United States of America v. Goodrich Corporation et al, No. 5:2020cv00154 - Document 13 (W.D. Ky. 2021)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM AND OPINION by Senior Judge Thomas B. Russell on 1/27/2021; re 4 Unopposed MOTION to Approve Consent Judgment - Consent Decree. A separate order and judgment shall enter.cc:counsel (KJA)

Download PDF

United States Case of America v. Goodrich Corporation et al 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 1 of 50 PageID #: 1094 Doc. 13 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY PADUCAH DIVISION CIVIL ACTION NO. 5:20-CV-00154-TBR PLAINTIFF UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. DEFENDANTS GOODRICH CORPORATION (f.k.a. B.F. Goodrich Corporation); WESTLAKE VINYLS, INC.; and POLYONE CORPORATION MEMORANDUM OPINION Before the Court is the Unopposed Motion to Approve Consent Judgment, DN 4. For the reasons stated below, the motion is GRANTED. The Court will enter a separate Order and Judgment contemporaneous to this Memorandum Opinion. I. Background The United States instituted this action alleging that defendants Goodrich Corporation, Westlake Vinyls Incorporated, and PolyOne Corporation are liable under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980 (CERCLA), 94 Stat. 2767, as amended, 42 U.S.C. § 9601 et seq., for costs incurred and to be incurred related to the releases and threatened releases of hazardous substances at the B.F. Goodrich Superfund Site in Calvert City, Marshall County, Kentucky.1 [DN 1, Complaint]. Thereafter, the United States filed a Notice of Lodging Proposed Consent Decree, which explained, “[t]he Consent Decree resolves the United States’ claims against the Settling Defendants in the above-captioned action.” [DN 3 at 1-2]. The United States informed the Court that it would publish a notice in the Federal Register to alert the 1 Superfund Site: B.F. Goodrich, Calvert City, KY, United States Environmental Protection Agency, https://cumulis.epa.gov/supercpad/cursites/csitinfo.cfm?id=0401930 (last visited January 27, 2021). 1 Dockets.Justia.com Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 2 of 50 PageID #: 1095 public that a proposed settlement had been filed and to provide an opportunity for public comment as required by statute. Id. The United States then filed an Unopposed Motion to Approve Consent Judgment, stating that the proposed Consent Decree was published in the Federal Register on September 24, 2020, and during the subsequent 30-day period for public comment, no comments were received. [DN 4 at 3]. In the motion, the United States describes the substance of the Consent Decree as follows: Under the proposed Consent Decree, the Defendants will implement the Remedial Action for the Site selected in EPA’s Record of Decision, issued in September of 2018. Key elements of the remedy include the installation of a three-mile long subsurface barrier wall around the perimeter of the onshore contamination; collection and treatment of groundwater within the containment area; recovery of nonaqueous phase liquid (“NAPL”) from accessible onshore areas; dredging of contaminated sediments from the barge slip; closure of two ponds; recovery of NAPL from beneath the Tennessee River; and treatment of the groundwater plume beneath the river. The estimated cost of the cleanup work to be performed by the Defendants pursuant to the Consent Decree is $97,000,000. Under the Consent Decree, the Defendants have agreed to pay all of EPA’s costs incurred in overseeing the construction of the Remedial Action. In return, the United States is providing certain covenants not to sue under Sections 106 and 107 of CERCLA, 42 U.S.C. §§ 9606 or 9607, and Section 7003 of RCRA, 42 U.S.C. § 6973, with respect to the Site. In addition, the Consent Decree provides protection from contribution claims pursuant to Section 113(f)(2) of CERCLA, 42 U.S.C. § 9613(f)(2). Id. at 2-3.2 II. Legal Standards Before approving the proposed consent decree, the Court must assess whether the decree is fair, adequate, and reasonable. United States v. Akzo Coatings of America, Inc., 949 F.2d 1409, 1435 (6th Cir. 1991). A consent decree’s consistency with CERCLA and its protection of the 2 Two days after filing the Unopposed Motion to Approve Consent Judgment, DN 4, the United States filed a Notice of Errata, DN 5, notifying the Court that the cost of cleanup work cited in the motion was incorrect. [DN 5 at 1]. Though the Unopposed Motion to Approve Consent Judgment states that the estimated cost of cleanup work to be performed by the Defendants pursuant to the Consent Decree is $97,000,000, the Notice of Errata clarifies that the cost of the cleanup in the Consent Decree is $89,000,000. [DN 4 at 2; DN 5 at 1]. The Consent Decree, DN 4-1, attached to the Unopposed Motion to Approve Consent Judgment, DN 4, accurately states that the estimated cost of the remedial work to be performed is $89,000,000. [DN 4-1 at 15]. The Court held a telephonic conference with the parties on this issue to ensure that the error in the motion was merely typographical. [See DN 10]. 2 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 3 of 50 PageID #: 1096 public interest bear on a court’s assessment of fairness, adequacy, and reasonableness. Id. (citing Acushnet River & New Bedford Harbor Procs. re Alleged PCB Pollution, 712 F. Supp. 1019, 1028 (D. Mass. 1989); United States v. Ketchikan Pulp Co., 430 F. Supp. 83, 86 (D. Ala. 1977)) (“Protection of the public interest is the key consideration in assessing whether a decree is fair, reasonable and adequate.”); Ford Motor Co. v. Mich. Consol. Gas. Co., No. 08–CV–13503–DT, 2012 WL 4498112, at *4 (E.D. Mich., Sep. 28, 2012) (citing United States v. County of Muskegon, 298 F.3d 569, 580–81 (6th Cir. 2002); United States v. Lexington-Fayette Urb. Cty. Gov’t, 591 F.3d 484, 489 (6th Cir. 2010)). As the Supreme Court recently described in Atlantic Richfield Co. v. Christian, 140 S.Ct. 1335, 1345 (2020), CERCLA was enacted “to address ‘the serious environmental and health risks posed by industrial pollution,’” and “to promote the timely cleanup of hazardous waste sites and to ensure that the costs of such cleanup efforts [are] borne by those responsible for the contamination.” Id. (quoting Burlington N. & S. F. R. Co. v. United States, 556 U.S. 599, 602, (2009); CTS Corp. v. Waldburger, 573 U.S. 1, 4, (2014)). III. Discussion The first factor the Court must examine is fairness. In evaluating a consent decree’s fairness, the Sixth Circuit has considered “the strength of plaintiff's case, the good faith efforts of the negotiators, the opinions of counsel, and the possible risks involved in the litigation if the settlement is not approved.” Akzo, 949 F.2d at 1435 (citations omitted). It is notable that the Kentucky Department of Environmental Protection (KDEP) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have been working with numerous involved parties to clean up and to evaluate the further work needed at the B.F. Goodrich Site since the 1980s.3 It is clear to the Court that 3 Superfund Site: B.F. Goodrich, Calvert City, KY, Cleanup Activities, United States Environmental Protection Agency, https://cumulis.epa.gov/supercpad/SiteProfiles/index.cfm?fuseaction=second.Cleanup&id=0401930#Done (last visited January 27, 2021) (“In the late 1980s, KDEP required Goodrich to pump and treat contaminated groundwater to prevent its discharge to the river.”). 3 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 4 of 50 PageID #: 1097 much time has been dedicated to studying the issues at the B.F. Goodrich Site and developing a cleanup plan. Additionally, it appears that Goodrich Corporation, PolyOne Corporation, and Westlake Vinyls have been aware of their potential liability for more than a decade.4 Thus, it is apparent that the plaintiff’s case is strong and the defendants have had ample time to assess their exposure and negotiate their liability. The Court also takes note that in the Complaint, the United States cited the estimated value of the cleanup work under the EPA Administrator’s Record of Decision as $108 million. [DN 1 at 6]. However, the parties agreed to financial assurance of $89 million in the consent decree. [DN 4-1 at 15]. This suggests to the Court that the consent decree was reached as a result of arm’s length negotiations by good faith negotiators. Given these considerations, the Court finds that consent decree is fair. The Court next considers the adequacy and reasonableness of the consent decree. As the Sixth Circuit outlined in Akzo, the reasonableness of a consent decree may be measured by “the nature/extent of hazards; the degree to which the remedy will adequately address the hazards; possible alternatives for remedying hazards; and the extent to which the decree furthers the goals of the statute.” 949 F.2d at 1436 (citations omitted). Moreover, “[o]ne of the most important considerations when evaluating whether a proposed consent decree is reasonable is ‘the decree's likely effectiveness as a vehicle for cleansing’ the environment.” Ford Motor Co., 2012 WL 4498112, at *6 (quoting Lexington-Fayette Urb. Cty. Gov’t, 591 F.3d at 489). The time the parties have dedicated to studying the issues, developing a remedial plan, and negotiating the consent decree is, on its own, a significant indication that the cleanup measures required by the decree will be effective. Moreover, this Court must give considerable deference to the EPA in its evaluation of the issues and the planned response. Akzo, 949 F.2d at 1426 (citations omitted) 4 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Superfund Program Proposed Plan: BF Goodrich Superfund Site 2 (2017), https://semspub.epa.gov/src/document/04/11095220. 4 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 5 of 50 PageID #: 1098 (“[I]n evaluating the efforts of an agency charged with making technical judgments and weighing complex data, we must give a proper degree of deference to the agency's expertise.”). After reviewing the record documents and considering CERCLA’s goals, in addition to the considerations above, the Court finds that the consent decree is adequate and reasonable. Because the Court finds that the consent decree is fair, adequate, and reasonable, and that it complies with CERCLA and protects the public interest, the Court will grant the motion to approve the consent decree. IV. Conclusion For the reasons stated herein, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED: 1. The Unopposed Motion to Approve Consent Judgment, DN 4, is GRANTED. 2. The Court will file along with this Memorandum Opinion a signed copy of the final consent decree. 3. The Court will enter a separate Order and Judgment contemporaneous to this Memorandum Opinion. 4. The Clerk is directed to close the case. January 27, 2021 cc: counsel 5 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 6 of 50 PageID #: 1099 # ' % ' $ ' ' % ' '4"2 ' ! # ' & ' ! ! $ ' "# ' & " ' ' $" ' Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 7 of 50 PageID #: 1100 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI. XII. XIII. XIV. XV. XVI. XVII. XVIII. XIX. XX. XXI. XXII. XXIII. XXIV. XXV. XXVI. BACKGROUND ........................................................................................................1 JURISDICTION .........................................................................................................2 PARTIES BOUND .....................................................................................................2 DEFINITIONS............................................................................................................3 GENERAL PROVISIONS .........................................................................................6 PERFORMANCE OF THE WORK...........................................................................7 REMEDY REVIEW .................................................................................................10 PROPERTY REQUIREMENTS ..............................................................................10 FINANCIAL ASSURANCE ....................................................................................15 PAYMENTS FOR RESPONSE COSTS..................................................................17 INDEMNIFICATION AND INSURANCE .............................................................20 FORCE MAJEURE ..................................................................................................21 DISPUTE RESOLUTION ........................................................................................22 STIPULATED PENALTIES ....................................................................................24 COVENANTS BY PLAINTIFF...............................................................................27 COVENANTS BY SDs ............................................................................................29 EFFECT OF SETTLEMENT; CONTRIBUTION ...................................................31 ACCESS TO INFORMATION ................................................................................32 RETENTION OF RECORDS ..................................................................................33 NOTICES AND SUBMISSIONS ............................................................................34 RETENTION OF JURISDICTION..........................................................................36 APPENDICES ..........................................................................................................36 MODIFICATION .....................................................................................................36 LODGING AND OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC COMMENT ............................36 SIGNATORIES/SERVICE.......................................................................................37 FINAL JUDGMENT ................................................................................................37 ii Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 8 of 50 PageID #: 1101 W|h¨Y } hf¨V ^ h ¨ m¨@ h }d^¨ Y } hf¨V ^ h ¨ ¨bh|^ m¨ m¨ |h¨@f } } ^ ¨ m @) |h¨Y } hf¨V ^ h ¨D ¡} h ^ ¨T hd } ¨@zh d¥¨ DT@ ¨v hf¨^¨d ^} ¨} ¨ |} ¨ ^ h ¨ ^ ¨ ¨Vhd } ¨ J¨1;¨^ f¨J¨1<¨ m¨ |h¨B h|h }¡h¨D ¡} h ^ ¨Uh h ¨ B h ^ } ¨ ^ f¨O}^b} } ¥¨@d ¨ BDUBO@ ¨96¨Y)V*B)¨ >;1;¨^ f¨>;1<)¨ W|h¨Y } hf¨V ^ h ¨} ¨} ¨d ^} ¨ hh ¨ J ¨ h} b h h ¨ m¨d A+ } d hf¨b¥¨ |h¨DT@¨^ f¨ |h¨Ch ^ h ¨ m¨L }dh¨ CSL ¨x ¨ h h¨^d } ¨^ ¨ |h¨ A*F*¨ G f }d|¨V h o f¨V} h¨} ¨B^ ¡h ¨B} ¥ ¨Q^ |^ ¨B ¥ ¨ Nh d ¥¨ V} h !¨ zh |h ¨¤} |¨ ^dd hf¨} h h ?