Nosbaum et al v. J.P. Morgan Securities LLC, No. 1:2017cv06202 - Document 36 (N.D. Ill. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM Opinion and Order signed by the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 7/30/2018. The Court grants JPMSs cross-petition 21 and confirms the Award in its entirety. Nosbaum's petition to vacate (Dkt. 1 -1) is denied. The Court therefore converts the Award into a final judgment in favor of JPMS and, pursuant to FINRA Rule 2080, directs the Central Registration Depository system to expunge the information related to FINRA Arbitration No. 15-02672 for broker Christopher D. Nield. The Court will enter final judgment and close the case. Mailed notice(lk, ) (lk, ).
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Dockets.Justia.com VWL \ O JQ LGURFFD GQD WQ H P HFURI QH WQHWDS VL V VH Q L V XE V¶&+9 ´&+ 9³ QRLWDURSUR& J Q L GOR+ ;WHQ UL 9 VV H Q L VXE V ¶ H O FQX UHK Q L NFRW V GH Y L HFHU P XDEVR1 HURI HE WQ LRS HPRV W$ VWFD) $ '1825*.&$% G O HL 1 ' UHKSRWV L UK& UHNRUE URI R1 QRLWDUWL E U$ $51,) RW GHWD O HU QRLWD P URI Q L HKW HJQ XS[H RW P HWV \ V ´'5& ³ \URWL VRSH' QRLWDUWV L JH5 O DUWQH& HKW VVWFHUL G HO X5 $51,) RW WQDXVUXS GQ D 603- IR URY DI Q L WQ H P JGX M O D Q L I D RWQ L GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD HKW VWUHY QRF \ EHUHK WUXR& HK7 GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD H KW P UL I QRF RW WN' QRLWLWHS VVRUF V¶603- VWQDUJ GQD WN' HWD FDY RW QRL WL WHS V ¶ P XDEVR1 V HL QHG WUXR& HKW ZRO HE KWURI WHV VQRVDHU HKW UR) O D Q L I URI GQD GUDZD QRL WDUWL EUD HKW P U L IQRF RW QRL WLWHS VVRUF D VWN' G H O L I UHWDO WL G HYRPHU ´60 3-³ &// V HL WLUXFH6 QDJUR0 3 - WQ HGQRSVH5 WVXJX$ Q2 WQ H P JGX M GQD QRLWFD HKW VWN' V L RQ L O O , \WQXR& NRR& IR WUXR& WL XFUL & HKW Q L GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD ´$ 51,) ³ \ WL URKWX$ \URWD O XJH5 \UWV XGQ, O D L FQ DQ L ) D HWDFDY RW QRL WLWHS D G H O L I WVXU7 P XDEVR1 Q D L O O L / HKW GQD WVXU7 P XDEVR1 * Q Q L ) HKW URI HHWVXU7 VD GQ D \ O O DXG L Y L GQ L P XDEVR1 DWWL U% UHQRL WLWH3 \ O X- Q2 5('52 '1$ 12,1,32 08'1$520(0 WQ HGQRSVH5 &// 6(,7,58&(6 1$*520 3 - O O DGQ H. 0 D L Q L JUL 9 HJGX- Y & R1 UHQRL WLWH3 VD GQ D \ O O DXG L Y L GQ L 08 $%621 $77,5% 76857 08$%621 * 11,) HKW URI HHWVXU7 76857 0 8$ %621 1$,/ /,/ HKW GQD 12,6,9,' 15(76$( 6,21,//, )2 7&,576,' 15(+7521 (+7 52) 7582& 7&,576,' 6(7$76 '(7,18 (+7 1, Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 1 of 18 PageID #:1118 Nosbaum et al v. J.P. Morgan Securities LLC Doc. 36 ´ QDRO³ H KW G QD ´WL G HUF IR H Q L O³ H KW KWRE VD RW GHUUH IHU VL W L G HUF IR H QLO VLKW Q R LQ L SR VL KW WXR K JXRUK7 /3/ KWL Z WQXRFFD Q L JUDP URLUS U HK K WL Z GDK HK V Q DRO JQ L GQDWVWXR Q D I IR \DS RW WUDS Q L WL GHUF IR H Q L O HKW GHVX P XDEVR1 WQ DY HO HU V $ ± WD WN' HH6 ´ \ HQ RP HHUI ³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± WD WN' QRL WDF L O SS$ GHJDQ D P QRQ HUHZ VWQXRFFD HKW V L WDKW² O O HV RW K FXP ZRK GQ D O O HV RW Q H KZ HVRK F \ O HWD P L WO X HKV WXE VWQXRFFD HHUKW HKW Q L VWHVVD HKW RW GUDJHU KWL Z HF L Y GD JQ L Q Q D O S O D L F Q D Q L I GHWVHXTHU P XDE VR1 \ O EDWR1 \ UDXUE H) Q L 603- RW /3/ P RUI GHYRP HUHZ VWHV VD HKW GQD \ UDXQ D- Q L GHWDHUF HUHZ VWQXRFFD ZHQ HK7 G, WD Q HK Z GQ D O O HV RW NFRWV K FXP ZRK QR HF L YGD HY L HFHU RW GQD RL ORIWURS UHK \ I L VUHY LG RW HUL VHG UHK GH \ H YQRF GQD HP RF Q L GHWL P L O V ¶GQ D E VXK UHK GQD UH K GH E L UFVHG HK V JQ L WHHP V L KW WD P XD EVR1 RW JQ LGURFF$ HF L YGD WQ HPWV HY Q L GQD NFRWV &+9 UHK JQ LGUDJHU WFDWQRF UDO XJHU RL ORIWURS UHK IR Q RL V L YUHSXV J Q L GX O FQ L HF L Y GD O D L FQ D Q L I KWL Z G HGL YRUS H E GOXRZ HKV HURI HUHKW GQD ´ WQ H L OF HWD Y L US³ D VD \ I L O DXT GO XRZ P XDEVR1 WDKW GH Q L D O S[H G O H L1 JQ L WHHP UL HKW W$ ± WD WN' HH6 VRL ORIWURS WQXRFFD HHUKW HKW GHWD Q L PRGHUS NFRWV V L KW VHUDKV GHQZR WVXUW K FDH GQD &+9 I R VHUDKV GH QZR P XDEVR1 H P LW HKW W$ KWL Z VWH VVD UHK J Q L Y RP VV XFVLG RW URWFHUL ' HY LWXFH[( QDJUR0 3 - D Q HKW G O HL 1 UHKSRWV L UK& WH P P XDEVR1 Q, ´/ 3/³ O DL F Q D Q L ) /3/ K WL Z Q HUG O L KF RZW WVXUW GHWDHUF GQ D I O HVUHK URI WQXRFFD Q L JUD P D G HQHSR P XDEVR1 NFRWV V L KW K WL : UHK URI VWQXRFFD H O L WDO RY V L NFRWV Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 2 of 18 PageID #:1119 O L US$ QR O HQ DS QRLWDUWL EUD HKW KWL Z V HFQ HUH I QRF JQ LUDHK HUS UHWI $ QRLWRP HKW GHVRSSR 603- UHZVQ $ HKW Q L GHQ LDWQRF VWQ HP XJUD O D JHO HKW RW HVQRSVHU D H O L I RW HY D HO URI GHY RP P XDEVR1 WO XVHU D V$ UHZ VQ$ ± WD WN' HH6 P L D O & IR WQ HPHWDW6 V¶ P XDEVR1 RW QRL WLVRSSR Q L I H L UE O DJHO D WUDS HJUD O Q L VDZ K FL KZ \ UDXQ D- QR VH VQ H I HG HY L WD P UL I I D GQ D ´UHZV Q $ ³ HJDS D G H