Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al, No. 2:2008cv01223 - Document 470 (D. Nev. 2010)
Court Description: ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 351 Motion for Attorney Fees. United Plumbing is awarded its taxable costs in the amount of $10,911.29; one-fifth (20%) of its attorneys fees and other costs in the amount of $33,679.87 for a total award of $49,591.16. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
1 2 3 4 UN I TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT 5 DI STRI OF NEV ADA CT 6 FD W I K . SLAUGH TER,e a1, N t . 7 Cas N o. e : 2: CV08- 01223RCJ- F GW Pl ai if ntf s, 8 VS. 9 UPONOK l a M i ot cor aton;et NC nnes a por i ., 10 O RDER al, . 11 Def endant s. 1 2 Thi oas i acl sac i l s tagai Def ndant ,whom mm f ur m ar t di hibut s e s as ton aw ui nst e s act ed, keed, s ed. 13 a / i t le a l ge l de e tvepl m bi c po n s whi h Pl i if a l g c us d ha ora e nd or ns a l d le d y f c i u ng om ne t , c antf s le e a e nn, r 1 4 lkel t caus har i t f ur t t rr dencesl ed i Clr Count N e i yo e m n he ' e, o hei esi ut ocat n a k y, vada. The cas has e 15 16 17 b e dimisdw11prj ie BeoeteCouri Dee n INI PLUMBI LLC' Moi e n s se t eudc . fr h . : ts fnda t J TED NG, S ton f Ator y' Fe sa Coss ( 351 Assae heei,heM otoni GRANTED i pa'a DENI or t ne s e nd t .# ) t td r n t i s n l nd t ED i par. n t 18 TheCou t wad Defnda t TEDPLUM BI LLCt nypec nt20 oftrquetd r a rs e n UNI NG, we t re ( %) is e se 19 Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al Doc. 470 ator y' f a non-a e cos s i udi expe s'f and tavele t ne s ees nd t xabl t , ncl ng rt ees r xpens ,i t am omA of es n he t 20 $33, 87. 679. 21 The Cour a a ds De e n I NI tw r f nda t - TED PLUM BI LLC is t x bl c t i t e a ot of J NG. t a a e os s n h m mt 22 $10, 29 f a t alf and c t awar of$45, 16. 911. or ot ees oss d 591. 23 l 24 1 2y Th Cou t wadsDee n UNI PLUM BI LLC pos-udg n it rs,r t dae e r a r fnda t TED NG, t. me t n e e tfom he t j o e r o t efna jdg nto J nua 27, 01 , tt fde a j me r t (hewe k la r g of f nty f h i l u me n a n' 2 0 a he e r l udg nt a e t e l' ve a e ' t l- m am r ' eas yi d f t weekbef eJ he year hlTr un, el or he or anuar 37, 0i . 1% .Thsdail r t f pos y 201 s 3 l' a e or t 26 !jdg n:ntr s i umit a r i s tsi da adal'ato .(3i7 ? r 00 di é b ' 65tme u me i c c t s lhe wa d s aife t ilr tt f 0) 1 2tê T. 31 vied )3 i s z ' j ' 1 ns 1 1 ' I I !