Page et al v. Grandview Marketing Inc. et al, No. 2:2009cv01150 - Document 141 (D. Nev. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER Granting 87 Motion for Summary Judgment, Denying 89 Motion to Extend Time, Granting in Part and Denying in Part 101 Motion to Dismiss, Denying 111 Motion to Strike, Granting 112 Motion to Dismiss, and Denying as Moot 113 Motion to Compel. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)
Download PDF
1 2 3 4 UN I TED STATES D ISTRI T CO U RT C 5 DI STR I O F NEVADA CT 6 EDDI PAGE e a1, E t . 7 Pl i if, antfs 8 vs . 9 GRANDVI M ARKETm G, NC. ta. EW I e 1, 1 0 11 Defnda t . e ns ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 2:9- v- I O- - F 0 c 0l S RCJ GW ORDER 1 2 13 Pl ntfsEddi Page,1 Bl nsbi Thom asLevandos ,M i haelM or tsa J ai î f e an anke p, ki c eti nd oyce 1 V a e s d D e e n sGr ndvi w M a ke i l a Ke n M .She ha f f iur t pa 4 nc ue f nda t a c r tng, nc. nd vi e n or a l e o y 15 overtm ew ages M os oft pr entm otonsconcel w hct Pl ntf s'ator i . t he es i ' n her ai if t neyspr l opery 1 c ntnue t ltga c t sc s on be l ofBl nke hi Pe ng bc o e t Co - a e 6 o i d o ii t hi a e ha f a ns p. ndi f r he ul r t 1 De e nt 'M o i f Su ay J 7 f nda s ton or mm r udgmc ( No. -Blnke hi sM o in f Ex e i nt ECF 87) a ns p' to or t nson Page et al v. Grandview Marketing Inc. et al Doc. 141 l ofTi ( No.8 . a ns p- M otonf Vol t r Dim is l( No.l ) Pl ntf s 8 me ECF 9) Blnke hi s i or un a y s s a ECF 01. ai if l M oto t Sti De c nt'M oto f rAto ne sFe s( No.11leEs nuc ' M oto 9 i n o rke f nda s î n o t r y' e ECF ) pi va s i n 20 f rVol a' Dimis l( No.11 .a Dc e n s' r c yM o i t Co l o untl s s a ECF y 2) nd f nda t 'Eme g nc ton o mpe 21 Atc nc ofI nBlnke hi a Augu t1 201 he rng( tnda c a a ns p t s 3. 0 a i ECF No.11 . 3) 22 1 . FACT S AND PR O CEDURAL H I STO RY 23 Pl ntf sEddi Pagc a l Bl ns p fl t scolectve acton Com pl ntagai ai if e nd an ankc hi icd hi l i i ai nst 24 D cf endant i s at cour f f l c t pa) oseri e urgcs undcrt Fai LaborSt sn t e l or aiur o . r tm , a he r andar Act ds 25 (- Q-)and Nexada ReNi t St ut (' -FLS. q rst at cs 'NRS-Jscctol 608.' 0.k ' om pl.Nza) 2' 2((C d i) (4 ScçC' 1 . l . - )1) , l I ! t Dockets.Justia.com 1 ECF No.1 a 9) De e a sr move TheCour ha c oldae t c s wih asmia c s , t . f nd nt e d. t s ons i td he a e t i lr a e 2 a i tDe e da sbr ug byLe n ki M o et, ndVa c ( de e v.1 2009, gans f n nt o ht va dos , r ti a nc . Or r No 0, ECF No. 3 58 . Coul ha a pr dt pa te 'si l to t dimisPa sa Blnke hi ssae ) The ' s p ove he ris tpu ain o s s ge' nd a ns p' t t t 4 1w cai a a ans She ha ( eOr r Se . 2009, No. ) a l ms s g i t e n. Se de . pt 30. ECF 41 . 