Case Energy Services L L C v. P A D C O Energy Services L L C, No. 6:2017cv00885 - Document 28 (W.D. La. 2019)
Court Description: OPINION: Defendant-appellant, Case Energy Services L L C appeals the June 27, 2017 ruling of the bankruptcy court denying its motions to dismiss the claims brought against it by Padco Energy Services and Padco Pressure Control L L C and denying its Motion to Transfer to another division in two adversary proceedings. The ruling of the Bankruptcy Court is AFFIRMED. Signed by Judge Mary Ann Vial Lemmon on 3/29/2019. (crt,ThomasSld, T)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Case Energy Services L L C v. P A D C O Energy Services L L C Doc. 28 "WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV YGUVGTP"FKUVTKEV"QH"NQWKUKCPC KP"TG"RCFEQ"GPGTI["UGTXKEGU. NNE."Fgdvqt 38/735:2 ECUG"GPGTI["UGTXKEGU."NNE EKXKN"CEVKQP XGTUWU PQ<""39/::6 RCFEQ"RTGUUWTG"EQPVTQN UGEVKQP<"$U$"*4+ ECUG"GPGTI["UGTXKEGU."NNE EKXKN"CEVKQP XGTUWU PQ<""39/::7 RCFEQ"GPGTI["UGTXKEGU UGEVKQP<"$U$"*4+ QRKPKQP Fghgpfcpv/crrgnncpv."Ecug"Gpgti{"Ugtxkegu."N0N0E0"*$Ecug$+"crrgcnu"vjg"Lwpg"49."4239 twnkpi"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"fgp{kpi"kvu"oqvkqpu"vq"fkuokuu"vjg"enckou"dtqwijv"cickpuv"kv"d{ Rcfeq"Gpgti{"Ugtxkegu."N0N0E0."cpf"Rcfeq"Rtguuwtg"Eqpvtqn."N0N0E0"cpf"fgp{kpi"kvu"Oqvkqp"vq Vtcpuhgt"vq"Cpqvjgt"Fkxkukqp."kp"vyq"cfxgtuct{"rtqeggfkpiu."39/7228"cpf"39/722903"Hqt"vjg tgcuqpu"vjcv"hqnnqy."vjg"twnkpi qh"vjg"Dcpmwrve{"Eqwtv"ku"CHHKTOGF0 DCEMITQWPF Vjku"ocvvgt"kpxqnxgu"vyq"fkuvkpev"dwv"tgncvgf"eqorcpkgu."Rcfeq"Gpgti{"Ugtxkegu."N0N0E0 *$Gpgti{$+."cpf"Rcfeq"Rtguuwtg"Eqpvtqn"*$Rtguuwtg$+0"Rtguuwtg."cp"chhknkcvg"qh"Gpgti{."ycu "Fwg"vq"c"lwfkekcn"xcecpe{"kp"vjg"Yguvgtp"Fkuvtkev"qh"Nqwkukcpc."vjgug"ocvvgtu"ygtg tgcuukipgf"vq"vjg"wpfgtukipgf"qp"Lwn{"48."423:0"Ekxkn"Cevkqp"39/::6."Tge0"Fqe0"3;="Ekxkn"Cevkqp 39/::7."Tge0"Fqeu0"48"("490 3 3 Dockets.Justia.com hqtogf"kp"Crtkn"4237."ykvj"ogodgtu"Lcuqp"Hctpgnn"*62'"qypgtujkr+"cpf"Okejcgn"Ectt"*82' qypgtujkr+0"Hctpgnn"ycu"vq"twp"vjg"fc{"vq"fc{"qrgtcvkqpu"qh"vjg"eqorcp{."fwg"vq"jku"rtgxkqwu gzrgtkgpeg"ykvj"vjg"ÐhnqydcemÑ"rtqeguu0 Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"*jgtgkpchvgt."eqnngevkxgn{"uqogvkogu"$Rcfeq$"qt"$fgdvqtu$+"cnngig vjcv"htqo"vkog"vq"vkog"dgvyggp"Crtkn"52."4236"cpf"Ugrvgodgt"46."4237."Rtguuwtg"*dwv"pqv Gpgti{+"rwtejcugf"ocvgtkcnu"htqo"Ecug0"Kp"Pqxgodgt"qh"4237."Ectt"ycu"kphqtogf"qh"c rqvgpvkcnn{"uwurkekqwu"tgncvkqpujkr"dgvyggp"Ecug"cpf"Hctpgnn0"Vjg"oqpvj"dghqtg."Ectt"jcf"jktgf gornq{ggu"vq"eqpfwev"c"tgxkgy"qh"cnn"Rtguuwtg"kpxqkegu"cpf"hkpcpekcn"uvcvgogpvu0"Vjku"tgxkgy tgxgcngf"pwogtqwu"fkuetgrcpekgu."kpenwfkpi"fwrnkecvgf"ugtkcn"pwodgtu"qp"gswkrogpv"rwtejcugf htqo"Ecug."fqwdng"dknnkpi."dknnkpi"hqt"kpxgpvqt{"vjcv"ycu"pgxgt"tgegkxgf."cpf"dknnkpi"uvcvgogpvu vjcv"fkf"pqv"ocvej"vjg"ukipgf"kpxqkegu"hqt"rtqfwevu"tgegkxgf"Î"cnn"htqo"Ecug0 Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"hwtvjgt"cnngig"vjcv"kp"tgurqpug"vq"kpswktkgu"vq"Ecug"tgictfkpi"vjg fkuetgrcpekgu"kp"kpxqkegu"cpf"ugtkcn"pwodgtu."Rtguuwtg"ycu"ikxgp"cnvgtgf"kpxqkegu."ykvj"fkhhgtgpv ugtkcn"pwodgtu0"Jqygxgt."ocp{"qh"vjg"pgy"ugtkcn"pwodgtu"fkf"pqv"ocvej"wr"ykvj"kpxgpvqt{0 Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi"vjgug"fkuetgrcpekgu."Ecug"kuuwgf"ytkvvgp"fgocpf"wrqp"Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"hqt vjg"uwo"qh"&3.458.34408;0"Jqygxgt."dcugf"wrqp"vjg"tgxkgy"qh"vjg"kpxqkegu."Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{ cnngig"vjcv"Ecug"qxgt/dknngf"Rtguuwtg"d{"&744.98;08;0"Vjg{"hwtvjgt"cnngig"vjcv"qh"vjg"&935.575022 vjcv"ujqwnf"jcxg"dggp"dknngf."Ecug"jcu"dggp"rckf"&:27.;:9097."tgrtgugpvkpi"cp"qxgtrc{ogpv"d{ Rtguuwtg"qh"&;4.856097."yjkej"Rtguuwtg"uggmu"vq"jcxg"tgvwtpgf0" Dgikppkpi"qp"Oc{"6."4238."Ecug"hkngf"nkgpu"cickpuv"dqvj"Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"*cpf qvjgtu+."qp"vjktv{/ukz"qkn"cpf"icu"ygnnu"kp"xctkqwu"rctkujgu"kp"Nqwkukcpc"cpf"eqwpvkgu"kp"gcuvgtp Vgzcu."gcej"kp"vjg"coqwpv"qh"&3.422.222022."hqt"uwou"cnngigfn{"fwg"kv"d{"Rtguuwtg0"Ecug"enckogf 4 vjcv"c"rtkxkngig"ycu"guvcdnkujgf"rwtuwcpv"vq"Nc0"T0U0"6:83."gv"ugs0."d{"xktvwg"qh"oqxcdngu"yjkej"kv jcf"uqnf"vq"cp"qrgtcvqt"qt"eqpvtcevqt"qt"fgnkxgtgf"vq"c"ygnn/ukvg0" Kp"eqpvtcuv."Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"cnngig"vjcv"vjg"ncuv"ocvgtkcnu"rwtejcug"htqo"Ecug"ycu"qp Ugrvgodgt"46."4237."vjg"rwtejcug"ycu"d{"Rtguuwtg."pqv"Gpgti{."cpf"vjcv"vjg"nkgpu."pqv"tgeqtfgf wpvkn"Oc{"6."4238"ygtg"wpvkogn{0"Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"hwtvjgt"cnngig"vjcv"vjg"nkgpu"ygtg"cnuq ngxkgf"cickpuv"pwogtqwu"ygnnu"vq"yjkej"Gpgti{"pgxgt"fgnkxgtgf"cp{"gswkrogpv"rwtejcugf"htqo Ecug."cpf"vjcv"vjg"nkgpu"ctg"vjgtghqtg"kpxcnkf"cpf"ykvjqwv"ghhgev0"Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"cnuq eqpvgpf"vjcv"vjg"nkgpu"ctg"kpxcnkf"dgecwug"vjg{"ctg"pqv"nkokvgf"vq"cevwcn"yqtm"rgthqtogf"qp"gcej ygnn."cpf"gcej"nkgp"ku"hqt"cp"kfgpvkecn"coqwpv"qh"&304"oknnkqp="pq"nkgp"ku"cnnqygf"hqt"gswkrogpv uqnf"kh"vjg"gswkrogpv"ku"ogtgn{"wugf"qp"c"ygnn"cpf"pqv"ÐeqpuwogfÑ"d{"vjg"ygnn="cpf"kp"vjku"ecug. cnn"qh"vjg"cnngigf"gswkrogpv"ycu"pgxgt"ÐeqpuwogfÑ"d{"qt"fgnkxgtgf"vq"vjg"nkgpgf"ygnn"d{"Gpgti{ qt"Rtguuwtg."dwv"yknn"rtguwocdn{"ncuv"hqt"ocp{"{gctu="cpf"vjg"nkgpu"eqpvckp"pq"cnnqecvkqp"qh"yjkej Rtguuwtg""gswkrogpv"ycu"wugf"qp"yjkej"ygnn0" Qp"Lwpg"36."4238."Ecug"hkngf"c"rgvkvkqp"kp"vjg"48vj"Lwfkekcn"Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"hqt"vjg"Rctkuj qh"Dquukgt"cickpuv"vjg"fgdvqtu"cpf"qvjgt"fghgpfcpvu"hqt"cnngigf"coqwpvu"qygf"hqt"gswkrogpv"uqnf vq"fgdvqtu."cu"ygnn"cu"cnvgt"giq"enckou"cpf"tgeqipkvkqp"qh"vjg"nkgpu"*vjg"$uvcvg"eqwtv"uwkv$+0"Qp Qevqdgt"6."4238."Gpgti{"cpf"Rtguuwtg"hkngf"hqt"tgnkgh"wpfgt"Ejcrvgt"33"qh"vjg"Dcpmtwrve{"Eqfg kp"vjg"Yguvgtp"Fkuvtkev"qh"Nqwkukcpc."Nchc{gvvg"Fkxkukqp0 Qp"Lwn{"34."4239."Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{"gcej"hkngf"cfxgtuct{"rtqeggfkpiu."cnngikpi"vjcv Ecug"cpf"Hctpgnn"gpicigf"kp"u{uvgocvke"cpf"qpiqkpi"htcwfwngpv"dwukpguu"rtcevkegu"kp"cp"ghhqtv"vq fghtcwf"Rtguuwtg0"Vjg"uwkvu"hwtvjgt"cnngig"vjcv"vjg"nkgpu"ygtg"ytqpihwnn{"hkngf."ecwukpi"fcocigu fwg"vq"nquu"qh"ewuvqogtu."dwukpguu."cpf"tgncvkqpujkru0"Gpgti{"cpf"Rtguuwtg"uggm."kpvgt"cnkc. 5 fkuuqnwvkqp"qh"cnn"nkgpu"ytqpihwnn{"hkngf"d{"Ecug."cpf"fcocigu"cpf"cvvqtpg{u)"hggu"wpfgt"vjg Nqwkukcpc"Wphckt"Vtcfg"Rtcevkegu"Cev."Nc0"T0u0"73<3623."gv"ugs0"*$NWVRC$+0 Kp"tgurqpug."Ecug"hkngf"kvu"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu."ctiwkpi"vjcv"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"ncemgf lwtkufkevkqp."vjcv"Gpgti{"cpf"Rtguuwtg"ncem"uvcpfkpi"vq"ejcnngpig"vjg"nkgpu.""cpf"vjcv"rnckpvkhh"jcu hckngf"vq"uvcvg"c"encko"wpfgt"NWVRC"qt"cp{"qvjgt"xkcdng"vjgqt{"qh"tgeqxgt{"hqt"fcocigu"tguwnvkpi htqo"vjg"hknkpi"qh"vjg"nkgpu."pqt"ctg"vjg{"gpvkvngf"vq"cvvqtpg{)u"hggu0"Ecug"cnuq"oqxgf"hqt"cp"kpvtc/ fkuvtkev"vtcpuhgt"htqo"Nchc{gvvg"vq"Ujtgxgrqtv."cpf"hqt"c"oqtg"fghkpkvg"uvcvgogpv"qh"vjg"htcwf enckou0"Vjg"Dcpmtwrve{"Eqwtv"fgpkgf"cnn"vjg"tgnkgh"tgswguvgf."gzegrv"vjcv"kv"qtfgtgf"vjcv"vjg"htcwf enckou"dg"tg/rngcfgf"ykvj"oqtg"urgekhkekv{0"Vjg"kpuvcpv"vkogn{"crrgcn"hqnnqygf0"Hkpfkpi"vjcv"vjg Dcpmtwrve{"Eqwtv"fkf"pqv"gtt."vjg"eqwtv"chhktou"kvu"twnkpi0 UVCPFCTF"QH"TGXKGY Fkuvtkev"eqwtvu"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"jcxg"lwtkufkevkqp"vq"jgct"crrgcnu"htqo"qtfgtu"qh"vjg dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv0"Ugg"4:"W0U0E0"¸"37:*c+0"Ð]E_qpenwukqpu"qh"ncy"ctg"tgxkgygf"fg"pqxq."hkpfkpiu qh"hcev"ctg"tgxkgygf"hqt"engct"gttqt."cpf"okzgf"swguvkqpu"qh"hcev"cpf"ncy"ctg"tgxkgygf"fg"pqxq0Ñ Kp"tg"Pcv)n"I{ruwo"Eq0."42:"H05f"6;:."726"*7vj"Ekt0"4222+0 FKUEWUUKQP Vjg"jgctkpi"qh"vjku"ocvvgt"ycu"jgnf"qp"Lwpg"49."4239."chvgt"yjkej"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv kuuwgf"kvu"qtcn"qtfgt"cpf"tgcuqpu"htqo"vjg"dgpej0"Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv<"*3+"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"oqvkqp vq"fkuokuu"hqt"ncem"qh"uwdlgev"ocvvgt"lwtkufkevkqp="*4+"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"Hgfgtcn"Twng"34*d+*3+"oqvkqp vq"fkuokuu"hqt"ncem"qh"uvcpfkpi="*5+"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"Hgfgtcn"Twng"34*d+*8+"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu Rcfeq)u"NWVRC"enckou"cpf"hqt"cvvqtpg{u)"hggu="cpf"*6+"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"oqvkqp"hqt"kpvtc/fkuvtkev vtcpuhgt"rwtuwcpv"vq"4:"W0U0E0"¸3626*d+0" 6 30" Lwtkufkevkqp Ecug"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"ncemgf"lwtkufkevkqp"qxgt"vjgug"cfxgtuct{ rtqeggfkpiu"dgecwug"fgdvqtu"uggm"fkuuqnwvkqp"qh"nkgpu"qp"rtqrgtv{"yjkej"ku"pqv"qypgf"pqt qrgtcvgf"d{"fgdvqtu."cpf"vjwu"kv"ku"pqv"rctv"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"guvcvg0 Vkvng"4:"W0U0E0"¸"3556*d+"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"Ðvjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtvu"ujcnn"jcxg"qtkikpcn"dwv"pqv gzenwukxg"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"cnn"ekxkn"rtqeggfkpiu"ctkukpi"wpfgt"vkvng"33."qt"ctkukpi"kp"qt"tgncvgf"vq ecugu"wpfgt"vkvng"330Ñ"Vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtvu"oc{."kp"vwtp."tghgt"Ðcp{"qt"cnn"rtqeggfkpiu"ctkukpi"wpfgt vkvng"33"qt"ctkukpi"kp"qt"tgncvgf"vq"c"ecug"wpfgt"vkvng"330"0"0"vq"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"lwfigu"hqt"vjg fkuvtkev0Ñ"4:"W0U0E0"¸"379*c+0" Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu"hqt"ncem"qh"uwdlgev"ocvvgt lwtkufkevkqp."dcugf"qp"kvu"hkpfkpi"vjcv"gxgp"kh"vjg"nkgpgf"ygnnu"ygtg"pqv"rctv"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{ guvcvg."tguqnwvkqp"qh"vjg"fkurwvg"cnngigf"kp"vjg"cfxgtuct{"rtqeggfkpiu"eqwnf"chhgev"vjg"dcpmtwrve{ guvcvg0"Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"cnuq"pqvgf"vjcv"vjg"fgdvqtu)"ecwugu"qh"cevkqp"ygtg"rctv"qh"vjg"guvcvg0 Vjku"eqwtv"citggu0 Cu"pqvgf"d{"vjg"Hkhvj"Ektewkv"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu."$]v_"jg"ueqrg"qh"rtqrgtv{"tkijvu"cpf kpvgtguvu"kpenwfgf"kp"c"dcpmtwrve{"guvcvg"ku"xgt{"dtqcf<"Vjg"eqpfkvkqpcn."hwvwtg."urgewncvkxg."qt gswkvcdng"pcvwtg"qh"cp"kpvgtguv"fqgu"pqv"rtgxgpv"kv"htqo"dgkpi"rtqrgtv{"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"guvcvg0$ Ocvvgt"qh"Mgor."74"H05f"768."772"*7vj"Ekt03;;7+="ugg"cnuq."Kp"tg"Lc||ncpf."Kpe0."544"D0T0"832. 