Johnson v. United Airlines, Inc. et al, No. 1:2017cv08858 - Document 37 (N.D. Ill. 2018)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM Opinion and Order signed by the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 7/31/2018. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction 19 is granted. Plaintiff's Complaint is dismissed without prejudice. Plaintiff's Motion to Remand 23 is dismissed as moot. The Court will enter final Judgment and close the case. Mailed notice(lk, )
Download PDF
Dockets.Justia.com UHKWR GQD QRVQKR- VWQHVHUSHU ´:$0$,³ VUHNUR: HFDSVRUH$ GQD VWVL QLKFD0 IR QRLWDLFRVV$ O DQRLWDQUHWQ, HK7 R1 WN' VLRQL OO, GQD HUDZDOH' IR VQH]LWLF HUD VWQDGQHIHG GHWLQ8 KWR% WD R1 WN' R1 WN' RJDFLK& QL WURSUL$ ODQRLWDQUHWQ, HUD+¶2 WD GHWLQ8 URI UHOGQDK HJDJJDE D VD GHNURZ RKZ QH]LWLF VLRQL OO, QD VL QRVQKR'1825*.&$% @ > WRRP VD GHVVL PVLG VL GQDPH5 RW QRLWR0 V¶QRVQKR- @ > VVLPVL' RW QRLWR0 HKW VWQDUJ WUXR& HK7 R1 WN' HH6 WN' QRVQKR- \E GHO LI WUXRF HWDWV RW UHWWDP HKW GQDPH5 RW QRLWR0 D VL JQLGQHS RVO$ R1 HH6 VQRLWDJHO O$ VVDO& HKW HNLUW6 UR VVL PVL' RW QRLWR0 D GHO LI HFQLV VDK GQD WUXRF ODUHGHI RW HVDF HKW GHYRPHU GHWLQ8 THV WH 6&/, ´$3,%³ WF$ \FDYLU3 QRLWDPURIQ, FLUWHPRL% VLRQL OO, HKW IR VQRLWDORLY URI GHWDXWLV \ OUDO L PLV VUHKWR GQD I OHVPLK IR IODKHE QR WUXRF HWDWV QL GHWLQ8 GHXV QRVQKR- WURSUL$ ODQRLWDQUHWQ, HUD+¶2 WD UHOGQDK HJDJJDE D VD NURZ IR WXR GQD QL GHQJLV HK QHKZ NFDUW RW VWQLUSUHJQLI V¶QRVQKR- GLYD' II LWQLDO3 GH]L OLWX ´GHWLQ8³ \ OHYLWFHOORF FQ, VJQLGOR+ ODWQHQLWQR& GHWLQ8 GQD FQ, VHQL/ UL$ GHWLQ8 VWQDGQHIH' 5('52 '1$ 12,1,32 08'1$520(0 O ODGQH. 0 DL QLJUL9 QR+ & R1 VWQDGQHIH' QRLWDURSURF HUDZDOH' D &1, 6*1,'/2+ /$71(1,712& '(7,18 GQD QRLWDURSURF HUDZDOH' D &1, 6(1,/ 5,$ '(7,18 IILWQLDO3 Y VODXGL YLGQL GHWDXWLV \OUDO L P LV IR VVDOF D IR I ODKHE QR GQD \ O ODXGL YLGQL 1261+2- ',9$' 12,6,9,' 15(76$( 6,21,//, )2 7&,576,' 15(+7521 (+7 52) 7582& 7&,576,' 6(7$76 '(7,18 (+7 1, Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 1 of 9 PageID #:220 Johnson v. United Airlines, Inc. et al Doc. 37 G, QRLWDPURIQL FLUWHPRLE ¶VHH\ROSPH ULHKW IR VHLWUDS GULKW RW QRLVVLPVQDUW \QD URI WQHVQRF HH\ROSPH QLDWER WRQ GLG GHWLQ8 VHH\ROSPH VWL IR DWDG WQLUSUHJQLI HKW JQLWFHOORF