Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al, No. 2:2008cv01223 - Document 472 (D. Nev. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 352 Motion for Attorney Fees. Hughes is awarded $52,672.38, which represents twenty percent (20%) of its requested attorneys' fees and non-taxable costs. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)
Download PDF
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 UN I TED STATE S DI STR I T C O URT C r a .1 .) ï 9 DI STRI O F N EV A DA CT 1 EDW I K . S 0 N LAUGHTER, ta, e l Ca eNo. s : i: $ ' 1 ) # *5 Z x' E pp rr t% :n c 7 . pani litss , l 2 &s ,. J. y 1 UPONOR,NC.e a. j 3 I ,t l ' c. ,o : ' X z -. 1 V N- 2 4 5 * ' 1 De e an s f nd t . x . z' @ a f Sgg l 5 r w J a / 16 crtë !z ' - Y)' $îl 2:8 CV- 2 3 RJ ( ) 0 - 0l 2 - C-GWF - .- j k i l 1 ' ) ORDER GIAxaax c Ix PA RT AxI I DENYI I PART HUGIES NG N I V' ATER & SEw ER I ' M oTl œ s ox FOR FEESAND COS 13 21 TS # 5 uj ; 1 7 T ics iacasat npoutlblylwsirgrigal el dfciepu ig hs ae s ls ci rd csi it a uteadn lgdy eet lmbn o ai e v . @ 1 8 k d t l e l n fcu e , r ee , itiu e , n /r n tle l e l e e com ponent oefn mzsalg dyma ua trd mak td dsrb td a do isald alg dy s. Y 1 9 t - Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al Doc. 472 de e tve pi ng c f ci umbi ompo n s Dee n s a e Upo r l .(l no ' ;RCR Pl ng a ne t . f nda t r no , nc û upo r' ) mnbi nd 20 l c nia,nc (4 '.nesaePlmbi & Ai Condii ng(tnesae'aUnie Pl ng Me ha c ll .: RCR' , trtt u ng r )I toni d trtte ' td umbi , l l :l 1 ! ' LLC (' td'; Feg o Entr ies I (''r s '' a Hu s ' ae & Se r LP $Unie ' rus n eprs , nc. 'legu on', nd ghe W tr ) çl l we 22 . 23 (C KHUGHES-) ( l d e n s c lci l t l f nda t ' . Edwi K.Slugh e ,Re cc Fln '; al efnda t . ole tvey, s ee n se l ) n a t r be a in, 2 / 1Hely a d Cao Hell (olciey ' anif- alg ta te d fdie pu ig 4 Me ae . n rl ae' clet l. Tlit s' lee h t h ee v lmbn v f ) 1 ' . ei ) o e r n he ur o hei es dcnces l t i oca ed n 25 ' com ponent caus ha m . or ar lkel t caus harn i t fut e.t t r r i j s ed r : 26 Cl .k Count..N m ,ada. m ) - / : Nou bror teCour i HUGIES'sl i f Atone ' k a Coss (?5',Assac a ch f ts I oton or tr ys Fc? nd t.:F -j ttd s ny hcran.la'A;'i .i G r ed.i)pan anc D e zJ 1lpan. zi it (Top s anl . r ) l ni - r ' . Dockets.Justia.com 11 nx lc opA T ox s lFC , 2I j Th Co r fn a fl ws e utids s ol : o 3 l O n J y 28,2008,Pl ntf sGl t pr entacton,on behal oft m s ves a al ul ai it ed he es i r he el nd l 4 o he ssmia st t d, nt DititCou tf rClr Cot y,Nc da. Pe . rRe t r i lr iuae i he src r o a k mt va ( t Fo mova ( ) Ex. l #1 , 5 1 . Dee n s a e ale e y e ag d i t b ies of de i ni de lpi ma a mrng, ) fnda t r l g dl ng e n he usn s sg ng, vco ng, nuf c i 6 di rbutng, m ar i seli and i t lng t W is PEX pl bi s t , W i bo bras sti i ketng, lng, nsali he r bo um ng ys em rs s 7 fti s a ohe plt ngmaeil Jd.a l 5 l ) itng , nd t r tmbi tras t r - 1, . T . # o 2. Pi i if a l ge t t t e W is o br s fti i t le i c ra n r s d nc s a ntfs le d ha h rb a s itngs nsa ld n e ti e i e e 9 t o houtCl r Coun y,N e hr ug ak t vada we e d f c i The ' is o fti s a l g y r a t d w1. t , r e e tve. W r b itng le edl e c e t1 he 1 'l . - ) ï kV ' l ( '' : t Q: 5 z' J 81 rœ T r. r. # .