In re: Elysium Health-Chromadex Litigation, No. 1:2017cv07394 - Document 188 (S.D.N.Y. 2021)
Court Description: ORDER denying 186 Letter Motion to Compel. The motion to compel is DENIED. The Court's Opinion and Order of January 19, 2021 was clear (as were this Court's prior Orders, see Dkt. Nos. 150, 159, 165) that the deadline for all fact disco very was February 9, 2021. See Dkt. 171. Elysium sought neither reconsideration nor clarification, and its interrogatories come months too late. The discovery deadlines after February 9, 2021 pertain to expert discovery only. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Lewis J. Liman on 4/16/2021) (va)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
In re: Elysium Health-Chromadex Litigation Doc. 188 ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ!"#$%&'ÿ(&%$$&)ÿ*$+ÿ,-%.)ÿ*$+ÿ,-%.ÿ/0001ÿ 2ÿ3 / 4ÿ 5611 7ÿ8ÿ379:4ÿ97 6 /05ÿ ;+<"&=$'>?..@A;-Bÿ ÿ CDEFGÿIJKÿJLJIÿ MNOÿQRSÿ TUVWÿXYZF[ÿ\WÿXF]^Vÿÿ _VF`Yaÿb`^`Y[ÿcF[`EFd`ÿ\eafYÿ _VF`Yaÿb`^`Y[ÿcF[`EFd`ÿgUeE`ÿ bUe`hYEVÿcF[`EFd`ÿUiÿjYZÿkUElÿ mLLÿnY^EGÿb`EYY`ÿ jYZÿkUElKÿjkÿILLLoÿ ÿ ÿ pqrÿ stÿvwÿxyz{|}~ÿw y v ~ w ÿ | | | tKÿjUWÿIoÿgF Wÿo ÿ X\X ÿ ÿ cY^Eÿ\eafYÿXF]^Vrÿ YÿZEF`YÿUVÿ Yh^GiÿUiÿqG [Fe]ÿTY^G`hÿ VdWKÿDeE[e^V`ÿ`Uÿ YaYE^GÿpeGY[ÿUiÿgF FGÿnEUdYaeEYÿ ÿ^Vaÿ oKÿ^VaÿpeGYÿ W WÿUiÿ`hYÿgUeE` [ÿ VaF Fae^GÿnE^d`FdY[Kÿ`UÿEY eY[`ÿ`h^`ÿ`hYÿgUeE`ÿdU]DYGÿ ghEU]^cY Kÿ VdWÿ`UÿEY[DUVaÿ`UÿqG [Fe] [ÿbYdUVaÿbY`ÿUiÿ V`YEEUf^`UEFY[ÿ V`YIEEUf^`UEFY[ ÿjU[Wÿ J I Kÿ^VaÿqG [Fe] [ÿ FE[`ÿbY`ÿUiÿpY eY[`[ÿiUEÿCa]F[[FUVÿ p C[ Wÿÿq [WÿCKÿ Wÿÿÿÿÿ hYÿUEFfFV^Gÿd^[Yÿ]^V^fY]YV`ÿDG^VKÿYV`YEYaÿUVÿ ^EdhÿJIKÿJLI KÿDEU FaYaÿ^ÿaY^aGFVYÿiUEÿ dU]DGY`FUVÿUiÿ^GGÿaF[dU YE ÿ^VaÿY[`^ GF[hYaÿdYE`^FVÿFV`YEF]ÿaF[dU