Brooks v. Gedney et al, No. 3:2010cv00481 - Document 4 (D. Nev. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER granting 1 Motion/Application for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis; full fee due in monthly instalmts due; $0 due immediately; clerk shall send to A. Peralta at NDOP. Clerk shall file complaint and send along with blank form to Plaintiff. Defendant Bannister terminated. Amended Complaint due within 30 days. See order for specifics. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/30/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)
Download PDF
1 - N 2 1' ' ., : , .. ., ,. . . r n ;? 3 4 J j - 6 7 UN I TED STATES DISTR I C O URT CT 8 DISTRICT O F NEVAD A 9 10 STANLEY W .BROOKS, #67477 1 2 Pli if antf, 11 1 v. 3 s 1 DR. 4 KAREN GEDNEY,e aI, t . 1 5 Defnda s e nt. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 3: 0 c 0 1RCJVPC 1 - v- 048 - ORDER / 16 1 7 Brooks v. Gedney et al Thi i a prs ne ci lrg sa ton fld purua t 4 U. C.j 1 s s io r vi iht ci ie s nt o 2 S. 983. Pli ifs antf l a iaint pr e dlfo mapau rsi grntd( c t/1.Thec ur n rviwst c ant 8 pplc to o oc e ' r n pe i s a e do ke /) o t ow e e he ompli . Doc. 4 19 1 Screeni St . ng andard 20 Purua t t Prs ne Lii to Reo ActI s nt o he io r tgain fnn PLRAI f rlc t mus dimisa ,edea ours t s s 21 prs ne ' c a m s ç ft a l ga i o pov r y i un r ey ori t ac i d s fi ous o m a i i , i o r s l i , ç he le ton f e t s t u ' f he ton i rvol i ' i r lc ous' ' 22 ç a l t s a eac ai o whi h r le m a beg a e 'o çs e m one a yr le a i t de e nt t is o t t l m n c e i f y r nt dy' r 'e ks f t r e i f ga ns a f nda who 23 i i nefo s hr if' 28U. C.j1 5()2) A cam i lgal fi o whe i lc a s mmu rm uc ele, ' S. 91 e( . li s e ly rvolus n t a ks n 24 ag bl ba i et ri lw ori fc. ez v.Wila 490U. 31 325( 989 . c ur ma rua e ss ihe n a n atNitke lims, S. 9, 1 ) The o t y, 25 t r f e dim is a c ai a f i o whe e i i ba e on a i s ut bl m e il s l ga t e y or he e or , s s l m s rvol us r t s sd n ndi p a y rtes e l h or 26 w he e t f c ua c e i ns ar c e ry ba e t s 1 a 327.Th c ii a i uiy i w h t e a r he a t l ont nto e l a l s l s . d. t e rtc l nq r s e h r Dockets.Justia.com 1 constt i iutonalcl m ,howeveri tuly pl ai narf l eaded,hasan ar guabl l and f ualbass.SeeJackson e egal act i 2 v Arz 8 F. 6 6 ( Ci.1 9) . iona, 85 2d 39, 40 9* r 98 . 