Hill v. Bevier, No. 2:2021cv12499 - Document 3 (E.D. Mich. 2021)
Court Description: OPINION and ORDER Summarily Dismissing 1 Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus, Denying a Certificate of Appealability, and Denying Leave to Appeal in Forma Pauperis. Signed by District Judge Stephen J. Murphy, III. (DPar)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Hill v. Bevier Doc. 3 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DIVISION BENJAMIN HILL, Case No. 2:21-cv-12499 Petitioner, HONORABLE STEPHEN J. MURPHY, III v. TROY BEVIER, Respondent. __________________________________/ OPINION AND ORDER SUMMARILY DISMISSING PETITION FOR A WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS [1], DENYING A CERTIFICATE OF APPEALABILITY, AND DENYING LEAVE TO APPEAL IN FORMA PAUPERIS Petitioner Benjamin Hill—a pretrial detainee at the Lenawee County Jail in Southern Michigan—filed a pro se petition for a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241. ECF 1. Because of the procedural posture of the state criminal proceedings, the Court will dismiss the petition. Federal habeas relief is premature. BACKGROUND Petitioner is charged in state court with three counts of fourth degree criminal sexual conduct. Id. at 2. Petitioner submitted a document along with the petition that appears to show that Petitioner pleaded guilty to at least some of the counts during Petitioner's June 2, 2021 arraignment. Id. But the document listed Petitioner's next court date as November 17, 2021 and that the purposes of the court date are "pretrial" matters. Id. The Court independently confirmed that Petitioner is scheduled to have two "pretrial hearing[s]" on November 17, 2021 in Lenawee County Circuit 1 Dockets.Justia.com Court and that the hearings are for the cases listed on the document that Petitioner submitted. See Exhibit 1; ECF 1, PgID 2. Based on the document and the state court's docket, see Exhibit 1; ECF 1, PgID 2, Petitioner is either a pretrial detainee who has not been convicted or an inmate who has pleaded guilty to and is awaiting sentencing on at least some of the charged offenses. One page of the petition states that Petitioner believes a "malicious prosecution" violated Petitioner's due process and equal protection rights and another discusses a brief recitation of case law about deficient warrants. Id. at 1, 4. Petitioner did not explain whether there was an arrest or search warrant issued in the state court case or what was malicious about the prosecution that violated due process or equal protection principles. See generally id. Other than the document and pages referenced above, Plaintiff appears to have attached several documents unrelated to the actual petition for a writ of habeas corpus. See generally ECF 1. For example, one document is a Freedom of Information Act request sent to the Lenawee County Jail in October 2021, id. at 3, and another relates to a civil lawsuit Petitioner filed in state court associated with injuries suffered while confined in the Lenawee County Jail, id. at 5. Neither document appears related to Petitioner's state court criminal proceeding, and Petitioner does not appear to reassert the civil claims from the state court lawsuit in federal court through the petition. The last two documents are letters from Petitioner to the Lenawee County Prosecutor. Id. at 6–8. The first letter detailed an alleged incident of sexual 2 harassment against Petitioner that apparently resulted in Petitioner's arrest because Petitioner connected the incident to the "malicious prosecution." Id. at 6–7. Petitioner did not provide a reason for the arrest. See generally id. The second letter discussed an incident in which Petitioner was allegedly assaulted by a woman, with a request that an investigation be launched against the woman. Id. at 8. LEGAL STANDARD If a habeas petitioner has not yet been convicted, Section 2241 is the proper vehicle for challenging the state court proceedings because the Sixth Circuit has "long recognized that pretrial detainees pursue habeas relief [] under § 2241." Phillips v. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton Cnty., Ohio, 668 F.3d 804, 809 (6th Cir. 2012). Relief can only be sought under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 when the petitioner is "in custody pursuant to the judgment of a State court" rather than "in custody pursuant to an indictment." Id. (emphasis in original) (internal quotation and citation omitted). If a petitioner has been convicted in a state court but files for habeas relief under § 2241, courts must still apply the restrictions on habeas relief associated with § 2254. Rittenberry v. Morgan, 468 F.3d 331, 337–38 (6th Cir. 2006) ("[T]here is really only a single 'gate' to federal habeas relief from state custody—through the general jurisdictional grant in § 2241—although all petitions seeking relief from state court convictions are more specifically filed 'under section 2254' as well, and are subject to its restrictions, as well as those of § 2244(b).") (cleaned up). Because Petitioner might be either a pretrial detainee or convicted and awaiting sentencing, the Court will analyze the petition as if both circumstances exist. 