Palmer et al v. Ocean Club at Biloxi, Ltd. et al, No. 1:2008cv00236 - Document 30 (S.D. Miss. 2008)
Court Description: ORDER denying 7 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Pursuant to Rule 12(b) or Alternatively for Summary Judgment Pursuant to Rule 56. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 10/21/2008. (YSM)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Palmer et al v. Ocean Club at Biloxi, Ltd. et al Doc. 30 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION GRADY RAY PALMER, JR., et al § § § § § § v. OCEAN CLUB AT BILOXI, LTD., et al PLAINTIFFS Civil Action No. 1:08cv236 DEFENDANTS ORDER AND REASONS DENYING DEFENDANT’S MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO RULE 12(b) OR ALTERNATIVELY FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULE 56 ! ! # $ " %& . " '(# 6 + )*%+( 12# " )7 " , ! " , " " "/ # ! ! , ) )44# %&9$. !,' # , - 34# *445# " " " "+ # " # " " ,$ ,:! ! + < # $ " %& ,$ / 9. ; 7# *445# 0 +'(# = 9! 0 0 &, '(# )1 / "! " 6 + )3 " "+ " 9 + + # 8 " 6 " 0 " ! - / "0 + " -# 9 9 . >) 4)# $ ) ! " %&= 9!'(# ". = "- " 1 -1- Dockets.Justia.com $ % 0 & ' %&,0 + " 6 6 E %& +#' - 9$. !, < " " " " / <# +E , 6 -C " -8 " 2 , "6 B " " " 0 < # - "F < )*%+(%)(# )*%+(%*(# )*%+(%2(# " BE "0 8 0" @ + "# " 6 "6 " " 9$. !, ,0 #6 # + 9$. !, C # " #+ 0 E # - 0 6 12# ! 6 " * 0 # 9$. !,# " 0 -# " 6 " 0 " " 6 @ 6 6 7# *441# + "& ! ,0 " 66 E '(" 0 "- +E '( '( " " & 0 9$. !, "? 60 >) 43% (%)(%,(A 6" @ >) 43% (%)(% ( ">) 4 # " " B@ >) 43% (A 6@ >) 43%+(# ,0 " -6 " + 0 0 " +C ,0 " 0 "0 0 0 ,0 A 6& 6 + " 0' @ >) 43%"(%)(A 6-" - 0 " @ >) 43%"(%*(A " 6 + >) 43% (%*(%,( 0 6 - 0 -" # " " 6 A . 66 8 8 66 6 D# 3 -2- 0 " " 66 6 %&$ ""- , " # " 0 " '(# " -6 + " 0 + E 6 " 6 " -6 , # " ! C $ ""- # - " &" 0 " 9$. !, 9 - "" 6 #' " E 99 !9. , 9 $ & 6 " ". - 06 0 6 +- + - #6 " 6 0 )7 5( &" 0 6 " ' + 6 6 *"75# 77 %1 6 6 %&9$. !,'( 9$. !, + #1 5 , # "" + ! C " C ..9 : -' , 6 6 " H D %: ! 