Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al, No. 2:2008cv01223 - Document 470 (D. Nev. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 351 Motion for Attorney Fees. United Plumbing is awarded its taxable costs in the amount of $10,911.29; one-fifth (20%) of its attorneys fees and other costs in the amount of $33,679.87 for a total award of $49,591.16. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)
Download PDF
1 2 3 4 UN I TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT 5 DI STRI OF NEV ADA CT 6 FD W I K . SLAUGH TER,e a1, N t . 7 Cas N o. e : 2: CV08- 01223RCJ- F GW Pl ai if ntf s, 8 VS. 9 UPONOK l a M i ot cor aton;et NC nnes a por i ., 10 O RDER al, . 11 Def endant s. 1 2 Thi oas i acl sac i l s tagai Def ndant ,whom mm f ur m ar t di hibut s e s as ton aw ui nst e s act ed, keed, s ed. 13 a / i t le a l ge l de e tvepl m bi c po n s whi h Pl i if a l g c us d ha ora e nd or ns a l d le d y f c i u ng om ne t , c antf s le e a e nn, r 1 4 lkel t caus har i t f ur t t rr dencesl ed i Clr Count N e i yo e m n he ' e, o hei esi ut ocat n a k y, vada. The cas has e 15 16 17 b e dimisdw11prj ie BeoeteCouri Dee n INI PLUMBI LLC' Moi e n s se t eudc . fr h . : ts fnda t J TED NG, S ton f Ator y' Fe sa Coss ( 351 Assae heei,heM otoni GRANTED i pa'a DENI or t ne s e nd t .# ) t td r n t i s n l nd t ED i par. n t 18 TheCou t wad Defnda t TEDPLUM BI LLCt nypec nt20 oftrquetd r a rs e n UNI NG, we t re ( %) is e se 19 Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al Doc. 470 ator y' f a non-a e cos s i udi expe s'f and tavele t ne s ees nd t xabl t , ncl ng rt ees r xpens ,i t am omA of es n he t 20 $33, 87. 679. 21 The Cour a a ds De e n I NI tw r f nda t - TED PLUM BI LLC is t x bl c t i t e a ot of J NG. t a a e os s n h m mt 22 $10, 29 f a t alf and c t awar of$45, 16. 911. or ot ees oss d 591. 23 l 24 1 2y Th Cou t wadsDee n UNI PLUM BI LLC pos-udg n it rs,r t dae e r a r fnda t TED NG, t. me t n e e tfom he t j o e r o t efna jdg nto J nua 27, 01 , tt fde a j me r t (hewe k la r g of f nty f h i l u me n a n' 2 0 a he e r l udg nt a e t e l' ve a e ' t l- m am r ' eas yi d f t weekbef eJ he year hlTr un, el or he or anuar 37, 0i . 1% .Thsdail r t f pos y 201 s 3 l' a e or t 26 !jdg n:ntr s i umit a r i s tsi da adal'ato .(3i7 ? r 00 di é b ' 65tme u me i c c t s lhe wa d s aife t ilr tt f 0) 1 2tê T. 31 vied )3 i s z ' j ' 1 ns 1 1 ' I I !