Hunter #242663 v. Joboulian et al, No. 1:2017cv00832 - Document 38 (W.D. Mich. 2019)

Court Description: OPINION AND ORDER APPROVING AND ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION 34 ; motion for summary judgment 22 is GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART; signed by Judge Janet T. Neff (Judge Janet T. Neff, clb)

Download PDF
Hunter #242663 v. Joboulian et al Doc. 38 WPKVGF UVCVGU FKUVTKEV EQWTV YGUVGTP FKUVTKEV QH OKEJKICP UQWVJGTP FKXKUKQP LGTOCKPG F0 JWPVGT %464885. Rnckpvkhh. Ecug Pq0 3<39/ex/:54 x0 JQP0 LCPGV V0 PGHH LQJP LQDQWNKCP. gv cn0. Fghgpfcpvu0 aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa1 QRKPKQP CPF QTFGT Vjku ku c rtkuqpgt ekxkn tkijvu cevkqp hkngf rwtuwcpv vq 64 W0U0E0 ¸ 3;:50 Fghgpfcpvu Rcnogt. Lqdqwnkcp. Twuugnn. cpf Itcjco hkngf c oqvkqp hqt uwooct{ lwfiogpv. ctiwkpi vjcv Rnckpvkhh hckngf vq gzjcwuv jku cfokpkuvtcvkxg tgogfkgu0 Vjg ocvvgt ycu tghgttgf vq vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig. yjq kuuwgf c Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp *T(T+. tgeqoogpfkpi vjg oqvkqp dg itcpvgf kp rctv cpf fgpkgf kp rctv0 Vjg ocvvgt ku rtgugpvn{ dghqtg vjg Eqwtv qp FghgpfcpvuÓ qdlgevkqp. kp rctv. vq vjg Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp0 Kp ceeqtfcpeg ykvj 4: W0U0E0 ¸ 858*d+*3+ cpf HGF0 T0 EKX0 R0 94*d+*5+. vjg Eqwtv jcu rgthqtogf fg pqxq eqpukfgtcvkqp qh vjqug rqtvkqpu qh vjg Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp vq yjkej cp qdlgevkqp jcu dggp ocfg0 Vjg Eqwtv fgpkgu vjg qdlgevkqp cpf kuuwgu vjku Qrkpkqp cpf Qtfgt0 Cp qdlgevkqp vq c ocikuvtcvg lwfigÓu tgrqtv cpf tgeqoogpfcvkqp owuv Ðurgekhkecnn{ kfgpvkh{ vjg rqtvkqpu qh vjg rtqrqugf hkpfkpiu. tgeqoogpfcvkqpu. qt tgrqtv vq yjkej qdlgevkqpu ctg ocfg cpf vjg dcuku hqt uwej qdlgevkqpu0Ñ Y0F0 Okej0 NEkxT 9405*d+0 Vjg Eqwtv tgxkgyu fg pqxq Ðvjqug rqtvkqpu qh vjg tgrqtv qt urgekhkgf rtqrqugf hkpfkpiu qt tgeqoogpfcvkqpu vq yjkej qdlgevkqp ku Dockets.Justia.com ocfg0Ñ Id. Cu c vjtgujqnf ocvvgt. ctiwogpvu pqv tckugf dghqtg vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig ctg fggogf yckxgf cpf ctg pqv rtqrgtn{ tckugf qp qdlgevkqp vq c tgrqtv cpf tgeqoogpfcvkqp0 See United States v. Waters. 37: H05f ;55. ;58 *8vj Ekt0 3;;:+= Bartlett v. Borgess Hosp.. Pq0 3<39/ex/335:. 423: YN 6743;58 cv ,3 *Y0F0 Okej0 Ugrv0 43. 