9 " , 0 ) # *441(% 354, *" )32)# )32* %! )7 ((A +" ". +- @ 9$. !, 6 , 6 " ! #1 5 # 15D $ %& *" *?4D D25# *441 " # # 77A *")*55# )*7* %3" )7 5(% 0 0 0" " ' 6 #: G $ )753517# $ &6 " 6 & 6 + 6 6 6 -3- - 6 6 - '( 0 " 6 6 0 " # 6 " >) 43% ( # *441 G $ )753517# 6 " " 6 8 0 0 +E , )1 " @ . >) 47A HD , 6 , " # *441 G $ )753517# ! "" $ C . +E " 6 HD / " )*%+(%)( , " E " " )*%+(%)( " *" D4D# D)* %1 6 0 8 0 E " " < - C " "# )*%+(%2( " # 6 +E ' " #& 8 C G # 6 " 6 + 8 8 " # " 6 6 0 )75)( G " 6 " )*%+(%)( C 6 ( $ # 2D1 0 # 0 C@ 6 " 6 " 0 6 E " " ' D)3 6 6 " 6 %1 " 0# " 0# - - " " ' " " C " " # 2)3 ) )754( 9 & # 0 E - < -4- ' *" 14 # 1)) # 2D1 *" D)D G # " < " E E # " 8 0 8E " # 6 6 6 8 " 6 6 + " ( +E " " % " " " " 0 + " < 6 "" 8 0 0 " " C D)1 -# & " +E E " " ' )774(% % 0 - "( 2D1 *" " 8 6 ! *" 6 " " # " 6 # 0 " (I+ " 3 0 " 6 6 6 " + 0 C - "6 < 3 - E "0 8" 8 #+ " 9$. !, * # D)1 " 6 6 )*%+(%)( 6 ? " " )*%+(%2(% 12 % " " ! ( $ # 2D1 ' " 0 0 6 0 ' # )75)(( . 6 "+- " C 0 C " " 6 *")1*1# )13) %)) D4D# D)* %1 " " " 7)7 + " E " 0 " + " + " " 6 " " 6 6 9$. !, 0 " -5- $ ""- , " " " 0 )*%+(%)( 66 6 " 0 0 " , &" + " < 6 6 " , 6 6 " # " % "6 " + " %&. " 0# + < C " " +- 8 6 C " ' " " # # " 6 " ' < &0 # +- " & +" '( 66 'D & " + 6 ' # )75*(% " , " &" 6 8 " ' # " 6 8 " . " 9$. !,# & # &0 " " E # 0& ! 0 " *" * # 3D %)) 6 E E 9$. !, 6 ' +8 + " -" " " 6 G -" # 27* " " # + " C 6 +E 9$. !,# ! 8 0 + 6 D 6 C '( 4 " E " " ! 8 + 6 2 9 66 6 # " + " " 0 " C +E E " 0 " &" 6 ' &0 ' " , 6 1 # " " " +" 0 " " - E "0 )*%+(%2( " " $ %& # 15D *" )*55 %3" )7 5(A #: *?4D D25# *441 G $ )753517 %: ! 9 " , 0 ) # *441(A+ ( $ , #3 D . 66 *1) %: ! = )7 D(A , # #3 D . 66 3)5 %: ! = )7 3( -6- % & 6 6 " 0 " 8E " , ( - E 6 6 + & 8 # 5 6 - 66 #' *" D)2 % " 8 + & " # 3D " "2 + " * #* 3")27 %1 " 6 ) ! # % 0 J" ) & " 0 66 )*%+(%2( " 6 + +E & C6 <6 " 0 . 0 9 ') !# 37* @ + " E " C " "+ " " )*%+(%)(0 " % 6 6 )*%+(%)( # # 37* 3")D # )14%1 *44D(# " < 6 0 @ - E "0 " " E " " ' " " < 6 66 + 0 , .9,# .9, 3" )14 ) 66 0 " ' # +" @ +0 -& " - 6 -" " )*%+(%)(0 ) 8 # *" )77D(# < C # 27* 0 " " 0E # 2D1 . 2 5# 25* %)7D1((A < 6 " '1 ' " 6 0 # 0 " " +- ' +E + 3* " # C " ' " " +E 8 E # 8 )*%+(%)( " " ' # 2D1 *" D)D % " 0 " )*%+(%)( C 6 8 6 #& 0 66 " - " 0 66 6 " '(A & # 27* *" 34% " 0 " " 9$. !, C +E E " " - " 6 "(A * # *" )4*5# )432 %. ! , *44 ( -7- " "+ - # 6 8 6 # 145 . 66 ! , -+ " B " $ C " " / "6 " C 0 & @ E " %' # D5D %%1 6 E " )1 . % / " " 0 6 # 6 # 557 " - < ' 2 # * )757((A ', 9$. !, " " " " . )773(% B % B " " +- " . 7 %)75 (( 6 " " *444(A . 66 )57# )7) %. ! " < 6 . 66 *"D25# D D %: ! # 5)4 ( E " +- # $# )4) )*%+(%*( )*%+(%*( 6 " " " " +- 66 *" 2)*# 2)2 %1 >) )7A # 5D1 ( . 