= , y ' l g j .. l 0 wae i Clr Cou y i s hama ne a t c us ac mia ra to knownasde i iiai tr n ak nt n uc n r s o a e he c l e cin zncfc ton. l Asars l o d zn iiain Pl ntfs f her aleged t t zi l l e ut f e icfc to , ai if urt l ha nc eached out of t W-r bo br he is ass 1 fti s whc i ie rsde e 'pl ngs tmsa h s (d. t! 2 33.Pli if tld 2 itng , ih mpard ei nc s umbi yse nd ome . 1 a 5 2- ) antfsie 1 s tunde t f lwi t oi ofla lt ()prduc la iiy'()src la lt ()b e c of 3 ui r he olo ng he res ibiiy: 1 o t iblt, 2 tit ibiiy, 3 r ah jx 9:) 4 xpes ra t 4) e c f mple ra t 5) e c f ra y rha a lt. nd 6) .n z 4 1 e r swarny;( bra ho i idwarny;( bra ho warnt ofmec ntbiiy'a ( ey* k > I . ,@ .2 -) . a . f' Rj 1 neign e (d aI 3 - ) x S y 5 gie c . I t T 493, ' % a:> .a . . q( )g 16 g!a j (' /? 4' ( A ? ' ' Q ë On Sept be l5,2008,Def em r endant Uponor l rem oved t l , nc. he awsui f om s at lr te l c u tofd rl o r p ru n t teCls AcinFare sAc (CAFA'. q 7 o r t e ea c u t u s a t o h as to in s t ' ' ' /l ' ) , 1 8 OnAprl20,2 PlitfsfldaM oinf Cis Cetfc ton./1 0)TheCour i 009, anif ie to or a s riiai 1 t . V 1 t r a tr pemit d a pero of dic e y, a t r h va i e e i ns s t a h rng f 9 he e fe r te id s ov r nd h oug rous xtnso , e eai or 20 Pl i i f ' o i f Cl sCe t i a i n on J a y 25,2 0. a ntf s M ton or as ri c to f anu r 0l , 2l h s t nta pa t of t e di c e y c duc e by Def nda t t da e ha be n t ubsa i l r h s ov r on t d e ns o t s e o 22 dcf agai tPl ntf s' oton f Ct Certfc i cnd ns ai if M i or ass ii aton; . 23 Thr oughoutt di he scover pcrod.D cf nt at y i enda s tcnded a pari pat i num e nd tci ed n rous I depostons i l i a e tmae ni ( ou o sa e d posto ,r viwe a ive tg td ii . ncud ng n si td ne 9) t f tt e ii ns e e d nd n siae 24 1 25 'hous t ands of pages of docul a i di os b) t Pl ntf s. r ai nenl ton scl cd ' he ai if et ned expens. atended t 26 k d s r tve t si g a or Niua i pe to o1a l a t fNe ( 'hom e .a a l nd d m e a l r c l ! e tuc î e tn nd/ ' l ns c i ns ' t e s i ' 5p s s nd te e t lu gi a ,i 2 t tng -7 'esi of pl bi com ponent sei c um ng s cct d li ntr' al Seal Labor ores 'ai it s at f .d . ' Segundo. ' l Cerii i , tfcaton' 2 Si et i ta i oft sc s , f n n sha e a d i nu r smotonflngs nc he niiton hi a e De e da t ve ng ge n me ou i ii 3 and ar e sprm arl r atng t di gum nt i iy el i o scover and concer ofcl s ce-iic i y ns as ltt aton; 4 8. On Decem ber 3,.009,Pl ntf s fl a N otce of W ihdr 2 ai i f ied i t awalo$ M oton f Cl s ' i or as 5 Celfc to /278 . On De e r7,20 Pli if fld aM oin t Volmtr Dimiste riiain 4 c mbe 09, antfs ie to o t