Uranga v. Adams et al, No. 3:2010cv00014 - Document 69 (D. Nev. 2011)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING Motions to Dismiss #'s 16 , 32 , 40 , 42 , 59 and the Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings # 21 . FURTHER ORD the Motion for Leave to File and Amended Response # 37 , and the Motions to Extend Time #'s 49 , 61 , 63 , 64 are DENIED. ( Jim Gibbons, McDonald, Carano, Wilson LLP, Montroy Supply Company, Nevada Equal Rights Commission, United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Brent T. Adams and Kimberly H. Albro terminated. ) Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 1/14/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
: E i . . e% ' x ; . * i : FE 'EC ETFZ NEE i ! ! ' . l ! 2 J 11 21 AF . 01 3 ' ( . 4 g y: ! RC SC C VE SE VE ON F ' ' u'''' '' FR : ' 0 ' t'' 'î' ' 9 D ' ' UYCS1 C' RC CCC I 5 X I IC J yyu ggjw A j l gj (S ) l ' ' IEFt' I JY r 5 j . 6 IN TED S J TATESDI TRI COURT S CT 7 DISTRICT O F NEV AD A 1 l I i ! 8 i ! ! I ' E ! E 2 ROBERTO URAN GA , 9 pli if antf, l 0 ) ) ) ) ) ) vs. 11 BR EXTT, AoAMse l ta. , 3:0c 0001 RCJRAM 1 -v- 4- - ) ORDER ! 1 : 1 1 2 1 3 ) ) ) ' l 4 Thi case ars outofa s i or ent ed agai tPl ntf i s t cour. Pl ntf s ies anctons der er ns ai if n m e t ai if i 1 ha s edtej dgewhois dt or ra welasf 5 su h u sue he de, s l onnerGovenorJm Gibo ,heEqu r i b ns t al i i I 1 E ly n Op o tnt Co s in(t eEE ',h Ne a aE u l g t Co sin 6 mpo me t p ru i mmiso th OC' te v d q a Rihs mmiso y t ) I I INE C',n svrl te idvd as n isi t n.P n igbfrteCorae'e 7 & R ' ad eeaohrn iiulad ntui s edn eoe h utrtv e I to i i Dee dan fn l. Uranga v. Adams et al Doc. 69 1 moto t dimis amoto f j dgme to t pla ngs amotonfrlav t fl an 8 ins o s s, in or u n n he e di , i o e e o ie l9 am ended r espons t one oft e motons and f m otonst ext tm e t r pond t one of eo hes i , our i o end i o es o 20 t . Fort r hem he easonsgi her n,t Cour gr st m otonst di isand t m oton f ven ei he t ant he i o sm s he i or 21 j gme ont pla ng a dde e temoto t a ndandt motonst e e tme. ud nt he e di s n nis h in o me he i o xtnd i 22 1 . FA CTS AN D PRO CEDU R AL Y STO R Y 23 A lhough Pl ntffRobert Ur t ai i o anga ls ss algener i grevancesaboutsoci al it ever alzed i et 24 r s and econom i har p,he alegesonl one contovers f whi he hasst ng t sue: acim c dshi l y r y or ch andi o 25 t een r ceofas c i o de a i thi i t a h tan an tons r r gans m n he moun of$1I085.3 i t Se d J di al t , 7 n he con u ci Dockets.Justia.com . ' i ! ; ' 1 : ; ; ' I i I i I l DititCour i Ne dab J dgeBrntT. ms ( eCo . 5 .Ba e ont e tyof src tn va y u e Ada .Se mpl2, -7) s d he nr ' I 2 t sor r Pl n ifs e De e a si t sCou ton s ve c us o a ton alh hi de , aitf u d f nd nt n hi r e n a es f c i , t oughnot I 3 Prcieye tte ornu rda s c i t compl nt ()Equ prtci vi ainpurua t e s l nild mbee s u h n he ai : I al oe ton olto s n ( l l . t 42 U o S. 91 8 ,2 Braho Co tata anth EE a dNERCI() gie t C. 9 3' ) ec f nrc (g iste OC n ( ;3 Ne l n g 4 i 1 . 