-RAM Kroshus et al v. United States of America, et al, No. 3:2009cv00713 - Document 294 (D. Nev. 2011)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING Defendants Re/Max Realty Professionals and Judy Ashton's 231 Motion for Good Faith Determination, each party to bear their own attorneys' fees and costs. All claims, whether known or unknown, against Re/Max Realty and Judy Ashton for contribution and/or equitable indemnity are hereby extinguished. Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 11/15/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
FIED L ENTERED qucrj yyn sEqggoON COUN UP ISoFR SE ARTE EcoRa MI CHAEL E S . TOBERj ES KA Q. Ne a aBa No 0 4 6S ESQ. vd r 07 2 ZACHARY AYHOMP ON, Ngy jj z j gj Neva BarNo.011 da 001 OLSON,CAN NON ,GO RM LEY & DESRUI SSEAU 9950 W estCheyenneA venue La Vega N evada 89129 e u s (0)34k0 2ozc 72 8- 1 f e 8Y : CL tsDl cTcouRT ERK l sTRl DI RI OFNE OA ST CT VA ---.. D.EU -L DPW -=: . - ( 02)3 7 83 0701f x a msobes o oc c t rki gd.om Ator ysf Def t ne or endant RE/ A X REALTY s M and J D Y ASI ON I W UNI TED STATESDJ STRI COURT CT DI STR I O F NEVA DA W X * * ** < ' * i ; p I z J > . 5. Q Qlj ge ao Y#':.'x > j U' 'M X t :u,' . %tt,,! ztel u 2=! zy d j. : <p y'z ( & o ai! Z)z f o xm .o A ? 'Ar .: -A e z . . 3 K - Q z R ' n @ w 5 Q J KROS ; L ADAY S SHARON UDY HUS BI L ON; DONNA ON; LAR ; '. LU HEATI G . ADAMSAGUI IM RyHI AGUIAR; PANFLO 'PECH LN & Al aDi so ofSpa klnHome ; EMMSLY K viin rc i sJ ALM ARI LORI O; LLEE BA BCOCK ; THOM A S BAI E;AM AND A BA I E; LI LI THOM A S an d AMANDA BAI E,n hiu l a do b h l o L id z yl n n e af f d y BE ; r hl BECK;OHN a d E;MIN termio c io E ZABERH BAIUOL 4 h i n EEN LI J CK COL d nLI J N EE BECK ,i vi ly and on behal oft rm i ndi dua l f hei nor e l aSEANDM BECL BENNAFI hid T I VESTM ENTS; ENNI BLAI BEVERLY N D S R; BLAI WI AM BORRELLI RACI ' R; LLI ; NE BR ADY- ARTI M NEZ;SRY VE BRONA UGH ; J ENNI BRONAUGH; FER STSVE a nd J ENNI FER BRON AUGH ,i vi l and on ndi dualy -RAM Kroshus et al v. United States of America, et al CA SE N O .3: cv09- 0071 3 be al oft ei mi rc l ySTERLI h f h r no hid NG Doc. 294 BRONAU G H ;M A RK CA RA ;J 4N CAU LK ; OI MARTI QUE CAULK;J NI OHN à nd MARTm I CAULK,idi du hr n on QUE n vi al a d b ha foft i m i oro l e J e l he r n hidr n, ARED HI RES CAULL J OHN HI CAULK a 'AYLOR RES nd F HI CAULK;SCOW ' RES CHAPMAN;J ANET CHAPM AN ;EV ERER' A.Cl O ;T0M W , T R1 CO OK I KA THLEEN M .COOK ;J ES I; AM CRUTCHEF;BRANDY CRUTCHER; AM ES J a BRAN DY CRU TCHER,i di du i a on nd n vi al nd y b ha foftli m i c l e y AKE CRUTCF ER e l lc r nor hidr n J I a d M ACK I N ON CRUTCH ER; GELA n N AN DA N I W I A