-VPC Tjeltveit v. McDaniel, No. 3:2011cv00163 - Document 7 (D. Nev. 2011)

Court Description: THEREFORE IS ORDERED that the petition is DISMISSED with prejudice as time-barred. FURTHER ORD P's # 3 Motion for appointment of counsel is DENIED. FURTHER ORD that a certificate of appealability is DENIED. FURTHER ORD the Clerk additio nally shall serve a copy of this order, the judgment, and as attachments to this order ## 1, 5 and 6 upon Rs by effecting informal electronic service of the order and judgment upon AG. No response is required from Rs, other than to respond to any or ders of a reviewing court. The Clerk of Court shall enter final judgment accordingly, in favor of Rs and against P, dismissing this action with prejudice. The Clerk shall provide P a copy of # 6 with this order along with a copy of ## 1 and 6 from No. 3:08-cv-00054. Signed by Chief Judge Robert C. Jones on 6/20/2011. ( Attachments: # 1 Attachment "#1", # 2 Attachment "#5", # 3 Attachment "#6" )(Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM) Modified on 6/20/2011 to reflect NEF regenerated to effect electronic service upon AG(DRM).

Download PDF

-VPC Tjeltveit v. McDaniel Doc. 7 Att. 3 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 1 of 85 - uoa . ' t / . ' . . y < . . % . J . . ' E :TF5 / e , 'z s/ ? . zmcopo t t rv sï ' z ' ) ... . 7 . .. . . . . . / cr . è . ' ' ' '' ' ' . . cl l a j x s sa xag a . . myI 2 j 2 pj . . . - -b R E ' v nœ E : #JJj 4 f . a o xx t ) lotn : rrv -t: 6&s r' -ypl .lp . ' . ''. ' ' .' . .. . . . . v s . . . . .. . . % . . . kr . f ( a . . . : . . . ' ' ' . o J/o Jmsze o v 'd . . ' ' ' ' ' . ' . ./ . . . . . n ' . .. .: ï ', . r . . . . . . z y p / ' . . . y , . # . . . . ' g FM . ' .. . . . > . ' ' . K . . . ' .. . . . . ' . . . . z . / . . / . L M ' . ' . . ' ' ; . ' . , : . , n e - Jresl ' -fonu/'.p / 7, e ?. r.e IJ , o ??. emk or ç /e.ea Jm, o z I . , . ' J? ) / / / p - z wowml z-. 7 (vvl, , F J.l.1 er z,p 1 / ? 2-. , '' . Q. . . . . ' . 2 . ' . . . u ' ' . . u ?oi ' zx ë/ . . z) 'v , . v . Z * A ' . , ' zz .n6zz( v ,r.?J) ). ' ; s lJ. . ? fl 3 .- /. . . e. .. . ' . . . .> . /J oy ys . w n g .. ghyy lgnh s u g g ./.. w a( u u . . ' : ' ., ). y ' . Dockets.Justia.com ' . . . . t/. . z -r .S ze ,s, r, l, ç./ ) o zns- 'o, xsl ? k r r.# ' / r . . . . ' ' gyi o è . . . .' ' ' - Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ : -VPC . ' Document 6 , , . Filed 05/12/11 Page 2 of 85 . , . Or a . . . . : ' s n Izn s , l m , &; ' . PLJ VL -- .Fi/z& e e A( . ö lA / -' ' . -- ASLA /n . . 10. ' z 0 k e /y y n uu x y . $ . . . '? ? At I/ 4e J (k l #. J ' ?. ? g d, zx lf * m n m . . ' ' . . . . . . . . . . . . . . oo h s ' . . i' . . x m? zJgx. n ' z / AJv 1 ,?r /bn Venk. J p ' p( n. ' ' . . o. ( .( '/ P / 2&. q e .4 / V- / u ;' ' . ' . ' . . ' - . Gmz ! ' ' j ' . . . . . y . . . . . ' I ' I : . I . n,.. ;A Jozc.i./ t#, lfl > W z-X z u. ; 7 Xxtl? u e ' k sn s ' . ' . . j t eJs*?,k/rgu '- .z . ,-z . // - l -Q . ?/ z - m y / a w- ep ' ' ' - I' 'o oe , v ' ' . ' j . . .. . , , / u N , . . . y . : . . x? a à;z twi . . . . o /. all . m. r. oe om. . p ep -a / . . ' . . : ' . ' ' . /0%i rmzt vl& z a1 sm ( gt/,'/2cw ' - .- . ,m n y /,i,. 7 g t, - è l1 / . - ' - / n. J . ! . 2z ' . - . . . , . /. /1/ z dooe J;es&r/ p Vz mpx y5 )sw/é : , / / ee s .s . ' ' ' fl oop zl z n. i 5 a n 'z/zn .mr pr , z o. hnu.r ?,V.e . a , /. . ( ' . . . ' . ' ' * . ' '' ' . v tr zo,/@=a ,L mm . . y o , Js .4 . o, n/ v ----. zy. F(E'?/ 4<). -, . (ô4 . d0 ' . x . * . - 1j . '' . ' '' ' . . . ' . , . . 6 nlJz' c uo z< /s ..t z. ,zz n% re Ar, . ls n./ / 0,< g / .. . e vrL; . . Az n . .at . . . ' .Z6. -/ ) ' ' ' .s . ' tt 0,. n z /.,: p /- o . . . . ' ' ' ,r /// ac ' s-s r zt / '. r m . - e / z :J--A . e.éu k wa. y ) 4 ' / ,/ g. kj g . v a -. . ' . :. ' . . , . g : . N . lr 1 A... awa- ./ (evl1 l,* -JI e- l.. u '#-& P z. ?: JJ . // 5 '' J . 6 . ' ' W/5, r6 vs i L- u tcsl .' lil p-. -* Ll k i xt qk -( p tl , zzv ts Aluh jq L g g Q t cn' bj e-mg y Ik , W s r ysj 4 )a uy y j Lrzlé s /'u &A u gs y y% s y J - ' u. , . .J. .J,LJ//s sodc. . / ,n zew /w ' <t o ? . , . . . . . . p . -kfocmc . . ' i ou '/ ) n-s . 'C . . ' . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 * '. ' I . Filed 05/12/11 Page 3 of 85 . ''' ' ' . ' ' . , ' ' ' ' ' ' . . l s s ' .' . . . . zn tJ : l 'ztés J . .. / f . J.p L J?, 22 ' ' z e tul z T . .Jx a. I- L u , J ) o- î g ' / i p l &5d# 2SY tt/ / J co& Z. 3 Z . Z L ' ' 5 . . ' zV z Vo Y. -K - ) Fr --s -zn# ' ô6. v at. J ztA.l/t s ; & . '. . g l ' / . .2 x .1..x c . /2 I s - 1 . '/ z . . . ' . : . p . # /,o ç./ A, g ' . . . . . . ' . ' . ' ' , . .. j j z . . . . . . .. . ' ' . . ' : . . . ' ' . ' (vrt t , 1 . . . ' ; . . ' ' . ? o// fo o f I -e 2 s T *Z.1. . mzu 'o ' f . . /d ' Y &z ' ujc y . . . . . ' ' . . . ' ' . . . ' < 1t - z/ r ra g J z o- lq . '' 1: ar e . yn' - a'c-l' z f c. k l ' ' . ' . . . , . y ' ' . . è . #u /- ' . mœ sti L -o. xu t rvn ff. ' t. l z z t yy, t 1 r zrs.c- ...x.. 1- p . m - - xu... f 5 .& . i ig' . % / l' ; . . ' . #JJ/? J r / c ' ? 7 .' . . . ö t : l . . . . J . j ' .. . . - . . . ' . ' n . . ' ' ' . . .. ' . . ' ' a .. .J ' . . ' . . ' ' . - / df A a e /- -dr c / 4<-2J -. 7 ' .. ' . . '' . ' ' ; . '' ' uj z/i- g aé- u ' ' . . . .. . ' ' . . . . ' . . . . .. &- - - Yb 37-4 -wJ , s. I ltzk-s= . uw ? . -7 't àr a w. 21 u l V( . , z ? l -qs ' . . / Z /d Z. ?J Z- ==- G Y2z Z. NZ S? ls ko-rm j a-nzlx q , g t o- rz l w - ' ' ' . . r ' . . ' . . . . ' ' ' . . > . ' ' . . . . . ' . . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 4 of 85 'r- z 1 (p x// 's fco ;. m/ 6 ,. r lJ/. -n ) / . . r yY . j. p j j . I . . . jj j j . ' j . , , , , ' . m (u-r.##) ve pa ...us r- st - / ..,, .. r /sdo . z /m.- . ' / t . n ,iz o e , s . . g . , ' . . . . ' . . . . : ' . . . . . ' . . g ' ' . . .. . ' . . i. . . '. . ' . z . : ' . ' . ' .. . ' . . . . .. z ' ' . . . . . . '' ' . ' . . . . ' k . . . ' . . . . ' . ' ' V ' . ' . ' ' l ' . . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 5 of 85 a ossrzoss r be4he c/p/r ? . , ê , 4 o ,-'xzy./y r nm p.-s , ' '. ' o , , ' -a . n-o -,. c z ir .g s ,' e, o ' . .. . . 7 ' 1' . ./ '' ' ' . . . ' Ao ,,. . . !.kj !(, y .g; sp y p % = . ., . . , r . u o . ., , - a e .,, j: r, : w. e F ' . . . , z , , $= v ' . J . & ' gc M . , . .a . . o . /z(s a . .. :,... .m? g. 6 3.q0 s ( / .W,' 6 to svz/zz UL,( eo./-> 'r/Azr ./ . ,t ts//vv', < / /.y. , )p .' ei ? ?z e / / ' . j f /' z ' ' . - ? ., . / un r . . . ' . ' ' ' '. . . . ' , . . . Ie J. . . . . ' ' ' . / ' r/zr,, qf cpx u ul.>. éej .uo J /p ru. vzgl m r . ./ s ' / . ' . . .' $ y 4 ( z z' v y z ', i c/, ,.4 , . Az/ . ,. s , . < r4 , , n g/ # e or?lzal, .' , .s gi , :J : o -zep , I . . . : . . .. r /tl y . aœlhuzz plojz uiu z< .e ,z?/) n , M s f u r - u'- z ,é? </'J,. n zz . z lzn c 7 . ' . > . . ' . . - r J ' . ' 1êzI A/ n, tliu t L-zn-in.ra. p yul ' s oo- ' mw/' l o yLal . c x t z ? 1 . zK zq u zg / t z e l/z yil-- uhk ,& h, .>0 y o î- r&n yùo 2 wq t lwm ' ' k s e j . . .. .' z pyo x W x va J ) .- u n 'SC z itp fxk o < w /xT,. t . s psuun go ', az r- - x/ 1,p n. x v Z .a x , J, , ' . A . . .. .. r . . . n g/.' nri f ev v a/1 . ool V. - --f/ / edaL / / lùz o z.es tz 3, er Yz l < ö z/ vz &/ /d.- ? vom J ?l .z d-' : ; % # . . y . . . . . , . 5.. - . . . u ku lw m mz - u.z c' . ' . . . , ' . . . , Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 .. ' . ' . . ' .. . . . ' e' ' .. Filed 05/12/11 Page 6 of 85 . . . . . . 68 - ï ' . . . . . # o ' '. . . . . , . . . . ' .. ' ' . ' ' p ql ê I/ / . . '( ' .. . 2 mj L rcum r4.n<r . $ ,r :z ? . . . . . ' . . ' . / o . . . z I o . ' . . . . . . . 23 o l . . . . e . r . . . . j : . . . . . :' z ' ' . . ' ,Jx/ -. yy ? s t v. . ' ? z . . o ' . / . . . .. .. ' on . ' . ' . l; 7 / . .. .' . ./ z - . l ' . ' . ' ' t t uoo! . . k A',.z . m ' op H *o. r J o z / /&tihon ,nJ ,/' , T J 'q % / . J o . x ' . . z , . / . ' . . . <- ' . tyy ' y e / .k ' 3 .' s- py . . fàz ? . . ' d -- . enaz, . . .. .. . . . '' '' z. ' o O/ . / a . . ' . .. ' , .. . . ' l e t . . 4 .. . . . . ' . . ' ' . . . . ' ' 4 . l . , z' z ' / . . 1 - . s' e ' ' . ' . .' . . . + . . . ' . .t ' t I # . . . ' ' e u . '' . . ' . . . . . . . . . / ? . . . , . . I .. ' z. z : ) , . . ' . ' Ia ni +jz m v . k <. - In , lJ. =t x J s nl v rA t zn z ./ . .. f . $ s c s z l z ko zo/ r t r op ss w/-y . - 6 . ' . . .' . . ' ' . . ' ' . . . .; ., j. j . . . Mo ' - . ' . ' . . ' ' ' ' . . jI . , j ; Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ' . . Filed 05/12/11 Page 7 of 85 . ' . .. . . . . . , . e ! j. , ' , . . , . z. y .a x . y . . ' . , . . p . . m .. ? r. . # . e . . p ' .. ? /3 4 . . u ' '' I . . , ? . .. . ' . ' . s. . . . ' ovh c z ej . , g r o ' ' . .. J . : . d)' . r . ' : . . x . ' . . . . / . U J .- s/ . ux x; ,r - z - ogz hi , unt/ù>srp.- ( ,,, - m,/nnk - s-. ea , ., z w tor o ri/ , r - n,hho , o c , ve . 7-. / . a - - ' ' . e ' . . . . e / .. . .. ' ' v Jo r4asf.s fJ ?.c. . ' o $) 7 x ?. ' , r e/ e . . . .. . ' ' /z ? z u . . . . . 'w. - . . , & - pyeo ) . . / ' I . . ' . . . . . . . . . w. c. . /w , . - . ; + . . . . . . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 w . .. ' ' . . . Filed 05/12/11 Page 8 of 85 ' . f' ct o/, , Ca s g s ? A ( s d , J Po / r6 or v o r . . 1 . ' . . '' . j . , ' . ' . M ' nKSYJ /nmx% ' ' Yr ' . z . . . j . .. '. . v . X X Xe lrl '1X m X .V 5 nw 1 f. s $ Y2h ' x . ' . : .3 j . / . . 3. ' + L < ,.., u t ' . / , . . gm jxy op a nn. . . ' y y . . u h ' . 5 .' ' , . . - k. p /. - r. r j y . a - ' .- . . ' e . e ' / ' $ . . '' : . ' ' e , . 1 . . . n . xs zs a . y ' . . . .' 1 ' . . . . ' r J . a ' . < . ' . . , . g zo J/' é z rc i' / x J/:>k .. +..# ' .x / ra' : ass o m, ' . ' z5 -5 , e , e' l . ' s ' . i f ' . ' ' . w /. ' ' . ' . ' t ts ' . . ;P : 0 ,. / .i . . F z; . . % ' ' . . . . 0/ .... z . . . . . ' ,). ; .ke ,.< g z. ' ' ' . ' . . . / ( oc 6 ' ' ' . . . : ' s ' T . '' . e.' . . ' p y,A)zou .p, .w n ? . - . i /s , . , t i yr e, J ' ' ' ' / ' . . . . . ' . . ' . . . zr , : . ' . . ' . ro ms o.-. o E .r rt . . z g up iu êew . ' , . . ' . . '. , / m/ t. W n A. ' . . 4 ' j1 . ; . l kck .7 dwihunhu .zwt n g.ze yz) . 0r e h w ys z w t, ' 'W . ' . . . . . u-. . . . . '. . p. .1 $t zs (6t r..p nn /- . z , , o ,z. s z. u .J. r nn a 2 '. . l g ./ . , z a tnf. Jx/ Idi.k r ; J' J .. ) ) ' '' . . . . & ' ' 'l ' A z . . . J . . . .. . ' . k ' . . . j; . . . . . . . , ., . .. . . r 1 ! Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 . . . . ' .. . ; . . .' . o . ! J / . i ' / . . , f ' . , , . ' ' * z . oi tr / 1 'i ' / z ' ' . ' t ' ' 1 ' . . . . ,/ . , . . ' . . . .. . f . . j ' / . , . > ' . ' # k I Filed 05/12/11 Page . of 85 9 . ' z ':' 6 ' . z ' . . ' ' / 4 * . , ' *' ' . 6, tosr zz r / / g, . . ' o . . . . . . . ' W < . n p, ' . . . , . * #. r . . , ' z . ( ? . J / ' . . < z ' z e- . an ! . Lnœ l s?r Jzm '. / x 'x er msv / 'y /z. . zzl .z & zc/ . ' ' - j .. . , z r - > ' & ' u/.a 5zt t q ,, /) zs j?' u ' . . l . I .w ' ' 1 , l L2en,, .çovl.r -s . ' ?, ; s , zz .. / 5k . , 5. #.. . nK . . . / J;M. .-./:l,:/, /' -4 : az,, ,5 I ' . . tF-e.o, g r- l '-z. .. * i/ ->/.5- ' 4 f // - / . . . '. ' ' . . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 . ' . Filed 05/12/11 Page 10 of 85 ' . . I ' ! J . . . / A ' i ' . . j ' * . . 1 dl h ,' ' . . ' ? ? ) ' . ' . . . . .. . g p . . . . .. . . .. '. . . . ui f d . . . . Eô / . . ' ' . . . > , . . . ' . ' . . . ' . ' . . y .. zm-4 à x . r . ,nl / . j . . . ,. . . .,. ). .. ' os o . % p .y . g , e . , 4. . . . . ' .. I .. . . # ' . . . . . . / . & ' ' '' . . . . . ' ' . '' . . . / . &' / y '. ' i.us s c a/ x èàl ' vz e l/n4 .' rz#e iorz b ,.! $/,.J-, op xz'se v ' nn /e ' y '/ U h $ , '- s + . kr Zs.6 'zJ ' u x / ma' w g -' ' . . . . . . ' . s. . . . ' ' . . . . / V 6 : j. :; ox , / / ' . . ., . x . . .. . . ' : /t J p . . . . . . . . . . 3 .. Z. l Q. . . . . ! . .4 . 0 ' . . . '. '' . . . ' I . . . . . .- . . ' . . . ' . . j ' . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 11 of 85 i ! . g o - v, p za, opx. ,, 1? r.; -t - > . z ) j ' l0?AF t c,'g ' / t 7 . jus f : I THE .t 2 J CI DIT CTCOURTOFV E N s =fqi UDI AL S RI ' STATE OF NEVADA I ANP FOR N vux corNly oF b / xs lr œ ' xr x ! i ' A l k p l./vv,p . e ev -. ' . zi y z P t in rplit eio e/ ani t l p. / ) ! 8Y ) ) )' ! - ) v j ôk b c/ x/ jec uxt ). zz zl f , . ' ) Re ponde eenda s nlD f nt CASE APPEAL STATEM ENT 1 . a pe ' Yl NameofApm lantfln tial lt ç n:. l i' hs pxa s t t z lg ' E +tCî. ,/ / 2 l e tf te j g iml .h de iin, jd e t o o d r a p ae d niy h ud e m i te ng cso u m ni r r e p e ld fo rm: Jb ' ; P. : / l # eve q 1' / o ' - . Me t y: 1 mte t t ep c e n si t diti c u t th u eo e a . o d n t p risi n i 1 p is o h rce di p n he srd o r t e s f t 1 t e o e a te s f rhbt ) c Poiid: . . . 4cI . . ' n ' . / yp v g P zj.a j e -' yv y g .p ux . 21 6/ J l%/ ' eZ n o zi WM 4 Ie?y alpatX Q.le i ti a le l th t. o d 2. t d n t pate i d.1 l H ris iv v d n l s p:a te ke f nt f z ' ; o e oe ris s . ubtd: . f t , ln . 'i ) . e . n : , ' r ./ I -V , x 1. e. 4 k rn v aw )rli te t 6x 1 ddres , l elphone nume rofa1 colnq on appe and SezrI$ hPz x l 5n1,a .s ard t e tf h or t nnmc,l 1 l el al pr o 5. . i ntf t pariso pa t whom t y r e nt de ty he te r ry ' he epr se : Jox pwl, n 'v CK. J e (z vc ' otk : el , ul - Ato ey c..>Iky Ee ' t m3 J. k rk z k P ne/ c'e:j o l ?.t. z . r f Atom e C z z ti v '' t y r'rlk - t# v A tom t o. v t .- .c.-Ae t . ' r . 4+F , y > c /' , ; ' , + i -- ' ; jco. + .- cqw.' f+tzqt. e-p . (& c b .L;bv y $e e r .% z ''r ' p 'r -7 ir . . / , 1, v ' 2ol, z' cb < l r. S -> AL J !. io , u < Tl t l 2. J , Al ' -' e z / 7 Addr ea t'tl. & Lgl) 7pr N - l Tee neNuml lpho v ' / ntkz. F- l z ' h y z ' . Re e e s pr s nt ' 4.e . z s 4 s o 1.w Ah u 1 -A , Addrss e' Ad wi d L 7r) 3pt-&a5. 7. . '? ) 7' .A *- 7. 4 G7D Telp onenum% r e Tel ephonenume r ke ./. et .v Re es nt pr e s ' Stx oc Re es s pr ent 6. I cat whehe appela p'srprs e by apm i e orr ane c eli tm di zc ndi e t r lnt a e e entd htd eti d ouns n l sti t cou : Apm i e Couns l rt ntd e Reni Col el l ned mr . oPer Pr / / . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 12 of 85 l l ! ! Idctwhteamlnwa rpeetdb amitdo rtie cuslnapa: niae ehrp l t sersne y p ne reand oneo ptl a I l I I Ap itdColq l w ne ' e n Rean dCo rsl tie uke P oPe r r . 8 Idmt wh te a mla twa pa tdla et p c e i fr pa w rs a dt d t o n i e ch r p ln s ne e v o rced n o ma u i, n he ae f ' et ote irtorodr atg uhl v: eX N nr fh dsi cltrcp ni sc e eYs o y tc t n a Da e 1 / 3t t: / ' Idc t ted t tep l e dn sc mme e i tedsrd c u t eg, aec mjlit n iae h ae h r e ig o ncd n h iti o r (..d t o an x iddme tif raiw o p tto wa fld :oae 1/l'./c s n i n nbrn to r ei n s ie ) t: i Tp al i Dtdhs:. (yo 5 tk yr = 20 a ji 7 I f . nl e j a 02. ' ' ,. . , . . V / . A ppelant l e ee >' ' . EN Stt Prs n ae io P. Box 1 O. 989 El N t y, vada 89301 CERN I CATE OF SEW CE BY M AI L I her y c tf tutatueandcore c oft f e goi NotceofApm al Cas Appe eb erly la r ' r ct opy he or ng i , e al Stt e vwa m aiedt aem nt s l o: :e c' ?. I.kl 0ê l j1 c w- i ,ça ) J )'i: l : /tw q-' - - f . rw o . ' r(.epl . sm ' -. zl ,#. b eu ' / , '< ' ' -5 t. rb 'v -l / ' 'x' s v. b s D t ti Xq dyo Y dh/ Lek' ,* 7. a dhs e af . z- 2 ' h . 3 lJ i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 ! Filed 05/12/11 Page 13 of 85 k ; I THE SUPREM E CO URT O F THE STATE O F NEVADA N MATTHEW JAM ES TJELW EI T, Supr e C oud No. 50518 em Appel , l ant THE. AT OFNE A V ST E S VAD Dititcoud cas No. CR052796 src e , .j . Respondent . R EM I TU R TTI ' TO : How ar W .Conyer W ashoe Di rctCoud Cl k d s, sti er k I ; . Pur suantt t r es oft s coud,encl o he ul hi osed ar t f l i e he olow ng: Cedii copy ofJudgmentand O pi on/ r . fed ni o der Recei f Rem itt . pt or tiur D T : Jnay 220 A E aur2,08 1 Tr e i aci ndem an,Cl k ofCoud er By:- Dep 1 . - - -. - -. Cl k er cc ( t encosur ) wihout l es : Hon.St even P.Eli t Di rctJudge lot , sti l ' Ator Gener Cat i Codez Mas o car on Ci t ney al herne t/ s W W ashoe Count Di rctAtor Ri d A.Gam m i y st i t ney char ck Mathew J t ames Tj t ei el t v RECEI FOR REMI I PT U TUR ; Recei ofTr e Li ved aci ndem an,Cl k oft Supr e Coud oft St e ofNevadé,t er he em he at he REM I TUR i TTI ssued i t above- il cause,on n he entted . Di rctCoud Cl k sti er l $ & v- , of / J ! CM / ECF -nv -DititVe son 3.0. d src r i 5 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Pa 1of1 ge Filed 05/12/11 Page 14 of 85 Ot Event her s 3: cv08- 00054LRHVPC Ti t tv M cDani etal elvei el . - HABEAS Unied St e Dit i Cour t at s s rct t C D i t c ofN e s ri t vada Notce ofEl r c Fii i ect oni lng Thef l ng ta a ton wm e er on 128/ olowi r ns c i s nt ed / 2008at4: PM PST and 5l d on 1 28 2008 09 e / / Ca eNa : s me T etet M c ne e a j lv iv. Da il t l C as Num ber: e Fier: l 3: - 54 08 cv- Do ume Nu r 2 od c me tatc e ) c nt mbe : @ o u n ta h d Do cketText : N OTI t Pl i ifh'm USDC: e ebe a s d t c e a i tde enda M c ni , eta1 has CE o antf o Pl ms dvie hat ms ga ns f nt Da el b . e n r ceveda a sgne ca enum be 3: cv- 00 LRHe e i nd s i d s r 08- 0 54VPC A l f t re paper sentt t cour 1 uu s o he t f t sc s mus i l t snumber Any cores or hi a e t ncude hi . r ponde e w ih t cour s d be m aie t t nc t he t houl l d o he . Clr ' Of ea n t ie tyt tea sg e j d e . eks sc nd o d rcl o h si n d u g s Thi c s h sb e s b te frr v e a a to b aj diil fie . i rv e p o e sma tke s a e a e n u mi d o e iw nd cin y u ca o fc r n s e iw r c s y a t s ve alwe ks Pl i ifwilbenotfe ass m f rhe aci ha be n tken a wilr cevec y of e r e . antf l ii d oon q u t r ton s e a nd l e i op a1 r r fld ( i g a t c d)( 1o des ie . no ma e ta he KL) 3: c - N otc ha ' en e ec r c l m aied t 08- v 54 i e s be l t oni aly l o: 3: c 54 Notc ha be de i ed by ot m eanst 08- vie s en lver her o: Mathe Tj lvet t w et i 83651 El Stt Prs y a e ion P. . x 1 9 O Bo 98 El N V 89301 y, 1 I ! ! ! I i ; i . h@ s/ec :/ fnvd.ic9. &c cr dc gib* ipac p17382457496011 s th. ? 