Kroshus et al v. United States of America et al, No. 3:2008cv00246 - Document 510 (D. Nev. 2010)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING CLASS CERTIFICATION AND APPOINTING CLASS COUNSEL re 132 MOTION. This action is certified as a class action; Counsel for the class shall be Robert C. Maddox, Esq., Calvin R.X. Dunlap, Esq., Vernon E. Leverty, Esq., Robert R. Hager, Esq., and Lee Hotchkin, Esq. ( see pdf order for details and specifics ) Signed by Judge Lloyd D. George on 10/22/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
FL P IE E EE NT R B . FE E CDV ' B SRE 0 EVD N C E / TES0FRE OFD OONI LMR I C 1 = 12 * 2 J 4 B ï Y Y 615ZV RC O C 00V DS IIC N V IIiC F E AM 5 UNI TED STA TES D I STRICT C OU R T 6 DP L F DI STRI 0F NEVADA CT 7 ALI A UH OU SE,etal CI . s Cas No.3: cve 08- 0285- GLD RAM Pl hzif , a tf s 9 vs. 1 UNI 0 TED STATES DEPA RTM EN T OF THE I NTERI BUREAU OF RECLANI ON ; OR, ATI 11 e a . t1 1 2 Dee ns f nda t . / 13 JUDY K ROSH USS ta . e 1 Ca eN o. 08 c 0 LDGs 3: - v- 246RAM 1 4 Pl i if , a ntf s OR DER G R ANTI G CLA SS N CERTI C ATI AN D FI ON APPO I NTIN G CLA SS C O UNSEL 1 5 vs. 1 6 I M TED STA TES OF AM BRI ; tal J CA e . 17 Def endant s, lî Kroshus et al v. United States of America et al 1 9 / Doc. 510 Thepli i i Kr hu,e a.v Unie Sats e aI,3: -v- 46- antFs n os s t l . td t e, t . 08o 02 LDG' RAM ( 32 #1 ) 2 a d Uh u e e a. . r a o ca d n e a.30 -v0 8 0 n o s , t lv Bu e u fRel ma o , t l :8c - 2 5LDO, RAM ( 5 )h v ak d # 0 a e se 21 t sc t o c riy t e ac i asc u s a tonsa d t a poi tt i a t r ysm c a sc t s hi our t e tf h tons l c i n o p n he r to ne s l s o m el 1 I 22 pur ua l FRCP 23. Th Kr s uspl i tf sa l gevi ato o t e A dm i s tv Pr e e s nt o e oh a n if le ol i ns f h nika i e oc dur 23 Ac (wr i te t G ' a i tt UniedSttso Ameiw De rme toft Itro t l enatr he E ) gans he t ae f rc pnt n he neir APA' 2 t o , isBur a ofRec a a n,M i pa ii Re on,Ca s Ciy Of i e Dik Ke p h n , 4 hr ugh t eu l m uo d- c tc gi r on t fc , r m t or e 25 Se r t r oft I eror a Elz be. Ri k Die oft Ca s Ciy Ofi e o t Bur a of c e a y he nt i , nd i a t e e, r dor he r on t tc f he e u h 26 Re l ton( ri fe % o husFe ea Dee nt' a da sr ij tvea d caaor cmnai heenatr xr s d rl fnda s' n se tnunci nd e lrt y ) 27 r le a i tt Kr s s Fe r l e e a s de l r t y r le a n i nc c a m sa i t e i f ga ns he o hu de a D f nd nt , o a a or e i f nd eglge e l i ga ns 28 Tm c e ca s n I rg i D i ti t Da d P. r ol Ga y St e, u ke Ri e Fe r lW a e ke - r o r i aton s rc vi Ove v d. r on Tr c e v r de a t r 1 ! Dockets.Justia.com ! 1 i l Matr( ri AerGons I g to Dititrlt d fnd nt' vi ainofc ns uina se heena * hun ni ain src-eaed ee n s), olto l o utto l 2 r g sa n glg nceo a m sa i tCiy ofFe nl y a Lyon Co y,a ne i nc a f i ue i ht nd e i e l i ga ns t r e nd unt nd glge e nd a l ' t 3 t dicl e cl i sa l td ve o r a r alor ,ba e u n ta J n r 5, o s os a m gs nq e l pe s nd e t s s d po le a ua y 2008 Tr c e Ca l u ke na 4 e bn m e f lle i Fe n e N e d The Uhou e Pl i if a l g v ol to o t A PA m nk nt aitr n r l y, va a. s a ntf s le e i a i ns f he 5 a i tt Unie St t s De n l e toft I t ror Bm'a ofRe l m a i n a Dik ga ns he t d a e p rm n he n e i , e u c a to nd r 6 Ke hor i hi o ca c paiya Se rtr o t Itro ( ri te L ous Fe rl mpt ne,n s m il a ct s ceay f he neir heenatr * uh e dea 7 Dee d ns'a da sr ij n tv al d cma oyrl f g is teUh u eFe ea Dee d ns fn a t' n se tnu cie t e l tr ei a al th o s d rl fn a t ) d e l 8 a decm t r r le andne i nc ca msa i tt Bo r o Die t so Tr ke - ro nd l o y e if glge e li gans he a d f r cor f uc e ca s n 9 I g to Di t i t Tr c e ca s n I rga i n D iti t & Da d P. r ol i hi om c a ni a i n s rc , u ke - r o r i to s rc , nd vi Ove v d, n s il 1 c pa iya Prjc Ma g rofteTmc - ronIrg to Ditit( ri fe Guhou e 0 a ct s oe t na e h keecas riain src heenatr % s 1 I i ainDititrltdd fn a tn, nb h l o p ro swh s fee d ma e a dij re 1 n g to sro-eae ee d ns )o e af f es n o u frd a g s n nu is 1 a ar s to a foo i Fe nly, v& o J nu r 5, 2 s e ul f l d n r e Ne da, n a a y 2008 c us dby t o rl ng a ,a e he ve fowi nd 1 br a h o t Tr c e Ca l 3 e c f he u ke na . 1 4 lzt Kr s s a uo D e e da t Re l x Re ly, ud A s t n,C. . I s m e l he o hu c n, f n n s m a a t J y h o A L. nve t nt 1 Pr pe t s Ca Eidc D i h Ei c LL Reat t Kr s sFe e a Def nd nt ,t K r s t 5 o ri , l l h, na hi h, e ly, he o hu d r l e a s he o ht s 1 I rga n D i ti tr lt d de e nt ,Lyon Co mt Ciy ofFe nl y,Ke t ne Re t a d Ki 6 r i do s rc - ea e f nda s t y, t r e ys o aly, n ng 1 Consr c i n,I .o 7 t u to nc ppos d c a sc ri a i e l s e tfc ton. 1 8 I t Uhou e a ton, he Uhou e Fe r lDe e n sa Uhou e Ir ga i Di ti t n he s ci t s de a f nda t nd s ri ton sr c - 1 r a e de e nt o 9 el t d f nda q ppos c a sc zii a i n. ed l s et ic to 2 0 'hi c ur ha ng r vi w e t pl a ngsa e b t t r t c ns de e tz a g e t I s o t vi e e d he e di ' nd xhi is he e o, o i r d l r um n s e 21 oft pa te m a a t he rng o S pt m be 1 2009 a ha n t ke t m a t rt d r he r i s de t he a i n e e r 6, nd, vi g a n he te m e 2 a vie e t m a 'w f l h g fndi off d a c l i ofl w . 2 d s m n , kest olow l i ngs a nd onc usons a l 2 3 2 4 FI DI G S OF FA W A ND C ON CLUSI S O F LAW N N ON Thi a ton a i e outoft J nuay 5 20 , u ke Ca lEm ba m e f iur mz t e s ci rs s he a t , 08 Tr c e na nk nt a l e d h 25 r s dng food t to u r d i Fe l y, va e ul l ha cc r e n m e Ne da. 26 The Uhou e a d Kr h pl i if s e a l de c ri y ng a c a s s n os us a ntf s e k r or r e tf i ls . 27 Fe R.Ci Pr 23c()A)povi st tSh c tmus deemiebyor rwh t rt d. v. o. ()1( r de ha t e our t tr n t de ehe o 28 c riyt a tona aca sa to 'tatane rypa ia etmealrapes s sori s e a e tf he ci s ls cingt l al rctc bl i fe ron ue s u d s l 2 1 a c a sr prze a i .' The c ur m u t t r i o y w h t rt e Uhou eandK r shu l s e e nt tve ' s o t s de e m ne nl e he h s o s 2 pl i if 'ale uo a pr f e ed e de c s ts y e c pr r ui ie ofFed. Ci Pr 23. a ntf s l ga ns nd o f r vi n e a i f a h e eq s t R. v. o. 3 Thes cfcr uie nsofacasa to a s tf t i Fe R.Ci Pr s e23() pe ii eq rme t ls cin s e orh n d. v. o.Rul a ' 4 a e: r 5 ()Prrq st . o mor me r o acls ma s orb s a a ee uiies One r e mbes f as y ue e ued s 6 ()tecm si s n meo sta j id ro a1 mb r i i rcia l; 1 h ls s o u ru h ton e f 1me es s mpa tc be ()t r aequeto oflw o fc c 2 hee r sins a r a t ommo t t cm s n o he ls ; ()t camsordee e o t rprsntivepate aet c loft 3 he li fnss f he e ee a ris r ypia he 7 r pr s n a i e pa te on be a fofa 1 e be son y i: e e e t tv r i s hl 1m m r l f ca mso d f ns soft cas ; nd li r e e e he l s a 8 ( t rp e e ai pateswilfil a a quaeyprt t i eesso 4) he e r snttve ri l ary nd de tl oed he ntr t f t cl ss. he a 9 1 0 Ther q rme o Fe R. v. o.Rul 23()f whihpli if a g t sa ton e uie ut f d. Ci Pr , e b or c antfs r ue hi ci qualfesi ii s: l1 1 2 l 3 1 4 ()Type ofCls Acins A cas a to ma bemanti di Rul 2 a i b s a s to . l s cin y i ane f e 3() s s ts d a i : a ife nd f ( t c tf t tt q sinsoflw orfc c 3)he our mds ha he ue to a a t ommo t ca sme r n o ls mbes p e om i t o ra que to a f c i on y i di dln m e r d na e ve ny s i ns f e tng l n vi l l mber ,at t ta s r ha d c as a ton i s pe i t ot ra l bl m e hodsf rf il a e fc e ty l s c i s u ror o he vaia e t o z ry nd fi i n l a j ctn tl c rves ... dudiaig le onto ry. 15 1 6 1 7 1 s Asi c td,a1o t prrquiiesi Fe R.Ci Pr 23()mus bef nda onl ndiae 1 f he ee st n d. v. o. a t ou nd y o o prrquiie i Fe R. v. o, e23( mus befund.Theplitfsag t tti ne f ee sts n d. Ci Pr .Rul b) t o anif rue ha bs caeme t a1tt prrquiie ofFe R.Ci Pr , e23()a t prrq st ofFed. s es 1 le ee sts d. v. o.Rul a nd he ee uiie R. Ci Pr ,Rul 2 3) Th dee da sdia ee v. o. e 309( . e fn nt s gr . 