CVD Equipment Corporation v. Taiwan Glass Industrial Corporation et al, No. 1:2010cv00573 - Document 213 (S.D.N.Y. 2014)
Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER re: 186 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Taiwan Glass Industrial Corporation. For the foregoing reasons, Taiwan Glass's motion for partial summary judgment is GRANTED. The Court orders the entry of judgment in favor of Taiwan Glass against CVD in the amount of $3,564,000, plus prejudgment interest at the rate of nine percent from the date of breach, January 10, 2010, the date on which the CVD shipment arrived in Taiwan. The parties are di rected to confer and to submit letters on or before November 19, 2014 addressing how they propose to proceed with the next phase of the case. The Court will address those proposals at the next conference, scheduled for November 21, 2014 at 10:00 a.m. The Clerk of Court is directed to close the motion at docket number 186. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge J. Paul Oetken on 11/13/2014) (ama)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CVD Equipment Corporation v. Taiwan Glass Industrial Corporation et al U I E S A E DS RC C U T NT D T T S I TI T O R S U H R DS RC O N O T E N I TI T F EWY R OK -------------------- X --------------------------------------: C DE UPM N C R O AI N V Q I E T O P R T O, : : Pi i, : l nf a tf : -v : : T IW NG A SI D S R A A A L S N U TI L : C R O AI N n MZ H C R O A E : O P R T O ad I U O O P R T B N,L D A K T. , : : D edn . e na s : f t -------------------- X --------------------------------------: T IW NG A S N U TI L A A L S I D S RA : C R O AI N O P R T O, : : Cu e l mPi i, on r a l nf t ci a tf : : -v : : C PT LO E NA AI A N, .. , : : Cu e l mD edn : on r a e na. t ci f t ---------------------X --------------------------------------- Doc. 213 1- V 53J O 0C -7 (P ) OI I NA DO D R PN O N R E J P U O T E,Dt cJde . A L E K N irt ug si : T ss cs a hs en o d eo , bu a o m clrnain oewog h i a ae s a be n e b r ao i , t fe t c m e i t sc o gn rn ra a t . C DEu.Cr v T wnG sIds Cr , 01 W 1119a* (.... M. 1 V q p op . a a l s nu op 21 L 209 t 1 SDNY a 3 i . i a . . , r , 21) P sn y eo teCu itescn m in o p tl u m yug e b 01 r e l b r h or s h eod o o fr ai s m a jd mn y . e t fe t t ra r t D edn T wnG sIdsi Cro t n T wnG s )aa s Pi i C D e na a a l s nurl opri ( a a l s g n l nf V f t i a ta ao i a i t a tf Dockets.Justia.com Eu mn Cro t n C D. Ot sm in T wnG s sesu m yug e o q p e opri ( V ) nh o o , a a l s eks m a jd mn n i t ao i t i a r t 1 b h V sb ah f o rcci adt cu e l m o b ah f o rcaa s C D o C D r c o cn a l m ni on r a fr r c o cn a g n V. t e t t a s t ci e t t it I . Frhraos h f l w T wnG s sm insg n d ote esnta o o, a a l s o oi r t . tl i a t ae Bc go n akr u d A . Fcu Bc go n a a akr u d tl Te o oiga s r d w u e o e w en c e fo te ais R e 6 hf l w fc a e r n n s t ri id a d r m h p t l n t a , l s h s it, re u 5 1 l . St mn adh sb i in mdi cneinw hhis n m in O yh fc t e e s nte u m s s aen onc o i ten a o o n te a s a t so t t tt t . l t r ea tt sm inr po dd Te a s r ud p e u e o e w e o d e vn oh o o a rv e h fc a n su d n s t ri n e l t i t e i . t e i t ls h s t. C Ds t cn oy o pn bsdnLn I ad N wYr I p n p fci,t V i ae ho g c may aei ogs n e ok t r c a al ya l l , . s i i l it a r ea t ms ws nRnok m N wYr C D ep t en uete eot n f l e vn i e ai okno a e ok V s xei ic ds h dpsi o ll t , , . rs l io t ni m o v iu k d osr cs n u n v a rcs cld ce iavpr h f s n a osi s f u ae ic d gi poe ae h m l ao i l r n f , li a s l c dpsin T wnG s ai n m sge shst p n p p c o bs e i T wn eot . a a l s st a e ugs, ai r c a l e f u ns n a a io i a, s t s iil a i s i ad pcl eitemnfc r g fls n se azs nh au t i o g s ii a un a. 1 Te A C DSs . h P V y em t Te poe frls pouin T wnG s sa oynLkn T wn we h rcs o g s rdc oa a a l s fc ri uag a a h e s a t t i a t , i r C D eu p e ws o el m e isl ds n w atef a g s m hd I a V s q i mn at b ui al n ae i ko n s h l tl s e o t t t y tl o a t . n f a g s l er wm e a a m e av yihe p a rsadhn o mdn t l tl s i , a a rl r i dt e h t me t e nte fr ei a i o a n ti s e x r g ru n b h t c a a heo g s T se tepsetruh lh a ogi a or t se fl s h he hna s hog a er ln k n w c t ee t a. e t s l hh i co adt n hn(r ana )h g s F a y h se i c i on v u pn s n o s n s eg es o ne s tel s i l, e he s u n id i a ae ad l r t l a. nl t t t t idl l s rd t e2 o . T sm in os oad s T wnG s s on r a m aa s C D otr os h o o de n dr s a a l s cu e l s g n V froiu i t t e i a t ci it t i e e nei cn a adru oi cu e l m g n Cpa Oe o wogu n r r cw h o rc n f d r s on r a aa s a t nfr rnf tf e t t t a, t t ci i t il l d hnr f lt o c d . i oo oaee f r i s tr et 1 T s ec p oi bsd nh s m ay o a ei T wnG s s 6 St mn ( e h ds i ins ae ote u m cni d n a a l s 5 1 t e e. S i rt r tn i a . a t e D.N 17 R e 6 St mno T wnG s( D. 6 S m )¶ 3 C D b c t k o 8 u 5 1 t e e f a a l s e 5 1 t, . V o e s o t . , l . a t i a f .t ) jt 2 I m - oa 20 T wnG s suha o pnt ds n n b l ah m a n i tl e 07 a a l s og c mayo e g ad u d ce i l d t , i a t i i c vpr eot n y e frt Lkn fc r Te n s nd y e wu dps ce ia ao dpsi ss m oi uaga oy h evi e ss m o d eot h m l io t s t . io t l i c f m o se s fls dr g rdc o t c a t o ye o g s L wE i inG s i s n he o g s u n pouin or t wtps fl s o - m s l t a i t ee a: so ls a ( L w ) n T np e CnuieO d G s( T O .(f 5 1S m ¶. ( C o - ad r sa n odc v x e l s C ) D. 6 t t 4 T O E a rt t i a e . , ) g si gn a y sd os a pn s w l L w Els itp a y m oe frnut n l ss ee l ue fr o r ae, he o - g s s y cl e p yd ois a o a rl l l i a il l li proe) Te y e wu b o ie ite estai ws o e c moe ote upss h ss m o d e n n nh sneh t at b a o pnn fh . t l l , t t fc r s mnfc r g rdc ol e a oy au t i pouini . t a un t n I Jn 20 f l w gme nsw had p snt n y C D T wnG s n u 08 o oi eig i , n a r e a o b V e l n t t e ti , a a ls i a s nd n re cnr a o w hC D oa Cn nosT OA msh i P su Ce ia i e a od of min i V fr g r i t t o iuu C t ope c r sr h m l t r e e c VprSs m( e A C DSs m. T wnG s adC Dhn n rdn a are e ao y e t t h P V y e ) a a l s n V te e e i o n g mn t i a te t e t d e Ags 2 20 ( e 5 1 t t E 3 Are e ), ne w c C Dwu ds n a d uu 9 08 D. 6 S m x ( g mn ) ud h h V o d e g t t , f . , . e t r i l i admnfc rteA C DSs m o a u o $1 8 00 n au t eh P V y e fr s m f 1 80 0 au t , , . O oao Sp me 1 20 a T wnG s seus M uoCro t Bn n r bu e e b 5 08 t a a l s rqe, i h opr e ak t t r , , i a t z a , L. M uo i ud lt oc d ( eC m e i L )i C D fvr o t ( i h )s e a ee fr i t o m cl C n V s aofr d z s tr et h ra $1 8 00 Rc rcl o o ao O oe 820 Cpa Oe NA( Cpa Oe 1 80 0 e poa y n r bu c b , 08 a t n .. a t n ) , , . i l, t t r , il , il i ud s nblt o c d ( e S nb L ) nC D bh foT wnG sfr s e at dyee f r i t t dy C o V s ea t a a l s o s a tr et h a l i a t s u m y nh gons h ii a so hn ds i in f o p xeho g a h s m a ote rudta ts i r t hr ad ec p o oc m e tcn o c t rt l l il poe e ad o is mn s nia fc r a ntte u e tcn oy ( t N rcs s n m[ ayi i cn a s et goh sb c eho g s t] g f t t li jt l . D. o k . 