3 First, the Court turns to the law surrounding pretrial habeas petitions challenging state criminal proceedings. In general, under the abstention doctrine federal courts should not interfere with pending state criminal proceedings "except under extraordinary circumstances, where the danger of irreparable loss is both great and immediate." Younger v. Harris, 401 U.S. 37, 45 (1971); see also In re Justices of Sup. Ct. Dept. of Mass. Trial Ct., 218 F.3d 11, 17–18 (1st Cir. 2000) (discussing approvingly the application of abstention principles to pretrial habeas relief from a state proceeding). Courts will apply the abstention doctrine when there is "an ongoing state judicial proceeding; . . . the proceeding[] implicate[s] important state interests; and . . . there [is] an adequate opportunity in the state proceeding[] to raise constitutional challenges." Middlesex Cnty. Ethics Comm. v. Garden State Bar Ass'n, 457 U.S. 423, 432 (1982). Federal courts routinely deny pretrial requests for habeas relief from state court proceedings unless there "is a claim that [the] state prosecution will violate the Double Jeopardy Clause" or there are claims related to the petitioner's right to a speedy trial. Carman v. Pinkney, No. 1:19 CV 2101, 2020 WL 224572, at *3 (N.D. Ohio Jan. 25, 2020) (Gaughan, C.J.). Second, the Court turns to the law surrounding habeas petitions submitted by convicted petitioners when the state court has yet to impose a sentence. Federal courts must not grant a petition for a writ of habeas corpus "unless the petitioner has exhausted available state court remedies, there is an absence of available state corrective process, or circumstances exist that render such process ineffective to protect the petitioner's rights." Turner v. Bagley, 401 F.3d 718, 724 (6th Cir. 2005) 4 (citing § 2254 (b) and (c)). A petitioner confined pursuant to a Michigan conviction must raise each issue in both the Michigan Court of Appeals and the Michigan Supreme Court before seeking federal habeas corpus relief in order to satisfy the exhaustion requirement. Hafley v. Sowders, 902 F.2d 480, 483 (6th Cir. 1990) (quoting Winegar v. Corr. Dep't, 435 F. Supp. 285, 289 (W.D. Mich. 1977)). Petitions are routinely dismissed on exhaustion grounds when a petitioner is awaiting sentencing after conviction. See Knox v. State of Wyo., 959 F.2d 866, 868 (10th Cir. 1992); Pizetzky v. Att'y Gen., 329 F. Supp. 2d 371, 373 (E.D.N.Y. 2004); Allen v. Att'y Gen. of the State of Me., 80 F.3d 569, 572 (1st Cir. 1996) ("[A] state criminal case is ripe for the ministrations of a federal habeas court only after completion of the state proceedings," which means "after the defendant has been tried, convicted, sentenced, and has pursued available direct appeals."). The petitioner has the burden of proving exhaustion of state court remedies. See Rust v. Zent, 17 F.3d 155, 160 (6th Cir. 1994). Finally, if a petitioner is plainly not entitled to relief, federal courts must dismiss the petition. Rule Four of the Rules Governing Section 2254 Cases in the United States District Courts. DISCUSSION The Court will deny the petition for a writ of habeas corpus because regardless of whether Petitioner is a pretrial detainee yet to be convicted or a convicted inmate awaiting sentencing Petitioner is plainly not entitled to relief. First, if Petitioner is a pretrial detainee yet to be convicted, Petitioner did not allege the proceeding against him violates double jeopardy and did not make any claims related to speedy trial 5 rights. See generally ECF 1. Because Petitioner did not allege claims related to double jeopardy or speedy trial rights, the abstention doctrine applies if Petitioner is a pretrial detainee yet to be convicted. Carman, 2020 WL 224572, at *3. Furthermore, Petitioner would still have an opportunity to raise any constitutional issue related to a malicious prosecution in state court before or during trial, so there is an adequate opportunity for the state court to prevent an "irreparable loss" resulting from the alleged malicious prosecution against Petitioner. Thus, irrespective of courts in the Sixth Circuit having only found double jeopardy and speedy trial claims to clear the abstention doctrine hurdle, abstention applies here given the adequate opportunity for the state court to prevent any "irreparable loss." See Middlesex Cnty. Ethics Comm., 457 U.S. at 432; Younger, 401 U.S. at 45. Second, if Petitioner is a convicted inmate awaiting sentencing, Petitioner has not exhausted state court remedies. Given that Petitioner still has pretrial hearings for the cases challenged in the petition, see Exhibit 1; ECF 1, PgID 2, Petitioner could not yet have been sentenced for any convictions related to the cases. Petitioner, therefore, could not have exhausted state court remedies. See Knox, 959 F.2d at 868; Pizetzky, 329 F. Supp. 2d at 373. Because either the abstention doctrine applies or Petitioner has not exhausted state court remedies necessitating dismissal under Rule Four of the Rules Governing Section 2254 Cases in the United States District Courts, the Court will dismiss the petition for a writ of habeas corpus. 6 CONCLUSION To appeal the Court's decision, Petitioner must obtain a certificate of appealability. See Greene v. Tennessee Dep't of Corrections, 265 F. 3d 369, 372 (6th Cir. 2001); Rule Eleven of the Rules Governing Section 2254 Cases in the United States District Courts. To obtain a certificate of appealability, Petitioner must make "a substantial showing of the denial of a constitutional right." 