¨^ f¨ 6 ¨ h q ^ dh¨ m¨ h h¨^d } ¨b¥¨ |h¨fhql f^ ¨^ ¨ |h¨V} h¨d } h ¨ ¤} |¨ |h¨R^ } ^ ¨B } zh d¥¨T ^ ¨91¨B)F+U)¨T^ ¨711¨ RBT )¨ J ¨^dd f^ dh¨¤} |¨ |h¨RBT¨^ f¨Vhd } ¨364 F ¨ mBDUBP@"¨96¨Y*V)B* B, >;63¨ t ¨I¨ F ¨ |h¨DT@¨ }whf¨ |h¨B ¤h^ |¨ m¨Nh d ¥¨ |h¨ V ^ h ¨ ¨@ z ¨6<# 613> ¨ m¨ hz }^ } ¨¤} |¨ h }^ ¥¨ h }b h¨ ^ }h ¨ TUT ¨ hz^ f} z¨ |h¨} h h ^ } m¨ |h¨ h hf}^ ¨^d } ¨ U@ ¨x ¨ |h¨V} h$¨^ f¨ |h¨DT@¨|^ ¨ ¡}fhf¨ |h¨V ^ h¨¤} |¨^ } ¥¨ ¨ ^ }d} ^ h¨} ¨ d|¨ hz }^ } ¨^ f¨bh¨^¨ ^ ¥¨ ¨ |} ¨B h ¨Chd hh¨ BC ) J ¨^dd f^ dh¨¤} |¨Vhd } ¨466\ ¨ mBDUBO@%¨96¨Y)V)B+¨ >;662 3 &¨ |h C) DT@¨ }vhf¨ |h¨Z } hf¨V ^ h ¨F} |¨^ f¨ ]} f }pl¨Vh ¡}dh¨ ¨@ z ¨6< ¨61¨K¨> ¨ m¨ hz }^ } ¨ ¤} |¨TUT ¨ hz^ f} z¨ |h¨ h h^ h¨ m¨|^¦^ f ¨ b ^ dh ¨ |^ ¨ ^¥¨|^¡h¨ h hf¨} ¨} ¥¨ ¨ |h¨ ^ ^ ¨ h dh ¨ fh ¨mhfh ^ ¨ hh |} ¨^ f¨h d ^zhf¨ |h¨ hh ¨ ¨ ^ }d} ^ h¨} ¨ |h¨ hz }^ } ¨ m¨ |} ¨BC)¨ W|h¨fhu f^ ¨ |^ ¨|^¡h¨h h hf¨} ¨ |} ¨BC¨ Vh } z¨Chmh f^ ¨ ¨ VC E) f ¨ ¨^f } ¨^ ¥¨ }^b} } ¥¨ ¨T ^} }mr ¨^ } } z¨ ¨ m¨ |h¨ ^ ^d } ¨ ¨ dd h dh ¨^ hzhf¨} ¨ |h¨ d ^} '¨ ¨f ¨ |h¥¨^d ¤ hfzh¨ |^ ¨ |h¨ h h^ h¨ ¨ | h^ h hf¨ h h^ h¨ m¨|^¦^ f ¨ b ^ dh ¨^ ¨ ¨y ¨ |h¨V} h¨d } h ¨^ ¨} } h ¨^ f¨ b ^ }^ ¨h f^ zh h ¨ ¨ |h¨ b }d¨|h^ |¨ ¨¤h pa h¨ ¨ |h¨h ¡} h .¨ T ^ ¨ ¨Vhd } ¨41:¨ mBDUBO@ ¨96¨Y*V)B)¨ >;1:(¨ |h¨DT@¨ ^dhf¨ |h¨V} h F) ¨ |h¨R^ } ^ ¨T } } }h ¨O} ¨ RTO ¨ ¨Vh h bh ¨= ¨3>=7*¨ J ¨ h h¨ ¨^¨ h h^ h¨ ¨^¨ b ^ }^ ¨ | h^ ¨ m¨^¨ h h^ h¨ m¨^¨|^¦^ f G) b ^ dh ¨^ ¨ ¨ s ¨ |h¨V} h ¨ |h¨DT@¨^ f¨VC ¨d h dhf¨ ¨Chdh bh ¨611> ¨^¨Uh hf}^ ¨ J ¡h }z^ } ¨^ f¨Fh^ }b} } ¥¨V f¥¨ U 0FV ¨x ¨ |h¨V} h¨ ^ ¨ ¨91¨B*F*U)¨§¨811)981,¨ X|h¨DT@¨^ f¨VC ¨d h hf¨^¨Uh hf}^ ¨K ¡h }z^ } ¨ UJ ¨Uh ¨^ f¨^ H) Fh^ }b} } ¥¨V f¥¨ FV ¨Uh ¨ ¨Vh h bh ¨: ¨615=,¨ K/ T ^ ¨ ¨Vhd } ¨34<¨ mBDUBO@ ¨96¨ [-V)B)¨ >;4< ¨ |h¨DT@¨ b } |hf¨ }dh m¨ |h¨d h } ¨ m¨ |h¨FV¨^ f¨ m¨ |h¨ hf¨ ^ ¨x ¨ h hf}^ ¨^d } ¨ ¨R ¡h bh ¨613< ¨ q ¨ ¤hf¨b¥¨ }dh¨ m¨^¨ hf¨ ^ ¨^ h f h ¨} ¨M h¨614= ¨} ¨^¨ ^ ¨ d^ ¨ h¤ ^ h ¨ m¨ zh h ^ ¨d} d ^ } *¨W|h¨DT@¨ ¡}fhf¨^ ¨ } ¥¨x ¨¤ } h ¨^ f¨ ^ ¨d h ¨y ¨ |h¨ b }d¨ ¨ |h¨ hf¨ ^ ¨^ f¨ hf¨ ^ ¨^ h f h ¨x ¨ h hf}^ ¨^d } )¨@¨d ¥¨ m¨ |h¨ ^ d } ¨ m¨ |i¨ c ~e¨ jh } {¨} ¨_¢_~ _c i¨ ¨ |k¨ b }e¨_ ¨ _ ¨ n¨ |i¨`g ~ ~ _ £h¨ he f¨ Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 9 of 50 PageID #: 1102 wjie zXZDX sXJ :IVZieA` (GbZeYqsnBshk -8( :JVZhe CBrIH sXJ rJ^JDsZhe hL tXI kIrjierJ BEsZie 2 =XJ HJFZrZie C} uXJ .9) ie uXJ lJbJHZB_ BFuZie ui CJ Zbj_JbJeuJH Bu uXJ <ZuJ Zr JbCiHZJH Ze B ReB` ;JFilH iM ,JFZrZie ;7, J|JFxsJH ie <JjuJbCJl " % ie {XZFX uXJ <uBuJ XBH B lJBrieBC`J ijjiluxeZu} ui lJyZJ{ BeH FibbJeu ie {XZFX uXJ <uBuJ XBr WZyJe Zur FieFxllJeFJ >XJ ;7, ZeF`xHJr uXJ .9) r J|j`BeBuZie Ul Be} rZWeZSFBeu HZNOJlJeFJr CJu{JJe uXJ MZeB` j`Be BeH uXJ jlijirJH j_Be Br {J`a Br B lJrjierZyJeJrr rxbbBl} ui uXJ jxC`ZF FibbJeur 6iuZFJ iM uXJ TeB_ j_Be {Br jxC`ZrXJH Ze BFFilHBeFJ {ZuX <JFuZie 1 1 $ C iM +.;+4) ! ? < + &# $ C 3 *BrJH ie uXJ ZeUlbBuZie jlJrJeu_} ByBZ`BC`J ui uXJ .9) .9) CJ`ZJyJr uXBu uXJ @il] {Z_` CJ jlijJl_} BeH jlibju_} FieHxFuJH C} <,r ZM FieHxFuJH Ze BFFilHBeFJ {ZuX uXZr +, BeH Zur BjjJeHZFJr 4 <i`J_} Ul uXJ jxljirJr iM <JFuZie iM +.;+4) ! ? < + &# uXJ lJbJH} rJu UmuX Ze uXJ ;7, BeH uXJ @il] ui CJ jJlUlbJH C} <,r rXB`_ FieruZuxuJ B lJrjierJ BFuZie uB]Je il ilHJlJH C} uXJ 9lJrZHJeu Ul {XZFX [xHZFZB` lJyZJ{ rXB`_ CJ `ZbZuJH ui uXJ BHbZeZrulBuZyJ lJFilH 5 =XJ 9BluZJr lJFiWeZ~J BeH uXJ +ixmu C} JeuJlZeW uXZr +, TeHr uXBu uXZr +, XBr CJJe eJWiuZBuJH C} uXJ 9BluZJr Ze WiiH PZuX BeH Zbj`JbJeuBuZie iM uXZr +, {Z`_ J|jJHZuJ uXJ FaJBexj iM uXJ <ZuJ BeH {Z`_ ByiZH jliaieWJH BeH FibjaZFBuJH `ZuZWBuZie CJu{JJe uXJ 9BluZJr BeH uXBu uXZr +, Zr QZl lJBrieBC`J BeH Ze uXJ jxC`ZF ZeuJlJru 67@ =0.;./7;. Zu Zr XJlJC} 7lHJlJH )H[xHWJH BeH ,JFlJJH' =XZr +ixlu XBr \xlZrHZFuZie iyJl uXJ rxC[JFu bBuuJl iM uXZr BFuZie jxlrxBeu ui 1 % ? < + BeH !" BeH ! ? < + &# # &# $ BeH &# C =XZr +ixlu B_ri XBr jJlrieB` [xlZrHZFuZie iyJl <,r Ul jxmjirJr iM sXZr BFuZie <i_J`} Um uXJ jxljirJr iM uXZr +, BeH uXJ xeHJl_}ZeW Fibj`BZeur <,r {BZyJ B`` iC[JFuZier BeH HJMJerJr uXBu uXJ} bB} XByJ ui [xlZrHZFuZie iM uXJ +ixlu il ui yJexJ Ze uXZr ,ZrulZFu <,r rXB`a eiu FXB`aJeWJ uXJ uJocr iM uXZr +, il uXZr +ixmu r [xlZrHZFuZie ui JeuJl BeH JeUlFJ uXZr +, =XZr +, Zr CZeHZeW xjie uXJ ?eZuJH <uBuJr BeH xjie <,r BeH uXJZl XJZlr rxFFJrrilr BeH BrrZWer )e} FXBeWJ Ze i{eJlrXZj il FiljilBuJ il iuXJl _JWB` ruBuxr iM B <, ZeF`xHZeW Cxu eiu `ZbZuJH ui Be} ulBerMJl iM BrrJur il lJB` il jJlrieB` jlijJlu} rXBa` Ze ei {B} B`uJl rxFX <, r lJrjierZCZ`ZuZJr xeHJl uXZr +, <,r rXB_` jliyZHJ B Fij} iM uXZr +, ui JBFX FieulBFuil XZlJH ui jJlUlb uXJ @il] BeH ui JBFX jJlrie lJjlJrJeuZeW Be} <, {ZuX lJrjJFu ui uXJ <ZuJ il uXJ @il] BeH rXBa` FieHZuZie Ba` FieulBFur JeuJlJH Zeui XJlJxeHJl xjie jJlUpdBeFJ iM uXJ @il] Ze FieUlbZu} {ZuX uXJ uJlbr iM uXZr +, <,r il uXJZl FieulBFuilr rXB__ jliyZHJ {lZuuJe eiuZFJ iM uXJ +, ui B`` rxCFieulBFuilr XZlJH ui jJlUfg Be} jilvZie iM uXJ @il] <,r rXB_` eieJuXJaJrr CJ lJrjierZC_K Ul JerxlZeW uXBu Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 10 of 50 PageID #: 1103 ueYfp VmlupSVumps SlX swUVmltpSVtmps oYpcrj ueY Rmpg fl SVVmpXSlVY yfte teY tYpjs m[ uefs =>) Rfue pYdSpX um ueY SVtfxfufYs wlXYruSgYl owpswSlu um tefs => YSVe VmlupSVtmp SlX swUVmlupSVtmp seShi UY XYYjYX um UY fl S VmlupSVuwSh pYhSufmlsefo yfue N>s yftefl ueY jYSlfld m[ NYVufml A 19 U 4 m[ =?L=G< 53 P )N)=* } :719 8 4 ) PlhYss mteYpyfsY YzopYssh{ opmxfXYX fl tefs => uYpjs wsYX fl tefs => ueSu SpY 5+ XYalYX fl =?L=G< mp fl pYdwiSufmls opmjwhdStYX wlXYp =?L=F< seSih eSxY ueY jYSlfld SssfdlYX um teYj fl =?L=G< mp fl swVe pYdwiSufmls, ReYlYxYp uYpjs hfsuYX UYhmy SpY wsYX fl~ uefs => mp fus SooYlXfWYs teY cihmyfld XYblftfmls seSii Sooh{ smhYi{ cp owpomsYs m\ uefs =>; <_YVtYX KpmoYrt{ seShi jYSl Sih pYSh opmoYrt{ Su teY NftY SlX Sl{ mteYp pYSi opmoYpt{ yeYpY ueY ?K< XYtZrjflYs Su Sl{ tfjY teSu SVVYss hSlX ySuYp mp mueYp pYsmwpVY wsY pYsupfVtfmls SlX0mp BlsuftwufmlSh =mlupmis SpY lYYXYX um fjoiYjYlt teY LYjYXfSi <Vufml flVhwXfld Uwu lmt ifjfuYX um ueY ciimyfld opmoYrtfYs hmVSuYX ml teY smwueYpl sfXY m] ueY OYllZssYY LfxYp SoopmzfjStYh{ 5 jfhYs XmylsupYSj ^qmj ueY EYltwVg{ >Sj UmpXYpYX ml teY lmrue U{ teY OYllYssYY MfxYp ml ueY smwte U{ EYltwVg{ @fdeyS{ 2634 fl teY yYsu U{ SpYSs mylYX U{ <fp KpmXwVus SlX =eYjfVShs ClV- SlX =SpUfXY BlXwstpfYs GG= SlX ml teY YSsu U{ SpYSs mylYX U{ Kmi{IlY =mpompSufml Kmh{IlY HYssYp FG= HYssYp RYsthSgY Qfl{is BlV. RYsuhSgY SlX <fpVm NwoYp[wlX NfuY mylYX U{ HYssYp) =?L=G< seSii jYSl ueY =mjopYeYlsfxY ?lxfpmljYluSi LYsomlsY =mjoYlsStfml! SlX FfSUfhft{ <Vu" 53 P)N)=) }} :712(:796) =mlsYlt >YVpYY mp => seSih jZSl uefs VmlsYlt XYVpYY SlX Sii SooYlXfVYs StuSVeYX eYpYtm ifsuYX fl NYVufml Bl teY YxYlu m[ Vml[hfVu UYuyYYl uefs => SlX Sl{ SooYlXfz uefs => seShi Vmltpmh/ >S{ mp XS{ seShi jYSl S VShYlXSp XS{* Bl Vmjowtfld Sl{ oYpfmX wlXYp tefs => yeYpY teY iSsu XS{ ymwhX ^Thi ml S NSuwpXS{ NwlXS{# mp [YXYpSi mp NuStY emifXS{$ teY oYpfmX seSii pwl wltfh ueY VimsY m[ UwsflYss m[ ueY lYzu ympgfld XS{) >ID seSih jYSl ueY PlftYX NtStYs >YoSptjYlu m[ DwstfVY SlX fts swVVYssmp XYoSptkYlts% SdYlVfYs& mp flsupwjYluSiftfYs) ?`YVtfxY >StY seSih jYSl ueY XSuY woml yefVe teY SoopmxSh m[ tefs => fs pYVmpXYX ml teY =mwrv s XmVgYu) ?K< seSih jYSl teY PlftYX NuStYs ?lxfpmljYluSh KpmtYVufml <dYlV{ SlX fus swVVYssmp XYoSrtjYlus SdYlVfYs mp flsupwjYluShftfYs. ?K< @S|SpXmws NwUstSlVY NwoYp[wlX seSih jYSl teY @S|SpXmws NwUstSlVY NwoYp[wlX YstSUifseYX U{ teY BluYplSi LYxYlwY =mXY' 37 P.N)=- } :619. EJ?K seSih jYSl teY EYluwVg{ >ZoSpvjYlu ^np ?lxfpmljYluSh KpmtYVtfml SlX Sl{ swVVYssmp XYoSpvjZlts mp SdYlVfYs m[ teY NtStY* 4 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 11 of 50 PageID #: 1104 q) ) r= &6% G % !; + < ! %! ' [ Ç)') Z G %!' '% pÕ· , < ' & 6 ! ) =& & 6 sX ç <! , \ % u z ' ' K% % ),% ì ü! , , ' K& % '% ) < [ %& GX & , ) & 6 , ' ,) =& K& 6 }&= ! ) < '' )! ' ' % GX ! K | ! , ,) & = 6 &< '! [ % u z¶ % K = e q) ) r= &6%' G ' ,|) % , & ,) % H & s ! ) ! ' // p< 6 ,& ! Z } ! e Ö , & P22 3# A # * 7RL t P22+ c@ # " .D d9 Y _ E L " A H $ Iý ( l?T $ v+22 1? # ] T ] ( - È # m b " ú ( ã" B " H $ ( * 7 4 * ! ; n?- * 5 Þ {M 7 ; ( U * C í n½U L " 4 ; C * T " 4 _ // 1¾ " # /. 30 + * 3 ^ : A $ + i1 : 0¿#¹Ì9M N. Ú $¤l§ jW/±1 R .j 19 É ô E B O P++ 1# # ( a $ P++2 3@ # ( R 1 " : A ! î ! "U wÜ > C ( f èþ + 0 _ 5ø B " $ v2+2 3? # " ~ ¡ Y Z 0 ; ^ 2 # 0 - 88+ J 0 8/à 88 @ 4 º ] 7 * ` ( k c û f a ï ß Ï 7 O k 1 ( J - 4; S \ w¥Ý C ä * 5 #9´ > 1 * ð ( é * $ 8 õ # x 0 8 C " ~ " ( L 3 A H $ O( F ( /. .V/D " À:5 Q ö* ?! - d Á:ë Q * ? I - 2 ` 4 I÷ " Iÿ * 5 @E Ë $ t 5 Q Ñ + N . Ûg$ m¨ ³°Vi3 - Ø 4 ( 5 Iê á J J ` ¢ Ù 5 ù Ò + : B # * µ>>a77- -ó *> y > æ - ¸gY£ Ê $ 4 : $ x O E MM Q ¦ 7 ( Ã@E + " $ $ y J " ñ $ A Ä@F × ©.. 3¬ \ 0Å#0Í9 N. H-$ 0 DW.. 3 1 - 9 $ ;å F " Ó 0 18 9Ô»b ò # ( o " F4 ^ ª/ «h/D 3¼Æ#0ÎF o { Ð - h N S.V/DS®²W¯ B Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 12 of 50 PageID #: 1105 1+à +à Nd¾ §¦d à<§¦¾ ¦ r¦hÎàR d¦à/ §°àÚÛN<Rà ³ d¡ à£rd¦à¾ ràNd¾ §¦d àQ àd¦nàEà dÖd°n©Æ³à WÆf´¿d¦isµàR© ÆÀ §¦à<§¦¾ ¦ r¦hÏàR d¦à«°§£Æ d¾soà¬Æ°¼Æd¦¾à¾§àWsh¾ §¦à Fà ¨à<AU<L4a(à '5à ]0W1<*à ßà h§n tnàd¾à <à0D+U)àRd°¾à d¦nàd¦Ðàd£r¥n£u¦Á¶à s°s¾§*à ÜÝà §¦&Xv¾¾ ¦ àPbc ¦j° Þà³ d à£wd¦àd¦Ñàu°·§¦+à§¾ s°àÃ d¦àdàY?(à¾ d¾à§Ë¦´à§°àh§¦¿°§ ´àd¦Ò 7 sh¾snà S°§¬s±¾Ó*à ¦k Æn ¦ à<d°f pxà F¦nÆ¸¾° y¹àHI>2à8 °àR°§nÆh¾ºàd¦qà< r£ kd »+àF¦kà,+àJÇf° ×§ à GnÉd¦mznàMd¾r° d ³+à<Ô£l¾jh à<§°§°d¾ §¦1àd¦nàMs¼¼s°*àZ sàm eÈ½{à O©¦&Y{ÀÀ ¦ àQÌ¦{² ½à 9 {mÀ{pàT²©®{²ÄÕ à¤{e¦½à9 {mÀ{pàT²©®{²ÄÕà©Ì¦{pà©²àm©¦À²© {pàgÕàO©¦&Y{ÀÀ ¦ àQÌ¦{²+à Q®{²eÀ ©¦àe¦pàMe ¦À{¦e¦m{ à©²à Q M à½ e à¤{e¦àe àemÀ Ê À {½à²{¯È ²{pàÀ©à©®{²eÀ{ à ¤e ¦Àe ¦ àe¦pà¤©¦ À©²àÀ {à{ {mÀ Ê{¦{½½à§ àÀ {àV9àe½à½®{m {pà ¦àÀ {à`©² àT e¦à©²àe¦ÕàBT9Ù e®®²©Ê{pàQ MàT e¦+à QÌ¦{²àY@ à½ e à¤{e¦àe¦ÕàY@àÀ eÀà©Ì¦½à©²àm©¦À²© ½àe¦Õà9 {mÀ{pàT²©®{²ÄÕ à ¦m Èp ¦ à T© ÕQ¦{àe¦pà`{½À e {-à[ {àm eÈ½{à QÌ¦{²àY@ ½à9 {mÀ{pàT²©®{²ÅÕ à¤se¦½à9 {mÀ{nàT²©®{²ÅÕà ©Ì¦{pà©²àm©¦À²© {nàgÕàQÌ¦{²àY@1à Te²e ²e® à©²à ¢ à½ e à¤{e¦àeà®©²Ä ©¦à© àÀ ½à=@à p{¦À |pàgÕàe¦à9²eg mà¦È¤{²e à©²àe¦à È®®{²à©²à ©Ì{²àme½{à {ÀÀ{²+à Te²Å {½ à½ e à¤{e¦àÀ {à^¦ À{pàYÀeÀ{½àe¦pàY@½+à T{² ²¤e¦m{àYÀe¦pe²p½ à©²à TY à½ e à¤{e¦àÀ {àm {e¦È®à {Ê{ ½àe¦pà©À {²à¤{e½È²{½à© à em {Ê{¤{¦Àà© àÀ {à²{¤{p e àemÀ ©¦à©g {mÀ Ê{½ àe½à½{Àà ª²Å à ¦àÀ {àVQ@.à T e ¦À à½ e à¤}e¦àÀ {à_¦ ÀspàYÀeÀs½-à T²©®² {Àe²Õà=©¦À²© ½ à½ e à¤{e¦à{e½{¤{¦À½à©²àm©Ê{¦e¦À½à²È¦¦ ¦ àÌ À àÀ {à e¦pàÀ eÀà e ¤ Àà e¦p àÌeÀ{²!à©²à©À {²à²{½©È²m|àÈ½{àe¦p3©²à®²©Ê p{àemm{½½à² À½àe¦pà g àe²{àm²{eÀ{p ®È²½Èe¦ÀàÀ©àm©¤¤©¦à eÌà©²à½ÀeÀÈÀ©²Õà eÌàgÕàe¦à ¦½À²È¤{¦ÀàÀ eÀà ½à²{m©²p{pà ¦àÀ {àe®®²©®² eÀ{ e¦pà²{m©²p½à© m{+ V=V9 à½ e à¤{e¦àÀ {àY© pà`e½À{à@ ½®©½e à9mÀ"à ^-Y+=-àØØà e ½©à ¦©Ì¦à e½àÀ {àV{½©È²m{à=©¦½{²ÊeÀ ©¦àe¦pàV{m©Ê|²Õà9mÀ .à V{m©²pà© à@|m ½ ©¦ à©²à VQ@ à½ e à¤{e¦àÀ {àBT9àV{m©²pà© à@{m ½ ©¦à²{ eÀ ¦ àÀ©àÀ {à Y À{à½ ¦{pà©¦àY{®À{¤g{²à6#à gÕàÀ {à9p¤ ¦ ½À²eÀ©²$àe¦pàe àeÀÀem ¤{¦À½àÀ {²{À©+à\ {àVQ@à ½à eÀÀem {pàe½à9®®{¦p Íà9+à V{¤{p e à9mÀ ©¦ à©²à V9 à½ e à¤{e¦àÀ {à²{¤{p e àemÀ ©¦à½{ {mÀ{pà ¦àÀ {àVQ@+à V{¤{p e à9mÀ ©¦à`©² àT e¦ à©²à `©² àT e¦ à©²à V9à`T à½ e à¤{e¦àÀ {àp©mÈ¤{¦Àà p{½m² g ¦ àÀ {àemÀ Ê À s½àY@½à¤È½Àà®{² ²¤àÀ©à ¤® {¤{¦ÀàÀ {àV9àe¦pàQ Mà²{ e²p ¦ àÀ {àY À{%à Ì m à ½àeÀÀem {pàe½à9®®{¦p Íà;.à V|¤{p e à@{½ ¦ à©²à V@ à½ e à¤|e¦àÀ ©½{àemÀ Ê À {½àÀ©àg{àÈ¦p{²Äe {¦àgÕàY@½àÀ©à p{Ê{ ©®à ¦e à® e¦½àe¦pà½®{m meÀ ©¦½à ²àÀ {àV9à®È²½Èe¦ÀàÀ©àÀ {à9Q=à <CU<K:à @§m ~¾àN©*à 6à Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 13 of 50 PageID #: 1106 :C*@:;J+BHGE Í® p®ÍºoÍx¼xt³¯xvÍr¾Í¯ xÍXcOÍo vÍgVÍ¯¡Ít¡ v³t¯Í¯ xÍex xv o ÍVx Ío¯Í¯ x g ¯xÍ¡ Í O¥¨ Í <= ÍA9>K4 gxt¯ ¡ Í o Í xo ÍoÍ¥¡¨± ¡ Í¡}Í¯ ÍSVÍ vx ¯ xvÍr¾ÍoÍe¡ o Í ³ x¨o 0Í gx¯¯ ÍVx}x vo ¯ Í¡¨Í gV Í o Í xo Í¯ ¡xÍco©¯ xÍ vx ¯ xvÍ ÍO¥¥x v ¼ÍV4Í g ¯x Í o Í xo Í¯ xÍR/[/Í\¡¡v© t Íg³¥x© ³ vÍg ¯x ÍAF9Íot¨x Í ¡to¯xvÍ ÍSo ¶x©¯ÍS ¯¾ Í ao© o ÍS¡³ ¯¾!Í^x ¯³t ¾"Ío vÍvx¥ t¯xvÍ x x¨o ¾Í¡ Í¯ xÍ o¥Ío¯²ot xvÍoÍO¥¥x v ¼ÍS0Í g¯o¯x Í o Í xo Í¯ xÍg¯o¯xÍ¡©ÍS¡ ¡ ºxo ¯ Í¡~Í^z ¯³t ¾1Í 30Í ÈÉh³¥zª· ÍT¡ ®ªpt®¡ªÍ o Í xp Í® yÍ¥ª u ¥p Íu¡ ®ªpu®¡ªÍ©x®p xwÍr¿ÍhWÍ®¡ ´¥zª· xÍp vÍw ªxu®Í® xÍ ¥ x x ®p® ¡ Í¡Í® xÍm¡ª Í ¢«ÍpÍªx xwÀÍt¡ ¦¡ x ®Í³ vzªÍ® ÍTW2 ,-iªp zª Í p Í xp Í°¡Íz 0Íp 3Íu¡ ·xÁ4Í xpx5Í ¡ª® p z0Í¡ªÍ ªp ®ÍpÍxt´ª ®ÁÍ ¯xª{®Í #Í¡ªÍ» xªxÍ´xvÍpÍpÍ ¡³ /ÍpÍp z$Ío x ®0Íu¡ ·zÁp tx/Í¡ªÍ¡® xªÍw ¥¡ ® ¡ Í¡Íp ÁÍ ®zªz°Í rÁÍ¡¥x¬p® ¡ Í¡Í p»Í¡ªÍ¡® xª» z7Í ÈÉk ®xwÍg®o®zÊÈÍ p Í zp Í® xÍk ®xwÍh®p®xÍ¡ÍP xª upÍp vÍypt Íwx¥pª® x ®5Íp z uÁ/ p wÍ ®¬µ z °p ®ÁÍ¡Í® zÍk °xvÍh®p®x3Í t ³w ÍYdQ0Íp wÍp ÁÍxwxªp Í p®³«p Í«z¡´ªtxÍ®«µ®x|7Í Ë mp®xÍap®xª p Í o Í zp Í ] Íp Í É pÄpªw¡´Í´r®p ux ÈÍ³ wzªÍhyu® ¡ Í]bÍ] Í Í?D Í¡ UZfT_Q$ÍD@Ík7h4T6Í ÅÍJG:Í]Í ;Í D LÍ @ Íp ÁÍ¦¡ ³®p ®Í¡©Íu¡ ®p p ®Í³ vxªÍhxt® ¡ Í]bÍ]Í BB Í¡Í 4 UZeT`Q3ÍD@Ík4h7U7Í ÆÍJG:; BB MÍ B Íp ÀÍ .-¡ wÍ»p®xÍ8Í´ wxªÍgxu® ¡ Í;::D @I Í¡ÍfTeP/Í D@Ík7h4U4ÇÍGJ:B @I 4Í ÉÌm¡ª Í p Í zp Íp Ípu® ¸ ® xÍp wÍ¡r p® ¡ ÍhWÍpªzÍªz§´ ªxvÍ®¡Í¥x« ¢ª Í´ wxªÍ® UW3 x½ux¥®Í® zÍpt® ¹ ® xÍªx§´ ªzwÍ´ vyªÍhxt® ¡ Ín]nÍ ez®x ® ¡ Í¡Ífxt¡ªw 7 ! ! ! ! ! j xÍ¡r xt¯ ¶xÍ¡~Í¯ xÍco©¯ xÍ Íx ¯x© Í ¯¡Í¯ ÍSV F4 o©xÍ¯¡Í¥©¡¯xt¯Í¥³r tÍ xo ¯ Í¡¨Íºx q©xÍ¡©Í¯ xÍx ¶ ¨¡ x ¯Ír¾Í¯ xÍ ¥ x x ¯o¯ ¡ Í¡}Í¨x¥¡ xÍ ot¯ ¡ Ío¯Í¯ xÍg ¯xÍr¾ÍgV%Í¯¡Í¥o¾Í©x¥¡ xÍt¡¯Í¡~Íc o ¯ ~ &Ío vÍ¯¡Í©x¡ ¶xÍ¯ xÍt o Í¡}Íc o ¯ ~Í o o ¯ÍgVÍoÍ¥©¡¶ vxvÍ Í¯ ÍSV4Í G4 ! sÃÍ o4 gVÍ o Í o txÍo vÍ¥x© £¨ Í¯ xÍm¡¨ Í Íott¡©vo txÍº ¯ Í¯ ÍSVÍo v o Ívx ¶x¨or xÍvx¶x ¡¥xvÍr¾ÍgVÍo vÍo¥¥¨¡¶xvÍ¡¨Í ¡v xvÍr¾ÍXcOÍ¥³¨³o ¯Í¯¡Í¯ ÍSV0ÍgVÍ o Í¥o¾Í¯ xÍl ¯xvÍg¯o¯xÍ £¨Í ¯Í©x¥¡ xÍt¡¯ÍoÍ¥©¡¶ vxvÍ Í¯ ÍSV/Í r/ gV Í¡r o¯ ¡ Í¯¡Í o txÍo vÍ¥x© £¨ Í¯ xÍm¡© 'Í t ³v Í¡r o¯ ¡ ¯¡Í¥o¾Ío ¡³ ¯Ív³xÍ³ vx¨Í¯ ÍSV"Ío©xÍ ¡ ¯Ío vÍx¶x©o NÍ¥©¤¶ vxv(Í ¡ºx¶x©%Í¯ o¯Í¯ ÍSVÍ o Í ¡¯Ío ¯x©%Í ¡v )Ío x vÍ¡¨Í³¥x¨xwxÍ Ío ¾Íºo¾Í¯ xÍo ©xx x ¯Írx¯ºxx Í¡©Ío ¡ Ío ¾Í¡}Í¯ xÍ gV&Í¡¨Ío ¾Ío©r ¯©o¯ ¡ Íoºo¨vÍ¡¨Ít¡³¨¯Í ³v x ¯Í¥x©¯o Í¯¡Ío ¾Í¡~Í¯ xÍgVÍ Ít¡ xt¯ ¡ Í GÍ Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 14 of 50 PageID #: 1107 hSdRmdREm8SdE& m >ZmdREmEgEZdm[GmdREmSZc[WgEZBjm[Gm?Zjm8*m[_mdREmLSXf_EmAjm?Zjm8*md[mSY]WEYEZdm ?Zjm_E^fS_EYEZdm[GmdRScm)* mdREm_EY?SZSZQm8*cmcR?XWmB[Y]WEdEm?XWmcfBRm_E^fS_EYEZdc m # &$'" % 0/ , 0 ''# " 0 / 03[dRSZQmSZmdRScm)*mWSYSdcm84c m[AWSQ?dS[Zcmd[ B[Y]XjmhSdRmdREm_E^fS_EYEZdcm[Gm?WWm?]]WSB?AWEmGEDE_?Wm?ZDmcd?dEmX?hcm?ZDm_EQfW?dS[Zc m8*cmYfcdm ?Wc[mB[Y]WjmhSdRm?WXm?]]WSB?AWEm[_m_EXEg?Zdm?ZDm?]]_[]_S?dEm_E^fS_EYEZdcm[Gm?Wm-mNDE_?Xm?ZDmcd?dEm EZgS_[ZYEZd?XmW?hcm?cmcEdmI\_dRmSZmdREm75*m?ZDmdREm<[_Vm6W?Z m9REm?BdSgSdSEcmB[ZDfBdEDm ]f_cf?Zdmd[mdRScm)* mSGm?]]_[gEDmAjmdREm+6' mcR?WWmAEmDEEYEDmd[mAEmB[ZcScdEZdmhSdRmdREm3)6m?cm ]_[gSDEDmSZm8EBdS[Zm # B SS m[GmdREm3)6 m ($ ,* ? 'cm]_[gSDEDmSZm8EBdS[Zm m E m[Gm)+7)0' m! m ; 8 ) m km%" m E m?ZD 8EBdS[Zm ! E m[GmdREm3)6 mZ[m ]E_YSdmcR?XWmAEm_E^fS_EDmH\_m@Zjm][_dS[Zm[GmdREm <[_Vm B[ZDfBdEDm EZdS_EWjm[Z cSdEm S E m hSdRSZmdREm?_E?XmEidEZdm[GmB[Zd?YSZ?dS[Zm[_mSZmgE_jmBW[cEm ]_[iSYSdjmd[mdREmB[Zd?YSZ?dS[Zm?ZDmZEBEcc?bjmP_mSY]WEYEZd?dS[Zm[GmdREm<[_V m<RE_Em?Zjm ][_dS[Zm[GmdREm <[_VmdR?dmScmZ[dm[Z cSdEm_E^fS_Ecm?mHFDE_?Xm[_mcd?dEm]E_YSdm[_m?]]_[g?X m8*cmcR?WXm cfAYSdmdSYEXjm?ZDmB[Y]XEdEm?]]WSB?dS[Zcm?ZDmd?VEm?XWm[dRE_m?BdS[ZcmZEBEcc?_jmd[m[Ad?SZm?WXmcfBRm ]E_YSdcm[_m ?]]_[g?Wc m A 8*cmY?jmcEEVm_EWSEGmfZDE_mdREm]b[gScS[Zcm[Gm8EBdS[Zm=..m ,[_BEm1?TEf_E I\_m?ZjmDEW?jmSZmdREm]E_J\_Y?ZBEm[GmdREm<[_Vm_EcfXdSZQmKa[Ym?mMSWf_Emd[m[Ad?SZ m[_m?mDEX?jmSZm [Ad?SZSZQ m?Zjm]E_YSdm[_m?]]_[g?Xm_EGE_EZBEDmSZlm$ ?m?ZDm_E^fS_EDmI\_mdREm<[_V m]_[gSDEDmdR?dm dREjmR?gEmcfAYSddEDmdSYEXjm?ZDmB[Y]XEdEm?]]XSB?dS[Zcm?ZDmd?VEZm?WXm[dRE_m?BdS[ZcmZEBEcc?bjmd[m [Ad?SZm?XXmcfBRm]E_YSdcm[_m?]]