Seabrook v. The New York City Dept. of Corrections et al, No. 1:2013cv06620 - Document 37 (S.D.N.Y. 2014)
Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER re: 21 MOTION to Dismiss the Complaint filed by Warden Newton, The City Of New York. For the foregoing reasons, Defendants' motion to dismiss is GRANTED. Plaintiff is granted leave to file a second amended complain t. An amended complaint form is attached to this order. If Plaintiff wishes to file a second amended complaint, he is directed to send it by mail to the Pro Se Office of this Court, 500 Pearl Street, Room 200, New York, New York 10007, by January 15, 2015. The Clerk of the Court is directed to terminate the motion at docket number 21. SO ORDERED., ( Amended Pleadings due by 1/15/2015.) (Signed by Judge J. Paul Oetken on 12/16/2014) Copies Mailed By Chambers. (ama) (Additional attachment(s) added on 12/16/2014: # 1 Amended Civil Rights Complaint Form) (ama).
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Seabrook v. The New York City Dept. of Corrections et al Doc. 37 U I E S A E DS RC C U T NT D T T S I TI T O R S U H R DS RC O N O T E N I TI T F EWY R OK ------------------------------------------------------------X : C LI S A R O , A VN E B O K Pi i , : l nf a tf : : -v : T ECT O N H I Y F EWY R,D P T E A N : O K E U Y LI E : B R E T DP T J SP R S O A R T, E U Y O E H U S, : D P T A T U R G I R,C P A N E U Y R H R U GE O A T I : S A O B N E,C P A NC U K U G H R N E D R A TI H N E N : L E C P A ND U L S MT H L, E, A T I O G A I C E L C P A N MC A LRC A D,CO E LS : A T I I H E I H R S .. LI , : CO G RI,CO H T H N O, CO .. A C A .. U C I S N .. : J C B, A D NN T N A O SW R E EW O, D edns : e na . f t : ------------------------------------------------------------X 1- V 62 (P ) 3C -60J O OI I NA DO D R PN O N R E J P U O T E,Dt cJde . A L E K N irt ug si : Pi i C v Saro ( ebok o“l nf ) poed gr s, r gt s l nf a i ebok “ aro” r Pi i ”, rce npo e b ns h a tf l n S a tf i i i ainl g g h h ws u e et ucni t n cn t n ocn nmn w l h ws c o ae n ta e asb c d o nost i a odi s f ofe e he e a t li t jt tuo l io i t i i cs d ateAn M Ko Cn r“ K ”o R e I ad Saro’ l w i n ms n u oyt h na . rs e e( AM C n i r s n ebok as t a e t s t ) ks l . s u v iu cr c oaoie ad h C y fN wYr (oeie, D edn ” 1 a os o ein f c s nte i o e okc lc v y“ e na s. r rt l f r t l t l f t) D edn mvt d m s h c m a t u unt Fd a R e fC i Poeu 1()6 e na s oeoi i te o pi pr a o ee l u o i l rcdr 2b ) f t s s ln s t r l v e (. Frhrao s h f l wD edn’m insg n d adSaroig n devt fe oteesn ta o o, e na s o oi r t , n eboksr t laeoi tl f t t ae ae l a eoda edd o pi . scn mne c m a t ln 1 I s n e i Saro’ a edd o pi i edt n m a a e na a e i t uc a f ebok mne c m a t n ns o a e s d edn n nt i lr s ln t f t ty ie i ea C m ineCnua s fN wYr (e D.N 2 ( A .C m . a4 dnf ds o pac os tn o e ok Se k o 7 “ m o p” t. ti l l t . t . l) ) Te mne c m a t o a s ol ginw head o hr e fh e i o h wts h a edd o pi cni n aea o i rg t te o ot s nt r o ii ln tn l t t r l i ty rsos lfr odin a AM C Acr n yayl m s o h d edni d m sd epn b o cn t st ie io K. cod g, n ci at t s e na si i e il a i f t s s t 3 , r I fra u t st al m Se h m v CyfN w ok 59F d 7 14 2 C. 09(t oflr ot e ci . e So o. i o e Yr, 7 . 