ëàC iC: ,t ? ' ? ' Dockets.Justia.com 1 t et a a r ) t ipad. h otl wa dl,mtl i 2 1 I . qxpl s o v FAC T xc 3 1 on Jul 2g, 200 pl i tfsEd i K . a ht r Re c a Fln M e He l y a y 8, a n if w n Sl ug e , be c i n, 1 a e nd 4 Ca olHealy f l t pr entc e ofac i , o be al o t m s l sa d a lo he s mia st t d i r e ied he es aus ton n h f f he e ve n l t r i l r i e n ua 5 t Ei ht J c a Dit i tCou t n Cl r Co t , Nevada. Pl ntfsalege t tDef he g h udi i l s rc r i a k un y ai if l ha endant Uponor s , 6 I . RCR Pll ng & M e ha c l l c. l e sae Pl i & Ai Condto ng LLC,Unt d nc t mbi c nia, n , ntrtt umbng r iini , ie 1 Plmbi ,LLC, r onEnt m rs s,nc.andHughesW aerandSe erlp ar engage i hebusness u ng Fe gus e ie I s t w , e d nt i F ofde gni .de l pi m a f c urn diti tn m a k tng s li a d i sali h W is si ng ve o ng, nu a t i g, srbu i g, r e i , e lng, n n t lngt e r bopEx 9 7 umbi s t m , W is br sfti , ndot rpl ngm a e i l a pa t t ot bl t r uppl l ng yse r bo as it a he umbi ngs t ra s s r of hep a ewa e s y 1 s t ms o r sde ta dwe lngsi Cl r Coun y, Nevada. 0 yse f e i n i l li n a k t 11 2 J ntfs alege t ç elow br ' W i bo fti i t l aspar ofW is nai if l hat t l y ass' rs itngs nsaled t r bo 1 Plu i s tmsi r sde ta dwelng i Clr Co t Ne ad , w er def c i e due t a pr ess 2 tubng yse n e i n il li s n a k uny, v a e e tv o oc 1 r f r e t a d z nc fc to . Pl ntf ss t D ef 3 e e r d o s e i ii a i n ai if ued he endant ,i udi U NI s ncl ng TED PLUM BI NG,LLC, 1 4 de t f i ngt oiso lablt ()Pr c Libiiy;2 Stit a lt ()Bra hof rs rhe olowi he re fi iiy: 1 odu t a lt () o Libiiy;3 ec Exp es 1 w arny ( Bra h o I id W arny;()Br a h ofW a a y ofMcc an lt a ( 5 ra t; 4) e c f mple ra t 5 e c n'nt rh mbiiy; nd 6) 16 N eglgenc . Pli tfss ugh ge r la d s ca da ge i e ce sof$1 0 0000 i e a n if o t nea n pe il ma s n x s 0,00, .0. 17 3 On Se em be 15, 20 , f nd nt mo ,l r m o d t l ws i f o Cl r pt r 08 De e a Upc r nc. e ve he a u t r m a k 1 Co t DititCo toFe ea Co r puru ntot Cls AcinFanls Ac (* 2 uny sro urt d rl u t s a t he as to i e s ttCAFA'.( 1 ' # ) ) 19 4 on Oct ober 1 , 2 , anif ildaMoint Re d( 7 u rhet r t 4 008 Plitfs ie to o man #1 ) nde t G t on' ma da 20 hom e-saerç a c toves 'a t iceinay, xcpto t c-lwj rs it tt,xl l onr ry' nd v srto r'e e ins o w h uidci oc d on. 21 5 on M a oh j, 200 plitfs moint rma wa de e (9 . r 9, anif' to o e nd s nid / 41 / 22 6 on Apri 20, 2 09 Pli if fIdaMot nfrCls Ce fc t n.#l 0)T l . , antfs ie . i o a s niiai ( 1 'he 0 o o 23 cou t r a t rpe mit d a pe i o dic e l a t oug va i e t ns o , s t a he rn on n hc e fe r te rod f s ov r ' nd hr h rous x e i ns e a ig 2 Pl i if 'M o i f rCl s Ce tfe to o M a c 29, 201 (2 )b wa move u byt Co to 4 a m fs ton o a s rii a i n n r h 0 7 27 ut s / d p he ur t 25 J nua y 2.5. Og272) a r 2O1 # . 2 6 7. . A subsanlalpartoft dicove s c t i he s r onduct b) t e Dei ed ' h èndant was i r ponset s n es o 27 1pl ntfs-m o:on f ci cenii i . ai if i or ass fcaton 1 : : ( . 