_[g?Wc m B :RScm)*mScmZ[d m?ZDmcR?XXmZ[dmAEmB[Zcd_fEDmd[mAE m?m]EbYSdmSccfEDm]f_cf?Zd d[m ?ZjmGEDE_?Xm[_mcd?dEmcd?dfdEm[_m_EQfW?dS[Z m 0 0 0 &&( % , &%0 % 0 -' (. * &% )&! ,0 &&) % ,&)+ - 8*c m6_[UEBdm)[[_DSZ?d[_cmYfcdmR?gEmcfOBSEZdmdEBRZSB?WmEi]E_eScE d[mB[[_DSZ?dEmdREm<[_V m8*c m6_[UEBdm)[[_DSZ?d[_cmY?jmZ[dmAEm?Zm?dd[_ZEjm _E]_EcEZdSZQm?Zjm8*mSZmdRScmY?ddE_m?ZDmY?jmZ[dm?Bdm?cm?m8f]E_gScSZQm)[Zd_?Bd[_ m 8*c m6_[UEBdm)[[_DSZ?d[_cmY?jm?ccSQZm[dRE_m_E]_EcEZd?dSgEc mSZBWfDSZQm[dRE_m B[Zd_?Bd[_c md[m?ccScdmSZmB[[_DSZ?dSZQmdREm<[_V m +6' cm]b[UEBdm B[[_DSZ?d[_m P_mdREmcSdEmhSXWmAEm(_?Dm/?BVc[Z 7EYEDS?Xm6_[TEBdm2?Z?QE_ m+6'mY?jmDEcSQZ?dEm[dRE_m_E]_EcEZd?dSgEc mhRSCRm Y?jmSZBXfDEmSdcmEY]X[jEEc mB[Zd_?Bd[_cm?ZD [_mB[ZcfWd?Zdc md[m[gE_cEEmdREm <[_V m+6' cm6_[UEBdm)[[_DSZ?d[` 'XdE_Z?dEm6_[UEBdm)[[_DSZ?d[_mhSXXmR?gEmdREm c?YEm?fdR[_Sdjm?cm?m_EYEDS?Xm]_[TEBdmY?Z?QE_m?ZD [_m?Zm[Z cBEZEmB[[_DSZ?d[_ m ?cmDEcB_SAEDmSZmdREm3)6 m:RScmSZBWfDEcmdREm?fdR[_Sdjmd[mR?XdmdREm<[_Vm?ZD [_md[m B[ZDfBdm[_mDS_EBdm?ZjmZEBEcc?_jm_Ec][ZcEm?BdS[ZmhREZmREm[_mcREmDEdE_YSZEcmdR?dm Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 15 of 50 PageID #: 1108 DcbEWiWcbhtBjtiVFt9XiFtDcbhjXiljFtBbtFaFgUFbDptcgtaBptegFhFbjtBbtXaaFEWBjFt iVgFBitjctelC_WDtVFB`jVtcgtnF`KgFtcgtiVFtFbmWgcbaFbjtElFtjctBtgF`FBhFtcgt iVgFBjFbFEtgF`FBhFtcGt=BhiFt2BiFgXB_ t " :VFt9jBjF ht5gcZFDit*ccgEWbBicgtnW`_tCFt9VFgXt;V_FbCglDV t:VF 9iBiFtaBptEFhWUbBjFtciVFgtgFegFhFbiBjXmFh tWbD`lEXbUtWihtFae_cpFFh tDcbigBDicght BbE cgtDcbhl`iBbihtictcmFghFFtjVFt=cg^ t-cgtBbptaFFjXbUhtBbEtXbheFDiXcbhtXbt nVXDVtiVFt,5)t ht5gcZFDit*ccgEXbBicgteBgiWDWeBiFh tiVFt9iBiF ht5gc[FDit*ccgEXbBicgt B_hctaBpteBgiXDWeBjF t9+hthVB``tbcjWHqtiVFt9iBjFtgFBhcbBC_ptWbtBEmBbDFtcGtBbpthlDVt aFFiXbUhtcgtWbheFDjWcbh t # 9+h t5gc[FDjt*ccgEWbBjcghthVB_`taFFjtBbE cgtDcbElDjtjF`FeVcbF DcbGFgFbDFhtnWiVtiVFt,5) htBbEtiVFt9jBjF ht5gc[FDit*ccgEXbBicgtBjt`FBhjtflBgiFg_p t cgtBhtciVFgnWhFtBUgFFEtjctCptiVFteBgjWFh t C ! $ $ 9+h tegcechFEt9leFgmWhWbUt*cbjgBDicg h talhi VBmFthlGNDWFbitiFDVbXDB`tFoeFgiWhFticthleFgmWhFtjVFt=cg^tBbEtBtflB`XiptBhhlgBbDFthphjFatiVBit Dcae_WFhtnWiVt)39/ )96*t,# ! $ t6lB`Xipt9phjFahtJdgt,bmXgcbaFbiB_t+BiBtBbEt:FDVbc_cUpt 5gcUgBah't7FflXgFaFbihtnWjVt.lWEBbDFtJdgt<hFt )aFgWDBbt3BjWcbB_t9jBbEBgE t D $ $ " $ $ 0 9+hthVB__tEFhWUbBiF tBbEtbciWJqtiVFt,5) tnWjVXbt>14@tEBphtBTFgtiVF ,LFDiWmFt+BiF tcGtiVFtbBaF tiWj_F tDcbjBDjtWbSgaBjWcb tBbEtflB`XNDBjXcbhtcGtiVFt 9+h tegcechFEt5gc\FDit*ccgEXbBicghtBbEt9leFgmXhWbUt*cbjgBDjcg h tnVchFt flB`XODBiXcbhthVB_`tCFthlC\FDjtictiVFt,5)t htgFmXFntSgtmFgWHYDBiWcbtCBhFEtcbt cC]FDjXmFtBhhFhhaFbjtDgXiFgWBt F U tFoeFgWFbDF tDBeBDXip tjFDVbXDB_tFoeFgiWhF tBbEt EctbcitVBmFtBtDcbRXDjtcGtXbjFgFhitnWjVtgFheFDitictjVFtegcZFDi t ! :VFt,5) tBIkFgtBtgFBhcbBC_FtceecgilbXiptJdgtgFmWFntBbEtDcaaFbj CptjVFt9iBiF thVB__tWhhlFtbcjWDFhtcGtEWhBeegcmB_tBbE cgtBljVcgXrBiXcbhtictegcDFFEt gFUBgEWbUtiVFtegcechFEt5gc\FDit*ccgEXbBicgtBbEt9leFgmXhWbUt*cbjgBDicg h tBht Bee`XDBC`F t0GtiVFt,5)tWhhlFhtBtbcjXDFtcGtEXhBeegcmB_ t9+hthVB__ tnXjVXbt" tEBph t hlCaWitjctjVFt,5)tBt`XhjtcGthlee_FaFbiB_tegcechFEt5gcZFDit*ccgEXbBicghtBbE cgt 9leFgmWhWbUt*cbigBDjcg h tBhtBee_WDBC`F tWbD_lEXbUtBtEFhDgXeiWcbtcGtiVFt flB_WPDBiWcbhtcGtFBDV t:VFt,5)thVB``tWhhlFtBtbciWDFtcGtEWhBeegcmB`tcgt BljVcgWrBiXcbtictegcDFFEtgFUBgEXbUtFBDVthlee_FaFbjB_tegcechFEtDccgEWbBjcgt BbE cgtDcbigBDicg t9+htaBpthF_FDitBbptDccgEXbBicg DcbigBDicgtDcmFgFEtCptBbt BliVcgWrBiWcbtictegcDFFEtBbEthVB_` tnWiVXbt?! AtEBph tbcjWHqtjVFt,5)tcGt9+h t hF_FDiWcb t " 9+htaBptDVBbUFtiVFWgt5gcZFDjt*ccgEWbBicghtBbE cgt9leFgmWhWbU *cbjgBDicg h tBhtBee`WDBC`F tCptId_`cnWbUtiVFtegcDFElgFhtcGsst & D _ tBbEt& D ! t $ $ $ $ $# $ $ $ 9+hthVB_`t B teFgSga iVFt7)(tBbEt C tceFgBiF taBWbiBWb tBbEtacbWjcgtjVFtFMFDjWmFbFhhtcGtiVFt8)(tB`_tXbtBDDcgEBbDFt nXjVtiVFt=cg^t5`BbtBbEtB`_tjVFt,5) BeegcmFE tDcbEWiWcbB_`ptBeegcmFE tcgtacEWQFEtEF_WmFgBC_Fht BhtgFflWgFEtCptiVFt=cg^t5`Bb t)`_tEF`XmFgBC_FhtgFflWgFEtictCFthlCaXjiFEtSgtBeegcmB_tlbEFgtjVFt %t Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 16 of 50 PageID #: 1109 )*yfly4(y9 3yqZ<aay>Ayqs>^A?ryrfy<jjmft<by>vyrZAy+3(y[ey<??fl@<e?Ayu[rZy4(y93y5A?r[fey" #y (jjlft<byfCy*Aa\tAl<>aAq y # # #5*qyqZ<bay?fdjbvyu\rZyrZAyAdAlYAe?vy<e@ylAbA<qA lAqjfeqAy<e@ymAjfmr\eYymAks\lAdAerqyse@Aly 4(y93y5A?r[fey" ! y +dAlYAe?vy4AqjfeqAy<e@y 4Ajfmr\eY y5s>_A?ryrfy5A?r\fey:8y )ftAe<erqy>vy3b<[er[IN yefrZ[eYy\eyrZ\qy)* y[e?bs@\eYy 4(y93y5A?r[fey" ! ya\d\rqy<evy<srZfm\rvyfDy3a<\er\GH%y < yrfyr<`Ay<bay<jjmfjl\<rAy<?r[feyrfyjlfrA?ry Zsd<eyZA<arZy<e@yrZAyAet[mfedAeryflyrfyjmAtAer y<><rA ylAqjfe@yrf yflyd[e[d\xAy<ey<?rs<byfly rZlA<rAeA@ymAaA<qAyfDy9<qrAy1<rAl\<ayfe y<r yfmy MnfdyrZAy5[rA yfmy > yrfy@[lA?ryflyfl@Alyqs?Zy<?r[fe y flyqAA`y<eyfl@AlyDogdyrZAy)fsmr yrfyjlfrA?ryZsd<eyZA<brZy<e@yrZAyAet\lfedAeryfmyrfyjlAtAer y <><rA ymAqjfe@yrf yflyd[e[d[xAy<ey<?rs<ayflyrZlA<rAeA@ymAbA<qAyfDy9<qrAy1<rAm\<byfe y<r yflyLpfdy rZAy5\rA y-E y @sAyrfy5*q y F=[asmAyrfyr<`Ay<jjlfjl[<rAylAqjfeqAy<?r[feyse@Aly4(y93y5A?r\fey" ! y rZAy+3(yr<`Aqyqs?Zy<?r[fey\eqrA<@ y5*qyqZ<abylA\d>smqAyrZAy+3(yse@Aly5A?r[fey:y 3<vdAerqyFhly 4AqjfeqAy )fqrq yFhly<cay?fqrqyfCyrZAymAqjfeqAy<?r\fe y "# ! ! # .CylAksAqrA@y>vyrZAy+3( y5*qyqZ<aby?fe@s?r ?fddse[rvy\etfatAdAery<?r\t\r[Aqyse@AlyrZAy+3( yqyftAlq[YZry<qyjmft[@A@yUly[e y<e@y\ey <??fm@<e?Ayu\rZ y5A?r\fey y )fddse\rvy-etfbtAdAer yfCyrZAy4(y93 y5s?Zy<?r\t\r\Aqyd<vy [e?as@A y>sry<lAyefryb[d[rA@yrf y@Aq[Ye<r[feyfDy<y)fddse\rvy-etfbtAdAery)ffl@[e<rfly<e@y [djbAdAer<r[feyfDy<yrA?Ze[?<by<qq[qr<e?Ayjb<e; y)fqrqy[e?sllA@y>vyrZAy7e\rA@y5r<rAqyse@AlyrZ[qy 5A?r[fey?feqr[rsrAy,srsmAy4AqjfeqAy)fqrqyrfy>AylA[d>slqA@yse@Aly5A?r[fey:y 3<vdAerqyFhmy 4AqjfeqAy)fqrq y # # # # # # ! < -DyrZAy+3(y@ArAld[eAqyrZ<ry[ry[qyeA?Aqq<lvyrfydf@\KwyrZAyufl`yqjA?\J]A@y[e rZAy9fl`y3a<ey<e@ fly\ey@Aa\tAm<>aAqy@AtAafjA@yse@AlyrZAy9fl`y3a<ey[eyfl@Amyrfy<?Z\AtAy<e@ fly d<\er<\eyrZAy3AlFhld<e?Ay5r<e@<l@qyflyrfy?<lmvyfsry<e@yd<\er<\eyrZAyAOA?r\tAeAqqyfDyrZAy 4( y<e@y qs?Zydf@[Q?<r[fey[qy?feq[qrAeryu\rZyrZAy5?fjAyfDyrZAy4AdA@vyqAryFhmrZy\ey5A?r[fey yfDyrZAy 4(y93 yrZAeyrZAy+3(yd<vyefr[Xy5*qyfDyqs?Zydf@[R?<r[fe yaC5*qyf>_A?ryrfyrZAydf@\S?<r\fey rZAvyd<v yu[rZ\ey y@<vqy<VAmyrZAy+3( qyefr\Q?<r[fe yqAA`y@[qjsrAylAqfbsr[feyse@Aly 5A?r\fey:0-- y > 6ZAy9fl`y3a<eyqZ<aay>Aydf@\QA@&y - y\ey<??fl@<e?Ayu[rZyrZAydf@[T?<r\fe \qqsA@y>vyrZAy+3('yfmy y[Dy5*qy\etf`Ay@[qjsrAymAqfasr[fe y\ey<??fl@<e?Ayu[rZyrZAyTe<ay lAqfasr[feyfCyrZAy@\qjsrA y6ZAydf@\Q?<r[feyqZ<aby>Ay[e?fmjfm<rA@y[erfy<e@yAeKhl?A<>aAyse@AlyrZ\qy )* y<e@y5*qyqZ<aby\djaAdAery<bbyufl`ylAks[mA@y>vyqs?Zydf@[D\?<r[fe y5*qyqZ<bay[e?fmjfm<rAyrZAy df@\S?<r\fey[erfyrZAy@Ab[tAm<>aAymAks[lA@yse@AmyrZAy9fm`y3a<e y<qy<jjlfjl[<rA y ? 2frZ[eYy\eyrZ\qy3<m<Yl<jZyqZ<bby>Ay?feqrlsA@yrfya\d[ryrZAy+3( qy<srZfl[rv rfylAks\lAyjAlLhmd<e?AyfDyWlrZAmylAqjfeqAy<?r[feqy<qyfrZAmu[qAyjlft\@A@y\eyrZ[qy)* y /y y 2frZ[eYy[eyrZ[qy)* yrZAy9fl`y3b<e yfly<evy@Ab\tAl<>bAylAks\lA@yse@AlyrZAy9fl`y 3a<ey?feqr[rsrAqy<yu<ll<ervyfmylAjlAqAer<r[feyfDy<evy`\e@y>vy3b<\er[PqyrZ<ry?fdja[<e?Ayu[rZyrZAy ufl`ylAks[lAdAerqyqAryDilrZy[eyrZAy9fl`y3a<eyfmylAb<rA@y@Ab[tAm<>bAyu\bay<?Z\AtByrZAy3AlKhld<e?Ay 5r<e@<l@q y $y Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 17 of 50 PageID #: 1110 < < < )0 $3+0#+"< $9+$: <K; ° |T °X Z¤X °} °TXX ZT X\°ª~ |°K\X ~ °2!0° H\ ~ Z~X J\¨}\ª°K¤ °H T ° e° |\°J7°RH ° ¤Z}\ °T Z°} ¨\ }{T } ° ° ¤ ° |\°?H7 ° \¨}\ª ° ¤ Z\ °K\X } °*-*° X° ° e°9?J9D7 °/-°O°K"9 ° 41-)° X° ° °T Z°T ~XTV \° \{¤ T ~ ° f°ª|\ |\ ° |\°J7°~ ° \X ~¨\° f°|¤ T °|\T |°T Z° |\°\ ¨} \ ° )1 < $-$"6+0/<0%< 736*$3< $420/4$< "6+0/4 < Cf° |\°?H7°Z\ \ ~ \ °T °T ~ \ ° |T ° |\°J7°} ° ° \X ~¨\° f°|¤ T °|\T |°T Z° |\°\ ¨~ \ ° |\°?H7° T° \ \X ° y |\ ° \ \°TX } °u ° |\°K} \°~ °TXX ZT X\°ª} |° |\° \ ¤} \ \ ° e°9?J9D7°T Z° |\° F9H#° *2! 220367/+6;<60< 0..$/6 < K; °T Z °}e° \ ¤~ \Z°V°K\X ~ °A°A°. - ° ° B°)2° e 9?J9D7 °/-°O!K 9!° 41°A°. - ° °41)2 ° |\° ¤V }X °ª~ °V\° ¨}Z\Z°ª~ |°T ° ¤ ~ ° ° X \ ° °T °e¤ |\ ° \ \°TX ~ ° \Z°V° |\°?H7°T °T° \ ¤ ° e° |\° \¨~\ª° X Z¤X \Z° ¤ ¤T ° °K\X ~ °*-° X ° e°9?J9D7°T Z° ° ¤V ~ °ª ~ \ °X \ °u ° |\° \X Z°Z¤ } {° |\°X \ ° \ ~ Z#° *3$ 4 < -+) 6+0/<60< $3(3.< 736*$3< $420/4$< "6+0/4 < Ce° |\°?H7° \ \X e¤ |\ ° \ \°TX } ° \ T } {° ° |\°K~ \ ° |\°?H7° T° \ ¤~ \°K< ° ° \ h ° ¤X|°z |\ ° \ \°TX } °V¤ ° ° ° |\°\¬ \ S ° |T ° |\° \ \ \ °X Z} } °} ° °1*° °1.° P ~ \Z°K T ] ° H ] T Z°H 9\ ~sXT ~ °J\ \ ¨T ~ °T \° T ~ t\Z$°K; ° T°} ¨ \° |\° X\Z¤ \ ° \ °u |° } °K\X } ° <} ¤ \°J\ ¤ } ° °Z} ¤ \° T ° |\°?H7° °Z\ \ ~ T ~ ° |T ° |\° \ \ \ ° X Z~ ~ ° e ° 1)° °1.°T \° T ~ e~\Z ° V ° |\°?H7 °Z\ \ ~ T ~ ° |T ° |\°J7°} ° ° \X }¨\° f°|¤ T °|\T |°T Z° |\°\ ¨~ \ ° ° X ° |\°?H7° ° \ \X ~ ° f° |\°y |\ ° \ \°TX ~ %° <} ¤ \ ° \{T Z} {° |\°?H7 °Z\ \ } T } ° |T ° |\°J7°~ ° ° \X ~¨\ ° ° |\°?H7 ° \ \X ~ ° f°e§ |\ ° \ \°TX } ° |T °V\° \ ¨\Z° ¤ ¤T ° ° °/1° J\X Z°J\¨}\ª ° 8!.,55,1/<1&< - /5 < +°g°L= °U ]° ] ¥~ ][°¡ ° ] h °i¦ |_ ° b ^°UY¡~ )4$ ¥ ¥U ¡° ° ° ,3!° |]®° |U ° ¥W ~ °U° U °j ° ¤Y|° _ b°UY¡~ °¡ °¡|]°@I8°v °U ©U °~ ° UYY [U Y]°«~ |° |]° Y][¥ ] ° f°L`Y¡~ °QA° Ia v U Y]° f° |\°R °W®° M= &° N= ° |U ° } b b £°¡|b°U ©b[° U °~ °TYY [U Yc°«}¢|°¡|~ °:>'° < -( )3$$.$/64< $) 3#+/)< ""$44< /#< 0/ /6$3'3$/"$ <K; ° |T °ª~ |° \ \X °T °F K\ } {°Gª \ °7lm\X \Z°H \ °¤ \°V\ °\ew ° ° \X¤ \°x ° ¤X|°F ¯ K\ } {°Gª \ °T °T{ \\ \ °\ u X\TV \°V°K; °T Z°V°H T} }q ° ¨~Z~ {° |T ° ¤X|°F ¯ K\ ~ {°Gª \ 5° } ° ¨~Z\°H T} }ne°T Z° |\° |\ °K; °T Z° |\~ ° \ \ \ T ~¨] °X TX ° T Z° ¤VX TX °ª} |°TXX\ °T °T ° ]T TV \° } \ ° ° ¤X|°7p]X \Z°H \ ° °X Z¤X °T ° TX }¨~ ° \{T Z~ {° |\°9; °} X ¤Z~ {° | \° ~ ]Z°} ° °-($T° 7XX\ °J\ ¤} \ \ 6°T Z° ~~ ° \xT~ ° x °¤ } {° ¤X|°7p\X \Z°H \ °} °T ° T \ ° |T ° |\°?H7°Z\ \ ~ \ °ª~ ° ]°T ° ¤ TXXd TV \° } ° °|¤ T °|\T |° ° ° |\°] ¨} \ °Z¤]° °\¬ ¤ \° °RT \°ET \ ~T ° ° } \ k\ \°ª} |° °TZ¨\ \ °Tp\X ° |\°~ \ \ T ~ °~ \{ } ° ° \X }¨\ \ ° f° |\°J\ \Z}T ° 7X } °~ X ¤Z~ {° |\° \ ~X } ° } \Z°} ° °-( V° DT Z °RT \ ° °G |\ °J\ ¤ X\°O \° J\ }X } °Gª \ °K; ° |T °ª} |° \ \X ° °Gª \ °K; ° \ \X }¨\°7ek\X \Z°H \ ° \o T~ ° o °¤ } {° ¤X|°7r\X \Z°H \ °~ °T ° T \ ° |T °?H7°Z\ \ } \ °ª~ ° \°T °¤ TXX\ TV \° )(° Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 18 of 50 PageID #: 1111 dPeVng_nOhY>ZnOB>WgOn_dng_nfOBnBZiPd_ZYBZfnAhBnf_nBka_ehdBnf_n<>egBn0>gBcP>X n_cnPZgBcGBdBnjPfOn _dn >AiBdeBWln>HGB@gnfOBnPYaWBYBZg>gQ_Z nPZfBNdQgl n_dnad_gB@fPiBZBeen_DnfOBn5BYBAP>Wn'@fP_Z n QZ@XhAPZNnfOBndBefdP@gP_ZenXPegBAnQZn Tn ?n />ZA n<>gBd n_cn1gOBcn 5Be_hc@Bn:eBn5BefdP@gQ_Ze n 62eneO>XWnad_iQABn>n@_aln_Eneh@On>@@Been>ZAnheBncBefdQ@gP_Zn>NdBBYBZf e ng_ngOBn+3'n>ZAngOBn 6f>fB n > 8OBnMWX_jPZNnPen>nWPegn_En>@gPiPfQBenK`dnjOQ@O >@@BeenQendBbhQcBAndBN>dAPZNnfOBn'LB@gBAn4d_aBcgl n - n n gOBn6g>gB%n 6QgB!n 0_ZQg_dQZNngOBn<_cV n ;BdQKmQZNn>ZlnA>g>n_cnPZM[\>fQ_Zneh?YPgfBAng_ngOBn :ZPfBAn6g>gBen_cn )_ZAh@fPZNnPZiBefPN>fP_ZendBN>cAPZNn@_Zf>YPZ>fQ_Zn>fn_dnZB>dngOB 1?f>QZQZNne>YaWBe" 'eeBeeQZNnfOBnZBBAnK`c naW>ZZQZN n_dnPYaWBYBZgQZNn>AAPgQ_Z>X dBea_ZeBn>@gP_Zen>fn_dnZB>dnfOBn6QfB#n 'eeBeeQZNnPYaXBYBZf>gQ_Zn_Fnbh>XQgln>eehc>Z@Bn>ZAnbh>XQfln@_Zfd_X ad>@fP@Ben>enABJUZBAnPZngOBn>aac_iBAn@_Zegdh@gQ_Znbh>XQgln>eehd>Z@Bnbh>XQgln@_Zfd_Xn aX>Zn>enac_iPABAnPZngOBn<_dVn3X>Z$n RYaWBYBZfPZNngOBn<_cVnahceh>Zfnf_nfOBn@_ZAQgQ_ZeneBfnK`dfOnPZn Sn <_dVn9>VB_iBd "n -ZeaB@gQZNn>ZAn@_alPZNncB@_dAe n_aBd>fPZNnX_Ne n @_Zgc>@fe n_cn_gOBd A_@hYBZgenY>PZg>PZBAn_dnNBZBc>gBAn?ln62en_dngOBPcn>NBZfe n@_ZeQefBZgnjPfOn 6B@fQ_Zn=;--.n '@@Beenf_n-ZK`[\>gQ_Z "n 'eeBeePZNn7*e n@_YaWQ>Z@BnjPgOnfOBn)*% n-n n *BgB]^PZPZNnjOBgOBdnfOBn'HGB@gBAn3d_aBcflnQen?BQZNn heBAnPZn>n Y>ZZBcngO>gnQenad_OQ?PgBAn_cncBegdQ@gBA n_dngO>fnY>lnZBBAng_n?Bnad_OQ?QfBAn_cn dBegcQ@fBAnhZABdngOBn)*&n>ZAn -YaWBYBZfPZN nY_ZPf_cPZN nY>QZf>QZPZN ncBa_dfPZNn_Z n >ZA BZMc@PZNn>ZlnW>ZA nj>gBc n_cn_fOBcncBe_hc@BnheCndBefcP@gP_Zen>ZAn-ZefPghfP_Z>Wn )_Zfc_Xe n n ,BZBd>XnQYaWBYBZf>gQ_Zn_EngOBndBYBAlneBfnK`cfOnPZngOB 6BafBY?Bdn n n 51* n ? (BX_jnPen>nWPefn_F W>ZA nj>gBd n_dn_fOBdndBe_hc@BnheBncBegdP@gQ_Zen>aaWQ@>?XBng_nfOBn'DIB@gBAn3d_aBdgl n n Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 19 of 50 PageID #: 1112 =ktucuxuclkPg :lkuqlgt {cgg RU xtUT ul txoolru ubU hlka uUqi oUqiPkUkSU PkT oqluUSuczUkUtt lW ubU qUjUT} R} gcjcucka PkT$lq oqUzUkucka U|oltxqU ul SlkuPickPuclk PkT qUtcTxPg {PtuU Pu ubU IcuU >ktucuxuclkPh :lkuqlgt PkT ubU xtU lW U|ctucka XQScgcu} tUSxqcu} oqlSUTxqUt {cgg oqUzUku xkPxublqc~UT ckuqxtczU PSuczcucUt lq aqlxkT{PuUq xtU! MkcXnqi <kzcqlkiUkuPg :lzUkPkut UtuPRgctbUT R} @UkuxSe} GUzctUT IuPuxuUt @GI ,,-"/% {chh RU TqP_UT PkT qUSlqTUT ul iUilqcPgcU ubU gPkT PkT PSuczcu} xtU qUtuqcSuclkt JbU UkzcqlkiUkuPh SlzUkPkut {chh ckShxTU Pu P j&*+)ixi1 FqlbcRcu ubU xtU lW aqlxkT{PuUq RUkUPub ubU IcuU ckShxTcka Xmq oluPRhU PaqcSxguxqPh ckTxtuqcPg PkT SliiUqScPh oxqoltUt FqlbcRcu ubU xtU lW ubU oqloUrv} {cubck ubU IcuU PqUP Xnq oxqoltVt lubUq ubPk ckTxtuqcPg xtUt" BlucW} ubU <F8 @D<F PkT lubUq l{kUqt$loUqPulqt {cubck ubU RlxkTPr} lW ubU IcuU lW Pk} SlktuqxSuclk PSuczcucUt ubPu iP} qUtxhu ck ubU TctuxqRPkSU lW SlkuPickPuUT iUTcP <|SUou Pt SlkuUiogPuUT ck ubU GE; oqlbcRcu ubU TqUTacka lW ubU qczUq Rluulj {cubck ubU 9PqaU Igco lq ubU FqloPkU ;lSf PqUP lW ubU IcuU RUgl{ Pk UhUzPuclk lW ,00 WUUu PRlzU iUPk tUP gUzUg Pjtg lq cktuPhhPuclk lW tuqxSuxqUt ubPu jP} qUtxgu ck ubU U|oltxqU lW SlkuPickPuUT iUTcP RUkUPub ubU JUkkUttUU GczUq {cublxu ubU <F8 klucWdSPuclk PkT PooqlzPg I;t tbPhg {cub qUtoUSu ul Pk} Clk IUuvhcka E{kUq t ,'# 8ZUSuUT FqloUqu} xtU RUtu U[lqut ul tUSxqU Blk IUuugcka E{kUq t SlloUqPuclk ck U|USxucka PkT qUSlqTcka FqloqcUuPr} :lkurlht5 PkT E{kUq I; tbPgh {cub qUtoUSu ul E{kUq I; t 8\USuUT FqloUrw} U|USxuU PkT qUSlqT ck PSSlqTPkSU {cub ubU orlSUTxqUt lW ubct ,' FqloqcUuPr} :lkuqlgt" IxSb FqloqcUuPq} :lkuqlgt tbPhg2 c aqPku P qcabu lW PSSUtt ul SlkTxSu Pk} PSuczcu} qUaPqTcka ubU :; ckSgxTcka ubltU PSuczcucUt hctuUT ck ,% P 8SSUtt HUpxcqUiUkut 5 PkT cc aqPku ubU qcabu ul UkXnqSU ubU gPkT {PuUq lq lubUq qUtlxqSU xtU qUtuqcSuclkt tUu ^rub ck ,% R APkT OPuUq lq EubUq GUtlxqSU MtU GUtuqcSuclkt " P JbU FqloqcUuPq} :lkuqlgt ixtu RU aqPkuUT ul lkU lq ilqU lW ubU Xnghl{cka oUqtlkt PkT ubUcq qUoqUtUkuPuczUt Pt TUuUqjckUT R} ubU <F83 KbU NkcuUT IuPuUt ubU IuPuU I;t PkT lubUq PooqloqcPuU aqPkuUUt# FqloqcUuPr} :lkuqlgt ck ubU kPuxqU lW P Mkc^qi <kzcqlkiUkuPh :lzUkPkut 8Su M<:8 TlSxjUku aqPkuUT ul oUqtlkt lubUq ubPk ubU MkcuUT IuPuUt ixtu ckSgxTU P TUtcakPuclk ubPu <F8 PkT$lq ubU IuPuU Pt PooqloqcPuU ct UcubUq Pk PaUkS} lq P oPru} U|oqUtth} aqPkuUT ubU qcabu lW PSSUtt PkT ubU qcabu ul UkYnqSU ubU SlzUkPkut Phhl{cka ubU <F8 PkT$lq ubU IuPuU ul iPckuPck ubU qcabu ul UkYnqSU ubU FqloqcUuPq} :lkuqlht {cublxu PSpxcqcka Pk ckuUqUtu ck qUPh oqloUqu}" R" I;t tbPhh {cubck -. TP}t P`Uq ubU <ZUSuczU ;PuU3 IxRicu ul ubU <F8 P ucugU cktxqPkSU ? SliicuiUku lq lubUq ucugU UzcTUkSU PSSUouPRgU ul ubU <F8 ubPu4 c kPiUt ubU oqloltUT cktxqUT lq ubU oPqu} ck {bltU XQzlq ubU ucuhU UzcTUkSU qykt lq ubU oPsu} {bl {cgh blgT ubU qUPh UtuPuU ckuUqUtu lq cW ubPu oPru} ct xkSUruPck kPjUt ubU MkcuUT IuPuUt ubU IuPuU ubU I; lq Ll 9U ;UuUqickUT6 cc SlzUqt ubU 8]USuUT FrloUqu} ubPu ct ul RU UkSxjRUqUT7 ccc TUilktuqPuUt ubPu ubU oUqtlk (, Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 20 of 50 PageID #: 1113 ot Plwdw} wbLw {dhi P|PNywP LlO tPNotO wbP EtortdPwLt} 9olwtoiv