ay s s h 6 e tr aci g j Al d fnd t e e tUpono ,l opposdt moto a rquetdt t nie ton. #285 . l ce ans xc p r nc. e he in nd e se ha 7 t sCo r dimistematrwih peudie a alw t d fnda t t mov f fe a d c t hi u t s s h te t rj c nd lo he ee ns o e or e s n oss 8 ( ri fe ,he' o ngDee nt' g 1 31 3l 31 320a 3 1. heenatrt ' vi M fnda s' #3 4, 6, 8, 9, nd 2 1 ) , u 9 Q < j 1 Ds sWiotrui,hs orstdhtt ololds swtpe d en tate 0 i s t uPe dc tiC uttetaiw ud ny i s i rui adhth mi h j e a mi h j c - ' -' On J anuar 5,2010,t s Cour hel a hearng on Pl ntf s'M oton t Vol a l y hi t d i ai if i o unt riy V 1 is ofatr y' fe a dc t woul b rs re f frhe he rng( 44, 3 . 1 sue tone s e s n oss d e e ev d or u t r ai #3 451 , rë x; ê ; z >r * s 3. r # (' , g gy1 V tz j4 ) ' Nz 2 g *1 x . ,' i R l S jg j 1 2 '1; : - I' i $7 z, : g 1 (, eM oton,) TheFe M oi rq se fesi t a nto $229, . a c t i t 6 :Fe i ,. e ton e uetd e n he mou f 26193 nd oss n he t' kJ k' 1K 3' 1 a mto $1 94149,i l n aBilo Co t d ume tng 558 0 i txa ec t r/ 2J 7 mot f 2, . ncudig l f ss oc ni ,98,5 n a bl oss /35 . $ 1 The Bilo Cosspr de an atda tat tng t ts h c t we e r a ona e a ne es aiy 8 l f t ovi s fi vi tesi ha uc oss r e s bl nd c s rl 1 O. OnJnuay27 201 t sCour e trda ode g a igteMoto t Volnaiy a r , 0,hi t nee n r r rntn h in o u trl 1 DimisWI PREJ CE.g3 9.Th Co r rtie jrs ito t alw tedfn at t 3 s s TH UDI # 4 ) e utean d uidcin o lo h ee dns o , - . w mw jya j ?l l - 1 mo efrfe a dc ss 4 v o es n ot; 1 5 Dee d n HUGHEStldaM oinfrF e a dCo t /3 2 o F b u r 1 , 0 0 fn a t ie to o e s n ss 5 1 n e ray 0 2 1 . R j ' - : l9 Ii ur ed, and pr ded i ces f t t nc r ovi nvoi or he axabl coss, On M a c t rch 1, 2010, Pi ntf s fl a ai if ied ; l 20 Re p c t M oto f Ator ys Fe s ( 1 a dr s i e c of t M ovi De e da s s ons o ins or t ne ' c *363 , d e sng a h he ng f n nt' 211r que tf r f sa c t On M a c 11 201 HUGHES fid a Re y i Su to M o in f r e s o ke nd oss. rh , 0, ie pl n ppor f to o I 22 i sa cos s (37 : ! Fee nd t . / 21 / 23 I i On Aprl 29.201 HUGHES fld a Supptme t t is Fe Moto (/ 1 i 0, ie e n o t e in 1 399 2 j(' 4 t supplmc t'.pr vi ng e de e of a ii lf e a c t i un'd by HUGIES i t s e n ' o di vi nc ) dd lona e s nd oss nc c I n hi 25 la to an r que tngagr ndt l lo $255- 8. i l sa $l 057. i c t: : cin d e si a oa f 57 90 n be nd 3. 39 n oss . a6 i i I Thi Jas pr s c escnt exceptonalcicum s a s i r t nces giv Pl ntfk. i ta i and pur t Aen ai it niilon sui 27 I of t casc and cl s ac i ferii lon pror l n't anrlot t m ol on ï cl s ceri-caton he as t on z tfcat i i o ihdr a . he l or as tl i i 28 ! and dinnisalof t e case. s s 'h 1 lii a i i sa ec r; ltg ton n tt ou t l 2jl beforcedAengarofscahe efortandfdneiwPlnifssesivo Dmidhe nwge i eplote oi D e atsaatfatcMoi difssn aa fdu tt Mvg cnenssby rie 'de i onn enat dn ei iv fn exp s rntd h tg se ts 3l l wi t o a 4 pr esentacton butcontnue t pur ue t rcl acton i s at cout; i