'l *q '; . i ' .. .. . I ' r ! j l h : . ua v . r r s r r.oz 'xe e ' 'ï.(I' ' nt' v .f ale c v g .r las s :. 2 ) () 25 a bde c ,k :. ' (. J n .- !age- (: ' 5 l 1 ' ' I ' 1 8 . Thr ugh o out t dic e y pe i , De e da s i l i De e da UNI he s ov r rod f n nt, nc ud ng f n nt TED 2 PLUMBI LLC, te de a patcp tdi numeousde ston ,ncudnga etmae ni ( NG, atn d nd riiae n r po ii s i l i n si td ne 9) ou o sa e de ii ns r vi we a i si t d t s d ofpa e o do u e t ton pr vi d by t f t t posto , e e d nd nve tga e hou ml s g s f c m n ai o de 4 t Pli if,atnde detu tvetsi a /rviua i pe to o a latfve( home,a d he antfs te d srci etng ndo s l ns cins f t e s i 5) s n 5 a tnde m e alu gi a t s i of u bi o m po n ss l c e b Pli tfsa Se lJa a oe i E1 te d t l r c l e tng pi m ng o ne t e e t d y a n i f t a w bor t s n 6 Se t g mdo,Ca ior i , nd s h dic e y oft e l whos a f av tw m s it d i s por of lf n a a oug t s ov r he xpe' t e fk i s ubm te n up t 7 Pl i tfs m o i t c riy c a s a n if ' ton o e tf l s . 8 9. Si et i ta i n oft sc s t De e a sha e ga d i num e ou m o i nc he niito hi a e, he f nd nt ve n ge n r s ton 9 ûl san a gum e sr l tn t d s o r a d c c r o c a sc rii a i The eM oto i l e i ng d r nt e a i g o i c ve y n on e ns f l s e tfc ton. s i ns nc ud d 1 aMoinfrPrlmi r Ij ncina /rTe rrr sri ngOr rfj b Dee a t Feg o 0 to o ei nay nu to ndo mpoajRetani de ied y fnd ns rusn 11 Ene ie,n a dUntdPl ng, ( 2 4 az Pli if' oi f Levet FieaSe on tmrs sIc. n ie mnbi LLC # 09 , l antfs M ton or a o l c d d 1. Ame dCo an ( 21 , c t Dee a s i l ngUNI PLUMBI LLC, os d. 2 nde mplit # 9)whih he fnd nt,ncudi TED NG, opp e 1 3 l 0. OnNove r23 2 Pli if ' l e ee t a e uia er me yp o d d b t mbe , 009, antfs Coms l loed n q tbl e d r vie y he 1 Com'a a e d t Ko - ut' 1 i vi l whofldaNRS Cha e 40Notc ( 48 . 4 t nd gre o Gpto 'a1 ndi duas ie ptr ie #3 q 1 5 On De e r3, 009 Pl ntfsfl d a Notc ofW ihdr wa ofM oto f rCl s c mbe 2 , ai if ie ie t a l in o a s 1 Cetfcain ( 2 4 Plstfsdi no se la oft Co tt fl a a nd d c litt 6 rii to # 78 . anif d t e k e ve he ur o ie n me e ompan o 1 wihdr w t c a sa l ga i i t i pl a ng . 7 t a he l s le tons n he r e di s 1 8 1 2. On De e r7, 9, ai if fl d aM oto t Volmt rl D im i st sltga i c mbe 200 Pl ntfs ie i n o t a iy s s hi ii ton 1 i ise iey( 28 ..1 Dee nt,e e tUpo r oppos t svountr dimislsekn t 9 n t ntrt # 51 * 1 fnda s xc p no , ed hi l ay s sa e ig he 20 ds sa t bewihprj c a a a r oft iat ysf san co t /31 3 31 , 9 3 imis lo t eudie nd n wad her 'ome ee d ss 4, 06. 