Van et al v. Ford Motor Company, No. 1:2014cv08708 - Document 418 (N.D. Ill. 2019)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER Signed by the Honorable Robert M. Dow, Jr on 8/22/2019: For the the foregoing reasons, the Court denies Plaintiffs' motion for class certification 318 . The The Court grants Defendant's motion to exclude the te stimony, reports, and opinions of Dr. Louise Fitzgerald 352 , and grants in part and denies in part Plaintiff's motion to bar the testimony and expert reports of Dr. Liza Gold and Dr. Gregory Mitchell, PhD. 370 . This case is set for further status hearing on September 12, 2019 at 10:30 a.m. Mailed notice (mw,)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Van et al v. Ford Motor Company Doc. 418 KP"VJG"WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" HQT"VJG"PQTVJGTP"FKUVTKEV"QH"KNNKPQKU" GCUVGTP"FKXKUKQP" " +" " EJTKUVKG"XCP."gv"cn0." +" " " Rnckpvkhhu." +" " " +" Ecug"Pq0"36/ex/:92:" x0" +" " " +" Lwfig"Tqdgtv"O0"Fqy."Lt0" HQTF"OQVQT"EQORCP[." " +" " +" Fghgpfcpv0" +" +" " " OGOQTCPFWO"QRKPKQP"CPF"QTFGT" Dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv"ctg"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"]53:_."FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq" gzenwfg"vjg"vguvkoqp{."tgrqtvu."cpf"qrkpkqpu"qh"Ft0"Nqwkug"Hkv|igtcnf"]574_."cpf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp" vq"dct"vjg"vguvkoqp{"cpf"gzrgtv"tgrqtvu"qh"Ft0"Nk|c"Iqnf."O0F0"cpf"Ft0"Itgiqt{"Okvejgnn."RjF0" ]592_0" " Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy."vjg"Eqwtv"fgpkgu"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp" ]53:_0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"itcpvu"kp"rctv"cpf"fgpkgu"kp"rctv"FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq"gzenwfg"vjg"vguvkoqp{." tgrqtvu." cpf" qrkpkqpu" qh" Ft0" Nqwkug" Hkv|igtcnf" ]574_." cpf" itcpvu" kp" rctv" cpf" fgpkgu" kp" rctv" RnckpvkhhuÓ" oqvkqp" vq" dct" vjg" vguvkoqp{" cpf" gzrgtv" tgrqtv" qh" Ft0" Nk|c" Iqnf" cpf" Ft0" Itgiqt{" Okvejgnn." RjF0" ]592_0" " Vjku" ecug" ku" ugv" hqt" hwtvjgt" uvcvwu" jgctkpi" qp" Ugrvgodgt" 34." 423;" cv" 32<52"c0o0" " " K0" Dcemitqwpf" " Rnckpvkhhu"ctg"yqogp"yjq"ewttgpvn{"ctg"gornq{gf"qt"yjq"ygtg"gornq{gf"cv"qpg"qh"vjg"vyq" Ejkeciq/ctgc" Hqtf" Oqvqt" Eqorcp{" hceknkvkgu" *vjg" ÐRncpvuÑ+Ïvjg" Ejkeciq" Cuugodn{" Rncpv" *ÐCuugodn{" RncpvÑ+" cpf" vjg" Ejkeciq" Uvcorkpi" Rncpv" *ÐUvcorkpi" RncpvÑ+0" " Rnckpvkhhu" uggm" vq" tgrtgugpv"c"encuu"qh"cnn"rtgugpv"cpf"hqtogt"hgocng"gornq{ggu"yjq"yqtmgf"cv"vjg"Cuugodn{"Rncpv"qt" vjg"Uvcorkpi"Rncpv"dgvyggp"Hgdtwct{"36."4234"cpf"rtgugpv0" " Vjg"gxkfgpeg"dghqtg"vjg"EqwtvÏkh" Dockets.Justia.com etgfkvgf" cv" vtkcnÏkpfkecvgu" vjcv" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" qvjgt" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" jcxg" dggp" uwdlgevgf" vq" c" rgtxcukxgn{" ugzwcn." jquvkng." kpvkokfcvkpi" cpf" cdwukxg" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" cv" FghgpfcpvÓu"Rncpvu0" " Hgocng"gornq{ggu"cv"vjg"Rncpvu"jcxg"dggp"hqtegf"vq"yqtm"kp"cp"gpxktqpogpv" eqpvckpkpi"ugzwcnn{"gzrnkekv"itchhkvk."ectxkpiu."cpf"ftcykpiu0" " ]545."cv"550_" " Rqtpqitcrjke"kocigu" jcxg"dggp"fkurnc{gf"kp"nqemgtu"cpf"eqooqp"ctgcu"qh"vjg"Rncpvu0" " ]Id0"cv"52/550_" " Uwrgtxkuqtu"cpf" vgco"ngcfgtu"xkgy"rqtpqitcrj{"cv"vjgkt"eqorwvgtu0" " ]Id0"cv"530_" " Rqtpqitcrjke"cpf"ugzwcn"kocigu" cpf"xkfgqu"ctg"ujqyp"vq"yqogp"qt"ctg"rcuugf"coqpi"ocng"gornq{ggu"*dqvj"jqwtn{"cpf"ucnctkgf+"kp" vjg" rtgugpeg" qh" yqogp0" " ]Id0_" " Ocng" gornq{ggu" jcxg" vcmgp" rkevwtgu" qh" vjgkt" igpkvcnkc" qp" vjgkt" oqdkng"rjqpgu"cpf"ujqyp"vjg"rkevwtgu"vq"hgocng"gornq{ggu0" " ]Id0_" " Ocng"gornq{ggu"cnuq"jcxg" vgzvgf"qhhgpukxg."itcrjke"cpf1qt"ugzwcnn{"gzrnkekv"tgswguvu"vq"hgocng"gornq{ggu0" " ]Id0_" Kp"cffkvkqp"vq"vjgug"gitgikqwu"cnngicvkqpu."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"rtgugpvgf"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"egtvckp" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" jcxg" dggp" uwdlgevgf" vq" wpygneqog" rj{ukecn" eqpvcev." kpenwfkpi" tcrg0" " Pcogf" Rnckpvkhh" Lgcpgvvg" Ictfgpgt" rtqxkfgf" vjg" hqnnqykpi" ceeqwpv" qh" cp" kpvgtcevkqp"ykvj"uwrgtkpvgpfgpv"O{tqp"Cngzcpfgt"kp"cp"GGQE"ejctig"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp<" Jg"rj{ukecnn{"dgpv"og"fqyp"ykvj"o{"ejguv"cickpuv"c"fgum0" " Jg"itcddgf"o{"pgem" ykvj"jku"qvjgt"jcpf"cpf"hkton{"jgnf"og"fqyp0" " Jg"rwujgf"jkougnh"wr"cickpuv"o{" dcemukfg0" " K" hgnv" nkmg" K" ycu" dgkpi" ugzwcnn{" cuucwnvgf" cpf" vjcv" K" ycu" cdqwv" vq" dg" tcrgf0" " K"etkgf."dwv"O{tqp"lwuv"yjkurgtgf"kp"o{"gct"Ðvt{"cpf"uc{"uqogvjkpi"gnug0Ñ" " K"ycu"uectgf"cpf"hgnv"rqygtnguu0" ]546/382"*Rnu0Óu"Gz0"382+."cv"70_" " Cpqvjgt"pcogf"Rnckpvkhh."Ncvtkekc"Ujcpmnkp."vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"ycu" kp" vjg" qhhkeg" qh" vjcv" ucog" uwrgtkpvgpfgpv" yjgp" jg" nqemgf" vjg" fqqt" cpf" dgicp" kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{" vqwejkpi" jgt0" " ]547/45" *Ujcpmnkp" Fgr0" Vt0+." cv" 54/550_" " Chvgt" Ou0" Ujcpmnkp" tglgevgf" Ot0" CngzcpfgtÓu"cvvgorv"vq"wp|kr"jgt"rcpvu."jg"vjgp"itcddgf"jgt"jcpf"cpf"hqtegf"kv"qp"jku"rgpku0" " ]Id0" cv" 550_" " Ceeqtfkpi" vq" Ou0"Ujcpmnkp." Ot0" Cngzcpfgt" yqwnf" pqv" ngv" jgt" ngcxg" jku" qhhkeg" wpvkn" Ou0"Ujcpmnkp"rgthqtogf"c"ugz"cev"qp"jko0" " ]Id0_" " Ou0"Ujcpmnkp"cnuq"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"ujg"ycu"tcrgf"d{" 4" Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"Ocpcigt"Vgttgpeg"OeEnckp"yjq"cnngigfn{"hqtegf"jkougnh"qp"Ou0"Ujcpmnkp"chvgt" jg"iqv"Ou0"UjcpmnkpÓu"fcwijvgt"jgt"lqd"dcem"chvgt"ujg"ycu"vgtokpcvgf0" " ]Id0"cv"63/660_" " Vjgug"ctg" lwuv"c"hgy"gzcorngu"qh"vjg"ocp{"kpuvcpegu"qh"okueqpfwev"cnngigf"d{"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"jcxg"kfgpvkhkgf"pwogtqwu"gzcorngu"qh"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"encko"vq" jcxg"dggp"uwdlgevgf"vq"ukoknct"eqpfwev0" " Hqt"gzcorng."c"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"yjq"uwdokvvgf"c" encko"cu"rctv"qh"vjg"GGQE"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"*fkuewuugf"dgnqy+"kpfkecvgf"qp"jgt"encko"hqto"vjcv" ujg"ycu"jctcuugf"cpf"cuucwnvgf"d{"pwogtqwu"gornq{ggu."kpenwfkpi"c"ocpcigt0" " ]629/37"*Fgh0Óu" Gz0":+0_" " Vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"cp"ctgc"ocpcigt"vjtgcvgpgf"jgt."jkv"jgt."ejqmgf" jgt." cpf" hqtegf" jgt" kpvq" c" ugzwcn" tgncvkqpujkr0" " ]Id0" cv" 70_" " Ujg" cnuq" kpfkecvgu" vjcv" ujg" ycu" kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"vqwejgf"yjkng"qp"FghgpfcpvÓu"rtgokugu"cv"ngcuv"yggmn{"htqo"4237"vq"gctn{"42390" " ]Id0" cv" 80_" " Vjg" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgt" iqgu" qp" vq" cnngig" cffkvkqpcn" jctcuuogpv" d{" pwogtqwu" gornq{ggu"qh"Fghgpfcpv0" " " Cu"pqvgf"d{"Fghgpfcpv."vjg"cnngicvkqpu"qh"okueqpfwev"ctg"pqv"nkokvgf"vq"ocng"gornq{ggu0" " Rnckpvkhh" Ejtkuvkg" Xcp" ceewugu" jgt" vjgp/uwrgtxkuqt" cpf" eq/Rnckpvkhh" Egrjcpk" Oknngt" qh" ocmkpi" kpcrrtqrtkcvg"eqoogpvu0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Ou0"Xcp"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"Ou0"Oknngt"tgvcnkcvgf"cickpuv"jgt"cpf" cumgf"Ou0"Xcp"yjgvjgt"ujg"vjqwijv"gxgt{qpg"ycu"ugzwcnn{"jctcuukpi"jgt"dgecwug"ujgÓu"uq"ugz{0" " ]57:/35"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"76"Î"Xcp"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"368/690_" " Ou0"Xcp."kp"vwtp."ycu"ceewugf"qh"gpicikpi"kp" okueqpfwev"d{"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"Ujcpgvvc"O{ngu0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Ou0"O{ngu"kpfkecvgf"kp"cp" kpvgtxkgy"vjcv"Ou0"Xcp"eqoogpvgf"qp"Ou0"O{nguÓu"ygkijv"cpf"dqf{"rctvu0" " ]57:/38"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0" 328+." cv" 340_" " Ceeqtfkpi" vq" Ou0" O{ngu." Ou0" Xcp" cnuq" uvcvgf" Ðikxg" og" uqog" qh" vjqug" ]vkvvkgu_0Ñ" " ]Id0_" " Ukoknctn{." c" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgt" Tqugvvc" Uokvj" uwdokvvgf" cp" chhkfcxkv" kpfkecvkpi" vjcv" Octkc"Rtkeg"qrgpn{"fkuewuugf"jgt"ugzwcn"rtghgtgpegu"kp"vjg"yqtmrnceg0" " ]57:/33"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"52"Î" Uokvj"Fgen0+."cv"323." "430_" " Ou0"Rtkeg"cnuq"yqwnf"itggv"ocng"gornq{ggu"ykvj"c"jwi"cpf"qhvgp" 5" yqwnf" dnqy" mkuugu" cv" vjgo0" " ]Id0" cv" 324." " 440_" " Ou0" Rtkeg" vguvkhkgf" vjcv" Ectogn" Itgiqt{" Ðycu" kpvgtguvgf"kp"c"tqocpvke"tgncvkqpujkrÑ"ykvj"Ou0"Rtkeg"cpf"Ðyqwnf"eqpuvcpvn{"ecnn"]Ou0"Rtkeg_"vq"vjg" qhhkeg"wruvcktu"cpf"vgnn"]jgt_"jqy"rtgvv{"]ujg_"ycu"cpf"uvqr"ikxkpi"]Ou0"Itgiqt{_"vjg"]dcd{"fqnn_" g{gu"cpf"lwuv"vq"igv"vq"mpqy"jgt0Ñ" " ]57:/35"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"72"Î"Rtkeg"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"3480_" " Kpfggf."kp" Ou0"RtkegÓu"GGQE"Ejctig."Ou0"Rtkeg"nkuvgf"Ou0"Itgiqt{"cu"qpg"qh"jgt"ugzwcn"jctcuugtu0" " ]4;/43."cv" 40_" " Rnckpvkhh"Jgngp"Cnngp/Coqu"ceewugf"Oqpkswg"Lqjpuqp"qh"cevkpi"kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"d{"Ðcnyc{u" itcddkpi" qp" ogp." ukvvkpi" qp" vjgkt" ncru.Ñ" cpf" uswgg|kpi" vjgkt" dwvvu" yjgp" ujg" jwiigf" vjg" ogp0" " ]57:/35"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"58+."cv":0_" " FghgpfcpvÓu"tgurqpug"dtkgh"qwvnkpgu"pwogtqwu"qvjgt"gzcorngu"qh" cnngicvkqpu"qh"okueqpfwev"cickpuv"yqogp"yqtmkpi"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " " Cnvjqwij"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"qh"okueqpfwev"cickpuv"Fghgpfcpv"ctg"cdwpfcpv."vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu" eqpvckpu" cv" ngcuv" c" fq|gp" yqogp" yjq" uygct" vjg{" Ðuwhhgtgf" pq" kplwt{Ñ" dgecwug" vjg{" pgxgt" gzrgtkgpegf" ugzwcnn{" jctcuukpi" eqpfwev0" " ]57:/33" *Fgh0Óu" Gzu0" ;/42+0_" " [gv" cpqvjgt" fq|gp" yqogp"cvvguv"vjcv"vjg{"oc{"jcxg"gzrgtkgpegf"cp"kuqncvgf"kpuvcpeg"qh"kpcrrtqrtkcvg"eqpfwev."dwv" gkvjgt"ygtg"pqv"dqvjgtgf"d{"vjg"eqpfwev="jcpfngf"kv"vjgougnxgu"kp"c"ucvkuhcevqt{"ocppgt"*e.g.."d{" vgnnkpi" vjg" qhhgpfgt" vq" uvqr+=" qt" hqwpf" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgurqpug" vq" vjg" tgrqtvgf" okueqpfwev" vq" dg" crrtqrtkcvg0" " ]57:/33"*Fgh0Óu"Gzu0"43/54+0_" " " Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"ycu"cyctg"vjcv"yqogp"cv"vjg"Rncpvu"ygtg"dgkpi"uwdlgevgf" vq"rgtxcukxg"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cpf"ugz"fkuetkokpcvkqp"hqt"cv"ngcuv"vyq"{gctu"dghqtg"Rnckpvkhhu"hkngf" vjku"ncyuwkv"kp"4236"dwv"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"hckngf"uwhhkekgpvn{"vq"tgogf{"vjg"kuuwg0" " Rnckpvkhhu"kfgpvkh{"c" pwodgt" qh" rwtrqtvgf" fghkekgpekgu" ykvj" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgurqpug" vq" mpqyp" eqornckpvu" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0" " Rnckpvkhhu" kfgpvkh{" eqornckpvu" vjcv" ygtg" ocfg" vq" Fghgpfcpv" dwv" vjcv" ygtg" pgxgt" fqewogpvgf" kp" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgeqtfu0" " ]545." cv" 62/640_" " Rnckpvkhhu" cnuq" eqpvgpf" vjcv" Fghgpfcpv" hckngf"uwhhkekgpvn{"vq"fkuekrnkpg"vjqug"yjq"ygtg"vjg"uwdlgev"qh"eqornckpvu0" " Hqt"gzcorng."Rnckpvkhhu" 6" kfgpvkh{"qpg"ytqpifqgt"yjq"vykeg"dkv"yqogp"qp"vjg"dwvvqemu."dwv"yjq"ycu"pqv"rwpkujgf"hqt"vjg" hktuv"kpuvcpeg"cpf"ycu"qpn{"ikxgp"Ðeqcejkpi"cpf"eqwpugnkpiÑ"hqt"vjg"ugeqpf"kpuvcpeg0" " ]Id0"cv"570_" " Vq" vcmg" cpqvjgt" gzcorng." Rnckpvkhhu" pqvg" vjcv" kv" vqqm" Fghgpfcpv" pgctn{" c" {gct" vq" fkuekrnkpg" cp" gornq{gg" hqt" ocmkpi" kortqrgt" eqoogpvu" vq" pwogtqwu" yqogp" kp" xkqncvkqp" qh" FghgpfcpvÓu" cpvk/jctcuuogpv"rqnkekgu0" " ]Id0"cv"650_" " Rnckpvkhhu"qwvnkpg"cffkvkqpcn"gzcorngu"qh"mpqyp"jctcuugtu" yjq"Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf"Fghgpfcpv"hckngf"vq"fkuekrnkpg"kp"c"vkogn{"cpf1qt"crrtqrtkcvg"ocppgt0" " ]Id0" cv"65/680_" Rnckpvkhhu" cnuq" eqpvgpf" vjcv" FghgpfcpvÓu" ocpcigogpv" cpf" jwocp" tguqwtegu" fgrctvogpvu" fkueqwtcigf"eqornckpvu."kpenwfkpi"eqornckpvu"vq"FghgpfcpvÓu"jctcuuogpv"jqvnkpgu0" " Hqt"gzcorng." pcogf" Rnckpvkhh" Ou0" Xcp" vguvkhkgf" vjcv" Jwocp" Tguqwtegu" uwrgtxkuqt" Ot0" OeEnckp" vjtgcvgpgf" Ou0"Xcp"hqt"ecnnkpi"vjg"jqvnkpg0" " ]547/4;"*Xcp"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"5;0_" " D{"yc{"qh"cpqvjgt"gzcorng." wpkqp"ejcktocp"Itcpv"Oqtvqp"vguvkhkgf"vjcvÏqp"ownvkrng"qeecukqpu"kp"qt"cdqwv"4234"cpf"gctn{" 4235Ïjg"ycu"vqnf"d{"ncdqt"tgncvkqpu"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"Pcvcnkg"Fcjtkpigt"vjcv"yqogp"pggfgf"vq"ftqr" eqornckpvu"dghqtg"ceeqooqfcvkqpu"yqwnf"dg"crrtqxgf"vq"tgcuukip"c"yqocp"vq"c"fkhhgtgpv"lqd"qt" fgrctvogpv" qt" ujkhv0" " ]547/68" *Oqtvqp" Fgr0" Vt0+." cv" 38/390_" " Ot0" Oqtvqp" vguvkhkgf" vjcv" vjku" jcrrgpgf"ykvj"eqornckpvu"ocfg"d{"pcogf"Rnckpvkhh"Ou0"Xcp0" " ]Id0_" " " Cnvjqwij"Ou0"Fcjtkpigt" fgpkgu"vjku."vjgtg"ku"eqphnkevkpi"vguvkoqp{"qp"vjg"kuuwg0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"hwtvjgt"eqpvgpf"vjcv"ugxgtcn"yqogp"jcxg"dggp"tgvcnkcvgf"cickpuv"d{"eq/yqtmgtu" cpf"uwrgtxkuqtu"hqt"eqornckpkpi"cdqwv"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv."cu"ygnn"cu"tglgevkpi"ugzwcn"cfxcpegu"qh" ocng" uwrgtxkuqtu0" " ]545." 6:/6;0_" " Hqt" gzcorng." yjgp" pcogf" Rnckpvkhh" Octkc" Rtkeg" eqornckpgf" cdqwv"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"vq"Eqd{"Oknngpfgt."jg"vqnf"jgt"vq"Ðdtkpi"]jgt_"rtgvv{"nkruÑ"vq"jku"qhhkeg"vq" fkuewuu" jgt"eqornckpv" cpf" vjtgcvgpgf" vjcv" jg" yqwnf" rwv" jgt" qp" c" yqtug" ujkhv" kh" ujg" fkf" pqv" iq0" " ]547/44"*Rtkeg"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"350_" 7" Vjku"cnngigf"okueqpfwev"qeewttgf"cv"FghgpfcpvÓu"Ejkeciq"Cuugodn{"Rncpv"cpf"Uvcorkpi" Rncpv." dqvj" qh" yjkej" ctg" ocuukxg" kp" uk|g0" " Vjg" Cuugodn{" Rncpv" jcu" hqwt" uvcpfcnqpg" dwknfkpiu" vqvcnkpi"oqtg"vjcp"4.:35.482"uswctg"hggv"qp"335"cetgu0" " ]57:."cv"38/39="ugg"cnuq"Hqtf"Oqvqt"Eq0." Rncpv" FgvcknÏEjkeciq" Cuugodn{" Rncpv." cxckncdng" cv" jvvru<11eqtrqtcvg0hqtf0eqo1eqorcp{1rncpv/fgvckn/rcigu1ejkeciq/cuugodn{/rncpv0jvon" *ncuv" xkukvgf" Cwiwuv"43."423;+0_" " C"ukping"xgjkeng"vtcxgnu"tqwijn{"807"okngu"htqo"vjg"uvctv"qh"vjg"rtqfwevkqp" e{eng"vq"vjg"gpf0" " ]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"4+."cv"3:." "3:0_" " Ukpeg"4234."vjg"Cuugodn{"Rncpv"jcu"twp" vjtgg"rtqfwevkqp"ujkhvu<"vjg"C"Etgy"*fc{+."vjg"D"Etgy"*pkijv+."cpf"vjg"E"Etgy"*yggmgpf+."ykvj" oqtg"vjcp"3.222"gornq{ggu"rgt"ujkhv0" " ]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"6"Î"Mcpvcwvcu"Fgen0+."cv"65." "3;0_" " Vjg" Cuugodn{"Rnckpv"cnuq"jcu"hkxg"igpgtcn"rtqfwevkqp"ctgcuÏdqf{."rckpv."hkpcn."swcnkv{."cpf"ocvgtkcn" rncppkpi" (" nqikuvkeu" *OR(N+Ïgcej" qh" yjkej" ku" qxgtuggp" d{" kvu" qyp" ctgc" ocpcigt0" " ]57:/320" *Fgh0Óu"Gz0"5"Î"Rkrmkpu"Fgen0+."cv"43." "340_" " Ugxgtcn"qh"vjgug"ÐctgcuÑ"vjgougnxgu"jcxg"ownvkrng" fgrctvogpvuÏyjkej."kp"uqog"ecugu."ctg"kp"ugrctcvg"dwknfkpiu0"]Id0"cv"43." "360_" " " Hkhvggp"okngu"cyc{"htqo"vjg"Cuugodn{"Rncpv"ku"vjg"Uvcorkpi"RncpvÏc"407"oknnkqp"uswctg" hqqv"dwknfkpi"qp"35;"cetgu0" " ]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"7"Î"¥cdqtqyumk"Fgen0+."cv"72." "7="ugg"cnuq"Hqtf" Oqvqt" Eq0." Rncpv" FgvcknÏEjkeciq" Uvcorkpi" Rncpv." cxckncdng" cv" jvvru<11eqtrqtcvg0hqtf0eqo1eqorcp{1rncpv/fgvckn/rcigu1ejkeciq/uvcorkpi/rncpv0jvon" *ncuv" xkukvgf" Cwiwuv"43."423;+0_" " Qpg"pcogf"Rnckpvkhh"fguetkdgf"vjg"Uvcorkpi"Rncpv"cu"c"Ðokpk"ekv{0Ñ" " ]57:/35" *Gz0" 64" Î" Gzwo" Fgr0" Vt0+." cv" 9:/9;0_" " Ukpeg" Oc{" 4234." vjg" Uvcorkpi" Rncpv" jcu" jcf" vjtgg" rtqfwevkqp"etgyu."gcej"ykvj"522/722"jqwtn{"gornq{ggu0" " ]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"8"Î"Vc{nqt"Fgen0+."cv" 78." "38."3;0_" " Vjg"rtqeguu"cv"vjg"Uvcorkpi"Rncpv"dgikpu"ykvj"ujggvu"qh"dncpm"uvggn."yjkej"ctg" nqcfgf"kpvq"vjg"Uvcorkpi"Rncpv"d{"gornq{ggu"qh"vjg"OR(N"fgrctvogpv0" " Htqo"vjgtg."vjg"uvggn" gpvgtu"vjg"uvcorkpi"qt"ÐrtguuÑ"ukfg"qh"vjg"rncpv"cpf"ku"vtcpurqtvgf"vq"qpg"qh"38"uvcorkpi"ocejkpgu" 8" urtgcf" qxgt" 822.222" uswctg" hggv." yjkej" ctg" ugrctcvgf" kpvq" ukz" |qpgu0" " ]57:/32" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 7" /" ¥cdqtqyumk"Fgen0+."cv"72." "90_" " Vjgug"|qpgu"ctg"qxgtuggp"d{"hqwt"hktuv/ngxgn"ucnctkgf"gornq{ggu"qt" ÐRtqeguu"Eqcejgu0Ñ" " ]Id0"cv"72." ":0_" " Htqo"vjg"rtguu"ukfg."vjg"uvggn"oqxgu"vq"vjg"cuugodn{"rqtvkqp" qh"vjg"Uvcorkpi"Rncpv."yjkej"eqxgtu"3.222.222"uswctg"hggv"cpf"kpenwfgu"67"ugrctcvg"cuugodn{"nkpgu" urtgcf" cetquu" hkxg" |qpgu0" " ]Id0" cv" 72." " ;0_" " Gcej" |qpg" ku" qxgtuggp" d{" c" Rtqeguu" Eqcej0" " ]Id0_" " Gornq{ggu"kp"vjg"cuugodn{"ukfg"qh"vjg"Uvcorkpi"Rncpv"ecppqv"ugg"vjqug"qp"vjg"rtguu"ukfg0" " ]57:/35" *Gzwo"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"9:0_" " " Dqvj"Rncpvu"ctg"uwdlgev"vq"xctkqwu"qh"FghgpfcpvÓu"cpvk/jctcuuogpv"eqtrqtcvg"fktgevkxgu"cpf" rqnke{"ngvvgtu."yjkej"ctg"korngogpvgf"d{"nqecn"Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"cpf"Ncdqt"Tgncvkqpu"rgtuqppgn0" " ]57:/32" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 3" Î" Ncxgpfgt" Fgen0+." cv" 9/:." " 4:/520_" " FghgpfcpvÓu" Cpvk/Jctcuuogpv" Fktgevkxg" ugvu" hqtvj" FghgpfcpvÓu" Ðrtqjkdkvkqp" qh" jctcuuogpv" cpf" kvu" eqookvogpv" vq" hquvgtkpi" c" tgurgevhwn." kpenwukxg" yqtm" gpxktqpogpvÑ" cv" cnn" hceknkvkgu0" " ]57:/36" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 84+." cv" 4/60_" " FghgpfcpvÓu" Cpvk/Jctcuuogpv" Rqnke{" *vjg" ÐRqnke{Ñ+" rtqxkfgu" gornq{ggu" ykvj" gzcorngu" qh" dgjcxkqt" vjcv" Fghgpfcpv" eqpukfgtu" jctcuukpi" cpf" ocmgu" engct" vjcv" cnn" gornq{ggu" ujqwnf" Ðkoogfkcvgn{"tgrqtvÑ"cp{"xkqncvkqp0" " ]57:/36"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"89+."cv"44/460_" " Gornq{ggu"ctg"vqnf"vjg{" ecp"tgrqtv"xkqncvkqpu"vq"*3+"vjgkt"uwrgtxkuqt="*4+"vjgkt"nqecn"Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"tgrtgugpvcvkxg*u+=" *5+"FghgpfcpvÓu"cpvk/jctcuuogpv"jqvnkpg="*6+"qt"Rgtuqppgn"Tgncvkqpu0" " ]Id0_" " Vjg"Rqnke{"yctpu"vjcv" xkqncvkqpu"yknn"tguwnv"kp"fkuekrnkpg."wr"vq"cpf"kpenwfkpi"vgtokpcvkqp"Ðgxgp"hqt"c"hktuv"qhhgpug0Ñ" " ]Id0_" " Vjg"Rqnke{"cnuq"gzrnckpu"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"uvtkevn{"rtqjkdkvu"Ðtgvcnkcvqt{"cevkqpuÑ"cickpuv"vjqug"yjq" ocmg" iqqf/hckvj" eqornckpvu" qh" jctcuuogpv" qt" eqqrgtcvg" kp" c" jctcuuogpv" kpxguvkicvkqp0" " ]Id0_" " Fghgpfcpv"vtckpu"cnn"pgy"jktgu"qp"kvu"cpvk/jctcuuogpv"Rqnke{"cv"qtkgpvcvkqp"]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"6"Î" Mcpvcwvcu"Fgen0+"cv"65." "39="57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"8"Î"Vc{nqt"Fgen0+."cv"78." "35_."cpf"gxgt{"pgy" gornq{gg" tgegkxgu" c" eqr{" qh" vjg" Rqnke{0" " ]Ugg." e.g.." 57:/36" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 92" Î" Dcttqp" Rqnke{" 9" Cempqyngfiogpv+." cv" 570_" " Fwtkpi" vjg" encuu" rgtkqf." Fghgpfcpv" tgrgcvgfn{" eqpfwevgf" cpvk/jctcuuogpv"cpf"fkxgtukv{"vtckpkpi"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " ]Ugg"57:/8"*Fgh0Óu"Crr0"G"Î"Rctv"3+="57:/9" *Fgh0Óu"Crr0"G"Î"Rctv"4+="57:/:"*Fgh0Óu"Crr0"G"Î"Rctv"5+0_" " Jqygxgt."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"kfgpvkhkgf" gxkfgpeg" kpfkecvkpi" vjcv" vtckpkpi" rtqitcou" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" oc{" jcxg" rtqxkfgf" eqpvtcfkevqt{" kphqtocvkqp0" " Hqt"gzcorng."Rnckpvkhhu"uwdokv"vjg"chhkfcxkv"qh"Dgtpcfgvvg"En{dwtp."yjkej"uvcvgu"vjcv" cnvjqwij"FghgpfcpvÓu"Rqnke{"ycu"qp"vjg"vcdng"kp"c"vtckpkpi"rtqitco"ujg"cvvgpfgf."Ðvjg"kpuvtwevqt" eqpvtcfkevgf" vjcv" ytkvvgp" rqnke{" cpf" hqewugf" qp" kpvkokfcvkpi" cpf" vjtgcvgpkpi" eqpugswgpegu" qh" tgrqtvkpi" yqtmrnceg" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0Ñ" " ]546/452" *Rnu0Óu" Gz0" 453" Î" En{dwtp" Fgen0+." cv" 4." "34/350_" " Kp" eqppgevkqp" ykvj" vjg" GGQE" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" fkuewuugf" dgnqy." Fghgpfcpv" cnuq"jcu"korngogpvgf"c"pgy"eqortgjgpukxg"cpvk/jctcuuogpv"vtckpkpi"rtqitco."yjkej"ku"fgnkxgtgf" cv" yqtm" d{" c" vjktf/rctv{" xgpfqt." Ug{hctvj" Ujcy0" " ]57:/32" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 3" /" Ncxgpfgt" Fgen0+." cv" 33/34." "64/670_" Cnvjqwij" Rnckpvkhhu" cuugtv" kp" c" eqpenwuqt{" hcujkqp" vjcv" Fghgpfcpv" ockpvckpgf" c" wpkhqto" Ðrqnke{" qh" fgenkpkpi" vq" hkpf" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" enckou" eqttqdqtcvgf" ykvjqwv" eqttqdqtcvkpi" ykvpguuguÑ"]545"cv"77_."FghgpfcpvÓu"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"gzrtguun{"fkuencko"vjg"gzkuvgpeg"qh"cp{"uwej" rqnke{0" " ]57:/38" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 32:" /" Ycujkpivqp" Fgen0+." cv" 47." " 8/9=" 57:/38" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 32;" /" Vc{nqt"Uwrrn0"Fgen0+."cv"4:." "80_" " FghgpfcpvÓu"cevwcn"iwkfcpeg"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"yjgp"eqphtqpvgf"ykvj" qpn{"Ðvguvkoqpkcnu"htqo"vjg"eqornckpcpv"cpf"vjg"ceewugf.Ñ"vjg"kpxguvkicvqt"ujqwnf"wug"jgt"dguv" lwfiogpv"vq"Ðeqpukfgt"vjg"etgfkdknkv{Ñ"qh"gcej="yjgvjgt"qpg"xgtukqp"qh"gxgpvu"uggou"Ðhct/hgvejgfÑ=" yjgvjgt"cp{qpg"jcf"Ðc"tgcuqp"vq"nkgÑ="yjgvjgt"qpg"rgtuqpÓu"ceeqwpv"Ðeqphnkev]u_"ykvj"cp{"qvjgt" gxkfgpegÑ="cpf"yjgvjgt"vjgtg"ku"c"Ðrcvvgtp"qh"dgjcxkqtÑ"cv"kuuwg"*e.g.."rtkqt"fkuekrnkpct{"cevkqp+0" " ]57:/36" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 8;+." cv" 540_" " Fghgpfcpv" cnuq" pqvgu" vjcv" vjgtg" jcxg" dggp" ocp{" kpuvcpegu" kp" yjkej" kpfkxkfwcnu" jcxg" dggp" fkuekrnkpgf" hqt" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" cdugpv" eqttqdqtcvkpi" ykvpguugu." :" gxgp"yjgp"vjg"ceewugf"jcu"fgpkgf"vjg"cnngigf"jctcuukpi"eqpfwev0" " ]57:."cv"55"p045"*ekvkpi"Fgh0Óu" Gz0":2+0_" " " Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcv" FghgpfcpvÓu" cvvgorvu" vq" ewtg" fgecfgu" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" jcxg" hckngf0" " Ugxgtcn" ownvk/rnckpvkhh" ncyuwkvu" jcxg" dggp" dtqwijv" cickpuv" Fghgpfcpv." kpenwfkpi"c"ncyuwkv"ecrvkqpgf"Rivera v. Ford Motor Company."Pq0";7/ex/4;;2"*ÐRiveraÑ+."cpf"c" encuu" cevkqp" ecrvkqpgf" Warnell v. Ford Motor Company." Pq0";:/ex/3725" *ÐWarnellÑ+." dqvj" qh" yjkej" ygtg" hkngf" kp" vjku" fkuvtkev0" " Kp" dqvj" ecugu." vjg" rnckpvkhhu" cnngigf" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv." ugz" fkuetkokpcvkqp."tceg"fkuetkokpcvkqp."cuucwnv."dcvvgt{"cpf"kpvgpvkqpcn"kphnkevkqp"qh"goqvkqpcn"fkuvtguu0" " Chvgt"c"encuu"ycu"egtvkhkgf"kp"Warnell."Fghgpfcpv"gpvgtgf"kpvq"c"eqpeknkcvkqp"citggogpv"ykvj"GGQE" *vjg"Ð3;;;"Eqpeknkcvkqp"CitggogpvÑ+0" " ]546/37"*Rnu0Óu"Gz0"38"Î"3;;;"Eqpeknkcvkqp"Citggogpv+0_" " Cu"kpfkecvgf"d{"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"kp"vjku"ncyuwkv."ceeqtfkpi"vq"Rnckpvkhhu."vjg"rtqdngou"jcxg"rgtukuvgf0" " " Kp"Cwiwuv"4239."Fghgpfcpv"gpvgtgf"kpvq"cpqvjgt"Eqpeknkcvkqp"Citggogpv"ykvj"vjg"GGQE" *vjg" Ð4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp" CitggogpvÑ+0" " Kp" vjg" 4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp"Citggogpv." ykvjqwv" cfokvvkpi" ytqpifqkpi." Fghgpfcpv" eqookvvgf" vq" ockpvckpkpi" tqdwuv." GGQE/crrtqxgf" cpvk/jctcuuogpv" vtckpkpi" rtqitcou" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" ]35;/3." cv" 6/7." " 33/38_." crrqkpvkpi" c" Jwocp" Tguqwtegu" rtqhguukqpcn" vq" qxgtugg" vjg" RncpvuÓ" jcpfnkpi" qh" jctcuuogpv" cpf" tgvcnkcvkqp" enckou" ]id0" cv" 8/9." "3;/44_."cpf"crrqkpvkpi"c"rcpgn"qh"kpfgrgpfgpv"oqpkvqtu"*vjg"ÐRcpgnÑ+"vq"qxgtugg"vjg"Rncpvu"hqt" cv"ngcuv"vjtgg"{gctu0" " ]Id0"cv"9/32." "47/590_" " Fghgpfcpv"cnuq"citggf"vq"guvcdnkuj"c"enckou"rtqeguu" hqt"cnn"yqogp"cpf"Chtkecp/Cogtkecpu"gornq{gf"cv"vjg"Rncpvu"htqo"Lcpwct{"3."4232"vq"Cwiwuv"3." 