52 12/0 8 /82 0 )l L ' t' ! : . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ; . : : ; as 3: cv 00054e 08- LRH- PC V Filed 05/12/11 Page 15 of 85 Docum en 3 t Fi 04/ 1 2008 l ed 1 / Page 1 of2 . ! ; l l i 2 3 1 . ! l 4 ; 5 . 6 UN I TED STATES DISTRI CO URT CT 7 DI STRI OF NEVA DA CT i ! i : 8 ; 1 2 I ! E i ! i 9 M AU HEW' ELTVEI TJ T, 1 0 , Pettone , ii r ll vs . 1 E. M CDANI e al, 2 K. EL, t . 1 3 Re p nt s onde s . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 3: - v- 054 LRH08 c 00 VPC ORDER . . . j ' ) / 1 4 ! I I 1 5 ! Mat w Tj tei, Ne daprs e,ha tlda a iai f la et pr e di ma the elv ta va ion r s ie n pplc ton or e v o oc e nfor i i 5 i 1 pau rs( ck t/1, peii f wrtofha a c r s purua tt 28U. C. 225 (ta he a 6 pe i do e /) a tton or i be s opu , s n o S. 9 4 atc d t l doc e #1,a damoi f a oi me tofc s (ta he a d ke /1. 7 kt ) n ton or pp nt n ounelatc d t oc t/) ! 1 8 l i 1 a iai f la t pr e di or pau rswilbed nid Pettonermustpayt $5 Glng 9 pplc ton or eve o oc e nf ma pe i l e e ii he i 2 se o ! 2l i ! 22 ha beascor petton.Ther i no constt i rghtt appoi ed couns f a f alhabeas pus ii es iutonal i o nt el or eder ' l 23 cor pr pus oceedi . ng 1 2 4 5 4 8( t Ci. 9 3 .Th d cso t a p it o nslsg n rl dsrt n r.Ch n yv 4 2 , 2 9h r 1 9 ) e e iin o p on c u e i e eal icei ay a e . y o 1 i 25 Le 1 l 26 73 F 2d1 28 1 ( hCi., e /de id, 69U. 838( 9 ) Howe rc ns mus b 0 2 , 234 9t r) c r. ne 4 S. 1 84 . ve, ou el t e ! 27 appoi ed i t compl xii oft cas ar such t deni ofcounselwoul am ountt a deni of nt f he e tes he e e hat a! d o al I ' . 28 duepr ocess and w her t pettoneri aper on ofsuch Im ied educaton ast be i , e he ii s s i t i o ncapabl of e I Bae o teifn ainsb te b p tinrrgrighstn n ilttste sd n h no n to u mi d y eio e e adn i ia ca sau ,h t t . . . i Peii ne aio h sm ke t i c l t p oviehi wih a n e é ns t a ss wih hi tto r s a s d hs ou' o r d m t ppoitd öu elo q it t s t i Pe s v avFi e 48lU. 551 5 ( 98 ; nv.Va qu z 99 F.d nnylani . nly, S. , 55 1 7)Boni s e, 9 2 : wi, 1F. ll 1 11 ( hCi.1 6)c r. nid 48lU. l 23(98 ;Bas v Rily,' s 80 2d 9 , 96 9t r 98 , e/de e , S. 0 1 7) hor . se . : ' . i ' I ! I l i I i j ' . / V . ' $. Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ase 3: c 00054- H08- vLR VPC Doc ent3 um Filed 05/12/11 Page 16 of 85 Fi 04/ / l ed 11 2008 Page 2 of2 I l f ry pr entng hi cl ms. See Chane 801F. at1196;see al A awkfz v. Bennet,423 F. ail es i s ai y, 2d so ?. ç t 2d 2 9 (t Ci.1 70 . 48 81 r 9 ) 1 3 Th pe ii i t sa ton i or n z d a d r s st i s e i acl a a un r t n bl e tton n hi c i s ga i e n aie he s u s n e r nd de sa da e 4 ma ne .l doe not pe rt t uns li j tfe i t i i tnc .n emo in s l b de e n r t s ap a ha co e s usiid n hs nsa e to hal e nid. 5 IT I TH EREFO RE OR DERED t pettoner' a i i f l S hat ii s pplcaton or eave t o 6 pr c e i or pau rs( oc t )i DENI Pe ii e s l ha tlr y( )da fom t o e d nf ma pe i d ke #1 s ED. tton r hal ve lit 30 ys r he . 7 e f oft sor e t h et fln feoftved lr ( )s ntt t Clr a or e e beo I nty hi d r o av he iig e i ola s $5 e o he e k, s d r d lw. f 8 pettonerf l t do s t sacton m ay bedim i s ii ais o o, hi i s s ed. 9 I IS FURTH ER O RDERED t t Cl k shal SEND t pettonert copi oft s T hat he er l o ii wo es hi 10 Or der. 11 I I FURTH ER O RDER ED t pe ii T S hat ttoneri or ed t arange t haveonecopyoft s s der o r o hi 1 Or e s ntt t Cl r w ih ac c f $5 a t c d. Pe ii e m a do s by s ndi g a c py oft 2 d r e o he e k, t he k or ta he tton r y o e n o he 13 Or al wih a Sbr sslp' t l at Ser ces f is der ong t ç as i ' o nm e vi or s uance oft check. he 14 . I I FU RTH ER O RDERED t t Cl k s lFILE AND DO C KET t m oton f T S bat be er hal he i or l a nme ofc s l(ta h da do ke #1. 5 ppoit nt oun e atc e t c t ) 1 6 I IS FURTH ER OR DERED t pettone sm oton f appoi mentofcouns i T hat ii r' i or nt el s 1 DENIED . 7 1 8 DATED t s 11 day ofAprl 2008. hi * i, 1 9 20 LA RRY R .HI KS C UNI TED STATES DI STRI JUDGE CT 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 z /# o9 t / (... t-33 . =< v-èn:rL - &-VPC t eL 6 . 5 f Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ : H-Document , ' ' ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 17 of 85 ; . ! j- l y ûuo .. C I k oJ ea. (,, o, #.. ' .. ï. JJ ' .E covr+ , e s ly ' i ' ' ' . ' E kxv àkcls a v q e/ #k. org . zv lk ? +s 1 ksv L p- z bz ' J y you à ie $ kou J . . - x <èpp. - o e z e/ w ek % 1lt. oé # . . pokwzz p- 1A' k-- lj . l . v z ' j cvi vzss . y . ! . p. D k Enal s / z -l: ,wer A . a s j . b orl j ' l eht-oee sk v. l ' 'x oe /z e wm e Ly rk. vetox w /hk hkk. 'xA ;' p J àk< . e n s 2 v- -a or,, , h.l k , ( of w y o- s .p F t b-z +n x . a # ep - . n o s x'r hkt-.ç't6 t! ,u ( . . Béèl o L k ,' k. l f e $ '' '' lk .c '' k ,ll e t ' s ' i .kg p Q h wu n o lxol # o L pe o uzn . t . . i r Y 'l + sep/ oa t ? D> oJ . I. 'e o e,, kw l MK . h vk rk. z oh tk .. l r% of .ge Z f+ l c s e zl et % J t r wr e# hx; io .' + tnuem 1 , ior y o myfpr. 1 ' 'q - p s p ' , à -.. r - w/k psb r s'? k' 1#- wm v Topqplh t ) b y erç x e &q ' ' n . ' ' ' ' . . . q . > jLr u s14 xn J wl k .r ev r/ - xe s )) . y r on, - she r , . r k+v no k.l ko 5mo J h , Ae ' -,y , . w k' . s G ' l . . . i kwww r uzwk ..p ( )y +0 ywt, r ' / u. so .1 ' . z kx xl œndllel r- suc al xly gi +0 oaxs sp o - x ok em s sl: ekz ç, ks f ).ko+ ' ; . 'p l vz. v - w-s lw'. , .vzn. a. w ez t ,k D ksve y kow6 - kz. #r,2 , p s c , J *X ' o qy con - ,, .l Tru (vn1, 7ke Jvc cJ.yroj$ <kp 1 )r- rk'e k +kz. ' se - o. s ft-op wil r.ere . bl 'y /. 41 > oz mè2I. f ï s $ ee t vov . c =p ' - '< z J ees , f r G - r -spx tk.y r o lr e 'e zfwsm l/ bi-. /ss r îe frorv lh. 50 . .pre. ilx+ y, L Lo m?f ; v r x y -a z m . - . .. . . ' ' . . , ' . . . ' <' ' ' . r O gd j w)s ky cs ks g à, ?. yp fkj o ' Oo G as v v g a w j : . . p s 4 . v x w x k w . ka : . k q ! l em zs tey 7 ï .# . tv q 1 . .s s . 1 -2. mv-y wfo ,h ko - o. . j jo e . c. q-. , j . . - -; -, - ..v I w. .. Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 18 of 85 U * 1' / 'f : 1 1 s #j q j r u . y j g 6( $m.5 3.@ -èitQO(kL- L*0: f :AyYj w . . ..h r.s g. 4 . 3+ V.ç z j . ! . : . Sjh ' . . c *. . 2? , , . : Z ' . qc'Box ? # ? - :F .. , . E1 W v F qzç l ' . - (;ijs;. (t;q)g ryj,j, yy:k t:, yg . l? L Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 19 of 85 /r 'j Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 20 of 85 Zô Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 21 of 85 zI IBG IOO Nevada -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 22 of 85 6/04/2008 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJDepartment of Correction s I R LI B CT I mat Ac o nt I qu r n e eu n iy ( A count/lnmate : i 1 1 21 1: 0: 83651 Last : TJELTVEIT Institution; ESP Effective Date: 7/10/2007 Unit: Mail Addl : Add2 : ' City : Wing : A . i Add3 : St : 7mFreeze 28 Bed : B Frozen Sel Fu nd Descri otion Fund Balance Y/ TvD N TRUST TRUST FUND TRUSZ SECOND TRUST FUND I J 6 /ell: Zip : Type options, press Enter. s=Display ss: v First : MATTHEW 2.75 17 .45 T T . 00 DEPT DEPARYMRNT CRKQGES FUND SAVE SAVINGS PUND N N N N D S 163. 74 I + nz l $, W ? c w lv ,q . ) . /lov.s f r J J n #y' j, o ./ o-y ' f 5 r O& o V / fa / . * z .z ' .. $ Z E Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 BADO CM S NR OR F O WSI ES O !JMGBOS I IBN w *e,ocw.z- v ,;: wpwoo, sxm o : xy x zl 'ttAi<jtr4l : 4 . Jofrlrjlr' fc l z . ze r yjgjsntxjjlkyj ji o r r' , a/fze MqœR !' . 's, ' ' ' +* . 9 ' . . . ,, j IY OF N S V O A ' Z xv oy, cop#sc za . - . j Filed 05/12/11 Page 23 of 85 Nrh n.- , ,.,- tj n otm. , - o -::jjj. -vjgjy . rj k j z u& ,., ,x . . N. r j .' .- uwx x uoaosox l l Wrr a ue smersw-e g z a s ao a a okx P. m h 7 ORn nCi . M 02 0. x 011 .r 1 NV Y ne ( 5)* 7- 6Fa ( 5)% 7. $ :r 331 x:W; 3:61 t/ ; J j . ' ' Dae; J t e To.u w L/ ar su- rvi . br y sor * 4 . t * Q Fo ImaeB n igS rie rm;n t a kn evcs . ! Re:U. Di rctCour Br Sl# s S. sti t ass i * * * k e/ sak, d-i - lsi t n é:/h ' c ' s/ n tui ' a to t ; ,mae n t . . - .. - l T e l d br slp i be ng r ur t t f l ng r asont ) he nc ose ass i s i et ned or he olowi e s: h imaed e n t aes mce tu d t po e sti bassi T/z/ 4.. en t o s o h v u in fn s o rcs hs rs l zw 7p t 6 . ! . Br ass slp m usthave appr i ovalsi gnat by an aut i i iutonal ure horzed nstt i per sonnel Pl . ease si and r ur t l at Banki Sew i gn et n o nm e ng ces. : . The i at di notatach a pr nm e d t opery addr l essed and/ st ped or am envel ope t f ward t t cour . o or o he t -- '' : . Ot ; her l at Banki Ser ces nm e ng vi b - ' ' ! . j Filed 05/12/11 Page 24 of 85 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 x. a .? % t: S= K0 I ( *2 I( aa * aa * u :t j s. c i.. . c ;x l : 1 . ..:5 u $ 4iis . .. . . .l la: . . il'.zl-l -.i' '.:l y (':.t 3. 'f ( .ë ' i )ftl ' . % . t. 1 . ? E p (:i)7 -z i' g . X . :'' ':. tz .' sa; 5 )T J . -! z . y sE - ' v= - 3!Eq - I' J t . xu! p -. t) . : . , < # x ,i d a f -se x ig : . t t . : .e. . . ... - . . , q:n Ti ct . l . I * c t. n r j j E a - - -; -t . r,. u-. c .- - u . x s u a k x o g c . . r v . . @jo = * 4 XQ q ) -: :u j. ' ' . * . j,j! j . . o m ! -t . o= l js o y , *'% u.z y ka .; xj y M jao . s a d. % . c, n c' sj oJ . . .' j œ & c m j!6sJa h -j .z x a s z- , j ej! j j , k jzjy!. o . ., x &a=a wj u. a .z< s. o- , - w w ç R . g ea w / ' g . su à .. , T.J, r i-Jt ' V e ; u N o .f . : s z - ' K ( . : n - ., j, . - - .. s .. .l nou ' X Ij o s. . @ ë!dE j .w. a . . k. k.t$w' lv :.E.i F . --' 1 , . 5: t. . -, . c 1 i . k rj' u. , r' , ' . l . ' ' u . x 'r - -i' e J -. u.tl- k: .c i vs . , ,y . al 'z rl t J = - , j ,j z) ,j x x ; :j o ! sk = . 1 zNo j yg . a u! n I y : - ' . - j1 c $ 2. w ( z: ' '-i' . ( z ' .- n- r j Q lir. p .t IJ . w ' ' - . x a . y 1 j z c iru oo . x ij = . . '-' , - .l t p Kb h . ui3 T H ! s-,TG' - . o i: -: ; . :. -, . . = I : . # J z a > ( ( $ . /- : . à . jj , w j; . ë K = r . jv t o : (g-jy.. c...- -.. u.. j zg . = .wz y j a. E :.. 4 ; --f . ... *. . - 5 < ' . . . q q . . F';I; : -.4V l '. Q'. '- ' '1i' ë3Z. :.. Flu . t 'X ; ? . . .J. : i. k t,1. ,. .. . . ...sn',t r '.. - . . 'r ; ;. . u k . : ir .k Vi p'; 1 .' .. 'i$' . f.' : kC1l ii''t ' , k l ' pk tt l -t . . I A Q ' ' C) à y( :, Qk t t g % v L V, 2 5 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Jl l & ' l' uu J.tyj yoygy ' + 24 ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 25 of 85 '1 ' j y : - pa a , u T 1 k . , z . ' . , o . u ., . y.x .c ,1 . h - < .. y zs o g, - -sa zt z 'u ,. , . o . vo xcoz . Kx - . y, Ztz, .t z o . up N.xs, ..z . -,x ussy eo y , -n t rm wz a:ia -x - vrq . 1 Ië ? ?% : rQI Lû 0 2. % 3 0t kî : 13 z : l 5 /: l ' .. , . , , u .'' x = ' , . m s . . - '; . ù 29. I . $ s, oo . . . y u vou y y o .. Nu. ZY I Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 I k ' ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 26 of 85 . ' ase 3: cv08- 0005 LRH4VPC Docum ent9 Fi 04/ 2009 l ed 28/ Page 1 of3 . i i ! 1 ' : I i 3 ! ' 4 5 6 7 i l i ! UNI TED STATESDI STRI COURT CT DISTRI O F NEVA DA CT ' 8 9 M AU HEw TJ ELTVEI , T l i 1 0 11 v . s i . Pe ii e , tton r 1 E. MCDANI e aI, 2 K. EL, t . 1 3 Re p nt. s onde s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )' . 3: c 0 408-v- 005 LRHVPC .. OR' ER O / 1 4 : ! 1 5 Thi acton i a petton r wrtofhabeascom us pur uantt 28 U .s. j 2 4 b pe iine s i s ii or i s o c. 25 y tto r ! 1 Mat w Tjl taNe dapione.Thi Cou t e ousyor rdt peii e t s ow c us 6 the ewei va rs r s r prvi l dee he tton r o h a e I I 1 why t i t petton f w rtofhabeascor s d notbedi ised,asi a 7 he nsant ii or i pus houl sm s t ppear t ed hat 1 p ii e , camsweeune ha td(oc e /7 Pettonerhas notr pon( (t tjscoutsode 8 etton rs li r x use d k t/) ii j r' r r es j jo j e . 1 a ha no s own t thi c ai sa e e use t r f e t e Co t ildim i st e pe ii w iho 9 nd s t h ha s l m r xba t d, he e or h ur w l s s h tton t ut ' 20 prj c . eudie 21 . A sat prs e mus e us a1a ia esaerme e prort tl afdea ha e s t e ion r t xha t l valbl tt e dis i o ii ng e r l b a ! 22 c p peiin.28U. C.j22 b)Roev Lu y, U. 5 ( 98 .n esaec ursmus b orus tto S. 54( . s . nd 455 S. 09 1 2) , tt'o t t e i 23 gi a f roppor uniy t acton each cl m bef et e cl ms ar pr ent i a habeaspetton t ven ai t t o ai or hos ai e es ed n ii o ' . I : i ! i i l 24 t e f d a di ti tc l ' O 'uli an v Bo rke, U. 83 8 (999 .Fur nnor, cli h e er l s rc oul. S lv . e c l526 S. 8, 44 1 ) t he e a am 25 w ilr m ai unexhaused untla pettonerhass l e n t i ii oughtr ew fom t hi tavaiabl sat c evi z he ghes l e t e ourt . 26 t r ugh die ta al c l t r l e e pr e d ng . se ca e v u o e, F. 896 9I ( h ho r c ppe or ola e a r vi w oc e i s e sy . or 386 3d , 6 9t . . pr 2 ci 2 4) A ha a peiine mus - esn t sat c rswiht smecai h ure upo te 7 r 00 . be s tto r t- e the t e ou t t he a l m e g s n h ( 6 &' ! . . *. . J '' -k '' 28 fdealc t'nor rt al asaec ur t co r tvi ai off dealrght.Pia d v Con , e r our'i de o low tt o t o rec oltons e r i s c r . nor ' I , I JT , - . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 I o . ï ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 27 of 85 i ase 3: cv 00054O8- LRHVPC Doc ent9 um Fi 04/ 2009 l ed 28/ Page 2 of3 ( ! 1 4 U. 270, ( 9 1. nc nv Heny, 3U. 3 3 ( 9 . 04 S. 276 1 7 )Du a . r 51 S. 64, 65 1 95) , i : 2 Ac er ng t ie s3 a d 4 oft pe ii pe ii ne d d a pe fom hi c nvi to b ve c di o t m n he tton, tto r i p al r s o c i n, owe r 3 t a pe lwa dimis dwih ac nc t r iea is s a p ttone di n s e saepo t he p a s s s e t out ha e o as ny sue , nd e ii r d ot e k tt s- l ' 4 c vito r if Se alopa s4, a 8oft peiin ( d itng fiur t e u tg ou f on c in ele . e s ge 6, nd he tto a m ti a l e o xha s r nds or j 5 r le Fr m t f c o t peii n,he e o e peii e ha a te t thi c amsf r i ha e eig. o he a e f he tto t r f r , tton r s dmit d ha s l i or el v ef i ' 6 n t e b e e huse i saec utAsal f eio e'camsrmanu eh utd tep tin o yt en x a td n tt o r. lo p tinrs li e i n x a se ,h eio t t i 7 wilb dimisdwihou peudie Rapbet v Gar a, 48F. 11 0,11 ( hCi. ) l e s se t t rj c . s ry . ci 4 3d 5 54 9t r2006 8 ( di t tac ur ne dnoth dapeii i a y nc pe di e a to i t peiinc ans Gn ng ha o t e ol tton n be a e n ng xh usin fhe tto onti I 9 o yun xha tdcams. nl e use li ) : i ! 1 0 Fu t nnor , h Co twil nype iine ac rii t ofa pe a l y I or rt pr c e rhe e t e ur l de tto r e t cae p albii . n de o o e d f t 11 wih a a alfom t sc r, e ii e mus r c i ac rii t ofa e a lt . 28U. C. . t n ppe r hi ou t p tton r t e eve e t cae pp albiiy f S. j 1 2 ()1.Ge eal apeiine mus ma $ s tnta s owi oft de a ofa 2 253c() n rly, tto r t ke e ubsa il h ng he nil a ' 1 c tt tona rg ' t wa r nta c ri c t ofa a a lt f . The Sup e e Cou 'ha h d t ta 3 onsiu i l i ht' o ra e tt a e ppe l biiy. # i rm l s el ha t . 1 peii rt tde srt ta raona ej it woul fndtedititc r, a ssme oft 4 ttone : mus mon tae h t e s bl urss d i h src ou ts ses nt he ' ' ( I . ! l i i 1 ' o tmto lcai d baa eorwr g. Slc v Mc e,5 U. 47 48 ( 00 . * c nsi ina l ms e tbl 5 on ' a k . Danil 29 S. 3, 4 20 ) ' 16 ' . W her a cour has di m is a pettonert habemscom uspetton on pr e t s s ed ii , s ii ocedur gr al ounds, 1 how ever t det naton ofwhet a cerii e ofappeal biiy i uesbecomes at partt . 7 , he enni i her tfcat a lt ss woest 1 The Supr e Cour hasst ed t undersuch cicum s ances: 8 em t at hat r t 1 9 2 0 A COA s dis ewhe t prs ne s ws.ha j rssofraon houl su n he io r ho .. t uit e s t woul tnd i de t bl whe h t e pe ii s a esa va i cl i oft e d i t ba a e t er h tton t t ld a m h de a ofac tmtona rg a t turssofraonwo dfn i nil onsi i l iht nd ha j it e s ul id t debat ewhet hediti cour w ascor ecti ispr abl hert srct t r n t ocedur r i al ulng. 21 22 / Se aloMilrElv Co k el5 U. 32 337- (003 .Th ef e,nor rt o ana #. e s le - . c rl, 37 S. 2, 38 2 ) er or i de o bti 23 CO A i c s s dim i s d on pr e r la o s pe ii ne h s t e b de o de n ae s se oc du a r und , tto r a h ur n f monsp tng b t t a t i 0h h t i on ttton rgh an haj rss f e s n ul i t baa e t r d 24 he wasdeni a val c siui ali t dt tuit o ra o wo dtndide tbl whehe ed 25 t c r' pr ce r l uln wa c re t l c s swh r t r i apl npr ce ur l rt a he ou ts o du a r ig s o r c. n a e e e he e s ai o d a ba o 26 pe ii rscl i sa t diti tc ur i c r c t i oket tpr c dur lba t dipo e oft e ttone ' a m nd he src o t s ore t o nv ha o e a r o s s h ' ; 27 c s, ' r ae - easonabl urs c dno c ncu eie t tt dsrc c t re i dimisngte ej it oul t o lde i rha he itit ourerd n s si l , a ! 28 2 i ' 1 ; i I 3? 1 j . J ' jp ' . * ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 * . . ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 28 of 85 g ' ! i ase 3: cv O005 LRH08- 4VPC Docum en 9 t Fi 04/ / l ed 28 2009 Page 3 of3 i ! i 1 petton ort t pettoners d be alowed t pr ii hat he ii houl l o oceed f t . urher 2 I Sa k 5 9U. a 4 4 lc , 2 S. t 8 . nteprsntc s,peii e ' ha e speiini bengdimis wih tprj iem t h ee ae tton rs b a tto s i s sed tou eudc s he 3 p ttonc t n onl u x use cams Noraon blj it oul co l ta t sCouts eii onais y ne ha td li . e s a e urs c d ncude h thi r' . 4 pr ce ur r lngwa i er .Petton ri no e ild t ac riiae o a aa lt o d al ui s n ror ii e s t ntte o e tfc t f poe lbiiv -.. ' 5 . I I THEREFORE ORDERED t tt peiin(oc t )i DI I T S ha he tto d ke #8 s SM SSED W I THOUT 6 PREJUDI E C ! ! : 7 i i ! 