YE ÿaY^aGFVY[Wÿÿqg ÿjUWÿooWÿÿ hYÿ UEaYEÿ]^lY[ÿdGY^Eÿ`h^`ÿ`hYÿiFV^GÿaF[dU YE ÿaY^aGFVYÿF[ÿVU`ÿGF]F`Yaÿ`UÿY DYE`ÿaF[dU YE Kÿ e`ÿE^`hYEÿF[ÿ iUEÿdU]DGY`FUVÿUiÿ ^GGÿaF[dU YE Kÿ|t y} |t ÿY DYE`ÿaF[dU YE W ÿs ¡ÿ¢ÿ Wÿÿ VaYYaKÿZhFGYÿ`hYEYÿ^EYÿ Y DGFdF`ÿaY^aGFVY[ÿiUEÿdU]DGY`FUVÿUiÿaUde]YV`ÿaF[dU YE ÿ^Vaÿi^d`ÿaYDU[F`FUV[KÿVUÿ[edhÿ[YD^E^`Yÿ aY^aGFVYÿY F[`[ÿiUEÿ[YE FdYÿUiÿFV`YEEUf^`UEFY[ÿ^Vaÿp C[Wÿÿ£VÿjU Y] YEÿI KÿJLJLKÿ`hYÿgUeE`ÿfE^V`Yaÿ `hYÿD^E`FY[ ÿ]U[`ÿEYdYV`ÿEY eY[`ÿ`UÿY `YVaÿ`hYÿEY]^FVFVfÿaY^aGFVY[KÿEY[Y``FVfÿ`hYÿaY^aGFVYÿiUEÿ i^d`ÿ aYDU[F`FUV[ ÿ`Uÿ Y Ee^E ÿ KÿJLJIKÿ^Vaÿ`hYÿaY^aGFVYÿiUEÿ ^GGÿaF[dU YE ÿ`UÿCDEFGÿJ KÿJLJIWÿÿqg ÿjUWÿ I mWÿ £Vÿ ^EdhÿImKÿJLJIKÿqG [Fe]ÿ[YE YaÿF`[ÿ V`YEEUf^`UEFY[ÿ^VaKÿUVÿ ^EdhÿJ KÿJLJIKÿqG [Fe]ÿ [YE YaÿF`[ÿp C[KÿFVÿ^ddUEa^VdYÿZF`hÿ`hYÿd^[Yÿ[dhYaeGYWÿÿ£VÿCDEFGÿJKÿJLJIKÿghEU]^cY ÿVU`FiFYaÿ qG [Fe]ÿ`h^`ÿF`ÿZUeGaÿVU`ÿEY[DUVaÿ `Uÿ`hYÿ YG^`YaÿFV`YEEUf^`UEFY[ÿ^VaÿEY eY[`[ÿiUEÿ^a]F[[FUVW ÿÿq Wÿ gWÿÿghEU]^cY [ÿE^`FUV^GYÿiUEÿdG^F]FVfÿ`hYÿaF[dU YE ÿF[ÿ YG^`Ya ÿF[ÿ`hYÿgUeE` [ÿEYiYEYVdYÿFVÿF`[ÿ \^Ve^E ÿI KÿJLJIÿUEaYEÿUVÿqG [Fe] [ÿ]U`FUVÿ`Uÿ^]YVaÿF`[ÿdUeV`YEdG^F][ÿ`Uÿ Y Ee^E ÿ KÿJLJIÿ^[ÿ `hYÿaY^aGFVYÿiUEÿdU]DGY`FUVÿUiÿi^d`ÿaF[dU YE Wÿÿs ¡ÿ eU`FVfÿqg ÿjUWÿIoIÿ^`ÿ KÿII Wÿÿ hYEYÿF[ÿVUÿ FVaFd^`FUVÿ`h^`Kÿ`hEUefhÿ`hF[ÿG^Vfe^fYKÿ`hYÿgUeE`ÿFV`YVaYaÿ`Uÿ^]YVaÿ`hYÿjU Y] YEÿI KÿJLJLÿd^[Yÿ ]^V^fY]YV`ÿ[dhYaeGY¤ZhFdhÿZ^[ÿVU`ÿ^`ÿF[[eYÿFVÿ`hYÿ]U`FUVWÿÿ VaYYaKÿ`hYÿ\^Ve^E ÿI ÿUEaYEÿUVÿ`hYÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ Iÿ hYÿD^E`FY[KÿFVÿfUUaÿi^F`hKÿdUViYEEYaÿ ÿ`YGYDhUVYÿUVÿCDEFGÿIJKÿJLJIKÿ e`ÿZYEYÿeV^ GYÿ`UÿEY[UG Yÿ`hYÿaF[De`YWÿÿÿÿ ÿ 122345678579 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ 56 6 5 ÿ ÿ Dockets.Justia.com 0123ÿ56789ÿ 3ÿ58 2ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ 6ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 1'812ÿ'1ÿ 62(ÿ7 9ÿ 699ÿ') 2ÿ* ÿ( +9ÿ, 1 ÿ')6ÿ-6. / +ÿ0 ÿ ÿ(6 ( 826 ÿ7)81)ÿ71/ (ÿ) 26ÿ (6ÿ8'ÿ8 1998. 