O L I 603- GL J H HH6 WD ´ J Q L \ I L VUHY L G IR GDHWV Q L NFRWV &+9 HKW GO RK ³ P XDEVR1 WDKW 60 3- \ E QRL WDGQ H P PRFHU GH JH O O D HKW VGUDJHU P L D O & IR WQ H PHWDW6 HKW Q L WQ L D O SP RF J Q L \ OUHGQX HURF HK7 P L D O & IR W Q H PHWDW6 ± WD WN' THV WH I R K FDHUE \ WL O L EDWL XV Q 8² H O X5 $ 5 1,) IR QRL WD O RL Y HH6 GXDUI GQD WFDUWQRF 6&/, WF $ VHFLWFDU3 H Y L WSHFH' GQ D GXDU) UH P XV QR& V L RQ L O O, HKW IR QRL WD O RL Y \WXG \ UD L FXG L I IR K FDHUE HV L YUHSX6 RW HUX O L D )² H O X5 $ 51,) IR QRL WD O RL Y HF Q HJ L O JHQ URI V P L DOF WKJXRUE P XD EVR1 \ O O DF L I L FHS6 G, ± WD ´ RL ORIWURS D KWLZ GHWD FRO O D \ OUHSRUS³ Q HHE GDK HY D K GOXRZ VWQXRFFD UHK GHY H L O HE P XDEVR1 WQXRP D HKW²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¶ P XDEVR1 QHHZWHE URI UHE P HWSH6 HWDO Q L NFRWV ± WD WN' GDHWV Q L WL GHUF I R H Q L O UHK IR WQ XRP D HKW HFXGHU \ E HUHKW GQD WL GHUF I R H Q L O ODUHWD O ORF UH K IR URRO I HFL US HKW UHZRO RW UH K GH V L YGD \ OGHWDHSHU V HH \ RO SPH 603- WQ LRS \ QD WD VJ Q L GO RK UHK \ I L VUHY L G HKV WDKW J Q L V L YGD IR GDHWV Q L WDKW V P L D O F P XDEVR1 HX O DY WVRO \ O G LSDU NFRWV &+9 HKW GQD WXRKJXRUK7 Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 3 of 18 PageID #:1120 @V ¶ P XDE VR1> QL \ WL Y LWFD HKW GQ D GHWDWV O HQDS HKW WQ H P XJUD JQ L UDHK UHWI$ ´ VWQXRFFD QRL WDWL F L ORV HKW RW VHWDO HU WL HV XDFHE ³ HVDF HKW RW WQ DY HO HU VD Z HFQ HG L Y H QDRO HKW V QRLWD OXJHU UR VZD O JQ L NQ DE I R VQRL WD O RL Y JQ L J H O OD WRQ V DZ HK V KJXRKWO D WD KW JQ L XJUD J Q L O XU \ UDL WQ HG L Y H V ¶ O HQ DS HKW IR QRLWDUHG L VQRFHU URI GHYRP UHWD O P XDEVR1 G, ± WD U7 JQ LUDH+ KFUD0 ' [( FLSRW WDKW QR \ Q RP LWVHW HKW IR QRL WDUHG L VQRF UL HKW G HWL P L O Q L DJD O HQDS HKW GQ D ´ VGH HQ QRL WXE L UWV L G³ ´ \ WL GL XT L O ³ UR ´ JQ L GQ X I ³ V ¶ P XDEVR1 GQD WL GHUF I R H Q L O HKW GHY O RY Q L WDKW V Q RL Q LSR H Y DJ I I DKF6 \ HUI I H- WUHS[ H V ¶ P XDEVR1 GHGHHFRUS J Q L UDHK HKW V$ HKW G, WD GHWWL P GD HUHZ \ HKW GQD H FQHG L YH RWQ L WQ H P HHUJD O DUHWD O ORF GQD HWRQ \ URVV L PRUS IR Q RL V V L PGD HKW RW QRL WFH MER K FUD0 $ [( WN' HH6 VWL ZHUGKWLZ UHWDO 603- ± WD U7 JQ LUDH+ /3/ WD GHUUX F Q L GDK HKV WE HG Q D RO Q L JUD P HKW I IR \DS RW WL GHUF N QD% HKW GHV X P XDEVR1 WDKW H FQ HG L YH GQ D \ QRP LWVHW VL WDKW ´ QDJUR0 3- RW /3/ P RUI QRL WLVRS @V ¶ P XDEVR1> GQ D JQ LWXWL WV EXV H FQ HG L YH IR VHVRSUXS WL GHUF I R H Q L O HKW GHWL P L O JQ LGUDJHU HKW URI ³ WQ H P XJUD GHWWL PGD GUDHK O HQ DS HE RW WL HK7 GHZRO O D \ O HWD P L WO X QRL WF L GV L UX M $ 51,) RW WFHM EXV UR WL XV HKW RW \WUDS D WRQ VDZ NQ D% HKW GQD ´NQ D% ³ HKW $ 1 NQ D% HV DK& QDJUR0 3 - \ E GHXV V L VDZ K F L KZ WL GHUF IR H Q L O HKW VV DSPRFQH WRQ GL G QRLWDUWL EUD WDKW JQ LXJUD GHWFHM ER 630- WL GHUF IR H Q L O HKW JQ L GUDJHU HFQ H GL YH HFXGRUWQ L RW Q DJHE P XDEVR1 QHKZ HUHK WQ DY HO HU V$ HFQ HG L Y H \UDWQ H PXFRG GQD VWUHS[H VH VV HQWLZ GHWQ HVHUS GQ D O HVQXRF KJXRUKW GHUDHSSD V HLWUDS HKW GQD O L US$ GQ D K FUD0 Q L VL RQ L O O, RJD F L K& Q L VURWDUWL EUD I R O HQDS UH E P H P HHUKW D HURI HE GHXVQ H V Q RL VVH V JQ L UDHK HWD UDSHV Q HHW[ LV RWQ L QHNRUE JQ L UD HK IR V \ DG WK JL( I H L U% J Q L UDH+ ¶VWQ D P L D O& ± WD WN' RVOD HHV ± WD WN' KFUD0 QR UHZVQ $ VWL Q L 603- \ E KWURI WHV HVRKW RW HVQRSVHU Q L VWQ H P XJUD O DJH O GHQ L DWQRF K F L K Z I H L U% JQ L UDH+ HJDS D G H O L I UHWD O P XDEVR1 UHGU2 O LUS$ WD WN' HH6 GH L Q HG VDZ QRLWRP V ¶ P XDEVR1 GQD Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 4 of 18 PageID #:1121 UR J Q L Q L DWQ L DP GH GQ HP PRFHU UHY H VHL WL UXFH6 QDJUR0 3- WD HQR\ QD URQ G O HL1 U0 UHK WL H@Q>³ WDKW GQ D ´Q HUG O L KF RZW UHK IR VWVXUW HWDUDSHV HKW URI HHWVXUW VD GQ D \ O O D XG L Y L GQ L KWRE P XDEVR1 V0 RW V QRLWD GQ H P PRFHU WQ HP WV HY Q L HWDLUSRUSSD GQ D H O E DWL XV HGD P V \ DZ O D G O HL 1 U0³ WDKW J Q L GX O F Q L VQRVDHU IR QRLWDWL FHU UHKWUXI D \E GHWURSSXV VL VL K7 Q RL WDP URI Q L UR QRLWDJ H O O D P L D O F HK7³ ´ VXRHQRUUH \ O UDHOF UR H O E L VVRS P L \ O O DXWFDI V L WFDI IR J Q L G Q L I HY L WD P UL I I D J Q L ZRO O RI HKW GHGL YRUS GUDZ$ HKW H O X5 $ 51,) GQD HO X5 HUXGHFRU3 QRLWDUWL E U$ IR HGR& $51,) RW WQDXVUXS WQ H P HJQ XS[H HKW IR WQXRFFD Q2 QRL WXO RVH5 HWXSV L ' IR HF L I I 2 $51,) GUDZ$ WD WN' ´ HY L WFHUL G WQ H P H JQ XS[H HKW HWXFH[ H O O L Z '5& HKW HURI HE QRL WF L GV L UXM WQHWHSP RF IR WUXRF D P RUI QRL WD P UL I QRF Q LDWER WVX P GO H L1 ' UHKSRWV L UK & \WUDS QRQ VUHE P H0 RW HFLWR1 RW WQDXVUXS WDKW J Q L GQDWVUHGQX HKW KWLZ '5 & GO H L 1 ' UHKSRWV L UK & \WUDS QRQ URI @\URWL VRSH ' QRLWDUWV L JH5 O DUWQH&> HKW \ E GH Q L DWQ L DP VGURFHU QRLWDUWVL JHU P RUI QRL WDUWL EUD GHQRLWSDF HYRED HKW RW VHFQ HUH IHU O O