16 Cr c dC DEu mn Cro t n Lc R e 6 Cu e St mn(P 5 1 9 o e e V q p e opri s oa u 5 1 on r t e e , rt i t ao l l . t a t l 6 . . S m ) a34 C Dr ssi i r b c osle h ent 5 1St mn ( eda69. tt , t . V a es ma o eine we i i 6 t e e. S i t ) ) i l jt s r s . a t e . H wv ,C Dnte o e o es l mr c m e oacr e ec p os fhr ea o ee V e h f r s n by o o pt r cu t ds i in otee vn r i r fs t i e le a rt l t tcn o c poe e n spost o ein w hit nt a m s l e dne Se eho g a rcs s o upr i b c os i ca os o d i i e v ec e l il s, r t s jt t ti sb i . Lc R e 6 () We C D o ein a d i e ud R e 6,h Cu ah et oa u 5 1d h e V s b c osr e c n ne u 5 1 e or de s o l l . . r jt e fi t r l .t t r tea s eo i T wnG s s 6 St mnfr upss fh m in hfc s u n a a l s 5 1 t e e o proe ot s o o t t t i a . a t i t . $ 54 0 3 o te ol u hs p c3 Oc Cpa Oesudh S nb L ,C D 3 6 00 0% f ht apr ae r e ne a t ni ete t dy C V , , t c i. il s a d w o n nh C m e i L frh s m a on (l5 1 t ta5) r d w ote o m cl C ote a e mu. P 6 S m t. e ra t . . , Te e g ote rpsdA C DSs mws o p x Te y e ws o e n n h ds n fh po oe P V y e a c m e h ss m a t b o ie i t l. t l , ca n tels se s eo te rahd hana n lh ( e 5 1S m ¶ 1 oig hg s he b r hyece teneig er D. 6 t t 1 ) t a t fe l . f . , . Acr nt a ce ac r w gp p e b C D( e 5 1S m E 8 w cC D cod go sh mi d i r a d y V D. 6 t t x . i t a n er f . , . ) hhV i cn ns a p l m ay adno pt(l5 1t ta6 1) tey e cniei o ed ws ri i r nic m e P 6 S m t , 9 hss m o a dt t e n le . . , t tn s o n eig n ( e DpsinLh ) epn b fra t n gtee p a r ote w ha n u tt t i h eot i o er rsos l om ni n ht me t e fh ie i ai ru g s W h teDpsinLh wu b a Dpsin Md e dpsig aeu l s i i h eot a. t n i o er o d e l eot i o ou, eot gsos l in ce ia ta wu c m nt fr ah f m v te nr se o g s TeDpsin h m l h o do b eo o m t ni oe h e i he f l s h eot cs t l i i l r te t a. io Md ews o ost f sv a i e o md e ec o w c wu hue s w ou at cn s o ee l n c r ou s ah f h h o d osi o n l i r jt l, i l t dpsin ed ad dpsin oz. ( f5 1 S m ¶ 4 eot ha n eot nz e D. 6 t t 1 ) io io l e . , . G etate r m y ups oteA C DSs mws h dpsin f h m a i nh h p a proe fh P V y e ate eot oce i l v t i r t io cs o oh g s i ws netotate o pnn ote y e taac m ihdh n tel s t a ud s dh h c moe s fh ss m h co pset s t a, ro t t t t l i proew eh msct a Fr x m e KS CagaT wnG s eg e ate ups e te o ri l oea p, .. hn r t ic. l , a a l s n ne t h i a i r Lkn fc r ds ie te eot n oz teic ote y e ta wu a ul uaga oy ec bdh dpsi nz e h p e fh ss m h o dc a y t , r io l e t t l tl sry h ce ia o oh g s a oe fh msi pr nc moe s ote y e. p te h m l n tel s s n ote o mo a o pnn fh ss m a cs t a t tt t t (d ¶ 7 K le zS o C D V eP s e frBs e Dv o mnadh I 1 ) a h n t b V s i r i n o u ns ee p e nte . . r i rl c ed t i s l t p n p s e i frh A C Dh ca ntcn oy r e etteDpsin Md e r c a c ns ote P V t n oigeho g i i l i tt i t l e r do h eot fr i o ou l ate ha oteA C DSs m (. 1 ) sh e t fh P V y e. I ¶ 9 r t d . L etes nblt s frd,h S nb L ws fr oscr y ne w c T wn i o rt dyee oc i te t dy C a a o m feut ud h h a a k h a tr et a i r i i G s ws u a ed a eud fhfsisl mno py e ite vntaC Dws l s a ga n e r n oteit n a e f a mn nh ee h V a a rt f r tl t t t t ua eo e o mt o ia os ne te o rc nb t p fr i b gin ud h cn a. l r s l t r t t 3 2 Te npc o a d hpmn . h Ise i n n Si et t Sc o 6 4 fh Are e l d ua P l m ay Mnfc r g ceu, w c ein. ote g mn a o t 1 e t i t ri i r au t i Shd e h h e n a un l i d iete r e i oi s gs n std ga fr ahtg ( g e e,t 81 ) i ddh po c n s t e adt e o s oec s e Ar mn a1 9 v jt t x a a l a. e t . A oghs ga ws h ds n n cnrc o oa R DA C D w c T wnG s mntee o s ate e g ad os uin f n & P V, h h a a l s l i t t i, i a sy ws on ue po tp oteDpsin Md e ni cni e p t 4 ( e 5 1 as atic d a r o e fh eot , l ty i o ou adt ost n as l s t u t r. D. 6 f . S m ¶ 0 H wv,n 09 C Dmd cags oh pooe ds n fh A C D t t 2 ) o ee i 20 V ae hnette rpsd e g ote P V , . r , i Ss m n sifr e T wnG s ( d¶ 2 2 )C D cneetai nte po dd y e ad ono md a a l s I ¶ 1 2 V ocds h t e h rv e a t i a. . . t i r i cp ote e ds noT wnG s nr hs a ymnfc rdh R D r o p b oy fh n w e gt a a l s opy cl au t ete & po t e u i i a il au t y, t sytateR D y e ws oa die b i m ud teAre e .(l5 1 m a as h h & ss m a n t t t e v a et l r l e ne h g mn P 6 S t t r e t . .t, 91 1 ) 0 9 , . Ud tee m oteAre et C Dws nt do a mnote eod 0% f ne ht s fh g m n V a e iet py e fh scn 3 o r r e , tl t te u hs p cf l w g S p n adTs n a Sl sFci ad ce acfr h pr ae r e o oi c i l n h p g n eigt ee al y n acp ne o ii t lr it t s p n b By. (g e e,t . Sc o 6 oteAre e, nt d P - h mn h p g y ue Ar mn a3 ) ein. fh g mn e ie r S p e ii r e t t 2 e t tl e i t Isein syte o oig Cs m vi dr g os uinr ecu gd P ot npc o as h f l w : u o e it u n cnrc o a nor e r ro t , l n t r ss i t t e a . i s p e wive u o e t oral yoi w o ptf acek uote y e ad h mn en t cs m s o ufci t v c m e i l hc o fh ss m n i t i t r it e le n t t i a l yomete pcia osmn oe h e. (. t 1 O O oe 2 20 a t bi t e h se f t n e ind e i I a1 ) n c b 8 09 s s it t i ci t rn d . t r , , rq rd yh S nb L,awnG s wo t C Dis uighlt t a ag eu e bte t dy CT a l s r e o V nrc nteae or ne i a i a t t t tr r s p e oteA V DS t m ( e 5 1S m E 1 ) H wv,T wnG s s e e ( h mn fh P C y e. D. 6 t t x 6 o ee a a l st s di i t s f . , . . r i a rs n b dd n ud l e tp ae h C D u n s ph ss mw hufs o a ig [ h o e ad nei d ye c ta V ms o h te y e i o it bi n t e l rn f ) t t t i t t tr tn ] acp ne os p ni ud yT wnG s] ce acfr h p gs e b [a a l s. t ii s i a Sc o 6 4fh Are e mks e rneoh ds n n mnfc r oaR D ein. ote g mn aer e ctte e g ad au t e f n & t 1 e t fe i au A C D y e, usy n h g bui cni e p t P V ss mb as o i ao t ost n as t t tn t s t u t r. 4 Apo m e amn l e o Nv me 2 ad 420 sv a T wnG s prx al i t y o ha r n oe b 3 n 2 09 ee l a a l s t t, r , , r i a e p ye,n u n Cagvi dC D fci fr nnpc o (l5 1S m a1 ) m oesic d g hn it l li , se V sal y o aisein P 6 t t t 2 it t . . . , . C D ocds h,t ht m otenpc o i hd opy cl mnfc rdo V cneeta atei e fhisein t a n hs a y au t e r t t , t il au a e b d ee l o pnn oteA C DSs m (.t 21 )I p t u r h T wn s m e sv ac moe s f h P V y e. I a1 3 n ai l, e a a s l r t t d . rc a t i G s e p ye w eifr etateDpsin Md ews oaaa e oiseinad l s m oes e no mdh h eot a l r t i o ou a n vlb frnpc o n l t i l t , tac moe s fh md ewu b adda rnT w. ( e 5 1 m ¶ 6 h o pnn ote ou o d e del ei a a t t l l t i n D. 6 S t 3. f .t, ) Nte d C D rdc a o ptd ein f h R DA C D r a p s fT Ols e h i V poue c m e v s ote & P V os m e o C g s i r d le ro l a fo teR D y e ( ¶ 3 4) huhC D ip e we ei ws b g et po d r m h & ss mi ¶ 9 0 tog V d u s h h t a o ia do rv e t d . , st tr l t i sc s m e(l5 1S m a1) F l w ghisein Cag d sdS o tah ad uh a p s P 6 t t t 9 o oi te npc o hn av e t b h e n l . . , . l n t , i rl t tetee p yew e n a hr et s n ce ac ote h mnt [ awnG s h o r m oese h l r o u o zdoi acp ne fh s p e o T a l s t t i g t i t i a] adh C D hu te fr n s ph ss