dv wbP o{lPt oT vyNb 8ZPNwPO EtorPuw}4 dz dOPlwd[Pv Lii tPNotO kLwwPtv wbLw LTWPNw wdwiP wo wbP 8ZPNwPO EtorPuw} dlNhyOdla Lih rtdot idPlv NiLdkv tdabwv vyNb Lv PLvPkPlwv kotwaLaPv LlO owbPt PlNykMtLlNPv NoiiPNwdzPh} Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv 5 LlO z dlNhyOPv NokriPwP iPadMiP NordPv oT vyNb Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv6 LlO , Col FPNotO IdwiP =zdOPlNP! GyMkdw wo wbP =E8 L tProtw oT wbP tPvyhwv oT Ll dlzPvwdaLwdol dlNiyOdla L rb}vdNLi dlvrPNwdol oT wbP 8VWPNwPO EtorPuw} {bdNb dOPlwd\Pv lol tPNotO kLwwPtv wbLw NoyhO LTWPNw wbP wdwiP vyNb Lv yltQNotOPO iPLvPv ot PlNtoLNbkPlwv" % % " % % % % % % " ( GDv vbLih vPNytP wbP tPhPL~P vyMotOdlLwdol koOd[NLwdol ot tPioNLwdol oT Lhh Etdot =lNykMuLlNPv ol wbP wdwiP wo wbP 8XWPNwPO EtorPtw} tPzPLhPO M} wbP wdwhP PzdOPlNP ot owbPt{dvP glo{l wo Ll} G; ylhPvv wbP =E8 {LdzPv wbdv tPsydtPkPlw Lv rtozdOPO ylOPt , i #N , . ! , GDv kL} M} wbP OPLOhdlP ylOPt ,)#M >ldwdLi JdwiP =zdOPlNP vyMkdw Ll dldwdLh tPsyPvw Ypt {LdzPt oT wbP tPsydtPkPlwv oT e ,)$N ? tPaLtOdla olP ot kotP Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv ol wbP atoylOv wbLw vyNb Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv NLllow OPTPLw ot LOzPtvPh} LVWPNw wbP tdabwv wo MP atLlwPO M} wbP EtortdPwLt} :olwtoiv LlO NLllow dlwPtUStP {dwb wbP tPkPO} ot tPvyhw dl ylLNNPrwLMiP P|rovytP wo KLvwP BLwPtdLi& - GDv kL} {dwbdl 1' OL}v LTwPt wcP =ZPNwdzP <LwP ot dT Ll dldwdLj {LdzPt tPsyPvw bLv MPPl TdhPO {dwbdl ./ OL}v LTwPt wbP =E8 v OPwPukdlLwdol ol wbP dldwdLi {LdzPt tPsyPvw vyMkdw L XdlLh tPsyPvw _t L {LdzPt oT wbP tPsydtPkPlwv oT f ,)!N h tPaLtOdla Ll} rLtwdNyhLt Etdot =lNykMtLlNP ol wbP atoylOv wbLw GDv NoyhO low oMwLdl wbP tPiPLvP vyMotOdlLwdol koOd[NLwdol ot tPioNLwdol oT vyNb Etdot =lNykMtLlNP OPvrdwP MPvw PXWotwv! . JbP dldwdLi LlO [lLi {LdzPt tPsyPvwv kyvw dlNiyOP vyrrouwdla PzdOPlNP dlNhyOdla OPvNtdrwdolv oT LlO NordPv oT wbP Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv LlO kLrv vbo{dla LtPLv LVWPNwPO M} wbP Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv! JbP [lLh {LdzPt tPsyPvw Livo kyvw dlNhyOP PzdOPlNP oT PVWotwv kLOP wo vPNytP tPhPLvP vyMotOdlLwdol koOd[NLwdol ot tPhoNLwdol oT wbP Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv! / GDv vbLih NokrhPwP wbPdt oMidaLwdolv ylOPt ,)%N @ tPaLtOdla Lii Etdot =lNykMtLlNPv3 {dwbdl +0' OL}v LUxRt wbP =TWPNwdzP ;LwR7 ot dT Ll dldwdLh {LdzPt tPsyPvw bLv MPPl [hPO {dwbdl )-/ OL}v L`Pt wbP =E8 v OPwPtkdlLwdol ol wbP dldwdLi {LdzPt tPsyPvw4 ot dT L [lLh {LdzPt tPsyPvw bLv MPPl [hPO {dwbdl 2' OL}v L`Pt wbP =E8 v OPwPmndlLwdol ol wbP ^lLi {LdzPt tPsyPvw! %! % ! % # % % % % $% A G;v vbLih vyMkdw wo wbP =E8 Uqt tPzdP{ LlO LrrtozLi M} wbP OPLOidlP vrPNd]PO dl *,+!N H Lih OtLUx EtortdPwLu} :olwtohv LlO OtL` )- Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 21 of 50 PageID #: 1114 NT[\Y_R>T\[g:==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg-T<_R;Y:T<>[ g7M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUP[gR_[\g;>gNTg [_;[\:T\N:PQcg\M>gJYRg:]\:<M>=gM>Y>\Ug:[g(WW>T=Nbg- g 9WUTg\M>g-4( [g:WWYU`:PgU?g\M>gWYUWU[>=g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUP[g:T= NT[\Y_R>T\[g:==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg-T<_R;Y:T<>[ g6*[g[M:Qg/ gaN\MNTg #g =:c[ g_W=:\>g\M>g UYNLNT:Qg\N\Q>gNT[_Y:T<>g<URRN\R>T\g gUYgU\M>Yg>`N=>T<>gU?g\N\P>g:<<>W\:;P>g\Ug\M>g -4( g_T=>Ydg ;g 0TN\N:Qg8N\Q>g-`N=>T<> g0?g\M>g_W=:\>=g\N\Q>g>b:RNT:\NUTg NT=N<:\>[g\M:\gTUgPN>T[ g<Q:NR[ gYNLM\[ gUYg>T<_R;Y:T<>[gM:`>g;>>TgY><UY=>=g[NT<>g \M>g>G><\N`>g=:\>gU?g\M>gUYNLNT:Qg<URRN\R>T\g UYgU\M>Yg\N\P>g>`N=>T<> g6+[g[M:QQg [><_Y>g\M>gNRR>=N:\>gY><UY=:\NUTgU?g\M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUQ[g:T=gNT[\Y_R>T\[g :==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg.T<_R;Y:T<>[gNTg\M>g:WWYUWYN:\>gP:T=gY><UY=[ g3\M>YaN[> g 6,[g [M:QPg[><_Y>g\M>gY>Q>:[> g[_;UY=NT:\NUT gRU=NH<:\NUT gUYgY>QU<:\NUTg _T=>Yeg < Pg g UYg\M>ga:N`>Yg_T=>Ydfg gQg < " gY>L:Y=NTLg:TcgT>aPcg=N[<U`>Y>=gQN>T[ g<P:NR[ g YNLM\[ g:T=g>T<_R;Y:T<>[ gWYNUYg\UgY><UY=NTLg\M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUP[g:T=g NT[\Y_R>T\[g:==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg-T<_R;Y:T<>[ g ! 0?g6+[g[_;RN\\>=g:g\N\Q>gNT[_Y:T<>g<URRN\R>T\g_T=>Yg ; g0 5><UY=g7N\Q>g-`N=>T<> g\M>Tg_WUTg\M>gY><UY=NTLgU?g\M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUQ[g:T=g NT[\Y_R>T\[g:==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg-T<_R;Y:T<>[ g6*[g[M:QPgU;\:NTg:g\N\Q>gNT[_Y:T<>g WUQN<cg\M:\$g N gN[g<UT[N[\>T\gaN\Mg\M>gUYNLNT:Qg\N\P>gNT[_Y:T<>g<URRN\R>T\%g NN gN[g EVYg gUYgU\M>Yg:RU_T\g:WWYU`>=g;cg\M>g.4(&g NNN gN[gN[[_>=g\Ug\M>g 9TN\>=g 6\:\>[ g6+[ gUYgU\M>YgW>Y[UTg:WWYU`>=g;cg\M>g.4(&g:T=g N` gN[gN[[_>=gUTg:g<_YY>T\g (R>YN<:Tg2:T=g7N\P>g([[U<N:\NUTg (2g7( gJZSg " 6+[g[M:QP gaN\MNTg! g=:c[g:K>YgY><UY=NTLg\M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUP[ :T=gNT[\Y_R>T\[g:==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg.T<_R;Y:T<>[ gUYg[_<MgU\M>Yg=>:=PNT>g:WWYU`>=g ;cg\M>g.4( gWYU`N=>g\Ug\M>g9TN\>=g6\:\>[g:T=g\Ug:PQgLY:T\>>[gU?g\M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg )UT\YUP[$g N g<>Y]NI>=g<UWN>[gU?g\M>gY><UY=>=g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUQ[g:T=gNT[\Y_R>T\[g :==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg-T<_R;Y:T<>[g[MUaNTLg\M>g<Q>YO [gY><UY=NTLg[\:RW['g:T=g NN g\M>g \N\P>gNT[_Y:T<>gWUPN<c N>[ gUYgU\M>Yg:WWYU`>=gEVYRgU?g_W=:\>=g\N\Q>g>`N=>T<>g=:\>=g :[gU?g\M>g=:\>gU?gY><UY=NTLgU?g\M>g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUQ[g:T=gNT[\Y_R>T\[ g > 6+[g[M:PPgRUTN\UY gR:NT\:NT g>TJY<> g:T=g:TT_:QPcgY>WUY]gUTg:PQ 4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUQ[gY>X_NY>=g_T=>Yg\MN[g)* g @ 3aT>Yg6*g[M:PPgTU\g7Y:T[?>YgN\[g(G><\>=g4YUW>Y]cg _TQ>[[gN\gM:[g>b><_\>= :T=gY><UY=>=g:PQg4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUP[g:T=gNT[\Y_R>T\[g:==Y>[[NTLg4YNUYg.T<_R;Y:T<>[gY>L:Y=NTLg [_<Mg(G><\>=g4YUW>Y^cgNTg:<<UY=:T<>gaN\Mg\MN[g4:Y:LY:WM g ([g_[>=gNTg\MN[g6><\NUT g ;>[\g>ABUY][ gR>:T[g\M>g>CBUY\[g\M:\g: Y>:[UT:;Q>gW>Y[UTgNTg\M>gWU[N\NUTgU?g6+[gaU_P=g_[>g[Ug:[g\Ug:<MN>`>g\M>gLU:QgNTg:g\NR>QcgR:TT>Y g NT<P_=NTLg\M>g<U[\gU?g>RWQUcNTLgWYUF[[NUT:Qg:[[N[\:T<>g:T=g\M>gW:cR>T\gU?gY>:[UT:;Q>g[_R[gU?g RUT>cg\Ug[><_Y>g:<<>[[g:T= UYg_[>gY>[\YN<\NUTg:LY>>R>T\[ g4YUWYN>\:Ycg)UT\YUQ[ gY>Q>:[>[ g [_;UY=NT:\NUT[ gRU=NI<:\NUT[ gUYgY>QU<:\NUT[gU?g4YNUYg.T<_R;Y:T<>[g\M:\g:AB><\g\M>g\N\P>g\Ug\M>g (AD><\>=g4YUW>Y]c g:[g:WWPN<:;P> g0?g6+[g:Y>g _T:;Q>g \Ug:<<URWPN[MgaM:\gN[gY>X_NY>=g\MYU_LMg ;>[\g >?BUY\[ gNTg:g\NR>QcgR:TT>Y g\M>cg[M:QPgTU\N?cg\M>g-4( g:T=gNT<P_=>g:g=>[<YNW\NUTgU?g\M>g[\>W[g \:O>Tg\Ug<URWPcgaN\Mg\M>gY>X_NY>R>T\[ g1?g\M>g9TN\>=g6\:\>[g=>>R[gN\g:WWYUWYN:\> gN\gR:cg:[[N[\g "g Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 22 of 50 PageID #: 1115 @2w ms xKgP dlOPoPlOPlx KNxdml dl mMxKdldla w|Nc KNNPww KlO ms |wP sPwysdNxdmlw >smosdPyKs 1mlxsmhw sPiPKwPw w|MmsOdlKydmlw kmOd[NKxdmlw ms sPhmNKxdmlw mS >sdms 3lN|kMsKlNPw xcKx KYPNx ycP xdxiP xm xcP 0ZPNxPO >smoPsy Kw KoohdNKMiP 0ih Nmwxw dlN|ssPO M xcP CldxPO @xKxPw dl osm}dOdla w|Nc KwwdwxKlNP ms yKgdla w|Nc KNxdml dlNh|Odla ycP Nmwy mS KyxmslP ydkP KlO xcP Kkm|ly mR kmlPyKs NmlwdOPsKydml ms e|wx NmkoPlwKydml oKdO Nmlwxdy|xP 4|y|sP ?PwomlwP 1mwyw ym MP sPdkM|swPO |lOPs @PNxdml H >K kPlyw Vns ?PwomlwP 1mwxw $% 5S xcP 3>0 OPxPskdlPw dl K OPNdwdml OmN|kPlx osPoKsPO dl KNNmsOKlNP ~dxc ycP <1> ycKy 6lwxdy|xdmlKh 1mlxsmiw dl ycP ^sk mS wxKxP ms imNKi hK~w sPa|hKxdmlw msOdlKlNPw mldla sPwysdNydmlw ms mycPs am}PvkPlxKh Nmlysmhw ms lmydNPw KsP lPPOPO @2w wcKii NmmoPsKyP ~dyc ycP 3>0 w IKlO xcP @xKxP wJ PZmsxw ym wPN|sP KlO Plw|sP NmkoidKlNP ~dyc w|Nc 5lwydy|xdmlKh 1mlxsmhw $& 5l ycP P}Ply mS Kl AsKlwSPs mS xcP 0YPNxPO >smoPsx |liPww ycP DldxPO @xKxPw mycPs~dwP NmlwPlxw dl ~sdxdla @2w wcKih Nmlxdl|P xm Nmkoi ~dxc ycPds mMhdaKxdmlw |lOPs xcP 12 dlNh|Odla xcPds mMidaKxdml xm wPN|sP KNNPww KlO Plw|sP NmkohdKlNP ~dxc Kl iKlO ~KxPs ms mxcPs sPwm|sNP |wP sPwxsdNxdmlw sPaKsOdla xcP 0ZPNxPO >smoPsx KlO xm dkohPkPly kKdlxKdl kmldxms KlO sPomsy ml 5lwxdy|ydmlKi 1mlysmhw $' <mx~dxcwxKlOdla Kl osm}dwdml mS xcP 12 >hKdlxdVW sPyKdl Kih mR dxw KNNPww K|xcmsdxdPw KlO sdacxw Kw ~Phh Kw Kih mS dxw sdacxw xm sPr|dsP iKlO ~KxPs ms mxcPs sPwm|sNP |wP sPwxsdNxdmlw KlO 7lwydx|xdmlKh 1mlxsmiw dlNi|Odla PlVnsNPkPlx K|xcmsdxdPw sPiKxPO ycPsPxm |lOPs 13?190 ?1?0 KlO Kl mxcPs KooidNKMhP wxKy|yP ms sPa|hKxdmlw $( 8l msOPs xm Plw|sP NmkoiPxdml mR ycP Gmsg @2w wcKhi wPN|sP \lKlNdKh Kww|sKlNQ dldxdKii dl xcP Kkm|ly mS *+ """ """ 3wxdkKxPO 1mwx mS xcP Gmsg KOf|wxPO Vns =Px >sPwPlx FKh|P ^s ycP MQlP]y mS ycP 3>0 BcP ]lKlNdKh Kww|sKlNP k|wx MP mlP ms kmsP mS xcP kPNcKldwkw idwxPO MPim~ dl K Vnsk w|MwxKlxdKhh dOPlxdNKh xm xcP sPhP}Kly wKkohP OmN|kPlxw K}KdiKMiP Rtmk ycQ 3>0 ms |lOPs ycP 4dlKlNdKh 0ww|sKlNP @PxxiPkPlyw NKxPams ml ycP 1iPKl|o 3lVnsNPkPlx ;mOPi :Kla|KaP KlO @KkoiP 2mN|kPlyw 2KyKMKwP Kx cy{pw, !N_|M PpK bm} NmkqidKlNP kmOPiw KlO wKxdwVLNyms xm xcP 3>0 @2w kK |wP k|hxdohP kPNcKldwkw dS ycP KsP hdkdxPO ym w|sPx MmlOw a|KsKlxPPdla oK kPlx hPxxPsw mS NsPOdx ys|wx `lOw KlO ms dlw|sKlNP omidNdPw K 0 w|sPy MmlO a|KsKlyPPdla oK kPly KlO ms oPsVnskKlNP mS ycQ Gmsg ycKy dw dww|PO M K w|sPx NmkoKl Kkmla xcmwP hdwxPO Kw KNNPoxKMhP w|sPxdPw ml XOPsKi MmlOw Kw wPy ^sxc dl 1dsN|iKs ')" mR ycP E @ 2PoKsxkPlx mS ycP BsPKw|u - M 0l dssP}mNKMhP jPxxPs mS NsPOdy oK KMhP ym ms Kx xcP OdsPNxdml mS xcP 3>0 xcKx dw dww|PO M Kl Plxdx ycKx cKw xcP K|ycmsdx xm dww|P iPxxPsw mS NsPOdy KlO ~cmwP hPzxPs mT NsPOdx moPsKxdmlw KsP sPa|hKxPO KlO PKkdlPO M K SPOPsKi ms wxKxP KaPlN . N 0 ys|wy U|lO PwxKMidwcPO ^s xcP MPlP]x mS 3>0 ycKy dw KOkdldwxPsPO M K ys|wyPP ycKx cKw xcP K|xcmsdx ym KNx Kw K xs|wxPP KlO ~cmwP ys|wy moPsKxdmlw KsP sPa|hKxPO KlO PKkdlPO M K SPOPsKh ms wxKxP KaPlN / #' Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 23 of 50 PageID #: 1116 > (k][WkP=ik[@kQZbe_;Z=?kcO;ck]_[fP>?bkcO?k*2(kgPcOk;==?]c;<W?k_QNOcbk;bk; <?Z?G=Q;`ikcO?_?[@k;Z>kcO;ckPbkPbbe?>k<ik;ZkQZbe_;Z=?k=;__Q?_kcO;ckO;bkcO?k;ecO[_Qcikc[kPbbe?k PZbe_;Z=?k][XQ=P?bkPZkcO?k;]]XQ=;<W?kUe_Qb>P=cQ[Z b k;Z>kgO[b?kPZbe_;Z=?k[]?_;cQ[Zbk;_?k_?NeX;c?>k ;Z>k?h;YPZ?>k<ik;k@?>?_;Wk[_kbc;c?k;N?Z=i&k ! 3)bkbO;XW k gPcOPZk k>;ibk[@kcO?k*BC?=cQf?k);c? k[<c;QZkcO?k+2(k bk ;]]_[f;Xk[@kcO? I_Yk[@k3)b k GZ;Z=P;Xk;bbe_;Z=? k7QcOQZk k>;ibk[@kbe=Ok;]]_[f;W k3)bkbO;XWkb?=e_?k;XXk?h?=ec?>k ;Z> [_k[cO?`gPb?kGZ;XQj?>kY?=O;ZPbYbk[_k[cO?_k>[=eY?Zcbk=[ZbQbc?ZckgPcOkcO?k*2( ;]]_[f?>k I`Yk[@kGZ;Z=P;Xk;bbe_;Z=?k;Z>kbO;XWkbe<YPckbe=OkY?=O;ZPbYbk;Z>k>[=eY?Zcbkc[kcO?k6ZPc?>k 3c;c?b k;Z>kc[kcO?k*2(k9;Z>kcO?k3c;c?:k;bkb]?=QG?>kPZk3?=cP[Zk88k 1[cQ=?bk;Z>k3e<YPbbP[Zb k # 3)bkbO;WXk>PWQN?ZcWikY[ZPc[_kcO?k;>?^e;=ik[@kcO?kGZ;Z=P;Xk;bbe_;Z=? k -@k;Zik3) <?=[Y?bk;g;_?k[@k;ZikQZI`Y;cP[ZkPZ>P=;cPZNkcO;ckcO?kGZ;Z=Q;Xk;bbe_;Z=?k]_[fP>?>keZ>?_kcOPbk 3?=cQ[ZkPbkQZ;>?^e;c?k[_k[cO?_gPb?kZ[kX[ZN?_kb;cQbG?bkcO?k_?^eP_?Y?Zcbk[@kcOPbk 3?=cP[Z kbe=Ok3)k bO;XWkZ[cQMkcO?k*2(k[@kbe=OkPZE\_Y;cP[ZkgPcOPZk"k>;ib k/@kcO?k*2(k>?c?_YQZ?bkcO;ckcO?kGZ;Z=P;Xk ;bbe_;Z=?k]_[fP>?>keZ>?_kcOQbk3?=cQ[ZkQbkPZ;>?^e;c?k[_k[cO?_gPb?kZ[kX[ZN?_kb;cPbG?bkcO?k _?^eP_?Y?Zcbk[@kcOQbk3?=cQ[Z kcO?k*2(kgQXXkZ[cQMkcO?k;BD?=c?>k3)k[@kbe=Ok>?c?_YQZ;cP[Z k3)bk bO;XX kgPcOQZk k>;ibk;K?_kZ[cQMPZNkcO?k*2(k[_k_?=?PfQZNkZ[cP=?kJ[YkcO?k*2(keZ>?_kcOQbk 2;_;N_;]O kb?=e_?k;Z>kbe<YPckc[kcO?k*2(kE\_k;]]_[f;Xk;k]_[][b;XkE\_k;k_?fQb?>k[_k;Wc?_Z;cPf?k @PZ;Z=Q;Xk;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZQbYkcO;ckb;cQbG?bkcO?k_?^eQ_?Y?Zcbk[@kcOPbk3?=cP[Z k4O?k*2(kY;ik ?hc?Z>kcOQbk>?;>WQZ?kE\_kbe=OkcQY?k;bkPbk_?;b[Z;<XikZ?=?bb;_ikE\_kcO?k;BC?=c?>k3) kPZkcO?k?h?_=Pb?k [@k>e?k>QXPN?Z=? kc[kb?=e_?k;Z>kbe<YQckc[kcO?k*2(k;k]_[][b;XkE\_k;k_?fPb?>k[_k;Wc?_Z;cPf?k@QZ;Z=P;Xk ;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZQbY kZ[ckc[k?h=??>k k>;ib k3)bkbO;WWkE\XW[gkcO?k]_[=?>e_?bk[@k k 0[>PG=;cP[Zk[@k,PZ;Z=Q;Wk(bbe_;Z=? kPZkb??VQZNk;]]_[f;Wk[A k;Z>kbe<YPccPZNk>[=eY?Zc;cQ[ZkE\_ k cO?k_?fQb?>k[_k;Xc?a;cQf?kGZ;Z=Q;Wk;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZPbY k3)b kPZ;<PWPcikc[kb?=e_?kGZ;Z=P;Xk ;bbe_;Z=?kPZk;==[_>;Z=?kgQcOkcOQbk3?=cP[Zk>[?bkZ[ck?h=eb?k]?_E\_Y;Z=?k[@k;Zik[cO?_k[<WPN;cQ[Zk eZ>?_kcOPbk3?ccX?Y?Zc k $ ; /@kcO?k*2(kPbbe?bk;kZ[cQ=?k[@kPY]X?Y?Zc;cQ[Zk[@k;k7[_Vk5;V?[f?_keZ>?_ Rk < kcO?Z kPZk;==[_>;Z=?kgQcOk;Zik;]]WP=;<W?k@PZ;Z=P;Wk;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZPbY kcO?k *2(kPbk ?ZcPcW?>kc[%k . kcO?k]?_I_Y;Z=?k[@kcO?k7[_V'k;Z> [_k k_?^eP_?kcO;ck;Zik@eZ>bkNe;_;Zc??>k<?k];P>k QZk;==[_>;Z=?kgQcOk Tk $k > k < -@kcO?k*2(kQbkZ[cQkd?>k<ikcO?kPbbe?_k[@k;kGZ;Z=P;Xk;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZPbY cO;ckQckPZc?Z>bkc[k=;Z=?WkcO?kY?=O;ZPbY k;Z>kcO?k;BC?=c?>k3)kFPXbkc[k]_[fP>?k;Zk;Xc?a;cPf?k GZ;Z=P;Xk;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZQbYkPZk;==[_>;Z=?kgPcOkcOPbk3?=cP[Zk;ckX?;bck k>;ibk]_P[_kc[kcO?k =;Z=?XX;cQ[Zk>;c? kcO?k@eZ>bkNe;_;Zc??>keZ>?_kbe=OkY?=O;ZPbYkYebck<?k];P>k]_P[_kc[k=;Z=?WX;cP[Zk PZk;==[_>;Z=?kgPcOk Sk $ > k = WA ke][ZkPbbe;Z=?k[@k;kZ[cP=?k[@kPY]X?Y?Zc;cP[Zk[@k;k7[_Vk4;V?[f?_keZ>?_ Tk <kcO?k *2(kQbkeZ;<W?kI_k;Zik_?;b[Zkc[k]_[Y]cXikb?=e_?kcO?k_?b[e_=?bkNe;_;Zc??>keZ>?_k;Zik ;]]WP=;<X?kHZ;Z=Q;Xk;bbe_;Z=?kY?=O;ZQbYk;Z> [_k_?W;c?>kbc;Z><ikLZ>PZNk=[YYPcY?Zc kgO?cO?_k PZk=;bOk[_kPZkVPZ> kc[k=[ZcQZe?k;Z>k=[Y]W?c?kcO?k7[_V kcO?ZkcO?k*2(kPbk?ZcPcW?>kc[k>?Y;Z>k;Zk ;Y[eZc k;bk>?c?_YQZ?>k<ikcO?k*2( kbeBG=P?Zckc[k=[f?_kcO?k=[bck[@kcO?k_?Y;PZPZNk 7[_Vkc[k<?k Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 24 of 50 PageID #: 1117 ^@`J`X@? j6*bjbN;VW jfOcNOYjcNO`chj?;hbj[Bjbd>Nj?@X;Y? j^;hjcN@j;X[dYcj?@X;Y?@?j;bj?O`@>c@?j =hjcN@j+4' j ? 'Yhj;X[dYcbj`@_dO`@?jc[j=@j^;O?jdY?@`jcNObj jbN;VVj=@ j;bj?O`@>c@?j=h cN@j+4'!j O j^;O?jc[jcN@j+4'jOYj[`?@`jc[jE<>OVOc;c@jcN@j>[X^V@cO[Yj[BjcN@j9[`Tj=hjcN@j+4'j[`j=hj ;Y[cN@`j^@`b[Y$j[`j OO j?@^[bOc@?jOYc[j;YjOYc@`@bc =@;`OYMj;>>[dYc j@bc;=VObN@?j;cj;j?dWhj>N;`c@`@?j =;YTj[`jc`dbcj>[X^;YhjcN;cjObjOYbd`@?j=hjcN@j,3Pj) jOYj[`?@`jc[jH>Oj/Ojc;c@jcN@j>[X^V@cO[Yj[BjcN@j 9[`Tj=hj;Y[cN@`j^@`b[Y j0Bj^;hX@YcjObjX;?@jc[jcN@j+4' jcN@j+4'jX;hj?@^[bOcjcN@j^;hX@YcjOYc[j cN@j+4'j.;i;`?[dbj6d=bc;Y>@j6d^@`KY?j[`jOYc[jcN@j(,j-[[?`O>Nj6^@>O;Vj'>>[dYcjfOcNOYjcN@j +4'j .;i;`?[dbj6d=bc;Y>@j6d^@`BdY?jc[j=@j`@c;OY@?j;Y?jdb@?jc[j>[Y?d>cj[`jIY;Y>@j`@b^[Yb@j ;>cO[Ybj;cj[`jOYj>[YY@>cO[YjfOcNjcN@j6Oc@ j[`jc[j=@jc`;YbB@``@?j=hjcN@j+4'jc[jcN@j+4'j.;i;`?[dbj 6d=bc;Y>@j6d^@`KY? j @ 'WWj+4'j9[`Tj7;U@[e@`j>[bcbjY[cj^;O?jdY?@`jcNObj jXdbcj=@ `@OX=d`b@?j;bj,dcd`@j5@b^[Yb@j)[bcbjdY?@`j6@>cO[Yj:j 4;hX@YcbjJ`j5@b^[Yb@j)[bcb j # % % $ # % ! % !% ! "% % % ""$! % 6*bjX;h bd=XOc j[Yj;Yhj;YYOe@`b;`hj[BjcN@j+CF@>cOe@j*;c@j[`j;cj;Yhj[cN@`jcOX@j;M`@@?jc[j=hjcN@j4;`cO@b j;j `@_d@bcjc[j`@?d>@jcN@j;X[dYc j[`j>N;YM@jcN@jJ`Xj[`jc@`Xb j[BjcN@jIY;Y>O;Wj;bbd`;Y>@jX@>N;YObX j 'Yhjbd>Nj`@_d@bcjXdbcj=@jbd=XOcc@?jc[jcN@j+4'jOYj;>>[`?;Y>@jfOcNj j;Y?jXdbcjOY>Wd?@j;Yj @bcOX;c@j[BjcN@j>[bcj[BjcN@j`@X;OYOYMj 9[`T j;Yj@g^V;Y;cO[Yj[BjcN@j=;b@bjG\`jcN@j>[bcj>;W>dV;cO[Y j ;Y?j;j?@b>`O^cO[Yj[BjcN@j^`[^[b@?j>N;YM@b jOBj;Yh jc[jcN@jE\`Xj[`jc@`Xbj[BjcN@jIY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@ j 8N@j+4'jfOVWjY[cOLj6*bj[BjOcbj?