ëàC iC: ,t ? ' ? ' Dockets.Justia.com 1 t et a a r ) t ipad. h otl wa dl,mtl i 2 1 I . qxpl s o v FAC T xc 3 1 on Jul 2g, 200 pl i tfsEd i K . a ht r Re c a Fln M e He l y a y 8, a n if w n Sl ug e , be c i n, 1 a e nd 4 Ca olHealy f l t pr entc e ofac i , o be al o t m s l sa d a lo he s mia st t d i r e ied he es aus ton n h f f he e ve n l t r i l r i e n ua 5 t Ei ht J c a Dit i tCou t n Cl r Co t , Nevada. Pl ntfsalege t tDef he g h udi i l s rc r i a k un y ai if l ha endant Uponor s , 6 I . RCR Pll ng & M e ha c l l c. l e sae Pl i & Ai Condto ng LLC,Unt d nc t mbi c nia, n , ntrtt umbng r iini , ie 1 Plmbi ,LLC, r onEnt m rs s,nc.andHughesW aerandSe erlp ar engage i hebusness u ng Fe gus e ie I s t w , e d nt i F ofde gni .de l pi m a f c urn diti tn m a k tng s li a d i sali h W is si ng ve o ng, nu a t i g, srbu i g, r e i , e lng, n n t lngt e r bopEx 9 7 umbi s t m , W is br sfti , ndot rpl ngm a e i l a pa t t ot bl t r uppl l ng yse r bo as it a he umbi ngs t ra s s r of hep a ewa e s y 1 s t ms o r sde ta dwe lngsi Cl r Coun y, Nevada. 0 yse f e i n i l li n a k t 11 2 J ntfs alege t ç elow br ' W i bo fti i t l aspar ofW is nai if l hat t l y ass' rs itngs nsaled t r bo 1 Plu i s tmsi r sde ta dwelng i Clr Co t Ne ad , w er def c i e due t a pr ess 2 tubng yse n e i n il li s n a k uny, v a e e tv o oc 1 r f r e t a d z nc fc to . Pl ntf ss t D ef 3 e e r d o s e i ii a i n ai if ued he endant ,i udi U NI s ncl ng TED PLUM BI NG,LLC, 1 4 de t f i ngt oiso lablt ()Pr c Libiiy;2 Stit a lt ()Bra hof rs rhe olowi he re fi iiy: 1 odu t a lt () o Libiiy;3 ec Exp es 1 w arny ( Bra h o I id W arny;()Br a h ofW a a y ofMcc an lt a ( 5 ra t; 4) e c f mple ra t 5 e c n'nt rh mbiiy; nd 6) 16 N eglgenc . Pli tfss ugh ge r la d s ca da ge i e ce sof$1 0 0000 i e a n if o t nea n pe il ma s n x s 0,00, .0. 17 3 On Se em be 15, 20 , f nd nt mo ,l r m o d t l ws i f o Cl r pt r 08 De e a Upc r nc. e ve he a u t r m a k 1 Co t DititCo toFe ea Co r puru ntot Cls AcinFanls Ac (* 2 uny sro urt d rl u t s a t he as to i e s ttCAFA'.( 1 ' # ) ) 19 4 on Oct ober 1 , 2 , anif ildaMoint Re d( 7 u rhet r t 4 008 Plitfs ie to o man #1 ) nde t G t on' ma da 20 hom e-saerç a c toves 'a t iceinay, xcpto t c-lwj rs it tt,xl l onr ry' nd v srto r'e e ins o w h uidci oc d on. 21 5 on M a oh j, 200 plitfs moint rma wa de e (9 . r 9, anif' to o e nd s nid / 41 / 22 6 on Apri 20, 2 09 Pli if fIdaMot nfrCls Ce fc t n.#l 0)T l . , antfs ie . i o a s niiai ( 1 'he 0 o o 23 cou t r a t rpe mit d a pe i o dic e l a t oug va i e t ns o , s t a he rn on n hc e fe r te rod f s ov r ' nd hr h rous x e i ns e a ig 2 Pl i if 'M o i f rCl s Ce tfe to o M a c 29, 201 (2 )b wa move u byt Co to 4 a m fs ton o a s rii a i n n r h 0 7 27 ut s / d p he ur t 25 J nua y 2.5. Og272) a r 2O1 # . 2 6 7. . A subsanlalpartoft dicove s c t i he s r onduct b) t e Dei ed ' h èndant was i r ponset s n es o 27 1pl ntfs-m o:on f ci cenii i . ai if i or ass fcaton 1 : : ( . 