16 8 (d i 20)“ i e a a i wl eld n h C c t h p sn iv v mn o d edn i aee cni t n s e st i t s i u ta e oa no e e f e na s nl gd ost i a l te i ri t r l l t f t l tuo l dp vini a r eui t a a ad f a ae ud §18 ”i en qot nm k er a oss p rq seo n w o d mgs ne it e it r r 93 ( t a u a o a s . n r l ti r o ie) H wv ,Saro my mn h ci at C m ineCnua sfN wYr mtd) o ee ebok a a edi l m s o o pac os tn o e ok t . r s a l l t i h a eddla n epist aee rsos it fri a n h r h . fi mne p d gx a i l gdepn bi o v ligi i t s ei ln sl ily ot s gs 1 Dockets.Justia.com I . Bc go n2 akr u d A . Fc as t Acr nt te mne c m a t Saro ws e i i aee in a o ae cod go ha edd o pi , ebok a h d n n ksc os l cld i ln l t t ,s l h d g es r b les ateAM C v sv adyi 21 3 ( m C m .t. Te o i pn o “u pn ”t h ln l , K oe ee l as n 02 A . o p a5 h r r . l ) h d g e we ic m g eiesrtkn o poe ig s ut o apo m e 1 o i pn h eno i d a e a ae fr rcs n i b lfr prx al 5 ln , r n tn e s , i i ty p sn b ala oe fh a ai “ wy oe r we w h eies i teag o 2 e os u tes n oter ss a as v co dd i d a e ”n hrne f 0 r , t t e l r t tn , t 3 (. Saro a es h d a es r sb ct d est n m s n ne o 0 I ) ebok s r ta ei e a u e oi aer s i i , sc . d st t t n e jt s a so i t ifst naak f e it n n d n n w e ad o- ok goe.(. Adinl n ti , lc o vnli ad r k g a r n nn wr nt l s I ) d t a y e ao ta o ii t, i it d i o l, d a es a fret s e o ai h cn e f ocv e w h rknlotefr p o ei e “ e o d ol p n fty oc t l r oe d i boe f ri s o ut 5 tn r c e l re o r t o l dy aai e fo adw ea s vd nn na t yah nad t myaeh e as o ast t m ” od n a r r e eia usna fs o n i atktr dyt , t e r ir i, e t e . nl l l tn semd as f (d(a tia o ae d)F a y Saro aee, So d D a e e e c t f I cpazinl r ) i l, ebok l gs “ hu a ei e i l a. . il t ne ayye f s s ner m nOie, hi m e WL sb ch me t ed ntp o a i acfo a f c [te n a] I L u e i s fo st f r t jt l h m][ t n]H ] s mn adn o e ae AViu a a t (d(a tia oi u [l]i [ ar s e, ni s m css i os s u. I cpazin n ii a o , [ a t c s l” . il t o g a. ri l ) i n) Saro aee tate odini teAM C n k sc ohv cue h m ebok l gs h h cn t s n h l t io K i ae einae asdi t t v iu pyh o c i u efrw c h hs og t a mnadmd a o ic d g oa os sco g a n r so h h e asuh r t e n e cin n u n ps r l i l ji i te t it , l i t . st t u act s d od , e o co ddlcs n axt d od.(da56 H a es r mi s e i re fa fr we p e ad n e i re I t - ) e s r a t rs s r r a , iy s r . ta D edn vl e h r h ud teE h adFu en A ed e s n ses 5 h e na sia d i i t ne h i t n or e h mn mn ad ek $ t f t ot s g s r gh t t t ml ni d mgso p n n sf r ga wl s h cs o“ e aha h a ” n ii l o n a aefr a ad u e n s e ate o s f mnl et c e ad i fi , l t t l r 2 Te o oigas rtknr m h aea os n h a edd o pi ,w c a hf l w ft a ae fo tel gini te mne c m a t h hr l n c e l t ln i e acp d sret h s g adr m tesb i ini cneinw h his n m in ce e atu at st e n fo o r u m s s n onc o i ten a o o t i a, h so t t tt t . 3 Te rc e a s nw ctel gd vn ocr d r sb ct qeinTe mne h p i d e o h h h aee ee s cu e a u e o us o h a edd es t i l t r e jt t . c m a tt ei oen actate a sw e Fbu y34 & ” A .C m .t ) n o pi sts n nis neh h d e e “era ,, 5 ( m o p a2 i ln a t t t r r l , ao ep c o “erayt [ c 3d4 ,t”i a3 ad eao ep c o “eray n h l e n Fbu 4 s ] r t 5 (.t ) n y n h l e n Fbu tr a r h i, , h h d , t tra r 2 2 M c 1 21 fo 4 0 m /7 2 nl:0AM3121” i a1)I aee 8 9 a h s 02r m : p 2 / u i4 , , r t 0 21 t 0 , --02(d t 0 n lt . . tr fe o Ar 121 Saro std h h ws r s d nFbu y, 02ad h “o e i d n pl, 04 ebokt eta e a a e e o era 221 nte cr c l i , a t rt r , rt d e” o h ci sr Fbu y truh eray , 02 ( k N 1 ) a s fri l ma era 3hog Fbu 721 D. o 8 t s a e r r . t . . 