6ÿ,1 ÿ3 +98/ ÿ'1ÿ'8 6 +ÿ96 26ÿ8'9ÿ42'6 1 '1 869ÿ 2(ÿ5- 9ÿÿ 'ÿ') 'ÿ 182'3ÿÿ 6626 ')6 699 ÿ7) 1 869ÿ112'82/69ÿ'1ÿ82989'ÿ') 'ÿ3 +98/ :9ÿ 6;/69'ÿ 6ÿ/2'8 6 +3ÿÿ <=ÿ ?@ABCDEFBÿ<HIJKKLMNILKCJBÿNKJÿOCEJ@AÿNHPÿQKLRJKÿÿÿ 42'6 1 '1 869ÿ6193ÿ S ÿ 6ÿ112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ.61 /96ÿ')6+ÿT966Uÿ82,1 '812ÿ .1/'ÿ')6ÿ, 1'/ ÿ. 969ÿ/2(6 +82 ÿ')6ÿ1 8 9ÿ 2(ÿ112'62'8129ÿ1,ÿ 2ÿ (26 96ÿ '+3VÿÿWXYZ[\]ÿ_`aÿ baÿc[XdYefY`ggYhÿ613ÿ0*ÿ7823ÿi j5 kjl0mk ÿ 00iÿn5ÿop q ÿ 'ÿrÿ ÿjs38363t3ÿs6 '3ÿ* ÿ 00ikÿ j18'82 ÿs1/')6 2ÿ889' 81'ÿ1,ÿ667ÿt1 Uÿ511 ÿ5/ 6ÿ**3*kuÿv\ÿX]ÿwxYfÿyX]Yezgÿy[]fÿ{[XdzxXe]ÿ |\gYgX[}gÿ~YgYea ÿ q ÿ-35383ÿ ÿpÿj838373ÿ kÿjT712'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869:ÿ') 'ÿ 9Uÿ ÿ '+ÿ7) 'ÿ 8'ÿ112'62(9ÿ1 ÿ'1ÿ9' '6ÿ ÿ')6ÿ, 1'9ÿ/ 12ÿ7)81)ÿ8'ÿ. 969ÿ ÿ112'62'812ÿ 6ÿ 6 ,61' +ÿ 6 8'8 '63Vk3ÿÿ -/ ')6 1 6 ÿ42'6 1 '1 869ÿ6193ÿ S ÿ)6 ÿT')6ÿ '869ÿ,11/9ÿ')68 ÿ / 62'9ÿ ,'6 ÿ(891126 +ÿ89ÿ 11 6'6ÿ 2(ÿ' 8 ÿ89ÿ26 ÿ.+ÿ 9U82 ÿ')6 ÿ'1ÿ8(62'8,+ÿ6 1)ÿ1 8 ÿ1 ÿ(6,6296ÿ1 6 +ÿ 2(ÿ 182'ÿ'1ÿ')6ÿ , 1'9 ÿ78'269969 ÿ1 ÿ(11/ 62'9ÿ') 'ÿ9/ 1 'ÿ')6 3Vÿÿy`Xgÿ ` Xgzÿ f` ]]} ÿw]gaÿy[\ ÿbaÿ acaÿ `Xex\ÿ_zx}]ÿ ÿ_`3 ÿ 0iÿ-35383ÿ00 ÿ ÿjs38363t3ÿ *k3*ÿÿ +ÿ / 6 ÿ112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ 6ÿ96 26(ÿj kÿT 'ÿ')6ÿ1121 /9812ÿ1,ÿ1')6 ÿ(891126 + Vÿ 2(ÿj kÿT 'ÿ 6 9'ÿ* ÿ( +9ÿ 81 ÿ'1ÿ')6ÿ(891126 +ÿ1/'S1,,ÿ( '63Vÿÿ5/ 6ÿ**3*j1k3ÿÿ 9ÿ112'62'812ÿ 82'6 1 '1 869 ÿ42'6 1 '1 869ÿ6193ÿ S ÿ 6ÿ'8 6 + ÿ6262ÿ8,ÿ')6ÿ71/ 'ÿ(618(69ÿ'1ÿ 