M T. EL; LLI DANI AN GELA a EL; nd W I AM T.DAN I i vi l and on LLI EL, ndi dualy be l o t i m i rc l e ha f f he r no hidr nuR i l A AN DAN I a VAN CE DANI DOUGLAS D . EL nd EL; DAVI RAM ONA DAVI W I AM K. S; S; LLI DA W S;DI ANE R.D AVI W I AM K . S; LLI Pa è 1o 6 g f Dockets.Justia.com ORDER GRANTI YG D EFENDAN TS R E/ AX REALTY M PROFESSI N ALS AN D JUDY O A SH TO N ' M OTI N FO R GO O D S O FAITH D ETERM I NATI N O ' i . DAVI lnfDIi mi orchidY idCI ulya d Sa d he R. l FELIvd al n ANE DAVI n ii R. On b afo i r n eh A DAVI JWE S;. NDELLDAVf; S LORRMNEC. DAV I PAM ELA M . ERR'JOIl E. S; DO , ' N DOIM; 4 DONNA L. DOHM ; ATRI DUYLE; P CK LORIDOY LE; TRI a d LORIDO YLE, PA CK n i vi l and on behal oft rm i chidr ndi dualy f hti nor l en, J SH UA DO YI. acd TANNA DO YLE; O E SH ERRE GONZALES; EREM Y GOTTLI J EB; W ARREN GRAY;BA RBA RA GRAY;DA RYY R.GROVER, R.DARYL R. J ; GROVEK J , R. i vi l and on behal ofhi ninorchidj ndi dualy f s i l PATRI GROVER'RI CK , CHARD HAR GETT; LI DA H ARG EW ;RO SEM M Y HI I S; N GG N ROLF G.HODM P; I IAEL A, M CI HUM PHREY;KI JAM ES;M I M CHAEL JONES; KI .TA J ES; AN FRED J II ON M URG EI J T; EAN I E RJ RGEI LYNN KAN TOR;DAN K ANTOR; T; E LI NDA KANTOR;BRANDON KNAPP; i ë T AX;U TN;USH RNONC E I K C JNA PJ Cm K K OH RE R YKS P adTE I X; NO In E X l 2 x : z: idvd al a do b h lo termio c i, n iiu l n n e af fh i n r hi y d coM KNox; LI KNOX;SUZANNE PHI P V>.> N* ' GRQG C # z1 l Esnc R L NE; o m Lm DE EI L ' BVt J NM ER; EO L DENMBI xAxcv LI NMEI Y ER; NDE ER; LEZLI M .LUCAS;J E ASON E. - MARI CH; DAVI C MARSHALL; D LEROY MARX; tERov Ml.. i viual ma onb hafo hi ax ndi d ly d e l f s :1 : 1x k t 1 td Jj 4j l v .z ' LC tG 1 p j = . , Kxox;ULI IANE; L J E - DAN Aws(N; ) LollAfl L tt hE AwsoN. LI L /LES E EVEREW ; . mio c i , E TNYMAR ME ANI n r hl D j I d X; L E Mcr e ;HI ARY MU GHT;K ATHLEEN Mc DAM; ESLBY M CKN I ROBERT A LL ADAM; W M CK NI GHT;GARY R.M EI KLE;CARM EN M EI . LARRY M EI KIE; KLE; TERAJM EI KLE; RJCHA RD M EPPEN;FRED M ESI BETIY ; ' M ESI ERI M ESI DEN N I M ORELLI ; C ; S ; M ARCI M OXELLI DI W E M ORSE; A ; AA. BRU CE E. AGEL;J N EAN NEW E M . AGEL; N J SEPH NEFF; ELI O M SSA N EFF)J SEPI a O ' nd I M ELI SSA N EFF,i i dua l a on be l of nd vi ly nd ha f t i m i orc id e SEAN K N EFF a he r n h l r na nd K ATELYN N EFF; DRI N ORI A AN EGA ;M A RY N ORI A;ADRI a d M A RY N ORI EG AN n EGA, i vi l and on bçhal bft rm i chidr ndi dualy f hei nor l en, ASA N ORI A ,AD RI A N ORI A , EG AN EG AlD l EW NORI q t EGA a d AU S N N ORI n TI EGA ; TRAV I PA W ERSON ; ENN S J RFER PAW ERSON ; AN PEAVEY;CP BRI JSTI NA PEREZ;CHARLES J PRES ELL;RU SSELL L. . N PUCKETT; PABLO QUI