5 Mirprsntton(gai tt EEoc a dxERc) ( oeamai ()ltni alInitonose ee ai a ns he n ;4) r ton; 5 ne ton n ci f i : I . I I 6 Emotonal ites (-I ,. 6)I va i orprva y; nd ( )Tori sl t rer c wih i o sr s - Eo-) ( n son , i c a 7 tou n e r en e t . . : ; 7 Pr pe tveEc mi Adv mg ( eCo .ECFNo. ) Deen nt aeJ dgeBr tT. os ci ono c an e.Se mpl, 5 . f da s r u en ' ! ë 8 Ad 'f merGovenorJm Gibo ;Monr Su yCo.t toy',EdwadW on ams or , r i b ns toy ppl (l r '' r j a, Mon ) ; i 9 J me D.W is a d J W is ( mplye o M o r ) Ki ry H. br ( al n y f r a s lon, n oy lon e o es f ntoy ; mbe l Al o an tor e o ! i I M on r ;M c nal Ca a ,W is LLP (: CW ,' br sGr * heEEOC;St a tIhi u 0 toyl Do d, r no lon, I M 'Al o' m1 t , u r s mar i l , i 11 ( tng Chaima oft EEOC) a NERC. aci r n he ; nd i i 1 n. 2 LEGAL STANDARDS I ! 1 3 A. i 1 4 Fe r lRul o Ci lPr e e 8()2)r uie o y t s or a pli sae ntoft e de a e f vi oc dur a ( eq r s ni I h t nd an tt me a h ! 1 ! ' ! I cl m s w i t a t e plade i e il d t r i f,i or rt <gi t e def nda tf i n i e of 5 ai ho ng h t h e r s ntte o ele n de o : ve h e . n ' r otc a 1 1 ( 95 .Fe rlRul o- vipr e e1 b)6 ma ae ta ac r dimisac us ofa to 7 1 7) dea e fci l oc dur 2( () nd ts h t ou t s s a e cin 1 I Rul 12( )6) e b( ! . l whatt . . . cl m i and t gr ndsupo whi i r t . Conly v Gi o 355 U . 41 47 6 he ai s he ou n ch t ess' ' e . bs n, S. , 18 t f l t s at a cl m upon whi r i can be gr ed. A m oton t di is underRul hat ais o t e ai ch elef ant i o sm s e I I b ( tsst c antss m cin Se N. a lt1vArz Cor Comm ' 7 F. 57 9 2()6) et he ompli ' u e cy. e Str n . i. p. n, 20 2d 8, 20 58I( t Ci.I 3 .W he co iern amo i t dimisund rRul l b)6 f f l et 9 h r 98 ) n nsd ig ton o s s e e 2( ( ) or aiur o 21 s a e acl m ,dim is i a op i t onl whe t c pl i do s no gi e t e de e ntf i tt ai s s al s ppr ra e y n he om a nt e t v h f nda a r 22 notce ofa l l cogni e cl m and t gr i egaly zabl ai he oundson whi i r t SeeBel At.Cor v. ch t es s. l l p. 23 Twombv 5 U. 54 5 ( ) l c i i whehert c anti s fce t saea l, 50 S. 4, 55 2007 . n onsderng t he ompli s ufiinto tt . 24 cl m ,t cour wilt a1 m at alalegatons astue and cons r t ai he t l ake I eri l i r t ue hem i t lghtmos n he i t 25 f rbl t t pl nifSe NL I s.lc.3 Ka a 7 F. 8 8 ( hCi.I .The avoa e o he aitf. e ndu . n c pln, 92 2d 96, 98 9t r 986) ' Page 2 of 9 i ! i i . ' 1 ( i 1 . . * j ; l i i ! 1 cour, bowev r i n r quie t a c p a t u ale tonst a ar mer y c cl or t e , s ot e r d o c e t s r e l ga i h t e el on us y, j p I . 