3 Dim i alofacom pl ntf f l t st e acl m upon whi relefm ay be gr ed i s ss ai or aiure o at ai ch i ant s 4 pr de fri Fe rl eofCi lPr e r 1 b)6)a t co tpple t smesa dadund r ovi d o n dea Rul vi oc due 2( ( , nd he ur a is he a tn r c 5 Se ton 1 15 e ( whe r viwi t a qua yofac anto a e e c ant Re e unde c i 9 ( )2) n e e ng he de c ompli r m nd d ompl i . viw r 6 Rul 1 ( ()i es ntal ar lngonaq sinoflw.Se Cha l fabo at yCop.o e 2b)6 s se ily ui ueto a e ppe v. r or r fAme ia, rc 7 23 F. 71 723( hCi.2 .A co ai mus co ai mor t natf 2 3d 9, 9t r 000) mpl nt t nt n e ha lonnuli rctto oft ac e iain he 8 el ent ofa cause ofactoni'i m us cont n f ualalegatons s t entt tr s a rghtt r i em s i 't t ai act l i ufici o 'aie i o elef 9 a e t s cu a i l ve . Be lAtantc Co p.v T bov he pe l tve e l' l l i r . wombl 550 U . 5 l S.Ct 1 ' y, S. 44, 27 . 955,1 965 1 ( 7) tf epla ngmus c an s t ng mo e.ha .asae ntoff cst tme eycr tsa 0 200 .t ' e di -h t onti omehi r .. n. t tme t . a t ha r l eae 11 s pi i g jalgal c ni a erg ofa to '/ J r viwi ac antunde t ssa a d, us con of e ly og z bl i ht ci n.' #. n e e ng ompll r hi tnd r 12 t courtm us acceptas tue t alegatons oft com pl nti quesi Hos t Bl Co.v.Re he t r he l i he ai n ton, pial dg. x 1 Ho pialTr s e s,4 U. 738 740 ( 976) c tue t pladi i t lgh mos f v a e t 3 s t u t e 25 S. , 1 , onsr he e ng n he i t t a or bl o 1 pl i ifa r ol aldo si t pli ifsfvo . nkn v M cKeihe 395U. 411 421( 96 . 4 antf nd es ve l ubt n he antf' a rJe is . t n, S. , 1 9) l5 Alegatons i a pro se com pl nt ar hel t l sr ngent s anda ds t n f m al l i n ai e d o ess ti t r ha or 1 pladngsdrûe b lwy r.Se Hu sv Rowe, U. 5,9( 980 * n sv Ke n r 40 U. 6 e i a d y a es e ghe . 449 S. 1 ) Haie . r e , 4 S. , 1 51 5 21( 97 L c iml s ealoBalsr r v Pa jcaPolc De t901F. 6 69 (t 7 9, 20- 1 2) per ura ; e s ite i . cll ie p', 2d 96, 9 9h 1 Ci.1 0) Alo pa'ofac mpli tl byaprs ne ma bedimis dsu s e howe ri t 8 r 99 . l r l t o antied io r y s se a pont, ve,f he 19 prioner scl m s l an ar s ' ai ack guabl bas seiheri l ori f . Thi i udescl m sbas on l e i t n aw n act s ncl ai ed egal 20 c ncusonst a el tna e( . cl msa i td e nt who a ei o l i hat r m e bl eg. ai gans efnda s r mmunefo s to cli ot r m ui r ams - ll i rnge nt alga i eeswhihee rydoe not xit, wela camsbae o fncf la t l nfi me of e lntr t c lal s e s)as l s li sd n a iu fcua 22 algai (. fntsi ordeusona se ros.SeeNetke 49 U. a 3 28*e aloMc e e le tons cg.a atc l i l c nai ) i , 0 S. t 27- , e s Ke v r z s 23 v Bl k 93 F. 795, ( hCi.1 91. . oc , 2 2d 798 9t r 9 ) 24 25 26 2 1 To s ti a a to und rscin 1 ,apli ifmus s ()t tt c uc usan n cin e e to 983 antf t how 1 ha he ond t 2 c mpl ne ofwa c o ai d s ommitdbyaperona tngunde colrofsaelw;a ( t tt c uc te s ci r o tt a nd 2) ha he ond t 3 deprved t pl ntf ofaf alconsiutonalorst ut yr ght'Hydri H unt 466 F. 676,689 i he ai if eder tt i at or i .' ckv. en 3d 4 ( hCi. 6) 9t r 200 . 