5 On N ovem be 5,2009,Bl ns p sentan e r lt Pl ntf s'ator ,s a i t he r anke hi -nai o ai if t neys t tng hat 6 d dnotwa t c tnuewihhi c s . sc E- lECF No.l Ex. . i nt o on i t s a e ( 'c mai, 07, A) 7 On Deccm ber8,2009,t Coultc tonaly ce iied Page' and Bl he - ondii l rtt s ankens p' hi s 8 c lc ie a ton. Se Or r De 8, ,ECF No.6 .OnDe e r1 ,20 M a ita e ole tv ci ( e de, c. 2009 4) c mbe 1 09, g sr t 9 J udge Leen condii l ce i i Pl ntf sLevandos ,M or t,a Vance' colectve acton. tonaly rtfed ai if ki eti nd s i i i 1 ( eM a J. de , c l1 200 ECF No. . 0 Se g. Or r De . , 9, 65) 11 Pl i if fld a Amc d Co ant(' ' byla ofCoul. Se AC,Fe l 201 antfs ie n nde mpli ç ) e ve AC' '( e t b. 2, 0, 1 ECFNo. , d r Fe 9, 0, No.7 .Dee da smove frs 2 80. e , b. 201 ECF Or 9) fn nt d o ummayj gme r ud nt 1 a i tPl i ifBl nke hi a gui t theno l rwi he t pur ue t a to a i a 3 ga ns a ntf a ns p, r ng ha onge s d o s he c i n nd n ny 14 easew ascxemptf om t FLSA ' oveni e pr sons. Rat t n r pond,Pl ntf sm oved r he S m ovii her ha es ai i f 15 f an ext i oftm e. On M ay l 2010,Bl or enson i 0, ankens p s an e- ai t hi ator hi ent m l o s - neys t 16 r s tng hi deci i t notbe i ved i t sl s t On M ay 20.2010.Bl nkens p m oved eas er i s son o nvol n hi aw ui. a hi 1 t v untrl dimishi cam sa i tDefnd t wiho pr i c .De e nt r q tt t 7 o ol a iy s s s li gans e an s t ut eudic fnda s e ues ha 1 dimis lbewih prj i e t tse aetke t e ur t t r c r i pe mit d f f e 8 s sa t eud c . ha tps r a n o ns e ha no e ovey s r te or e s l and cost as oci t w ih Blnkens p.and t D ef ndant be aw ar ator s f f wor 9 s s a ed t a hi hat e s ded t ncy- ees or k 20 do r s ne e pondi t Binke s p' mo insa movi f s mmar jdg n n a i thi . ng o a n hi s to nd ng or u y u r e t gans m 21 On J 7.2010.Pl ntfsf l anotce ofcons satng t Joanna Es nueva unc ai if ied i cnt t i hat pi 2 e ns ntd t i n t saci a aplitf. On J nc25. ) 0. pi vamove t vol a iy 2 o e e o oi hi ton s an if u 2(1 Es nue d o untrl 23 d s ishc camsa ns Dc c an swihoutp cudie Dc e nt do no oppos t smoton. im s r li gai t f nd t t r i c . fnda s t c hi i 24 O n June 17.20l Pi ntfsm ovcd t srkc D cf 0. ai i' f o ti endant r pons t Bl s' cs c o ankcns p' hi s -f ' Pagc . oj 7 - ., I I i l m oton f vol ar dim isalf f l e t com pl w ih l r es. i or unt y s s or aiur o y t ocal ul 2 On June 28,2010,D ef ndant m oved t compelPl ntf Bl ns p t atend an e s o ai if anke hi o t 3 upcom i hea i ng rng. 4 l l. D I USSI N SC O 5 A. 6 Es nue move t vol trl dimisal he cli wih prj c ,e c pa t t pi va s o un a iy s s l r ams t out cudie a h ry o Es nue ' M oton t Vo unt iyDimis( pi va s i o l arl s s ECF No 11 . 2) 7 bearis ow n a t ney' f and cost Thc Courtm ay dim i san acton ata pl ntf sr t tor s ees s. s s i ai if eques by t 8 c r or rFe R.Ci P. ()2) Dee nt donoto cEs nue ' moto Theeoe, ou t de. d. v. 41a( . fnda s ppos pi vas in. r fr 9 t Co tgrnsEs nue ' motont dimisan dimis she camswiho prj c he ur a t pi vas i o s s d s se r li t ut eudie. 