Sahara Inn, LLC v. XL Specialty Insurance Co. et al, No. 1:2008cv00616 - Document 10 (S.D. Miss. 2008)
Court Description: ORDER denying 7 Motion to Remand. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 12/8/2008. (YSM)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Sahara Inn, LLC v. XL Specialty Insurance Co. et al ! Doc. 10 " # " $ " ! % % & $ '() " ! " +! ,01 " * 2( 3 ! 6 5 4 & - , 9 * ( " ! ! + ! ! + , ./* 4 - !" ( #$ " - 3-4- %' %&&' ++ 34 - - /0 +1 + , , + - + ,-).+' +! ! - 5 - * #$ %&&'( ) + ! $ ! " 4 4 * +! ,) 5 +! , 8 8 4 - ! ) !7 ) ./ 7 3 "- 01 ) + + , : " ! 4 4 ! ! ! + ! ! 4 4 ! 4 4 6 -1- Dockets.Justia.com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
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