1 9 Be o e ad e sng t epr r qu st ofc as c r ii a i n,t e c ur w ila r s tl f r dr s i ' e e i ies l s e tfc to l o t l dd e s le N l 20 21 Uhous Plitfsalg tonso volto oft APA,nt tv rle a de lzt yr le e anif le ai f i ains he ijmcie eif nd caaor eif a a ns tl Uhou e Fe r lDe e dan sa t Kr s s pl i i t ale a i s o vi a i o t g i t le s de a f n t nd he o hu a ntfk l g ton f ol tons f he 22 APA aga ns t Kr ht Fe r lDe e a s A t he Se e be l 20 h rng t Kr s s i t he os t de a f nd nt . t s pt m r 6, 09 ea i , he o hu 23 ml Uhot e Pl i if a r s e t ne s iy o a c as a to t a s r t i r s c i c a m s d t a ntfs dd e s d he ce st f l s c i n o s e t he r e pe tve l i s 24 a ai tt Fe r lDe e n s Att h rngKr s s Pl i if c ede a c as c d notbe g ns he de a f nda t . ' ea i he o hu a ntf s onc d l s oul 25 c rii a i tt Fe rlDefnda t.( a cito Se tmb r1 200 He rng, os t etfed gans he dea e ns Trnsrp f pe e 6, 9, ai Kr ht s 26 DOC 405,Uh eDOC 1 a 8 4-8:3 .Si lry,Uhous Pli f sae t tt IAILI ous 78 t 8: 8 1 ) mial e anufs ttd ha he II ' II 27 22 pli if w<es fce t a sr t APA camsa i tt Fe ea Defnda t.tt a 96:4antfs ufiint o sethe li gans he d rl e ns ff t 1 3 ' i 1 96:9.Ac odi l tec td nisPli i 'moi frca sc rikaina is t Fe rl 1 ) c r ngy,h our e e antls ton o ls ett to gant he dea 2 Def endant. 3 The c tnow t nsisa t nto t whe he Pl n if h e m e t i d de of our ur t te i n o t r ai tf s av t her ç bur n 4 de nsr i t tterquie nt ofRuls23()a ( aeme'a t t rr i ng mo tatng ha h e rme s e a nd b) r t s o he enanl ' 5 Dee d ns Uni dSe l . n c phlèsCo n s paa * ct Zr e v Ac ul fn a t. t te v Co o o i e l mpa y, u r t 4 ihg it r . cjx s 6 ze e c I t I .2 F. 1 8 1 86( lCi. ) sar h ns , nc, 53 3d 1 0, 1 9tz r 2001 . 7 Fed.R .C i Pro. R ul 23( 1)- Num erosiv v. . e a)f t 8 J o d t me thefrtee ntofFe R.Ci Pr 23() tep po tdcms mts be . r er o e t ts lme n d. v. o. a ,l ur re l s ut A 9 s n meo st a j i e i i rcia.Rlmp a t a ii d e n t a i o sbly, u o u r u h tond r s mp a t l ll rci bly o s o me n mp si it b t c c t i 1 o l t (fiut o i o v ne c o j iigal mb r o teca s'Ha rsv Pam S ig 0 ny he l fc ly r nc n e in e f onn lme es f h ls. r l . l prn s i ' 11 Al neEs.I .329F. 90 91 1 ( hCi.1 4) ctngAdvr.S cal NatAsn.v pi t, nc, 2d 9, 3-4 9t r 96 , ii et pe i t . s . y 1 . 238F. 1 ,l 9( s Ci.1 ) s ealoRo dou v Ceani98 F. 9 ,9 ( Ci. 2 # Vr, 2d 08 1 1t r 956; e s bi x . l , 7 2d 31 35 2d r 1 1 . 3 993) 1 4 llm ovi pa r a a t e Se e b r 1 2009 h ng, e e n sRe a Re ly, t ng pe s nd t l pt m e 6, l , emi D f nda t N x a t 1 J y A slo C . . I s m e Pr ri s Ca Eir c ,Di l Eir c ,LL Re ly, e t 5 ud lt n, A L. nve t nt ope te , 1 li h na z li h a t K ysone 1 Reat a Ki g Con tu to I a s re tw nu e o iypr ng c ul no beme a i tt m. 6 ly, nd n sr ci n, nc. s e td l m r st o o d t t gans he 1 Fori tnc , Re ly sae t ti wa ivove i t es l o sx t egh ho e .Tr ns rpt 7 nsa e LL at ttd ha t s n l d n l ae f i o i t us s ( a c i z 1 o Se e r1 200 He rng, o hu DOC 405,Uh eDOC 1 a 78:- 1 . 8 f ptmbe 6, 9, ai Kr s ous 78 t 878:0) 1 Si ia l Re M a Re ly a J dy As on s e t y wm' on y i vol d i onet a s c i n. 9 m l ry, / x a t nd u ht lt d he e l n ve n r n a to 20 (2 a 8 1 8 1 ) I r po e tt Kr hu Plitfsrs f t 0:4- 0- 8 . n es ns,le os s anif eponde t ttlywo dsi aet t d ha le ul tpult ha 21 be a et nume ost pr ngmi l notbeme,acl a ton a i tDefnda sReM a c us he r iy o gl t t us ci gans e nt / x 22 Reat J y A s o C. . I s ntPr pe te ,Ca Eir c D i h Eir c LL Rea t ly, ud ht n, A L. nve hne o ri s l li h, na li h, ly, 23 Ke tneRe ly,a Ki Co % cin,I . oul notbec riid.(2 a 93:2-4:) yso at nd ng ns to nc c d e t e f t 2 9 3. f 2 Ac or ngl t e c r d ni st Kr s sPl i if 'm oto f c a sc rii a i n a i t 4 c di y, h ou t e e he o hu a ntf s i n or l s e tfc to ga ns : 2 D e e nt Re M a Re ly,J A s on, A . I s m e Pr pe t s Ca Eirc D i b 5 f nda s / x a t udy ht C. L. nve t nt o ri , I li h, nn e i 2 Eirc LL Re ly,Ke t ne Re ly,a Ki Co t u to I . 6 lih, at ys o a t nd ng nsr c i n, ac ! i 27 Thec r' a l i t nt nst whehe cm sc ri ton f rPl ntf camsagans ou ts nayss he ur o t r ls e tscai o ai if li it 28 tz I rga i Di ti t r a e de en n s Lyo Co y,a t Ciy ofFe nl y i a o i t le ri ton sr c -el t d f da t , n unt nd he t r e s ppr pra e. 4 1 Ge r ly,c r swillnd t e nume ost p o ha be n m e whe t r a e a l as 40 ne a l ou t l i h r iy r ng s e t n he e r t e t 2 ca sme es Mon ov St ,8 F. D.5 ( D. Y.1 ) Clse wihf rknown ls mb r. ac . one 7 R. 0 E. N. 999 . m ss t ewe 3 c a sm e b r m e s he e ha be n c rii Se Hor v An oci e W h e al C r c I . l s m e s s xit r ve e e tled. e n . at d ol s e r gc r , nc , 4 55 F. 270,2 (01 Ci.1 77 ( - cl sme r) Cr sv Nai alT us f! Is Co, 5 2d 75 1 r 9 ) 4146 ms mbes; os . ton r t , n . . x 5 55 F. 1 ( hCi.1 77)( ca smemb a)A#oAmerc Patol n'Lec ev Du k, 3 2d 026 6t r 9 7 ls e ; ian r me s pz . c 6 503F. 294,29 (t Ci.1 4)( cusme r)Jac v Ame ianLi nSupl Co.498 2d 8 6h r 97 35 l mbes; k . rc ne p y , 7 F. 1 l (t r 1 4)51casme r)Ar an a Edu atonAs ' M Boa do 2d 22, 24 5hCi. 97 ls mbes; k s s c i sn r f 8 Educ to 44 F. 763,7 (t Ci.1 )( cms me o) a Cy esv Newpor Xe ç ain, 6 2d 65 8h r 971 20 l s mbe ; nd pr s . ? w. 9 Hopial s', F. 648 65 (t Ci.1 67 ( 8cas me s.Ge rly,nu r i s t As n 375 2d , 3 4h r 9 ) 1 l s mber) neal mbes n 1 1 e cs o 1 0 s santen meoiyrq ie n t e F 2 ()1.Ne eg, as 0 x es f 0 ,uti l u rst eurmetmdr RCP 3a() wb r Cls z 1 11 Acinsj305a 325;s eas 38 M o esFe ea Prci P 23. 1 a 2 1 - (ded. to t - e lo or' d rl a tce 05() t 3-4345 2 . 1 1 ) 2 995 . 1 3 TheCiyofFenl i wha ina dt a ofEsi tdEfe d( C)AraUpd td: t r ey,n tt me t p M tmae fde SI e ae 1 1112008s f ove fvehu r home weeafce byt Jrt y 5 2 fo ( p 4 - - ' ound r i nded ' s r fe td he almz , 008,lod. Ma 1 o Esi tdEfe tdAraUpdae 1 1 5 f tmae fce e td: - 12008,tahe heeoasExhii t1' Thec ur atc d rt btt. 3. o t 1 f ii notp éc bl t ha o r500spaaec s so e nj nde o t tma y i one 6 mds t s mc a e o ve ve e rt a e r ve oi r f ha n n 1 c s . I i doub f lt a a l ore n a s g fc n num be of tl pr os d c as m e be si t s 7 ae ts t u h t l, ve i ni a t r , le op e l s m r n he e 1 ne g hood ,woul ha e t fna i lr s c st i tt t s t a hie t e ne r a 8 i hbor s d v he i nc a e our e o nsiu e uis nd r he ngi e s nd 1 o h rs i ntsc e rsw ho w ot d be n ed d t pr ve la lt And ofc r et c ur c l be 9 t e c e i xpe t z l e e o o i biiy. ou s he o t ou d 2 i mda e i a l r num be oft pr s d c a sm e be s we e t s e i di d ly. e c a s 0 nl t d f a ge r he opo e l s m r r o u n vi ua l n l s 21 a to woul frhe udii e o cia d at rj cal c nomysnc amuli iiyo a tomswoul bea d ie tplct f ci d voied. 