5 l I antCom pl nt I. nst ai 6 Pl i if who i c r nty i a c r t d a N o t r N e da Co r c i na Ce e a ntf , s ur e l nc r e a e t rhe n va r e to l nt r 7 (Q tNNCC' ha s dDrKae Ge ey c rci ofie Beg, ade Be ed tiAso aeW ade ' s ue . r n dn , ore tons fcr r W r n n et, s cit r n ) 8 of ogr ms(6 P' LiaW a s a Pr a ( AW ' s lh, ndNe daDe lme tof r e tons(t ) va pal n Co r ci ç NDOC' M e c l r tr ' dia Dieco ) 9 Dr Ba ser.Pl ntf as rt t tt . nnit ai if se s ha hough hei di betc,D r Gedney hasdeni hi i uln, uli s a i . ed m ns i res tng 1 i blndnessi hi l teyeand nearblndnessi hi r ghteye.H eal o cl m st he s f sconsanty 0 n i n s ef i n si s ai hat ufer t l 1l fom pai i bot e r n n h yes.Pl ntf alegest he hasbee deni any tai ng ort apy t dealwihhi ai if l hat n ed r ni her o t s 1 blndnes a deni a tblnd ca 't Dr.Donnely or ed.Pl ntf alo ass t t of i Be 2 i s nd ed i i ne' hat l der ai i f s ers hat fcer rg 1 and Gedney cons r t s 3 pied o hootandkil ai ifi or t s op t l s t Healegest Ber tsetup l pl ntf n der o t he aw ui. l hat g s 1 pl ntf i poston t be s by hi wih as gun upon l ng m y cel and t or ed m eoutof 4 ai if n ii o hot m t hot eavi l hen der 15 m y cel i o har sway cl m i 1 çhoul tf w ih G edney.'Pl ntf st est t i ew e i l nt m ai ng s dn' -k t '' ai if at hat he nt nton 1 ofa uni ii i vi pr nt hi m ur r.Fi l pl ntf cl m st W alh alow edofi s 6 n dentfed ndi dual eve ed s de naly, ai if ai hat s l tcer 1 t cont cat hi t pl r f booksf t blnd. 7 o is e s ape aye or or he i l8 Pl ntf ai ifcont ndst def nt havebeen delber el ndif entt hi s i m e cal e hat enda s i at yi fer o s erous di 1 needsi vi aton oft Ei h Am endm ent TheEi h A m endm entprohi t t i poston ofcr 9 n ol i he ght . ght bis he m ii uel 20 a u ual s e sa ' m bodi sbr d a d i a itc c nc pt ofdi iy, vii e s a r , nd nus punihm nt nd ç e e oa n de lsi o e s gn t ci lz d t nda ds 21 huma t a d e y'Eselev. niy nd ec nc .' t l Gambl, U. 97,1 (976) A deane o prs e ' cam of e 429 S. 02 1 . ti e r ion rs li 22 i nadequat m edi car doesnotconsiut cr and unus puni hm entunl t m i r m entr s e cal e tt e uel ual s ess he steat i es 23 t t l o he evel of tdelbe at i f er nce t s i m edi needs.' 1d. at 106. The çdelber e s i r e ndif e o erous cal ' i i at 24 i fee e'tndadivol sa o jctvea asb e tvepr g.Fis,healg dde i tonmus ndifrnc 'sa r n ve n b e i nd u j ci on rtt le c prvai t 25 be,i o j ci tr ,ts fce l sro .' me v Brnn 51 U. 825,8 4 ( 99 (ii n b e tve ems tufiinty eius'Far r . e an, 1 S. 3 1 4) ctng 26 Wis n v Se tn 5 U. 2 298( 991) Se nd,t prs ofi ilmus a twih a d ufi inty lo . ie 01 S. 94, 1 ). co he ion tca t c t t tce l s 3 1 c pa e sa e of i dy w hi h e a l m or t n m e ene lge ce butl s t n c ul bl t t m n ' c nt is e ha ' r g i n , e s ha ondu tund ra n f c e tke or t ver pur e of causi hann. Farmer,511 U . at 837, A prson of i aldoes not act i a he y pos ng S. i fci n d lbe a e y i i f r nt a runl