2 “u r md ac e”(. t. Cnrel e l,Saro s o pi a o ek a f u e c a . I a8 os udi rl ebok c m a tl ses n t e il r d ) t b ay ’ ln s i uc o rq r gAM C oi mdt ytp h oe r w n o‘u pn’t “os n nineui j t in K t “ m e al s te v co d g f b les”o hue ie o r i l , d a esw hn8 or a p s ie bl w ad oie eies md at a mni a ei e i i 4 hu s r c bd ya, nt g d a e “ e c r t e n tn t s er ” v tn il e t t m ymne ” snayry ofo ” snay r k g us ad aeu eero i e an, “a t t s f od “a t d n n cp ”n “dqa rs o m l r ir a , ir i i , t t fcie ”(d alis I ) it . . Saro aeetah fe a r vnea AM C oc n g odini ten k ebokl gs h ei d g eac t l t l i K cne i cn t s n hi ae rn io t sc o, urc vd o e y (. t. I rsost te o pi fr ’ qeyoc n g ein b ee e n rp. I a7 nepneo h c m a t o m u cne i t t i l d ) ln s r rn s ptkn o pe t “h h hslv ote r vne rcs ”Saro de n aee t saet apa o tei e ee fh g eac poe, ebok os o l g e l g t l i s tl taay u h s p w eae a eteni fig f g eac (. Saro’ h n fr e t s e tkn f rhi tli n oa r vne I ) ebok t tr e r t ia l i . d s c m a t ost e h h “i fr ad cp o[ s uas e d r vneo hise o o pi dest ta e wl o w a oy f h] nn w e g eact tenptr ln a t l r i r i c gn a”(d a8 ee l I t. r. . ) B . Poe ua Htr rcdr i oy l s Saro fe t s c o o Sp me 1 21 ( k Ns12 D edn mvd o eboki d h ainn e e b 6 03 D. o - ) e na s oet l i t t r , . t . . f t d m s nAr 721 ( k N 2 ) Sbeun yprunt a od ot sCu, h i i o pl, 04 D. o 1 usqe l u a o n re fh or te s s i . t . . t, s t r i t C y fN wYr fld lt n m g e a D edn wow e n e i ei Saro’ i o e ok i aee a i c t n e na s h e u dnf d n ebok t e tr n ri f t r i ti s i tl o pi .( k N 2 ) Saro fe a a edd o pi (c m a t o ni c m a t D. o 3 eboki d n mne c m a t“o pi ” r ia ln t . . l ln ln “ mne c m a t o Jn 221 ( m C m . D edn rqe etate m in a edd o pi ” n ue, 04 A. o p) e na seus d h h r o o l n) . l f t t t i t t d m sebok i tlla ns e e md rsost te mne c m a t ( k oi i Saro’ ni p d g b de e aepneo h a edd o pi . D. s s s ia e i ln t N 2 ) Saro rsodd yeerc vd nSp me 2 21 ( k N 3 o 8 ebok epne blt ee e o e e b 6 04 D. o 3 . . tr i t r , . t . (Saro B”) D edn’e ym mrnu ws ok e o O oe 821 ( k “ebok r ). e na srp e o d m a dce d n c b , 04 D. .. f t l a t t r . t N 3 ) Saro fe a usqe lt, a dO oe 3 21 w c teCu acp a o 4 eboki d sbeun ee d e c b 1 04 h h h or ce s s . . l t tr t t r , , i t t a u e ym mrnu .( k N 3 (Saro Rp ”. sr p e o d m D. o 6“ebok e y ) rl a t . l) 3 I I . D cs o i uin s s A . Lg Sa dr ea t n ad l O am in oi m s u unt R e 2b 6 a or ms“ce a aea os n n o ot d i pr a o u 1() ) cu u acp l l gini t s s s t l (, t t tll t te o pi atu ad r wlif ecs n h nn mv g a y fvr CyfN wYr h c m a t sre n d a n rnei te o- o n p t’ ao” i o e ok ln a l e i r s . t v Brt U..Cr , 2 F d 8 32 2 C. 08( t n qot nm k o ie) T . ee a . A op 54 . 34 9 (d i 20)i e a u a o a s mtd o t S . 3 , r n r l ti r t . sr v am in oi m s a o pi ms p a “nuha s ot e ci t ri tai uv e o ot d i , c m a t u l d eog fc t st al m oee h s i t s s ln t e t a a lf t p u b oi fc ”BlA.Cr v T o b , 5 US5450 20) “ ci hs a a l s l nt ae e t op . w m y 50 .. 4 7 (07 Al m afcl ai e s . l l . l , . a i p u bi wetelae fc acn na o s h cu t d whraoa en rne l s it hn h p dda u o e l wte or o r teesnb if ec a ily e tl ttl t a l e tate e na il b frh m cnu aee ” sco vIb , 5 US6268 h h d edn si l ote i odc l gd Ahr t. qa 56 .. 6 7 t f t ae s tl . f l , (09 A or wl ocn d m e oc sr aea os h lc aa u bs.Hye 20) cu i n os e e cn uoyl ginta ak fc a a s adn . t l t ir r l l t t tl i v P e o, 9 F d 5 106 (dC. 00 Al nf s o pi “ u aam i u . a r n 54 . 10 6-1 2 i 21) pi i’ c m a t ms t i m m ts 3 , r . a tf ln t n a e nnoc sr fc a mt sf c nt ndet ci s co teier m s r ocn uoya u ae ui e o ugi l m a s hl fo st l t l t r fi t s a rs n t t Y . , 6 . 