-JMR Tubbs v. Northrop Grumman Shipbuilding, Inc., No. 1:2006cv00834 - Document 411 (S.D. Miss. 2011)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER granting 389 Motion for Summary Judgment; finding as moot 399 Motion for Summary Judgment; finding as moot 404 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney; finding as moot 406 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. This case will be dismissed with prejudice. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 8/29/11 (RLW)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
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
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
