Smith et al v. Mississippi Security Police, Inc. et al, No. 1:2008cv00370 - Document 88 (S.D. Miss. 2010)

Court Description: ORDER denying Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment 56 . Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 7/6/2010. (YSM)
Download PDF
Smith et al v. Mississippi Security Police, Inc. et al Doc. 88 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION WENDY JANE SMITH, individually and as Mother and Natural Guardian of JM NMB, JM NMB § § § § v. § § MISSISSIPPI SECURITY POLICE, INC., § et al. § ! " #$ !%&' (( " .' "( " ' ) *( !5 9 ' ( "":+ " 4 4 + " 4' ( / 78 " ( "' 9 "" '( " " *- ' ' '4 4 " 12 ' - ) " <<' 2== ' ( ! +( * " + - !" .0 ' 6- 4 +, /( " + DEFENDANTS ' "* " + #$ ! /%&' Civil Action No. 1:08cv " .3 - / ", ) PLAINTIFFS *" ! "" ; + > ! / >" "" !"-5 ( "- "' '4 " ' ? @@666A) / "" * "( 9 ) - ( ' *"* '4 - 3: ' -1- Dockets.Justia.com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