27 5 (d J 3 , cne a eolu b t poed” E C.Pr A ho N . &N. 78F d 4 24 2 oc vb t p s l o rce. E O v o u .f . i l ai e C. 04(u igIb , 5 USa60(t a os ni en qot nm k o ie) i 21) qo n qa 56 ..t 8)ae t n ad n ra u a o a s mtd r t l l ri t l ti r t . A o pi fe po e ms b cnrel e l t r stetogsag mn i c m a ti d r s “ u e os udi rl oa eh s ne ru e st ln l t t b ay i r t t l 3 , r a t t l ti sge s W kr. cu 77F d 1 14 2 C. 03(rce ad n raqot n ugs. a e vSh t, 1 . 19 2 (d i 21) b k s n i en u a o t” l m k o ie) “ A po e i gni p t u r hu b a odd v yesnb a s mtd [ ] r s lia n ai l so d ef re ee raoa e r t . t t rc a l f r l opr n yo e os a tah hs vi ci . Nle v Rb , 4 F d 86 (dC. po u tt d mnr eh e a a a dl m i sn. a n 76 . 5 2 2 i ti tt t l a ” e i 3 , r 21)i en qot n m k o ie) H wv, po ei g n ms nn h e “ ed 04( t a u a o a s mtd o ee a r sliat u oe e s p a n r l ti r t . r t t tls l f t sf c nt st al m oee tai p u b oi fc ” e h an.N wYr, as ui e ot e ci t ri h sl s l nt ae T c mn v e ok c fi t a a lf t a i e s . i 79F d 2 85 2 C. 04(ecr m ( t n qot nm k o ie) 6 . 81 2 (d i 21) p u a )i e a u a o a s mtd 3 , r r i n r l ti r t . B . E h ui n x as o t Prunt tePsnLia o Rfr A (P R ” a ainead g odin u a o h r o i gin e o m c “ L A, n c o rg i cn t s s t i t t t ) t rn io ocn n mni a o ein fci cno b bog u ite xas o o “uh f of e e n cr c oa al y an e ruh nl h ehuin f sc i t r t l it t t t t 4 a m iriee e e a a aaa e 4 USC§19e ) “Th P R ’ehuin d i s a vr md s sr vlb. 2 ... 97 a []e L A xas o nt t i e i l” (. s t rq r mnapet a i m e us bu psni,we eteiv v gn a eu e e p is ol n a s t ao r ol e h h hyno e ee l i t l l t i ti f tr l r c c m acs r aiu r p oe adwe ete aee xe ie o e r o ete i u s ne o p t l e sds n h h hyl g ecs vfr os m o r r t rc a i , tr l s c h wog”Pr r.Ns e 54US5652 20) “ h pro oteP R i t rdcte rn . o e v u l , 3 .. 1 3 (02 Te up e fh L As oeueh t s , . s qa i ad mrvte ui o psn s t ad ofod o ein oi a t m ad unt ni poeh qat f r oe us nt a r cr c os f cl i e n ty ly i r i f rt fi s opr n yo drs c m a ti enl b o a oighi tt n f fd acs ” po u tt ad s o pi s n ra y e r l w tenii oaee l ae ti e ln t l f el n ia o r . A ao v Ade s 65F d 99 (dC. 01(t a os ni en qot nm k mdr. nr w, 5 . 8 6 2 i 21)ae t n ad n ra u a o a s 3 , r l ri t l ti r o ie) mtd t . “ od t ehu al mpsn smsc m e te d i s a vrv w rcs I re o xas ci , r oe u o pt h a m iriee e poe n r t a i r t le nt t i s i acrac w h h apcb poeu l u s Jhsn.R w y 59F d 04 (dC. n codne i te p ia e rcdr r e ” ono v ol , 6 . 4 5 2 i t l l a l. e 3 , r 20) p cr m( t n qot nm k o ie) Tee u s a d ie n bte 09 (e u a )i e a u a o a s mtd hs r e “ e e nd o yh r i n r l ti r t . l r f t P R, ubte r o g eac poe i e. Jns.Bc, 4 US1928 20) L Ab yh psn r vne rcs t l ” oe v ok 59 .. 9 1 (07 t i i s sf , . “rp ehuin e ad c m inew h n gny da ie adtect apoeu l Poe xas o d mns o pac i a aec’ ed ns n o rri l rcdr r t l t s l h ic a r e bc s n a u cie y e cn uc o e eie w hui ps g o e re y u s ea e o d d a v ss m a fninf c v y i o mo n s m od l l u j it t t ft l t t i r s u u ote ore ft poed g”Wo od.No, 4 US8 9-1 20)“] t c r n h cu oi rce ns od r v g 58 .. 1 09 (06 [ f rte s s i . f , . I nn xas oi ap e fo teae fh [o pi ] aR e 2b 6m inste rp o- huins pa n r m hfc ote c m a t e t rt l n, u 1() )o oi h poe l ( t r t t o 1 i 60 P C . v vhlt r sia a ai mie e ne Mr n.CyfN w ok,N 1 C . 