8 31 , 20 t 21 a d321. n j 22 l 3. On J r a y 27,201 t i Co t e t r d a Or e gr n i g Pl i tf s M o i n f r am r 0, h s ur n e e n d r a tn a n if - to o 23 Vot ay Dimis l i pa t a cimis d t s lws i wih pr i i e i l di Pli tfs c a s lmt r s s a, n r, nd ls s e hi a ut t qud c , ncu ng an if' l s 2 alg tonsi t i Co lit(t49 TheCou txpe syrt ne j idcint c i r i f 4 le ai n her mpan.#3 ) re rsl eai d urs ito o onsde Motons or 25 Atorl Fees and Cost tl b) t Def ndant ,i udi UN I l reys' s ied 'he e s nel ng TED PLUM BI G.LLC. N 26 On Febr y l 20l0. NI uar 0, U TED PLUM BI G.LLC fl isM oton f Ator 8Fees N ied t i or t ney' 27 a Coss( 3 1.Pli fsfldars s o Mac î 2 )1$36 a onMao 5l 3 . TED nd t # 5 J amif ie epon e n rh . 0 ((1 3) nd rh , 009 UNI 2 t LtX BI L f e isRe l t Pamii Rtp n et i l oirfrAto n lsFzta dCo t.' 8 P JI NG. LC i d l p) o ii fs t o s o : ' tolo trc' t n ss i i s sv i s 1 : ! i 1 q Prgt 3 oï t' ' 1 i whi h UNI n c TED PLUM BI NO, LLC s ppl m e t d is M oto a i l e a Af a t f o u e ne t i n nd nc ud d n ûd vi r m 2 Stp ni A. e, q,i s tnilc mpla ewihLR 5 - 6.( 371 e ha e Le Es - n ubsa ta o inc t 41 # ) 3 1 5. Att h rng o M a 1) 201 t i Cou la r r UN I he ea i n y t, 0, h s t wa d d TED PLI M BW G 1 J 00% ofis t 4 t xa ec t a 20 o a1a t ne f e a o he c s sa or r d t r -a ngofc t t c nir a bl oss nd % f l tor ys e s nd t r o t nd de e he e t xi oss o o i m 5 t tnoa un ofa tr y fe we ei l e i t orgna txain ofc t. ha mo t to ne s e s r ncud d n he i i l a to oss 6 1 6. On M a 25,201 UNI y 0, TED PLU M BI il isam ended bilofcost confnni is NG 'ed t i l s i ng t 7 txa ec ssi tet al mou of$70,22. ( )a f t rc nfnni ta t ec t d no a bl o t n h ot a nt 1 41 #425 nd urhe o i ng h thos oss o t 8 i udeany ator ncl t neystm eoranyot i herm a rnotpr ry t bl underLR 54- t ough LR 54-15and ue ope l mxa e 1 hr 9 28U. C.j1 20-92 S. 9 1 4. 1 0 1 7. On Jme4, 0, antfsfld aM o in f rReTa ton ofCo t L 32) UNI t 201 Pl i if ie to o - xai ss #4 . TED 11 PLUM BI ildonOppoii onJ ne21 201 g441, ndPlitfsfidaRe yo J y1 201 NG ie ston u , 0 # )a anif ie pl n ul , 0 1 E44 . 2 # 7) 1 3 1 8. A h a i wa he d on A u t 1 201 a t Cou ti s d a f r a Or e on e rng s l gus 3, 0 nd he r s ue om i d r 1 Se tmbe 20,201 r-a ngLNI'D PLUMBI Sc t fom $7 1 41t S1 91l29/453. 4 pe r 0 etxi T 'E I NG' oss r 0,22. o 0, . ) 1 5 I . CO NCLUSION S OF LAS I V 1 6 1 . TheCou t xpr syrti dj idito t r l u t Dee a s Motonsf r e esl eane urs cin o ue pon he fnd nt' i or l7 Atonl sFeesard Coss. t ey' t t 1 8 2. Loc l e 5 1 o lne t f l w i g f c o st c nsd rwhe a a d ng a t r ys a Rul 4- 6 uti s he olo n a t r o o i e n hrr i to ne ' 1 fe :()t rs t oban da dt a tivoled;( t nov lya difc t oft qu si 9 e s 1 he euls tie n he moun n v 2)he et nd fiul he e tons y 20 i ol d;()t s l rquiiet pef m t l a srvcspopel ()t pr lson o ot