NTERO;PABLO QUI NTERO à dJ n EMMELY ALM ARI O, i i d l a d on be l oft i m i c l r n, nd vi ual n y ha f hè r nor hid e J ADREA QUI EM NTER0!J ESSAL'N ' Y QUI RO a PABLO F.QUm TERO,J ; NW nd R. Page 2 of6 ' . @ ' I 1 ' . J ESREED; AM TERESA REED; AM ESa J nd ) 2 Te E AREi rniiv lado Andaf f S ) t imio c D, dvdI yR EnbhALEM ) h r S r hl e JJ AN n D e lo ER n Edi IL E REED; BERTREZSMA; ATRI A P CI ' ) 3j REI NSMA; ES RODRI J US GUEZ; MONI CA RODRI GUEZ;J ESUSa MONI nd CA z j .=' 1 5' 6 ' 1 RODRI GUEZ&idi d l N d onbe a foft e r n viualy hl hi mi rchid etGuEz;RODRI J Gutz; no Roof,J lr nlESUS LI Room J GI EA Ro J osuE BNI sm l RODRI A GUEZ;FRANK RocsRs; J TH RoGsRs;Ilf M . As;GLORI UDI ars Rol A M Rol Lt J Rol PATRI A A. As; ns . As; CI ROJ GARY ROM A; LANE RosE, I AS; H. I; . a D . tz ' I E B Ol kl Su U l j x o A su s o ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ' . ' . . . . , ohlSIDRRjDvdDltdDa af ) A DHEEo-;AlllEo ; l ) v Lts AiiujaLnQh SJ iVSjs'' ; oSn Isjo l ; dYayns fi 1 0 j . . ) ' ) 9 S ELDS; èIs - u ; HI DANI - ofAcl BARBARX D. ) o smi o l ' xkAl sE HopE nor hid A nr 1 j j ). ) i z 1 j sl -t,lomspllphlcTILE & 1 c uccf- x; stAcl c m pNsnlcr ;pu N o luhHo l l l c f a j . spEccul J EPH A SPECCHI r ; o; OS O JR. g 5 . I , ' ) ) STON E;scorr spn cKf - ' u p Q 1t sn c t ; EY S -lPNS;ESoxs ) . 21 p K m wESL 1Al D NI TY ) fkrE vAul q MI ; :lw . j sru-oNs; LEY adM1 y s S ? .I '/ l WES tj . n ) a , , 1 ' 4 1 I idvdalado bhlo te mio ci , 1%E -1 n iiul n n eaf fhi nr hl 1' 4 1 y r d $1 . 11 ANGELI B. 'v l ; CA sr oxs RANDAIL ' P 1 I s- s sr vl sr s DA D 4' a Aga ; ' E ' g AuB ; VI . PI I si 'puAx; mo s E uE oAvl ad r u a T p x; o n j jq , j II STEP qx ; 5! D 1 ; 1 tNDAn r hlrfidvE alE doXe afo 6 l r o cHAN,HAL u l a HA b h l f wimi i eln iiYS n n ad d . d yP T n ol' STEPHAN;m w A.o fsTEvsxs; ! x f l r t t ! I J . l s'svsxs;DERBK.Av op; L ' cop E r eq ' . - ! . ' 1 l JNNIE T yL R; E adJNNIE 7 ' FR A , . K n ' FR E o DER E 1 8 . ) ' ) ) I ) ) ) j j , 1 ) ' . ) ) TAYLOK idiiual a do b afo t i n vd ly n n eh l f hèr ' lt t olTox; l n l n. oclM t l p M n aocKs ol-ox; t kr . ) - ) I mio c ide IABELTAYLORadcohhoR ) n r hlrm S n ri TAyf R; èHAETTE m MI - ETER; M KI .) 1 9 BEATON MdKYLETHROCKMOYTON; I 1. 22 ) ) VAIGHAN>i ii alya onbe afo/he J ndvdu l nd hl r mi c l e , nor hidr n TOM M Y HAYES a AUSTI nd N Y A U G HA N ;W ES WyR(W ARN ; ozAW E . R I W ARN;BARBARA WI LSON a ROBERT nd WI LSON,onbe l oft e evesan a1 o h r ha f h ms l d l îe Pero smia l st ae , s ns i lry iu td ' 23 ' . 2 4 2s ' . . . .. . 26 . ' .' . v. 27 . . . . Pli il éntfk, . ' ' . 2 8 ;. . 