@>ObO[Yjc[j;^^`[e@j[`j?Ob;^^`[e@j;j`@_d@bc@?j`@?d>cO[Yj[`j >N;YM@j^d`bd;Ycjc[jcNObj4;`;M`;^N j6*bjX;hj`@?d>@jcN@j;X[dYcj[BjcN@jIY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@j X@>N;YObXj[YWhjOYj;>>[`?;Y>@jfOcN"j ; jcN@j+4' bj;^^`[e;V%j[`j = jOCjcN@`@jObj;j?Ob^dc@ jcN@j ;M`@@X@Yc jIY;Wj;?XOYObc`;cOe@j?@>ObO[Y j[`jIY;WjQd?O>O;Wj?@>ObO[Yj`@b[VeOYMjbd>Nj?Ob^dc@jdY?@`j 6@>cO[Yj:110j *Ob^dc@j5@b[VdcO[Y j6*bjX;hj>N;YM@jcN@jG\`Xj[`jc@`Xbj[BjcN@jIY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@j X@>N;YObXj[YWhjOYj;>>[`?;Y>@jfOcNjcN@j+4' bj;^^`[e;W j'Yhj?@>ObO[YjX;?@j=hjcN@j+4'j[Yj;j `@_d@bcjbd=XOcc@?jdY?@`jcNObj4;`;M`;^Njc[j>N;YM@jcN@jG\`Xj[`jc@`Xbj[Bj;jIY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@j X@>N;YObXjbN;VVjY[cj=@jbd=R@>cjc[j>N;WW@YM@j=hj6*bj^d`bd;Ycjc[jcN@j?Ob^dc@j`@b[VdcO[Yj^`[eObO[Ybj [BjcNObj)*j[`jOYj;Yhj[cN@`jE]`dX j9OcNOYj j?;hbj;Bc@`j`@>@O^cj[BjcN@j+4' bj;^^`[e;Wj[D j[`jcN@j ;M`@@XAYcj[`j?@>ObO[Yj`@b[VeOYMj;j?Ob^dc@j`@W;cOYMjc[ jcN@j`@_d@bc@?jX[?OI>;cO[Ybj^d`bd;Ycjc[jcNObj 4;`;M`;^N j6*bjbN;VVjbd=XOcjc[jcN@j+4'j?[>dX@Yc;cO[Yj[BjcN@j`@?d>@? j`@eOb@? j[`j;Vc@aZ;cOe@j IY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@jX@>N;YObXjOYj;>>[`?;Y>@jfOcNj j " % # % !% " # $ # % % % ""$! % 6*bjX;h `@W@;b@ j>;Y>@V j[`j?Ob>[YcOYd@j;YhjIY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@j^`[eO?@?jdY?@`jcNObj6@>cO[Yj[YVh#j ; jOBjcN@j +4'jObbd@bj;j)@`cOI>;cO[Yj[Bj9[`Tj)[X^W@cO[YjdY?@`j j )@`cOI>;cO[Yj[Bj9[`Tj)[X^W@cO[Y j [Bj5'j94$j = jOYj;>>[`?;Y>@jfOcNjcN@j+4' bj;^^`[e;Vj[Bjbd>Nj`@W@;b@ j>;Y>@VW;cO[Y j[`j ?Ob>[YcOYd;cO[Y&j[`j > jOBjcN@`@jObj;j?Ob^dc@j`@M;`?OYMjcN@j`@W@;b@ j>;Y>@VW;cO[Yj[`j?Ob>[YcOYd;Y>@j [Bj;YhjIY;Y>O;Vj;bbd`;Y>@ jOYj;>>[`?;Y>@jfOcNjcN@j;M`@@X@Yc jIY;Vj;?XOYObc`;cOe@j?@>ObO[Y j[`j IY;WjSd?O>O;Vj?@>ObO[Yj`@b[VeOYMjbd>Nj?Ob^dc@jdY?@`j6@>cO[Yj:111j *Ob^dc@j5@b[WdcO[Y j % % % 4;hX@Ycbj=hj6*bjG\`j,dcd`@j5@b^[Yb@j)[bcb j6*bjbN;VWj^;hjc[jcN@j+4'j;VVj,dcd`@ 5@b^[Yb@j)[bcbjY[cjOY>[YbObc@YcjfOcNjcN@j2)4 j Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 25 of 50 PageID #: 1118 8 .Qc8cT<VJR;J:c98XJX cYI<c%/!c]JOOcX<Q;c1$Xc8c9JNOcV<U[JVJQH T8_P<QYcYI8YcJQ:N[;<Xc8c1#.0/).1c0<TRVY c]IJ:IcJQ:N[;<Xc;JV<:Yc8Q;cJQ;JV<:Yc:RXYXcJQ:[VV<;c9_c YI<c%/! cJYXc:RQYV8:YRVX cX[9:RQYV8:YRVX c8Q;c$.* c4TRQcV<8XRQ89N<cV<U[<XYcFRPc1$X cYI<c%/!c XI8ONc8NXRcTVR\J;<cV<N8Y<;c98:M[Tc;R:[P<QY8YJRQ c 1$XcXI8ONcP8M<c8ONcT8_P<QYXc]JYIJQc c;8_Xc 8AZ<Vc1$X cV<:<JTYcR=c<8:Ic9JNOcV<U[JVJQHcT8_P<QY c<^:<TYc8XcSYI<V]JX<cTVR\J;<;cJQac cJQc 8::RV;8Q:<c]JYIc:c JQXYV[:YJRQXcEVcGY[V<cV<XTRQX<c:RXYcT8_P<QYX c 9 2I<cYRY8Nc8PR[QYcYRc9< T8J;c9_c1$XcT[VX[8QYcYRbc 8c /<VJR;J:c"JNNX cXI8NOc9<c;<TRXJY<;c9_cYI<c%/!cJQcYI<c" & c 'RR;VJ:Ic1[T<V=[Q;c1JY<c1T<:J8Nc!::R[QYcYRc9<cV<Y8JQ<;c8Q;c[X<;cYRc:RQ;[:YcRVcCQ8Q:<cV<XTRQX<c 8:YJRQXc8YcRVcJQc:RQQ<:YJRQc]JYIcYI<c1JY< cRVcYRc9<cYV8QX=<VV<;c9_cYI<c%/!cYRcYI<c%/!c(8`8V;R[Xc 1[9XY8Q:<c1[T<V=[Q; cTVR\J;<; cIR]<\<V cYI8Yc%/!cP8_c;<TRXJYc8c&[Y[V<c0<XTRQX<c#RXYXc T8_P<QYc;JV<:YN_cJQYRcYI<c%/!c(8`8V;R[Xc1[9XY8Q:<c1[T<VGQ;cJ> c8YcYI<cYJP<cYI<cT8_P<QYcJXc V<:<J\<; cYI<c%/!c<XYJP8Y<XcYI8YcYI<c" & c'RR;VJ:Ic1[T<VGQ;c1JY<c1T<:J8Oc!::R[QYc98O8Q:<cJXc X[@D:J<QYcYRc8;;W<XXc:[VV<QYO_c8QYJ:JT8Y<;c=[Y[V<cV<XTRQX<c8:YJRQXcYRc9<c:RQ;[:Y<;cRVc DQ8Q:<;c9_c YI<c%/!c8YcRVcJQc:RQQ<:YJRQc]JYIcYI<c1JY< c : #RXYXc/8_P<QYXc8Q;c1YJT[O8Y<;c/<Q8OYJ<Xc-.2% #IRRX<cRQ<cR=cYI<cE[VcRTYJRQXc9<NR]cEVcT8_P<QYc9_c%&2 c9_c!#( c RVc9_c:I<:M c O c &RVc8ONcT8_P<QYXcX[9K<:YcYRcYIJXac : c1$XcXI8NOcP8M<cX[:Ic T8_P<QYc9_c&<;]JV<c%&2 cV<BV<Q:JQHcYI<c1JY< 1TJONc)$c8Q;c$+c Q[P9<VX c2I<c &<;]JV<c%&2cT8_P<QYcP[XYc9<cX<QYc8XcEONR]X c &<;<V8Nc0<X<V\<c"8QMcR?c-<]c7RVMc !"!c c !::R[QYc c)c c 15)&3c8;;V<XX &0-741 c c,J9<VY_c1YV<<Yc -<]c7RVMc-7c c &J<O;c28Hc cR=cYI<c&<;]JV<cP<XX8H<cXIR[N;cV<8;c $c c)c c%Q\JVRQP<QY8Oc/VRY<:YJRQc!H<Q:_ c &RVc8NOcT8_P<QYXcX[9L<:YcYRcYIJXbc : c1$cXI8NOcP8M<cX[:I T8_P<QYc9_c![YRP8Y<;c#N<8VJQHIR[X<c !#( cT8_P<QYc8XcEOOR]X c /-#c"8QMc c 1YV<<Y c-5c 58XIJQHYRQ c$#c c #RQY8:Yc *<XX<c5IJY<c c !"!c c 2V8QX8:YJRQc#R;<c c :I<:MJQHc %Q\JVRQP<QY8Oc/VRY<:YJRQc!H<Q:_c !::R[QY c #26c&RVP8Yc c Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 26 of 50 PageID #: 1119 /hm{Aac{jAxeEgpo{osB^ECp{ph{pXYo{ Z{ C {=,{oXAab{eA`E{osCX jAxeEgp{Ap{Xppko' vvv kAy Vhu{ph{pXE{? = {-;){ACChsgp{Yg{ACChmDAgCE{vYpX{ YgopmsCpYhgo{ph{BE{jmhuYDED{ph{=,o{Bx{pXE{-;){IibahvYgW{bhDWYgW{hF{pXE{+, { ! /hm{Aab{jAxeEgpo{osB_ECp{ph{pXYo{ Z{ C {=,{oXAbb{eA`E{osCX jAxeEgp{Bx{hNCYAb{BAg`{CXEC` o {eADE{jAxABbE{ph{pXE{ -;){0AzAmDhso{ =sBopAgCE{=sjEmHsgD {mEMmEgCYgW{pXE{gAeE{AgD{ADDmEoo{hF{pXE{jAmpx{eA`YgW{pXE{ jAxeEgp {=,o{oXAab{oEgD{pXE{CXEC` o {ph({ ? = {-guYmhgeEgpAa{;mhpECpYhg{)WEgCx{ =sjEm tgD{;AxeEgpo{ +YgCYggApY{/YgAgCE{+EgpEm{ ; : {*hw{&$& $#{ =p {6hsYo {7:{# &$ & { " /hm{Aba{jAxeEgpo{eADE{sgDEm{pXYo{ [{ C {=,o{esop{YgCbsDE mEFEmEgCEo{ph{pXE{=YpE =jYab{4,{AgD{,5{gseBEmo {)p{pXE{pYeE{hF{Agx{jAxeEgp{ mElsYmED{ph{BE{eADE{Yg{ACChmDAgCE{vYpX{ \{ C {=,o{oXAab{oEgD{ghpYCEo{pXAp{ jAxeEgp{XAo{BEEg{eADE{ph{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo {.;) {AgD{pXE{-;){+YgCYggApY{ /YgAgCE{+EgpEm {Aba{Yg{ACChmDAgCE{vYpX{ ]{%$ {)ab{ghpYCEo{esop{YgCbsDE{mEFEmEgCEo{ph{ pXE{=YpE =jYba{2,{AgD{,5{ gseBEmo { =,o{eAx{osBeYp{A{8hpYCE{hF{,YojspE YgYpYApYgW{pXE{jmhCEDsmEo{hF{=ECpYhg{@223{ ,YojspE{<EohbspYhg {mEWAmDYgW{Agx{/spsmE{<EojhgoE{ +hopo{BYbaED{sgDEm{ { ;AxeEgpo{Bx{=,o{Rm{/spsmE{<EojhgoE{+hopo {YF{pXEx{DEpEmfYgE{pXAp{pXE{ -;){XAo{eADE{A{eApXEeApYCAb{Emmhm{hm{YgCbsDED{A{Chop{YpEe{pXAp{Yo{ghp{vYpXYg{pXE{DEOgYpYhg{hG{ /spsmE{<EojhgoE{+hopo {hm{YF{pXEx{BEbYEuE{pXE{-;){YgCsmmED{EwCEoo{Chopo{Ao{A{DYmECp{mEosbp{hF{Ag{ -;){ACpYhg{pXAp{vAo{YgChgoYopEgp{vYpX{A{ojECYPC{jmhuYoYhg{hm{jmhuYoYhgo{hF{pXE{8+; {=sCX{8hpYCE{ hF{,YojspE{oXAaa{BE{osBeYppED{Yg{vmYpYgW{vYpXYg{ {DAxo{AKqEm{mECEYjp{hF{pXE{BY{11{AgD{esop{BE{oEgp{ ph{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo{jsmosAgp{ph{=ECpYhg{@@{ 8hpYCEo{AgD{=sBeYooYhgo {=sCX{8hpYCE{hG{,YojspE{ oXAbb{ojECYQCAbbx{YDEgpYU{pXE{ChgpEopED{/spsmE{<EojhgoE{+hopo{AgD{pXE{BAoYo{Jim{hB^ECpYhg {2F{=,o{ osBeYp{A{8hpYCE{hF{,YojspE {=,o{oXAab{vYpXYg{pXE{ DAx{jEmYhD {Aboh{Ao{A{mElsYmEeEgp{Jim{ YgYpYApYgW{pXE{DYojspE { A {jAx{Aaa{sgChgpEopED{/spsmE{<EojhgoE{+hopo{ph{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo {AgD{ B EopABaYoX {Yg{A{Dsbx{CXAmpEmED{BAg`{hm{pmsop{ChejAgx {Ag{YgpEmEop BEAmYgW{EoCmhv{ACChsgp{pXAp Yo{YgosnED{Bx{pXE{/EDEmAb{,EjhoYp{1gosmAgCE{+hmjhmApYhg{ /,2+ {AgD{mEeYp{ph{pXAp{EoCmhv ACChsgp{TgDo{ElsYuAaEgp{ph{pXE{Aehsgp{hG{pXE{ChgpEopED{/spsmE{<EojhgoE{+hopo {=,o{oXAba{oEgD ph{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo {Ao{jmhuYDED{Yg{=ECpYhg{@@{ 9hpYCEo{AgD{=sBeYooYhgo {A{Chjx{hG{pXE pmAgoeYppAa{aEppEm{AgD{CXEC`{jAxYgW{pXE{sgChgpEopED{/spsmE{<EojhgoE{+hopo {AgD{A{Chjx{hG{pXE ChmmEojhgDEgCE{pXAp{EopABaYoXEo{AgD{FsgDo{pXE{EoCmhv{ACChsgp {YgCasDYgW {Bsp{ghp{aYfYpED{ph YgJimeApYhg{ChgpAYgYgW{pXE{YDEgpYpx{hF{pXE{BAg`{AgD{BAg`{ACChsgp{sgDEm{vXYCX{pXE{EoCmhv ACChsgp{Yo{EopABbYoXED{Ao{vEaa{Ao{A{BAg`{opApEfEgp{oXhvYgW{pXE{YgYpYAc{BAaAgCE{hF{pXE{EoCmhv ACChsgp {2F{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo{jmEuAYao{Yg{pXE{DYojspE {=,o{oXAab{jAx{pXE{oseo{DsE{ vYpX{ACCmsED YgpEmEop {ph{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo{vYpXYg{${DAxo{ALrEm{pXE{mEohdspYhg{hF{pXE{DYojspE {>G{=,o{jmEuAYb ChgCEmgYgW{Agx{AojECp{hF{pXE{ChgpEopED{Chopo {=,o{oXAaa{jAx{pXAp{jhmpYhg{hF{pXE{Chopo{ jbso AoohCYApED{ACCmsED{YgpEmEop {Kim{vXYCX{pXEx{DYD{ghp{jmEuAYb{ph{pXE{?gYpED{=pApEo{vYpXYg{${DAxo{ASEm &{ Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 27 of 50 PageID #: 1120 aO:m]:`YUdaPYXmY=maO:m8P`[ a: m,)`m`O4UUm6:m8P`6d]`:8m4Xhm64U4X7:mY=maO:m:`7]Yfm477YdXa m Um$m [4hV:Xa`maYmaO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`mdX8:]maOP`m*4]4N]4[Om`O4UUm6:mV48:mPXm477Y]84X7:mfPaOm Q Rm 7m PX`a]d7aPYX`mH]m=dad]:m]:`[YX`:m7Y`am[4hV:Xa` m-O:m8P`[da:m]:`YUdaPYXm[]Y7:8d]:`m`:amH]aOmPXm aOP`m*4]4N]4[OmPXm7YXSdX7aPYXmfPaOmaO:m[]Y7:8d]:`m`:am@Z]aOmPXm,:7aPYXm P`[da:m+:`YUdaPYX m `O4UUm6:maO:m:g7Ud`Pe:mV:7O4XP`V`m@Z]m]:`YUePXNm8P`[da:`m]:N4]8PXNm, ` mY6UPN4aPYXmaYm]:PV6d]`:m aO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`mI]maO:P]m dad]:m+:`[YX`:m Y`a` m !XmaO:m:e:XamaO4am4Xhm[4hV:Xam@Z]m dad]:m+:`[YX`:m Y`a`m]:\dP]:8mdX8:] aOP`m,:7aPYXmP`mXYamV48:m6hmaO:m84a:m]:\dP]:8 m,)`m`O4UUm[4hm"Xa:]:`amYXmaO:mdX[4P8m64U4X7: m-O:m #Xa:]:`amYXm dad]:m+:`[YX`:m Y`a`m`O4UUm6:NPXmaYm477]d:mYXmaO:m84a:mY=maO:m6PUU m-O:m!Xa:]:`am`O4UUm 477]d:maO]YdNOmaO:m84a:mY=m,)` m[4hV:Xa m*4hV:Xa`mY=m!Xa:]:`amV48:mdX8:]maOP`m*4]4N]4[Om`O4UUm 6:mPXm488PaPYXmaYm`d7OmYaO:]m]:V:8P:`mY]m`4X7aPYX`m4e4PU46U:maYm*U4PXaP=A`m6hmeP]cd:mY=m, ` m @5PUd]:m aYmV4T:maPV:Uhm[4hV:Xa`mdX8:]maOP`m,:7aPYXmPX7Ud8PXN m6damXYamUPVPa:8maY m[4hV:XamY=m`aP[dU4a:8m [:X4UaP:`m[d]`d4XamaYm,:7aPYXm3!1m ,aP[dU4a:8m*:X4UaP:` m .O:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m8Y:`mXYam4``dV:m4XhmUP46PUPahm6hm:Xa:]PXNmPXaYmaOP`m 4 Y]m6hmeP]bd:mY=m4Xhm8:`PNX4aPYXmY=m,)`m4`maO:m * `m4daOY]Pj:8m]:[]:`:Xa4aPe:`mdX8:]m ,:7aPYXm $m : mY=m + & m m0 , mkm : m,)`m`O4UUmPX8:VXP=h m`4e: m4X8mOYU8mO4WU:``m aO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m4X8mPa`mYD7P4U` m4N:Xa` m:V[UYh::` m7YXa]47aY]` m`d67YXa]47aY]` m4X8m ]:[]:`;Xa4aPe:`m@Z]mY]mC_YVm4Xhm4X8m4UUm7U4PV`mY]m74d`:`mY=m47aPYXm4]P`PXNmJYV mY]mYXm477YdXamY= m X:NUPN:XamY]mYaO:]mf]YXNLUm47a`mY]mYVP``PYX`mY= ,)` maO:P]mY>E7:]` m8P]:7aY]` m :V[UYh::` m 4N:Xa` m 7YXa]47aY]` m`d67YXa]47aY]` m4X8m4Xhm[:]`YX`m47aPXNmYXm, ` m6:O4U=mY]mdX8:]maO:P]m7YXa]9U mPXm 74]]hPXNmYdam47aPePaP:`m[d]`d4XamaYmaOP`m mPX7Ud8PXN m6damXYamUPVPa:8maY m4Xhm7U4PV`m4]P`PXNmJYVm 4Xhm8:`PNX4aPYXmY=m, `m4`maO:m * `m4daOY]Pj:8m]:[]:`:Xa4aPe:`mdX8:]m,:7aPYXm %m : mY=m + ' m d]aO:] m, `m4N]::maYm[4hmaO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m4UUm7Y`a`mPamPX7d]`mPX7Ud8PXN m6damXYam UPVPa:8maY m4aaY]X:h` m@<:`m4X8mYaO:]m:g[:X`:`mY=mUPaPN4aPYXm4X8m`:aaU:V:Xam4]P`PXNmKYV mY]mYXm 477YdXamY? m 7U4PV`m V48:m4N4PX`amaO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m64`:8mYXmX:NUPN:XamY]mYaO:]mf]YXNMUm47a`mY]m YVP``PYX`mY=m, ` maO:P]mY=G7:]` m8P]:7aY]` m:V[UYh::` m4N:Xa` m7YXa]47aY]` m`d67YXa]47aY]` m4X8m 4Xhm[:]`YX`m47aPXNmYXmaO:P]m6:O4U=mY]mdX8:]maO:P]m7YXa]YU mPXm74^]hPXNmYdam47aPePaP:`m[d]`d4XamaYmaOP`m /O:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m`O4UUmXYam6:mO:U8mYdam4`m4m[4]ahmaYm4Xhm7YXa]47am:Xa:]:8mPXaYm6hmY]mYX 6:O4U=mY=m,)`mPXm74]]hPXNmYdam47aPePaP:`m[d]`d4XamaYmaOP`m m(:PaO:]m, `mXY]m4Xhm`d7Om7YXa]47aY] `O4UUm6:m7YX`P8:]:8m4Xm4N:XamY=maO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:` .O:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m`O4UUmNPe:m,)`mXYaP7:mY=m4Xhm7U4PVmH]mfOP7OmaO:m0XPa:8 6 ,a4a:`m[U4X`maYm`::TmPX8:VXPF74aPYXm[d]`d4XamaYmaOP`m Qm m4X8m`O4UUm7YX`dUamfPaOm,)`m[]PY]maYm `;aaUPXNm`d7Om7U4PV m , `m7Ye:X4XamXYamaYm`d:m4X8m4N]::mXYamaYm4``:]bm4Xhm7U4PV`mY]m74d`:`mY=m47aPYX 4N4PX`amaO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m@Z]m84V4N:`mY]m]:PV6d]`:V:XamY]m@Z]m`:aYBBmY=m4Xhm[4hV:Xa`mV48:mY]maYm 6:mV48:maYmaO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`m4]P`PXNmJYVmY]mYXm477YdXamY=m4Xhm7YXa]47a m4N]::V:Xa mY]m 4]]4XN:V:Xam6:af::Xm4XhmYX:mY]mVY]:mY=m,)`m4X8m4Xhm[:]`YXm@Z]m[:]H]V4X7:mY=m2Y]TmYXmY]m ]:U4aPXNmaYmaO:m,Pa: mPX7Ud8PXN m6damXYamUPVPa:8maY m7U4PV`mYXm477YdXamY=m7YX`a]d7aPYXm8:U4h` m!Xm 488PaPYX m, `m`O4UUmPX8:VXP@i m`4e:m4X8mOYU8mO4]VU:``maO:m0XPa:8m,a4a:`mfPaOm]:`[:7amaYm4Xhm4X8m l Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 28 of 50 PageID #: 1121 c ái c ¢¹á ²álc¢c n¹á¨±á±n ¢hÄ²¹n¢n¤¾ác± ¹ ¤ á ¨¢á¨²á¨¤ácii¨Ä¤¿á¨sác¤Ôái¨¤¿²ci¾ ác ²nn¢n¤¾ á ¨±ác±±c¤ n¢n¤¾áhn¿Ðnn¤ác¤Ôá¨¤ná¨±á¢¨±ná¨sá[U¹ác¤lác¤Ôán²¹¨¤á ²án²x¨²¢c¤iná¨sáa¨± á¨¤á§±á ±n c¾ ¤ á¿¨á¾ ná[ ¾n á ¤i Äl ¤ áhÄ¾á¤¨¾á ¢ ¾nlá¾¨ ái c ¢¹á¨¤ácii¨Ä¤¿á¨sái¨¤¹¾²Äi¿ ¨¤áln cÔ¹!á 38" T¨á d¿p²á¿ d¤á /6ámdÕºáhpyª²oáj¨¢¢p¤j ¤ ád¤Öá¨¤ ¹ ¿oáa¨² "á \U¹ ¹ d á¹pjÅ²p ád¤má¹ d á¢d ¤¿d ¤áÅ¤¿ á¿ páy ²¹¿ád¤¤ Æp²ºd³Ûád n²á ººÄd¤jpá§táÀ páJW<áÞ¹á ?o0Á | jd¿ §¤á§tá Y<á@¨¢ p¿ ¨¤áÅ²¹Äd¤¿á¿§á\pj¿ ¨¤á8-5á @p²¿ y jd¿ §¤á§tá Y<á@¨¢ o¿ §¤ á§uá¿ ná Y<áaWáj¨¢¢p²j d á p¤p´e á dh ¿Öá ¤¹Å²d¤jpáÍ ¿ á ¢ ¾ºá¨tá dh ¿×á§t á ¢ ¨¤á o²á ¨jjÄ²²p¤jp#ádÄ¿§¢¨h pá dh ¿Øá ¤¹Å²d¤jpáÎ ¿ á ¢ ¿ºá¨sá dh ¿×á¨tá 1á ¢ ¨¤áp²ádjj mp¤¿%ád¤má Å¢h²n dá ch ¿×á ¤ºÅ¶d¤jpáÎ ¿ á ¢ ¿¹á¨tá dh ¿Øá ¨tá 7á¢ §¤á ¥áoÒjo¹ºá§tá¿ ná²n¯Ä ²omá j§¢¢o²j d á n¤n²d á dh ¿Øád¤mádÄ¿§¢¨h ná dh ¿×á ¢ ¿º$á¦d¢ ¤ á¿ pá`¤ ¿pmá]¿d¿o¹ád¹á dmm ¿ ¨¤c á ¤ºÅ²pmºá Ï ¿ á²o¹oj¿á¿§ád á dh ¿Ùád² » ¤ á¨Å¿á¨tá¿ pádj¿ Ç ¿ o¹áo²z«²¢pmáh×á§²á¨¤á hp d tá§tá ^I¹áÅ²¹Åd¤¿á¿§á¿ ºáAV!á Q¤ádmm ¿ ¨¤"á ²á¿ pámÅ¶d¿ ¨¤á§tá¿ ¹áBI%á \I¹á¹ d á¹d¿ ¹v×&á§²á º d áo¤¹Å²oá¿ d¾á¿ p ²ák¨¤¿²dj¿§²¹á§²á ¹Åhi§¤¾²dj¿¨²¹á¹c¿ ¹{Ü ád ád jdh pá d.È¹ád¤má²n Å d¿ §¤¹á ²o d²m ¤ á¿ pá²§É ¹ §¤á§táÎ¨² p²ß¹áj¨¢p¤ºd¿ ¨¤á ¤¹Å²d¤jpáyª²ád áo²¹¨¤ºáp² ²¢ ¤ á¿ páb©² á ¨¤áho d tá§tá\F¹á ¤átÅ²¿ p¶d¤joá¨sá¿ ¹áCI'áW² §²á¿§áj¨¢¢p¤jn¢p¤¿á§sá¿ náa¨² #á]G¹á¹ d ¡á ²¨Ê mpá¿¨á¿ oá JW=á jp²¿ y jd¿oºá¨táºÅj á ¤ºÅ·d¤jpád¤mádáj¨Õá¨tándj á ¤ºÅ²d¤jpá¨ jÚ(á \I¹á¹ d ¡á ²p¼Åh¢ ¿áºÄi ájp¶¿ y jd¿p½ád¤máj§ nºá¨tá§ j o¹ápdj á×pd²á¨¤á¿ pád¤¤ Ëp²ºd²Öá§tá¿ páK|}oj¿ Épá Hd¿p(á Qtá]áGºámo¢§¤º¿²d¿páh×ápÆ mo¤jqá¹d¿ ¹|fj¿¨²×á¿§á¿ oáJW<á¿ d¿ád¤Øáj§¤¿²dj¾¨²á§²á ºÅhi§¤¿¶di¿¨²á¢d ¤¿d ¤ºá ¤¹Å¶d¤jpáp¯Å Æd p¤¿á¿§á¿ d¿ámpºi² hpmádh§Éo)á¨²á ¤¹Ä²d¤jnáj¨Æp² ¤ á¿ pá ºc¢oá² º ¹áhÅ¿á ¤ádá oººo²ád¢§Å¤¿%á¿ p¤#áÏ ¿ á²oºpj¿á¾§á¿ d¿áj¨¤¿²dj¿¨²á¨²á¹Åhj¨¤¿¶di§¶"á \Hºá¤ppmá ®²¨È mpá§¤ Øá¿ d¿á¨²¿ ¨¤á§sá¿ ná ¤¹Å²d¤jnámpºj² hpmádh¨Æpá¿ d¿á ¹á¤¨¿á¢d ¤¿d ¤pláhØá¿ oá j¨¤¾¶dj¿§²á¨²áºÅhj§¤¿¶dj¿§²"á \Fºáº d áo¤¹Å²pá¿ d¿ád á¹Åh¢ ¿¿c ¹á¿¨á¿ páLW<áÅ¤mo²á¿ ¹áWd²d ²d á mp¤¿ t×áÃ rá >NáP¨§m² k á\ ¿n%áDd Æo²¿áA ¿×*á Rp¤¿Åj ×ád¤má¾ páj É ádj¿ §¤á¤Å¢hp²á¨tá¿ ¹ájd¹o"á 39+ à O¨±iná¢c nÄ²n á ¬²áÄ±§¹n¹á¨sá¾ ¹áEI á ¹áln ¤nlác¹ác¤ÔánÌn¤¾ác± ¹ ¤ á ¨¢ icÄ¹n¹áhnÔ¨¤lá¾ nái¨¤¾±§ á¨sá[I¹ á¨sác¤Ôán¤¾ ¾Ôái¨¤¾±§ nláhÔá[I¹ á¨²á¨sá[I¹ á i¨¤¾²ci¾¨±¹á¾ c¾á ln cÔ¹á¨±á²nÌn¤¾¹á¾ nán² ¬±¢c¤iná§sác¤Ôá¨h c¾ ¨¤áÄ¤ln²á¾ ¹áEIáln¹ ¾ná[I¹ á hn¹¾ánw ±¾¹á¾¨á á¾ ná§h c¾ ¨¤,á_ ná²n°Ä ²n¢n¤¾á¾ c¾á[I¹ánÓn²i ¹ná hn¹¾ánw¨²¾¹á¾§á á¾ ná§h c¿ ¨¤ á ¤i Äln¹áÄ¹ ¤ áhn¹¾ánwx¨±¾¹á¾¨ác¤¾ i c¾nác¤Ôá¨¾n¤¾ c á ±iná¢c nÄ±nác¤láhn¹¾ánw~¨±¾¹á¾¨ácll±n¹¹á ¾ nánw~ni¾¹á¨sác¤Ôá¨¾n¤¾ c á ¬²iná¢c nÄ²ná c ác¹á ¾á ¹á¨iiÄ±± ¤ ác¤lá h á ¬ ¨Ð ¤ á¾ ná¨¾n¤¾ c á ±iná¢c nÄ²ná¹Äi á¾ c¾á¾ náln cÔác¤lác¤ÔáclÌn²¹nán ni¾¹á¨sá¾ náln cÔác±ná¢ ¤ ¢ Ýnlá¾§á¾ ná ²nc¾n¹¾á nÓ¾n¤¾á¨¹¹ h n"á O§±iná¢gnÄ±n ál¨n¹á¤¨¾á ¤i Älná ¤c¤i c á ¤ch ¾Ôá¾¨ái¨¢ n¾ná¿ ná a¨² á§±ácá Ä²ná¾§áci nÌná¾ náXn² µ£c¤iná[¾c¤lc²l¹!