i o s hei ass i n t e 5 W hie t bul of f l he k ees i r by def ncured endant have val i subs s ue n equent 6 pr oceedi ngs, s e s gnii om i fcant porton of t f i r w il be dupica i i he ees ncur ed l i tve. The M ovi ng 7 De e a s s ul notbe f c d t i r t s me f s whee t f s ha be n c us d by f nd nt ho d or e o ncu he a ee r he ee ve e a e 8 Pl i if ' de i i n t a s r c a s a ton s a u i t i ltg to a d l t r w ihdr w t i m oton a ntfs c s o o s e t l s c i f t s n h s ii a i n n a e t a he r i u 9 based on t rdeci on t ptr uet s e cl si a dif entf um ; bei si o ls he am as n fer or < <- 1 0 jV 1 atr e ' fe : 1 ter s lso tie a dt a u tiv le ;()ten v l a ddfiut o 1 t n ys e s () h e ut ban d n he mo n n ov d 2 h o et n iic l f o y y xJ E g5 1 1 1 t que to i ve ( t s il r qu st t pe f r t l a s r c pr pe l ( t 2 he si ns nvol d; 3) he k l e iie o ro m he eg l e vies o ry; 4) he ' -' c '' : * >% * 1 6. Local Rul 54-16 outi t f l i f t s t consder w hen a a ng e lnes he olow ng ac or o i w rdi ;- V , % 1 p el so o oh re l y n b teatr e d et a c pa c o t ec s ;5 wheh rt efe J j 1a # 3 r cu in f te mp o me t y h t n y u o c e tn e f h a e ( ) t e h e o ' x 0( r , k , , jz ï 1 i txe orc ntn nt ( t tme lmiai i s d by t cin or crumsa e;( t . ;* c j 4 s i d o ige ; 6) he i i ttons mpo e be le t ic tnc s 6) he > x . u' @ . a . ,s rw- 1 e pe inc ,r putto a a lt oft at ne '( )t tnde ia lt oft c s ,i a ( )t . $ :o 5 x re e e a in, nd biiy he tor ys 7 he l sr biiy he a e f ny; 8 he p t , E q N)' $ ' ;ls. - :* J S p I(v 1 ntradl g o te rfsoarli siwi te ln'n ()w rsns lrae' gj 6 aue n e t fh poes nleao hp t h cetad 9 a ad i i acss nb i tn h i, mi 5 u: z 1 7 HUGHES h sa dc s d te fco ssae i LR 5 - 6 t te stsa t n o ti a d rse h a tr ttd n 4 1 o h aifci f hs o t m S ' j j l; 8 Coul V) q 1 9 l 8 . I t Fe M o i n, e e s c n he e to D f n e ouns la t t t tt l w tr bil a h l r t of e tess ha he a i m led n oury a e 20 $305. f r c ns ls tme a a ho l rt of$1 00 f pa aeg ltme. De e s c s l 00 o ou e ' i nd n ury ae 50. or r l a i f n e oun e 21 f her a-est t t num bcr of hour t l tnn s urt t s o he t s he aw ' i pem i dcf ng I U GH ES i t s acton. n endi ' I n hi i 2 I an if di no o cc t eihe t hou l r t sort numbe sofh sbild; 2 Pl itfs d t bj t o t r he ry ae he r our le j 23 g ' Th s Cou ti f m ii r w ih t c t m a l b li r t s f r l ga s nrc s i sm ia i r s a la t he us o r ' ilng a e o e l e i e n i l r J 2 ' a esa fnd t :t e hou l r t sa e r as na l f t l a s n' e r nde e 4 c s nd i s ha hes ry a e r e o b c or he eg l e i s e r d: c 1 25 p j ! . Thi Cour i f ii wih t s ac i and t ef or r r b) def s t s . lar t bi ton am he f t equied . ense t def o cnd p I 26 #ag i tt e cls c riiato moto a fndst tt n e o hou s e e d b) IUGHES I ans h a s e tfc in i n nd i ha he umb r f r xp nde ' I E J wasr easonabl e: * u1ss11 n.-'C. h 1 sa -s1 . w . 