s t ofi i l t e i r t l nd fe e m nne e s he fc a t knowsofa dir ga dsa e e s vers t i a e nd s e r n xc s i i k o nm t he lh ors f t ' 1 at a e y. d. ' l appl ng t s sandar t Ni h Cicui has hel t bef e i can be sai t a n yi hi t d, he nt r t d hat or t d hat prs r sc vi r g sha be n a i d, t i f e e c t hi m e c lne dsm us be s t nta . ione ' i l i ht ve e brdge t he ndif r n e o s di a e t t ubs a i l M er tndi f ence, t i nces or E edi m al actce'w ilnots e i fer ' neglge ' m cal pr i l uppor t s caus of acton.' t hi e i ' Br ghtnv Cutrlab at is 6 1. ou o . te v or ore , 22 72d458, (t Ci.1 0)ctngfxc/ 429U. a 1 06. 460 9h r 98 , ii /fc, S.t 05SAJco antt tap sca lasbenne i nti dig i orte tngame c lc iim d s C I mpli ha hyiin l e glge n a nosng rai dia ondtc oe nots at avald cl m ofm edi m it eat entundert Ei hA m endm e .M edi m al te i ai cal s r m he ght nt cal practce does i notbecom ea consi tonalvi aton m er y becaus t vi i i a prs tm i ol i el e he ctm s ioner.'Est l v.Gam bl 429 ' ele e, U. a 1 ,s ealoAndes v Cou y o r 45F. 1 0,1 6 (t Ci.1 ) Mcc knv S. t 06, e s ron . nt fKe n, 3d 31 31 9h r 995 . mc i . , k mi 97 F. 1 î t 4 2d 050,1 0( hCi.1 92)( e r ldo ot rgr s,HM. Te h .I .v Milr h, 05 9t r 9 ov r ue n he ound ) ' , c s,nc . le, Y l F.d 11 11 ( h Ci.1 )e ba ) Eve gos ne i nc i i ufiintt esa ih 04 3 33, 36 9t r 997(n nc, n r s glge e s ns fce o tbls dei r t i fee t s ro me c lne ds Se Woodv Hou ewrght900F. 1 1 4 ( h lbe ae ndifr nce o e i us dia e . e . s i , 2d 332, 33 9t Ci.1 0) A pione ' meedia r me wihdign i orte t ntdoe no s po'acam of r 99 . rs rs r sgee nt t a oss rame s t up l li t dei rt i fee e.S he v Vids8 lF. 240 242( hCi.1 . lbeae ndifrnc anc z . l 9 2d , 9t r 989) D e a of o i t r e e e wih, m e i a te t e c n a s a ount t de i r t l y , r n e f r nc t d c l r a m nt a lo m o lbe a e i fee .Se tv Pe ne , 9F.d 1 91 1 6( t Ci. 06) Clme v Gome , F. 898 ndifr nce elet . n r 43 3 0 , 09 9b r 20 . e nt . , z 298 3d , 905(tCi. )Halet . gan, F.d73 7 (tCi. 9b r2002 . ltvMor 296 3 2, 44 9h r2002)Lo zv Smih, F. 1 22, , , . pe . t 203 3d 1 1 31(tCi.1 96)Jacz'nvMcnts 9 F. 33 332(tCi,1 6)M c knvSmih, 74F. 1 9b r 9 . lo . l o h, 0 3d 0, 9b r 99 . Guc i . t 9 2d , , 1 ,1 9(*Ci.1 ov ruldonot rgr sb F'' T c .I .v Milr 1 F. 1 33, 050 05 9 r 992) e r e he ound y A. e hs, nc . le , 04 3d 1 /Y ('Ci.1 )(nba l Huchns v Unie St e ,838F. 39 3 (tCi.1 ) W heet 9h r 997 e nc; t i on . td ats 2d 0, 94 9b r 988. r he prs e i algi t t lyofme c lr ame e nc sde i r t i ifr nc , ion r s le ng ha de a dia te t nt vi e lbe ae nd fee e howe e ,hep ione v r t rs r mus s t tt dea ldt frhe ij y.SeeHalet,2 F, a 745- , t how ha he ly e o u t r nur l t 96 3d t 46. McGuc n, F.da ki 974 2 t 1 , a e v Ne Bd.Ofst ePrs Comm 's 766F.d404,40 (tCi.1 )( rc im) 060. ply . v. Sh at ion r, 2 7 9h r 985 pe ura . 