1 0 B. Bl ns p' M o i t Vol a iyDimis( No.1 ) anke hi s ton o unt r l s s ECF 01 11 Bln ns pmove t vou aiydimishi camswiho prj die, a hpat t be r a ke hi s o lntrl s s s li t ut eu c e c ry o a 1 isown a t ne sf esa c t . Th Cou tm a dim i sa a to a t pl i if sr que tby 2 t tor y' e nd os s e r y s s n c i n t he a ntf e s 1 co 'or r Fe R. v.P. ( )2) k et d e ntha fld as nma r u m e na i n 3 uz de . d. Cj 41 a ( . û t onc he cfnda s ie u a yj dg n! oto 1 4 orans e t pl ntf m ay dim i st ac i onl by si aton ...orby or oft cour, w r, he ai if s s he ton y tpul i der he t 15 t upon s t uch enns a condii ast cour deem spr '....'Coot J:Gel J Hart x nd tons he t oper ' er lc mar 16 Col , U. 38 39 (990) tl pupos ofRul 41a( i t prtc ad fnda tfom p.496 S. 4. 4 1 . t- r e -he e ()2)s o oe t ee n r l un prj ieo i on ninc fom pli if vol tl dimisl'C(ln%3 Ba e 7 duc eudc r nc ve e e r anlfs una' s sa. ) i. ' xtr y f I . 1 He lhc r Cop. 200F. D.l l 1 2 ( D. 20 ) t ineal r i tld u rFcd. 8 at a e l , R. 5 , 5 D. C. 01 . L e r ly, notons ie nde c R. 19 Ci P. 1a)2)s dbel r l grntd. slnga nooh rpat i prj died. Hhton3 v. 4 ( ( houl i al a e a o s te ry s eu c ' s . bc y ' 20 Cl k. 6F.Su 1 54.1 ( Nev.1 9) al 71 pp. 3 355 D. 98 . 21 Pl i lg pr j c maybes an e al eudie hownwhe ea t a lga rght a ct e tne o whe c r c- l e l i s r hr ae d r r u m onet yorot burdensa ar hcr ppcart beextem eorunr o r casonabl Forcxa pl pl n e. m c. ai 22 lga p eudi ha be n s e l r i ce s e hown ure et moton f v untr dim is c mc a h r hc i or ol a y s sal a t s h a a va e sa oft pr e di s a t pr j c dee ntb B'seo uc n d nc d tgc hc oc e ngs o s o eudic fnda y a t f 23 tm c and cxpcns i prc aton oldef c. i e n par i - ens 24 l atl356. d. 2: F Pagc 3 oJ 7 ' 1 l i ! 1 Dee nt donoto edimislbu t yrqu s dinlsa wihprj die t tse fnda s ppos s sa, the e c t s isl t eu c ,ha tps 2 ar t e aken t ens e no r o ur ecove y i pennit f f a coss as at wih Blnkens p,and r s ted or ees nd t soci ed t a hi 3 t D ef hat endant be awar a t s ded torney' f f w or done r pondi t Bl nkens p' m otons s ees or k es ng o a hi s i 4 a mo ngfrs mmayj me a i thm.Dee nt noet tat ughBlnke hi nd vi o u r udg nt gans i fnda s t ha, lbo a ns p 5 r q se t ber m ove fom t i c s i Nove be o 20 Pl i ifr f e t a ndo hi e uc t d o e d r hs ae n m r f 09, a ntf e us d o ba n s 6 cli .Thi ldt Dec nsiingar tonfrs mmayj dgme a ai tBln ns i ams s e o fnda t ii noi o u r u nt g ns a ke hp. 7 Pli if t nmove f a c e inoftmet rs ndt t moi f smmayj mc , antfs he d or n xtnso i o epo o he ton or u r udg nt 8 t w hi D ef ndant alo r ponded. o ch e s s es 9 Pl ntfs i r y,pr de a decl aton ofBl nkens p s atng t t Tr Law Fim ai if , n epl ovi ar i a hi