Feld v. Pioneer Credit Recovery, Inc. et al, No. 2:2020cv01156 - Document 17 (D. Nev. 2020)
Court Description: ORDER Granting 16 Stipulated Protective Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge Nancy J. Koppe on 10/14/2020. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - JQC)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Feld v. Pioneer Credit Recovery, Inc. et al Doc. 17 Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 1 of 12 " 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 JQNNG["FTKIIU."NVF0" LCOGU"Y0"RW¥G[."GUS0" OKEJCGN"T0"C[GTU."GUS0" CPFTGC"ICPFCTC."GUS0" :22"U0"Ogcfqyu"Rctmyc{."Uwkvg":22"" Tgpq."Pgxcfc":;743" Vgngrjqpg<" 9971:73/:922" Hceukokng<" 9971:73/98:3" Attorneys for Defendants NAVIENT SOLUTIONS, LLC and PIONEER CREDIT RECOVERY, INC. " KP"VJG"WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" : ; 32 33 34 35 36 37 HQT"VJG"FKUVTKEV"QH"PGXCFC" CCTQP"HGNF."" " " " " Rnckpvkhh." " x0" " PCXKGPV"UQNWVKQPU."NNE."cpf"RKQPGGT" ETGFKV"TGEQXGT[."KPE." " " " " Fghgpfcpvu0" "" Ecug"Pq0"4<42/EX/23378/IOP/PLM" " COGPFGF"TGSWGUV"HQT"QTFGT"VQ" GPVGT"UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG" QTFGT" " " " 38 " Rnckpvkhh"Cctqp"Hgnf"*ÐRnckpvkhhÑ+."cpf"Fghgpfcpvu"Pcxkgpv"Uqnwvkqpu."NNE"*ÐPUNÑ+."cpf" 39 Rkqpggt" Etgfkv" Tgeqxgt{." Kpe0" *ÐRET.Ñ" vqigvjgt" ÐFghgpfcpvuÑ+" *lqkpvn{." vjg" ÐRctvkgu+" hkng" vjku" 3: cogpfgf"tgswguv"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv"gpvgt"vjg"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"dgnqy03"Kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjgkt" 3; tgswguv."vjg"Rctvkgu"uvcvg"vjcv"vjg{"jcxg"eqpuwnvgf"cpf"citggf"qp"vjg"vgtou"vjgtgkp0"Vjg"Rctvkgu"uggm" 42 gpvt{" qh" vjku" uvkrwncvgf" rtqvgevkxg" qtfgt" vq" rtqvgev" eqphkfgpvkcn" cpf" rtqrtkgvct{" kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" 43 oc{"dg"rtqfwegf"kp"fkueqxgt{."cpf"rtqxkfg"iwkfgnkpgu"hqt"vjg"Rctvkgu"vq"ugpf."tgegkxg."cpf"jcpfng" 44 uwej"ocvgtkcnu."fwtkpi"cpf"chvgt"vjku"nkvkicvkqp0"Cu"gpvt{"qh"vjku"qtfgt"yknn"rtgenwfg"hwvwtg"fkurwvgu." 45 kv"yknn"rtqoqvg"lwfkekcn"geqpqo{0""" 46 1"1"1" 47 1"1"1" 48 49 4: " "Vjku"cogpfgf"tgswguv"ku"hkngf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"EqwtvÓu"qtfgt"qh"Qevqdgt";."4242"*Fqe0"Pq0"35+."yjkej"fgpkgf"vjg" RctvkguÓ"kpkvkcn"tgswguv"fwg"vq"kpcfxgtvgpv"kpeqttgev"kpvgtpcn"etquu/tghgtgpegu0"Vjqug"gttqtu"jcxg"dggp"eqttgevgf."cpf"vjg" tgswguv"ku"qvjgtykug"vjg"ucog0" 3 3254936^52833:8890x3" Dockets.Justia.com Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 2 of 12 " 3 YJGTGHQTG."Rnckpvkhh"Cctqp"Hgnf"cpf"Fghgpfcpvu"Pcxkgpv"Uqnwvkqpu."NNE."cpf"Rkqpggt" 4 Etgfkv"Tgeqxgt{."Kpe0."tgswguv"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv"gpvgt"vjg"Uvkrwncvgf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"cvvcejgf"vjku" 5 tgswguv"cu"Gzjkdkv"30" 6 Fcvgf"vjku"35vj"fc{"qh"Qevqdgt"42420" " " " " " " " 7 8 9 : " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " ; 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 JQNNG["FTKIIU."NVF0" /s/ Michael R. Ayers LCOGU"Y0"RW¥G[."GUS0" OKEJCGN"T0"C[GTU."GUS0" LQJP"UCXCIG."GUS0" :22"U0"Ogcfqyu"Rctmyc{."Uwkvg":22"" Tgpq."Pgxcfc":;743" Attorneys for Defendants NAVIENT SOLUTIONS, LLC and PIONEER CREDIT RECOVERY, INC. Fcvgf"vjku"35vj"fc{"qh"Qevqdgt"42420" " " " " " " " MKPF"NCY" " " " " /s/ Michael Kind, Esq. OKEJCGN"MKPF."GUS0" ::82"Uqwvj"Oct{ncpf"Rctmyc{."Uwkvg"328" Ncu"Xgicu."PX":;345" Attorneys for Plaintiff Aaron Feld " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " 39 3: 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: /4/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 3 of 12 " UVKRWNCVGF"RTQVGEVKXG"QTFGT" 3 4 Vjg" Eqwtv." jcxkpi" tgxkgygf" vjg" Uvkrwncvkqp" hqt" Gpvt{" qh" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt" *Uvkrwncvkqp+" 