r nv ve 3 he kil e st o ror he eg l e ie r ry; 4 he ecu i f he 21 e o n byteatr yduet t a c ptrc ofh c s'5) t rt fei fx dorc ntng t mplyme t h tone o he c e ale te ae ( whehe he e s ie o i en; , 22 ()t tmelmiai i e byt cintort crumsa es ()t e re e rputton, nd 6 he i i ttons mposd he le he ic tnc ; 7 he xpeino ,e ai a 23 a lt o t a tr y ;( t und sr biiy oft c c,i a y;( t naur a d lngt o t biiy f he to ne s S) he e ia lt he as f n 9) he t e n e h f he 2 pr f s i lr lton hi wih t oint a ( 0) wa dsi smia c s s 4 o e sona e ai s p t he le ; nd 1 -a r n i lr a e 25 LJ I - TED PLUM BI ' N NG, LLC s it Af i vis of St ubm ted fda t ephani A. Lee, Es and e q. i 26 The r Pa ke 11 Es w ih is M o i n f r Ator e s Fc a . Cos s a Re ) t Pli tf s odo e r r 1, q. t t to o t n y' es nd t , nd pl, o a n if 27 !Res pons t is li i f Ator l' Fees and Cos s whih s t ntall compled wih t ' e o t voton or t ne 's t. c ubs a i l' i t he 1 I 2 4rxliens so Lot l l 5 1 8 ; t u rl nt f - l Rue 4- 6. a 1 : ! ' . !Cgt u (: àtr': ' M 1 ' 1 4. l d ume ss bmi e wihUNI PLUM Bm G, n oc nt u t d t l TED LLC' M ovi a Re yPa r , S ng nd pl pe s 2 UNI TED PLUM BI LLC' i oie pr vet a t lw $11 bilda h ry rt o $1 pe hol NGS S nv c s o h t he a 144 le n ou l ae f 35 r tr 3 f p t rtme $1 pe hou f a s it tme, nd $ pe hourf pa aeg lt . Cou e f r or arne i , 25 r r or socae i a 60 r or r l a hne ns l o 4 U NI TED PLUM BI ,LLC a s a t ss t t n NG l o te t o he umbe of hou s t 1 w 511 s n on I NI r r he a 1: pe t J TED 5 PLUM BI , NG LLC' d f ns i t i a to S e e e n h s c i n. 6 Pl i lf h e ha t e op t t t r viw a r s d t t e d nc UNI a ntf s av d h poruniy o e e nd e pon o he vi e e TED 7 PLUM BI G,LLC s i e i s ppo to is M o i n f Atom e s Fe s a Coss i l i t N ubm t d n u r f t to or t y' e nd l t, nc ud ng he 8 Afi visofc mslal i c sf txa l a n txa ec t i ure Plitfsdi no o jc fda t ot e ld nvoie ora be nd on-a bl ossnc rd. anif d t bet 9 t t ho r ybilngr t of ns l n t nunb rof ur b le i de en ngI NI o he u l li a e cou e , or he l e ho s ild n f di J TED PLUM BI , NG 1 LLC,n t r m ona e s a ne es iyoft f e , t xa ec t , d t xa e c s si c r e by 0 or he e s bl ne s nd c st he e s non-a bl os s an a bl o t n u r d 11 L NI T TBD PLUM BI , NG LLC , 12 6. The Courtgener l fndst tt bul oft at ney' f a non-axabl cos s aly i ha he k he tor s ees nd t e t 13 i ured by t D ef ndant i udi LT TED PLUM BI ,LLC,wilhave val i s equent nc r he e s, ncl ng NI NG l ue n ubs 1 pr ee ngsa dma no bet s jc o a atre 'e sa r i t sltg to 4 oc di n y t he ubet f n ton ys fe wad n hi iiain. 