Q, G, VHVRSUXS JQLSHHNHPLW URI GQD WXR GQD QL JQLNFROF IR VQDHP D VD WQLUSUHJQLI ULHKW HSLZV \ HKW NURZ URI HYLUUD VHH\ROSPH QHK: WD R1 WN' WQHP \ROSPH IR QRLWLGQRF D VD VQDFV WQLUSUHJQLI HULXTHU \HKW RV GQD \DG \UHYH NURZ IR ´WXR NFROF³ GQD ´QL NFROF³ RW VHH\ROSPH VWL URI VQDHP D VD \JRORQKFHW WQLUSUHJ QLI VHVX GHWLQ8 $%& HKW IR VHFLSVXD HKW UHGQ8 WD R1 WN' WQHPWVXMG$ IR GUDR% PHWV\6 HKW HURIHE QRLWDUWLEUD RW VHRJ UHWWDP HKW QHKW WQHPHOWWHV QL WOXVHU WRQ VHRG HUXGHFRUS HFQDYHLUJ HKW IL WDKW VHWDWV UHKWUXI $%& HK7 $%& HKW IR WU$ WD $ [( R1 WN' HH6 ´ H]L OLWX O O LZ \QDSPR& HKW « WQHPSLXTH @GQD> VHLWL O LFDI IR QRLWDFRO GQD HS\W HKW HQLPUHWHG RW³ GQD ´VHLWL OLFDI V¶\QDSPR& HKW QL \FQHLFL IIH GQD HQL OSLFVLG QLDWQLDP³ RW WKJLU HKW JQLGXOFQL ´ VHFURI JQLNURZ GQD VVHQLVXE HKW IR \FQHLFL IIH HKW QLDWQLDP GQD HWDUHSR HJDQDP RW WKJLU HYLVXOF[H GQD HORV HKW VDK @GHWLQ8>³ WDKW VHGLYRUS RVOD $%& HK7 WD R1 WN' ´ VHUXGHFRUS @KWURI WHV> HKW UHGQX HVQHV QRP PRF GQD VWFDI HKW QRSX GHVDE OHYHO HOELVVRS WVHZRO HKW WD GHOWWHV HE GOXRKV WQLDOSPRF HKW @QHKW> @\OUHSRUSPL> WQHPHHUJ$ HKW GHLOSSD UR GHWHUSUHWQL « VDK \QDSPR& HKW WDKW VHYHL OHE³ HH\ROSPH QD HUHKZ VHFQDWVPXFULF QL VVHFRUS QRLWDUWLEUD GQD HFQDYHLUJ SHWV HHUKW D VH]L OLWX $%& HK7 $ [( R1 WN' WD R1 WN' HH6 GHWLQ8 GQD QRVQKR- QHHZWHE WQHP \ROSPH IR VQRLWLGQRF GQD VPUHW HKW VQUHYRJ VJQLGDHOS ULHKW RW GHKFDWWD VHLWUDS KWRE KFLKZ ´$%&³ WQHPHHUJD JQLQLDJUDE HYLWFHOORF HK7 ]UHLSUD. DRWUR' IR OFH' [( WD R1 WN' GHWLQ8 KWLZ WQHPHHUJD JQLQLDJUDE HYLWFHOORF D JQLKVLOEDWVH URI VHH\ROSPH GHWLQ8 Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 2 of 9 PageID #:221 [HS$ JQLWRXT UL& KW G ) WQHPD&F0 Y URO\D7 ´¶ VWVL[H QRLWFLGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEXV WFDI QL UHKWHKZ HQLPUHWHG RW HXVVL HKW QR GHWWL PEXV QHHE VDK HFQHGLYH UHYHWDKZ ZHLY GQD WQLDOSPRF HKW IR VQRLWDJHOOD ODQRLWFLGVLUXM HKW GQR\HE NRRO \DPµ @WUXRF WFLUWVLG HKW> QRLWVHXT RWQL QRLWFLGVLUXM V¶WUXRF HKW OODF VWFDI ODQUHW[H WXE³ WQHLFL IIXV \ O ODLFDI VL WQLDOSPRF HKW HUHKZ UHYHZR+ UL& KW G ) HXUWV$ Y VUHY( I ILWQLDOS HKW IR URYDI QL VHFQHUHIQL HOEDQRVDHU OOD ZDUG GQD VQRLWDJHOOD ODXWFDI GHGDHOS O OHZ OOD HXUW VD WSHFFD WVXP WUXRF WFLUWVLG D QRLWFLGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEXV IR NFDO QR GHVDE ODVVL PVLG URI JQLZHLYHU QHK: ´UHKWUXI RQ GHHFRUS WVXP WL QRLWFLGVLUXM VNFDO WL WDKW VHGXOFQRF WUXRF HKW IL GQD HVDF \UHYH QL QRLWVHXT WVULI HKW VL QRLWFLGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEX@V>³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¶II LWQLDO3 R1 WN' HH6 \OODUHQHJ JQLSHHNHPLW IR HVRSUXS HKW URI GHWLQ8 \E GHURWV GQD GHQQDFV VWQLUSUHJQLI ULHKW GDK PRKZ IR O OD VI ILWQLDOS IR VVDOF D IR IODKHE QR $3,% IR QRLWDORLY D JQLJHOOD WUXRF HWDWV QL WLXVZDO VLKW GHOLI HK RV QRLWDPURIQL FLUWHPRLE IR HVX GQD QRLWFHOORF V¶GHWLQ8 RW VWFHMER QRVQKR- Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 3 of 9 PageID #:222 HKW \E GHKVLOEDWVH GUDRE WQHPWVXMGD QD GQD VHUXGHFRUS QRLWXORVHU HWXSVLG ODQUHWQL V¶UH\ROSPH QD HGXOFQL KFLKZ VPVLQDKFHP $/5 UHGQX GHWDFLGXMGD HE WVXP VHWXSVLG URQL P O O$³ ´ $%& JQLWVL[H HKW JQLWHUSUHWQL \E GHYORVHU \OHYLVX OFQRF HE QDF HWXSVLG HKW WDKW VL HWXSVLG URQL P D IR HUXWDHI JQLKVLXJQLWVLG HKW³ WDKW JQLWDWV UL& KW G ) FQ, G OUR: V QDU7 Y UHNR& HH6 VHQLOUL$ $%& HKW IR QRLWDWHUSUHWQL VHULXTHU P LDOF V¶II LWQLDOS HKW IR QRLWXORVHU HKW QHKZ $/5 HKW UHGQX QRLWDUWLEUD HYLVXOF[H GQD \URWDGQDP RW WFHMEXV HURIHUHKW VL GQD HWXSVLG URQLP D VD GH]LUHWFDUDKF \OUHSRUS VL P LDOF V¶I ILWQLDOS $ WD R1 WN' ODVVL PVLG VWQDUUDZ GQD P LDOF $3,% HKW VWSPHHUS HURIHUHKW KFLKZ $/5 HKW UHGQX :$0$, HKW GQD GHWLQ8 QHHZWHE $%& HKW IR ´HWXSVLG URQL P³ D VL P LDOF $3,% V¶QRVQKR- WDKW VHXJUD GHWLQ8 WD 6 8 QDLLDZD+ ´ VQRLWLGQRF JQLNURZ UR VHOXU \DS IR VHWDU JQLUHYRF VWQHPHHUJD IR QRLWDFLOSSD UR QRLWDWHUSUHWQL HKW IR WXR UR VHFQDYHLUJ IR WXR ZRUJ³ VHWXSVLG URQLP HO LKZ ´ VQRLWLGQRF JQLNURZ UR VHOXU \DS IR VHWDU³ VD KFXV VWKJLU ODXWFDUWQRF HWDHUF WDKW HVRKW HUD VHWXSVLG URMD0 D & 6 8 RVOD HHV G, VHWXSVLG URQL P GQD URMDP IR ´¶WQHPHOWWHV \OUHGUR GQD WSPRUS HKWµ URI P VLQDKFHP O DUWLEUD \URWDGQDP D³ VHKVL OEDWVH $/5 HKW RV JQLRG Q, 6 8 OOHX% Y R& 5 ) 6 7 QRVLKFW$ JQLWLF 6 8 VLUUR1 Y FQ, VHQLOUL$ QDLLDZ D+ ´ VHWXSVLG UREDO JQLYORVHU URI NURZHPDUI HYLVQHKHUSPRF D JQLGLYRUS \E VQRLWDOHU WQHPHJDQDP UREDO QL \WL OLEDWV HWRPRUS³ RW ´$/5³ WF$ URED/ \DZO LD5 HKW GHVVDS VVHUJQR& QRLWSPHHU3 $/5 12,668&6,' UL& KW G ) OOHZUX% Y GW/ UHFQD& QLN6 \JRORWDPUH' URI UW& QRLWRP E D IR