5 hkngf" d{" Rnckpvkhh" Cctqp" Hgnf" *Rnckpvkhh+." cpf" Fghgpfcpvu" Pcxkgpv" Uqnwvkqpu." NNE" *PUN+" cpf" 6 Rkqpggt" Etgfkv" Tgeqxgt{." Kpe0" *RET+" *vqigvjgt." Fghgpfcpvu+" kp" vjku" cevkqp." cpf" iqqf" ecwug" 7 crrgctkpi."jgtgd{"CRRTQXGU"vjg"Uvkrwncvkqp"cpf"QTFGTU"cu"hqnnqyu<""" 8 30" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" Fqewogpvu." Ocvgtkcnu." cpf" Kphqtocvkqp0" " Vjku" Qtfgt" ujcnn" 9 iqxgtp"cnn"fqewogpvu"rtqfwegf"qt"gzejcpigf."cnn"ytkvvgp"cpuygtu."fgrqukvkqp"cpuygtu."cpf"qvjgt" : tgurqpugu"vq"fkueqxgt{."cpf"cnn"eqoowpkecvkqpu"qh"cp{"mkpf"ocfg"d{"Rnckpvkhh."RnckpvkhhÓu"cvvqtpg{u." ; eqpuwnvcpvu." cigpvu." cpf" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu=" Fghgpfcpvu." vjgkt" cvvqtpg{u." eqpuwnvcpvu." cigpvu." 32 gornq{ggu." cpf" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu0" " ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcnu" ujcnn" dg" vjg" fqewogpvu" qt" 33 kphqtocvkqp" tgurgevkxgn{" fgukipcvgf" wpfgt" vjku" Qtfgt" cpf" cp{" pqvgu." yqtm" rcrgtu." qt" qvjgt" 34 fqewogpvu" tgurgevkxgn{" eqpvckpkpi" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcnu" fgtkxgf" htqo" uwej" kvgou0"" 35 Rnckpvkhh."Fghgpfcpvu."qt"cp{"vjktf"rctv{"oc{"kfgpvkh{"cp{"fqewogpvu"qt"kphqtocvkqp."kpenwfkpi"dwv" 36 pqv"nkokvgf"vq"fkueqxgt{"ocvgtkcnu"rtqfwegf"d{"vjcv"rctv{."kpkvkcn"fkuenquwtgu."fqewogpvu"cpf"vjkpiu." 37 cpuygtu" vq" kpvgttqicvqtkgu." tgurqpugu" vq" tgswguvu" hqt" rtqfwevkqp." tgurqpugu" vq" tgswguvu" hqt" 38 cfokuukqp." fgrqukvkqp" gzjkdkvu." cpf" cnn" qt" rqtvkqpu" qh" fgrqukvkqp" qt" jgctkpi" vtcpuetkrvu." cu" 39 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" cpf" fgukipcvg" vjg" fqewogpvu" qt" kphqtocvkqp" cu" uwej" d{" chhkzkpi" vjgtgvq" c" 3: ngigpf"qh"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"qt"d{"fgukipcvkpi"vjtqwij"cpqvjgt"ogvjqf"ugv"hqtvj"kp"vjku"Qtfgt"qt" 3; citggf"vq"d{"vjg"rctvkgu0""" 42 Rnckpvkhh." Fghgpfcpvu." qt" cp{" vjktf" rctv{" oc{" fgukipcvg" fqewogpvu" qt" kphqtocvkqp" cu" 43 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjg"rctv{."vjtqwij"eqwpugn."dgnkgxgu"Ðiqqf"ecwugÑ"gzkuvu"vq" 44 ecvgiqtk|g"vjg"ocvgtkcn"cu"eqphkfgpvkcn"dgecwug"vjg"ocvgtkcn"eqpvckpu"qt"kpenwfgu<"*3+"eqphkfgpvkcn" 45 dwukpguu"kphqtocvkqp="*4+"vtcfg"ugetgvu="*5+"rtqrtkgvct{"dwukpguu"ogvjqfu"qt"rtcevkegu="*6+"cp{"qvjgt" 46 eqorgvkvkxgn{" ugpukvkxg" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocvkqp=" *7+" rgtuqpcn" kphqtocvkqp." kpenwfkpi" rgtuqpcn" 47 hkpcpekcn"kphqtocvkqp"cdqwv"ewuvqogtu"qt"crrnkecpvu."vjktf"rctvkgu."vjg"Rctvkgu."qt"cp"gornq{gg"qh" 48 cp{" rctv{" vq" vjku" ncyuwkv=" *8+" kphqtocvkqp" tgictfkpi" cp{" kpfkxkfwcnÓu" dcpmkpi" qt" ngpfkpi" 49 tgncvkqpujkru."kpenwfkpi."ykvjqwv"nkokvcvkqp."kphqtocvkqp"tgictfkpi"cp{"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"nqcp"qt"etgfkv" 4: /5/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 4 of 12 " 3 jkuvqt{" cpf1qt" eqpuwogt" kphqtocvkqp" pqv" qvjgtykug" cxckncdng" vq" vjg" rwdnke=" cpf" *9+" cp{" qvjgt" 4 ecvgiqtkgu"vjcv"ctg"ncvgt"citggf"vq"kp"ytkvkpi"d{"vjg"rctvkgu"qt"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv0"""" 5 Vjku"citggf"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"qtfgt"fqgu"pqv"kpenwfg"vjg"coqwpv"qh"cp{"lwfiogpv"vjcv"oc{"dg" 6 gpvgtgf"kp"vjku"ocvvgt"qt"cp{"ugvvngogpv"coqwpvu"citggf"vq"d{"vjg"rctvkgu"jgtgvq."cu"uckf"kvgou"yknn" 7 dg"ugrctcvgn{"pgiqvkcvgf"d{"vjg"rctvkgu"cv"c"ncvgt"fcvg0""" 8 40" Fgukipcvkqp"qh"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"Ocvgtkcn0""Fqewogpvu"ujcnn"dg"fgukipcvgf"cu" 9 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"d{"uvcorkpi"vjgo"ykvj"vjg"yqtf"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"kp"c"ocppgt"yjkej"yknn" : pqv"kpvgthgtg"ykvj"vjgkt"ngikdknkv{0""Vjku"fgukipcvkqp"ujcnn"qpn{"dg"wugf"kp"c"tgcuqpcdng"hcujkqp"cpf" ; wrqp" c" iqqf" hckvj" fgvgtokpcvkqp" d{" eqwpugn" vjcv" c" rctvkewnct" fqewogpv" eqpvckpu" pqp/rwdnke" 