t i hat he an r 1 wasa ho iedt pr e dwihhi c s untlM a l 201 ( a ns p De l, No.11 , 0 ut rz o oc e t s a e i y 0, 0. Blnke hi c .ECF 0 11 Ex. .Be a eDe e a sha i u e c t ofde e di Bl n ns i scamsf o ra A) c us f nd nt ve nc n'd oss f n ng a ke hp' li or ve 1 ye rdimis lwil wihprj c Andbea ePli if'at n yse nd drs re 2 a, s sa lbe t eudie. c us antfs tore xpe e e ouc s 1 tl gf rs 3 'ni o umm ayi i r udgme ta ans Blnke hi a oppo i hi mo i t e e tme t n g i t a ns p nd sng s ton o xtnd i , he 1 Cour wilalo awar Def nt atom ey' f 4 t l s d enda s t s ees. 1 5 1 . l 6 Dimis lwih Pr j c s s a t e udi e Dee nt aguet tBlnke hi scamss dbedimisdwihpeudi be a e fnda s r ha a ns p' li houl s sc t rj cc c us 17 t have i hey ncurr t expens ofdcf ng agai tBl ns pf cl m s f ove a yea and ed he e endi ns anke hi s ai or r r 1 be a et ha eara tldamotonfrs 8 c us hey v le dy ic i o ummayj me to hi cl ms Plitfsdonot r udg n n s ai . anif 1 a esDee ntfrquetf ds sa wihprj c i t i rpl Defnda t ha i u e 9 ddrs fnda s c s or imisl t tudic n her e y. e ns vc nc n'd 20 e pe e de e ng Bl n ns pe c a m s Bl nk ng p s ul not a l d t f c x ns f ndi a ke hi s l i . a e hi ho d be lowe o or e 2l Def nt t i enda s o ncurt hosc expens ane s d he deci t r fl Thc Cour di i es es w houl de o e- ic. t sm ss '2 Binke hi scamsu't prj c . A a ns p' li ih eudie - 23 2. 24 3 -1 C ondii on Pl ntf *Fut e R e tons ai ifs ur coverl of At or ' t ney- Fees s Def kndant ar t Pl ntf s s d not i t f urc.bc alow ed t r ' a . s guc hat ai if houl . n he ut l o ccoxer n) ' . j paga4 (f 7 ) ( 1 a t r y' f e a s i t d wih r pr s nt ton ofBl nke hi afe N o m be of20 a d t t to ne s e s s oc a e t e e e a i a ns p t r ve r 09 n ha 2 any awar ofa t ney' f t Pl ntf si t f ur s d t accountt rf l e t tm el d tor s ees o ai if n he ut e houl ake hei aiur o i y 3 dim is Blnkens p' cl m s. s s a hi s ai 4 Pl ntf sdo notoppos t sr ai if e hi eques ,buti t poi outt t t s ves as t t ns ead nt hat hey hem el ked hat 5 t pani bea t rown f and cos sass at d w ih Bl he es r hei ees t oci e t ankens p' cl m s t Courtagr hi s ai . he ees 6 t Def hat endant s d notl e be m ade t pay Bl s houl at r o ankens p' ator y' f butt e i no hi s t nc s ees, her s 7 r on t i pose a addii condii on Bl nkens p' vol ar di m i ali t sr pec . eas o m ny tonal tons a hi s unt y s ss n hi cs t 8 3. 9 Def endant R ecovery ofA torney' F'e:and C os s s' t s e t D e e nt a guct tt Cou t ho d s nc i n Bl nk ns p' a t r ysby r q r n f nda s r ha be r s ul a to a e hi s to ne e uii g 10 t t pay D ef hem o endant ator s f f r pondi t Blnkens p' i e r t i se s' t ney' ees or es ng o a hi s nt r oga or es rved 11 afe Blnke hi as dt wihda drfigt moi f s tr a ns p ke o t rw, atn he ton or umma'j me a i t l udg nt gans y 1 Bl nke hi a d a tng r s i pa r