m ( e 5 1S m ¶ 2) Nn h e, n r nta V so dh eo o h te y e . D. 6 t t 4. oe e s o o t l r e t i t f . , tls ao Nv me 2 20 C D akdh p t oteA C DSs m h hd en vlb bu oe b 7 09 V pcete as fh P V y e ta a be aaa e t r , , r t t i l frnpc o b T wnG si oh e h mncnie ada te snt T wn oisein y a a l s n tr s p e o a r nhd h me o a a t i a t e i t t ns t i solte a e Aon te a ei e C Dr ne fr h mnoc t ntr asr m hr yh e t . rudh s mt m V a agd os p e f e a oe p tfo t r fr , r i t ri h r i sp i s nC n d elt T wn Te h mn cnee yi n ic d a te t upe i h ai c yo a a h s p e s ocdd d o n uel h s lr i rt i . i t l d t l l c moe s fh ss m n u nteDpsin Md e (l5 1t ta 1 1 ) o pnn ote y e , c d gh eot t t ili i o ou. P 6 S m t 5 6 l . . , . B h ais usqe l ad nucs u y ae p do bi py e :C D o p t sbeun y n usce f l t m et o a a mn V t re t sl t t tn t ud teC m e i L frh scnisl mnote u hsp c adTi a G s ne h o m cl C ote eodn a e fh pr aer e n a wn l s r ra tl t c i, a ud teS nb L fr h 3 i tl p doC D T wnG s suh py e ote ne h t dy C ote 0%nil a t V. a a l s og a mn nh r a ia y i i a t t std rudta C D a be ua eome[ etsrq r mn ad a s pete t e gons h V hd en nb t e t ]e eu e e n hd h pdh a t l th t i t i gos nh asne f acp ne os p ni ud y T wnG s. ( e 5 1 t t¶ odite bec o ce acfr h p gs e b [ a a l s t ii s i a ] D. 6 S m f . , 4 )T wnG sr uet c a te V s p e truh u o s adtwsl m e 8 a a l se sdol r hC D h mn hog cs m , ni a ui al . i a f e i t t t ty s pe bct C D (d ¶ 1 O Jnay 221 C Dwo t T wnG stcnr h pd ako V. I 5 ) n au 2 00 V r eo a a l s oof m i . . r , , t i a i r ein fh gos ( e 5 1S m E 1 ) e c o ote od D. 6 t t x 9 jt . f . , . . B . Poe ua Htr rcdr i oy l s C Di dhis nain n au y 621 aa s T wnG s adiuo V feten a c o o Jna 2 00 g n a a l s n M h l tt t r , it i a z , ae n b ah f o rcadwogud hnrrseie.( k N 1 T wnG s l g g r c ocn a n rnf i oo epc v y D. o . a a l s li e t t l s , t l t .) i a fe a on r a m g n C D o b ah f o rc o Ar 1 21 ad g n Cpa i d cu e l aa s V fr r c o cn a n pl 5 00 n aa s a t l t ci it e t t i , , i t il Oe frwogud hnr nAgs 3 21 ( k Ns1 & 2 M uomvd o n o rnf i oo o uu 1 00 D. o 2 3 ) i h oe fr l s t , . t . . z s m ayug e aa s C D n u 2 21 ( k N 2 )C D rs - oe fr u m jd mn g n V o J y 8 00 D. o 6 V co mvd o r t it l , . t . . s s m ayug e aa s M uoo Ags 3 21 ( k N 3) O Jnay 821 u m jd mn g n i h n uu 1 00 D. o 3 n au 2 01 r t it z t , . t . . r , , Cpa Oemvdoi m sT wnG s s on r a madT wnG s co -oe fr a t n oet d i a a l s cu e l , n a a l srs mvd o il s s i a t ci i a s s m ayug e ote a e ( k Ns6 & 4 u m jd mn nh s m D. o 0 6 ) r t . t . . T s c o hs ee td h e o n nt d e I a o n n a d M c 3 21 h ain a gn a tr p i s o a. n n p i d e a h 1 01 i t re e i o t io t r , , JdeH wlt wo t smt ws rv u y s ge) rn d M uo m in o ug o e ( h m h ae a p i s a ind g t i h s o o fr l l o i tr e ol s ae z t s m ayug e ad e e C D cos m in os m ayug e o a ci s u m jd mn n dn d V s r s o o fr u m jd mn nl l m r t i - t r t l a w hepct M uo C DEu.Cr v T wnG sIds Cr , 01 W 1119a i rse o i h t t z . V q p op . a a l s nu op 21 L 209 t i . i a . . , * (.... M. 121) Adinl JdeH wl e e b hCpa Oe m ino 4 SDNY a 3 01 d t a y ug o e dn d o a t n s o ot r , . i o l, l l i t il t d m s n T wnG s srs-o o fr u m yug e at Cpa Oe I a* i i ad a a l s co m in os m a jd mn s o a t n d t 6 s s i a s t r t il . . . O Ar 1 21 T wnG s mvd o p tl u m yug e otesu o n pl 2 02 a a l s oe fr ai s m a jd mn nhi e f i , , i a ra r t s we eteC m e i L se f a y t da ie os p e ws nopr ei oh h h h o m cl C pci l , s ednfr h mn aicro tdn te tr ra i cl i l i t a t Are e.( k N 9 )I a o n n a dNv me 721 t sCu dn dh m in g mn D. o 6 n n p i d e oe b , 02 h or e ete o o e t t . . io t r ,i t i t . C DEu.Cr v T wnG sIds Cr , 02 W 5010 SDNY Nv721) V q p op . a a l s nu op 21 L 562 (.... o , 02 i . i a . . . . O J y 221 Cpa Oemvd os m ayug e o T wnG s s n u 1 03 a t n oe fr u m jd mn n a a l s l , , il r t i a cu e l m ( k N 10 TeCu dn d h m inn n p in a dFbu y 9 on r a . D. o 3 ) h or e ete o oi a o n d e era 1 t ci t . . t i t io t r , 21 C DEu.Cr v T wnG sIds Cr , 04 W 612 (....Fb1 04 V q p op . a a l s nu op 21 L 440 SDNY e 9 . i . i a . . . , 21) 04 . T wnGa fet s m in o p tl u m yug e o J y 521 ( k a a ls i dh o o fr ai s m a jd mn n u 1 04 D. i sl i t ra r t l , . t N 16 C Di d n pot n nAgs 1 21 adT wnG sfei rp o o 8 ) V fe a opsi o uu 4 04 n a a l si dt e y n . . l io t , , i a l s l Ags 2 21 ( k Ns17& 0 ) uu 7 04 D . o 9 24 t , . t . . I I . D cs o i uin s s A . Sa dr o Rv w t n ad f e e i S m ayug e sa b g n d hn te i n gn n d p e s o n m e a u m jd mn hl e r t we h es o eu ei u at ay a rl r t l ae r i st ti fcadh mvni e ietjd mna amt ol w Fd R C .P5(.A a i a nte oa s nt doug e s ae fa. e . i . 6 ) fc s t t tl t tr . v a t m e aii m ha e te u o e fh s t nete oen ga, Adro v L e y a rlft i t f c h o c m ote u ud h gv i l w ne n . i r ti g ft t i r rn s bt LbyIc, 7 US2228 18)adh es gn ni ufrrlwe , os e n ob n 47 .. 4 4 (96 nte i a eu es e ot a h ecn d ig , . , , r i s i r ir teeod s wo, rin t e ofccu f dnao ote o- o n p t R cv hrcr a a h ea a oa r r f a o di i fvr fh nn mv g a y i i. l t li t l n i r, c DSfn , 5 US5756 20) qo nM ss t E cIds C v Zn hRd e e o 57 .. 5 8 (09(u iga uh a l . nu o . e t a o ta , t t i e . . i i Cr , 7 US5457 18) op 45 .. 7 8 (96. . , ) I s h mvns udno h wh n gn n fc ad p e xt ad h cu t te oa bre t so ta o eu ea u i u e s, n te or i t t i t l s t is t msrs v a a b uis n d wlraoa en rneite o- oa sao V u eo el m g t ad r a esnb if ecs nh nn mvn fv. t t l l i ie a l l e t r . TdyBa C, n v180Baga C , 7 F d 4 24 2 C. 04 Itemvn ed er o Ic . 0 err m o 33 . 21 4 (d i 20) fh oa . . . 3 , r . t me i bre te udn httte o- o n p t t d mnr e h te i i fc a e st udn h bre s f oh nn mv g a yo e os a ta h es na, t s , is i r tt t r , t gn ni ufrrl Sn s. Mrok 23F d 8 63 2 C. 01(e cr m(t g eu es e ot a a o v udc, 4 . 61 8 (d i 20) p u a ) ci i s i. t 3 , r r i in C o xCr v C rt 47US37332 (96. cu cno w gte v ec o e t op . a e , 7 .. 1 2 4 18) A or an le . tt , ) t t e hh e dne r i i , a e terd it o w nse ors vi us fa o am in os m ayug e, s s h c i l y f i ess reo es e ofc n o o fr u m jd mn ss e bi t , l s t t r t b ntecn t e m te o mv g a yo e uo cn uoyt e e scn c r u e h a i p i h nn o n p t t r y pn oc sr st mn, o e u , t i r rt - i r l l a t jt e oseut n K a v CyfN w ok 8 F d 37 (dC. 96(u igor uz. r pc a o li . u k. i o e Yr , 8 . 6 1 2 i 19) qo nRd ge v l t 3 , r t i CyfN w ok 7 F d 0116 (dC. 95 ( t n qot nm ko ie) i o e Yr , 2 . 15 01 2 i 19) i e a u a o a s mtd. t 3 , r ) n r l ti r t B . TeA pc b L w h pl al a i e Ah eh dsu ot sm in oc n te ore fa gv n gh cn a ci s t rso i e nh o o cne s h su ol w oe i te o rc l m l s i t r c rn t t a it sip eT wnG s ageta Ai e oteU fr C m e i Cd( U C nh d u. a a l srus h rc 2 fh n o m o m cl oe C ) i st i a t tl i ra ape,heC Dn s ta N wYr c m o l w gv n Hv g e e eteais p isw l V ist h e ok o mna oe s a n rv wdhp t l i is t r. i i re b e n ite rseie rt a m mrna D .Ns14& 7) nte pp s r f g nh repc v p -i e o d ( k o 5 10ad h r ae ii i t erl a t . i r sb ie ot sm in D.Ns1617& 0) h Cu cn ue a amt ol w h u mtd nh o o ( k o 8 9 24 te or oc ds s ae fa ta t i t t . , , t l tr t teAre e i a o rcp m iy ogosads cod g gv nd yh U C h g mn s cn a r al frod ni acr n y oe e bte C. e t t ti r , il r Ai e oteU C p is ot naini gos NY UCC§ -0 5 We a rc 2 fh C apet r sc os n od tl l a t . .. ... 