The United States of America v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. et al., No. 1:2013cv00220 - Document 57 (S.D.N.Y. 2014)
Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER re: 49 MOTION for Leave to File AMENDED MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO INTERVENE AND AMENDED REPLY AS IT RELATES TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'S OBJECTION, 37 MOTION to Intervene, 26 MOTION to Interven e. For the foregoing reasons, Viola and Kelley's motions to intervene are DENIED. Viola's request for documents is DENIED. Kelley's request that the settlement agreement be stayed is DENIED. The Clerk of Court is directed to close the motions at docket numbers 26, 37, and 49, and to close this case. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge J. Paul Oetken on 10/31/2014) Copies Mailed By Chambers. (ja)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
The United States of America v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. et al. Doc. 57 U I E S A E DS RC C U T NT D T T S I TI T O R S U H R DS RC O N O T E N I TI T F EWY R OK ------------------------------------------------------------X : U I E S A E O AM RC,e r. NT D T T S F EI A x e l : KI HE A D, ET DW R S : : Pi i , : l nf a tf : -v : : : J M R A C A EB N,NA ad P P O G N H S A K .. n J , M R A C A E&C P N, O G N HS OM A Y : : D edn . : e na s f t ------------------------------------------------------------X 1- V 20J O 3C -2 (P ) OI I NA DO D R PN O N R E J P U O T E,Dt cJde . A L E K N irt ug si : I Jnay 03R a rKt E w d bog t s ut m c o o bh f fh n au 21 et e h d a s ruh h q a ain n ea ot e r , lo i r ti i t l U tdSts fA e c aa s D edn J Mra CaeBn NA ad P Mra ne t e o m ia g n e na s P ogn hs ak .. n J ogn i a r it f t , , Cae&C may(oeie, J C . Te aews e e u i Fbu y, 04 we hs o pn c lc v y“PM ” h cs asa d nl era 421 hn l t l ) l t r , teoen e e c d o n ree ( k N 7 O Fbu y, 04 h Cu apoea hGv mn l t t i evn D. o . n era 521 te or prvd r t ee t . t .) r , t st mna ogh U tdStsJ CadE w d ud w c J C g et py 64 el e mnte ne t e PM, n d a s ne h h PM ar d o a $1 te t i a, r, r i e ml n t teGv n e.( k N 8 At ut ne e d n M c 721 d e m e ii l o o h oe mn D. o . s p a o n r o a h, 04 e r i d r t t . ) i li , t e r ,t n E w d’sa oteel mn poed ( k N.. T s oc dd h sb ac ote d a ss h e fh st e rces D. o 9 h cn uete us ne fh r r te t . t ) i l t cs ae . B o My 621 nna yA hn L V l ( V l” poed gr s, ld u n a 1 04 op t n oy . i a “i a , rce npo efe a t , , r t o o ) i i m inon reen h ainadeus d e a dc mn.( k N 2 )i arqe s o oti evni te c o nrqe e c t n ou e s D. o 6 V l eus t t t t ri t t . . o t cp s f hla feud l nteGv n e ’ c m a t n h cs tafe b o e oteonis ne y gh oe mns o pi i t s ae h i s e i l ri r t ln i ; tl po ddoh U tdStsA ony OienO o oa e r ia o o we ete a rv ette ne t e t re’ f ci h fr d e m t n f h hrhyr i i a t s f i t ni t e r ea t V l s r m acs ad lt f eod ud sai t s ae J C n te e vn o i a c i l ae n ai orcrs ne e n h cs PM ad h l t o’ i n ; s r l i . Gv n e opste eus ( k Ns3 3 ) oe mn poeh rqe. D. o 2 3 r t t t . , . 