D IR WQ H P HJQ XS[H HKW VGQ H P P RFHU O HQD3 HK 7³ G QD ´ \ WHUL WQ H UL HKW Q L GH L Q HG HUD V P L DO F V ¶WQ D P L D O & ³ VWUDS RZW VQ L DWQRF GUDZ$ HK7 ´GUDZ $ ³ HKW 603- IR URY DI Q L J Q L OXU QHWWL UZ D GHXV V L O HQDS HKW \ D0 Q2 ± WD U7 JQ LUDH+ O LUS$ , [( WN' V HGL V KWRE \ E VWQ HP XJUD J Q L VRO F H P RV O XI K WL Z J Q L GXO FQRF V \DG HURP RZW URI GHXQ L WQRF QRLWDUWL EUD HK7 WN' RVOD HHV ± WD U7 JQLUDH+ O L US$ + [( WN' HH6 GUDZ$ ± WD GHHFRUS RW V P L DO F \ WL O L E DWL XV GQD HFQ H J L O JHQ UH K J Q L ZRO OD VWQXRF Q HY HV V ¶ P XDEVR1 IR H Y L I RW VD QRLWRP HKW GHWQDUJ \ O HWD P L WO X O H QDS HK7 VWQ HP XJUD \ KWJQ HO GHU H I I R VHLWUDS HKW GQD WF L GUHY GHWFHUL G D URI GHY RP 603- HVDF UHK GHWV HU P XDEVR1 UHWI $ G, ± WD U7 JQ LUDH+ KFUD0 ( [( WQ HP XJUD J Q L VROF HKW RWQ L VWQ HP XJUD UXR\ WXS RW HP RF O HZ QDKW HURP HU¶XR\ GQD Q L V HPRF WDKW HFQ HG L Y H GQ D VH FQDWV P XFU L F GQ D VWFD I HKW O O D UHG L VQRF RW JQ L RJ HU¶H : Q DRO HKW WXRE D P L DOF D WRQ V L ²V L GHG HFQRF HY DK VHLWUDS V D P L DO F IR WQ HPHWDWV HKW GQ $ V HVVHFRUS HKW GQ D VUH E P XQ HKW RW GUDJHU Q L HV DF V L KW Q L J Q L UHG L VQRF HU¶HZ WDKZ Q L HUH K \ DZH HO IR WRO D Q HHE V ¶HUHKW²IR WRO D GUDHK HY ¶HZ GQDWVUHGQX XR\ V $ WL GH L QHG HYDK WQ LRS V L KW WD GQD QRL WDUHGL VQRFHU URI QRLWRP UXR\ GHWRQ \ O XG H@:> Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 5 of 18 PageID #:1122 OO, ' 1 NUD3 QLONQDU) IR OOL9 Y HLSVLOOL* G SSX6 ) J Q LWR XT ´ H P DV H KW \ OODL WQ H VVH VL WF $ Q RLWDUWLEU$ &// P UR I LQ 8 VL R Q LO O, H KW GQD $ $) H KW IR H JDXJ QDO HK7³ OO, ' 1 G SSX6 ) JQLVQHFL/ WQHWD3 KFLUHIOH+ Y FQ, VHURW6 WUD0 OD: HH6 $ $ 8 , H KW G QD $ $) H K W KWRE UH G Q X H PDV H KW HUD²URWDUWLEUD QD \E \WLODLWUDS WQ H G L Y H G QD Q DRO H K W IR H FQ H G L Y H UDH K R W J QL VXIHU Q L WF XG QR F VLP URWDUWLEUD ²UXWDFDY URI V H LO HU PXDEVR1 K FL K Z Q R VG Q XRUJ HKW WQ H Y H \QD Q, QLONQR& GRRO) Y SUR& WQLD3 DPLU3 R& JI0 6 8 G H Y O RY Q L H VL Z UH KWR VL Q R LWVH XT ODUH G H I R Q H UH K Z H VDF \WLVUH Y L G VQLNSPR7 Y R& GDRUOLD5 D QL $ $) H KW IR VQ R LVL YRUS H KW \OSSD WVXP VWUXRF ODUH GHI 6 8 HLU( UH G QX ZDO HWDWV \ E GQ XRE H E \ OO DPUR Q GO XR Z \ WLVUH Y L G Q L J QLWWLV WUXRF ODUH GHI D K J XR KWO$ WD WN' HH6 ± $ $ 8 , H KW RW ´ H JDXJQDO UDO L P LV VQ LDWQRF³ WL WDKW VH WR Q GQD $ $) H KW VH LOSSD UH Y H Z R K Q R LWLWHS V¶603- RW Q R L WLVR SSR Q L G QD Q R LWL WHS UH K IR WURSSXV Q L IH LUE V¶PXDEVR1 WH WN' HH6 THV 6&/, ´ $ $ 8,³ WF$ Q RLWDUWLEU$ P UR IL Q 8 VL R Q LO O, H KW UH G QX Q R L WLWHS UH K WK JXRUE PXDEVR1 R& VD& O¶WQR& Y GW/ HSRUX( IR R& VQ, HQLUD0 HUL) DGXVD< HH6 V L GUDZD QRL WDUWL EUD QD IR ZH L YHU V¶WUXR& V L KW VGURZ UHKWR Q, FQ, $68 WV\ODWD& Y FQ, RUEVD+ KW ± G ) VGUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD IR QRL WD P UL I QR& ´ GHWL P L O \ O HP HUW[ H³ GHWWL PR QRLWDWLF UL & ´ \ UD P PXV UR HQ LWXRU \ O O D XVX³ V L pUp0 HG Y QLD- U L& KW G ) ´ VWUXRF O DUHGH I GQD HWDWV KWRE Q L VWFDUWQRF O D L FUH P PRF Q L V HVXD O F QRL WDUWL EUD IR QRLWDWHUSUHWQ L GQ D \ WL G L O DY THV WH WQ H P HFURI QH HKW VQUHYRJ³ & 6 8 ´$ $ )³ WF $ QRL WDUWL EU$ O DUHGH) HK7 '5$'1$76 /$*(/ D & 6 8 HUD QRL WF L GV L UXM \ WL VUH Y LG URI VWQ H P HULXTHU HKW VHVVRO WQ H PWV HY Q L Q L Q RL O O L P RW VNHHV QRL WDUWL EUD J Q L \ O UHGQX HKW WDKW JQ L HH6 ±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³ ± WD G, VURWDUWL EUD ´ VHL WUDS HKW \ E GH O L I V O DL UHWD P HKW \E WQ H P HJGHO ZRQ NFD QD ´ \ WL UXFHV V L KW Q L QRL WLVRS GHWDUWQ HFQRF D J Q L GO RK Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 6 of 18 PageID #:1123 PLOD+ WD G ) ´ GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD Q D JQ L QUXWUHYR WURSSXV RW WQ H L F L I I X V Q L VL VVRUJ ZRK UHWWDP RQ URUUH O DJHO UR O DXWFD) ³ ´ ZDO HKW HE RW Z HQN H KV WDK Z GHGUDJHUV L G \ O HWDUH E L OHG URWDUWL EUD HKW V VH O Q X GUDZD Q D JQ L WDFDY URI VGQXRUJ HGL YRUS WRQ VHRG HVQ H I HG O DJH O HY L WL VRSVLG D QHYH UR G L O DY D JQ LWFH M HU \ OVXRHQRUUH \ E HNDWV L P JI0 HOEL[HO) D VH NDP URWDUWL EUD QD WDKW WFD I HK7³ WD G ) ´VHF QDWV P XFU L F O D XVXQX UHWWX6 \ UHY Q L \ O QR³ Q RL V L FHG V¶URWDUWL EUD HKW HWDFDY \ DP WUXRF D W& 6 Y &// VQDO3 KWODH+ GURI[2 RVOD HHV GHWWLPR VQRLWDWRXT GQD VQRLWDWLF UL& KW ± FQ, VORUWQR& QDPG( Y FQ, VORUWQR& QRVQKR- G ) ´ \ NFDK Z QHYH UR WFHUURF Q L V L QRL V L FHG HKW UR URUUH VXRLUHV GHWWL P PRF URWDUWL E UD Q D³ Q HK Z QHYH GUDZD QD WSXUV LG WRQ O O L Z \ HKW WXE ´ GUDZD HKW RW HWXRU HY LWHUSUHWQ L H O E L VVRS R Q V L HUHKW H VXDFH E HFL WVX M O DLUWV XGQ L IR GQDUE QZR V L K V HVQ H SV L G \ O HY L WFH I I H³ URWDUWL EUD HKW I L GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD QD WSXUV L G \ O QR O O LZ VWUXR& GHWWL