32 kphqtocvkqp"cpf"hcnnu"ykvjkp"qpg"qh"vjg"ecvgiqtkgu"gpwogtcvgf"kp"Rctcitcrj"30""Vjku"fgukipcvkqp" 33 ujcnn"qtfkpctkn{"dg"ocfg"dghqtg"qt"cv"vjg"ucog"vkog"cu"vjg"rtqfwevkqp"qt"fkuenquwtg"qh"vjg"ocvgtkcn0"" 34 Dgecwug"ocvgtkcnu"fguetkdgf"kp"Rctcitcrj"3"ujcnn"dg"eqxgtgf"d{"vjku"Qtfgt."vjgtg"ujcnn"dg"pq"yckxgt" 35 qh" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" kh" uwej" ocvgtkcnu" ctg" kpcfxgtvgpvn{" rtqfwegf" ykvjqwv" dgkpi" uvcorgf" 36 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ""Ocvgtkcnu"cntgcf{"rtqfwegf"kp"fkueqxgt{"kp"vjku"nkvkicvkqp"oc{"dg"fgukipcvgf" 37 cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"wrqp"ytkvvgp"pqvkeg"*ykvjqwv"uvcorkpi+."ykvjkp"hqwtvggp"*36+"fc{u"qh"vjg" 38 gpvt{"qh"vjku"Qtfgt."htqo"vjg"rctv{"cuugtvkpi"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"fgukipcvkqp"vq"cnn"eqwpugn"qh"tgeqtf" 39 vq"yjqo"uwej"fqewogpvu"jcxg"dggp"rtqfwegf"d{"pqvkh{kpi"vjg"qvjgt"rctv{"qh"vjg"kfgpvkv{"qh"vjg" 3: fqewogpvu"qt"kphqtocvkqp"vq"dg"uq"fgukipcvgf0""Cp{"qh"vjg"rctvkgu"vq"vjku"cevkqp"ecp"tgoqxg"cv"cp{" 3; vkog" kvu" fgukipcvkqp" qh" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" htqo" cp{" qh" vjg" fqewogpvu" qt" kphqtocvkqp" kv" jcu" 42 rtgxkqwun{"uq"fgukipcvgf0" 43 50" Vtgcvogpv"qh"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"Kphqtocvkqp0""Wpnguu"qvjgtykug"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg" 44 Eqwtv."ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn."cpf"cp{"swqvgu."uwooctkgu."ejctvu."qt"pqvgu"ocfg"vjgtghtqo." 45 cpf"cp{"hcevu"qt"kphqtocvkqp"eqpvckpgf"vjgtgkp"qt"fgtkxgf"vjgtghtqo."ujcnn"dg"jgnf"kp"eqphkfgpeg" 46 cpf" wugf" d{" vjg" rctvkgu" vq" yjqo" vjg" fqewogpvu" cpf" kphqtocvkqp" ctg" rtqfwegf" uqngn{" hqt" vjg" 47 rwtrqug"qh"vjku"ecug0""Vjg"rctvkgu"citgg"vq"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng"uvgru"vq"ockpvckp"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"qh" 48 vjg"fqewogpvu."kphqtocvkqp."cpf"vguvkoqp{"tgncvkpi"vjgtgvq0""Fwtkpi"vjg"rgpfgpe{"qh"vjku"nkvkicvkqp." 49 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn."kpenwfkpi"cnn"eqrkgu"vjgtgqh."ujcnn"dg"tgvckpgf"uqngn{"kp"vjg"ewuvqf{" 4: qh" vjg" rctvkguÓ" cvvqtpg{u" cpf" ujcnn" pqv" dg" rncegf" kp" vjg" rquuguukqp" qh" qt" fkuenqugf" vq" cp{" qvjgt" /6/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 5 of 12 " 3 rgtuqp."gzegrv"cu"ugv"hqtvj"kp"vjku"Qtfgt."cu"qvjgtykug"citggf"wrqp"d{"vjg"rctvkgu."qt"wrqp"ngcxg"qh" 4 Eqwtv0""Gcej"rgtuqp"vq"yjqo"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn"ku"fkuenqugf"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku"Qtfgt"ku" 5 jgtgd{"rtqjkdkvgf"htqo"gzrnqkvkpi"kp"cp{"yc{"uwej"fqewogpvu"qt"kphqtocvkqp"hqt"jku."jgt"qt"kvu" 6 qyp"dgpghkv."qt"htqo"wukpi"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"hqt"cp{"rwtrqug"qt"kp"cp{"ocppgt"pqv"eqppgevgf"ykvj" 7 vjg"rtqugewvkqp"qt"fghgpug"qh"vjku"ecug0" 8 60" ÐFkuenquwtg0Ñ""Cu"wugf"jgtgkp."ÐfkuenquwtgÑ"qt"vq"ÐfkuenqugÑ"ujcnn"ogcp"vq"fkxwnig." 9 tgxgcn." fguetkdg." uwooctk|g." rctcrjtcug." swqvg." vtcpuokv." qt" qvjgtykug" eqoowpkecvg" : ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn0" ; 70" Rgtokuukdng"Fkuenquwtg"qh"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"Ocvgtkcn0""Gzegrv"d{"qtfgt"qh"vjku" 32 Eqwtv."qt"qvjgtykug"cu"tgswktgf"d{"ncy."ocvgtkcn"fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"*cpf"cp{"pqvgu" 33 qt"fqewogpvu"vjcv"tghngev"qt"tghgt"vq"uwej"fqewogpvu"cpf"kphqtocvkqp+"ujcnn"pqv"dg"fkuenqugf"vq"cp{" 34 rgtuqp"qvjgt"vjcp<" 35 *c+" C"rctv{"jgtgvq="" 36 *d+"Eqwpugn"gornq{gf"d{"c"rctv{."qt"cp"gornq{gg"qh"uwej"eqwpugn."vq"yjqo"kv"ku"pgeguuct{" 37 