4239." ocmkpi" vjgug" kpfkxkfwcnu" gnkikdng" vq" tgegkxg" eqorgpucvkqp" htqo" c" hwpf" qh" wr" vq" &320347" oknnkqp"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjg{"ygtg"hqwpf"d{"vjg"Rcpgn"vq"jcxg"gzrgtkgpegf"ugz"qt"tceg"jctcuuogpv." fkuetkokpcvkqp." qt" tgvcnkcvkqp0" " ]Id0" cv" 32/33." " 5:/5;0_" " Vjg" 4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" guvcdnkujgf"vjtgg"vkgtu"qh"cyctf"coqwpvu."ykvj"cpvkekrcvgf"cyctf"vctigvu"qh"&32.222."&42.222."cpf" ;" &52.2220" " Vjg"4239"Eqpeknkcvkqp"Citggogpv"kpkvkcnn{"kfgpvkhkgf"392"kpfkxkfwcnu"*9:"ocng"cpf";4" hgocng+." vjcv" tgegkxgf" c" ugvvngogpv" qt" ygtg" fggogf" gnkikdng" hqt" cp" cyctf" ykvjqwv" pggfkpi" vq" eqorngvg"qt"uwdokv"c"encko"hqto0" " ]629."cv"50_" " Cp"cffkvkqpcn"958"yqogp"uwdokvvgf"enckou"hqtou0" " ]557/6"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"F"/"Twuv"Fgen0+."cv"5." "60_" " Cu"qh"Oc{"42."423;."778"yqogp"ygtg"qhhgtgf"cp" cyctf" kp" eqppgevkqp" ykvj" vjg" 4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" cpf" 744" qh" vjqug" yqogp" ejqug" vq" ceegrv"vjgkt"cyctfu0" " ]5;8/3"*Oknnu"Fgen0+."cv"4." "9/:0_" " Cu"qh"vjcv"fcvg."vjg"ciitgicvg"xcnwg"qh" vjg"cyctfu"ceegrvgf"d{"yqogp"ycu"&8.598.5860720" " ]Id0"cv"4." "320_" " Vjg"coqwpvu"tgeqxgtcdng"d{" vjqug"kp"gcej"vkgt."jqygxgt."ygtg"nqygt"vjcp"vjg"vctigv"coqwpvu"kfgpvkhkgf"kp"vjg"4239"Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv"dgecwug"vjg"vqvcn"coqwpv"qh"eqorgpucvkqp"cyctfgf"cpf"cuuqekcvgf"vczgu"gzeggfgf"vjg" eqpvtcevwcnn{"citggf/wrqp"vqvcn"coqwpv"qh"vjg"ugvvngogpv"hwpf"*&32047"oknnkqp+0" " ]624/3."cv";/33." "5;."69="ugg"cnuq"62;."cv"50_" " " KK0" Ngicn"Uvcpfctf" " Vq"dg"egtvkhkgf"cu"c"encuu"cevkqp."c"rtqrqugf"encuu"owuv"ucvkuh{"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh"Hgfgtcn" Twng"qh"Ekxkn"Rtqegfwtg"45*c+."cu"ygnn"cu"qpg"qh"vjg"vjtgg"cnvgtpcvkxg"tgswktgogpvu"kp"Twng"45*d+0" " Messner v. Northshore Univ. HealthSystem." 88;" H05f" :24." :33" *9vj" Ekt0" 4234+0" " Twng" 45*c+" rtqxkfgu"vjcv"c"pcogf"rctv{"oc{"uwg"qp"dgjcnh"qh"kpfkxkfwcnu"yjq"ctg"ukoknctn{"ukvwcvgf"kh<"*3+"vjg" encuu"ku"uq"pwogtqwu"vjcv"lqkpfgt"qh"cnn"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"ku"kortcevkecdng"*Ðpwogtqukv{Ñ+=" *4+"vjgtg"ctg"swguvkqpu"qh"ncy"qt"hcev"eqooqp"vq"vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"*Ðeqooqpcnkv{Ñ+="*5+"vjg"enckou" qt"fghgpugu"qh"vjg"pcogf"rctv{"ctg"v{rkecn"qh"vjg"enckou"qt"fghgpugu"qh"vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu" *Ðv{rkecnkv{Ñ+="cpf"*6+"vjg"pcogf"rctv{"yknn"hcktn{"cpf"cfgswcvgn{"rtqvgev"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"vjg"encuu" *Ðcfgswce{Ñ+0" " Hgf0" T0" Ekx0" R0" 45*c+0" " Ð]C_" rtqrqugf" encuu" owuv" cnyc{u" oggv" vjg" Twng" 45*c+" tgswktgogpvu0Ñ" " Messner." 88;" H05f" cv" :330" " ÐDgecwug" Twng" 45*c+" rtqxkfgu" c" icvg/mggrkpi" hwpevkqp"hqt"cnn"encuu"cevkqpu."qtfkpctkn{"]eqwtvu_"dgikp"vjgtg"cpf"qpn{"vwtp",",","vq"Twng"45*d+"chvgt" 32" ]vjg"eqwtv"ku_"egtvckp"vjcv"cnn"qh"Twng"45*c+Óu"tgswktgogpvu"jcf"dggp"ogv0Ñ" " Bell v. PNC Bank, Nat. Ass’n.":22"H05f"582."596"*9vj"Ekt0"4237+0" Twng"45*d+"ugvu"hqtvj"hqwt"ektewouvcpegu"wpfgt"yjkej"c"encuu"cevkqp"oc{"dg"ockpvckpgf." vyq"qh"yjkej"Rnckpvkhhu"tgn{"qp"jgtg<" " Twng"45*d+*4+"cpf"Twng"45*d+*5+0" " Twng"45*d+*4+"rgtokvu" encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"kh"Ðvjg"rctv{"qrrqukpi"vjg"encuu"jcu"cevgf"qt"tghwugf"vq"cev"qp"itqwpfu"vjcv"crrn{" igpgtcnn{" vq" vjg" encuu." uq" vjcv" hkpcn" kplwpevkxg" tgnkgh" qt" eqttgurqpfkpi" fgenctcvqt{" tgnkgh" ku" crrtqrtkcvg" tgurgevkpi" vjg" encuu" cu" c" yjqng0Ñ" " Twng" 45*d+*5+" rgtokvu" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" kh<" *3+" swguvkqpu"qh"ncy"qt"hcev"eqooqp"vq"vjg"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"rtqrqugf"encuu"rtgfqokpcvg"qxgt"swguvkqpu" chhgevkpi"qpn{"kpfkxkfwcn"encuu"ogodgtu"*ÐrtgfqokpcpegÑ+="cpf"*4+"c"encuu"cevkqp"ku"uwrgtkqt"vq" qvjgt"cxckncdng"ogvjqfu"qh"tguqnxkpi"vjg"eqpvtqxgtu{"*Ðuwrgtkqtkv{Ñ+0" " Messner."88;"H05f"cv":330" " Oqtgqxgt." vjg" encuu" owuv" cnuq" oggv" Twng" 45Óu" Ðkornkekv" tgswktgogpv" qh" Òcuegtvckpcdknkv{.ÓÑ" ogcpkpi" vjcv" vjg" encuu" ku" Ðfghkpgf" engctn{" cpf" dcugf" qp" qdlgevkxg" etkvgtkc0Ñ" " Mullins v. Direct Digital, LLC."9;7"H05f"876."87;"*9vj"Ekt0"4237+0" Rnckpvkhhu"dgct"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rtqxkpi"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Oshana v. Coca-Cola Co.."694"H05f"728."735"*9vj"Ekt0"4228+0" " Cnvjqwij"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"rtqeggfkpiu"ctg" pqv" Ðc" ftguu" tgjgctucn" hqt" vjg" vtkcn" qp" vjg" ogtkvu.Ñ" Messner." 88;" H05f" cv" :33." hqt" rwtrqugu" qh" fgekfkpi"vjg"egtvkhkecvkqp"swguvkqp."vjg"Eqwtv"fqgu"pqv"rtguwog"vjcv"cnn"ygnn/rngcfgf"cnngicvkqpu"ctg" vtwg0" " Ugg"Szabo v. Bridgeport Machs., Inc.."46;"H05f"894."898/99"*9vj"Ekt0"4223+0" " Tcvjgt."dghqtg" kv"cnnqyu"c"ecug"vq"rtqeggf"cu"c"encuu"cevkqp."vjg"Eqwtv"Ðujqwnf"ocmg"yjcvgxgt"hcevwcn"cpf"ngicn" kpswktkgu" ctg" pgeguuct{" wpfgt" Twng" 450Ñ" " Id0" cv" 8980" " ÐC" rctv{" uggmkpi" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" owuv" chhktocvkxgn{"fgoqpuvtcvg"jku"eqornkcpeg"ykvj"vjg"TwngÏvjcv"ku."jg"owuv"dg"rtgrctgf"vq"rtqxg"vjcv" vjgtg"ctg"in fact"uwhhkekgpvn{"pwogtqwu"rctvkgu."eqooqp"swguvkqpu"qh"ncy"qt"hcev."gve0Ñ" " Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes."786"W0U0"55:."572"*4233+0" " Dwv"vjg"ujqykpi"pggf"pqv"dg"Ðvq"c"fgitgg"qh" 33" cduqnwvg" egtvckpv{0" " Kv" ku" uwhhkekgpv" kh" gcej" fkurwvgf" tgswktgogpv" jcu" dggp" rtqxgp" d{" c" rtgrqpfgtcpeg"qh"gxkfgpeg0Ñ" " Messner."88;"H05f"cv":33"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"gzgtekugu" dtqcf"fkuetgvkqp"kp"fgvgtokpkpi"yjgvjgt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"ku"crrtqrtkcvg"ikxgp"vjg"rctvkewnct"hcevu" qh"vjg"ecug0" " Keele v. Wexler."36;"H05f"7:;."7;4"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;:+0" KKK0" Cpcn{uku" Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" oqxgf" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" qp" vjgkt" Vkvng" XKK" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" cpf" jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Rnckpvkhhu"rtqrqug"vjcv"vjg"encuu"dg"fghkpgf"cu<" Cnn"yqogp"yqtmkpi"cv"vjg"Hqtf"Ejkeciq"Cuugodn{"Rncpv"cpf"Ejkeciq"Uvcorkpi" Rncpv"htqo"Lcpwct{"4234"vq"rtgugpv0" " " " ]53:."cv" "5."70_" " Vjg"rctvkgu"fq"pqv"fkurwvg"vjcv"RnckpvkhhuÓ"rtqrqugf"encuu"ucvkuhkgu"Twng"45*c+Óu" pwogtqukv{" tgswktgogpv" qt" Twng" 45Óu" kornkekv" cuegtvckpcdknkv{" tgswktgogpv0" " Fghgpfcpv" ctiwgu." jqygxgt." vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" hckn" vq" ucvkuh{" Twng" 45*c+Óu" eqooqpcnkv{." v{rkecnkv{." cpf" cfgswce{" tgswktgogpvu0" " Fghgpfcpv" hwtvjgt" ctiwgu" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" ecppqv" ucvkuh{" vjg" tgswktgogpvu" qh" cp{" Twng"45*d+"uwdugevkqp0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"cfftguugu"gcej"qh"vjgug"ctiwogpvu"kp"vwtp0" " Dghqtg"fqkpi"uq." jqygxgt." vjg" Eqwtv" cfftguugu" vjg" rgpfkpi" oqvkqpu" vq" gzenwfg" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{0" " Beaton v. SpeedyPC Software.";29"H05f"323:."3249"*9vj"Ekt0"423:+"*gzrnckpkpi"vjcv"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"ÐÒowuv" eqpenwukxgn{"twng"qp"cp{"ejcnngpig"vq"vjg"gzrgtvÓu"swcnkhkecvkqpu"qt"uwdokuukqpu"rtkqt"vq"twnkpi"qp"c" encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"oqvkqp.Ó"kh"vjg"ÒgzrgtvÓu"tgrqtv"qt"vguvkoqp{"ku"etkvkecn"vq"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqpÓÑ" *swqvkpi"Am. Honda Motor Co., Inc. v. Allen."822"H05f":35.":36/37"*9vj"Ekt0"4232++0" C0" Daubert"Oqvkqpu" " Dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv"ctg"vjg"rctvkguÓ"oqvkqpu"]574="592_"vq"gzenwfg"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{0" " Hgfgtcn" Twng" qh" Gxkfgpeg" 924" cpf" vjg" Uwrtgog" EqwtvÓu" fgekukqp" kp" Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc.."72;"W0U0"79;"*3;;5+."rtqxkfg"vjg"ngicn"htcogyqtm"hqt"vjg"cfokuukdknkv{"qh" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{0" " Ugg" Bielskis v. Louisville Ladder, Inc.." 885" H05f" ::9." :;5" *9vj" Ekt0" 4233+=" 34" United States v. Pansier."798"H05f"948."959"*9vj"Ekt0"422;+0" " Twng"924"tgswktgu"vjcv"vjg"fkuvtkev" lwfig"cev"cu"c"ÐÒicvg/mggrgtÓ"yjq"fgvgtokpgu"yjgvjgt"rtqhhgtgf"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"ku"tgnkcdng"cpf" tgngxcpv"dghqtg"ceegrvkpi"c"ykvpguu"cu"cp"gzrgtv0Ñ" " Winters v. Fru-Con Inc.."6;:"H05f"956."963/64" *9vj"Ekt0"4229+"*swqvkpi"Autotech Tech. Ltd. P’ship v. Automationdirect.com."693"H05f"967."96;" *9vj" Ekt0" 4228++=" ugg" cnuq" Kumho Tire Co., Ltd. v. Carmichael." 748" W0U0" 359." 369/6;" *3;;;+=" Daubert."72;"W0U0"cv"7:;0" Kp" tgxkgykpi" c" oqvkqp" vq" gzenwfg" vguvkoqp{" wpfgt" Twng" 924." vjg" fkuvtkev" eqwtv" owuv" Ðcuegtvckp"yjgvjgt"vjg"gzrgtv"ku"swcnkhkgf."yjgvjgt"jku"qt"jgt"ogvjqfqnqi{"ku"uekgpvkhkecnn{"tgnkcdng." cpf"yjgvjgt"vjg"vguvkoqp{"yknn"Òcuukuv"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev"vq"wpfgtuvcpf"vjg"gxkfgpeg"qt"vq"fgvgtokpg"c" hcev"kp"kuuwg0ÓÑ" " Bielskis."885"H05f"cv":;5/;6"*swqvkpi"Hgf0"T0"Gxkf0"924+="ugg"cnuq"Myers v. Ill. Cent. R.R. Co.."84;"H05f"85;."866"*9vj"Ekt0"4232+"*qwvnkpkpi"vjg"Ðvjtgg/uvgr"cpcn{ukuÑ"hqt"cuuguukpi" vjg" cfokuukdknkv{" qh" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{+0" ÐVjg" rtqrqpgpv" qh" vjg" gzrgtv" dgctu" vjg" dwtfgp" qh" fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"vjg"gzrgtvÓu"vguvkoqp{"yqwnf"ucvkuh{"vjg"Daubert uvcpfctf0Ñ" " Lewis v. CITGO Petroleum Corp.." 783" H05f" 8;:." 927" *9vj" Ekt0" 422;+0" " Fkuvtkev" lwfigu" rquuguu" eqpukfgtcdng" fkuetgvkqp"kp"fgcnkpi"ykvj"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{0" " Carroll v. Otis Elevator Co..":;8"H04f"432."434"*9vj" Ekt0"3;;2+="ugg"cnuq"Gen. Elec. Co. v. Joiner."744"W0U0"358."363/65"*3;;9+"*jqnfkpi"vjcv"cdwug"qh" fkuetgvkqp" uvcpfctf" crrnkgu" kp" tgxkgykpi" fkuvtkev" eqwtv" twnkpiu" qp" cfokuukdknkv{" qh" rtqrqugf" Twng"924"qrkpkqp"vguvkoqp{+0" Fghgpfcpv" jcu" oqxgf" vq" gzenwfg" vjg" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" qh" RnckpvkhhuÓ" gzrgtv" ykvpguu" Ft0"Nqwkug" Hkv|igtcnf0" " ]5740_" " Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" oqxgf" vq" gzenwfg" vjg" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" qh" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgdwvvcn" gzrgtv" ykvpguuguÏuqekcn" ru{ejqnqikuv" cpf" ncy" rtqhguuqt" Ft0" Itgiqt{" Okvejgnn."L0F0."Rj0F0."cpf"ru{ejkcvtkuv"Ft0"Nk|c"Iqnf."O0F0" " ]5920_" " " 35" " i. Dr. Louise Fitzgerald Kp" vjgkt" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp." Rnckpvkhhu" tgn{" kp" rctv" qp" vjg" gzrgtv" tgrqtv" qh" Ft0"Nqwkug" Hkv|igtcnf."yjq" Rnckpvkhhu" eqpvgpf"ku" Ðjkijn{" tgictfgf" kp" vjg" hkgnf" qh" ru{ejqnqi{" cu" gzrgtv"qp"uqekcn"ru{ejqnqi{Ñ"hqewukpi"qp"Ðkuuwgu"tgictfkpi"igpfgt"cpf"yqogpÓu"uvwfkgu0Ñ" " ]595." cv"30_" " Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"rwtrqtvu"vq"itqwpf"jgt"qrkpkqpu"kp"vjg"uqekcn"htcogyqtm"ogvjqfqnqi{0" " ]577" *Hkv|igtcnf" Fgr0" Vt0+." cv" 4220_" " Fghgpfcpv" tgeqipk|gu" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" cu" cp" gzrgtv" kp" jgt" hkgnf" urgekcnk|kpi" kp" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0" " Jqygxgt." Fghgpfcpv" ctiwgu" vjcv" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" vguvkoqp{" ujqwnf"dg"gzenwfgf"dgecwug"kv"ku"pqv"cevwcnn{"dcugf"qp"vjg"Ðuqekcn"htcogyqtmÑ"ogvjqf"vjcv"ujg" rwtrqtvu"vq"wug."qt"qp"cp{"qvjgt"tgnkcdng"uekgpvkhke"ogvjqf0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv" Ð]c_" rtqrgt" uqekcn" htcogyqtm" tgrqtv" uwooctk|gu" igpgtcn" tgugctej" kp" c" uwdlgev/ocvvgt" ctgc" cpf" rtqxkfgu"eqpvgzv"hqt"vjg"fact-finder"vq"kpvgtrtgv"ecug/urgekhke"gxkfgpegÑ"]575."cv"33/34_Ïcpf"fqgu" pqv"crrn{"vjg"tgugctej"vq"vjg"hcevu"qh"vjg"ecug0" " Id0"cv"34"*Ð]C_"xcnkf"uqekcn"htcogyqtm"qrkpkqp"oc{" Òpqv"vgnn"vjg"lwt{"yjcv"vq"fgekfg"kp"cp{"ikxgp"ecugÓÏqpn{"Òyjcv"vq"eqpukfgt0ÓÑ"*swqvkpi"Tuli v. Brigham & Women’s Hosp., Inc.." 7;4" H0" Uwrr0" 4f" 42:." 433" *F0" Ocuu0" 422;++0" " Dgecwug" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf"uggmu"vq"vgnn"vjg"lwt{"yjcv"vq"fgekfg"kp"vjku"ecugÏceeqtfkpi"vq"FghgpfcpvÏjgt"qrkpkqp" hcknu" vq" rtqrgtn{" crrn{" vjg" uqekcn" htcogyqtm" ogvjqfqnqi{0" " Fghgpfcpv" cnuq" ctiwgu" vjcv" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpu"yknn"pqv"cuukuv"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev0" " Vjwu."cnvjqwij"Fghgpfcpv"fqgu"pqv"fkurwvg" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"swcnkhkecvkqpu"cv"vjg"hktuv"uvgr"qh"vjg"Twng"9241Daubert"cpcn{uku."Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu" vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpu"fq"pqv"ucvkuh{"vjg"ugeqpf"cpf"vjktf"uvgru"qh"vjg"cpcn{uku0" " " Rnckpvkhhu" cuugtv" vjcv" ÐFt0" Hkv|igtcnf" jcu" wugf" ogvjqfu" cpf" tgnkgf" qp" eqpegrvu" cpf" kphqtocvkqp" igpgtcnn{" ceegrvgf" cu" tgnkcdng" d{" qvjgt" gzrgtvu" kp" jgt" hkgnf" ," ," ," vq" hqtowncvg" jgt" qrkpkqpu"vjcv"kh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"cpf"fcvc"qp"vjg"yjqng"*fqewogpvu"rtqfwegf"kp"fkueqxgt{"cpf"ykvpguu" uvcvgogpvu" cpf" fgrqukvkqpu+" ctg" vtwg." c" eqooqp" swguvkqp" vjcv" cp" qdlgevkxgn{" jquvkng" yqtmrnceg" 36" gpxktqpogpv"gzkuvu."cpf"c"eqooqp."ogcpkpihwn"kplwpevkxg"tgogf{"ku"tgswktgf"vq"ocmg"kv"uvqr0Ñ" " ]595." cv" 50_" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhhu" rtqxkfg" vjg" hqnnqykpi" qxgtxkgy" qh" vjg" qrkpkqpu" qhhgtgf" d{" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf<" 30" Vjg"Ejkeciq"Hqtf"Rncpvu."dqvj"ECR"cpf"EUR."gzjkdkv"jkij"ngxgnu"qh"gxgt{"kpfkecvqt"qh" tkum"hqt"jctcuuogpv"mpqyp"vq"uqekcn"uekgpeg0" " 40" Vjg"yqtmkpi"gpxktqpogpv"cv"vjg"Ejkeciq"Hqtf"Rncpvu"*ECR"cpf"EUR+"crrgctu"vq"dg" rgtogcvgf"ykvj"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"qh"vjg"itquuguv."winkguv."cpf"oquv"fgitcfkpi"mkpf0" ,","," vjg" jctcuuogpv" ku" uq" rgtxcukxg" cu" vq" jcxg" kpgxkvcdn{" gzrqugf" gxgt{" hgocng" gornq{gg"qh"vjg"rncpvu."vq"c"itgcvgt"qt"nguugt"fgitgg0" " Cv"vjg"xgt{"ngcuv."gxgt{"hgocng" gornq{gg"yqtmu"kp"cp"gpxktqpogpv"kp"yjkej"yqogp."ugz."cpf"ugzwcnkv{"ctg"kpuwnvgf" cpf"fgitcfgf"cu"c"ocvvgt"qh"eqwtug0" " Vjgug"gxgpvu"ctg"pgkvjgt"tcpfqo."kuqncvgf."pqt" wpkswg."dwv"tcvjgt"eqpuvkvwvg"vjg"yctr"cpf"yqqh"qh"gxgt{fc{"nkhg"kp"vjg"rncpv0" " 50" Fghgpfcpv"ku"cyctg"qh"vjku"ukvwcvkqp"cpf"jcu"dggp"ukpeg"cv"ngcuv"4234"cpf"jcu"ejqugp"vq" kipqtg."qduewtg."fqyprnc{"cpf"qvjgtykug"hckngf"vq"vcmg"ku"qdnkicvkqpu"ugtkqwun{0" " 60" Vjgtg"ku"cp"wtigpv"pggf"hqt"eqortgjgpukxg."nqpi/vgto."oqpkvqtgf"kpvgtxgpvkqpu"kp"vjg" Rncpvu" ykvj" vjg" cko" qh" ejcpikpi" dgjcxkqt." dgjcxkqtcn" eqpvkpigpekgu." gornq{gg" rgtegrvkqpu." ocpcigogpv"cvvkvwfgu."cpf"vjg"gpvktg"qticpk|cvkqpcn" enkocvg0" " Cp{vjkpi" nguu" eqpuvkvwvgu" c" ycuvg" qh" vkog" cpf" tguqwtegu." cu" ygnn" cu" c" vjtgcv" vq" qticpk|cvkqpcn" tgrwvcvkqp" cpf" iqqf" yknn." cpfÏoquv" korqtvcpvn{Ïyqtmgt" ru{ejqnqikecn" jgcnvj." rj{ukecn"uchgv{."cpf"qxgtcnn"ygnndgkpi0" " ]595."cv"50_" " " Vjg" Eqwtv" hktuv" yknn" cfftguu" Twng" 924Óu" tgnkcdknkv{" tgswktgogpv0" " ÐTwng" 924" ycu" uwduvcpvkcnn{"tgxkugf"kp"4222"vq"chhkto"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtvÓu"tqng"cu"icvgmggrgt"cpf"rtqxkfg"uqog"igpgtcn" uvcpfctfu"vjcv"vjg"vtkcn"eqwtv"owuv"wug"vq"cuuguu"vjg"tgnkcdknkv{"cpf"jgnrhwnpguu"qh"rtqhhgtgf"gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{0Ñ" " Lees v. Carthage Coll.." 936" H05f" 738." 743/44" *9vj" Ekt0" 4235+" *kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu."ekvcvkqpu."cpf"cnvgtcvkqpu"qokvvgf+="ugg"cnuq"United States v. Parra."624"H05f"974."97:"*9vj" Ekt04227+"*ÐCv"vjku"rqkpv."Twng"924"jcu"uwrgtugfgf"Daubert."dwv"vjg"uvcpfctf"qh"tgxkgy"vjcv"ycu" guvcdnkujgf"hqt"Daubert"ejcnngpigu"ku"uvknn"crrtqrtkcvg0Ñ+0" " Kp"qtfgt"vq"gxcnwcvg"vjg"tgnkcdknkv{"qh"cp" gzrgtvÓu"vguvkoqp{."eqwtvu"ujqwnf"vjg"hqnnqykpi"hcevqtu<"Ð*3+"yjgvjgt"vjg"rtqhhgtgf"vjgqt{"ecp"dg" 37" cpf"jcu"dggp"vguvgf="*4+"yjgvjgt"vjg"vjgqt{"jcu"dggp"uwdlgevgf"vq"rggt"tgxkgy="*5+"yjgvjgt"vjg" vjgqt{"jcu"dggp"gxcnwcvgf"kp"nkijv"qh"rqvgpvkcn"tcvgu"qh"gttqt="cpf"*6+"yjgvjgt"vjg"vjgqt{"jcu"dggp" ceegrvgf"kp"vjg"tgngxcpv"uekgpvkhke"eqoowpkv{0Ñ" " Gopalratnam v. Hewlett-Packard Co..":99"H05f" 993."99;"*9vj"Ekt0"4239+"*swqvkpi"Krik v. Exxon Mobil Corp..":92"H05f"88;."896"*9vj"Ekt0"4239++" *kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0" " ÐKp"cffkvkqp."vjg"Twng"924"cfxkuqt{"eqookvvggÓu"pqvg"vq"vjg" 4222" cogpfogpv" qwvnkpgu" qvjgt" dgpejoctmu" tgngxcpv" kp" cuuguukpi" cp" gzrgtvÓu" tgnkcdknkv{<" *7+"yjgvjgt" Òockpvgpcpeg" uvcpfctfu" cpf" eqpvtqnuÓ" gzkuv=" *8+" yjgvjgt" vjg" vguvkoqp{" tgncvgu" vq" Òocvvgtu"itqykpi"pcvwtcnn{"cpf"fktgevn{"qwv"qh"tgugctej"vjg{"jcxg"eqpfwevgf"kpfgrgpfgpv"qh"vjg" nkvkicvkqp.Ó" qt" fgxgnqrgf" Ògzrtguun{" hqt" rwtrqugu" qh" vguvkh{kpiÓ=" *9+" Ò]y_jgvjgt" vjg" gzrgtv" jcu" wplwuvkhkcdn{"gzvtcrqncvgf"htqo"cp"ceegrvgf"rtgokug"vq"cp"wphqwpfgf"eqpenwukqpÓ="*:+"Ò]y_jgvjgt" vjg" gzrgtv" jcu" cfgswcvgn{" ceeqwpvgf" hqt" qdxkqwu" cnvgtpcvkxg" gzrncpcvkqpuÓ=" *;+" Ò]y_jgvjgt" vjg" gzrgtv"ku"dgkpi"cu"ectghwn"cu"jg"yqwnf"dg"kp"jku"tgiwnct"rtqhguukqpcn"yqtm"qwvukfg"jku"rckf"nkvkicvkqp" eqpuwnvkpiÓ="cpf"*32+"Ò]y_jgvjgt"vjg"hkgnf"qh"gzrgtvkug"enckogf"d{"vjg" gzrgtv"ku"mpqyp"vq"tgcej" tgnkcdng"tguwnvu"hqt"vjg"v{rg"qh"qrkpkqp"vjg"gzrgtv"yqwnf"ikxg0ÓÑ" " Id0"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" " " ÐKorqtvcpvn{." vjku" nkuv" ku" pgkvjgt" gzjcwuvkxg" pqt" ocpfcvqt{0Ñ" " Id0" *swqvkpi" C.W. ex rel. Wood v. Textron, Inc.." :29" H05f" :49." :57" *9vj" Ekt0" 4237++" *kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu" qokvvgf+0" " Dgecwug"Ðvjgtg"ctg"ocp{"fkhhgtgpv"mkpfu"qh"gzrgtvu."cpf"ocp{"fkhhgtgpv"mkpfu"qh"gzrgtvkug.Ñ"Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael." 748" W0U0" 359." 372" *3;;;+." vjg" vguv" hqt" tgnkcdknkv{" ku" ÐhngzkdngÑ" cpf" ÐDaubertÓu"nkuv"qh"urgekhke"hcevqtu"pgkvjgt"pgeguuctkn{"pqt"gzenwukxgn{"crrnkgu"vq"cnn"gzrgtvu"qt"kp" gxgt{"ecug0Ñ" " United States v. Romero."3:;"H05f"798."7:6"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;;+"*swqvkpi"Kumho."748" W0U0"cv"359+0" " ÐWnvkocvgn{."tgnkcdknkv{"ku"fgvgtokpgf"qp"c"ecug/d{/ecug"dcuku0Ñ" " C.W. ex rel. Wood v. Textron, Inc..":29"H05f":49.":57"*9vj"Ekt0"4237+"*ekvkpi"Ervin v. Johnson & Johnson."6;4"H05f" ;23.";26"*9vj"Ekt0"4229++0" " 38" Cnvjqwij"vjg"rctvkgu"fq"pqv"cfftguu"vjgug"hcevqtu"cu"uwej."vjg"Eqwtv"owuv"crrn{"vjg"ncy"qh" vjg"ektewkv."cpf"vjwu"yknn"cfftguu"vjgo0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"dgikpu"d{"eqpukfgtkpi"yjgvjgt"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf" cevwcnn{"gornq{gf"vjg"Ðuqekcn"htcogyqtmÑ"ogvjqfqnqi{"ujg"rwtrqtvu"vq"jcxg"wugf"kp"tgcejkpi"jgt" qrkpkqpu." cu" vjku" ku" FghgpfcpvÓu" rtkoct{" qdlgevkqp" vq" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" qrkpkqpu0" " Cu" pqvgf" d{" Fghgpfcpv."pwogtqwu"uejqnctu"jcxg"pqvgf"vjcv"vjg"Ðc"uqekcn"htcogyqtm"pgeguuctkn{"eqpvckpu"qpn{" igpgtcn"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"tgnkcdng"rcvvgtpu"qh"tgncvkqpu"coqpi"xctkcdngu"cu"fkueqxgtgf"ykvjkp"uqekcn" uekgpvkhke" tgugctej" ,","," cpf" iqgu" pq" hwtvjgt0Ñ" " Lqjp" Oqpcjcp" gv0" cn0." Contextual Evidence of Gender Discrimination: The Ascendance of “Social Frameworks”." ;6" Xc0" N0" Tgx0" 3937." 3967" *422:+0" " Kpfggf." Rtqhguuqt" OqpcjcpÏvjg" kpfkxkfwcn" yjq" d{" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" qyp" cfokuukqp" eqkpgf"vjg"vgto"Ðuqekcn"htcogyqtmÑ"]595/4."cv"8." "35*d+_Ïvcmgu"vjku"rqukvkqp03" " Gxgp"cp"ctvkeng" tgnkgf"wrqp"d{"Rnckpvkhhu"kp"vjgkt"tgurqpug"vq"FghgpfcpvÓu"kpkvkcn"Daubert oqvkqp"tgeqipk|gf"vjcv." wpfgt"vjg"Ðuqekcn"htcogyqtmÑ"ogvjqfqnqi{."vguvkoqp{"ku"Ðqhhgtgf"pqv"vq"rtqxg"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"c" rctvkewnct"ecug"qt"ecuguÏvjcv"fgvgtokpcvkqp"ku"qpg"vjg"hcev"hkpfgt"yknn"ocmg"kp"nkijv"qh"cnn"qh"vjg" gxkfgpegÏdwv" vq" qhhgt" c" dcemftqr" qh" kphqtocvkqp" cdqwv" jqy" vjg" rjgpqogpqp" qh" uvgtgqv{rkpi" qrgtcvgu"uq"vjcv"vjg"hcev"hkpfgt"ecp"cuuguu"vjg"urgekhke"ecug"kp"nkijv"qh"vjcv"kphqtocvkqp0Ñ" " Ognkuuc" Jctv" (" Rcwn" O0" Ugewpfc." A Matter of Context: Social Framework Evidence in Employment Discrimination Class Actions."9:"Hqtfjco"N0"Tgx0"59."74"*422;+04" " " " Kp"fghgpug"qh"jgt"tgrqtv."