1 w hi aut i ed t i or aton cont ned i t pl ngs and contr i t ts it f ch hentcat he nf m i ai n he eadi - m ng ha ubm ted ees i 2 and cos swer r ewed and t t f and cos schar w er reas t e evi hat he ees t ged e onabl neces ar and act ; e, s y ual 3 22. HU GH ES pr i e a iem i ton a des rp i of l a s r c s pr de a ov d d n t za i nd c i ton eg l e vi e ovi d nd 4 t tme e pe d,a wel a s po tn a fda t o c e . The ma o iy of t M o ng he i x nde s l s up ri g fi vis f ouns l j rt he vi 5 Def endant i uded af i t of counselcat i ng a s m arzi t br s ncl fdavis egorzi nd um i ng he eakdown of f ees, 6 cos s and t ks r a i t t f r t as el tve o he ees equesed. Thi Couz fnds t r rng a delneaton off t s ' i hat equi i t i i ees 7 i lne by-i e,d t - - t f nna ,w o d r quie bo h pa e t i ur m o c f e a e f ta n i - ln a e by da e o t ul e r t di s o nc r e s nd for nd 8 t t Courti s ifed wi. t afi t ofcounsel hat he s ats i t he ldavis h ; () . 9 A sa r ul oft num e ous def es t he r endant requestng f t bur ofpr r ng and s i ees, he den epa i a Q- % 10 r ewi r t ine- lne iem i ton, t Cour fnds tït an i gr s r i of f i evi ng edac ed i by-i t za i he t' i la n- os ulng ees s i% s l a p o raea dtn sta a a r o 15o oe ic re b e c d fnd n i arao a l a r l p r p it n ' d l t n wad ï ? f s n urd y a h ee a t s e s n be wad i a .s., ' ë 'z5 ' p: k >œ * 1 otoes 2 - ; :- rC# l -= = % 3 5 1z $ A1 h h aigo Ma 1 , 01 ,hsCo r a r e HUGHES 1 0 o i tx be t e e rn n y 0 2 0 t i u t wad d 0% ft aal s . s , + 1 coss and 20% of al a t neys.f and non-axabl cos s and order t r t ng of coss t om p ) e .. t 4 e e t 1 tor ees t e t ed he e-axi t o x ' m.1 > î u' > Q J a . , . =- S 9 o 1 c nfnn t tno a untofat y sf e we ei l d i t o i i ltxa i ofc t. 4 5 o i ha mo tome e s r ncude n he rgna a ton oss . i < X w; oU %p> $ G ) jra fl j ë* ( g 1 1 6 2. O Ma 2,00HU E Ge i a ne Blo C s ./ 11oimigi 5 n y 421, GH S l t medd i f ot (49 cnr n t ds l s/ i s 1 txa ec t i t a untot$5-8 05a rrh c mi t tt ec t di n icude 7 a bl oss n he mo - 98. nd u ter onsr ng ha hos oss d ot n l m $ . 1 1a y at ne ' f e o ot r ma tr not p ope l t xa e unde t Loc l Rul . Al ot r 8 , n tor ys e s r he te s r ry a bl r he a es 1 he h * 1 jDee dnse cp Up n rtlda n e Bil f ss 9 l fn a t x e t o o 'e me d d lo Cot; i l p r $ 2; 0j 1 2. O Jn 421,lnf fea Ojco tBl oCs adMoo tR6 nue ,00Patf idn b tno isf ot n yyyaj e iis l ei l s tno i 21'Ta ( 1,a t ralrfld aM oi f Re- ton ofCossonJ ne 9.201 g : x #43 1 nd hee fe ie . ton o1 Taxai t u 0 . on ' 22 j une l 201 HUGHES fld Re l t Pli if ' Objc in a M oto t Re -a a a 7, 0, ie pl' o antfs e to nd i n o --xs nd n l tJ j ) '1 . - . . 23 !Ame e Or r Gr ntng i PM HUGHES M o i f Fe s a Coss (/ 5- 64 1 : nd d de a i n ton or e nd t /43 43 . he I i 24 'Am ended Or atem pt t addr t er or se f t i Pl ntf s M oton t Re-ia and i der t ed o ess he r s t orh n ai if ' i o -x I 25 !r duc d t t xa e c t t $5.304. consst u'h Pl ntf s'pl ng: e e he a bl os s o 37. i ent i ai if eadi t 1 26 On A ugus 13. 