Shook et al v. Winn-Dixie Montgomery Leasing, LLC et al, No. 1:2008cv00330 - Document 86 (S.D. Miss. 2009)
Court Description: ORDER denying 43 Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; granting 55 Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment.Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 12/4/2009. (Brown, T.)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Shook et al v. Winn-Dixie Montgomery Leasing, LLC et al Doc. 86 !! $ " % ' "# & ' & ( &# ( !"#$% & &# ' 1223* ) ( & 4 )* * +,* * -. ( ' ) ( 5 ' ) & ' 4 6 (5 * / 5 & & * ' 5 %7 & ? 5 5 ? & ( 6 )9 & : ) & & 6 /< 5 (( * = ) 5 ' & ' 5 ( & + 7 & 8 ) ' #) 9 7 7 & ( & /;) 1! 122> ' ' ' & & +* / ' 5 ( 5 * & ' 5 95 5& & & 5 & $0 * + --#$% ' 7 / (( 7& ( & 4 & (( * / Dockets.Justia.com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
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