0( K) e c oa et s nfr a v d es ” ai v i o e Yr ie i f t f . ( L) 21 W 1968a* (....Ar2 21)i en qot nm k o ie) R E 02 L 324 t 5 SDNY p 0 02( t a u a o a s mtd , , . , n r l ti r t . “ xas oi mna r uehu e ci s my o b prud nee l or” Ehuins ad oy—nxas dl m a n e u ei fd acu. t t t a t s r t A ao, 5 F dt 6H wv , h Scn C c t arcg zd h e a gr s f mdr 65 . a9 o ee te eod i u hseon etr c eo e o 3 . r ri i e t i “ae st teehuineu e e,we “1a m iriee e e a n aaa eo cva ”o h xas orq r mn h e() d i s a vr md sr o vlb t t t i t r nt t i e t i l te r oe () e na s ae te w vd h d es oflrt ehu oa ei sc h psn ; 2 d edn hve h a ete e ne f a u o xas r c d n uh i r f t i r i f i e t t [ wy s o s p h mr maigh d es o() pcli u s ne sc a a a a at e ote fo r s te e ne r 3se ac c m acs uh s ] t in f ; i r t , raoa em ud s n n ote r vne rcdrs uiyh psn ’flrt c m y esnb i net d g fh g eac poeu , sfte r oe s a u o o p l s ra i i ejt i r i e l 5 w hh ehuineu e e. Rg eo.C yo Oag , 6 F d 7 15 2 C. i te xas o rq r mn ” ug r v n.f rne 47 . 10 7 (d i t t i t i t 3 , r 20)cig e p lv N w ok 30F d 8 66 2 C. 04. 06(t H mhl. e Yr , 8 . 60 8 (d i 20) in i 3 , r ) 1 . C im C nenn C ni os fC n n et l s ocri g o di n o of emn a t i D a es wow h o hlneh r odin ocn n mn tAM Crrq rd ei e h i t caegte cn t s f of e e a tn s l i io i t K a eu e e i t c m yw h h N wYr C yDp t e o Cr c o’ m tp t n a G eac o o p i te e ok i ea mn f o ein ui a I m e r vne l t t r t r t s l- r t i Rs u o Por m“ G P. Se M mn.NYC Dp o Cr ,N 1 C . 05 N B eo t n rg ( R” 4 e a o v ... e’ f o . o 0 i 85( R) li a I ) t r . v , 21 W 208 a* (.... a 2 21) Tapoe poed af l w 02 L 627 t 3 SDNYJn 7 02 h rcs rces s o o s , . , . t s l : A esb iig n ni g eacfr t te n a G eac f r u mt ai tl r vne o m o h I m e r vne t tn ia i t i Rs u o C m ie( G C , h I R hsie as o no ml eo t n o mte“ R ” te G C af dyt ifr a y li t I ) v l rs vtesu ot rv wh g eac Ite G C os orah eo ehi e ro e e te r vne fh I R de n ec a l s i i . t dcinde n rsodw h f e asoiten a de n e s , os o epn i i i dy rf hi m e os o io t tnv , t t cne t te rpsd eo t n h g ea myeusa o m osn o h pooe rs u o te r vn a rqe fr a t li , i t t l ha ni fo ote G C Tu te udns n h g ea t se a e ignrn fh I R. hs h brei ote r vn o ek r t , i t ha ni h de n haaepner m h I R. Atap n te e igf e os o e rsosfo te G C t h o t h r t r t i, I R msi u awt n e s n Ite r vni uhpyw hth G C u s e rt dci . fh g ea s nap i i e ts ie i o i t t , my pe te e s n o h c m ad g f c oteal y ri a apa h dci tte o mn n oie fhfci o h l io i f r it s ds ne hn o h Cn a OieRv wC m ie adia yo h e ge tet te e r f c e e o mte n f l t te i , tl f i t , nl N wYr C yBad fCr c o ( B C . O yf rhs s p a e ok i o o o ein“ O ” n a eteet sr t r rt ) l t e e f l wd a ai m ei s t n h dt ccu. o o e cn n n a fe u i teirt or l t l i si t Jhsn. cr o N 1 C . 29 H)21 W 5144a* (....O. 521) ono vSh r, o 2 i 73 (W P 03 L 787 t 3 SDNY c 1 03 i . v , , t , (tin ad n raqot nak o ie) “ e G P rcdrslo d sta‘f o ca os ni en u a o m s mtd . T I R poeu a av eh i yu it t l ti r t h e s i t d n rc v a epne o or r vnet n s p fh G eac Poeu w h te o o ee e rsost yu g eac aayt ote r vne rcdr i i h t i i e i e tn t m p ideu e[ yumy rcet te e s p fh G eac Poeu. R ea. i e e o rq rd] o a poed o h nx t ote r vne rcdr’ i r v r i , te i e” v N w okCy N 1 C. 6( L) 21 W 6679a* (....Nv1 21) e Yr i , o 2 i 70 D C 03 L 015 t 2 SDNY o 8 03 t . v , , . , (n rab ce adl p s mtd i en r k s n eis o ie) t l a t l i t . 4 TeCu tks u cl oc ote G P s or rg a y o n h dt c Se e. h or aejdi n ie fh I R, cuseu r di t sirt e,., t ia t a t ll i si. g Me v CyfN wYr N 1 C . 55 P E 21 W 3777a * n (.... yr . i o e ok, o 1 i 82 ( A) 02 L 760 t 4. SDNY s t . v , , 6 Ag2 21) TeI R d eie h ws nf cdr g h apcb t m p ids u 9 02 h G Pi c v ta ai e e u n te p ia e e e oi . , . rt t ft i l li r aaa eoteDp t e o Cr c o’ wbt Se NYC Dp o Cr c o D eie vlb n h ea mn f o ein ese e ... e’ f o ein i c v i l r t rt s i. t rt , rt 37 R A e eie a 1 20t Sp 921) aa a et 35- ( fc vM . 