á Qsác¤ÔánÌn¤¾á¨iiÄ±¹á¨±á c¹á¨iiÄ²±nlá¾ c¾á¢cÔáln cÔá¾ nán± ±¢c¤iná¨sác¤Ô 3:" ¨h c¾ ¨¤áÄ¤ln±á¾ ¹áEIá ²áÐ i á[I¹á ¤¾n¤lá¨±á¢cÔá ¤¿n¤lá¾¨ác¹¹n²¾ácái c ¢á¨sá ²iná¢c nÄ±n á [U¹á¹ c á¤¨¾ sÔá¾ náMW<á ¹áW±¨ ni¾áE¨¨²l ¤c¾¨²á¨²c Ôá¨² á ¤á ¹á¨²á n²ách¹n¤in á¾ ná MX<á ¹á < ¾n¸c¾náX±¨ ni¿áE§¨²l ¤c¾¨²á¨± á ¤á¾ nánÌn¤¿áh¨¾ á¨sá¾ náMX<á ¹áln¹ ¤c¾nlá²n²n¹n¤¾c¿ Ìn¹ác±ná Ä¤cÌc ch n á¾ náI ±ni¾¨±á§sá¾ ná[Än±sÄ¤lá áM¢n² n¤iÔáSc¤c n¢n¤¿áI Ì ¹ ¨¤ á MX<á Zn ¨¤á4 á Ð ¾ ¤á Ìná lcÔ¹á ¨sáÑ n¤á[I¹ás ±¹¾á ¤nÐá¾ c¾á¾ nánÌn¤¾á¢ ¾áicÄ¹nácáln cÔ"á a ¾ ¤á21á lcÔ¹á ¾ n±nc n² á[I¹á¹ c á±¨Ì lná ¤áÑ² ¿ ¤ á¾¨á¾ náMX<ác¤ánÓ c¤c¾ ¨¤ác¤láln¹i± ¾ ¨¤á¨sá¿ ná²nc¹¨¤¹á ²á¿ náln cÔ;á¿ nác¤¾ i c¾nmálÄ²c¾ ¨¤á¨sá¿ náln cÔ;ác áci¾ ¨¤¹á¿c n¤á¨²á¾¨áhná¿c n¤á¿¨á²nÌn¤¿á¨±á ¢ ¤ ¢ Ýná¾ náln cÔ;ácá¹i nlÄ ná ¬²á ¢ n¢n¤¿c¾ ¨¤á¨sác¤Ôá¢nc¹Ä±n¹á¾§áhná¿c n¤á¿¨á²nÌn¤¾á¨±á ¢ ¾ d¿ná¿ náln cÔá¨²á¾ nánsni¿á¨sá¾ náln cÔ;á [I¹ á²c¾ ¨¤c ná ±ác¾¿² hÄ¿ ¤ á¹Äi áln cÔá¾¨ácá ²iná 21á Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 29 of 50 PageID #: 1122 W3O9g`9!m3Y8m3mcd3d9W9Ydm3cmdZmiM9dM9` mNYmdM9mZ^NYNZYmZ;m-$c mcg7Mm9h9YdmW3km73gc9mZ`m 7ZYd`N6gd9mdZm3Ym9Y83YL9`W9YdmdZm^g6UN7mM93TdMmZ`mi9UC`9 mZ`mdM9m9YhN`ZYW9Yd m -$cmcM3TUmNY7Ug89m iNdMm3YkmYZdN79m3UUm3h3NT36T9m8Z7gW9Yd3dNZYmcg^^Z`eNYLmdM9N`m7U3NWmdM3dmdM9m89U3kmi3cm3dd`N6gd36U9m dZm3mG`79mW3P9g`9 m-$cmcM3TUm69m899W98mdZmSYZimZ;m3Ykm7N`7gWcd3Y79mZ;miMN7Mm-$c m3Ykm9YdNdkm 7ZYd`ZUU98m6km-$c mZ`m-$c m7ZYd`37dZ`cmZ`mcg67ZYd`37dZ`cmSY9imZ`mcMZgU8mM3h9mSYZiY m&3NUg`9mdZm 7ZW^UkmiNdMmdM9m36Zh9m`9_gN`9W9Ydcm`9L3`8NYLm3Ym9h9YdmcM3UUm^`97Tg89m-$cmHZWm3cc9`eNYLm3Ykm >\`79mW4R9g`9m`9L3`8NYLmdM3dm9h9Yd m^`ZhN898 mMZi9h9` mdM3dmN;mdM9m%+" m89c^Nd9mdM9mT3d9m 7T3NWmZ;m Z`mNY7ZW^T9d9mYZdN79 mNcm36U9mdZm3cc9ccmdZmNdcmc3dNc>57dNZYmiM9dM9`mdM9m9h9YdmNcm3m>\`79mW3O9g`9m gY89`m m3Y8miM9dM9`m-$cmM3h9m9j9`7Nc98mdM9N`m69cdm9;?Z`ecmgY89`m mdM9m%+"mW3k mNYmNdcm gY`9hN9i36T9m8Nc7`9dNZY m9j7gc9mNYmi`NdNYLm-$c m>5NTg`9mdZmcg6WNdmdNW9TkmZ`m7ZW^U9d9mYZdN79cm gY89`mdMNcm+3`3L`3^M m (;mdM9m%+"m3L`99cmdM3dmdM9m89U3kmZ`m3YdN7N^3d98m89T3kmNcm3dd`N6gd36T9mdZm3mA\`79 W3P9g`9 mdM9mdNW9mG`m^9`G`W3Y79mZ;mdM9mZ6UNL3dNZYcmgY89`mdMNcm#$mdM3dm3`9m3;?97d98m6kmdM9mG`79m W3P9g`9miNUTm69m9jd9Y898m6kmdM9m%+"m>\`mcg7MmdNW9m3cmNcmY979cc3`kmdZm7ZW^U9d9mdMZc9mZ6UNL3dNZYc m "Ym9jd9YcNZYmZ;mdM9mdNW9mG`m^9`>\`W3Y79mZ;mdM9mZ6TNL3dNZYcm3D97d98m6kmdM9mG`79mW3P9g`9mcM3UUm YZd mZ;mNdc9U< m9jd9Y8mdM9mdNW9mA\`m^9`A\`W3Y79mZ;m3YkmZdM9`mZ6UNL3dNZY m(;mdM9m%+" m3I9`m3m `93cZY36T9mZ^^Z`dgYNdkm;]`m`9hN9im3Y8m7ZWW9Ydm6kmdM9m-d3d9 m8Z9cmYZdm3L`99mdM3dmdM9m89U3kmZ`m 3YdN7N^3d98m89U3kmM3cm699YmZ`miNTUm69m73gc98m6km3mG`79mW3O9g`9 mdM9m%+"miNUUmYZdNKm-$cmNYm i`NdNYLmZ;mNdcm897NcNZY m(;mdM9m%+"m3L`99cmdM3dmdM9m89U3kmNcm3dd`N6gd36U9mdZm3m>\`79mW3P9g`9 mdM9m %+"miNUUmYZdNBlm -$cmNYmi`NdNYLmZ;mdM9mT9YLdMmZ;mdM9m9jd9YcNZY mN;m3Yk mG`m^9`>\aX3Y79mZ;mdM9m Z6TNL3dNZYcm3@?97d98m6kmdM9mG`79mW3O9g`9 m (;m-$cm9U97dmdZmNYhZS9mdM9m8Nc^gd9m`9cZTgdNZYm^`Z798g`9cmc9dm>\`eMmNYm-97dNZYm2)(( $Nc^gd9m,9cZUgdNZY m`9L3`8NYLmdM9m%+"m cm897NcNZY mdM9kmcM3UTm8ZmcZmYZmT3d9`mdM3Ym m83kcm3J9`m `979N^dmZ;mdM9m%+" cmYZdN79 m(Ym3Ykmcg7Mm^`Z7998NYL m-$cmcM3UUmM3h9mdM9m6g`89YmZ;m89WZYcd`3dNYLm 6km3m^`9^ZY89`3Y79mZ;mdM9m9hN89Y79mdM3dmdM9m89T3kmZ`m3YdN7N^3d98m89U3kmM3cm699YmZ`miNTUm69m73gc98m 6km3mA\`79mW3P9g`9 mdM3dmdM9m8g`3dNZYmZ;mdM9m89T3kmZ`mdM9m9jd9YcNZYmcZgLMdmi3cmZ`miNTUm69m i3``3Yd98mgY89`mdM9m7N`7gWcd3Y79c mdM3dm69cdm9@?Z`dcmi9`9m9j9`7Nc98mdZm3hZN8m3Y8mWNdNL3d9mdM9m -$cm73``km 9@?97dcmZ;mdM9m89T3k m3Y8mdM3dm-$cm7ZW^TN98miNdMmdM9m`9_gN`9W9YdcmZ; m3Y8m m(;m dMNcm6g`89Y mdM9m89U3km3dmNccg9mcM3TUm69m899W98mYZdmdZm69m3mhNZU3dNZYm6km-$cmZ;mdM9m3;?97d98m dMNcm#$mN89YdNE98mdZmdM9m%+"m3Y8mdM9m#Zg`e m Z6TNL3dNZYmZ;m .M9mCNTg`9m6kmdM9m%+"mdZmdNW9Ukm7ZW^T9d9m3YkmZ6TNL3dNZYmgY89`mdM9m#$mZ`mgY89` dM9m1Z`Sm+U3YmNcmYZdm3mhNZT3dNZYmZ;mdM9m#$ m^`ZhN898 mMZi9h9` mdM3dmN;mcg7Mm>5NUg`9m^`9h9Ydcm-$cm ;bZWmW99dNYLmZY9mZ`mWZ`9m8938UNY9cmNYmdM9m1Z`Sm+T3Y m-$cmW3kmc99Sm`9UN9;mgY89`mdMNcm-97dNZY m 0YU9ccmZdM9`iNc9m9j^`:ccTkm^`ZhN898mA\`mNYmdMNcm#$ mdM9m8Nc^gd9m`9cZUgdNZY ^`Z798g`9cmZ;mdMNcm-97dNZYmcM3TTm69mdM9m9j7TgcNh9mW97M3YNcWmdZm`9cZUh9m8Nc^gd9cm`9L3`8NYLmdMNcm #$ 'Zi9h9` mdM9m^`Z798g`9cmc9dm>\`eMmNYmdMNcm-97dNZYmcM3UUmYZdm3^^UkmdZm37dNZYcm6kmdM9m0YNd98 -d3d9cmdZm9Y=[`79mZ6TNL3dNZYcmZ;m-$cmdM3dmM3h9mYZdm699Ym8Nc^gd98mNYm377Z`83Y79miNdMmdMNcm-97dNZY "m8Nc^gd9mcM3TTm69m7ZYcN89`98mdZmM3h9m3`Nc9YmiM9YmZY9m^3`dkmc9Y8cmdM9mZdM9` $Nc^gd9 m"Ykm8Nc^gd9m`9L3`8NYLmdMNcm#$mcM3UUmNYmdM9mF`cdmNYcd3Y79m69m ^3`dN9cm3mi`Ndf9Ym*ZdN79mZ;m dM9mcg6Q97dmZ;mNYG`W3TmY9LZdN3dNZYcm69di99YmdM9m^3`eN9cmdZmdM9m8Nc^gd9 m/M9m^9`NZ8mG`mNYG`W3Vm Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 30 of 50 PageID #: 1123 wShy lL lyw iLtt wy S QSSR " RL gyv iS mvS iS Rm ~ S L m S wrS l m vyRmcSR O m Sw Lh SSvSw xY iS ~L lS x iS Rm ~ S M 9w jS S Sw jM jU ~M mS QMwwx S xr S M Rm ~ S O nw^{ vMs wShx mL lxw wRU jS ~ SQSRmwh =M Mh M~j jSw jU ~x m mxw MR MwQSR O iS 3=, iMtr OS Qxw mRS SR OmwRmwh wrS KHl jmw # RM MZ S jU QxwQr mxw x[ iS nwd vMr wShx mM mxw ~T mxR B0 mw xpS iS d vMt Rm ~ U S xt lxw ~ xQSR U x\ jm CSQ mxw O U mwh xw jS Gwm SR B M S M n Uw B M SvSw x[ =y m myw xw jS vM S mw Rm ~ S mwQr Rmwh O wy smvm SR x Mw [MQ Mr RM M MwMr m x x~mwmxw ~~x nwh jM ~x m mxw MwR Mw ~~x mwh RxQ vSw M lxw SrmUR ~xw O C0 DjS B M UvUw x[ =y m nxw iMrr ~SQm[ Bz ~y m mxw M x jU jS e vMr Rl ~ S S xr nxw jx tR ~ xQSSR wRS $) ASQx R AS nS x $ * O Im jmw $' RM M\ S SQSm~ xZ C0 B M SvSw xZ =x m nxw iS 2=, mrr S S xw B1 n B M SvSw x[ =x m mxw mwQr Rmwh O wx 9 mvm SR x Mw _NQ Mr RL M MwMr m x x~mwmxw ~~x mwh iM ~x m mxw MwR Mtr ~~x mwh RxQ vUw M mxw SrmSR ~xw O jS 3=+ EjS 2=+ B M UvUw x\ =x m nxw iMrt mwQt RS M M SvUw M x jS jS _| vMr Rn ~ S S xr mxw ix rR ~ xQSSR wRU $) ?SPx R @U lU x $ * Im imw $( RM M[ S UQSm~ x[ jS 2=, C M SvSw x[ =x m mxw C0 v Ovl M S~t x jS m S jS vM S mrr OS RSVvSR Qrx UR Q 9[ jS S m Rm Mh SSvUw OU SSw jS 4=, MwR B0 M x jU iU Rn ~ S W xr mxw jx tR ~ xQSSR wRU $) ?SQx R ?S mU x $* jS ~M mU x jS Rm ~ U kMrr `|trx jS ~ xQSR U U d i ow iS =M Mh M~i RS S vmwXR O jU 5=, x OS M~~rmQMOuU 8x S S m[B0 t mvM Sr M~~SMt x jS -x x S xr S jS Rm ~ S jS .x jMtr RU U vmwS inQi =M Mh M~j m M~~rmQMOtU mw MQQx RMwQS m j jS MwRM R x[ M~~rmQMOmrm S d !j mw %) MwR $* $) ASQy R AS mS 6y vLt Rm ~ S S yt lyw b} Rm ~ S ~S Mmwmwh y iS SrSQ lyw x LRS LQ y\ Lw S ~yw S MQ lxw LwR Lrt x iS Rl ~ S jM L S LQQx RSR S mS yw iS LRvlwm M l S SQy R wRS L~~tlQLOrS ~ lwQm~rS x\ MRvlwl L l S rL iLrt OS QxwR Q SR ~ Mw x iS ~ xQSR S S f i mw il >L Lh L~i 7y ~ ~x S xY il >L Lh L~i iS LRS LQ xY Lw S ~yw S LQ lyw mwQt RS m iy rmvm L mxw iS LRS LQ y L~~ y~ mL SwS y\ ~tLw ~ yQSR S y lv~rSvSw ~tLw y Lw x iS m Sv S m mwh L~~ x Lt O iS 2>, wRS il /0 LwR iS LRS LQ yY iS ~S b} vLwQS yY S ~yw S LQ myw LqSw ~ Lw y il /0 ;y imwh lw il /0 iLrt OS Qyw SR y Lttx Lw Rm ~ S O C0 ShM Rlwh iS LrlRm x] iS @<0 ~ y m lxw L ,w LRvmwm L l S SQx R yY iS Rl ~ S iLrt OS vLmw LmwSR O iS 2>, LwR iMtr Qxw Lmw Lrt M SvSw x] ~x m lxw mwQt Rlwh ~~x mwh RxQ vSw L myw Ovl SR ~ Lw y im CSQ mxw JiS S L~~ x~ mL S iS 2=, vL Lrry Ovm lyw x\ ~~tSvSw Lr L SvSw x[ ~y l mxw O iS ~L mS x iS Rl ~ S O FiS 0l SQ x x\ iS C ~S a wR 2vS hSwQ :LwMhSvSw 0l m lyw 2>, @Shmyw & lrr m S M cwLr LRvmwl M m S RSQm myw S xt mwh iS Rl ~ S OL SR yw iS Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 31 of 50 PageID #: 1124 MPmcnduvsMvdzQ sQOosP PQuOsdNQP dn e (* M Cbdu PQOcucon ubMll NQ NdnPcna xqon B1u uxNhQOv onl vo vbQ sdabv vo uQQj ixPdOcMk sQzdQ{ qxsuxMnv vo g f (* O MnP (* P .n MPmdncuvsMvdzQ PQOducon mMPQ N vbQ 2@. qxsuxMnv vo (* N ubMkk NQ O sQzdQ{MNkQ N vbcu 0oxsv qsozdPQP vbMv M movdon \s hxPdOdMl sQzcQ{ oR vbQ PQOdudon cu ZkQP N B1u {cvb vbQ 0oxsw MnP uQszQP on Mkk @MtwdQu {dvbdn $" PMu M^Qs sQOQcqv oR vbQ 2@. u PQOcudon DbQ movcon ubMkl dnOlxPQ M PQuOsdqvcon oR vbQ mMvvQs cn PduqxvQ vbQ QSWpswu mMPQ N vbQ qMtvdQu vo sQuolzQ cv vbQ sQldQR sQrxQuvQP MnP vbQ uObQPxkQ dR Mn {cvbdn {bcOb vbQ PduqxvQ mxuv NQ sQuolzQP vo QnuxsQ osPQsl cmqlQmQnvMvcon oR vbcu 01 CbQ GncvQP BvMvQu mM ZkQ M sQuqonuQ vo B1u movcon 6n qsoOQQPcnau on Mn PcuqxvQ aozQsnQP N vbdu @MsMasMqb B1u ubMlk bMzQ P vbQ NxsPQn oR PQmonuvsMvdna vbMv vbQ PQOcucon oR vbQ BxqQs`nP 2mQsaQnO ;MnMaQmQnv 1czducon 1csQOvos cu MsNcvsMt MnP OMqscOdoxu os ovbQs{duQ nov dn MOOosPMnOQ {dvb kM{ 9xPcOdMk sQzcQ{ oR vbQ 3@. u PQOcucon ubMll NQ on vbQ MPmdnduvsMvczQ sQOosP OomqckQP qxsuxMnv vo e (* M 4osmMl PcuqxvQ sQuolxvcon \s PcuqxvQu vbMv nQdvbQs qQsvMdn vo vbQ uQlQOvcon os (+ MPQrxMO oR Mn sQuqonuQ MOvcon nos MsQ ovbQs|duQ MOOosPQP sQzdQ{ on vbQ MPmcnduvsMvdzQ sQOosP xnPQs MqqlcOMNlQ qscnOcqlQu oR MPmdncuvsMvdzQ lM{ ubMkk NQ aozQsnQP N vbdu @MsMasMqb EbQ 1dsQOvos oR vbQ BxqQsTynP 3mQsaQnO ;MnMaQmQnv 1czducon 3@. M AQacon ( {cll cuuxQ M [nMk PQOdudon sQuokzcna vbQ PduqxvQ NMuQP on vbQ uvMvQmQnvu oR qoudvdon MnP sQqk cR Mn uQszQP xnPQs () CbQ BxqQs`nP 3mQsaQnO ;MnMaQmQnv 1dzducon 1csQOvos u PQOducon ubMkl NQ NcnPcna on B1u xnkQuu {cvbdn 7> PMu M_Qs sQOQdqv oR vbQ PQOducon B1u ZlQ {cvb vbQ 0oxtv MnP uQszQ on vbQ qMsvcQu M movcon Ups hxPcOdMk sQzdQ{ oR vbQ PQOcucon uQvvdna \swb vbQ mMvvQs dn PcuqxvQ vbQ QYoswu mMPQ N vbQ qMtwcQu vo sQuolzQ dv vbQ sQldQR sQrxQuvQP MnP vbQ uObQPxkQ dR Mn {cvbdn {bcOb vbQ PcuqxvQ mxuv NQ sQuokzQP vo QnuxsQ osPQsl dmqkQmQnvMvdon oR vbQ 01 FbQ HncvQP BvMvQu mM [kQ M sQuqonuQ vo B1u movcon <ov{dvbuvMnPdna ; 02A0:. %$'# sQOosP sQzdQ{ oR A?1 MnP N Kosj oR BQOvcon 6 /MOjasoxnP hxPdOdMk sQzdQ{ oR Mn PduqxvQ aozQsnQP N vbcu @MsMasMqb ubMkk NQ aozQsnQP N MqqkcOMNlQ qscnOdqkQu oR lM{ CbQ cnzoOMvcon oR \smMk PduqxvQ sQuolxvdon qsoOQPxsQu xnPQs vbdu BQOvcon PoQu (, nov Q}vQnP qouvqonQ os MYQOv cn Mn {M Mn oNkcaMvcon oR B1u xnPQs vbdu 01 Q}OQqv Mu qsozcPQP cn '' 0onvQuvdna 5xvxsQ AQuqonuQ 0ouvu Mu MasQQP N vbQ 3@. os Mu PQvQsmdnQP N vbQ 0oxtv BvdqxlMvQP qQnMkvdQu {cvb sQuqQOv vo vbQ PduqxvQP mMwvQs ubMkl OonvdnxQ vo MOOsxQ Nxv qMmQnv ubMkk NQ uvMQP qQnPcna sQuolxvdon oR vbQ PcuqxvQ Mu qsozdPQP cn )* =ov{dvbuvMnPdna vbQ uvM oR qMmQnv uvdqxkMvQP qQnMlvcQu ubMlk MOOsxQ ]om vbQ Zsuv PM oR nonOomqkcMnOQ {dvb Mn MqqkcOMNlQ qsozducon oR vbdu 01 6n vbQ QzQnv vbMv B1u Po nov qsQzMdl on vbQ PcuqxvQP cuuxQ uvdqxkMvQP qQnMlvcQu ubMkk NQ MuuQuuQP MnP qMcP Mu qsozdPQP cn BQOvdon L8J BvdqxlMvQP @QnMkvdQu B1u ubMkl NQ lcMNlQ vo vbQ IncvQP BvMvQu Vps uvdqxkMvQP qQnMlvcQu dn vbQ Mmoxnvu uQv (- \svb cn )"!M MnP )$ Vps XckxsQ vo Oomqk {cvb vbQ oNldaMvdonu uqQOcRcQP dn e f )" N MnP )$ xnlQuu Q~OxuQP xnPQs BQOvdon L66 4osOQ ;MhQxsQ 0omql Mu xuQP dn vbQ qsQzcoxu uQnvQnOQ cnOkxPQu OomqkcMnOQ N B1u {dvb Mkl MqqkcOMNlQ sQrxcsQmQnvu oR vbdu 01 {cvbdn vbQ PQMPlcnQu &( Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 32 of 50 PageID #: 1125 ?_`:<QJ_I?>lbU>?\l`IJ_l&' l,Al:UlJUJ`J:RQfl_b<TJ``?>lW\l\?_b<TJ``?>l>?RJc?\:<Q?l=WU`:JU_l:lT:`?\J:Ql >?C=` l:U>l`I?l>?QJc?\:<R?lJ_l>J_:YY\Wc?>lW\lTW>JE?>l<fl`I?l(2%lbU>?\l3%l82l4?=`JWUl l>b?l `Wl_b=IlT:`?\J:Rl>?D=` l`I?Ul`I?lT:`?\J:Ql>?A?=`l_I:QQl=WU_`J`b`?l:lQ:=OlWAl=WTYRJ:U=?lBX\l Yb\YW_?_lWAl`IJ_l2:\:H\:YI l 4`JYbQ:`?>l2?U:Q`fl%TWbU`_l 2:fT?U`_ l)JU:U=J:Rl%__b\:U=? l/:NW\ '?QJc?\:<Q?_ l:U>l1`I?\l/JR?_`WU?_l : 5I?lGSQWeJUHl_`JYbR:`?>lY?U:R`J?_l_I:RQl:==\b?lY?\lcJWR:`JWUlY?\l>:flBX\ :UflUWU=WTYSJ:V=?lJ>?U`JAM?>lJUl Ll <"l 2?\JW>lWAl0WU=WTZQJ:U=?l .l_`l`I\Wb Il `Il>:gl `Il`I\Wb@Il `Il>:hl l-l_`l>:cl:U>l<?iWU>l 2?U:R`fl2?\l7JWR:`JWUl2?\l':dl l l l - 2:fT?U`lWAl:Ufl:TWbU`l>b?lbU>?\l4?=`JWUl9l 2:fT?U`_lBX\ 3?_YWU_?l&W_`_ l (_`:<QJ_IT?U`l:U>lT:JU`?U:U=?lWAlEU:U=J:Rl:__b\:U=?lJU :==W\>:U=?leJ`Il4?=`JWUl.9l )JU:U=J:Rl%__b\:U=? l (_`:<QJ_IT?U`lWAl:Ul?_=]Wel:==WbU`l`WlIWQ>l:Ufl>J_Yb`?>l)b`b\? 3?_YWU_?l&W_`_lbU>?\l Ll l &WU`?_`JUHl)b`b\?l3?_YWU_?l&W_`_ l *:JRb\?l`Wl_b<TJ`l>W=bT?U`_lRJ_`?>lJUl`I?l:YY\Wc?>l3%l8W\Pl2Q:U 6I?lBXQRWeJUHl_`JYbQ:`?> Y?U:Q`J?_l_I:RRl:==\b?lY?\lcJWR:`JWUlY?\l>:flBX\lB;JQb\?l`Wl_b<TJ`l`JT?RflW\l:>?[b:`?l>?RJc?\:<Q?_l Yb\_b:U`l`Wl`I?l&'lW`I?\l`I:Ul`IW_?l_Y?=JE?>lJUl2:\:H\:YIl <#l 2?\JW>lWAl0WU=WTZQJ:U=?l .l_`l`I\Wb Il `Il>:jl `Il`I\Wb Il `Il>:kl l-l_`l>:dl:U>l<?gWU>l 2?U:Qajl2?\l7JWQ:`JWUl2?\l':dl l l l .Ul`I?l?c?U`l`I:`l`I?l(2%l:__bT?_lY?\BX\T:U=?lWAl:lYW^`JWUlW\l:QQlWAl`I?l8W\P Yb\_b:U`l`Wl Ll l 8W\Pl6:O?Wc?\ l4'_l_I:RRl<?lSJ:<Q?lG\l:l_`JYbQ:`?>lY?U:Q`flJUl`I?l:TWbU`lWAl l4`JYbR:`?>lY?U:Q`J?_lbU>?\l`IJ_l2:\:H\:YIl:\?lJUl:>>J`JWUl`Wl`I?l\?T?>J?_l:c:JQ:<R?lbU>?\l K Ll !l %==?__l`Wl)JU:U=J:Rl%__b\:U=? l:U>l l 8W\Ol6:O?Wc?\ l %RQlY?U:Q`J?_l_I:RQl<?HJUl`Wl:==\b?lWUl`I?l>:fl:A`?\l`I?l=WTYQ?`?lY?\G\T:U=?lJ_ >b?lW\l`I?l>:fl:lcJWR:`JWUlW==b\_l:U>l_I:QRl=WU`JUb?l`Wl:==\b?l`I\WbHIl`I?lEU:Rl>:flWAl`I?l =W\\?=`JWUlWAl`I?lUWU=WTYRJ:U=?lW\l=WTYR?`JWUlWAl`I?l:=`JcJ`f l+We?c?\ l_`JYbR:`?>lY?U:Q`J?_l _I:RQlUW`l:==\b?$l : leJ`Il\?_Y?=`l`Wl:l>?F=J?U`l_b<TJ__JWUlbU>?\l4?=`JWUl l %YY\Wc:RlWAl l Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 33 of 50 PageID #: 1126 +@TNe@];=U@_ iYCi`M@i3)i82 i?c]NXLi`MAi[@]NY? iNCi;Xh i=@LNXXNXLiYXi`M@i _`i?;hi;C`@]i`M@i,2) _i ]@>@N[`iYCi_c>Mi_c=WN__NYXicX`Ni/i`M@i?;`@i`M;`i`M@i,2)iXY`NF@_i4+_iYCi;Xhi?@G>N@X>h%i = ifN`Mi ]@_[@>`i`Yi;i?@>N_NYXi=hi`M@i+N]@>`Y]iYCi`M@i5c[@]CcX?i i,W@]L@X>hi0;X;L@W@X`i+NeN_NYX i,2)i 3@LNYXi icX?@]iQi ! =iY]i " ;iYCi5@>`NYXi +N_[c`@i3@_YTc`NYX i?c]NXLi`M@i[@]NY? iNCi;Xh i =@LNXXNXLiYXi`M@i _`i?;hi;J@]i`M@i?;`@i`M;`i4+_ i]@[Thi`Yi`M@i,2)i _i4`;`@W@X`iYCi2Y_N`NYXiN_i ]@>@Ne@?icX`NTi`M@i?;`@i`M;`i`M@i+N]@>`Y]iN__cB_i;iGX;Ti?@>N_NYXi]@L;]?NXLi_c>Mi?N_[c`@&iY]i > ifN`Mi ]@_[@>`i`YiRc?N>N;Ui]@eN@fi=hi`MN_i*Yc]`iYCi;Xhi?N_[c`@icX?@]i4@>`NYXi +N_[c`@i3@_YUc`NYX i ?c]NXLi`M@i[@]NY? iNCi;Xh i=@LNXXNXLiYXi`M@i _`i?;hi;Ea@]i`M@i*Yc]` _i]@>@N[`iYCi`M@iGX;Ti _c=WN__NYXi]@L;]?NXLi`M@i?N_[c`@icX`NTi`M@i?;`@i`M;`i`M@i*Yc^`iN__c@_i;iFX;Ti?@>N_NYXi]@L;]?NXLi _c>Mi?N_[c`@ i1Y`MNXLiNXi`MN_i*+i_M;TUi[]@e@X`i`M@i_NWcU`;X@Yc_i;>>]c;TiYCi_@[;];`@i[@X;U`N@_i H]i _@[;];`@ieNYU;`NYX_iYCi`MN_i*+ i -YUTYfNXLi`M@i,2) _i?@`@]WNX;`NYXi`M;`i4+_iM;e@iD<NT@?i`Yi>YW[UhifN`Mi; ]@\cN]@W@X`iYCi`MN_i*+ i`M@i,2)iW;hiLNe@i4+_if]N``@XiXY`NG>;`NYXiYCi`M@i_;W@i;X?i?@_>]N=Bi`M@i XYX>YW[UN;X>@ i6M@i,2)i 9;X?i`M@i4`;`@:iW;hi_@X?i5+_i;if]N``@Xi?@W;X?iDZ]i[;hW@X`iYCi`M@i [@X;T`N@_ i.Yf@e@] i[@X;T`N@_i_M;UUi;>>]c@i;_i[]YeN?@?iNXi`M@i[]@>@?NXLi2;];L];[Mi]@L;]?U@__iYCi fM@`M@]i`M@i,2)iM;_iXY`NG@?i4+_iYCi;ieNYT;`NYX i )TUi[@X;T`N@_i;>>]cNXLicX?@]i`MN_i5@>`NYXi_M;UTi=@i?c@i;X?i[;h;=U@i`Yi`M@i 7XN`@? 4`;`@_i fN`MNXi i?;h_i;K@]i4+_ i]@>@N[`iIYWi`M@i ,2)iYCi;i?@W;X?iDZ]i[;hW@X`iYCi`M@i[@X;T`N@_ i cXT@__i5+_iNXeYS@i`M@i+N_[c`@i3@_YTc`NYXi[]Y>@?c]@_icX?@]i5@>`NYXi +N_[c`@i3@_YUc`NYX i fN`MNXi`M@i ?;hi[@]NY? i)TUi[;hW@X`_i`Yi`M@i7XN`@?i5`;`@_icX?@]i`MN_i4@>`NYXi_M;TUiNX?N>;`@i`M;`i `M@i[;hW@X`iN_i DZ]i_`N[cU;`@?i[@X;U`N@_i;X?i_M;TUi=@iW;?@iNXi;>>Y]?;X>@ifN`Mi >i NX_`]c>`NYX_i EZ]iCd`c]@i]@_[YX_@i>Y_`i[;hW@X`_ i ! 2@X;U`N@_i_M;TUi>YX`NXc@i`Yi;>>]c@i;_i[]YeN?@?iNXi i?c]NXLi;Xhi?N_[c`@ ]@_YUc`NYXi[@]NY? i=c`iX@@?iXY`i=@i[;N?icX`NTi`M@iEZTUYfNXL#i ; /Ci`M@i?N_[c`@iN_i]@_YUe@?i=hi;L]@@W@X`iYCi`M@i[;]`N@_iY]i=hi;i?@>N_NYXiYC `M@i ,2)i `M;`iN_iXY`i;[[@;U@?i`Yi`MN_i*Yc]` i;>>]c@?i[@X;U`N@_i?@`@]WNX@?i`Yi=@iYf@?i_M;UTi=@i[;N?i `Yi`M@i,2)i ;X?i`M@i4`;`@:ifN`MNXi i?;h_i;J@]i`M@i;L]@@W@X`iY]i`M@i]@>@N[`iYCi`M@i,2) _i ?@>N_NYXiY]iY]?@]'i = UCi`M@i?N_[c`@iN_i;[[@;U@?i`Yi`MN_i*Yc^bi;X?i`M@i7XN`@?i4`;`@_i[]@e;NT_iNX fMYT@iY]iNXi[;^` i 5+_i _M;TUi[;hi;UTi;>>]c@?i[@X;U`N@_i?@`@]WNX@?i=hi`M@i*Yc^`i`Yi=@i Yf@?i `Yi`M@i ,2)ifN`MNXi! i?;h_i;Ea@]i]@>@N[`iYCi`M@i*Yc]` _i?@>N_NYXiY]iY]?@] i@g>@[`i;_i[]YeN?@?iNXiPVi ! >(i > TCi`M@i+N_`]N>`i*Yc^b _i?@>N_NYXiN_i;[[@;U@?i=hi;Xhi2;^bh i 4+_i_M;TUi[;hi;TT ;>>]c@?i[@X;T`N@_i?@`@]WNX@?i=hi`M@i+N_`]N>`i*Yc]`i`Yi=@iYf@?i`Yi`M@i7XN`@?i4`;`@_iNX`Yi;Xi NX`@]@_` =@;]NXLi@_>]Yfi;>>YcX` i@_`;=TN_M@?i;`i;i?cUhi>M;]`@]@?i=;XSiY]i`]c_`i>YW[;Xhi`M;`iN_i NX_c]@?i=hi`M@i-+/* ifN`MNXi! i?;h_i;K@]i]@>@N[`iYCi`M@i*Yc]` _i?