Starr Indemity & Liability Company v. American Claims Management, Inc., No. 1:2013cv00742 - Document 36 (S.D.N.Y. 2014)
Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER. Starr's invocation of the attorney-client privilege and the work-product doctrine is rejected with the two exceptions noted in the Opinion and Order. (Signed by Judge Denise L. Cote on 4/8/2014) (gr)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
UIE SAE DSRC CUT NTD TTS ITIT OR SUHR DSRC O NWYR OTEN ITIT F E OK ------------------- X ------------------: SARIDMIY&LAIIYCMAY TR NENT IBLT OPN, : : Panif litf, : -v : : AEIA CAM MNGMN,IC, MRCN LIS AAEET N. : : Dfnat eedn. : : ------------------- X ------------------- 1 Cv 72(L) 3 i. 4 DC OIINADODR PNO N RE APAACS PERNE FrtePanif o h litf: Jsi Ken Toa Chl utn li, hms ail SteleSehn Bre&BreLP atre tpes uk uk L 20Pr Aeu 3 ak vne NwYr,N 11907 e ok Y 06-09 FrteDfnat o h eedn: Toa J MCrak St Kulk hms . comc, eh rga Cabun &PreLP hdore ak L 3 RceelrPaa 0 okfle lz NwYr,N 112 e ok Y 01 DNS CT,Dsrc Jde EIE OE itit ug: PanifSarIdmiy&LaiiyCmay(Sar) litf tr nent iblt opn tr ivkstewr-rdc dcrn adteatre-let noe h okpout otie n h tonycin piieet spotisca-ako dcmnspoue i ti rvlg o upr t lwbc f ouet rdcd n hs ltgto. Frteraosstfrhblw Sars iiain o h esn e ot eo, tr apiaini dne wt almtdecpin plcto s eid ih iie xeto. 1 BCGON AKRUD Ti ato,fldo Fbur 1 21,cnen hs cin ie n eray , 03 ocrs algtosta Aeia Cam Mngmn Ic (AM) leain ht mrcn lis aaeet n. C ipoel hnld7 isrnecam o bhl o Sar mrpry ade 7 nuac lis n eaf f tr prun t acam srie areet Fc dsoeyi usat o lis evcs gemn. at icvr s cretyshdldt coeo Arl2,21. urnl ceue o ls n pi 2 04 Drn teMrh2,21 dpsto o McalHlso uig h ac 7 04 eoiin f ihe aike (Hlso ,acam mngra Sar Sarojce t AMs aike) lis aae t tr, tr betd o C ueo aJl 21 emi can(Emi btenHlso ad s f uy 02 -al hi -al) ewe aike n aohrSarcam mngr DbrhCak(Cak) wih nte tr lis aae, eoa lr lr , hc md rfrnet alte peae b Sarslclcusli ae eeec o etr rprd y tr oa one n Mcia (Lte . Floigatlcneec wt teCut ihgn etr) olwn eeofrne ih h or, tedpsto poeddwtotqetosaotteEmi,ad h eoiin rcee ihu usin bu h -al n teprismd witnsbisosrgrigSarscam h ate ae rte umsin eadn tr li ta teEmi adLte wr poetdb bt teatreht h -al n etr ee rtce y oh h tony cin piieeadtewr-rdc dcrn. let rvlg n h okpout otie TeLte,wihwsas poue t AMi dsoey i h etr hc a lo rdcd o C n icvr, s fu pgsln,dtdJl 2,21,adwitnt Cak Te or ae og ae uy 3 02 n rte o lr. h Lte bgn b dsrbn teatre asgmn,wihws etr eis y eciig h tonys sinet hc a t rve anme o n-al I cam smais Tee o eiw ubr f ofut PP1 lis umre. hs 1 I rfr t esnlIjr Poeto adi gnrly PP ees o Proa nuy rtcin n s eeal a etnino atmbl isrneta cvr sm mdcl n xeso f uooie nuac ht oes oe eia epne adls wgsrsligfo ijre ssandi a xess n ot ae eutn rm nuis utie n n atmbl acdn. uooie ciet 2 wr lrels cam frctsrpi ijre. TeLte ee ag os lis o aatohc nuis h etr cnb bodycaatrzda gvn bsns