212 h e . r cn a iv vs m o gos n s v e we e Ai e i apcb trs nh o rc no e a i f od ad e i s h h rc 2s p ia eun ote t t l x r c , t r tl l l e ec o m n b c v ote aisare e.Md o L ..Bs n c C r , 4 s ne r a o eie fh p t s i jt re g mn e n t v o o S. o p 36 e t il d t i . F Sp 2 5553 SDNY20) cig yaisCr o A.. nlHre e C , 2 . up d 7 9 (.... 04(t Dn m . , in c op f mvI . t avs r o 49 t . F Sp 3136 SDNY17) selo r n eUdr re, n v Hny e, n , 0 . up 4 4 (.... 97; e a T a g ne wtr Ic . oe wlIc 64 . , ) s i l i s . l . F d 3 (dC. 99. We te rvin f h s v e p d m a s adh s eo . 77 2 i 17) 2 r ) h eh po s ote e i r o i t nte a f r io rc e ne l i mi m e ic e a te o rci oe os v e T ag Udr re , 0 F dt t ss e l n dnl h cn a s nfr e i s r n e ne wtr 64 . a e r y i t, t t r c. i l i s 2 72 qo n N A.L sr Cr v A &BDpc o ,L .48F d 9 67 2 C. 92 4 (u ig. m e ue op . t i . u ia r t, 6 . 65 9 (d i 17) l ts d 2 , r ) ( t n qot nm k o ie) i e a u a o a s mtd n r l ti r t . T wnG s d wt sCu st n otteScn C c t dcinnT ag a a l s r s h or ae inoh eod i u s e s i r n e i a a i t tt ri io i l Udr re ,w c cn d et i uite o e oaa gufc. Teo rcte ne wtr i s h h os e d e s enh cn x f n oosa s hcn a h e i ir h s tt l t t t r Gos a d ie i r ea p ta a t nsic d g pcl mnfc rd od od r e nd n e vn a, s l h g( l i se a y au t e gos e f , l t r li nun il au ) w c a mvb atet m oie i cinoh cn a fr a o etatemnyn h hr oa et h i e fdnf a otte o rc os et r hnh oei i e l ti t t t l h w cte r es o e a,ne mnscris Ai e ) nt ns n c o NY UCC h hh p cit b p d vs e eut ( rc 8 adh gi ain .. ... i i ii t t ie tl i t . § -0() 2151 . 5 rq rdh d ednt sp yh pi i w h sp sc e c mu r y e ta mc eu ete e na o up tel nf i a oht a d o p ess m h uh i f t l a tf t ii t t t t l eh A C DSs mws e ge se f a y otel nfad ostd f o i te P V y e a ds nd pci l frh pi i n cn s o b h k t i i cl a tf ie t h d a ad o w e o pnn . da79 Te orcn uetate o rcws n a w e n sf a c moe s I t 3 h cu oc ddh h cn a a oe r r t r t . . t l t t t fr odr h ta s v e o gosa e hne i s tr r c. Tre a o w e e r t te ors oc s nI a73 e a ot An h fc r e cn a o h cu cn u o d t 4 se l S ne e t s r tl t li . . ; s . - Ncai P pC v Rsac- orlIc, 8 F Sp 79733 (.... 92 ak w u o . eerhC te, n 78 . up 2 3 4 SDNY19) c l . tl . . , (p y ghtre a ots.it hfcta gosw eh sb cote o rc ws ap i teh - c re) Fs tea h od e te u e f h cn a a ln e f t t r, t t r jt t t r lc dnh v y t ote o rc Are e frh S e fD aPoe ig e e eite e tl fh cn a: g mn ote a o a rcs n f t r ie t t e t l t s Eu mn T ag Udr re , 0 F dt 4 Scn te g e e cn m a d o q p e. r n e ne wtr 64 . a 73 eod h ar mn o e pt n i t i l i s 2 . , e t t le t tate e na wu rn n no g ev e o pi i, uis atai wu dv o a h h d edn o d u a og n s i frl nf b n edh t o d ee p t f t l i rc a tf t t t l l c m e d y e ad e v i tr-e t [ e l nf t oe t I (u igr n e o pt ss m n die t unky ot pi i] o p a. d qo nT ag le t l r h a tf re . t i l Udr re, n ..Hny e, n, 5 F Sp 7579 SDNY17) Te e na s ne wtr Ic v oe wlIc 47 . up 6 6 (.... 98. h d edn i s l . . , ) f t o ym o o ia ottel nff l w gn aa o ote y e wsm n nne I n a r b ginoh pi i o oi islt n fh ss m a a t ac d l j l t a tf l n tli t ie . . T r te u hs p c ote ad a md u a ote e na s o pna o te h d h pr ae r e fh h w e ae pl fh d edn c mesin h i, c i r r l f t t ; d edn d n bl os v e p o dr g r usqe tislt n I e na i o i fr e i s r r u n osbeun on aa o f t d tl r c i, i t tli . d . I ec otee epc,h Are e h es k t te o rci T ag n ah fhs rse s e g mn e i a no h cn a nr n e tt e t r i t t i l Udr re . Wlte o rcs o m n mi Are e N C D 50 G te oe ne wtr i s heh cn a fr a a es g mn o V i t t l e t . 72, h cv r lt tteAre e ds ieia afr a Are e o a o iuu[ P V ]md e ee oh g mn ec bst s o m g mn n cn nos A C D ou. tr e t r l e t t l (g e e ,t. Ar mn a2 e t ) Scn ,h Are e evindh C Dwu s m y e g mnfc r ad eod te g mn n s eta V o di p ds n au t e n e t io t l l i, a u, dieteA C DSs m oT wnG s TeAre e po ds h C Dwu isl e v h P V y e t a a l s h g mn rv e ta V o dn a l r t i a. e t i t l tl te y e adr nT wnG s p sneii oe t ni a1 1)b n we dete h ss m nt i a a l s e on nt p a o (.t 1 2 u o h e os h t a i a r l s ri d , t r Are e id a ad oiiaee b C D h C Dwu brsos lfr g mn n c e n nrstl gd y V ta V o d e epn b o e t it l t l ie po d g n no g ev eoT wnG s C D o ia os o oign aa o ote rv i a og n s i t a a l s V s b ginf l w islt n fh in i rc i a. l t l n tli A C DSse w e o eof et w rn rp r adeh c spo.(da 1 ) P V y m e t bcn ndo a a yeas ntcn a upr I t 2 t r i r t i il t . . Mroe teAre e ep s y rv eta C Ds oei a otenl c apoe y o v e r,h g mn xr s po ds h V it r a l fhi ee u rp t e t el i t tnl tl t l r ud l n teA C DSs m b t s n T wnG s s ru e tate ais ne y g h P V y e 6 ur s g a a l s ag mn h h p t ri t tei i a t t re cn a e fr od n s v e o rc d o gos o e i s t t , t r c. F a y h o y ev e o w c T wnG s bldC Daa fo islt n ws i l, e n s i fr h h a a l s ie V, p tr m n aa o a nl t l r c i i a l r tli , [r n gt T wnG s sfci. (da 3 Te o otas v e $0 0 i t a i a[ a a l s ] al y I t . h cs fh e i ]i n i a it . ) t t r c 1 00 s , ng g l ite o e ote v a cn a,wr a ms $2ml n (. I so, oe f e i b nh cn x fh oe l o rc o hl o 1 ii . I ) n hr nn o li e tt rl t t t t lo d t tee vnfc rsge s h teAre e i ao rcfr ev e hr ea a o ugs ta h g mn s cn a os i s l t ts t t e t t t r c. I spo oi ag mntateAre e i a o rcfr ev e ads h eo n upr ft ru e h h g mn s cn a os i s n ite fr t s t t e t t t rc r e o s eh soe fh U C C Dee a msec s e o T P wrIcv Tx o ui te cp ote C td V risl o x u v y n K o e n . e rn l t lil , . t , Ic 43F Sp 2 15 (..C. 06 Te ,h d ednsuht hvtel nf n, 3 . up d 08 ND a 20) h e e e na og o aeh pi i . . l . rt f t t a tf dv o ad rdc bt y h g s oe ci g f as I a16 Ateittg ote ee p n poue ae ca e frl t c o c t d t 00 t hfss e fh l tr r r e r l r. . . r a cn a ,h pi i ws eu et po d wr n po tps fh pou frao tr o rc tel nf arq rdo rv e ok g r o e ote rdc olbr oy t t a tf i i i ty t a ts n I Te orcn uetat s oin fh cn a ta i e ec oe o eig d h cu oc ddh h pr o ote o rc ws n s ne n fr t . . t l ti t t , s , s v e I a16 6 E pa z gh te u ote o rcp c ws ote e i s d t 04 5 mhsi ta h b k fh cn a r e afrh r c. . . in t l t ti dv o mnosfw e oe ntate r o psw e e ge m e freigr h ee p e f o a cd adh h po t e e ds nd e l ots n ( te l t t r t ty r i ry t a r ta ue yh d edn os eo os m s te orepietate e na hd hn s bte e na r a t cnu e ) h cu x a dh h d edn a f t l r, t ln t f t Se g e e,t 6 T wnG s are n t cp o dpc et ds n fh ss m e Ar mn a1 ( a a l s g s o o oy r u ia h e g ote y e e t i a e t l t e i t ot n eifr a ot ayte p tta wl oy n mnfc r or e g . . T wn rr s rno mino n o r a yh i cp ad au t e u ds n . a a af t h r t l au i. i G s aretaay n a ivn osd cv isdv o mn adnoa os oc vd l s g s h n adl ne in i oe e ee p e s ninvin cne e a e t l t , s r, l t t i b C DEu mn Cro t n u nt s nae e r a vtte ue ud t s y V q p e opri dr gh egg mn et eoh d is ne h i t ao i i t li t ri Are e sa r m n h ec s e rp t o C DEu mn Cro t nadC D g mn hle a te x u v poe y f V q p e opri ; n V e t l i li r i t ao Eu mn Cro t n os oa in n r h,ieadn rsite a eoT wn q p e opri de n s g ayi t tl ni e t nh s mt a a i t ao t s g s t, te i G s Ay n a ivn osd cv isdv o mn adnoa os oc vd yC D l s n adl ne in i oe e ee p e s ninvin cne e b V a. l t , s r, l t t i Eu mn Cro t n r roht m fh Are e adtie bte i rne n q p e opri p ottee ot s g mn n ul d yh m ned ig i t ao i r i e t iz r d is oT wnG s a h eylo ol esdoT wnG sfr sii oe t n ) uet a a l sr e b a n i ne t a a l s o uent p a os t i a e r s tc i a s ri . 