66 )5*# *)D %! : / )773( " " 66 " " " + < # 6 6 " +- 6 E " - B 6 " , / 66 B " E 0 0B " 6 " ?%)( 66 0B A " %*( 6 " -8- " %%1 # D5D " # )4) , < C B -?%)( " %' " @ " ! D D% 6 + . 66 *" . 7 # )4DB41 %)75 (( 6 E " " + 6 " 6 6 %3(" -6 0 -+ 6 - A%*( " B - " A C $ # )35 # 9.. +- . 66 *" 3# 1 %. ! &" 0+ *44)(A ,:: > )3B3B1 ! 8 6 " 66 0 "- 00" 66 6 6 9$. !, 66 0B # 6 " B ' &" " 0+ &%)( 6 6 6 0' -" 66 A%*( + E " " +- + A " %3( 66 E ' " " # )35 # # 211 . *" 5 3# 5 " 0+ ' &6 *44 (% " 6 +E ' 3 ) # 6 6 - . 66 *" % 9.. " ! 6 1% )771(( - &" " ,:: > )3B3B1 ( &" J 0 6 0+ . 66 *" )*7# )33 66 . 6 ' " " 0& -+ 6 #1 # # 112 . *" 343# 347 % -9- + ' # 14D * " , C (* %. ! 6 3" 5 )757( # 55* %1 0 )773((A " " 6 @ " - % 6 " " *442((A )777( &G " # , 6 " E * - ' # DDD # )55 ( * 0# + " 6 6 " + 8 " - 3" " * 0 . 6 # DDD 6 + 6 K 6 " +- 6 6 6 " " " ) " % ' )323(A B $ - !# ! . D2*# D 2B %)751( 9 66 , " )*%+(%*( # + " &" & " 9$. !, " ! 66 7 9 " " #8K + + 6 ' < &,' 0 . 66 E ! . " + K66 6 8 0 0 " - # D) . D 2B % . *52# *7* %)754(( " " 6 ' &0 ' +E E " 8 $ """ , 6 2B A 6 6 & ! 8 . DDD E $ 3"2)7 %1 " # %*( " %3( 3")312# )323 % " " &%)( " # D ) C @ $ ""- , # " - " !# D ) . D2* %)751(# 8 K + " "E " 0 " 6 #8K 6 #8K E" #8 " 0 " + ' 4' 5 $ -10- 8 " 8 K 6 ' 8 " 8 ' # @ 66 8 - 6 - 6 E " @ " *54%1 @ 6 0 " + # + # 252 *"* 2# + " " #: 0 " " 5 6 '(A .7)B4DD4% (# )77* G $ 37*23 # - 2# )77*( 8 9$. !, 6 " " 0 <# " 66 66 ' C " " &" 0# " 0 "- 0# 0 " 00" -# 6 6 0 "6 + " " 0 " 8 # 6 + 6 6 ' "- " 6 6 C 6 - E "0 6 " 66 86 8 " +" # 0 + "F + L 1% ( " +- " & + 0 "F 6 00 , " ' " ( H1 %. ! 0 . 5 , " 0& E # 6 -+ "" 6 )75*(% " 0 " " " " < # + 0B E "0 66 ' " " " + " " " . 66 " -11- 8 668 0 6 8 . , " & 8 C 6 ) # )*%+(%*( )*%+(%*( ! + " ! , - 9 " )*%+(%2(# . - / "0 . 0 " 6 + )772(% " " &0 "' 3" )7 + G 6 6 " 0 0 & # #' * # )* . 6 6 + C -8 ' " 6 -# ' -+ % 66 6 -6 6 ++ # 0 6 " "@ 6 " + 0 "" M )*%+(%2( @ 0 B6 0 )711# )72DB21 %*44 ( & #& 3" )74# )72 *" D1# D %1 C " +- " + # 1 $7 4 C+ - " 0 " $ - & "" . "" ( B6 6 ) )77*(( M $ # 1 )*%+(%2(# 12 " " 0 %1 " - 0 )727 C "K # D)2 " +- ' " )721 - E "0 - " . *3*# *32 %)7 D(% (( G " " + " " 6 " 0# - E "0 -12- )*%"( @ 0 $ %' # 7)4 .# + " +- 6 0 *")* 7# )*54%1 + 0 0 +- " 6 0 %1 B 06 0 66 0 "- + " -N 6 " 0A " " " B " " # 8 E "0 # " "+ 0 # C + " 3*DA 6 < &,' # 7*2 " 0 ! 