b ^] fWTcWTa HW^¥Pb WPb P eP[XS QPbXb c^ RWP[[T]VT WXb VdX[ch _[TP( 077 (74B@? F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& 7Xe( B^( K8E'*+'**-/& 7a( B^( K8E')1'))1/& +)*, K@ */,..2,& Pc %/ #8( AS( 5_a( *.& +)*,$ #ST]hX]V 5@B3> ?@4;C _TcXcX^] STb_XcT _TcXcX^]Taqb nUP¥X[h ¥T¥QTabq aTVaTccPQ[T X[[]Tbbo$( ** c^ aPXbT P]h bdRW R^]RTa]b Pc TXcWTa _a^RTTSX]V ^a U^a ¥P]h hTPab cWTaTPUcTa( GXV]XUXRP]c[h& c^^& >dSVT AdZPbThqb `dTbcX^]b c^ HW^¥Pb SdaX]V WXb _[TP WTPaX]V PSSaTbbTS Q^cW c^_XRb& _dccX]V HW^¥Pb ^] ]^cXRT cWPc cWTbT PaTPb _aTbT]cTS _^cT]cXP[ X¥_TSX¥T]cb c^ P eP[XS VdX[ch _[TP( =] aTb_^]bT& HW^¥Pb& ]^cPQ[h& cTbcXUXTS cWPc WT WPS SXbRdbbTS cWT RPbT fXcW WXb R^d]bT[& X]R[dSX]V _^bbXQ[T STUT]bTb& P]S cWPc WT fPb bPcXbUXTS fXcW WXb R^d]bT[qb aT_aTbT]cPcX^]4 P]S cWPc ]TXcWTa WT ]^a P]h ^cWTa _Tab^] WPS QTT] cWaTPcT]TS X] R^]]TRcX^] fXcW WXb VdX[ch _[TP( D[TP Ha( Pc -l.& *)l**( HWT 7^dac cWTaTU^aT UX]Sb HW^¥Pbqb 5@B3> ?@4;C _TcXcX^]& c^ cWT TgcT]c QPbTS ^] bdRW R[PX¥b& d]cX¥T[h( &,+&*1/),+ :^a cWT U^aTV^X]V aTPb^]b& cWT 7^dac ST]XTb HW^¥Pbqb DTcXcX^] U^a P faXc ^U Taa^a 5@B3> ?@4;C( HWT 7^dac STR[X]Tb c^ XbbdT P RTacXUXRPcT ^U P__TP[PQX[Xch P]S RTacXUXTb cWPc P]h P__TP[ Ua^¥ cWXb ^aSTa f^d[S ]^c QT cPZT] X] V^^S UPXcW4 cWTaTU^aT& ;? 8@B>3 A3EA7B;C bcPcdb Xb ST]XTS U^a cWT _da_^bT ^U P] P__TP[( %@AA7697 F" 1?;D76 0D3D7C& ,/2 I(G( -,1& --. #*2/+$( HWT 7[TaZ ^U 7^dac Xb aTb_TRcUd[[h SXaTRcTS c^ cTa¥X]PcT cWT ¥^cX^] _T]SX]V Pc S^RZTc ^]T P]S c^ R[^bT cWXb RPbT( HWT 7[TaZ ^U 7^dac Xb UdacWTa X]bcadRcTS c^ ¥PX[ P R^_h ^U cWXb ^aSTa c^ HW^¥Pb( GC CF89F98( OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO DPd[ 5( 9]VT[¥PhTa I]XcTS GcPcTb 8XbcaXRc >dSVT 8PcTS3 >d]T 23& +)+) BTf L^aZ& BTf L^aZ *+
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