22 J nd rofa lm e b r i o s to fln ofi i du s t i i p a tc bl i t i oi e l m e s n ne ui r ii g nd vi al uis s m r c i a e n ' s h 23 c s . A c o di y, a ntf s h ve d m ons r t d t n e ost pr r quiie a a ns t ae c r ngl Pl i if a e ta e he um r iy e e st g i t he 24 l ga i D ii c - e a ed d f nda t ,Lyo Co t ,a Ciy ofFe nly i m e . ni ton s tr l t e e n s n un y nd t r e s t 25 Fe 1 .Ci Pr . e23( ) 2)- C o m ona i d. t v. o. Rul af m lw 26 Fe R.Ci Pr 23()2)rqtrs% esi of1w orfctc d. v. o. a( e tie i tons a qu a ommo t tecas' n o h ls. ' 2 7 A1 q s i of1 w a h c ne d no bec m on. Hanl v.Chr l rCo p. 1 0 F.d 1 ue tons a nd t e t om on ys e r , 5 3 22 1 ,1 9( hCi.1 .Rahe,lthee se eofs r dlg is ewi di re fcua 011 01 9t r 998) t r tl xitnc hae e alsue t veg nt a t l l s h 5 l j I 1 pr d c t si s t i nt a i a c m o c e ofs le f c s c e wih d s a e l ga e i a e s ufk e s s om n or a i nt a t oupl d t ipr t e l 2 rme e wihi tz cms'I .s eas Parav Bt s'I .536F.d975( hCi. 08; e dis t n le ls.'d; e lo r . uha ,nc, 3 9t r 20 ) 3 St onv Boen Co.3 F.d93 9 ( hCi.20 ;a d,Ba l v As n'e l$fc, at . ig , 27 3 8, 53 9t r 03) n ft . pe c/ n . s ) 4 236F. D. 2,656( I ho200 . R. 65 D.da 6) 5 TheNi h Cic tc t e t c nt r ui onsnzs he ommo lt pr r q st pe misbl Hanon, upr , naiy e e uiie r s i y. l s a. 6 1 F. d a l 9. n St on,s a. 9 F. a 9 t e c ur s i 50 3 t 01 I at upr 32 3d t 53, h o t a d: 7 A l que tons of f c a 1 w ne d not b c m on t s ts y t e r e The l si a t nd a e e om o a i f h ul . e se eofs a e l a is swih dve ge tf c a p e i ae i s fce t as xitnc h r d eg l s ue t i r n a m l r d c ts s ufi in , i aco m on c r o s le f c sc upl dw 11 dipa a e l l e e e w ihi he s m o e f a i nt a t o e t s r t ega r m di s t nt . : cl s. ms s 9 l t s c s t de e mi to ofwhe he t ac i ns o i c i nsoft e I rg to n hi a e, he t r na i n t r he to r na to h ria in l 0 11 l Ditc-eae dfn at weecnrr t 1w al cusdado e aebtdPanis sl t ltd ee d ns r o tay o a r a e n /r x crae litft i r d f, ijre i t ke is o la lt a ta sts t is sofcommonaiy.Smial t nu is s he y sue f ibiiy nd h t aises he sue lt i lry,he l 2 d t r i ton ofw h t rt a tonso i c i ofLy Cot y a t Ciy ofFe l y w e e e e m na i e he he c i r na tons on mt nd he t me r 13 1 4 c n r t lw a dc u e a do e a eb tdPlitfs ij e i t ek yis eo la ii a d o te o a n a s d n /r x c rae anif'nmis s h e su f ib ly n t t ts ts st is sofcomm o lt Th ac i a i tt I rga i Di ti tr l t d ha a ife he s ue na iy. e ton ga ns he r i ton s rc - e a e 15 d f nda t ,t a ton a i t Lyon Cou y. nd t a to a i ttw Ciy ofFe l y a la i e e e n s he c i ga ns nt a he c i n ga ns l t m e 1 rs 1 6 o oft eJ n z 5, 08,Tr o eCn lEmbs mel f iur a t r uli fo t a ut h a ua ' 20 y u ke nn nk rt al e nd he ts tng l od h t 17 oc ur e i Fe ly, va . A c o di l Pl i ifs ha de o ta e t c m o lt c r d n m e Ne da c r ng y, a n f ve m nsr t d he om na iy 1 8 p e e uiiea i tt Irga i Diti tr lt dde e t,Lyon Co t a Ciy o Fe nly i r r q st gans l ri ton src-ea e f ndM s w un y, nd t f r e s 19 m et . 20 Fe R.Ci Pr . ul 23( f - Tvoi alw d. v. o. R e aàm c i 21 22 Fe R. v. o.Rul 23a()rq rsta t cli o t rpr e ttveplitfsb d. Ci Pr , e ()3 e uie h t he ams f he e esnai anif e t pia oft s o t c a s Thecamsordee e m ts bet i a oft camso dee e o y c l ho e f he l s . li fns s lt yp c l he li r fas s f 23 t c as . The f e os c nsde a i i t tt r i a a e e o a a e s i e e tbe e n he l s or m t o i r ton s ha he e s n bs nc f n dv r e nt r s > e 24 t e r pr e u tve pa te a o he m e be soft c a s Ti l v Sc ke ,67 F. 5 0, h e es n i ri s nd t r m r he l s . dwe l . hwei r 7 2d 5 25 26 5 (t Ci.1 2) c r deni4 461U. 905( 98 9 ak v Ar t 663F. 90 91 ( h 66 7h r 98 , et e S. 1 3)Bl e . net 2d 6, 3 9t Ci.1 1 .Theis ofla lt i t f usoft ltga heea i tes mefral r 98 ) sue ibiiy s he oc he ii don r nd s h a o 1 27 m e ber Each cl m em ber' cl m ars f om t sa e cok ofconductby t I m s. ass s ai i es r he m rse he nigaton i 28 6 ! i 1 Di ti -e a e d f nda t a e o c a s me be hmst e s m e l ga a gu e st pr t s rctr l t d e e n s nd a h l s m r h a e l r m nt o ove he 2 I ga i Dit i tr l t d d e a t 'r s i lt f t ha ni ton s rc -e a e ef nd n s e ponsbiiy or he nned c us d. Si ia l e c c a s a e m l ry, a h l s 3 m e b r sc a m a i e f o t s m e c u s o c nduc b Lyo Coun y a d t Ciy o Fe nl y m e ' l i r s s r m he a o re f o ty n t n he t f r e 4 a e c c a sm e b rha tl s m e l ga a g e t t p ove Lyo Cot y a Ciy ofFe nl y nd a h l s m e s le a e l r um n s o r n mt nd t r e 5 i/ r r s onsbl f t ha me c us d. lga a gu e sa i tt e I ga i D iti t sa e e p i e or he r d a e The e l r m nt ga ns h ni ton sr c 6 r l t d de e nt , t lga agtne sa i tI Cot y, r t lga agume t a a ns t e e a e f nda s he e l r u nt gans a a yon mt at he e l x ns g j t l d 7 Ciy o Fe nl y a la ie o o t J nu r 5 2 ,Tr k e Cn lEm bn e tf iu e a t tl t f r e I rs ut f he a a y , 008 uc e nn nkm n a l r rd l e 2 r s tng Ioo tz too ure i Fenfey, va e uli l d la c r d n Ne da 9 i t ug s i uiyi t t s t n eofac s m a bene e s r t %c ran t ho h ome nq r n o he ubsa c Al ae y c s a y o e ti 1 stsa to oft c mmonaiya t iaiyr uie nt ofRul 23a,ti i ope t 0 aifoin he o lt nd ypc lt eq rme s e ()i s mpr r o 1 a nc a d c s on o t m e ist t c m s c rii a i sa . St t n v Boe n C(. 327 F. d 1 dva e e i i n he rt o he l s e t c ton t ge ' a o . i g ?, t ' 3 1 938, ( bCi. ) quoi Moo ev Hu sHeko es I n708F. 475 480( bCi. 2 954 9t r2003, tng r . ghe l ptr, nc, 2d , 9t r 1 1 ) 3 983 . 1 4 S caiytoe n me nt tt cai oftl cms rp e e ai g)mus bei ntc ' Typi lt d s ot a ha he l ms le l s e r snttves t de ial 1 ors M ta l i n i a t t s o tl a e c a sm e b r .' St on,s r , 7 F. a 95 5 ubs i ly de tc l o ho e f le bs nt l s m e s '' at up a. 32 3d t 7 1 ( i t n o t d ; e as Pa r s u r . 36F3 a 9 9( n igt a itec u eo te 6 ct i s mit ) se lo ra s pa 5 .d t 7 t dn h tf h a s fh ao e i 1 da gei t smet nt ti e oughf cascriiai )Thec r tndstz t c lt 7 ma s he a ha ha s n or ls e tfc ton. ou ti le zpiaiy 1 r uie e ti m e i t sc e a t t I rg to Di i c - e a ed de e nt , on Coun y, nd 8 eq r m n s t n hi as s o he r i a i n s tr l t f nda s Ly t a 1 Ciy o 'e l y. 9 t fF m e 2 Fe R . v.Pr . ul 23( 6 - A de 0 d. Ci @. R e 114) quac v 21 The r F e e i pl i tf sm us be a et f il a a e t l pr ec t i er t of e s nGtve a n if t bl o a ry nd d qua ey ot t he nt ess 2 a 1c a sm e b r . To de e m i whe e t r pr s n to m e t tts sa r we as t o 2 1 ls m es t r ne i r he e e e u i n e s li t nda d, kw 23 queto :()Dot rprs nttvepli if a t i c t e ha a yc nfit o i eetwih sins 1 he e e e ai antfs nd her oms l ve n o lcs f ntrs t 2 oh rca sme es a () lt erp e e ot panif a t erc u s l rs c t ti 4 te ls mb r, nd 2 wi h e rsn i litfs nd h i o n e po e ue h s l ve 25 a to vi r l o be fo t cas ?St o v Bo n Co a 9 The eha be nno c in go ousy n hnl f he l s atn . eig . t 57. r s e 26 e de e ofc lc so i e e tb e t rp o e c a sr pr s nt tve orc uns l n e eha vi nc onfi t f nt r s y ihe r pos d l s e e e a i s o e . r s 27 bee no e i nc t r pr s nu tve pl i tf sa d t i c uns lwilno pr e ut t sa to n v de e he e e e i a n if n he r o e l t os c e bi c i n 28 vi r l o be l o t c a s To t c t'r t cou tfndst r pr s n a i pli if a go ousy n ha f f he l s . he on z y, he r i he e e e t tve a ntf s nd a 7 ' 1 t i c ms lha et ra n t a quaey rpr s ntaIpu ai cms me r wh we e her ot e v mde tke o do t l e e e 1 t tve l s mbe s o r 2 a f ce b t foo r gadls o t i du t pe ofda ge . fe td y he l d, e r e s f he ndvi al y s ma s 3 I St onv Bo i a 95 t o j tr c mpl dt te r o ctgoydi no ha n at . eng t 7,he beco s o ine ha veyj b ae r d t ve 4 isown r pr s notve A lho h t o le wasm a o t bmss o t c lt t c ts t e e e i . t ug he ha l nge de n he i f ypi a iy, he our ' 5 rs ns i i tuci .l s iatnHa o wesae t tçEq erter l spemisv epo e s nsr tve t ad < nln, ttd