@>N_NYXiY]iY]?@] i2@X;T`N@_i_M;UTi =@i[;N?iNX`Yi`MN_i;>>YcX`i;_i`M@hi>YX`NXc@i`Yi;>>]c@ i;`iU@;_`i@e@^hi! i?;h_ i8N`MNXi i?;h_i;J@]i ]@>@N[`iYCi`M@iGX;Ui;[[@TT;`@i>Yc]`i?@>N_NYX i`M@i@_>]Yfi;L@X`i_M;UTi[;hi`M@i=;T;X>@iYCi`M@i;>>YcX`i `Yi`M@i ,2)iY]i`Yi4+_i`Yi`M@i@g`@X`i`M;`i`M@hi[]@e;NT i " UCi4+_iE<NUi`Yi[;hi_`N[cT;`@?i[@X;U`N@_ifM@Xi?c@ i5+_i_M;UTi[;hiOX`@]@_`iYXi`M@ cX[;N?i_`N[cU;`B?i[@X;U`N@_i;_iHUTYf_$i ; iNCi5+_iM;e@i`NW@UhiNXeYS@?i?N_[c`@i]@_YTc`NYXi_c>Mi !i Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 34 of 50 PageID #: 1127 £zT£½£z^½ V |xT£{ ½£ ½ T³½ £{ ¦ T£^\½ ^ T £{^ ½zT ½V^^ ½ £T³^\½ ^ \{ x½£z^½ ¦£Y ^½ e½\{ ¦£^½ ^ ¦£| ½: £^ ^ £½ zT ½TYY ¦^½n ½£z^½\T£^½ £{ ¦ T£^\½ ^ T £{^ ½T ^½\¦^½ ¦ ¦T £½£ ½ )*½¦ £{ ½ £z^½\T£^½ e½ T³ ^ £/½T \½ V ½|e G4 ½iU{ ½£ ½£{ ^ ³½{ © ^½\{ ¦£^½ ^ ¦£| ½: £^ ^ £½ zT ½TYY §^½ u ½£z^½\T£^½ e½\^ T \½¦ \^ ½ ))½¦ £{ ½£z^½\T£^½ e½ T³ ^ £ ½:e½G4 ½iU| ½£ ½ T³½ £{ ¦ T£^\½ ^ T £{^ ½T \½; £^ ^ £½z^ ½\¦^ ½£z^½O {£^\½G£T£^ ½ ½£z^½G£T£^½ T³½| £{£¦£^½ Y^^\{ x ½£ ½ Y ^Y£½£z^½ ^ T £|^ ½T \½: £^ ^ £ ½ ), Mz^½ T³ ^ £½ e½ ^ T £{^ ½T \½ ; £^ ^ £ ½|e½T ³ ½ zT ½ £½T £^ ½| ½T ³½T³½G4 » V {xT£| ½£ ½Y ^£^½£z^½ ^ r T Y^½ e½£z^½R ½ ^ ¦{ ^\½¦ \^ ½£z{ ½24 ½ )- @ ¤z} y½| ½¥z}¡½34½¢zT ½W_½Y ¡¤ §`\½T¢½ z}V|¤} y ½T ¤` ~ y ½ ½| ½T ´½®T´ | |¤| y½¤za½TX| }¤µ½ f½¤zb½ P }¤b\½H¤T¤`¡½¤ ½¡`b ½T µ½ ¤za ½ ^ `\~`¡½ ½¡T Y¤| ¡½TªT} TW `½Wµ½ ª ¥§a½ fI5¡¼½ ª| T¤~ ½ e½¤z{¡½35½ ½ f½¤zb½¡£T¤§£a¡½T \½ by§ T¤} ½§ ½®z}Yz½~¤½}¢½XT¢a\ ½ } Y §\{ y ½W§£½ ¤½ | |¤`\½¤ ½ b T ¤|b¡½ § ¡§T ¤½¤ ½JbY¤| ½ "## ½ e½36E3=1 ½'#½O K 3 ½¹½ .*## S ½ «|\`] ½z ¯aªb ½¤zT¤½£zb½P }¤b\½J¤T¤b¡½ zT ½ £½¢`` ½Y}ª| ½ a T ¤|a¡½ § ¡§T ¤½£ ½ HaY¤| ½ "$% S ½ e½37E3=0½g ½T ´½ª} T¤| ½m ½®z}Yz½T½¢¤{ § T¤a\½ a T ¤¶½ |¡½ ª}\a\½~ ½¤z}¡½ 34 c±Y` ¤½| ½¤zb½YT¡b½ e½T½°| v ½ª} T¤| ½ f½¤z|¡½34 *! ¤°|¤z¡¤T \} y½T ¶½ ¤za ½ ª|¡} ½ f½¤z} ½KaY¤| ½¤z`½Q }¤b\½ J¤T¤_¡½ T· ½| ½|¤¢ § bª}b°TW ^½\|¡Y `£| ½®T}ªb½T ¶½ £| ½ f½¡¤} § T¤b\½ ` T ¤|`¡½¤zT¤½zTª`½TYY §a\½ § ¡§T ¤½£ ½ ¤z}¡½34 ½ " " *½>½ 2 ©^ T £ ½i ½G4 ½V³½O |£^\½G£T£^ ½8²Y^ £½T ½ ©{\^\½| ½ *# ½*&½ O |£^\½ G£T£^ ½B ^ T \½C £ 2^ £|pYT£| ½F^ ^ ©T£| ½T \½*)½ 9^ ^ T ½F^ ^ ©T£| ½ e½F{xz£ ½£z^½ O |£^\½G£T£^ ½Y ©^ T £ ½ £½£ ½ ¦^½ ½£ ½£T ^½T\ { { £ T¤|©^½TY£{ ½TxT{ £½G4 ½ ¦ ¦T £½£ ½^{£z^ ½ G^Y£| ½ "!*½T \½ "!+ T ½ e 27F2?1½ ^ T£{ x½£ ½£z^½G|£^½ ½ G^Y£{ ½+!!&½ e F2F1 ½(#½O G 2 ½ º *-+&½ ^ T£{ x½£ ½£z^½R ½7²Y^ £½{£z½ ^ ^Y£½£ ½w£§ ^½ {TV| |£³ ½£z^ ^½Y ©^ T £ ½ zT ½£T ^ ^o^Y£½¦ ½£z^½8lk^Y£{©^½4T£^ ½ R|£z½ ^ ^Y£½£ ½h¨£¦ ^½ {TV{ |£³ ½£z^ ^½Y ©^ T £ ½ zT ½£T ^½^jk^Y£ ¦ ½2^ £|pYT£| ½ e½F1½2 ^£| ½V³½£z^½8D1½ ¦ ¦T £½£ ½G^Y£{ ½+ (½ 2^ £{qYT£{ ½ e½F1 2 ^£| ½ e½£z^½F1½RD ½ Mz^ ^½Y ©^ T £ ½T ^½Y \{£| ^\½¦ ½£z^½ T£{ iUY£ ³½ ^ r T Y^ V³½G4 ½ e½£z^{ ½ V {xT£| ½¦ \^ ½£z| ½24 ½Nz^ ^½Y ©^ T £ ½^²£^ \½ ³½£ ½G4 ½T \½\ ½ £ ^²£^ \½£ ½T ³½ £z^ ½ ^ *# " " " ! " A £{£z £T \| x½T ³½ £z^ ©{ | ½ e½£z{ ½24 ½£z^½O |£^\½G¤T£^ ½ ^ ^ ©^ ½T \½£z| ½24½| ½|£z ¦£½ ^ ¦\{Y^½£ ½£z^½ {xz£½ £ ½| £{£¦£^½ Y^^\{ x ½| ½£z| ½TY£| ½ ½{ ½T½ ^½TY£{ ½T \ ½£ ½| ¦^½T ½T\ | { £ T£{©^½ \^ ½ ^^ { x½£ ½Y ^ ½G4 ½£ ½ ^ s ½e¦ £z^ ½ ^ ^½TY£{ ½ ^ T£| x½£ ½¤z^½G{£^½T \ ½£ ½ T³½£z^½O {£^\½G£T£^ ½r ½T\\{£{ T ½Y £ ½ e½ ^ ^½{e ½ T ½ | ½£ ½2^ £|j{YT£{ ½ e½F1½ 2 ^£{ ½ < ½Z \}¤} ¡½T¤½£za½L}¤` ½ `«} §¡ ´½§ ° ½¤ ½¤z`½7B1 ½T a½\}¡Y ª` b\ ½ ½ # } t T¤} ½ dª} §¡ ´½§ ® ½¤ ½¤zb½7B1 ½}¡½ a[`}¬`\ ½~ ½°z a½ ½} ½ T ¤ ½T \½ X ½¤z` 7B1½\`¤^ } `¡½¤zT¤½¤zb¢d½ aª} §¡ ¸½§ ° ½Y \}¤{ ¡½ ½} g T¤} ½¤ y`¤z_ ½°}¥z½T ´ ¤zb ½ _ aªT ¤½} t T¤| ½} \}YT¤a¡½¤zT¤½¤z`½E1½}¡½ ¤½ ¤`Y¤}¬`½ f½z§ T ½zcT ¤z½ ½¤zb a ¬} ` ¤ #+½ Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 35 of 50 PageID #: 1128 -_ipQiPhi9^=Q^Os9^rs_jP>d ad_oQhQ_^s_AsiPQhs'( siP>s5^Qi>=s3j9i>hsd>h>do>h s9^=siPQhs'(sQhspQjP_lisad>Vl=Q<>si_ siP>sdQOPisj_s Q^hiQili>sad_<>>=Q^OhsQ^siPQhs9<iQ_^s_dsQ^s9s^>ps9<iQ_^ s9^= _dsj_sQhhl>s9^s9=\Q^Qhid9iQo>s_d=>d s h>>XQ^Osi_s<_\a>Ys3.hsj_sa>dG`d\sAmdjP>dsd>ha_^h>s9<iQ_^hsd>Z9jQ^Osj_sjP>s3Qj>s9^= _dsj_sa9rsiP>s 5^Qi>=s3i9i?hsLds9==QiQ_^9Ys<_hihs_Asd>ha_^h>sQB s 9 shl;h>bl>^jsi_s'>diQGT<9jQ_^s_As2&s '_\aY>iQ_^ s + s<_^=QiQ_^hs9jsiP>s3Qi> sad>oQ_lhZrsl^X^_p^si_siP>s)0& s9d>s=Qh<_o>d>= s_ds Q^Ld\9iQ_^ sad>oQ_lhYrsl^X^_p^sj_sjP>s)0& sQhsd><>Qo>= sQ^spP_Y>s_dsQ^sa9di s9^=s ; siP> )0&s=>i>d\Q^>hsiP9jsiP>h>sad>oQ_lhZrsl^X^_p^s<_^=QiQ_^hs_dsiPQhsQ^Ld\9iQ_^si_O>iP>dspQjP _iP>dsd>Z>o9^isQ^Ld\9iQ_^sQ^=Q<9i>siP9isjP>s1&sQhs^_isad_i><iQo>s_AsPl\9^sP>9YiPs_dsjP> >^oQd_^\>^i *_dsalda_h>hs_A Rs s 5^Qi>=s3i9i>h s 0d> '>diQK<9iQ_^s1>h>do9jQ_^h sjP> Q^Le]9iQ_^s9^=siP>s<_^=QiQ_^hsX^_p^si_siP>s)0&spQYYsQ^<Yl=>s_^ZrsjP9isQ^Ld\9jQ_^s9^=sjP_h>s <_^=QjQ_^hsX^_p^sj_siP>s)0&s9hs_AsjP>s=9i>siP>s1/(sp9hshQO^>=s9^=sh>isE`djPsQ^sjP>s1/(sLdsiP>s 3Qi>s9^=sjP>s9=\Q^Qhid9iQo>sd><_d=shlaa_djQ^OsiP>s1/( s*_dsalda_h>hs_A Ss s 6^Qj>=s3j9j>h s 0_hi '>diQFQ<9iQ_^s1>h>do9iQ_^h siP>sQ^E`d\9iQ_^s9^=sjP>s<_^=QiQ_^hsX^_p^sj_s)0&shP9YZsQ^<Zl=>s _^ZrsiP9jsQ^Ld\9iQ_^s9^=siP_h>s<_^=QiQ_^hsX^_p^sj_sjP>s)0&s9hs_AsjP>s=9j>s_As'>djQK<9iQ_^s_As 1&s'_\aZ>jQ_^s9^=sh>isLdiPsQ^siP>s1/( siP>s9=\Q^Qhjd9iQo>sd><_d=shlaa_djQ^OsiP>s1/( siP>s a_hj 1/(s9=\Q^Qhjd9jQo>sd><_d= s_dsQ^s9^rsQ^Ld\9iQ_^sd><>Qo>=s;rsiP>s)0&saldhl9^jsj_sjP>s d>blQd>\>^jhs_AsjPQhs'(sadQ_dsj_s'>djQGU<9jQ_^s_As1&s'_\aZ>iQ_^ s 4P>s5^Qi>=s3j9i>hsd>h>go>h s9^=sjPQhs'(sQh pQiP_lisad@Wl=Q<>sj_ s9ZYsdQOPihs9O9Q^his3(hspQjPsd>ha?<isj_s9YYs\9ji>dhs^_is>qad>hhYrsQ^<Yl=>=s pQiPQ^s0Z9Q^jQFJhs<_o>^9^ih s-_ipQjPhj9^=Q^Os9^rs_iP>dsad_oQhQ_^s_AsiPQhs'( siP>s7^Qi>=s3j9i>hs d>h>go>hs9YZsdQOPihs9O9Q^his3(hspQiPsd>ha><jsi_!s 9 [Q9;QZQjrsLdsE:QYld>s;rs3(hsi_s\>>is9sd>clQd>\>^js_AsjPQhs'(" ZQ9;QYQirs9dQhQ^OsM_\siP>sa9hi sad>h>^j s_dsEnild>s=Qha_h9Y sd>Y>9h> s_dsjPd>9j ; _Asd>Z>9h>s_As89hj>s,9i>dQ9Ys_ljhQ=>s_AsiP>s3Qi>#s < YQ9;QZQirs;9h>=s_^sjP>s_p^>dhPQas_AsiP>s3Qi>s;rs3(hspP>^shl<Ps_p^>dhPQa <_\\>^<>hs9N>dshQO^9ild>s_AsiPQhs'(s;rs3(h$s = YQ9;QYQjrs;9h>=s_^sjP>s_a>d9jQ_^s_AsjP>s3Qj>s;rs3(hspP>^shl<Ps_a>d9iQ_^ <_\\>^<>hs9Gk>dshQO^9jld>s_AsiPQhs'(s;rs3.hs9^=s=_>hs^_js9dQh>sh_Y>ZrsIf_\s3.h sa>dLd\9^<>s _AsiP>s8_dX%s > YQ9;QZQjrs;9h>=s_^s3(h sid9^ha_dj9iQ_^ sjd>9i\>^j shi_d9O> s_ds=Qha_h9Y s_d 9dd9^O>\>^isLdsid9^ha_dj9jQ_^ sid>9j\>^i shi_d9O> s_ds=Qha_h9Zs_As89hj>s,9i>dQ9Zs9js_dsQ^s <_^^><iQ_^spQjPsiP>s3Qi> s_iP>dsiP9^s9hsad_oQ=>=sQ^sjP>s1/( siP>s8_dX s_ds_iP>gpQh>s_d=>d>=s;rs iP>s)0& s9Hk>dshQO^9jld>s_AsiPQhs'(s;rs3(h"s YQ9;QYQjrsH`ds=9\9O>hsG`dsQ^Vlgrsj_ s=>hjdl<jQ_^s_D s_dsY_hhs_As^9ild9Y C d>h_ld<>h s9^=sLdsiP>s<_hihs_As9^rs^9jld9Zsd>h_ld<>s=9\9O>s9hh>hh\>^jh"s O <dQ\Q^9YsZQ9;QYQir" Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 36 of 50 PageID #: 1129 ^ e`IJ_e_pwyRjmyt`ifIp`ihoyiOyONLNmIfyimyoqIqNyeIuyq^IqyiKKsmyLsm`h]yimyIYNm `gkfNgMhqIq`ihyiOyp^NyEimd,yIhLy ` e_IJ_e_pw ykm`imyqiyIK^_NtNgNhpyiOy>NmWmgIhKNy@pIhLImLo yWmyILL`p_ihIe mNokihoNyIKp_ihoyq^Ipyp^Ny4>1yLNqNng_hNoyImNyhNKNooImwyqiyIK^_NtNyIhLygI`hpI`hy>NmPimgIhKNy @qIhLImLoyimyqiyKImmwyisqyIhLygI`hpI`hyp^NyNOQNKq_tNhNooyiOyp^NymNgNLwyoNqyRjnq^y_hyq^Ny?=3 yJsqy p^IpyKIhhipyJNymNls`mNLyksmosIhpypiy !#y ;iL`UKIp_ihyiOyEimdy>eIhyimy?NfIqNLy3Nf`tNmIJfNo -y && I 9hyq^NyNtNhpyq^Ny4>1yLNqNng`hNoyp^Iqy@3o*y 7 y^ItNyKNIoNLy`gkfNgNhpIp_ih iOyIhwykinq_ihyiOyp^NyEimd.y " yImNyoNm`isoewyimymNkNIqNLewyLNO_K_NhpyimyeIqNy_hyp^N`mykNmSjngIhKNy iOyp^NyEimd/yimy # yImNy_gkfNgNhq_h]yp^NyEimdy`hyIygIhhNmyq^IqygIwyKIsoNyIhyNhLIh]NmgNhpypiy ^sgIhy^NIeq^yimyp^NyNht`mihgNhq yq^Ny4>1ygIwy`oosNyIyum`qpNhyhipaKNy EimdyBIdNitNmy<ip_KN y qiy@3o y1hwyEimdyBIdNitNmy<ip_KNy`oosNLyJwy4>1yubffyokNK`\yp^Ny]mishLoyskihyu^`K^yosK^y hip_KNyuIoy_oosNLyIhLyu_ffykmit`LNy@3oyIykNm`iLyiOy yLIwoyu_p^`hyu^`K^yqiymNgNLwyq^Ny K_mKsgopIhKNoy]`t`h]ym_oNyqiyq^Ny4>1 oy`oosIhKNyiOyosK^yhip`KN y J 8O yIZNmyNvk`mIq_ihyiOyp^Ny9y LIwyhip_KNykNm`iLyokNK_UNLy`hy y&& I y@3o ^ItNyhipymNgNL`NLypiyp^Ny4>1 oyoIq`oTKq_ihyp^NyK_mKsgoqIhKNoy]`t_h]ym`oNypiyq^Ny4>1 oy_oosIhKNy iOyp^NymNeNtIhqyEimdyAIdNitNmy<ip_KN yq^Ny4>1ygIwyIpyIhwyq`gNyq^NmNIZNmyIoosgNyq^Ny kNmRjngIhKNyiOyIfeyimyIhwykinq`ih o yiOyq^NyEimdyIoyq^Ny4>1yLNNgoyhNKNooInwy Eimdy BIdNitNm yB^Ny4>1yu_feyhiq`\y@3oy_hyum`q_h]y u^`K^yum_p_h]ygIwyJNyNeNKrmih_K y`Oyp^Ny4>1y LNpNmg`hNoyq^Ipy`gkeNgNhqIp`ihyiOyIyEimdyBIdNitNmy`oyuImmIhpNLyshLNmyp^`oy && J y5shL`h]yiOy EimdyBIdNitNmyKioqoy`oyILLmNooNLyshLNmy "(y 1KKNooypiy5`hIhK`Ify1oosmIhKN y K @3oygIwy_htidNyp^NykmiKNLsmNoyoNqyRjnq^y_hy $&y ?NKimLy?Nt_Nu ypi L_oksqNyp^Ny4>1y oy`gkeNgNhpIp`ihyiOyIyEimdyBIdNitNmyshLNmy && J y6iuNtNm yhiqu`q^opIhL`h]y @3o y _htiKIq`ihyiOyosK^yL`okspNymNoiesp`ihykmiKNLsmNo yIhLyLsm_h]yp^NykNhLNhKwyiOyIhwyosK^y L`oksqN yq^Ny4>1ygIwy_hy`qoyoieNyL_oKmNq`ihyKiggNhKNyIhLyKihp`hsNyIyEimdyBIdNitNmyshLNmy y && Jyshp_y9yq^NyNImf_NmyiOy 9 yp^NyLIqNyp^Iqy@3oymNgNLw ypiyp^Ny4>1y oyoIp_oTKq_ih yp^NyK`mKsgopIhKNo ]`t`h]ym`oNypiyq^Ny4>1 oy`oosIhKNyiOyq^NymNeNtIhpyEimdyBIdNitNmy<iq`KN yimy " yq^NyLIqNyp^IpyI VhIfyLNK`o`ihy`oymNhLNmNLy`hyIKKimLIhKNyu`q^y %&y ?NKimLy?Nt`Nu ymNls_m`h]yp^Ny4>1ypi pNmg`hIqNyosK^yEimdyCIdNitNm &' <iqu`q^opIhL`h]yIhwyiq^Nmykmit`o`ihyiOyq^`oy23 yp^NyDh`qNLy@pIqNoyIhLyp^Ny@qIqN mNpI_hFoHyIfeyIsq^im`pwyIhLymNoNmtNGoHyIfeymb]^qoyqiypIdNyIhwyIhLyIfeymNokihoNyIKq`ihoyIsq^im_xNLyJwy eIu y 2itNhIhqoyJwy@3o y@sJcNKqypiyq^NymNoNntIq_ihoy_hy ' y@3oyKitNhIhqyhipypiyosN IhLyI]mNNyhipypiyIooNmpyIhwyKeI_goyimyKIsoNoyiOyIKp`ihyI]I`hoqyp^NyDh`qNLy@qIpNoyu_q^ymNokNKqyqiyq^Ny @_qNyIhLyq^`oy23 y`hKesL_h] yJspyhiqye`g_qNLyqi+y I IhwyL_mNKpyimy`hL`mNKpyKeI`gyWmymN`gJsmoNgNhpyXigyp^Ny4>1y6IxImLiso @sJoqIhKNy@skNm[hLyp^mis]^y24?2:1y & J " y ' y !"yimy imyIhwyip^Nmy kmit_o`ihyiOyfIu0y ")y Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 37 of 50 PageID #: 1130 H GatxJ]GX`kxpaKLix-0=-8,x &xdix 6x " x=-=,x>LJlXdax& ! G #!x @ > - x %(&! G xdixklGlLx^GrxiLVGiKXaVxlWLx>XlLxlWLxEdi[ xgGklxiLkgdakLxGJlXdakxiLVGiKXaVx lWLx>XlL x3plpiLx=LkgdakLx-dklk xGaKxlWXkx-.*xdix J GatxJ^GX`kxGiXkXaVxdplx dNxiLkgdakLxGJlXdakxGlxdix Xax JdaaLJlXdaxrXlWxlWLx>XlL XaJ]pKXaVxGatxJ]GX`xpaKLixlWLx@aXlLKx>lGlLkx-daklXlplXda xlWLx?pJ[Lix,Jl x!'x @x > - x #( xlWLx 0hpG]x,JJLkkxldx7pklXJLx,Jl x!'x @ > - x !# ! xdixGlxJd``dax^Gr x %( x 1sJLglxGkxgidqXKLKxXax &!x EGXqLixdNx-^GX`kxHtx>.k xGaKx&'x =Lkx7pKXJGlGxGaKx ;lWLix/LNLakLk xlWLxJdqLaGalkxXaxlWXkx>LJlXdaxkWG]^xadlxGgg^txXNxlWLx @aXlLKx >lGlLkxHiXaVkxGxJGpkLx dNxGJlXdaxdixXkkpLkxGaxdiKLixgpikpGalxldxGatxdNxlWLxiLkLiqGlXdakxXax>LJlXdaxFDx -dqLaGalkxHtx <]GXalXo_ xdlWLixlWGaxXax Y Yx%$ Gx J]GX`kxOeix PX]piLxldx`LLlxGxiLhpXiL`LalxdNxlWLx-. x%$ Vx JiX`XaG]x]XGHX]Xlt xGaKx%$ Wx qXd]GlXdakxdNxOMKLiG] klGlLx]GrxKpiXaVxdixGULixX`g^L`LalGlXdaxdNxlWLx Edi\ xHplxda]txldxlWLxLslLalxlWGlx>.k xJ^GX`kxGiXkLxTd`xlWLxkG`LxiLkgdakLxGJlXda xiLkgdakLx Jdklk xdixKG`GVLkxlWGlxlWLx@aXlLKx>lGlLkxXkxkLL[XaVxgpikpGalxldxlWLxGgg^XJGH]LxiLkLjqGlXda x & >.kxiLkLiqL xGaKxlWXkx-.xXkxrXlWdplxgiLZpKXJLxld xJ^GX`kxGVGXaklxlWLx AaXlLKx>lGlLk kpHZLJlxldxlWLxgidqXkXdakxdNx-WGglLix & x dNx?Xl^Lx!'xdNxlWLxBaXlLKx>lGlLkx-dKL xGaKxHidpVWlx gpikpGalxldxGatxklGlplLxdlWLixlWGax-0=-9,xdix=-=,xGaKxOeixrWXJWxlWLxrGXqLixdNxkdqLiLXVax X``paXltxXkxSpaKxXaxGxklGlplLxdlWLixlWGax-1=-9,xdix=-=, xOeix`daLtxKG`GVLkxSixXbpitxdix ^dkkxdNxgidgLimtxdixgLikdaG]xXcpjtxdixKLGlWxJGpkLKxHtxlWLxaLV^XVLalxdixridaVNp^xGJlxdixd`XkkXdax dNxGatxL`g]dtLLxdNxlWLx@aXlLKx>lGlLk xGkxlWGlxlLi`xXkxKLRaLKxXax!'x @ > - xwx!%& xrWX]LxGJlXaVx rXlWXaxlWLxkJdgLxdNxWXkxdixWLixdQJLxdixL`g]dt`LalxpaKLixJXiJp`klGaJLkxrWLiLxlWLxCaXlLKx >lGlLk xXNxGxgiXqGlLxgLikda xrdp]KxHLx^XGH]LxldxlWLxJ]GX`GalxXaxGJJdiKGaJLxrXlWxlWLx^GrxdNxlWLxg^GJLx rWLiLxlWLxGJlxdixd`XkkXdaxdJJpiiLK x4drLqLi xlWLxOeiLVdXaVxkWG]^xadlxXaJ^pKLxGatxJ^GX`xHGkLKxdax lWLx0<, kxkL]LJlXdaxdNxiLkgdakLxGJlXdak xdixlWLxdqLikXVWlxdixGggidqG]xdNx>.k x KL^XqLiGH^Lkxdix GJlXqXlXLk x & :dlWXaVxXaxlWXkx-.xkWG]x6xHLxKLL`LKxldxJdaklXlplLxGggidqG^xdixgiLGplWdiXvGlXdaxdNxG J^GX`xrXlWXaxlWLx`LGaXaVxdNx>LJlXdax xdNx-2=-9, x#!x@ > - x (% xdix# x- 3 = x " & K &! Iux >.kxGViLLxadlxldxGkkLilxGatxJ]GX`kxGaKxldxrGXqLxG]^xJ^GX`kxdixJGpkLkxdN G GJlXdax XaJ^pKXaVxHplxadlx]X`XlLKxldxJ]GX`kxdixJGpkLkxdNxGJlXdaxpaKLix>LJlXdakx 6x & G xGaKx 6x "xdNx -0=-9, xlWGlxlWLtx`GtxWGqL)x 5 3dixG^]x`GllLikxiL^GlXaVxldxlWLx>XlLxGVGXakl GatxgLikdaxrWLiLxlWLxgLikda kx^XGHX^Xltxldx>.kxrXlWxiLkgLJlxldxlWLx>XlLxXkxHGkLKx kd^L^txdaxWGqXaVxGiiGaVLKxOeixKXkgdkG^xdixliLGl`Lal xdixSixliGakgdilxOfixKXkgdkG^xdix liLGl`Lal xdNxWGvGiKdpkxkpHklGaJLkxGlxlWLx>XlL xdixWGqXaVxGJJLglLKx OeixliGakgdilx Ofix KXkgdkG^xdixliLGl`LalxdNxWGvGiKdpkxkpHklGaJLkxGlxlWLx>XlL xXNxG^]xdixgGjnxdNxlWLx KXkgdkG^ xliLGl`Lal xdixliGakgdjmxdJJpijLKxHLSiLx,giX^x 6 x! x5 xGaKxlWLxldlG^x G`dpalxdNx`GlLiXG]xJdalGXaXaVxWGvGiKdpkxkpHklGaJLkxJdaliXHplLKxHtxkpJWxgLikdaxldx lWLx>XlLxrGkx^LkkxlWGax xVG]]dakxdNx]XhpXKx`GlLiXG^kxdix! xgdpaKkxdNxkd]XKx `GlLiXG^k+x " x Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 38 of 50 PageID #: 1131 @ 1 9TCvo?UnCfvmaBCfvkTUjv Yv&!vjT?]]vabkv?dd]qvoVkTvfCjdCAkvkbv?aq BCOajC vA^?U_ vbfvA?mjCvbEv?AkVbavkT?kv?v8/v_?qvT?nCv?S?Uajkv?aqvdCfjbav bkTCfoUjCvAbnCfCBv@qvjmATvo?VnCfvVEvjmATvdCfjbav?jjCfkjv?vA]?V_vbfvA?mjCvbFv?AkUbav fC]?kVaSvkbvkTCv8UkCv?S?VajkvjmATv8/ v ! 9TCvo?UnCfvmaBCfv Yv&!v /Cv4VAfb_Ujv<?UnCf vjT?^]vabkv?dd]qvkbv?aq A]?V_vbfvA?mjCvbFv?AkVbav?S?Vajkv?aqvdCfjbavbkTCfoUjCvAbnCfCBv@qvjmATvo?UnCfvVFv 06-vBCkCf_UaCjvkT?k)v V vkTCv_?kCfU?^jvAbak?UaUaSvT?r?fBbmjvjm@jk?aACjvAbakfV@mkCBv kbvkTCv8VkCv@qvjmATvdCfjbavAbakfU@mkCBvjUSaUPA?ak]qvbfvAbm]BvAbakfU@mkCv jUSaVPA?ak]q vCVkTCfvVaBVnUBm?]^qvbfvVavkTCv?SSfCS?kC vkbvkTCvAbjkvbFvkTCvfCjdbajCv ?AkUbavbfva?kmf?^vfCjbmfACvfCjkbf?kVbav?kvkTCv8UkC*vbfv VU vjmATvdCfjbavT?jvNU]CBvkbv Ab_d^qvoUkTv?aqvVaQf_?kVbavfCemCjkvbfv?B_VaUjkf?kVnCvjm@dbCa?vUjjmCBvdmfjm?akv kbv8CAkVbav # C vbfv !! C " ' vbFv.07.3- v#!v: 8 . vuv(% # C vbfv (%!! C " ' vbfv8CAkVbav" &vbFv7.7- v#!v: 8 . vuv%(!& vbfvT?jvV_dCBCBvbfvUjv U_dCBVaS vkTfbmSTv?AkUbavbfvVa?AkVba vkTCvdCfGcg`?aACvbEv?vfCjdbajCv?AkUbavbfv a?kmf?^vfCjbmfACvfCjkbf?kUbavoVkTvfCjdCAkvkbvkTCv8UkC+vbfvVEv UUU vjmATvdCfjbavT?jv@CCav AbanUAkCBvbEv?vAfV_Va?^vnVb]?kVbavQfvkTCvAbaBmAkvkbvoTVATvkTCvo?VnCfvobm^Bv?dd]qv ?aBvkT?kvAbanUAkVbavT?jvabkv@CCavnVkU?kCBvbav?ddC?^vbfvbkTCioVjC v &" 0pACdkv?jvdfbnUBCBvUav Wv&!v <?UnCfvbFv.]?U_jv@qv8/j vabkTVaSvUavkTUjv./vjT?]] @CvAbajkfmCBvkbvAfC?kCv?aqvfVSTkjvUa vbfvSf?akv?aqvA?mjCvbFv?AkVbavkb v?aqvdCfjbavabkv?v6?hkqvkbvkTVjv ./ 0pACdkv?jvdfbnVBCBvVav8CAkUbav=;^v .bnCa?akjv@qv8/j vC?ATvbEvkTCv6?fkUCjvCpdfCjj]q fCjCfnCjv?aqv?aBv?]]vfVSTkjv VaA]mBUaS v@mkvabkv]U_VkCBvkb vdmfjm?akvkbv8CAkVbav "vbEv.07.3- #!v:v 8 . vuv(% " vBCGDajCj vA^?U_j vBC_?aBj v?aBvA?mjCjvbFv?AkUbavkT?kvC?ATv6?hlqv_?qvT?nC oVkTvfCjdCAkvkbv?aqv_?llCf vkf?aj?AkUba vbfvbAAmffCaACvfC]?kUaSvUav?aqvo?qvkbvkTCv8VkCv?S?Vajkv?aq dCfjbavabkv?v6?fkqvTCfCkb v5bkTUaSvUavkTVjv./vBV_UaUjTCjvkTCvfVSTkvbFvkTCv:aUkCBv8k?kCj vdmfjm?ak kbv8CAkVbav " t ! v?aBv " vbEv.07.3- v#!v : 8 . vuv(% " s ! " vkbvdmfjmCv?aqvjmATvdCfjbaj kbvb@k?Uav?BBVkVba?^vfCjdbajCvAbjkjvbfvfCjdbajCv?AkVbav?aBvkbvCakCfvVakbvjCkk]C_CakjvkT?kvSUnCvfUjC kbvAbakfV@mkUbavdfbkCAkVbavdmfjm?akvkbv8CAkUbav " t ! v -jvjCkv LchlTvVav Yv% vabkTUaSvUavkTVjv./ ?^kCfj v_bBUPCj v?_CaBjvbfvjmdCfjCBCjvVav?aqvo?qvkTCv?SfCC_Cakjv@CkoCCavbfv?_baSv?aqvbFvkTC 8/j vbfv?aqv?f@Ukf?kVbav?o?fBjvbfvAbmhkvZmBS_CakjvdChk?UaVaSvkbv?aqvbFvkTCv8/jvUavAbaaCAkUba oUkTvkTCv8VkC &# 9TCv6?hkVCjv?SfCC v?aBv@qvCakCfVaSvkTUjv./vkTVjv.bmfkvPaBj vkT?kvkTVjv./ AbajkVkmkCjv?v[mBVAV?