Cribbs v. Walgreen Co., No. 2:2022cv01167 - Document 13 (D. Nev. 2022)

Court Description: ORDER Granting 12 Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge Nancy J. Koppe on 9/30/2022. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - YAW)

Download PDF

! " # $ %& ' ( % ) *+ , ' " -./ 0 //1/// 2-./ 0 //1///* Cribbs v. Walgreen Co. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2 21 22 23 24 Doc. 13 345 785978 :; 94<4==>? 83@; ABCDED GDH AIJ KLMN O>PQ>R9>3P5==? 83@; ABCDED GDH AIJ STST U4:83V; W5=XY? 83@; ABCDED GDH AIJ NZZT 94<4==> Y4<>8= V5[=89 \:594<?==P ]SM^_J `IHabIc daEeB fDHghDijkZ^^ lBmBnoIcBp qL^]r MLLsLLLM tDuvawamBp qL^]r MLLsLLLN HDcDmmavBHCauBxHDcDmmamDhiBHvJuIw yzz{|}~ {| ~ ~} }z y <>X8R3X4X83R>3X9>PXP5 9X V59XW8R>3X9>PX5V<8O4R4 ` d A d GG j r r DvBAIJp]p]]suCs^ZZ Ls sA r fmDac a j r r P5<V>R8<X>4=>X¤ CvJ r 3X>¥ =4X>5<4<R r ¥95X8PX>O859R89 _ d A J E D _ d A jDr tIHBaec IHnIHD aIc r f ¡ t _ d A j r Zs]^DcE d G¢ A Al l r Zs]^jacum£vaCB r r B BcEDc vJ r r P5<V>R8<X>4=>X¤3X>¥ =4X>5<4<R¥95X8PX>O859R89 BH Dac nDH aBv BmaBCB oD EavuICBHi hamm BcuIwnDvv EIu£wBc v DcE ac IHwD aIc oD hI£mE cI IHEacDHami B EavumIvBE I oB n£ mau DcE oD EavumIv£HB IH wav£vB I v£uo wD BHaDmv hI£mE uD£vB uIwnB a aCB oDHwj EaC£meB HDEB vBuHB vj HDavB nHaCDui uIcuBHcvj DcE CaImD B uIc aEBc aDma i nHICavaIcv vB 1 Dockets.Justia.com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`\ab]]67<6c dC I4:39?A:69<E e:345T<694:c f45 BK5B4=A= 43 679= D@5AA? M5?A5G OI4:39?A:69<E e:345T<694:P =7<EE TA<: ?4;KTA:6= 45 467A5 T<6A59<E= 67<6 4:A 45 T45A B<569A= >AE9AHA 64 9:;EK?A B54B59A6<5F 9:345T<694: 5AE<69:@ 64 67A95 >K=9:A==G ?9=;E4=K5A 43 S79;7 T9@76 >A 7<5T3KEG 9:;EK?9:@ >K6 :46 E9T96A? 64G 9:345T<694: 67<6 7<= :46 >AA: T<?A <H<9E<>EA 64 67A BK>E9; <6 E<5@AG ;4:39?A:69<E 5A=A<5;7G ?AHAE4BTA:6G ;4TTA5;9<E 9:345T<694:G ;4:65<;6=G ;4EEA;69HA ><5@<9:9:@ <@5AATA:6G <:? 65<?A =A;5A6=G 9:;EK?9:@ >K6 :46 E9T96A? 64 5KEA= <:? 5A@KE<694:=G B4E9;9A= <:? B54;A?K5A=G B54;A==A=G 4BA5<694:=G 65<9:9:@T<6A59<E=G=<3A6FT<6A59<E=C g46S967=6<:?9:@ 67A 345A@49:@G 67A 6A5T hI4:39?A:69<E e:345T<694:h ?4A= :46 9:;EK?A 9:345T<694: S79;7 N<Q 9= 9: 45 >A;4TA= < B<56 43 67A BK>E9; ?4T<9: S9674K6 H94E<694: 43 679= D@5AA? M5?A5 >F <:F B<56F 64 679= E969@<694: 45 67A95 ;4K:=AEi N>Q S<= j:4S: 64 < B<56F 64 679= E969@<694: 4: < :4:k 1 ! " # $ %& ' ( % ) *+ , ' " -./ 0 //1/// 2-./ 0 //1///* 2 3 1 4 5 6 7 8 9 2 22 23 21 24 25 26 27 28 29 3 32 33 31 34 34567895:7;< >;?7? @A74A :4 7:? 87?3<4?BA9 :4 ?B3C @;A:D 4A :C97A 34B5?9< 75 :C7? <7:7E;:745F 4A G3H 7? 