ha sund h ue' r s ie l 6 sa r ,r pr s nttvecam sa e'y c l i t y aer a ona l c xtnsvew1. t eof t nda ds e e e a i li r t pia ' f he r e s by oe e i t1 hos 1 7 absn cas me r;h yne dnotbes tntalyie ial'ctton omitd)Tl camsof e t l s mbes te e ubsa i l d ntc . (iai s te . w li ' s t ef mii a c lr nwho e de ce t fo a er o bl c xtnsvewiht ec a s h n les nd hid e xpe n d he l od r - na y oe e i t b ls 9 r pr s n ai who as e pe inc dt foo e e e t tves lo x re e be l d. 1 0 Thi c tf , s d o t i e re ea ced n i l, ha t c ns loftl s our mds bm e n her xpe inc nd r e tas t t he ou e le 11 pr s d c ms r pr s notv s h vel c c e ,a iiy a t r s ur est a m ua e y r pr s nt opo e l s e e e i e a be hm t r b l ' r e o c o d t d tl e ee 1 t put sve c as . The c ur a s fndst a q c r q r m e ti m e i t sca e a i t he 2 he a i l s o t l o i he de ua y e uie n s t n hi s ga ns t 13 I gaton D it ctr at def ni i sri -el ed endant ,Lyon Count atd Ciy ofFer ey. s y, l t nl 1 Pe R .CM Pr . e 2 b1m - Pr dom i 4 d. o. Rul 3( ( e nanc and Supe i iv e r or t 1 5 Pl nif aepeii ngfrcasc liiaint rFe R.Ci Pr , e23 ()l aitfs r ttoni o ls elfc to mde d. v. o.Rul *)3 n 1 whi h t c tm us fnd t tt e que to o 1 w a f c c m o t tz m e b r oftw c m s 6 c he our t i ha h s i ns f a nd a t om n o le m e s l l s 1 pr omi t o rml q sinso y a f ci i i dua me r a t tacms a to i 7 ed na e ve y ue to nl fe tng ndvi l mbe s nd ha l s c in s 1 s p ro t oh r to so a j dc t n. eRuesae ta tematr p rie t ote e 8 u eir o t e meh d f du iai Th l tts h th t s et n t h s o e n 1 fndi i l 9 i ngs nc ude: 20 ( t casme r'itrssi Zdi dual c ntolhg t pr e uton o A) he ls mbes neet n vi l o r l he osc i r y 21 ( t e e a naur ofa ltg ton c nc r ngt c to ry ara B) he xtnt nd t e ay iiai o eni he onrves le dy de e le efs p a e a ton ; f zs e m-t o i s be n b o a i tc a sm e be s gu y r ga ns l m r; 22 ( t de ia lt o un ia iiyofc nc ntni teltgai oft cli C) he srbiiy r desrblt o e rtng h ii ton he ams 23 ( t lkeydi clte i ma gi acasado D) he i l o tlis n na ng ls c n. 24 i t pa tc a f nl ;a n he ri ul r o m nd Thec nsdeai ctdu r( i wheh rme r o tx dasaeitrse i o i rton ie nde A) s te mbes fl s r neetd n 25 c ntoli tz luga i i vi ly. I t sc s , le e i no e de e t ta c a sm e b r o r lng le i ton ndi dua l n hi a e tl r s vi nc ha ny l s m e s 26 d s r t ha e cl i c ntoloft ei c s I a c e i i i u c t olb e c o t lr e e ie o ve x usve o r h r a e. n ny as , nd v d al on r y a h f he a g 27 n be o pr pe tvepl ntf sw o d no bepr c i bl orm a a a e. um r f os c i ai if ul t a tca e n ge bl 28 Unde ( t c ti t c ie t naur a e e ofot rltgainc mme e by r B) he our s o onsd r he t e nd xtnt he ii to o nc d 8 1 c as m e be s The eha b e o he ltg ton i b0t s a e a f de a c ur . The Uhou e l s m r . r s e n t r ii a i n h t t nd e r l o t s 2 pli if'alr e ha etldf r()ohe a tonsi saec t( )ac s a i tTr ke antfs to n ys v ie ou 4 t r oi n tt our: 1 ae gans uc e l 3 Cas IrgainDitit(eeno e TCI t tha ale dyb e c riida aca saci ( ron ri to src h ri r D) ha s ra e n etfe s ls ton,2) ! 4 apu a i o a sa te a i tt Ci ofFenly a Lyo Co mt ( )apu a i ca sa ton t tve l s c in gans he t y r e nd n t y, 3 t tve ls c i ; 5 a i tpe s nsa c m p i s i vol d i t c ns r c i a d de e o e to t e Roli ga ns r o nd o an e n ve n he o tu ton n v l pm n f h lng 6 M e d s vii i Fe e t wa afce byt fo a ( aputtveca sa ton a ows ubdi son n mly l s fe td he lod, nd 4) ai ls ci wt 7 a a ns pe s a c m pa esi vol d i t c ns r c n a d de l pm e toft W r ngl r g i t r ons nd o ni n ve n he o t u uo n ve o n he a e 8 Roa ç uc e. The Uh s Pll if'atm e ha a s fl dt a to i Unie Stts d t kl ' kn ' ou e antfs to ys ve lo ie wo ci ns n t d a e 9 D it i tCou ta ai tt Unie St t sBur a ofRe l m a i t de t Fe r lTo 'Cl i s s rc r g ns he t d a e eu c a ton m r he de a l a m t 1 Ac -M o e e a. Unie atso rc 3: -v- 67- RAM m dAd t,e a. . 0 t or, t lv. tdst e fAme ia, 09c 001 LDGget t lv 1 Unie atso 1 tdst e fAme ia,3:9-v- 649LDG-l . Th c s o Moo e e aIv Unie Stts rc 0 c 00 lAM e a e f r, t . . td ae 1 o 2 fAme ia 3:9c - 0 6 - RAM i flda p o p cieca sa t n T i o d rd e n t rc , 0 -v 0 1 7LDGs i s r s e t ls ci . h s re o s o e v o 1 a dr s c a s c rik a i ag i s t f d ald f nda t f cl i sm a urde t Fe r lTo t 3 d e s l s e tf ton a n t he e er e e n s or a m de l r he de a r 1 Cl i s Ac . The i s o cas c r i a i i M o e i a s d, ilbe a dr s e i a s pa a e 4 am t s ue f l s e t k ton n or . fr i e w l t d e s d n e rt 1 o d ra t a op it tme.Si lry,heKr s plitfs atr ysha fl tre() 5 r e the ppr rae i mial t o hus anif' tone ve ied he 3 1 o he a tonsi t Unie S aesDititCour: 1 Kr s s e aI v Unie ats e a. 3: 6 t r ci n he t d t t src t ( ) o hu , t . , tdst e , t I, 09 1 c 0 3LDG- ;()Ad o e aIv UntdStts 3: -w0 21LDG7 v-071 RAM 2 ams n, t . . ie ae, 08c 06 - RAM an () d3 l Adams n e al v Unt dst e ,3: c 00 58 o t . . ie ats 09-v- 7l LDGRAM . 1 9 Re a e t t c i r ton o ot ra o i t de ia lt o c c nta i t s l t d o he onsde a i f he di ns s he sr biiy f on e r tng hi 20 ltga ni t sfnl Fe R. v. o.Rul 23()3)C)'helrgainDitktr ae ii do n hi o m. d. Ci Pr , e b( ( .I ri to sr -eltd 2 d fn r s Ly nComt , n Ciyo Fenlys o l n t esbe t omut l ato so te 1 ee dmt, o t y a d t f r e h ud o b u jc t lp e cin n l i l 2 s m e i s . Atttspoi tt r i no r a o wh t e i s ofI rga i D iti t r l t d 2 a s ue li n he e s e s n y h s ue r i ton s rc - e a e 2 de e n s ,Lyon Coun y' ,a d Ciy ofFe nl y' la lt s ul not de e m i d i t s 3 f ndn t ' t s n t r e s i biiy ho d be t r ne n hi 2 f nl . Si e t sc s i vol sa di c e ee nta r a iy i ntfa e cl s m e be s 4 o m nc hi a e n ve s r t ve nd e d l de ii bl a s m r y 25 m n a m e toft sc m s a to i n a s g fc ntpr bl m . M os eft pr s d cl s i s il n ge n hi l s ci n s ot i nii a o e t he opo e m s s tl 26 l a e htt c y a t i n ii a i oft e who a e n s d notbe i t no a e s oo t d he ount nd he de tfc ton hos r ot houl nsm unt bl o 27 t a vi ua l al t c ms m e be sw il e ei e notce The dico r c n,f t m os pa t be h t rt ly l he l s m r l r c v i . s ve y a or l w t r, 28 c uc e l a l whe e a lc uns la e r a iy a ia e ond t d oc ly r l o e r e d l va l bl . 9 ! 1 . r( tz c tmus c zsd rt lkeydifc te i man gi acasaci Thi Unde D) le our t olie he i l fiulis n a ng ls ton. s 2 c r m us co i rwhe he a c a s a to i s e i t o he a ia em e ho f a f i a ou t t ns de t r l s c i n s up ror o t r va l bl t ds or a r nd 3 efce a j iainoft sc ves Asbrefydic sda ieeaec rntysve fiint dudc to hi onko ry. i l s use bove r r ure l e n 4 ( c s stl i t Un td Sut aDiti tCour Ditito Ne daco e ngt J nua y5, 7) a e ied n he ie e src t src f va nc mi he a r 5 2002,l d: 1 Kr s ,e a.v Unie St e,e al,3: -v-246;2)Kr s s e alv' foo ( ) o hus t f, . td ats ? . 08c 0 ( o hu, t . J . E ; 6 Unie St e 3: -v- 3;()Uhot e et .v Bu e o clmai 3: c 0 5.