8 668 # 8 8 A. " < " 8 " "+ " "# " #+ - E "0 " " -" 0 " )*%+(%2( " " 12% ( 9O < &,' $ ""- , " " . " # +0 #D B 0 B " $ ""- , " # " # ! 3" )427# )4 1 . 3) # 3*1 %)752(( 0 + 0 0 6 & 6 -" )77)(A 6 # +- 7 *" D7D# D75 %1 # 0 #D < - "" #3 0 "# + " 0 7 " , " # ' )77D(% + )774( 9 6 " )*%+(%2( - @ - 9$. !, 6 # " -13- - 6 " 6 " # " # " # @ " #: 9 " , 0 ) # *441( " & -6 0 +" C +- 6 0 C 0 ++ 6 )1 . " " 0 , 6 " 6 - 0 6 0 ' )1 . ' 0 6 " " " 6 0 #" 0 "# " # " + 6 "+" " 6 6 6 0 " 6 " " & " 0 " 06 # *441 G $ )753517# " " 0 6 # " " "# 0# HD + 0 -14- " 0 " " 6 " 6 # . +" " " & " 0 - " " "" 6 6 " 0 # 6 6 ' )1 . >) 4) " 6 J 9 6 # 6 A - >) 4)%D( " 0 9$. !, " +" 0 " #" " + & HD %: ! & -6 - " # " 6 8 0 6 >) 4)%1( # 9$. !, " # " . 0 6 " # '7 )1 6 6 6 # +" >) 4)%2( 6 *?4D D25# *441 G $ )753517# 9$. !, " -# - " "+ 6 " ' " " + " "" 6 -. # 6 & " 0 + - ' 0 HD# # 15D # B B )% 0 *" )*55# )*73 %3" )*%+(%2(# " + )7 5(( 0" " " " 6 6 $ %& " " " - +E 9$. !, 0 H1 # " 0 -" 6 "# 0 # " 6 " " C " 0 00" "" " # "6 6 " "F " -6 + "" " &" - J" "F 6 ' "& 0 " - ' " + 0 " + 6 6 C " " " 6 & - 6 LL % (B%+(# )4# )) E # 6 E O" " C +# " " + @ " LL )*# )3 += '+- " 6 0 6 E # " "$ C # " " . " 0 , # C -9 L *2 " - "# 0 E # < # "# " 0 # " "6 0 # "F E # 6 6 C " 5% (%*( & " " "6 # 0 -15- 6 6 " "# " '& 0 # )* . $ 0# 6 6 6 " " 8 6 " & )*%+(%2(+ " 0 0 0 - " " , # " C " - + " " 0 " 8 " 6 6 ' " - 0 < 6 " 6 0 " -16- < " &0 6 6 ' " , " 6 ' , " " &" 0 &" " )*%+(%2( $ ""- , " ' " +- . 8 J" 6 " " # " 6 , " & " 6 - E "0 00" & 66 " 8 $ ""- , " " 0 +- # ' )711# )72DB21 %*44 ( " J 6 " 9 " 8 " + + 0 - " 6 6 8 6 - 0 " " 0 )*%+(%2( 0 * # )* . 6 6 9$. !, 0 ( . +E & 0 #' 6 " 6 6 " - 0 0 *)7 # **44%*44 ( 8 + + <# 6 + E 8" " 6 6 + . 6 E " = " "$ C # C -9 6 "# K O" C #. , 8 '. , # < 8 "K L 7%"(# " < &,' 8 668 6 " " &" 9$. !, " # &" 6 8 0 - E "0 '6 + 0 " 8 " 9 . $ - " # 66 ". E " 0 " 6 >) )7 0 0 " E " " 66 6 # " )5 "+ 86 . > )32 % (A . 1D2# 11 B15 %*441( 8 9$. !, 89$. !, 9$. !, 86 *5 6 # 1D1 E " 0 ) * 0 E >)32 % ( 0 &77 6 ' " 6 )1 0 . " " # 66 E " " 999 " 6 0 : $ .9 : 0# " )*%+(%)(# )*%+(%*(# )*%+(%2(# " 12 8 + " " -17- "6 " E " # 0 89$. !, # " # " - ! # ! )*%+( 12# " " + 6 , " - " " . + ! # $ "# - / "0 / 34# *445# +# *) "- + # *445 ,$9$ . $ ; ,: P ! : :9 ! . , . !9. 9 / != -18- "+
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