62(ÿ')6ÿ 81 ÿ 91)6(/ 82 ÿ1 (6 ÿ9/1)ÿ') 'ÿ-6. / +ÿ0ÿ7 9ÿ 91ÿ')6ÿ7 8''62ÿ, 1'ÿ(891126 +ÿ1/'1,,3ÿÿ712'62'812ÿ 82'6 1 '1 869ÿ 6ÿ 1 6 +ÿ96 26(ÿx g]Xÿ, 1'ÿ(891126 +3ÿÿ{]]ÿv\ÿX]ÿyxd]Z`` hÿv\dahÿ613ÿ 85ÿ S *q0 ÿ ÿn5ÿo q o ÿ 'ÿr*ÿjs38363t3ÿ / +ÿi ÿ kÿj11 61'82 ÿ1 969k3ÿÿ42(66( ÿ82ÿ Xdz`\Yxÿ _`X aÿbaÿ Y}}``\ ÿ613ÿ iÿ74 3ÿq 0 ÿ857 ÿ ÿn5ÿ*0 p ÿ 'ÿr*ÿjs38363t3ÿ / 3ÿ ÿ k ÿ T')6ÿ71/ 'ÿ1 (6 6(ÿ') 'ÿ9/1)ÿ112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ ÿ11/ (ÿ.6ÿ96 26(ÿ12 +ÿ ,'6 ÿ, 1'ÿ (891126 +ÿ) (ÿ.662ÿ11 6'6(3Vÿ ÿ 42'6 1 '1 869ÿ6193ÿ S oÿ966Uÿ, 1'/ ÿ82,1 '812ÿ') 'ÿ3 +98/ ÿ/29/11699,/ +ÿ ''6 '6(ÿ '1ÿ8 818'ÿ') 1/ )ÿ(6 198'812ÿ'69'8 12+ ÿ821 /(82 ÿ5/ 6ÿ* j.kj kÿ78'2699693ÿÿ5/ 6ÿ**3*j.kÿ 6 8'9ÿ 68')6 ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ ,'6 ÿ ÿ(6 198'812ÿ1 ÿ ÿ(6 198'812ÿ ,'6 ÿ82'6 1 '1 8693ÿÿ-6(3ÿ53ÿ7823ÿ 113ÿ**ÿ (2891 +ÿ11 8''66:9ÿ21'6ÿj 0pikÿjT4'ÿ +ÿ.6ÿ;/8'6ÿ(698 . 6ÿ1 ÿ261699 +ÿ'1ÿ6 818'ÿ ((8'812 ÿ 82,1 '812ÿ.+ÿ')6ÿ8269 629826ÿ 6')1(ÿ1,ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ7)6 6ÿ ÿ(6 198'812ÿ) 9ÿ 6 (+ÿ.662ÿ ' U623Vk3ÿÿ429'6 (ÿ1,ÿ 69 12(82 ÿ'1ÿ')6ÿ8269 629826ÿ 6')1(ÿ1,ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ96 26(ÿ82ÿ (2 216ÿ1,ÿ ')6ÿ 8 ÿ * ÿ ÿ(6 ( 826ÿ'1ÿ11 6'6ÿT ÿ(891126 + Vÿ7) 1 869ÿ /69ÿ') 'ÿ3 +98/ :9ÿ12 +ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿ7) 1 869ÿ7 12 +ÿ 996 '9ÿ') 'ÿ112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ1 221'ÿ966Uÿ 2+ÿ, 1'/ ÿ82,1 '812ÿ/2(6 +82 ÿ 7) 1 869:9ÿ112'62'81293ÿÿ017626 ÿ')6ÿ1 969ÿ 6 86(ÿ/ 12ÿ.