3 08 o e., 02 v lb a f t r , t , i l h p/ w.y gv t l o d w od pf 35-.d t : w w c o h m dc o n as d 37 R A f t/ n. / / / l / / p. 6 I s pa nfo teae fh a edd o pi taSaro fld o xas t ap e r m hfc ote mne c m a t h ebokae t ehu i rt ln t i t a m iriee e e aaa e o h cn t n ocn n mnci sH fe o y n d i s a vr md s vlb fri odi s f of e e l m e i d n a nt t i i l s io i t a . l l i tl r vnen d n rqe a o m ha n o o e w e o iutruh h I R ni g eacadi o eus fr a e ig rt ri cn ne hogte G P ia i d t t l r h s t apa poe.W lte o pi a es h Saro rc vd o e y r e s n n pe s rcs heh c m a t s r ta ebok ee e n rp o dci i l s i l n st t i l io rsost h i tl r vne“]i wl eld h ai m ewoee e n rsost epne oi ni g eac [ts e st ta n n a h rc vs oepneo s ia i ,i l te t t i h g eac mscn new h h nx s pite r vne rcs ”T e v Ag ,N 1 i r vne u o iu i te e t s nh g eac poe . y r. ro o 4 si t t t t e i s l . C . 09( ) D F 21 W 5728a* (....O. 021)seloR ea i 24 CM( C) 04 L 344 t 4 SDNY c 1 04;e a i r, v , , t , s v 21 W 6679a* ( Bcueh P R i pss n n n a te u t ehu a 03 L 015 t 6 “ easte L A moe o ai m eh d yo xas l , t t tl aaa ee e e ad h I R mks n pe aaa eai m emsfe n pe i h vlb r md s nte G P ae a apa vlb, n n a u i a apa f e i l i, l i l t tl l w hs o rp l ehu h a m iriee e e eei n ain a betkn n i et poe y xas i d i s a vr md s vnf o c o hs enae o a s r t s nt t i t g eac ateitee ” r vnet hfslv.) i r l . Te p ia e aea “os oecs aa u t ehu we ai m e l nf h apcb csl w de n xue flr o xas hn n n a/ a tf l l t i e t t pi i a mtd d n apat teihsaaa eeeoa m iriee e ad rv e n d ie yi o pe o h h e vlb lv f d i s a vrv w n po ds o t l d t l g t i l l nt t i i r . v , jsf b ep nin o h flrt d s ” ere. Mr sn N 0 C . 18 S S ui a e x aa o fri a u o o o Gog v o io , o 6 i 38( A) ti l l t si e . 20 W 1831a* &.2 SDNYJn 1 20)cig e y.Kr , 6 F d 5 07 L 662 t 4 n (.... ue 1 07(t Br v e k 36 . 8 , 5 , in r i 3 , 8 (dC. 04.Saro sts n tah c m idw h hfs s p fh I R 8 2 i 20) ebokt e o yh e o pe i teit t ote G P r ) a l t l t r e poeu b fig g eac “ te r vne f c” fAM C ( m C m .t. Ad rcdr yi n a r vne a h g eac oie o e l i t i f K. A. o p a7 n l ) w l h sts h h “i fr ad cp o[ s uas e d r vne o hise o he et eta e wl o w a oy f h] nn w e g eact tenpc r i a t l r i r i t gn a (da8 t s de n cni t atp te G P d i s a v poe, Jns. ee l i t ) h “os o ost e s i h I R a m irie rcs ” oe v r” . , i t tu en nt t s R e I adCr Cs d ,N 0 C . 01( S 21 W 181 a* (.... a i r s n ae u oy o 7 i 144 RW) 00 L 466 t 2 SDNYJn ksl t . v , , . 1 21) d m s g o pi fra u t ehu we pi i hd o a ete npc r 4 00( s i i c m a t oflr o xas h el nf a cn c d h Ise o , i sn ln i e t r a tf tt t Gn as f c. A cr n y Saro’ cn t n ocn n mnci sr d m sd ee l oie c od g, ebok odi s f of e e l m a i i e r’ f ) il s io i t a e s s w hup jd e io ruc t t e i. 7 H wv ,[]t ccus ae ostn y e taa a m iriee eys o o ee “dsi or hv cn s t h d h n d i s a vr mdi n r irt t i el l t nt t t aaa eo n n a wos oifr e ote r vne rcdr ”R ea 21 W vlb t ai m e hi n no md fh g eac poeu. i r , 03 L i l t t i e v 6679a* (t g ae.I Saro p as p m s ljsf a o friflrt 015 t 4ci css f ebokl d a e i i eui cin o h a u o , in ) e r s b ti t si e ehu i a a edd o pi , h mye v h ci s O e w e fSaro w hs o xas n n mne c m a t i a rv e i l m t ri , ebok i et t l nt s i s a . h si s poedw hi cs h msfe n w c o a e ehuigh apcb g eac rce i h ae e u i a e ainf r xas nte p ia e r vne t s , tl t t t l l i mca s s ehn m i . 