2 u warne d d cin o fc, ru raon beifrn e . e S e lv God nSae n ra td e u to s f a to n e s a l nee c s S e pr wel . le tt 9gg gh r 0 ) b muac e iai fa a s f ci t 3 wa ros 2 6F.d979, tt ci 2 01.A f r li rctt no' c u eo a t nwih r ir , 6 3 o o l I 4 concl or alegatons i notsum ci ;a pl ntf us pl r s s i t a vi aton i us y l i s ent ai ifm t ead act how ng hat ol i s i i . I 5 pl sbl,no j s posi e As rs v I ,1 S. ,1 ,1 ( 09)( ttonsomitd) au i e t u t sbl. hco .qbal 29 Ct 937 949 20 ciai te . l 1 6 i e er l a dit itc r m a n co i ra y m a era be nd t pl a n i r i ' n aly, src ou t y ot ns de n G t i l yo he e di gs n ulng i I i ! I ! : ' 7 o aRul 1 b)6 moi Ho v r mae ilwhihi pr rys te aspatofte n e 2( () ton. we e , tra c s opel ubmitd r h 8 c aitma bec i r d - HalRoach st di ,l .v.Ri hur t ner 4:co. 896 I. d 1542ompl n y onsde e u os nc c d ui r2 , 9 l 5 n.9 ( t Ci.1 55 1 9 h r 990)( ia in omitd) Si ia l ld ume swh ec e sa ea lge ct to te . m lry.loc nt os ontnt r le d i E 1 i 0 l I i I t tepe dn , ma bec sde e i r ig ona Rue 1 b ( moto t dimis-sihou I o l la ig y on i r d n uln , l 2( )6) in o s s - t t 1 i 1 ! i I i i n ac aitandwhos a t en iiy nopa t que ton ,b whi ar notphysc l atche ompl n e u h tct ry si s ut ch e ialy ta d 1 c eri t motont dimisi oamoi f s 2 onv tng he i o s s nt ton or ummayj dgme . a v Tu l,1 r u ntBr nch . nnel 4 l F 3 3 4944(t CrI9) Moevrudr eeaRueo E iec 2 1acut ytk d 4,5 9h i.94. roe,neFdrl l f vdne 0, orma ae . . I j di a n ieoft tesofpu i rc d. Mac v S.Ba Be rDitis, n 798F. l 4 u cil otc t tr ma blc e or ' k . y e srb I c, ' 2d 279, 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) Otewie,it dititc tc sdesmaeil ousdeoft 5 282 9t r 986 . h r s f he src our on i r tras ti he j l i ! 1 ' 1 . 1 pe dn s temo int ds s i c n etd it amoinfrs mmayj d me tS eAr nv 6 la ig ,h t o imis s o v re no o t o u r u g n. e pi . o . l Sant Cl a V ly Tr ns Age y, lF. 91 925( h Ci. 1 . 7 a ar ale a p. nc 26 3d 2, 9t r 200 ) 1 8 B. Rul 12() e c I 9 TARert pl ngsar cl ed buteary enough nott del t i a pary m ay m ove ' he eadi e os l o ay ral t i I l I 1 / i I j ( 2 f j dgmen ont pla ngs,Fe R.Ci P.1 c.Th sa r go ni aRul j c 0 or u t he e di . d. v. 2() e tndads ver ng , e 2() 21 motonar t e s mea t os go r nga Rul 1 b ( moton. eDwor i v Hu te i e h a s h e ve ni e 2( )6) i Se kn . s lr 2 Ma zie l ,86 F. 11 ,ll (t Ci.1 (I prncpal fee e.. i tetmeof 2 ga n , nc. 7 2d 88 92 9h r 989) I The i i difrnc .s h i 23 flng.( h motonsar f nci l i ntc ...'. ii T)e i e u tonal de ial .) y ' 24 C. Rul 1 b) 1 e 2( ( ) 25 F er c rsa eo lmie i idito pos e si oni t e p sgr n e b t ed al ou t r f i td urs c in, s s ng y hos ower a t d y he Page 3 of 9 ' ' i i i i ' l Con tttonan satt.beUnie at v Mara,5 F.d799 8I ( hCi. )(iai s siui d t ue ve ' tdst es . k 30 3 , 0 9t r2008 ctton 2 omit ) Thepat a sri fdea j iditonbe st bude o oveco n t ted . ry se tng e rlurs ci ar he r n f r mig he ' . 