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ctiwgu"vjcv"yjcv"vqfc{"ku"tghgttgf"vq"cu"vjg"uqekcn" htcogyqtm"ogvjqfqnqi{"ycu"wugf"nqpi"dghqtg"vjg"vgto"ycu"eqkpgf."ekvkpi"vjg"wug"qh"uqekcn"uekgpeg" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 3 " Cnvjqwij"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"chhkfcxkv"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"Lqjp"Oqpcjcp"ukorn{"eqkpgf"vjg"vgto."kp"jgt"fgrqukvkqp" ujg" vguvkhkgf" vjcv" ujg" dgnkgxgf" vjcv" kv" ycu" Rtqhguuqt" Oqpcjcp" yjq" kpxgpvgf" vjg" eqpegrv" qh" vjg" uqekcn" htcogyqtm"ogvjqfqnqi{0" " ]577"*Hkv|igtcnf"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"4220_" " " " 4 " Chvgt"vjg"Eqwtv"pqvgfÏkp"fgp{kpi"FghgpfcpvÓu"kpkvkcn"Daubert oqvkqp"cu"rtgocvwtgÏvjcv"vjg"ctvkeng"fkf" pqv" uwrrqtv" RnckpvkhhuÓ" rqukvkqp." Rnckpvkhhu" ukorn{" tgoqxgf" tghgtgpeg" vq" vjg" ctvkeng" kp" vjgkt" tgurqpug" vq" FghgpfcpvÓu"tgpgygf"Daubert"oqvkqp0" " " " 39" gxkfgpeg"kp"nkvkicvkqp05" " ]595/4"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"Tgdwvvcn"Chh0+."cv"8." "35*d+0_" " Hqt"gzcorng."Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf"pqvgu"vjcv"vjg"uvtcvgi{"qh"eqodkpkpi"ngicn"ctiwogpv"ykvj"uekgpvkhke"gxkfgpeg"ycu"wugf"kp" Brown v. Board of Education."569"W0U0"6:5."6;7"*3;76+0" " ]595/4"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"Tgdwvvcn"Chh0+."cv" 8." " 35*d+0_" " Vjku" ctiwogpv" okuugu" vjg" octm." cu" Fghgpfcpv" ku" pqv" ctiwkpi" vjcv" uqekcn" uekgpeg" gxkfgpeg"ku"c"ecvgiqtkecnn{"kortqrgt"dcuku"hqt"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{0" " Tcvjgt."Fghgpfcpv"eqpvgpfu"vjcv" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"kortqrgtn{"crrnkgf"vjg"uqekcn"uekgpeg"ogvjqfqnqi{0" " Crctv"htqo"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" wpuwrrqtvgf"vguvkoqp{."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"kfgpvkhkgf"cp{"gxkfgpeg"uwrrqtvkpi"vjg"eqpenwukqp"vjcv" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"rtqrgtn{"crrnkgf"vjg"Ðuqekcn"htcogyqtmÑ"ogvjqfqnqi{"vjcv"ujg"rwtrqtvu"vq"crrn{0" " " Oqtgqxgt."gxgp"rwvvkpi"cukfg"vjg"swguvkqp"qh"yjgvjgt"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"rtqrgtn{"crrnkgf"vjg" uqekcn"htcogyqtm"ogvjqfqnqi{."Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"guvcdnkuj"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpu"tgictfkpi" vjg"rtgxcngpeg"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cv"vjg"Rncpvu"qvjgtykug"ctg"tgnkcdng0" " Vq"dgikp."gxgp"kh"vjg" wpfgtn{kpi"uqekcn"uekgpeg"gxkfgpeg"wrqp"yjkej"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"dcugu"jgt"qrkpkqpu"ku"tgnkcdng"cpf" ceegrvgf" kp" vjg" tgngxcpv" uekgpvkhke" eqoowpkv{." Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" oc{" pqv" gzvtcrqncvg" wphqwpfgf" eqpenwukqpu"htqo"vjcv"gxkfgpeg06" " Gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"ujqwnf"dg"gzenwfgf"yjgp"Ðvjgtg"ku"ukorn{"vqq" itgcv"cp"cpcn{vkecn"icr"dgvyggp"vjg"fcvc"cpf"vjg"qrkpkqp"rtqhhgtgf0Ñ" " Gen. Elec. Co. v. Joiner."744" W0U0"358."368"*3;;9+0" " Dcugf"qp"vjg"gxkfgpeg"ekvgf"d{"Rnckpvkhhu."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"wpcdng"vq"fgvgtokpg" jqy" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf" tgcejgf" jgt" qrkpkqpu" tgictfkpi" vjg" rtgxcngpeg" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" cv" vjg" Rncpvu"htqo"vjcv"tgugctej0" " Kp"qvjgt"yqtfu."Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"kfgpvkh{"any"tgnkcdng"ogvjqfqnqi{"wugf" d{"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"tgrgcvgfn{"pqvg"vjcv"Ðtgnkcdknkv{Ñ"rtkoctkn{"ku"Ðc"swguvkqp"qh"vjg"xcnkfkv{"qh"vjg" ogvjqfqnqi{"gornq{gf"d{"cp"gzrgtv."pqv"vjg"swcnkv{"qh"vjg"fcvc"wugf"kp"crrn{kpi"vjg"ogvjqfqnqi{" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 5 " Vjg"Eqwtv"pqvgu"vjcv"vjku"ctiwogpv"oqtg"rtqrgtn{"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"tckugf"d{"eqwpugn"kp"c"dtkgh"vjcp"d{"c" rtqrqugf"gzrgtv"kp"jgt"tgrqtv"qt"chhkfcxkv."cu"vjg"cfokuukdknkv{"qh"gxkfgpeg"kp"eqwtv"rtgugpvu"c"ngicn"kuuwg0" " " " 6 " Cnvjqwij"Fghgpfcpv"fqgu"pqv"rwtrqtv"vq"cfftguu"vjku"hcevqt"urgekhkecnn{."ocp{"qh"FghgpfcpvÓu"ctiwogpvu" ctg"tgngxcpv"vq"fkuewuukpi"vjku"hcevqt0" " " 3:" qt"vjg"eqpenwukqpu"rtqfwegf0Ñ" " Manpower, Inc. v. Ins. Co. of Penn.."954"H05f"9;8.":28"*9vj"Ekt0" 4235+0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"tgeqipk|gu"vjcv"Ð]v_jg"uqwpfpguu"qh"vjg"hcevwcn"wpfgtrkppkpiu"qh"vjg"gzrgtvÓu" cpcn{uku"cpf"vjg"eqttgevpguu"qh"vjg"gzrgtvÓu"eqpenwukqpu"dcugf"qp"vjcv"cpcn{uku"ctg"hcevwcn"ocvvgtu" vq"dg"fgvgtokpgf"d{"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev."qt."yjgtg"crrtqrtkcvg."qp"uwooct{"lwfiogpv0Ñ" " Id0"*swqvkpi" Smith v. Ford Motor Co.."437"H05f"935."93:"*9vj"Ekt0"4222++0" " ÐTwng"924Óu"tgswktgogpv"vjcv"vjg" fkuvtkev"lwfig"fgvgtokpg"vjcv"vjg"gzrgtv"wugf"tgnkcdng"ogvjqfu"fqgu"pqv"qtfkpctkn{"gzvgpf"vq"vjg" tgnkcdknkv{" qh" vjg" eqpenwukqpu" vjqug" ogvjqfu" rtqfwegÏvjcv" ku." yjgvjgt" vjg" eqpenwukqpu" ctg" wpkorgcejcdng0Ñ" " Id0"*swqvkpi"Stollings v. Ryobi Technologies, Inc.."947"H05f"975."987"*9vj"Ekt0" 4235+" *kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu" qokvvgf+0" " Jqygxgt." qvjgt" vjcp"ekvkpi" vq" vjg" uqekcn" htcogyqtm" ogvjqfqnqi{." Rnckpvkhhu" fq" pqv" gzrnckp" vjg" rtqeguu" d{" yjkej" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" tgcejgf" jgt" eqpenwukqpu"tgictfkpi"vjg"rtgxcngpeg"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cv"vjg"rncpvu0" " Cpf"Joiner"gzrtguun{" tgswktgu"rtqrqugf"gzrgtvu"vq"uwrrn{"vjcv"eqppgevkxg"tgcuqpkpi"dghqtg"qdvckpkpi"lwfkekcn"rgtokuukqp" vq"rtgugpv"vjgkt"eqpenwukqpu"kp"c"eqwtvtqqo0" " 744"W0U0"cv"3680" Vjg"qpn{"gxkfgpeg"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"rtgugpvgf"tgictfkpi"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"ogvjqfqnqi{"hqt" tgcejkpi"vjku"eqpenwukqp"ku"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"chhkfcxkv."yjkej"uvcvgu<" Gcej" qh" vjg" qrkpkqpu" K" gzrtguugf" kp" o{" tgrqtv." o{" Uwrrngogpvcn" Fgenctcvkqp1Chhkfcxkv."o{"fgrqukvkqp"cpf"kp"vjku"Tgdwvvcn"Fgenctcvkqp"ctg"gzrtguugf" vq"c"tgcuqpcdng"fgitgg"qh"ru{ejqnqikecn"cpf"uekgpvkhke"fgitgg"qh"egtvckpv{"cpf"ctg" dcugf" qp" ocvgtkcnu." ." ]uke_" gxkfgpeg." kphqtocvkqp." rtkpekrngu" cpf" uqwtegu" ewuvqoctkn{" tgnkgf" wrqp" d{" qvjgt" gzrgtvu" kp" o{" hkgnf" cpf" ctg" fgxgnqrgf" wukpi" ogvjqfu"cpf"tgn{kpi"qp"eqpegrvu"cpf"kphqtocvkqp"igpgtcnn{"ceegrvgf"cu"tgnkcdng"d{" qvjgt"gzrgtvu"kp"o{"hkgnf0" " " " ]595/4"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"Tgdwvvcn"Chh0+."cv" "370_" " Jqygxgt."vjku"cuugtvkqp"rtqxkfgu"pq"cffkvkqpcn" enctkv{0" " Cnvjqwij"gzenwukqp"qh"Ðgzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"ku"vjg"gzegrvkqp"tcvjgt"vjcp"vjg"twng.Ñ"Woods v. Amazon.com, LLC."423;"YN"4545:96."cv",37"*P0F0"Knn0"Oc{"52."423;+"*swqvkpi"Hgf0"T0"Gxkf0"924." cfxkuqt{"eqookvvgg"pqvgu"*4222"Cogpfogpvu++."vjg"Eqwtv"ecppqv"ucvkuh{"kvu"icvgmggrkpi"hwpevkqp" 3;" d{"ukorn{"ceegrvkpi"cp"gzrgtvÓu"eqpenwuqt{"cuugtvkqp"vjcv"ujg"tgcejgf"jgt"eqpenwukqpu"d{"wukpi" ogvjqfu"cpf"tgn{kpi"qp"eqpegrvu"cpf"kphqtocvkqp"igpgtcnn{"ceegrvgf"cu"tgnkcdng"d{"qvjgt"gzrgtvu"kp" jgt"hkgnf0" " Robinson v. Davol Inc..";35"H05f"8;2."8;8"*9vj"Ekt0"423;+"*ÐTwng"924"cpf"Daubert tgswktg"vjg"lwfig"vq"cev"cu"c"xkiqtqwu"icvgmggrgt"vq"gpuwtg"vjg"tgnkcdknkv{"qh"gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{0Ñ" *ekvkpi" Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael." 748" W0U0" 359." 36;" *3;;;++=" Joiner." 744" W0U0" cv" 368" *Ð]P_qvjkpi"kp"gkvjgt"Daubert qt"vjg"Hgfgtcn"Twngu"qh"Gxkfgpeg"tgswktgu"c"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"vq"cfokv" qrkpkqp"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"ku"eqppgevgf"vq"gzkuvkpi"fcvc"qpn{"d{"vjg"ipse dixit"qh"vjg"gzrgtv0Ñ+0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"hwtvjgt"ctiwg"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"vguvkoqp{"ujqwnf"dg"cnnqygf"dgecwug"eqwtvu" tgiwnctn{"cnnqy"*kpenwfkpi"kp"gornq{ogpv"fkuetkokpcvkqp"ecugu+"uqekcn"uekgpeg"vguvkoqp{"kp"yjkej" ru{ejqnqikecn" tgugctej" jcu" dggp" crrnkgf" vq" vjg" hcevu" qh" c" urgekhke" ecug" ykvjqwv" enkpkecn" gzcokpcvkqpu" qh" kpfkxkfwcn" encuu" ogodgtu0" " Vjg" Eqwtv" cempqyngfigu" vjg" rqvgpvkcn" korqtv" qh" uqekcn"uekgpeg"gxkfgpeg"kp"nkvkicvkqp"cpf"tgeqipk|gu"vjcv"eqwtvu"jcxg"cnnqygf"uwej"vguvkoqp{"yjgp" Twng"924"cpf"Daubert qvjgtykug"ctg"ucvkuhkgf0" " Cu"vjg"Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"pqvgf."Ðuqekcn"uekgpeg" vguvkoqp{"ku"cp"kpvgitcn"rctv"qh"ocp{"ecugu."tcpikpi"htqo"gornq{ogpv"fkuetkokpcvkqp"cevkqpu."vq" hcokn{"ncy"ocvvgtu."vq"etkokpcn"rtqeggfkpiu0Ñ" " United States v. Hall.";5"H05f"3559."3564/65"*9vj" Ekt0" 3;;8+0" " Uvknn." DaubertÓu" Ðhtcogyqtm" hqt" cuuguukpi" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" ku" crrnkecdng" vq" uqekcn" uekgpeg"gzrgtvu."lwuv"cu"kv"crrnkgu"vq"gzrgtvu"kp"vjg"jctf"uekgpegu0Ñ" " Tyus v. Urban Search Mgmt.." 324" H05f" 478." 485" *9vj" Ekt0" 3;;8+" *ekvcvkqpu" qokvvgf+0" " Cu" Lwfig" Uv0" Gxg" jcu" ytkvvgp." Ðvjg" ogvjqfqnqi{"wugf"d{"uqekcn"uekgpeg"gzrgtvu"vq"tgcej"vjgkt"eqpenwukqpu"owuv"Òcfjgtg"vq"vjg"ucog" uvcpfctfu" qh" kpvgnngevwcn" tkiqt" vjcv" ctg" fgocpfgf" kp" ]vjgkt_" rtqhguukqpcn" yqtmÓ" kp" qtfgt" vq" dg" tgnkcdng0Ñ" " Obrycka v. City of Chicago." 9;4" H0" Uwrr0" 4f" 3235." 3246" *P0F0" Knn0" 4233+" *swqvkpi" Chapman v. Maytag Corp.,"4;9" H05f" 8:4." 8::" *9vj" Ekt0" 4224++0" " Rnckpvkhhu" fq" pqv" uwhhkekgpvn{" 42" gzrnckp" jqy" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" vguvkoqp{" ucvkuhkgu" vjku" uvcpfctf" ykvj" tgurgev" vq" jgt" vguvkoqp{" tgictfkpi"vjg"rtgxcngpeg"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " " Fghgpfcpv"jcu"kfgpvkhkgf"c"pwodgt"qh"rtqdngou"ykvj"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"ogvjqfu"kpfgrgpfgpv" qh" yjgvjgt" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" ku" rtqrgtn{" crrn{kpi" vjg" uqekcn" htcogyqtm" ogvjqfqnqi{0 7 " " Hktuv." Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"qrkpkqpu"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ujqwnf"dg"gzenwfgf"dgecwug"ujg"kortqrgtn{" ftcyu" igpgtcnk|cvkqpu" cdqwv" vjg" rwvcvkxg" encuu" dcugf" qp" cp" wptgrtgugpvcvkxg" ucorng0" " Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf" jgtugnh" jcu" pqvgf" vjcv" Ð{qw" ecppqv" igpgtcnk|g" htqo" c" nkvkicvkqp" ucorng" vq" c" pqp/nkvkicvkqp" ucorng" vq" cp" qticpk|cvkqp" ucorng0Ñ" " ]577" *Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" Fgr0" Vt0+." cv" 3;20_" " Fwtkpi"jgt"fgrqukvkqp."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"eqwnf"pqv"uc{"jqy"ocp{"yqogp"ygtg"kp"vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu" *ujg"dgnkgxgf"vjgtg"ctg"qxgt"qpg"vjqwucpf."dwv"ujg"ycu"pqv"uwtg+0" " ]Id0"cv"3630_" " Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"cnuq" vguvkhkgf"vjcv"jgt"qrkpkqpu"fq"pqv"tgrtgugpv"c"tgugctej"uvwf{"cpf"vjcv"jgt"qrkpkqpu"vjgtghqtg"ygtg" pqv"dcugf"qp"cp{"ucorng"uk|g0" " ]Id0"cv"3930_" " [gv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"cvvgorvu"vq"ocmg"igpgtcnk|cvkqpu" cdqwv"vjg"gzrgtkgpegu"qh"gxgt{"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"dcugf"qp"vjg"gzrgtkgpegu"qh"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" egtvckp" qvjgt" eqornckpcpvu0" " Cnvjqwij" vjg" Eqwtv" citggu" vjcv" enkpkecn" vguvkpi" ku" pqv" c" rtgtgswkukvg" vq" rtqxkfkpi" gzrgtv" uqekcn" uekgpeg" vguvkoqp{.8" gzrgtv" uqekcn" uekgpeg" vguvkoqp{" uvknn" owuv"eqorn{"ykvj"Twng"924"cpf"Daubert0" " Obrycka."9;4"H0"Uwrr0"4f"cv"32460" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 7 " Kp"cffkvkqp"vq"vjg"ctiwogpvu"cfftguugf"dgnqy."Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpu"ujqwnf"dg" gzenwfgf"dgecwug"ujg"ceegrvgf"cu"vtwg"vjg"vguvkoqp{"cpf"tgrqtvu"rtqxkfgf"d{"Rnckpvkhhu0" " Vjku"ku"pqv"c"xcnkf" etkvkekuo."hqt"Ðkv"ku"ygnn/ugvvngf"vjcv"gzrgtvu"ecp"dcug"vjgkt"qrkpkqpu"qp"fkurwvgf"hcevu"dgecwug"vjg"Òuqwpfpguu" qh"vjg"hcevwcn"wpfgtrkppkpiu"qh"vjg"gzrgtvÓu"cpcn{uku"cpf"vjg"eqttgevpguu"qh"vjg"gzrgtvÓu"eqpenwukqpu"dcugf" qp"vjcv"cpcn{uku"ctg"hcevwcn"ocvvgtu"vq"dg"fgvgtokpgf"d{"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev0ÓÑ" " Harris v. City of Chicago."4239" YN"4658538."cv",34"*P0F0"Knn0"Lwpg"7."4239+"*swqvkpi"Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha, Ltd. v. Plano Molding Co.." 9:4"H05f"575."582"*9vj"Ekt0"4237++0" " 8 " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"ujqwnf"dg"gswkvcdn{"guvqrrgf"htqo"ctiwkpi"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ujqwnf" jcxg" fqpg" enkpkecn" vguvkpi." cuugtvkpi" vjcv" kv" ycu" Fghgpfcpv" vjcv" rtgxgpvgf" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" htqo" fqkpi" uq0" " Rnckpvkhhu" fq" pqv" ekvgÏcpf" vjg" Eqwtv" ku" pqv" cyctg" qhÏcp{" ecugu" ocmkpi" cp" gswkvcdng" gzegrvkqp" vq" vjg" EqwtvÓu"icvgmggrkpi"hwpevkqp0" " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"pqvg"vjcv"enkpkecn"vguvkpi"jcu"kvu"qyp"nkokvcvkqpu0" " Vjg"Eqwtv" yknn" pqv" hcwnv" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" hqt" pqv" eqpfwevkpi" c" enkpkecn" gzcokpcvkqp0" " Jqygxgt." vjg" Eqwtv" uvknn" owuv" cfftguu"yjgvjgt"vjg"ogvjqfu"cevwcnn{"wugf"d{"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ygtg"tgnkcdng0" " " " 43" Fghgpfcpv"cnuq"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"qrkpkqpu"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ujqwnf"dg"gzenwfgf"dgecwug"ujg" Ðejgtt{"rkemgfÑ"vjg"fcvc"ujg"wugf"vq"uwrrqtv"jgt"qrkpkqpu0" " Hqt"gzcorng."jgt"tgrqtv"fqgu"pqv"gxgp" ogpvkqp"vjg"fq|gp"fgenctcvkqpu"htqo"yqogp"yjq"uygct"vjg{"pgxgt"gzrgtkgpegf"qt"ykvpguugf"cp{" ugzwcnn{"jctcuukpi"eqpfwev"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " Pqt"fqgu"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"cfftguu"GGQE"kpvgtxkgyu"ykvj" rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"kpfkecvkpi"vjcv"vjg{"oc{"jcxg"dggp"gzrqugf"vq"kuqncvgf"kpekfgpvu"qh"ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv."dwv"vjcv"vjg"yqtmrnceg"pqpgvjgnguu"ycu"pqv"rgtogcvgf"ykvj"ugzwcnn{"qhhgpukxg"cpf" fgitcfkpi"dgjcxkqt09" " Hqt"gzcorng."kp"cp"GGQE"kpvgtxkgy."qpg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"kpfkecvgf" vjcv" ujg" qpeg" ycu" kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{" vqwejgf" d{" c" eq/yqtmgt" dwv" vjcv" ujg" pgxgt" jgctf" cp{" ugzwcn" eqoogpvu"qt"ucy"cp{"ugzwcn"rkevwtgu."ectxkpiu."itchhkvk."qt"vjg"nkmg0" " ]Ugg"546/;2"*Rnu0Óu"Gz0";2"Î" Rwvcvkxg" Encuu" Ogodgt" Swguvkqppcktg+0_" " Kv" ku" rtqdngocvke" vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf" fqgu" pqv" cfftguu" vjku"gxkfgpeg0:" " Gzrgtvu"yjq"gpicig"kp"ejgtt{/rkemkpi"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"hckn"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"uekgpvkhke" ogvjqf"cpf"Daubert0" " Fail-Safe, LLC v. A.O. Smith Corp.."966"H0"Uwrr0"4f":92."::;"*G0F0"Yku0" 4232+="ugg"cnuq"Barber v. United Airlines, Inc.."39"H0"CrrÓz"655."659"*9vj"Ekt0"4223+"*vguvkoqp{" gzenwfgf" yjgtg" gzrgtv" Ðogtgn{" ceegrvgf" uqog" qh" vjg" vguvkoqp{" cpf" ," ," ," fcvc" vjcv" uwkvgf" jku" vjgqt{"cpf"kipqtgf"qvjgt"rqtvkqpu"qh"kv"vjcv"fkf"pqvÑ+0" " Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"qhhgtgf"pq"tgurqpug"vq"vjku" ctiwogpv0" " " Dcugf"qp"vjg"ctiwogpvu"rtgugpvgf"d{"vjg"rctvkgu."vjg"Eqwtv"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg" pqv" ogv" vjgkt" dwtfgp" qh" guvcdnkujkpi" vjcv" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" qrkpkqpu" tgictfkpi" vjg" rtgxcngpeg" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" cv" vjg" RncpvuÏkpenwfkpi" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" vguvkoqp{" tgictfkpi" gcej" rwvcvkxg" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 9 " Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"uvcvgu"vjcv"Ðcodkgpv"jctcuuogpvÑ"tghgtu"Ðvq"vjg"gzrgtkgpeg"qh"yqtmkpi"kp"cp"gpxktqpogpv" rgtogcvgf"ykvj"ugzwcnn{"qhhgpukxg"cpf"fgitcfkpi"dgjcxkqt."vjcv"ku."c"jkijn{"ugzwcnk|gf"cvoqurjgtg"kp"yjkej" etwfg"cpf"qhhgpukxg"ocvgtkcnu"ctg"eqooqp"cpf"gornq{ggu"ugg"jctcuukpi"dgjcxkqt"cu"pqtocvkxg."yjgvjgt" urgekhkecnn{"fktgevgf"cv"vjgo"qt"pqv0Ñ" " ]548/3"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"Tgr0+."cv"350_" " " " : " Fghgpfcpv"cuugtvgf"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"hckngf"vq"cfftguu"vjku"gxkfgpeg."cpf"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"kfgpvkhkgf" cp{vjkpi" kp" vjg" tgeqtf" kpfkecvkpi" vjcv" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" fkf" eqpukfgt" vjku" gxkfgpeg0" " Vjg" Eqwtv" vjgtghqtg" ceegrvu"FghgpfcpvÓu"wpeqpvtqxgtvgf"tgrtgugpvcvkqp"vjcv"vjku"gxkfgpeg"ycu"pqv"cfftguugf"ykvjqwv"eqodkpi" vjg"tgeqtf"vq"eqphkto"kv0" " " 44" encuu"ogodgtu"gzrquwtg"vq"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cpf1qt"codkgpv"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpvÏctg"dcugf"qp" tgnkcdng"ogvjqfu0" " Vjwu."vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"qhhgtu"qrkpkqpu"tgictfkpi"vjg"rtgxcngpeg" qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cv"vjg"Rncpvu."FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq"gzenwfg"vjg"vguvkoqp{"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf" ku"itcpvgf0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"jcxg"pqv"fgoqpuvtcvgf"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"vguvkoqp{Ïvq"vjg"gzvgpv"tgnkgf" wrqp"kp"vjgkt"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqpÏyqwnf"cuukuv"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev0" " Vq"dg"tgngxcpv."gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{"owuv"Ðjgnr"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev"vq"wpfgtuvcpf"vjg"gxkfgpeg"qt"vq"fgvgtokpg"c"hcev"kp"kuuwg.Ñ" Hgf0"T0"Gxkf0"924."cpf"cp"ÐgzrgtvÓu"qrkpkqp"ku"jgnrhwn"qpn{"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjg"gzrgtv"ftcyu"qp"uqog" urgekcn"umknn."mpqyngfig."qt"gzrgtkgpeg"vq"hqtowncvg"vjcv"qrkpkqp0Ñ" " United States v. Benson.";63" H04f"7;:."826"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;3+."co0"qp"wptgncvgf"itfu0.";79"H04f"523"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;4+0" " " Kp"vjgkt"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp."Rnckpvkhhu"tgn{"qp"vjg"gzrgtv"tgrqtv"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"vq" guvcdnkuj"vjg"hqnnqykpi<;" 30" Vjg"yqtm"hqteg"pwogtkecnn{"ku"fqokpcvgf"d{"ogp"cpf"vjcv"c"itgcv"oclqtkv{" qh"uwrgtxkuqtu"ctg"ocng"]545."cv"48_=" " " 40" Hgocng"gornq{ggu"cv"vjg"Rnckpvu"fq"pqv"mpqy"yjgtg"vq"iq"vq"eqornckp"]id0"cv" 59_=" " 50" FghgpfcpvÓu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqrgtn{"tgeqtf"cpf"vtcem"egtvckp"eqornckpvu"cdqwv" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" fgoqpuvtcvgu" vjg" ncem" qh" korqtvcpeg" vjcv" Fghgpfcpv" rncegf"qp"vjg"kuuwg"]id0"cv"64_=" " 60" Fghgpfcpv"jcu"dggp"qp"pqvkeg"hqt"{gctu"vjcv"yqogp"ctg"dgkpi"jctcuugf"cv" vjgug"Rncpvu."cpf"rqtpqitcrjke"itchhkvk"cpf"ocvgtkcnu"jcxg"dggp"gxkfgpv"kp" rwdnke"ctgcu"vjtqwijqwv"vjg"rncpvu."{gv"Fghgpfcpv"jcu"hckngf"vq"vcmg"ghhgevkxg" tgogfkcn"cevkqp"]id0"cv"8:_=" " " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ; " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ekvg"vq"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"tgrqtv"igpgtcnn{"hqt"vjg"rtqrqukvkqp"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"mpgy"qt"ujqwnf" jcxg" mpqyp" cdqwv" vjg" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" cpf" hckngf" vq" vcmg" crrtqrtkcvg" cevkqp" vq" rtgxgpv"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv0" " ]545."cv"580_" " Ykvjqwv"urgekhke"ekvcvkqpu"cu"vq"yjcv"rqtvkqpu"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" tgrqtv"uwrrqtv"vjku"dtqcf"rtqrqukvkqp."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"wpcdng"cfgswcvgn{"vq"cfftguu"RnckpvkhhÓu"ctiwogpv"cu"vq" vjku" rqkpv0" " Cickp." kv" ku" pqv" vjg" EqwtvÓu" tqng" vq" ueqwt" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" tgrqtv" hqt" ctiwogpvu" vjcv" uwrrqtv" RnckpvkhhuÓ"rqukvkqpu="Rnckpvkhhu"owuv"cv"ngcuv"rtqxkfg"rtqrgt"ekvcvkqpu0" 45" 70" Ocpcigtu" cv" cnn" ngxgnu" qh" vjg" Rncpvu" pqv" qpn{" vqngtcvgf" dwv" oqfgngf" vjg" etwfguv"uqtv"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"fwtkpi"vjg"rgtkqf"qh"eqornckpv"]id0"cv"8:_=" " " " 80" Vtckpkpi"qp"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"rqnkekgu"cpf"korngogpvcvkqp"qh"fkuekrnkpct{" ogcuwtgu" xktvwcnn{" fkucrrgctgf" hqnnqykpi" vjg" rtkqt" GGQE" oqpkvqtkpi" rgtkqf"vjcv"dgicp"kp"3;;;"]id0_=" " " 90" Fghgpfcpv" ockpvckpgf" c" rqnke{" qh" fgenkpkpi" vq" hkpf" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" enckou"eqttqdqtcvgf"ykvjqwv"eqttqdqtcvkpi"ykvpguugu."tguwnvkpi"kp"vjg"xcuv" oclqtkv{"qh"eqornckpvu"dgkpi"fgvgtokpgf"vq"dg"wphqwpfgf"]id0_=" " :0" Vjg"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"cv"Ðvjg"Rnckpvu"ku"jkijn{"ugzwcnk|gf."ngcfkpi"vq"jkij" ngxgnu"qh"codkgpv"jctcuuogpvÑ"]548/3"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"Tgr0+."cv"89_=" " " " ;0" Jctcuuogpv"cv"vjg"Rnckpvu"Ðku"uq"rgtxcukxgÑ"vjcv"gxgt{"hgocng"gornq{gg"qh" vjg"rncpvu"Ðkpgxkvcdn{Ñ"jcu"dggp"gzrqugf"vq"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv."vq"c"itgcvgt" qt"nguugt"fgitgg"]id0"cv"8:_=" " " " 320"Vjcv" vjg" pgy" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" ku" guugpvkcnn{" c" tgrtkpv" qh" vjg" qnf" citggogpv"]545."cv"332_0" " " " Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"qhhgtu"ngicn"qrkpkqpu"qt"eqpenwukqpu"tgictfkpi"RnckpvkhhuÓ" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" enckou." vjg" Eqwtv" citggu" vjcv" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" vguvkoqp{" ku" wpjgnrhwn0" " Vjg" Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"gzrgtvu"oc{"rtqxkfg"Ðeqpetgvg"kphqtocvkqp"cickpuv"yjkej"vq" ogcuwtg"cduvtcev"ngicn"eqpegrvuÑ"dwv"ecppqv"ogtgn{"uvcvg"Ðc"ngicn"eqpenwukqp0Ñ" " United States v. Blount."724"H05f"896."8:2"*9vj"Ekt0"4229+0" " Eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjcv"crrtqcej."eqwtvu"jcxg"eqpenwfgf" vjcv"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"kp"vjg"hqto"qh"ngicn"eqpenwukqpu"ku"pqv"jgnrhwn"vq"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev"cpf"vjcv"uwej" vguvkoqp{" vjgtghqtg" ujqwnf" dg" gzenwfg" wpfgt" Twng" 9240" " Ugg" RLJCS Enterprises, Inc. v. Professional Benefit Trust Multiple Employer Welfare Benefit Plan & Trust."6:9"H05f"6;6."6;:" *9vj"Ekt04229+"*ÐCtiwogpv"cdqwv"vjg"ogcpkpi"qh",",","eqpvtcevu",",","dgnqpiu"kp"dtkghu."pqv"kp" ÒgzrgtvuÓ"tgrqtvuÓÑ+="Sommerfield v. City of Chicago."476"H0T0F0"539."552"*P0F0Knn0422:+"*Ðgzrgtv" vguvkoqp{"vjcv"eqpvckpu"c"ngicn"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"fgvgtokpgu"vjg"qwveqog"qh"c"ecug"ku"kpcfokuukdngÑ+=" Apotex Corp. v. Merck & Co., Inc.."4228"YN"3377;76."cv",:"*P0F0"Knn0"Crt047."4228+"*gzenwfkpi" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" vjcv" eqpukuvgf" qh" Ðrnckpn{" kpcfokuukdng" ngicn" eqpenwukqpuÑ" vjcv" Ðyqwnf" dg" 46" eqorngvgn{"wpjgnrhwn"vq"vjg"hcev"hkpfgtÑ+="Clintec Nutrition Co. v. Baxa Corp.."3;;:"YN"7824:6." cv",;"*P0F0"Knn0"Cwi048."3;;:+"*ÐNgicn"eqpenwukqpu"ctg"pqv"cfokuukdng"dgecwug"vjg{"ctg"pqv"jgnrhwn" vq" vjg" vtkgt" qh" hcevÑ+0" " Jgtg." egtvckp" qh" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" qrkpkqpu" ctg" kp" vjg" hqto" qh" ngicn" eqpenwukqpuÏurgekhkecnn{." Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" qrkpkqpu" tgictfkpi" vjg" gzrquwtg" qh" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu"vq"cevkqpcdng"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv0" " Dgecwug"vjgug"qrkpkqpu"ctg"wpjgnrhwn"vq"vjg"vtkgt"qh" hcev."vjg"Eqwtv"itcpvu"FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq"gzenwfg"uwej"vguvkoqp{"qp"vjcv"dcuku0" " " Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"vguvkoqp{"ku"ekvgf"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"hcevwcn"cuugtvkqpu"vjcv" ecp"dg"guvcdnkujgf"ykvjqwv"tguqtv"vq"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpuÏcu"vjg{"tgncvg"vq" RnckpvkhhuÓ" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqpÏcnuq" fq" pqv" jgnr" vjg" vtkgt" qh" hcev" vq" wpfgtuvcpf" vjg" gxkfgpeg"qt"vq"fgvgtokpg"c"hcev"kp"kuuwg0" " Hqt"gzcorng."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"gzrgtvkug"ku"pqv"jgnrhwn"hqt" fgvgtokpkpi"yjgvjgt"vjg"yqtm"hqteg"pwogtkecnn{"ku"fqokpcvgf"d{"ogp032" " Ukoknctn{."vq"vjg"gzvgpv" vjcv" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" vguvkoqp{" ku" ekvgf" kp" cp" cvvgorv" vq" gzrnckp" FghgpfcpvÓu" eqtrqtcvg" uvcvg" qh" okpf."jgt"qrkpkqpu"fq"pqv"jgnr"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev0" " Kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjgkt"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp." Rnckpvkhhu"ekvg"igpgtcnn{"vq"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"gpvktg"tgrqtv"cpf"cuugtv"vjcv"Ð]d_g{qpf"gxkfgpeg"qh"c" eqooqp"rtcevkegu"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cickpuv"yqogp"cv"vjg"]Rncpvu_."]Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu_"tgrqtv" kornkecvgu"eqooqp"swguvkqpu"tgncvkpi"vq"]FghgpfcpvÓu_"mpqyngfig"qh"vqngtcvkqp"qh"vjku"rgtxcukxg." u{uvgocvke"rtcevkeg"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cickpuv"yqogp"cpf"c"rqnke{"qh"tgvcnkcvkqp"cickpuv"vjqug" yjq"qrrqug"kv0Ñ" " ]545."cv"89/8:0_" " Jqygxgt."kv"ku"pqv"engct"vq"vjg"Eqwtv"yj{"uekgpvkhke."vgejpkecn." """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 32 " Jcf"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"fqpg"uqog"mkpf"qh"uvcvkuvkecn"cpcn{uku"vq"fgvgtokpg"vjku"hcev."uwej"cp"cpcn{uku"okijv"dg" tgngxcpv" kh" ujg" ygtg" rtqrgtn{" swcnkhkgf" vq" crrn{" urgekcnk|gf" mpqyngfig" cpf" vtckpkpi" cu" c" uvcvkuvkekcp0" " Jqygxgt."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"crrgctu"vq"tgn{"qp"wpfgtn{kpi"fcvc"vq"guvcdnkuj"vjku"hcev0" " ]548/3"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf" Tgr0+."cv"39/3:0_" " Vjg"fcvc"urgcmu"hqt"kvugnh"cpf"ecp"dg"kpvtqfwegf"vjtqwij"nc{"ykvpguugu"ykvj"hktuv/jcpf" qdugtxcvkqpu."tcvjgt"vjcp"d{"cp"gzrgtv"yjq"rcttqvu"yjcv"qvjgtu"jcxg"vqnf"jgt0" " Vq"dg"uwtg."Twng"925"cnnqyu" gzrgtvu" vq" tgn{" qp" hcevu" rtqxkfgf" d{" qvjgtu." gxgp" ncy{gtu0" " Dwv." cu" pqvgf" cdqxg." vjg" gzrgtv" rtqxkfgu" vguvkoqp{"qh"xcnwg"vq"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev"qpn{"kh"ujg"vjgp"crrnkgu"vjqug"hcevu."wukpi"c"tgnkcdng"ogvjqfqnqi{"cpf" uwrrn{kpi" c" nqikecn" ejckp" qh" tgcuqpkpi." vq" tgcej" c" eqpenwukqp" vjcv" ku" tgngxcpv" vq" cp" kuuwg" kp" vjg" ecug0" " Fgvgtokpkpi" yjgvjgt" c" rtqrqugf" gzrgtv" jcu" hqnnqygf" vjcv" rcvj" ku" vjg" guugpeg" qh" vjg" Daubert1Twng" 924" ÐicvgmggrkpiÑ"kpswkt{"tgswktgf"qh"fkuvtkev"lwfigu0" " 47" qt" urgekcnk|gf" mpqyngfig" ku" pgeguuct{." qt" gxgp" jgnrhwn." kp" fgvgtokpkpi" yjgp" Fghgpfcpv" cpf" FghgpfcpvÓu" gornq{ggu" mpgy" qt" ujqwnf" jcxg" mpqyp" cdqwv" egtvckp" cevkqpu" cpf1qt" eqpfkvkqpu0" " Hkpcnn{."vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"rtqxkfgu"qrkpkqpu"tgictfkpi"ukoknctkvkgu"dgvyggp"vjg"3;;;" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" cpf" vjg" 4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv." vjg" Eqwtv" cnuq" hkpfu" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu"vguvkoqp{"vq"dg"wpjgnrhwn."cu"vjg"Eqwtv"cpf1qt"vjg"vtkgt"qh"hcev"ctg"gswcnn{"ecrcdng"qh" eqorctkpi"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjg"citggogpvu033" " Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpu"cfftguu" vjgug"kuuwgu."FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq"gzenwfg"vjg"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ku"itcpvgf0" " " Uvknn."dcugf"qp"vjg"ocvgtkcnu"dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"oc{"dg"cdng"vq"qhhgt"rtqrgt" gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"tgictfkpi"vjg"rtqrgt"rtqegfwtgu"vq"rtgxgpv"cpf"tgurqpf"vq"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv0" " Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"cnuq"oc{"dg"cdng"vq"qhhgt"rtqrgt"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"tgictfkpi"yjgvjgt"cpf"vq"yjcv" gzvgpv" FghgpfcpvÓu" rtqegfwtgu" cpf" tgurqpugu" ctg" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjqug" rtqrgt" rtqegfwtgu0" " FghgpfcpvÓu"ctiwogpvu"hqt"gzenwfkpi"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"vguvkoqp{"fq"pqv"hqewu"qp"vjcv"vguvkoqp{0" " Vjwu." vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" FghgpfcpvÓu" oqxg" vq" gzenwfg" vjcv" vguvkoqp{." FghgpfcpvÓu" oqvkqp" vq" gzenwfg"vjg"vguvkoqp{"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"ku"fgpkgf"ykvjqwv"rtglwfkeg"vq"tgpgycn"ncvgt"kp"vjg"ecug0" " Hkpcnn{." kv" dgctu" tgrgcvkpi" vjcv" lwuv" dgecwug" Rnckpvkhhu" oc{" pqv" kpvtqfweg" egtvckp" hcevu" vjtqwij" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf." vjqug" hcevu" tgockp" kpfgrgpfgpvn{" cfokuukdng" vjtqwij" hcev" ykvpguuguÏcpf" vjwu" tgockp" dghqtg" vjg" Eqwtv" kp" kvu" eqpukfgtcvkqp" qh" yjgvjgt" Rnckpvkhhu" ecp" ucvkuh{" vjg" Twng" 45" tgswktgogpvu"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" ii. Dr. Gregory Mitchell and Dr. Liza Gold Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" oqxgf" vq" gzenwfg" vjg" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" qh" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgdwvvcn" gzrgtv" ykvpguuguÏuqekcn" ru{ejqnqikuv" cpf" ncy" rtqhguuqt" Ft0" Itgiqt{" Okvejgnn." L0F0." Rj0F0." cpf" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 33 " Kp"cp{"gxgpv."cu"fkuewuugf"dgnqy."vjg"Eqwtv"tglgevu"ocp{"qh"FghgpfcpvÓu"ctiwogpvu"tgictfkpi"vjg"4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp"Citggogpv"qdxkcvkpi"vjg"pggf"hqt"cp"cnvgtpcvkxg"ngicn"tgogf{0" " Vjwu."vjg"EqwtvÓu"cpcn{uku"qh" RnckpvkhhuÓ" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" yqwnf" pqv" ejcpig" gxgp" kh" vjg" Eqwtv" etgfkvgf" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" qrkpkqpu"qp"vjku"kuuwg0" " " 48" ru{ejkcvtkuv" Ft0" Nk|c" Iqnf." O0F0" " ]5920_" " Hktuv." Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcv" vjg" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" qh" Ft0"Okvejgnn"cpf"Ft0"Iqnf"ujqwnf"dg"gzenwfgf"dgecwug"vjgkt"vguvkoqp{"ku"kttgngxcpv"vq"vjg"hcevu"kp" vjku" ecug0" " Ugeqpf." Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcv" vjg" gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" qh" vjgug" ykvpguugu" ujqwnf" dg" gzenwfgf"dgecwug"pgkvjgt"qhhgt"vguvkoqp{"tgngxcpv"vq"vjg"kuuwg"qh"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Vjktf."cu"vq" Ft0"Iqnf."Rnckpvkhhu"tckug"uwduvcpvkxg"ejcnngpigu"vq"jgt"qrkpkqpu0" " " " Ykvj" tgurgev" vq" vjg" hktuv" ctiwogpv." Rnckpvkhhu" okuejctcevgtk|g" FghgpfcpvÓu" rqukvkqp0" " Fghgpfcpv"fqgu"pqv"ctiwg"vjcv"gzrgtv"vguvkoqp{"pggf"pqv"eqorn{"ykvj"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh"Twng"qh" 924"cpf"Daubert."cu"Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf0" " ]5:9."cv"4/50_" " Tcvjgt."Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"gzrgtv" vguvkoqp{" qh" Ft0" Okvejgnn" cpf" Ft0" Iqnf" ku" tgngxcpv" vq" wpfgtuvcpfkpi" vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf."yjkej"Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" ocfg" cp" kuuwg" kp" vjku" ecug"d{"tgn{kpi"qp"jgt"vguvkoqp{"kp" uwrrqtv" qh" vjgkt" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Gxgp" kh" FghgpfcpvÓu" gzrgtvu" fkf" pqv" cpcn{|g" gxkfgpeg"kp"vjku"ecug."Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"gzrnckp"yj{"vjgkt"vguvkoqp{"ku"pqv"tgngxcpv"vq"wpfgtuvcpfkpi" cpf"cpcn{|kpi"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"rtqrqugf"vguvkoqp{0" " " Vjcv" ngcfu" vq" RnckpvkhhuÓ" ugeqpf" ctiwogpvÏvjcv" vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgdwvvcn" gzrgtvu" ujqwnf" dg" gzenwfgf" dgecwug" kv" ku" pqv" tgngxcpv" vq" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" kuuwgu0" " Cickp." vjku" ctiwogpv" okuugu" vjg" octm0" " Fghgpfcpv" tgn{" qp" vjgkt" gzrgtvu" vq" tgdwv" vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf."wrqp"yjkej"Rnckpvkhhu"tgn{"kp"vjgkt"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " " Vjcv" ngcxgu" RnckpvkhhuÓ" uwduvcpvkxg" ejcnngpigu" vq" Ft0" IqnfÓu" qrkpkqpu034" " Kp" jgt" tgdwvvcn" tgrqtv." Ft0" Iqnf" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" *3+" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" fqgu" pqv" jcxg" c" uekgpvkhke" dcuku" vq" qhhgt" eqpenwukqpu" cu" vq" yjgvjgt" rctvkewnct" rnckpvkhhu" qt" c" encuu" gzrgtkgpegf" vjg" eqpfwev" cnngigf." *4+"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" kornkecvkqp" vjcv" cnn" ugzwcn" eqpfwev" kp" vjg" yqtmrnceg" ku" qhhgpukxg" cpf" wpygneqog"vq"cnn"yqogp"cnuq"ku"uekgpvkhkecnn{"kpxcnkf."*5+"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"fqgu"pqv"jcxg"c"uekgpvkhke" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 34 " Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"ejcnngpig"vjg"swcnkhkecvkqpu"qh"Ft0"Iqnf"cu"ygnn"cu"vjg"uwduvcpeg"qh"jgt"qrkpkqpu."vjg{" fq"pqv"ocmg"ukoknct"ejcnngpigu"cu"vq"Ft0"Okvejgnn0" " " 49" dcuku"vq"qhhgt"eqpenwukqpu"cu"vq"yjgvjgt"cp{"rnckpvkhh"uwhhgtgf"ru{ejqnqikecn"eqpugswgpegu"cu"c" tguwnv"qh"vjg"eqpfwev"cnngigf."cpf"*6+"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"fqgu"pqv"jcxg"c"xcnkf"uekgpvkhke"dcuku"vq"qhhgt" eqpenwukqpu" cu" vq" yjgvjgt" RnckpvkhhuÓ" gzrgtkgpegu" ygtg" kp" hcev"ukoknct" vq" gcej" qvjgt" qt" vq" qvjgt" yqogp"yqtmkpi"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " ]Ugg"593/60_" " " Cu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg."dgecwug"vjg"Eqwtv"ku"itcpvkpi" FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq"gzenwfg"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"rqtvkqpu"qh"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"vguvkoqp{"tgncvkpi"vq" vjgug"kuuwgu"ykvjqwv"tgnkcpeg"qp"vjg"tgdwvvcn"tgrqtv"qh"Ft0"Iqnf."vjg"Eqwtv"fgpkgu"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp" vq" gzenwfg" vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" Ft0" Iqnf" cu" oqqv0" " Vjg" Eqwtv" cnuq" fgpkgu" FghgpfcpvÓu" oqvkqp" vq" gzenwfg"vjg"vguvkoqp{"qh"Ft0"Okvejgnn."cu"vjg"Eqwtv"tglgevgf"vjg"vyq"qdlgevkqpu"Rnckpvkhhu"tckugf"cu" vq"jku"vguvkoqp{0" " Hkpcnn{Ïcpf"rgtjcru"qdxkqwun{Ïikxgp"vjcv"Ftu0"Iqnf"cpf"Okvejgnn"jcxg"dggp" qhhgtgf" cu" rebuttal ykvpguugu." vjg" gzenwukqp" qh" rqtvkqpu" qh" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" rtqrqugf" vguvkoqp{" fkokpkujgu" vjg" ukipkhkecpeg" qh" vjg" vguvkoqp{" rtqrqugf" vq" tgdwv" Ft0" Hkv|igtcnfÓu" kpcfokuukdng" qrkpkqpu0" " D0" Eqooqpcnkv{"wpfgt"Twng"45*c+*4+" " Hqt"c"encuu"vq"dg"egtvkhkgf."swguvkqpu"qh"ncy"qt"hcev"owuv"gzkuv"eqooqp"vq"vjg"encuu0" " Hgf0"T0" Ekx0"R0"45*c+*4+0" " Qpn{"qpg"eqooqp"swguvkqp"ku"pgeguuct{"vq"ucvkuh{"Twng"45*c+Óu"eqooqpcnkv{" tgswktgogpv0" " Ugg"Dukes."786"W0U0"cv"57;"*ÐYg"swkvg"citgg"vjcv"hqt"rwtrqugu"qh"Twng"45*c+*4+" gxgp" c" ukping" eqooqp" swguvkqp" yknn" fq0Ñ" *ekvcvkqp." kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu." cpf" cnvgtcvkqpu" qokvvgf++="Walker v. Bankers Life & Cas. Co.."4229"YN"4;253:2.",6"*P0F0"Knn0"Qev0"3."4229+"*ÐPqv" cnn" hcevwcn" qt" ngicn" swguvkqpu" tckugf" kp" c" ncyuwkv" pggf" dg" eqooqp" uq" nqpi" cu" c" ukping" kuuwg" ku" eqooqp" vq" cnn" encuu" ogodgtu0Ñ" *ekvcvkqp" cpf" kpvgtpcn" swqvcvkqp" octmu" qokvvgf++0" " Jqygxgt." uwrgthkekcn" eqooqp" swguvkqpuÏnkmg" yjgvjgt" gcej" encuu" ogodgt" ujctgu" c" ejctcevgtkuvke" qt" Ðuwhhgtgf"c"xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg"ucog"rtqxkukqp"qh"ncyÑÏctg"pqv"gpqwij0" " Jamie S. v. Milwaukee Pub. Sch0." 88:" H05f" 6:3." 6;9" *9vj" Ekt0" 4234+" *swqvkpi" Dukes." 786" W0U0" 572+0" " Eqooqpcnkv{" vjwu" 4:" tgswktgu"c"eqooqp"kuuwg"ecrcdng"qh"encuu/ykfg"tguqnwvkqp."Ðyjkej"ogcpu"vjcv"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qh"kvu" vtwvj"qt"hcnukv{"yknn"tguqnxg"cp"kuuwg"vjcv"ku"egpvtcn"vq"vjg"xcnkfkv{"qh"gcej"qpg"qh"vjg"enckou"kp"qpg" uvtqmg0Ñ" " Dukes."786"W0U0"cv"5720" " Kp"qtfgt"vq"dtkpi"qvjgtykug"jkijn{"kpfkxkfwcnk|gf"enckou"cu"c" encuu."vjg"encuu"owuv"guvcdnkuj"u{uvgoke"xkqncvkqpu"qt"cp"knngicn"rqnke{0" " Jamie S.."88:"H05f"cv"6;90" " ÐÒKh."vq"ocmg"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ujqykpi"qp"c"ikxgp"swguvkqp."vjg"ogodgtu"qh"c"rtqrqugf"encuu"yknn"pggf" vq"rtgugpv"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"xctkgu"htqo"ogodgt"vq"ogodgt."vjgp"kv"ku"cp"kpfkxkfwcn"swguvkqp0" " Kh"vjg" ucog"gxkfgpeg"yknn"uwhhkeg"hqt"gcej"ogodgt"vq"ocmg"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ujqykpi."vjgp"kv"dgeqogu"c" eqooqp"swguvkqp0ÓÑ" " Messner."88;"H05f"cv":37"*ekvcvkqp"cpf"kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+=" ugg"cnuq"Tyson Foods, Inc. v. Bouaphakeo."358"U0"Ev0"3258."3267"*4238+"*Eqooqp"swguvkqpu"gzkuv" yjgtg"Ðvjg"ucog"gxkfgpeg"yknn"uwhhkeg"hqt"gcej"ogodgt"vq"ocmg"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ujqykpi"]qt_"vjg" kuuwg"ku"uwuegrvkdng"vq"igpgtcnk|gf."encuu/ykfg"rtqqh0Ñ"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf++0" " " Rnckpvkhhu" eqpvgpf" vjcv" vjg{" jcxg" ogv" vjgkt" dwtfgp" qh" guvcdnkujkpi" eqooqpcnkv{" d{" kfgpvkh{kpi"ukipkhkecpv"rtqqh"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"Ðqrgtcvgf"wpfgt"c"igpgtcn"rqnke{"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp.Ñ" yjkej"ku"cp"ceegrvcdng"ogvjqf"qh"guvcdnkujkpi"eqooqpcnkv{0" " Dukes."786"W0U0"cv"5750" " Cu"ycu" vjg"ecug"kp"Dukes."rtqqh"qh"eqooqpcnkv{"kp"vjku"ecug"pgeguuctkn{"qxgtncru"ykvj"RnckpvkhhuÓ"ogtkvu" eqpvgpvkqp" vjcv" Fghgpfcpv" gpicigf" kp" c" rcvvgtp" qt" rtcevkeg" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0" " 786" W0U0" cv" 573/740" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"cfftguugu"vjg"ogtkvu"qh"RnckpvkhhuÓ"enckou"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"pgeguuct{"vq" gxcnwcvg"Twng"45*c+Óu"eqooqpcnkv{"tgswktgogpv0" " Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"vjg{"jcxg"cnngigf"ugxgtg" cpf" qpiqkpi" jctcuukpi" dgjcxkqt" vjtqwijqwv" vjgkt" gornq{ogpv" ykvj" Fghgpfcpv0" " Kp" rctvkewnct." Rnckpvkhhu"cnngig"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"jcu<" ‚" Ockpvckpgf" c" rqnke{" qh" hcknkpi" vq" vcmg" rtqorv" tgogfkcn" cevkqp" kp" tgurqpug" vq" etgfkdng" cnngicvkqpu" qh" jctcuuogpv." fgurkvg" tgrqtvu" vq" FghgpfcpvÓu" Jwocp" Tguqwtegu"fgrctvogpvu."uwrgtxkuqtu."cpf"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"jqvnkpg=" " " " ‚" Cu"c"twng."cnnqygf"mpqyp"jctcuugtu"vq"tgockp"kp"vjg"yqtmrnceg=" " 4;" ‚" Hckngf" vq" fkuekrnkpg" jctcuugtu" fgurkvg" vjg" jctcuuogpv" dgkpi" ykvpguugf" d{" uwrgtxkuqtu=" " ‚" Vjtgcvgpgf"hgocng"eqornckpcpvu"ykvj"vgtokpcvkqp"qt"qvjgt"cfxgtug"cevkqpu=" " " ‚" Cuukipgf"hgocng"gornq{ggu"yjq"tglgevgf"ugzwcn"cfxcpegu"vq"nguu"fguktcdng"vcumu=" cpf" " ‚" Gpicigf"kp"qvjgt"okueqpfwev0" " " " ]545."cv"870_" " Rnckpvkhh"cuugtvu"vjcv"Ð]v_jgug"eqooqp"swguvkqpu"cpf"kuuwgu"tgictfkpi"vjg"gzvgpukxg" cpf"hct/tgcejkpi"rtcevkeg"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cpf"tgvcnkcvkqp"cv"vjg"]Rncpvu_"ctg"cv"vjg"eqtg"qh"cnn" vjg"Vkvng"XKK"enckou"jgnf"d{"vjg"rtqrqugf"encuu"kp"vjku"ecug0Ñ" " ]545."cv"880_" " Jqygxgt."kp"vjgkt" qrgpkpi"dtkgh."Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"eqppgev"vjgug"rwtrqtvgf"swguvkqpu"vq"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt"enckou0" " Cu" pqvgf" kp" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgurqpug" dtkgh." vjg" Eqwtv" urgekhkecnn{" fktgevgf" vjcvÏujqwnf" Rnckpvkhhu" cickp"oqxg"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqpÏRnckpvkhhu"ujqwnf"cfftguu"vq"yjcv"gzvgpv"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt" enckou" ecp" dg" fgekfgf" qp" c" encuu/ykfg" dcuku0" " ]528." cv" 370_" " ÐCpcn{uku" qh" rtgfqokpcpeg" wpfgt" Twng"45*d+*5+.Ó"cpf"vjwu"qh"eqooqpcnkv{"wpfgt"Twng"45*c+*4+."Òdgikpu",",","ykvj"vjg"gngogpvu"qh" vjg"wpfgtn{kpi"ecwug"qh"cevkqp0ÓÑ" " Boundas v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores, Inc.."4:2"H0T0F0"62:." 635"*P0F0"Knn0"4234+"*swqvkpi"Messner,"88;"H05f"cv":37+0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"vwtpu"vq"cp"cpcn{uku" qh"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjg"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"enckou"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"uggm"vq"dtkpi0" " " i. Pattern-and-Practice Analysis RnckpvkhhuÓ" qrgpkpi" dtkgh" cfftguugu" vjg" rcvvgtp/qt/rtcevkeg" ogvjqf" qh" guvcdnkujkpi" fkuetkokpcvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"htcogyqtm"ugv"hqtvj"kp"International Brotherhood of Teamsters v. United States."653"W0U0"546"*3;99+0" " ÐRcvvgtp/qt/rtcevkeg"enckou",",","tgrtgugpv"c"vjgqt{"qh"kpvgpvkqpcn" fkuetkokpcvkqp0Ñ" " Puffer v. Allstate Ins. Co.."897"H05f"92;."938/39"*9vj"Ekt0"4234+"*ekvkpi"Council 31, Am. Fed’n of State, Cnty. & Mun. Emps., AFL-CIO v. Ward." ;9:" H04f" 595." 59:" *9vj" Ekt0" 3;;4++0" " ÐRcvvgtp/qt/rtcevkeg" enckou" tgswktg" c" Òujqykpi" vjcv" cp" gornq{gt" tgiwnctn{" cpf" 52" rwtrqughwnn{"fkuetkokpcvgu"cickpuv"c"rtqvgevgf"itqwr0ÓÑ" " Id0"*swqvkpi"Ward.";9:"H04f"cv"59:+0" " Vq" guvcdnkuj"fkuetkokpcvkqp"wpfgt"uwej"c"vjgqt{."ÐRnckpvkhhu"owuv"rtqxg"vjcv"fkuetkokpcvkqp"Òycu"vjg" eqorcp{Óu" uvcpfctf" qrgtcvkpi" rtqegfwtgÏvjg" tgiwnct" tcvjgt" vjcp" vjg" wpwuwcn" rtcevkeg0ÓÑ" " Id0" *swqvkpi"Int’l Bhd. of Teamsters."653"W0U0"cv"558+0" " " Vjku"ogvjqf"qh"rtqxkpi"fkuetkokpcvkqp"qhvgp"eqogu"wr"kp"vjg"eqpvgzv"qh"jktkpi"rtcevkegu0" " E.E.O.C. v. Int’l Profit Assocs., Inc.."4229"YN"534228;."cv",4"*P0F0"Knn0"Qev0"45."4229+"*Ð]V_jg" vtcfkvkqpcn"Òrcvvgtp"qt"rtcevkegÓ"htcogyqtm"ycu"fgxgnqrgf"d{"vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"kp"Teamsters."c" ecug"fgcnkpi"ykvj"tcekcnn{"fkuetkokpcvqt{"jktkpi"cpf"rtqoqvkqp"rtcevkegu0Ñ+0" " Hqt"gzcorng."Ð]k_h"cp" gornq{gt" jcu" cp" guvcdnkujgf" rqnke{" qh" ocmkpi" gornq{ogpv" fgekukqpu" ykvj" tcekcn" cpkowu" kp" xkqncvkqp"qh"Vkvng"XKK."kv"ku"nkmgn{"vjcv"cp{"urgekhke"gornq{ogpv"fgekukqp"cnuq"xkqncvgu"Vkvng"XKK."cpf" kh"c"rctvkewnct"fgekukqp"ycu"pqv"fkuetkokpcvqt{."vjg"gornq{gt"ku"kp"vjg"dguv"rqukvkqp"vq"ujqy"yj{0Ñ" " Id0="ugg"cnuq"Chicago Teachers Union, Local No. 1 v. Bd. of Educ. of City of Chicago."9;9"H05f" 648."663"*9vj"Ekt0"4237+"*eqpenwfkpi"vjcv"encuu"qh"Chtkecp/Cogtkecp"vgcejgtu"eqwnf"dtkpi"c"encuu" cevkqp"ejcnngpikpi"gornq{gtÓu"vwtpctqwpf"rqnke{"qp"vjg"dcuku"vjcv"rqnke{"tguwnvgf"kp"c"fkurctcvg" korcev" qp" Chtkecp/Cogtkecp" vgcejgtu+0" " Vjwu." cu" pqvgf" d{" Rnckpvkhhu." vjg" nkcdknkv{" rjcug" kp" c" rcvvgtp/cpf/rtcevkeg"ecug"fqgu"pqv"tgswktg"ujqykpi"vjcv"gcej"kpfkxkfwcn"ogodgt"qh"vjg"encuu"ycu"c" xkevko"qh"vjg"gornq{gtÓu"fkuetkokpcvqt{"rqnke{."ukpeg"rtqqh"qh"vjg"rcvvgtp"qt"rtcevkeg"uwrrqtvu"cp" kphgtgpeg"vjcv"cp{"rctvkewnct"gornq{ogpv"fgekukqp"fwtkpi"vjg"rgtkqf"kp"yjkej"vjg"fkuetkokpcvqt{" rqnke{"ycu"kp"hqteg"ycu"ocfg"rwtuwcpv"vq"vjcv"rqnke{0" " ]545."cv"84/850_" " " Jqygxgt."kv"ku"pqv"engct"vq"vjg"Eqwtv"vjcv"uwej"c"encko"ecp"dg"dtqwijv"kp"vjg"eqpvgzv"qh"vjku" ecug0" " Rnckpvkhhu"encko"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"jcu"ockpvckpgf"c"rqnke{"qh"hcknkpi"vq"vcmg"rtqorv"tgogfkcn" cevkqp" kp" tgurqpug" vq" etgfkdng" cnngicvkqpu" qh" jctcuuogpv0" " ]545." cv" 870_" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhhu" eqpvgpf"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"cu"c"twng"jcu"cnnqygf"mpqyp"jctcuugtu"vq"tgockp"kp"vjg"yqtmrnceg."hckngf"vq" 53" fkuekrnkpg" jctcuugtu" fgurkvg" vjg" jctcuuogpv" dgkpi" ykvpguugf" d{" uwrgtxkuqtu." vjtgcvgpgf" hgocng" eqornckpcpvu" ykvj" vgtokpcvkqp" qt" qvjgtykug" tgrtkocpfgf" hgocng" eqornckpcpvu." cuukipgf" nguu" fguktcdng" vcumu" vq" yqogp" yjq" fkf" pqv" uwdokv" vq" ugzwcn" cfxcpegu." coqpi" qvjgt" eqpfwev0" " ]Id0" *ekvkpi" Ugeqpf" Cogpfgf" Eqornckpv+0_" " Cnvjqwij" Rnckpvkhhu" ekvg" vq" cnngicvkqpu" kp" vjg" ugeqpf" cogpfgf"eqornckpv"vq"uwrrqtv"vjgug"cuugtvkqpu."yjkej"ctg"kpuwhhkekgpv"vq"ectt{"FghgpfcpvÓu"dwtfgp" qh" ucvkuh{kpi" Twng" 45." Rnckpvkhhu" tgpgygf" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" gnugyjgtg" kfgpvkhkgu" cpgefqvcn"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"egtvckp"qh"FghgpfcpvÓu"gornq{ggu"jcxg"gpicigf"kp"uwej"eqpfwev0" " " " Gxgp"cuuwokpi"vjgug"hcevu"vq"dg"vtwg."jqygxgt."Ðc"hkpfkpi"vjcv"cp"gornq{gt"jcf"c"rcvvgtp"qt" rtcevkeg"qh"vqngtcvkpi"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"kp"xkqncvkqp"qh"Vkvng"XKK"fqgu"pqv"pgeguuctkn{"guvcdnkuj"vjcv" cp"kpfkxkfwcn"enckocpv"ycu"gzrqugf"vq"jctcuuogpv"qt"vjcv"vjg"jctcuuogpv"cp"kpfkxkfwcn"enckocpv" uwhhgtgf"xkqncvgu"Vkvng"XKK0Ñ" " Int’l Profit Assocs., Inc.."4229"YN"534228;."cv",50" " Vjg"Teamsters" rcvvgtp/qt/rtcevkeg"htcogyqtm"ecp"Ðcuukuv"c"eqwtvÓu"cpcn{uku"qh"yjgvjgt"c"fghgpfcpv"jcu"gpicigf"kp" c"rcvvgtp"qt"rtcevkeg"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp"rtqjkdkvgf"wpfgt"Vkvng"XKK.