vjcv"vjg"ocvgtkcnu"dg"ujqyp"qt"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"mpqyp"hqt"rwtrqugu"qh"vjku"ecug"qpn{="" 38 *e+" Cp{" gornq{gg" qt" cigpv" qh" c" rctv{" vq" yjqo" vjg" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcnu" ctg" 39 ujqyp"hqt"vjg"rwtrqug"qh"yqtmkpi"fktgevn{"qp"qt"vguvkh{kpi"kp"eqppgevkqp"ykvj"vjku" 3: nkvkicvkqp"cv"vjg"tgswguv"qh"qt"cv"vjg"fktgevkqp"qh"eqwpugn"hqt"uwej"rctv{="" 3; *f+"C" rgtuqp" tgvckpgf" vq" cuukuv" kp" vjku" cevkqp." uwej" cu" cp" kpxguvkicvqt." kpfgrgpfgpv" 42 ceeqwpvcpv." qt" qvjgt" vgejpkecn" gzrgtv" qt" eqpuwnvcpv." yjq" jcu" ukipgf" cp" 43 cempqyngfigogpv"kp"vjg"hqto"qh"Gzjkdkv"C"jgtgvq."yjkej"ukipgf"cempqyngfiogpv" 44 ujcnn"dg"tgvckpgf"d{"vjg"rctv{"yjq"jcu"tgvckpgf"uwej"rgtuqp."jqygxgt."kp"vjg"gxgpv"vjg" 45 fkuenquwtg"kpenwfgu"ocvgtkcnu"fgukipcvgf"d{"c"vjktf"rctv{"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN.Ñ"vjg" 46 rctvkgu"ujcnn"qdvckp"vjg"ytkvvgp"eqpugpv"qh"uwej"vjktf"rctv{"rtkqt"vq"fkuenquwtg"wpfgt" 47 vjku"rctcitcrj=" 48 *g+" Vjku"Eqwtv"*qt"kvu"gornq{ggu"qt"cigpvu+=" 49 *h+" Cp{"rgtuqp*u+"fgukipcvgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv"kp"vjg"kpvgtguv"qh"lwuvkeg."wrqp"uwej"vgtou"cu"vjg" 4: Eqwtv"oc{"fggo"rtqrgt=" /7/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 6 of 12 " 3 *i+"Ogodgtu" qh" vjg" lwt{" cv" c" rwdnke" vtkcn" qh" vjku" ocvvgt." uwdlgev" vq" vjg" tgswktgogpvu" qh" Rctcitcrj"32"dgnqy="qt" 4 5 *j+"C"rgtuqp"yjq"ku"fgrqugf"qt"yjq"vguvkhkgu"cv"vjg"jgctkpi"kp"vjku"ocvvgt"yjq"jcu"ukipgf" 6 cp"cempqyngfigogpv"kp"vjg"hqto"qh"Gzjkdkv"C"jgtgvq."yjkej"ukipgf"cempqyngfiogpv" 7 ujcnn"dg"tgvckpgf"d{"vjg"rctv{"yjq"jcu"eqorgnngf"uwej"rgtuqp"vq"vguvkh{"cv"c"fgrqukvkqp" 8 qt"vtkcn0""Kh"vjg"ykvpguu"tghwugu"vq"ukip"uwej"hqto."vjg"rctv{"eqorgnnkpi"uwej"vguvkoqp{" 9 ujcnn"koogfkcvgn{"pqvkh{"qrrqukpi"eqwpugn"cpf"rgtokv"vjgo"ugxgp"*9+"fc{u"vq"uggm" : tgftguu" ykvj" vjg" Eqwtv" rtqxkfgf." jqygxgt." kp" vjg" gxgpv" vjg" fkuenquwtg" kpenwfgu" ; ocvgtkcnu"fgukipcvgf"d{"c"vjktf"rctv{"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN.Ñ"vjg"rctvkgu"ujcnn"qdvckp" vjg"ytkvvgp"eqpugpv"qh"uwej"vjktf"rctv{"rtkqt"vq"fkuenquwtg"wpfgt"vjku"rctcitcrj0" 32 33 80" Tgxkgy"qh"Qyp"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"Ocvgtkcnu0""Vjg"tguvtkevkqpu"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"ujcnn" 34 pqv" crrn{" vq" rctvkgu." cpf" vjgkt" gornq{ggu." cvvqtpg{u." gzrgtvu" qt" qvjgt" cwvjqtk|gf" cigpvu." yjgp" 35 tgxkgykpi"vjgkt"qyp"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcnu0" 36 90" Fgrqukvkqp"Vtcpuetkrvu0""Fgrqukvkqp"vguvkoqp{"cpf"fgrqukvkqp"gzjkdkvu"eqpvckpkpi" 37 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn"ujcnn"dg"eqxgtgf"d{"vjku"Qtfgt0""Fwtkpi"c"fgrqukvkqp"vcmgp"kp"vjku" 38 ocvvgt." Rnckpvkhh." Fghgpfcpvu." qt" cp{" vjktf" rctv{." qp" vjg" tgeqtf." oc{" fgukipcvg" cu" 39 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"rqtvkqpu"qh"vjg"fgrqukvkqp"vguvkoqp{"qt"fgrqukvkqp"gzjkdkvu0""Cnvgtpcvkxgn{." 3: Rnckpvkhh."Fghgpfcpvu."qt"cp{"vjktf"rctv{"oc{."d{"ytkvvgp"pqvkeg"vq"qrrqukpi"eqwpugn"cpf"vjg"eqwtv" 3; tgrqtvgt"pqv"ncvgt"vjcp"hqwtvggp"*36+"dwukpguu"fc{u"chvgt"tgegkrv"qh"vjg"hkpcn"fgrqukvkqp"vtcpuetkrv." 42 fgukipcvg"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"cp{"rqtvkqpu"qh"vjg"fgrqukvkqp"vguvkoqp{"qt"fgrqukvkqp"gzjkdkvu0"" 43 Wpvkn"gzrktcvkqp"qh"vjg"cdqxg"hqwtvggp"*36+"fc{"rgtkqf."cnn"fgrqukvkqp"vtcpuetkrvu"yknn"dg"vtgcvgf"cu" 44 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn"wpnguu"qvjgtykug"citggf"vq"kp"ytkvkpi"d{"vjg"rctvkgu0" 45 :0" Qdlgevkqpu" vq" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" Fgukipcvkqpu0" " Vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" cp{" rctv{" 46 eqpvguvu"c"fgukipcvkqp"wpfgt"vjku"Qtfgt."uwej"rctv{"ujcnn"qdlgev"vq"uwej"fgukipcvkqp"kp"ytkvkpi"pqv" 