3 prs tona i ti. k nv Gua dinLfcls Co.o ,5l U. 375, ( 99 . e umpi gans tKok one . r a / n . fAm. 1 S. 377 1 4) ' i 4 Fe rlRul o ci lPr e e1 b)1 prvi sanafr tvedee evi amotont dimis dea e f vi oc dur 2( () o de fimai fns a i o s s j ' ! I 5 f Ickofs j c matrj rs ci Se Fe R. v.P.l b () Addii ly, c r ma or a ube t te uiditon. e d. Ci 2() 1. tonal a ou t y ' ! : 6 r s t quetonofs be tmatr urs cins as ea a tmedu igpe de yofa aie he si uj c te j idito u pont t ny i rn n no n E 7 a ton.uni ausv uo e uorlo,3 I. sI 8 (t ci. ) -wq e afdea ci udst . r no- il 34 r3d 9, 30 9i r2003 . - h n e rl , l ' . 8 c r c u sta iIck s j c- ter u iditon,t coutmus dimist c ai i ou t onclde h t ta s ube tmat j rs ci he r t s s he ompl ntn : . 9 isen iey. Ar gh v Y Cor ,5 U. 500, 4 ( )( ii I J M oor e al, t tr t ' bau . &H p. 46 S. 51 2006 ctng 6 . ' et . I ; , 1 Moor sFe r PrciejI 66() p l - 8t l 8 (de 2 52. 0 e deal a tc 06. 1, p. 06 8 o 06-9 3 d. 00 4 1 1 D. 1 2 l Ruls1 b)5)and 4( e 2( ( m) Und rRul 1 b() ac ai c nbedimisdf f lr t pr e l s rea e e 2()5 , ompl nt a s se or aiue o op ry ev i : ! ; I de e an wih p oc s .Rul 4( r quiesdim is f rf iu et s v t s 3 f nd t t r e s e m) e r s s al o a lr o er e he ummonsa nd i : 1 com pl ntw ihi 1 days ofGlng t com pl nt unl sgood caus i show n f t f l e. 4 ai t n 20 i he ai , es es or he aiur ; i 1 H1 5 . ANA LY SI S ! 1 6 Asat rs odmatrJ d eAd msh s u iilmmu i f r cin lk ni hs he h l te, u g a a j dca i nt o a t s e n i y o ( I ! i I j di a c pa t Hei i 7 u cil a ci y. s mmun fom t equ pr e toncli Th rmai n cl msae e k be al otci am. e e nig ai r ! i ' 18 concl y and wilbe di ised f f i e t s e a cl m , asw el. A lo,s alD ef usor l sm s or aiur o mt ai l s ever endant s 1 ha e n be n pr ry s l d,a d ne t rt EEOC no f m e G ov r Gi ns i hi 9 v ot e ope l ewe n ihe he r or r e nor bbo n s i I 2 o f ij a a i ma b s e . 0 fi a c p ct y e u d c y 21 A. Judi alIm m uniy ci t 22 J e a dc rsha ab olt ci li udg s n out ve s ue vi mmuniyf t ij ci a s icldi t or her udi al ct,n u ng 23 i mmuniyfom 4 U. C. 1 3cl ms a r ga dls ofa erone a i tonoft i t r 2 S. j 98 ai , nd e r e s ny r ous pplcai he aw, 2 u e st ya ti at larab e ce'ofs jctmater uiditon. u 3 S k ,435U. 4 nls he c n ' e s n ' ube - l j rs ci Stmp ' parman c . S. 25 3 356- 8(978 ( tngBr ltv Fihe ,8 U. 335( 8 I) Pli ifsCompl nti 49, . l ) cii adeê . s r 0 S. 5 I 7 ). antf ai s Page4 of 9 ' i j ( I ' ' p . t , E E ' I 1 based on t alegedl wr he l y ongf i posii ofs i agai thi ,nota l oft cour ' ul m ton anctons ns m ack he ts 2 j iditonov teund l ngmat ort a lyt i esnci .Ne da' Ditit urs ci er h eryi ter he bii o mpos a tons va s src t E i 3 coursha urs cinove cvimat s a t si l st a lt t is ealwrt pr er t vej idito r i l ter, nd hi ncude he biiy'o su l is op ! 