Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al, No. 2:2008cv01223 - Document 468 (D. Nev. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 350 Motion for Attorney Fees and Costs. Ferguson is awarded 100% of its taxable costs in the amount of $14,554.77; one-fifth (20%) of its attorneys fees and other costs in the amount of $66,731.67 for a total award of $81,286.44. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)
Download PDF
1 2 3 4 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COUR T CT 5 DI STRI OF NEVADA CT 6 EDW I K.SLAUGHTER, .a. N et 1 7 ) ) 2: - v 22 RCJ GW F 08 c -1 3- - Pli if, antfs ) 8 ) vs . ) 9 ) UPONOR,I C. M ime o aCor rton;e.a. ) N a l s t po ai t l l 0 ) De e nt , f nda s ) ORDER l1 1 2 Pe ng be o et Co t r De e an sUniedPll bi , ndi f r he ur a e f nd t t t ng LLC a Fe gu o Entr ie , m nd r s n e prs s 1 I .sMoto frAto y' Fee a Coss(/50 ,Pli if Opposto (/ )a Dee a s 3 nc' in o tme s s nd t 83 ) antfs iin /363, nd fnd nt' 1 Re y (/ 0) Dee ns Moi wa fldbaedu n t Cour' Or rds si t cae 4 pl /37 . fnda t' ton s ie s po he ts de imisng he s 1 (/ a i t c i t prte t fl b if o t is so fesa cc s A h rngwa hed 5 /349) nd nsnttng he is o ie re s n hc s ue f e nd st. eai s l 1 on M a 1 2 0 r a di t m oto fl d,a t g d c us a pe rngt r f e Fort r a o 6 y 0, 01 eg r ng he i ns i e r oo a e p a i he e or . d be e s ns 1 gi n he e n, he M oton i Gr n e i pa ta d De e i pa t 7 ve r i t i s a td n r n ni d n r . 1 8 1 FI DI G S OF FACT . N N 1 1 9 . On J y 28, ul 2008 PiitfsEd n K. a htr Re c aFlnn, e He l ya d Ca o) , an if wi Slug e , be c i M l a e n r 20 He l y f l d t pr s n ca e o a to o b ha fo t m s l s a a l he ssm ia l a e ie he c c t us f c i n, n e l f he e ve nd 1 ot r i l ry 21 st t d, n t e D iti tCour f r Cl r Cot y, r da De e a s Upo r i . iua e i h s fc t o a k mt N va . f nd nt no , nc ; 2: 1 Upono N o t A m e i a, nc. U p rCo . RCR Pl m bi & M e ha lc , n ; r rh rc I ' ono p ; , u ng c zi al l c. 23 l e saePlmbi & Ai Cond toni LLC;Unie Pi nbi LLC; r s n ntrtt u ng r ii ng, t d ur ng, Fe gu o 24 Enl prs l ;HughesB? er& SewerLP'ars HD Suppl Cons r i Suppl er i es, nc, at S ll y t uclon y 2 5 Li ie Pa L r hi a e a l ge t b e g d i t busne sofd i ng. ve opi g, m t d rne s p r le d o e nga e l he i s è esgni de i n 26 ma a trng diriutng, rl ng sli .a i tli t BrrboPEX pi ng , nufcu i . srb i mal . elng nd nsalng he is mi umbi Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al Doc. 468 J Pg 1f5 ac ot l 1 ' 1 i 1 . Dockets.Justia.com s t m,W is br s fti ,a d o h rplmbi mae il a pa t -hepo a l wa e ysc r bo a s itngs n t e u ng t ras s r oit t b e tr s pl s tm sofrsdc i d li i Clr Co t Ne d up y yse e i ntal welngs n ak uny, va a. Pl n ii a l e t ta 1oft W is b a sfti i t le aspa t t po a l wa e ai tfk leg d ha 1 he r bo r s it ngs nsa l d r of ht t b e t r s t m soft e r s de i ldweli s i Cl r Cu y N e daa e de ec i a t r s tof ys e h e i nta lng n a k unt , va r f tve s he e ul ac m ia r a tc l he c l e cim mown a d zi iia in.Plitfsa es n t e t f l wi s e ncfc to an if r uig md r he olo ng t oi ofla lt ()podu tla iiy;( src la lt ()b e c ofc es he res ibiiy: 1 r c iblt 2) titibiiy; 3 r ah xprs warny;( be c ofi idwarnt ( bra hofwarnt o mec