423:+0 Vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig ocfg ugxgtcn hkpfkpiu cpf tgeqoogpfcvkqpu kp vjku ecug0 Qpn{ qpg ku rtgugpvn{ dghqtg vjg Eqwtv0 Vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig hqwpf vjcv c hcevwcn fkurwvg gzkuvu qxgt yjgvjgt Rnckpvkhh rtqrgtn{ gzjcwuvgf jku cfokpkuvtcvkxg tgogfkgu cu vq vjg enckou hqwpf kp cp cnngigfn{ wphkngf itkgxcpeg uwdokvvgf d{ Rnckpvkhh vq vjg Itkgxcpeg Eqqtfkpcvqt *T(T. GEH Pq0 56 cv RcigKF0496/498+0 Dgecwug qh vjcv hkpfkpi. vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig tgeqoogpfgf vjcv vjg enckou Rnckpvkhh cuugtvu kp vjcv itkgxcpeg ujqwnf oqxg hqtyctf0 Fghgpfcpvu Ðqdlgev vq vjg cuugtvkqp kp vjg Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp vjcv Rnckpvkhh rwtuwgf cnn cxckncdng tgogfkgu ÈÑ hqt vjg cnngigfn{ wprtqeguugf itkgxcpeg *Fghu0 Qdl0. GEH Pq0 57 cv RcigKF049:/49;= T(T. GEH Pq0 56 cv RcigKF0496/497+0 Fghgpfcpvu cfxcpeg vjtgg ctiwogpvu kp vjgkt qdlgevkqp< K0 Rnckpvkhh pgxgt hkngf vjg cnngigf wprtqeguugf itkgxcpeg. hqt kh jg jcf. kv yqwnf jcxg dggp tgrqtvgf kp vjg itkgxcpeg fcvcdcug0 KK0 Gxgp kh Rnckpvkhh fkf hkng vjg cnngigf wprtqeguugf itkgxcpeg. jg jcf c tgurqpukdknkv{ wpfgt vjg itkgxcpeg rqnke{ fktgevkxg 250240352 vq uwdokv c uvgr KK itkgxcpeg chvgt vjg vkog rgtokvvgf hqt OFQE uvchh vq tgurqpf jcf rcuugf0 KKK0 Hcnukhkecvkqp qh fqewogpvu ku pqv c xcnkf Gkijvj Cogpfogpv encko0 Cffkvkqpcnn{. cp{ encko cdqwv kpcfgswcvg fgpvcn ectg kp tgncvkqp vq vjg hcnukhkecvkqp qh fqewogpvu yqwnf jcxg jcf vq dggp tckugf d{ Rnckpvkhh kp 4236. yjgp jg cnngigu vjcv vjg hcnukhkecvkqp qeewttgf0 4 *Fghu0 Qdl0. GEH Pq0 57 cv RcigKF049;+0 Fghgpfcpvu cnuq uwdokv vjg chhkfcxkv qh Mwtv Oknngt. Itkgxcpeg Eqqtfkpcvqt. cu hcevwcn uwrrqtv hqt vjg ctiwogpvu kp vjgkt qdlgevkqp *Chh0. GEH Pq0 58 cv RcigKF04:8/4::+0 Vjg qdlgevkqp ku fgpkgf0 Hktuv. Ctiwogpv KKK qh vjg qdlgevkqp. swqvgf cdqxg. ycu pqv tckugf dghqtg vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig0 Vjg Eqwtv fgenkpgu vq eqpukfgt ctiwogpvu tckugf hqt vjg hktuv vkog qp qdlgevkqp vq vjg Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp0 Ugeqpf. Ctiwogpvu K cpf KK fq pqvjkpi vq wpfgtokpg vjg Ocikuvtcvg LwfigÓu cpcn{uku qt eqpenwukqp0 Fghgpfcpvu guugpvkcnn{ tgcuugtv vjgkt ctiwogpvu dghqtg vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig0 FghgpfcpvuÓ qdlgevkqp tgkvgtcvgu OFQE Rqnke{ cpf rtqxkfgu vjg chhkfcxkv qh