Ñ"dwv"kv"ku"Vkvng"XKK"kvugnh"Ðvjcv" fghkpgu"vjg"ueqrg"qh"rtqjkdkvgf"fkuetkokpcvkqp"cpf"ugvu"vjg"uwduvcpvkxg"dqwpfctkgu"ykvjkp"yjkej"vjg" ogvjqf"qh"rtqqh"owuv"qrgtcvg0Ñ35" " Hohider v. United Parcel Servs., Inc.."796"H05f"38;."3:5"*5f" Ekt0"422;+"*ekvkpi"Teamsters."653"W0U0"cv"558+0" " Kp"qvjgt"yqtfu."Ðcfqrvkpi"vjg"Teamsters ogvjqf" qh"rtqqh"vq"cflwfkecvg"rnckpvkhhuÓ"enckou"fqgu"pqv"qdxkcvg"vjg"pggf"vq"eqpukfgt"vjg",",","uvcvwvqt{" gngogpvuÑ"qh"vjg"urgekhke"ecwug"qh"cevkqp"rngf0" " Id0"cv"3990" Tgn{kpi"qp"ecugu"vjcv"jgnf"vjcv"Ðvjg"ncpfuecrg"qh"vjg"vqvcn"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv."tcvjgt"vjcp" vjg"uwdlgevkxg"gzrgtkgpegu"qh"gcej"kpfkxkfwcn"enckocpv."ku"vjg"hqewu"hqt"guvcdnkujkpi"c"rcvvgtp"qt" rtcevkeg"qh"wpygneqog"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"yjkej"ku"ugxgtg"cpf"rgtxcukxg.Ñ"Warnell v. Ford Motor Co.."3:;"H0T0F0"5:5."5:9"*P0F0"Knn0"3;;;+"*ekvkpi"EEOC v. Mitsubishi Motor Mfg. of America, Inc.." """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 35 " Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"gzrnckp"jqy"guvcdnkujkpi"vjg"rcvvgtp"cpf"rtcevkeg"kfgpvkhkgf"cdqxg"tgncvgu"vq"vjg"gngogpvu" qh"vjgkt"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou0" " 54" ;;2"H0"Uwrr0"327;."3296"*E0F0"Knn0"3;;:++."Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"Ðvjg"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"]ku_"vjg" eqooqp" kuuwg0Ñ" " ]545." cv" 88" *swqvkpi" Warnell." 3:;" H0T0F0" cv" 5:7+0_" " Vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" vjgug" ecugu"jqnf"vjcv"rnckpvkhhu"ecp"guvcdnkuj"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou"ykvjqwv"tghgtgpeg"vq"vjg" uwdlgevkxg"gzrgtkgpeg"qh"gcej"kpfkxkfwcn"enckocpv."vjg"Eqwtv"tgurgevhwnn{"fkucitggu036" " Cu"Lwfig" Iqvvuejcnn"gzrnckpgf"kp"International Profit Associates, Inc.."vjgug"ecugu"ctg"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg" Uwrtgog" EqwtvÓu" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" lwtkurtwfgpeg0" " 4229" YN" 534228;." cv" ,340" " Urgekhkecnn{."vjg{"qxgtnqqm"vjg"tgswktgogpv"vjcv"eqpfwev"uwdlgevkxgn{"dg"rgtegkxgf"d{"vjg"xkevko"vq" dg"cdwukxg"kp"qtfgt"vq"dg"cevkqpcdng0" " Harris v. Forklift Sys., Inc.."732"W0U0"39."43/44"*3;;5+"*Ð]K_h" vjg" xkevko" fqgu" pqv" uwdlgevkxgn{" rgtegkxg" vjg" gpxktqpogpv" vq" dg" cdwukxg." vjg" eqpfwev" jcu" pqv" cevwcnn{"cnvgtgf"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu"qh"vjg"xkevkoÓu"gornq{ogpv."cpf"vjgtg"ku"pq"Vkvng"XKK"xkqncvkqp0Ñ+0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"ecppqv"guvcdnkuj"nkcdknkv{"qp"vjgkt"kpfkxkfwcn"ugzwcn" jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou"dcugf"qp"c"rcvvgtp/cpf/rtcevkeg"vjgqt{037" " Kpuvgcf."vjg"Eqwtv"yknn" nqqm"vq"yjgvjgt"cp{"qh"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"RnckpvkhhuÓ"ugzwcn"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou"ecp"dg" cfftguugf"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku038" " " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 36 " Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"ekvg"vjgug"ecugu."Rnckpvkhhu"fq"pqv"fkuewuu"vjgo"gzvgpukxgn{0" " Kpuvgcf."Rnckpvkhhu"tgn{" jgcxkn{"qp"Sellars v. CRST Expedited, Inc.."kp"yjkej"vjg"eqwtv"egtvkhkgf"c"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"jquvkng"yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" encuu0" " Sellars v. CRST Expedited, Inc. (Sellers I)." 543" H0T0F0" 79:" *P0F0" Kqyc" 4239+0" " Jqygxgt."tgn{kpi"kp"rctv"qp"vjg"tgcuqpkpi"kp"International Profit Associations, Inc.."vjg"ucog"eqwtv"tgegpvn{" fgegtvkhkgf"vjg"encuu."eqpenwfkpi"vjcv"Ð]k_v"yqwnf"dg"wphckt"vq"eqpenwfg"vjcv"c"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"cu"c"yjqng" ku"jquvkng"d{"vcnn{kpi"wr"cnn"kpuvcpegu"qh"ugzwcn"okueqpfwev"yjgp"gcej"rgtuqp"kp"vjg"encuu"oc{"jcxg"dggp" uwdlgev"vq"qpn{"qpg"qh"vjqug"kpuvcpegu"cpf"wpcyctg"qh"vjg"qvjgtu0Ñ" " Sellars v. CRST Expedited, Inc. (Sellers II)."57;"H0"Uwrr0"5f"855."89:"*P0F0"Kqyc"423;+0" " 37 " Vjg"Eqwtv"ngcxgu"qrgp"vjg"rquukdknkv{"vjcv"c"uocnngt"itqwr"qh"Rnckpvkhhu"oc{"dg"cdng"vq"wug"vjg"Teamsters" uvcpfctf" vq" guvcdnkuj" vjg" qdlgevkxg" gngogpv" qh" vjgkt" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" encko." kh" vjg" itqwr" ycu" gzrqugf"vq"vjg"ucog"eqpfwev0" " " " 38 " Vjg"Eqwtv"cnuq"ngcxgu"qrgp"vjg"rquukdknkv{"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"ecp"guvcdnkuj"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"kplwpevkxg" tgnkgh" dcugf" qp" FghgpfcpvÓu" cnngigf" okueqpfwev." cu" c" rqnke{" qh" vqngtcvkpi" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" ku" kvugnh" c" xkqncvkqp0" " Int’l Profit Assocs., Inc.."4229"YN"534228;."cv",360" " Dgecwug"Rnckpvkhhu"rtkoctkn{"ctg"uggmkpi" fcocigu."jqygxgt."vjg"Eqwtv"hqewugu"kvu"cpcn{uku"tgictfkpi"RnckpvkhhuÓ"rcvvgtp"cpf"rtcevkeg"ctiwogpv"qp"vjg" fcocigu"enckou"cpf"yjgvjgt"vjqug"enckou"ecp"dg"dtqwijv"cu"c"encuu0" " " " 55" ii. Sexual Hostile Work Environment Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"qrgpkpi"dtkgh"hqewugu"qp"vjg"Teamsters"cpcn{uku."Rnckpvkhhu"fq"cfftguu" vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt"prima facie"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"encko"kp"vjgkt"tgrn{"dtkgh039" " ]5:6."cv" 4:/4;0_" " ÐVq" guvcdnkuj" c" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" encko." c" rnckpvkhh" owuv" ujqy" vjcv" ujg" ycu" Ò*3+"uwdlgevgf"vq"wpygneqog"ugzwcn"eqpfwev."cfxcpegu."qt"tgswguvu="*4+"dgecwug"qh"jgt"ugz="*5+"vjcv" ygtg"ugxgtg"qt"rgtxcukxg"gpqwij"vq"etgcvg"c"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv="cpf"*6+"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"dcuku" hqt" gornq{gt" nkcdknkv{0ÓÑ" " Equal Employment Opportunity Comm’n v. Costco Wholesale Corp.." ;25"H05f"83:."847"*9vj"Ekt0"423:+"*swqvkpi"Lapka v. Chertoff."739"H05f";96.";:4"*9vj"Ekt0"422:++0" " ÐWpfgt"Vkvng"XKK."cp"gornq{gt"ecp"cxqkf"nkcdknkv{"hqt"jquvkng"gpxktqpogpv"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"kh"kv" rtqorvn{" kpxguvkicvgu" c" eqornckpv" yjgp" ocfg" cpf" vjgp." kh" ycttcpvgf." Òvcmgu" uvgru" tgcuqpcdn{" nkmgn{"vq"uvqr"vjg"jctcuuogpv0ÓÑ"" Lucero v. Nettle Creek Sch. Corp.."788"H05f"942."953"*9vj"Ekt0" 422;+"*swqvkpi"Saxton v. AT&T,"32"H05f"748."758"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;5++0" Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcv" vjgtg" ku" c" eqooqp" swguvkqp" ykvj" tgurgev" vq" yjgvjgt" Rnckpvkhhu" ctg" yqogp"cpf"vjgtghqtg"rctv"qh"c"rtqvgevgf"encuu"dgecwug"vjku"ecp"dg"guvcdnkujgf"d{"cpuygtkpi"Ðc" ukping" eqooqp" swguvkqp" qh" yjgvjgt" yqogp" ocmg" wr" vjg" ]rtqrqugf_" encuu0Ñ" " ]5:6." cv" 4;0_" " Jqygxgt."gxgp"kh"vjg"rtqrqugf"encuu"fghkpkvkqp"nkokvu"vjg"encuu"vq"yqogp."rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu" uvknn"yqwnf"pggf"vq"ujqy"vjcv"vjg{"hcnn"ykvjkp"vjg"ueqrg"qh"vjg"encuu"fghkpkvkqp0" " Oqtgqxgt."kv"ku"ygnn" guvcdnkujgf" vjcv" uwrgthkekcn" eqooqp" swguvkqpuÏnkmg" yjgvjgt" gcej" encuu" ogodgt" ujctgu" c" ejctcevgtkuvke"qt"Ðuwhhgtgf"c"xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg"ucog"rtqxkukqp"qh"ncyÑÏctg"pqv"gpqwij"vq"guvcdnkuj" eqooqpcnkv{0" " Jamie S.."88:"H05f"cv"6;9"*pqvkpi"vjcv"yjgvjgt"gcej"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"ycu"c" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 39 " Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"gzrnckp"vjg"kpvgtrnc{"dgvyggp"vjgkt"rcvvgtp"cpf"rtcevkeg"ctiwogpvu"cpf"vjgkt"ctiwogpvu" tgictfkpi"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou."ocmkpi"kv"fkhhkewnv"hqt" vjg"Eqwtv"vq"fgvgtokpg"wpfgt"yjcv"vjgqt{"Rnckpvkhhu"ctg"rtqeggfkpi0" " Kp"twnkpi"qp"RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp" hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp."vjg"Eqwtv"kpuvtwevgf"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"vq"cfftguu"jqy"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt"enckou"ecp"dg" guvcdnkujgf"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku"kh"vjg{"cickp"oqxgf"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Jqygxgt."Rnckpvkhhu"fkf"pqv"fq" uq"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou"wpvkn"vjgkt"tgrn{"dtkgh0" " 56" Oknycwmgg" Rwdnke" Uejqqn" uvwfgpv" ycu" c" uwrgthkekcn" eqooqp" swguvkqp" kpuwhhkekgpv" vq" guvcdnkuj" eqooqpcnkv{+0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"vjgtg"ctg"eqooqp"swguvkqpu"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"yjgvjgt"jctcuuogpv" ycu" ugxgtg" qt" rgtxcukxg" gpqwij" vq" guvcdnkuj" c" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" *i.e.." vq" chhgev" c" vgto." eqpfkvkqp." qt" rtkxkngig" qh" gornq{ogpv+0" " ]5:6." cv" 520_" " Cu" pqvgf" d{" Rnckpvkhhu." vjku" gngogpv" tgswktgu" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" guvcdnkuj" vjcv" vjg{" ygtg" uwdlgevgf" vq" uwhhkekgpvn{" ugxgtg" cpf" rgtxcukxg" eqpfkvkqpu"vjcv"ygtg"dqvj"uwdlgevkxgn{"cpf"qdlgevkxgn{"jquvkng0" " ]Id0_" " ÐVq"swcnkh{"cu"jquvkng."vjg" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" owuv" dg" Òdqvj" qdlgevkxgn{" cpf" uwdlgevkxgn{" qhhgpukxg." qpg" vjcv" c" tgcuqpcdng" rgtuqp" yqwnf" hkpf" jquvkng" qt" cdwukxg." cpf" qpg" vjcv" vjg" xkevko" kp" hcev" fkf" rgtegkxg" vq" dg" uq0ÓÑ" " McPherson v. City of Waukegan."59;"H05f"652."65:"*9vj"Ekt0"4226+"*swqvkpi"Hilt-Dyson v. City of Chicago."4:4"H05f"678."684/85"*9vj"Ekt0"4224++0" " Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf"vjcv"Ð]k_v"ku"qdxkqwu"vjcv"vjg" qdlgevkxg"jquvknkv{"eqorqpgpv"ecp"dg"cfftguugf"cu"c"eqooqp"swguvkqp"dgecwug"vjg"tgcuqpcdngpguu" uvcpfctf"ecp"dg"crrnkgf"vq"vjg"eqpfwev"cpf"vjg"gpxktqpogpvcn"hcevqtu"vjcv"ocmg"wr"vjg"jquvkng"yqtm" gpxktqpogpv0Ñ" " ]5:6." cv" 52/530_" " Rnckpvkhhu" hwtvjgt" eqpvgpf" vjcv" Ð]s_wguvkqpu" uwej" cu" yjgvjgt" ugzwcn" dcvvgtkgu" cpf"cuucwnvu."tgswguvu"hqt"ugzwcn"hcxqtu."uvqtkgu" qh" ugzwcn" eqpswguvu." eqpuvcpvn{" uvctkpi"cpf"tgswktkpi"yqogp"vq"dgpf"qxgt."cpf"vjtgcvu"qh"ugzwcn"cuucwnv"ygtg"eqooqprnceg."ctg" uwdlgev"vq"eqooqp"rtqqh0Ñ" " ]Id0"cv"530_" " Jqygxgt."dgecwug"vjg"qdlgevkxg"jquvknkv{"eqorqpgpv"uvknn" fgrgpfu"qp"vjg"urgekhke"eqpfwev"vq"yjkej"gcej"pcogf"Rnckpvkhh"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"ycu" gzrqugf."RnckpvkhhuÓ"ctiwogpvu"okuu"vjg"octm0" " Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"rtgugpvgf"vjg"Eqwtv"ykvj" gxkfgpeg" kpfkecvkpi" vjcv" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" ygtg" gzrqugf" vq" c" ykfg/tcpig"qh"eqpfwev"vjcv"egtvckpn{"yqwnf"uwrrqtv"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"enckou."vjg"gxkfgpeg" fqgu"pqv"uwiiguv"vjcv"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"cnn"ygtg"gzrqugf"vq"vjg"ucog" 57" eqpfwev0 3: " " Vq" vjg" eqpvtct{." vjg" gxkfgpeg" kpfkecvgu" vjcv" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" ygtg" gzrqugf" vq" c" ykfg" tcpig" qh" rwtrqtvgf" okueqpfwevÏhtqo" gzrquwtg" vq" ugzwcn" itchhkvk."vq"quid pro quo"ugzwcn"rtqrqukvkqpu."vq"tcrg03;" " " Rnckpvkhhu"crrgct"vq"dg"ctiwkpi"vjcv"kortqrgt"eqpfwev"ycu"uq"rgtxcukxg"cv"vjg"Rncpvu"vjcv" gxgt{" yqocp" pgeguuctkn{" ycu" gzrqugf" vq" c" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv0" " " Kp" uwrrqtv" qh" vjcv" ctiwogpv." Rnckpvkhhu" ekvg" vq" vjg" gzrgtv" tgrqtv" qh" Ft0" Nqwkug" Hkv|igtcnf0" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhhu" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 3: " Rnckpvkhhu"tgegpvn{"hkngf"c"pqvkeg"qh"uwrrngogpvcn"cwvjqtkv{."ekvkpi"vq"vyq"tgegpv"fgekukqpu"kp"yjkej"Lwfig" Mgppgnn{" egtvkhkgf" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" encuugu0" " ]Ugg" 639/3=" 639/40_" " Kp" Brown v. Cook County" *Ecug"Pq0"37/ex/:2:7+."Lwfig"Mgppgnn{"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"vjg"hqnnqykpi"kuuwgu"rtgugpvgf"eqooqp"swguvkqpu<" Ðyjgvjgt"vjg"cvvcemu"d{"kpocvgu"ygtg"uq"ugxgtg"qt"rgtxcukxg"cu"vq"cnvgt"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu"qh"gornq{ogpv"cpf" etgcvg" c" jquvkng" qt" cdwukxg" yqtmkpi" gpxktqpogpv=" yjgvjgt" vjg" fghgpfcpvuÓ" rqnkekgu" ngf" vq" vjg" tcrkf" rtqnkhgtcvkqp"qh"ocuvwtdcvkqp"cvvcemu"cickpuv"rwdnke"fghgpfgtu"cpf"ncy"engtmu"cetquu"vjg"Eqqm"Eqwpv{"Lckn" u{uvgo=" yjgvjgt"vjg"fghgpfcpvu"fkueqwtcigf"vjg"rnckpvkhhu"htqo"tgrqtvkpi"yjgp"vjg{"ygtg"cvvcemgf="cpf" yjgvjgt"vjg"fghgpfcpvuÓ"fgnc{"kp"ocmkpi"ghhgevkxg"ejcpigu"vq"tgfweg"vjg"tcvg"qh"xkqngpeg"eqpuvkvwvgf"cp" wptgcuqpcdng"fgnc{"kp"fkueqxgtkpi"cpf"tgogf{kpi"vjg"ukvwcvkqp0" " ]639/3."cv"3;/420_" " Ukoknctn{."kp"Howard v. Cook County Sherriff’s Office"*Ecug"Pq0"39/ex/:368+."Lwfig"Mgppgnn{"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"Ðyjgvjgt"vjg"yqtm" gpxktqpogpv"cv"vjg"lckn"cpf"vjg"eqwtvjqwug"ku"qdlgevkxgn{"qhhgpukxgÑ"rtgugpvgf"c"eqooqp"swguvkqp"uwhhkekgpv" vq" ucvkuh{" Twng" 45*c+Óu" eqooqpcnkv{" tgswktgogpv0" " ]639/4." cv" 350_" " Kp" Brown." vjg" rnckpvkhhu" ygtg" ejcnngpikpi"c"urgekhke"mkpf"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpvÏkpekfgpvu"qh"Ðocuvwtdcvkqp"cvvcemuÑ"d{"fgvckpggu0" " ]Ugg" 639/3."cv"50_" " Kp"Howard."vjg"rnckpvkhhu"rtgugpvgf"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"gcej"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"yqwnf"jcxg" dggp"gzrqugf"vq"vjg"ejcnngpigf"eqpfwev"dgecwug"gcej"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"kp"vjg"ctgcu" yjgtg"vjg"ejcnngpigf"eqpfwev"ycu"qeewttkpi0" " ]Ugg"639/4."cv"37"*Ð]V_jg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"cnn"yqtm" ykvjkp"c"ukping"eqorngz"cpf"encuu"ogodgtu"igpgtcnn{"owuv"vtcxgn"vjtqwij"ownvkrng"fkhhgtgpv"rctvu"qh"vjcv" eqorngz" kp" vjg" eqwtug" qh" vjgkt" gornq{ogpv0" " Vjg" fghgpfcpvu" cempqyngfig" vjku" hgcvwtg" qh" vjg" lckn1eqwtvjqwug"eqorngz0Ñ+0_" " Ikxgp"vjcv"vjgug"ecugu"cfftguugf"oqtg"hqewugf"cnngicvkqpu"qh"c"jquvkng"yqtm" gpxktqpogpv." vjg" Eqwtv" hkpfu" vjgug" ecugu" vq" dg" fkuvkpiwkujcdng0" " Kp" cffkvkqp." vjg" Eqwtv" pqvgu" vjcv" Lwfig" Mgppgnn{Óu"eqooqpcnkv{"cpcn{ugu"kp"Brown"cpf"Howard"tgnkgf"ukipkhkecpvn{"qp"Chicago Teachers Union, Local No. 1 v. Bd. of Educ. of City of Chi.."9;9"H05f"648."655"*9vj"Ekt0"4237+0" " Cu"fkuewuugf"jgtgkp."vjg" Eqwtv" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" RnckpvkhhuÓ" ecug" jgtg" ku" fkuvkpiwkujcdng" htqo" vjcv" ecug." yjkej" cnuq" kpxqnxgf" oqtg" hqewugf" cnngicvkqpu" qh" okueqpfwev0" " Urgekhkecnn{." vjg" rnckpvkhhu" kp" vjcv" ecug" cuugtvgf" Ðvjcv" c" wpkhqto" gornq{ogpv" rtcevkeg" *]c" urgekhke_" ugv" qh" etkvgtkc" wugf" vq" gxcnwcvg" vjg" uejqqn+" wugf" d{" vjg" ucog" fgekukqp/ocmkpi" dqf{" vq" gxcnwcvg" uejqqnu" ycu" fkuetkokpcvqt{0Ñ" " Id0" cv" 6620" " Vjgtg" ku" pq" uwej" urgekhke" rqnke{"cv"kuuwg"jgtg0" " Cnvjqwij"vjg"Eqwtv"jcu"tgxkgygf"Howard"cpf"Brown"kp"vjgkt"gpvktgv{."vjg"Eqwtv"qpn{" cfftguugu"vjg"eqooqpcnkv{"cpcn{ugu."yjkej"ku"oquv"rgtvkpgpv"vq"vjg"EqwtvÓu"cpcn{uku"jgtg0" " " " 3; " Hqt"gzcorng."Rnckpvkhhu"ekvg"vq"c"swguvkqppcktg"eqorngvgf"d{"c"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"yjq"kpfkecvgf"vjcv" ujg"ycu"gzrqugf"vq"ugzwcn"eqoogpvu."lqmgu"cpf"kppwgpfq."cpf"fgtqicvqt{"vgtou0" " ]546/363"*Rnu0Óu"Gz0"363" Î"Rwvcvkxg"Encuu"Ogodgt"Swguvkqppcktg+0_" " Jqygxgt."vjku"ucog"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"fgpkgu"gxgt"jcxkpi" dggp"vqwejgf"kp"cp"kpcrrtqrtkcvg"ocppgt"fwtkpi"jgt"gornq{ogpv0" " ]Id0_" " Vjku"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"cnuq" fgpkgu" gxgt" jcxkpi" uggp" kpcrrtqrtkcvg" vqwejkpi" fwtkpi" jgt" gornq{ogpv0" " ]Id0_" " D{" eqpvtcuv." cpqvjgt" rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"fkuewuugf"cdqxg"kpfkecvgf"vjcv"ujg"jcf"kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"dggp"vqwejgf"dwv"jcf"pqv" jgctf"kpcrrtqrtkcvg"eqoogpvu0" " " " 58" ctiwg"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"tgrqtv"guvcdnkujgu"Ðgxkfgpeg"qh"c"eqooqp"rtcevkeg"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv" cickpuv"yqogp"cv"vjg"]Rncpvu_0Ñ" " Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg."jqygxgt."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"gzenwfkpi" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"qrkpkqpu"tgncvkpi"vq"vjcv"kuuwg0" " Gxgp"kh"vjg"Eqwtv"ygtg"vq"ceegrv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu" vguvkoqp{"qp"vjcv"kuuwg."Ft0"Hkv|igtcnfÓu"eqpenwukqpu"fq"pqv"guvcdnkuj"c"eqooqp"kuuwg"ykvj"tgurgev" gcej" rnckpvkhhuÓ" gzrquwtg" vq" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0" " Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" vjg" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv"cv"Ðvjg"Rncpvu"ku"jkijn{"ugzwcnk|gf."ngcfkpi"vq"jkij"ngxgnu"qh"codkgpv"jctcuuogpv0Ñ42" " ]548/3" *Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" Tgr0+." cv" 890_" " Ft0" Hkv|igtcnf" hwtvjgt" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" jctcuuogpv" cv" vjg" Rnckpvu"Ðku"uq"rgtxcukxgÑ"vjcv"gxgt{"hgocng"gornq{gg"qh"vjg"Rncpvu"Ðkpgxkvcdn{Ñ"jcu"dggp"gzrqugf"vq" ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv."Ðto a greater or lesser degree0Ñ" " ]Id0"cv"8:"*gorjcuku"cffgf+0_" " Vjku"cpcn{uku" jkijnkijvu"vjg"xct{kpi"ngxgnu"qh"cnngigf"okueqpfwev"vq"yjkej"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu" ogodgtu"jcxg"dggp"gzrqugf0" " Yjkng"uqog"yqogp"cnngig"vjcv"vjg{"jcxg"dggp"rj{ukecnn{"cuucwnvgf" qt"gxgp"tcrgf."qvjgtu"oc{"qpn{"jcxg"dggp"gzrqugf"vq"Ðcodkgpv"jctcuuogpv0Ñ43" " Vjwu."gxgp"kh"vjg" Eqwtv" ecvgiqtkecnn{" fgpkgf" FghgpfcpvÓu" oqvkqp" vq" gzenwfg" vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf." vjg" Eqwtv" uvknn" yqwnf" eqpenwfg" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" pqv" guvcdnkujgf" vjcv" vjg" qdlgevkxgn{" qhhgpukxg" gngogpv" qh" vjgkt" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" enckou" ecp" dg" rtqxgp" qp" c" encuu/ykfg" dcuku0 44" " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 42 " Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"uvcvgu"vjcv"Ðcodkgpv"jctcuuogpvÑ"tghgtu"Ðvq"vjg"gzrgtkgpeg"qh"yqtmkpi"kp"cp"gpxktqpogpv" rgtogcvgf"ykvj"ugzwcnn{"qhhgpukxg"cpf"fgitcfkpi"dgjcxkqt."vjcv"ku."c"jkijn{"ugzwcnk|gf"cvoqurjgtg"kp"yjkej" etwfg"cpf"qhhgpukxg"ocvgtkcnu"ctg"eqooqp"cpf"gornq{ggu"ugg"jctcuukpi"dgjcxkqt"cu"pqtocvkxg."yjgvjgt" urgekhkecnn{"fktgevgf"cv"vjgo"qt"pqv0" " ]548/3"*Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"Tgr0+."cv"350_" " " " 43 " Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Ft0"Hkv|igtcnf"rwtrqtvu"vq"gswcvg"Ðcodkgpv"jctcuuogpvÑ"vq"Ðcevkqpcdng"jctcuuogpv.Ñ" vjg"Eqwtv"citggu"ykvj"Fghgpfcpv"vjcv"uwej"vguvkoqp{"cnuq"yqwnf"rtqrgtn{"dg"gzenwfgf"cu"eqphwukpi"cpf" okungcfkpi"wpfgt"Twng"6250" " " " 44 " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"vjgkt"Ðcpgefqvcn"gxkfgpeg"nkmgykug"uwrrqtvu"vjgkt"cnngicvkqpu"cpf"c"hkpfkpi"qh" eqooqpcnkv{0Ñ" " Jqygxgt."cu"fkuewuugf"cntgcf{."vjg"cpgefqvcn"gxkfgpeg"dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv"cevwcnn{"kpfkecvgu" vjcv"yqogp"cv"vjg"Rncpvu"ygtg"gzrqugf"vq"c"ykfg/tcpig"qh"okueqpfwev0" " Kp"hcev."Fghgpfcpv"jcu"uwdokvvgf" fgenctcvkqpu" htqo" vygnxg" yqogp" cxgttkpi" vjcv" vjg{" pgxgt" gzrgtkgpegf" qt" ykvpguugf" ugzwcnn{" jctcuukpi" eqpfwev" cv" vjg" Rncpvu0" " ]57:/33" *Fgh0Óu" Gzu0" ;/42+0_" " Cpqvjgt" vygnxg" yqogp" jcxg" uwdokvvgf" chhkfcxkvu" uvcvkpi"vjcv"yjkng"vjg{"oc{"jcxg"dggp"uwdlgevgf"vq"qt"oc{"jcxg"ykvpguugf"uwej"eqpfwev."vjg{"gkvjgt"ygtg" pqv"dqvjgtgf"d{"vjg"eqpfwev"qt"vjg{"dgnkgxgf"vjcv"vjg"eqpfwev"ycu"cfftguugf"crrtqrtkcvgn{"*gkvjgt"d{"vjg" chhkcpv" qt" d{" Fghgpfcpv0" " ]57:/33" *Fgh0Óu" Gzu0" 43/54+0_" " Yjkng" Rnckpvkhhu" oc{" eqpvgpf" vjcv" Fghgpfcpv" 59" Hwtvjgtoqtg."ikxgp"vjg"uk|g"qh"vjg"Rncpvu"cpf"vjg"hcev"vjcv"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"yqtmgf"kp" ocp{"qh"vjg"Rncpvu"fkhhgtgpv"fgrctvogpvu"cpf"etgyu"fwtkpi"cnn"tgngxcpv"vkog"htcogu"]57:."cv"3;/43_." vjg" Eqwtv" fqgu" pqv" ugg" jqy" RnckpvkhhuÓ" cpgefqvcn" gxkfgpeg" qh" okueqpfwevÏvjqwij" cdwpfcpvÏguvcdnkujgu"vjcv"uwej"eqpfwev"wpkxgtucnn{"ycu"qeewttkpi"kp"cnn"ctgcu"qh"vjg"Rncpvu"cv"cnn" vkogu0" " Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"eqpegfg"vjcv"vjg"uwdlgevkxg"gngogpv"qh"vjgkt"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv" encko"yknn"tgswktg"cv"ngcuv"uqog"kpfkxkfwcnk|gf"rtqqh."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"vjg"uwdlgevkxg"gngogpv" uvknn"ecp"dg"cpuygtgf"vq"uqog"gzvgpv"vjtqwij"eqooqp"swguvkqpu0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Rnckpvkhhu"uwdokv" vjcv" egtvckp" v{rgu" qh" jctcuuogpv" uwej" cu" cuucwnv." tcrg." cpf1qt" wpycpvgf" vqwejkpi" d{" vjgkt" xgt{" pcvwtg" ctg" wpygneqog0" " Jqygxgt." vjg" Eqwtv" ecppqv" hktuv" fgvgtokpg" vjcv" vqwejkpi" ku" wpycpvgf" ykvjqwv"hktuv"guvcdnkujkpi"vjcv"vjg"eqpfwev"qeewttgf"cpf"vjgp"nqqmkpi"vq"vjg"uwdlgevkxg"kpvgpv"qh"vjg" rgtuqp"dgkpi"vqwejgf045" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"vjg"uwdlgevkxg"gngogpv"qh"RnckpvkhhuÓ" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" encko" fqgu" pqv" rtgugpv" eqooqp" kuuwgu" crrtqrtkcvg" hqt" encuu/ykfg" fgvgtokpcvkqp0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"ukoknctn{"ctiwg"vjcv"vjg{"ecp"guvcdnkuj"qp"c"encuu/ykug"dcuku"vjcv"vjg{"cpf"rwvcvkxg" encuu"ogodgtu"ygtg"gzrqugf"vq"jctcuuogpv"qp"vjg"dcuku"qh"ugz0" " Jqygxgt."kh"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf" rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"ecppqv"guvcdnkuj"vjcv"vjg{"gxgp"ygtg"gzrqugf"vq"vjg"ucog"eqpfwev"qp"c" encuu/ykfg"dcuku."vjg{"ecppqv"cfftguu"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku"yjgvjgt"vjg"fkhhgtkpi"eqpfwev"vq"yjkej" vjg{"ygtg"gzrqugf"ycu"dcugf"qp"ugz0" " " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" rtguuwtgf"vjgug"yqogp"vq"ikxg"uvcvgogpvu."gxgp"RnckpvkhhuÓ"qyp"gxkfgpeg"fgoqpuvtcvgu"vjg"ykfg"tcpig"qh" okueqpfwev" vq" yjkej" yqogp" yqtmkpi" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" encko" vq" jcxg" dggp" gzrqugf0" " Hqt" gzcorng." kp" cp" kpvgtxkgy"ykvj"c"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt."vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"kpfkecvgf"vjcv"ujg"kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"jcf" dggp"vqwejgf"dwv"vjcv"ujg"pgxgt"jcf"jgctf"cp{"kortqrgt"ugzwcn"eqoogpvu0" " ]546/;2"*Rn0Óu"Gz0";2+0_" " " " 45 " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"cp{"rwvcvkxg"encuu" ogodgtu"yjq"fkf"pqv"hkpf"vjg"gpxktqpogpv"jquvkng"eqwnf" cnyc{u"qrv"qwv"qh"vjg"encuu0" " Jqygxgt."vjg"Eqwtv"ecppqv"eqpenwfg"vjcv"cp"kuuwg"rtgugpvu"c"eqooqp"swguvkqp" ukorn{"dgecwug"vjqug"ykvj"fkhhgtkpi"enckou"ecp"qrv"qwv0" " " 5:" Hkpcnn{."