( td ath 09c 0071 3 u', al, . r au fRe a ton, 08-v-28 , 4) ! i 7 M oo e e a.vv Unie St ts 3:9- v- 67;( )Ad t,e a . ç Uniedst e 3: - vr , t l a td a e , 0 c 001 5 ge t t I vu t ats, 09 c . , 1 I 2 0 49;()Adammnt e alv'Unie bats 3: -v- 21 a ( Ada on e alv.Unie 06 6 t . tds e , 08c 006 ; nd 7) ms , t . z td . t 9 St e ,3; c 0 5. Ce t yhl a c as a to w o d Ir ttl pr e ur li s sc r i at s 09- v- 071 r i g l s c i n ul ini le oc d a s ue onfontng f 1 t c t Nomatrwha ot rmeh ofaj iauo i c i rd, t ribemuli e 0 he our. te t he tod dudç n s onsdee whehe t tpl 1 c ur a tomsj ide i on c ta tono abirto orme ai weaesilfc dw1.te 1 o t ci ,on r n e our ci r r tain diton, r tl a e t: h 1 1 lr e num b rofpo e ta ltg nt . Es c a l c s de i t a l e fna i de s i t t 2 ag e t n i l ii a s pe i ly on i rng he leg d i nc al va uton ha 1 s t of he p a i c a sm e b r e r e e b t food, c a s a on i s ro t ot r 3 om t ut tve l s m e s xpe i nc d y he l a l s di s upe i r o he 1 meho f tz fi a e ce a j c tonofti c e 4 t ds or ie ar nd o int dudiai bs as. 1 5 I t co m o que to t e e as g t a ms c o t c e a t y c n be r s ve f he m n s i ns ç s nt i nik nt pe t f he as nd he a pr e ol d 1 fralme r o t cms i asngea j i to tlr i ce rj tfc tonf h ndlngt 6 o 1 mbes f he l s n i l dudcain,lee s la usi ai or a i he 1 d s t o a r pr s n i r t rf n o a l di dua bu i . H anl , pr 1 0 F. a 1 7 i pu e n e e e Vtve a he ba n n vi l s' ' on su a. 5 3d t 022 l (nena quoainomitd) I lcti t stsa tonoft prd na ets i t noin 8 itr l tto te . mpii n he aifci he e omi nc e ts he to 1 tatt aj di to ofc mmonis ,wil l a hivejdiile ono Val tnov Care9 b he du cain o sue lhep c e u ca c my. eni . tr s 2 Walac ,I c. s r 97 F. a 1 ctlg 1He b t Ne e g & Al Co e Ne e g o 0 l e n , up w 3d t 234, ii z r er B. wb r ba nt, wb r n 21 Cls Acins 994. a 4-6(de 1 2) as to , 25 t 8 3 d. 99 . 2 2 I Parav Bas 'I .536F.d97 9 ( ) t Ni hCic i Cour sae n r . ho , nc, 3 5, 79,2008 ,he nt rut t ttd: 2 3 Ba hnq, nc. r ue a t di c t i r dr s i t ha m a c lultngtl s 'I a g di t he m uly n e e sng he r nd ac ai le vmi pa d s rtesf rt difr nte oyme postonspr cud s cas ous y ipa ii o he fee mpl m ii el e l s c r i a ' n.W e di a ee W e ha p e otsy he d t tc a s s wih f rm or e t k to l t s gr . ve r vi k l l ha l s e t a e c pl' r m e i sc n s e r dr s i t f m ofacl s a to Se e g. t o om t e d e a e k e e s n he or x m s c i n. e . S at n, 3 27F. t9 57. eclhne dfiuli i bec lultono da g s as h y 3da 53- Th a d ifc tes nt ac a i f ma e , t e a r c e t vmi s c a sm embe s do notp ec ude c a sc rii a i n. f e t d he ou l s rs r l l s e tfc to 2 4 25 26 Tht o r i ng a pr do i nti s i t sc s i t i s ofla iiy.Consde i ve rdi nd e m na s ue n hi a e s he s ue i b lt i rng 27 t pur e ofcas acin c ri ton,ti e nmor i ra tt tcls a tonbeal d i he pos s l s to e tfcai i s ve e mpo tn ha a s ci lowe n 28 1 0 E è k i 1 t sc s,I Amc m Pr t,I . .Wi on 5 U. 591 61 (99 ,heUnie Stts hi ae n he oducs nc v nds 21 S. , 7 1 W t td ae 2 Su e eCou tsa e pr m r t t d: 3 4 5 W ll tl txt Rul 23(8()do sno e i efo c riiainc s i c le l e of e 1 3 e l xcud rm e tfc to aesnwhih i e i vi aldn ag r hi h, le Advi o y Co m it e ha do i nty i m i ndi du m es un g tl s r m te d m na l n nd vi o to o sierg sofgr psof opl whoi vi lywo dbewihout ndiai n f tt i ht t ou pe e ndi dua l ul t efe dvesrngtlobrngt i o ne si t c t a al'Asc ncs l e al d fc te lt i her ppo nt n o out t 1. ' o ieyr c le i a r c ntSe n h Cic to n o n ee ve t r ui pi i n: 6 lf epo i y a t c eo t c a sa to m e ha s i t ove c m et pr bl m G ' lc t he or f he l s c i n c ni m s o r o he o e -h t ts a lr c ve i do notpr vi t e i e i f a i di du t b i a ha m l e o res o de h nc ntve or ny n vi al o lng 7 s l a to p o e u iyh so h r ihs A ca sato s le ti p o lm b oo cin r s c tn i r t rg t. ls cin ov s hs r be y 8 s o s(s lyanatr y')lhm'(iainso te ome ne' ' ual tone s a 'ctto mitd) u 9 a gr gai t r awel paty po e i rco re i o s t ng wo t g e tng he elt y lr t ntal e ve is nt omehi rh A cms a to i t scaei s eirt ohe mehodsofaj iai Thec ne tt l s cin n hi s s up ro o t r t dudcton. omr n o 1 t Fe R.Ci Pr , e 23 s a e : 0 he d. v. o. Rul tt s 1 1 1 2 ( 09()a to e ompas t ec s i whihacm sa tonwouda hive A) 3 cin nc seshos aesn c ls ci l ce e o e oftme efr, nde pe e a l t t fr t ofd csonsa c nomis i , fb ta x ns, nd yomoe miomiy e ii s t pe s s m iary st t ,wiho s orfc g pr e ur f i e sorbrng n o r ons i l l iua ed t ut a ii m oc d al a m s i ig a utunde i a e r s t . bo s r bl e uls 13 Th c ur f d acl sa to i t sc s wo d a c mpls t er s t, swela e o t m s ms c ln n hi a e ul c o ih hos e uls a l s 14 ob a ni r le f r t e c a sm embe swho m i hti vi ualy be un e o unwilng t ltg t t i ng e i f o hos l s r g ndi d l abl r li o ii a e 15 a a ton f fna aloro h rr as ns As e a ne b t c r i No t s e n Fr tCo v n c i or i nci te e o . xpl i d y he ou t n r hwe t r ui . . 16 17 ls 1 9 /.fei t . Ze ne Co.1 6F. D.33 38 ( D. l 1 6)Cl uli elws t .. ul be 1 ' t f nt r , 1 R. 0, 9 E. Ca. 98 ,çml tpl a uis .wo d z y c ty a d i f i e ,a t e l i n ofe l cl s m e be tz tc nn a f r s pa a e os l n ne fci nt nd he xc uso ve y a s m r la a ot f o d e r t rpr e ttonwoul benet rGar no a ûdudîai oft i camsn e esnai d ihe fi' r n a j cton' her li . A c o di y, he c tor r a c a sbe c r ii d a a n t le Ir g to Di ti tr l t d c r ngl t our de s l s e tte g i s tl ri a i n src -e a e 20 de e mls Lyon Co y,a t Ciy o Fe l y. f nd t , unt nd he t f m e 21 Fed.R.Ci Pro. Rul M ( ( f - Cl s Defnii v. . e e) 1) B) as i ton 22 A ss a e pr vi l t Ciy ofF r e pr uc d a m a e tte G a ofEsi a e t t d e ousy he t e nl y od e p n ild t p M tm t d 2 3 24 Efe d( C)Ar Updae 1 1 - . Sadma ie tfe ove lveht e home fde S1 ea td: - 12008' i p d niid ri mdrd % s a f c e by t J nua y 5, fe t d he a r 2008, l d. The c a si g r p ca l de i d b t Ciy o Fe l y foo l s s eog a hi ly f ne y he t f m e 25 ma ( bi 1.Ac r ngl t cass lb p. Exhi t ) codi y,he ls hal e: 26 27 28 Owne . a r nt r ,i l ng t i f m ii s ofr i n i r al o ry wihi ! nd e e s nc udi he r a le , esde tal e pr pe t t n s t a e i n i i d by t Ciy ofFe nl y on J nua y 11 2 , b ng a f c e he r a de t fe he t r e a r , 003 as ei f e t d b t c l ps ofa s g e oftl Tm c Ca lEm bn m en i t e ry y he ola e e m nt le kee na nk t n he a l m om i ofJ mar 5,2008. ng ar y 11 ! 1 A s ls, ls ntt Fe R.Ci Pr , e23()5 , h lbe: ubca sptrua o d. v. o.Rul c() s al 2 3 4 Re e s i c udi t i f m ii s o r sde talr a pr r y wihi t a e nt r s n l ng he r a le , f e i n i e l ope t t n he r a i ntfe b t e Ciy ofFe l y on J a y l1 20 m be ng a f c e by t de i d y h t m e mw r , 08, s i f e t d he c la eofas m e toft Tr k eCa a Emba o lps eg n he uc e n l nkme i t ee ry mor ng nt n h a l ni ofJ n r 5 20 . a ua y , 08 5 Fe R .Ci Pr . Rul 23f ) 1 ( - Cl s Cl i s a I s s d. v. o . e c f 1 C) a s a m nd s ue . 6 The a bove d fne c a sa to i o t i s oft e la lt oftl Irga i Di ti t - e i d l s c i n s n he s ue h i biiy le r i ton s rc - 7 r lt dde e nt, ea e f nda s Lyon Cot y,a Ciy ofFe ly.Thecas c amsag i t heIrgain mt nd t me l s li ans t ri to 8 DiGotrltddee ansae: 1 Ne i nc a dGr s Ne ie e-Fal et Manano s -eae fnd t r ( ) glge e n o s glg nc iur o iti r 9 M o tr ( Ne i n ea Gr sNe ie e-Falr t Re d orPrve tHam;3 nio ;2) glge c nd os glg nc iue o me y e n r () ! 