+ÿ7) 1 869ÿ69 699 +ÿ /')1 8 6ÿ112'62'812ÿ 82'6 1 '1 869ÿ') 'ÿ966Uÿ, 1'/ ÿ82,1 '812ÿ/2(6 +82 ÿ112'62'812ÿ8,ÿ9/1)ÿ112'62'812ÿ 1 8 '6 +ÿ2 17ÿ')6ÿ899/69ÿ 6962'6(ÿ,1 ÿ' 8 3ÿÿl)6ÿ112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ82ÿ')196ÿ1 969ÿ(8(ÿ21'ÿ2 17ÿ')6ÿ899/69ÿ(/6ÿ'1ÿ18 1/ 9' 2169ÿ21'ÿ 6 62 2'ÿ)6 63ÿÿ{]]ÿ_f]x\ÿ xXgzÿw] ] YxgY`\ÿ ÿ_`\}gaÿ{]Xb}ahÿv\daÿbaÿ| aÿv\g fÿ X ahÿv\da ÿ poÿ-35383ÿ *i ÿ p ÿ js38363t3ÿ ikÿj112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ76 6ÿ8 1 6 ÿ.61 /96ÿ, 1'ÿ(891126 +ÿ7 9ÿ21'ÿ11 6'6kuÿcx}g]X\x ÿbaÿ ` ÿ Y ÿ613ÿ ÿ74 3ÿo poÿ5lsÿ 57 ÿ ÿn5ÿpoo *q0 ÿ 'ÿr*ÿjs38363t3ÿs6 '3ÿ q ÿ kÿj112'62'812ÿ82'6 1 '1 869ÿ 76 6ÿ8 1 6 ÿ.61 /96ÿ')6+ÿ(8(ÿ21'ÿ2 17ÿ899/69k3ÿ *ÿ -1 ÿ69 6 ÿ')6ÿ42'6 1 '1 869ÿ966Uÿ7) 1 869:9ÿ, 1'/ ÿ9/ 1 'ÿ,1 ÿ')6ÿ112'62'8129ÿ') 'ÿU6+ÿ (26 '896 62'9ÿ 6ÿ T, 96ÿ1 ÿ 89 6 (82 Vÿ 6ÿT 8U6 +ÿ'1ÿ82, /6216ÿ1129/ 6 :9ÿ / 1) 982 ÿ(61898129 Vÿ 2(ÿ11216 2ÿT 2ÿ82)6 62'ÿ;/ 8'+ÿ1 ÿ 1) 1'6 89'81ÿ1,ÿ')6ÿ 1(/1'3Vÿÿ393ÿ ÿ42'6 1 '1 +ÿ6193ÿpSo3ÿÿ .962'ÿ')89ÿ82,1 '812 ÿ')6ÿ '869ÿ78 ÿ 8U6 +ÿ7 9'6ÿ '8 6ÿ 2(ÿ /(818 ÿ 691/ 169ÿ78')ÿ 6S' 8 ÿ(89 /'69ÿ .1/'ÿ9' '6 62'9ÿ') 'ÿ 6ÿ21'ÿ 6 '8262'ÿ'1ÿ')6ÿ1 8 9ÿ 'ÿ899/63ÿÿÿ ÿ !"#ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ $% " &&ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ56789ÿ 3ÿ58 2ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ 6ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 6(1) 96ÿ7 9ÿ*1ÿ 1+6ÿ*1ÿ(1 6 ÿ,) *-6 ÿ*69*8 12.ÿ/ 960ÿ) 12ÿ8*9ÿ, ) *.ÿ 6 082 ÿ1,ÿ*-6ÿ9(-60) 82 ÿ 1 06 ÿ*- *ÿ 2.ÿ82*6 1 *1 869ÿ- 0ÿ*1ÿ/6ÿ96 +60ÿ82ÿ 0+ 2(6ÿ1,ÿ06 198*81293ÿ 1- 1 263ÿ,) *-6 ÿ1/46(*9ÿ*1ÿ*-6ÿ52*6 1 *1 869ÿ12ÿ*-6ÿ 1)20ÿ*- *ÿ*-6.ÿ63(660ÿ*-6ÿ 67 82*6 1 *1 .ÿ 8 8*3ÿÿ0176+6 ÿ*-6ÿ52*6 1 *1 8698ÿ9)/ *9ÿ 6ÿ9, (*) .ÿ82*6 (1226(*60ÿ 20ÿ 06 62062*ÿ) 12ÿ*-6ÿ:)69*812ÿ 1960ÿ/.ÿ*-6ÿ/ 98(ÿ82*6 1 *1 .3;ÿÿ<=>?@AB?ÿD@E?FGFHI?IJÿK@LMÿNMÿ OF?BA@EP?B?