201(, a hea ng Mz hell on Pl ntfs' N'oton t Re-lax. On t ) ri as s ai if l i o -- Sc t m bc 20. 1 .t sC ou tis a f m a O r rr -a ng 1 LJ HEF'co t f on $ 8C8.i t p e r 20 0 hi ' r s ued or l de e t xi I G s s r l 5. ) (5 o . ' $5 3( (1 77 4 1 28. To t ext t s Cour ' tndi off tshoul be m or a oprat y s f h as he ent hi ts i ngs ac d e ppr i el et ort 2 ac l i n, ts a lbe d e e s c onc us o i h l e m d u h. 3 CON CLUSIO NS OF LA W 4 The Cour concl t udesasf l olows: 5 Thi Co t eai dj idito t r eupont r ues f at n ysf e a d c t; s ur r t ne urs ci n o ul he eq t or tor e e s n oss 6 The Fee M oton and Suppl ent adequa el a ess t r r ent of Local i em t y ddr ed he equiem s 7 Rul 54-16 and w astm el e i y; 8 u il . a - % n e boury bilng r e ofcouns and t ntm berofhour bil t Hughes W at , l li at el he l s led o er 9 wasr onabl f t com m uniy and f tl s cespr ded and s d r es wer notopposed as eas e or he t or le crvi ovi ai at e l0 excessve orotl r s i i le wi e nappr i e' oprat , i: ' s .. .q s '5 l l uucucss b tnil c mpidwi uerq ie nso-- 5 -6a dr q iiga i u sa t l o l t , e urme t ftR 4 1 n e urn ay e h l' E !1 >œ X 1 l eb -i add t-yd t bek o o fe a dc sswo l n tb po utv a dcudcue 2 i -yl n aeb -ae ra d wn fe s n ot ud o e rd cie n o l a s n ne r.r, ï 1 tep ris oic ra dto a fe a dc ss l = ë y 3 h at t n u d i n l e s n o t; d. e i < , fc t b ' :m = yZ'g 1 4 Thefe a no txa ecossi urdbyHUGHESwer at lya ne es rl e s nd n-a bl t nc rc e cual nd c saiy >,G s I , 1, 1 ic rdbyde.l n; . -$ 5 n ure K n tt t e da . . . $ = , %;R >w i d :L e $ Gg ' j j,a ' u ' 1 6 The t xa e c t s bm it d by HU GI ES a e s ppore by t a r pra e a bl oss u te I r u td he pp o i l I 1 doc me ttona rquie und rLR 54 1b)a ha ebe nacual a ne e srl pr de a 7 u nai s e rd e - ( nd v c L ly nd c saiy ovi d nd t - ' @ 1 ma e 8 d; V 1 9 g As ar ul o t f c t tva i de e nt a e r que tng a t ne ' ee a c t , es t f he a t ha rous f nda s r e si tor ys f s nd os s 7 . 20 t i Co ttn t ta i g os r ln a a di a t n ys f san no t xa e c t i a pr pra e h s ur i ds ha n n- r s u i g w r ng tor e ' ee d n-a bi os s s p o i t 21 a tnds t t a a r of t t pe c nt ( OC of t a t ne s f e a no txa e c ss nd i ha n wa d wcny r e 20z) ) he tor y ' e s nd n-a bi o t 2 jnurdb,ahote v g f dnsic d gH G Siaesnbe w r oaony, 2 l cr ) c fh moi Dee at nl i U HE .s raoala ad ft res j e e i n n , un t f 21esatdnsn-aal css ili epr'c adtvlxes taedt nmrs 31 e ïi no txbe ot nun xesfsn rec nsotn h ueu I no cdg t e a p e t e o 1 1 . 