'l *q '; . i ' .. .. . I ' r ! j l h : . ua v . r r s r r.oz 'xe e ' 'ï.(I' ' nt' v .f ale c v g .r las s :. 2 ) () 25 a bde c ,k :. ' (. J n .- !age- (: ' 5 l 1 ' ' I ' 1 8 . Thr ugh o out t dic e y pe i , De e da s i l i De e da UNI he s ov r rod f n nt, nc ud ng f n nt TED 2 PLUMBI LLC, te de a patcp tdi numeousde ston ,ncudnga etmae ni ( NG, atn d nd riiae n r po ii s i l i n si td ne 9) ou o sa e de ii ns r vi we a i si t d t s d ofpa e o do u e t ton pr vi d by t f t t posto , e e d nd nve tga e hou ml s g s f c m n ai o de 4 t Pli if,atnde detu tvetsi a /rviua i pe to o a latfve( home,a d he antfs te d srci etng ndo s l ns cins f t e s i 5) s n 5 a tnde m e alu gi a t s i of u bi o m po n ss l c e b Pli tfsa Se lJa a oe i E1 te d t l r c l e tng pi m ng o ne t e e t d y a n i f t a w bor t s n 6 Se t g mdo,Ca ior i , nd s h dic e y oft e l whos a f av tw m s it d i s por of lf n a a oug t s ov r he xpe' t e fk i s ubm te n up t 7 Pl i tfs m o i t c riy c a s a n if ' ton o e tf l s . 8 9. Si et i ta i n oft sc s t De e a sha e ga d i num e ou m o i nc he niito hi a e, he f nd nt ve n ge n r s ton 9 ûl san a gum e sr l tn t d s o r a d c c r o c a sc rii a i The eM oto i l e i ng d r nt e a i g o i c ve y n on e ns f l s e tfc ton. s i ns nc ud d 1 aMoinfrPrlmi r Ij ncina /rTe rrr sri ngOr rfj b Dee a t Feg o 0 to o ei nay nu to ndo mpoajRetani de ied y fnd ns rusn 11 Ene ie,n a dUntdPl ng, ( 2 4 az Pli if' oi f Levet FieaSe on tmrs sIc. n ie mnbi LLC # 09 , l antfs M ton or a o l c d d 1. Ame dCo an ( 21 , c t Dee a s i l ngUNI PLUMBI LLC, os d. 2 nde mplit # 9)whih he fnd nt,ncudi TED NG, opp e 1 3 l 0. OnNove r23 2 Pli if ' l e ee t a e uia er me yp o d d b t mbe , 009, antfs Coms l loed n q tbl e d r vie y he 1 Com'a a e d t Ko - ut' 1 i vi l whofldaNRS Cha e 40Notc ( 48 . 4 t nd gre o Gpto 'a1 ndi duas ie ptr ie #3 q 1 5 On De e r3, 009 Pl ntfsfl d a Notc ofW ihdr wa ofM oto f rCl s c mbe 2 , ai if ie ie t a l in o a s 1 Cetfcain ( 2 4 Plstfsdi no se la oft Co tt fl a a nd d c litt 6 rii to # 78 . anif d t e k e ve he ur o ie n me e ompan o 1 wihdr w t c a sa l ga i i t i pl a ng . 7 t a he l s le tons n he r e di s 1 8 1 2. On De e r7, 9, ai if fl d aM oto t Volmt rl D im i st sltga i c mbe 200 Pl ntfs ie i n o t a iy s s hi ii ton 1 i ise iey( 28 ..1 Dee nt,e e tUpo r oppos t svountr dimislsekn t 9 n t ntrt # 51 * 1 fnda s xc p no , ed hi l ay s sa e ig he 20 ds sa t bewihprj c a a a r oft iat ysf san co t /31 3 31 , 9 3 imis lo t eudie nd n wad her 'ome ee d ss 4, 06. 