PR VQRLWDWRXT GQ D VQRLWD WL F O DQUHWQ L ´ VGUDZD O XQQD RW VWUXRF H]LURKWXD WRQ RG²VURUUH VVRUJ UR UDH O F Q HYH²VURWDUWL E UD \ E VURUUH O DJH O UR O DXWFD) $ $ ) HKW UHGQX GHWWL P UHS W[HWQRF SUR& VGRU3 UHSX6 Y GW/ \W3 V\6 JI0 HOEL[HO) \ O Q L K7³ WRQ HUD Q RL VL FHG V¶URWDUWL EUD Q D IR ZH LYHU HWD O O HSSD Q LDWER RW VWSPHWWD G H O L HY UL & KW G ) WQ H P HHUJD J Q L Q L DJUDE HY L WFH O ORF O¶WQ, VUHNURZUHSD3 GHWLQ8 HH6 6 8 FQ, RFVL0 Y 2,&±/)$ QRLQ8 GH Q L P UHGQX HE GOXRZ VQRLWSR QRL WXORVHU HWXSVL G HY L WFH I IH WVRF GQ D \ GH HSV V D VJQ L GHHFRUS QRLWDUWL E UD IR HVRSUXS HKW HV L ZUHKWR P HKW KWL Z V HHUJDV L G WL HVXD FHE \ O HUHP WFD I IR VJ Q L G Q L I V¶URWDUWL EUD QD KWL Z HUH I UHWQ L WRQ \ D P WUXRF $ ´ WRQ HUD \ HKW WXE @$ $ )> HKW UHGQ X VGUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD IR Z H L YHU O D L FL G X M Q L GHJDJQH HUD VWUXRF WDKW NQ LKW RW JQ L WSPHW &// FH6 DLYRKFD: Y HVL: V L W,³ UL & KW G ) FQ, \UHOOD* QRLWFX$ V¶\EVWD* WDHU* Y PLOD+ RVOD HHV G ) UL & KW UL & KW G ) Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 7 of 18 PageID #:1124 ´ P L DO F HKW JQ LW UHVV D \WUDS HKW KWL Z VWVHU \ WL O DLWUDS WQ HG L YH JQ L YRUS &// FH6 DLYRKFD: Y UHWWH0 I R QHGUXE HK7³ WSH6 O O, ' 1 /: RVOD HHV ´ GUDZD @QRL WDUWL EUD> HKW JQ L WDFDY URI GQXRUJ G L O DY D I R HFQ HWV L [ H HKW JQ LWDUWV QRP HG UHFOD% Y VDPL6 IR QHGUXE HKW V DK UHQRL WLWHS HK7³ Q D- O O, ' 1 /: J H HHV 6 8 SUR& O¶WQ, VGHH)ODPLQ$ Y $ 6 QHVOHL1±WORW6 D UDHOF WV XP GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD QD HWDFDY RW JQ L NHHV UH QRLWLWHS $ ´ H O GUXK K J L K ³ ± WD WN' HH6 UHZV QD V¶ 603- Q L GHQ LDWQRF VWQ H P XJUD O DJH O \ KWJQ HO HKW RW HVQRSVHU D J Q L O L I \ O H P LW P RUI UHK GHWQ HYHUS \ HKW Q HK Z \ WL O DL WUDS GH \ D O SVLG GQD QDR O HKW RW J Q L Q LDWUHS H FQ HG L YH WQ DY H O HU O DL UHWD P O O X I Q L WQHVHUS RW \ WLQXWURSSR HKW IR UHK GHY L USH G \ HKW Q HKZ WFXGQRF V L P Q L GHJDJQH VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW VGQHWQRF GQD VGQXRUJ GUL KW GQ D GQRFHV HKW QR UXWDFDY URI VHXJUD P XDEVR1 GUDZ$ QRLWDUWLEU$ HKW HWDFD9 RW QRLWLWH3 V¶PXDEVR1 $ 12,668&6,' ± D & 6 8 H GDP WRQ VDZ GHWWL P EXV UHWWDP WFH M E XV HKW QRSX GUDZD HWL Q L I HG GQD O D Q L I O DXWXP D WDKW P HKW GHWXFH[ H \ O WFHI UHS P L RV UR VUHZRS UL HKW GHGHHF[H VURWDUWL EUD HKW HUHKZ UR GHF L GXM HUS Q HHE HY DK \WUD S \ QD IR VWK JL U HKW K F L KZ \ E URL Y DK HE V L P UHKWR \ Q D IR UR \ VUHYRUWQRF HKW RW O D LUHWDP GQD WQ HQ LWUHS HFQ HG L YH UDHK RW JQ L VX I HU Q L UR QZRK V HVXDF WQ H L F L I I XV QRSX J Q L UDHK HKW HQRSWVRS RW J Q L V XIHU Q L WFXGQRF V L P I R \ WO LXJ HUHZ VURWDUWL E UD HKW HUHKZ P HKW IR V Q DHP HXGQX UR GXDUI QRLWSXUURF \ E GHUXFRUS VDZ GUDZD HKW HUHKZ UHKWLH UR VURWDUWL EUD HKW Q L QRLWSXUURF UR \ WL O DLWUDS WQ HG L Y H VDZ HUHKW HUHKZ VH FQDWVQ L ZRUUDQ UXRI Q L GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD QD HWDFDY RW WUXRF D VWL P UHS $ $ ) HKW \ O O DF L I L FHS6 FQ, OHWWD0 Y VFRVV$ W6 OOD+ 6 8 ´ QRLWDUWL EUD QRSX GHHUJD ¶ VHLWUDS HKW PRUI VHUXWUDSHG VXRL JHUJH³ QR VXFRI UXWDFDY URI VGQXRUJ HKW GDHWVQ, Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 8 of 18 PageID #:1125 HWDXTHGD²V VHQ U L DI IR VWQ H P HU L XTHU O D P L Q L P HKW VWHH P ³ WL I L U L D I \ O O DWQ H P D GQ XI V L J Q L UDHK $ ODFL0 WD [ ¶SS$ ) ´ HXV V L ODWRY L S D QR H FQ HG L Y H HORV HKW V HGX O F[ H \ O JQRUZ URWDUWL E UD QD Q HK Z \ O QR WHP V L \ O O DF L S\ W³ GUDGQDWV JQ L UDHK U L D I QX HK7 G¶IID UL & KW [ ¶SS$ ) ´JQ L UD HK UL D I \ O O DWQ H P D GQ XI D HGL YRUS ³ O HQDS HKW WDKW \ O S P L V VHULXTHU D UD0 R& VQ, HIL/ P$ OO$ Y GW/ VQ, HNDU' HUHKS6 J H HHV O O, ' 1 WD /: NFLO* Y ODFL0 UL & KW [ ¶SS$ ) J Q L UDHK ´ UL D I \ O O DWQ H P DGQ X I ³ D I R P XDEVR1 JQLWRXT ODFR/ VDWVLXTQRU7 HG QRLQ8 Y KFDH% RGDGQR& VHOHWR+ HKW GHY L USHG HY DK WVX P HFQ HG L YH WQ HQ LWUHS UH GL VQRF RW HUX O L DI ¶VURWDUWL EUD HKW UHKWD5 UL& WV G ) ´ GUDZD V¶URWDUWL EUD Q D IR UXWDFDY J Q L ULXTHU WFXGQRFV L P HWXWLWVQRF WRQ VHRG HFQ HG L YH WQ DY HO HU R& SLX4 DQKFH7 HY L HFHU RW URWDUWL E UD Q D I R HUX O L D I \ UHY(³ UL & KW G ) Y SUR& UHGQHO) RVOD HHV G¶IID UL& KW [ ¶SS$ ) FQ, V¶\FD0 Y QUX+ HH6 WD /: WSH6 O O, ' & GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD Q D JQ LWDFDY WQDUUDZ WRQ VHRG HQRO D JQ L GQDWV JQ L UDHK HKW WD HF Q HGL YH WQ DY HO HU HY L HFHU RW O D VXIHU V¶URWDUWL EUD Q $ &// , GOUR: ZH1 QHK= QHK6 Y & / / JQLVLKFQDU) WWD\+ UL & KW G ) V QRL V L FHG V¶URWDUWL E UD QD I R ZH L Y HU HY LWQ DWVEXV URI HGL YRUS WRQ VHRG HWXWDWV HKW URL Y D K HE V L P P RUI GQ L N QL VUH I I LG URUUH QD WXE O D L F L GXM URI VH GL YRUS HWXWDWV V LK7 ´ URL Y DKH E V L P ³ VWL P PRF URWDUWL EUD QD Q HKZ QRL WQ HY UHWQ L ´ \ VUHYRUWQRF