Dender et al v. Katchoulev et al, No. 2:2014cv00190 - Document 19 (N.D. Ind. 2015)

Court Description: AMENDED OPINION AND ORDER: The Court GRANTS Defendant Dimitre Katchoulev and Katchoulev Corp., d/b/a Bultrans Express's Motion to Compel Non-Party Discovery 13 and ORDERS Franciscan to provide Defendants with the requested documents. Signed by Magistrate Judge Paul R Cherry on 4/17/2015. (cc: Franciscan Physicians Network)(rmn)
Download PDF
Dender et al v. Katchoulev et al Doc. 19 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF INDIANA HAMMOND DIVISION JULIA D. DENDER and WILLIAM R. DENDER, individually and as husband and wife, Plaintiffs, v. DIMITRE KATCHOULEV and KATCHOULEV CORPORATION d/b/a BULTRANS EXPRESS, Defendants. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Cause No.: 2:14-CV-190-JVB-PRC AMENDED OPINION AND ORDER This matter is before the Court on Defendants Dimitre Katchoulev and Katchoulev Corp., d/b/a Bultrans Express’s Motion to Compel Non-Party Discovery [DE 13], filed on February 25, 2015. The motion was served on all parties and on non-party Franciscan Physicians Network (Franciscan). No responses have been filed, and the time to do so has passed. Defendants represent that Plaintiff William Dender has been treated by doctors at Franciscan for the injuries for which he is seeking compensation in this case. They represent that, on June 19, 2014, they served a Subpoena as well as a Request for Production on non-party Franciscan seeking medical records of that treatment. They also represent that Plaintiffs have not objected to the Subpoena or Request for Production and that the records are necessary for Defendants to properly defend this case. Franciscan has refused to comply, explaining that an authorization signed by the patient (that is, Plaintiff William Dender) is required before it will hand over the medical records to Defendants. Defendants now ask that the Court compel Franciscan to produce the requested records. The motion is well taken. Protected health information may be disclosed by a covered entity Dockets.Justia.com such as Franciscan under HIPAA without a written authorization when the requesting party gives the covered entity satisfactory assurance that the requesting party has taken reasonable efforts to ensure that the person whose records are being sought has been given notice of the request. See 45 C.F.R. § 164.512(e)(1). [A] covered entity receives satisfactory assurances from a party seeking protected health information if the covered entity receives from such party a written statement and accompanying documentation demonstrating that: (A) The party requesting such information has made a good faith attempt to provide written notice to the individual . . . (B) The notice included sufficient information about the litigation or proceeding in which the protected health information is requested to permit the individual to raise an objection to the court or administrative tribunal; and (C) The time for the individual to raise objections to the court or administrative tribunal has elapsed, and: (1) No objections were filed; or (2) All objections filed by the individual have been resolved by the court or the administrative tribunal and the disclosures being sought are consistent with such resolution. Id. Here, Defendants provided Franciscan with a certification on August 28, 2014, stating that they had fulfilled all these requirements. Neither Plaintiff nor Franciscan have responded to this motion. And the Court is not aware of any reason why a written authorization would otherwise be required here. As laid out in the original version of this Order, this dispute might have been resolved without Court action had the parties first conferred. But in the interests of efficiency and economy, the Court now GRANTS Defendants Dimitre Katchoulev and Katchoulev Corp., d/b/a Bultrans 2 Express’s Motion to Compel Non-Party Discovery [DE 13] and ORDERS Franciscan to provide Defendants with the requested documents. SO ORDERED this 17th day of April, 2015. s/ Paul R. Cherry MAGISTRATE JUDGE PAUL R. CHERRY UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT cc: Franciscan Physicians Network 770 Indian Boundary Road Chesterton, Indiana 46304 3