2 . A al a d Hrs etC im s u n aa s t smn l s a A a t n h a mnci su ieh o eci s a ec ddr m h I R s u ad a s e l m n ktet rl m ,r x ue fo te G P sl rs t a , l h a e l t t . C , , poe.Se at.CyfN wYr,N 1-V 50 ( E)21 W 3054a* rcs e Tr v i o e ok o 2 -45 V C 04 L 729 t 3 s (.. YJ y 621) Rg d s o we e te i ay d i s a v g eac poe SD.. u 1 04 ea l s f h h h es n a m irie r vne rcs N l , . re tr r nt t i s ta decv a a t n h a mnci st K , o ee ai u tateC y a n h osoe s u ad a s e l m aAM C h wv t r sl rs t a r— s e h h i hs o ns t t t b e d ebok a a t n h a mnci sa o o e gons r f —Saro’ s u ad a s e l mfl nt r rud. ie s sl rs t a i h Te mne c m a tt e o ya a ee l mt, h d a eswo ne ay h a edd o pi sts n, s gn a ae ta ei e h “ed n ln a l r tr t t n tp o a i ac”r mAM Ct fwl e u e et h miinh a mn ad ye f s s nefo st K s f i b sb c d o u i a o a s e , n a l jt lt , r s t s mi e a a t ( m C m .t. Te o pi de n aeeh Saro sf rd o e ms s u. A. o p a5 h c m a t os o l gta ebok u e t sl l ) ln tl t fe sc h mh wv , n al nf poed g r s cn ersn o yi s f SeGe v uh a , o ee ad pi i rce n po e a rp e n h me. e us . r r a tf i e t l l t 3 , r r t t ai Hne , 0 F d 52 (dC. 00( A e o wo a n be a mtd o h p cc o asn 63 . 1 0 2 i 21)“ p sn h hs o en d iet te r t e f l wmy orp snayoyteta h me.. F te mr w hua aea ota a a n er e nbd o rhni s f) u h o, i o nl gin h t e t h l” r r e t t l t t Saro h me ws n rd n onc o w hi ci s f sa t n h a mn hlcs eboki s f ai u i cnein i h l m oa u ad a s e, eak l je t t s a sl rs t s n nt r ste.Se Mhn.T o TlIs C , 8 F d 96 (dC. 02 t d goa eh m e ao v i r ie n o 63 . 5 2 2 i 21) ai i c t . . 3 , r ( e os a ntate e na ’ aee y n wucnu cuei uyo h pi i “ mnrigh h d edn sl gd u a f odc asd n rt tel nf D tt t f t l l l l t j a tf h s fs .gn a y n se i c moe o Ai eIs n n ” e e i ..ee l a e na o pnn f rc I t d g) rl rl s tl t tl I a i .. I h opsin o h m in Saro ci s oteiti eh h ws sb c d ni pot t te o o ebokl mfrhfst mta e a “u e e s io t , a r t jt t cn o a o(, bs ad sa t ) yte psn (. (ebokB a2 p e hss n o of nt n )aue n a u( b o r r oe s ” Saro r t (a n eei r ti s s ls h i r) . rt 8 o g a. H wv, scal mis n i al nfaee “e b a idf ec” h r i l ) o ee uh ci l o y f pi i l gs die t n f rne i n) r a e l a tf l l r e ie —ta t i “ psn f cl my e e l b ud teE h A ed e fr ey g u ae s a r o oi a a b h di l ne h i t mn mn o dn nh mn , i fi l ae r gh t i cn t n ocn n mn o yf e n wtai m efc a us nar k f e os a m odi s f of e e n i h ko s h n a sae sb a i i os iu h io i t l t t t tl s r r adi eadtar k yaigoaeesnb mau s o b et Fr e v Benn n drg s h i b fl t tk raoa e esr t aa i” a mr. rna , s r ts in l e t . 51US8587 19) H e Saro mks olea ota“ r c os f c s n w 1 .. 2 4 (94 e, ebok ae n a gin h c r t n oie ke , . r l t t o ei f r oadi eadd p t u rik oi s e . Mra v CyfN wYr 1 C . 8 f n drg e a ai l r t h a t ” ogn. i o e ok, 2 i 22 s r rc a s s fy t v ( L) R E 21 W 3597a* (....Ag1 21) Acr n y hci s A C( L) 04 L 921 t 3 SDNY u 2 04 cod g, e a m , , . , . ilt l p m e o a a t n h a mn a a oi m sd r i d n s u ad a s e r l d i e e s sl rs t e s s s . C . P itf Ag et l nf s r umn a i’ s I h opsin o h m in oi m s Saro rqe s h e r oa e u ni pot t te o ot d i , ebokeus te n y f d a t s io t s s t t fl jd mn (ebokB a1 Bcueh es o rud oa e u, h rqe i dn d ug e. Saro r t. easte i n gon fr d a t eeus s e e t . ) r f lt t i. I h sr pym mrnu ,Saro ci s h h ws er e o ncsay ni u e s r l e o d m ebokl mta e a dp vd f ee r a a t i s md a os yAM Ct fadi stesu e ol wic d gh A e cn w h e cin b it K s f n ce o r or s fa ( l i te m ias i a t h c nun r t D a lisA adt e et p vcl w ta h ci sw e rahd yh cn t n o i bie c n st ha h r aya s h el m e b ce bte odi s f s it t a l i ) t a r e io cn n mna AM C (ebokRpyt. H wv, e os oepi wy hs o e of e e t i t K. Saro e a2 o ee h de n x a h teet r l ) r t ln h ci sa origr m odin ateal y wu n a o e a e b h flrt l m l as fo cn t st hfci , o d o l b b rd yi a u o a , s in io it l ts r si e g lt n , . v , ehu a m iriee e e Se e. V e ie.L da N 1 C . 