HKW RW O DLUHWD P GQD WQ HQ LWUHS HFQ H G L YH UDHK RW J Q L VXIHU Q L WFXGQRF V L P IR \ WO LXJ HUHZ VURWDUWL EUD HKW HUHKZ³ GUDZD V¶URWDUWL EUD Q D HGLVD WHV \ DP HJGXM D WDKW VH GLYRUS D Q L DJ$ QRLWXWL WVE XV QRL WLVRS RW HFQ HG L YH WL GHUF I R H Q L O HKW I R QRLWDUHG L V QRF UL HKW GHWL P L O \ HKW QHKZ D IR QRL WD O RL Y Q L ´ \ VUHYRUWQRF HKW RW O DL UHWD P GQD WQ HQ LWUHS HFQ H GL YH UDHK RW @GH>V XIHU³ VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW V HXJUD P XDEVR1 WV UL ) HFQHGLY( QDR/ UDH+ RW JQLVXIH5 QL WFXGQRFVL0 Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 9 of 18 PageID #:1126 RWQ L GHWWL P GD HUHZ VWQ HP XFRG Q DRO ODXWFD HKW WQ HPHWDWV J Q L QHSR UHK Q L QDRO HKW GH VVXF VL G HK V I HL U% JQ L UDH+ UHK Q L GHQ L DWQRF VWQ HP XJUD HKW Q L QDRO HKW GHGX O F Q L P XDEVR1 HQR UR) WL GHUF IR H Q L O HKW JQ L QUHFQRF WQ H P XJUD GQD H FQ HG L YH VXRQ L P XO RY ZDV GQD GUDHK VURWDUWL EUD HKW JQ L O XU HKW HWL SVHG GQ$ QDRO HKW WXRE D P L DO F D HGXO F Q L WRQ GL G HVDF HKW WDKW JQ L G Q L I GH L Q HG Q L DJD \ HKW K F L KZ QRL WDUHGL VQRFHU URI QRLWRP UHK J Q L UHG L VQRF GQD J Q L Q LDWUHWQ H \ O O XI \ E P XDEVR1 GHJ O XG Q L VURWDUWL EUD HKW J Q L O XU \ UDL WQ HG L Y H UL HKW JQ L UHGQHU UHWI $ WN' HH6 GL ± WD ( [( ± WD $ [( QDRO HKW WXRE D P L D O F D GHVV DS PRFQ H P L DO & IR WQ HPHWDW6 V ¶ P XDEVR1 UHKWHK Z GQD VQRL WDWL P L O O DQRL WF L GV L UX M V¶ $ 51,) IR WQXRFFD QR \ WL O L E L V V L P GD IR VHXV V L J Q L KFUDUHYR GH Y O RY Q L K F L K Z VHL WUDS HKW PRUI VWQ H P XJUD \ KWJQ HO J Q L UDHK UHWI D H FQ HG L YH WL GHUF I R H Q L O HKW UHG L VQRF RW K FL KZ URI HVRSUXS GHWL P L O HKW WXRED Q RL V L FHG UL HKW GHKFDHU VURWDUWL EUD HKW UHYHZR+ ± WD WN' WD WN' H O E DQRVDHUQX HUHZ VWQXRFFD UHK URI VQRL WDGQ H P PRFHU V¶630- WD KW P L D OF UHK RW O DUWQHF GQD WQ D Y HO HU VDZ H FQ HG L YH HP DV WDKW HVXDFHE UHSRUS P L VDZ ´QDJUR0 3- RW /3/ P RUI QRL WLVRS @V ¶ P XDEVR1> JQ LWXWL WVE XV IR HVRSUXS GH WL P L O HKW URI ³ GHWWL P GD HE GOXRZ WL G HUF IR H Q L O NQ D% O DUHWD O O RF HKW JQ L Q UHFQRF H FQ HG L YH \ UDWQ HPXFRG GQD WUHS[ H O D L Q RP LWVHW WDKW J Q L O XU HWD P L WO X ¶VURWDUWL EUD HKW WD KW V Q L D O SPRF UHKWUX I HK6 V QRLWF HM ER V¶60 3- \ E I IR WXF HUHZ I I DKF6 \ H UI IH- VWUHS[H UHK IR HQR I R \ QRP LWVHW HKW GQD Q DRO HKW WXRE D \ Q RP LWVHW QZR UHK WDKW V Q L D O S PRF P XDEVR1 UD O XFLWUDS Q, HKW WRQ VL V LKW WX% GHUHGL VQRF HE RW WL GHWQD Z HKV VQRVDHU HKW IR OOD UXWDFDY URI GUDGQDWV URI WL UHGL VQRF RW GHV XIHU GQ D P L D O F \ WL O L E DWL XVQ X UHK IR WURSSXV Q L WQHVHUS RW WKJXRV HK V HFQ HG L YH HKW IR RW GHVXIHU VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW VL WQ L D O SPRF \ UD P L US V ¶ P XDEVR1 OOD UHG L VQRF U L D I Q X \ O O DWQ H P DGQ XI VDZ J Q LUDHK UHK WDKW JQ L ZRKV IR Q HGUXE UHK \UUDF RW G H O L D I V DK P XDEVR1 GUDGQDWV V L KW JQ L V8 Q¶GH) UXHWDP$ UL & KW G ) O¶WQ, Y \HQDO6 ´ URWDUWL EUD HKW \ E Q RL V L FHG O D LWUDS P L QD GQD HFQ H GL YH HKW QR JQ L UDHK D HFLWRQ Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 10 of 18 PageID #:1127 VDZ GQXRUJ UHK WL H QR QRL WD Q L PUHWHG ¶VURWDUWL EUD HKW I L Q HY( ´ UHWDHUJ Q HY H \ O E DXJUD VL URWDUWL EUD HKW RW H FQ HUHI H G GQ D \ WL O L E L VV L P GD GQ D H FQD Y H O HU IR V HXVV L QR WFD I IR UH LUW HKW RW HFQ HUHI HG H O E DUHG L VQRF H Y L J V \ DZOD VWUXRF JQ L Z H L Y H5³ WSH6 O O, ' 1 WD / : QQHO* Y UHQLHW6 J H HH6 QRL WF L GV L UX M $ 51,) I R V L V \ O DQ D U L HKW GQ D P L D O & IR WQ HPHWDW6 HKW IR QRL WDX O DYH UL HKW QR WQ L RS VL KW QR V JQ L O XU \ UD LWQ H G L YH UL HKW GH VDE ¶VURWDUWL EUD HK7 VVH Q UL D I O DWQ H P D GQ XI V ¶J Q L UDHK HKW HWDF L O S P L WRQ GL G VQRLWVHXT NVD RW \ WL O L ED V L K GHGH S P L O H QDS QRLWDUWL EUD G¶IID HKW WDKW VWQ L D O SP RF V ¶ I I L WQ L DOS D UL & KW [ ¶SS$ ) &// FH6 ('$57 ( Y LXRU]$ J H HH6 ' 1 WD /: J Q L UDHK QRLWDUWL E UD HKW GHUHGQ HU HFQ HG L YH WDKW IR J Q L O GQ DK UL HKW \ D0 O O , UL D I Q X \ O O DWQ H P DGQ X I WDKW \DV WRQQDF WUXR& HKW H FQ HG L Y H QDRO HKW I R QRLWDUH GL VQR F UL HKW GHWL P L O VURWDUWL E UD HKW KJXRKWOD HURI HUHK7 ± WD ( [( WN' ´ WQ HP XJUD JQ L VRO F HKW RWQ L VWQ HPXJUD UXR\ WXS RW HP RF O HZ QDKW HURP HU¶XR\ GQD Q L VH PRF WDKW HFQ H GL Y H GQD VH FQDWV P XFUL F GQD VWFDI HKW O O D UHG L VQRF RW JQ LRJ HU¶ H: ³ QRL WDUHGL VQRFHU URI QRLWRP V ¶ P XDEVR1 QR JQ L O XU Q H KZ VH LWUDS HKW GORW O HQ DS QRLWDUWL EUD HKW IR U L DKF HKW HFQ HG L Y H QDRO HKW RW GUDJHU KW L Z P L D O F \ WL O L E DWL XVQX UHK IR WURSSXV Q L GHWQHVHUS H FQ HG L Y H H O E DQRL WFHM ERQX HKW RW QRL WL GGD Q L \UDUWQRF HKW R7 P L D O F \ WL O L E DWL XVQX V ¶ P XDEVR1 V L WDKW H XVV L ODWRYLS D QR HF Q HG L YH HORV HKW UH GL VQRF UR HY L HFHU RW HVXIHU WRQ GLG VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW VHWDUWV QRP H G \ O SPD HURI HUHKW GURFHU HK7 VWQXRFFD UHK Q L NFRWV H O JQ L V D IR V QRLWDUWQ HFQRF K J L K Q L DWQ L D P HK V WDKW VQRL WDGQ H P PRFHU GHJ H O O D HKW JQ L Q UHFQRF HFQ HG L Y H \ O H P DQ H O E DWL XVQX HUHZ VWQXRFFD UH K URI VQRL WDGQ H P P RFHU V¶603 - WDKW P L DO F UHK WURSSXV RW WQ HP XJUD GQ D H FQ HG L YH UHKWR²JQ L WQ HVHUS P XDEVR1 QL HFQ HG L Y H GHGH S P L QDRO VDZ HKW IR HKV H XVVL WDKW WQ H P XJUD HWH UFV LG HKW \ QD GHWUHVVD GQ R\ HE WRQ V DK JQ LNRR/ GQ D²GHWQHVHUS WQ H P XJUD JQ L VRO F UHK Q L Q DRO HKW JQ LGUDJHU WQ H P XJUD GHGX O F Q L P XDE VR1 GQD Q DRO HKW J Q L Q UHFQRF \ Q RP LWVHW WUHS[H Q L DWUHF UHI IR RW GHWWL P UHS VD Z I I DKF6 QDRO HKW WXRE D \ I LWVHW RW GHWWL P UHS VD Z P XDEVR1 H FQ HG L YH Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 11 of 18 PageID #:1128 WUXRF HWD O O HSSD HKW QRVDHU VL KW UR) PXURI UHKWRQD Q L H P LW UHKWRQD WD QRLWXORVHU URI VHWXSVL G JQ L VRO F WVRS HKW J Q L GO RK H P L W HP DV HKW WD H O L K Z WO XD I HG HKW JQ L GUDJHU HFQ H GL YH HWDUWL E UD GQD HWDUDSHV WRQ GOXRF VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW GQXRI WUXRF HWD O O HSSD HKW \ O JQ LGURFF $ IR O HFUDS GQD WUDS HUHZ VH VDE VWL GQD WO XDI HG HK7 G, ± WD P L D O F HP DV HKW HVXD O F QRLWDUWL E UD HKW \ E ODWRW Q L GHUHYRF VD Z²VH L WL UDO XJHUUL J Q L VROF WVRS HKW IR WQXRFFD QR VWQ H P \ DS IR QRL WDV VHF ¶VWQ DGQ HI HG HKW VDZ K F L KZ²VURWDUWL EUD HKW RW GHWWL P EXV HWXSVLG WQ H P \DS HKW GQ D HVXD O F ´ FL UHQ HJ³ D GHQ LDWQRF WFDUWQRF ¶V HLWUDS HKW WDKW GQXRI WUXR& HWD O O HSS$ V L RQ L O O, HK7 QRLWDUWL EUD HF QDWV Q L WV UL I HKW Q L H O EDUWL EUD HUHZ V HXVV L JQ L VROF WVRS HKW UHKWHKZ GHWXSV LG V HLWUDS HKW V JQ LGHHFRUS WUXRF UL HKW Q, VWQ DGQ HI HG HKW \ E HJDSSRWV WQH P \ DS GHQRL WQ HP UH L O UDH HKW URI V L VDE HKW HUHZ WDKW \ FQ DSHUFVL G QRL WDXO DY WQDWO XVHU D GQD VHWXSV LG JQ L VROF WVRS GHQ UHFQRF \ O O D F L VDE ´ VHV Q HI HG GQD VUHWWD P ³ HKW WQ DY H O HU V$ QRLWDUWL EUD RW WFH M EXV WRQ VD \ HQURWWD ¶VWQ DGQ HI HG HKW P RUI UHWWHO D Q L G HV L DU ´VH VQ HI HG GQD VUHWWD P ³ HKW RW GHWD O HU \ QRP L WVHW GQD H FQ HG L Y H HGXO F[H RW GHHUJD VURWDUWL EUD HKW I I L WQ L DOS HKW URI Q RL V L FHG D J Q L KFDHU Q, J Q L UDHK QRL WDUWL EUD Q D Q L GHWDS L FLWUDS V HLWUDS HKW GQD WFDUWQRF HKW UH GQX H XG V P XV Q LDWUHF IR WQ H P \ DSQRQ ¶VWQ DGQ H I HG HKW UHYR J Q L QUHFQRF HVRUD \ O WQ HXTHV EXV HWXSVL G $ QRVQKR- WD G SS$ O O, VPUHW VWL UR HVDKFUXS HKW RW GHWDO HU UHWWDP UHKWR \ QD UR WFDUWQRF HKW IR QRLWDWHUSUHWQ L JQ L GUDJHU VHWXSVLG HWDUWL EUD RW GHHUJD \ HKW RV JQ L RG Q L GQ D \ Q D SPRF ORRW GQ D H L G D IR H O DV HKW URI GHWFDUWQRF GDK VHLWUDS HKW ± WD WGUDJPXD% Y QRVQKR- WN' Q L GHWLF WVL' G G SS$ O O, HUD \ HKW HUHZ \ HKW IL Q HY H GQ D O D LWQHGHFHUS WRQ HUD P XDE VR1 \E Q L WVUL ) GHWL F HWL VRSSD Q L V HVDF HK7 G, VQ RL V L FHG ¶VURWDUWL E UD HKW IR Z H L YHU HY L WQDWV E XV Q L HJDJQH WRQ O O LZ WUXR& HKW URL Y DK H E V L P RQ GQ XRI J Q L YD+ & / / JQLVLKFQDU) WWD\+ WD G ) URL Y DK H E V L P PRUI V UH I I LG URUUH Q LDJD URUUH Q L Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 12 of 18 PageID #:1129 Q HYH V WL E L K [ H GQ D VH VVH QWL Z \ Q D P KWL Z V \ DG \ Q DP UH YR O O X I Q L HVDF UHK WQHVHUS RW \ WLQXWURSSR HKW Q HY L J VDZ HKV WDKW ODUXGHFRUS UD O L P LV R1 VWFH O IHU GURFHU G, WD HKW GQD H VDF V ¶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´ GHF L GX M HUS³ QRL QX D GQ D \ Q DSPRF H Y L VQHW[H RWQ L GHY O RYHG VWQ H P HHUJDV L G ¶ VHLWUDS HKW J Q L UDHK HQR W$ GQD VDZ D QHHZWHE HWXSVLG D HWDUWL EUD RW GHWQ LRSSD VDZ URWDUWL EUD QD HUHK7 VWQ HP XJUD GHWDHK RL UDQ HFV O DXWFDI HWDUD SVL G HURP Q HY H QD VWQHVHUS WD WN' Q L GHWLF < 1 ' 1 SSX6 ) SSDO& ' ( Y R1 QRLQ8 ODFR/ VUHSOH+ SUR& QHPHVXRKHUD: VUXHIIXDK& VUHWVPDH7 QRVQKR- QL GHUUXFFR WDKW JQLYUDF P LDOF ODHPHFHLS HKW RW HVROF HPRF Q HYH WRQ VHRG HV DF V ¶ P XDEVR1 Q L J Q L O XU \ UDLW Q HGL YH HKW HURI HUHK7 WUDS Q L WV DHO WD GHUHG L VQRF GQD GHWQHVHUS HE RW HFQ H GL Y H QDRO GH ZRO OD O O L WV \ HKW GHUL VHG HK WDKW QRL WDUHG L VQRF IR HSRFV O O XI HKW P L K WQDUJ WRQ GLG VURWDUWL EUD HKW KJXR K WO $ VWQ H P XJUD \ WL O L E DWL XV Q X V L K URI GHUHG L VQRF HE RW HF Q HG L YH QDRO HKW GHWQ DZ \ O S P L V H K GH P DQ HE RW GHH Q GOXRZ NQD% HKW WDKW RV Q DRO HKW RW GUDJHU KWL Z V QRLWD OXJHU UR V ZD O JQ L NQ D E IR V QRL WD O RL Y J Q L JH O OD WRQ VDZ HK WDKW JQ L UDHK HKW WD GHGHF QRF O HV QXRF V¶ P XDEVR1 WQ L RS VL KW QR WX E QRL WD Q L P UHWHG \ WL O L E DUWL EUD Q D IR VHQRWUHYR HY DK VHRG HVDF UHK Q L J Q L O XU \ UD LWQ H GL YH GHWX SV LG HKW WEXRG HKW IR WL I H Q HE HKW P XDEVR1 J Q L Y L * G, WD GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD HKW GHWD FDY GQ D \ VUHYRUWQRF HKW RW O DL UHWDP H FQHG L YH UDHK RW GHVXIHU VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW GHGXO FQRF Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 13 of 18 PageID #:1130 QRL WDUHG L VQRF HKW GHWL P L O WDKW J Q L O XU \ UDL WQ HG L YH Q D HGDP VURWDUWL EUD HKW KJXRKWO D HUH+ HVL: G ) WD HNDWV L P D HGDP VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW GQXRUJ HKW QR WRQ ´HWDUWL EUD RW WQ HPHHUJD HKW GHWD O RL Y³ VURWDUWL EUD HKW I L RV RG \ O QR QDF H KV GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD JQ L WO XVHU HKW VHJQ H O O DK F VHLWUDS HVRKW I R HQR Q HK Z GQD P HWV\ V WUXRF HKW IR WXR WSR \ HKW HWDUWL EUD RW HHUJD VHL WUDS Q HK : P L D O F \ WL O L E DWL XV QX UHK IR IRRUS WQHVHUS RW \ WL QXWURSSR HKW GH L QHG WRQ V DZ HK V HV XDFHE WFXGQRF V L P IR O HY HO HKW RW HVLU WRQ QDF WL WXE GUDZ$ HKW J Q L Q L PUHWHG Q L GHK JLHZ VURWDUWL EUD HKW HFQ H GL YH HKW RW VL HJQ H O O DKF UH+ GOLKFULD) Q RL VX O FQRF H P DV HKW VHKFDHU WUXR& HKW Q L KWURI WHV VGUDGQDWV HKW UHGQ8 I R O HY H O HKW RW HVLU WRQ GL G Q RL V L FHG V¶URWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW GO HK WUXRF HK7 HUHK WF XGQRFV L P G, WD ´ H VQ HI HG UR P L D O F D IR IRRUS WQHVHUS RW \ WL QXWURSSR WQ HL F L I I XV IR GH Y L USHG HE HVL ZUHKWR GO XRZ \WUDS HKW GQD HWXSVL G Q L H XVV L O DWQ H P DGQ XI D IR QRL WDF L GXM GD HKW RW O D LWQ H VVH HFQ HG L YH WQ DY HO HU IR QRLWDUHG L VQRF VWFH M HU VHLWUDS HKW IR HQR I R HF L GXMHUS HKW RW URWDUWL EUD Q D³ HUHKZ HE RW GUDGQDWV WF XGQRFV L P HKW GHWDWV WUXRF HK7 WD G SSX6 ) SUR& GOLKFULD) ´ HFQ HG L Y H IR GUDJHUVL G WV H I L Q DP IR GQXRUJ HKW QR \ O HO RV GHQUXWUHYR HE WRQ Q DF GUDZD QRLWDUWL E UD Q D³ GQD ´ WQ D Y HO HUU L UR HY L WD O XP XF HE \ DP V O DL UHWDP WDKZ H Q L PUHWHG GQ D HFQ HGL YH WFH MHU UR WL PGD RW QRL WHUFVL G V DK URWDUWL EUD Q D³ WDKW WXE Q RL VX O FQRF VL K RW J Q L PRF Q L GHWL GHUF GQD GHK JL HZ URWDUWL EUD HKW H FQ HG L YH HKW RW HJQ H O O DKF D RW QZRG G H O LRE WQ HP XJUD V¶ UHQRLWLWHS HKW WDKW GHWRQ WUXRF HKW Q RL V XO FQRF VL KW J Q L KFDHU Q, D UHGQX WFXGQRF V L P UHSRUS P L HWXWLWVQRF WRQ G L G I H L UE JQ L UDHK WVRS V¶ UHQRLWLWHS HKW WSHFFD RW O DV XIHU V¶URWDUWL EUD HKW VWL UHP HKW QR J Q L UDHK O O XI D UHWID WDKW GQ XRI WUXRF WFLUWV LG HKW HUHK7 QRL WLVRS V ¶ P XDEVR1 URI WURSSXV V VH O Q HYH V HGL YRUS WD WN' FQ, DRFO$ Y SUR& GOLKFULD) Q L GHWLF < 1 ' 6 G SSX6 ) \ O O D Q L ) VUHWVPDH7 RW VXRJRODQD WRQ \ O S P L V V L HVDF UH+ V HHUJDV L G HK V K F L KZ K WL Z Q DRO HKW QR J Q L O XU \ UDL WQ HG L Y H HKW HWL SVHG Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 14 of 18 PageID #:1131 RW HV LU GOXRF WDKW VD L E H O EDUWVQRP HG GQD H WL Q L IHG WFHUL G V VHO K FXP 603- IR URY DI Q L V D L E V ¶ O HQDS HUL WQH HKW GHFQ HG L Y H I H L U% JQ LUDH+ HKW GQD UHZ VQ $ HKW QHHZWHE GRL UHS KWQRP H O S P L V HKW WDKW G Q L I RW J Q L O O L ZQ X VL WUXR& HK7 WD WN' HH6 I H L U% JQ L UDH+ UHK KJXRUKW VWQ H P XJUD O DJH O V¶603- RW GQRSVHU RW H O E D VD Z HKV WDKW VWL P G D I O HVUH K P XDEVR1 GHHFFXV WRQ QDF WQ H P XJUD UHK GQ D VD L E IR HF QDUDHSSD HKW Q HYH ZRKV RW GH O L D I V DK P XDEVR1 V D L E I R HFQ HG L Y H GHJH O O D \ O QR UHK V L UHZVQD V¶603- RW HVQRSVHU D H O L I RW HY DHO URI QRLWRP UHK QR J Q L O XU HVUHYGD HKW H VXDFH% UL & KW VHKJX+ Y SUR& WPJ0 VYUH6 KWODH+ GURFFD G ) LXRU]$ WD [ ¶SS$ ) UXWD FDY URI GQXRUJ G L O DY D WRQ VL J Q L O XU HVUHY GD QD PRUI GHUUH I Q L H O S P D[H URI V D L E IR HF QDUDHSSD HUHP HKW VGURZ UHKWR Q, R& QLDU* DZR, Y UHWUD+ UL & KW ± G ) FQ, V¶\FD0 Y QUX+ D & 6 8 JQ L WLF UL & KW [ ¶SS$ ) WQ HG L YHµ HWXWLWVQRF RW WQ H L F L I I XV ¶ VD L E HVUHY GD Q D ³ JQ L KW HQR UR) WX% ± WD WN' HO EDUWV Q RP HG GQD HWL Q L IHG WFHUL Gµ WRQ V L ´¶ \ WL O DLWUDS HQ RO D JQ L O XU V D L E JQ L ZRK V IR Q HGUXE K J L K UHK WHHP RW O L DI VWQ HP XJUD V ¶ P XDEVR1 GHWD FDY HE WVXP GUDZD HKW WDKW K FXV 60 3- IR URY D I Q L O H QDS HKW IR WUDS HKW QR ´ \ WL O DLWUDS WQ HG L Y H³ GHWXWLWVQRF HURI HUHKW GQD²UHWD O UD H\ D \ O UDHQ GH O L I ² I H L UE QRLWDUWL EUD UHK Q L VWQ HP XJUD HVQRSVHU UHK WXS RW UHK GHUL XTHU UH ZVQ $ V¶ 603- Q L GHQ L DWQRF VWQ H P XJUD O DJH O HKW RW GQRSVHU RW H Y DHO URI QRLWRP UHK I R O D L Q HG V ¶ O HQDS HKW WDKW VHXJUD P XDEVR1 GQRFH6 JQLOX5 HVUHYG$ KJXRUK7 \WLODLWUD3 WQHGLY( GQXRUJ VL KW QR GUDZ$ HKW HWDFDY WRQ O O LZ WUXR& HKW GQD D Q L GH E L UFVHG VD ´ \ VUHYRUWQRF HKW RW O DLUHWD P GQD WQ HQ LWUHS H FQ HG L YH UDHK RW @H>VXI HU³ WRQ GLG VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW VHWDUWVQ RP HG \ O SP D GURFHU HKW VXK7 VD \ WL O L E DWL XV Q X O O DUHYR I R PLDOF V ¶ P XDEVR1 QR GQD WL GHUF GQ D H FQ HG L YH WQ DF L I L Q J L V G H Y L HFHU O O L WV \ HKW WL