^^q ?ddfbnCBvjCkk^C_Cakvdmfjm?akvkbvoTVATvC?ATv8/vT?j v?jvbFvkTCv0FICAkVnCv /?kC vfCjb^nCBv]V?@V]VkqvkbvkTCv:aVkCBv8k?kCjvoVkTUavkTCv_C?aUaSvbFv8CAkUbav 2v]v" G ! vbFv.07.3- v #!v:v 8 . vuv(% " ! v?aBvVjvCakUk^CB v?jvbFvkTCv0JKCAkUnCv/?kC vkbvdfbkCAkUbavRb_vAbakfU@mkUbav ?AkVbajvbfvA]?V_jv?jvdfbnUBCBv@qv8CAkUbav ]v]v" H ! vbFv.07.3- vbfv?jv_?qv@CvbkTCfoUjCvdfbnUBCBv @qv]?o vGcfvkTCv _?kkCfjv?BBfCjjCB vUavkTVjv./ v 9TCv _?kkCfjv?BBfCjjCB vUavkTVjv./v?fCv?]]v fCjdbajCv?AkVbajvk?\Cavbfvkbv@Cvk?\Cav?aBv?]^vfCjdbajCvAbjkjvVaAmffCBvbfvkbv@CvUaAmffCB v?kvbfvVav AbaaCAkVbavoVkTvkTCv8VkC v@qvkTCv:aVkCBv8k?kCjvbfv?aqvbkTCfvdCfjba vCpACdkvQfvkTCv8k?kC,vdfbnVBCB v TboCnCf vkT?kvVEvkTCv:aVkCBv8k?kCjvCpCfAUjCjvfUSTkjvmaBCfvkTCvfCjCfn?kVbajvVav8CAkUbav>;v .bnCa?akjv@qv6^?VakVFM vbkTCfvkT?avUav X Yv%$ ?v A^?U_jvGcfvNU^mfCvkbv_CCkv?vfCemUfC_CakvbFvkTCv v Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 39 of 50 PageID #: 1132 56 .-$e KugnhpIl lhIJhlhz qu .-%f }gqmIzgqpy qP PMLMuIl'yzIzM lI L|uhpe qu IaMu hnslMnMpzIzhqp qP zfM Gquk zfM nIzzMuy ILLuMyyML gp zfgy 56 gll pq lqpeMu gpKm|LM zfqyM uMysqpyM Kqyzy qu uMysqpyM IKzgqpy zfIz IuM hzfhp zfM yKqsM qP zfM M MuKgyML uMyMu}Izgqp& /-& CfM @IuzhMy P|u{fMu IeuMM IpL J MpzMuhpe zfhy 56 zfgy 5q|uz _pLy zfIz zfM KqnsmIhpz _mML J zfM DpgzML BzIzMy gp zfhy IKzhqp gy I Kh}hl IKzgqp hzfhp zfM nMIphpe qP BMKzhqp 9 : + S ) qP 58A5>3 ,* D%B$5$ 1. ; + T l IpL zfIz zfgy 56 Kqpyzgz|zMy I i|LhKhIll "Issuq}ML yMzzmMnMpz s|uy|Ipz zq fhKf MIKf BMzzlhpe 6MPMpLIpz fIy Iy qP zfM 8\MKzh}M 6IzM uMyql}ML mhIJhlhz zq zfM DphzML BzIzMy hzfgp zfM nMIphpe qP BMKzhqp : < + Y + 4 qP 58A5>3 ,* D $B&5$ 1. : + Y + 4 $ /.$ 8IKf B6 yfIml hzf uMysMKz zq Ip y|hz qu KmIgn Juq|efz J gz `u nIzzMuy uNlIzML zq zfgy 56 pqzhP zfM EpgzML BzIzMy gp uhzgpe pq lIzMu zfIp .( LI y sugqu zq zfM gphzhIzgqp qP y|Kf y|hz qu KlIhn% //% 8IKf B6 yfIml hzf uMysMKz zq Ip y|gz qu KmIgn Juq|efz IeIhpyz gz `u nIzzMuy uMlIzML zq zfhy 56 pqzhd gp uhzgpe zfM DpgzML BzIzMy gzfhp LI y IPzMu yMu~hKM qQ zfM KqnslIgpz qp y|Kf B6& <p ILLgzgqp MIKf B6 yfIml pqzhd zfM DpgzML BzIzMy hzfhp LI y IaMu yMx}hKM qu uMKMhsz qP Ip ?qzgqp Tru B|nnIu =|LenMpz IpL hzfgp LI y IbMu uMKMgsz qP Ip quLMu Xwqn I Kq|u{ yMzzgpe I KIyM Sru zugIl& /0& %+ ) ' + ! + ' $+ !% % + <p Ip y|JyMt|Mpz ILngphyzuIzg}M qu j|LgKgIl suqKMMLgpe hpgzgIzML J zfM DphzML BzIzMy Tru gpi|pKzh}M uMmhMR uMKq}Mu qP uMysqpyM Kqyzy qu qzfMu IssuqsuhIzM uMlgMP uMmIzhpe zq zfM BhzM B6y yfIml pqz IyyMuz IpL nI pqz nIhpzIhp Ip LMUOpyM qu KmIgn JIyML |sqp zfM suhpKhslMy qP Ig}Mu uMy i|LhKIzI KqllIzMuIm MyzqssMm hyy|M suMKm|yhqp KmIgn#yslhzzgpe qu qzfMu LM[pyMy JIyML |sqp Ip KqpzMpzhqp zfIz zfM KmIhny uIgyML J zfM DphzML BzIzMy gp zfM y|JyMt|Mpz suqKMMLgpe MuM qu yfq|mL fI}M JMMp Juq|efz hp zfM hpyzIpz KIyM2 suq}gLML fqM}Mu zfIz pqzfhpe hp zfhy @IuIeuIsf IUVMKzy zfM MpUruKMIJhlgz qP zfM Kq}MpIpzy pqz zq y|M yMz Tru{f gp BMKzgqp HF 5q}MpIpzy J @lIhpzgQWy $ + + + /1$ B6y yfIml suq}gLM zq zfM 8@3 |sqp uMt|Myz KqsgMy qP Ilm uMKquLy uMsqu{y LqK|nMpzy IpL qzfMu gpTrunIzhqp gpKm|Lgpe uMKquLy uMsqx{y LqK|nMpzy IpL qzfMu hpSrunIzhqp hp MmMKzuqpgK Urun fMuMgpIcMu uMPMuuML zq Iy AMKquLy hzfhp B6y sqyyMyygqp qu Kqpzuql qu zfIz qP zfMgu KqpzuIKzquy qu IeMpzy uMmIzgpe zq IKzg}hzhMy Iz zfM BgzM qu zq zfM gnslMnMpzIzgqp qP zfgy 56 hpKl|Lhpe J|z pqz lhnhzML zq yInsmgpe IpIm yhy KfIgp qP K|yzqL uMKquLy nIpgPMyzy zu|Kkhpe mqey uMKMhszy uMsqx{y yInslM zuI^K uq|zhpe KquuMysqpLMpKM qu qzfMu LqK|nMpzy qu hpUrvoIzgqp uMeIuLhpe zfM Gquk$ B7y yfIlm Imyq nIkM I}IhlIJmM zq zfM 8@3 IpL zfM BzIzM `u s|usqyMy qP gp}MyzheIzhqp hpSrunIzhqp eIzfMuhpe qu zMyzhnqp zfMhu Mnslq MMy IeMpzy qu uMsuMyMpzIzh}My gzf kpqlMLeM qP uMmM}Ipz ZKzy KqpKMuphpe zfM sMuTrunIpKM qP zfM Gquk$ 0($ $ * + " + $#( ( + & I$ B6y nI IyyMx{ zfIz Imm qu sIuz qP I AMKquL uMt|MyzML J @lIgpzg]y gy suh}gmMeNL qu suqzMKzML Iy suq}hLML |pLMu PMLMuIm lI hp lhM| qP suq}hLgpe zfM AMKquL suq}gLML B6y Kqnsl hzf 0(&J! IpL M KMsz Iy suq}gLML hp 0(%K& Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 40 of 50 PageID #: 1133 '6b-$Yb1YY5VZb1b3M1IObQ6bTVI]IN5G5bQVbTVQZ53ZIQP bZH5`bYH1NNbTVQ]I45 2 +N1IPZI>Yb^IZHbZH5b<SMMQ^IPGbIP;SVO1ZIQPbV5G1V4IPGbY\3Hb,53QV4 bIZYbZIZM5 bIZYb41Z5 bZH5bP1O5 bZIZM5 b 186INI1ZIQPb 5 G b3QOT1P`bQVbBVO b1P4b144V5YYbQ6bZH5b1\ZHQV bQ6b513Hb144V5YY55 b1P4bQ6b513Hb V53ITI5PZ b1b45Y3VITZIQPbQ6bZH5b,53QV4 Yb3QPZ5PZY b1P4bZH5bTVI]IN5G5bQVbTVQZ53ZIQPb1YY5V[54 b'6b1b 3N1IObQ6bTVI]IN5G5bQVbTVQZ53ZIQPb1TTMI5YbQPM`bZQb1bTQVZIQPbQ6b1b,53QV4 b-$YbYH1MMbTVQ]I45bZH5b ,53QV4bZQb+N1IPZI89YbIPbV5413Z54b;SVObZQbO1YKbZH5bTVI]IN5G54bQVbTVQZ53Z54bTQV[IQPbQPM` b-$YbYH1NNb V5Z1IPb1NNb,53QV4YbZH1ZbZH5`b3N1IObZQb25bTVI]IN5G54bQVbTVQZ53Z54b\PZINb+M1IPZI86bH1YbH14b1bV51YQP12N5b QTTQVZ\PIZ`bZQb4IYT\Z5bZH5bTVI]IN5G5bQVbTVQZ53ZIQPb3M1IOb1P4b1P`bY\3Hb4IYT\Z5bH1Yb255PbV5YQM]54bIPb ZH5b-$Y b =]QV b -$YbO1`bO1K5bPQb3M1IObQ6bTVI]IM5G5bQVbTVQZ53ZIQPbV5G1V4IPG b N b1P`b41Z1b 3 V5G1V4IPGbZH5b-IZ5 bIP3N\4IPG b2\ZbPQZbNIOIZ54bZQ b1NMbY1OTMIPG b1P1M`ZI31N bOQPIZQVIPG b H`4VQG5QNQGI31N bY3I5PZIB3 b3H5OI31M bV14IQNQGI31NbQVb5PGIP55VIPGb41Z1 bQVbZH5bTQV[IQPbQ6b1P`b QZH5Vb,53QV4bZH1Zb5]I45P35Yb3QP4IZIQPYb1ZbQVb1VQ\P4bZH5b-IZ5 bQVb bZH5bTQV[IQPbQ6b1P`b,53QV4bZH1Zb -$Yb1V5bV5U\IV54bZQb3V51Z5bQVbG5P5V1Z5bT\VY\1PZbZQbZHIYb#$ b -$YbO1`b1YY5VZbZH1Zb1NMbQVbT1VZbQ6b1b,53QV4 TVQ]I454bZQb+M1IPZIAY0b\P45VbZHIYb-53ZIQPbQVb-53ZIQPb ,5Z5PZIQPbQ6b,53QV4Y bIYb2\YIP5YYb 3QPB45PZI1MbZQbZH5b5_Z5PZbT5VOIZZ54b2`b1P4bIPb133QV41P35b^IZHb-53ZIQPb 5 bQ6b#%,#(! b b. - # b 5 b1P4b b# & , b 2 b-$YbYH1MNbY5GV5G1Z5b1P4b3N51VN`bI45PZI;ab1MMb ,53QV4YbQVbT1VZYbZH5V5Q6bY\2OI[Z54b\P45VbZHIYb#$b;SVb^HI3Hb-$Yb1YY5VZb2\YIP5YYb3QPB45PZI1MIZ`b 3N1IOY b,53QV4YbZH1Zb-$Yb3N1IObZQb25b3QPB45PZI1Nb2\YIP5YYbIPDVO1ZIQPb^INMb25b1@QV454bZH5b TVQZ53ZIQPbYT53IB54bIPb b# & , b+1VZb b-\2T1V[b '6bPQb3N1IObQ6b3QPB45PZI1MIZ`b133QOT1PI5Yb ,53QV4Yb^H5PbZH5`b1V5bY\2OI[Z54bZQbZH5b%+! bQVbI6bZH5b%+!bH1YbPQZIB54b-$YbZH1ZbZH5b,53QV4Yb1V5b PQZb3QP:I45PZI1Nb\P45VbZH5bYZ1P41V4YbQ6b-53ZIQPb 5 bQ6b#%,#)!bQVb b# & , b+1V[b b -\2T1VZb" bZH5bT\2MI3bO1`b25bGI]5Pb1335YYbZQbY\3Hb,53QV4Yb^IZHQ\Zb6\V[H5VbPQZI35bZQb-$Y b '6bV5M5]1PZbZQbZH5bTVQ3554IPG bZH5b+1VZI5Yb1GV55bZH1Zb]1NI41Z54bY1OTMIPGbQV OQPIZQVIPGb41Z1bG5P5V1Z54bIPb133QV41P35b^IZHbZH5b/QVLb+M1Pb1P4bV5]I5^54b1P4b1TTVQ]54b2`bZH5b %+!bYH1NNb25b14OIYYI2M5b1Yb5]I45P35 b^IZHQ\ZbQ2J53ZIQP bIPb1P`bTVQ3554IPGb\P45VbZHIYb#$ b *QZ^IZHYZ1P4IPGb1P`bTVQ]IYIQPbQ6bZHIYb#$ b+M1IPZI?bV5Z1IPb1NMbQ6bIZYbIPDVO1ZIQP G1ZH5VIPGb1P4bIPYT53ZIQPb1\ZHQVIZI5Yb1P4bVIGHZY bIP3N\4IPGb5PDV35O5PZb13ZIQPYbV5N1Z54bZH5V5ZQ b \P45Vb#%,#)! b,#,! b1P4b1P`bQZH5Vb1TTMI312N5bYZ1Z\Z5YbQVbV5G\M1ZIQPY b .PZIMb b`51VYb1E5VbZH5b%+! Yb#5VZIB31ZIQPbQ6b/QVKb#QOTM5ZIQPb\P45Vb-53ZIQPb b #5V[IB31ZIQPbQ6b/QVLb#QOTN5ZIQP bQ7bZH5b,!b/+ b513Hb-$bYH1MNbTV5Y5V]5b1P4bV5Z1IPb1NMb PQPI45PZI31Nb3QTI5YbQ6b,53QV4Yb IP3M\4IPGb,53QV4YbIPb5M53ZVQPI3bDVO bPQ^bIPbIZYbTQYY5YYIQPbRWb 3QPZVQNbQVbZH1Zb3QO5bIPZQbIZYbTQYY5YYIQPbQVb3QPZVQNbZH1ZbV5N1Z5bIPb1P`bO1PP5VbZQbIZYbNI12INIZ`b\P45Vb #%,#)!b^IZHbV5YT53ZbZQbZH5b-IZ5 bTVQ]I454 bHQ^5]5V bZH1Zb-$Yb^HQb1V5bTQZ5PZI1MN`bNI12N5b1Yb Q^P5VYbQVbQT5V1ZQVYbQ6bZH5b-IZ5bO\YZbV5Z1IP bIPb144IZIQP b1MMb,53QV4YbZH1ZbV5N1Z5bZQbZH5bMI12INIZ`bQ6b 1P`bQZH5VbT5VYQPb\P45Vb#%,#)!b^IZHbX5YT53ZbZQbZH5b-IZ5 b%13Hb-$bO\YZb1MYQbV5Z1IP b1P4bIPYZV\3Zb IZYb3QPZV13ZQVYb1P4b1G5PZYbZQbTV5Y5V]5 bDVbZH5bY1O5bT5VIQ4bQ6bZIO5bYT53IB54b12Q]5b1NMb PQPI45PZI31Mb3QTI5YbQ6bZH5bN1YZb4V1FbQVbCP1Mb]5VYIQPbQ6b1P`b,53QV4Yb IP3N\4IPGb,53QV4YbIPb 5N53ZVQPI3bDVO bPQ^bIPbIZYbTQYY5YYIQPbQVb3QPZVQNbQVbZH1Zb3QO5bIPZQbIZYbTQYY5YYIQPbQVb3QPZVQNbZH1Zb Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 41 of 50 PageID #: 1134 WpO W kv Ov tOvvW x iW |W e tOvSW x\ iW Mx n | x kVWV ix W W iO WOSi H5 OvV k Sxv OS x OvV OgWv t W Okv kv OVVk kxv Sx|kW x\ Oqq VO O gWwW O WV V kvg iW |W e tOvSW x] iW Mx o OvV vx Sxv OkvWV kv iW O_{ WtWv kxwWV GWSx V W k WV x RW W OkvWV 6OSi x\ iW ORx W WSx V W Wv kxv W k WtWv iOpq O||p WgO VqW x] Ov Sx |x O W W Wv kxv |xqkS x iW Sxv O ,( 2 iX SxvSq kxv x\ ik WSx V W Wv kxv |W kxV H5 iOqp vx k` iW Jvk WV H O W O pXO - VO | kx x iW VW S kxv x] Ov Si GWSx V OvV |xv W W R iW Jvk WV H O W OvV W SW| O | x kVWV kv , E k kqWgWV OvV E x WS WV 4qOkt H5 iOqq VWqk W Ov Si GWSx V x iW 7E2 ,) 6OSi H5 SW kdW kvVk kV Opq iO x iW RW x\ k nwx qWVgW OwV RWqkW^ Oa W ix x gi kv k k iO vx Op W WV t kpO WV Vk SO VWV VW x WV x x iW k W Vk |x WV x] Ov GWSx V x iW iOv kVWv kSOq Sx|kW WqO kvg x k |x Wv kOr qkORkpk WgO Vkvg iW Hk W kvSW vx kcSO kxv x\ |x Wv kOq qkORkqk R iW Jvk WV H O W x iW H O W OvV iO k iO fqq Sxt|pkWV k i Ov OvV Oqp 7E2 OvV H O W W W _{ kv`{ tO kxv WgO Vkvg iW Hk W | Ov x HWS kxv ! ' W OvV < $$ W % 3 x\ 46G4?2 '$ K H 4 -) ' W OwV -)$$ W % 3 OvV HWS kxv % + x] G4G2 '$ J H 4 )-$+ OvV O W qO ,+ 2pq O|| x Op Sxv Wv VWpk W ORrW txVkcSO kxv vx kSW vx kdSO kxv xRmWS kxv | x|x Op W|x OvV W W |WSkdWV kv ik 45 t RW kv k kvg vqW x iW k W |WSkdWV MiWvW W vVW ik 45 vx kSW k W k WV x RW gk Wv x O W|x x x iW VxS tWw k W k XV x RW Wv R xwY EO x Owx iW k t RW Vk WS WV x iW |W xw |WSk]lWV RWpx O iW OVV W W |WSkdWV RWpx 2v EO tO SiOvgW iW |WN xv OvV x OVV W O||qkSORqW x k R | x kVkvg vx kSW x\ Si SiOvgW x Opq EO kW 2qq vx kSW vVW ik HWS kxv O W WbWS k W |xv WSWk| vpW x iW k W |WSkcWV Bx kSW W k WV x RW Wv x iW 6E2 OvV vx x iW Jvk WV H O W ix pV vx RW Wv x iW 5D> 6 SW| O x iW k W | x kVWV vx kSW x O EO R WtOkq k\ iO x| kxv k | x kVWV RWqx x R Wg qO tOkq kw OSSx VOvSW k i ik HWS kxv O k dW Ov vx kSW W k XtWv x\ iW 45 WgO Vkvg Si EO 77H 4O W @OvOgWtWv Jwk J H 5W|O tWw x\ > kSW 7v k xvtWv OwV CO Oq GW x SW 5k k kxv E D 3x +) MO ikvg xv 5 4 $ '' +)! WW SVSx| Wv V0 Vxm gx GW. 5> - " % $$ ( 4O xp @xwWqq 5k WS x I }W _ wV 8uW gWwS @OwOgWuWw 5k k kxw L I 9w k xwuWw Os F x WT kxw 2gWwT GWgkxw ' *# :x j I WW IM 2 rOw O ;Wx gkO / & & AywZ = = UP zs1[~Q hx %' Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 42 of 50 PageID #: 1135 -yPT <PSg rq 3E, EyrfUS /rryTcqP ry K H 4q cyrqmUq Pi Eyr US crq ,]UqS FU]crq " 8ry a H yUU HM , jPq P 9Ury]cP ;QSg rq R{QT UuQ ^s EP jP L EPcq Uy Eyr]~Pm ,qPi 5q\ySUmUq -yPqSa I vU~[ qT 6mUy]UqS APqP]UmUq 2c c crq " 7ry a H yUU HN , jPq P 9Ury]cP EQcq Uz uQ iQ(UwQ _r 6E, /cqScqqP c 7cqPqSU /Uq Uy " N AP~ cq ? aUy =cq] 2yc U /cqScqqP c Cacr ! "$ Scq TQSS {USUd QRiU)UwQ _r IaUyc KaiUqRy Sa =Uq Sg 2UvPy pUq [ty 6q cyrqmUq Pi Eyr US crq 2c c crq rZ NP U APqP]UmUq .jT] qT 7irry Hr Uy .j T 7yPqh[t~ =Uq Sg " k bU{d QTgdq (g _r Eri CqU /r~vryP crq 6 cU HSaP R !$# MPjgUy FrPT , rq @PgU Cacr UncU SbQ R*wri rqU Srm % " MV jPgV Ldq i :qS >W cq E HbUyeTQq "$ :qT dQi EQyg Q ED -r # 0Qi Uy 0d >O & g bUycTPq+ U iPgU Srm # '! " 9rrTydSb 0ryxr}Q drq -| SX ,oc` # MU J rlQ GrQT 1bQ|is Y B0 $ # ! Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 43 of 50 PageID #: 1136 0mtLN /f_].D?1 Lhf} ) & &"$ * ) @^_n}2hslo}lOoJ_gn}asl_nM_Lp_hg}huOl}Khp^}o^O}ntKaOLo}fJooOl}hP}o^_n}23}JgM}>3n}Yl p^O}MtlJo_hg}hP}o^O}kOlUjlfJgLO}hP}o^O}pOlfn}JgM}klhu_n_hgn}hP}o^_n}23}Ujl}p^O}ktlkhnO}hP} OgJKc_g\}Jgy}hP}o^O}<Jlq_On}oh}Jkkcy}oh}o^O}2hslo}Jp}Jgy}p_fO}Ujl}nsL^}[lr^Ol}hlMOl }M_lOLo_hg }JgM} lOc_OP}Jn}fJy}KO}gOLOnnJly}hl}Jkklhkl_JoO}Yl}p^O}LhgnpltLp_hg}hl}fhM_WLJp_hg}hP}p^_n}23 }hl}ph} ORSOLpsJoO}hl}OgYlLO}Lhfkd_JgLO}w_o^}_pn}pOlfn }hl}ph}lOnheuO}M_nktpOn}_g}JLLhlMJgLO}w_p^}>OLp_hg} I777} 3_nkspO}=Onhcto_hg } A^O}Zechw_g\}JkkOgMQiOn}JlO}JooJL^OM}ph}JgM}_gLhlkhlJpOM}_gph}p^_n}23- /kkOgM_x}/ }_n}p^O}=;3 } /kkOgM_x}0 }_n}p^O}Hhlb}<eJg } /kkOgM_x}2 }_n}o^O}MOnLl_ko_hg}JgM hl}fJk}hP}p^O}>_oO } /kkOgM_x}3 }_n}p^O}LhfkcOoO}e_no}hP}>3n } , 4xLOko}Jn}klhu_MOM}_g|} %} 9hM_XLJp_hg}hP}Hhlb}<eJg}hl}=OeJoOM}3Oc_uOlJKcOn } fJoOl_Je}fhM_XLJp_hgn}oh}p^_n}23 }_gLcsM_g\}p^O}Hhlb}<eJg }n^Jce}KO}_g}wl_p_g\ }n_\gOM}Ky}p^O} Eg_pOM}>oJpOn}JgM}>3n }JgM}n^Jde}KO}ORTOLp_uO}tkhg}JkklhuJe}Ky}p^O}2htlo }4xLOkp}Jn}klhu_MOM}_g} |} % }ghg fJoOl_Jd}fhM_P_LJo_hgn}oh}p^_n}23 }_gLcsM_g\}p^O}Hhlb}<cJg }n^Jce}KO}_g}wl_p_g\}JgM} n^Jcc}KO}OVOLp_uO}w^Og}n_\gOM}Ky}Msdy}Jtp^hl_zOM}lOklOnOgpJo_uOn}hP}o^O}Eg_pOM}>oJoOn}JgM}>3n } /}fhM_XLJo_hg}oh}o^O}Hhlb}<cJg}n^Jcc}KO}Lhgn_MOlOM}fJpOl_Je}_P}_p}_fkeOfOgon}J}=;3} JfOgMfOgo}o^Jp}PsgMJfOgpJdcy}JcoOln}o^O}KJn_L}POJpslOn}hP}o^O}nOcOLpOM}lOfOMy}w_o^_g}o^O} fOJg_g\}hP}& }1 5 = } % &%' L # __ }0OZlO}klhu_M_g\}_pn}JkklhuJc}ph}Jgy}fhM_WLJp_hg}ph} o^O}Hhlb}<cJg }p^O}Dg_pOM}>pJoOn}w_ee}klhu_MO}p^O}>pJoO}w_o^}J}lOJnhgJKeO}hkkhlotg_py}ph}lOu_Ow} JgM}LhffOgo}hg}p^O}klhkhnOM}fhM_U`LJo_hg } ,! :hp^_g\}_g}p^_n}13}n^Jee}KO}MOOfOM}oh}JcpOl}p^O}2hslo n}khwOl}ph}OgUjlLO nskOlu_nO }hl}JkklhuO}fhM_XLJo_hgn}oh}o^_n}23 } B^_n}23}n^Jee}KO}dhM\OM}w_p^}p^O}2htlp}Zl}Jp}cOJno}% }MJyn}Ujl}ktKc_L}ghp_LO}JgM} LhffOgp}_g}JLLhlMJgLO}w_o^}>OLp_hg} ## }M # }hP}24=28/ }&#}F} > 2 }{},(## }M # }JgM} #+}2 6 = }{}' ) }C^O}Gg_pOM}>pJoOn}lOnOlvOn}p^O}l_\^o}oh}w_p^MlJw}hl}w_p^^hcM}_pn}LhgnOgp}_P}p^O} "} Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 44 of 50 Page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ase 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 45 of 50 PageID #: 1138 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 46 of 50 PageID #: 1139 Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 47 of 50 PageID #: 1140 &')/-"*9 $,)-)340"4/09 9 -7)0/-,&-4"+9 0/4&#4)/-9 '&-#89 &')/-9 9 4*"-4"9 &%&0"+9 &-5&19 9 /0384(9 40&&4 9 ! 9 5*"-4" 9 &/0')"9 9 )2.9 9 /-&39 33)34"-49 &')/-"*9 /6-3&+9 9 -7)0/-,&-4"+9 0/4&#4)/-9 '&-#89 &')/-9 9 4+"-4"9 &%&0"*9 &-4&19 9 /1384(9 40&&4 9 ! 9 4*"-4" 9 &/0')"9 9 Í Í Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 48 of 50 PageID #: 1141 +=;/LNG3V)/83V5EGV VG38/G2=C8VL<3V V DD2G>1<V+NF3G7C2V+=L3V % % % #%U V /L32V T $ ) V AD0/@V(F3G/L=DCKV/C2V)GD13KKV #BFGDO3B3CLV 22G3KK V V-/A?3GV*D/2 V ODCV%/?3 V(!V V 83CLV NL<DHR32VLDV 113FLV+3GO=13V '/B3V FG=CL V ,=LA3 V DCV 3</A4VD4V 0DO3 K=;32V)/GMP V DBF/CP V 22G3KK V )<DC3 V 3B/=@ V ,V DIDG/L=DCV+QKL3BV NL<DG=S32V 93CLV ,V DJDG/L=DCV+QKL3BV V-3KLV&/=CV+LG33L V+N=L3V V G/C?6GL V$.V V"V =C6 1L/2O/CL/:3 1DB % % % ! % % ! % % % "% % % Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 49 of 50 PageID #: 1142 !50:'@A>+F '0+F/>F F>+0'>*5:0F@4+F F ;;*>5)4F!A<+>.A:*F!5@+F % >5:@F:'9+F;-F!+@@75:0F +-,:*':@&F F '@+*F '9+F <>5:@ F >5?@+:F$ F!4+>9':F "5@7+ F ??;)5'@+F +:+>'8F ;A:?+7F **>+?? F :+F '957@;:F ;'* F !F F$5:*?;>F ;)6? F "F F 0+:@F A@4;>5E+*F@;F ))+<@F!+>B5)+F '9+F <>5:@ F "5@7+ F ;:F +4'7-F;-F (;B+ ?50:+*F '>@C F ;9<':C F **>+?? F 4;:+ F +9'58 F >A)+F 951F +9+*5'@5;:F ':'2+>F #:5@+*F"+)4:;7;35+?F ;>=;>'@5;:F F$+?@F"DB;7'F ;'*F 4'>7;@@+F F >A)+ 951 #" );9F Case 5:20-cv-00154-TBR Document 13 Filed 01/28/21 Page 50 of 50 PageID #: 1143 ' ' ' ' +H@t ;t *;}HF &R h~ ' SmyX IG &DJ r Nu YEK lg (HT;cO lO %@l H zWQgHF 5;t} 2;fH qtWg} *; WF 8W}bH *WtHC}lt 4qHt;}Wlgz 6HQWlg ... %FFtHzz .gF z}tW;c 5;t] ; - );c Ht )W} 0Hg} C] 3<eK suZi 8W}cH! )lfq;g " 5TlgH# Hf;Wc! /n{A ,y?ia 5;v}gHt (;^Kv (l z 1 7 wLL 2: 9=zU[jR mj *) d \o|V < P<k_$B>`MxBp Clf ' '# ! " $ '# $%" '! ' %#$' '# ' &' '# $$ " '

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.