MCGOVERN v. BUILDING MATERIALS CORPORATION OF AMERICA, No. 2:2014cv05258 - Document 19 (D.N.J. 2015)

Court Description: OPINION. Signed by Judge Jose L. Linares on 6/26/2015. (Attachments: # 1 Opinion Exhibit 1, # 2 Opinion Exhibit 2)\(nr, )

Download PDF
MCGOVERN v. BUILDING MATERIALS CORPORATION OF AMERICA Doc. 19 Att. 1 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers EXHIBIT 1 Count 1 Claim Negligence Previously Dismissed/ Plaintiffs Affirmatively Do Not Oppose Plaintiffs Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Shepherd Megerle Barker Bender Mapp Stidham McGovern 2 Indiana Consumer Protection Statute 3 New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act All Plaintiffs 4 Michigan Consumer Protection Act Missouri Merchandising Practices Act 6 Ernst 7 Virginia Consumer Protection Act Wolcott 8 Montana Consumer Protection Act Hoover & Cohen Colorado Consumer Protection Act Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Ross Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) McGovern Narducci Claxton 5 Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Kaiser Turcheck Barker Megerle Tuthill 9 Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Page 1 of 6 Dockets.Justia.com 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers EXHIBIT 1 Count Claim North Carolina Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act Robertie 10 Previously Dismissed/ Plaintiffs Affirmatively Do Not Oppose Plaintiffs 11 12 13 Ohio Product Liability Act Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act New Hampshire Consumer Protection Act Shepherd Burger Burger Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Khanna 14 Pennsylvania Unfair and Deceptive Acts and Practices Montante 15 New York General Business Law ยง 349 Giovannetti 16 California False Advertising Law Williams 17 California Consumer Legal Remedies Act Williams 18 Nebraska Unfair and Deceptive Practices Warren 19 Iowa Consumer Fraud Law 20 Breach of Express Warranty Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Sheridan Denton Bender Burger Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Page 2 of 6 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers EXHIBIT 1 Count 21 22 Claim Breach of Implied Warranties Negligent Misrepresentation Previously Dismissed/ Plaintiffs Affirmatively Do Not Oppose Plaintiffs Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Page 3 of 6 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers EXHIBIT 1 Count 23 24 Claim Fraudulent Misrepresentation Fraudulent Concealment/ Omission Previously Dismissed/ Plaintiffs Affirmatively Do Not Oppose Plaintiffs Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Page 4 of 6 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers EXHIBIT 1 Count 25 26 Claim Violation of Magnuson Moss Warranty Act Strict Products Liability: Defective Design & Manufacture Previously Dismissed/ Plaintiffs Affirmatively Do Not Oppose Plaintiffs Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Burger Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Page 5 of 6 15-18 In re Elk Cross Timbers EXHIBIT 1 Count 27 28 Claim Unjust Enrichment (Pleading in the alternative) Declaratory Judgment Previously Dismissed/ Plaintiffs Affirmatively Do Not Oppose Plaintiffs Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Burger Robertie Ross Sheridan Hoover & Cohen McGovern Warren Narducci Claxton Ernst Kaiser Stidham Williams Wolcott Montante Denton Turcheck Tuthill Khanna Giovannetti Bender Barker Megerle Shepherd Mapp Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Plaintiffs do not oppose GAF's MTD (ECF No. 61-1) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 51) Voluntarily Dismissed Claims (ECF No. 59) Page 6 of 6

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.