ntbiiy; nd ra t 4) ra h mpie ra y;5) e c ra y f rha a lt a ( )ne lge e. 6 g i nc On Se t m be 1 200 De e nt r m o t l ws tfom s a e c r t f d r lc ur p e r 5, 8, f uda s e ved he a ui r t t ou t o e e a o t pt s ntt t Cls Aci Far sAc (t FA' o t e g o l ua o he a s ton ines t ' r CA. ' n h r undst tt a u i ) ha be mo nt n co r r ye e ds$5, 0,00,he ei di r iyofctze hi bewe n Pli if a ntove s xc e 00 0 t r s vest ii ns p t e antfs nd m or t n o prm a y De e n , nd t r a e c am ed t b m o e t 1 cl s e ha ne i r f nda t a he e r l i o e r h= 00 a s m em ber s. OnOco r1 20 ,Pli if fldaMoi t Re nd( 7 t e t ç n tr tbe 4, 08 antfs ie ton o ma #1 ) md r he c daoy ma ho -tt' tl a c nto ry'a dt icei r ' xc pi t CAFA jtidci mesae' toc l o rves ' n t srtonay'e e tons o , d trs iton. OnMac 5 200 Plitfsmoi t rma wa de ed(/4) rh , 9, anif ton o e nd s ni /9 . OnAprl2 20 Plitfsmo dt cri teca s( 1 ) Dee a srs ed i O, 09, anif ve o e tf h ls #1 0 . fnd nt epond y wih mo insf rla t c uc dic ve ( 18a /1 9)whihwe era t da d t t to o e ve o ond t s o or#1 nd / 1 c r n e n he h aigo cascriiainwa stfrNove r23,2009( 4 .Att rqueto e rn n ls etfcto s e o mbe #l 4) he e s f De e nt U po , n a RCR Pl m bi & M e ha c l I , l she rng w a f nda s nor l c. nd u ng c ni a , nc tl a i i s 21 c tnue t M ac 29, 1 (/ )a t nmove u b t Co toJnuay25 201 oni d o rh 20 0 /227 nd he d p y he urt a r , 0 ( 2) #27 . 7* D - The prm a y go lml f c oft dico r c ndu t b ' f nda t w a i r s ns t i r a d o us he s ve y o c ed ) De e n s s n e po e o Pl ntf sm ozon f Cl sCerii i ai if i or as ticaton. Dc e a s a t nd ! de s to of r o m os i o e e bl -a lofD e e a t ; f nd nt te 5 po ii ns pe s ns t m wl dg a e l f nd n s s he ul : nun c o cc s tonsofw i s e i cl ng t na e pl i if :i p t d 5 c d el z r us l pu ii t s s n udi he m d antfs ns ec e ne Pagc 2 of6 ; ho e viu la 3ho d tu tvey;atnda e u t si o mae il i m s s a nd mes esr c i l te gred pon e tng f tra s n Caior a s h dic r oft e r whos a fda twa s lf ni ; oug t s ovey he xpe t e fi vi s ubmi d i s po t ue n up r of Pi l if m oton t Ce tf Cl s i l di g a pca i t e M a it a e' Or rt t a ntf s i o riy a s nc u n p lng h g sr t s de o he D iti tCo q a tl d a M o i f aTe r y Resr i ng Or ra orPr lm i a ' src ur nd ie ton or mpo m' ta ni de nd/ ei n t y Ij to o tl c ntmporme sCha e 40pr-ii tonpr e i bengfld nuncin n le o e l ou ptr cl gai ocedngs i ie t duri t cl dieovc y perod. ng he ass s r i 0nNo m b r23 200 Pli if'c t e ee td a e tbl r med pr vi e b t e ve e , 9, antfs oms l lce n quia e e y o d d y h Cour a a e dt S to 'ali v d l whofi ac ptr40notc ( 48 . t nd gr e o t - ut l ndii uas op ' ied ha e i e #3 ) 0n De m be 3, ce r 2009 Pl i if , t tnotc t t pu a i c a sm e be s w i e , antf s wihou i e o he t tve l s m r , t w hdr t f M otont Ce tf Cls (/ 8) her i o rty a s /27 . ' On De e be 7, 9, a n ir fl d a M oton f rV o ur a ' Di m i s lo t e tr c m r 200 Pl i tf s ie i o l l z s s a f he n ie t y a to ( ) A1Dee nse e Upon o s dt svolnt dimis l e kn cin #285 . 