47 ncvgt"vjcp"hqwtvggp"*36+"dwukpguu"fc{u"chvgt"tgegkrv"qh"ocvgtkcnu"fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ"" 48 Vjg"rctvkgu"ujcnn"hktuv"vt{"vq"tguqnxg"vjg"fkucitggogpv"kp"iqqf"hckvj"qp"cp"kphqtocn"dcuku."uwej"cu" 49 vjg"rtqfwevkqp"qh"tgfcevgf"eqrkgu0""Kh"vjg"rctvkgu"ctg"wpcdng"vq"tgcej"cp"citggogpv"tgictfkpi"vjg" 4: fgukipcvkqp."vjgp"vjg"rctv{"qdlgevkpi"vq"uwej"fgukipcvkqp"ujcnn"hkng"cp"crrtqrtkcvg"oqvkqp"ykvj"vjg" /8/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 7 of 12 " 3 Eqwtv"hqt"c"twnkpi"vjcv"vjg"fqewogpvu"qt"qvjgt"kphqtocvkqp"ujcnn"pqv"dg"ceeqtfgf"uwej"uvcvwu"cpf" 4 vtgcvogpv0" " Kp" vjg" gxgpv" vjcv" uwej" c" ejcnngpig" ku" ocfg." vjg" rctv{" cuugtvkpi" vjg" eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" 5 fgukipcvkqp"ujcnn"jcxg"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"guvcdnkujkpi"iqqf"ecwug"gzkuvu"vq"ockpvckp"vjg"fgukipcvkqp0"" 6 Wpvkn"vjku"Eqwtv"gpvgtu"cp"qtfgt"ejcpikpi"vjg"fgukipcvkqp"qh"uwej"fqewogpvu"qt"kphqtocvkqp."uwej" 7 fqewogpv" qt" kphqtocvkqp" ujcnn" eqpvkpwg" vq" dg" rtqvgevgf" cu" rtqxkfgf" d{" vjku" Qtfgt0" "Ujqwnf" vjg" 8 Eqwtv"twng"kp"hcxqt"qh"vjg"rctv{"qdlgevkpi"vq"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"fgukipcvkqp."vjg"rctv{"cuugtvkpi"vjg" 9 fgukipcvkqp"ujcnn"rtqfweg"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"fqewogpv*u+"ykvjqwv"vjg"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"fgukipcvkqp0" : ;0" Fkuenqukpi" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" Ocvgtkcn0" " Kh" cp{" rctv{" ykujgu" vq" fkuenqug" cp{" ; ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn"dg{qpf"vjg"vgtou"qh"Rctcitcrju"6/8"qh"vjku"Qtfgt."vjcv"rctv{"ujcnn" 32 rtqxkfg"cnn"qvjgt"rctvkgu"ykvj"tgcuqpcdng"pqvkeg"kp"ytkvkpi"qh"vjg"tgswguv"vq"fkuenqug"vjg"ocvgtkcnu." 33 wpnguu"qvjgtykug"tgswktgf"d{"ncy0""Kh"vjg"rctvkgu"ecppqv"tguqnxg"vjgkt"fkucitggogpv"ykvj"tgurgev"vq" 34 vjg" fkuenquwtg" qh" cp{" fgukipcvgf" kphqtocvkqp." vjgp" c" rctv{" oc{" rgvkvkqp" vjg" Eqwtv" hqt" c" 35 fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"vjgug"kuuwgu0""Kp"vjg"gxgpv"vjcv"uwej"c"ejcnngpig"ku"ocfg."vjg"rctv{"cuugtvkpi"vjg" 36 eqphkfgpvkcnkv{" fgukipcvkqp" ujcnn" jcxg" vjg" dwtfgp" qh" guvcdnkujkpi" vjcv" vjg" fgukipcvkqp" ku" rtqrgt0"" 37 Uwej"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcn"ujcnn"tgockp"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"cu"uvkrwncvgf"d{"vjku"Qtfgt" 38 wpvkn"vjg"Eqwtv"twngu"qp"vjg"rctv{Óu"urgekhke"rgvkvkqp0" 39 320" Rngcfkpiu"cpf"Qvjgt"Eqwtv"Uwdokuukqpu0""Gcej"rctv{"citggu"vjcv"yjgp"hknkpi"ykvj" 3: vjg"Eqwtv"cp{"rcrgtu"*kpenwfkpi."ykvjqwv"nkokvcvkqp."chhkfcxkvu."ogoqtcpfc."kpvgttqicvqt{"cpuygtu." 3; qt" fgrqukvkqp" vtcpuetkrvu+" vjcv" fkuenqug" fktgevn{" qt" kpfktgevn{" cp{" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcn." uwej"rcrgtu"ujcnn"dg"hkngf"wpfgt"ugcn"kp"ceeqtfcpeg"ykvj"vjg"EqwtvÓu"nqecn"twngu"cpf"tgswktgogpvu" 42 See order issued concurrently herewith hqt"hknkpi"fqewogpvu"wpfgt"ugcn0""" 43 44 Vjg" rctvkgu" hwtvjgt" tgeqipk|g" vjg" rquukdng" pggf" vq" wug" fqewogpvu" octmgf" 45 ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"fwtkpi"vjg"vtkcn"qh"vjku"ocvvgt0""Jqygxgt."vjg"rctvkgu"citgg"vq"vcmg"tgcuqpcdng" 46 uvgru"vq"rtqvgev"vjg"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{"qh"cp{"vtkcn"gzjkdkvu"uq"fgukipcvgf"vq"kpenwfg"cumkpi"vjg"Eqwtv" 47 vq"gpuwtg"vjcv"cp{"uwej"fqewogpvu"tghgttgf"vq"qt"qhhgtgf"kpvq"gxkfgpeg"cv"vtkcn"ctg"hkngf"ykvj"vjg" 48 Eqwtv"wpfgt"ugcn0" 49 Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"qtfgt"ujcnn"dg"eqpuvtwgf"cu"cwvqocvkecnn{"rgtokvvkpi"c"Rctv{"vq"hkng"wpfgt" 4: ugcn0"Vjg"Rctv{"uggmkpi"ngcxg"qh"Eqwtv"ujcnn"ujqy"Ðeqorgnnkpi"tgcuqpuÑ"*fkurqukvkxg"oqvkqp+"qt" /9/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 8 of 12 " 3 Ðiqqf" ecwugÑ" *pqp/fkurqukvkxg" oqvkqp+" hqt" hknkpi" wpfgt" ugcn0" See Kamakana v. City & Cnty of 4 Honolulu."669"H05f"3394."339;/:2"*;vj"Ekt0"4228+0"Cffkvkqpcnn{."uwej"Rctv{"uggmkpi"vq"hkng"wpfgt" 5 ugcn"ujcnn."ykvjkp"vjg"crrnkecdng"fgcfnkpg."hkng"c"tgfcevgf."wpugcngf"xgtukqp"qh"cp{"oqvkqp."tgurqpug" 6 qt"tgrn{"kh"uwej"Rctv{"ku"yckvkpi"hqt"c"twnkpi"htqo"vjg"Eqwtv"qp"hknkpi"cp"wptgfcevgf."ugcngf"xgtukqp" 7 qh"vjg"ucog"fqewogpv0" 8 330" Fqewogpv"Tgvgpvkqp0""Chvgt"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"vjku"ocvvgt"*kpenwfkpi"vjg"gzrktcvkqp" 9 qh" cnn" crrgcnu+." cnn" qtkikpcnu" cpf" tgrtqfwevkqpu" qh" vjg" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcnu" ujcnn" dg" : tgvwtpgf"vq"vjg"rtqfwekpi"rctv{"ykvjkp"vjktv{"*52+"fc{u"qh"uwej"eqpenwukqp"qt"dg"fguvtq{gf"*kp"yjkej" ; ecug"eqwpugn"hqt"vjg"rctv{"fguvtq{kpi"uckf"fqewogpvu"ujcnn"egtvkh{"kp"ytkvkpi"vq"vjg"rtqfwekpi"rctv{" 32 ykvjkp"vjktv{"*52+"fc{u"qh"uwej"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"fguvtwevkqp"qh"vjg"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcnu" 33 jcu"vcmgp"rnceg+0""Kpuqhct"cu"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"tguvtkev"vjg"wug"qh"vjg"fqewogpvu"rtqfwegf" 34 jgtgwpfgt."vjg"Qtfgt"ujcnn"eqpvkpwg"vq"dg"dkpfkpi"vjtqwijqwv"cpf"chvgt"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"vjku"ecug." 35 kpenwfkpi"cnn"crrgcnu."gzegrv"cu"ugv"hqtvj"kp"Rctcitcrj"370" 36 340" Cfokuukdknkv{0" " Pqvjkpi" kp" vjku" Qtfgt" ujcnn" dg" eqpuvtwgf" vq" nkokv" cp{" rctv{" htqo" 37 rtqfwekpi"qt"kpvtqfwekpi"cp{"fqewogpv"kpvq"gxkfgpeg"cv"rwdnke"jgctkpi0""Uwdlgev"vq"vjg"Twngu"qh" 38 Gxkfgpeg." ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcnu" cpf" qvjgt" eqphkfgpvkcn" kphqtocvkqp" oc{" dg" qhhgtgf" kp" 39 gxkfgpeg"cv"vtkcn"qt"cp{"eqwtv"jgctkpi0""Cp{"rctv{"oc{"oqxg"vjg"eqwtv"hqt"cp"Qtfgt"vjcv"vjg"gxkfgpeg" 3: dg" tgegkxgf" in camera" qt" wpfgt" qvjgt" eqpfkvkqpu" vq" rtgxgpv" wppgeguuct{" fkuenquwtg" qh" cp{" 3; ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcn0" " Vjg" Eqwtv" yknn" vjgp" fgvgtokpg" yjgvjgt" vjg" rtqhhgtgf" gxkfgpeg" 42 ujqwnf"eqpvkpwg"vq"dg"vtgcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"cpf."kh"uq."yjcv"rtqvgevkqp."kh"cp{."oc{"dg" 43 chhqtfgf"vq"uwej"kphqtocvkqp"cv"vjg"vtkcn"qt"jgctkpi0" 44 350" Ueqrg"qh"Fkueqxgt{0""Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Qtfgt"ujcnn"rtgenwfg"cp{"rctv{"htqo"qrrqukpi" 45 rtqfwevkqp" qh" cp{" fqewogpvu" qt" kphqtocvkqp." qt" htqo" uggmkpi" hwtvjgt" qt" fkhhgtgpv" tgnkgh" ujqwnf" 46 hwvwtg"rtgvtkcn"cevkxkvkgu"kpfkecvg"uwej"c"pggf0" 47 360" Enkgpv" Eqpuwnvcvkqp0" Pqvjkpi" kp" vjku" Qtfgt" ujcnn" dct" qt" qvjgtykug" tguvtkev" cp{" 48 cvvqtpg{"jgtgkp"htqo"tgpfgtkpi"cfxkeg"vq"jku"qt"jgt"enkgpv"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjku"ecug"qt"htqo"fqkpi" 49 cp{vjkpi"pgeguuct{"vq"rtqugewvg"qt"fghgpf"vjku"ecug"cpf"hwtvjgt"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"jku"enkgpv."rtqxkfgf." 4: /:/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 9 of 12 " 3 jqygxgt." vjcv" vjg" cvvqtpg{" ujcnn" pqv" fkuenqug" cp{" ocvgtkcn" fgukipcvgf" hqt" rtqvgevkqp" jgtgwpfgt" 4 yjgtg"uwej"fkuenquwtg"yqwnf"dg"eqpvtct{"vq"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjku"Qtfgt0" 5 370" Fkuetgvkqp"qh"vjg"Eqwtv0"Pqvjkpi"kp"vjku"Qtfgt"ujcnn"crrn{"vq."dkpf."qt"nkokv"vjg"Eqwtv" 6 qt"kvu"gornq{ggu"kp"vjg"rgthqtocpeg"qh"vjgkt"fwvkgu0""Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"cp{"hqtgiqkpi"uwiiguvkqp"vq" 7 vjg" eqpvtct{." vjg" Eqwtv" ujcnn" tgvckp" hkpcn" cpf" eqorngvg" cwvjqtkv{" vq" tg/fgukipcvg" cp{" ocvgtkcn" 8 rtgxkqwun{"fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"cu"c"rwdnke"fqewogpv0" 9 380" Pqvkeg"qh"Dtgcej0""Kv"ujcnn"dg"vjg"qdnkicvkqp"qh"eqwpugn."wrqp"jgctkpi"qh"cp{"dtgcej" : qt"vjtgcvgpgf"dtgcej"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"d{"cp{"rgtuqp."vq"rtqorvn{"pqvkh{"eqwpugn"hqt"vjg"qrrqukpi"cpf" ; rtqfwekpi"rctvkgu"qh"uwej"dtgcej"qt"vjtgcvgpgf"dtgcej0""" 32 390" Nkvkicvkqp"Wug"Qpn{0""Cnn"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcnu"rtqfwegf"kp"vjku"nkvkicvkqp." 