1 Dockets.Justia.com O Jn 2 21 ao e nna y rce n po e F n s M Kl , ld n ue 5 04 n h op t poed g r s, r c e . ee fe a , , tr r i ai ly i dc mncp oe a a “ m gny M in o n ree ( k N 3 )S ctat m se ou e a ind s n E e ec o ot I evn ” D. o 7 i eh i e h t t r t t . t . . n t hsmd a e e o fig w h h Cu, n u naeust fe n mne rqe t a ae s is f i ns i t s or ic d g rqe oi a a edd eus o r l t i t li t l t i evn I Sp me,h Cu g n dee ’rqe tate u n o h m ino n ree n e e b te or r t Kly seus h hr ig n e o ot t . t r t ae l t t l r t i evn b d aeu i a eO oe 621 s tase o did onet rp ee h n ree e e ydnl f r c b , 04 o h h cu f cus oer sn e t l t t t r , t l n l t r it s ae Tat m hs o pse ad o pe ac hs en n rd nKly bh f nh cs h i e a n w a d n n apa ne a be e e o ee’ ea. i . t s, r te l s l I . Lg Sa dr ea t n ad l Ud R e 4 fh Fd a R e o C i Poeu, nna ymyn reena ne u 2 ote ee l u s f i l rcdr a op t ai evni n r l r l v e r t aini d y o en e e Tecu ms p m i evn o a amt or hfr ais c o fe b s moel . h or u e i n re in s ae fi t o p t t l s t t rtt t tr g re woci ai e si te rp t ot naintsuta wu n b po c d y h l m n n r t n h poe y rr sc o ai eh o d o e r e e b a te r a t s t l t tt e s n p t s o h ain Fd R C .P2(. Te ora omy e m i evn ob a xt g ai t te c o. e . i . 4 ) h cu l a p i n re iny ii re t . v a ts rtt t p t wo hs ci o d estasa sw h h m n c o ac m o qein fa o a y h “ a al m r e neh h e i te a ain o mn us o ol w r r a f t r t i t t fc” Fd R C .P2()1 I dc ig m in o n ree“ e or mscn d a. e . i . 4b ) n e d a o ot i evn t cu u os e t . v (. in t t , h t t ir we eten re inwl nu d a o p jd eh a u cinote r iap t s h h hi evn o i ud y e y r r u cte d d a o f h o g l ai ’ tr t t l l l e i j it i n re r h. Fd R C .P2()3 i t” e . i . 4b ) gs . v (. I dc igwe e a a y ateih oacst jdi rcrscus m o t o ned i n h h p t hs h r t fce o u cleod or e p y w tr r g s ia , t l “ l e b dt cp s m ini fvr f u i acst cu .. eod atog o m r a d u ii t r u p os nao o pbc ce o or . rcrs s n fr et t s n e t l s t : r ro dnh Fs A ed e ad s g l waefr bsd nee l o mna. o eite it mn mn n al h y ek o aei fd ac m ol w t r t it r m r ” N wdyL C.C yo Nsa , 3 F d 5 13 2 C. 03 B h rs m in aah e sa L v n.f a u 70 . 16 6 (d i 21) o p u p ost c t s 3 , r . t e t t o yojdi dc mn. Lgsh.Pr m C o Oodg , 3 F d 1 19 2 C. n t “ i a ou e s uoc v yai o f nnaa 45 . 10 1 (d i l u cl t” d . 3 , r 20) U e te ou e ii e e dnen t aos m ayug e m ini w c 06 n s h dc mn st l v eci arl r u m jd mn o o — h h . ls t sf i i r t t n i cste rs m in p is s mt ol wi —or cn d sv afc ri aeh p u p o ape a a ae fa, dcus os e ee la o n e t l tr . t ir r ts d e m igwe e a ou e i “ di. C ea og h mswe e o n te orhs e r i n h h dc mn sj i a” h f mnt e i h h r o h cu a t n tr t u cl i tr t t 2 rid nh dc mni te x c e ftjdi fnin I ( T et mi dms b ee ote ou e n h ee i oi u cl uc o d “ ] i fe u e l t rs s ia t . .