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"eqooqp" kuuwg"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"yjgvjgt"vjgtg"ku"c" dcuku" hqt" gornq{gt" nkcdknkv{0" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcv" Ðyjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" mpgy" qt" ujqwnf" jcxg" mpqyp" qh" vjg" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv." yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" gpeqwtcigf" vjg" gpxktqpogpv." yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" vqqm" cp{" cevkqp" vq" tgogf{" vjg" gpxktqpogpv." yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" ycu" pginkigpv." yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" jcf" pqvkeg" qh" vjg" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv." yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" vqqm" rtqorv" tgogfkcn" cevkqp" kp" tgurqpug" vq" etgfkdng" cnngicvkqpu" qh" jctcuuogpv."yjgvjgt"]Fghgpfcpv_"jcf"c"rqnke{"qh"rgtokvvkpi"jctcuugtu"vq"tgockp"kp"vjg"yqtm"rnceg." yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" hckngf" vq" fkuekrnkpg" jctcuugtu." cpf" yjgvjgt" ]Fghgpfcpv_" gtcfkecvgf" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" cpf" igpfgt/dcugf" fkuetkokpcvkqp" kp" kvu" Ejkeciq" Rncpvu0Ñ" " ]5:6." cv" 4;/520_" " Yjkng" vjgug"swguvkqpu"oc{"xgt{"ygnn"dg"tgngxcpv"vq"fgvgtokpkpi"yjgvjgt"vjgtg"ku"c"dcuku"hqt"gornq{gt" nkcdknkv{."Rnckpvkhhu"fq"pqv"cfftguu"yjcv"ujqykpi"ku"pgeguuct{"vq"guvcdnkuj"gornq{gt"nkcdknkv{0" " ÐKv"ku" pqv" vjg" qdnkicvkqp" qh" ]vjg_" eqwtv" vq" tgugctej" cpf" eqpuvtwev" vjg" ngicn" ctiwogpvu" qrgp" vq" rctvkgu." gurgekcnn{"yjgp"vjg{"ctg"tgrtgugpvgf"d{"eqwpugn0Ñ" " Beard v. Whitley Cty. REMC.":62"H04f"627." 62:/2;"*9vj"Ekt0"3;::+="ugg"cnuq"Schaefer v. Universal Scaffolding & Equip., LLC.":5;"H05f"7;;." 829" *9vj" Ekt0" 4238+" *ÐRgthwpevqt{" cpf" wpfgxgnqrgf" ctiwogpvu" ctg" yckxgf." cu" ctg" ctiwogpvu" wpuwrrqtvgf"d{"ngicn"cwvjqtkv{0Ñ"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf++0" Kp" cp{" gxgpv." dcugf" qp" vjg" gxkfgpeg" rtgugpvgf" d{" Rnckpvkhhu." vjg" Eqwtv" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" gornq{gt"nkcdknkv{"ku"pqv"c"eqooqp"swguvkqp"kp"vjku"ecug046" " ÐCp"gornq{gt"ku"xkectkqwun{"nkcdng"hqt" c"jquvkng"gpxktqpogpv"etgcvgf"d{"c"uwrgtxkuqt"Òuwdlgev"vq"egtvckp"fghgpugu0ÓÑ" " Wilson v. Chrysler Corp.."394"H05f"722."72:"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;;+"*swqvkpi"Adusumilli v. City of Chicago."386"H05f"575." 583"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;:++0" " ÐCp"gornq{gt"ku"nkcdng"hqt"jctcuuogpv"d{"eqyqtmgtu"qpn{"yjgp"kv"jcu"dggp" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 46 " Vjg"Eqwtv"ecp"eqpegkxg"qh"uegpctkqu"yjgtg"vjku"gngogpv"eqwnf"dg"guvcdnkujgf"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku0" " Hqt" gzcorng." kh" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" cnn" ygtg" ejcnngpikpi" okueqpfwev" d{" vjg" ucog" uwrgtxkuqt"cpf"c"etkvkecn"ocuu"qh"gornq{ggu"uwhhkekgpv"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"pwogtqukv{"tgswktgogpv"ygtg"xkevkou"qh" vjcv"okueqpfwev0" 5;" Òpginkigpv"gkvjgt"kp"fkueqxgtkpi"qt"tgogf{kpi"vjg"jctcuuogpv0ÓÑ" " Jarvis v. Sigmatron Int’l Inc.." 445"H0"Uwrr0"4f";:3.";:8"*P0F0"Knn0"4224+"*swqvkpi"Parkins v. Civil Constructors of Ill., Inc.."385" H05f"3249."3257"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;:++0" " ÐPqvkeg"qt"mpqyngfig"d{"vjg"gornq{gt"qh"vjg"jctcuuogpv"ku"c" rtgtgswkukvg"hqt"nkcdknkv{0Ñ" " Id0"*ekvkpi"Parkins."385"H05f"cv"3257+0" " ÐCp"gornq{gt"ecp"igpgtcnn{" cxqkf"nkcdknkv{"hqt"c"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"kh"kv"rtqorvn{"kpxguvkicvgf"eqornckpvu"ocfg"d{"vjg" rnckpvkhh"cpf"cevgf"vq"uvqr"vjg"jctcuukpi"dgjcxkqt0Ñ" " Montgomery v. Am. Airlines, Inc.."848"H05f" 5:4."5;4"*9vj"Ekt0"4232+"*ekvkpi"Lucero v. Nettle Creek Sch. Corp.."788"H05f"942."953"*9vj"Ekt0" 422;++0" " " Cnvjqwij" vjku" cpcn{uku" okijv" fgrgpf" qp" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgurqpug" vq" urgekhke" cnngicvkqpu" qh" jctcuuogpv"ocfg"mpqyp"vq"Fghgpfcpv."yjkej"yqwnf"tgswktg"kpfkxkfwcn"cpcn{uku."Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf" vjcv"vjg{"ecp"guvcdnkuj"c"dcuku"hqt"gornq{gt"nkcdknkv{"d{"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"jcu"c"rqnke{" qh"hcknkpi"vq"vcmg"rtqorv"tgogfkcn"cevkqp"kp"tgurqpug"vq"etgfkdng"cnngicvkqpu"qh"kortqrgt"eqpfwev0" " ]545."cv"870_" " Urgekhkecnn{."Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"jcu"*3+"cnnqygf"mpqyp"jctcuugtu"vq" tgockp"kp"vjg"yqtmrnceg."*4+"hckngf"vq"fkuekrnkpg"jctcuugtu"fgurkvg"vjg"jctcuuogpv"dgkpi"ykvpguugf" d{"uwrgtxkuqtu."*5+"vjtgcvgpgf"hgocng"eqornckpcpvu"ykvj"vgtokpcvkqp"qt"ytkvvgp"tgrtkocpfu."cpf" *6+"cuukipgf"nguu"fguktcdng"vcumu"vq"gornq{ggu"yjq"fkf"pqv"uwdokv"vq"ugzwcn"cfxcpegu0" " ]Id0_" " " Jqygxgt." vjg" qpn{" eqtrqtcvg" rqnkekgu" vjcv" jcxg" dggp" guvcdnkujgf" tgncvg" vq" FghgpfcpvÓu" cpvk/jctcuuogpv"eqtrqtcvg"fktgevkxgu"cpf"rqnke{"ngvvgtu."yjkej"ctg"korngogpvgf"d{"nqecn"Jwocp" Tguqwtegu"cpf"Ncdqt"Tgncvkqpu"rgtuqppgn0" " Rnckpvkhhu"fq"pqv"eqpvgpf"vjcv"FghgpfcpvÓu"eqtrqtcvg" fktgevkxgu"cpf"rqnke{"ngvvgtu"ctg"fkuetkokpcvqt{"qt"kortqrgt0" " Tcvjgt."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"egtvckp" qh" FghgpfcpvÓu" gornq{ggu" jcxg" cevgf" kortqrgtn{" fgurkvg" *cpf" kp" xkqncvkqp" qh+" vjgug" rqnkekgu0" " Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv."jqygxgt."guvcdnkujgf"Ðukipkhkecpv"rtqqhÑ"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"cevgf"wpfgt"c"igpgtcn" rqnke{"vjcv"ocpkhguvgf"kvugnh"kp"vjg"ucog"igpgtcn"hcujkqp0" " Dukes."786"W0U0"cv"575"*ÐUkipkhkecpv" 62" rtqqh"vjcv"cp"gornq{gt"qrgtcvgf"wpfgt"c"igpgtcn"rqnke{"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp"eqpegkxcdn{"eqwnf"lwuvkh{" c" encuu" qh" dqvj" crrnkecpvu" cpf" gornq{ggu" kh" vjg" fkuetkokpcvkqp" ocpkhguvgf" kvugnh" kp" jktkpi" cpf" rtqoqvkqp" rtcevkegu" kp" vjg" ucog" igpgtcn" hcujkqp." uwej" cu" vjtqwij" gpvktgn{" uwdlgevkxg" fgekukqp/ocmkpi0Ñ+0" " Vjg"Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"jgnf"vjcv"Ðuwdlgevkxg."fkuetgvkqpct{"fgekukqpu"ecp"dg" vjg"uqwteg"qh"c"eqooqp"encko"kh"vjg{"ctg."hqt"gzcorng."vjg"qwveqog"qh"gornq{ogpv"rtcevkegu"qt" rqnkekgu" eqpvtqnngf" d{" jkijgt/ngxgn" fktgevqtu." kh" cnn" fgekukqp/ocmgtu" gzgtekug" fkuetgvkqp" kp" c" eqooqp"yc{"dgecwug"qh"c"eqorcp{"rqnke{"qt"rtcevkeg."qt"kh"cnn"fgekukqp/ocmgtu"cev"vqigvjgt"cu"qpg" wpkv0Ñ" " Chicago Teachers Union, Local No. 1 v. Bd. of Educ. of City of Chicago."9;9"H05f"648." 65:" *9vj" Ekt0" 4237+0" " Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" pqv" guvcdnkujgf" vjcv" cp{" qh" vjgug" ektewouvcpegu" ku" rtgugpv" jgtg0" " " Cnvjqwij"dqvj"Rncpvu"jcxg"vjg"ucog"itkgxcpeg"rtqegfwtgu"cpf"ctg"iqxgtpgf"d{"vjg"ucog" eqnngevkxg"dctickpkpi"citggogpv."cu"pqvgf"d{"Fghgpfcpv."vjg"Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"fgrctvogpvu"kp"vjg" Rncpvu" ctg" ugrctcvg" cpf" fkuvkpev" htqo" vjg" eqtrqtcvg/ngxgn" Rgtuqppgn" Tgncvkqpu" Fgrctvogpv" cv" FghgpfcpvÓu"jgcfswctvgtu"kp"Fgctdqtp."Okejkicp0" " ]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"3"Î"Ncxgpfgt"Fgen0+."cv"5." 7." "4.";0_" " Yjkng"Rnckpvkhhu"cuugtv"vjcv"Ðvjg"rgtuqppgn"qxgtuggkpi"vjg"eqornckpvu."fkuekrnkpg"cpf" vgtokpcvkqp"qh"jqwtn{"gornq{ggu"*Lko"Nctgug."qt"qvjgt"gornq{ggu"fgukipcvgf"htqo"jku"Rgtuqppgn" Tgncvkqpu" qhhkeg+" ycu" ]uke_" eqooqpÑ" ]545." cv" 39/3:_." Fghgpfcpv" ctiwgu" vjcv" vjku" cuugtvkqp" ku" kpeqttgev."pqvkpi"vjcv"Lko"Nctgug"pgxgt"qxgtucy"Rgtuqppgn"Tgncvkqpu0" " ]57:."cv"3;0_" " Rnckpvkhhu"hckn" vq" tgurqpf" vq" vjcv" rqkpv0" " Rnckpvkhhu" fq" kfgpvkh{" gxkfgpeg" kpfkecvkpi" vjcv" Rgtuqppgn" Tgncvkqpu" dgecog"kpxqnxgf"kp"cevwcnn{"eqpfwevkpi"kpxguvkicvkqpu"kpvq"cnngicvkqpu"qh"okueqpfwev"cv"vjg"Rncpvu" ctqwpf"42360" " ]547/5;"*Nctgug"Fgr0+."cv"33/340_" " Kpfggf."Fghgpfcpv"tgeqipk|gu"vjcv"dgikppkpi"kp" Ugrvgodgt"4236"cpf"eqpvkpwkpi"wpvkn"crrtqzkocvgn{"Lwn{"3."4238."c"Rgtuqppgn"Tgncvkqpu/ngf"vgco" uwrrqtvgf" Jwocp" Tguqwtegu" cpf" Ncdqt" Tgncvkqpu" rgtuqppgn" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" kp" eqpfwevkpi" 63" kpxguvkicvkqpu"qh"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cnngicvkqpu0" " ]57:/32"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"3"Î"Ncxgpfgt"Fgen0+."cv"8." " 3;0_" " Cpf" ogodgtu" qh" vjg" Rgtuqppgn" Tgncvkqpu" Fgrctvogpv" jcxg" eqpvkpwgf" vq" rtqxkfg" nkokvgf" kpxguvkicvkxg"uwrrqtv"qp"cp"cu"pggfgf"dcuku"ukpeg"Lwn{"3."42380" " ]Id0"cv"8." "420_" " Jqygxgt."vjg" Rncpvu" tgvckpgf" wnvkocvg" fgekukqp/ocmkpi" cwvjqtkv{" hqt" fkuekrnkpct{" kuuwgu" kpxqnxkpi" jqwtn{" gornq{ggu" vjtqwijqwv" vjg" gpvktg" rgtkqf0" " ]Id0" cv" 8." " 430_" " Cu" pqvgf" d{" Fghgpfcpv." vjgtg" ygtg" crrtqzkocvgn{"64"fkhhgtgpv"Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"cpf"Ncdqt"Tgncvkqpu"rgtuqppgn"yjq"kpxguvkicvgf"cpf" fkuekrnkpgf" jqwtn{" gornq{ggu" hqt" jctcuuogpv0" " ]Id0" cv" 8." " 390_" " Wpfgt" uwej" ektewouvcpegu." Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"ujqyp"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"cevgf"wpfgt"c"igpgtcn"rqnke{"vjcv"ocpkhguvgf"kvugnh"kp"vjg" ucog" igpgtcn" hcujkqp0" " Dukes." 786" W0U0" cv" 5750" " Dukes" Ðfktgevu" eqwtvu" vq" gzcokpg" yjgvjgt" cnn" ocpcigtu" gzgtekug" fkuetgvkqp" kp" c" eqooqp" yc{" ykvj" uqog" eqooqp" fktgevkqp0Ñ Chicago Teachers Union, Local No. 1 v. Bd. of Educ. of City of Chicago."9;9"H05f"648."659"*9vj"Ekt0"4237+" *swqvkpi"Scott v. Family Dollar Stores, Inc.."955"H05f"327."335"*6vj"Ekt0"4235++"*kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp" octmu"qokvvgf+0" " Vjgtg"ku"pq"kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"vjg"kpxguvkicvkxg"cpf"fkuekrnkpct{"fgekukqpu"ocfg"ykvj" tgurgev"vq"jqwtn{"gornq{ggu"ygtg"ocfg"Ðykvj"uqog"eqooqp"fktgevkqp0Ñ" " " " Wpnkmg" fkuekrnkpg" kpxqnxkpi" jqwtn{" gornq{ggu." fkuekrnkpg" qh" ucnctkgf" gornq{ggu" hqt" xkqncvkqpu"qh"FghgpfcpvÓu"cpvk/jctcuuogpv"rqnkekgu"ku"tgxkgygf"cpf"wnvkocvgn{"fgvgtokpgf"d{"uvchh" kp" vjg" Rgtuqppgn" Tgncvkqpu" Fgrctvogpv0" " ]57:/32" *Fgh0Óu" Gz0" 3" Î" Ncxgpfgt" Fgen0+." cv" 8." " 440_" " Ð]K_h"c"igpgtcn"rqnke{"vjcv"ku"gphqtegf"cv"vjg"eqtrqtcvg"ngxgn"tcvjgt"vjcp"d{"kpfkxkfwcn"uwrgtxkuqtu"ku" enckogf" vq" dg" fkuetkokpcvqt{." gxgp" kh" uqog" fkuetgvkqp" gzkuvu." eqooqpcnkv{" oc{" dg" hqwpf0Ñ" " Chicago Teachers Union, Local No. 1."9;9"H05f"cv"662"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf++0" " Uvknn."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg" pqv" guvcdnkujgf" vjcv" cp" cevkqpcdng" eqtrqtcvg" rqnke{" gzkuvgf0" " Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" pqv" rtgugpvgf" uvcvkuvkecn"gxkfgpeg"qp"vjcv"rqkpv0" " Cpf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"cpgefqvcn"gxkfgpeg"ku"kpuwhhkekgpv"vq"guvcdnkuj"cp" cevkqpcdng"rqnke{"qh"hcknkpi"vq"vcmg"rtqorv"tgogfkcn"cevkqp"kp"tgurqpug"vq"etgfkdng"cnngicvkqpu"qh" 64" kortqrgt"eqpfwev."gurgekcnn{"kp"nkijv"qh"vjg"hcev"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"fkf"fkuekrnkpg"ucnctkgf"gornq{ggu" hqt" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0" " ]Ugg" 57:/;" *ejctv" uwooctk|kpi" fkuekrnkpg" cpf" eqttgevkxg" cevkqpu" cv" vjg" Rncpvu"htqo"4234/423:+0_" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"ogv"vjgkt"dwtfgp" qh"ucvkuh{kpi"Twng"45*c+Óu"eqooqpcnkv{"tgswktgogpv0" " " E0" V{rkecnkv{"wpfgt"Twng"45*c+*5+" Twng"45*c+*5+"tgswktgu"vjcv"Ðvjg"enckou"qt"fghgpugu"qh"vjg"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"rctvkgu"ctg"v{rkecn" qh"vjg"enckou"qt"fghgpugu"qh"vjg"encuu0Ñ" " Enckou"qh"encuu"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"cpf"encuu"ogodgtu"ctg" v{rkecn"kh"vjg{"ctkug"htqo"vjg"ucog"rtcevkeg"qt"eqwtug"qh"eqpfwev"cpf"ctg"dcugf"qp"vjg"ucog"ngicn" vjgqt{0" " Keele." 36;" H05f" cv" 7;70" " V{rkecnkv{" cpf" eqooqpcnkv{" ctg" enqugn{" tgncvgf0" " Rosario v. Livaditis." ;85" H04f" 3235." 323:" *9vj" Ekt0" 3;;4+0" " ÐV{rkecn" fqgu" pqv" ogcp" kfgpvkecn." cpf" vjg" v{rkecnkv{"tgswktgogpv"ku"nkdgtcnn{"eqpuvtwgf0Ñ" " Gaspar v. Linvatec Corp.."389"H0T0F0"73."79"*P0F0" Knn0" 3;;8+0" " V{rkecnkv{" ku" ogcpv" vq" gpuwtg" vjcv" vjg" enckou" qh" vjg" encuu" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu" jcxg" vjg" Ðucog"guugpvkcn"ejctcevgtkuvkeu"cu"vjg"enckou"qh"vjg"encuu"cv"nctig0Ñ" " Retired Chicago Police Ass’n v. City of Chicago."9"H05f"7:6."7;8"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;5+"*ekvcvkqp"cpf"kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0" " Ð]V_jgtg"owuv"dg"gpqwij"eqpitwgpeg"dgvyggp"vjg"pcogf"tgrtgugpvcvkxgÓu"encko"cpf"vjcv"qh"vjg" wppcogf" ogodgtu" qh" vjg" encuu" vq" lwuvkh{" cnnqykpi" vjg" pcogf" rctv{" vq" nkvkicvg" qp" dgjcnh" qh" vjg" itqwr0Ñ" " Spano v. The Boeing Co.."855"H05f"796."7:8"*9vj"Ekt0"4233+0" " " Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"pcogf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"enckou"ctg"pqv"v{rkecn"dgecwug"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu" ceeqwpv"hqt"c"fkurtqrqtvkqpcvgn{"nctig"pwodgt"qh"cnn"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"eqornckpvu"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " Ð]C_"encuu"ujqwnf"pqv"dg"egtvkhkgf"kh"kv"ku"crrctgpv"vjcv"kv"eqpvckpu"c"itgcv"ocp{"rgtuqpu"yjq"jcxg" uwhhgtgf"pq"kplwt{"cv"vjg"jcpfu"qh"vjg"fghgpfcpv0Ñ" " Kohen v. Pac. Inv. Mgmt. Co.."793"H05f"894." 899/9:"*9vj"Ekt0"422;+0" " Vjcv"dgkpi"uckf."vjg"Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"cnuq"jcu"tgeqipk|gf"vjcv"ÐÒc"encuu" yknn"qhvgp"kpenwfg"rgtuqpu"yjq"jcxg"pqv"dggp"kplwtgf"d{"vjg"fghgpfcpvÓu"eqpfwev="kpfggf"vjku"ku" 65" cnoquv"kpgxkvcdng.Ó"ikxgp"vjcv"c"encuu"ecp"dg"egtvkhkgf"{gv"hckn"vq"rtqxg"kvu"ecug"qp"vjg"ogtkvu0Ñ" " Lacy v. Cook Cty., Ill.." :;9" H05f" :69." :86" *9vj" Ekt0" 423:+" *swqvkpi" Kohen." 793" cv" 899+0" " Cnvjqwij" Fghgpfcpv"jcu"kfgpvkhkgf"gxkfgpeg"kpfkecvkpi"vjcv"uqog"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"uwhhgtgf"pq" kplwt{."kv"jcu"pqv"ujqyp"vjcv"Ðc"itgcv"ocp{Ñ"jgtg"ygtg"pqv"kplwtgf."cu"pgeguuct{"vq"hkpf"v{rkecnkv{" ncemkpi"qp"vjcv"dcuku0" " Id0" " " Fghgpfcpv"cumu"vjg"Eqwtv"vq"kphgt"vjcv"c"itgcv"ocp{"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"jcxg"pqv"dggp" kplwtgf" dgecwug" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" ceeqwpv" hqt" c" ukipkhkecpv" rqtvkqp" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" enckou" ocfg" d{" gornq{ggu" qh" vjg" Rncpvu0" " FghgpfcpvÓu" ecnewncvkqp" ycu" dcugf" qp" vjg" pwodgt" qh" fqewogpvgf" eqornckpvu" ocfg" d{" hgocng" gornq{ggu" cv" vjg" Rncpvu" vq" FghgpfcpvÓu" jctcuuogpv" jqvnkpg." cu" ygnn" cu" vq" Jwocp" Tguqwtegu." Ncdqt" Tgncvkqpu." vjg" Gswcn" Gornq{ogpv" Qrrqtvwpkv{" Eqookuukqp." qt" vjg" Knnkpqku" Fgrctvogpv" qh" Jwocp" Tkijvu" vjcv" ygtg" ctiwcdn{" ugzwcn/jctcuuogpv/tgncvgf" hqt" 4234/370" " ]57:/6." cv" 3" p030_" " Jqygxgt." vjgug" pwodgtu" fq" pqv" crrgct" vq" ceeqwpv" hqt" cnn" qh" vjg" yqogp" yjq" uwdokvvgf" enckou" hqtou" cu" rctv" qh" vjg" GGQE" eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu0" " Vjgug"pwodgtu"vjgtghqtg"crrgct"vq"wpfgteqwpv"vjg"pwodgt"qh"yqogp"yjq" encko" vq" jcxg" dggp" uwdlgevgf" vq" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg." dcugf" qp" vjg" gitgikqwu" cnngicvkqpu"kp"vjku"ecug"*kpenwfkpi"cnngicvkqpu"cickpuv"vjqug"kp"ocpcigogpv"cpf"vjqug"kpxqnxgf"kp" jcpfnkpi"eqornckpvu+."kv"ku"wpfgtuvcpfcdng"yj{"yqogp"oc{"jcxg"tghtckpgf"htqo"tgrqtvkpi"ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv." gurgekcnn{" kh" vjg" yqogp" fkf" pqv" dgnkgxg" Fghgpfcpv" cfgswcvgn{" yqwnf" cfftguu" vjg" eqornckpvu"cpf1qt"hgctgf"tgvcnkcvkqp0" " Dgecwug"kv"ku"tgcuqpcdng"vq"cuuwog"vjcv"vjqug"yknnkpi"vq"cev" cu"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ygtg"oqtg"yknnkpi"vq"ocmg"fqewogpvgf"eqornckpvu."kv"ku"pqv"uwtrtkukpi" vjcv"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"ocmg"wr"c"ukipkhkecpv"rgtegpvcig"qh"vjqug"yjq"ocfg"fqewogpvgf"eqornckpvu0" " Uvknn."vjg"Eqwtv"owuv"Ðgpuwtg"vjcv"encuu"ogodgtu"ykvj"uvtqpigt"enckou"ctg"pqv"rtglwfkegf"d{" c"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"ykvj"c"ygcm"qpg0Ñ" " Osada v. Experian Info. Sols., Inc.."4234"YN"3272289."cv",9" 66" *P0F0"Knn0"Oct0"4:."4234+"*ekvkpi"CE Design Ltd. v. King Architectural Metals, Inc.."859"H05f"943." 948"*9vj"Ekt0"4233++="ugg"cnuq"Randall v. Rolls-Royce Corp.."859"H05f":3:.":46"*9vj"Ekt0"4233+" *chhktokpi" fgpkcn" qh" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" dgecwug" pcogf" rnckpvkhhuÓ" enckou" ygtg" ygcmgt" vjcp" vjg" enckou"qh"qvjgt"encuu"ogodgtu+0" " Dcugf"qp"vjg"hcevu"qh"vjku"ecug"cpf"vjg"ctiwogpvu"cfxcpegf"d{" Rnckpvkhhu."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"wpcdng"vq"fq"uq"kp"vjku"ecug0" " " Pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"cnngigfn{"jcxg"dggp"gzrqugf"vq"c"ykfg/tcpig" qh" okueqpfwevÏtcpikpi" htqo" tcrg." vq" quid pro quo" rtqrqukvkqpu." vq" gzrquwtg" vq" kortqrgt" eqoogpvu"cpf1qt"ugzwcn"itchhkvk0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"eqpvckpu"cv"ngcuv"c"fq|gp"yqogp" yjq"uygct"vjg{"Ðuwhhgtgf"pq"kplwt{Ñ"dgecwug"vjg{"pgxgt"gzrgtkgpegf"ugzwcnn{"jctcuukpi"eqpfwev0" " ]57:/33" *Fgh0Óu" Gzu0" ;/42+0_" " Cpqvjgt" fq|gp" yqogp" cvvguv" vjcv" vjg{" oc{" jcxg" gzrgtkgpegf" cp" kuqncvgf"kpuvcpeg"qh"kpcrrtqrtkcvg"eqpfwev."dwv"gkvjgt"ygtg"pqv"dqvjgtgf"d{"vjg"eqpfwev="jcpfngf"kv" vjgougnxgu"kp"c"ucvkuhcevqt{"ocppgt"*e.g.."d{"vgnnkpi"vjg"qhhgpfgt"vq"uvqr+="qt"tgrqtvgf"vjg"eqpfwev" vq"Fghgpfcpv"cpf"eqpukfgtgf"FghgpfcpvÓu"tgurqpug"crrtqrtkcvg0" " ]57:/33"*Fgh0Óu"Gzu0"43/54+0_" " " Rnckpvkhhu"tgeqipk|g"vjcv"gcej"encuu"ogodgt"oc{"jcxg"ykvpguugf"cpf1qt"dggp"uwdlgevgf"vq" fkhhgtgpv" uv{ngu" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv." fgrgpfkpi" qp" vjg" kpfkxkfwcn" rgtrgvtcvqt" cpf" vjgkt" qyp" tgcevkqp0" " ]545."cv"980_" " Uvknn."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"Ðokpqt"xctkcvkqpu"kp"vjgkt"gzrgtkgpegu"ecppqv" fghgcv"v{rkecnkv{0Ñ" " ]Id0_" " Jqygxgt."cu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg."vjg"ykfg"tcpig"qh"cnngicvkqpu"cv"kuuwg"kp" vjku" ecug" ecppqv" ceewtcvgn{" dg" ejctcevgtk|gf" cu" Ðokpqt" xctkcvkqpu0Ñ" " Ykvj" uwej" ykfg/tcpikpi" cnngicvkqpu."pcogf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"enckou"ecppqv"dg"uckf"vq"jcxg"vjg"ucog"guugpvkcn"ejctcevgtkuvkeu"cu" vjg"enckou"qh"vjg"encuu"cv"nctig0" " Pcogf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtuÓ"enckou"fgrgpf"qp" gzrquwtg" vq" fkhhgtkpi" eqpfwev." d{" fkhhgtgpv" gornq{ggu" qh" Fghgpfcpv." kp" fkhhgtgpv" ctgcu" qh" vjg" Rncpvu."qp"fkhhgtgpv"ujkhvu."cpf"ykvj"fkhhgtgpv"tguqnwvkqpu"*i.e.."yjgvjgt"vjg"xkevko"eqornckpgf."jqy" vjg"eqornckpv"ycu"jcpfngf."gve0+0" " Wpfgt"uwej"ektewouvcpegu."pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"ecppqv"dg"gzrgevgf" 67" vq"xkiqtqwun{"nkvkicvg"kuuwgu"tgncvkpi"vq"vjgug"etwekcn"curgevu"qh"cnn"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtuÓ"enckou." ocmkpi"fgpkcn"qh"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"hqt"ncem"qh"v{rkecnkv{"crrtqrtkcvg0" " Muro v. Target Corp.."7:2" H05f"6:7."6;5"*9vj"Ekt0"422;+"*chhktokpi"fgpkcn"qh"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"cpf"eqpenwfkpi"vjcv"v{rkecnkv{" ycu"ncemkpi"yjgtg"pcogf"rnckpvkhhÓu"enckou"ygtg"fkhhgtgpv"htqo"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtuÓ"enckou" uwej"vjcv"vjg"pcogf"rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"jcxg"vjg"kpegpvkxg"vq"nkvkicvg"xkiqtqwun{"egtvckp"kuuwgu+0" " Hqt" gzcorng."ykvj"pq"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"htqo"vjg"OR(N"fgrctvogpv"cv"vjg"Cuugodn{"Rncpv."kv"ku"pqv" engct" vq"vjg"Eqwtv" yj{" cp{" pcogf" Rnckpvkhh" yqwnf" jcxg" vjg" kpegpvkxg"vq" guvcdnkuj"vjg" gzvgpv" vq" yjkej"kortqrgt"eqpfwev"ycu"qeewttkpi"kp"vjcv"fgrctvogpv0" " Hkpcnn{." vjg" Eqwtv" ku" eqpegtpgf" vjcv" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" ykvj" uvtqpigt"enckou"oc{"dg"rtglwfkegf"d{"vjg"hcev"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"ctg"uggmkpi"vq"nwor"uvtqpigt"enckou" ykvj"ygcmgt"enckou0" " Vjku"eqpegtp"ku"jkijnkijvgf"d{"RnckpvkhhuÓ"ctiwogpv"vjcv"Ðkh"kv"vwtpu"qwv"vjcv" hgy" ogodgtu" qh" vjg" encuu" ygtg" jctogfÏyjkej" ku" pqv" vjg" ecugÏvjcv" ku" pqv" cp" ctiwogpv" hqt" tghwukpi"vq"egtvkh{"vjg"encuu."dwv"tcvjgt."hqt"egtvkh{kpi"kv"cpf"vjgp"gpvgtkpi"lwfiogpv"qp"vjg"ogtkvu" vjcv"gzqpgtcvgu"]Fghgpfcpv_0Ñ" " ]5:6."cv"3:0_" " Cu"pqvgf"d{"vjg"Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"kp"Butler v. Sears, Roebuck and Co.."kh"c"encuu"ku"egtvkhkgf"cpf"vjgp"lwfiogpv"ku"gpvgtgf"gzqpgtcvkpi"c"fghgpfcpv."Ðcnn" encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"fkf"pqv"qrv"qwv"qh"vjg"encuu"cevkqp"yqwnf"dg"dqwpf"d{"vjg"lwfiogpv0Ñ" " 949" H05f"9;8."9;;"*9vj"Ekt0"4235+0" " Kp"qvjgt"yqtfu."ceeqtfkpi"vq"Rnckpvkhhu."kh"kv"vwtpu"qwv"vjcv"qpn{"c" hgy"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"gzrqugf"vq"c"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv."vjgp"Fghgpfcpv"ujqwnf"ycpv"c" encuu"vq"dg"egtvkhkgf"dgecwug"Fghgpfcpv"vjgp"yqwnf"dg"gpvkvngf"vq"c"hcxqtcdng"lwfiogpv"ykvj"tgurgev" vq"cnn"encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"fkf"pqv"qrv"qwv"qh"vjg"encuu0" " Jqygxgt."kh"RnckpvkhhuÓ"cnngicvkqpu"ctg"vtwg." vjgtg"ctg"pwogtqwu"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"jcxg"uvtqpi"enckou"cickpuv" Fghgpfcpv0" " " 68" D{"cvvgorvkpi"vq"vkg"vqigvjgt"vjg"enckou"qh"cnn"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu" d{"wukpi"cp"qdlgevkxg"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv"cpcn{uku."Rnckpvkhhu"wpfgtokpg"vjg"enckou"qh"vjqug" yjq"ygtg"gzrqugf"vq"vjg"oquv"gitgikqwu"okueqpfwev0" " Cu"vjg"Eqwtv"jcu"qdugtxgf"cv"rtkqt"jgctkpiu" kp" vjku" ecug." kh" vjg" Rnckpvkhhu" yjq" gzrgtkgpegf" vjg" oquv" ugxgtg" okueqpfwev" kfgpvkhkgf" kp" vjg" cnngicvkqpu"cpf"fgrqukvkqp"vguvkoqp{"kp"vjku"ecug"ecp"eqpxkpeg"c"lwt{"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"ycu"cyctg"qh" vjcv" okueqpfwev" cpf" fkf" pqvjkpi" vq" uvqr" cpf1qt" rwpkuj" kv." vjg{" oc{" dg" gpvkvngf" vq" c" nctig" xgtfkevÏhct"nctigt"vjcp"cp{"tgcuqpcdng"xgtfkev"dcugf"qp"rtqxgp"cnngicvkqpu"qh"gzrquwtg"vq"ugzkuv" itchhkvk"qt"gzrquwtg"vq"kuqncvgf"eqoogpvu"vjcv"fkf"pqv"dqvjgt"vjgo0" " Vq"fcvg."