8 31 , 20 t 21 a d321. n j 22 l 3. On J r a y 27,201 t i Co t e t r d a Or e gr n i g Pl i tf s M o i n f r am r 0, h s ur n e e n d r a tn a n if - to o 23 Vot ay Dimis l i pa t a cimis d t s lws i wih pr i i e i l di Pli tfs c a s lmt r s s a, n r, nd ls s e hi a ut t qud c , ncu ng an if' l s 2 alg tonsi t i Co lit(t49 TheCou txpe syrt ne j idcint c i r i f 4 le ai n her mpan.#3 ) re rsl eai d urs ito o onsde Motons or 25 Atorl Fees and Cost tl b) t Def ndant ,i udi UN I l reys' s ied 'he e s nel ng TED PLUM BI G.LLC. N 26 On Febr y l 20l0. NI uar 0, U TED PLUM BI G.LLC fl isM oton f Ator 8Fees N ied t i or t ney' 27 a Coss( 3 1.Pli fsfldars s o Mac î 2 )1$36 a onMao 5l 3 . TED nd t # 5 J amif ie epon e n rh . 0 ((1 3) nd rh , 009 UNI 2 t LtX BI L f e isRe l t Pamii Rtp n et i l oirfrAto n lsFzta dCo t.' 8 P JI NG. LC i d l p) o ii fs t o s o : ' tolo trc' t n ss i i s sv i s 1 : ! i 1 q Prgt 3 oï t' ' 1 i whi h UNI n c TED PLUM BI NO, LLC s ppl m e t d is M oto a i l e a Af a t f o u e ne t i n nd nc ud d n ûd vi r m 2 Stp ni A. e, q,i s tnilc mpla ewihLR 5 - 6.( 371 e ha e Le Es - n ubsa ta o inc t 41 # ) 3 1 5. Att h rng o M a 1) 201 t i Cou la r r UN I he ea i n y t, 0, h s t wa d d TED PLI M BW G 1 J 00% ofis t 4 t xa ec t a 20 o a1a t ne f e a o he c s sa or r d t r -a ngofc t t c nir a bl oss nd % f l tor ys e s nd t r o t nd de e he e t xi oss o o i m 5 t tnoa un ofa tr y fe we ei l e i t orgna txain ofc t. ha mo t to ne s e s r ncud d n he i i l a to oss 6 1 6. On M a 25,201 UNI y 0, TED PLU M BI il isam ended bilofcost confnni is NG 'ed t i l s i ng t 7 txa ec ssi tet al mou of$70,22. ( )a f t rc nfnni ta t ec t d no a bl o t n h ot a nt 1 41 #425 nd urhe o i ng h thos oss o t 8 i udeany ator ncl t neystm eoranyot i herm a rnotpr ry t bl underLR 54- t ough LR 54-15and ue ope l mxa e 1 hr 9 28U. C.j1 20-92 S. 9 1 4. 1 0 1 7. On Jme4, 0, antfsfld aM o in f rReTa ton ofCo t L 32) UNI t 201 Pl i if ie to o - xai ss #4 . TED 11 PLUM BI ildonOppoii onJ ne21 201 g441, ndPlitfsfidaRe yo J y1 201 NG ie ston u , 0 # )a anif ie pl n ul , 0 1 E44 . 2 # 7) 1 3 1 8. A h a i wa he d on A u t 1 201 a t Cou ti s d a f r a Or e on e rng s l gus 3, 0 nd he r s ue om i d r 1 Se tmbe 20,201 r-a ngLNI'D PLUMBI Sc t fom $7 1 41t S1 91l29/453. 4 pe r 0 etxi T 'E I NG' oss r 0,22. o 0, . ) 1 5 I . CO NCLUSION S OF LAS I V 1 6 1 . TheCou t xpr syrti dj idito t r l u t Dee a s Motonsf r e esl eane urs cin o ue pon he fnd nt' i or l7 Atonl sFeesard Coss. t ey' t t 1 8 2. Loc l e 5 1 o lne t f l w i g f c o st c nsd rwhe a a d ng a t r ys a Rul 4- 6 uti s he olo n a t r o o i e n hrr i to ne ' 1 fe :()t rs t oban da dt a tivoled;( t nov lya difc t oft qu si 9 e s 1 he euls tie n he moun n v 2)he et nd fiul he e tons y 20 i ol d;()t s l rquiiet pef m t l a