6 b g nde frm e agos n mrfrh pi i s koldes lad bi. I a a els o a rl od ad o otel nf ri s ti e a tf n w g kl n a l y d e , i it . a16 t 02 . Ee w eh Cion fd acu s n rr a o o Cion l w e us e T vn e te afr a ee l or i ep tin f afr aa p sa v K r l i r t t et l i r i, P wriiapse Te ors oc s nh teU C i n ap wsi i doh o e s npot h cu cn u ota h C d o p yal mette i. t li t d t l t pr o ote o rcda n w h r oye 7 I cn a,ts n su dh teA C D oin fh cn a eig i po tps n o rs ii ud p eta h P V t t t l t t . t t i t t Ss mws ds nd o uaenT wnG s sLkn fc r I adina n e aoe y e a e ge fr sgi a a l s uaga oy n d t , s o d bv t i i a t . io t , C Deie r h t a otenl c apoe y ne y gh A C DSs m Ee V r a di t ol fhi ee u rp t ud l nte P V y e. vn t n gs l tl t l r ri t c digC D cn n otai ws naet ds n a e,t eote rtcn oy r i n V s o e inh t a eggdo e g n wst-f h a eho g et tt t i a - -t l fo s a h(k N 14 Pi i sP -i M mrnu o L w(P P )a1) h r m c t D. o 5 l nf r T a e o d m f a rc t . , a tf e rl a l TM ,t 6 t s . ,i fc de n,w hu mr cne a o rcfr odi o nfr ev e Set An a os o i o o, ov t cn a o gos n oe os i s e S ne t t t t e r t t t r c. . - Ncai P pC , 8 F Sp a 733 ( Th sp sc e ad u o ie n u ote ak w u o 78 . upt 3 4 []e oht a d n cs m d a r fh c l . . ii t t z te eu mnde n mkiaye a od (t gr n eUdr re , 0 F dt 4) q p e os o aet nls go ci T ag ne wtr 64 . a73. i t t s . in i l i s 2 ) Acr n y h Cu cn ue a amt ol wh teAre e ws cn a cod g, e or oc ds s ae fa ta h g mn a a o rc ilt t l tr t e t t t frh s e f od ad h Ai e oteU C oente o rcci s nh ain ote a o gos n ta rc 2 fh C gv s h cn a l mit s c o l , t tl r t t a i t . C . TeC n a C im h ot c l s rt a Te r c ls oen g u m yug e ite o e oa o rcd p er wl h p n p gv i s m a jd mn nh cn x f cn a i u a e iie rn r t tt t t st e l e a ihd S m ayug e i aport o yiteagae fh cn a i wo y s bse u m jd mn s prp a n fhlnug ote o rc s h l tl . r t ie l t t l ua b uu Lcn vI lBs Mcs Cr , 1 F d 4 27 2 C. 02(u ig n m gos ue e. n u ah op 30 . 23 5 (d i 20) qo n i . t t . . . 3 , r t MlnBn v U tdBn Cr 3 F d 1 15 2 C.94 ( t n qot nm k e o ak. ne ak op 1 . 13 1 (d i 19) i e a u a o a l i ., 3 , r ) n r l ti r o ie) Iteagaes ucp b t df e r snb i ep tin adwe te mtd. fhlnugi sse i eoi e n e oa en rr a os n h eh e t tl fr t a l t et , r r ir ea e r s e dne fh p t s a u i e,tete o rcsma n bc ms se vn xi i v ec ote ai c a n n hnh cn a l t tnc i re t l t t t t en g eo e i Ide teais n KP wraretateU Cwu hv gv nd h pr o ote ned hp t i T o e g dh h C o d ae oe e te oin fh , re e t l r t cn a da n w h hms pouin n s e fhcag s I a16 o rc eig i tea rdc o ad a oteh e. d t 03 t t l t s t l rr . . 7 ai u ofcp c d g u m yug e . Syr v Rce e T.Cr Sp e e a ns e fa r l i s m a jd mn ae . ohs r e op up mn l s t eun r t s t l . l t M m Pn o P n, F d 0119 (dC. 93 gt es n l . i a 7 . 19 04 2 i 19) 3 , r . We eawt gs m gos i a us o ol ww h te uv w f h cu. hh t r ri i a b uu s qein fa i i h pr e ote or in i t tn i t Lcn , 1 F dt 5 A b u y xt we teagae fh cn a i cpb o ue e 30 . a27 m g t e s h ehlnug ote o rc s aa e f t 3 . i i is r t t l mr ta oema n we v wd b c v y y raoa ynl gnp snw h te o hn n en g hni e o eie b a esnb i eie e o i i h e i e jt l l tl t r tn cn xo b h h e i are e adh cs m ade m o go teaiu rrd o o e f o te nr g mn nte u o s nt i l yf hp t l t e r tt t te e t t r no rc a a bs e.Syr, F dt 05 n raqot nm k o ie) I cn a, o m g t u ns ae 7 . a19( t n u a o a s mtd n o rs n a b u y i s s 3 i e l ti r t . t t ii e s we te o rchs a e ne n p c ema n uaedd y ag o xt h eh cn a a d i t ad r i en g ntne b dne f is r t t fi es i, t r m cne in. adcnen gw cte i n raoa ei e ne f p in I i ocp o.. n oc i h hh es oesnb df ec o o n . d s t rn i r l fr io . O s m ayug e,T wnG s ie i efu p t u rn acs f rah y n u m jd mn a a l s dnf s or ai l is ne o b c b r t i a ti rc a t e C Di flrt dieteA C DSs mt npc o i s p e ote q p e i V:t a u o e v h P V y e aisein t h mn fh eu mn n si e l r t t ,s i t i t te bec oacp ne yT wnG s i flrt dieteA C DSs m yh h asne f ce ac b a a l s t a u o e v h P V y e bte t i a, s i e l r t diey a,adtae pt d w pnh C m e i L uo s p e. T wnG s e v d e ni t m or uote o m cl C pn h mn 8 a a l s l r t st t a ra i t i a a o ek s m ayug e o C D b ah f o rcci . l ses u m jd mn n V s r c o cn a l m s r t e t t a TeCu cn uetate i n gn n d p eh C Db ahdh Are e h or oc ds h h es o eu ei u ta V r cete g mn t l t r i st t e e t i ala s motee epc , nta T w G s ws h eo e iet r e te ntes o efhsrse s adh a a l s a te fr nt doe c h t t t i n a r e tl jt gos Fr e ii byn gn n d p eh T wnGa d n b ahh Are e. od u h,ts eod eu ei u ta a a ls i o r cte g mn . tr i st t i s d t e e t 1 Te npc o Po s n . h Ise i n rvi t io T bg w h h es eu eiare e at teiniac ote P - h mn o e n i , e i gn n d g mn s o h s i cnefh r S p e i tt r i s e t gf e i t I pc o po s nt 6 oteAre e. A d cse aoe h po s nived n ein rvi a §. fh g mn si u d bv t s rvi n t ] s t io 2 e t s s ,i io i[ Se k N 10 M mrnu o T wnG sIdsi Cro t nnSpo oi e D. o 9 e o d m f a a l s nurl opri i upr ft t . , a i a ta ao t s M in o P tlS m ay ug e ( D. M m )a2 T wnG s n eta [ h e o o fr ai u m Jd mn t ra r t e e o ,t 4 a a l s o s h t e f . i a t t ]r w en m oste b ahs fh cn a b C Db t si n sf cs o p sn e u e u o r r ce ote o rc y V, u h lay uiefr r e r r h e t t ti t f e t proe (d TeCu cn nst aa s h e ohie i e b ahs upss I ) h or of ei n y s e ttednf d r ce . . t i s li r ti e . 8 T wnG st v wc m e f acek uote y e adt a l yomete a a l so i i a e o pt i l hc o fh ss m ni bi t e h le n t t s it t se f a osmn oe h e. ( g e e,t 1 T wnG s cn ns h isein pci t n e ind e i i ci t r n Ar mn a 1 ) a a l s o edta npc o e t . i a t t t ws p cn t no h mnote y e ad oein f a mn ( e M m a91 ) a a r odi t s p e fh ss m n c lc o o py e. D f e o t 0 e io i t t l t t . , . Acr n y C D flrt mkteA C DSs maaa e oiseintC D cod g, V s a u o aeh P V y e vlb fr npc oa V s il i e t i l t haqa e,T wnG s a escni td b ah fh Are e.C D h wv, edu t s a a l s s r ,ost e a r c ote g mn V , o ee rr i a st tu e e t r ras h po s nsm e ivigT wnG st vi C D fc r ,w hui ps g edte rvi a e l n t io r y i n a a l s oit V sa oy i o mo n a i a s t t t i lg o ia o o C D o e os a te u oe t n fh A C DSs m ( k N ea b gin n V t d mnr ehf l p a o ote P V y e. D. o l l t tt l ri t t . 