1 fnda t xcpt or ppo e hi u my s sa s e ig 13 t dimis lobewihprj iea f ral wado t i al re fe a c ss he s sa t t eudc nd o ra r f her torzys e s nd ot (/ 4, 6 31 ,319 3 a 321 . /31 31 , 8 , 20, nd ) 15 On J nua y 5, 0, he r n w a he d o Pl i tf sm o i n t vo u a iy di mi s a r 201 a a i g s l n a n if to o l nt rl s s wihou prj diewh ri t Co tsaedt tiwo do l dimiswihprj iea t t eu c een he ur tt ha t ul ny s s t eudc nd t tti is o at ne sfe a c sswoudbers re frfrle he rng( l ha hs sue f tor y es nd ot l e cv d o lt r ai #344 md n 18 3 ) OnJnua' 27, 0,hsmatrwa dimisdwihpcudie(.49 . 45 . a l 201 ti te s s se t rj c #3 ) y 19 OnFe ray1 , 01 , RGUS ildamoinf ra of y fe a dc ss/3 0 b u r 0 2 0 FE ON ic to o t ri s e s n ot 5 ) l e s edng.293202. i a tr y f e sa b ec ssund LR 54- t oug 5 1 i t e e l $ , 00 n to ne s e s txa l o t er 1 hr h 4- 5 n h 21 a t $ , .6a ohe c sst rLR 5 1 i t a t of$41, 3 momt 21551 1 nd t r o t mde 4- 6 n he momt 456.3. FERGUSON i ntfe t tisbilngrt we e$1 pe hourf pa t r ;$1 pe de i d ha t li aes r 60 r or rne s 40 r 7* J - ho rf as o ae l $ pe h f rpaalg l whih wasi r a e du i ltgai u or s cit s md 75 r our o r e as c nc e s d rng ii ton t $1 5 pe ho f rp nne s $1 pe ho t f a s c aesa $ pe ho f r o 8 r ur o a r ; 60 r tr or s o i t nd 95 r ur o p z l g l. Plitfsfld ar s ns o M i c 1 20l (/ 3)a FERGUSON tld a a a e as an if e e po e n z h , 0 /36 nd r ie r pl' M a c 11 20l0( 70à e lon r h , #3 . Page 3 of6 Att he rng o M a 1 ,201 ,t sCo ta r c FERGUSON 1 % o istxa l he ai n y 0 0 hi ur wa d d 00 f t a b e c ssa 20% ofala t ne f e a ote c t al o de e t r -a ngofc sst o t nd l tor ys e s nd h r oss rd r r d he e txi ot o c nfr t tno a o ofa r y f e we e i l d i t o i i lt xa i n o c t . o im ha m unt to ne s c s r ncude n he r g na a to f oss On M a 21 201 FERGU SON fl d isn e e bilofco t c im i ist x bl y , 0, ie t m nd d l s s ontr ng t a a e c t i t et aln un o $21551 1 (W1 a f rhe c nfr ngt a t os c t do oss n h ot mo t f , .6 # 8) nd ' t r o imi h t h e oss u noti ude any ator ncl t neystm e orany ot r trnotpr r y t i her nate ope l axabl underLR 54-1 e t r ghLR 5 1 a 22U. C.j 1 20 1 24. l ou z 4- 5 nd S. 9 -9 OnJ 4,201 Pl nif fldaM oi frReTa tonofCoss( ) FERGUSON une 0, aitfs it ton o - xai t #432 . flda Oppostoro Jme22, 0(/ 3)a PlitfsfldaRe l ( 47)o J l 1, ie n ii l n t 201 /44 nd anif ie py #4 n uy 201 A H e r ng w a he d on Aug t1 201 a l t Co -i s d a f r a Or ro 0. ai s l us 3, 0 rd he m t s ue o m l de n Se t mb r20, 0r -a ngFERGUSON' c ssfom $ ,51l t $1 55 77. pe e 201 e txi S o t r 2l5 ,6 o 4, 4. (/ 3) /45 . I . CO NCLUSI S OF LAW l ON 1 3 Tli Cou teane jtidito o rtedeemiainofatr e fe a c t. ls r rti d trs cin ve h tr n to to n ys e s nd oss FERGU SON ' M o i f Ator y Fe a Co t wa tm e y a c pled wih t S ton or t ne s es nd s s s i l nd om i t he 1 6 r r m ent ofLR 54equie s 16. Thehoury b li rt sc r edb FERGUSON' c ms lm' r a ona ef rt l ilng ae ha g y S ot e e e s bl o he c r m u kt a f t s r i e pr vi d a s i r t w e e uo o o n riy nd or he e v c s o de nd a d a es r t ppos d a e e sve or e s xc s i o he wie i ppr pr a e t r s na o i t . Thet xa e a ot rco t s b i td by FERGU SON a e s ppo t d by t a r pra e a bi nd he s s u m te r u re he pp o it d u ntto a r urdund rLR 5 1 ai h veben a t lya ne es rl oc me ain s eq ie e 4-@) rd a e cuai nd c saiy pr ded and m adc, od F ERGUSON i urelal ne sf e i t a nto $ 20 00. a b eco t i t nc r : tor y c s n he mou f 292, 2. , xa l ss n he t a o of$1 5 77 a o he c t i t a o ofT . 