1 1 Nuia e;a d, ( Tr pa s ()Ijmci ai M a dae;6) oltonof 0 s nc n 4) es s; 5 nt ton r d n t ( Vi ai DuePr es ai () oc s; rd, 7 i 1 Ne i nc .n ecascai a i ttz CiyofFenlym>:()Iju ina Ma t;() 1 glge e ls l ms gans le t re 1 n twto nd ndae 2 1 Vi a nofDu Pr e s a ()Ne i nc Th cascamsa i theComt ofLyo ae 2 oléo e oc s; nd,3 glge e. e ls li gans t t y n r; 1 ()ljmci a Ma t;( Vi ai o DuePrc s;a ( Ne ie e. 3 1 nt ton nd ndae 2) olton f o e s nd,3) glg nc 1 Fe R . i Pr . ul 23f 1-A ppoi m e o Cl sCo e 4 d. C v. o. R e e nt nt f as uns l 1 5 Pu s ntt Fe R.Ci Pr ,Rul 2 g, e ac r c riis&cast ç ur mus rua o d. v. o. e 3()wh n ou t etfe ls he o t t 1 a ntcusco e.Fe R.Ci Pr , l 23( ()A)prvi si a poitngcl so un e 6 ppoi l unsl d. v. o.Rue g)1( o de n p ni as o s l 1 t courtm ustconsi 7 he der: l 8 (lhewokc unsl d i i ntài ri e dgalgpotn cai i he it r o e has one n de i ngo nv s t e dz l ms nt l 9 (ic nslse re ei ha dlngcasa fok,ot rc mplxltgai a i) ou e' xpeinc n n i lq c xs he o e ii tow nd 2 0 titpso camsasr diteat n ( y e f li set n h ci ; / i e o 21 a ton; ci 1coms ' k edg oft a ia elw;a ) t els nowl e he pplc bl a nd (v tl rs ce t tc e wilc unit rpesntngt cms; i) le eour s ha ounsl l on t o e r e i l l s x A l oft e a o c ns de a i nse ubls t to a so ns lpr pos d b t e pa te a e l h b ve o i r t o s i h ha l s ou e o e y h ri s r 22 a r it cls c t el Tbec t r by a po n sRobe tC. a ox,Es a Nmly H. gp oprae a s oms . our he e p i t r M dd q. nd c 23 J s ul w Es oft l w tnn Robe tC. a o & As oc a es Ve non E. ve t Es , ti k ac c q. he a i r M dd x s it ; r Le ry, q. Pa rc 24 R . ve t Es a W iln R . ' Es .o tl 1 w fr I ve t & A s oc a e La Cht , Le ry, q. nd li m G I nn, q f le a lm x ry s i t s w, d. 25 Cavi R. . l n X Dunlp, q. nd M oniueLa at Bs o t lw fr Dunlp & La at Robe tR. a Es a q x l, q. f he a im a xl r 26 H a r Es a Tr va Hea ne, q. t lw fr Hag r& H e m e a Le Hot hki Fs of ge , q. nd e r Es of he a im e a nd e c n, aq. 27 t La Ofi e o Le T.Ho c n c u sc uns l n e a n e c as o s lw ilf il a he w lc s f e t hki l o e . ppoi t d l s oun e l a ry nd 28 1 2 j ! l a q t l r pr e tt ile es o t c as . de ua e y e es n he tt r t f he l s 2 C ON CLUSI N O 3 I i he e y ORD ERED : ts rb 4 1 . Thi a ton i c rii a a c a s a ton t e I gai n Di t it r a e de e da s s c i s e t ed s l s c i h ni to s rc -el t d f n nt , f 5 Lyon Cot y,a d t Ciy o Fe nl y. mt n he t f r e 6 2. Thecu ss l be l hal : . 7 Owne sa e es i l i gt i a iis of sde tir r ndr ntr ,ncud n herfm le , R i n i eipr o wihi ope t nie 8 a e de ii d b heCiyof m l yon J nua ' 11 2008 a benga f c e byt e r ai ntfe yt t Fe e a l , y , s i fe t d h c l ps o as m e oft Tnz ke Cn Embn ola e f eg m he c e nal nkme i t e ry m o nh g of nt n he a l r l J nua y 5, a r 2008. 9 3. A s bcas pusmn t Fe R.Ci Pr ,Rul 23c() s lbe u ls, rt t o d, v. o. e ()5, hal : l 0 11 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 Re t r ,i l ng t e r f m ii s of r i n i lr alpr pe t wili t a ea n e s nc udi l i a le , esde ta e l o r y tzn he r i ii by t Cij ofFer ey on J dentfed he tr nl anuar 11,2008,asbei afect by t y ng f ed he c l ps ofa s gm e oft Tr c e Ca lEmbn e i t e e ry m o n ng of ola e e nt he u ke na nkm nt n h a l r i J n r 5, a ua y 2008. 4. Co m s lf t cl s s l be: t e or he a s ha l Rober C.M addox,Esq. t N a y H . a c l a,Es nc J s uc q. ROBERT C. ADD OX & ASSOCI M ATES Cal n R.X .D unl Fwq. vi ap, s M o que La lyEs ni xa t q. DUNLA P & LAX ALT V e n E.Le ry, q. r on ve t Es Pa rc R. ve t Es ti k Le r ys q, W ila R . nw Es li m Gi q. LEVERTY & ASSO CI ATES LA W ,CHTD. Ro r R . a e , w q be t H g r Fs Tr vaHe e, q. e am Es HA GER & HEA RN E 1 8 i 1 9 20 Lee Hot n,Esq. chkl THE LA W OFFI CES OF LEE T.H OTCH I N U 5. T'e Pl l tf si s l pr deno i e oft c m sa to t put tve c a sm e be s h a if n ha l ovi tc he l s c i n o a i l s m r 21 p s l tt t a o d no i e a t c d he e o a Ex bi 1 . ur l o he ppr ve tc ta he r t s hi t Q ' nn ' 2 2 6. Sevi e ofs i no i e t e c m e be o tl c a s s l be s ntvi fr tc a sm a l l c a d tc o a h m r f le l s ha l e a is l s i 23 t t c r ntm a lng a r s o t c % sm e be , o t e e tpo s b e a d a r s t t o he ure ii dd e s f he l m r t he xt n s i l , n dd es ed o he 24 c as m e b ra c a sm e r sf m iy. Cl s c l s m e nd l s mbe ' a l a s ouns ls l s ow pr ofm a ln t e c e ha l h oof ii g o a h 25 a es b pu o i a c r ik a e ofm a lng f e c m a l d notc Cl s c ddr s y r hasng e t t f ii or a h ie i e. a s ouns ls l a c mt e hal c ot 26 f t c r ii a esofm a lng i a m a lng book t be ke by o a sc m s lf t d a i n of or he e ttc t ii n ii o pt l s ot e or he ur to 27 t i a i n. The c tofp ovi i t no i e s l be b n by cl s co el Se v c o s i h s cto os r d ng he to ha l or e a s uns . r i e f a d 28 no i s l be c pl t d t t e e tpos i es orb or N o m be 1 201 tce ha l om e e , o he xt n sbi on ef e ve r , 0. 13 E l 7, Re s st o - tm us b m a ld t Ro r C. a dox, q. Ro r C. que t o ptou t e ie o be t M d Es s be t 2 Ma ddox a d As oc a e ,1 7 D o e R Bl S t 1 Re o, e d 8 n s i t s 058 ubi vd uie 00, n N va a 9521 a pos m a ke nd t r d 3 no l t rt n De e be 3,2 0. , a e ha c m r 01 . à ' 4 ot ti adhs e yo ( r ' . . ,00 . 21. 5 ' 6 8 9 10 l1 1 2 1 3 1 4 15 16 l7 1 8 1 9 20 21 22 23 2 4 25 ! ! 26 l l ! i 27 2s 14 ' . , ' . , Uni d tt sDi - J ae s udge 7 : , E xhi t 1 bi E xhi t 1 bi E xhi t 2 bi E xhi t 2 bi M. DI W CX RT * STRI R >S l * Ne#*#* LE G % ' - l a uo.--' ' j û2 1 1 ï1 T û 2 oa wsx. u w = 3 ' > mœ e oale l . .e Aex zu : 4 5 UN I TED STA TES DI STRI CO URT CT 6 DISTRICT O F NEVADA 7 A LI A U HOU SE,etal, CI . CaseN o.3: cv08- 0285LDG -l M 1A 8 Pl ntf s ai if , 9 1 0 VS . 1 1 U NI TED STATES DEPA RTM ENT OF THE m TERI BU REAU OF RECLAM ATI , OR, ON etal, . 1 2 1 3 De e nt . f nda s l 4 J DY K RO SHU S,e a . U t1 Ca e No.3: - v- 46s 08 c 02 LDGRAM 15 Pl i if . a ntf s 1 6 N OTI O F PENDEN CY O F CLA SS CE A cr ox n 1 7 VS' , 8 UN I TED STATES O F AM ER I .e a . CA t 1 1 9 20 21 2 2 2 3 2 4 25 26 To: 27 D e e nt . f nda s N otce:A f t i ederalcqurtlasent l ered an order erantne cl s certfi en i a l i as i cati n awsuj kno n asUkous e aL v Bur au ofRe l aton. tql. 08-' 0 w e. t . e c am i e .3: c 285- G- AM . vLD R and Kr s . tq .p Unie a e .e Jl. 0 t - 6- G - AM . You m a haveal e dv o hus e l . t dst t s t . 3: 8-' 024 LD R v v ra r eve no i e f o t N e da s at c ec i d tt s r m he va t e ourtt t l w s t fl d i t Thi d Judi i l ha a ui s ie n be r ca D lt i tCo taeai tTruc e car e I r za i D k t i ta isBoar ofb i e t r c ur ns ke - s n r i ton s r c nd t d r c on ( GTCI . v ds t al%p TC1D .et el.Cas N um ber Cl 18948.and t Civ of DN Re nol . . . . / e he t Fer e and Lvon Counw .Rev l s e al.# Cl o Fe nl v e aL.C a eN um be nl v no d . t . . * f r e . t s r cl 190 . ha be n c rtfe as c a s a tons Thi Nedc e ai t na ur oftl 02 ve e e ii d ls ci . s e xol ns be t e le ltgati pendi ilt f ii on ne l he ederalcourt . .. - - Ow ne sand r nt r y nc udi t i f ii s o r s de i r alpr r y wili t r e e s i l ng be r am le , f e i ntal e ope t tln he area i dentli by t Ciy ofFernly on January 11,7008.as bei af ect by t fed be t e ng f ed he eolaps ofa s entoft T ruckee CanalEm banl l e egm he unenti t earl m orni of n he y ng Januar 5, y 2008 a c as ac i l ui m a af e tyour r aht : , l , ton aws t y f c s i s 28 - I- ' E i ! I l (fyou we e a o r o r sde i lr a pr ry afeced by t c laps o t I r n wne f e i nta e l ope t f t be o l e f he 2 TruckeeCanalem bankm enton January 5,2008 and re ed yourpropert t a rent nt yo er i Jasuar 2 ,plas pr dea c py oft sNt c t yourr nt ra t tm e) n y 008 e e ovi o bl die o e e t he i . 3 4 TH I N O T S ICE H AS BEEN APPRO VED W y TI E UN I I TED ST TES w szw cr co L r A m TH I I N O TA SOLI A H ON FR OM M A TTOR NE Y S S CIT 5 . 6 Owne s a r nt r o r s d nta r alp op r y st a e i t Ciy ofFe nl y, nt of r nd e e s f e i e i l e r e t iu t d n he t r e Cou y Lyo i J nt y 2 ha s d Tr c e ca s n l ga i D i ti , r ofD ie t sof n n a mr 008 ve ue u ke - r o ni ton s rct Boa d r cor Tr ke - r on Irga i n D iti t Da d P. r o d, t ofFe nl y,a Lyo Co y uc e ca s r i to sr c a vi Ove v l Ciy r e nd n unt 1 ( ri fe H fnda t' frda ge t ys sane a ars to t fiur oft heenatr Dee ns' o ma ' be u ti d s eul f he al e he ) s Tr ke Ca le ba km e o J nua y 5, 8uc e na m n nt n a r 200 8 . 