17 M mrnu o L wnOpsinoh Scn M in oP tlS m ay ug e 9 e o d m f a i pot tte eod o o frai u m Jd mn , a io t ra r t (P Op)a6 l p ,t. . . ) Itu,h Are e i n amd oc r yadtas oe n te pci cn n nr h e g mn s o oe fl i , n iflt d ie h se f o e tt e t t l at i f ic t t o C D o ia o ud §. C D psin as m m i te a mntacs m f V s b gin ne 6. V s ot hs o e et hst e h u o e l t r 2 io r: te t t t r vi a ecu gd adh ue fh t mivesge s h iseins m e p o it r nor e nte s ote e ss e a r n t ugs ta npc oi a e o in i t t t r t w h oeacneunead o ignh po s nn c e a oe m hepcit i nlg osqec n n h ite rvi id a s s n i t xe t o t l , tn io it g t taf loe t n fh A C DSs m isein seu e C Da o as h T wn h u p a o ote P V y e a npc o irq rd V l syta a a t l ri t t t i . s t i G s ud s otad mnrin fhf l p a o ote y e p ot s p n ws l s net dh e os a o ote u oe t n fh ss m r ro h p g a a ro t tt l ri t i ii nte ps b nr xe e I ws ops b ,C D as eas otei it n o e h o i e oepc d t a n o i e V sy bcue fhl ma os f i r sl t. t sl , ti C D fciyadhfctate y e s uc oat dpne oi erinn T wn V sal nte a h h ss m fnini eedd nn g t i o a a it t t t t ly t ao t i G s sla g sl e ( k N 15 Dc o LoadRsna m nOpsino M in o l s f tl si . D. o 9 e. f en a o a n t . , l r oebu i pot t o o fr io t P tlS m ay ug e , ¶, 7 I ws o epc d ae o te rvl g o mite ai u m Jd mn ¶ 62 ) t a n xe e bsd n h p ai nr s nh ra r t . t t e in ids y (. ¶ 23 ) nur I ¶ 3 3 t. d . H wv , uig g n C D i ep tinsagaele h enh cn a. o o ee ct n aa s V s n rr a oilnug e we ite o rc Fr r t it t et s r t t ea p, a mnote eod 0% fh prhs p c i cn t nd nS p n ad x m epy e fh scn 3 ote u ae r e s odi e o h p g n l t c i io ii Ts n aSlr Fc i adce acfr h p g ( re e,t ( mhs add) eigt ee s alt n a p ne os p n. A e mn a3 e pa s de) t l i y ct ii g t i . Mroe a ogh ga o tssta C D epc e] oi s as gf e fh o v, mnte o s r ak h V xe [dt f ih tt ei ote e r l t t n a v P l m ay Mnfc r g ceu ws p -h mn F a Ts o O ieA C D ri i r au t i Shd e a a r s p e i l e f n n P V e n a un l e i t n t l Ss m n [ a wnG s fc r s n f (. t 9 T sagae ugs tate y e ad T a l s a oyi o. I a1 ) h lnug sge s h h t i a] t g f d . i t t Are e cn m a d o eid f r s p e iseineetogte aiu r o g mn o e pt s m k o p -h mn npc o vnhuhh p t l s f e t t le n e i t t , rc a sc aiseinw e osee o. uh nnpc o e n pld u t r t l t I so,we e C Dws b g et po da r-h mnisein adf o n hr h h V a o ia do rv e p s p e npc o nis t tr l t i e i t t , wai wseu et d mnr et h isein a i us fm e afcat w c h t arq rdo e os a ata npc o t i tt t t r s e o a rl a s o h h es ti t i te i gn n d p e h es eu ei u. r i st 2 Si et n h Asne f Acpac . hpmni te bec o cet ne N w h ad gh aoe ts eod eu e ip etaC D rahdh cn a o i s n nte bv ii byn gn n d u h V b cete o rc t tt i , i st t e t t b fl go bi T wnG s s acp ne arq rd yh Are e,b o s p n yai t o a a a l s ce ac, seu e bte g mn e r h p g in tn i a t i e t fe ii teo pnn oteA C DSs m hc moe sfh P V y e. t t A n e aoe ht r s fh Are e ua b uu y dnf acp ne o s o d bv te e m ote g mn n m gos ie iy ce acfr t , e t i l t t s p n b [ awnG s a a odino a mnote eodn a mnote u hs h p g y T a l s s cn t t py e fh scnisl e fh pr ae ii i a] io t tl t c p c.( g e e,t. T wnG s s x aa o oteo c ne y gh cn t ns r e Ar mn a3 a a l s ep nin fhlg ud l nt s odi i i e t ) i a l t i ri i io p sa v ipo ddT wnG s w h nls opr n yb o py gh nx 3 e us e trv e a a l s i oea po u t e r a nte e 0% r i: i i a t t t i, f e i t isl mnad h t g o nt pouinieon a teA C DSs m o r e i e n a e n sui d wi rdc ol tisl h P V y e, po c t l tl t tn s t n tl t t t t sf ite vntai ws og nt g waihd ag nd o. Adh es oreip e nh ee h t a n o go e h ta b a e fr nte i ntu d u t t t i t t ri r st taT wnG s w he i acp ne os p n A S o h me n ei h ps h a a l s i h dt ce acfr h p g s t b i s f o dni oti a t l s t ii. rl l t s t iseineo,Cag ntetee p ye av eta te [ e ] oa hr et npc o rpr hn adh o r m oes d sdh hy w e n u o zdo t t h l i t r t t i s n ce ac os p e t [ awnG s ad h C D hu te fr n s ph i acp ne f h mn o T a l s nta V so dh eo o h te g t i t i a] t l r e t i ss m ( e 5 1S m ¶ 2 y e . D. 6 t t 4 ) t f . , . C D os o ma nf l cn stat sagae fh cn a c a d n V de n en gu y o e h h lnug ote o rc r t a t i l tt t i t t ee o ia o uoit scr a r s p e apoafo T wnG s 9 Is a itks h b gin pnt o eu p -h mn prv r m a a l s ned taete l t e e i t l i a. t , psin n u m yug e ta T wnG s acp d s p e we irp sn do ot o s m a jd mn h a a l s ce e h mn hnter e et io r t t i a t i t e t Cpa Oeii O oe 2lt i acrac w hht m oteS nb L tai a t n nt c b 8ee n codne i tee sfh t dy C h t il s t r tr t r a t hdnrc dC Do h te qi mn1 (l Op a32 ) ais u e V t s ph eup e. P p,t, 4 t t i t0 . . . Taag mni cnue Tee vnt r oteS nb L ii m 6,w c h ru e s ofsd hr ea e m f h t dy Cst 4 A h h t t . l t a e i rq rdT wnG st poue cp o[ erqe snt [ V ] nrc nte t s p eu e a a l s o rdc a oy ft ]eus e o C Dis uigh m o h i i a h t t t t i Cn nos C A C DSs m n Ehu GsSs m d e n l e Nv me 120 o iuuT O P V y e ad xas a y e a d o a r oe b , 09 t t t t t tt r [ c ( e 5 1S m E 7a1 Te ups ot se mwsp s mb,o nu ta s ] D. 6 t t x ,t. h proe fh t i. f . , . ) i r a r u a y esr h , e lt e t T wnG s hd e u i ed fh b g n eo a oig t rcu i py e. a a l s a h d pt n ote a a b r l w i oeopt a mn i a l s ri fel n t s t Te i nid a otate ais netot s nrc ot s p s uiigh h es on cinh h p t ud s d h is uino h af fl te r it t re ro i t t i ll n cn a u rq r mnta T wnG s po d a r-h mn acp ne ote od o rc a eu e e h a a l s rv e p s p e ce ac fh gos t tl i t t i a i e i t t . Ote o r y T wnG s sO oe 2lt c a ynrc dC Do h te y e o nh cn a , a a l s c b 8ee l r is u e V t s ph ss m n tr i a t r tr el t t i t t cn t nh irc vdhrq se acp nefo T wnG s ( e 5 1S m E h odi ta tee eteeui ce ac r m a a l s D. 6 t t x e io t i it t i a. f . , . 1 ) Nr osC D psin o pr w h o mn es A T wnG s os vs h 6 o de V s ot c mo i c m o sne s a a l s be e te . io t t . i a r , is uinnh S nbL c m b o icu ko we e C Di i fc hv a nrc oite t dy C a e e r t o d n w h h V d ,na, ae t t a fe l tr d t ss m o h.I wu b a odeu i i se nt f f te o m rq r mn ote y e t s p t o d e n d rs tf n ek go ui hfr a eu e e s fh t i l l, i ll l i t Ii pp s po n T wnG s sm in C D as N h gn aarp 6 mks nt ae ops g a a l s o o V sy o i i prgah. ae s r i i a t , : tn 2 isein o acp ne otenpc d q p e ) cn t n rcdnt s p n (l npc o (r ce ac fhise e eu mn a odi p ee o h p g P t t t i t io e t ii. . Op a6( mhs add) Ta mc my ereb C Das o x a wyhky p,t e pa s de) h uh a btu u V flt epi htee . i . t , t i ln lnugoteh d aef h Are e w c mks a me cn t n o acp ne agaenht r pg ote ge mn h h ae py n odi a n ce ac i t i t io l t fr h p g de n c a sc a odin rcdn os p n ii os o r t uh cn t p ee. t ee io e t 9 Ii p v ufig C D ocddh T wnG s w he i acp neb aee nt r i si ns V cneeta a a l s i h dt ce ac u l gd s eo l , t i a t l s t , tl