[h e l t r ea t te e o mne fhjdi fnin n ueui teu cl rcs ” e vn o h p fr ac oteu cl uc o ad s l n hjdi poe.. l t r ia t f ia s) I I . At o yV l’ Mt n o n ree n t Usa Rcrs nh n i a o o t It vn a d o ne eod o s i e l I 21 V l ws ovtd y fd ajri teNr enDt co O o o n 01 i a a cn c b aee l uyn h o h , o ie r t r irt f h fr si i o esst m igr m mr aeru sh m SeU tdt e v V l,N 0-V 56 f nes m fo a o ggf d ce e e ne S ts. i a o 8 -0 f e n t a . i a o . C , 21 W 3425a* (..O o u 2 21) V l ws e ecd o 5 mn s n 02 L 049 t 1 ND h J y 5 02 i a asn ne t 10 o hi , i l , . o t t psn n ip sn y na e tdV l ageta h nes h dc mn fei t sae r o ad sr e l ic c a . i arus h e edte ou e si d n h cs i e t rre o t t l i bcuehyee taJ Cws oi fcf l w g s t e mr ae ne wt g easte rva h PM a n na o oi i std o gg ud ri l t t tl nt a t r in g die S ma yh cn ns h h hs r ht i evni te c o frh proe f u e ns i i r, e o edta e a ai t o n reen h ain ote ups o il . ll t t g t t o a ighs dc mn adteifr a o bi ntoe ou e s n o rno min tn t h t . V l hsi d n me orqe s ntecss no iged gni t n i a afe a u b feus i o r aeiv v ln nist i s o l r t h ln i tuo cne et h poeu o See.Fd Hu n F.Aec vJ ognCae &C, onc doi rsc in e . ,e . os g i gny. PMra hs t s t . , g i n o . Ns1- V 68 ( L)1- V 69 ( L)21 W 1067 SDNY Ar1 21) o 1 C -18 D C 1 -12 D C 04 L 476 (.... p 1 04 . , C , . , ; i a l M ino n ree n Rqe fr u clDc mn, U tdt e v Wl FroBn , o ot I evn ad eus oJdi ou e s ne S ts. es ag ak t t t ia t NA,N 1-V 72 ( F(....i d My, 04[ k N 19 U tdt e v .. o 2 -57JM) SDNYfe a 521) D. o 0] ne S ts. . C l t . ; i a Du ceBn A , 1 V 27 ( A ) H p o m int i evn adrqe s o e sh ak G 1- -96 L K i r r o os o n ree n eus fr t C . si t t t r i a l , . C dc mn hv be dn d Se re U td t e v Wl FroBn NA,N 1-V ou e s ae en e e e Od, ne S ts. es ag ak .. o 2 t i. 72 ( F(.... My, 04[ k N 10(ey geust i evn fr a u t 57JM) SDNY a 721) D. o 1] dn n rqe o n ree oflr o t . i t t i e si yR e 4 U td t e v Du ceBn A , 1 V 27 ( A ) SDNYJn 2 as u 2) ne S ts. e sh ak G 1- -96 L K(.... ue 7 tf l ; i a t C , 21) D.N 5] dn n rqe t i evn. 04[ k o 5(ey geus o n ree t . i t t ) V l s rsnrqe s r w hu m i H po ds o a s o oc dtat s i a p e eus a i o et e rv e n bs t cn ueh h o’ e t t e t t r. i i l ti cs,w c cnen mr aewt n n onc o w h se f gv n e por m a ae h h oc s o ggsrt i cnein i a pci oe mn rg , s i r t ie t t ic r t a h ay igo ow hi cs Fr e mr te ny ou e s nesai t saer() n h t d i h ae u h o, h o dc mn ud e n h cs a 1 tn t s . tr e l t r l i e E w d s r ia c m a t D.Ns1356 () ou e setd o h Gv n e ’ d a s o g l o pi ( k o - -) 2 dc mn r a t te oe mns r’ in ln t . , ; t le r t 3 i evn o ( k Ns1-1 ad 3E w d srqe fr es n cs ( k N 1) n re in D. o 01) n () d a s eus ofe ad o s D. o 9 t t t . ; r’ t t t . . V l hsmd n soigh h cnoacsteno min eeu e b cnuig 1 i a a ae o h w ta e an ce hifr a o hrq rs y os t () o n t t s t i ln te eod mne c m a t D.N 1) nte el mnare e ( k N 8 b h f h scn a edd o pi ( k o 2ad h st e g mn D. o ) o o ln t . te t e t t . , t w c a pbc Ad e an cne a yrc a a o pl gesnwy e ed h hr u i n h cno oc vb aiut c mei rao h h nes i e l. t i l t le ln acst E w d s m in ofe ad o s H rqe s otee ou e sr dn d ce o d a s s r ’ o o fres n cs. i eus frhs dc mt a e e t t s t n e i. Bcueh o yn rs h aiutsw h epct t si ginrv v aon acst easte n i e t erc a i rse o h lia o eo erud ce o l t es t l e t t