4 an ne e sr frisc eee rie Ne Cons. r. jj1 6() Pl nifha c ncl orl d c say o t omplt xecs . v. tat6, , 1. aitf s o us iy i i j i , t 5 alge alckof uidito i hi rs ons t Co aitd snotale ea y Ickof le d a j rs cin n s e p e he mpi n oe lg n a ' 6 j idito bu heha note ai dwhyb t n ter wasalckof urs ci l ta h urs cin t s xpl ne e hiks h e a j iditon. nse d, e ! : j p I . ' 7 h c e i hi r s ons t dic st os - t alM or boun i ' a pe ce ve hit i l as hos n n s e p e o s us l s cul cr ur al dares' nd r i d sorca ' 8 wr ongst oughoutsoci y atl ge. He a s mak s a gu e sabo t Tr a y ofG u da u hr et ar lo e r m nt ut be e t a l pe i 1 ' I . ; 9 H i go and r dal ecount i dent ofr alt on i t Unied St es.N one oft s i r evantt s nci s aci ensi n he t at hi s el o I p : I ' ' 11 causesofacton m us be dim i ed ast hi . tI entonalr alaggr onr'asPj ntf put i, i t s ss o m 'nt i aci essi ' ai ir s t 1 l t fc t tJ geAda i a oltl i net ci lIa lt f hij cal tons an aI 0 he a tha ud ms s bs uey mmu o vi ibiiy or s udii aci , d l j I ' ! j ' 1 i n a e e i t t j ca i 2 s ot n xc pton o he udiilmmuniydo ti . t crne Furher e,t t ext Pl ntf eanst appealt s i or diecty t t s t mor o he ent ai ifm o he anctons der r l o hi ' I ! 1 Court t Courtcannotent ai hi cas Congr hasnotpr ded t U . D it i Cour 4 ert n s e. ess ovi he S. s rct t , he , 1 3 j i E I I ' l wiha elaej rs ci ov tesaec t. eU. Cons.a t11û2'Ex on.l?s Cor 5 t pp lt u iditon er h tt ours Se S. t, r. 1, , x &'A' p. ( / ' i E I v Sau Ba i ldu.Cor 5 U. 280, 4( )(ii Rook rv Fi T us Co.263U. 6 . di sc n s y, 44 S. 28 2005 ctng e . d. r t , S. ' ! ' 1 l 4l ( 9 , C.Cou to pe l v Fedman, U. 46 (1 :.Pl nifmus a ea t 7 3 1 23)D. . r fAp as . l 460 S. 2 983 aitf t pp lhe ! ! ! ! I I 1 s nc i nst t e x e ad sup e e cou a t n,i he l e , tton t e unie st e supr e 8 a to o h v a rm u, nd he f os s pe ii h t d at s em 19 cour f a w rtofceri ari t br i tor . 20 B. Sover gn I m uniy ei m t 21 N ext ast EEO C cor ecty not Congr has notw ai s ei i m uniy t , he r l es, ess ved over gn m t o 22 per i a sui agai t EEOC f aleged neglgence i i mt t nst he or l i n nvestgatng char See.e. ,Smih v. i i ges. g. t 2 Ca el ,11 F. 3 3 ( C.Ci.,c r. nid. 52 U. I 37 ( 997) An f mer 3 s las 9 3d 3, 4 D. r) c /de e , 2 S. 0 1 . d or 2 Gove norG i onsc r c l no e t a h i no h e i plc t d i t e bod oft Com pl i a 4 r bb or e ty t s h t e s w er m i a e n h y he a nt s 25 ha ngc te an ci lwr gs ev nasu ngh di no ej i ni und te vi ommitd y vi on , e s mi e d t noy mmu t er h y Pa 5 o 9 ge f i . i ( t ' l * ; E ' : i ' i ! 1 El event Am endm enti hi om ci capaciy,w hi he does. The Cour di is as agai t h n s al t ch t sm s es ns 2 hi f t m or hese addii tonalr ons, eas 1 ! 3 c I ! 4 NERC a dii alyagu t tiha n ve b npopel sr e a t ttmef s r c d ton l r es ha t s e r ee r ry e v d nd ha i or evie ! es he ame gum n t e p c o br 5 las expied. M c w m ak t s ar e tw ih r s e tt A l o. pl ntf a r ai irhasent ed er I l l 6 v rouss a i ummons si ot rc d.Se Summon e,ECFNos 6t 6-0) Pl niftldte e nt he e or ( e ss . o l . aitf ie h 7 compl nton Fe ua y9, 2010,and t r f e had untlJ 9,2010 t s rve Def ndant w ih ai br r he e or i une o e e s t 1 I pr rse ie m ope rvc 8 c pi oft Summonsa d compl n . cFe R.Ci P. m) A r t r ofs r c a a si o es he n ait Jc d. v. 4( . e u n e vie ppe r n 9 t rc dale ngs r c up J W is b dei r t Ed r Wona bu t r i no he e or lgi evie on oy lon y ivey o wad j , t hee s 1 i caton t t per on acceptng s vi w asaut i t acceptser ce f t per 0 ndi i hat he s i er ce horzed o vi or he son 1 s mmonsd.