avc. Te a e ral hrceie s iig uies die h Lte ato daso hsfmlaiywt fadln cam etrs uhr rw n i aiirt ih ruuet lis adietfe rdfasfrSart b aaeo we n dniis e lg o tr o e wr f hn cnutn a adto AMswr frSar odcig n ui f C ok o tr. Toprgah o teLte cnanrfrne t a w aarps f h etr oti eeecs o Mcia saueadpatcso jde i apyn istrs ihgn ttt n rcie f ugs n plig t em. Bt teeprgah aenttefcso teLte. u, hs aarps r o h ou f h etr Sgiiaty teEmi mksrfrnet ol tebsnsinfcnl, h -al ae eeec o ny h uies rltdcnlsoso teLte,nttelmtddsuso o eae ocuin f h etr o h iie icsin f tesaue h ttt. DSUSO ICSIN Sarrle picplyo tewr-rdc dcrn i tr eis rnial n h okpout otie n seigt rdc teprin o teEmi ta mk rfrne ekn o eat h otos f h -al ht ae eeec t tecnlsoso teLte. I as rle o te o h ocuin f h etr t lo eis n h atre-letpiiee Ec isei adesdi tr. tonycin rvlg. ah su s drse n un Wr-rdc Dcrn okPout otie Tewr-rdc dcrn gat qaiidpoeto t h okpout otie rns ulfe rtcin o aeil peae b o a tebhs o cusli mtras rprd y r t h eet f one n atcpto o ltgto o frtil I r GadJr niiain f iiain r o ra. n e rn uy Sbon DtdJl 6 20,50F3 10 13(dCr 20) upea ae uy , 05 1 .d 8, 8 2 i. 07 3 (iainoitd;seFd R Cv P 2()3() Adcmn ctto mte) e e. . i. . 6b()A. ouet i peae natcpto o ltgto i, nlgto te s rprd i niiain f iiain f i ih f h ntr o tedcmn adtefculstaini te aue f h ouet n h ata iuto n h priua cs,tedcmn cnfil b si t hv be atclr ae h ouet a ary e ad o ae en peae o otie bcueo tepopc o ltgto. rprd r band eas f h rset f iiain Uie Sae v Ala,14F3 19,10 (dCr 19) ntd tts . dmn 3 .d 14 22 2 i. 98 (iainoitd. Tewr-rdc dcrn de ntpoet ctto mte) h okpout otie os o rtc dcmns rprdi teodnr cus o bsns o ta ouet peae n h riay ore f uies r ht wudhv be cetdi esnilysmlrfr irsetv ol ae en rae n setal iia om repcie o teltgto. I.a 10. Tepryivkn te f h iiain d t 22 h at noig h dcrn bas h haybre o etbihn is otie er te ev udn f salsig t apiaiiy GadJr Sbon,50F3 a 13 plcblt. rn uy upea 1 .d t 8. Sarhsfie t cryisbre o poigta teE tr a ald o ar t udn f rvn ht h mi o teLte i poetdb tewr-rdc dcrn. al r h etr s rtce y h okpout otie TeLte de ntsaeo ipyta i wspeae bcue h etr os o tt r ml ht t a rprd eas o tepopc o atcptdltgto btenSaradAM f h rset f niiae iiain ewe tr n C, adSarhsntpeetdayafdvtt spotadfeet n tr a o rsne n fiai o upr ifrn assmn o iscnet Rte,a teato epan,h seset f t otx. ahr s h uhr xlis e wsmrl akdt rve cam smais Acrigy a eey se o eiw lis umre. codnl, nihrteEmi nrteLte i poetdb tewrete h -al o h etr s rtce y h ok poutdcrn. rdc otie Sarmksesnilytoagmnsi rsos,nihr tr ae setal w ruet n epne ete o wihi prusv. Frt Saratmt t cnette f hc s esaie is, tr teps o onc h 4 Lte t ti ltgto. I pit t tefc ta i etr o hs iiain t ons o h at ht t cnutdfv adt i Jl adAgs o 21,ta te odce ie uis n uy n uut f 02 ht h Lte wswitndrn ti tm pro,adta ti etr a rte uig hs ie eid n ht hs ltgto ge oto teadt. Bt Sarrglry iiain rw u f h uis u, tr eual cnut adt a pr o isbsns. Teeitneo a odcs uis s at f t uies h xsec f n adtde ntidct ta teLte wswitnbcueo ui os o niae ht h etr a rte eas f tepopc o ltgto. Ayohrcnlso wudsep h rset f iiain n te ocuin ol we alcrepnec wt cusldrn adt it tewrl orsodne ih one uig uis no h ok poutdcrn. rdc otie Scn,SarctsGinl Cr.v ITCr. 2 FRD eod tr ie rnel op . T op, 2 ... 