8 Accolol -v. t xcl i i 9 1 0 . I IS FURTH ER O R DERED t t T hat he ce ks a.ENTER JUDGM ENT lr h l l I I FURTHER ORDERED ta peii e i DENI ac riiaeofa pe lbiiy. T S h t tton r s ED etfc t p aa lt DATED t s28* da ofAprl 20 hi y i, 09. 11 1 2 1 3 LA RRY RS H 1 KS C UNI TED STATES DI STRI JUDG E CT 1 4 15 I 16 I ! 17 I 18 1 9 20 I 21 2 2 l 23 1 24 I I . . 25 26 1 2 7 28 3 ' .) l k ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 29 of 85 cux.cp- sgxvqi a o . o. oe tNo. p y j :p (. .( 1) ggjs .s jy j:a. t j p . H0'AlD b co'yERs f l b N ï ' ). 8Y I ''R <.. ,) x I. ' . 0e s n opxxvu xm m u C. Gae x px .psi crcov ' cuzïte v m xlovve pu TY yoR'lEcovx'voF pzw sk nlI r . A xeke 5. '-alv v , y w rr k ml a . peuuono , PETI ON FOR W RI TI T OF HA REA S CO RPUS . F- Z. M c D>e, . z -. e l . eosc vleoN T ox cn ) Re ondent I NSTRUW I ONS: () ' d e u mutl lgil b r i no tm wh/ q ïg e b temtto e a v rfe . 1 f s oa s x e by adwrne ry ' l e n y h i n r nd eiid i ( ) Ad i n l a e aen txr te e œp wheen t e 3M rqxc t tefcswhihy u 2 ddo a p g s r o l mitd x t r oe rV e to h a t c o r l l t s r yourgr z f rr ne No cia i o aut ki snee l Glnihal I bhef or ey qxm o upm t nzndt o e f tton f hoz e dx r K . f s a gtn n sa es bmi c t ys td l sbmi e i t f r o as p t me rndmk r u e t r u t br hod x v t d n he o m f e m e mo u l t l ( ) l uwa ta atre a m itd m umu t l teAoda ii S p to Re e to 3 fm n n tea p ne , s &mpde h vtn u N f qu s t Pï e i F maIa l s. mu tuv a a t villo t a t p io c mpeetec riiaea t lxe d n or bu e .Xou s l e n ubt +w o zr te rsn o lt h et c t % o q z f teG o n o mo e au sc zte o d w st oy rc ti a yaxun i teisi œ h u t f n y xl e uiis n e it ou mdi n n rv dt n h n te t () . umt t a a rs n e th J nbywho y uaec n me o ro ie I y uae 4 Yo t n me s em d a te o g m o r o f d r a n d. f o r i a sm 'i i lt on e t Dc lmentofCore omq na t war orbea o t i utd o I n l fc nsimi f bt w l rdi me he dtn d f ht ns ti n. f y u'e n ti a s cfc is tt n o teDq aî n b twiln isc se 'n me t Di co o te' o r o n w l n dui f h p rme t u tl t u t , a hr z tr f h ' o i e De rz tofCore ins pa lno r clo . () Yo mu ta ld al nt M cnmqfrrie wlc y uma h rg rigm u 5 u s icu e l gpu l r li o q f d h o y m e adn s r Gmvitonors e .Faiur t r s aB gr uxl i t sm tdon.n yprdudeyo fom ilngf t r ci entnœ l e o aie ot s n hi i qa e u r ii u u e I e toLc le gn y rc n ciaa dsne œ. ir haln ig mz o vito n e ta s () Yo mu t Be esm 'i fcss m rmgtecamji teI é nyo Sl e kigrEe 6 u s a g l fc at up t h li n l e o u e * n e, f fo a yc n dino snq c .Falr t aig s ii fdsrt t j s c ncu im rkyct r m a o vi o r e ta e iuq o l e mcfc a ae e u t o lso s tl ac e ' . y u te t l dimi. I o re to O nnn ac m o iercien qqn rQ c u xlt o re in e e r p fy u e in fil bi f n fe t milnc r o n ,ut v cam wil m rt t wa v t at me - e ! nvl g f rt e li l o a e o i e he to y di n p ' l e o h ' e ' gi wb c y u car y urY u s l n ih o liù o ne wa i ge iv . s ne cie V 1 rQ Y CP zï Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 30 of 85 () W h nt l i ni fl c mpee teoi'a a do ec p mus b lldwihteceko 7 e hc xt s ul o ltdzh r l n n o y t q ie t b lr f do y pn t sa dili c r f t c yi whihyo we ec de . Onec mus t maiedt t he t2 lzct ou t or be ount n è u r onvi r opy t x l o he rs n e t o eœ p t t eAto n Ge e a ' Om c , ldo ec p t t edi d at r t o tl œ u t ew d a v n y b h t r v n r ls e al n o y o h Oi to n y f le py i whi yo wer oo ctdort l oxgmalpr s cu o i n ch u e nvi e o he i ' o e t r fyou aechale ng y orgialc vi i or r lngi our i n m cton s ntnœ .Co e mus c f m i alpari lr t t orgi ls bmit f sing. e e pis t on or n 1 tmla s o he i na u td or i PETI ON TI 1 Na o isi to a dc u t i wlc y uaeprs n yi rxmd o rh r a dh w y u . me f nlt in n o ny n l h o r ee d mpk u i r ee n o o a psnye ndfortr: r retr eoyuE t e e l Mi ay w ' % k ' ç1 . ./ a 2. Na a dl t no o t t ibe tidtejd n o cmvi o u d ratc me n = i f ot whc nte h u gme t f x din n e t k: o r a se rrl . 'f d. f z ' f. trvr+ oT 4ùe 4 + z c# . FnJw s , -- j' ' l l' ' z # ' J. t z ge . xî . , A L . . . K f . ' 6 - 3 Daeojd etf ovdin i -V ' Q V . t fu> n ocni o : * ' . 4 ca en m- r c- 0F - >> q J . . s u : t. 5 ( Iengt ors ntnr L' w Ik o ; ' 1 e ' I z' r s tIii a) - h c e z; - . e. -. . #- <r () I e tn kdnt saea yd t ux whc e a to L sh d e : b fsne œ s h tt n ac lm ih a f n s c e uld x i 6. AR you pr e l K wi as ncef a c ci otrrtu t c œ onl crat k i es nty n eme or onviton l l' ht onvi m md tac n t smoto u Yes hk in? No C l y s . ci t s vn r l sne œ W igs tGla ti i : f e n EM rme,a e uma ai e tn n ev thstme 7 Nal oo l ivle imnitnGigcal e: . grJer' Iu. 1k. . hr ffewenovd n vci n ll d X e o h og ' 'e 8 N h tya y u pe ?(h .n ) . / a es o r la c o e: () èo g s4 a lt u'r () tu y . b löt (j hooc ne d r c ll o tn ec 9. I fyou e e e apl. o gutt t oneœ untofa i c merteridbr ntr d ra f 'y o l n ndit l r mne n,arda Plaofnot l e g it t a ohe œt Q azn it n o ifr t n o i pe o gut wa n g t t $v deal: uly o a t r mt f !idcme t r uo mai , rfa la f tly s e oi d e tis o ' a l Iy uweeft g lyatrap> o n t it,wa tein igma by (heko e 0. f o t om ui te l f o gul s h dn de :c c n ) t y ()11. a 1: r ()J u ewih u aj r b u g to ! uy l1. Di y t tf att til Ye d ou esiy he ra? s X* No , l Di yo apl lfr tejdm eto con cin?Ye y s 2 d u xa om h u n f vito s o . l I cud da l , n we t ef lo n : 3. fy i p e a s r h o l Wi g () Na o Co l a me f ut Gw () Caen ml grctto : b s u xr i .in, . a fv Crt P 'z 1 ' ' ' () Re ut- :( * 1 c s l - 1- 65md ' & - 2 Zn Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 31 of 85 7 IN TH E SU PREM E COU RT OF TH E STATE OF NEVADA M Ar rl w lw ss TJSLTU II, u '' Appexant , vs. ! xo.50518 v ondent.o v o , ussa s vxs x a vv nzs ! FI n LE E : 1 20 2 07 k ORDER DI I NG APPEAI. SM SSI . (4UT x R : aw Thi i a pr pe per on appea f' aj ss o r s l zom udm e o c nviton. nt f o c i Sec ond Judi alDi r c Com ',W ashoe Count St ci st i t t y; even P.Eli t Judge. lot , TM s courts prelm i ' i nary r ew of t s appeal reveal a evi M s : j i di to def t Spe e c ly,t di t i t c urtent r t j ur s c i nal ec . c a l he s rc o e ed he udm e nt ofconyi i on June 7,2007. Appelant di notfl the notce of appeal cton l d le i , how ever,unti N ovem ber 7, 2007, w el aft t expi i of t t r yl l er he rat on he bi t : day appe? pe i d pr c i d by NRAP 4(9. An t i ey no ie o appeal r o es rbe 1 mtm l tc f f l t ves j idito i t s c ur . Ac o ngl we c ncude t we ais o t m s c in n hi o tl c rdi y, o l hat ; i l k j i di t o t c ns dert sappeal and we ac ur s c i n o o i M , ORD ER t s appealDISM IS hi .ô j q ' . i l j . J. bons . ch J. ; J Sai t ta l eLoz v.St e.11 Ne 349,871P. 944 ( 994) se ada at 0 v. 2d 1 . @F Heulaa . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 32 of 85 . * I . * à. ' cc: f' : H on.Steven P.Em ott D i h c Judge , st t M athew Jam esTj lvet t et i A t orney G eneralC atheri C ort M ast cazson Ci y t ne ez o/ t W as hoe Count D i ri A t orney R i hard A .G am m i y st ct t c ck W as hoe D i ri t Cot t Cl st c u' erk ! ' i ï E : ' i ; . ' I HM ol a + x7 g J Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ()Daeo rs I d t f eut Filed 05/12/11 Page 33 of 85 lJ- - A V - o >' t tc o p o od ro d cst ia i l. Ata, o y f re r e ii f vahbe) h m, l I o ddn t pxa,e panbifywh y uddn t 4. fy u i o a l l x li rel y o i o: . l . Otc t nadie t pxa fom tejlm e t fc n dina dsne œ,kv y up e iusy 5 h hq rc a l lr h t d n o o vi o n c tn l e o rvo l q f t a ym tt n y ppi a o moin w11rs totij d mr i a yc u ksaeo fdea? l d n ii s a lœ l o r to s t el t hs u g m n n o r tt r e rl 1 v Ye X ' No ' s l Iye ra we t No.1 ya ç e ' gv tefl wigi br to 6. f u ro 5 sç s' e l ol n x mnin: y z o d ()1 Na o c ur! U nIœ l .l 1. D ,.r, . C cw'/' a () me f o t' t. $ w z4 ' / '+ , . t % ,'* ( ) Na u eo p Gxe i g 2 tr f r dn : . 'x . , () Gru d mie : fp ..p v . olx ,, a /,./f.w#,& . d <x,., u<. wx 3 o n s m. 'mce . wt v; w > .nz d z e % . ' ; > x k#- = , t* . . T> ' h ) - * . ( Di you r veanevdenlay he i on y w tton ap iaton ormoton? 4) d eœi i i l arng our ii v plc i i s () Yeul: 5 Re t s No N k. ' '- .. '( w àke h . nve bee/ '.Lxv.: 2. l' u ' ' e t o< ( ) Daeo m l L ->z - *. 6 t f l t , 6f î ( ) I n wn ctto so a ywrt no i t o %t o o d r e trdpt mn t s11rs l: 7 fk o , iain f n it pni r e f r es nee l t ; t, eut e m m c1 () M t a y= o dp tto , p lc to o mo iw #v tesmei o rn'n: b on n eiin a piaia r to e h a nfrn n e () N meo o11 . r3 .wJj1 l fa>.c+ u - y uT W.e -I a f z : f .J ) '' l *l . r . . c xLx 1 +< cx a . ( ) Naueo p xe dig pr.-# '. -p. l ol çe r u 1+ a#- l> b. x/ 6or ss 2 tr f n e n z .. e, 1 ,v yr x . . . po . , ? z u ' rz ( ) Gr l m141 3 omx e : . v K. J n /nw f6.zz lz % , .- tz ' ' ' .1 ' e j .. 'z y 04r2 z x,. zL , ,'.. . : .5 . .. w . , >. <.! n . . ( Ddooioe eiye' oy r inahaoomtn 4Y yu va ? na hngno mto,pci roo? )i œ Nnv tr -n u t p tn i e i q i () Ie l: .. * ' ' w 5 lnl t >% ' '. . . v 1 . ' V r f ( ) Da eo e l: 6 t frnt t () I e o dtto so a y wrte o iino d t o ndese tra pzs n t s c a 7 f wnz ain f n itn pnn r ae f r r nee rua t o u h lt () Ast a yt mdo s b e e t d o a a pl o so moin gv tesme c o n br r u squ n a e n l p i n r to ie h a ' œ l or ai aqa e ls t onao aat s e a atct nf m ton e , it h= r e he t nd ta l ( Di y ua - t tehih s saeo fd rloutl vngjm'l o ters l o à to * d o p o h g el lt r e ea r u i ' l i az h e ut r cin q y di tk n c a ye 'ir a l a in o mo n ae n n to q ppi t r do ? c o () FH l o a pia o o mo o ? Ye 1 xe nz p lc d n r u n s No X ' * Ciaton ordaeofdv ii ti t xon: ' ( ) S III io y p hc to o moin Ye 2 = M vtin a p ain r to ? s t No Ci i ordaeofdœ ii . t on at t soa: () n ido s b e u n Ktto s a piain Q moin ? Ye 3 r r u sq e t iin z p icto s r to s s No I ' Ci in or( eofde son: . tto ht cii () l y uddn ta m a fo t ales a o o a ymt inz p ic o o moih mçl n e f o i o p l rm be t te Y n n n i o a piMin r t v t o pai b ily wh yo di n t ( umt trlt s c'c*c5i msmnx t td q e ok Yo rrs nK Ia rel y u d o. Yo k eae w t : L n j s s o ls u l u em ny 1 icud o I = wl k 8 % b l ic atc e t teK tia Yo qrs n ema n te . n l v n KI e s y l n hu ta h d o h io t u ew s y o xIv hn d i œ o tm wrtc N g si lngk) % l.v . i e n wrt r y it t e ne t aw Y % . . . 0 . k . ' 1 .( . 4 , Y J/ Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 34 of 85 ()crousu one: ' 'el'.#,'. s-sJ 4-' e ef dr'4% ! . ax 5n.t c 'e s ' . ', . w q s, 'c .. : . s rigFAc's(e! o rsoybif wih u ctn a o uw.: r NW t n r ' ly u tx rel to t i gc u r ) r y i -. ' g ' , . # +ç . < . . , . w g . . . uz e s m rz.. zee zk..x ty zcce .. . wl , ' ' , '. : ' y . y . xW s . . () Grmal : Pr -- gxl bêa.#!, s b t tTwo peell ltl 'me Sq rigF Y O'ly u soyb nywi u ct gc so Iw.: X tw t ACI el o r tr he Go t in a r a ) n i . . . u x% Nrees# l d t J . *. xp . ' ' '& y . sk. , ()Gr al re W orvdt' l gr .o,tc mztn e : - /w. z g , '-. t jr sp tgF I (e1ors r bin wi uct gc'srlw. . (,1 t x rrs/ ' l umri . AC' Tly u ty z y iotia aeo a ) X n Y e e i ; : '. t x-rlw ' . . ' K/<. r' ' j % - . . h ' ' ' Hr x r ' * J . . . .- n ae z j re qbkne ' n t () cruuFu: p( r.e w. ti 1 1f p. d on or , . evl ' m .a x a. o . s Su m z ig F Y t l o rsoy b fy wih u ctn c vso 1w.: p tn ACI Tely u tz he l t o t iig a t a ) . w . ê i / #' l ' - '/ l jg q. y. J3 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 35 of 85 W HEREFORE,m ttone pr yst tt c tgr x ttone r i t whih he raybeendue ii r a ha'hc our ant ii r elef o c n d 1 1 1 pr e n g. ' E E U E aEyS t fo,nh 1/ dy ft mmto X C T b tl utPi no tt ' ao l l b f s ' t t 1 oft ar200.2. hèye . . aur of t e tone i r El Stt Prs y ae ion Pos Onk e Box 1 t 989 El, d 8 3 - 9 9 y Nm n 9 61 1 8 S> t eo Ato y( a y i ur f tme 1 n ) Atome f m ttoner t y or ii Addr q eq VERI CATI FI ON Un e N n lyo m ru y teu d li e d cne t th k teKtto e n me i tefrg zg d r qt f j r ,h n espzd e lrq ha e s h i n r a d n h o e o i I ïo a d l wst c n e st ee t t tt p e tig L tu o Mso k twl g ,e c p m t t o e < n n mo he o tat h r o ha he lal s z e f wn l e e x e t q o h s n o matr sae o i f r no a dt e a d a t s c I e sh O e e t e t t tue te s ttd n l o mn 'n n e t n : o u h œ r e z VSh m o e x . eiiner tto Atemeyf m ttcter t cr ii l 6 3,1 - i . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 36 of 85 > : A FFG M A TI N O i Purs uantt N R S 2398. o 030 n epnder i ed doesher am r t tt pk sr eby m àa he ecedi ng p b' b, (àz Vrt c f Ps Le-. corpvs w èl . ' ) y x rg ( teéfDoc nt Til ume ) fe i Ditit ut s No C R 0X -X V' t d n sr Co r Cme . l c lé D oes notcont n t s als urt num berofany per m' he oci ec iy son. - C1 O R- Cont nnt s i s ni he ocal ecuriy numberofaper on asr r by: t s equied A . A speci s at orf fc t e eder l ,t w i: al aw o t ( es céclw) Sut pe a I - OR- B Fort admi staéon ofapublcpr am or he ni i ogr f an applcatqn f a f alors a e gr . or i i or eder t t ant > - t -oF ' l ( i a re s h ) O ae) t 3/ ' ; Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 . ; ' $ ! ase 3: cv08 00054LRH- PC V - Docum ent7 Filed 05/12/11 Page 37 of 85 Fi 06/ 2008 l ed 30/ E 1 : 3 4 4 ! : 5 E 6 UNITEP STATES olse c' CO URT rm r 7 Page 1 of2 DI STRI O F NEVADA CT ; : ! ! ' 8 9 M AU HEW TJ ELTVEI T, 1 0 Pe ii e , tton r 11 vs . 1 E. M CDANI et . 2 K. EL, aI, E ' 1 3 ; 3: c 0 408-v- 005 LRHVPC . ORDER 1 4 i j ; I I j i ( ! Re p nt. s onde s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) / . l 5 M at w Tj l t: Ne dap io r ha tldapr s pe iin f rawrtofha a c pus the ewei.a va rs ne , s ie ' o e tto o i be s or , 16 pur suantt 28 u s. 9 2 4 ( t c d a do ke #1 a d h spad t a opraefl fe( c t o c. 25 at he t c t ) n m i he ppr it ii e do ke a ng . 1 /5) Thep ttonwilbeoree fld,d kee a s re upont rs nd nt,h ve,he 7 /. eii l d rd ie oc td nd ev d be e po e s owe rt 1 rs 8 e ponde swilnoty tberquie t r s d t i. nt l e e rd o e pon o t 19 l appear t t Courtt t gr t s o he hat he oundsf r i i t petton ar c r l unexhaused i or elef n he ii e ur enty t n 20 saec r.Peii ri a vie t th mus fr tp e e hi gr undsf r i t asa ec t tt ou t ttone s d s h àa e t is r s nt s o or el o tt our ef i ' ai 21 bef e a f alcour may r ew t m ert oft is he r s To exhausta cl m , pettoner or eder t evi he is he s ues ai es. ii ' 22 m us have 'f rl pr nt 't s fc cl m t t Supr e Court of Nevada. See Pi t 'ai y ese ed' hat pecii ai o he em card v . ' 1 23 Con r 4 U. 27 2 7 (97 ) Sc ne , 04 S. 0,75-6 1 1; hwarz l rv Gar e , F.d 1 ,144(t Ci. tmil . dn r 752 2 341 3 9h r e ! 24 1 ) A r alcourtcannotheara r xed petton t cont nsbou:exhaused and unexhaused 984 eder ni ii hat ai t t i 25 cli f ha a c p rle.Ros v fu y, U. 50 5 - (98 ;Sz t v' s n,7 ams or be s orus eif e . nd 455 S. 9, 2122 1 2) eo .Ru e 09 I i 26 F.2 140,1 4l( hCi.1 3) Afe rvi i t, petton i t s cas , i a s o he hat d 3 3 9t r 98 . tr e ew ng le ii n hi e t ppear t t courtt ! 27 al ofpettoner3 cl m sm ay be unexhaust 1 ii s ai ed. l 2 8 i . s cton Acodn t i ms3a d4o tep tin ptt n rdd ap ealfrom hi convi i , h wee crig o t e n fh eio , eio e i p t i o vr i i j i i ! . ' 15 ' : : . . N Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 j $ ' ase 3: c O0O54O8- vLRH- PC V Docum ent7 Filed 05/12/11 Page 38 of 85 Fi 06/ 2008 l ed 30/ Page 2 of2 @ : 1 t appealwas di ise wihoutachanc t r s any isues, and pettonerdi nots sat poshe sm s d t e o aie s ii d eek t e t i 7 i : ! ' I 2 convi i r i . se as ja e 4, a 8o t peiin(d tigfi et e a t rundsfr cton elef e lo g s 6, nd f he t o a mit al o xh us go t n ur o 3 r it Fr t fc oft peii ,teeoe peii e h sa mitdt thi cai frrle ha ele). om he a e he tton h rfr, tton r a d te ha s l ms o eif ve 4 notyetbeen exhaus ed i sat court l t si onnaton i i t n te . f hi nf i s nacctrat t pettonershoul fl an l e, hen ii d ie 5 am ended petton s ii howi w hen and how he e ust hi st ed gr ng xha ed s at oundsf r i . or elef E j 6 I I TH ER EFORE O RDER ED t t Cl k s lFI A ND DO CK ET t petton T S hat he er hal LE he ii E 7 f wrtofha m c or i be s omus(ta he a d ke /1. atc d t oc t/) i 8 : 9 ha m c pu (ndac ort sor r up r po nsbyc riidmai.Reponde ss lno be s or s a opy hi de) on es nde t etfe l s nt hal t ' I I FURT HER OR DER ED t tt Cl r s l T S ha he e k hal SERVE a c py oft pe ii n f rwrtof o he tto o i ! ' 10 ans erorot m ie r pond t t petton untlf rt ror oft Court w he s es o he ii i u he der he . 11 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tp tto rs l h et ry( )da i whih t fl a T S ha e iine hal av hit 30 ys n c o ie n ' 12 am ended petton s i w hen and how he e ust t sat gr ii how ng xha ed he t ed oundsf r i . Pettoner' or elef ii s : 1 f l et c mpl i atmel ma rwil e uti t d s is o hi peii Pe ii ri a ie 3 ai o o y n i y nne lr s l n he im sal f s tton. ttone s dv s d ur : i I 1 t a teCo tmus dim ist wihi peii i pe iine i u bl t de s rt ho a wh n 4 h t h ur t s s he t n tton f tto r s na e o mon tae w nd e 1 15 he f l exhaused a1 cl m sf r i i hi petton. uly t l ai or elef n s ii ' ! : . 16 o DATED t s27 day ofJ hi une,2008. i I i I ' . . 17 1 8 19 LA RRY R.HI S CK UNI TED STATES D I TRI J S CT UDGE 20 I I 21 ! i E 22 ! ! 23 I 2 4 1 I 25 i 2 6 I 2 7 t i : : 28 ; 2 ë i i ! I ! ! ! l z# . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 39 of 85 C as 3: cve 08- O0O54LRHVPC Fi 04/ 2009 l ed 28/ Docum en 1 t 0 Page 1 of1 An zGlPoz&I% 11 mo e1 oC''C'e m !. ( q R ) .r n n 11 n e f l x1 , I TED STA TES D I STR I CO CT *++ ++ T Dj r t cT O F NEVADA sel j M AW HEW TJELTVEI T, Pe iine , tto r JU DG M EN T I A CI I CA SE N V L V. CASE NUM BER:3: cv08- 00054LRH VPC E. M CDANI etal, K. EL, . Res ponde s. nt Jur Ve dit Thi a i c meb or t Cou tf atilbyj r Theis sha eb entid y r c . s cton a ef e he r or ra u y. s ue v e re a dt j yha rndee isvedit n he ur s e rd t r c. Decii by C ourt Thi acton came t ti orhea i bef e t Cour. The is have been s on . s i o ral rng or he t s ues ti orhear and a deci i hasbeen r red d son ender ed. X Decii by C ourt Thi acton came t be consi ed bef et Cour. The i ues havebeen son . s i o der or he t ss consi ed and a de si hasbeen r der ci on ender ed. I I O RDERED AND ADJUD GED t a t /8 p tton i DI I T S h t he / e ii s SM SSED W I THOUT PREJUDI CE. I I FURTHER ORDERED t tpettoneri DEN I aceri i e ofappeal lt T S ha ii s ED tfcat abiiy. Aprl28.2009 i LA NCE S.W I LSO N Cl k er / /Kal Li es s ani zar D e y Cl k put er VJ ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 40 of 85 F IL E D ' Elllrlltll/ Ett trill t z s . 1 02042 00 0 1 PM - -01 :5:0:0 Howar w .conyer d s 1 CM e: 2922 Clr O teCo r ek f h u t Tr ansaci # 1303233 ton r 2 ; k 3 ! . 4 ! ! 5 6 : 7 ; 8 j : 9 E 10 i 11 i 12 I THE SECOND JUDI ALDI RI COURT OFTHE STATE OF NEVADA N CI ST CT I AND F THE COUVF OF W M HOE N OR Y * * * M ATTHEW J ES TJELW EI AM T ' , Pettoner li , Cas No. e : vs. ' : 1 3 ! é 1 4 E C205P2796 Dept No. 10 . : E. MC L. DANI W ARDEN, EL, 1 5 Res pondent . / ! 1 6 j ; 1 8 O RDER GRANH NG M OTION T0 DI SMISS PETI TION AND SUPPLEM ENTAL PETI O N F0 R W RI OF HABEAS CORPUS ( STTI T O COINW W I ONI Pr nty be or t Cour l a Moton t Di s Petton and Suppl e* l f e he ts i o smis il emen lPetton o ii 1 9 2 0 21 2 2 ( f Wrto Ha e sComu (os- n c nl fe W Re p d tST OFNW ADA 0r l f b a s P tco vl pi d to l s on en ATE ( e ea ' s on en o J u y5 2 0 F l wig onJ nu r 1 ,2 0,P t e h r fer' p d f n an ar , 01 . ol n , a a y 2 01 dli r Re o on MA HE J STJ L E T ( r a r' e iln ' fld a Opm sto t Mo i t TF W AME E W I he e Ne ' t o erl i n p t ' e ino t o i on DlmisP t i an Su plme t l e ii f W r o Hab a C p ( o tco vdln) s r e lon d p e n a P t on or i f e s or us P s- n l o . x t t t ' : . Subs equenty,on J l anuar 19,2010,Res ndentfl a Repl t Opposil t Mo i t . y m i ed y o ton o ton o . 23 i 2 DimlsP tt an Su plmen P tlnf Wr o Hab sCop ( olc vi o . 4 s r eion d i e ll elo or i f ea rus P s-on dln) x l t t 1 I - 25 ' Cont emm r aneousl wih is Repl Res y t t y, pondentfl a Reques f Subm i i s l ed t or % on, ubmt l ng 2 t matrfrteCo t c sd rto . 6 he te o h ur' on lealn s 27 : 28 i As par ofis Moton t Dfmly,Resm ndentar t t i o s r s gues t t Cour shoul dim is hat he t d s s Pe ii ' Petton b ttoners li ecaux P ii ettonerQ i t tmel fl sai Petton. I hi Opposil l o i y ie d li ed n s tnn i i ' . 1- z/t -j j , * .. . ' ' ' . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ' ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 41 of 85 1 t Re ndents Moton t Dim is,P ii c endst alhough he sl hi P ii o sm ' i o s s ettoner ont hat t ed s et on t 2 It , ru n t NKS43.2 1 , e h d g e c ef rhsdeay a d t rf r dimic l a e pu s a t o 7 6( ) h a o zus o l l , n hee e e, s s 3 i notwarant s r ed. 4 Acc di t t r d O f e t Cour,9n J 7,2 or ng o he ecor or he t une 007,t sCour c vi hi t on de 5 Pettoner pur antt aj yver d,offr - r mur wlh t uœ ofafr m. li , su o ur dl istdœ ee der t he lear 6 R er ealer on Novem ber7,2007,Pettonerfl a Notc ofAppeal whih t Neva , il l ed ie , c he da 7 Supr eme Cour dim is on Dec t s s ed em- r27,2007. F l ng,on J ol owi anuar 22,2008,t y he 8 Supr eme Cour i ued isr tiur Subs uenty,on Augus 5,2008,a ttonerfl a tu t emit . t m l t ii i ed 9 postcon ci pettonf wrtofhabeasc pus. - viton ii or i or 1 0 A X tt f rwr ofh asc p s( s on it )mu tt 5ld wi no y a ii o i a- or u m bc vci on t on s ) e li ne e r e 1 a re tyo t j d 1 oe n r f he u gmen o c ve o o ,fa ap alst en w4 l o ey a a t e t f on i n r I n œ i ak , t n n e r Rer h h 1 is a c o r mi iu . NR 3 7 6 1 .Ho v r wh a a pe lst k ,t eon -e 2 s u n e f e t t r S 4.2 ( ) we e , en n p a i a en h ey ar t 1 pere t 5l Y gi t r fom t isu e ofr it onl when t diu apl aîi 3 l o e ns o un r he s anc em tur y hen r x s 1 fl tmel . Di er n p St e.11 Nev.1084,1087,967 P. 11 1133- ( 4 i i y. %e ck so ; at 4 e 2d 32, 34 1998) . 1 Furher or i t X ttoners X tton i un i y,i i pr edur l Y red and m us be 5 t m e, f he ii ' ii s tmel t s x al y r t 1 , lmi dab e tas o ngo g e c s NIS 3 . 2 4 ) NRS 3 81 6 .s d s n h wl f c au e. k 4 7 6 1 , 4. 0 1 . 7 I maki a showi ofgc ) c e,a pettonerm ustdem onstat t tt del n ng ng x d aus ii r e ha he ay 1 wast ough no f tofhi own an t di m aloft petton a untm el woul undul 8 hr aul s d hat smiq he ii s i y d y 1 p eu c X t n . NKS 3 7 ( ) Th A t men o go c u e mu ta l ront 9 rj dle i er :o 4.26 1 . e e t f Y a s s pxa he 2 f c oft e p t n. NKS 3 7 5 tm ur a m t ln t sa e t e r a o f fl gan 0 a e h eto 4.3 r li ng lo er o t t h e s n or in t i 21 untmel peœ onerI t pe ll 1 1 Furher e,t sat l y n he tton * 9. t mor he t ementofgoe c auœ mus t 22 al e sa cfc f t t demons r t t del was nott f tofpettoner . e l œ il ac s hat ta e he ay he aul il . % 2 Ha wa M S a e 1 9 NN .2 ,2 2- ,71P3 5 ,5 ( 0 ) . e ak R /p . p 3 la y r t , 1 48 5 53 .d 03 06 2 07 ;* l /aç ; 2 Slt,1 0Ne .3 ,44 8 P. 8 8 82 (0 4)(t igt a % p tln frp s4 e 2 v 7 , 3 3d 1 , 3 2 0 s n h t' elo er o ozt a t t 25 c c i r l I entted t an evi i y hearng onl i he supm c hI cl mswih onvitoô el s il o ef dentar i yf s al t 2 s e fcf du al a in t a i tu woud e t l hm t r if) I i t e r ion rwh 6 p l a al l to s h tf r e l n ie I o el '. t s h m t e o eg t e' i 27 i st bur ofes abl hi t f war he den t i ng he adual lgatons i s s al i n upm r ofhi X tton. I e t s il d 28 // / - 2- L, (' ? Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 Filed 05/12/11 Page 42 of 85 A p t lne ma e t l h g o c s W s o n t a h ra on by Y l v d hi e io r y sabi o d au e h wig h t e e s a l i e s t s e 2 counœ lNm el fl an appealand t tt pettoneril a hab c pus petton wl l a yl ed ha he li ed eas or ii l n 3 r K nabl tme aoerI ni t a died apm alhad notbeen fld. Hat ea el ear ng hat r i e hawayi11 Nev. 9 4 at255,71 P. at508. 3d 5 I t pr entmater i I undl ed t fPettonerf l t fl tmel hi diec n he es t ,t s sput ha li ai o i i y, s r t ed e 6 apx al t t e Ne da Supr wih h va eme Cour, M s t uch,t tm e Pettonerhad t ;l hi Petton he i ii o e s ii 7 f HabeasComus( tconvi i wasoneyearfom t dat t sCour ent ed is or Pos - cton) r he e hi t er t 8 j dg to c n i on. NRS 3 72 ( ) F t er e,ti u dip t dt a P t in u men f o vdl 4. 6 1 . urh mor i s n s u e h t e io er t 9 f i dt fe hl'e il f rW rto Ha e sCor u l os- on lt lwl i on y a al o i sp t on o l f b a p s p tc vcl e l t on t n e e r h 1 f l ng t sCour' en r oft j 0 ol owi hi ts ty he udgmen ofc ci R er or P ii ' Pe ii t onviton. ef e, ettoners tton 11 f W rtc HabeasCor wa un l y ab enta s or i f pus s tmel s howl ofgood c s I ng au e. d. 12 Up eu m i i b t Cour,t Cour does no bel e Pettonerpl on naton y he t he t t l ev ii ead 1 s fcentf t t woul per tt s Cour t mak a det m l i ast t exi enc of 3 ufii ac s hat d mi hl to e er naton o he s e l 1 good c 4 au* r dl Pet i ' dely. Sœ cllal Pe il egar ng i oners a t fc l ttonernevers li when he y, pecfe 1 atempt t c ad hi œ unsel norwhen and how Pet%onerfr tI ne hI c 5 t ed o ont s , i is ear d s ouns e! 1 kai d t fl tmel a died appeal W ihoutkn edge oft s if maton,t Cour 6 fl o i i y r e e . t owl hl n or l he t 17 c annotdet m l w h herPe i er ne et ttoners dely i il hi P ii was r on e. ' a n i ng s etton eas abl 1 8 Furher e,bas on t r or bef e t Coul Pe il rwa notfed b t t mor ed he ec d or he t ttone s li y he 1 Su e C to Dc e er2 ,2 7 t a hI drd a a wa rj rpl n e eor , 9 ùrme our n mb 7 00 , h t s i pœ l s ee ' r. r f e e t 20 Pe oners i had mor t n fve mon hst fl tmel hi Petton f W rtofHabe e tl l e ha l t o i l y s li or i e as 21 Cor ( pus Posbconviton) However P ii dl nntfl hI Petton untlmor t an ci . , eitoner d l s il e l eh 22 r zven mon hs f lwi t Supr t ol ng he o eme Cnur' dlm iq ofPettoners apx al Gi t s ts s t al ii ' . ven hi 23 tme pere ,ev i an unl uli y k mentpr ent Pettonerfom tmel fl a died i i en f awf m di ev ed il r i y ing r l 24 appeal t Cour does no Y l ve t ts an i x di tafe pd Pe ii ' ablt t , he t t l e ha uch m men f ttoners ly o l 2 tl tmel hsP tt . . Byan M Ar o a Jtp e Ge er 4 9 F3 1 $ 1 60( t 5 i l y i e ion %e e i t i n tm y n aé 9 .d 05 0 9 h z 2 Ci. 0 ) 6 r 2 07 . 2 // 7 / 2 // 8 / - 3 - &J / Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 Filed 05/12/11 Page 43 of 85 NOW ,THEREFORE,I IS HEREBY ORDERED t tRes ndenrs Moton t T ha x i o 2 DimisP tt n a d Su pe n P t in f Wrto qa e sComus( o tc vdln)i s s e io n p lme ol e io cr i f b a l t P s- on l o s 3 GRANTED. 4 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tPec oners Petbon f W rtofHabeasCom us T S ha ' i or l 5 ( tconvl on)l W SMISSED Pis- di s 6 . I IS FINALLY ORDERED t P onersSuppl T' hat ee ' ementt Petton f W rtof o ii or i 7 Habeas Cor i DI SSED . pus s SMI 8 9 D T Dtl $ dyo Fbur, 00 AE h s a fe ray2 1. N 10 - 11 12 GSTEVEN P. ELU OU Diti Ju s rd dge 1 3 1 4 15 16 17 18 1 9 20 21 22 2 3 24 25 26 27 2 8 + Y# Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 i Filed 05/12/11 Page 44 of 85 ! i ! I cem n cv e oF MAzu xs I 1 1 2 I I 3 usn: t ECF w s em whi s ved t f l ng x r .s elctonial i he t ch er he ol owi ue e r c l y: 4 I MERCHANT E f MA z SQ. or TFHE TJ TVE T W EL I 1 5 J PH PL TER,11 F . o S ATE OF NW ADA OSE A 1, . f r T m 1 1 6 : : 1 7 8 ! l 9 E olHow nE s 1 0 J dal sit t udl M s an I I Ih r yc ri ta Iee r ial fldt efrg n wihleCl ko teCo r b eeb ety h t l onc l l h oe oig t f y e er f h ut y , DATED tl hs d yO F rar,2 . a f ebu y 01 - ' ! I I i ! 1 1 1 2 13 i r ! 1 4 l s i 16 l 1 7 ! 18 ! i ! 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1 ! . - 5- 2 /S ' I Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1l .. ./ . . j ( Filed 05/12/11 Page 45 of 85 . '' A ' . ! l coos:2540 F'- L E D I .t ' i - i k . j i 1 i 3 . . 4 5 . . 6 7 I THE SECOND J CI DI CT COURT OF Tl STATE 0F NEVADA N UDI AL STRI v I xxo FoR THE coux'v oy w xsuos x r . . ! ! ! ë 8 *** . 9 M ATTHEw J Bs TJ o ELTVEI , T 1 1 i j 1 0 I t Peiine, tto r txgs xo; cj jpzgg y o y VS. 1 2 . I I DéPT. : 1 N0. 0 . ' THE STATE OF NEVADA, 3 ! e R CS Ijn & POI( t ' / 14 . 1 5 I ' ' 11 i j B y . . ! I ' pE tyy pj . i ' i ! i jc'An j c yras jr y y ' . l 1 i 1 j 1 6 NOTI OF ENTRY OF ORDER CE ( l 7 1 8 PLEASE TAKE NOTI t to Fe 'ua y 4, 201 t Cour e e ed ade i i or CE ha n br r 0 he t ntr c son or r i t s m a r atuea c r c c ofwhi h i a tche t t snotc de n hi ue , r nd ore t opy c s ta d o hi ie. 1 9 ' 20 vou m a a alt t supr mecour fom t de ii oror roft Cou t y ppe o he e t r he c son de he r. t t n hit l you wih t a al you m us tl anotc ofa a wih t Clr oft sCour wihi t ry f s o ppe , t ie ie ppe l t he e k hi - 21 Thr ( da , afert dat t snotoe i m aied t you. Thi notcew asm aied on t 24t day ee 33) ys t he e hi i s l o s i l he h . : 22 of M mth, 2 0. 01 1 ' . 23 ., ' . 2 4 .. HOW Akb w ;coxkkRs .. ,. . 25 ;. ; ' ,. . . C1r Oft O ' '. S: # k ie F4 ' ' . i .' 26 . B3 C z -. . . . ' ' : . rw u -. e. e . . 27 . . Df tt Clr m l: lk ' . :8 2 ' ' . . j ' . ... , . ' . . ' ' /..' :. . ? g . 1 . .. ,. w , ,. ,. '. ' ,. . - . : . .' J %' '' ' '' . àJ:.* * '' '' .. . . ' J : .. '; , . , . ! . : . ' . ' ( . . ' . . . ; . ,. .'' '. ' 1 1- J Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 46 of 85 F IL E D El tonial ecr c l y 02- 2 05: 10 PM 04.010: 00: H- ar W .Conyer d s 1 Cod 2922 e: Clr o teCo d e k fh u Tr cton# 1303233 anu i ' 2 3 4 5 6 1 THE SECOND J CI DI RI COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA N UDI AL SF CF 7 I AND F THEY UN'YOFWM HOE N OR I ' * ** 8 9 M AU HEW JAM ES TJELW EI . T . 10 tt Pettoner ll , Cas No. e : vs. CR05P2796 Dep .No. 10 t : 12 13 1 4 E. MC L. DANI W ARDEN, EL, Res pondent . / 15 16' 1 7 1 8 . DRDER GRANTI M OTION T0 DI NG SMISS PETI ON AND SUPPLEMENTAL TI PETI ON FOR W RI OF HABEAS CO RPUS (POSTTI T COINW W I ONI Pr en l bef e t Cour i a Moton t Dim's Petton and Suppl es ty or he ts i o s i s ii ement P ii al etton 1 f Wrto Ha e sCo pu ( os- on i on ,fldb Re p d n ST TE OFNE 9 or i f b a r s P tc vdl ) i y s on e t ' e A VADA 2 ( ee fe h s o e t' o J nu r 5,2 0. F lwig, J u r 1 ,2 0 P t i e 0 h r a tr' p nd n ' n a a y 01 el n on an a y 2 01 , e lon r Re l o t 2 MATT W J STJ L EF ( er fe ' e ion r tld anOp st n t Mo i t 1 HE AME E W T h eat r' tt e ' ie p i m ii o ton o o s r e io d p e n a P t in o i f b a r s P s o vdi ) t t t 221 Dimi P t inan Su plme t l e io f rWr o Ha e sCo pu ( c bc n i on . 23 Sub sequenty cn J l, anuar 19,201 Res y 0, pontentfl a Repy t Opp ton t Moton t i et l o osii o i o 2 DimisP t in a t Su l n a P t inf Wr o Ha e Co p s( o tc vci ) 4 s s e io n ppeme t l e do or i f b as r u P s-bn it . t t t on . 25 Cont por em aneousl wlh is Repl Res y t t y, pondéntfl a Reques f Subm i i s l ed t or % on, ubmitng tl 26 t materf t Cour' c i a i he t cr he ts onsder ton, As par ofis Moton t Di ni ,Res t t i o sr ss ponden ar t gues t t Cour s d timi hat he t houl s ss ' Pettoners Petton becaus Petton f l t tmel fl sai Pe il l hI Opp ii ii ' ii - e ii er ai o i y i d tton. n s oston ed e ' 27 28 . ' ! f - 1 - Copyofor i documenton5I wiht Cl kofCour - Sec Judi alDititCoud, i nal g e t he er t ond ci s rc Count ofW as y hoe,St e ofNevada at ; Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 47 of 85 1 5 ! ' . 1 t Respondents Moton t Di s P ii o ' i o smis, ettonerc t on endst atalh h t ongh he fl hi P ii i ed s etton i 1 2 l e, p s a tt NKS43.2 ( ) heh d gpd c us f rhst a ,a dt e e oe ds s al at uru n o 7 6 1 , a t a e o i ely n h r fr , imis I i l 3 i no warant s t r ed. 4 Ac or ng t ta r u be or t cour, c di o le ecor f e he t 1 s P sin r p ru n t ajr v ri, fi t x remui r t teu eo ase r et e, usa t o uy edc o fs- e re wi h s f ram. o t rd b - ' 6 Th e feronNo emb r7, 0 ,P tto eri daNoieofAp e lwhc t Ne a a erat , v e 20 7 ei n fl i e tc p a, ih le v d i 2 7 supr cour di is on Dec eme t sm s ed ember27, 2007. rol nq,on J -l owi anuar 22,zoca,t y se ! 8 Su r Co r is e I rmiju.Su s u t ,o Au s 5 i0 8,P tt n feda peme u ts u d t e tt r b m enl n gu t , 0 e io er i s t y i l l I 9 pos-on ci pettonf wrtofhabe c pus tc viton ll or l as or . I onJ e7,2 07 t scoutc n it un 0 ,hi r o vced . . ! 1 l c Ap tinrr îo h ba cru ( b d vcin mutb fe wi no ey a eio o wr f a e s op s ys c n lt ) s e id ti n e r t t o l I ; I 11 aoerentyoft j r he udgmentofc di or i anapm ali t eniwihl oneyearaferte onvi on ,f s ak tn t h 1 is a c o r mit ur NP 3 72 ( ) Ho v , ena a p a itk n teo ey a 2 s u n e f e tl . S 4. 6 1 . we er wh n p e ls a e ,h n -e r t : 13 p i t fl begi s t r f om t l s ere o i e n o un r he s uanc ofr it onl w hen t diec appe i e em t ur y hen r t al s ! 1 fl tmel. S< D/# m 7?B Aa e 1 4 Ne 1 8 1 7 9 7 P.d 11 2,11 3 3 ( 99 ) 4 i i y e è e / . t. 1 v. 0 4, 08 , 6 2 3 . 3 - 4 1 8 . . . 15' Furher e,i t œ ttonerspetton I untmel I i pr edur l bare and m us be t mor f he ii ' ii s l y, t s oc al y rd t 1 1 dimis d a s ta s o n o q o c s . NK 3 7 6 1 ,NP 3 81 6 s s e b en h wlg f' d au e S 4.2 ( ) S 4. 0 ' o i 1 7 i I i 1 1 wa t'u hn futo hso a dta ds sa o tep tina u t llo l u d l 8 s ho g o a l f i wn n j t imisl fh eio s n mey ud n uy r n t ' 1 peu i p tin r N S3 .2 () n esae n o g o c uemuta pa o te 9 rjdc elo e. R 47 61. ttme t f o d as s p e r n h e t I l 2 fc o t e p t in. NK 3 73 (e tln a K t lne t sa et e r s n frflg a 0 a e f h e lo t S 4. 5 rq lig r io r o tt h ea o o in n t l 21 untmel pettnneri t petton i el) Furher e,t s ementofgood c e mus i y ii n he ii t f. t mor he ot s aus t . i I maki a s ng ofgx d caus a pe ii m us demons r e t t des n ng howi e, ttoner t tat hat he ay . i 22 al sp i f t t demons r e t del was nott f tofpettoner . l ege edfc ac s hat tat he ay he aul ii . %e l ë 1 ! i ' 2 3 2 4 25 2 6 . . l 2 b asteb re o etbihn tefdul lq t n i s p ot fhsXtin I 7 e r h ud n f sa l ig h a e al ai s n u p ro i io . d s e o t I I j Ha wa k St e 11 Ne .2 ,2 2 5 71P.d 5 3,5 6 ( 0 ) s am T ma k Ya y $ att 9 v 48 5 - 3, 3 0 0 20 7 ; ee / ho s ( St e 1 Ne .37 4$ 83P.d 81 ,82 ( 00 (t tn t t' p t i erf m sat, 20 v , 3 8 3 2 4) sa ig ha ' e ion or t a t c n lt ; r ifI en ildt a e i n i h a igon i h s K rshl càmswl o vcl èl s t e o n vde t o e t al e rn # f e up t s lp t h s e icfdu l l ga i st titu wo d e t l hm t rl e .l i t e m tt e wh p cf a a al t ha f r e ul n ie i o ei ' t s h i e on t ef) ion r o i 28 // / ' ! ! - 2- Cpoogadcm no f wtt Ce oCu -Scn JdiDt torCutoWaheS tosvd oyfrilouetni i h lkfod-eoduia ir Cut on f so,tefeaa in l he r e c! si , y c a ' Yz y - ! i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 Filed 05/12/11 Page 48 of 85 A pe ii ttonermay es abls good caus by s t ih e howi t the r onabl bel ng ha eas y i eved hi s 2 c ouns tmel fl an appealand t tt pçttonerfld a hab c pus petton wihi a el i y i ed ha he ii i e eas or ii tn 3 r onabl tm e aoerI nig t ta diectapp had notbeen fld. Hat eas e i ear n ha r eal ie hawaA 11 Nev. 9 4 a 255,71 P. a 508. t 3d t 5 i t pr en m a t ,i i undi ed t tPettnnerf l t ft tm el hi di n he es t ter t s sput ha ii ai o i i y, s r ed e ed 6 app wih t Ne eal t he vada Supr eme Cour . As su t tme Pettonerha t ql hi Pe ii t ch. be i ll d o e s tton 7 8 9 1 0 f rHa e sC p s( o tc vdin)wa nn y a fom t e d t t i Co te t rd is o b a oru P s-bn i o s e e r r h a e hs ur n e e t j dg to c n i o . NKS 3 7 6( ) F rh r r ,i i u dip t dt tP t i e u men 'f o vdin 4.2 1 . u t e mo e t s n s u e ha e ion r t f l d t fl hsP tt f rWr o Ha e sCor u ( o lco vlto )wi i o ey a al o i i e ii o i f b a p s P s- n cin t n n e r e e on t h f l ngt sCour' entyoft j ol owi hi ts r he udgmentofc vi on.R erf e P ii ' Peii on di eor, èt oners tton t 11 f W rtofHabea Cor wa un i el ab or i s pus s tm y senta showig ofgood c se. I n au d. 12 Upon exam i ton by t Couf t Cour doesnotbel Pettnnerpl na i he t he t i eve ii ead 13 s centf t twoul per tt s Cour t mak a de er naton a t t e exit um i ads ha d mi hl to e t mi i s o h sence of 1 4 g ood c e r dl Pettonersdely. Spectcal Pe ii aus egar ng ii ' a i l ttonerneverspected when he l y, i i 15 a t pt t c ad hi c tem et o ont s ouns ,norwhen and how Pe ii fr tl ned hi c el ttoner is ear s ouns el 16 f l t fl tmel a died appe . W ihou knowl ai o i i y ed e r al t t edge oft s l or i t Cour hi nf maton, he t 17 c otdet f ne whe herPe it ' del l flng hI Petton wa r onabl ann ernl t ttoners ay n i l s ii s eas e. 18 Furher or bas on t r d bef e t Cour Pettcn wasno i ed by t t m e, ed he eccr or he t ii er tt i he 1 Su emeCou ton De emb 2 ,2 07 t a hi drd a p a wa rj de n e efr , 9 pr r c er 7 0 , h t s i p e l s ee d. r o e e 20 Pe ii ttoners i had mor t fve mont t fl tmel hi Pe li f W rtofHabeas tl l e han i hs o i i y s tton or i e 21 Cor ( cs - di . Hopever Peii di notfl hi Petton untlmor t pus P tconvi on) , itoner d l s iî e i e han 2 s v nmo t sfi wigteSu rmeCn t dimis l fP tine'ap e l Gie t i 2 e e n h ol n h pe o ur' s sa o eio r p a. v n hs s t s 23 tme perod,even i a unlwf i i i f n a ut mpedi mentpr en ed Pettonerfom tmel sl a dlect ev t ii r i y l ng r 24 appe ,t Cour does not% l e t s h an i al he t l hat uc ev mpedl mentafect Pe i f ed tdoners abit t ' ly o i 25 fl tmel hi P ii See Fr p ArtonaAtor y t at499 F. 1 i l y s etton. e yanl ; l t ne zndr 3d 056,1 ( h 060 9t 26 Ci.2007) r . 