vjg Itkgxcpeg Eqqtfkpcvqt. cxgttkpi vjcv cnn itkgxcpegu tgegkxgf qp vjg fc{ kp swguvkqp ygtg hkngf rgt rqnke{ cpf tqwvkpg *see Fghu0 Tgrn{ Dt0. GEH Pq0 55 cv RcigKF0456 *ÐFghgpfcpvu ockpvckp vjcv vjg itkgxcpeg kp swguvkqp ycu pgxgt hkngfÑ++0 FghgpfcpvuÓ cuugtvkqpu ogtgn{ uwrrqtv vjg Ocikuvtcvg LwfigÓu eqpenwukqp vjcv c swguvkqp qh hcev gzkuvu cu vq Ðyjgvjgt Rnckpvkhh rtqrgtn{ gzjcwuvgf jku cfokpkuvtcvkxg tgogfkgu ykvj tgurgev vq vjg enckou cuugtvgfÑ *T(T. GEH Pq0 56 cv RcigKF0497+0 Vjgtghqtg. FghgpfcpvuÓ ctiwogpvu hckn. cpf vjg qdlgevkqp ku fgpkgf0 Ceeqtfkpin{. vjku Eqwtv cfqrvu vjg Ocikuvtcvg LwfigÓu Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp cu vjg Qrkpkqp qh vjku Eqwtv0 Vjgtghqtg< KV KU JGTGD[ QTFGTGF vjcv FghgpfcpvuÓ Qdlgevkqp *GEH Pq0 57+ ku FGPKGF cpf vjg Tgrqtv cpf Tgeqoogpfcvkqp qh vjg Ocikuvtcvg Lwfig *GEH Pq0 56+ ku CRRTQXGF cpf CFQRVGF cu vjg Qrkpkqp qh vjg Eqwtv0 KV KU HWTVJGT QTFGTGF vjcv vjg Oqvkqp hqt Uwooct{ Lwfiogpv *GEH Pq0 44+ ku ITCPVGF KP RCTV CPF FGPKGF KP RCTV0 Urgekhkecnn{. RnckpvkhhÓu enckou cickpuv Fghgpfcpv Twuugnn ctg fkuokuugf hqt hcknwtg vq uvcvg c encko qp yjkej tgnkgh oc{ dg itcpvgf0 5 RnckpvkhhÓu itquu pginkigpeg enckou cickpuv Fghgpfcpvu Lqdqwnkcp. Itcjco. D{tpg. Rcig. cpf Rcnogt ctg fkuokuugf hqt hcknwtg vq uvcvg c encko qp yjkej tgnkgh oc{ dg itcpvgf0 Ykvj tgurgev vq Fghgpfcpvu Rcnogt. Lqdqwnkcp. Twuugnn. cpf Itcjco. RnckpvkhhÓu enckou ctg fkuokuugf hqt hcknwtg vq gzjcwuv cfokpkuvtcvkxg tgogfkgu gzegrv hqt vjg hqnnqykpi< *3+ RnckpvkhhÓu Gkijvj Cogpfogpv encko vjcv Fghgpfcpvu Rcnogt cpf Lqdqwnkcp. dgvyggp vjg fcvgu qh Hgdtwct{ 43. 4236. cpf Lwpg 48. 4236. hckngf vq rtqxkfg jko ykvj crrtqrtkcvg fgpvcn ectg= *4+ RnckpvkhhÓu Gkijvj Cogpfogpv encko vjcv qp Hgdtwct{ 42. 4236. Fghgpfcpv Itcjco rncegf kp RnckpvkhhÓu ogfkecn hkng c ÐhcdtkecvgfÑ tgrqtv Ðfqyprnc{kpiÑ vjg ugtkqwupguu qh RnckpvkhhÓu pggf hqt fgpvcn ectg= *5+ RnckpvkhhÓu Gkijvj Cogpfogpv encko vjcv qp Lwpg 46. 4236. Fghgpfcpv Lqdqwnkcp rncegf kp RnckpvkhhÓu ogfkecn hkng c ÐhcdtkecvgfÑ tgrqtv Ðfqyprnc{kpiÑ vjg ugtkqwupguu qh RnckpvkhhÓu pggf hqt fgpvcn ectg= cpf *6+ RnckpvkhhÓu uvcvg ncy kpvgpvkqpcn kphnkevkqp qh goqvkqpcn fkuvtguu enckou tgncvkpi vq vjgug rctvkewnct cnngicvkqpu0 /s/ Janet T. Neff LCPGV V0 PGHH Wpkvgf Uvcvgu Fkuvtkev Lwfig Fcvgf< Octej 7. 423; 6

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.