>HAÿQMÿRBMJÿK@LM ÿS13ÿ T15U TV WXS ÿ VÿY5ÿ 6TV6 ÿ *ÿZ ÿ[X323S3\3ÿ] 3ÿ ^ ÿ V_3ÿÿ *9ÿ 6ÿ, (*) .ÿ82*6 (1226(*60ÿ6+62ÿ8,ÿ*-6.ÿ 9`ÿ,1 ÿ*-6ÿ 2976 ÿ*1ÿ/6ÿ9089 6 *60ÿ /.ÿ*. 63;ÿÿK>Mÿÿa ÿ9)/ *ÿ89ÿ089( 6*6ÿ 20ÿ 6 060ÿ 9ÿ ÿ96 *6ÿ82*6 1 *1 .;ÿ12 .ÿ7-62ÿ98*ÿ89ÿ 1 8( .ÿ1 ÿ, (*) .ÿ8206 62062*ÿ1,ÿ*-6ÿ:)69*812ÿ 1960ÿ/.ÿ*-6ÿ/ 98(ÿ82*6 1 *1 .3;ÿÿQ?bÿ<=PEÿ c=P>H@dÿ<=FGMÿNMÿefgÿc=P>H@djIÿ=hÿOPAMJÿK@L3 ÿS13ÿ15U3ÿ i 1U V ÿ[ 12_ ÿ ÿY5ÿ 6 j ÿ *ÿZ ÿ[23ÿ11223ÿk6/3ÿT ÿ _3ÿ llmÿ opqrstuvwxyÿ{|}v~ r yÿrÿpvÿ v vyyÿ rqÿ s yy r yÿ qvÿl t v tvÿ .98) ÿ96 +60ÿ k 9ÿ966`82 ÿ 0 8998129ÿ 6 082 ÿ899)6ÿ1,ÿ )*-62*8(8*.ÿ 20ÿ 0 8998/8 8*.ÿ 1,ÿ Tÿ01() 62*9ÿ 10)(60ÿ/.ÿ1- 1 263ÿ82ÿ 80ÿ1,ÿ9* 6 8282 ÿ899)69ÿ,1 ÿ) (1 82 ÿ9) .ÿ 4)0 62*ÿ 1*812ÿ (*8(6ÿ 20ÿ* 8 3ÿÿ1- 1 263ÿ 6(62* .ÿ*11`ÿ*-6ÿ 198*812ÿ*- *ÿ8*ÿ78 ÿ 69 120ÿ*1ÿ *-6ÿ k 9ÿ*1ÿ*-6ÿ63*62*ÿ*-6.ÿ(12* 82ÿ9 6:)69*9ÿ,1 ÿ )*-62*8( *812ÿ 1263;ÿÿ 33ÿ13ÿÿ ,*6 ÿ .98) ÿ 8960ÿ0) 82 ÿ*-6ÿ 66*ÿ 20ÿ(12,6 ÿ*- *ÿ*-6ÿ k 9ÿ 91ÿ(12* 82ÿ 6:)69*9ÿ*1ÿ 0 8*ÿ*- *ÿ*-6ÿ01() 62*9ÿ 76 6ÿ 6 60ÿ82ÿ*-6ÿ 6 ) ÿ(1) 96ÿ1,ÿ/)982699ÿ/.ÿ 2ÿ6 1.66ÿ78*-ÿ`217 60 6ÿ1,ÿ*-6ÿ **6 ÿ 33ÿ ÿ1- 1 263ÿ(12,8 60ÿ*- *ÿ8*ÿ78 ÿ21*ÿ 69 120ÿ*1ÿ9)(-ÿ 6:)69*93ÿÿ1- 1 263ÿ- 9ÿ1,,6 60ÿ21ÿ 4)9*8,8( *812ÿ,1 ÿ*-89ÿ1/46(*812 ÿ7-8(-ÿ78 ÿ 6 6 .ÿ7 9*6ÿ*-6ÿ *8698ÿ*8 6ÿ 20ÿÿ4)08(8 ÿ 691) (69ÿ 0172ÿ*-6ÿ 1 03ÿÿ ??ÿ H@>?ÿNMÿRFA ÿ A@ Jÿ <M ÿS13ÿ1U7 j7 V^^ÿS ÿUU ÿ ^ÿY5ÿ T^ ^T ÿ *ÿ Z ÿ[ 323S3\3ÿ )26ÿ ÿ ^_ÿ[1 06 82 ÿ*- *ÿ01() 62*9ÿ/6ÿ9066 60ÿ 0 8998/ 6ÿ 9ÿ )*-62*8(ÿ /)982699ÿ 6(1 09;ÿ0)6ÿ*1ÿ829),,8(862*ÿ 69 1296ÿ*1ÿ 6:)69*ÿ,1 ÿ 0 899812_36ÿ ((1 082 . ÿ .98) ÿ 69 6(*,) .ÿ 6:)69*9ÿ*-6ÿ11) *ÿ 2*ÿ8*9ÿ 1*812ÿ*1ÿ(1 6 ÿ 1- 1 263ÿ*1ÿ 69 120ÿ*1ÿ8*9ÿX6(120ÿX6*ÿ1,ÿ52*6 1 *1 869ÿS193ÿ 7 ÿ 20ÿ .98) 89ÿk8 9*ÿX6*ÿ1,ÿ 6:)69*9ÿ,1 ÿ 0 8998123ÿ ÿ 69 6(*,) .