tai d s wogu y( ee. D.N 1 C m a t 4 ( f r goT wnG s s h ti o rnf l S ,. , k o , o pi , 6r ei t a a l s t d l. e g t . l n¶ ern i a bda ht m s o o eC Do ce adin cn t n n iteCn a,ic d g a ft ae p t fr i t t c V t acp d t a odi s o nh o rc n u n t io l io t t t li w ho ighfr aacp ne os p n ) P P ,t ([ awnG s b ahdh i h d te o m ce acfr h p g ; l TMa2 T a l s r cete t ln l t ii . i a] e cn a i bd a hr u nt po di acp ne os p e .. ) o rc n a ft e s go rv et ce acfr h mn . .. t t i, f i i s t i t ) 1 0 S nb L te ups o w cit po c T wnG s aa s nne o mne y t dy C h proe f h hs o r e a a l s g n op fr ac b a i tt i a it r C D T wnG s cnu e l po ddh acp nefr h p g e iigC Do V a a l s ocr n y rv ete ce ac os p n nt n V t i a rt i t ii tl py e ote eod 0%n a mn I ay vn teT wnG sis uin u unt a mn fh scn 3 isl e. n n ee,h a a l s nrc o pr a o t tl t t i a t t s t teS nb L d e e C Do h te nr Cn nosT OA C DSs m n Ehu h t dy C i c d V t s p h e i a rt i t e o iuu C P V y e ad xas t t t GsSs m ( d n jss m oi cni e p t w c b C D a m s n swai a ye t i ) o u o e ft ost n as h h y V s d i i , h t . t t , s tu t r i, so i t s pe h pd i . T b sr T wnG s hd d yo x c etr ht w ho acp ne o o e u, a a l s a a u t ee i i i t o i h d ce acfr e i a t rs s g t l t s p n i go ft I N wYr eey o rccnis n m id oea o go ft h p g n oda h n e ok v cn a o a ai pe cvnn f od a h ii i. , r t t tn l t i ada da n Tae e I l AGv Tas Wr Al e Ic 4 F d 5017 (dC. n f r eig rvlr n , ... rn o d ii s n, 1 . 17 55 2 i i l . l st l rn , . 3 , r 19) Ee we a o rccn r dcin mk g o e o aig p t teeuig 94 . vn hn cn a of s e s - a n p w n s l a y h rs t t t e io i r n e r, ln d c t ns ee h e sb ct a o ia otai b ee iei go ft I I i ri i nv te s u e o n b gin h t e x c dn oda h d n s eo r l s jt l t t rs i. . df e c c m acs fsy C D a poue a tec moe sf cno m g i e n i u s ne i a V hd rdcd l h o pnn o a ofr i fr t r t , , l t n A C DSs madT wnG s s u b sw els m e a T wnG s siht P V y e , n a a l s q b e e e a rl a a l s r t o t i a il r s ti i a g rs vi acp ne os p n wu b mr db u H enti s n n C D ee et ce acfr h p g o d e o u os e, ow h ad g V s r s t ii l e i . r tt i a eintte o r yn raoa euy o d oc d ta T wnG s a ei bd a h s r os oh cn a , oesnb jr cu cn ue h a a l s c dn a ft st tr l l l t i a t i i w ho ig ce acfr h p g1 C D afldop snsf c ne dneo n i h d acp ne os p n 1 V hsaet r e ui e v ect t ln t ii. i e t fi t i d mnr e m e aqein fip e fc a teeod o a s ore pot no e os a a a rl us o o d u da, s hrcr cni n tu opsi t tt ti t st t tn io Ii pp s po nt sm in C D as h T wnG s s npc o ws aid u nt ae ops gh o o V syta a a l s isein a c r o s r i i t , t i a t re t i b ft. Se f a y C D o edta bcuehT wnG s e p ye wo na a h pci l , V cn ns h, eastea a l s m oes h di i cl t t i a l cnu etenpc o a mtdh telce te u ott acpeu mnfr odc dhisein d ieta hyakd h a hr yo ce q p e o t t t t t i t i t s p e, awnG s e dn y ee hdhi e in f rv ig s ce acfr h mn T a l s v e l nv ate n n o o po d i acp ne o i t i a i t r tt int t s p e.(l Op a2 n 7 TeCu flt se adC D as o x a h wh h mn P p,t 3. . h or as o e n V flt epi o ta i t . . 1) ti i ln t cn u o ncsal f l w m e fo te m oeslc o a hr a o fr ce ac oc s n ee r y o o s e l r m h e p ye ak f u o zin oacp ne li si l ry l t it t . HdC D rdcd f l cno m gA C DSs mtisein oea p, h T wn a V poue a u y ofr i l n P V y e a npc o fr x m ete a a t t , l i G s e p ye m hhv cn c dh r ue o w hnrc os o rv e ce acfr l s m oes i t ae o a ete sp ir i is uint po d acp ne o a l g tt i r s t t t i t s p e.I o e wrs hrcr de n ba o a eu eip e bu we e T wn h mn nt r od teeod os o e u gn n d u ao h h a a i t h , t r t i st t tr i G s a ei bd a hnw ho ig s ce a c l s c dn a fti i h d i acp n e a t i t lnt t . 1 1 T wnG s s contai w he acp ne eas ii raoa y e v w ay a a l s acu h t i h d ce ac bcue nt esnb h di , n i a t t t l t , s l l e s p e o C Dwu n hv cnie te o s o w ci hd ag nd h mn f V o d o ae o a d h go fr h ht a b a e i t l t tn d i ri . Acr n y C D s p e ite bec o T wnG s s acp ne o cod g, V s h mn nh asne f a a l s ce acfr il i t i a t s p n d n cno m oh Are e.Se..UCC§ - 0() Gos r odc h p g i o ofr tte g mn e NY ... 2 162( od o cnu ii d t e t t ic d gn p t f p fr ac a cno m g o cno m oh cn a wete a i n u nay a oa e o mner ofr i li r r e n r ofr tte o rc hnhyr n t t e acrac w hh o ia os nete o rc ) T s ocno m yfoddT wn codne i te b gin ud h cn a.. h nnofr i a re a a t l t r t t i t f i G steih uotne o dieynT wn oe cte od Se d§ -0 a( I l s hr t pned f e v i a a t r e h gos e i 261) [f a g, r l r i , jt . . ( ] te od oteed o dieya i ayepct cno m oh cn a,h by my h gos rhtne f e v fl n n rse o ofr tte o rc te ue a r l r i t t t r ..e ctewo .. )Fs o wa( V) t v Rg t (. A L C 0- V59 20 .r e h h e ..; ah n er P T L .. ea a U.. L , 3C -57 06 jt l i d t S ) , W 655 a* (.... M. 720) 1 T wnG s d,na, e cte h pd L 926 t 3 SDNY a 1 06 2 a a l s i i fc r e h s pe , r , . i a d t jt i gos1 adC Di n set cri i poetne o diey Se..UCC§ -0 od 3 n V d o eko u t mrp ed f e v . e NY ... 258 , d t es r r l r . A aeu,T wnG si o ete u i p d oC Dt h o s ote r e. Se d s rs t a a l ss wdh s mt a t V ate u e fh po c e i l i a i tt jt . C D o edta ud ni ep tin fh Are e cu C Dtne te n n V cn ns h ne on rr a o ote g mn o d V ed h o ie t t r t et e t l r l A C DSs mb oe tws n ae o [ awnG s sf ag sl e (l Op a1 ) P V y e e r i aisl d n T a l s ]l tl si . P p,t 7 t f tl i a o a n . . . T s an b su e w hh U C d i t n fed. Sei o N w ok.P l a h cno e qa d i te C s e ni otne e Cyf e Yr v u mn i t r t fio r t l Ic 62F d 1 99 2 C. 91( Tne o diey ocr we te ee p s n, 6 . 90 1 (d i 18) ed f e v . 2 , r r l r cu hn h sl u s lr t cno m g od ate ue sipsin NY UCC§ -0() Tne o dieys ofr i gost h by d ot . .. ... 2531 ed f e v i n r s io . r l r fr e d ie a sc p fr ac b teed ig a y s u tete p t i d a tf u h e nd s uh e o mne y htne n p t a p s h o r a yn e u i tr f r r r t h r fl hflt poedn o emne Oi a C m e t NY UCC§ -0 ) C Dla y eas o rcei s m an. f cl o mn o .. ... 253 . V c r i r fi t . el p te od a T wnG s sipsinweis pete t T wnad a u igh u h gost a a l s d ot t i a s i o hnt h pdh m o a a n s m te i i , s n gos a be cno m g T wnG s s a u t acpte wu hv p cdt n od hd en ofr i n a a l s flr o ce h m o d ael eii i a i e t l a d at e u. fl 1 2 Ta C Dws w e fT wnG s s e c o ote od i byn gn n d p e I h V a a a o a a l s r ein fh gos s eod eu ei u. n t r i a jt i st i p -i m mrnu ,C Daete ot nh [ awnG s d n tk ay t rt a e o d m V tks h psi ta T a l s i o ae n s erl a io t i a] d t ai mietpt saoa y of C Dh i hd e ddo e cte q p e. (l fr a v s s o esnb n iy V ta t a dc et r e h eu mn P f t e l t t i jt i t . P ,t 0 Ote o r y C D as T wnG s r m nd nr yi n ad vn TMa2 ) nh cn a , V sy a a l s e a e e i l se, n ee . tr , i a i te l t r uetifr C Dh i hde c dh eu mn we se f a y se b C Di e sdono m V ta t a r e ete q p e hn pci l akd y V v f t jt i t i cl a lt il eau y 00 (d T ss dignosru e. C D lt a u e ee na Jna 21 I ) h i ai neuu ag mn V see s md tr t r . . i s t tr s T wnG s s e cinisuhaepne n tte x nta T wnG s d n i ed a a l s r e o t og rsos o yoh e e h a a l si o n n i a jt ; t l tt t i a dt t t r e te od ( e 5 1S m E 1 (T seeit cnr ta T wnG s hs oe c h gos D. 6 t t x 9 h lt s o of m h a a l s a jt . f . , . i tr i t i a r e ete od It ss o T wnG s psinp ae of C Dw h fr - g e c dh gos fh i n a a l s ot ,l s n iy V i i o yih jt . i t i a io e t t n te t (8 hu. Asnsc n ieyur einwl e of md ) 4) or be uh oc ore c o i b cnr e . s t t , jt l i .) 