MCGOVERN v. BUILDING MATERIALS CORPORATION OF AMERICA, No. 2:2014cv05258 - Document 19 (D.N.J. 2015)
Court Description: OPINION. Signed by Judge Jose L. Linares on 6/26/2015. (Attachments: # 1 Opinion Exhibit 1, # 2 Opinion Exhibit 2)\(nr, )
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
MCGOVERN v. BUILDING MATERIALS CORPORATION OF AMERICA Doc. 19 Att. 2 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers: EXHIBIT 2 Count Count Applicable State Law Ohio Plaintiffs California Virginia New Hampshire New York Burger Robertie Shepherd Ross Sheridan Denton Hoover & Cohen McGovern Narducci Claxton Warren Ernst Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Megerle Barker Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Indiana Stidham North Carolina Missouri Iowa Montana Michigan 1 Negligence Nebraska Illinois Colorado MTD Decision Not moved on except as alternative Granted: Dismisseded without prejudice Granted: Dismisseded with prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 2 Indiana Consumer Protection Statute 4 Michigan Consumer Protection Act Michigan McGovern Narducci Claxton 5 Missouri Merchandising Practices Act Missouri Ross Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 6 Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act Illinois Ernst Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 7 Virginia Consumer Protection Act Virginia Wolcott Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 8 Montana Consumer Protection Act Montana Hoover & Cohen Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Not moved on Kaiser 9 Colorado Consumer Protection Act Colorado Turcheck Barker Megerle Granted: To the extent that Plaintiffs' class claims for monetary damages are dismisseded with prejudice Tuthill 1 of 6 Dockets.Justia.com 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers: EXHIBIT 2 Count Count Applicable State Law 10 North Carolina Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act North Carolina 11 13 15 16 Ohio Product Liability Act New Hampshire Consumer Protection Act New York General Business Law ยง 349 California False Advertising Law Plaintiffs MTD Decision Robertie Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Shepherd Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Ohio Burger Granted: Dismissed without prejudice New Hampshire Khanna Not moved on New York Giovannetti Not moved on California Williams Not moved on Not moved on 17 California Consumer Legal Remedies Act California Williams 18 Nebraska Unfair and Deceptive Practices Nebraska Warren Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 19 Iowa Consumer Fraud Law Iowa Sheridan Denton Not moved on Ohio Burger Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Missouri Ross Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Iowa Montana Sheridan Denton Hoover & Cohen Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice McGovern Michigan 20 Breach of Express Warranty Nebraska Illinois Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Narducci Claxton Warren Ernst Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Kaiser Colorado Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Indiana Stidham Granted: Dismissed without prejudice California Virginia New Hampshire New York North Carolina Mississippi Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Shepherd Mapp Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 2 of 6 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers: EXHIBIT 2 Count Applicable State Law Plaintiffs Ohio Count Burger MTD Decision Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Robertie North Carolina Montana Shepherd Hoover & Cohen Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice McGovern Michigan 21 Breach of Implied Warranties Narducci Claxton Nebraska Warren Illinois Ernst Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Indiana Mississippi Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Stidham Mapp Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Ohio Burger Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Robertie Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Shepherd Ross Sheridan Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Colorado North Carolina Missouri Iowa Montana Michigan 22 Negligent Misrepresentation Nebraska Illinois Denton Hoover & Cohen McGovern Narducci Claxton Warren Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Indiana Ernst Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Stidham California Williams Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Virginia Wolcott Granted: Dismissed without prejudice New Hampshire Khanna Granted: Dismissed without prejudice New York Giovannetti Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Mississippi Mapp Colorado 3 of 6 Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Denied 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers: EXHIBIT 2 Count Count Applicable State Law Ohio North Carolina Missouri Iowa Montana Michigan 23 Fraudulent Misrepresentation Nebraska Illinois Plaintiffs Burger Robertie Shepherd Ross Sheridan Denton Hoover & Cohen McGovern Narducci Claxton Warren MTD Decision Not moved on except as alternative Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Not moved on Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice California Virginia New Hampshire New York Mississippi Ernst Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Mapp Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Denied Ohio Burger Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Robertie Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Shepherd Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Colorado North Carolina Missouri Nebraska Sheridan Denton Hoover & Cohen McGovern Narducci Claxton Warren Illinois Ernst Iowa Montana Michigan 24 Fraudulent Concealment/ Omission Ross Colorado Indiana California Virginia New Hampshire New York Mississippi Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Stidham Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Mapp 4 of 6 Not moved on Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Granted: Dismissed with prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers: EXHIBIT 2 Count Count Applicable State Law Ohio North Carolina Plaintiffs Burger Robertie MTD Decision Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Shepherd Missouri Iowa Ross Sheridan Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Denton Montana Hoover & Cohen Granted: Dismissed without prejudice McGovern Michigan 25 Violation of Magnuson Moss Warranty Act Nebraska Illinois Narducci Claxton Warren Ernst Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Kaiser Colorado Indiana California Virginia New Hampshire New York Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska Illinois 26 Strict Products Liability: Defective Design & Manufacture Colorado California New Hampshire Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Stidham Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Mapp Ross Hoover & Cohen Warren Ernst Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Williams Khanna 5 of 6 Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers: EXHIBIT 2 Plaintiffs Burger Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Robertie Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Shepherd Count Applicable State Law Ohio Count Granted: Dismissed with prejudice North Carolina MTD Decision Missouri Iowa 27 Sheridan Denton Montana Unjust Enrichment (Pleading in the Alternative) Ross Hoover & Cohen Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Nebraska Warren Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Illinois Ernst Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Colorado Indiana California Virginia New Hampshire New York Mississippi Ohio North Carolina Missouri Iowa Montana Michigan 28 Declaratory Judgment Nebraska Illinois Colorado Indiana California Virginia New Hampshire New York Mississippi Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Stidham Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Mapp Burger Robertie Shepherd Ross Sheridan Denton Hoover & Cohen McGovern Narducci Claxton Warren Ernst Kaiser Turcheck Tuthill Barker Megerle Stidham Williams Wolcott Khanna Giovannetti Mapp 6 of 6 Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Not moved on Denied Not moved on Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Granted: Dismissed without prejudice Denied
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