i t t l s tee ou e sh m in o n rees e e hs dc mn,i o ot i evni dn d t s t t i. I . Kly Mt n o n ree I I ee’ o o t It vn l s i e Kl ymvs o n reen h ain eas sel m aiht fs fests e e oet i evni t s c o bcue h ci s r t oit i rt u l t i t a g r -l a ud teF s Ci sA.Tehu o h ag mnse s o eh se o td ute ne h a e l m c htrs f e ru e e mt bta h p n o h r l a t t r t t ie t s mf u aeei t s u i h m in ae i a ea t c il wu tasews a er dl gd n h s t n e o o pp s n sp a i la s t h h a a l i i r t r re v i t poeu n aa sJ C Se ee vJ ognCaeBn ,N 1-V 29 (..G rsc ig g n PM. e Kly. PMra hs ak o 1 -47 ND a t it l . C . 21) Serus h sead o Kt E w d 01 h ageta h—n n e h d a s—ws h eo tefsfe w h te . t t i r ate fr h “r i r i i h r e it l ” t n ma n oteF s Ci sA. T sru e i w hu m i bcue vnf h d n i y en g fh a e l m c h ag mn s i o et eas eeisei o f i l a t i t t t r d t teG en e, r PM, f hfc ud l n teru cagd e, h d n , na, h o r mn oJ Co tea s ne y g hf d h e h esei o i fc v t t ri a r r d t t fe q t m c o fs1 E w d d . N oe u E w d ad h Gv n e my i a u a ainit d a si o n b d a s nte oe mn a l i t r. r d t r r t p tia i t s c o Se3 USC§ 70b 5( hn p sn r g a ain ne ai p e n h ain e 1 ... 33() )“We a e o b ns n c o ud rc t i t . ( r i t r [ eF s Ci sA ]n p sntetateGv n e myn ree r r g r a d t a e l m c, o e o o rhn h oe mn ai evn o b n aet h l a t r h r t t i le ain ae ote a s ne y gh pn n ain)U tdt e e r. ha.Clo c o bsd n h fc ud l nte ed g c o ” ne S ts x e Se v ec t t ri i t .; i a l l 3 , r . r o r e i. Pr e h , 4 F d 3 31 DC C. 04 H m t ns h eo dn d a nr i 78 . 38 4 (.. i 21) e oi ite fr e e 2 t sp 1 Kly ain n h Nr enDt co G og cnend h frc sr o poe y Se ee’ c oi te o h l s t t r irt f er a oc ete o l u f rp t h si i r eo e r. d n mn oteF s Ci sA i taain nl erqe t fe s t a edd i o e in h a e l m c n h c o u i h eus oi ai h mne d t t l a t t t t r t l x c m at o pi . ln 2 Kly ek a o otyh st mnare e b weteGv n e ad PM. ee sesl t s te el e g mn e en h oe mn n J C l s a te t e t t r t BcueKl y a n aiutd vi i e si t s c o h rqe i dn d eas ee hs o rc a a a d n r t n h ain e eus s e e l t t le l te i t , r t i. 4 I. V Cn u o oc s n li Frhfrg n raos V l adKly sm int i evna D NE .i a ote o o gesn i a n ee ’ o os o n reer E I D V l s ei , o l t t e o’ rqe fr ou e ssD NE. Kly rqe tate el mnare e b s yds eus o dc mn i E I D ee’ eus h h st e g mn et e i t t l s t t te t e t a D NE. EI D TeC r o C u i d e et c s tem inadcen me 2 3 ad 9 a h l k f or si c d ol e h o o t ok u b s 6 7 n 4, n e t rt o t s t r , , d t c st s ae ol eh cs o i . S O DRD O R E E. D e O oe 3, 04 a d c b 121 t: t r N wYr N wYr e ok e ok , __________________ __________________ JP U O T E . AL EKN UtdStsDt cJde ne t e irt ug i a si 5 Cp sml d y h me t po e aist h f l w g drse o e a e b ca b s o r s p t ate o oi ad ss i i r re l n e : A hn V l n oy i a t o I # 2310 D 3286 M Ka Fd a Cr c oaIst in c en ee l o ein ni t r r t l tuo PO Bx 00 .. o 80 B dod P 171 r fr A 60 a , F n s M Kly r c e . ee ai l 60 B k o T c 53 a s n r e rt a Du avl G 315 og s l, A 03 l ie 6
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
