Time Insurance Company v. White, No. 1:2008cv00016 - Document 85 (S.D. Miss. 2008)

Court Description: ORDER granting 39 Time Insurance Company's Motion to Dismiss Third-Party Defendant Albert Small's Cross-claim. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 12/10/2008. (YSM)
Download PDF
Time Insurance Company v. White Doc. 85 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION TIME INSURANCE COMPANY § § § § § v. LARRYE J. WHITE LARRYE J.WHITE PLAINTIFF Civil Action No. 1:08cv16 DEFENDANT § § § § § v. ALBERT W. SMALL THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT ORDER AND REASONS GRANTING TIME INSURANCE COMPANY’S MOTION TO DISMISS THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT ALBERT SMALL’S CROSS-CLAIM ! "# + $%& ' * . , () /0& 1220& ( + (+ 3< . + > ( ! /?& 1220& 3 ' ( *9 4 A 14 ' , & 8 ( (+ . (4 ; ( . @ *+ ( < . ( ( ( ( & ( 4 & !' . + . @ () - *9 *:' != ) ! 76 4 * ( - (3 - 4 ( & * , ( 8& 4 *+ ( ( ( ( +3 56 & !' ( + ' ( ( 9 ! >4 16& 1220& -1- Dockets.Justia.com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