( ePrc sRe eitandReur ECFNo.7.Th s mei tu f Jme W is 1 u e Se o es c p t n, ) e a s re or a s lon l a J eAd ms( e ECFNos 9,l1 . Al o' s 2 nd udg a Se . ) br s ummon wa r t m e un xe t ( eeECF s s e u d e cued. S l No.1 ) W on M o r teEEOC,MCW,lhi r Gi ons a NERC, 3 4 . j a, ntoy,h s mau, bb , nd howev r a a t e, ppe r o 1 ha be npe s alys r d o s v d t ou t i a nt. Se ECFNos 8,1 l l l 33, 4 ve e r on l e ve r er e hr gh her ge s ( e . 0, 2, 3, 5, 1 34) 5 . 16 M C W ' m oton t di i f i pr S i o sm ss or m operser ce ast A l o w ilbe gr ed,asPl ntf vi o br l ant ai if 17 hasnotshown good caus f hi f l e t s ve her N ERC appearst have been ser e or s aiur o er . o ved,buti t 1 ar ue t atPl n ifh s f ie t s r e t a i s r tve he d o N ERC . Se vi e w a m a on 8 g s h ai tf a a ld o e v he dm nit a i a f r c s de 1 Aprl29z 0t S akLe le Sr De yAG'a tec tlbuidi i Cas Ciy.S ECF 9 i 20I o ' r si, . put Cl ' t h apia l ng n ron t (ee 20 No,3 .A saece tdgov n nt or niainmus bes re bys vieont c e 4) tt-rae erme al ga z to t ev d er c he hif 21 e c ieofie (h g r r orby t ma e pr s ie by s e 1w f s l ig s c a xe utv fc r t e ove no ) he nn r e crb d mt a or ew n u h 22 d end nt Fe R. v.P. ()A) B) Th r i noe de ef merGov r Gi swa ef a . d. Ci 4()2( -( . ee s vi nc or enor bbon s 23 per onaly ser s l ved. Forsat agenci N evadar r s vi on bot t Ator G ener and te es, equies er ce h he t ney al 24 t lper on ser ng i t of ce ofadm i s r i head oft nam ed agency.'N ev.Rev.Smt he : s vi n he fi nitatve he ' . 25 j4l0312)a-() Theei noevien eteh adofNERC wa s r d.Pli ifha nots own . ( () b. r s d c h e s eve antf- s h Page 6 of 9 . ' ' J . ! I . . ' i 1 : ! ! I 1 i ! l ood e or he aiur i y es o he i g caus f t f l e and hasnottm el r ponded t t m oton Th Co rgatNE S e ut rns RC' . in o s s 2 moto t dimis . 3 D. T be M e is rt . 4 Fis t bra ofc ta tcai a ns t EEOC a NERC alge no c ta t rt he e ch onr c l m gai t he nd le s on r c. 5 Pl n ifc ai t tt s or nia i sa eu rt fe a h vepolcisma ng i di cul aitf ompl ns ha he e ga z ton r nde saf d nd a i e ki t m t . 6 f hi t obt n t r i he s or m o ai he elef eeks. Thes ar gener i grevancest tdo nots e e alzed i ha uppor t 7 sa di fra c niabl cam.Asd fom Pl ni sc ncls ya srinofa Qua i tn ng o ny og z e li ie r aitm o u or se to s8 contactagr entand/ i pled contact,t e ar no f spl i catng t exit r / eem or m i r ,,her e act ed ndi i he sence of ! l I i l j I I ! 