t Pl i i f 'r q s f a tona tm e t oppos 2 a ns p, nd r f i e ponsvc pc s o a ntfs e ue t or ddii l i o e 1 t moto f s 3 he in or ummayj dgme .Defnda t e tmaet tt yic rd$1 70600i r u nt e ns si t ha hc n ure 2, . n 1 ator sf r pondi t Bl 4 t ney' ees es ng o ankens p' t i a'erheas t wihdr fom t cas hi s ilngs h ked o t aw r he e. l5 The Courtm ayrequie an ator y twho s m uli i t pr r t ne G o tples he oceedi i any case ngs n l unr onabl a vexa i l ft pay ia t reys'f r onabl i r beca ofs h 6 eas y nd tousy' o ùtorl ees eas y ncur ed use uc 1 c ue . 28U. C.j l 27.Cou t as ha t i rntpowe t a s s at ne sf e 7 ond t' f S. 9 rs lo ve he nhe e r o s e s tor y' e s 18 agai tcouns t iasact i bad f t want y.vc i leorf oppr si r ons. ns el hat l ed n aih. onl xatousl' or es ve eas 1 Ch î r ! -L 9 anbe s 'TASCO. ? . 501U. 3 45 (l 1. TheCou-a e sn'h Defnda t t t . f3 . c S. 2, -46 99 ) l grc i t t e n s ha 20 Bl ankens p- ator hi s t neysunr onabl'and vexatousy nn tple t pr eas l i l uli i d he ocecdi and t Cour ngs. hc t 2l or st der hem t pay t atonl f and cos sasr o he t eys ecs t cquesed. Def nt ator t enda se t ncys s lf l a hal ie :2 s at afidavi and pr ed or f t spur 2 . epar c i t opos der or hi posc. 23 C. 24 Dcc nt mov f s fnda s c or umma )i me a ns Bl lc hi bc a cBlnke hi n r. udg nt gai l ant ns p c us a ns p o ' o - p f , E Debnda s M oton f/ Sum mar ' l nt - i tr l Judgme (. F N(.:7) nt EC' ) - Iagk j ot 3 ?i k 1 l ongerwihest pur ue t s ac i a bc e Bl nkens p i exe ptf om t FLSA ' s o s hi ton nd caus a hi s m r hc S 2 overi cpr sons As di cus above,t Cour gr sBl tm ovi i . s sed he t ant ankenshi sm oton t vol ar l p' i o unt iy 3 ds s hi cli wihprj c Totee e t motonf s imis s ams t eudie. h xtnthe i or ummayj r udgme i no mo , nt s t ot 4 t Cour gr nt i f f l et oppos . eLoc lR. v.P. 2( .TheCo tde c he t a s t or aiur o e Se a Cî 7- d) ur nis 5 Bl ankens p' m oton f ext i oftm e. hi s i or enson i 6 D. M o i t St i ( ton o rke ECF No.11 1) 7 Pl ntf sm ove t sti t pori ofDef ai if o rke he ton endant r pons t Bl nkens p' m oton t s' es eo a hi s i o 8 di m i t seeksator s f abecause i doesnotcom pl w ih LocalRul 54-1 LocalRul s ss hat t ney' ees t y t e 6. e 9 54-l6 r r m otonsf ator f s,unl a courtor rsot wie,t i ude iem i i equies i or t ney ee ess de her s o ncl t zatons 10 and s m ares r at t t wor peronned and an afidavi by an ator satng t t f um i el ed o he k f t t t ney t i hat he ees 11 a d c t a er a on bl. a . Ci P. - 6( .( ) t iur t pr det i onnai n oss r e s a e Loc l R. v. 54 l b) c . Tal c o ovi he nf ton 1 r q r dby LR 5 1 b)a ( i amo i f a t n ys f e c tt e ac e t t dc a 2 e uie 4- 6( nd c) n ton or tor e ' e s onsiuts ons nt o hc nil 1 o t moton. Loc l R.Ci P. - 6( . 