1 5 An a a d ofs epori n o t r que t d a t r ys f e a non-a bl c s s w r om to f he e se to ne ' e s nd t xa e o t , 1 i i i g e rs f e a ta le pe e f ral nd ng nu e ousouto s a ede ii nsn i e b 6 nc ud n xpe t' e s nd r ve x ns s o te i m r f t t posto otc d y 1 Pl i if , sr a on bl a a o i t i t sm a trbe a eoft rs t t h De e n s i l di 7 a ntf s i e s a e nd ppr pra e n hi te c us he ik ha t e f nda t , nc u ng 1 UNI 8 TED PLL M BI G, J N LLC, il nc rd i a i a t n ys f e i de e ngi n i a i s e i ut r w l i u uplo tve tor e ' e s n f ndi de tc l s u s nf u e 1 pr c d ng i l n b not i ie t apo e ta r qu tf c a sce t i a i n.M or i po tnty, 9 o ee i s no udi g, ut lm t d o, t n i l e es or l s ri c to f e m ra l 2 a t ne s f eswe ei un'd b Pl i if our de i i n t s e c a sa to s a u ,on yt l t ri t 0 tor y ' e r nc e y a ntf s n c so o e k l s c i n t t s l o a e n he 21 casew ihdr t i M oton f Cl Ce tcaton. t au' he r i or ass dii i 2 2 8. The Cour t n t tr ue tng a de i ai off e i lne by lne da e- y- a e t' ds ha eq si i lne ton e s n i - i , t b d t 23 f r t a d o r q rngl l Y D PLU M BI LLC t pr uc r da t dbilngi c s woul e ie o ma , n / r e uii W l NG, o od e e c e li nvoi e a dr qu r 24 I TED PLU M BI G,LLC t unncces rl i m or ator sf JNI N o sa iy ncur e t ney' ees. 25 9. A sa r ul oft f t ts r Def es t he ac: ha eve al endant ar r s e equesi ator .sf and cost, lng t nel- ees s l 26 tl Coul fndst ani gr sr i aw a di atona 'sf and non-axabl cos si appr i eand le - i hat n- os ulng r ng t el' ees t t e t s oprat 27 f dst ta a d of12 oft at R l' f e a non î xa e c t i un'd b) e c oft M o ng m ha n uur 5 he ton e ' e s nd - a bl oss nc e ' a h hhe vi s 28 D z e a s i l i g t NI -' PLU I BI G. . i a r a o bi a r o a t r l' f r a no . f nd nt . nc ud n . '., T 1FD N N LIC. s c s na e wa d f to nr 'F c s nd nI . i l t i l ! ! Ja;t ' oJ ' .. z ' ! : i 1 t axabl cos s i udi expe s f and tavelexpe e t , ncl ng rt' ees r nses t atend t num er de ii of o t he ous postons 2 De e a Upo r l ' pe s nne no i e b t e Pl i tfsi M i ea ols M im e ot f nd nt no , nc.s r o l tc d y h a n if n nn p i , r s a. 3 10. 4 TheM ovi Def ng endant ha r s ve equest ator sf non-a e coss,and ed t ney' ees, t xabl t txa ec t i ac l tv a un ofsi ty mor t n $1milon. An a r o 1 5 or2 $ o a bl oss n olecie mo t lgh l e ha li wa d f / , 0% , f 5 a t ne s f e a non t xa e c t i u r d by I TED PLUM BI G,LLC a e c oft o h r tor y' e s nd -a bl oss nc r e JNI N nd a h he t e 6 M ovi Def ndant i r onabi undert cic sancesand fndi ass f t above,asr ng e s s eas e he r um t i ngs et orh eduoi ng 7 t f sr qu t d by e c D e e n pr vi sf a r a o bl c l c i f ea a d o a pr xi a e y he ee e ese a h f nda t o de or e s na e ole tve e w r f p o m t l 8 $ ,00.Thi a r ofat ne sf e a no ix bl c t i s cfc lye t r da