837"*G0F0"Nc0"4227+."chh)f."383"H0"Crr)z"658"*7vj"Ekt0"4228+0"Cp"cfxgtuct{"rtqeggfkpi"hcnnu ykvjkp"vjg"eqwtv)u"Ðtgncvgf"vqÑ"lwtkufkevkqp"kh"Ðvjg"qwveqog"qh"vjcv"rtqeggfkpi"eqwnf"eqpegkxcdn{ jcxg"cp{"ghhgev"qp"vjg"guvcvg"dgkpi"cfokpkuvgtgf"kp"dcpmtwrve{0Ñ"Kp"tg"Yqqf.":47"H04f";2.";5 *7vj"Ekt03;:9+0"Crrn{kpi"vjku"vguv"vq"vjg"rtgugpv"ecug."vjg"cfxgtuct{"eqornckpvu"ctg"uwhhkekgpvn{ 7 tgncvgf"vq"vjg"rgpfkpi"dcpmtwrve{"vq"cnnqy"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"vq"gzgtekug"lwtkufkevkqp"wpfgt"ugevkqp 35560 "Cu"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"qdugtxgf."Rtguuwtg"cpf"Gpgti{)u"cfxgtuct{"eqornckpvu"cnngig vjcv"yjgp"Ecug"hkngf"vjg"nkgpu."vjg"qypgtu1qrgtcvqtu"qh"vjqug"ygnnu"koogfkcvgn{"dgicp"guetqykpi oqpg{"vjcv"qvjgtykug"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"rckf"vq"Rtguuwtg."vjwu"eqpuvtkevkpi"kvu"ecuj"hnqy"cpf ecwukpi"fcocigu0"Rtguuwtg)u"eqornckpv"cnuq"uggmu"c"tgvwtp"qh""qxgtrc{ogpvu"ocfg"vq"Ecug0 Hkpcnn{."fgdvqtu)"ecwugu"qh"cevkqp"ctg"rctv"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"guvcvg0"Vjwu."cv"c"okpkowo."vjg dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"rquuguugu"$tgncvgf"vq$"lwtkufkevkqp"dgecwug"cflwfkecvkqp"qh"vjg"enckou"kp"vjg cfxgtuct{"rtqeggfkpiu"eqwnf"eqpegkxcdn{"chhgev"Gpgti{"cpf"Rtguuwtg)u"dcpmtwrve{"guvcvgu0 40" Uvcpfkpi Ecug"cnuq"crrgcnu"vjcv"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv)u"twnkpi"fgp{kpi"kvu"oqvkqp"vq fkuokuu"fgdvqtu)"enckou"hqt"ytqpihwn"nkgpu"cickpuv"Ecug"rwtuwcpv"vq"34*d+*3+0"$Oqvkqpu"hkngf wpfgt"Twng"34*d+*3+"qh"vjg"Hgfgtcn"Twngu"qh"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"cnnqy"c"rctv{"vq"ejcnngpig"vjg uwdlgev"ocvvgt"lwtkufkevkqp"qh"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"vq"jgct"c"ecug0Ñ""Tcookpi"x0"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu,"4:3 H05f"37:."383"*7vj"Ekt0"4223+0""ÐNcem"qh"uwdlgev"ocvvgt"lwtkufkevkqp"oc{"dg"hqwpf"kp"cp{"qpg"qh vjtgg"kpuvcpegu<"*3+"vjg"eqornckpv"cnqpg="*4+"vjg"eqornckpv"uwrrngogpvgf"d{"wpfkurwvgf"hcevu gxkfgpegf"kp"vjg"tgeqtf="qt"*5+"vjg"eqornckpv"uwrrngogpvgf"d{"wpfkurwvgf"hcevu"rnwu"vjg"eqwtv)u tguqnwvkqp"qh"fkurwvgf"hcevu0$"Kf0"Kp"c"34*d+*3+"oqvkqp."vjg"rctv{"cuugtvkpi"lwtkufkevkqp"dgctu"vjg dwtfgp"qh"rtqqh"vjcv"lwtkufkevkqp"fqgu"kp"hcev"gzkuvu0"Kf0 Kp"ocmkpi"vjgkt"ytqpihwn"nkgp"encko."fgdvqtu"ctiwgf"vjcv"Ecug)u"kortqrgt"hknkpi"qh ownvkrng"nkgpu"qp"ownvkrng"ygnnu"cetquu"Pqtvj"Nqwkukcpc"cpf"Gcuv"Vgzcu"tguwnvgf"kp"c"fgrngvkqp"qh qrgtcvkpi"ecrkvcn"cpf"tgxgpwg."cpf"vjwu"ycu"c"rctvkcn"ecwug"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"hknkpiu0"Ecug 8 ctiwgf"vjcv"fgdvqtu"jcf"pq"uvcpfkpi"vq"dtkpi"c"ytqpihwn"nkgp"encko."dgecwug"vjg{"fkf"pqv"qyp"vjg nkgpgf"ygnnu0"Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"hqwpf"vjcv"qypgtujkr"qh"vjg"nkgpgf"ygnnu"ycu"pqv"c rtgtgswkukvg"hqt"uvcpfkpi"vq"dtkpi"c"ytqpihwn"nkgp"encko0"Kp"uq"hkpfkpi."kv"rqkpvgf"vq"R"("C"Ygnn Ugtx0"Kpe0"x0"Dncemkg)u"Rqygt"Uykxgnu"Kpe0."729"Uq0"4f"4:2."4:3"*Nc0"Crr0"5tf"Ekt0+."ytkv"fgpkgf. 