4 1 Pl ntf s at an Ei h Am endm entcl m agai Dr K ar Gedney. ai if t es ght ai nst . en 2 W ih r pectt pl ntf'sr alaton cl m i countI ,t es a ih aprm af ecasef t es o ai if' et i i ai n I o t bls i aci or 3 r t la i pl i ifm us a l g a s w t t f nda sa t d t r a i t f rhi e r i eofapr e t d e a i ton, a ntf t le e nd ho ha de e nt c e o et la e o s xe c s ot c e 4 actviy, def i t and endant actonsdi notser al tm at penol calpur e.SeeBar tv.Cent , s' i d ve egii e ogi pos net oni 5 31 F.d 81 81 ( h Ci.1 4) Pr tv Rowl 65 F, 8 8 ( t Ci.1 ) A pli if 3 3, 6 9t r 99 . at . , and, 3d 02, 07 9h r 995 . antf 6 as ertng ar alaton cl m m us dem onsr e atbutf ' caus nexusbet ee t aleged r alaton s i et i i ai t tat t - or' al w n he l et i i 7 a pli ifspr e tda tv t (. ,tlngalga a ton .M c nd antf' ot ce c iiy ie. ii e l c i ) Donal v Hal, 0F.d 1 ,1 ( s Ci. d . l61 2 6 8 1 t r 8 1 9)s eMtHe tyCf Sc DitBd.fEduc v. yl, U. 274(977 .Theprs rmus 97 ,e . alh y' hool s. o . . Do e 429 S. 1 ) ione t 9 s i evi nce, t diectorcicum s a i ,t es a ih alnk bet ubm t de eiher r r t ntal o t bls i weent exer s ofconstt i he cie im onal 10 rght and t alegedl r alat y acton.Pr t 65 F. at806. Ti i oft event s r i s he l y et i or i at, 3d m ng he s ur oundi t ng he 11 aleged r alaton m ay cons iut cicum st i evi l et i i tt e r antal dence ofr t i or i ent See Sor e alat y nt . anno ' Gasco, s 1 I .v Mor 8 F. 1 0,1 1 ( hCi.1 ) Pli ifsaesartlai cam a ai tDr 2 nc . gan, 74 2d 31 3 6 9t r 989 . antf tt eaiton li g ns . l3 Kar G edney and cor ectonsof- Ber en r i tcer g. i 14 W ih r pe t Banni t ,pl ntf aleges gene aly t unde Banni ert m edi t es ct o ser ai if l r l hat r st he cal 1 d pat nt sde e hi a ri ngo t rpyt a ptoblndne s Howe rtgla lt u e gl 5 e rme ha nid m nytani rhea o da t i s . ve,ilibiiy nd r ' j 16 1 arsesonl upon a s 983 i y howi ofper onalpari paton byt def ndant A s viori onl la e ng s tci i he e . uper s s y i bl 17 f t consiutonalvi atons of ...s di es i t s vi pari pat i or diect t or he tt i ol i ubor nat f he uper sor tci ed n r ed he 1 v ol tons o kne o t vi a i s a d f l d t a tt pr ve t em .Th r i no r po a s ror 8 i a i , r w f he ol ton n aie o c o e nt h e e s es nde t upe i 1 la lt 9 ibii yunde (q1 ' Ta o . s, 0F. 1 0,1 45(QCi.1 9)( tto o te ;eealo r j 983. ylrvLit88 2d 04 0 9' r 98 ciains mitdls s ' 20 Hydrc . e , F.d978, 8(tCi. ) Ore v Was ngt Cou y,St eo ikvHuntr 500 3 98 9b r2007 . tz . hi on nt at fon,8 F. , 8 3d 21 8 8 (t Ci.1 )(on ldi pope t dimiswhee no ale tonsofk e ofor 04, 09 9b r 996 c cu ng r r o s s r lgai nowldge 22 p rii toni alge vi aton .Pli ifdoe no alg t tBa se patcpae i die tdo