6 ( G( A xas d i s a vr md s e,., a n n v i sy o 0 i 88J )JM ) t nt t i. 21 W 3421a* n 6 EDNY Ag1 21) n igh “ D v lin a 01 L 686 t 7. (.... u 7 01(o nta A Ai a osr , 1 . , t t ot e sb ctteP R ” n i ehuineu e e ) u e oh L A adt xas o rq r mn. jt s t i t D . D ae amgs Al nfcn nd n jl an b n afd ac ir h ain o c mes oy pi i of ei aa cno r g ee li li t c o fr o pna r a tf i i ti r v gs t t d mgs frmnl r m in i uy u e dw li cs d w hua r r h w g f a ae “o e ao e o oa n r sf r hen u oy i o p osoi o t t lj fe i t t t i n py c i uy 4 USC§ 97 e se h msn.Cr r 24F d 1 471 (dC. hs a n r ” 2 ... 19e ) e To po v a e, 8 . 41 1-8 2 i il j . (; t 3 , r 20) H wv , 19e ) de n p vna r oefo o a ig n nie r 02 o ee § 97 e “os o r e psn r m bi ni uc v o . r ( t e t i r tn j t 9 dc r oyee ” o dei“ m te vlbi o n m ad mgs otei a o oa e a tr ri , nr ost l i h aaa l y f o i l a aefrh v lin f la lf it i it n ot cni t n r h o o pnie a ae ”To po , 8 F dt 1 T a edd ost i a i t r f u t d mgs h msn 24 . a48 h mne tuo l g iv . 3 . e c m a t os o p u b aee n py c i uy SeBo n.De N 1 C . 49 o pi de n l s l l g ay hs a n r. e r w v o, o 3 i 80 ln t ai y l il j . v ( R 21 W 5685a*-0 SDNY O. 821)d m s gpsn ’rqe fr E) 04 L 411 t 91 (.... c 2 04(s i i r oe seus o , , t , i sn i r t c mes oy a aefr mnl nu h . Tu eei Saro fe a a edd o pna r d mgs o“ e aag s” hs vnf eboki s n mne t t i ) , l c m a t h Cu n etah c m a t aea oswu n p m h rqe fr 5 o pi , e or o s h i o pi ’ l gin o d o e i i eus o $ l nt t t t s l ns l t l t rt s t ml nn o pna r d mgs o y rqe frtetps f a ae o i uc vri ii i c mes oy a ae n a eus oo r ye o d mgs r n nieee lo t ; l t h j t lf wu sr v o d uv e l i. E . Lae oAmn evt ed Prunt R e 5 fh Fd a R e o C i Poeu,evt a ed hu b u a o u 1 ote ee l u s f i l rcdr laeo mn so d e s t l r l v e l g n d f e. Fd R C .P1( () Fr e mr “apo ec m a t hu n b r t “ e y e . i . 5 )2 u h o, [ r s o pi so d o e a e rl” . v a . tr e ] ln l t d m sdw huteCu g n nlaeo mn ala oc we aie l ed g fh i i e i o h or r t gevt a edtes ne hn l r ra n ote s s t t t ai t ba i i i 3 c m a tie ayn cin h a a dl m m h b s td Ca s.Cap s 68F d o pi g s nid a ota vi ci i t et e ” hv v hp u , 1 . ln v it t l a g a . 1210 2 C. 00(rce ad n raqot nm k o ie) Bcueh Cu 6 7 (d i 21) b k s ni en u a o a s mtd easte or , r a t t l ti r t . t cn ueta Saro cu a edi c m a t ot e vi ci t ri ,evt oc ds h ebok o d mn h o pi t st a a dl m oee laeo l t l s ln a l a lf a eds rn d mni g t . ae I. V Cn u o oc s n li F te o g n raosD edn’m in od m ss R N E . l nfi o hfr o g e n e na s o ot i i i G A T D Pi i s r ei s , f t t s s a tf g n devt fe scn a edd o pi . A a edd o pi fr i aahd o r t laeoi a eod mne c m a t n mne c m a t o mst cet ae l ln ln t t s re I Pi i w hs oi a eod mne c m a thid e et sni b h od. f l nf i et fe scn a edd o pi , esi c d o edt y i r a tf s l ln rt ml oh PoS Oie fh Cu, 0 Pa S e,Ro 20 N wYr N wYr a tte r e f c ot s or 50 e l t e o m 0 e ok e ok i f i t r rt , , 107b Jnay 521 00 y au 1 05 , r , . 1 0 TeC r o teori drc d oe m a te m int ok n me 2 h l k f hCu s i t t t i t h o o adce u b 1 e t ee r ne t t r . S O DRD O R E E. D e Dc me 1, 04 a d ee b 621 t: r N w ok N wYr e Yr e ok , __________________ _________________ JP U O T E . AL EKN UtdStsDt cJde ne t e irt ug i a si C P M I E T P OS P R Y O Y AL D O R E A T 1 1
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