735"Uq0"4f"4::"*Nc0"3;:9+0" Kp"vjcv"ecug."Dncemkg)u"ngcugf"cp"qkn"hkgnf"ftknnkpi"vqqn"ecnngf"c"rqygt"uykxgn"vq"Hkujkpi Vqqn"hqt"&622"rgt"fc{0"Hkujkpi"Vqqn"vjgp"tgpvgf"vjg"rqygt"uykxgn"vq"R(C."c"ygnn"eqpvtcevqt."hqt wug"kp"kvu"yqtmqxgt"qrgtcvkqp0"R(C"wugf"vjg"uykxgn"qpn{"vyq"fc{u."tgvwtpgf"kv"vq"Hkujkpi"Vqqn. cpf"rckf"vjg"citggf"wrqp"tgpvcn0"Jqygxgt."Hkujkpi"Vqqn"fkf"pqv"tgvwtp"vjg"uykxgn"vq"Dncemkg)u"hqt cnoquv"vyq"cpf"jcnh"oqpvju."kpewttkpi"c"&4;.;52"dknn"hqt"vjg"rqygt"uykxgn"tgpvgf"vq"kv"cpf rwtrqtvgfn{"wugf"d{"R(C0"Dncemkg)u"hkngf"c"nkgp"pqvkeg"cickpuv"egtvckp"qkn1icu"ngcugu"yjgtg"R(C ycu"rgthqtokpi"yqtmqxgt"qrgtcvkqpu"kp"Uv0"Octvkp"Rctkuj0"R(C"vjgp"hkngf"uwkv"cickpuv"Dncemkg)u hqt"ecpegnncvkqp"qh"vjg"nkgp"cpf"fcocigu"htqo"hknkpi"cp"kortqrgt"nkgp0"Dncemkg)u"cpuygtgf"cpf tgeqpxgpgf"cickpuv"R(C"hqt"tgeqipkvkqp"qh"vjg"nkgp"cpf"rc{ogpv"qh"vjg"tgpv"fwg"qp"vjg"rqygt uykxgn0"Chvgt"fkueqxgt{"fgrqukvkqpu"ygtg"vcmgp."Dncemkg)u"uwduvkvwvgf"vjg"Fqy"Ejgokecn"Pq0"3 ygnn"hqt"vjg"qtkikpcnn{"pcogf"ygnn."cpf"cffgf"Gfyctf"cpf"Octictgv"Guvku."qypgtu"qh"vjg"qkn"ygnn cpf"uqng"uvqemjqnfgtu"qh"R(C."cu"fghgpfcpvu"ykvj"R(C0 Yjkng"vjg"uwkv"ygpv"vq"lwfiogpv"qp"qvjgt"kuuwgu"kttgngxcpv"vq"vjg"ecug"cv"dct."vjg dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"ekvgf"cpf"fkuewuugf"vjg"R(C"Ygnn"Ugtxkeg"ecug"cu"cp"gzcorng"kp"yjkej"uwkv ycu"dtqwijv"d{"c"pqp/qypgt"eqpvtcevqt"hqt"ytqpihwn"hknkpi"qh"nkgpu"qp"c"ygnn."cpf"pq"uvcpfkpi kuuwg"ycu"tckugf0"Kp"R(C"Ygnn"Ugtxkeg."pgkvjgt"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"pqt"vjg"crrgnncvg"eqwtv"vqqm kuuwg"ykvj"vjg"rnckpvkhh)u"uvcpfkpi"vq"rwtuwg"c"encko"hqt"ytqpihwn"hknkpi"qh"vjg"nkgpu."qt"uwiiguv 9 vjcv"cu"c"pqp/qypgt"vjg"eqpvtcevqt"eqwnf"pqv"rwtuwg"uwej"c"encko0"Cpf."cu"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv qdugtxgf."yjkng"vjg"hcevu"kp"R(C"Ygnn"Ugtxkeg"fkhhgt"unkijvn{"htqo"vjg"kpuvcpv"ecug"kp"vjcv"vjg uqng"uvqemjqnfgtu"qh"vjg"eqpvtcevqt"ygtg"cnuq"qypgtu"kp"vjg"qkn"cpf"icu"ygnnu."uvqemjqnfgtu"qh"c eqorcp{"ctg"fkuvkpev"htqo"vjg"eqorcp{"kvugnh."cpf"kp"R(C"Ygnn"Ugtxkeg."vjg"rctv{"dtkpikpi"vjg cevkqp"ycu"vjg"eqpvtcevqt"cpf"pqv"vjg"ygnn"qypgtu0" Vjg"eqwtv"ku"cnuq"wprgtuwcfgf"d{"vjg"tgcuqpkpi"qh"Igpkpc"Octkpg"Ugtxkegu"Kpe0"x0"Cteq Qkn"("Icu"Eq0."yjkej"jgnf"vjcv"$]v_jg"Qkn"Ygnn"Nkgp"Cev"]$NQYNC$_"fqgu"pqv"etgcvg"cp{ rgtuqpcn"qdnkicvkqpu0"Vjg"cev"itcpvu"c"rtkxkngig"qxgt"egtvckp"rtqrgtv{"vq"egtvckp"rgqrng0$"774""Uq0 4f"3227."322:"*Nc0"Crr"3"Ekt0"3;:;+0"Igpkpc"Octkpg"ku"kpcrrqukvg"dgecwug"kv"kpxqnxgf"cp"cevkqp cickpuv"c"ygnn"qypgt"uggmkpi"tgeqipkvkqp"cpf"gphqtegogpv"qh"c"NQYNC"nkgp0"Kv"ku"kpcrrnkecdng"vq vjg"rtgugpv"ecug"kp"yjkej"c"pqp/qypgt1eqpvtcevqt"uggmu"fcocigu"hqt"vjg"kortqrgt"hknkpi"qh"nkgpu qp"vjg"dcuku"vjcv"vjg{"ygtg"kortqxkfgpvn{"cpf"ocnkekqwun{"hkngf"gzrtguun{"vq"ecwug"fcocigu"vq vjg"eqpvtcevqt0"Rcfeq"ku"pqv"cvvgorvkpi"vq"dtkpi"cp{"v{rg"qh"cevkqp"wpfgt"NQYNC."tcvjgt."kv"ku dtkpikpi"cp"cevkqp"wpfgt"NWVRC"ctiwkpi"vjcv"vjg"fgegrvkxg"rtcevkeg"xkqncvg"qh"NWVRC"ycu"vjg ocnkekqwu"cpf"kortqxkfgpv"hknkpi"nkgpu"qp"ygnnu0""Cpf."cu"pqvgf"d{"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"lwfig."Ecug jcu"rqkpvgf"vq"pq"ngicn"cwvjqtkv{"hqt"vjg"rtqrqukvkqp"vjcv"qpn{"c"ygnn"qypgt"oc{"uggm"c"tgogf{ hqt"fcocigu"ecwugf"d{"vjg"ytqpihwn"hknkpi"qh"c"nkgp0 50" Nqwkukcpc"Wphckt"Vtcfg"Rtcevkegu"Cev Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"cnuq"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"34*d+*8+"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu"fgdvqtu)"enckou"wpfgt vjg"Nqwkukcpc"Wphckt"Vtcfg"Rtcevkegu"Cev."Nc0"T0U0"73<3623."gv"ugs0"*$NWVRC$+0" Twng"34*d+*8+"qh"vjg"Hgfgtcn"Twngu"qh"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"rgtokvu"c"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu"c eqornckpv"hqt"hcknwtg"vq"uvcvg"c"encko"wrqp"yjkej"tgnkgh"ecp"dg"itcpvgf0""Vq"uwtxkxg"c"Twng : 