1 j ) DAVI M .TRI VI NI TRJ D PP; RGI A pp; J ENNI VAIGHAN;J FER J ENNI FER l 1 . . . . j . DEP UNIED S NTOFTHE1 ERI T TATE OFAME%N AC ARTME S NR OR J . . , . . 1 . ' . ' .' . ' . . ' ' . j . . . , . .. ) tru hi ) ho g t s . . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) . . 2 KdoneIf >hei mi rRrp,niiul ) 0 I abJM' t o lno chidrni vday ) M ndblof r t - k BRAD l a r c Mo oe d l 21 . I . . . Pa e. of6 $3 . , . . . I l ' . 1' I BUREAU OF RECLAM ATI ON MI PXCII D- FC ) REGI CARSON CI OFFI KEN ON, TY CE, 'sAt se r tr oft l e i q KENNE'H c ea y be ntro I ' ) ) S 2 l 31 P eau DicomatonCIsnCi Omo o te ) ' AR fr tao te 'ro t CARSON R, ec r fh a y e fb ) Bur o Re l i , RUCKEE- j . 4I I 5I 1 ) ) ) ) BI CRI DEVELOPM E ,NC.V POI SP NT I , NT ENGE NEERI AKA 'R C ENGI NG I NEERI G, N ) ) 9j ' I GATI DI CT, RRI ON STRI DAVI P, ' D OVERVOLD, W OFFERNLEY, CI COUNTY OF L N, YO CHRH, ; LTD.GARY HUTCHI . NGS RI CHARD HUTCO GS,C. . I A L.NNESTMENT MIHA LTNUG KE,TB R EIA T ) mC. ER I A XL ESONETBD R . ) C, BD RA DYROE R A T MA LY =! PROPERTIj zl UOUOUwlNC L ) i NEVADADjjTj,SCSRS.O ,OY, j EL II BUI u SmTEVEPCsP A ) IRC4 E LDER C N TN F CAMP , Tr 1 . . , REM AX REAITv , UDY ASHTON , , J DAN 1 1 A RS L RE T adC DWE L 0 NDE ON L AL Y,n OL L , 1 E j B NKE (e l ,eaa, A R Fre Nvd) ny 1' 1 ë . l . !1!. ,j j 2I '1-2 13I Q1 ' l1: ' ' : . 1I 1 z s ll 1 lgt j 1 ' l 4 ) ) ' ) D e endant . f s ! h 'I ) I ' j' 1 ) 1 ! , l ou cux co Fx x a Ir luR l nx ss o x.k h s s ux REAI'V puoFss l -' I s oxAssxxo z As r s uov uroN' MoTl IoR cooo F TH OETERMT OX ox ? AI NATI 1j s j*> q x : j , l oeed nsRsxlav p ss l -, c. on uiesa ls- xx RsAuzv rn a t - Rop soxAr m d igb sns s' s . i - j : . . p l ( j 1 POES NL(.M XRayreia'adU Y STNS'so' : 6 RFSI AS'E A etPfsnl)nJD AHO ' Ahn) j O R/ l oso s ( t Q 5 ' j 1 7 1 8 (oleci el ' M A. Re t Pr e so l De e n s' M otonf Go Faih Deer n tö c l tv y ' RW X aly of s ina/ f nda t' ) i or od t t mi a in ha i c o f h a i gon te 2 d y o J y, 1 ,Za hay J n omps n, Es of t 1 w yng ome n or e rn h 91 a f ul 20 1 c z . o q. he a 1 9 Gr OLSON,CAN NON , m GORM LEY & D ESRUI SSEA L X a pm rng on be l o t e RE/ AX T p ii ha f f b M 2 0 Rel Prfsin l Dee d nsa dRo et j o o telw f o M-ODOX& at oeso as fn at, n b rMa d x fh a i f A y nn 21 ASSOCI ATES, l n R. . Ca vi X Dunl p, t fnn ofDUN LAP & LAX ALT, Eu e Le ry, a of he i g ne ve t 2 2 LEVERTY & ASSOCI ATES, be tHa e oft Gnn HXGER & HEARNE, and Lee Ro r g r he 2 3 Hoi lki s q.p e rn o b l l o tePanifcas a dteCo r h vn o n iee te o t ns Es a p aig n el f f h lit ls, n h ut a ig o sd rd h a f 2 4 pa r a pl a ngsb fl he ei a ha ng h a d o a a g l'e t pe s nd e di n ie r n, nd vi e r r l r tm n , ' . ' . . 