9 any cont act The Cour dim i est scause ofac i r . t s ss hi ton. I0 Second, t ne i n mir pr e a in cl m a ais t EEOC a NERC doe no he glge t s e es ntto ai g n t he nd s t l alg a yflesae n o fc.l Ne a a acam frn giet se rsnainrq ie: l l e n as ttme t fat n v d , li o e l n mirpee tt e urs e g o l 2 l 3 ' '4 1 1 arprs n1 i ta if s 2 t tt rprs nttonwa ma i t c s of ) e e e mton h t s ale; ) ha he e e e ai s de n he oure ted fn a ts u ie s i a ya t ni whc h h s c nayitrs; ) h h ee d n 1 b sn s orn n ci n ih e a aje u ir neet3 te o rp ee tt nwa f rteg ia c o o h r i terb sn s ta s cin ; )te e rs nai s b h ud n e f tes n h i u les rn a t s 4 h o o rpeehainwapasianlrtetuede5ndatf hrlneesleaipblnay es sn t yi sutf by)ldho ;et tu lei c rs tdn eu ir r t o j ti ei pn )h sce o xeci e onac ae a a u ls t terl ng ry; d6 ha t f an ai dt e r er s ec r o o e orc ee ei o ai ngorcommu c tngtei or to omp tnc n bt ni niai h nf main. 1 5 G K La V gasLt . P ' p v Si Prp. y, nc, F. s e d s hi . mon o Gr l 460 Supp. 1 1 ( Ne 2d 246, 262 D. v. I6 2006 ( r J) Unde Rul 9() cicu onc scontt i fau ormit emutbes ed ) Eza, .. r e b , r ms e siutng r d sak s lt 17 wihpariulrt Fe R. v.P. b.Thi ha b enc tue t r r apl nirt çsae t tc aiy. d. Ci 9() s s e onsr d o equie aitf o 'tt I8 pr ciel t tm e, a e an na ur oft e m il a ng sa emen s m i r es nmton a d s e fc e s y he i pl c d t e h s e di t t t , s epr e i s n p cii 1 9 a t o fa ' Ka an v Ros 49 F. l 1 0 ( t Ci.1 4) A pli ifmus pladf cs cs f r ud. pl . e, 3d 363, 37 9 h r 99 . antf ' t e at 20 s a t eb uch s : ough ahous f om de e n , ha t d en nta s e hi t ti wa i pe f c h t er f nda t t t he ef da s ur d m ha t s n re t 2I s hape,and t i f t hous t ned outt be buiton a l il....'Fbr-/tu'v.Xom a hat n act he e ur o l andf l ' çlz 22 Cor ,7 F. 955, (t Ci 1 96 ( i l r GlnFe l .Se .Lii , F. l 41 p. 4 3d 960 9h r 9 ) quotng n e e d,nc c t 42 3d 5 , g. 23 1 ( hCi.1 4)(nb c) Th pl nilmu taloee f t a e pl ai a t whyte 548 9t r 99 e an l. e aitf- s s ' t orh n x an ton s o s h 24 sa e e orom is on c pl i d ofw a f s a m i la n ' l r G l Fe I . . t , t t m nt s i om a ne s ale nd se di g.' n e en d. nc Sec Lii g. 25 Page 7 of 9 I d I I 1 ' ' ( i i i i ! 1 42 F. d a 1 48. Pl n ifale sonl t tt EEOC a N ERC f ie t i o m hi t tt y 3 t5 ai tf l ge y ha he nd a l d o nf r m ha he ! 2 wer under t f and under e s af ed funded,and t t salo cons iut a br hat hi s tt ed each ofcontact Even i r . f ! I ! . 3 such an om isi wer a m ateroff as oppos t opi on,Pl ntf s on e t act ed o ni ai ircannothave r i on eled l l ! I 4 such an om isi t hi det ment He alegest he w oul haveexpl ed ot s r egi t s on o s ri l hat d or her tat es o . ! l i ; 5 e oc hi rghs Butonl t EEOC a NERC c ni talya j diaedic i n to cl ms nfre s i t y he nd a nii l d u c t srmiain ai . 6 Pl ntf cannothave Gl a cl m i cour diecty w ihoutfis fii i w ih t EEOC or ai i ed ai n t r l t r t lng t t he ! ' ! l i . l . I 7 N ERC . Alo,he alegesno dam agesf om t saleged r i s l r hi l elance. The Courtdi i es t scause sm ss hi ' 8 ofacton. i . 