27 // / 28 // / ' - 3. Cop oforgi doc enton fl wiht Cl kofCoud- Sec d Judi al srctCour,CounyofW as y i nal um i t he er e on ci Diti t t hoe,St eofNevada at r Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 49 of 85 . i . 1 ; i NOW ,THEREFORE,I I HEREBY ORDERED t Resm ndents Moton t T S hat ' i o 5 . 2 DlmisP tt a dSu pe ol e io f rWr ofHa e sCo p s( os- on l cn ' s s e ion n p lmen P tt n o i i i t b a r u P tc vdj li s 3 GRANTED . 4 ' . rrz F s URTHER ORDERED ta p tt n r P tu nfrwr ofHab a Cop s h t eio e' eio o i i s t e s ru ' . l I 5 ( tcon di i DISMISSED, Pos- vi on) s ' 6 I I FI T S NALLY ORDERED t atPeii ' Sup ementt P ii f Wrto h ttoners pl o ettoc or i f ! 7 Habe Cor i Dî I as pus s SM SSED . X 8 i ! 1 0 i . ll 12 ' sn w Ex p. ' Ej uorr Dlt itl s rc uège 13 . 14 ! 15 ' ' 16 17 zc . ; j u 21 ! i ! ' 1 9 i j ' j ' 1 8 , 22 2 3 ' I . ' i I , 2 4 ' 25 i 2 6 2 7 , ' . 28 1 j ' : j ' dop o oiia d c me o fe y f r n l o w nt n i g l + wtte lk for-Scn Jd ilirtorC utoWaheSaeoNvd i h Ce oC ut eod uiaDsiC ut on f so,t feaa h r c t c , y t VD : i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 50 of 85 i I i i l i i 2 , i 3 usn te E s t whc s re t fl wlgp risee to cl ig h cF vsem lh ev d he ol n at ljrni l o e y: ! 4 4 i CERII I IF CATEoF MAI NG U 1 ! 5 ! Iher y c f t tIel onial fl t f egoi wi t cl koft Cour by eb eaiy ha edr c l i he or ng + he er he y ed t AZZMER AN E Q.f MA HE TJ L E I CH T, S or U W E W R 6 i 7 J OSEPH PL ATER, 11 ESQ.orSF OFNE 1, f ATE VADA DATED t s hl day ofF u y,201 . ebr ar 8 9 1 0 E I How DEN x J dalAs io nt udi ss '' ' 11 12 13 14 15 16 ' 17 18 1 9 2 0 l 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 - 5- Copyoforgi docum entontl wiht Cl kofCour - Second J ci Diti Copd,Count ofW ashoe, at o Nevada i nal ie t he er t udi al srct y St e f ; ; Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 . Filed 05/12/11 Page 51 of 85 :* . * ' k i . ! ' . l ; 2 . i , 3 1 C ERTIFICA TE O F SERV ICE Cas No CR05P2796 e j ; ( . 4 i ' Puruan t NRCP 5 ( , c f t atI an empl eeoft e Sec s to b) I edi h $ y am oy h ond j x . ( ( Judi alDi rctCoud,and t on t 24t day ofMar 2010,ldeposi i t W ashoe ; ci sti hat he h ch, t n he ed y Count m ai ng sys em f pos age and m ai ng w ih t U . Post Ser c i Reno. y l i t or t l i t he S. al vi e n i 5 i l C I i ! g o l 0 Nev ada,a tue copyoft atached document addr est r he t , ess o: W ASHOE COUNTY DI STRI CT ATTORNE#' OFFI S CE APPELLATE ot sl vl ox (ntro fc mal I e- fie i) k 1 1 i j ATTORNEY GENERAL' OFFI z S CE i 1 ' 100 N , CARSON STREET I ' ' 1 CAI ON CI N' 8 7 - 71 3 W TY, V 9 014 7 t 1 S/ 4 I ATTHEw J ss TJ -TV EI #83651 xv EI T 4 ELY STATE PRI 5 SON P. .BOX 1 O 989 16 ELY ,N V 89301 i l 1 hzj N M ERCHANT,ESQ. 7 % 1 l lON. - GTON AvE.STE. 0 8 0 ARIm , 29 I 1 9 ! 20 . : . RENO,NV 8 9501 > ' i k 21 22 w Iene Fl es ' r or oeput Cl k y er 23 i .. 24 25 26 ' 27 ' ! 28 N . . 2- SL l Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 . Filed 05/12/11 Page 52 of 85 . ' . , ' . $ 51 2 5 ' 1 A zi N . M e c nt Es z r ha , q. ! 2 Ne daBa No. 1 48 va r : 01 ë i i Me c a tIa Fim, d rh n aw r Lt . 3 10N. l go Av .S i 20 0 Ari tn e, ut 9 n e R eno, ' v 8 N 9501 4 ph:775 337 8 - 400 s Fa 775- 8401 x: 3376 Ato n yf rPeiin rM ate J me T emet tr e o t o e t w a s j l i t h 7 I THE SECOND J J CI DI N LDI AL STRI COURT OF TIE STATE OF NEVADA CT ' 1 i 8 I A ND FOR THE COU NTY 0 F W A SH OE N 1 ! 9 j 1 0 1 1 1 13 ! j 1 ! VS . 1 TH E STA TE OF N EV A DA 6 , 1 7 Res ponden s t . 1 8 19 xoe cs OF APPEAL rl 2 c xo iei i e ygie ta Mau J me T ewetp tto e .b v - me , e e y to s wrb v n h t tww a s j l i, ei n ra o ena d h rb i 2 z so l emeco ofxe uu vadafom an or ' g antngt sut sm oton t dir s hi r de r i he e' r i o snis aa appeal t tw supr ' 2 p s-o ito p tt no F b u r 4, 01 .Noieo e tyo tec utsod rwa sre b 3 o tc nvcin eio n e ray 2 0 tc f nr fh o r' re s ev d y i i 2 4 1 i 25 I . z ELY STATE P SON, and; s RI i I . D e :10 pt 14 E. .M CD AN I W A RD EN , K EL, I ; caexo:c R05p2796 s M A W HEW J M ES TJ A ELTV EI T, 1 2 Pettone , ii r 26 2 7 . t e diti tcou tcl k pur u t NRS 3 575 a NRS 34. on M a c 24,201 h src r er s ant o 4. nd 830 rh 0. A r inPu s a t oNRS 2 9 0 0 flmat o ru n t 3 8.3 Theunderi d doeshe e afim t tt pr ce ng doc sgne r by fr ha he e di umentdoesnotc an t ont i he s ca sc rt n mb ro a ypes n. o il e u iy u e f n ro 2 8 l Notice ot Appeal ' 3 XJ i l I Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 53 of 85 ! ; 2 I i l i : 1 l oae Api6 201 td, rl , e XllAzi N.M e c t s z r han 2 3 l i ë 5 i i ! Mec a tLa Fim, d rh n w r Lt. 4 i Azi N . M er hant Esq. z c , Neva Ba No. 1 48 da r : 01 6 I ! ! ;. i i i ! : 7 8 9 1 o 1 N . A r i on Ave ,Suie 290 0O lngt . t Re N V 8 01 no, 95 Ph 7 53 78 0 : 7 -3 r4 0 Iax:775- r 337 8401 cer iiat ofser c tfc e vie Iher c riy t ton4/ / 0, Iel toni aly tl t f egoi w ih t Cl r oft eby e tf ha 6 201 ec r c l i ed he or ng t he e k he cour-by usng-heEcF s t whih wils d a notce ofel toni tlng t t f l ng; t i t ysem c l en i ecr è ii o he olowi J OSEPH PLATER,ESQ.f STATE OFNEVADA or Azl M ERCHANT,EsQ.orSHAW N M I z f CHAEL THOM AS : E : 1 H ar Co m aie t 2 d py l d o: la E1 St t Prs y a e ion 1 Atn: ate T et et 4 t M th w j l i v l at # 83651 nm e l P0 B0X 1 5 989 l6 El ' V 89301 y,N 17 18 A or l6.2 0 i 0l / Azi N . e c -Esl S/ z M r hant c. 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 2 Notice of Appeal sY - ! Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 j ! I Filed 05/12/11 Page 54 of 85 . : : l I THE SI N JPREM E COURT OF 'M E STA TE O F NEVAD A I 1 I 2 ! i 3 ! I 4 i c M AW HE W J M ES TJ A ELTVEI T, as x o. 55773 e : 5 2 6 ù APP ELLANT, vs . ! 7 ! E K.M CDANI w ARDEN,ELY STATE EL, . 8 ! Pl l N ;Ax o THE STA TE ol N EV AD A t so r 1 9 RES ONDE S P NT ! 1 0 . I l I 1 1 AP PELLANT' OPEM NG BQT S EF 1 2 I l 3 1 1 4 ! APPEAL FROM A DEM AL OF A POSTCONM CTI PETI ON ON TI 1 5 I I St eo v a at fNe ad L T eHo o a l Se e P. l tPrsdn h n r be tvn Eli t eiig o 1 6 ! I ! ! s c n u iil rç eo dl dca oaf// 1 7 ' 1 Az zNe l e c a t ESQ 8 i a M rh n J e R. ae, osph Pltr ESQ. . 1 j NVBa No 1 4 q r . 018 I Ap elt De uy NVBa No 2 71 p l e p t, a r .7 Ator v f App lant t ne or el W m h Cou y DititAto ne sOo c s oe nt src tr y' e l I 20 M er chantLa Fi , LTD. w nn I ! ! aj l N.Ari on Ave. Suie290 00 lngt , t Reno, N V 89501 PO BOX 30083 i ! 22 7 - 744 7533 00 Re , 8 2 no NV 95 0 1 23 7 - 3,5, 75 3 / / . 5, I I 2 4 I 2 5 j 2 6 i i l i I l ! ' lSout SiraSt,7 foor h er . l ' . ' . . ' . 27 28 . . 1 1 j At or t ne f R e ondent or s ' ' 55 ; Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 55 of 85 ! i : i I ! . T l LE OF CON TEN TS . 2 E -11l)(f?kll(lt(s.................-..........................-.........1 r 1 1)f )rùttlln 1r .................-.........................-.--....... -- i ! ; i i i . ! . 2 Jun-(iril1t Etttl (1t............................................................-.......................... 1 t 1 t1 1 S lt t: l ;l lA) ' .. .... .... ..--. 5 6 Ettk r( l (ttl:(fs)...........-..................-......................1 ;ltl p) t )-l( 2t(...................................................-. f r 7 ' 8 i ! I ! ! . 1 0 A 11 A. e dlt cour er e l r l t tM a ew dl notpl ad good caus t exc l s nct t r d n ulng ha d e e o ts .. hi pr dur de aul f fl g hi pos s oce al f t or lm ' s tconvi i pe ll abouthvœ m ont l e cton tton hs at 12 : ! 1 3 ! , 1 4 1 5 : 1 ' ; : i ' j . v wh nM ate pr pel pldg dc us f ted lyun r e th w o ry e oo a e or h ea de S3 7 4)o t 4.26 1 n he f ce ofhI oetton afd sur l ent pe ll l t he r as a s ll l m em al tton n hat e onabl beleved h1 couns v l s e * ** ' * œ ' . had fl d an appealon hi be fand M a t le s hal thew di i f tfl hi ha l c puspe ii d n ac le s ber or q tto 1 6 . : w lhm a r as bl tm e a l r ng t thl couns had notfld a dle a t e ona e l Rer ea nl ha s el le r ct ppeal.. .. 5 1 7 B. . nct e dl t. cour ered m dlm.. s.'g M athe yscl l t hl tl cot el s t r . . l m s s t w a. hat . ral ms m s . j2 Cavetsd csont pu s as l-efns teoyoft c K f lb o a o jci l r' e ii o rue efd e e h r he ne el elw n b e tve s dadofrm o blnesta p eudie M at w m vi ai o hi n toe lci r e s na e s h t rj c d the ' olton f s ' t fk tv 1 9 20 . b b l as l c cot elunde t f de alcons . uton,s5t ,6t,8tla 1 t a e s. s e ms r he e r tt . l l nd 4 h m n 2l ent .. s. . 9 ' i l 2 2 C. Ma e stil ou e Cavetsfiu et n kf aj w' ra c ns l l r' alr o K or inrci o whe n tu ton n n i 23 M athe f t w onned t r st m t t c m l t aleged r he equl le ent o om t he l obbe y oftl vl tm f l r le c l el 2 4 beow a o j ciesa ado ra o a e e st tprj ie Ma e m vilto of l n be tv tnd r f e s n bln s ha eudc d w ' oain 25 . . . hl n tt efkctve a si cecouns unde t f r cons . uton.s5t ,6t,8tlnnd s o l l s. s el r he ede al tt . ) h b l l l ! j41 1 ! i ; ! ' 27 ' 11 !1 D. M al e hm ava i a a d p ' to ca' u e Ne daRulsofAppelt th w s ld ppe l e nvai n lt nd r va m e lae lrltlrll( tl hr1titl)sl zl) l 1())......................1; àtrtltz ; lt &t1 ltklltrl ,!)6..... ................ t tlt ( ) lt l l ft; t r ( .. ... . . . . . . . . . 1 1 ' . ' ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 56 of 85 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 TABLE OF AUTHORI ES TI 1 ; i 2 4 4 i ! i ! 1 ' 3 Filed 05/12/11 Page 57 of 85 a E s . Br owni v. st e, Nev. w nc at .. 4 5 6 ' 1 8p.d60 7 (œ 8 . 3 ,0 2 ) 8 ' crwf dv Ra e 1 lNe . 6 7 0 l 1P 3 5 , 8 ( 00 ) a or . t . 2 v 74 , 5 , 2 . d 82 5 6 2 5 1 5 Ga cav sa e 1 Ne . 7 3 4, 1 P3d8 684 ( 0 5 ri . t t . 21 v 32 , 3 1 3 . 3 0 2 0 ) . 1 - -z Har ovev. t e.100 Nev 498,502,686 P. 222,22 ( gr S at . 2d 5 1984) 9 7 8 Ha h wa v S a e 1 9 Ne . 4 ,7 . . d5 3 (00 ) t a y . t t . 1 v 2 8 1P 3 0 2 3 - ,6 7 3 ,, : ' K i v L Ra ,1 9 Ne . 72 3 4 7 P3 3 7 3 9( 0 3) ef . o n 1 v 3 , 7 , 5 .d 5 , 5 2 0 e ' L v a dv H t h r 2 F3 64 , 4 ( t C r 2 0 ) ' o eln . a c e . 31 .d 0 64 9s i. 0 0 l 0 . Ma z nv wa d n 1 2 N . 3 , 42 92 p2 9 0 9 ( 9 6 z a . r e - l ev 8 8 8 , 1 .d 2 , 22 1 9 ) l l1 Mc ennav. tt .11 Nev.1 4 1 s2- 8p.d739,74s(998) x sa e 4 c4 , 0 96 2 1 o . i i i i I ' I ' l ' l a 1 R s sv S a e 1 Ne . 2 8 1 P3d 1 0 , 1 8 ( 0 6 o a . t t . 22 v 1 5 , 47 . 1 1 1 0 2 0 ) 1 3 1 4 1 S h dv Ar o a 5 U.. 2 (9 ) c a . i n . 01 S 5 4 1 91 z 1 Sr ka dvWahn t . 6 U..668 687-88(984) ti ln . sizon 4 j S , 6 1 c ' . 1 5 - i : 1 I i Vad zv Rae Ne . , 1 6P.d4 , 6(* 8 le . t . v -. 9 ) 65 47 2 ) = 1 7 18 . NR 2 .3 4b) 5 œ 00( 1 NRS2* . 0 08 1 . 1 9 20 NRs g4,s7 1 5( ) 21 NR M . 61 S 72 () 22 E 23 ! 1 . S AU E TT TS ! ! i ! i ! I ---- 1 6 , 8 , . . 24 NI 4b I () AP 25 NR 4c AP () . 26 , ,,s1 s1 .8 . I 27 28 . . : I . i v . I I I sg ' j k Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 58 of 85 j J SDI ONAL STATEM ENT URI CTI n i i an a ss ppealfom adeni ofa pos r al tconvi ton petton. n e dit itcour ci ii s rc t 2 cl k s vednotc ofenty oft diti c tsor on M ar 24, 201 v2J 45c. er er ie r he srct our, der ch A I 0. 3 4 A notce ofappealw a tm el tl on A prl6,2010. V2 J 457. Thi Cour ha i s i y ied i A s t s 5 urs c i puruantt x' iditon s o l t j xp4( a x's3 s ( ) b) nd R 4.75 l. . 6 i 7 i S ; 9 1 D i t diti tcour er i r i t tM athew di notpl ad good caus t e . d he s rc t r n ulng ha t d e e o xcus e 1 0 hi pr s ocedur def tf tlng hi posal aul or ii s tconvi ton petton aboutt m ont I e ci ii wohs at 1 1 whe M at e pr pe l pld g od c us f t dea und rNRS 34.26 1 o t n th w o ry e o a e or he ly e 7 4) n h 1 2 f ce ofM spe ii a s e ent petton i t he r ms a tton nd uppl m al ii n hat e onabl beleved hi y i s 1 3 c u s l a flda a p a o hsb h la dMate ddi fc tl hsh b a o ne h d i n p e l n i e af n t w i n a tie i a e s e h c ru p tinwi i arao a l t a e lann ta hsc t e h dn t op s eio t n e sn be i R re rig h t i omsl a o t h me tldadrc a a? ie ie t ppe l . i i k STATEM ENT OF TH E I SSUES . I 1 4 1 I l 5 1 6 2. Di t dititc ur eri dimisngM at w' cai t thi tilc un e d he src o t r n s si the s l m ha s ra o s l i i 1 7 Cal er' dec son t pul as fdef e t or oftl ca e f lbel an v ts i i o sue el- ens he y le s el ow : i 1 8 o j ci sa d r ofra on be s +a prj ie M at w i viluo ofhs be tve tn ad e s a lne s t eudc d the n oa n i 1 9 rghtt e l i a sit nce c m s unde t f dm' c tt i s 5t 6t 8t1 i o fkctve s s a ot el r he e al ons iuton h, h, 1 , . . 20 and 1 h am endm ent ? 4t s , , j y 21 3. Di M at w stil ou e Cavetsfiur t a kfraj r jt knonwhe d the ra c ns l l r al e o s o u y snxto n 22 M athe f m e t r st i e t cor i t aleged r t w or d he equi ie nt nt o nm t he l obbe y oft vitm r he c i i 23 flbeo a o jci sa adofra o bln s ta prj ie M ate i el lw n be tve tnd r e s na e e s h t eudc d th w n ' j I 1 24 vi aton ofhi rghtt efec i as sance c ol i si o tve sit ouns undert f r el he ede al 25 consiuton s 5t 6t 8t1and 1 h am endm ent ? tt i h, h, . 1 4t s ' I i ) . ! g j a 6 2 7 28 4. D oesM a t w ha ava i a alde i i cl m underN e the ve ld ppe pr vaton ai vadaRul of es Apltrer4)a etteeJy 2009? peaPcu (tt nioFcu 1 l odechw n tl e j . , I : j V sandsf Voll e and J s a f J ntAppe x. t or tm A t nds or oi ndi . V ' g) i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 5 Filed 05/12/11 Page 59 of 85 ! i I l . ! 1 . a S TXTEM E TOF' E CASE N I TI 1 . - ! . ' 3 Thi i an a ss ppealf om a de alora pos r ni tconvi ton petton n e dit itc t ci ii s rc our . c nvitdtepeiine M ate J me Tj l it at e pus n t uyvedc of o ce h tto r th w a s ewetM th wl rua toj r r it i 4 i ! ! 5 fr td g e mu de wiht u eofafr a m onJ ne7 20 V2 J 3 6.M at w wa is e r e r r t he s le r u , 08. A 8 the s - 6 i ! s enc t lf wih t pos i lt ofpar eaRe zo- r wih a equalc ecutve ent ed o ie t he sbiiy ol r yea s t n ons i 7 i i , i 8 .r frueo at er L .Male st a c u slo nCav r( lettee ûe t m o s f i am. 4 t w r l o n e J h letCav r)h ra r e r h . ! g 9 fie t tl a a pe la p o sd.V2J 403 41 Mate te flda uni l ald o ie n p a s r mie A , 9. th w h n i n tmey e j i 1 0 I 1 l 1 2 7.v2J 38 39 M ate t ntldlpr r 2 00 A 8, 2. th w he ie ope ! 1 11 ' pr rnoieofa pe lo No mb r7 20 t tt sCo tds se o De e e 2 , ope tc p a n ve e , 07 ha hi ur imis d n c mb r 7 habeaspe ii on Augus 5 tton t , 2 08. 0 1 V 1 J 397. Couns w asa 3 A el ppoi e who fl a s em ent V 2 J 41 41 The St t nt d ied uppl . A 0, 3. ae I ' . 1 m oved t dimist petton, athe oppoj a t St er pledt t opposton. 4 o s s he ii M t w ed nd he at e i o he ii l 5 ) V 2 J 423,430,437. n e diti tcour t di m is t petton a pr A s rc t hen s s ed he ii s ocedur ly al ' . . 1 1 6 I 1 d ful wi utc nsdei t meisofM at w' cams V2J 4 .Noieof 7 ea t t ed ho o i rng he rt the s li . A 45 tc i l ! I l 1 e e ofor rwa s re o M ac 2 201 v2J 4 0.Thi tmeya pe f iowe 8 nt de s e v d n rh 4, 0. A 5 s i l p al ol d. 1 9 V2J 457. A ' ' ' 1 : x I i I I i i i 21 . 22 STATEM ENT OF TII FACTS 'E M at waschar by i cmentwih mtr rwih t us ofafr thew ged ndit t lde t he e ieann on 23 I I ! 2 5 5 Du i till stt p od e svespaaewi se ,a1ofwho r c ntdt te . rng ra iw ae r uc d e rt mes s 1 m e ou e o h 26 i . ' , . 24 Dec ber7,2005. V 1 J 1.A tor Cal r r pr ent d M a t em A t ney ve t e es e thew durng t i . V 1J i ral A j r ta M at a te t s o i t vitm a rt vitm t e tne t c o hs uy h t tl dmltd o h otng l ci ae hi ci hrae d o h p i ww w I 27 ! I 28 s u i oltl pic sa mal m t Mat w. J 7879 85.As e Re dy on p nt ite e e nd ihl o the V1 A - , ( hle e , i I ! j l l . ' gg q i . ' ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ! ! Filed 05/12/11 Page 60 of 85 . i . ! i . ! ! I findo Mat w)V1J 1 0,11 11 ta o Hol r findofMat w) V1J 1 re f the , A 1 2, 4 l s n de, re the , A 92- ! i ! 2 1 93 i 3 j 4 j 1 5 M ate , n V1J 2l 21 - l , Br a Ca raf rye a e t M ate a th w) a d A 4, 6 2 8 ( e nne mb a onnel ng g d o th w nd , ! t 1 6- 97. Kr s Ga i f me Iv -n gilre d w ih M athew and had son 9 1 ( y ol r, or r i e i rfin t tgehe) V1J 20820 t it Ga s a qu i a ea onfin ytr wi o t r, A - 9.Krsa ddi, c antnc nd re dl ems t h , . I 1 6 sil asr e igso rM a e .z s Hol r a rindotM a e tsi d i t emos tl h e ln a w) a on de , re ' - uh w, e tse n h t i l 7 bl ttr , st i t tM athew t d hi t the 'r un ems atng ha t ol m ha tucked up' a ts ppçd' and t t ' nd tna ' hat he I l 8 ! 