srvcspopel ()t pr lson o ot r nv ve 3 he kil e st o ror he eg l e ie r ry; 4 he ecu i f he 21 e o n byteatr yduet t a c ptrc ofh c s'5) t rt fei fx dorc ntng t mplyme t h tone o he c e ale te ae ( whehe he e s ie o i en; , 22 ()t tmelmiai i e byt cintort crumsa es ()t e re e rputton, nd 6 he i i ttons mposd he le he ic tnc ; 7 he xpeino ,e ai a 23 a lt o t a tr y ;( t und sr biiy oft c c,i a y;( t naur a d lngt o t biiy f he to ne s S) he e ia lt he as f n 9) he t e n e h f he 2 pr f s i lr lton hi wih t oint a ( 0) wa dsi smia c s s 4 o e sona e ai s p t he le ; nd 1 -a r n i lr a e 25 LJ I - TED PLUM BI ' N NG, LLC s it Af i vis of St ubm ted fda t ephani A. Lee, Es and e q. i 26 The r Pa ke 11 Es w ih is M o i n f r Ator e s Fc a . Cos s a Re ) t Pli tf s odo e r r 1, q. t t to o t n y' es nd t , nd pl, o a n if 27 !Res pons t is li i f Ator l' Fees and Cos s whih s t ntall compled wih t ' e o t voton or t ne 's t. c ubs a i l' i t he 1 I 2 4rxliens so Lot l l 5 1 8 ; t u rl nt f - l Rue 4- 6. a 1 : ! ' . !Cgt u (: àtr': ' M 1 ' 1 4. l d ume ss bmi e wihUNI PLUM Bm G, n oc nt u t d t l TED LLC' M ovi a Re yPa r , S ng nd pl pe s 2 UNI TED PLUM BI LLC' i oie pr vet a t lw $11 bilda h ry rt o $1 pe hol NGS S nv c s o h t he a 144 le n ou l ae f 35 r tr 3 f p t rtme $1 pe hou f a s it tme, nd $ pe hourf pa aeg lt . Cou e f r or arne i , 25 r r or socae i a 60 r or r l a hne ns l o 4 U NI TED PLUM BI ,LLC a s a t ss t t n NG l o te t o he umbe of hou s t 1 w 511 s n on I NI r r he a 1: pe t J TED 5 PLUM BI , NG LLC' d f ns i t i a to S e e e n h s c i n. 6 Pl i lf h e ha t e op t t t r viw a r s d t t e d nc UNI a ntf s av d h poruniy o e e nd e pon o he vi e e TED 7 PLUM BI G,LLC s i e i s ppo to is M o i n f Atom e s Fe s a Coss i l i t N ubm t d n u r f t to or t y' e nd l t, nc ud ng he 8 Afi visofc mslal i c sf txa l a n txa ec t i ure Plitfsdi no o jc fda t ot e ld nvoie ora be nd on-a bl ossnc rd. anif d t bet 9 t t ho r ybilngr t of ns l n t nunb rof ur b le i de en ngI NI o he u l li a e cou e , or he l e ho s ild n f di J TED PLUM BI , NG 1 LLC,n t r m ona e s a ne es iyoft f e , t xa ec t , d t xa e c s si c r e by 0 or he e s bl ne s nd c st he e s non-a bl os s an a bl o t n u r d 11 L NI T TBD PLUM BI , NG LLC , 12 6. The Courtgener l fndst tt bul oft at ney' f a non-axabl cos s aly i ha he k he tor s ees nd t e t 13 i ured by t D ef ndant i udi LT TED PLUM BI ,LLC,wilhave val i s equent nc r he e s, ncl ng NI NG l ue n ubs 1 pr ee ngsa dma no bet s jc o a atre 'e sa r i t sltg to 4 oc di n y t he ubet f n ton ys fe wad n hi iiain. 