ÿ9)/ 8**60 ÿ ÿ I ÿ<FAHdÿ Mÿ HE@? ÿ ÿ 1 8 ÿ 3ÿY-8*26.ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ jÿ 112* .ÿ*1ÿ8*9ÿ( 8 9 ÿ1- 1 263ÿ* 6 *60ÿ9)/ *9ÿ 9ÿ ÿ982 6ÿ82*6 1 *1 .ÿ82ÿ8*9ÿ172ÿ 6:)69*93ÿÿ ??ÿ 33ÿ2 ÿ 52*6 1 *1 .ÿ ÿ[95062*8,.ÿ*-6ÿ9* *82 ÿ 20ÿ62082 ÿ0 *69ÿ7-62ÿ .98) ÿ )/ 89-60ÿ 0+6 *896 62*9ÿ 6,6 62(82 ÿ*-6ÿ 6,,6(*ÿ1 ÿ 1*62*8 ÿ6,,6(*ÿ1,ÿ 989 ÿ *6 19*8 /626 ÿ1 ÿ28(1*82 806ÿ 8/19806ÿ82ÿ* 6 *82 ÿ0896 96 ÿ 6+6 982 ÿ(1 28*8+6ÿ 06( 826 ÿ1 ÿ82( 6 982 ÿ-) 2ÿ 8,6ÿ9 23;_ÿ 6ÿ ??ÿAPI=ÿ AIE?F@A ÿNMÿ =bÿ HBJÿS13ÿ ÿ15U3ÿ6 j6ÿ5WXÿ 51 ÿ ÿY5ÿj66 ^ ÿ *ÿZ6ÿ[X323S3\3ÿX6 *3ÿ ÿ _ÿ [9112* .ÿ*1ÿ 8 89ÿ 996 *8129 6:)69*9ÿ,1 ÿ 0 899812 ÿ 6ÿ21*ÿ 2ÿ63*629812ÿ1,ÿ06 198*812ÿ (*8(63ÿ529*6 0 ÿ ) 6ÿ Tÿ 60)(69ÿ*-6ÿ(19*9ÿ1,ÿ 8*8 *812ÿ /.ÿ6 8 82 *82 ÿ*-6ÿ26(6998*.ÿ1,ÿ 1+82 ÿ, (*9ÿ*- *ÿ 6ÿ21*ÿ82ÿ9)/9* 2*8 ÿ089 )*6 ÿ*1ÿ 2 17ÿ*-6ÿ9(1 6ÿ1,ÿ089 )*60ÿ899)69 ÿ 20ÿ*1ÿ, (8 8* *6ÿ*-6ÿ 6962* *812ÿ1,ÿ( 969ÿ*1ÿ*-6ÿ* 86 ÿ1,ÿ, (*38;ÿ[(8* *812ÿ 1 8**60__3ÿ ÿ !"#$ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ %& # ''ÿ ÿ 0123ÿ56789ÿ 3ÿ58 2ÿ 8 ÿ ÿ ÿ 6ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ (()ÿ*8 ÿ+,-ÿ.1ÿ,1/296 ÿ10ÿ16(1 2ÿÿ The motion to compel is DENIED. The Court's Opinion and Order of January 19, 2021 was clear (as were this Court's prior Orders, see Dkt. Nos. 150, 159, 165) that the deadline for all fact discovery was February 9, 2021. See Dkt. No. 171. Elysium sought neither reconsideration nor clarification, and its interrogatories come months too late. The discovery deadlines after February 9, 2021 pertain to expert discovery only. SO ORDERED. 4/16/2021. ÿ !"#$ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ %& # ''ÿ ÿ
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