GHUF IR H Q L O IR HQLO HKW HYRE D GH O LDWHG JQ LGUDJHU WQ HP XJUD NQ D% V ¶ P XDE VR1 IR HFQ H GL Y H IR Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 15 of 18 PageID #:1132 ± WD WN' HH6 ODLWUDS WR Q H UHZ VURWDUWLEUD H KW WDKW WQ H P XJUD VWL I R Q RLWURS D G H P URI VL KW Q H K Z \OUDOXFLWUDS H J QDK F H KW J Q L WKJ L O K J LK WXR K WL Z RV G LG 603- \ K Z VQ RL WVHXT WUXR& H KW GQD URUUH UH K WR UR QR LWSLUFVQDUW D VD HNUX% U0 RW VWQ H P HWDWV V¶UDJ Q 8 U0 HWXELUWWD QDF WL H UH K Z Q R LWL VR S H KW Q L WR Q VL WUXR & H KW Q R LWDQDOS[H UH KWUXI \ QD WXR K WL: O H VQ XRF V ¶PXDEVR 1 HNUX% U0 RW VWQ H P HWDWV V¶UDJ Q8 U0 VHWXELUWWD WL WXE WSLUFVQDUW J Q LUDH K H KW I R QR LWUR S H PDV H KW VWSUH F[H 603- Q R L WLWHS VVRUF VWL Q, 603- VWQ H VHUSHU UDJ Q8 U0 \OEDWR1 ± WD $ [( WN' \DN2 5$*18 50 VWVLO VV H QWL Z H KW GQD I HLUE IL ZRQN W¶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´ JQ L UD HK HKW WD GHWQ HVHUS HFQ H G L YH GQ D \ Q RP LWVHW V J Q L GDHO S H KW JQ L UHG L VQRF UHWI @D>³ GHUHGQ HU VDZ Q RL V L FHG UL HKW WDKW GQ D ´V HLWUDS H KW \ E GH O L I V O DLUHWD P UHKWR G Q D VJ Q L GDH O S HKW GDHU K FDH HY DK \ HKW WDKW HJG HO ZRQNFD VURWDUWL EU$ HK@W>³ WDKW WQ H P HJGH O ZRQNFD WL F L O S[ H Q D VQ LDWQRF GUD Z$ HKW \UDUWQRF HKW R7 GURFHU HKW \ E GHWURSSXV WRQ VL WQ H P XJUD VL KW WX% WD WN' ´ O HQ DS HKW \ E GHUHG L VQRF UR GDHU UHY HQ VDZ WL WDKW QRL WSP XVHUS HKW J Q L V L DU³ I HL U% JQ L UDH+ UHK IR QRL WQ HP GHWWL PR GQD VQ RL V V L P E XV ¶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²GUDZ$ HKW JQ L WDFDY I R O HY HO HKW Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 16 of 18 PageID #:1133 P L DO F HKW \ O O DF L I LFHS6 H O X5 $ 51,) Q L GHWDUH P XQH VGUDGQDWV HURP UR HQR QR GHV DE V L HY L WFHUL G WQ H P HJQ XS[H HKW WDKW J Q L G Q L I HY L WD P U L I I D Q D V HGX O FQ L WL QRL WL GGD Q, \ UWVXGQ, URI HUXGHFRU3 QRLWDUWL E U$ IR HGR& UR VHWXSV L ' VHWXSVL ' UHPRWVX& URI HUXGHFRU3 QRLWDUWL E U$ IR HGR& V ¶$ 51,) KWL Z HFQ D L O SPRF VWF H O IHU GUDZD QRLWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW VHWRQ $ 51,) ³ WDKW VHWDWV UHY L DZ HK7 WD WN' H O X5 $ 51,) KWL Z HFQDGURFFD Q L QRL WDJ L WL O WQDWV Q L HKW RW \WUDS D GH P D Q J Q L HE VWL IR $ 5 1,) \ E UH Y L DZ HWL VL XTHU HKW GH GL YRUS VDK 603- VGURFHU QRLWDUWV L JHU '5& V¶ G O H L 1 IR WQ H P H JQ XS[ H HKW IR H XVV L HKW RW WFH SVHU K WL : I R V PUHW Q L VHJ Q H O O D K F \ QD KWLZ WUXR& HKW WQHVHUS WRQ VHRG GUDZ$ HK7 WL J Q L GQ HK HUSPRF \ D0 QR \ UWQH VWL IR UDH \ HQR Q L KWLZ GUDZ$ HKW IR QR L WD P UL I QRF WKJXRV VDK 603- QRLWFD WQHVHUS HKW Q, UL & KW ± G ) VFRVV$ HFQDLOO$ OD\R5 Y R& VQ, HIL/ 6', ´ GUDZD HKW P U L IQRF WVXP @HKV> V L QRLWXORVHU WDKW WDKZ WXR HUXJ L I Q DF GQD HWXSV L G HUL WQH HKW GHY ORVHU VURWDUWL EUD HKW WDKW GH L I V L WDV V L HJGXM WFL UWVL G HKW I@,>³ & 6 8 HH6 & 6 8 UR & 6 8 UHGQX G H L I L GRP UR GHWDFDY Q HHE VDK GUDZD HKW V VHO QX RV RG WVXP WUXRF HKW GQD GH L I LFHSV RV WUXRF HKW Q L WL P U L IQRF RW NHHV \ D P \ WUDS D GUDZD Q D IR \UWQH HKW IR UDH \ D Q L KWL : GUDZ$ HKW IR QRL WD P U L I QRF VNHHV 603- GUDZ$ QRLWDUWLEU$ HKW PULIQR& RW QRLWLWH3 VVRU& V¶630- % R& UL & KW ± G ) VQ, \EUHKWDH/ Y VQ, WLUH0 JQ LWRXT ´¶V DL E IR HY L WVHJJXV \ O O XIUHZRSµ HUD WDKW VHF QDWV P XFUL F UR ¶ VD L E O DXWFDµ ³ VD GH Q L I HG V L ´QRLWSXUURF UR \WL O DLWUDS WQ HG L Y H³ HVXDF HE \ WUDS J Q L O L DYHUS GUDZRW ´ \ WL O DLWUDS³ RW GHWQXRPD VURUUH ¶VURWDUWL EUD IR QRL WFH O ORF WDKW WQ HP XJUD JQ L WFHMHU O O, ' 1 QRVNFLU( Y FQ, RFKVD/ J H HH6 SSX6 ) J Q L UDHK \ DG WK JL H HKW J Q L UXG GQD HURI HE GHUHG L VQRF WQ H P XJUD GQ D HFQ HG L YH HKW I R O O D IR WK J L O Q L \ O UD O XFLWUDS GUDZ$ HKW JQ LWD FDY Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 17 of 18 PageID #:1134 \ O X- HWD' HJGX- WF LUWV L' VHWDW6 GHWL Q8 O O DGQ H. 0 D L Q L JUL9 QR+ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB HVDF HKW HVRO F GQD WQ H P JGX M O D Q L I UHWQ H O O LZ WUXR& HK7 G O HL1 ' UHKSRWV L UK& UHNRUE URI R1 QRL WDUWL EU$ $51,) RW GHWDO HU QRL WD P URI Q L HKW HJQXS[H RW P HWV \ V \URWL VRSH' QRLWDUWV L JH5 ODUWQH& HKW VUHGUR HO X5 $51,) RW WQDXVUXS GQD 603- IR URY DI Q L WQ H P JGX M O D Q L I D RWQ L GUDZ$ HKW VWUHYQRF HURI HUHKW WUXR& HK7 GH L Q HG VL WN' HWDFDY RW Q RL WLWHS V ¶ P XDEVR1 \ WHUL WQ H VWL Q L GUDZ$ HKW V P UL I QRF GQD WN' QRL WLWHS VVRUF V ¶603- VWQDUJ WUXR& HKW HYRE D GH Q L D O S[ H VQRVDHU HKW UR) 12,68/&12& O O X I Q L GH P UL I QRF V L GUDZ$ HKW K FXV V$ $ E HO X5 $ 51,) RVOD HHV G, ´ VXRHQRUUH \ O UD HOF UR H O E L VVRS P L \ O O DXWF DI VL QRL WDP URI Q L UR QRL WDJH O O D Case: 1:17-cv-06202 Document #: 36 Filed: 07/30/18 Page 18 of 18 PageID #:1135
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