1 9 ! vi i wasdea . ctm d le hi f end Jas Hol r w ho w asw i l d s ri on de , t vlJ l 4.Mate frtc A 1 th w is a I ! 1 hi gilrend A s e Reedy, a r h ki i As e Re dyi t l pik du t p ne 0 s rf i hl e ae te lng. hle e 'nii l c e p he ho l ay I ll I l 2 l I ! i t e rymor n ho si dit yaae t kli a n tdMat w' pa c e , n he al nig ur mme ael r he il nd oe the s nik d ng srse ou nev sa sae voie V1J 818 n ejtt ms dAh leRe d t te s d- t r ou nd c rd c . A - 2. ae ke se e y,o 1 3 1 wh M at e c i d i me ae ya trt kilng: Q: S i w& i r s s t t t 4 om th w onfde m ditl fe he li R o t s n e pon e o ha I . ' 1 s e e by lh vitm)a ou t ed e ntsc l e a cu tn t e i t p e e a 5 ut m nt t e c i b t h efnda ' hidr n nd ti g h m n o ic s nd I E ! 1 6 1 I I i 1 7 , ae r 1 vi i i t hea As e a s r d q : Co r c . V 1J 88.n e st t neve 8 ctm n he d hle n we e & A re t , A . I I ! s ng t t hi ,accor ng t t def endi hem o m di o he endant t tcaus M m t r tand s ha ed o eac hoott he . 1 atem pt i t rcas i chi t i peac any w ii s t pr ent d M at w asha ng 9 t ed n hei e-n- ef o m h tw s hat es e the vi 20 onl s t vi tm i r cton t t vi i ' t ea agai tM athe ' s y hot he c i n ea i o he ctm s hr t ns t w s on. I t ad,tz ns e le I 21 1 n saefc sdo so n te uyta M ate i fc ddkltevci i ra t nt a tt o u e n h wig h j r h t tlw n at i i h itm n eci o l l o 1 I 23 t r a a hltM at e ss a pr s n e wi s e c nsse twiht tt or Se h e t ga s th w' on nd e e t d me s s o itn t ba he y. e ! I i I i 24 Re r lv. J 8 2 ,V2J 2 - 9.M at w as tsi da di no d nykilng neal V1 A - 29 A 3026 the lo etfe nd d t e li 25 he ctm 26 t vi i V2 J 237. M athew a s neve diput d t the w asi pos es i oft A t lo r s e ha n s s on he . . . i ; i ' A 2 27 vi i , pos es i s h ashi c a t vi i . de t . v2 J 24 . ctm s s s ons uc s ar Rer he ctm s ah 28 ! i 1 l I 2 ; ' . #' . / . - Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 61 of 85 ' j ' W h ns tlngj yisrci s tepr e btrs bmitdaflnymude j r e eti ur n tu ton , h os c o u te eo r r uy 2 i t uc i t f l t defne a t ns r ton hat aied o i tempt d r e obber asale i t St e' i ct ent y lged n he at s ndi m . ' q v2 J 35 M at e st al t r e Ca v r di n o j c t a j r i sr to sa d A 8. th w' l at n y le t d ot be to ny uy n tucin n i o 4 ' di n to j c s ct l t t fln mur r uyi t cin.V2J 27 - 77. sld o b et pe i l o he eo . ka y y de j r nsnlto A 6 2 A ef 5 6 dee ej l i tu to wa as s bmi e t t uydepiet lc ofa ye d nc fns uy nsrcin s lo u t d o hej r s t he a k n vie e. l 7 V2 J 367A 368 8 . M at w wa c n ce p a t u yvedit frtde e mtde wihte the s o vitd uru ntoj r r c of ts- gre l r t h r 9 , 1 us ofa tr ar on J 7,2007.V2 J 38 M athe ' ti ator y Cal r agr t 0 e ie m une A 6. t w s lal t ne ve t eed o . d . t t ed . bl o act s ll tl M a t , a albutdi not M athew atem pt butw msuna et cont hi ie thew s ppe ' ' , 2 to e t ou c le tc lsa d lte ss n e ig.V2 J 403 41 M at w t e tl tm y hr gh o l c al n etr e tncn A , 9. the h n ie a 1 3 1 4 . an untm el ore notce ofa alt t s Cour di m ise on D e m be 27,2007. i ypr r i ppe hat hi t s s d ce r . 1 V2 J 38S 392 5 A ! ' 1 6 . ;t w hen ied . M athe t fl a habe petton on A ugus 5,2008,abouthvoas ii t . . . mont patt tmeyo -e rde dlnec ui di NRS3 7 64 ) n eCo t hs s l i l ney a a i on ne n w 4.2 1 . ur 1 a nt counsel who argued i a suppl entt tM athew had pl good causet 7 ppoi ed , n em ha t ed o 1 8 1 over ehi pr edtr de a ti c 9 com s oc zal f ul n ompla w ih Hat i nce t hawav v.Sàt 11 N ev.248,71 e. 9 2: b d upon an appe de i ton c ai . v2 j 41 41 M a t al prva i l m x 0, 9. thew P. 5 ( p , a e 3d 03 20 3) s 21 lo r e ha ra c uns Cavet s n fe tv n eu ca or r ig s a e n as agu dt ttil o el l r wa ie fciea dprj diilf agun hi c s ' . 23 a sl-ee ea o pos dt vol ayma lughe,orfii t rqu s aj r s efd fns s p e o t r nsa tr f al o e e t uy mt ng . ns r ton t w or he nt nt o ob he tm m l or 24 i t uc i on when M athe f m ed t i e t r t W c i and f aly,f 25 una ul de rv ngM a t w o ad r c a a pu s n t lwf ly p ii the f 'ie t ppe l rua t o 4() V2J 41 c. A 3 2 6 27 422. The St e fl amotont dimiswihM athe opposmg.TheStt r pled.V2 at ied i o s s t t w i ae e i . 1 A 437. 'he dit ctcour t n dim is ' t petton aspr edu aly bar ed I sri t he s s ed he ii oc r l r 28 J 423:430, 3 . .yg , , . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 62 of 85 I i . ' a di notcons derany ofM athew' cl m s on t m e is.Thi tm el appeal nd d i t s ai he rt si y I 1 i 2 f lwe V2 JA 457. olo d I ! ! i j . 3 4 S 5 6 Y OFTl ARGUMENT v n e dit i c ter ed i dim isi M a t s rct our r n s s ng thew' petton a pr s ii s ocedur l def uled aly a t b c us h tldhi p ttona o t monh It Mat w pldavai a pe l e a e e ie s eii b ut wo- ts ae. the e ld p a 7 8 deprvaton cl m i complanc w ih Hat a v.Sàt 11 N ev.248,71P. 503 i i ai n i e t haw v e. 9 3d 9 ( 03 t e c ehsprc dua d fulalgi t thi atr ya e b tfie t tl 20 ) o x us i o e rl ea t le ng ha s tone pe d u ald o ie 1 0 a diec appeal V2 J 403,41 M athe t tl a habea petton aboutt m ont r t . A 9. t w hen ied à ii wohs 11 l lt ,frs ne t a t pe ii n ri Haha v, o tld hi pe ii o ray a pa tt 2 ae a oo r h n he tto e n i wa wh ie s tton ve e r s he 13 de i f tlngatmel haber petton.'' diti c tlkewieeredi f lngt adlne or ii i y ii Ihe slct our i s r n aii o 1 4 l5 ' c sd rM at w p tto ontemeis whihal ge j v r te re ofprj diil on ie the eiin h rt, c l d e ealh o is eu ca e ' i j 1 iefe tv a ssa eofc ns l n av ld a pe ld prv to ' l i u e NRAP 4( ) 6 n f ci e s itnc ou e a d a i p a e i a in c am nd r c. ' 17 M atàew ' ti at ne Cal twasi f i f purui as fdef et . oft t s ral tùr y ver nefectve or s ng el- ens heor y he ; 18 cas whe he s d have pur ue a vol a y m ans aught rt y.A tti , he Sht e n houl s d unt r l e heor ral t e ' '( 1J E I '' *'' # 20 p o c d tvewi s e whot sii d t tM at w i sv l s ot hevjtm i r du e i me s s e tte ha the mpuli ey h t ci n . . 21 r a to t hi tra t c opu Mat w' s it ltl pic sa mal ss nt hi e cin o s h e t o h p t s on no ite e e nd ihi o o m. ie I I I I ! I 22 V 1J 78- 79 8 ( hleRe d fin o M ate , J A , 5.As e e y,re d f th w) V1 A 23 11 ,1 2,11 ta on 0 1 4 ls Hole ,find o M at w) V 1J 1 2- 93 1 6- 9 ( ysa Ga i f me l -n d r re f the , A 9 1 , 9 1 7. Kr t l r, or r i i ve 24 2j gilre wihMat w a ha s ntgeh r, J 20 2 ( it Ga di, rfind t the nd d o o te )Vl A 8-09.Krsa d s 26 a nu i an ea do fin vtr wi M at w) a dV1J 21 21 21 ( e nn c ant c n n re dl ems t the , n h A 4, 6- 8,Bra e > ' ' ' ' ' ' 27 Ca r f r rye a dt M ate a silha feigsf M at w) M at w as mb w omel ng ge o th w nd tl s e ln or the . the lo 28 4 : i ! . #J y 1 i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 4 ' i l 3 5 a ns hi s gai t s on un rNRAP4() algigta t pr s c trfie i s mi ap o rfl ymu d r de c, le n h the o e uo ald o ub t rpe eon r e i tuc i compl t y om it t detnii ofa t m pt r nsr ton, e el ted he i ton te ed obbe y f om t f ony r r he el 1 mtd risrcina dtee yc rmie po euoilo d c o ac n tuin l 0 z e n tu t n h rb on t d rsc tra c n u t f o si t a r o t to 1 di nsi V2J 41 n eerone usfl ymur rj r isrctonwaspli erora 1 me on. A 8. r o eon de u y n tu i an r nd 1 2 I 3 . 1 4 i 1 1 . . M athew r t eques sr s a r and w ih t ,dit itcourtorder t conduct t ever al nd em t he s rc . ed o ' . 15 evi i r hearng on hi habeœspetton. denta y i s ii ) 1 6 1 7 A RGUM ENT 1 8 19 A . ITI DI E STRI COURT EI CT X D I RI LI G THAT M AT T EW Dm N OT N J N TI PLEAD GO OD CAU SE TO EXCU SE I I PRO CEDU RAL DEFA ULT FO R IS - 20 21 22 23 24 FW I I I PO ST. NG I S CON V I ON PETI ON ABOW TW O- ONTH S LA TE CTI TI M W II M AT I EW PROPERLY PLED GO OD CAU SE FOR TI E D ELAY 'EN TI 1 UN DER N RS 34. 726(1 ON 'TI FA CE OF H I PETI ON A r ) I E S TI SI JPPLENI TM PETI ON I TI T l E REA SONA BLY BELI EN TI N M 1 EVED H I S COUNSEL HAD FI LED AN APPEAL ON H I BEHALF AND M ATFIEW S I Dm I FACT FI I I R ABEAS CORPUS PETI ON W I N A N LE IS TI THI REASONABLE 'I E AFTER LEARNT THAT I I COUNSEL HAD NOT 1M ' NG IS FI LED A DI RECT APPEAL . 25 26 1 1 . wœsnothannl sbeyond ar ona edoubt es eas bl . i i ! V2J 2 7 Lmt , t e rie av l a p a d piaincam A 3 . sl Mat w asd ai p e l e rk t li y h d o 9 i j . 8 I 2 i ts ii t hes t vi i nott r butonl i r actont t vi i ' t eat e tted hat hot he ctm, o ob, y n e i o he ctm s hr 7 i ! M athe adm it t bei i pos es on oft vi i , pos es onsaherhi m ur rbut t w ted o ng n s si he ctm s s si s de 6 ! i . 4 ' l I i d li he ctm t tsed and di notdeny kilng t vi i v2 J 237. cal r wasIke ie es i A ve t i ws 2 i fe tv l prj dii f fiigt rq s a isr cino a rhou ht o bey. nef ciey eu calor al o e uet n n tu to n ûet g r b r n I I Filed 05/12/11 Page 63 of. . 85 EA di ti tcour' r di off tar entte t def ence and wilnotbe t s rc ts m ngs ac e il d o er l 27 e. 28 di u bed on appeali t y ar s st r f he e uppored by s t i e de , Br wn nav. sot t ubsantal vi nce., o i ' - . ' 5 . . #Y Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 j Filed 05/12/11 Page 64 of 85 ! ' I E i i N ev. l ' 1 P. 6 70( 08 .E-o ve ,hedititc ur' c cusonsoflw 88 3d 0, 20 ) tl we r t src o t on l i l s a -- - ' 7 . 2 aerviwe den o. Kef v. a ,lI Ne 37 37 7 P.d357 35 (00 . r e e d ov ,, ie Loa n 9 v. 2, 4, 5 3 , 9 2 3) 3 l Hah wa v. ae 1 9Ne 2 7lP. 5 ( 0 ) ti Co t d ptdte9h n ta v Stt. 1 v. 48, 3d 03 2 03 ,hs ur a o e h t 4 cic tt s i toy lnd v. th r 2 F.d 6 6 ( a ci. ct ),w l n t tr ui e t n - e a uac e . 31 3 40, 44 9 ' r 2 ) ) I di g ha ( a 5 . 6 pe ii ne c ne t b ih go c u e f rt d I y un tto r a sa ls od a s o he e a derxa s 34 72 1 i'w pe ne 6( ) fu uuo r . : 7 ' t ihe t t pettone r ona y beleved t c esabls s hat he ii r eas bl i hat ouns had tl an appe apd el ied al 1 8 t t oettonertl a habeascor s petton wihi a r ona e tm e afe l i hat he ii ied ou ii t n ea bl i t r eam ng 9 - - - l l t adiectappe hadnotbe tl ' Hat vs11 Ne at255,71P. a 508. 0 hat r al en ied ' bawa 9 k. 3d t I l 1 Mate p o el pe g o cu ei b t hsoiia a ds p jme tl eiin t w rp ry ld o d a s n oh i rgn l n u pe na j tt h o l 2 . us n i butt dit i c tdim i s d hi pe ii as f lng t pl good ca e i com plance he s rct our s s e s tton aii o ead I I ! . . . l3 . 1 wi Hah wa b c ueMate R e e s e ie wh nh atmpe t c nat i 4 t ta v e a s t w n v r p ct d e e te td o o tc hs h h i . 1 c ns l( l r) no whe a dho I at w)frtlane lsc ns lfie t fl 5 ou e Cavet, r n n w ' the ls e r d z ou e ald o ie M i l6 ' tnel adie ta pe . n edsrc c r we to t saeta Rwlt u kno e eof h y rc p al' ' itit ou t n n o tt h t t iho t wldg ' I 7 : i he o r a no tr ne 1 t si orm aton, t c u tc n tdeemi whehe ( at w')dea i tlnghi 8 hi nf t r M the s ly n ii s I ! i ' 1 Petton wasr ona e.'V2J 447.Thedititcour a 9 ii ems bl ' A src t ppear t ha hnpos d iso s o ve e t wn 20 sandar i de er i ng w he l rM a t t d n t m ni tw thew del y wasr as bl bas upon t pl f t a e ona e ed he ed ac s 21 za wihoutany r er e t t acualsa d.Lovel asado ed i Hat t ef enc o he t tndar andpt n haway.onl y 23 rq rst tM ate eobl hher ao a ybeive t thi c un e Cavet ul tl e uie ha th w s i s e n bl le d ha s o s l l r wo d ie 2 4 ! i ! a diec a r t ppealon hi be fand t tM a t w tl d a ha ascor pe ii w ihi a s hal ha the ie be pus tton t n . 25 26 rm on bl tmeatrla nngt tadie tJ a ha n tb e tld.Hah wa l1 e s a e i fe e r i ha rc ppe l d o e n ie ta v. 9 27 Ne a 255,71P. at508.I M athew' orgiz petton,M a t pl t the v. t 3d n t s i ial ii thew ed ha 28 rq etdCav ra p a hsc n it n Cav ra re t a p a hsc n ito b th n e u se let p e l i o vci . let ge d o p el i o vcin u te o y 6 ' I I . g; t 2 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 I 1 ! .' Filed 05/12/11 Page 65 of 85 i r tdi notappealhi convi ton. 2 J 403. I M a t ' s e ent lpetton, n ac d s ci A n thew s uppl m a ii 2 M at w pldta hstilc ns l vetu a ul de ie hi ofhi rg t the e h t i ra ou e Cal r nlwf l prv d m y s ihto 3 . diecty appealhi ver s rousfr tder e m ur w ih t us ofa fr ar convi i r l s y e i tse der t he e le m cton. I 4 : M athe pl t ti gr ed an evi ntar hearng,M athew w oul t tf r di hi t w ed ha f ant de i y i t d es iy egar ng s 5 6 a alde i i cl m as f l s Cal tt d M athew i m edi el afe s nt ng ppe prvaton ai olow : ver ol t m at y t r e enci i 1 i ! I t t thew oul appealhi convi ton. M athew t inm edit y aRe s enci was ha d s ci t hen r a el r ent ng 8 t et cont tCal r r di hi appe be mabl o ac ve t egar ng s al causehi al neydi notvii hi s tor d st m, 9 10 r pond t hi l t sora es o s eter ccepthi. sphone cals. V2 J 41 l A 9. ll l 2 , M a t t n di pl t the a t ed t cont thi couns t ough phone thew he d ead ha tempt o ac s el hr calsand l t s t tw entunans er n i diecty contadi st dit itcour ' . l etel ha w ed ts s r l r ct he s rc . 13 1 tndi r di a t ney/ i cont ctand t t diti c ts f di ar not 4 i ngs egar ng tor clent a hus he srct our ' m ngs e ) 15 suppore by s t i evi nc Re r pg t r onabl belefr r e of 't d ubs antal de e. ga di he eas e i equiem nt . 1 ' ! I I ' i . 1 6 H at hawav. athe di pl t the r ona y be i ve t thi Z aIcouns lCal t M t w d ead ha eas bl le d ha s e ver 17 1g di tl a diec appealbecauseCal tt d hi he w oul tl an a al Thi ofcour e d le r t ver ol m d ie ppe . s s 1 9 ZS UT S HCS t whe ar atom ey t l a cle he i goi t do s et ng, he i f wil hat n l t els i nt s ng o om hi n act l 2 0 I . . . . t ut uly do ashe s es. r hf l ut 2l 22 t w s ie s ii t n ea onabl e Bas d upon H a haw a . M athe alo fl d hi habeaspetton w ihi a r s e t v i 23 tm e aterl ni t thi t i c i t ear ng ha s ral ouns Cal tdi notfl a die appeal I H a hawav. el ver d ie r ct .n t ! 24 t pettonerH at w ay w asconvi ed pur uantt guit pl of,am ong ot cri es, he ii ha ct s o ly ea her m I ' 25 26 , on - o to frtd gremur e a s ntnc d t wh ta un e t lf wiht e c un f ls- e e d r nd e e e o a mo t d o ie t he 2 posblyo prl o Dee e 1, 9 8 OnNo e e 6 2 01HahFa Glda 7 siii f aoe n cmbr 119 . t v mbr , 0 , ta y e 28 pr rh b a peiin.Tlswasove t e z a rhij gme tofc nvito is d ope a e s tto z i r woy a. he s ud n o cin sue s I . 7 1 . ' xg Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 i . Filed 05/12/11 Page 66 of 85 : i a ov ro -e rp s tedea i t flng atm el ha spetton perxu s3 72 1. nd e ney a at h dlne br ii i y bea ii 4. 6( ) . l i . 2 I s t o Hah wa pedn g iyp ru n t g iype- a da apat a,e l t n pi f tg y la ig ul usa to ul la n s rci lrai i e t t c sc i 3 ma trn lkey t g ta y r le ondie ta a fo hi j dgme tofc viton a d te ot i l o e n eif rc ppe l r m s u n on ci - n 4 alo i s t off lng hi pr s n pie ii s operha spe ii overone- rpas t dea i f jjng bea tton yea t he dlne or ik i 5 6 atmey ha a p ttona c nt i d i Nls 3 72 ( ) t sCou t e i n d i l be s e ii s o ane n k 4. 6 1 ,hi r r n a de 1 Haha y' peiin f a e i nta y hea i . Hah wa l 9 Ne a 25 ,71P.d a r ng t a v, 1 t wa s tto or n v de ir v. t 3 3 t 8 505. M a t w i contas onl ûl bl operha aspetton aboutt m ont l e,ms the n r t y ed spr be ii wohs at i 9 1 M at w' j gme tofc n ci is e o J ne', 2007 and M gthew tl hi pr per 0 the s ud n o viton su d n u 7 t ied s o 11 habe petton on Augus 5, 2008. V 2 J 386,397.M at as ii t A thew w msal o convi ed s ct I l : I 1 2 . . purua t j r ve dit n tgu ly p e a i I l t r c ver le t r ug t c ams s nt o u y r c o it lw nd s i y o e ei ei f h o h he li ke 1 3 1 r s i hi s 4 ai ed n s uppl m ent ha s c puspe ii e al bea or tton. 1 5 . . IcnlsnteaaoHa aaae e yietàtMate sae I nocui ,)fc f t wvrnll dnilo t w'cs.n ol ' h c h 1 1 Hahwa t pettoneraleged t he request hi ator y tl an appeal t 6 ta v he ii l hat ed s t ne ie , he i , l 7 pettone ' a t ey act tve y i cat t he woul tl a a ii r s tom nna i l ndi ed hat d i e n ppeal he be i ved t t , le ha 1 8 . . 19 li atom e had tl an appealon hi behal' t he t l hi ha 1 t y ied s fand hat ied s beaspe ii wihi a tton t n S 20 r onabl tm e aRerl r . t thi a t ne had nottl an a eas ei ea nl ha s tor y ng ied ppeal 0n t s f t , . he e ac s I 21 .ft ever ed aa t N evada Supr e Cotr r s and r anded H at he em em hawa spetton f an y' ii or . 23 e dentar hearng on whe herH a ha a es ihe good caus t exc e hi vi i y i t t w y lbls d e o us s ! . 2 pr dur de a tbecats t epl d f c s i t ue,woul excus hi pr 4 oce al f ul le hes e a t , f r d e s ocedt def t mal aul. ! ' I l 25 26 Hah wa l1 Ne a 25 - , P.da 5 08.I Mat w' c e Mat w di ta v 9 v. t 4 53 71 3 t 0$5 n the s as, the d . 27 pla fcsa lgo t te ea dic se a ve Co e e ty M ate i e ildt e d a t nao us o h s s j u s d bo . nsqu nl, th w s ntte o 28 a e ie ir he rn o wh te hi alge pr e r dea ti e u e un rNRS n vd ntay aig n eh r s le d oc dual ful s xc s d de ' 8 ' + gt 7 e . . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 ' Filed 05/12/11 Page 67 of 85 ( ! . 1 3 7 ( ) M o e v r M ate woudas beu ul prj die be a eM at w rie 4.26 1. r o e , th w l lo nd y eu c d c us t he as d i E I d I : ! ' 2 t, t l ng pos le blowi tconvi i cl m ss outbel t woul entte M athew t r i cton ai et ow hat d il t o elef 3 f om hi flstdegr m ur convi i A l oft e cl m sw er properl r sed i t r s r - ee der cton. l hes ai e y ai n he 4 5 dititc tbutt dititcour de i t consdert be src our he src t clned o i hem causet diti cour he srct t 6 i r cty f ncor e l ound M athew ' ha aspetton t be pr dur l de aule V2 J 413, t s be ii o oce aly f t d. A 7 445 . 8 9 l i ! i i d i 1 1 j j ' B THE DI STRI COURT ERRED I DI I SI M ATI EW ' CLAI CT N SM S NG TI S M 1 0 TH AT H I TRIAL COUN SEL CALVERT' DECI ON TO PUR SU E A SELFS S SI DEFEN SE TH EORY oy 'i cA ss FELI BElo w Ax oBm c'l E rm - rv 11 s'AxoN t oFREAsoxu t r o lxEssTHATPREJ CED M A''l w I UDI rru N l 2 vl lA ' ox oF Hls RI o - fl GHT TO EFFEc' vs A ssl ru cE cotm sEl rl se UNDER TIE FEDERAL CONSTI 1 TUTI , 5:. 