9 1 0 1 . 1 12 The Co tha al e t l w s tt be a c a sa i n on be a fofa Iowne sa r n e s ur s l d he a ui o ow l s cto hl 1 r nd e t r ofr sde i r a pr pe t i cl di t ei f m iy m e r ,i t Ciy ofFe nl y, e i ntal e l o ry, n u ng h r a l mbe s n he t r e Coun y ofLy N e d on J nua y 5,2 .who w e e a f c e by t c l ps oft e t on, va a a r 008 r fe t d he ola e h Tnz ke Ca a emba m en i t e ry m or ng ofJ nua y 5, c e nl nk t n he a l ni a r 2008. The Cou t s n de i d w h he De e n sha do a hi w r g. Th r i n r ha ot c de et r f nda t ve ne nyt ng on ee s o m oney avaia e now ,and no guar ee t e wilbe. H ow e ,yourl rght ar lbl ant her l ver egal i s e a f c e an you ha a c i e t m a no : f e t d, d ve ho c o ke w 13 Y OU R LEG AL RI I A ND O PTI NS I TH I LA W SU I GI TS O N S T 14 15 Do N OTH I NG st i t sI s t Aw ai t out e. ay n hi aw ui. t he com G i up eert n ri s ve ai ght . By d ng not ng, you ke p t pos i iiy o oi hi e he s b lt f ge tng m one orbeneft t m ay com e fom a ti y is hat r t alorasetl e . But you gi up any rght ri tem nt , ve i s t s Def o ue endant s at y a s epar el boutt s e he am l g lc am s i t sl w s t e a l i n hi a ui. ASK TO BE EXCLUDED Ge oute t sl w s t G e no be ft f o t f hi a ui. t ne is r m i. K e p r ght . t e i s I you m k t be e l d a m o y orbe ft f s o xc ude nd ne ne is a e l t ra r d, w il slr i t s r a e wa de you l not la e n ho e. But you ke p a y rg st s D e e a s , e n i bt o ue f nd nt s at I aboutt s e l cl m s i t s epar e y he am egal ai n hi l ws i. a ut 1 6 1 7 j 8 1 9 2 0 21 22 2 3 2 . 4 Yotroptonsa e e pl i d i t s no i e To b e ud d, m us ac be or z i r x a ne n hi tc . e xcl e you t t f e D e ber3,2010. cem 25 26 27 Atom e m us pr ve t c am s a i tD e e nt a a ti notye s he ul d l m o y t ys t o he l i ga ns f nda s t ral t c d e . f ne orb ne isa e o a ne f o De e n s e ft r bt i d r m f nda t iIbeno i e a utho t a k I a 1 tt d bo i w o s br , you w shar e. 28 * A ny que i stons? R e on. ad * - 2- W H AT TH I N OT I CON TAI S S CE N BA SIC I FO N A TI N O 1 ' by di Ige t snotce . ... ... .... ... ... .. .... .. ... ... .- -. .W d t hi i ? . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 2. W ha i t sl ' ui a t .. . . . .... ... ... ... -.. ... .. . -.. . . t s hi avs t bou ? . . . . s . . . . . . -. ..4 3. W ha i a c a sa to a who i i l ? .... ... ... ... -.. .... ... . . t s l s c i n nd s nvo ved . . . . . . ..4 4 W hy i t s l h ui a c a sa ton .. .... .. ... . . . . .. .... ... .. .. s hi a vs t l s c i ? . . . ..... . # . . 4 TH E CLA I S I TH E LAW SUI M N T 5. a doest l w sui cor ai a ' .....,........-.............-.......5 t he a' t npl n bout? 6. How di De e nt a we ? .. .... d f nda s ns r ... ..... .... ..... .. .... .... .... ..., 5 ... 7. Hasi e Coud dec' who i rght .....................................,.5 l ded si ? 8. #/ ta e t Pl i i as ng f ? . ha r he antls ki or ..... .... .... .... .... .... .... ..... ... .. 5 9. I t e any n y avaiabl now ? ........................................5 s her aone l e W H O I I TH E CLASS S N 10. A m lpad oft sCl ? ...............................................5 hi ass 11 la n s ilno s e i I n i l d... ... .. ... ... ... ... ... ...- - ..5 . l tl t ur f ar nc ude . . . . . . . . .. YO U R RI HTS A ND O PTI NS G O 1 s a ha pe fldo not ng a a 1 ... 2. vh t p nsi hi t l? . .... .... .... ...... .. ,... .... .6 ... ... 1 N y w ou d la k t be e l d .. 3. fh l s o xc ude ? .... .... ... .... .... .... .... .... ... 6 ... . 1 Ho do Ia k t Cou t o e l r fom t Cl s ? .. .... ... ... .. ... 6 4. w s he r t xc ude ne r he a s . . . . . . TH E A O EYS P SENTI G Y OU N 1 Do lhave an ador n t s cas ......................,................6 5. neyi hi e? 1 Shoul Ige my own a n y? . 6. d t uon e .... .... ..... ... ... ... ...... .... .. ..... 7 .. 1 How w ilt ator 7. l he t neysbe pai ,........................................7 d? TH E TRIAL 1 H o a d whe wil h Co de i wbo i ngh ? .. ... ... ... ... ... . .7 8. w n n l t e un c de s' t . . . . . .. G ETTING M O RE I NFO ATI N O 1 Ar m O de aisa ia e ... 9. e K t l va l bl ? .... .... .... ... .... .... ... ...... .... .7 .. ... g j i 1 M o ei o ma in a utwh t Co ti al ngt slws tt beaca sa to i i t Or e r nf r to bo y he ur s lowi hi a ui o ls ci n s n he d r Re Cl s Ce tfc t o a A poo nt e ofCl s Coun e , c i a aia e a : a s rii a i n nd i m nt as s l whi h s v l bl t 2 www f r e l od-or e nl yfo g. 3 4 B. TH E CLAI S I THE LAW SUI M N T 5 5. W batdo s tl l w s tc pl i a e le a ui om a n bout ? l t lws i,t Pl i if s yt tDe e a s a tonso i ci rs td i ham t o r n he a u t he antfs a ha f nd nt' ci r na tons e ule n r o wnes he 6 an r ntr , i l ng t i f miis ofr sde ilr a pr pe t wihi t a e i n iidby1 d e e s ncudi her a le . e i nta e l o ry t n he r a de tfe Ciy ofFe n e on J nua y 1 , t r ly a r 1 2008 who w e e a f c e by t c l ps ofa s gm e toft , r f e t d he ola e e n he 7 Tr c e Ca lEm ba km e i t e ry m or ng ofJ nu r 5, 20 u ke na n nt n be a l ni a ay 08. 8 6 H o di D e e w d f ndant ans e ? s w r . 9 Defnda t de y t t y dd a yt ngwr ng. e n s n hat he i n hi o 1 7. H a t Cour de i d w ho i r ght 0 s he t e de si ? The Cour ha notde i d whe he tl Pl i if orDe e a s a e c r e t By e t bls ng t t s c de t r le a ntfs f nd nt r o r c . sa i hi he 1 cl s a is ng t sN otc ,t Cou ti nots ge tng t tt e Pl i if w ilwi orl e t s 1 a s nd s ui hi i e hc r s ug s i ha h a ntf s l n os hi c s ThePli if mus pr vet i c amsa ati whihwilbes h duld i t f u c ( e a e. antfs t o her l i t ral c l c e e n he utr . Se , TheTral jej oppagey.) i , ) ow 1 q 2 , 1 3 8 % ata et Pl i if a ki f ? . r he a ntfs s ng or 1 Th Plitf aeakn t b cmpestdfrtelse te a dohrme eso teCls 4 e ani s r sig o e o nae o h ossh y n te mb r fh as f s sant a ar s toft f iur oft Tr c e Ca lon J nua y5,2 u ti d s e ul he al e he u k e na a r 008. 15 9 1 t rea mone a l eno : he ny y vaiabl w? 1 No m on y o ne isa e a ia e no be a e tl Cou t s n ye de i ed whe he 6 e rbe ft r va lbl w c us le r ha ot t c d t r D e e n sha don a t ng w r ,a t tv s de ha nots tl d t c s The e i no f nda t ve e ny hi ong nd he so i s ve e te he a e. r s 17 gu r nt e t tm one o be ft wile rbe o ai e l t y a e yo wilb notfe a ut a a e ha y r ne s l ve bt n d. f he r , u l e ii d bo j low t a kf as r l i pos i et tyo ma n e t pr vi s pr o l s si o d r 8 l o s or ba e. t s sbl ha u y e d o o de ome oof f os e n r e t r ove m o y. n e t a s u yo m i r c ve i t s c s a i o h rc s, a ii o of o ec r ne ot l t n u ght e o r n hi a e nd n t e a e r sng ut s 1 tez n r 5, 9 h a ua y 2008 foodca e e d t tt lda g you s f rd a ar s to t foo l nnot xc e he o a ma es ufe e s e ul f he l d. 2 0 c. w Ho I I THE CLASS sN 21 Y o ne d t de de whe he yo a e a f ct d by t sl ws t u e o ci t r u r fe e hi a ui. 22 10 oft sC l ss bi a ? . Am I part 23 The Co tde i d t a a1 owne s a r n e sofr s de ta r a pr pe' i l ng f m iy ur c de h t l r nd e t r e i n i l e l o ly, no udi a l t m e be s o owne ' o r t r , iu t d i t Ciy ofFe n e Cou y o Lyon, e da a o m r f z r en e s s t a e n he t s r l y, nt f N va s f 2 J nua y 5, 4 a r 2008,a w ho w e e a f c e by t ec l ps oft e Tr ke Ca le br e i t nd r f e t d l ola e h uc e na m mkm nt n he l e ry m o n n ofJ n r 5, al r ig a ua y 2008 a epa loftl c as . r r ie l s 2 5 2 11 Iam s ilnets e Iam i l d. 6 . tl ur nc ude l y a e silnots e w h h ry m' î l d, u ca c l o wrt t t l wye si t sc s f ou r tl ur et e ou e nc ude yo n a l r ie o he a r n hi a e, 27 lse i que ton 1 it d n s i 9. 