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv" ocfg"c"ujqykpi"vjcv"cp{"vyq"kpfkxkfwcnuÏowej"nguu"vjg"encuu"vjg{"uggm"vq"egtvkh{Ïgzrgtkgpegf" vjg"ucog"okueqpfwev"kp"vjg"ucog"yc{0" " Cu"pqvgf"cdqxg."rgtjcru"vjg{"ecp"ykvj"hwtvjgt"ghhqtv0" " Dwv" hqt" cnn" qh" vjgug" tgcuqpu." vjg" Eqwtv" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" pqv" cv" vjku" lwpevwtg" ucvkuhkgf" Twng"45*c+Óu"v{rkecnkv{"tgswktgogpv0" " " F0" Cfgswce{"qh"Tgrtgugpvcvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*c+*6+" Dghqtg"c"encuu"yknn"dg"egtvkhkgf."Twng"45*c+*6+"tgswktgu"vjcv"pcogf"rnckpvkhhu"ujqy"vjcv"Ðvjg" tgrtgugpvcvkxg" rctvkgu" yknn" hcktn{" cpf" cfgswcvgn{" rtqvgev" vjg" kpvgtguvu" qh" vjg" encuu0Ñ" " Hqt" vjg" cfgswce{"tgswktgogpv" vq" dg" ucvkuhkgf." vjg" enckou" cpf"kpvgtguvu"qh" vjg" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" owuv" pqv" eqphnkev" ykvj" vjqug" qh" vjg" encuu." vjg" encuu" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu" owuv" jcxg" uwhhkekgpv" kpvgtguv" kp" vjg" qwveqog" qh" vjg" ecug." cpf" encuu" eqwpugn" owuv" dg" gzrgtkgpegf" cpf" eqorgvgpv0" " Retired Chicago Police Ass’n v. City of Chicago."9"H05f"7:6."7;:"*9vj"Ekt0"3;;5+0" " Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu" hckn"vq"ucvkuh{"Twng"45*c+*6+Óu"cfgswce{"tgswktgogpv"dgecwug"*3+"vjg"encuu"ku"rgtogcvgf"d{"eqphnkevu" qh"kpvgtguv."*4+"RnckpvkhhuÓ"rwtuwkv"qh"vjku"ecug"kp"vjg"hceg"qh"vjg"GGQE"Eqpeknkcvkqp"Citggogpv"cpf" vjgkt"cvvgorvgf"kpvgttghgtgpeg"ykvj"vjcv"citggogpv"tgpfgt"vjgo"kpcfgswcvg"encuu"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu." cpf"*5+"RnckpvkhhuÓ"eqwpugn"ku"pqv"cfgswcvg0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"cfftguugu"gcej"qh"vjgug"ctiwogpvu"kp"vwtp0" " " 69" i. Conflicts of Interest Fghgpfcpv" ctiwgu" vjcv" eqphnkevu" qh" kpvgtguv" coqpi" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu"dctu"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"ecppqv"ucvkuh{"vjg" cfgswce{" tgswktgogpv" dgecwug" egtvckp" pcogf" RnckpvkhhuÓ" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" cnuq" ctg" ceewugf"qh"gpicikpi"kp"vjg"okueqpfwev"cv"kuuwg"kp"vjku"ecug0" " Ð]F_wg"rtqeguu"tgswktgu"vjcv"cdugpv" encuu"ogodgtu"dg"cfgswcvgn{"tgrtgugpvgf"kp"qtfgt"vq"dg"dqwpf"d{"c"eqwtvÓu"lwfiogpv0Ñ" " Susman v. Lincoln Am. Corp.." 783" H04f" :8." ;2" *9vj" Ekt0" 3;99+" *ekvcvkqpu" cpf" hqqvpqvg" qokvvgf+0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg." Knnkpqku" Twng" qh" Rtqhguukqpcn" Eqpfwev" 309" gzrtguun{" rtqjkdkvu" wpfgtvcmkpi" c" tgrtgugpvcvkqp"qh"qpg"enkgpv"vjcv"ku"Ðfktgevn{"cfxgtug"vq"cpqvjgt"enkgpv0Ñ" " Ceeqtfkpin{."eqwtvu"jcxg" hqwpf"kpcfgswcvg"tgrtgugpvcvkqp"yjgtg"rnckpvkhhu"uqwijv"vq"tgrtgugpv"c"encuu"vjcv"kpenwfgf"vjqug" yjq"cnngigfn{"rctvkekrcvgf"kp"vjg"ytqpihwn"eqpfwev0" " Lee v. Children’s Place Retail Stores, Inc.." 4236" YN" 732282:." cv" ,5" *P0F0" Knn0" Qev0" :." 4236+=" Wright v. Family Dollar, Inc.." 4232" YN" 6;84:5:."cv",5"*P0F0"Knn0"Pqx0"52."4232+="Mateo v. V.F. Corp.."422;"YN"578375;."cv",7"*P0F0"Ecn0" Qev0"49."422;+="Sample v. Aldi Inc.."3;;6"YN"6:9:2."cv",6"*P0F0"Knn0"Hgd0"37."3;;6+0" " Cnvjqwij" Rnckpvkhhu" cvvgorv" vq" fkuvkpiwkuj" vjgug" ecugu." vjg{" hckn" vq" fq" uq" kp" cp{" ogcpkpihwn" yc{0" " Hqt" gzcorng."Rnckpvkhhu"pqvg"vjcv"kp"Wright"vjg"pcogf"rnckpvkhh"ycu"Ðc"ocpcigt"yjq"cevwcnn{"vqqm"vjg" cevkqpu"eqornckpgf"qh"kp"vjg"ecug0Ñ" " ]5:6."cv"45"*ekvkpi"Wright."4232"YN"6;84:5:+0_" " Jqygxgt." Fghgpfcpv" jcu" kfgpvkhkgf" uwej" c" eqphnkev" kp" vjku" ecug0" " Urgekhkecnn{." Fghgpfcpv" jcu" kfgpvkhkgf" cnngicvkqpu" qh" okueqpfwev" cickpuv" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu0" " Kp" cp{" gxgpv." vjg" Eqwtv" citggu" vjcv" kv" ku" c" eqphnkev"qh"kpvgtguv"vq"kpenwfg"vjqug"yjq"cnngigfn{"jcxg"gpicigf"kp"vjg"okueqpfwev"cv"kuuwg"kp"vjg" encuu0" " " " Kpfggf."vjg"ecugu"tgnkgf"wrqp"d{"Rnckpvkhhu"uwrrqtv"vjg"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"ytqpifqgtu"ujqwnf" pqv"dg"kpenwfgf"kp"vjg"encuu"yjgp"vjg{"ctg"rctv"qh"vjg"rtqdngo0" " Brown v. Yellow Transp., Inc.." 6:" 4233" YN" 3:5:963." cv" ,6" *P0F0" Knn0" Oc{" 33." 4233+0" " Kp" Brown." vjg" eqwtv" egtvkhkgf" c" encuu" vjcv" kpenwfgf"uwrgtxkuqtu0" " Id0"cv",90" " Dghqtg"fqkpi"uq."jqygxgt."vjg"eqwtv"pqvgf"vjcv"Ð]k_p"uqog"ecugu." vjg"kpenwukqp"qh"uwrgtxkuqtu"cu"rctv"qh"vjg"encuu"yjgp"vjg{"ctg"cnuq"rctv"qh"vjg"rtqdngo"tgpfgtu"encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" kpcrrtqrtkcvg0Ñ" " Id0" cv" ,60" " Dgecwug" vjgtg" ycu" pq" kpfkecvkqp" vjcv" vjg" Chtkecp/Cogtkecp"uwrgtxkuqtu"ygtg"rctv"qh"vjg"tcekcn"fkuetkokpcvkqp"cv"vjg"jgctv"qh"vjcv"ecug."vjg" kpenwukqp"qh"Chtkecp/Cogtkecp"uwrgtxkuqtu"kp"vjg"encuu"fkf"pqv"coqwpv"vq"c"eqphnkev0" " Id0" Kp"vjku"ecug."qp"vjg"qvjgt"jcpf."Fghgpfcpv"jcu"kfgpvkhkgf"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" eqpvtkdwvgf" vq" vjg" ugzwcnn{" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" ejcnngpig0" " Rnckpvkhh"Xcp"ceewugu"jgt"vjgp"uwrgtxkuqt"cpf"eq/Rnckpvkhh"Egrjcpk"Oknngt"qh"ocmkpi" kpcrrtqrtkcvg"eqoogpvu0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Ou0"Xcp"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"Ou0"Oknngt"tgvcnkcvgf"cickpuv"jgt"cpf" cumgf"Ou0"Xcp"yjgvjgt"ujg"vjqwijv"gxgt{qpg"ycu"ugzwcnn{"jctcuukpi"jgt"dgecwug"ujgÓu"uq"ugz{0" " ]57:/35"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"76"Î"Xcp"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"368/690_" " Ou0"Xcp"kp"vwtp"ycu"ceewugf"qh"gpicikpi"kp" okueqpfwev"d{"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"Ujcpgvvc"O{ngu0" " Urgekhkecnn{."Ou0"O{ngu"kpfkecvgf"kp"cp" kpvgtxkgy"vjcv"Ou0"Xcp"eqoogpvgf"qp"Ou0"O{nguÓu"ygkijv"cpf"dqf{"rctvu0" " ]57:/38"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0" 328+." cv" 340_" " Ceeqtfkpi" vq" Ou0" O{ngu." Ou0" Xcp" cnuq" uvcvgf" Ðikxg" og" uqog" qh" vjqug" ]vkvvkgu_0Ñ" " ]Id0_" " Ukoknctn{."rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"Tqugvvc"Uokvj"uwdokvvgf"cp"chhkfcxkv"kpfkecvkpi"vjcv"Octkc" Rtkeg"qrgpn{"fkuewuugf"jgt"ugzwcn"rtghgtgpegu"kp"vjg"yqtmrnceg0" " ]57:/33"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"52"Î"Uokvj" Fgen0+."cv"323." "430_" " Ou0"Rtkeg"cnuq"yqwnf"itggv"ocng"gornq{ggu"ykvj"c"jwi"cpf"qhvgp"yqwnf" dnqy"mkuugu"cv"vjgo0" " ]Id0"cv"324." "440_" " Ou0"Rtkeg"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"Ectogn"Itgiqt{"Ðycu"kpvgtguvgf" kp"c"tqocpvke"tgncvkqpujkrÑ"ykvj"Ou0"Rtkeg"cpf"Ðyqwnf"eqpuvcpvn{"ecnn"]Ou0"Rtkeg_"vq"vjg"qhhkeg" wruvcktu"cpf"vgnn"]jgt_"jqy"rtgvv{"]ujg_"ycu"cpf"uvqr"ikxkpi"]Ou0"Itgiqt{_"vjg"dcd{fqnn"g{gu"cpf" lwuv"vq"igv"vq"mpqy"jgt0Ñ" " ]57:/35"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"72"Î"Rtkeg"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"3480_" " Kpfggf."kp"Ou0"RtkegÓu" GGQE" Ejctig." Ou0" Rtkeg" nkuvgf" Ou0" Itgiqt{" cu" qpg" qh" jgt" ugzwcn" jctcuugtu0" " ]4;/43." cv" 40_" " 6;" Rnckpvkhhu" cnuq"pqvg"vjcv"cp"gornq{gg"qh" Fghgpfcpv"vguvkhkgf"vjcv"Ncdqt"Tgncvkqpu"tgrtgugpvcvkxg" Pcvcnkg"Fcjtkpigt"vqnf"jko"vjcv"Rnckpvkhh"Xcp"yqwnf"pggf"vq"ftqr"jgt"ecug"dghqtg"ujg"yqwnf"dg" oqxgf"qwv"qh"jgt"nqecvkqp"yjgtg"ujg"ycu"dgkpi"jctcuugf0" " ]547/68"*Oqtvqp"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"38/390_" " Cnvjqwij"Ou0"Fcjtkpigt"fgpkgu"vjku."vjgtg"ku"eqphnkevkpi"vguvkoqp{"qp"vjg"kuuwg0" " Rnckpvkhh"Jgngp" Cnngp/Coqu"ceewugf"Oqpkswg"Lqjpuqp"qh"cevkpi"kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"d{"Ðcnyc{u" itcddkpi" qp" ogp." ukvvkpi"qp"vjgkt"ncru.Ñ"cpf"uswgg|kpi"vjgkt"dwvvu"yjgp"ujg"jwiigf"vjg"ogp0" " ]57:/35"*Fgh0Óu"Gz0"58" Î"Cnngp/Coqu"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv":0_" " FghgpfcpvÓu"tgurqpug"dtkgh"qwvnkpgu"pwogtqwu"qvjgt"gzcorngu"qh" cnngicvkqpu"qh"okueqpfwev"cickpuv"yqogp"yqtmkpi"cv"vjg"Rncpvu0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"vjgougnxgu"crrctgpvn{"jcxg"tgeqipk|gf"eqphnkevu0" " Cv"jgt"fgrqukvkqp."Iyclwcpc" Itc{"rtqxkfgf"vjg"hqnnqykpi"vguvkoqp{"tgictfkpi"jgt"kpcdknkv{"vq"rtqeggf"ykvj"jgt"fgrqukvkqp"qp" vjg"uejgfwngf"fc{<" K"co"ukvvkpi"jgtg"vqfc{"wpfgt"c"nqv"qh"fwtguu"cpf"qxgtyjgnogf"fwg"vq"vjg"jctcuuogpv" qh"uqog"qh"vjg"pcogf"rnckpvkhhu"yjqug"eqwpugn"ku"jgtg"vqfc{"cpf"vjcv"K"jcxg"lwuv" tgegpvn{"ugrctcvgf"htqo0" " K"lwuv"tgegpvn{"hqwpf"qwv"vjcv"Ot0"Jwpv"ku"tgrtgugpvkpi" uqog"ocpcigogpv"uvchh"vjcv"K"ugg"qp"c"fckn{"dcuku0" " O{"eqpegtp"ku"vjcv"vjg{"yknn" ujctg"yjcv"K"uc{"ykvj"o{"koogfkcvg"jctcuugt0" " K"co"pqv"kp"c"iqqf"rnceg"yjgtg"K" dgnkgxg"vjcv"K"ecp"jcpfng"vjku"fgrqukvkqp"vtwvjhwnn{"qt"tgogodgt"cnn"qh"vjg"gxgpvu" dgecwug"o{" okpf"ku"hqewugf"qp"yjcv"oc{"jcrrgp"vq" og"cv" yqtm"cv"Hqtf" Oqvqt" Eqorcp{0" " K"tgugtxg"o{"tkijv"vq"uggm"eqwpugn"vq"rtqvgev"og"htqo"o{"ecug"cickpuv" Hqtf0" " KÓo"chtckf"qh"vjg"tgvcnkcvkqp"vjcv"okijv"qeewt0" " " " ]57:/36"*Itc{"Fgr0"Vt0+."cv"3620_" " Vjg"eqphnkevu"kp"vjku"ecug"vjgtghqtg"ctg"pqv"ogtgn{"urgewncvkxg"cu" Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvgpf0" " Cf. Kohen v. Pac. Inv. Mgmt. Co. LLC."793"H05f"894."8:2"*9vj"Ekt0"422;+" *chhktokpi"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"yjgtg"vjg"gzkuvgpeg"qh"eqphnkevu"qh"kpvgtguv"ycu"Ðj{rqvjgvkecnÑ+0" Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcv" egtvckp" qh" vjku" cnngigf" okueqpfwev" ku" pqv" tgngxcpv" dgecwug" Ðhgocng" jctcuuogpv"ku"pqv"cv"kuuwgÑ"kp"vjku"ecug0" " ]545."cv":40_" " Jqygxgt."Ðugz"fkuetkokpcvkqp"eqpukuvkpi"qh" ucog/ugz" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" ku" cevkqpcdng" wpfgt" Vkvng" XKK0Ñ" " Oncale v. Sundowner Offshore Servs., Inc.." 745" W0U0" 97." :4" *3;;:+0" " Vjg" hcev" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" ctg" cumkpi" vjcv" vjg" Eqwtv" ukorn{" 72" kipqtg" cnngicvkqpu" qh" Ðhgocng" jctcuuogpvÑ" vjcv" ctiwcdn{" eqwnf" uvtgpivjgp" vjg" enckou" qh" egtvckp" rnckpvkhhu"fgoqpuvtcvgu"jqy"vjg"eqphnkev"kfgpvkhkgf"d{"Fghgpfcpv"nkmgn{"yknn"ocpkhguv"kp"vjku"ecug0" " Ð]C_" eqphnkev" qh" kpvgtguv" ctkugu" yjgp" cp" cvvqtpg{" jcu" cp" kpegpvkxg" vq" tglgev" nkpgu" qh" kpswkt{" qt" ctiwogpv"vjcv"okijv"jgnr"jku"enkgpvÓu"ecug0Ñ" " Doe v. Nielsen."::5"H05f"938."93;"*9vj"Ekt0"423:+" *ekvkpi"United States v. Algee."52;"H05f"3233."3236"*9vj"Ekt0"4224++0" " Rnckpvkhhu"crrgct"vq"dg"fqkpi" uq"jgtg"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"Ðhgocng"jctcuuogpvÑ"cnngicvkqpu"kfgpvkhkgf"d{"Fghgpfcpv0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"pgzv"ctiwg"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"pq"cevwcn"eqphnkev"dgecwug"ogtg"Ðcpgefqvcn"cnngicvkqpu"qh" ugzwcn" eqoogpvu" qt" kppwgpfq" ocfg" d{" vjg" encuu" ogodgtu." d{" kvugnh" fqgu" pqv" eqpuvkvwvg" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv0Ñ" " ]545." cv" :3" *ekvcvkqp" qokvvgf+0_" " Jqygxgt." Rnckpvkhhu" tgn{" qp" ukoknct" cpgefqvcn" gxkfgpeg" vq" uwrrqtv" vjgkt" enckou0" " ]Ugg" 545." cv" 77" *ÐRnckpvkhhuÓ" cpgefqvcn" gxkfgpeg" nkmgykug" uwrrqtvu"vjgkt"cnngicvkqpu"cpf"c"hkpfkpi"qh"eqooqpcnkv{0Ñ+0_" " Kpfggf."kp"Gzjkdkv"76"vq"RnckpvkhhuÓ" kpkvkcn"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp."Rnckpvkhhu"vjgougnxgu"ecvgiqtk|gf"uqog"qh"vjgug"cnngicvkqpu"cu" ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv0" " Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"pqy"encko"vq"fkucxqy"cp{"kpvgpv"vq"rwtuwg"enckou"dcugf" cnngigf"okueqpfwev"d{"yqogp."vjku"fqgu"pqv"ejcpig"vjg"ejctcevgt"qh"vjg"eqpfwev"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu" vjgougnxgu"ecvgiqtk|gf"cu"kortqrgt0" " Cu"pqvgf"d{"Fghgpfcpv."vjg"hcev"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"eqwpugn" ctiwg"dqvj"ukfgu"qh"vjku"kuuwg"wpfgtueqtgu"vjg"ugtkqwu"eqphnkev"ykvjkp"vjg"encuu0" " " Hwtvjgtoqtg."Rnckpvkhhu"vjgougnxgu"jcxg"ctiwgf"vjcv"kv"ku"kortqrgt"vq"cnnqy"vjqug"yjq"jcxg" gpicigf"kp"okueqpfwev"vq"dg"eqorgpucvgf"hqt"okueqpfwev0" " Kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjgkt"ctiwogpv"vjcv"vjg" GGQE"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"ku"hncygf."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"kv"ku"vtqwdnkpi"vjcv"xkevkou"cpf"jctcuugtu" ctg" eqorgpucvgf" htqo" vjg" ucog" hwpf." cu" ocng" Chtkecp/Cogtkecp" gornq{ggu" yjq" cnngigfn{" gpicigf" kp" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" ctg" dgkpi" eqorgpucvgf" hqt" tcekcn" jctcuuogpv0" " Dwv" Rnckpvkhhu" pqpgvjgnguu"cum"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv"egtvkh{"c"encuu"eqpvckpkpi"yqogp"yjq"ctg"ceewugf"qh"gpicikpi"kp"vjg" okueqpfwev"cnngigf"kp"vjku"ncyuwkv0" " Kp"vjgkt"dtkghkpi"qp"vjgkt"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp." 73" Rnckpvkhhu" cuugtvgf" vjcv" kv" Ðku" vtwgÑ" vjcv" Ðvjgtg" ctg" c" hgy" yqogp" yjq" jcxg" dggp" xkevkou" qh" vjg" codkgpv" ugzwcnn{" jctcuukpi" yqtmrnceg" gpxktqpogpv." dwv" yjq" jcxg" cnuq" hqwijv" vq" rtgugtxg" vjg" ugzwcnn{"jctcuukpi"ewnvwtgÑ"kp"vjg"Rncpvu0" " ]488."cv"390_" " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"cvvgorvgf"vq"gzrnckp"cyc{" vjg" vguvkoqp{" qh" Qtkuuc" Jgpt{." yjq" vguvkhkgf" vjcv" Uwrgtxkuqt" Icnkpfc" Ngg" eqpvtkdwvgf" vq" vjg" ugzwcnn{"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv."d{"ctiwkpi"vjcv"dgecwug"Ou0"NggÓu"jwudcpf"ycu"vgtokpcvgf"hqt" jcxkpi"ugz"ykvj"hgocng"eqyqtmgtu."Ðkv"ku"gcu{"vq"ugg"yj{"uwej"ektewouvcpegu"eqwnf"qhhgpf"Ou0" Ngg." cpf" jqy" vjg" uwdugswgpv" fkutwrvkqp" qh" jgt" hcokn{Óu" kpeqog" eqwnf" etgcvg" eqphwukqp" qt" cpkoqukv{"d{"jgt"vqyctf"jgt"eqornckpkpi"hgocng"yqtmgtu0Ñ" " ]488."cv"390_" " Rnckpvkhhu"eqpvkpwg"vq" ocmg" uwej" uvcvgogpvu" kp" vjgkt" dtkghkpi" qp" vjgkt" rgpfkpi" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" oqvkqp0" " Rnckpvkhhu" cuugtv" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" ygtg" hqtegf" Ðvq" dgeqog" rctv" qh" vjg" ugzwcnn{" jctcuukpi" ewnvwtg" qt" kipqtg" vjg" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" gpvktgn{" vq" dg" uweeguuhwn" cpf" pqv" quvtcek|gf." cffkpi"vq"vjg"jquvknkv{0Ñ" " ]5:6."cv"430_" " Vjku"fghgpug"qh"rgtuqpu"yjq"Rnckpvkhhu"cfokv"uqwijv"vq" rtgugtxg" vjg" ugzwcnn{" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" fgoqpuvtcvgu" vjgtg" ku" pqv" ukorn{" c" urgewncvkxg" eqphnkev"qh"kpvgtguv."dwv"cp"cevwcn"eqphnkev"qh"kpvgtguv047" " " Hkpcnn{."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"kv"ku"pqv"ecvgiqtkecnn{"kortqrgt"vq"egtvkh{"c"encuu"vjcv"kpenwfgu" gornq{ggu"cv"fkhhgtgpv"ngxgnu"qh"gornq{ogpv0" " Dwv"vjcv"ctiwogpv"okuugu"vjg"octm0" " Fghgpfcpv"ku" pqv" ctiwkpi" vjcv" eqphnkevu" gzkuv" ogtgn{" dgecwug" vjg" rtqrqugf" encuu" kpenwfgu" dqvj" ocpcigtu" cpf" pqp/ocpcigtu0" " Fghgpfcpv" ku" ctiwkpi" vjcv" eqphnkevu" gzkuv" dgecwug" vjg" rtqrqugf" encuu" kpenwfgu" kpfkxkfwcnu"yjq"cnngigfn{"gpicigf"kp"vjg"okueqpfwev"cv"kuuwg0" " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv" jcu"cwvjqtkv{"vq"tguqnxg"cp{"rqvgpvkcn"eqphnkevu"dgvyggp"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"cpf"vjg"encuu"d{"etgcvkpi" uvtwevwtcn"rtqvgevkqpu."uwej"cu"hqtocn"uwdencuugu."qt"crrqkpvkpi"ugrctcvg"eqwpugn"hqt"ogodgtu"yjq" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 47 " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"Fghgpfcpv"qpn{"jcu"rqkpvgf"vq"hgy"kuqncvgf"kpekfgpvu"kp"yjkej"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" jcxg" dggp" ceewugf" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" d{" cpqvjgt" yqocp0" " Jqygxgt." vjg" gzcorngu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg"cpf"kp"FghgpfcpvÓu"dtkghkpi"fgoqpuvtcvg"vjcv"eqphnkevu"gzkuv0" " Cickp."ikxgp"vjg" ctiwogpvu" dgkpi" ocfg" d{" Rnckpvkhhu" cu" c" tguwnv" qh" vjgug" kfgpvkhkgf" eqphnkevu." vjg" eqphnkevu" ocmg" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp"kpcrrtqrtkcvg0" " " 74" oc{"jcxg"fkxgtigpv"kpvgtguvu0" " Rnckpvkhhu"vjgtghqtg"ctiwg"vjcv"kh"vjg"Eqwtv"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"ocpcigtu" ecppqv"cfgswcvgn{"tgrtgugpv"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"pqp/ocpcigtu."vjg"Eqwtv"eqwnf"egtvkh{"vyq"uwdencuugu" *i.e.."c"encuu"qh"ocpcigtu"cpf"c"encuu"qh"pqp/ocpcigtu+"vq"tgogf{"cp{"kpvtc/encuu"eqphnkevu0" " Cickp." vjku"ctiwogpv"okuugu"vjg"octm0" " Cu"Fghgpfcpv"pqvgu."uwej"c"fkxkukqp"yqwnf"pqv"gnkokpcvg"eqphnkevu" qh" kpvgtguv" dgecwug" vjgtg" ctg" cnngicvkqpu" qh" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv" d{" pqp/ocpcigtu" cickpuv" pqp/ocpcigtu0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."vjgtg"ku"pq"kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"cnn"hgocng"ocpcigtu"ctg"cnngigf"vq"jcxg" gpicigf" kp" okueqpfwev0" " Kv" vjgtghqtg" uvknn" yqwnf" dg" rtqdngocvke" vq" jcxg" ocpcigtu" ceewugf" qh" okueqpfwev" kp" vjg" ucog" uwdencuu" cu" ocpcigtu" yjq" ctg" pqv" cnngigf" vq" jcxg" eqookvvgf" cp{" ytqpifqkpi0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"rtqrqug"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv"cnuq"eqwnf"gnkokpcvg"eqphnkevu"qh"kpvgtguv"d{"egtvkh{kpi"c" uwdencuu"qh"yqogp"yjq"jcxg"dggp"ceewugf"qh"gpicikpi"kp"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv"cpf1qt"eqpvtkdwvkpi" vq" c" ugzwcnn{" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv0" " Jqygxgt." uwej" c" fghkpkvkqp" yqwnf" dg" korgtokuukdng" xciwg0" " ÐCxqkfkpi"xciwgpguu"ku"korqtvcpv"Òdgecwug"c"eqwtv"pggfu"vq"dg"cdng"vq"kfgpvkh{"yjq"yknn" tgegkxg"pqvkeg."yjq"yknn"ujctg"kp"cp{"tgeqxgt{."cpf"yjq"yknn"dg"dqwpf"d{"c"lwfiogpv0ÓÑ" " Steimel v. Wernert." :45" H05f" ;24." ;3:" *9vj" Ekt0" 4238+" *swqvkpi" Mullins." 9;7" H05f" cv" 87;+0" " ÐVq" cxqkf" xciwgpguu." encuu" fghkpkvkqpu" igpgtcnn{" pggf" vq" kfgpvkh{" c" rctvkewnct" itqwr." jctogf" fwtkpi" c" rctvkewnct" vkog" htcog." kp" c" rctvkewnct" nqecvkqp." kp" c" rctvkewnct" yc{0Ñ" " Mullins." 9;7" H05f" cv" 882" *ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"jcu"pq"yc{"qh"mpqykpi"cv"vjku"vkog"yjgvjgt"cp{"pcogf"Rnckpvkhh"qt" rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"yknn"dg"ceewugf"qh"gpicikpi"kp"okueqpfwev0" " Kp"cffkvkqp"vq"vjg"xciwgpguu" rtqdngo."eqphnkevu"yqwnf"uvknn"tgockp"ykvjkp"vjg"itqwr"qh"encuu"ogodgtu"ceewugf"qh"okueqpfwev0" " Urgekhkecnn{."vjcv"itqwr"uvknn"yqwnf"kpenwfg"yqogp"yjq"cnngig"vjcv"vjg{"ygtg"jctcuugf"d{"qvjgt" yqogp" ykvjkp" vjg" uwd/encuu0" " Hqt" gzcorng." Ou0"Xcp." yjq" jcu" dggp" ceewugf" qh" okueqpfwev." rtguwocdn{" yqwnf" dg" kp" vjcv" uwd/encuu" ykvj" Ou0"Oknngt." cickpuv" yjqo" Ou0" Xcp" jcu" ocfg" 75" cnngicvkqpu" qh" okueqpfwev0" " RnckpvkhhuÓ" rtqrqugf" uwdencuugu" fq" pqv" gnkokpcvg" vjg" eqphnkevu" kfgpvkhkgf"d{"Fghgpfcpv0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"eqpenwfgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"ucvkuh{"Twng"45*c+Óu" cfgswce{"tgswktgogpv"cpf"fgpkgu"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"qp"vjcv"dcuku0" " " ii. EEOC Conciliation Agreement Fghgpfcpv" ctiwgu" vjcv" RnckpvkhhuÓ" rwtuwkv" qh" vjku" ecug" kp" vjg" hceg" qh" vjg" 4239" GGQE" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" cpf" vjgkt" cvvgorvgf" kpvgthgtgpeg" ykvj" vjcv" citggogpv" tgpfgt" vjgo" kpcfgswcvg"encuu"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu0" " Twng"45*c+*6+Óu"cfgswce{"tgswktgogpv"ku"pqv"ogv"yjgtg"encuu" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"hckn"vq"cev"Ðkp"vjg"dguv"kpvgtguvu"qh"vjg"wppcogf"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"encuuÑ"cpf"fq"pqv" Ðmggr" vjg" kpvgtguvu" qh" vjg" gpvktg"encuu"cv"vjg"hqtghtqpv0Ñ" " Conrad v. Boiron, Inc.." :8;"H05f" 758." 