33 yjgvjgt"d{"c"rctv{"qt"pqprctv{."cpf"cnn"kphqtocvkqp"eqpvckpgf"vjgtgkp"qt"fgtkxgf"vjgtghtqo."ujcnn" 34 dg"wugf"uqngn{"hqt"vjg"rtgrctcvkqp"cpf"vtkcn"qh"vjku"cevkqp"*kpenwfkpi"cp{"crrgcnu"cpf"tgvtkcnu+."cpf" 35 oc{"pqv"dg"wugf"hqt"cp{"qvjgt"rwtrqug."kpenwfkpi"dwukpguu."iqxgtpogpvcn"qt"eqoogtekcn."qt"cp{" 36 qvjgt"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"qt"lwfkekcn"rtqeggfkpiu"qt"cevkqpu0" 37 3:0" Uwdrqgpc"d{"Qvjgt"Eqwtv"qt"Cigpekgu0""Kh"cpqvjgt"eqwtv"qt"cp"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"cigpe{" 38 uwdrqgpcu"qt"qtfgtu"rtqfwevkqp"qh"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcnu"vjcv"c"rctv{"qdvckpgf"wpfgt"vjg" 39 vgtou"qh"vjku"Qtfgt."vjg"rctv{"tgegkxkpi"vjg"uwdrqgpc"ujcnn"rtqorvn{"pqvkh{"vjg"rctv{"qt"qvjgt"rgtuqp" 3: yjq"fgukipcvgf"vjg"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ocvgtkcnu"qh"vjg"rgpfgpe{"qh"uwej"uwdrqgpc"qt"qtfgt0" 3; 3;0" Kpcfxgtvgpv"Fkuenquwtg" Rtqvgevkqp0" " Tgxkgy" qh" vjg" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" ocvgtkcnu" 42 ncdgngf"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"d{"eqwpugn."gzrgtvu."qt"eqpuwnvcpvu"kp"vjg"nkvkicvkqp"ujcnn"pqv"yckxg" 43 vjg" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" fgukipcvkqp" qt" cp{" qdlgevkqpu" vq" rtqfwevkqp0" " ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" 44 ocvgtkcnu"kpcfxgtvgpvn{"rtqfwegf"d{"cp{"rctv{"qt"pqprctv{"vjtqwij"fkueqxgt{"kp"vjku"cevkqp"ykvjqwv" 45 jcxkpi"dggp"fgukipcvgf"cu"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ"ujcnn"dg"uwdlgev"vq"vjg"rtqxkukqpu"qh"vjku"Qtfgt"vq" 46 vjg"ucog"gzvgpv"cu"kh"vjg"kpcfxgtvgpv"fkuenquwtg"jcf"pqv"qeewttgf"uq"nqpi"cu"vjgtg"ku"tgcuqpcdng" 47 pqvkeg"vq"vjg"qvjgt"rctv{"qh"vjg"kpcfxgtvgpv"fkuenquwtg0""Kh"c"rtqfwekpi"rctv{"kpcfxgtvgpvn{"fkuenqugu" 48 vq" c" tgegkxkpi" rctv{" kphqtocvkqp" vjcv" ku" rtkxkngigf" qt" qvjgtykug" koowpg" htqo" fkueqxgt{." uckf" 49 rtqfwekpi"rctv{"ujcnn"rtqorvn{."wrqp"fkueqxgt{"qh"uwej"fkuenquwtg."uq"cfxkug"vjg"tgegkxkpi"rctv{" 4: kp"ytkvkpi"cpf"tgswguv"vjcv"vjg"kvgo"qt"kvgou"qh"kphqtocvkqp"dg"tgvwtpgf0""Pq"rctv{"vq"vjku"cevkqp" /;/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 10 of 12 " 3 ujcnn"vjgtgchvgt"cuugtv"vjcv"uwej"fkuenquwtg"yckxgf"cp{"rtkxkngig"qt"koowpkv{0""Kv"ku"hwtvjgt"citggf" 4 vjcv"vjg"tgegkxkpi"rctv{"yknn"tgvwtp"uwej"kpcfxgtvgpvn{"rtqfwegf"kvgo"qt"kvgou"qh"kphqtocvkqp"cpf" 5 cnn"eqrkgu"vjgtgqh"ykvjkp"hqwtvggp"*36+"dwukpguu"fc{u"qh"tgegkxkpi"c"ytkvvgp"tgswguv"hqt"vjg"tgvwtp" 6 qh"uwej"kvgo"qt"kvgou"qh"kphqtocvkqp"htqo"vjg"rtqfwekpi"rctv{0""" 420" 7 Pqp/Rctvkgu0" Pqp/rctvkgu" yjq" ctg" tgswktgf" vq" rtqfweg" ÐEQPHKFGPVKCNÑ" 8 ocvgtkcn" kp" tgurqpug" vq" c" uwdrqgpc." cpf" yjq" kp" iqqf" hckvj" dgnkgxg" vjcv" uwej" ocvgtkcn" eqpvckpu" 9 eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp."oc{"tgn{"qp"vjku"Qtfgt"cpf"crrn{"kv"vq"vjgkt"rtqfwevkqp0" 430" : Tgurqpukdknkv{"qh"Cvvqtpg{u0"Vjg"cvvqtpg{u"qh"tgeqtf"ctg"tgurqpukdng"hqt"gornq{kpi" ; tgcuqpcdng" ogcuwtgu" vq" eqpvtqn." eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjku" Qtfgt." vjg" fwrnkecvkqp" qh." ceeguu" vq." cpf" 32 fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh"eqrkgu"qh"ocvgtkcnu"ncdgngf"ÐEQPHKFGPVKCN0Ñ""Rctvkgu"ujcnn"pqv"fwrnkecvg"cp{" 33 uwej"ocvgtkcnu"gzegrv"hqt"yqtmkpi"eqrkgu"cpf"hqt"hknkpi"kp"eqwtv"wpfgt"ugcn0""Vjg"cvvqtpg{u"qh"tgeqtf" 34 hwtvjgt"ctg"tgurqpukdng"hqt"gornq{kpi"tgcuqpcdng"ogcuwtgu"vq"eqpvtqn."eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjku"Qtfgt." 