7,7 (....20) Ntigi ti Oiin hwvr i i 4 7 SDNY 03. ohn n hs pno, oee, s n tninwt Ginl. Sarhsfie t me isbre t eso ih rnel tr a ald o et t udn o so ta teLte wsntpeae i teodnr cus o hw ht h etr a o rprd n h riay ore f isbsns. t uies Atre-letPiiee tonyCin rvlg Tesadr frivcto o teatre-let h tnad o noain f h tonycin piieei wl etbihd I poet cmuiain 1 rvlg s el salse. t rtcs omnctos () btenacin adhso hratre ()ta aeitne ewe let n i r e tony 2 ht r nedd t b,adi fc wr,kp cnieta ()frteproe o e n n at ee et ofdnil 3 o h ups o otiigo poiiglglassac. BennCr fr f bann r rvdn ea sitne rna t. o Jsiea NUSho o Lwv US Dpto Jsie 67F3 utc t Y col f a . .. e f utc, 9 .d 14 27(dCr 21)(iainoitd. 8, 0 2 i. 02 ctto mte) 5 Temr fc ta atresaeivle i a h ee at ht tony r novd n cmuiainde ntcoki wt piiee T qaiyfr omncto os o la t ih rvlg. o ulf o tepiiee acmuiainms b eeae frte h rvlg, omncto ut e gnrtd o h proeo otiigo poiiglglavc a opsdt ups f bann r rvdn ea die s poe o bsns avc. I r Cut o Ei,43F3 43 49(d uies die n e ony f re 7 .d 1, 1 2 Cr 20)(mhssadd. I dtriigteproeo a i. 07 epai de) n eemnn h ups f cmuiain cut cnie hte tepeoiatproe omncto, ors osdr wehr h rdmnn ups ...i t rne o slctlglavc. I.a 40 s o edr r oii ea die d t 2. Lea avc ivle teitrrtto adapiaino []gl die novs h nepeain n plcto f lglpicpe t gieftr cnuto t ass ps ea rnils o ud uue odc r o ses at cnut I.a 49 A aoe tepryivkn te odc. d t 1. s bv, h at noig h piieebas h haybre o etbihn is rvlg er te ev udn f salsig t apiaiiy GadJr Sbon,50F3 a 13 plcblt. rn uy upea 1 .d t 8. Sarhsfie t cryisbre o poigta te tr a ald o ar t udn f rvn ht h Lte adEmi aepoetdb teatre-let etr n -al r rtce y h tonycin piiee TeLte lreyofr assmnso tecam. rvlg. h etr agl fes seset f h lis Bt a epandaoe teeaebsns assmns nt u, s xlie bv, hs r uies seset, o lglavc. Smlry teEmi rfr ol t tebsns ea die iial, h -al ees ny o h uies cnlsosi teLte. Tu,nihrdcmn i poetd ocuin n h etr hs ete ouet s rtce b teatre-letpiiee wt tefloigecpin y h tonycin rvlg, ih h olwn xeto: Sarmyrdc fo teLte tetoprgah o pg 3 tr a eat rm h etr h w aarps n ae dsusn teMcia saue T teetn ta Sarses icsig h ihgn ttt. o h xet ht tr ek t poetayohrdcmn fo dsoey i salflo o rtc n te ouet rm icvr, t hl olw 6 tegiac stfrhi ti Oiin h udne e ot n hs pno. CNLSO OCUIN Sarsivcto o teatre-letpiieeadte tr noain f h tonycin rvlg n h wr-rdc dcrn i rjce wt tetoecpin ntd okpout otie s eetd ih h w xetos oe hri. een S ODRD O REE: Dtd ae: NwYr,NwYr e ok e ok Arl8 21 pi , 04 _________________ _________________ DNS CT EIE OE Uie Sae Dsrc Jde ntd tts itit ug 7
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