34*d+*8+"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu."gpqwij"hcevu"vq"uvcvg"c"encko"hqt"tgnkgh"vjcv"ku"rncwukdng"qp"kvu"hceg owuv"dg"rngcfgf0"Kp"tg"Mcvtkpc"Ecpcn"Dtgcejgu"Nkvki0."6;7"H05f"3;3."427"*7vj"Ekt0"4229+"*swqvkpi Dgnn"Cvn0"x0"Vyqodn{."349"U0Ev0"3;77."3;86/87"("3;95"p0"36"*4229++0""C"encko"ku"rncwukdng"qp"kvu hceg"yjgp"vjg"rnckpvkhh"rngcfu"hcevu"htqo"yjkej"vjg"eqwtv"ecp"Ðftcy"vjg"tgcuqpcdng"kphgtgpeg"vjcv vjg"fghgpfcpv"ku"nkcdng"hqt"vjg"okueqpfwev"cnngigf0Ñ"Cujetqhv"x0"Ksdcn."34;"U0Ev0"3;59."3;6; *422;+0"ÐHcevwcn"cnngicvkqpu"owuv"dg"gpqwij"vq"tckug"c"tkijv"vq"tgnkgh"cdqxg"vjg"urgewncvkxg"ngxgn. qp"vjg"cuuworvkqp"vjcv"cnn"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"kp"vjg"eqornckpv"ctg"vtwg"*gxgp"kh"fqwdvhwn"kp"hcev+0Ñ Vyqodn{."349"U0Ev0"cv"3;870""Vjg"eqwtv"Ðowuv"ceegrv"cnn"ygnn/rngcfgf"hcevu"cu"vtwg"cpf"xkgy vjgo"kp"vjg"nkijv"oquv"hcxqtcdng"vq"vjg"pqp/oqxkpi"rctv{0Ñ"Kp"tg"U0"Uetcr"Ocvgtkcn"Eq0."NNE."763 H05f"7:6."7:9"*7vj"Ekt0"422:+0" NWVRC""fgenctgu"wpncyhwn"cp{"Ð]w_phckt"ogvjqfu"qh"eqorgvkvkqp"cpf"wphckt"qt"fgegrvkxg cevu"qt"rtcevkegu"kp"vjg"eqpfwev"qh"cp{"vtcfg"qt"eqoogteg0Ñ"Nc0"T0U0"73<3627*C+0"Ugevkqp 362;*C+"itcpvu"c"rtkxcvg"tkijv"qh"cevkqp"vq"Ð]c_p{"rgtuqp"yjq"uwhhgtu"cp{"cuegtvckpcdng"nquu"qh oqpg{"qt"oqxcdng"rtqrgtv{."eqtrqtgcn"qt"kpeqtrqtgcnÑ"cu"c"tguwnv"qh"c"NWVRC"xkqncvkqp"vq tgeqxgt"cevwcn"fcocigu"cpf."kh"uwej"fcocigu"ctg"cyctfgf."tgcuqpcdng"cvvqtpg{)u"hggu0"$Cevu yjkej"eqpuvkvwvg"c"xkqncvkqp"qh"NWVRC"ctg"pqv"urgekhkecnn{"fghkpgf"kp"vjg"uvcvwvg"cpf"ctg"kpuvgcf fgvgtokpgf"d{"eqwtvu"qp"c"ecug/d{/ecug"dcuku0$"Iwnh"Eqcuv"Jqwu0"("Fgx0"Eqtr0"x0"Ecrkvcn"Qpg. 425"Uq0"5f"588."593"*Nc0"Crr0"6"Ekt0"3217138+"*ekvkpi"Swcnkv{"Gpxktqpogpvcn"Rtqeguugu."Kpe0"x0 K0R0"Rgvtqngwo"Eq0."Kpe0.366"Uq0"5f"3233."3247"*Nc0"719136++0 Kp"fgp{kpi"Ecug)u"oqvkqp"vq"fkuokuu"vjg"NWVRC"enckou."vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"qdugtxgf vjcv"vjg"dwnm"qh"Ecug)u"ctiwogpv"tguvgf"qp"vjg"vjgqt{"vjcv"dgecwug"fgdvqtu"ygtg"pqv"Ecug)u eqorgvkvqtu."NWVRC"fqgu"pqv"crrn{"vq"vjgo0"Jqygxgt."cu"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"pqvgf."NWVRC ; itcpvu"c"tkijv"qh"cevkqp"vq"any person."$pcvwtcn"qt"lwtkfkecn."yjq"uwhhgtu"cp"cuegtvckpcdng"nquu"cu"c tguwnv"qh"cpqvjgt"rgtuqp)u"wug"qh"wphckt"ogvjqfu"qh"eqorgvkvkqp"cpf"wphckt"qt"fgegrvkxg"cevu"qt rtcevkegu"kp"vjg"eqpfwev"qh"cp{"vtcfg"qt"eqoogteg$="kv"ku"pqv"nkokvgf"vq"dwukpguu"eqpuwogtu"cpf eqorgvkvqtu0"Ejgtcokg"Ugtxu0."Kpe0"x0"Ujgnn"Fggrycvgt"Rtqf0."Kpe0."57"Uq0"5f"3275."3279"*Nc0 6145132+0"Oqtgqxgt."vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"pqvgf"vjcv"kp"kvu"uwtxg{"qh"ecug/d{/ecug"fgvgtokpcvkqpu qh"yjcv"swcnkhkgu"*qt"fqgu"pqv+"cu"c"NWVRC"xkqncvkqp."pq"eqwtv"jcu"hqwpf"cu"c"ocvvgt"qh"ncy"vjcv vjg"ytqpihwn"hknkpi"qh"c"nkgp"oc{"pqv"dg"eqpukfgtgf"c"fgegrvkxg"rtcevkeg"wpfgt"NWVRC0"Yjkng vjku"eqwtv"tgeqipk|gu"vjcv"vjg"tcpig"qh"rtqjkdkvgf"rtcevkegu"wpfgt"NWVRC"ku"gzvtgogn{"pcttqy *ugg"Ejgtcokg."57"Uq0"5f"cv"3282+."vjg"ikuv"qh"fgdvqtu)"eqornckpvu"kp"vjgug"cfxgtuct{"rtqeggfkpiu ku"vjcv"Ecug"eqpurktgf"ykvj"Hctpgnn"*c"eqorcp{"fktgevqt+."vq"qxgtdknn"fgdvqtu."cpf"yjgp ejcnngpigf."hkngf"kortqrgt"nkgpu"qp"ygnnu"ykvj"yjkej"fgdvqtu"fkf"dwukpguu"kp"cp"ghhqtv"vq"ejqmg qhh"vjgkt"ecuj"hnqy."vjwu"ftkxkpi"vjgo"qwv"qh"dwukpguu"cpf"jcuvgpkpi"vjgkt"dcpmtwrve{"hknkpiu0 Crrn{kpi"vjg"34*d+*8+"uvcpfctf."cpf"ceegrvkpi"cu"vtwg"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"qh"vjg"cfxgtuct{ eqornckpvu."vjg"eqwtv"hkpfu"vjcv"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"fkf"pqv"gtt"kp"fgp{kpi"Ecug)u"oqvkqp"vq