a tcpai n le d ol i ) antf s t le e ha nnitr rii td n, rce r 23 f l t actt pr aied o o eventvi atons of pl ntf s Ei h Am e entrght A ccor ngl pl ntf s ol i ai i f ght ndm i s. di y, ai if 24 c a m s a ai tde e n Ba s e a e di m is d,a he i di m i s d f o t sa to l i g ns f nda t nnit r r s s e nd s s s e r m hi c i n. 25 W ih r pe t W a den Be t es ct o r nedeti pl ntf st est hei çf cedbyW a den Benedeti t, ai i f at hat s tor r t 26 t f nd f hi s fwih no ass sance ata1.' W hie pl ntf appear t com pl n t Benede t has o e or m el t it l' l ai if so ai hat ti 5 l been delber el i f er t hi s i m edi needs f tai ng ort a t adaptt blndnes i at y ndif ent o s erous cal or r ni her py o o i s, 2 hi alegatons agai tBenedetiar t vague f t cour t det m i whet t s at an Ei h s l i ns t e oo or he t o er ne her hey t e ght 3 A m e e m e c lc a m . Pl i if f is t i ntf w ha s c fc a tonsBe de t t k a how ndm nt di a l i a ntf a l o de iy t pe ii c i ne ti oo nd 4 Benedetialegedl vi at hi constt i t l y ol ed s i- onall s.A ccor ngl pl ntf scl m sagai tBenedeti ut ight di y, ai i f ai ns t 5 m ustbe di m i s s s ed. However becaus hi alegatons agai t Be , e s l i ns nedet m a i i e hi Ei h ti y mplcat s ght 6 A m endm entr ght he m ay a e hi com pl nt i s, m nd s ai . 7 W ih res t pectt Lia W alh,pl ntf salegatonst s alowedhi t pl yert be o s s ai if l i hat he l s ape a o 8 confscat ar al t vaguef t cour t det m i whet t y st eacl m .Pl ntf cl m st i ed e so oo or he t o er ne her he at ai ai if ai hat 9 t sw asdonet puni and t m e .Pl ntf cl m sagai tW al ar di i ed.Tot ext t t hi o sh or nt ai ifs ai ns sh e sm ss he ent ha 10 pl ntf s ks t brng a r alaton cl m ,he has l ai if ee o i et i i ai eave t am end hi cl m sagai tW alh. As wih o s ai ns s t 11 Benedeti pl ntf m usts fcalyi iy W al h' actonsand how t t, ai if pecii l dentf s s i hoseactonsalegedl vi at i l y ol ed 12 w hats tc constt i pecii i- onalrght ofpl ntf . ut i s ai if 13 A ccor ngl pl ntf hasl ave t f l an am ended com pl nt l pl ntf el t t fl di y, ai if e o ie ai . f ai if ec s o ie 1 an am ended com pl nt he i advied t he s d s fcaly i ntf each def 4 ai , s s hat houl pecii l de iy endantt t bes of o he t 15 hi abiiy,cl i y whatconstt i s lt ar f iutonalrghthe beleveseach def i i endanthasvi at and s ol ed upporteac h 16 cl m w ih f ualalegatonsabouteach def ai t act l i endantsac i . Agai t e can beno labiiy under42 ' tons n, her i lt 1 U. C, 1 3unls t r i s afr tvelnkorc nne to bewe nadee a ' a to a te 7 S. j 98 e shee s ome fimai i o cin t e fnd nts cins nd h 1 cli dde i ton.Riz v Goo , U. 362( 9 . yv. 8 ame prvai z o . de423 S. 1 76)Ma Enomoo, F. 1 4,1 (tCi. , t 633 2d 6 67 9b r l 1 ) Joh onv. fk,58 F. 7 743( hCi.1 ) Pli ifscamsmusbestf t i s r 9 980 , ns Dul 8 2d 40, 9t r 978 . antf li . t e orh n ho t zt and pl n t m s,si pl conci y and diecty.See Swi kei c v.Sor j ai er m y, sel r l er ewiz ema N A. 534 U , 506,514 , S. 21 ( 2) Fe R.Ci P.8. 