2 Ide s 4 g po , i l n svca ou ofsae d postons 'hc Nf r Dec da sha e rqa se ncudig e rl 1 tt e ii . F osng fn nt v e e td i i 25 at r ys f e ,non-a bl c ss a t xa l e t i ac ic ie a ntofsi tl mo e t n $l to ne ' e s txa e o t . nd a be oss n ole tv mou lgh l' r ha I 26 ln ilon. A n a r of on -it ( ' ) or t t pe c ntr t ) o1 a t n ls f es a no t x bl j li wa d e t fh l 5 . wen ) r e 20t . - tor e '' e nd n-a a c . t 27 lc t i ur e t Hti I ES a e c of t ot r n' ' D e e nt . i r a ona l unda t oss ne r d n ) GI nd a h hr he l i oh ng f nda s s e s b e r he 28 cicul t l and t ings r usalces inti i bnh l duci t f r quesec b) ' e ng he ees a t l ' 1 De e n pr vi sf ra r a o bl c le i f e a a d; f nda t o de o e s na e o lctve e w r 2 8. Thca r o al ne s f e a n t xa e c t i s ctc ly e e e a i tt wa d f tor y ' e s nd on-a bl oss s pe ii al ntr d gans he 3 na e Pl i tf s a notc ns lf rt Pl i tfs m d a n if s nd ou e o he a n if ; 4 Thi Cour fnds t i i r onabl and appr at t awar HU GHES t s ti hat t s eas e opri e o d axabl e 5 c t i t e a mtof$ 3 37 a t r f r a r e s h a oss n h mot 5,04. , nd he e o e wa d d uc moun i hs S ptmbe 20 201 , tn e e r , 0 6 Or e /4 , d r 531 . 7 l 0. Dee ns ae n e tte t pr-udg ntitr s.Ho ve,Dee ns ae fnda t r ot nild o ej me neet we r fnda t r 8 e ildt p tj dg n i eetfo t d t o e r oft fna J gme tofDimis lwih ntte o os-u me t ntrs rm he ae f nty he i l ud n s sa t u 9 Prj c , a my 27 201 untlt a r i stsidi f l eudie J nu , 0, i he wad s aife n ul; < a- 10 % To t e entt sCour Concl onsofLa s d be m or appr at y se f t he xt hi fs usi w houl e opri el t orh ZV 1 a at dn o fc, i s lbe deem ed ass 1 s i ig f a t t hal n uch. z' J p1 Jœ * l 2 7 4aï . j 1 p; % ' ,. l 1x ) 5 yz g q ) x . e' z ra t r g.p r % x/ G; j )t j 1 3 t *' : Z. : - - . ORDER I I HEREBY ORDERED t tHUGHES, otonf Atone , esa Coss/35 i TS ha M i br tr ysFe nd t 21 s 1 GRANTED i p r a d DE ED i p r. HUGHES i a r e $ 26 2.8 whc rp ee t 4 n at n NI n at s wad d 5 ,7 3 , ih e rsns , 1 t nyp re (0 o i rq e tdatne sfe a dn n tx bec ss Co ic wi tec s 5 we t ec nt2 %) ft e u se t ay e s n o -a a l o t. mbn d t h o t s o . h 1 a r o $5, . t sCour a r HUGHES at t lmuou of$ 9 7 f f e a d c t. 6 wa d f 30437,hi t wa ds oa nt 57,76.5 or e s n oss ;:a o l 7 .s ur Rhi Co tFURTHBR OIDERSa a r o pos-udg nti eeta t fd r j dg nt L n wad f tj me ntrs t he e ealu me t $ 1 r t t t mov n De e n s The we kl a r oft 1 y a c nsa maurt Tr as r yii 8 ae o he i g f nda t. e y veage he - e r o tut t iy e u y ed i ' ' V 1 lfrtewekbfr Jnay2,21 i 03%. Tedi rt frpsjdmetitrsi 9 o h e eoe aur 7 00 s .1 h al ae b otug n neets y 20 . 008 5( 0031365) Po t u m e ti e e twil c a eat$ 49 da un i s tsid. 000 4931 0. / . s- dg n ntr s l ac umult 0. / y tl aife j 21 I I T S 22 D -RJ, D . V NORABLE . VVI Y D ONES W 2l 31 LNI D S F-DI TRI J T TE TA S CT UDGL 24 l l . yy DA TED :Qovem be.rg apqz , i 25 CI rj t h): jSuhn sed , j : i . 6! ! . .- I ..-'t'...z.s':.--. 2-- ..c:E --. ?. -; -:---. .-. iRos a 'Nzl i an.Esq, em rh lsssi -' l , - 7 V. NBERG.V ) EI HEELER.H UDGI GUNN & D C LLC. NS. AL. f''z' ï)'. clnft'J. 'b.(. J (/;'&..t''-' -? t?Ft' (. D c /pl J ? r :à r ?fJ ' -t(.Jf ? l ' k i? b ' 'ï ! k E- J . 1 . n8 D .'Eb ' sFttda.o1S' tmbe. )C. t1 t .l l - e e r2619 k- hi è t p