2 5 26 2 7 28 . ' . . I I HEREBY ORDERED , T S ADJUD GED AND DECREED t a : ht . 1' . . The Cou thm c s d r d t f c or dic s d i Ve s c lChe c Co p . v. r s on i e e he a t s s us e n l i q mi al r Davd on,1 Ne 356 811P. 5 I( 991. is 07 v. , 2d 6 1 ) . ' Page 4 of6 . ' l . 1 j ' ' . . I j l 1 . hCutacnirdh f osi sei h Dcos ..icn 2 d c c c ,0 '1l Nev '2 Te orhsoseeteatrdsusdnTe otr'ovVnel1 j l j l . 2 . 64 692, P.d681 687(00 . 4, 98 3 , 2 4) . 3' ' 3 . Th Co rhsc niee tefcosdsusdi *GM Grh Hoe Fie 5 0. I e ut a o sd rd h atr ic se n a d tl rk 7 I . 4 Rsupp.91 ( Ne 1 83. 3 D. v. 9 ) ' s ' ' 4. ! ' t RF AX Re lyPr f s inasDe e n s whih i t bepad fom is a efz . The ' he JM at o e so l f nda t, c s o i r n ur nc t nds 7 Cour lndst t! s tem enlamounti rasonabl and sufi ent ' ti hat le etl se e lci . ' . . 8l 9 1 . j n e Co t sco i r t s tl men a o of$1 , 0 b t e Pl i i a 1 ur hï nsde ed he e te t m unt 2 00 e we n a ntls nd s ' ' l j . 5. ' n e Cour has consi ed t dam agescl med by Pl ntf s,and i hms c i e t der he ai ai ir t onsder d t rsks ofpr he i oceedi on bot si n e Cour fndst lt e i a sàong pot i t ng h des. t i ha her s ental hat ' 1 l R J R at Poes nladAstnwo lb alt pealgistePaniscams 0 EMAX el rfsi as' ho ud e beo rviaanth litf'li y o n f 1 j y 11pratNS hpr4. ! 'snoR Cae65 j uut t . 9 - 1I 4 é 2 6 : c . IIi !: . . . ' n eCo t asc nsdee wheh rteewa c lyo o fa r ai t t ur h o i rd te b r s olu in r 'ud eltng o he r . I I l . 1 ,2, l I stlme t n eCo rfn stateewa n cl so o i drltn t teste n bh en : . . a et n. 2 e utid hthr s o ol in rhu eaig o i el me t eve u l l fq' 1jPatfad EMA Rayrfsnln e setdem entam ountwasarrived atti anns l!h 5-! 4 lnf nR/ X elP eia !@ -pu iis t oso s uough . 46: 8z t ' ' k ! 1 . ln ! n g t to s j f 2 5I eg. eoi in . . h a . . I I : ) i : 1: j 1 61 7. n eCou t sc ie e t Gn nca c diin o t s tln def an sa d te , r hm onsd r d he a il on to f he etig bnd t n b j - . . y - E j r s . ' 1 1 j 17 ' i tr 1 ns lance cover ofî setlng def . s RE/ A' Realy Pr cs onal i a defunctN evada age he ti endant M x t of si s s I . . . . o 1 j c or to . n e e i i i ur d, nd t i ur n e i s c e t c ve t e s tl m e .'he . 8 om a i n . ntl s ns e a he ns a o s um i nt o o r h e te nt l y ' ' ! . . 1 ' Cour fndst s tem entam ountr onabl and s ci i lghtoft i ancecover 9 t i he etl cms e um ent n i he nsur age. 20 8. . : The Courthasconsi r t sr ' h and wea de ed he tengt knes es ofpot i conti i s ental rbuton ' . . t . 2 a ibemitcisthateotnotsaac'iRJA neCourosoapotcntialn m s l 1 woulneanyl . hheyudhlhavet vefMtX ayrindsthatDfdcls n dd bltoa TtC di o tteF RlPfsnsen t d e show m r dh h aul e t ttei l eaai 22 t . ' . 