28 - 5- ! , : i ' 1 D. Y OU R RI H TS AN D O PTI N S G O 2 Y o ba t de i whe he t sa i t cl s ora k t be e ude be o e ti , and you have u ve o c de t r o t y n he a s s o xcl d f r ral 3 t deci t snow . o de hi 4 1 W hathappe i Ido not ng atal? 2. ns f hi l Y ou do n ha t do a hi now i you w a t ke p t pos i lt ofge tn m o y o ot ve o nyt ng f nt o e he s biiy ti g ne r 5 be ft fom t s l w s t By d ng no bi g, ; e sa n i t Cl s . I yo s a i a t t ne is r hi a ui. oi t n you r t yi g n he a s f u t y n nd h Pl i i f obt i m on y o be is e t ra a r s toft t- lora s tl m e ,y u w ilbe a ntf s a n e r neft , ihe s e ul he na e te nt o l 6 noiid a thow t a pl f as r (rho t a k t bee l d fom a y s tlme ) tfe bou o p y or hae o w o s o xcude r n e te nt. Pl as ke i m i t ti vou do not ne no .r e dl s ofw he he t Pl ntf sw i or e e ep n nd ha f hi w e ar e s t r he ai if n 1 l set t i . vou w ilnotbe abl t s .o c nt nuet s .De e o he r al l e o ue r o i e ue f ndant .a par ofa s s t nv 8 otl r l w s t a le a ui. bouttl s m e I ealc a m stl a e t s ec oft sl w s t Th sm e ns le a e l i lat r be ubi t hi a ui. i a t ti you d no hi yo w il l g ly bo nd by a lort O r e s t Co tis s a d ha f o t ng, u l be e a l u 1 he d r he ur s ue n 9 j gme st Co t kesi t scasato ud nt he ur ma n hi ls cin. 1 1 W hy w oul I as t be e l d? 0 3. d k o xcude I yo a r a ha y urown l w s ta i tDe e a s a d w a t c ntnue wib i, u m a f u le dy ve o a ui ga ns f nd nt n nt o o i t t yo y 11 w ih t be e l ed fom t Cl s . I vou e l vour e ff om t Cl s w hi h a s m e ns s o xc ud r he a s f xc ude sl r he as . c l o a t r m ovevour e ff om t Cl s a i s m e i e c l d Go i - ' n t Cl s . o e sl r be as . nd s o tm s ale otne out' f be a s v@u 1 w ilnoteetauv m one or bene t from t sI s i e n i t Pl ntf s obt n t 2 l v fis hi aw u t ve f he ai if ai hem as a 1 r s t o t t i lorf o anv s t l m e f ha m a orm a no be r ac d)be w e n 3 e ul f he r a rm e te nt t t y v t e he t e De e nt and t Pl ntf s Howe r yo m a t n be a e t s o c i e t s f nda s he ai if . ve , u y he bl o ue r ontnu o ue 1 Dee ns I youe l yo sl, ouwilno bel al bo byt Cour' udg nt i 4 fnda t. f xcude urefy l t eg ly und he tsj me s n t scl ssacton. hi a i 15 I y u sa t uro n Iw s ta i s Def nd nt a t ryo e l y s l, wilha e t h r f o t r yo w a ui ga n t e a s fe u xc ude our e f you l v o ie l6 and pay yourow n l yerf t l ui and you wilha t pr yourcl m s. I you do aw or hat aws q l ve o ove ai f 1 e cl y s fs you ca sa to c i e yo o l w s tag i tDe e nt ,y u s d 7 x ude our el o n t r r ontnu ur wn a ui a ns f nda s o houl tl t y rownlwy rs be a eyo camsma bes jctt asamt ofImiains ak o ou a e oon, c us ur li y ube o t e i tto . 18 14. H ow do Iask the C ourtt excl m e f e ude rom t Cl s? be as 1 To a k t be e l d, m us fl o ,sgn, n r t r t e l e pos c r s a i t tyo 9 s o xc ude you t il ut i a d e u n he nc os d t a d, t tng ha u wa t bee ud fo Uho e e alv Bur a o camato ,e al,3: -v- 5nto xcl ed rm us, t - . e u fRe l în t . 08c 028 LDG- 20 I M S a Kr s us e al v Unie S a e .e a . 3: - v- 246u nd o h , t . . t d t t s t l, 08 c 0 LDGRAM ,Unie St t s td a e Diti tCou tf t Dit i tofNe da t Cl s Co e Robe tC . a x, q. Ro r C. src r or he s rc va , o a s uns l r M ddo Es , be t 21 Ma ddox & Ass ats, 1 7Do bl R Bld.S t 1 , n Ne da895 ( - 366 . oci e 058 u e v , uie 00 Re o, va 21 775322- 6) 2 Y o m us m a l urExc us on Re s po t a k d b De e be 3, 0. 2 u t i yo l i que t s m r e y c m r 201 23 E. TH E AW O RN EYS R EPRESENTI G YO U N 24 15. I) Ihave an atorne i t scas o t y n hi e? 2 n ecou td ci d t tt 1 w fr so Ro r C . M a 5 r e de ha he a im f be t ddox & Associ es,D unl & Laxal, at ap t Le e t & A s o a e La Cht ,Ha e & He r ,a t taw Om c ofLr T.Ho c n of v ry s ci t s m d. g r a ne nd he e e t hki 2 Re o,Ne da a e qual i t r m es nty an a 1Cl s M e r . Toge:e t 1 w fr s a e 6 n va r i ed o e e ou d l a s mbe s t t r he a im r 27 c le ' a s Co e m n e a e e pe i nc d i ba dln c a sa ton lw s t . M o e . a l d t s uns l' cl ' y r x re e n n i g l s c i a uis r i f nna i n a m t e e 1 w fr s t i p a tc s a d t i ator y e re e i a ia e a n o to bo h s a i m , be r r c i m , n l r t ne s' xpe i nc s va l bl t w 28 w ww.e nl yfo or f r e l od. g. i i -6- ! 1 16 Shoul I ge m y o n at or y? . d t w t ne You do notnee t hieyourown a tr ybe us Cl sCouns li wor ngon yourbebaf do r to ne ca e as e s ki l 2 Bu , i yo wa yo ow n a t ne you F ilha t pa t ta l ney Fore m pl ,yo c n as t f u nt ur tor y, l ve o y ha tor . xa e u a k 3 hi e lert a ari Co tf ryou i you wa s m r l o ppe n ur o f nt omeoneot rt n Cl s Co e t s a f r be ha m s uns l o pe k o you. I 4 I 1 17. How w ilt at r ysbepa d? l he o ne i 5 I Cls Co ms ge r y orbe ison be l oft Cl s ,t y m a a k tl Cour t be f m s t el t none neft ha f he a s he y s le to a r d f sa e ns s I t Co t a sCl s Co el'r que t t f e a e ns s wa de ee nd xpe e . f he ur gr nt a s uns s e s, he e s nd xpe e 6 ma ybede uced for a m o y ob ane f t Cls o pad s pa a ey by Def ndan s d t r n ny ne t i d or he m s r i e r t l e t. 7 F Tu E Tm x t v 8 Th e Co twils dul ati l o decdewho i rghti t sc s ur l che e ra t i s i n hi a e. 9 1 H o a w he w ilt Co de i w le i ri ? 8. w nd n l he urt c de l s ght 1 A s l a t c s i notr s ve by a s tl m e o o he w ie,Cl sCouns lw ilha t pr ve 0 ong s he a e s e ol d e te nt r t r s as e l ve o o t Pli if cli sa ati l The ti lba notye be n s he ul dbuto e i i s he e i he antfs' am t ra . ra s t e c d e nc t s c dul d, t 11 w ilt ke pl e a t Br e R . Tho ps Unied St t Co t e, l a ac t he uc m on t aes urhous 400 S. r ni St& no, Vigi a .Re Ne da Durng t ti ,a J y wilhe ra 1oft e de t hel t m r c a de so a va . i he ral ur l a 1 he vi nce o p he ea h cii n bout 1 w het rt Pl i if orD e e nta er ghta utt c am si t l w s j. Ther i no 2 es he he a ntf s f nda r i bo be l i n he a u t l gu a e t tt Pl i i f w il i ort tt y w ilge a m o y f t Cl ss 3 ar nt e ha he a nt f s l w n, ha he l t ny ne or he a . 1 4 G . G ETTI G M O R E I N NFO R M A TI N O 1 19. Are m or de aisavaiabl 5 e t l l e? Y o m ay s k t o oft a t r ysby c lng o wr tng t t m : u pea o ne he to ne ali r ii o he 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 20 Robe tC . r Ma ddox,Es q. Nanc H . y J s ul ,Es a c ca q. RO BERT c . H M m ox & ASS ATES OCI 21 (7 )3 2 3 6 7 5 2 - 66 Ca vi R . . l n X Dunl p,Es a q. M oni La t que xal, Es q. DUNt, & e LA X AL T V e non E. r Le t Es very, q. Pa rc R. tik Le t Es very, q. w ila R. lim G i Es nn, q. (75 3 - 7 0 LEVER'Y & 7 ) 23 7 9 I ' ASSOCI ATES Rober R . t H a r Es ge , q. Tr vaHea ne e r , Es q. H AGER & H ' RN E RA Lee H ot hk n, c i Es q. TH E LAW O FFI CES OF LEE T. H o Tc l fm ( 5 3 95 0 77 ) 2 - 8 0 ( 5 7 6 5 91 77 ) 8 - 7 LA W ,C H TD . 22 ( )3 6636 775 22- 23 p A-- p tg js l s ) KJ dy f c br21. aoot e,00 o ' 24 s 25 /' e L o D. o g T Unied St e Dim c J t s s t udge 26 Encl ur os e: Excl i Req s us on ue t 27 28 - 7- '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