35 36 vjg"fkuugokpcvkqp"qt"tgxgncvkqp"qh"eqphkfgpvkcn"kphqtocvkqp0" IT IS SO ORDERED. KV"KU"UQ"QTFGTGF."vjku"aaaaaaaa"fc{"qh"aaaaaaaaaaaa."42420"" Dated: October 14, 2020 37 " 38 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""LWFIG."WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV " " United States Magistrate Judge 39 3: " " " 3; 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: /32/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 11 of 12 " 3 GZJKDKV"C 4 EGTVKHKECVKQP"TG"EQPHKFGPVKCN"FKUEQXGT["OCVGTKCNU 5 K" jgtgd{" cempqyngfig" vjcv" K." aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"]PCOG_." 6 aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" ]RQUKVKQP" CPF" GORNQ[GT_." 7 co"cdqwv" vq" tgegkxg"EQPHKFGPVKCN"ocvgtkcnu" uwrrnkgf" kp" eqppgevkqp" ykvj" vjg"cevkqp" 8 gpvkvngf"Aaron Feld v. Navient Solutions, LLC, and Pioneer Credit Recovery, Inc.."Ecug"Pq0"4<42/ 9 EX/23378/IOP/PLM." Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" Fkuvtkev" Eqwtv" hqt" vjg" Fkuvtkev" qh" Pgxcfc0"K" egtvkh{" vjcv" K" : wpfgtuvcpf" vjcv" vjg"EQPHKFGPVKCN"ocvgtkcnu"ctg" rtqxkfgf" vq" og" uwdlgev" vq" vjg" vgtou" cpf" ; tguvtkevkqpu"qh"vjg"Uvkrwncvkqp"cpf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt"hkngf"kp"vjku"cevkqp0"K"jcxg"dggp"ikxgp"c"eqr{"qh" 32 vjg"Uvkrwncvkqp"cpf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt="K"jcxg"tgcf"kv."cpf"K"citgg"vq"dg"dqwpf"d{"kvu"vgtou0 33 K"wpfgtuvcpf"vjcv"EQPHKFGPVKCN"ocvgtkcnu."cu"fghkpgf"kp"vjg"Uvkrwncvkqp"cpf"Rtqvgevkxg" 34 Qtfgt."kpenwfkpi"cp{"pqvgu"qt"qvjgt"tgeqtfu"vjcv"oc{"dg"ocfg"tgictfkpi"cp{"uwej"ocvgtkcnu."ujcnn" 35 pqv"dg"Fkuenqugf"vq"cp{qpg"gzegrv"cu"gzrtguun{"rgtokvvgf"d{"vjg"Uvkrwncvkqp"cpf"Rtqvgevkxg"Qtfgt0" 36 K" 37 cp{"EQPHKFGPVKCN"ocvgtkcnu"qdvckpgf" rwtuwcpv" vq" vjku" Rtqvgevkxg" Qtfgt." gzegrv" cu" rtqxkfgf" 38 vjgtgkp"qt"qvjgtykug"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg"Eqwtv"kp"vjku"cevkqp0 yknn" K" 39 pqv" eqr{" hwtvjgt" qt" wug." gzegrv" wpfgtuvcpf" vjcv" uqngn{" K" hqt" co" vjg" vq" rwtrqugu" tgvckp" cnn" qh" vjku"cevkqp." eqrkgu" qh" 3: cnn"EQPHKFGPVKCN"ocvgtkcnu"rtqxkfgf"vq"og"kp"vjku"ecug"kp"c"ugewtg"ocppgt."cpf"vjcv"cnn"eqrkgu" 3; qh"uwej"ocvgtkcnu"ctg"vq"tgockp"kp"o{"rgtuqpcn"ewuvqf{"wpvkn"vgtokpcvkqp"qh"o{"rctvkekrcvkqp"kp" 42 vjku"cevkqp."yjgtgwrqp"vjg"eqrkgu"qh"uwej"EQPHKFGPVKCN"ocvgtkcnu"yknn"dg"tgvwtpgf"vq"eqwpugn" 43 yjq"rtqxkfgf"og"ykvj"uwej"ocvgtkcnu0 44 1"1"1" 45 1"1"1" 46 1"1"1" 47 1"1"1" 48 1"1"1" 49 1"1"1" 4: 1"1"1" " /33/" 3254936^52833:8890x3" Case 2:20-cv-01156-GMN-NJK Document 16 17 Filed 10/13/20 10/14/20 Page 12 of 12 " K"fgenctg"wpfgt"rgpcnv{"qh"rgtlwt{."wpfgt"vjg"ncyu"qh"vjg"Uvcvg"qh"Pgxcfc."vjcv"vjg"hqtgiqkpi" 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; 32 33 34 35 ku"vtwg"cpf"eqttgev0"Gzgewvgf"vjku"aaaaa"fc{"qh"aaaaaa."42aa."cv"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa0 " FCVGF<aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"" " " D[<"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Ukipcvwtg " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Vkvng " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"" Cfftguu " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Vgngrjqpg"Pwodgt " " " " " " " EGTVKHKECVG"QH"UGTXKEG" 36 K"jgtgd{"egtvkh{"vjcv"qp"vjg"35vj"fc{"qh"Qevqdgt."4242."K"ugtxgf"c"eqr{"qh"vjg"hqtgiqkpi" 37 TGSWGUV" HQT" QTFGT" VQ" GPVGT" UVKRWNCVGF" RTQVGEVKXG" QTFGT" wrqp" vjg" 38 rctv{"dgnqy"xkc"gockn"cpf"hktuv"encuu"ockn<" 39 " 3: 3; 42 " D{" 1u1Mgnug{"Hwueq" Cp"Gornq{gg"qh"Jqnng{"Ftkiiu."Nvf0" 43 44 45 Okejcgn"Mkpf."Gus0" MKPF"NCY" ::82"Uqwvj"Oct{ncpf"Rctmyc{."Uwkvg"328" Ncu"Xgicu."Pgxcfc":;345" Attorney for Plaintiff " 46 47 48 49 4: /34/" 3254936^52833:8890x3"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