23 f conti i a equiabl i or rbuton nd t e ndem niy do notwei i f t gh p avorofdenyi good f t ng aih. . . . 24 9. l . C I. n e s te entaar entbet etl m eem ween Pli if and t RF/ ? Realy a ntf s he aM kx t ' 25 2 s 1 7Ncv. 6,811P.d5 ( 9 ) TheDocor Co k Vi e ,1 0Ne '6. 65 98P.d681 1 0 35 2 61 1 91, t s . . ncnt 2 v. 44, 2, 3 , 2 7 68 ( 4)an MGM Gr dSoffFie 57 Rsu jl ( Ne 1 3) . 7 200 , d an e r , 0 pp. 3 D. v. 98 . 28 . Pr es onal Def of si s endant s tifest f ct s s f t i Vel colChemi Cor v.Davi on, s a s i he a or et orh n si cal p. L ...' I . . ' ' . ! ' 7 jage 5 of6 ' ' ' . t ' ' j j j.. j ' 1 11 j 1 0. ' l n e s tlm e a r eme be e n Pl ntfsa t RE/ AX Re t e te nt g e nt hv e ai if nd he M aly 1 . 2! Poes nlDeedns s'ee itigo fi. rfsi as fnatwmetrdnon odat o n h . 3 1 .1 Nopoiosrlnooawseevdo EMA Ray rfsinl 1. opsinwie rrl arçietR / X elPoes as t t ., . t o I I 4j DfnatMoinfrAoRealtyDtessionals. endanls'M otionforGood Faith I e dns nt RFJMGodFi ProfmiaoDef e 12.' o o X ab er ntn t e i . 5 e . ' - - ' ' . . . ' - s Del m i i i her gr ed i isentr y. er naton s eby ant n t iet . 1 ' ' ! . . 7 1 . l li a eh r n wno In n wn a an t 3. Alcams wh te k o rlk o , g is RelyPrfsin l at o e so as 1 8 Def endant f conG bm i and/ equi e i s or on or ubl ndem niy ar 'er extnguihed ptr t eh eby i s tsuantt NR S o 9 1 245. 7. ' . 1 0 , ' . . I I HEREB Y ORDERED,ADJUDG ED ,AN D DECREED t : T S hat E . I . Z 1 ' 1 1 RF AX Re l Pr e sona sa J y As on' M oton f G o Faih JM a l of s i l nd ud ht s y i or od t : ë D 1 Dee iaini h rb ga ld each pm y t beart row n ator tnun to s ee y rne , ' o hei t neys'f and cos s; ees t : : 1 I 2 . =1 3: 4 :1Qj.1 ' &!- 3I 1 tz-. j . ë . 1 , l j l. ' 2. AIcams whte k o o u k o , gis1 . A. Rel Poeso as 1 1 li , eh r n wn r n n wn aantG.M.X at - fsin l I / yr ' 'j ; 1 1 n u y ho o o tiui n /r q i l n en iy r ee y xi use . ' * ':l .4. adJd Astnfrcbrb t nado eutbeid rnt aehrb e t g ih d . i ? rt Iq o a n j . 1 . . g. t t . . , tfT 1t I t 15 '4 ! t1 j J 7 6i j F . 5 C h D TDts 1h dyfome 21. AE b 5 aoNv b, 01 i t er N 17 ' 1 8 ' SUBM I TTED BY: , 2 OL ON, NO GOR E & o DESRUICAN N, ML Y S SSEAUX < q zz;. ,. r: ' , 7 zz . .' z z;' ' . r .. J z BY / . . .. . . ' 21 . . . . ( k : . , 22 . ' LI I N TED STATES M AG I STRATE J UDGE ' 1 9 ; ' ' j j .. j .t I ' 23 W CHAEL E.STOBERSKIESQ. , 24 z HARY J THOMPSON,ESQ. . e aBa xo. 0 7 2 r 04 6 1 l 25 xeaa axoo10 vd ar .l01 9950 W es Cheyenne Avenue t 1 I 2 ; 6 Ato ne f De e a t Rf-M , x REA LTY t r ys or f nd n s / t LasVe s Ne da 8 29 ga , va 91 I I I . , ' ' dJ an UDY ASHTON ;j ? ; ! 2! 81 j 1 ' ' u , . .! ' . , . . . page 6 oj6 - .
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