1 3 § -1() We .. h by r h u ye c ojsf b rvks ce acte.. 2711( h e. te ue i t l r e s rui a yeoe acp nehn. r r g fl j t ti l t w hepcttewo ite rah os oh wo cn a ..,h by my ac ad i rse oh h efh b c gette h e o rc . te ue a cne n t t l e l t t r l we e o n h hs oe omy. rcv [ omc ote r e s a be p d.. . h h r o e a dn s a.. eoe] uh fh p c a hs en a .. ) tr t rs i i 3 Lt Diey . a e vr e l I adin T wnG s ageta C D rahdh Are e b fl go e v n d t , a a l srus h V b cete g mn yai t die io i a t e e t in l r te o rc d o Ss m yh cn a u diey a. ( e M m a2 ) he h cn a e fr y e bte o rc a e v d e D. e. t 4 W l t tt t tl l r t f , . i cneig h mc oteri iay ceu hs n ap a oa tnt eoe T wn ocdn ta uh f hp l m r shd e a a s rin,e a vtn a a t e n l i t l ti , i G s cn ns h n sctnifudntg s ote ceu,w c ad se diey l s o edta o uhoes oni s ei fh shd e h h dr ss e v . a t t a x l i e l r (da8 I p t u r htss ntg s a n u ie veytes g p fcdw h I t. n ai l , eaki s ei r o n k e r o rt e r ae i . ) rc a t a x e t l h a e t teagae C D xe s oi ste o oigaki s g[ ] (. Frt p t C D hlnug V epc t f ihhf l w tss nt e X I ) oi a, V t n l n a . d s r cnee tas p e d n ocr yh d e pcidnh diey ceu, u ocds h h mn i o cu bte a se f ite e v shd eb t i t d t t ie l r l t nn h e m nis h t si e n ws ae o t g d e r h ta h d n fs oe e s a t nta h t mie a bsd n a e a s a e hn a ad a tls ia ti l rt t tr r t da ie (l Op a1 2 ) ed ns P p,t 9 0 l . . . . Tea i N wYrita w e a e nei e f e o mnes pcidn hl wn e oks h t h e d i tt m o p fr aci se f i a r fi r ie cn a,i es fh e ec u e tei u s ne ai mie id a a o r yn n o rc t mi ote s ne n s h c c m acs fr a v yn c e cn a i e. t t s ls r t f t l it tr t t K mrA s Icv Kc Sp y & rd g L , 0 V 70 21 W 6856a* o a m, n . oh up l . . l Ta n P 1- -95 01 L 326 t 8 i, C , , (....Dc1 21) qo n Sak vSc, 3 AD d 8 9152NYS d 0 79 SDNY e 5 01(u ig prs.t h 15 .. 99 9 2 ... 77 0 . , t i 2 , , 2 , (dDp 18)( ak s n i en qot nm k o ie)acr T wr Ca e & 3 e t 97 b ce ad n ra u a o a s mtd cod o e hr r )r t t l ti r t ; s t Mr eCr v Cdlc n C 84F d 1 53 2 C. 90 H e h s niac o a n op . a l Is o 9 . 56 2 (d i 19) e, e i i cne f i . i a . ., 2 , r . rt gf te a s nh die shd es oc afo t fc oteAre e . W l s g s h d eite e v y ceu i n l rr mh ae fh g mn t l r l t e e e t het ei i a x lcs hpo s n lnug e e h enh mnfc r g ceu,h shd e aktervi a agael we ite au t i shd e e ceu iol s r a un lt l nn h e s s u ga fr ahtg w hu mk g n xrs ecp o frh diey oe e s e o o s oec s e i o a n a ep s xe in ote e v tls t t l a t t i e t l r s g Mroe T wnG s acp tate tes gs fh shd er ac ma e b t e o v , a a l s ce s h h o rt e ote ceu a co pn d y a. e r i a t t h a l e i a ap a oa adtnt etn ad n wu epctad as n e g ad n s rin n e a v oe n oe o d xe h e yi ds n n it l ti , l t t l i mnfc r gwu,n un ocs n e y i diey Acr n y we et mwsote au t i o d tr ca o d as n e v . cod g, h h i ea fh a un li , i l l r il tr e ec ud teAre e i n f er m eu eip e s ne ne h g mn s o r fo gn n d u. s r e t te i st 4 C D A em t oC lc Pymn . V s t p t oe a et t l t If l wfo te oc s nead g rah bvta C D sbeunae pt t o o sr m hcn u o rg i b c aoeh V s usqe t m o l li rn e t tt t d w o n nh C m e i L frh scnisl mnote o rca o mu s o r d w ote o m cl C ote eod n a e fh cn a l a on t a a ra tl t t ts t b ah f o rc N o yi C D h w hu T wnG s s ce ac b ia o r c o cn a. o n d V s p i o a a l s acp ne u tl e t t t l d i t t i a t , t s cnee ys pe o yas fh A C DSs m C Dws oe ie t c lcpy e, ocdd h pd n p t ote P V y e. V a n nt do oe a mn l i l r t t tl l t t adt ae pt d s rnfuote xrst m oteAre e. ni t m o o oa ao fh ep se sfh g mn st t l e r e t 5 C D Bec C im . V s rah l a L g ynihote o g n aa s, u m yug e i a ow rn d nao a e il t fh fr o g n y ss m a jd mn sl a a e i fvr rl g ei li r t s r t o T wnG s o C D b ah f o rcci .C D as h i b ahl mi bsd f a a l s n V s r c ocn a l m V syta t r c ci s ae i a e t t a ts e a uo [ awnG s sdcin yt ese l O oe 20tai nlne wn d n n n pn T a l s] e s b ala a y c b 09h t oog a e a o ie i a io t r t r t r t l A C D y e, ni sbeunainttyo v dh Are e,ic d g seua P V ss madt usqe c os ort ao te g mn n u ni r s t s t t i e t li t f l t c a C D s p e truh u o s (l Op a2 ) V a o as h T wnG s ol r V s h mn hog cs m P p,t 3 C D l syta a a l s e i t t . . . . s t i a hd oiht r ueh s p e bcueC Dws o tne n te od b s p n a n r t oe ste h mn eas V a n ed ig h gos y h p g g f i t t r ii te t T wnadh T wnG s b ahd y oc r n o i iseinn od a h h m o a a nta a a l s r ce b n a y g u t npc oi go ft i , t i a e t ri ts t i. Teeru e sr as e d bv T wnG s wsw h i cn a u r h i hs ag mn a n w e aoe a a l s a i i t o rc a i t n t e r . i a t ns t t l gs w ho ig ce acfr h mnadeu n t c ate h mntruh u o s Ee i h d acp ne os p e n r s gol rh s p e hog cs m vn t ln t i t fi e i t t . i C Dws oi fc tne n te q p e aisein h Are e nn h e f V a n na ed ig h eu mn t npc o te g mn oe e s t t r i t t , e t tls cn r d nT wnG ste o rc ar ht r ue ce ac ud tei u s ne of r o a a l s h cn a u i t o e s acp ne ne h c c m acs ee i a t tl g f t r r t . T wnG s nter uet s ce ac nr aid ui isein n a ft I a a l s e h e sdh acp ne o c r o t npc o i bda h n i a i rf i t , re t s t , i. so,C D a po e d o v ec g igie o gn n d p efm e afcat hr V hs rf r n e dnei n r t a eu ei u o a rl a s o t fe i v s i st ti t we e T wnG s b ahdh Are e. h h a a l s r cete g mn tr i a e e t I. C n u o I I oc s n li Frh frg n raos T wnG s sm in o p tl u m yug e i ote o o gesn a a l s o o fr ai s m a jd mn s ei , i a t ra r t G A T D TeCu od s h e r ojd mni fvr f awnG s aa s C D n R N E . h or re te n y fug e nao oT a l s g n V i t r t t i a it te mu o $ 54 0 p s r ug e i e satea o n e e e fo te a o h a on f 3 6 00 l p jd mn n r tt hr e fi p cn r m h d e f t , , , u e t te t n r t t b ahJnay 021 te a o w cteC D h mnaiei T wn r c au 1 00 h d e n h hh V s p e r vdn a a e , r , , t i i tr i . Te ais r d e et cn r nt sb ilt s n r eo Nv me 1 21 h p t a i c d o of ado u m ee o o b r oe b 9 04 re e r t e t tr fe r , ad s n h why rpst poedw h h nx pae fh cs TeCu wl drs dr s g o te pooeo rce i te e hs ote ae h or i ad s ei t t . t l e toe rps st h nxcn rneshd e frNv me 2 21 a 1 0 am hs pooa ate e of ec ceu d o oe b 1 04t 0 0.. l t e , l r , : TeC r o Cu i d e et c stem int ok n me 16 h l k f or si c dol eh o o adce u b 8 e t rt o t t r . S O DRD O R E E. D e Nv me 1 21 a d oe b 3 04 t: r , N wYr N wYr e ok e ok , __________________ __________________ JP U O T E . AL EKN U tdStsDt cJde ne t e irt ug i a si
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