200 * d. v. , 22 Pl ntf i i or ed t t courtca ai if s nf m hat he nnotr er t a pror pl ng i or t m ake ef o i eadi n der o 23 pl ntf s am ended com pl nt com pl e.LocalRul 15-1 r r t an am ended compl ntbe ai if ai et e equies hat ai 24 com pl ei isel wihoutr er et n t f t ef encet anyprorpl ng.Thi i because,asagener r c,an am ended o i eadi ss al ul 25 co ants pe s de t o i i lc ant Se Z(l v. y,3 F. 5 5 ( t Ci.1 7) Onc mpli u r e s he rgna ompli . e /? Rha 75 2d 5, 7 9h r 96 . e . x 26 pl i tf tl s a a e e co pl nt t orgi lpl a ng n l nge s r sa f nc i n i t c s . a n if i e n m nd d m ai , he i na e di o o r e ve ny u to n he a e 6 1 The e or , n a a e e c m pl ntasi a org nal m pl i t e c c ai a t i ol m e ofe c r f e i n m nd d o ai , n n i i co a n , a h l m nd hc nv ve nt a h 2 def ndantm ustbe s tci l aleged. e uf- enty l i 3 11 Concl on 1. usi 4 I I THEREFORE ORDERED t tpl ntf' a plc ton t pr e d i fo ma T S ha ai ifs p iai o oc e n r 5 pau rs( ke #1 wiho ha ngt pr pa t f lflng f ei GRANTED;pl itf s l not pe i doc t ) t ut vi o e y he ul ii e s an if hal be 6 r quie t pa a i ta i t lm e f e Ne rhe e s t f l ii f e s l s il d p s ntt e r d o y n nii l ns a l nt e . ve t l s , he ul f l e ha l tl be ue, ur ua o ng 7 28 U. C.j 1 l a a nde by t Prs e Lii ton Ref Actof1 96. Themova h r i i S. 9 5, s me d he ion r tgai onn 9 nt e en s 8 per it t m ai ai t sacton t concl on wihoutt necesst ofpr ym entoff orcos sor m ted o nt n hi i o usi t he iy epa ees t 9 t gvi ofsc iyt rfr Thi or rgrntngi for pau rssa'ss lnote tndt t he i ng e urt heeo . s de a i n ma pe i tt hal u xe o he j( i uance ofs ) ss ubpoenasatgove m entexpe e. nz ns 11 I I FURTHER ORDERED t a , s ntt 28 U. C.j 1 5, a nde byt T S h t purua o S. 91 as me d he 12 Prs ionerLii i Ref m Actof 1996,t N evadaD epa m entofCor ectons s lpay t t Cl k tgaton or he rt r i hal o he er 13 oft Unied St esD iti Cour,Di tictofNevada,20% oft pr he t at sr ct t sl he ecedi m ont s depost t t ng h' is o he 1 a c untofStnlyW . o , nmat No. 477(nmo hst tt a c un e e ds$1 00 untl h 4 co a e Br oks l e 67 i nt ha he c o t xc e 0. ) it e l f l$35 flng f e ha be n pai f t sacin. The Clr s l s nd a c py oft sor e t t 5 ul 0 ii e s e d or hi to e k ha l e o hi d r o he l6 atenton ofAl tG . rala, efofl at Servi f t N evadaD eparm entofPrsons,P. . t i ber Pe t Chi nm e ces or he t i O Box 1 7 1 Ca s n Ciy, V 897 7 01 , r o t N 02. l8 I IS FURTH ER O RDERED t ,even i t s ac i i dim ised,ori ot nvi T hat f hi ton s s s s he se 1 uns c s f ,t f lflng f e s l silbe due purua t 28 U. C.j1 5 a a nde b t 9 uc e sul he ul ii e hal tl , s nt o S. 91 , s me d y he 20 Pr s i onerLii i Ref m Actof 1996. tgaton or 2l I I FURTHER ORDERED t theClr s lFI t c ant(oc t#11. T S ha t ek hal LE he ompli d ke - ) 22 I I FURTHER O RDERED t a pl i ifsEi ht Am e e m e c l l i ag i t T S h t a ntf ' g h ndm nt di a c a m a ns 23 Dr K a e G e ne M A Y PRO CEED . . rn d y 2 4 I I FUR TH ER O RDERED t tpl i if s r t la i cl i s s f t i c nt1 T S ha a ntf ' e a i ton a m et orh n ou 1 2 a ns Dr Ka e Ge y a c r e tons o fc rBe g M AY PR O CEED . 5 gai t . r n dne nd o r c i fie r 26 IT I FURTH ER O RD ERED t pl ntf scl m s agai tdef S hat ai if' ai ns endantBa st ar nni er e 7 DISM ISSED . D ef endant Bamzst i D I ISSED fom t s acton. s i er s SM r hi i IT IS FU RTH ER O RDER ED t pl ntf s Ei h Am endm ent cl m s agai t hat ai if' ght ai ns de e nt W a de Be de t a e DI I f nda r n ne ti r SM SSED wi h l ave t am e i c nf t e o nd n o onnan w ih t ce t he i r i pr ded i t sor . nstuctons ovi n hi der IT I FUR TH ER O R DER ED t pl ntf scl m sagai def ntLi W all ar S hat ai if' ai nst enda sa sl e DI I SM SSED w ih l a t am e i c nf m a e wih t i tu i nsp ovi d i t sor r t e ve o nd n o or nc t he nsr cto r de n hi de . I I FURTHER ORDERED t t antf wil v t ry( day:fo t d t t t TS ha pli if lha e hit 30) r m he a e ha tlsOr i ent ed t fl hi am ended compl nt i he choos t fl one,i conf li der s er o ie s ai , f es o e n onnancewih t s t hi Or der. The am ende com pl ntm us be a com pl e docum enti and ofisel,a wils s t d ai t et n t f nd l uper ede he orgi compl nti isentr y. Any alegatons pari ,orr i nal ai n t iet l i , tes equest f r i fom prorpaper t s or elef ' r i s hat arenotcanied f ar i t am ended com pl ntw ilno l rbebef e t cour .Faiure t am end om d n he ai l onge or he t l o w ilres ti t m ater proceedi as t t cl m salow ed i t sorder. l ul n he t ng o he ai l n hi IT IS FURTH ER O R DER ED t i pl ntf chooses tlfl an am ended com pl nt hat f ai if t ie ai , he s lcl l tte t am ended com pl nt as s by pl ng t wor EFI hal eary il he ai uch aci he ds C RST AM EN DED' ' i e aeya eçci l g sCompli P s nto42U. C. 1 3onpa 1i t ca ton, nd mm ditl bov d viRi ht ant ur ua t S. j 983' ge n he p i a pl ntf s l pl ai if hal ace t case num ber, 3: he 10-CV00481RCJVPC , above t wor 'FI he ds C RST A M END ED'iIt s 'I he pacef tcas No.' or t e ' IT I FURTH ER O RD ER ED tm tt Cl kshal s t pl ntf abl s i 1983 S l he er l end o ai i f ank ecton ci lrght com pl ntf w ih i t i al wih one copy oft or gi com pl nt vi i s ai orm t nsructons ong t he i nal ai . pr ded i t sor r. ovi n hi de DA TED t s 30t dayof hi h Novem ber I D S'' T R IA 8 , 201 . 0 I STRI JU DGE CT