3 f he i ' a . ' v. 54 1 d) 1 4 Loc lRul 5 1 sae t tt wq napa t i e il dt movcf at e sf e ,s h a e 4- 6 tts ha t he L ry s ntte o or tom y' e s uc 1 mo in s al b fldwih t cou'a s r dwihi f ure n ( 4)d safe e l o t tna 5 to h l e ic t he l nd e ve t n o te l ay tr nty f he i l t ' 1 j gme o ohe ode diposngo t a ton. Lo lR. v. 5 1 Li wie. e5 of 6 ud nt r t r r r s i f he ci ' ca. Ci P. 4- 6. ke s Rul 4 ' l t Feder Rul ofCi lPr 7 he al es vi ocedur s a cst a m oton f ator s f m ay be 'be fl no e t t hat i or t ney' ees t ied 1 lt t n l da ahe t c r ofi m e *tg q e sasa corac to de p ovi s 8 aer ha 4 ys r he nty udg nt''u nls tmt our r r r de 1 ot nvie'Fe R.Ci P. d)2)B) 9 he s . d. ' v. 54( ( ( . 20 Def ndant a gue t s an icm i i i notneces ao'untlafcrt Coun ent s e sr hat ucb t zaton s s i t hc er 21 j men oro de ss nc i s.Furhemor . t nt ha e fidas c ntt t i r p e udg t r r a ton t r c Dcknda s v ie upplme o her es ons 22 whi iem i t rf and cos s.A snot a ch t zes hei ees t ed bovc.t Cour Mzl awar atorll'sf hc t il d t re ' ees, 23 D cf ndant se at af dasi and pr c s' par c fi 'l opos or u'l com pl' ih t LocalRui cd dcr il q u't he cs. 24 ''' ' F Pagz6 Of = ' . . h i ' 1 E. De e f ndant'M o i t Compe (/ 13 . s ton o l /1 ) 2 D ef endant m ove t compelPl ntf Bl nkens p t atend a hearng t w assche ed s o ai if a hi o t i hat dul 3 f Augus 13e2010 t exam i hi r di whet hew ihed t pr or t o ne m egar ng her s o oceed i t sm aterand n hi t 4 havePl ntfs'c ai if ouns r es hi atal tm esprort M ay l 2010. Becaus t Court el epr ent m 1i i o 0, e he 5 deci t spoi i Def des hi nt n endant f ,t m oton i dc ed asm oot s' avor he i s ni . 6 CO N CLUSIO N I I HEREBY ORD ERED t Def T S hat endant M oton f Sum m ar J s' i or y udgme ( No. nt ECF . 7 8 8 i GRANTED. 7) s 9 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tPl ntf sM o in f ExtnsonofTi ( No,8 TS ha ai if to or c i me ECF 9) 10 i DEN I . s ED 11 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tPl i ifsM o i f Volntr Dim is l( No. TS ha antf ' ton or u ay s s a ECF 1 1 )i GRANTED i pata DENI i pa t Binkc hi scamsa edimis d wih 2 01 s n r nd ED n r. a ns p' li r s s e t 1 peudi . 3 rj ce 1 4 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tPli ifsM oton t Sti ( No.1 1 i DENI T S ha antf ' i o rke ECF 1 )s ED. 1 5 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tPli ifsM oton f Vol a yDimis ( No. T S ha antf i or untr s s al ECF 1 11 i GRANTED. 6 2) s l7 I I FURTH ER ORDERED t Def T S hat endant Em er s' gency M oton t Com pelAtendance i o t 1 o In Blnke hi a Augu t1 201 he rng ( No.1l )i DENI asm o . 8 f a a ns p t s 3. 0 a i ECF 3 s ED ot l9 I I SO ORDERED . T S 20 21 Dat t s 29t cav osNovem ber 2O10. ed hi h i Z Z %. 23 0u ) - ' untdsttsalti.ld e ie at, src x g ' u t' I % I f - . RCI BERW ? . .I 7 ONES . E . ' 1 ! . . >t u - (I :g . ) i ! I j !