28 U.S.C. § 2253(c)(2). To make such a showing, Petitioner must show "that reasonable jurists could debate whether . . . the petition should have been resolved in a different manner or that the issues presented were adequate to deserve encouragement to proceed further." Slack v. McDaniel, 529 U.S. 473, 483–84 (2000) (cleaned up). Here, the Court will deny a certificate of appealability because "a plain procedural bar is present and the [] [C]ourt is correct to invoke it to dispose of the case," so "a reasonable jurist could not conclude either that the district court erred in dismissing the petition or that the petitioner should be allowed to proceed further." Id. at 484. The Court will also deny Petitioner leave to appeal in forma pauperis because an appeal cannot be taken in good faith. See Fed. R. App. P. 24(a). ORDER WHEREFORE, it is hereby ORDERED that the petition for a writ of habeas corpus is DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a certificate of appealability is DENIED. 7 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Petitioner is DENIED in forma pauperis status on appeal. SO ORDERED. s/ Stephen J. Murphy, III STEPHEN J. MURPHY, III United States District Judge Dated: November 15, 2021 I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing document was served upon the parties and/or counsel of record on November 15, 2021, by electronic and/or ordinary mail. s/ David P. Parker Case Manager 8 EXHIBIT 1 11/2/21, 2:44 PM Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC 11/17/2021 Today Print PARTY NAME BOLTON, ROBERT BRUCE ELLENWOOD, TIMOTHY RICHARD LODISE BAIL BONDS 24 7 BAIL BONDS 24 7 BAIL BONDS 24 7 BAIL BONDS ATWATER BAIL BONDS BOLTON, ROBERT BRUCE TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020549FH 462100187201 8:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BRANDT,ALFRED P., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020503FH 462100147301 8:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020503FH 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000019977FH 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020127FC 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020206FH 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020078FH 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020549FH https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 462100187201 1/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME BRAZEE, RONALD STANLEY CRABTREE, LUCAS EDWARD DOUBLE, CHRISTINE ANN GARROW, JOSEPH RANDALL GARROW, JOSEPH RANDALL J & J BAIL BOND LEE, CYNTHIA ANN SANTIAGO, SHELBY IVAN SCAMP, JARED ALLAN Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,SPECIAL PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020229FC 462000295101 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020127FC 462000094701 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020206FH 462000337001 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: LACASSE,DAVID EDMER, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000019977FH 462000147801 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020545FH 462100182301 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020127FC 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: SAVICH,MATT, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019285FH 461800341301 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020104FH 462000232501 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000019983FH 462000149601 https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 2/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME SCAMP, JARED ALLAN SCAMP, JARED ALLAN SCAMP, JARED ALLAN SCAMP, JARED ALLAN SCAMP, JARED ALLAN TAYLOR, DAVID CURTIS TAYLOR, DAVID CURTIS TAYLOR, DAVID CURTIS Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020078FH 462000230301 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020259FH 462000351101 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020260FH 462100029201 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020261FH 462100031901 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: BENNETT,JEFFREY G., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020262FH 462100057301 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019313FH 461900043201 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019314FH 461900047901 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019315FC 461900054601 https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 3/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME TAYLOR, DAVID CURTIS TAYLOR, DAVID CURTIS 24 7 BAIL BONDS 24 7 BAIL BONDS BARNHART, MATTHEW STEPHEN CASAREZ-RUIZ, JESUS ANTONIO GONZALES, JOHN ALEX GONZALES, JOHN ALEX HILL, BENJAMIN DEAN Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019367FC 461900085001 8:15 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019433FH 461900121301 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020215FH 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020383FH 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: SECREST,JOHN C., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020585FH 942190089701 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020340FH 462100096601 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020023FH 462000135501 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020024FH 462000224401 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020344FH 462100059301 https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 4/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME HILL, BENJAMIN DEAN JUSTICE, BRIAN SHANE KOLLE, MICHELLE ELIZABETH KOLLE, MICHELLE ELIZABETH MORBACH, MARK ANTHONY PERRY, JEREMY LEE PERRY, JEREMY LEE ROBERTS, KYLE LEE Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020345FH 462100062101 