6-' 81 AN D 14T ON S -1 nI 1 . H H 13 w sxov sxvs. 1 4 . . l ' 1 . To Saeacam f rle bae u oni fe tv m ssa c ofc t e rqurs tt li or eif s d p nefcie sitn e 6ms l e ie i 1 5 1 botzdetci per onnance andprj die St i and v.W as nzt 466 U . 668,6876 l i ent f eu c rckl hi om S. . 17 1 6 8(9 4 .80ho mp n n mut eso a da is mce t h wigo ete 8 8 18 ) t o o e e sb h wn n n nu in s o n n i r h elet r c and. 1 pr pr l desr i - sti kl 466 U . at697.A pe ii ri onl entted t a 9 ong ec u s. ttone s y il o n . 20 evi i y hea i on cl m ss dentar rng ai uppore by s t f ct notbeled by t r cor whi td peciu a s i he e da ch 21 22 i t ue,woul e il t pe ii fr d ntte he ttonert r i . Har ove v.Smt 100 Nev.498.502,686 o elef r e. a3 P. 22 225( 98 . ' 2d 2, 1 4) 24 ' scl m wa pr ry pl d i t s em enti t di ti c t V2 J 41 rhi ai y ope l e n he uppl n he s rct our A 3. 25 41 6 26 a7 . M a t ' t i couns s d nothavepur ued a s f def et y t thew s ral el houl s el- ens heor hat 28 s uggesedM a t waspr ectng hi c l agai ta uns t i e t eatt t t thew ot i s hid ns n ubsantatd hr hat he ' p . ' . : y l Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 j Filed 05/12/11 Page 68 of 85 ' ! , . es lt o f m t he i he c i t r d he hr at ns e 1 vitm had no pr entabiiy t per or a t tm e t vi tm ute e t t e .l t ad, ci : i 2 ti couns s d ha pur ue a vol ar m ans a ert y t w oul have r ul r al el houl ve s d unt y l ught heor hat d es t 3 i M athe bei acquit d offr - gr m ur a convi e ofvol a y n t w ng te istde ee der nd ct d unt r 4 d I ! I 5 6 beo a o j c i sa a d ofr a o blne st tprj c d M at e l ta Cale t lw n b e tve tnd r e s na e s ha eudie th w. nse d, v r ' 7 shoul have pur ued avol ar m a l d s unt y nsaught t y oft ca e c aj ts i f ec i er heor he s ver' ne f tve . 8 . 1 i tu tont t uyprj c dMét w.' frCav rN ie fcie s i p s n a 0 nsr ci o hej r eudie the - o le ts n fe tv nes n uruig But 11 1 I 1 2 : . sel- ens t y oft cas al w ih t i c un e pr di as l- f n ej r f def e heor he e ong t ral o s l ovi ng e fde e s u y 9 i 1 m ans aught r Cal tsper onnance i pur ng a s l- ens t y ojtj ca e j l e . ver, f n sui e f def e heor rje s aj . . s l- f n et o yoft c s ta prj die Mal e hewo dha b ç a qute of efdee s he r he a e h t eu c d th w, ul ve e n c itd fr - ee m ur rand i t d w oul have been convit ofvol ar m ansl lstdegr de ns ea d c ed unt y aught r e. 1 3 1 Theprj c t ti rdt M at w i s sa tal Fis d gremur rc risa 4 eudie ha nue o the s ub tni . lt e e ' de are 15 m a m um penaly oflf w ihoutt pos i lt ofpar b w her vol ar xi t ie t he sbiiy ol eas unt y 1 ma l 6 ns aught rcar i a m axi um penaly of10 ye sw ih m i m um pa ol elgi lt of e res m t ar t ni r e i biiy 1 7 . 1 8 1 e r Se NRS20 03 409, a e 0. 0 NRS2 08 00. 0. y . ' i 1 9 i . 20 c d be beca eM athe adm it kilng t vi i t tve s par e i vi s aI of oul ms t w ted li he ctm o i e at ndi dual , l 21 n w hom w er M at ' f endsoracqua nt esand al ofwhom w e e c l durng t e thew s ri i anc l r aled i he ! 1 I ! : : i n e st e' cas t M athew kil t vi tm wasaboutasai i asa c e at s e hat t led he c i rtght as 23 Sxt' c s -n c e .V1J 7879. 5.As e Re d findofM at w)V1J 1 0, t es a ei-hif a A - 8 ( hle e y, re the , A 1 ' '' 24 1l ,1 4ta o Hol r fin ofM ate ,V1J 1 2- 9 1 1 7.Krs Ga t 2 1 l s n de, re d th w) A 9 1 3, 96- 9 ( y tl r 25 ' f me Ivei giIre dwihM ate a dh ds ntg'te) VlJ 20820 ( it or r i n rfin t th w n a o o eh r, A - 9.Krsa - ' 1 26 . 27 G a s a qu nan ean o findy t r wihM a t w) a dV1J 21 21 - 8 ddi c ait c d n re l e ms t the , n A 4, 621 , , 28 1 0 I . 19 . ? ! ' 1 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 69 of 85 : ! : I ! i i I ! i I ! I ; l ! : i i l ( e nn ca rafr rye ga dt M at w a dsil sfei sfrM at w) Bra e mb a o mel n ge o the n tlha e lng o the . 2 Mate as tsiida ddi no de kil tevitm.V2J 2 . th w lo e tfe n d t ny li h ci ng A 37 . 3 n es eq sinf t j r wa whehe tekiln s oul b pu s e a frt ol ueto or he u y s t r h l g h d e nih d s isi 4 5 de e mu de o ma sa ghe a s l- fn ewa fcu lyi osil. ej r gre r r r n lu tr s efdee s s a tal mp sbe n uy 6 how e neverw asf ed wih s a di om ousde son. I t ad,M a t ' ti l ver ac t uch chot ci i ns e thew s r a 7 c ns l ru das l fn et oyoft c s t t nylwye o j ci l Iokiga ou e pu s e epdee s he r he a e ha a a r b e tvey o n t 8 9 1 0 tefcsofti c s s oul h v kn wnwoul c vi en rton l uo t a q t h a t hs a e h d a e o d on nc o ai a j rr o c ui . M athe . t w 11 . ' Mat w tsiida a te t s o igt vitm i teh a a rh the etfe nd dmitd o ho tn he ci n h e d Re e I 2 13 t r a e dt c u hi s a d s n hi s nt hi i pic s l M at e r o wo ds h e tne o ut p s on n e d s o o m n e e . n th w s wn r , j he ts 4 çnapped' a ti m edi el 's hi e s whie fi nd i t f ' nd tm at y' hot s r t l re n he ace. V 2 J 237. Rat A he ' . . ) 1 t r 5 h= ebutt cont i ofvol ar m ans a er t st e' cas i c eff ts on he enton unt y l ught , he at s e-n- hi oc ked 1 6 . cali w i es e t whom M athe adm it kilng t vi i i m edi el aRerhe lng m s s o t w ted li he ctm m at y 1 7 1g . t ea ene t cutup hi s As ey Reedy,a f ind ofM athe ' ,t tted t tM athe hr t d o s on. hl re t w s es ii ha t w 1 t I he t hehad s t vitm i t head i r pons t t vitm t e eni t cut 9 o d r hat hot he c i n he n es e o he c i hr at ng o ' 20 21 22 . up hi s i o pi s on nt eces. V 1J 87. J on H ol r a f end ofM a t w ,t s i i eve A as de , ri the e tsed n n m or bl t r s satng t M atl w t d hi t the u ucked up' and ts e unt e m , t i hat tw ol m ha f , tnappèd,. v l ' . a e ver te ed n hei e-n- ef o m ny m s hat 23 J 11 n e St t ne a t m pt i t rcms i chi t i peach a wi es t A 4 . 24 pr ent M at es ed thew msha ng onl s t vi i i r cton t hi t ea r gar ng vi y hot he ctm n ea i o s hr t e di 25 2 Mate ssn lse d teSaefc sdo so n tejr ta Mate i fc dd 6 t w' o . nta ,h tt o u e n h wig h uy h t t w n at i h h I 1 I I i 27 kilt vi tm The St e t ough isow n ca e-n- efl ope ie.cr at d a f ual l he c i at hr t s i chi eR n . e e act I 28 i . diput r r ng whe hert kilng waspr m edi t a delbe a e ort r ul ofa s e ega di t he li e u ed nd i r t he es t . ' I : ' 1 1 ; 1 t i E Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 70 of 85 ' j ' i 1 r h i pule whe e t voi ofr as and hum a t di noti er as m s r he ce e on. niy d nt vene. l s q i was n hor t . 2 t St t t c ea e t f t diput ofwhet rt vi i ' m ur s d be he a e hat r t d he ac ual s e he he ctm s der houl 3 punihe astr tde ee m ur orvol ar m ans aught r.Y e ,ti couns i e t s d i s - gr der unt y l e t ral el gnor d he i : 4 ! i ) . 5 we kn s ( rp r a i viai n)i t S ae sc s t a gu volntr a e s o e h ps n tto n he t t a e o r e u a y 6 m ansaught and i t d pul d a s f dekns t or s l er ns ea sue ell t e he y uppored by abs ut y no t ol el 7 evi dencea ti t lal . I 8 1 9 ! I Bu frra c u slsiefcie esi p run asl-ee s te r o tec s to til o ne' n fet n s n us ig efd fn e h oy fh ae v 1) suppore by no evi nce M athew woul have been ac ted ofrr tde ee m ur and ( td de , t d quit ls gr der . 11 , convitd ofvol ar mansl ce unt y aughtr l r a e anevi i y he i M athe sti e . f ntd dentar arng, t w lal 1 2 i I l 3 c n el le t dtsiya flows Cav r wo da mit th dhea tal ou s cav r woul e tf s ol : le t ul d tha a cu ly 1 dicus e and r ewed t f t oft scas w ih M athe ,and bms upon t sandar 4 s sd evi he ac s hi e t t w ed he t d 1 5 '. i ofw ha ar as t e onabl l w yerw oul do,hew oul ha de i t pur ue a s f def e ea d d ve clned o s el- ens 1 6 . . . ' t or oft c s b c u enorton lur woul ha fun t t at w a tdi s lhe y he a e e a s ai a j y d ve o d ha M the ce n ef : 1 7 : lg def e unde t e c r u t ens r hes ict us mwes cal twoul a i t tt tgsi t cl s i cas . ver d dm t ha hat l s he a s c e I ' i i 1 I i 1 ofa f t ldi put r r 9 ac ua s e eaa dhm whe hç t de e t r he f ndantcom m it d vol a y m ansaught r te unt r l e ' ' ' ! ' 24 ! prj c dM at w be a es l- ee ewa s p tdbynoe d nc b v l tr eudie the c us efd fns s u pore vie e, ut ouna y , m ansl aught rw ass e uppored by a pl e de t m e vi nce. 27 ! I . 25 26 I . 23 c s f l b l a o j c i sa da d o r a o a e s a d t th st e y o t c s a e el eow n b e tve t n r f e s n blne s n ha i h or f he a e 1 ! ' ' . ' 21 c ed l er i 22 m tr erand convi t ofm ansaught . Tralcounselwoul adm i t hi t y oft ld d t hat s heor he j i ' ' ' 20 and t tbutf hi i f tvenes ,M a t w oul ha been a ted off degr ha or s nef ec i s thew d ve cquit ust ee M athe woul t tf asf l t w d esiy olows:M athew ne a eedwih Cal tt pur uea t ver gr t ver o s 28 s l def ns t or oft ca e orany ot rt y f t m ater l f Caxe t v r ef e e he. y he s r ne e he heor or hat t . n act - 1 2 . . . z/ g Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 i j . Filed 05/12/11 Page 71 of 85 ' . ; . dicus ed hi ti sr egy wihhi cle .Had ti couns t oughl andpr l s s s ral tat t s int ral el hor y opery 1 ! . 2 dicus ed t i s r egy w ih M athe , M athew w oul t tf t hi s e f s s ral tat t t w t d esiy hat s ol ocusatti l ra . 3 woudbet c vic t l yt a uihm oftrtde emude a c vithi of l o on n e hejj o cq t i r is- re r r nd on c m 4 l 1 vou ayma sa htr lntr n lug e . 5 6 7 C M AT TH EW ' TRI COU NSEL CALVERT' FA I J TO A SK FO R A S AL S LI RE JURY I NSTRUCTI ON W HEN NI ON ATTIEW FORM ED THE REOII TE I J SI m '' f TO COM M I RTI ALLEGED RO BBERY OF TH E W CTI FELL lEv T E M 8 I BELOW AN OBJ ECTI STANDARD OF REASONABLENESS THAT VE 9 z ' I cEo m r rlE w I vl d ON s GH I x OLATI oy Hl RI T To EFFEC'M - 1 i 10 11 vu .u j . ) x u sxo u sx vs. 4vu 6 .8 AN D . : . ' l2 i i - ASSI STANCE COUNS UNDER R E FEDERAL CONSTI ON' 5 H EL TI TUTI S T . . Ba e u s d ponti e de epr uc d a til t e ewm as bsa ild s u ea t le vi nc od e t ra ,' r s u tnta ip t s o h 1 3 wh te Mate so tevitm b cu eo tevci shetoc t i s nu it lt eh r th w h th ci ea s fh it tra t u hs o p no il m' te 14 ' 15 pi cesordi s t r t vi i ofhi pos e i e d o o ob he ctm s s ssons. n i i i porantbec et St t ss m t aus he a e 1 prce de u atr aete re oftlt gremur ra alwe b lw;eon 6 o e d pon l n t h o is i' de e de s lo d y a fl y e s j 1 7 ! l8 1 occuni w ih m alce pr edi i a delbe a i V lJ 1 M athew ne r 9 ng t i , em hton nd i r ton. A . t ve I ' ; i I I j ' m u de wih r be yorat mptdr bey b n t eun ryig f o an mu de r r t ob r t e ob r ei g h de l n elny d r r e 20 dip e ta hewm i po s si o tevitm' po s sin s c a hi c ra rt s utd h t s n se son f b ci s se so s u h s s a Ae he 2 kilng. V2 JA 242. n e questi i whet rM atthew form ed t i entto rob before or 1 li on s he he nt 22 ag aRert kilng.J y i t uc i 21def e f ony m ur ri t cont xtoft St t s he li ur nsr ton m d el de n he e he a e' . 24 t y ofr heor obbe y V2 J 358. Tra couns lhoweve m ade no r r A il e r eques f an i t ucton t or nsr i . 25 t i t i e t com m i t r hat f he nt nt o t he obbe y oratem pt r r t ed obbe y oft vi tm w asf m ed r he c i or . ) . 2 aeteiigthen t Statehasnotproven thatM att w isguily offel m urder 6 h ln he 27 Rr kl he t ony 1 , . . I 28 be yond a r onabl doubtbec e t r st i e t c m i r ems e aus he equi ie nt nt o om t obber wmsnotpr en y es 1 3 I I ' . . 1 . ; VZ Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 i j ' ! : l ' durng t kilng l ot rwor ,itej yfu t tM ate di ifc kilhe i he li n he ds f h ur o nd ha th w' d t a t lt . 2 vi i i r ton t t vitm' com ment abouthi s and onl aferkilngt vi i ctm n eaci o he ci s s s on y t li he ctm i i 1 Filed 05/12/11 Page 72 of 85 . 3 di M a t pani and t t vi i ' car t M athew c d notbe guit asa m ate d thew c ake he ctm s , hen t oul ly t . 5 o lw o fln mud r ae u o teSaeste r. fa f eo y re b sd p n h tt' h oy . ë i i . 4 . 6 n i cl m waspr ry pl i a s s ai ope l ed n uppl m enti t dit i cour. V 2 J 41 e n he srct t A 6- 7 418 g . . . ' vi m at y he li upporst t or t M athew t he he y hat t M athe ' beha ori m edi el aRert kilng s t W S i 9 l l s t vi i i puli y i r cton t t vi i ' t e t 0 hot he ctm m s vel n ea i o he ctm s hr at owar hi s and onl ds s on y i l 1 ' ! I ' ! i . 11 aûe di M athe pani a drve of n t vi tm , c f. M a t tr tc l d hi f i r d t w c nd i fi he c i s a thew i s ale s rend 1 2 Jas H ol ,who wasw ih hi gilrend A s e Re on der t s rf i hl e edy. As ee Ree i taly pi hl dy nii l cked 1 3 . 1 up t phone i t ea l m or ng hour inm edit y aRe t kilng and not d 4 he n he ry ni sl a el r he li e 1 M athe ' pani 5 t w s cked voi . v lJ 8l.M athe ' voi wasalo s s out ner ce A t w s ce s kes ed- , vous 1 and s e 6 car d v lJ #2.n e st t sown que ton and s eque ans by A hs e a e' si ubs nt wer le A . 1 7 l8 Re s edy upporsM at ' pot ntaldef e t f ony m ur t thedi noti end t t thew s e i ens o el der ha d nt o 19 r t vitm butonl t t vi i ' caraRerhe pani d. ob he c i y ook he ctm s cke 20 Q:Soiwm i r s s t ta s e n b lhevitm)a ou tedee da ' t s n epon e o h t otme t y t ci b t h fn nts 21 c l en and cuti t hidr tng hem i o pi nt ecesa s ndi t nd e ng hem t hi ,accor ng t t o m di o he aa def endant t ca ed hi t r cta s a hat us m o ea nd hoott vi i i t head. he ctm n he A : Cor ect r . 2 3 24 vlJ 8 ' st t di notpr e a si ew i ess' pr ed a dif rent A 8 rhe a e d oduc ngl m t hat oduo fe . 26 27 28 Thedef ntneed ùotbe t one t pr e e denc t s ' he enda o es nt vi e hat upporshi t or of t s he y . a Stt. 2 v. 258 47 3 01 08 2 6 . l r s ul dC ens . Ros sv. ae 1 2Ne 1 ,1 P.d 11 , 11 ( 00 ) Cave t ho d f e ! l i . 25 r as f w hy M athe s t vi tm . e on or t w hot he c i 1 4 . ' . . . - 7 1 ! Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 I Filed 05/12/11 Page 73 of 85 i j have i m e at y notce t spa tr i t t tm ony oft SG t . w i es esand as m di el i d hi te n n he es i he e) m s s ked ! . 2 f anisr cinta t uyma eadeemi to wh te Mat w f me t i e t or n tu to h t hej r k tr nain eh r the or d he ntn i 3 t r bef e oraAe t kilng. o ob or r he li 4 : E I : n e e denc f tadii vi e or r tonalfr tdegr m ur r qui ng pr ediaton, is - ee der e ri em t i 5 6 delber i w il ul sand m alce af e houghtw a weak. n e St e s i aton lf nes i or t s at ubm it gene al ted r , J ' j r Ver c f r wiho rq rngt ni. t a t t t or offrtde e mu de a u F dit oms t ut e uii ma mi s o he he y is- gre r r s y . 8 a l d by Sc dv. io . 0lU . 5 4 ( 9 )a d Cr wf r v. a e 1 Ne 74 lowe ha Arz na 5 S. 2 1 91 n a o d Stt , 21 v. 6, p 1 75 1 p.d5 ,5 6( 005 .I i Ik l t ttej r c vitdM at w offrtd gr 0 0, 2l 3 82 8 2 ) ts iey ha h u y on ce the ts-e e 1 m ur rbased upon f ony m ur wihoutany consi ati ofwhen heformed t 1 de el der t der on he l 2 i e tt r b.Butf Cave tsi fe tve e si f ii gt r qu s ani s c i ntn o o or l r' ne f ci n s n aln o e e t n a ton : 1 3 I' 1 rg r n aj'r d tnniaino whe Mat w fr dt itntt r t vitm, 4 e adig u y ee n to f n the o me he ne o ob he ci . ) . . 1 M at w woudha be na q te o fln mur r n ej r woul h v as unl l 5 the l ve e c uitd f eo y de. uy d a e lo i ke i 1 convi t d M a t ofta tonalfr tdegr m ur rand i t ad convit M athe of 6 ce thew r dii is- ee de ns e c ed t w 17 . . I volmtr ma lught .Ofcour e,t pr ecuton i goi t diagre. t poi i g t a y nsa er s he os i s ng o s e But he nt s 1 t tiwa utmaeyfrt u yt d cdewhehe o n M at w f e t itnto 9 ha t s li tl o hej r o e i t r r ot the onn d he ne t : ; 20 r bef e orafe t kilng and M athe ' i ob or tr he li t w s nefec i ti lcot elCal r pr ve e tve ra ms ve t e nt d 21 n tej r fo ma n t sdeemi to h u y rm klg hi tr nain. 23 . I gr nt a evi ntar he i M athe woul t tf t the di notf m t f a ed n de i y arng, t w d es iy ha d or he I ! 1 24 i entt t t vi i ' ve cl untlaRe he i pul i y s t vi i i t he as nt o ake he ctm s hi e i r m svel hot he ctm n he ad 25 a r ul oftz vi tm t eat ni t cutup hi s He onl t t vehi e aAerhe es t le c i hr e ng o s on. y ook he cl 26 . ' 27 pani cked isoonfnnedbyt Stt sown wine s pr e ed dlrngt Slt scms -nt he ae' t s es es nt li he e' e i l 28 . I I 15 ' i 7 l 1 Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 74 of 85 ; I l 1 3 7 f m ed t i t t r . M at or he n ent o ob mew w oul have been ac te offr tdegr e m ur and d quit d is- e der 8 9 convi ed ofmansaughtr ct l e. 10 l1 j 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 i i i NEVADA RULESOFAPPELLATEPROCEDURE 4 C)THAT W ENT I ( NTO EFFECT J ULY 1 20 . 09. Ne a aRueo Ap elt Prcd r 4c alwsfrtet i l n tc o a p a ' v d l f p lae o e ue () lo o h mtmey oie f p e l . 1 7 I I . D.M ATI EW HAS A VALI APPEAL DEPRW ATI CLAI UNDER TI D ON M 1 fo ajd me t f o vcin po ie ap s-o vcinp tt nfrwlt f a e s 5 rm u g n o c n it , rkd d otck it eio o i o h b m o o i 1 c m ushasbeen tm el fl and assez sa vi e c1 j t t pettonerwas unl uly 6 o i y ied t abl a m hat he ii awf l ! i ! Cavet l a tt t s l ha m k dfraj r isr cinrgadngte l rwoud dmi ha he houd ve s e o uy n tu to e ri h . i : : . 6 f hsfiigt m kf ra i tu to r g ri aj r dee mi tonofwhe M ate or i aln o s o n nsr cin e adng u y tr nai n th w d ' ' : ' ' ' 4 5 prcs tmigofMat w' f r tonofteitn t r b.Cave t da tha bu e ie i n the s o mai h ne t o o l f woul dmit t t i i , 2 f s- m'emure a c vitdhi ofv u tr ma lu tr u tde e d r nd on ce m olnay nsa ghe. i i c e .Hewoldtsiyce bl a t u ywo dha b le e a a q te hi of hif tl e tf rdi y nd hej r ul ve eiv d nd c uitd m de i d oft rghtt atm el die a al Thi cl m wasconceded by t St e as prve he i o i y r ct ppe . s ai he at 1 8 . 1 pr 9 operi M athe tl d a tm el pos- onvi ton pe ii V 2 J 427. M a t hms f t w i e i y tc ci tton. A thew 20 ar d i t sappealtl t diti cour ered i r i hi habe petNon i gue n hi lat he srct t r n ulng s as i s 21 ocedur l def uled. aly a t 22 pr . 