33. m unt 4, 54. nd t r os s n he m unt 41456. Ar a r o a t ne s f e a c t i r s na e i t sc s i ig o t du i a i . wa d f tor y e s nd oss s ca o bl n hi a e n i ht f he plc tvc 1 - na-reoftz ef ol expenced i tzscaszand î bcexpcndcd ilf ur ltgaton Pl ntfl. tu ie f l l n ii o r ut e ii i ai ii s P g 4o ( ac : ' - 1 1 1 c ns l vesae t bepe ngr g r ngt s meis ss tf t i ttsma tr ou e ha tt d o ndi e a di he a s ue e orh n ii te 2 r g r i t W is fti si a d f e e tf r m . Spe ii a l t ne d f rFERGUSON e a d ng he r bo itng n i f r n o u c fc ly, he e o 3 t i si a e a dc e a c a sa to i t s m a t ra d i s e n pe ng a d t be o nve tg t nd f nd l s c i n n hi tc n n ubs que t ndi n o 4 fl d ltga i ie ii ton. 5 7. FEROU SON ha s s a ta l co ple w ih t e r quie e t ofLR 54 1 a r q rng s ub t n i ly m i d t h e r m n s - 6 nd e uii 6 a lne- lne and da e- dat br ldown off a coss woul notbe pr i by-i t by- e eat ees nd t d oductve and i 7 wo dc us t pa te t i u addto lf e a c t . ul a e he ris o nc r ii na e s nd oss 8 8. The Co tGnd t ta l wa d o 1 0% oft xa e c t pu s ntt LR 5 1t ou h LR ur s ha r a r f 0 a bl os s r ua o 4- hr g 9 5 1 i r a on bl al a o i t 4- 5 s e s a e ld ppr pra e. 10 9. TheCo ti t ta i gr sa r of)5( ur Inds ha n n- os wad / 20%)o al ysfe a ohe c t f tome e s nd t r oss . 11 s ugh p s ntt LR 54- 6i a pr ra ea r a on bl . o t ur ua o 1 s p op it nd e s a e 1 l 2 0. TheCo t' t tpeudgme titrs i nota r dbu pos-udg nti cet ur inds ha rj i n neets wade t tj me ntrs 1 3 s dbca r dfo tl daeo t e tyo t j houl wade rm le t f he nr fhe udgme ta t fdca rt n t he e rl ae. 14 l5 16 1 7 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 // // 26 // // Jpge 5 ol6 '- I 1 l , 1 IH . O RDER 2 I I H EREBY ORDERED,ADJUD GED, nd DECREED t tFER GUSON ' M o i T S a ha S ton 3 frAtone sFe sa Coss(/ i GRANTED i pala DENI i pat FERGUSON i o tr y' e nd t / 350) s n l nd ED n r. s 4 a r d1 % ofistxa ec t i t a u u $1 5 4, o -it ( %)ofisat n ys wade 00 t a bl oss n he mo nt f 4,5 77; neffh 20 t tore 5 f e al ot rc t i t a mtof$ 7 .7 f rat t la r of$812864 e s rd he oss n he mot 66,316 o o a wa d , .4 6 I I FURTHER ORDERED,ADJUDGED ,ard D ECREED t t M oton f T S z hat he i or 7 Atore sFe san Cossi GRANTED a t pos-udg nti ceta t fdea j gme rt t n y' e d t s s o tj me ntr s t he e rlud nt ae 8 (hewe l a r geo t ly rco tntmaurt Tr a ur yil f t we k beor J n r t edy ve a f he -ea nsa t iy e s y ed or he e f e a ua y 9 27 201 i . %. Thedal lt f rpos-ud n i eeti . 002 , 0,s 31 1 iy 'e o tj gme tntrs s 000 49315( 0 dvd dby a $.031 iie 1 3 tme t t t la r o $0. pe da , ntl i 0 65 i s he o a wa d) r 6907 r y) u ipad; 11 D ATED : Novem ber29,2010 12 13 14 ' Honor e Rob u .J abl - ones Unied St es ' 'tJudge t at c 15 16 RESPECTFULLY SUBM I TTED BY 17 OLSON , CANNON ,GORM LEY 18 & D ESRUI SSEAI X J 19 By:s) '* ..Ctpe // ,6 zsy s 20 Phii S. r on, q. lp Ge s Es 9950 W .Cheyenne Avenue 21 LasVegas,N evada 89129 Atonz y f De c a t t e or f nd n s 22 Un t d Pl m bi LLC a ie u ng, nd Fer on Ent prses l gus er i , nc. 23 . 24 25 l I 2 6 't lhssfd r ' cv .ozee ss l 5 0i 01 / ht / ww'e c' e rr g N' iae . l / 0 25 p:T . ils e , / r r o Q ' Pa 6of6 gc ' 1 I l 1 l ) j l @ (