is t name 2000 s wad tor y' e s nd n- a e oss s pe iial n e e gal the t d 9 Pl ntfs,and notc ai if ounself t Pl ntfs. or he ai if 10 11. The Com' t t i i r onabl a appr i e t awar UNI t inds hat t s eas e nd oprat o d TED PLUM Bm G , 11 LLC istxa ec ssi t ea n o $1 9112 ass tf t i LNI t a bl o t n h mou t f 0, .9, e orh n T TED PLUM BI LLC' Bil NG, S ls 1 o Cot ontl heena teCou tsOr r(453,Thi a r i alos ci lye ee a anst 2 f ss ie ri nd h r' de # ) s wad s s pe ikal ntrd g i the 1 n m e Pl i tfs a d n c m s l ort Pl i if . 3 a d a n if , n ot ol e f he a ntfs 1 4 1 2. INI PLUM BI LLC i e ildt pr-udgme tntrs.Ho ve, TED J TED NG, snotntte o ej n i eet we rUNI 1 PLUM BI LLC i e tte t po tj gme tit rs fo t daeofe ty o t efn lJ dg n of 5 NG, s nild o s-ud n n e et r m he t n r f h ia u me t 1 DimislwihPrj die J nuay2 201 unit a r i stsidi fl. 6 s sa t eu c , a r 7, 0, tlhe wad s aite n ul 1 7 1 1. O RDER 1 1 8 I I HEREBY ORDERED , ADJ DGED mz DECREED t a De e n UNI T S U d h t f nda t TED 1 PLUMBI LLC' M oinf Atone sFe a Cot g )i CRANTED i p r a DENI 9 NG, S to or l r y' es nd ss #351 s J n at nd ED 20 i r.L IYD PLUM BI i a r e istxa l c t i bea o tof os 129. e tfht % l npa t m ' I NG s wa d d ! a be oss nt m un sl gl . , -ll zo on 21 o hsa tm e f e a ot rc t i t ea un of$ 679.7 f at t la r ef$ 5 .6. f to ys e s nd he oss n h mo t 33, 8 or o a wad 49.91 1 22 I I FURTHER ORDERED ,ADJ DGED AN D DECREED t t M oton f Ator s T S U hat he i or t ney' 23 Fe sa Cossi GRANTED a t pos-udgme i r s,r t d t o e r o-hetna j me t e nd t s s o ti ntme e t fom he a e f nty tt ' )udg n i 24 1o Jnuay2 201 ,a t fd rludg n rt thewe kl a rgeo t ly rmauiyTraur . n a r 7, 0 the e ea j me t ae t e y vea f he -ea trt e s y . 2 lilfrh wekbfr Jna '72 l i.1à T edi rtfr otu g nitrsi u t . yed o te e eoe aun 2-O Os3?. h al ae o p sc dmetneets ni 5 z y j l 2 it a r i s tsi ca acal r t o . 38 6 he wa d s aifel t iiy ae f 00 72% (, 31d v d d b . 65 tme t tt l wad:. i 5. 00 i i e ) 3 i s he o a a r )untl 17 Ipad. 1 ' i 1 1 t 8 l ! r ! ' a -. ' . Z np:'v v .c ir r ea'. ' rca z ' ! 2(lC''25 h ?'u' f ce alcs r s goîr k s g l .' / 1t J hF :. k FagS t i1 ' ' ' 7- ' ' ' l l D a ed Novem ber29.2010 t 2 3 o a eRo , J ne norbl C.o s 4 Unied St es i ' Cour t at ct t 5 6 RESPECTFU LLY SUBM I TTED BY 7 PARX ER NELSON & A SSOCI ATES, CHTD. 8 9 //t/ pàceakrH1 s fltfr rql t 1 THEODOV lP Courq11ES 1 2 6 Pr essonal 4 0 of ARKER Suie 200 1, Q. t 10 LasVegas N V 89128 , 1 Co co m s lf rD e e mz 2 - t e o f nd t Unied Pl bi LLC. t um ng, 13 14 15 1 6 1 7 1 s 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 n 71 1 , > - - 8t Ja c' :L ' - h; '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