fkuokuu"vjg"NWVRC"enckou0 60" Xgpwg"/"Kpvtc/fkuvtkev"vtcpuhgt Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"cnuq"fgpkgf"Ecug)u"oqvkqp"hqt"cp"kpvtc/fkuvtkev"vtcpuhgt"htqo Nchc{gvvg"vq"Ujtgxgrqtv."urgekhkecnn{"hkpfkpi"vjcv"Ecug"jcf"pqv"ogv"kvu"dwtfgp"qh"ujqykpi"vjcv"vjg crrnkecdng"hcevqtu"kp"vjku"ecug"engctn{"ygkijgf"kp"hcxqt"qh"c"vtcpuhgt"htqo"Nchc{gvvg"vq Ujtgxgrqtv0"Vjg"kuuwg"rtgugpvu"c"okzgf"swguvkqp"qh"ncy"cpf"hcev"cpf"ku"vjgtghqtg"tgxkgygf"fg pqxq0"Kp"tg"Pcv)n"I{ruwo"Eq0."42:"H05f"cv"7260" Vkvng"4:"W0U0E0"ugevkqp"3626*c+"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"Ð]h_qt"vjg"eqpxgpkgpeg"qh"rctvkgu"cpf 32 ykvpguugu."kp"vjg"kpvgtguv"qh"lwuvkeg."c"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"oc{"vtcpuhgt"cp{"ekxkn"cevkqp"vq"cp{"qvjgt fkuvtkev"qt"fkxkukqp"yjgtg"kv"okijv"jcxg"dggp"dtqwijv0Ñ"Vjg"rwtrqug"qh"vjg"uvcvwvg"ku"vq"rtgxgpv ycuvg"Ðqh"vkog."gpgti{"cpf"oqpg{Ñ"cpf"Ðvq"rtqvgev"nkvkicpvu."ykvpguugu"cpf"vjg"rwdnke"cickpuv wppgeguuct{"kpeqpxgpkgpeg"cpf"gzrgpug0Ñ"Eqpv)n"Itckp"Eq0"x0"Vjg"HDN/7:7."586"W0U0"3;."48/49 *3;82+0"Vq"fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"c"vtcpuhgt"qh"xgpwg"rwtuwcpv"vq"4:"W0U0E0"¸"3626*c+"ku"ycttcpvgf. eqwtvu"eqpukfgt"dqvj"rtkxcvg"cpf"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"hcevqtu0"Kp"tg"Xqnmuycigp."767"H05f"526."537 *7vj"Ekt0"422:+0"Vjg"ucog"eqpukfgtcvkqpu"crrn{"yjgp."cu"jgtg."vjg"vtcpuhgt"uqwijv"ku"ykvjkp"vjg ucog"fkuvtkev0"Ugg"Kp"tg"Tgfocz."Nvf0."942"H05f"4:7."4:8"*7vj"Ekt0"4235+0 Vjg"rtkxcvg"kpvgtguv"hcevqtu"ctg<"*3+"vjg"tgncvkxg"gcug"qh"ceeguu"vq"uqwtegu"qh"rtqqh="*4+"vjg cxckncdknkv{"qh"eqorwnuqt{"rtqeguu"vq"ugewtg"vjg"cvvgpfcpeg"qh"ykvpguugu="*5+"vjg"equv"qh cvvgpfcpeg"hqt"yknnkpi"ykvpguugu."cpf"*6+"cnn"qvjgt"rtcevkecn"rtqdngou"vjcv"ocmg"vtkcn"qh"c"ecug gcu{."gzrgfkvkqwu"cpf"kpgzrgpukxg0"Vjg"rwdnke"kpvgtguv"hcevqtu"ctg<"*3+"vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkxg fkhhkewnvkgu"hnqykpi"htqo"eqwtv"eqpiguvkqp="*4+"vjg"nqecn"kpvgtguv"kp"jcxkpi"nqecnk|gf"kpvgtguvu fgekfgf"cv"jqog="*5+"vjg"hcoknkctkv{"qh"vjg"hqtwo"ykvj"vjg"ncy"vjcv"yknn"iqxgtp"vjg"ecug="cpf"*6+ vjg"cxqkfcpeg"qh"wppgeguuct{"rtqdngou"qh"eqphnkev"qh"ncyu"]qt"kp_"kp"vjg"crrnkecvkqp"qh"hqtgkip ncy0"Kp"tg"Xqnmuycigp."767"H05f"cv"537"*ekvkpi"Iwnh"Qkn"Eqtr0"x0"Ikndgtv."89"U0"Ev0":5;.":65 *3;69++"*kpvgtpcn"ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0 ÐVjg"oqxkpi"rctv{"dgctu"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"vjg"ecug"ujqwnf"dg"vtcpuhgttgf vq"cp"cnvgtpcvg"hqtwo0Ñ"Vkog."Kpe0"x0"Ocppkpi."588"H04f"8;2."8;:"*7vj"Ekt0"3;88+0""Vq"lwuvkh{"c vtcpuhgt."vjg"cnvgtpcvkxg"xgpwg"owuv"dg"$engctn{"oqtg"eqpxgpkgpv$"vjcp"vjg"ejqugp"xgpwg0"Kp"tg Xqnmuycigp."767"H05f"cv"5370"ÐYjgp"vjg"vtcpuhgtgg"hqtwo"ku"pq"oqtg"eqpxgpkgpv"vjcp"vjg ejqugp"hqtwo."vjg"rnckpvkhh)u"ejqkeg"ujqwnf"pqv"dg"fkuvwtdgf0Ñ"Kp"tg"Xqnmuycigp"qh"Co0"Kpe0."728 33 H05f"598."5:6"*7vj"Ekt04229+0"Vjku"eqwtv"citggu"ykvj"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"vjcv kp"vjku"ecug."vjg"hcevqtu"fkf"pqv"engctn{"ygkij"kp"hcxqt"qh"cp"kpvtc/fkuvtkev"vtcpuhgt"htqo"fgdvqt)u ejqkeg"qh"hqtwo."Nchc{gvvg."vq"Ujtgxgrqtv0 Ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"gcug"qh"ceeguu"vq"uqwtegu"qh"rtqqh."vjg"fgdvqt)u"qpn{"qhhkeg"ku"kp Nchc{gvvg0"Cpf."cu"urgekhkecnn{"pqvgf"d{"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv."vjg"hcev"vjcv"vjg"nqecvkqp"qh"vjg