23 Thef lo n v ld camsf r le o die ta e l r r ie i t e o lwi g a i li or e if n r c pp a we e as d n h ' . 24 s l enti t dit i c t V 2 J 41 421. n es cl m s a epr e ed f t n he s rct our upp em A 8e ai r es nt or he . 25 Cour ' r viw becaus M a t w pr e e t diti tc twih va i and m e iorous ts e e e the es nt d he s rc our t ld rt i 26 li frrl fh t ewo l asro drc a p a a dfrh rrifre ta r l g ams o ei ta h ud set n ie t p e l n u te enocs h t ui e n 27 C 28 ' 16 . ? . i . T : i J Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 . Filed 05/12/11 Page 75 of 85 i ! ; ' i M athew ' habe petton a pr edur 1y def ule woul r s ti a f t s as ii s oc a1 a td d e ul n undam ent al l . 2 m ic rigeo j tc M a z v. ade ,11 Ne 4 ,8 2, P. 92 9 (99 . sara f usie. z nn W r n 2 v. 38 4 921 2d 0, 22 1 6) 3 M at e , ti l ou s l l r u a u l de i dhi ofhi rg t die ty th w s ra c n e Cave t nlwf l prve m y s iht o r c l 4 I a ppealhi ver s i convi ton oftr tde ee mur rw ih t us ofa sr ar . Is y erous ci i s - gr de t he e e m t 5 6 rng gr ed an evi i y hea i , M athew woul t s iy m r l sr ga di hi appeal ant dentar t d e tr s olow e r ng s 7 de i toncli .M at w wa t d byCav r i d aey a rs nt n i t a he prvai am the s ol le t mme it l le e . cng l t e i : ; E E : 8 w oul a d ppealhi conviton. M a t w ast i edi t y a s nt nci unabl t s ci thew hen mm a el Aer e e ng eo 9 1 c tc Cavet e adi hsa al e a s Cav r di n vsthi r s o t hi 0 ona t l r r g r ng i ppe b c u e le t d ot ii m, e p nd o s ' l lte so a c p hi pl c ls M athew t tl aproper notce ofappealt w as l e tr r c e t s mne a l t hen ied i hat . 1 2 j. ! , i k dim is by t N evada Supr e Cour i an unpubls wrten opi on on D e be s s ed he em tn ihed it ni cem r l 3 1 4 27,2007 f om whi t r m itt is d on J r ch he e tiur s ue anual 25,2008. l alow ed t diec l y f l o r ty 1 5 d aie he olow ng s ue c ' d i l es t n a ppealhi convi i he woul c s t f l i i s sw hih w oul lke y r ul i s cton, 1 6 O ver ala r a ofhi cas f a ne ti . s nd em nd s e or w ial )' l 7 . I g Pli er ra p o e uo ilmic nd ts i e tdMat w' u yi t cins an ro nd r s c tra so uc o nfce the sj r nsnlto 1 t t e i t ctonale r sr r t sCour t r ver e and r and M at w ' fr t 9 hat hes nsnz i r or equie hi to e s em the s ts l : 20 21 . . d re mu d rc nvitonwihu eofafra m f rane til Cal r ne ro j ce t e e r e o ci t s te r o w ra. ve t ve b e td o - . . za a uyi tucins n i Cour mu tte rviw t uyisr ci sf rpl ner r nyj r nsr to . s t s h n e e hej r n tu ton o ai ro . ' ! 2 Gaoav. e 1 Ne 3 ,3 4,1 3P.d8 68 ( 005 .n i Co th sad yt 3 r i Slt. 21 v. 27 3 1 3 3 40 2 ) s ur a ut o ! j 24 pr ectM athe ' rghtt r ver ala r a ofhi c e be e t e r s wer s ot t w s i o e s nd em nd s as caus he r or e o 25 ' I 27 M a t w ' r g t af rti l the s i ht o ai ra . ' ! 2 pl na dpae l prj iilt ttlsc ur mu ts as nt se i a dpr tc 6 ai n tnty eudca ha l o t s u po e tp n n oe t i ! I 1 . . . . ' I I I M c r v. ttsl 4Ne 1 4 1 2, P.d73 Kema S ae 1 v. 0 4, 65 968 2 9, 2 7 ( 998 8 45 1 ) I 1 7 ' . vz . . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 76 of 85 i i ! ae o e de pon le nae h o is i' e e d s d t s lo d y The stt pr c e ' u a tr t t e re oft1 td gremur e à al we b . 1 . , 2 l ;f ony m ur rwih r aw el de t obbe y ora t pt r r tem ed obbe y bei t unde l ng f ony and r ng he ryi el ! ' 3 m ur oc rng w ih m alce,pr ediaton and delber i V lJ 1. W hen s tlng der cur i t i em t i i aton. A e ti 4 ' ' 5 j r i t cinsa t co eo tilt dsrc c ur stldalisr to swiht u y nsnlto t he ls f ra,he itit o t et 1 n tucin t he e nsr i 6 e e i n ofi tucton 21, t f l y mur e j r i tu to whih t epr s c to xc pto he eon d r u y nsr c in c h o e u i n ; 7 appar nty di notpr de t eihert cour orCal rtprort t m or ng ofM ar 21 e l d ovi o t he t ve i o he ni ch , 8 i i 9 e tl n s A ns r i 20 whe j r i t uctonswer se ted i cham ber . V 2 J 273,276. l tuiton 21, 09 n u y nsr i . ' 1 tefl ymu d r uyi tu ton, st npr uc db teStt, atr e k cjmb r 0 h eon r e j r nsr ci w& he od e y h ae s to n y j ja es . ; i ' 11 a t lmch and pr ort afe noon cl ng ar ent Cav r d d no o j c t isr ci n fer t i o r osi gum s l e t i t b e t o n tu to . 1 2 1 3 21 n i i de piei sr ci alb i a i c r c sa e e torr l y mur e a s s s t n tu ton eng n n ore t tt m n eon dr s ' 1 algdb teS e V2J 27 n eS epoedduo atmaetèrso fs 4 l e yh ut. A 7. tt rcee pn l t hoi ftt e e e r l de ee m ur rasalowed by l .f ony m ur w ih r bber ora t pt r 5 c de l aw , el y tem ed obber bei v n der t o 1 6 : : . . . t unde l ng f ony and m ur roc he ryi el de cuni w ih m alce, pr m e t i a delber i ng t i e diaton nd i aton. 1 7 j V 1J 1. Y e , he St t s i t uc i 21nowher r e e s a i t uc i on t g A tt a e' nsr ton e ef r nce ny nsr ton he r 19 el me t ofatmotd r be V2 J 3 I t a S ae' u y i tu to 21r f r nc s e n s -te e ob a. A 58. nse d tt sj r nsr cin eee e % ' t r he obber ora t ed r y tempt obbe y m a el entoff ony m ur rand doesgo on t de m r s n em el de o f j ' 21 . n r b r bu c ob e y t omoli v la e ou a v d fnii o e l n to oftl elme sof eel e v s t n e i ton r xp a ai n le e nt - 2 atmoe r be v L. fc nw r iay fh jr isut n ia ae tne 3 te td ob r 4I at oleen n o teuynt ci ss n tmp udr n r o t 1 2 xvawre dmd tcttfnmrrdt pdbr 4 'alppleeih oeoeyuenamtrby eda or r nenxfl da t eoe. y o e 25 1 1 2 6 ! j 27 t e em ent A s a r ul, athe ' convi i m us be overur and hi cas he l s. es t M t w s cton t t ned s e ' ! I . n ej z c nn tlgial c nvits me peo aci f whiht ydono kn w uy a o o c l o c o o f rme or c he y t o 28 rma de f ane t1 1 t apr rfln mur r uyi tu to e n d or w 1a wih ope eo y de j r nsrcin. . I ; . i I . 1 8 7 . ' ! . Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 77 of 85 ! I i I ! . : I n i cour s s t houl al o c de t af e entone i t uc i d s onsi r he or m i d ns r tonalenorcl m i t ai n he 1 ! I 2 cont xtofpr ecut i m iconduc . Fis,t Cour m us det r i whe he t e os or al s t r t he t t e m ne t r he I 3 ! ' ' 5 1 1 ! . . pr scuo ' c du tofs mitnga i omplt a h nc i ore t u yisr ci o e trs on c ub ti n nc ee nd e e nc rc j r n tu ton 4 mpr ; wo h ur s o i r t r h mpr e j n tu in 5 W% i oper and t , teco tmu tc nsde whehe tei op r ue isrcto . I E : i le os or r s e sal dez 6 s bm i by t, pr ecut w acant r vel val v.st e, x e u ued at = v. . , - - , 196 p. 3d ! l 7 4 , ( 08 .Su tiga i r pe a dic mplt ur i tuci i i o r 65 476 20 ) bmitn n mp o r n n o eej y nsr ton s mprpe I 8 l I 9 n equ sinte b c swhehe a i r ryi tu tdj r r a hi avsdit e to h n e ome t r n mpopel nsrce u y e c ng r c . . ! i 1 bm e u on f ul i tu to s ul beo e t r e a r v re Thi q sin t r son 0 s d p a t nsr c ins ho d v ru n d nd e e s d. s ue to u n y I I 1 wheh rtepr s c tra mic nd tofi o el isr tngaj r o teeeme sof 1 te h o e uo iI s o uc mpr p ry n tuci u y n h l nt ' i i i 1 2 1 I 1 3 ' f ony m tr asaleged by t St e i ofa cons iutonaldi ensi I t pr ecut el lder l he at s tt i m on. f he os or 1 i o ry i tu tngt u . i ofac n tt to ld me i n,he t sCou t t 4 mpr pe l nsr c i hej r s y o siu ina i nso t n hi r mus ' 1 5 I 1 6 I ! i ' ) . r r e t es t St e de ons e ,beyond a r ona e doubt t tt er ordi not eve s ml s he at m kat s eas bl a ha he r d 1 7 l g c ntiut t t ve dit L o rb e o he r c . 4. n eprs c t s b ti a i omplt a i o rj yisr cinc nsiue o e uor u mitng n nc ee nd mprpe ur n tu to o ttts 1 pr ecut i m iconductofa cons i tonaldi ensi t r r r r alof 9 os oral s tm i m on hat equies eve s j ' ' ' i 20 I 1 21 22 cons iu espl i e r t tr r r ve s . Eac cl i s par el and ever m or s tt t a n r or ha equies e r al h a m e at y î e o i I Mat w' mude c nviton.Lie s,teçr e sfl ymt d r u yi tu ton the s r r o ci k wie h ron ou eon l e j r nsrci r I i ' I , j t ; 23 t hercombi t r oget ne o enderM athe smur conviton c t utonaly i lm,l vi t w der ci ons j j nfr ea ng ! 1 ! 24 1 25 I 26 ! ! i I ! i i ! 1 I 27 28 . tusc tw ih onl t r se a r a M athe , cas sr ne til l our t y o ever nd em nd t w s e a w ra ' . ' I i r s cflyrquetdt tt sc ur f ta M at w ha pr e e av i ts epe tul e se ha hi o tmd h t the s esntd al d . j 1 - a pe ld prvaincai a al Mate t die tya al sj > e tof p a e i to l m nd l ow th w o rcl ppe hi ud n c n ci onfltde emur ri a c da c wihteprvii so o viton ls pe ' de n c or n e t h o son f 1 9 4() c. $ . l i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 I Filed 05/12/11 Page 78 of 85 . ! E i i ' l E i ; j 2 3 hi habeaspe ii aboutt m ont l e. l i r s ct uly r s tton wohs at t s e pe f l equesed t t s Cour t hat hi t ' 1 j 4 r vel andr mand wiht dititcour i tucedt grntM auhe an evi i e se e t he src t nsr t o a w dentae ' i ! 5 I 6 i 1 rs t hearng on hi alega i r gar ng hi aleged pr i s l tons e di s l ocedur def ul asw el ast emei o al a t l h . 7 ! CON CLU SI ON M a t di pl good c e t over om e hi aleged pr thew d ead auk o c s l ocedur def ul i tlng al a t n i i hi p tto s e ii n 8 ' . . I I 1 9 10 1 ! 1 I 1 1 1 2 x 1 3 co s lfrApp la Mat w J me T el t un e o elnt the a s j wei ! i I I I E . ' ) . . . . 1 6 j I l . 1 4 1 5 1 j dt si y ul Res tuly s te s 3 * da ofJ y, 2010 pecf l ubmit ' 1 7 ' . . 1 8 . 1 9 1 ! 2 0 i I 21 22 ! I ! 23 i 2 4 1 . 1 25 I . 2 6 I i I I ! I ! i I ' 1 . . . . ' . ' . 27 i : 28 i . ! I q 20 . . k yq I 1 1 ' ' / ' 1 i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 79 of 85 ! i ! j ' i i l z ceri at ofcom olanc tsc e i e : : 2 . 1 : 3 1 AZ Ne lM e c nt ESQ,c riya f lwspu s n t NRAP 282. , Q a r ha , e tf s ol p rua t o . I . ! ! 4 lha r t sbrefbef e si i i. ve ead hi i or r ng t s To t be tofm y know ldge,i onnatôn a belef t sbrefi notf i ous or he s e nf i nd i , hi i s rvol ; i ! 6 i er ed f any i operpur e s h ast ha a s orcaus unnec s y del or nt pos or mpr pos uc o rs e es ar ay i , n e e si r a ei t c s orl i a in e dls nc e s n he o t i g to t . i i : i ! 1 k ' a Tot b s ofmy k wld e t sb ifc mple wih a l va Ru e o he e t no e g , hi re o is t l Ne da l s f : Ap la ePr e r ,i l n t r q r me sofNRAP 28 e t te e y a s ri i pe lt oc du e ncudig he e uie nt ( ) ha v r s e ton n z tebifeadn matritercrb spotdb rfrneotepg ad o h r' rgrig t snh eod e upr y eeec t h ae n e e e 11 vol e num be ,i any,oft a ndi oft m a t r i d on i t be f um r f he ppe x he ter ele so ound. I 12 13 i z4 i 1 Dae 5 t i z 6 I j 1 -. . .. s.l +. s c ' 4c. e I ech ntESQ. aM r a I . I 1 7 j 1 8 ' i ! . 19 : 20 i 21 . I ! 2 2 i ! : 2 3 i 2 4 ; ! 2s I 26 ! I i j ! 2 7 j I ' ' I .' . ' 28 I I I ! : F& 2 I Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 Filed 05/12/11 Page 80 of 85 I I l ' ' n = i l 2 ! 1 . Ce tfc t ofSer c riia e vie . Ic riyta 1 AzzNe l r h n , , -ie ac pyo tef r on d c me t e t h t , i a Mec a tESQ.e l d o f h o g ig o u n , f l 3 Appela ' Ope ng Bref w hi h w ilsend el ct oni notce t t f l i l nts ni i, c l e r c i o he olow ng: 4 ! ' s Azzxe l rh n orAp l n i a Meo a t -lt a 6 J eph pl t o rRes os aer ponden t R i i ! i ' Ca he i Core M a t f Re m nde t rne t z s o or s nt . ! 8 1 ! 9 . ' ë . ,, I ! j j i . p w. 11 ' 1 2 ! 13 I. z4 j I I I I I cn ' ' ls ' 1 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 ' 26 27 28 ' I ! . :/ ( j Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 81 of 85 . . ! ! I THE SUPREM E COI RT OF TH E STATE OF NEVADA N J k I I i M AW H EW JAM ES TJELW EI T, No.55773 Appelant, l V:. MC ANILAr THEPAT OF K WA DEN, L ST ESRS #, .. D R EE Y AT TIO E E x Evxo a F1 E D k ' J 13 2 1 AN 21 Respondent s. !' I . ! : ' ki l u vpj uv cvz DEPG Y CLE ; j . : . 2' . . i 1 i '' * OR D ER o F A FFI cE ' ,. . 'hi i gn gppelf pm an order qft di xi t c r ss r he st c ourtdi i ng sm ssi . t . . !. t , . pos ct vi .im . ti f r >. !, .x pe q j c q ts. yq, jj Judiit . a t- m .d j pqti on qz: Fri) pf. . :: . , l .J z ha o . . spc l; ; y cal d . . . . . : . ' ' . ' l y;! ., . 1 . .s o ï'yrit:o tz qs- j l ' y .vç!P.jlit ,. z .. .:...rjp. . j.. Dit c ' ur ,W hpesom l st !'.. .pj ;t ç. .j,. j L , œ c F ç t . l t Jvdg4 .:$y yi E .. j , ; , i . . . . .. . ' l ' ' 1 y . ' . . .,. . . . ' A poelant.led hi . et t on.' .. A ueusttl ' 2008,m ore t l fl s p i i ';on '''.' 5. 2: X i '' han one * ' 'A . .' . ' ' J . ' . .' . ' '' * . ' ' . i j 1 : year aae e r o t j m e o . pnviton o June 7,2007. Thus r nt y f he udg nt f c c i n , . . . t appe l ' pe ii n. was untm e y fl Se NRS .34. u. ) Appe l ' lants - tto i l led. e 7264 . . lants 1 -- ! , ' ' ent t i è or he pett on w as proceduraly barred abs a dem ons rat pn of caus f t ii l . j ' del and unduepr j c Se NRS 34. 1 . ay' e udie. e 726( ) . he st c ourt er . red i n l l m hat t di ri t c 0 n appeal ,appelant ç ai , t , cpus t overcpm e t procedm ' bar e o he al denyi hi cl m t he had good. ng s ai hat ' ; , be aus he. ke t i lc c e as d r a ouns lt appe hi c nviton a t alc uns l e o al s o c i nd ri o e . . f l t 4o s Appplantf l .o dem ons rat t t di r c c ' erred aied o o. l aist t e hat he st i t ouzt . i denyi hi good caus c ai . I order t est i h good c n ng s e l m n o abls ause f t or he 2 ' i ! deay' e upo a pe iine ' mit p bele t c uns lha fl a l bas d n tto rs s ake if hat o e d ted di rect appeal. pet t pneç p l> ç t. i h r hytthe pptt.np r ys n>bl ya ii zt .a s t bl t ii r e o o y , ; ?, ., . . .:. . ,;y . . y , ,) . . .. , Aqd, zed . .t #p pppeal.. j t...t pettoner fl a 1 ' .;: ). . hAt he ii ' ?bbe i ve t t s z ethpd:1:dg ; le d' ha oèn: x'k /. . . No, . . . 1 . , . . . , . . . ... , . . . . , . : J 'h a peiip: tj a J A o beni a tv la ni t t a dr d ! . be s tto wih n r s p> l tme fq e r.ng ha p ie . . ' ' ' ) .. ' appealhad nptbven f dy H at wav v.St e 11 Nq 2 255,71 P. d e ' , ha at , 9 v. 48, 3 . . p- -cx ' * t - 5 5 ( 03, 08 2003) Appe lntap . st have kno by Nov . la pear o wn embe 7 2007 r ,. , ' O m j (,.x op )f , ! . ' I 1 2 - . . . ' t . . -. ' ' . J a .. . .. . .. - r.?à'- '' ' t -'.. ' '*-- e 4% e r'.I '1i ï ' wbJ ' :ê *i l ., . . . . . . e * ' . ' . XL l ' J. . I Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 1 Filed 05/12/11 Page 82 of 85 @ : ! ; d t ti lc u s ldi no sl an a albe aus a hat ra o e d t e ppe c e ppenantsld a pr pe e o r . i ls udgm e o c nvi i n nt f o d o pers on noti e of appeal 1om li j c j appelant shoul have know n t c l d hat ouns di not S1 an appealw hen .ls el d e li ' . i i s s e or ng i l embe 27 200,, apd t r , appealwasdi mis d f bei untmey on Dec 7 he ' i rem i i w as i ued on Januar 22,2008k r el ei v.state.Docket N o. u tur ss v n w t . Furt her, . E ' ' . ! @ 5051 ( de Di m i s ng Appeal De e ber 27, 200W . The e o e, 8 Or r s s i , cm r fr i r ' appel ant s il had m ore t l tl han Sve m ont t 5l a t m el pet t on and hs o e i y ii ai i over s t ng even m ont t f w as ,nreasonabl l Accordi y, t us o ue ' e ngl be W i ! . . i di t c com ' di not er i denyi the pet t on as procedtraly barred, s ri t t d r n ng ii l l I d ànd we . ! i ! i i . ORDERtejd me to tedsrc cu t h u g n fh itit o r AFHRMED. . . J I Sai t ta I I i : . 1 / . J. ' Iardes y t ! 1 ' l 1 2 - 2-' a pa r r e r aguir I i p . ! ' ! l e no e t be aus appelantwas c de pur uantt a j . W t hat c e l onvi d s o uz y t al t al c ri ri ounsel had an oblgat on t c i i o onsul wi h appelant regardi t t l ng w het her appelant w ant t appeal li c l ed o ls onvi i d on. See Lozada v.St e. at 7 1 110 N ev. 349,35 871 P. 944,94 ( 994) W e e o e i wasr s 6, 2d 8 1 . r fr , t ea onabl e j I f r a la t beleve t t t i c ms l had fl an a o ppel nt o i ha ral ot e zed ppeal and . appe l di not have t de ons r e t he r ques e a appe i lant d o m t at hat e td n al n i I ; or der to m ake an appeal depr vat on cl m . H owever, as st ed above, i i ai at appelant w ai ed an unreas l t onabl am ount of t m e t fl bi pe i i and e i o l e s t t on, hi cl m i pr edur l barred. s ai s oc aly ; i i E - a i t v j G M . i i . j ' ' Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 i Filed 05/12/11 Page 83 of 85 I . i . d ! c c: Ho st ve P. lo t Dit itJudge n. e n Elit , s rc i i I : M erc hant Law Fi , Lt rm d. At orney General carson Ciy t / t W asboe Cot t D i r ctAt or m y st i t ney W ashoe Di t d CourtCl s ri erk 1 1 I I j ' I i 1 ! ! I I I I i . ! ! I I i i i . I i i I I i 1 i i . I I I l I . . . I I I .- -c . v I i o o i i t v . 3 .,a> o), - '. <- yY . . . .. % l l 4i '' % à= . CA i 1 .' + 2* , j Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 84 of 85 A FFIR M A T IO N PU R SU A N T T O :N . . 2398. R S. 010 I H ER EB Y C ER TI FY TH A T I A M TH E U N D ERSI N ED G 7 W D I I UA L A N D TH A T THE ATTACH ED DOCU M EN T V D THAT I ENTI S TLED: V say -q. o J ..6 , / c / . / V/zxJ V , e Jt - # z, / . , DOES NOT CO NTA I TH E SOCI L SECU RI N A TY N U M BER O F A N Y PER SO N , U N D ER TH E PA I S A N D N P RJ THI DAY OF E URY, SSX, , SI GMATURE: PEN A LT I ES OF IQX. ' v I NMATENAME P NT M n VJgv/ WJ /1<4 RI ED: k A/ ; $ I ATE N UM BER: NM $ 36 . 1 *.',t* ' A D D R ESS:EIY STATE PRI ON.P O. , S . BOX 1 8 .ELY.NV 8 3 99 9 01 I i Case 3:11-cv-00163-RCJ -VPC Document 6 Filed 05/12/11 Page 85 of 85 C qelclW 0, SGW ICE %m . ' >k J . ' b) z JmL . ./,e.-., do hereby certify pursuant to ERcp s( that on this 1'6 . /I , e?, ,/ . / da of ' y r r oi g. o es n / A . - 2 */ , 0 1 s rv a t u an c r ec c y of t e ed r e a o r t op h - . #- z. r. e . B GI Y VING SAME T A PRI N GUARD AT THF El O SC z y State Prison to deposit in th U - S. Mail, sealed in an envelope , postage pre paid , addressed to the following /.: ' f' < h 1 4 v , . . ,! j f l e z ?xf-h vc#'g' c s ,ct è jj l vy j -j , tol ; j: j wl j r j , p . B #41 zz y; It . - gefv 1'# . 3(s-l t Iq* 8. ' . y ' - . . ?2y State Prison P . . Box 1989 O Fly, Neuxan 89301 F< i 1

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.