HFDI HKW QL VWVL[H QRLWF LGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEXV WDKW JQLKVL OEDWVH IR QHGUXE HKW VUDHE I ILWQLDOS HK7 UL& KW G ) R& NFXEHR5 VUDH6 Y FQ, ODWLJL' Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 4 of 9 PageID #:223 ZDO HWDWV VD KFXV ± HFUXRV UHKWR HPRV QL GHGQXRUJ VL P LDOF V¶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´ VHLWL O LFDI V¶\QDSPR& HKW QL \FQHLFL I IH GQD HQL OSLFVLG QLDWQLDP³ RW \WL O LED HKW JQLGXOFQL GQD ´ VHFURI JQLNURZ GQD VVHQ LVXE HKW IR \FQHLFL IIH HKW QLDWQLDP GQD HWDUHSR HJDQDP RW WKJLU HYLVXOF[H GQD HORV³ HKW JQLYDK VD GHWLQ8 JQLGXOFQL KWJQHO V¶PUD WD GHWDLWRJHQ VHLWUDS HKW KFLKZ VPUHW WLFLOS[H GHGXOFQL $%& HK7 :$0$, GQD GHWLQ8 QHHZWHE $%& JQLWVL[H HKW JQLWHUSUHWQL WXRKWLZ P LDOF $3,% D HXVUXS RW IILWQLDO3 HKW URI \DZ RQ VL HUHKW HVXDFHE $/5 HKW UHGQX QRLWSPHHUS RW WFHMEXV HWXSVLG UR QL P D VL QRVQKR- \E GHVLDU HXVVL HKW HUHK GHL OSS$ G, RW WQDXVUXS HVUHYLG \OHWHOSPRF HUD VHLWUDS HKW IL VD KFXV QRLWFLGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEXV URI VLVDE UHKWRQD ZRKV QDF WQDGQHIHG HKW IL GHWQDUUDZ \OQR VL ODYRPHU QHKW ´ QRLWSPHHUS HWHOSPRF³ URI VLVDE RQ VL HUHKW I, G, QDJHE QRLWDJLWLO HKW HUHKZ WUXRF HKW QL GHKVL OEDWVH GQD GHGDHOS HE WVXP WDKW HVQHIHG D VL QRLWSPHHUS \UDQLGUR VDHUHKZ ODYRPHU VWL PUHS \ OODUHQHJ GQD ´JQLGDHOS HKW OXIHUDF ZRK UHWWDP RQ PLDOF ZDO HWDWV D WXR HNDP RW HO ELVVRSPL VL WL WDKW HYLVDYUHS RV VL ZDO ODUHGHI KFLKZ UHYR VWFHMEXV RW VH LOSSD ¶QRLWSPHHUS HWHOSPR&³µ G ) FQ, VHQL/ UL$ GHWLQ8 Y VHKJX+ UL& KW ´ ZDO ODUHGHI QR WVHU WVXP P LDOF \QD WDKW GQD ¶GHWSPHHUS \OHWHOSPRFµ VL ZDO HWDWV WDKW G OHL I HKW VHLSXFFR RV³ $/5 HKW HVXDFHE HOELVVRSP L V L $3,% UHGQX P LDOF D WDKW ZRKV GHWLQ8 WDKW VHULXTHU \URHKW VLKW QR VVHFFX6 GHWWLPR VQRLWDWRXT O DQUHWQL UL& KW G ) R& UL& KW G ) R& 5 5 FD3 LUXRVVL0 5 5 WQH& OO, Y QZRU% Y HRUQR0 JQLWRXT ´ UH\ROSPH HKW GQD VQRLQX Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 5 of 9 PageID #:224 UL& KW WD G ) QZRU% HH6 QRLWFLGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEXV IR WUXR& VLKW VSLUWV RV JQLRG QL GQD $%& HKW UHGQX KWURI WHV VQRLVLYRUS QRLWDUWLEUD HKW IR HVX VHWDGQDP GQD QRLWFD HKW VWSPHHUS $/5 HKW KFXV V$ $3,% UHGQX VWQHPHULXTHU HKW VWFLGDUWQRF \OWFHULG $%& HKW IR QRLVLYRUS HOEDFLOSSD UHKWR \QD UR QRLVLYRUS ´HVXDF WVXM³ HKW UHKWHKZ HQLPUHWHG RW VPUHW VWL GQD $%& HKW RW NRRO RW GHULXTHU HE GOXRZ $3,% IR QRLWDORLY D URI P LDOF V¶II LWQLDO3 JQLZHLYHU WUXRF D \UDY VQRLVLYRUS HVHKW V$ 6&/, HVX VWL RW URLUS ´UHLILWQHGL FLUWHPRLE HKW IR WFHMEXV HKW \E GHWXFH[H³ HVDHOHU QHWWLUZ D VHULXTHU $3,% WVDUWQRF Q, WD $ [( WN' ´¶ HVXDF WVXMµ WXRKWLZ GHJUDKFVLG UR GHQL OSLFVLG HE WRQ O OLZ³ GRLUHS \UDQRLWDERUS ULHKW GHWHOSPRF HYDK RKZ VHH\ROSPH WDKW VHGLYRUS $%& HKW \ OODF L ILFHS6 :$0$, GQD GHWLQ8 QHHZWHE $%& HKW IR QRLWDWHUSUHWQL HULXTHU GOXRZ QRLVLYRUS D KFXV KWLZ GHL OSPRF GHWLQ8 UHKWHKZ UR GHUUXFFR VLKW UHKWHKZ JQLWHUSUHWQL WDKW GQXRUJ HKW QR VO LDI RVOD WQHPXJUD VLKW UHYHZR+ WD R1 WN' VUHLILWQHGL FLUWHPRLE JQLVX RW URLUS HVDHOHU QHWWLUZ D QLDWER WVXP \WLWQH QD WDKW JQLGLYRUS GQD ´HVDHOHU QHWWLUZ³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¶QRVQKR- HUHKZ HUHK HVDF HKW \OUDHOF VL WDK7 WD 6 8 VHQLOUL$ QDLLD Z D+ JQLWRXT WD G ) QZRU% ´ $%& HKW JQLWHUSUHWQL \E ¶GHWDFLGXMGD \ OHYLVXOFQRFµ HE QDF WL IL UR $%& HKW JQLWHUSUHWQL WXRKWLZ GHWDFLGXMGD HE WRQQDF WL IL GHWSPHHUS HE O OLZ³ WL ± Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 6 of 9 PageID #:225 J 6&/, JQLWLF - KDK6 OO, ' 1 WD /: 9& R1 &// GURQ[H5 Y UDOLXJ$ HH6 ´ QRLWDPURI QL GQD VUHLILWQHGL FLUWHPRLE IR QRLWFXUWVHG GQD QRLWQHWHU HJDURWV JQLOGQDK JQLGUDXJHIDV HVX QRLWFHOORF HKW JQLWDOXJHU³ KJXRUKW QRLWDPURIQ L FLUWHPRLE V¶ODXGL YLGQL QD IR ´\WHIDV GQD \WLUXFHV HUDIOHZ FLOEXS HK@W>³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´¶ PLDOF V¶I ILWQLDOS HKW IR HYLWLVRSVLG HE GOXRFµ WQHPHHUJD UREDO HKW IR ¶VQRLVLYRUS HPRV IR QRLWDWHUSUHWQL HKWµ IL ZDO HWDWV UR ODUHGHI IR HFUXRV WQHGQHSHGQL QD QR GHVDE \ O ELVQHWVR HWXSVLG D QHYH³ JQLWDFLGXMGD PRUI WUXRF WFLUWVLG D VHGXOFHUS $/5 HKW UL& KW [SS$ GH) FQ, SVQDU7 ;6& Y V HPLU* VPUHW @$%&> HKW IR QRLWDWHUSUHWQL QD QRSX WQHGQHSHG VL P LDOF HKW IR VVHFFXV HKW³ HUHKZ VUXFFR QRLWSPHHUS UL& KW G ) QRQQDK6 Y WQH& FVL: $%& HKW JQLWHUSUHWQL \E IR GHVRSVLG HE QDF HXVVL HKW IL $/5 HKW \E GHGXOFHUS VL HWXWDWV ODUHGHI WQHGQHSHGQL QD UHGQX WKJXRUE P LDOF Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 7 of 9 PageID #:226 HFLGXMHUS KWLZ GQD QRLWFLGVLUXM R1³ UL& KW G ) FQ, RFHVQR& HH6 Y \DUUX0 HFLGXMHUS WXRKWLZ GHVVLPVLG VL WQLDOSPRF V¶QRVQKR- GQD @ > GHWQDUJ VL QRLWFLGVLUXM UHWWDP WFHMEXV IR NFDO URI VVL PVL' RW QRLWR0 V¶GHWLQ8 HYRED KWURI WHV VQRVDHU HKW UR) 12,68/&12& HFDOS WVULI HKW QL $/5 HKW \ E GHWSPHHUS WRQ UHWWDP HKW HUHZ JQLGQDWV IR NFDO URI VVL PVLG GOXRZ WUXR& HKW KFXV V$ HURP JQLKWRQ GQD HWXWDWV HKW IR VQRLWDORLY WQHVQRF GQD HFLWRQ URI QRLWDORLY \URWXWDWV D \OQR VHJHOOD I ILWQLDOS HKW HUHKZ VJQLR* GQD UDOLXJ$ QL GQXRI HVRKW KWLZ GHQJLOD HURP KFXP HUD HUHK VWFDI HK7 WD R1 WN' HH6 HUXVROFVLG IR HFQHVVH RQ VHGLYRUS KFLKZ ´ GRLUHS VQRLWDWL P LO HOEDFLOSSD HKW QLKWLZ HPLW \QD VWQDGQHIH' \E GHVX UR GHURWV GHQLDWER GHWFHOORF GHUXWSDF HUHZ VFLUWHPRLE HVRKZ VODXGL YLGQL OO@D>³ QRLWL QLIHG VVDOF VLK \E GHWURSSXV UHKWUXI VL VLK7 \UXMQL HKW PURI GOXRZ WDKW HUXVROFVLG WQHXTHVEXV \QD VDZ HUHKW ZRKV RW VLVDE ODXWFDI RQ VHGLYRUS WXE WQHVQRF Q LDWER RW HUXO LDI V¶GHWLQ8 QR \ OHULWQH GHVDE QRLWDORLY \URWXWDWV D VHJHO OD QRVQKR- $3,% IR VQRLWDORLY \URWXWDWV \ OHUXS QDKW HURP HJHOOD RW \WL O LED V¶I ILWQLDOS QR GHVDE JQLGQDWV JQLKVLOEDWVH - \ O OHQQH. OO, ' 1 WD /: 9& R1 \OUHYH% \WP& KWLP6 HQD- GQD QRWJQLKVD: Y QR[L' IF JQLGQDWV IR NFDO URI JQLVVLPVLG - RONFX% OO, ' 1 WD /: 9& R1 FQ, 1*8 Y VJQLR* RVOD HHV G, ´ HUXVROFVLG IR NVLU D HWDHUF HURP WXRKWLZ WRQ RG VQRLWDORLY WQHVQRF GQD HFLWRQ³ UHYHZR+ WQLDOSPR& V¶I ILWQLDO3 JQLWLF WD R1 WN' HH6 ´ VUHLILWQHGL FLUWHPRLE UR GQD QRLWDPURIQL FLUWHPRLE ¶VUHNURZ ULHKW \RUWVHG QHKW GQD QLDWHU GOXRZ VWQDGQHIH' QHKZ GQD ZRK GHOLDWHG KFLKZ VFLWLORS QRLWHOHG GQD HOXGHKFV QRLWQHWHU D KWLZ FL OEXS HKW GQD VUHNURZ HGLYRUS RW GHO LDI \ OUDO L PLV GQD QRLWDPURI QL FLUWHPRLE ULHKW JQLWFHOORF GQD JQLUXWSDF RW URLUS VUHNURZ ULHKW PRUI WQHVQRF QLDWER RW³ GHO LDI GHWLQ8 WDKW VL QRLWDFL ILWUHF VVDOF URI WVHXTHU GQD WQLDOSPRF V¶QRVQKR- IR HURF HKW GHOS V$ Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 8 of 9 PageID #:227 HJGX- WFLUWVL' VHWDW6 GHWLQ8 O ODGQH. 0 DL QLJUL9 QR+ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB \OX- HWD' HVDF HKW HVROF GQD WQHPJGXM ODQLI UHWQH O OLZ WUXR& HK7 @ > WRRP VD GHVVL PVLG VL GQDPH5 RW QRLWR0 HK7 ´ HYLVXOF[H \ OODXWXP HUD Case: 1:17-cv-08858 Document #: 37 Filed: 07/31/18 Page 9 of 9 PageID #:228