9 I Thid,Pl ntf ai sdef aton,butm er y r t t el ent oft cl m . He r ai ifci m am i el ecies he em s he ai ! j i I I i i d i lI i plc t d oru rw hi c tt ton san r t e cour m u tde e m i t s m ci nc of m iae nde ch ons iu i al t da d h t s t r ne be u e y - i j I l ' j 1 ie tfe n p riuird fmao' sae ns s i i n t n wnwhc Dee d nsae 0 d niis o at a ea tl ttme t, o ts o k o c y ih fn a t r ' 12 t alegatons becaus s at he l i , e t ement i plcatng m ater ofpublc i porance r r a mor sm i i ts i m t equie e 1 e c i s da d ofco tt i s u iy t a t et a do n , e r e sofwhehe a 3 xa tng mn r nsiutonal cr tn h n hos h t ot r ga dls tr . . 1 4 pli ifi ap iaeo publcGgue.Heprs mabl grundst cl m ont j di alsnci s antf s rv t r i r eu y o he ai he u ci a ton 1 orer Su a or rc no b t s j c ofadea toncli TheCour dimis t s 5 d . ch n de an t e he ube t fmai am. t s ses hi 16 caus ofacton. e i l7 Fourh,Pl ntf cl m s IED butaleges no physcalmaniest i ofs e em otonal t ai if ai I l i f atons ever i 1 dite ss ppori s ch a cl i . Hi cl i i a r cia i n oft c e ofac i a wil 8 sr s u tng u am s a m s e t to he aus ton nd l be I dim i ed. 9 s ss 20 Fit Pl n ifcl i san i son ofhi prv y b no h r i t Com pl ntale s fh, ai tf a m nva i s i ac ut w e e n he ai l ge 2 I f s m aki pl bl s an i r on. The caus ofacton i concl y,and t Cour act ng ausi e uch nt usi e i s usor he t 22 di ises i. sm s t 23 Si h,Pl ntf cl m st tous i erer xt ai if ai ori nt f ence wih pr pectve econom i advant buthe t os i c age, 24 alegesno f t maki s a cl m pl bl Thealegatonsdo noteven r t t necess y l ac s ng ucb ai ausi e. l i ecie he ar 25 el ent oft scaus ofacton. Pl ntf aleges onl t he ent ed i o a busi r atons p em s hi e i ai if l y hat er nt ness el i hi Page 8 of 9 l w ih a t r pary and antci ed an econom i advant t efom . A par f om t tte oft t hid t i pat c age her r t r he il he 2 cl m ,i i noteven cl whet Pl ntf meanst pl i er er ai t s ear her ai if o ead nt f ence w ih contact r atons t r ual el i 3 orw ih pr pectve ec t os i onom i advant c age. The Courtdim i est scl m . . s ss hi ai 4 Fi aly,Pl ntf ha m ad no a l ga i i t e b oft Com pl n t tM CW ,A l o, n l ai if s e le tons n h ody he ai t ha br 5 M ontoy,orM ontoy' em pl r r s oyeeshave com m it any ci lwr ted vi ongs. 6 7 CO N CLUSIO N I I HEREBY ORDERED t tt eM oton t Dimis( Nos I 32, 42,59 TS ha h i s o s s ECF . 6, 40, ) 8 a t eM o i f J dgme ont e Pla ngs( No. )a eGRANTED. nd h ton or u nt h e di ECF 21 r 9 I I FURTHER ORD ERED t t M oton f Leave t Fie an Am ended Respons T S hat he i or o l e 1 ( No.37 a dMoto t Exen Ti ( Nos 49,61 63, ar DENI 0 ECF )n ins o t d me ECF . , 64) e ED. 11 I I SO O RDERED . T S I 2 ' l Da e t s 1 h dav ofJanuar 2011. 3 t d hi 4t v. l 4 15 ' RO Unied t 16 17 I8 l 9 20 2l 22 23 24 25 Page 9 of 9 T C .J ES ON t D it i J es s rct udge '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