gswkrogpv"uwdlgev"vq"nkgpu"ku"kp"Okpfgp"ku"pgwvtcn"kp"vjku"ecug0"Eqwpugn"hqt"cpf"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"qh Ecug"yknn"jcxg"vq"ftkxg"htqo"vjgkt"qhhkegu"kp"Ujtgxgrqtv"vq"Okpfgp"vq"ceeguu"vjg"gswkrogpv tgictfnguu"qh"yjkej"xgpwg"ku"ejqugp0"Vjwu."vjg"hktuv"hcevqt"hcxqtu"Nchc{gvvg0 Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv)u"kpswkt{"cv"vjg"jgctkpi"hqewugf"kp"nctig"rctv"qp"vjg"cxckncdknkv{"qh eqorwnuqt{"rtqeguu"vq"ugewtg"vjg"cvvgpfcpeg"qh"ykvpguugu"yjkej"ygtg"pqv"wpfgt"vjg"eqpvtqn"qh vjg"rctvkgu0"Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"gorjcuk|gf"vjcv"ocp{"qh"vjg"ykvpguugu"ygtg"gornq{ggu"qh"vjg rctvkgu"cpf"vjwu"wpfgt"vjg"rctvkgu)"eqpvtqn."cpf"vjgtghqtg"eqwnf"dg"tgswktgf"vq"cvvgpf0"Jqygxgt."cu pqvgf"d{"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv."Ecug"eqwnf"qpn{"urgekhkecnn{"kfgpvkh{"qpg"ykvpguu."Tgdgeec Eqorvqp."yjqo"kv"enckogf"ycu"pgeguuct{"cpf"pqv"uwdlgev"vq"eqorwnuqt{"rtqeguu0"Oqtgqxgt."vjg dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"uvcvgf"qp"vjg"tgeqtf"vjcv"kv"ycu"pqv"engct"vjcv"Ou0"Eqorvqp"ycu"pqv"wpfgt"vjg eqpvtqn"qh"c"rctv{"cpf"vjwu"eqwnf"dg"tgswktgf"vq"cvvgpf0"Vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"cnuq"pqvgf"vjcv ocp{"qh"vjg"fgdvqt)u"ykvpguugu"ctg"nqecvgf"kp"Jqwuvqp."cpf"kp"pgkvjgt"ekv{"yqwnf"vjg"Jqwuvqp ykvpguugu"dg"uwdlgev"vq"eqorwnuqt{"rtqeguu0"Cpf"hkpcnn{"qp"vjku"rqkpv."vjg"Eqwtv"pqvgf"vjcv tgictfnguu"qh"yjgtg"vjg"ecug"ycu"hkngf."vjgtg"yqwnf"dg"uqog"ykvpguugu"hqt"yjkej"vjgtg"yqwnf"dg kuuwgu"cu"hct"cu"eqorgnnkpi"rtqeguu0"Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"ugeqpf"hcevqt"fqgu"pqv"engctn{"hcxqt Ujtgxgrqtv."cpf"ku"gkvjgt"pgwvtcn"qt"unkijvn{"kp"hcxqt"qh"Nchc{gvvg0 Ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"equv"qh"cvvgpfcpeg"hqt"yknnkpi"ykvpguugu."cu"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"qdugtxgf. 34 hqt"vjg"Jqwuvqp"ykvpguugu.""Nchc{gvvg"yqwnf"dg"oqtg"eqpxgpkgpv"*qt"cv"c"okpkowo."pq"nguu kpeqpxgpkgpv+"cu"c"xgpwg"vjcp"Ujtgxgrqtv."cpf"hqt"vjg"Ujtgxgrqtv"ykvpguugu."vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv hqwpf"vjcv"c"vjtgg/cpf/c/jcnh"jqwt"ftkxg"ycu"pqv"wpfwn{"dwtfgpuqog."pqvkpi"vjcv"vjg"Nchc{gvvg dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"gpvgtvckpu"ocp{"ecugu"kpxqnxkpi"Ujtgxgrqtv"etgfkvqtu"cpf"rctvkgu0"Cickp."vjku hcevqt"fqgu"pqv"ygkij"uvtqpin{"kp"hcxqt"qh"gkvjgt"xgpwg0"Pq"qvjgt"rtcevkecn"rtqdngou"ygtg kfgpvkhkgf"d{"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"vjcv"yqwnf"hcxqt"qpg"xgpwg"qxgt"vjg"qvjgt."cpf"vjg"rwdnke kpvgtguv"hcevqtu"ctg"gkvjgt"pgwvtcn"qt"kpcrrnkecdng"kp"vjku"ecug."yjkej"kpxqnxgu"c"rqvgpvkcn"vtcpuhgt ykvjkp"vjg"ucog"fkuvtkev0 Dcugf"qp"vjg"hqtgiqkpi."vjg"dcpmtwrv{"eqwtv"hqwpf."cpf"vjku"eqwtv"citggu."vjcv"Ecug"jcu pqv"ogv"kvu"dwtfgp"qh"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"vjg"hcevqtu"engctn{"ygkij"kp"hcxqt"qh"vtcpuhgttkpi"vjku ecug"vq"Ujtgxgrqtv0"Ceeqtfkpin{."vjcv"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"lwfiogpv"ku"chhktogf0 EQPENWUKQP Hqt"cnn"qh"vjg"hqtgiqkpi"tgcuqpu."vjg"twnkpi"qh"vjg"dcpmtwrve{"eqwtv"gpvgtgf"qp"Lwpg"49. 4239"ku"CHHKTOGF0 March 4;vj Pgy"Qtngcpu."Nqwkukcpc"vjku"aaaa"fc{"qh"aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa."423;0 ""aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa """"OCT["CPP"XKCN"NGOOQP """WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"LWFIG 35
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