54: 4:C9AI7?9 ?B>J93: :4 ; A9?:A73:745 45 87?3<4?BA9 ;58 7? A7EC:6B<<D 4>:;7598 >D ;5D @;A:D 4A :C97A 34B5?9< 6A4K ; ?4BA39 4:C9A :C;5 ; @;A:D 75 :C7? <7:7E;:745L M96958;5:? K;D 89?7E5;:9 843BK95:?N 7564AK;:745 4A :9?:7K45D ;? O4567895:7;< P564AK;:745 B589A :C7? QA89A ;? 64<<4I?R ;L SC9 89?7E5;:745 ?C;<< >9 K;89 >D 3<9;A<D ?:;K@75E 4A K;AT75E ;5D 843BK95:N 753<B875E ;5D 75:9AA4E;:4AD ;5?I9A 4A :A;5?3A7@:N I7:C :C9 I4A8UOQVWPMXVSPYZL[ >L SA;5?3A7@:? G4A @4A:745? :C9A946H K;D >9 89?7E5;:98 \OQVWPMXVSPYZ\ >D 75?:AB3:75E :C9 A9@4A:9A :4 ?:;K@ 4A K;AT :C9 :A;5?3A7@: G4A @4A:745? :C9A946H I7:C75 :95 G]^H 8;D? ;6:9A 7: 7? A9397_98N ;58 ?C;<< >9 :A9;:98 ;? O4567895:7;< B5:7<:C9 :95 G]^H 8;D 89?7E5;:745@9A748C;?@;??98L 3L P5 :C9 3;?9 46 9<93:A4573;<<D`?:4A98 7564AK;:745N ; @;A:D @A48B375E O4567895:7;< P564AK;:745 75 ;5 9<93:A4573;<<D` ?:4A98 64AK;: ?C;<< ?:;K@ :C9 @CD?73;< K987BK >D IC73C :C9 7564AK;:745 7? :A;5?K7::98 G9LEL 34K@B:9A :;@9N 34K@B:9A 87?TN OM a4KN 9:3LH ;? UOQVWPMXVSPYZL[ P6 :C9 @;A:D :4 IC4K ?B3C 9<93:A4573;<<D`?:4A98 7564AK;:745 7? @A48B398 ?C;<< 3A9;:9 ;5D A9;8;><9 A9@4A: 4A 4B:@B: 6A4K ?B3C 34567895:7;< 8;:;N :C;: @;A:D ?C;<< @A4K7595:<D <;>9< 9;3C @;E9 46 ?B3C 4B:@B: A9@4A: ;? UOQVWPMXVSPYZL[ 8L Y @;A:DN @A4_789A 46 843BK95:? 4A 545`@;A:D I7:59?? K;D 8954K75;:9 ;5D A9?@45?9 :4 ;5D IA7::95 87?34_9AD A9b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`< >C? @4G7 ?@ ?=9 9;?94? 49B9FF3A7 I@A ?=9 B@45CB? @I ?=:F 3B?:@4^ 8A@K:595< =@Y9K9A< ?=3? 4@ H@4I:594?:3G J4I@AD3?:@4 F=3GG >9 A9K93G95 ?@ FCB= 89AF@4F C4?:G ?=9 B@45:?:@4F 59?3:G95:4a3A3EA38=b=3K9>994D9?^ BU P98@F:?:@4A98@A?9AF^ 5U J459894594? 9;89A?F< :4K9F?:E3?@AF< 345 @?=9A B@4FCG?34?F A9?3:495 >7 B@C4F9G^ 8A@K:595< =@Y9K9A< ?=3? 4@ H@4I:594?:3G J4I@AD3?:@4 F=3GG >9 A9K93G95 ?@ FCB= 89AF@4F C4?:G ?=9 B@45:?:@4F 59?3:G95 :4 a3A3EA38= b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` ? JCF59E54K9 FC>9C 3456 C9AJ9E5 5F ?7@ ADE6 >4AEFK9C@C9_D9A5a GQ ]7@ J?C5@^A C4I65 5F A99` ?7 FC>9C EFMJ9LL47I >4AEFK9C@ 3456 C9AJ9E5 5F?7@>4AEFK9C@C9_D9A5a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` VYa ]bcY_` bd ebYbfcfcJ ggh i5jG 33hk lm<A F?;5 kQQno5 78 9 ECERGB@?pE9<?Ep :9;<= ?@ @Iq:CBE9BG C; C;GB;BG <C :;CGILB FCE8?GBE<?9D 7E8C;K9<?CE q= 9EC<AB; LCI;< C; 9GK?E?@<;9<?rB 9pBEL=J @ILA :9;<= @A9DD :;CK:<D= EC<?8= <AB GB@?pE9<?Ep :9;<= C8 <AB :BEG?Ep @Iq:CBE9 C; C;GB; 9EG @A9DD EC< :;CGILB 9E= FCE8?GBE<?9D 7E8C;K9<?CE IE<?D <AB GB@?pE9<?Ep :9;<= A9@ A9G 9 ;B9@CE9qDB <?KB <C CqsBL< C; C<AB;>?@B <9tB 9::;C:;?9<B @<B:@ <C :;C<BL<@ILAFCE8?GBE<?9DH9<B;?9D5 7u 7v vw vu7xyNPuz{5 {9<BG| m}km}kk ~ }@} B<@= B88B;?