1 5 An a a d ofs epori n o t r que t d a t r ys f e a non-a bl c s s w r om to f he e se to ne ' e s nd t xa e o t , 1 i i i g e rs f e a ta le pe e f ral nd ng nu e ousouto s a ede ii nsn i e b 6 nc ud n xpe t' e s nd r ve x ns s o te i m r f t t posto otc d y 1 Pl i if , sr a on bl a a o i t i t sm a trbe a eoft rs t t h De e n s i l di 7 a ntf s i e s a e nd ppr pra e n hi te c us he ik ha t e f nda t , nc u ng 1 UNI 8 TED PLL M BI G, J N LLC, il nc rd i a i a t n ys f e i de e ngi n i a i s e i ut r w l i u uplo tve tor e ' e s n f ndi de tc l s u s nf u e 1 pr c d ng i l n b not i ie t apo e ta r qu tf c a sce t i a i n.M or i po tnty, 9 o ee i s no udi g, ut lm t d o, t n i l e es or l s ri c to f e m ra l 2 a t ne s f eswe ei un'd b Pl i if our de i i n t s e c a sa to s a u ,on yt l t ri t 0 tor y ' e r nc e y a ntf s n c so o e k l s c i n t t s l o a e n he 21 casew ihdr t i M oton f Cl Ce tcaton. t au' he r i or ass dii i 2 2 8. The Cour t n t tr ue tng a de i ai off e i lne by lne da e- y- a e t' ds ha eq si i lne ton e s n i - i , t b d t 23 f r t a d o r q rngl l Y D PLU M BI LLC t pr uc r da t dbilngi c s woul e ie o ma , n / r e uii W l NG, o od e e c e li nvoi e a dr qu r 24 I TED PLU M BI G,LLC t unncces rl i m or ator sf JNI N o sa iy ncur e t ney' ees. 25 9. A sa r ul oft f t ts r Def es t he ac: ha eve al endant ar r s e equesi ator .sf and cost, lng t nel- ees s l 26 tl Coul fndst ani gr sr i aw a di atona 'sf and non-axabl cos si appr i eand le - i hat n- os ulng r ng t el' ees t t e t s oprat 27 f dst ta a d of12 oft at R l' f e a non î xa e c t i un'd b) e c oft M o ng m ha n uur 5 he ton e ' e s nd - a bl oss nc e ' a h hhe vi s 28 D z e a s i l i g t NI -' PLU I BI G. . i a r a o bi a r o a t r l' f r a no . f nd nt . nc ud n . '., T 1FD N N LIC. s c s na e wa d f to nr 'F c s nd nI . i l t i l ! ! Ja;t ' oJ ' .. z ' ! : i 1 t axabl cos s i udi expe s f and tavelexpe e t , ncl ng rt' ees r nses t atend t num er de ii of o t he ous postons 2 De e a Upo r l ' pe s nne no i e b t e Pl i tfsi M i ea ols M im e ot f nd nt no , nc.s r o l tc d y h a n if n nn p i , r s a. 3 10. 4 TheM ovi Def ng endant ha r s ve equest ator sf non-a e coss,and ed t ney' ees, t xabl t txa ec t i ac l tv a un ofsi ty mor t n $1milon. An a r o 1 5 or2 $ o a bl oss n olecie mo t lgh l e ha li wa d f / , 0% , f 5 a t ne s f e a non t xa e c t i u r d by I TED PLUM BI G,LLC a e c oft o h r tor y' e s nd -a bl oss nc r e JNI N nd a h he t e 6 M ovi Def ndant i r onabi undert cic sancesand fndi ass f t above,asr ng e s s eas e he r um t i ngs et orh eduoi ng 7 t f sr qu t d by e c D e e n pr vi sf a r a o bl c l c i f ea a d o a pr xi a e y he ee e ese a h f nda t o de or e s na e ole tve e w r f p o m t l 8 $ ,00.Thi a r