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020594FH 462100187601 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020518FH 462100108901 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020519FH 462100110101 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000019973FH 461900266701 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020097FC 462000150701 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020098FH 462000229601 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019684FH 461900305101 https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 5/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019685FH 461900305301 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019686FH 461900312801 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020215FH 462100003401 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020383FH 462100106901 THOMPSON, ISREAL KEATON 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020012FH 462000079601 WATSON, CHARLES W. 8:30 AM JURY TRIAL Location: FL 2/RM202 ATTY: LUCAS,FREDERICK, 18050410-CZ WATSON, DAVID C. 8:30 AM JURY TRIAL Location: FL 2/RM202 ATTY: WORKER,GREGORY T., 18050410-CZ WATSON, ANTHONY W. 8:30 AM JURY TRIAL Location: FL 2/RM202 ATTY: SCHAEDLER,PHILLIP A., 18050410-CZ WATSON, DANNY H. 8:30 AM JURY TRIAL Location: FL 2/RM202 ATTY: LUCAS,FREDERICK, 18050410-CZ 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020586FH ROBERTS, KYLE LEE ROBERTS, KYLE LEE ROBERTS, KYLE LEE ROBERTS, KYLE LEE WELLMAN, NATHAN https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 462100187701 6/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 8:30 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020600FH 462100220501 9:00 AM FINAL PRETRIAL Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,SPECIAL PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020229FC 462000295101 LAWRENCE, KEVIN RICHARD 9:30 AM MISCELLANEOUS HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020449FH 462100151601 24 7 BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020053FH 24 7 BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020101FH 24 7 BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020119FH 24 7 BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020120FH 24 7 BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020343FH 24 7 BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020510FH WILLIAMS, XZAVIER ANTONE BRAZEE, RONALD STANLEY https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 7/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME DENMAN, KEVIN LOUIS DENMAN, KEVIN LOUIS JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020287FH 462100029801 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020287FH 462100029801 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019675FH 461900277701 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000019932FH 462000042201 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020053FH 462000168001 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020101FH 462000257201 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020119FH 462000300401 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2020-0000020120FH 462000301201 https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 8/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM PARTY NAME Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER CTN JAKEWAY, ANDREW PATRICK 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DALY,JAMES W., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020447FH 462100115001 JOHNSON, GREGORY ERNEST 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: BRENNER,SARAH K., 2021-0000020333FH 941990151101 JUDY, TYLER WAYNE 10:00 AM SENTENCE HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: PRATER,ANN M., PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019385FH 461900068601 LEO'S BAIL BONDS 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020287FH 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2019-0000019675FH 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020343FH 462100021801 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: DEFENDER,PUBLIC, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020408FH 462100106001 WARRING, MICHAEL MARK 10:00 AM PRETRIAL HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: MUAWAD,ELIAS, PROS: LENAWEE PROSECUTORS OFFICE,, 2021-0000020510FH 462100134601 CUNNINGHAM, AUSTIN L 10:30 AM MISCELLANEOUS HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: ROTHFUSS,TIMOTHY D., 2016-0000042507DS SMITH, COURTNEY K 10:30 AM MISCELLANEOUS HEARING Location: FL 3/RM 2 ATTY: SMITH,RUSSELL A., 2016-0000042507DS LODISE BAIL BONDS MILLER, CORREY GLEN MITCHELL, MARTY RAY https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# 9/10 11/2/21, 2:44 PM Lenawee County Circuit, Probate and FOC - Court Display PARTY NAME TIME HEARING INFO CASE NUMBER WILLIAMS, LESA DORRIEE 11:00 AM REFEREE HEARING Location: FL GRD/RM1 ATTY: MORGAN,TODD MICHAEL, 2018-0000045581DM WILLIAMS, TERRANCE LEE 11:00 AM REFEREE HEARING Location: FL GRD/RM1 ATTY: PANAGOULIA,LANA A., 2018-0000045581DM RENWAND, AMY RUTH 1:30 PM NON-JURY TRIAL Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: IDDINGS,ADRIENNE L., 2020-0000048103DO RENWAND, WILLIAM HENRY 1:30 PM NON-JURY TRIAL Location: FL 3/RM 1 ATTY: RAINS,LOWRY MATTHEW, 2020-0000048103DO https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CourtDisplay/Display/public/gUxamcleUUGKvlD91D6RNg# CTN 10/10
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