@ PpI?D9; SBr9G9 9; SC5 3km Q knjQv5 CEB@ DrG5 N9@ Bp9@J SBr9G9 m3gn P<<C;EB=@ 8C; xD9?E<?88 {9<BG|m}km}kk }@} BC;pBH5O9E9DD? SBr9G9 9;SC54hg ~ SBr9G9 9;SC5 33m SBr9G9 9;SC5jmjm kjgQ¡5¢C;?£CEO?GpBx9;t>9=J ¤3QQ ¥__b¦Y§`db¦¨§d§YaVY_© ]¦bªª«]fV^WVY_¬¥®¯°±±²]³\ 12 ! " # $ %& ' ( % ) *+ , ' " -./ 0 //1/// 2-./ 0 //1///* 1 3 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 13 12 14 15 16 17 18 19 3 31 33 32 34 34564 89 ;<=>?@ ABB? C9>DEF<9BG AH <?G AB9IBB? 9;B D<J9>BC 9;<9 9;>C K9>DEF<9>L? MLJ NJL9BO9>=B PJGBJ >C <@JBBG 9L AH 9;B D<J9>BCQ 8R 8K KP PSTUSUTQ TVRUT September 30, 2022 WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW United States Magistrate Judge SBCDBO9MEFFH CEA_>99BG AH` 4abaccd eabd6c f3gc64 hi34abjcck lCl ^BLJ@B mQ S<?<FF> WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW n634n6 io 4abaccdj 6pqo rB=<G< s<J rLQ tuvw xai6pfo y3czej 6pqo rB=<G< s<J rLQ w{{| }dk~d54dpk3ccj 6pqo rB=<G< s<J rLQ || YvZ Q LJ> L? S>G@B N<J I<HX {ZZ 12 ! " # $ %& ' ( % ) *+ , ' " -./ 0 //1/// 2-./ 0 //1///* 1 3 4 2 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 13 14 12 15 16 17 18 19 3 31 33 34 32 345634 89 6:;:<<=> 4?@9 ABCDED GDH AIJ KLMN O=PQ= R6=?P5<<> 4?@9 ABCDED GDH AIJ STST U:84?V9 W5<XY> 4?@9 ABCDED GDH AIJ NZZT 6:;:<<= Y:;=4< V5[<46 \856:;><<P ]SM^_J `IHabIc daEeB fDHghDijkZ^^ lBmBnoIcBp qL^]r MLLsLLLM tDuvawamBp qL^]r MLLsLLLN HDcDmmavBHCauBxHDcDmmamDhiBHvJuIw yzz{|}~ {| ~ ~} }z y ;=X4R?X:X4?R=?X6=PXP5 6X V56XW4R=?X6=PX5V;4O:R: ` d A d GG j r r DvBAIJp]p]]suCs^ZZ Ls sA r fmDac a j r r CvJ r r _ d A J E D _ d A jDr tIHBaec IHnIHD aIc r f ¡ t _ d A j r Zs]^DcE d G¢ A Al l r Zs]^jacum£vaCB r r B BcEDc vJ r r P46X=V=P:X45VP58¤<=:;P4 j ¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥¥jDvHBuanaBc I ¦ Ic aEBc aDm§ ac IHwD aIc Dv D HBv£m I wi acCImCBwBc ac oB wD BH I d GG CvJ _ d A Jj oDCB HBuBaCBE D oB P5;V=R4;X=:<=X¨ ?X=¤ <:X=5; :;R ¤65X4PX=O4 56R46 DcE oDCB HBCaBhBE a ac a v Bc aHB i DcE DeHBB I uIwnmi ha o oB nHICavaIcv oBHBI J BH oB uIcum£vaIc I oav wD BHj hamm uIwnmi ha o nDHDeHDno N i HB £Hcace IH awwBEaD Bmi EBv HIiace 12 ! " # $ %& ' ( % ) *+ , ' " -./ 0 //1/// 2-./ 0 //1///* 1 3 4 5 2 6 7 8 9 1 11 13 14 15 12 16 17 18 19 3 31 33 34 35 345 789: ;<98=>4?7@ A4B<C=3?A<4@ 9<DA>7@ DCA4?7@ 78==3CA>7@ 34; <?:>C C>DC<;89?A<47 4?ABA>; 37 EF<4BA;>4?A3GHI JKLMJ?:A7 NNNN ;35 @P<7A?A<4@O87A4>77 NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN RAS43?8C> RTORFUVOMJKQJRWXUQ?<Y>B<C> =>?:A7NNNN;35 12

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.