ofat ne sf e a no ix bl c t i s cfc lye t r da is t name 2000 s wad tor y' e s nd n- a e oss s pe iial n e e gal the t d 9 Pl ntfs,and notc ai if ounself t Pl ntfs. or he ai if 10 11. The Com' t t i i r onabl a appr i e t awar UNI t inds hat t s eas e nd oprat o d TED PLUM Bm G , 11 LLC istxa ec ssi t ea n o $1 9112 ass tf t i LNI t a bl o t n h mou t f 0, .9, e orh n T TED PLUM BI LLC' Bil NG, S ls 1 o Cot ontl heena teCou tsOr r(453,Thi a r i alos ci lye ee a anst 2 f ss ie ri nd h r' de # ) s wad s s pe ikal ntrd g i the 1 n m e Pl i tfs a d n c m s l ort Pl i if . 3 a d a n if , n ot ol e f he a ntfs 1 4 1 2. INI PLUM BI LLC i e ildt pr-udgme tntrs.Ho ve, TED J TED NG, snotntte o ej n i eet we rUNI 1 PLUM BI LLC i e tte t po tj gme tit rs fo t daeofe ty o t efn lJ dg n of 5 NG, s nild o s-ud n n e et r m he t n r f h ia u me t 1 DimislwihPrj die J nuay2 201 unit a r i stsidi fl. 6 s sa t eu c , a r 7, 0, tlhe wad s aite n ul 1 7 1 1. O RDER 1 1 8 I I HEREBY ORDERED , ADJ DGED mz DECREED t a De e n UNI T S U d h t f nda t TED 1 PLUMBI LLC' M oinf Atone sFe a Cot g )i CRANTED i p r a DENI 9 NG, S to or l r y' es nd ss #351 s J n at nd ED 20 i r.L IYD PLUM BI i a r e istxa l c t i bea o tof os 129. e tfht % l npa t m ' I NG s wa d d ! a be oss nt m un sl gl . , -ll zo on 21 o hsa tm e f e a ot rc t i t ea un of$ 679.7 f at t la r ef$ 5 .6. f to ys e s nd he oss n h mo t 33, 8 or o a wad 49.91 1 22 I I FURTHER ORDERED ,ADJ DGED AN D DECREED t t M oton f Ator s T S U hat he i or t ney' 23 Fe sa Cossi GRANTED a t pos-udgme i r s,r t d t o e r o-hetna j me t e nd t s s o ti ntme e t fom he a e f nty tt ' )udg n i 24 1o Jnuay2 201 ,a t fd rludg n rt thewe kl a rgeo t ly rmauiyTraur . n a r 7, 0 the e ea j me t ae t e y vea f he -ea trt e s y . 2 lilfrh wekbfr Jna '72 l i.1à T edi rtfr otu g nitrsi u t . yed o te e eoe aun 2-O Os3?. h al ae o p sc dmetneets ni 5 z y j l 2 it a r i s tsi ca acal r t o . 38 6 he wa d s aifel t iiy ae f 00 72% (, 31d v d d b . 65 tme t tt l wad:. i 5. 00 i i e ) 3 i s he o a a r )untl 17 Ipad. 1 ' i 1 1 t 8 l ! r ! ' a -. ' . Z np:'v v .c ir r ea'. ' rca z ' ! 2(lC''25 h ?'u' f ce alcs r s goîr k s g l .' / 1t J hF :. k FagS t i1 ' ' ' 7- ' ' ' l l D a ed Novem ber29.2010 t 2 3 o a eRo , J ne norbl C.o s 4 Unied St es i ' Cour t at ct t 5 6 RESPECTFU LLY SUBM I TTED BY 7 PARX ER NELSON & A SSOCI ATES, CHTD. 8 9 //t/ pàceakrH1 s fltfr rql t 1 THEODOV lP Courq11ES 1 2 6 Pr essonal 4 0 of ARKER Suie 200 1, Q. t 10 LasVegas N V 89128 , 1 Co co m s lf rD e e mz 2 - t e o f nd t Unied Pl bi LLC. t um ng, 13 14 15 1 6 1 7 1 s 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 n 71 1 , > - - 8t Ja c' :L ' - h; '