75;/62"*9vj"Ekt0"4239+"*ekvkpi"In re Aqua Dots Prods. Liab. Litig.."876"H05f"974."96:"*9vj"Ekt0" 4233++0" " Yjgtg"vjgtg"ctg"Ðtgogfkgu"cntgcf{"kp"rncegÑ"hqt"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu."cfgswce{"oc{" dg"ncemkpi"dgecwug"pcogf"rnckpvkhhu"ecppqv"Ðdtkpi"cp{"ukipkhkecpv"gzvtc"xcnwg"vq"vjg"cdugpvgg"encuu" ogodgtuÑ"cpf"vjgtghqtg"oc{"pqv"dg"cevkpi"kp"vjg"dguv"kpvgtguv"qh"vjg"wppcogf"ogodgtu"qh"vjg" encuu0" " Id0" " Jqygxgt."vjku"ku"pqv"c"ecug"yjgtg"kv"ku"engct"vjcv"nkvkicvkqp"ecppqv"dtkpi"cp{"ukipkhkecpv" gzvtc" xcnwg" vq" cdugpv" encuu" ogodgtu0" " Cu" pqvgf" d{" Rnckpvkhhu." ocp{" enckocpvu" jcf" vjgkt" enckou" fgpkgf"vjtqwij"vjg"GGQE"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu0" " Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjgug"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu" jcxg" xkcdng" enckou." kv" ecppqv" dg" uckf" vjcv" vjgug" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" cntgcf{" jcxg" cfgswcvg" tgogfkgu"kp"rnceg0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."cnvjqwij"c"ukipkhkecpv"rgtegpvcig"qh"enckocpvu"yjq"ygtg"qhhgtgf" cyctfu"ceegrvgf"vjgo."uqog"fkf"pqv0" " Cickp."vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjgug"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"jcxg" xkcdng" enckouÏkpenwfkpi" enckou" vjcv" okijv" dg" xcnwgf" cv" cp" coqwpv" ygnn" kp" gzeguu" qh" cp{" eqpegkxcdng"tgogf{"qhhgtgf"d{"vjg"GGQEÏkv"ecppqv"dg"uckf"vjcv"vjgug"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu" cntgcf{"jcxg"tgogfkgu"kp"rnceg0" " Vjku"ecug"vjgtghqtg"ku"wpnkmg"In re Aqua Dots Product Liability Litigation."kp"yjkej"rnckpvkhhu"uqwijv"vjg"gzcev"tghwpf"coqwpv"cntgcf{"dgkpi"qhhgtgf"vq"ogodgtu"qh" 76" vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"d{"vjg"fghgpfcpv0" " 876"H05f"96:."974"*9vj"Ekt0"4233+"*ÐC"tgrtgugpvcvkxg"yjq" rtqrqugu"vjcv"jkij"vtcpucevkqp"equvu"*pqvkeg"cpf"cvvqtpg{uÓ"hggu+"dg"kpewttgf"cv"vjg"encuu"ogodgtuÓ" gzrgpug"vq"qdvckp"c"tghwpf"vjcv"cntgcf{"ku"qp"qhhgt"ku"pqv"cfgswcvgn{"rtqvgevkpi"vjg"encuu"ogodgtuÓ" kpvgtguvu0Ñ"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf++0" " " Ukoknctn{." vq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" uggm" kplwpevkxg" tgnkgh." vjg" Eqwtv" tgkvgtcvgu" vjg" eqpegtpu"kv"kfgpvkhkgf"kp"kvu"rtkqt"qtfgt"qp"RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"oqvkqp0" " Kv"uvknn"ku"pqv" {gv" engct" vjcv" vjg" oqpkvqtkpi" ogejcpkuou" ugv" hqtvj" kp" vjg" 4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv" yqwnf" fwrnkecvg"vjg"tgnkgh"uqwijv"kp"vjku"ecug0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"tgeqipk|gu"vjg"tgcuqpcdng"cuuworvkqp"vjcv"vjg" GGQE"ku"cevkpi"kp"vjg"dguv"kpvgtguvu"qh"vjqug"yjqo"kv"ku"vcumgf"ykvj"rtqvgevkpi0" " Ugg"Thornton v. State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co.."4228"YN"557;6:4."cv",5"*P0F0"Qjkq"Pqx0"39."4228+"*ÐRtqeggfkpiu" d{"vjg"uvcvg."yjgvjgt"kp"c"lwfkekcn"qt"cp"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"hqtwo."ctg"rtguwocdn{"vcmgp"ykvj"vjg"dguv" kpvgtguvu"qh"uvcvg"tgukfgpvu"kp"okpf0" " Tgcuqpcdng"ugvvngogpv"d{"vjg"ceewugf"ujqwnf"dg"gpeqwtcigf0" " Kpfggf."rqvgpvkcn"encuu"ogodgtu"yknn"qhvgp"tgeqxgt"oqtg"vjcp"vjg{"yqwnf"kp"c"rtkxcvg"cevkqp"yjgp" equvu" cpf" cvvqtpg{uÓ" hggu" ctg" hcevqtgf" kp0Ñ+0" " Uvknn." vjg" cnngicvkqpu" qh" FghgpfcpvÓu" tgekfkxkuo" rtqxkfg"c"dcuku"hqt"uqog"umgrvkekuo"*cpf"c"eqttgurqpfkpi"fgitgg"qh"ecwvkqp"cpf"fwg"fknkigpeg+"kp" vjku"ctgc0" " " Fghgpfcpv"cnuq"ctiwgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"eqwpugn"jcxg"rtqxgp"vjgkt"kpcfgswce{" d{"qrrqukpi"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtuÏhktuv"d{"hknkpi"cp"Ðgogtigpe{"oqvkqpÑ"vq" rtgxgpv"vjgkt"eq/yqtmgtu"htqo"gxgp"tgegkxkpi"vjg"Enckou"Hqtou"vjcv"yqwnf"gpcdng"vjgo"vq"dgpghkv" htqo"vjg"Citggogpv"vjcv"vjg"GGQE"pgiqvkcvgf"qp"vjgkt"dgjcnh."cpf"ncvgt"d{"hknkpi"c"oqvkqp"vq"uvc{" vjg" fkuvtkdwvkqp" qh" cyctf" pqvkegu" vq" vjqug" yjqo" vjg" Rcpgn" kfgpvkhkgf" cu" gnkikdng" hqt" cp" cyctf0" " Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" kfgpvkhkgf" tgcuqpu" hqt" jcxkpi" eqpegtpu" tgictfkpi" vjg" GGQE" enckou" rtqeguu0" " Cnvjqwij"vjg"Eqwtv"rtgxkqwun{"fgenkpgf"vq"kpvgthgtg"ykvj"vjg"GGQE"enckou"rtqeguu."pqvkpi"vjcv" 77" vjgtg"ycu"pq"tgcuqp"yj{"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"fgekfgf"vq"hkng"enckou"hqtou"ujqwnf"pqv"dg" rgtokvvgf" vq" fgvgtokpg" hqt" vjgougnxgu" yjgvjgt" vjg{" ycpv" vq" ugvvng" vjgkt" enckou" cu" rctv" qh" vjg" eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"qt"rwtuwg"qvjgt"cxgpwgu"qh"tgnkgh"]56:."cv";/32_."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"pqv"rgtuwcfgf"vjcv" RnckpvkhhuÓ" ghhqtvu" tgncvkpi" vq" vjg" GGQE" enckou" rtqeguu" fgoqpuvtcvg" c" hcknwtg" vq" cev" kp" vjg" dguv" kpvgtguvu"qh"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu0" " " iii. Adequacy of Counsel Kp"cuuguukpi"vjg"cfgswce{"qh"encuu"eqwpugn."vjg"Eqwtv"eqpukfgtu"ÐeqwpugnÓu"yqtm"qp"vjg"ecug" vq" fcvg." eqwpugnÓu" encuu" cevkqp" gzrgtkgpeg." eqwpugnÓu" mpqyngfig" qh" vjg" crrnkecdng" ncy." cpf" vjg" tguqwtegu"eqwpugn"yknn"eqookv"vq"vjg"ecug0Ñ" " Reliable Money Order, Inc. v. McKnight Sales Co.." 926" H05f" 6:;." 6;:" p0" 9" *9vj" Ekt0" 4235+" *ekvkpi" Hgf0" T0" Ekx0" R0" 45*i+*3+*C++0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg." vjg" Eqwtv"owuv"jcxg"eqphkfgpeg"vjcv"eqwpugn"yknn"Ðrtqugewvg"vjg"ecug"kp"vjg"kpvgtguv"qh"vjg"encuu."qh" yjkej"vjg{"ctg"hkfwekctkgu]0_Ñ" " Creative Montessori Learning Centers v. Ashford Gear LLC."884" H05f";35.";39"*9vj"Ekt0"4233+"*ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0" " ÐYjgp"encuu"eqwpugn"jcxg"fgoqpuvtcvgf"c"ncem" qh"kpvgitkv{."c"eqwtv"ecp"jcxg"pq"eqphkfgpeg"vjcv"vjg{"yknn"cev"cu"eqpuekgpvkqwu"hkfwekctkgu"qh"vjg" encuu0Ñ" " Id. cv";3:0 Vjg"Eqwtv"fgpkgf"RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"dcugf"qp"RnckpvkhhuÓ"hcknwtg" vq"guvcdnkuj"vjg"cfgswce{"qh"encuu"eqwpugn0" " ]Ugg"5280_" " Ukpeg"Rnckpvkhhu"hkngf"vjgkt"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp" hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp."jqygxgt."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"cffgf"cvvqtpg{u"htqo"vjg"ncy"hkto"qh"Tqocpweek"(" Dncpfkp"NNE"cu"encuu"eqwpugn048" " Cnvjqwij"vjg"swcnkhkecvkqpu"qh"vjg"cvvqtpg{u"htqo"Tqocpweek"(" Dncpfkp"NNE"ctg"pqv"fkurwvgf."vjg"Eqwtv"eqpvkpwgu"vq"jcxg"eqpegtpu"tgictfkpi"vjg"cfgswce{"qh" eqwpugn"cu"uvtwevwtgf0" " " """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 48 " Rnckpvkhhu"cffgf"Tqocpweek"("Dncpfkp"NNE"cu"eqwpugn"dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv"twngf"qp"RnckpvkhhuÓ"rtkqt"oqvkqp" hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Jqygxgt."dgecwug"Fghgpfcpv"ycu"pqv"ikxgp"vjg"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"tgugctej"cpf"tgurqpf" vq" vjg" cffkvkqp" qh" eqwpugn." vjg" Eqwtv" fkf" pqv" fgekfg" cv" vjcv" vkog" yjgvjgt" vjg" cffkvkqp" qh" Tqocpweek" (" Dncpfkp"NNE"ycu"uwhhkekgpv"vq"guvcdnkuj"vjg"cfgswce{"qh"eqwpugn0" " " 78" Vq"dgikp."Rnckpvkhhu"kpfkecvg"vjcv"Ot0"Jwpv"yknn"eqpvkpwg"vq"eqpvtqn"rkxqvcn"curgevu"qh"vjku" ecug0" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhhu" kpfkecvg" vjcv" Ot0" Jwpv" Ðyknn" eqpvkpwg" jku" ngcf" tqng" kp" enkgpv" eqoowpkecvkqp." oqvkqp" rtcevkeg." cpf" ctiwogpvuÑ" ykvj" Ðvjg" eqorcp{" qh" Ot0" Tqocpweek0Ñ" " Cnvjqwij" cvvqtpg{u" htqo" Tqocpweek" (" Dncpfkp" NNE" yknn" cev" cu" eq/eqwpugn." Ot0" Jwpv" jcf" eq/eqwpugn"kp"Warnell."Ot0"JwpvÓu"rtkqt"hgfgtcn"encuu/cevkqp"ncyuwkv"kp"yjkej"jg"ycu"ucpevkqpgf" cpf"yjkej"tguwnvgf"kp"pwogtqwu"ocnrtcevkeg"ncyuwkvu0" " ]528."cv";/330_" " Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"ku"pqv" ucvkuhkgf" vjcv" vjg" cffkvkqp" qh" Tqocpweek" (" Dncpfkp" NNE" gnkokpcvgu"vjg" cfgswce{" eqpegtpu" vjg" Eqwtv"qwvnkpgf"kp"kvu"rtkqt"fgekukqp"fgp{kpi"RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"vjg"EqwtvÓu"eqpegtpu"tgictfkpi"vjg"eqpfwev"qh"Ot0"Jwpv"kp"vjg"Warnell ocvvgt"ujqwnf"pq"nqpigt"dg"qh"eqpegtp"vq"vjg"Eqwtv"dgecwug"vjgtg"ku"pq"kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"Ot0"Jwpv"jcu" eqookvvgf"cp{"qh"vjg"ucog"okuvcmgu"qt"gpicigf"kp"okueqpfwev"kp"vjku"ecug0" " Jqygxgt."kp"vjku"ecug." Ot0"Jwpv"jcu"ocfg"okuuvgru"vjcv"ecnn"kpvq"swguvkqp"jku"cdknkv{"cfgswcvgn{"vq"tgrtgugpv"vjg"encuu0" " Hqt" gzcorng." cv" qtcn" ctiwogpv" qp" RnckpvkhhuÓ" kpkvkcn" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp." RnckpvkhhuÓ" eqwpugn" ocfg" yjcv" vjg" Eqwtv" *rgtjcru" ejctkvcdn{+" ejctcevgtk|gf" cu" cp" gttqt" kp" lwfiogpv0" " Kp" Gzjkdkv"76"qh"Crrgpfkz"C"vq"RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp."Rnckpvkhhu"rtgugpvgf"c" ejctv"rwtrqtvkpi"vq"kfgpvkh{"cnn"vjg"kpfkxkfwcnu"yjq"jcf"jctcuugf"Rnckpvkhhu0" " Vjg"ejctv"kpenwfgf" pwogtqwu" hgocng" gornq{ggu" coqpi" vjg" rgtrgvtcvqtu0" " Chvgt" Fghgpfcpv" ctiwgf" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" eqwnf"pqv"egtvkh{"vjgkt"rtqrqugf"encuu"dgecwug"kv"kpenwfgf"yqogp"yjq"ctg"cnngigf"vq"jcxg"gpicigf" kp"okueqpfwev."Rnckpvkhhu"rtgugpvgf"vjg"Eqwtv"cp"wrfcvgf"Gzjkdkv"76"cv"qtcn"ctiwogpv0" " Fghgpug" eqwpugn"pqvgf"*cpf"vjg"Eqwtv"ncvgt"eqphktogf+"vjcv"vjg"wrfcvgf"ejctv"gzenwfgf"vjg"hgocng"pcogu" *cpf"qpg"ocng"pcog+0" " Kp"vjgkt"dtkghkpi"qp"vjg"rgpfkpi"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp."Rnckpvkhhu"vt{" vq" gzrnckp" vjku" qeewttgpeg" d{" cuugtvkpi" vjcv" Gzjkdkv" 76" qtkikpcnn{" ycu" rtgrctgf" hqt" kpvgtpcn" 79" rwtrqugu0" " ]545."cv"930_" " Gxgp"kh"vjcv"ku"vtwg."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"vtqwdngf"vjcv"eqwpugn"yqwnf"oqfkh{"kvu" kpvgtpcn"fqewogpv"vq"qokv"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"okijv"fgoqpuvtcvg"cp"kpvtc/encuu"eqphnkev0" " " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"eqpvgpf"vjcv"vjg{"tgoqxgf"gzcorngu"qh"hgocng"qp"hgocng"jctcuuogpv"htqo" Gzjkdkv"76"dgecwugÏcv"ngcuv"hqt"vjg"rwtrqugu"qh"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqpÏvjg{"ctg"pqv"enckokpi"vjcv" hgocngu"ugzwcnn{"jctcuugf"vjgo0" " ]Id0"cv"93/940_" " Vjku"tckugu"cpqvjgt"eqpegtp"hqt"vjg"Eqwtv0" " D{" gzenwfkpi" kpuvcpegu" qh" hgocng/qp/hgocng" jctcuuogpv." Rnckpvkhhu" ctg" ygcmgpkpi" vjg" enckou" qh" pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"jcxg"dggp"uwdlgev"vq"uwej"jctcuuogpv0" " Vjg"hcev" vjcv"RnckpvkhhuÓ"eqwpugn"yqwnf"tglgev"c"vjgqt{"qh"jctcuuogpv"vjcv"eqwnf"uwrrqtv"vjg"enckou"qh"egtvckp" pcogf" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" uwiiguvu" vjcv" eqwpugn" oc{" dg" oqtg" kpvgtguvgf" kp" egtvkh{kpi"c"encuu"vjcp"kp"rtqvgevkpi"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu0" " " Vjku"ku"pqv"vjg"qpn{"ctiwogpv"ocfg"d{"RnckpvkhhuÓ"eqwpugn"vjcv"oc{"dg"rtglwfkekcn"vq"egtvckp" pcogf"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu0" " Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"ctiwg"vjcv"Ðkh"kv"vwtpu"qwv"vjcv"hgy" ogodgtu"qh"vjg"encuu"ygtg"jctogfÏyjkej"ku"pqv"vjg"ecugÏvjcv"ku"pqv"cp"ctiwogpv"hqt"tghwukpi"vq" egtvkh{" vjg" encuu." dwv" tcvjgt." hqt" egtvkh{kpi" kv" cpf" vjgp" gpvgtkpi" lwfiogpv" qp" vjg" ogtkvu" vjcv" gzqpgtcvgu" ]Fghgpfcpv_0Ñ" " ]5:6." cv" 3:0_" " Cu" fkuewuugf" cdqxg." kh" RnckpvkhhuÓ" cnngicvkqpu" ctg" vtwg." vjgtg" ctg" pwogtqwu" Rnckpvkhhu" cpf" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgtu" yjq" jcxg" uvtqpi" enckou0" " Nworkpi" vjgug"Rnckpvkhhu"cpf"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"ykvj"qvjgtu"ykvj"ygcm"enckou"oc{"cfxgtugn{"chhgev" vjqug"ykvj"uvtqpigt"enckou0" " Butler."949"H05f"cv"9;;"*pqvkpi"vjcv"kh"c"encuu"ku"egtvkhkgf"cpf"vjgp" lwfiogpv"ku"gpvgtgf"gzqpgtcvkpi"c"fghgpfcpv."Ðcnn"encuu"ogodgtu"yjq"fkf"pqv"qrv"qwv"qh"vjg"encuu" cevkqp"yqwnf"dg"dqwpf"d{"vjg"lwfiogpvÑ+0" " " Vjg"Eqwtv"pqvgu"vjcv"RnckpvkhhuÓ"eqwpugn"cnuq"hckn"vq"tckug"ctiwogpvu"cxckncdng"vq"Rnckpvkhhu0" " Hqt"gzcorng."Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"eqwnf"pqv"egtvkh{"cp{"kuuwg"hqt"encuu"vtgcvogpv"wpfgt" Twng"45*e+*6+"dgecwug"vjcv"twng"uvknn"tgswktgu"vjcv"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh"Twng"45*c+"cpf"*d+"dg"ogv0" " 7:" ]57:."cv":70_" " Vjg"Eqwtv"citggu"ykvj"FghgpfcpvÓu"ejctcevgtk|cvkqp"qh"vjg"ncy"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg" Twng"45*c+"tgswktgogpvu0" " ÐTwng"45*e+*6+"fqgu"pqv"gzgorv"encuu"tgrtgugpvcvkxgu"htqo"vjg"vjtgujqnf" tgswktgogpvu"qh"Twng"45*c+0Ñ" " In re Fluidmaster, Inc., Water Connector Components Prod. Liab. Litig.." 4239" YN" 33;8;;2." cv" ,6;" *P0F0" Knn0" Oct0" 53." 4239+0" " Jqygxgt." kp" cp" qrkpkqp" ekvgf" d{" Fghgpfcpv." vjku" Eqwtv" eqpenwfgf" vjcv" Ðvjg" Ugxgpvj" Ektewkv" nkmgn{" yqwnf" hqnnqy" vjg" vtgpf" qh" cwvjqtkv{"jqnfkpi"vjcv"c"eqwtv"oc{"gornq{"Twng"45*e+*6+"Òvq"egtvkh{"c"encuu"cu"vq"nkcdknkv{"tgictfnguu" qh"yjgvjgt"vjg"encko"cu"c"yjqng"ucvkuhkgu"Twng"45*d+*5+Óu"rtgfqokpcpeg"tgswktgogpv0ÓÑ" " Id0"cv",83" *ekvkpi" Nassau County." 683" H05f" cv" 449+0" " Kp" vjcv" fgekukqp." vjg" Eqwtv" fkuewuugf" vjg" urnkv" qh" cwvjqtkv{"qp"vjg"kuuwg0" " Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"gpvktgn{"vq"cfftguu"vjcv"cwvjqtkv{."gxgp"vjqwij"kv"eqwnf"dg" jgnrhwn"vq"vjgkt"ecug"hqt"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*e+*6+0" " Kpuvgcf."Rnckpvkhhu"ukorn{"tgurqpf"vjcv" vjg{"jcxg"ucvkuhkgf"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh"Twng"45*c+"cpf"*d+0" " ]5:6."cv"620_" " Kp"uwo."vjg"Eqwtv"uvknn" jcu"eqpegtpu"tgictfkpi"vjg"cfgswce{"qh"encuu"eqwpugn0" " Cnvjqwij"vjgug"eqpegtpu"cdqwv"eqwpugn" yqwnf" pqv" cnqpg" dg" uwhhkekgpv" vq" fgp{" egtvkhkecvkqp" qp" cfgswce{" itqwpfu." eqwrngf" ykvj" vjg" ukipkhkecpv" eqphnkevu" qh" kpvgtguv" kfgpvkhkgf" cdqxg." vjg" Eqwtv" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" pqv" ucvkuhkgf"Twng"45*c+Óu"cfgswce{"tgswktgogpv0" " " G0" Twng"45*d+"Tgswktgogpvu" " " i. Rule 23(b)(3) Vq"egtvkh{"c"Twng"45*d+*5+"encuu."Rnckpvkhhu"owuv"fgoqpuvtcvg"rtgfqokpcpeg"cpf"uwrgtkqtkv{0" " Cnvjqwij" tgncvgf" vq" vjg" eqooqpcnkv{" tgswktgogpv." Ðvjg" rtgfqokpcpeg" etkvgtkqp" ku" hct" oqtg" fgocpfkpi0Ñ" " Amchem Prods., Inc. v. Windsor."743"W0U0"7;3."846"*3;;9+0" " Kv"tgswktgu"Ðvjcv"vjg" swguvkqpu"qh"ncy"qt"hcev"eqooqp"vq"encuu"ogodgtu"rtgfqokpcvg"qxgt"cp{"swguvkqpu"chhgevkpi"qpn{" kpfkxkfwcn" ogodgtu0Ñ" " Hgf0" T0" Ekx0" R0" 45*d+*5+0" " Vjg" rtgfqokpcpeg" kpswkt{" vguvu" yjgvjgt" vjg" rtqrqugf"encuu"ku"Ðuwhhkekgpvn{"eqjgukxg"vq"ycttcpv"cflwfkecvkqp"d{"tgrtgugpvcvkqp0Ñ" " Amchem."743" 7;" W0U0"cv"8450" " Rnckpvkhhu"ucvkuh{"rtgfqokpcpeg"tgswktgogpv"qpn{"kh"vjg{"ecp"ujqy"vjcv"ÐÒeqooqp" swguvkqpu"tgrtgugpv"c"ukipkhkecpv"curgev"qh"]c_"ecug"cpf",",","ecp"dg"tguqnxgf"hqt"cnn"ogodgtu"qh"]c_" encuu"kp"c"ukping"cflwfkecvkqp0ÓÑ" " Messner."88;"H05f"cv":37"*ekvcvkqp"cpf"kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu" qokvvgf+0" " ÐÒKh."vq"ocmg"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ujqykpi"qp"c"ikxgp"swguvkqp."vjg"ogodgtu"qh"c"rtqrqugf" encuu"yknn"pggf"vq"rtgugpv"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"xctkgu"htqo"ogodgt"vq"ogodgt."vjgp"kv"ku"cp"kpfkxkfwcn" swguvkqp0" " Kh"vjg"ucog"gxkfgpeg"yknn"uwhhkeg"hqt"gcej"ogodgt"vq"ocmg"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ujqykpi."vjgp" kv" dgeqogu" c" eqooqp" swguvkqp0ÓÑ" " Id0" *ekvcvkqp" qokvvgf+=" ugg" cnuq" Tyson Foods, Inc. v. Bouaphakeo."358"U0"Ev0"3258."3267"*4238+"*Eqooqp"swguvkqpu"ctg"yjgtg"Ðvjg"ucog"gxkfgpeg"yknn" uwhhkeg"hqt"gcej"ogodgt"vq"ocmg"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ujqykpi"]qt_"vjg"kuuwg"ku"uwuegrvkdng"vq"igpgtcnk|gf." encuu/ykfg"rtqqh0Ñ"*ekvcvkqp"cpf"kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf++0" Cu"vjg"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"tgegpvn{"gzrnckpgf."Ð]v_jg"rtgfqokpcpeg"kpswkt{"Òcumu"yjgvjgt"vjg" eqooqp." ciitgicvkqp/gpcdnkpi." kuuwgu" kp" vjg" ecug" ctg" oqtg" rtgxcngpv" qt" korqtvcpv" vjcp" vjg" pqp/eqooqp." ciitgicvkqp/fghgcvkpi." kpfkxkfwcn" kuuwgu0ÓÑ" " Tyson Foods." 358" U0" Ev0" cv" 3267" *ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" " ÐYjgp"Òqpg"qt"oqtg"qh"vjg"egpvtcn"kuuwgu"kp"vjg"cevkqp"ctg"eqooqp"vq"vjg"encuu" cpf"ecp"dg"uckf"vq"rtgfqokpcvg."vjg"cevkqp"oc{"dg"eqpukfgtgf"rtqrgt"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*5+"gxgp" vjqwij" qvjgt" korqtvcpv" ocvvgtu" yknn" jcxg" vq" dg" vtkgf" ugrctcvgn{." uwej" cu" fcocigu" qt" uqog" chhktocvkxg"fghgpugu"rgewnkct"vq"uqog"kpfkxkfwcn"encuu"ogodgtu0ÓÑ" " Id0"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" " " Jgtg."vjg"Eqwtv"citggu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"oggv"vjgkt"dwtfgp"qh"guvcdnkujkpi"vjcv"eqooqp" kuuwgu" rtgfqokpcvg0" " Cu" fkuewuugf" cdqxg." Rnckpvkhhu" ecppqv" rtqeggf" qp" c" rcvvgtp" cpf" rtcevkeg" vjgqt{"hqt"vjgkt"fcocigu"enckou0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"kfgpvkhkgf"cp{"eqooqp"kuuwgu" kp"vjku"ecug0" " Gxgp"kh"Rnckpvkhhu"eqwnf"rtqeggf"qp"c"rcvvgtp"cpf"rtcevkeg"vjgqt{"qt"eqwnf"qvjgtykug" guvcdnkuj" gornq{gt" nkcdknkv{" qp" c" encuu/ykfg" dcuku." vjg" Eqwtv" uvknn" yqwnf" eqpenwfg" vjcv" eqooqp" kuuwgu" fq" pqv" rtgfqokpcvg." cu" jkijn{/kpfkxkfwcnk|gf" jgctkpiu" uvknn" yqwnf" dg" pgeguuct{" hqt" gcej" 82" pcogf" Rnckpvkhh" cpf" gcej" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgt0 49 " " Rnckpvkhhu" ctiwg" vjcvÏvq" vjg" gzvgpv" vjcv" kpfkxkfwcn" kuuwgu" tgockpÏvjg{" ecp" dg" jcpfngf" vjtqwij" Ðuvtgconkpgf" ogejcpkuouÑ" uwej" cu" chhkfcxkvu" cpf" rtqrgt" cwfkvkpi" rtqegfwtgu0" " Ugg"Beaton v. SpeedyPC Software." ;29" H05f" 323:." 3252" *9vj" Ekt0" 423:+." egtv0" fgpkgf." 35;" U0" Ev0" 3687" *423;+0" " Cnvjqwij" vjg" Ugxgpvj" Ektewkv" jcu" crrtqxgf"vjg"wug"qh"uwej"uvtgconkpgf"ogejcpkuou."vq"egtvkh{"c"encuu"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*5+."vjg"Eqwtv" uvknn"owuv"eqpukfgt"yjgvjgt"eqooqp"kuuwgu"rtgfqokpcvg"qxgt"kpfkxkfwcn"kuuwgu0" " Kp"Beaton."vjg" Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"chhktogf"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtvÓu"eqpenwukqp"vjcv"eqooqp"kuuwgu"rtgfqokpcvgf"dgecwug" vjg"kpfkxkfwcn"swguvkqpu"ygtg"Ðuwhhkekgpvn{"ukorngÑ"vjcv"Ðuvtgconkpgf"ogejcpkuouÑ"ygtg"cxckncdng" vq"fgvgtokpg"yjkej"encuu"ogodgtu"jcf"c"xkcdng"encko0" " Beaton v. Software."4239"YN"696284:."cv" ,:"*P0F0"Knn0"Qev0"3;."4239+."chhÓf"uwd"pqo0"Beaton v. SpeedyPC Software.";29"H05f"323:"*9vj"Ekt0" 423:+."egtv0"fgpkgf."35;"U0"Ev0"3687"*423;+0" " Cu"vjg"fkuvtkev"eqwtv"kp"vjcv"ecug"pqvgf."vjg"kpfkxkfwcn" swguvkqpu"jcf"Ðuvtckijvhqtyctf"dkpct{"cpuygtuÑ"cpf"Ðvjg"rctvkgu"eqwnf"wvknk|g"c"hqto"chhkfcxkv."ykvj" ceeqorcp{kpi"cwfkv"rtqegfwtgu."vq"cfftguuÑ"vjqug"swguvkqpu0" " Id0" " Vjg"kpfkxkfwcn"swguvkqpu"jgtg" ctg" owej" oqtg" eqorngz04:" " Gxgp" cuuwokpi" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" eqwnf" guvcdnkuj" c" dcuku" hqt" gornq{gt" nkcdknkv{"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku."jwpftgfu"*kh"pqv"vjqwucpfu+"qh"kpfkxkfwcn"jgctkpiu"uvknn"yqwnf"dg" pgeguuct{" vq" tguqnxg" vjg" tgockpkpi" gngogpvu" qh" RnckpvkhhuÓ" jquvkng" yqtm" gpxktqpogpv" enckou0" " Wpnkmg"kp"Beaton."jqygxgt."vjgtg"ctg"pqv"uvtgconkpgf"yc{u"vq"tguqnxg"vjgug"kpfkxkfwcn"kuuwgu0" " Vjg" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 49 " Dgecwug"kpfkxkfwcn"kuuwgu"tgncvg"vq"nkcdknkv{."vjku"ecug"ku"wpnkmg"vjg"ecugu"tgnkgf"wrqp"d{"Rnckpvkhhu"kp"yjkej" eqwtvu" jcxg" eqpenwfgf" vjcv" vjg" rtgfqokpcpeg" tgswktgogpv" ku" ucvkuhkgf" fgurkvg" vjg" pggf" vq" ocmg" kpfkxkfwcnk|gf" fcocigu" kpswktkgu0" " Ugg." e.g.," Butler." 949" H05f" cv" :23" *ÐKh" vjg" kuuwgu" qh" nkcdknkv{" ctg" igpwkpgn{" eqooqp" kuuwgu." cpf" vjg" fcocigu" qh" kpfkxkfwcn" encuu" ogodgtu" ecp" dg" tgcfkn{" fgvgtokpgf" kp" kpfkxkfwcn"jgctkpiu."kp"ugvvngogpv"pgiqvkcvkqpu."qt"d{"etgcvkqp"qh"uwdencuugu."vjg"hcev"vjcv"fcocigu"ctg"pqv" kfgpvkecn"cetquu"cnn"encuu"ogodgtu"ujqwnf"pqv"rtgenwfg"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp0Ñ+0" " 4: " Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"Ð]k_h"vjgug"uvtgconkpgf"ogejcpkuou"ctg"cxckncdng"vq"rnckpvkhhu"kp"c"eqpuwogt"htcwf" encuu" cevkqpÏyjkej" jcxg" jkuvqtkecnn{" dggp" htqypgf" wr" cu" ygnnÏegtvckpn{" vjgug" ucog" ogejcpkuou" ctg" cxckncdng"vq"c"encuu"qh"hgocng"yqtmgtu"uggmkpi"tgftguu"hqt"xkng"yqtmrnceg."ugz/dcugf"fkuetkokpcvkqp0Ñ" " ]5:6." cv" 540_" " Jqygxgt." vjg" EqwtvÓu" cpcn{uku" qh" Twng" 45Óu" tgswktgogpvu" fqgu" pqv" fgrgpf" qp" vjg" EqwtvÓu" cuuguuogpv"qh"vjg"korqtvcpeg"qh"vjg"v{rg"qh"encko"dgkpi"dtqwijv0" " Eqpuwogt"htcwf"enckou"qhvgp"kpxqnxg" ukorngt"kuuwgu."ocmkpi"vjgo"oqtg"uwuegrvkdng"vq"encuu"vtgcvogpv0" " " 83" Eqwtv" vjgtghqtg" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" eqooqp" kuuwgu" fq" pqv" rtgfqokpcvg0" " Andrews v. Chevy Chase Bank." 767" H05f" 792." 799" *9vj" Ekt0" 422:+" *ÐKh" vjg" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp" qpn{" ugtxgu" vq" ikxg" tkug" vq" jwpftgfu" qt" vjqwucpfu" qh" kpfkxkfwcn" rtqeggfkpiu" tgswktkpi" kpfkxkfwcnn{" vcknqtgf" tgogfkgu." kv" ku" jctf"vq"ugg"jqy"eqooqp"kuuwgu"rtgfqokpcvg"qt"jqy"c"encuu"cevkqp"yqwnf"dg"vjg"uwrgtkqt"ogcpu"vq" cflwfkecvg"vjg"enckou0Ñ+0" Vwtpkpi"vq"vjg"ugeqpf"rtqpi"qh"Twng"45*d+*5+."yjkej"ku"ucvkuhkgf"yjgp"Ðc"encuu"cevkqp"ku" uwrgtkqt" vq"qvjgt" cxckncdng" ogvjqfu" hqt" hcktn{" cpf" ghhkekgpvn{"cflwfkecvkpi" vjg" eqpvtqxgtu{0Ñ" " C" encuu" cevkqp" ku" Ðvjg" uwrgtkqt" ogvjqf" hqt" ocpcikpi" nkvkicvkqp" kh" pq" tgcnkuvke" cnvgtpcvkxg" gzkuvu0Ñ" Valentino v. Carter Wallace, Inc..";9"H05f"3449."3456/57"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;8+0" " Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" jgtg" jcxg"vyq" uwrgtkqt" ogvjqfu" hqt" gxcnwcvkpi" cflwfkecvkpi"encuu" enckouÏvjg" GGQE" eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"cpf"kpfkxkfwcn"fcocigu"uwkvu0" " " Rnckpvkhhu" tgurqpf" vjcv" vjg" GGQE" eqpeknkcvkqp" rtqeguu" ku" kpcfgswcvg0" " Urgekhkecnn{." Rnckpvkhhu" eqpvgpf" vjcv" *3+" vjg" cyctfu" ikxgp" ygtg" nqygt" vjcp" vjg" vkgt" coqwpvu" kfgpvkhkgf" kp" vjg" citggogpv."*4+"vjg"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"tguwnvgf"kp"vjg"fgpkcn"qh"oqtg"vjcp"qpg/vjktf"qh"vjg"enckou" uwdokvvgf" d{" yqogp." cpf" *5+" vjg" enckou" rtqeguu" ycu" ogejcpkecn" cpf" kphngzkdng0" " ]Ugg" 62;0_" " Ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg"hktuv"ctiwogpv."cnvjqwij"vjg"cyctfu"ikxgp"ygtg"nqygt"vjcp"vjg"vkgt"coqwpvu" kfgpvkhkgf"*&32.222."&42.222."qt"&52.222."fgrgpfkpi"qp"vjg"ugtkqwupguu"qh"vjg"encko+."vjg"cyctfu" uvknn" ygtg" eqpukuvgpv" ykvj" vjg" vgtou" qh" vjg" 4239" Eqpeknkcvkqp" Citggogpv0" " ]62;." cv" 50_" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."enckocpvu"ygtg"kphqtogf"qh"vjg"coqwpv"qh"vjgkt"cyctfu"dghqtg"vjg{"fgekfgf"yjgvjgt" vjg{"yqwnf"ceegrv"vjgkt"tgurgevkxg"cyctfu0" " Vjg"hcev"vjcv"vjg"cyctf"coqwpvu"ctg"nqygt"vjcp"vjg" rtguworvkxg"vkgt"coqwpvu"fqgu"pqv"kvugnh"ocmg"vjg"GGQE"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"kpcfgswcvg0" " " RnckpvkhhuÓ"vjktf"ctiwogpvÏvjcv"vjg"enckou"rtqeguu"ycu"ogejcpkecn"cpf"kphngzkdng"dgecwug" kv"Ðhckngf"vq"cfgswcvgn{"fkuvkpiwkuj"enckocpvu"dcugf"qp"vjg"tgncvkxg"ugxgtkv{"qh"vjg"eqpfwev"vjg{" 84" gzrgtkgpegfÑ"]629."cv"9/:_Ïnkmgykug"ku"wprgtuwcukxg0" " Kp"ocmkpi"vjku"ctiwogpv."Rnckpvkhhu"ekvg"vq" vjg" hcev" vjcv" c" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgt" yjq" uwdokvvgf" c" encko" fguetkdkpi" gitgikqwu" ugzwcn" jctcuuogpv"qpn{"ycu"qhhgtgf"cp"cyctf"qh"&46.2:80:20" " ]624."cv"9/:0_" " Urgekhkecnn{."vjku"rwvcvkxg" encuu"ogodgtÓu"encko"hqto"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"ujg"ycu"jctcuugf"cpf"cuucwnvgf"d{"pwogtqwu"gornq{ggu." kpenwfkpi"c"ocpcigt0" " ]629/370_" " D{"yc{"qh"gzcorng."vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"cp" ctgc"ocpcigt"vjtgcvgpgf"jgt."jkv"jgt."ejqmgf"jgt."cpf"hqtegf"jgt"kpvq"c"ugzwcn"tgncvkqpujkr0" " ]Id0"cv" 70_" " Kp"cpqvjgt"gzcorng."vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"ujg"kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"ycu"vqwejgf" yjkng" qp"FghgpfcpvÓu"rtgokugu"cv"ngcuv"yggmn{"htqo"4237"vq"gctn{"42390" " ]629/37." cv" 80_" " Vjg" rwvcvkxg" encuu" ogodgt" iqgu" qp" vq" cnngig" cffkvkqpcn" jctcuuogpv" d{" pwogtqwu" gornq{ggu" qh" Fghgpfcpv0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"citggu"vjcv"vjg"cnngigf"eqpfwev"kfgpvkhkgf"d{"vjku"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgt"ku" crrcnnkpi0" " Jqygxgt."hqt"uwej"ugxgtg"enckouÏcpf"vjgtg"oc{"dg"ocp{"uwej"enckou"kp"vjg"rwvcvkxg" encuu"jgtgÏkpfkxkfwcn"Vkvng"XKK"ncyuwkvu"ctg"c"xgt{"xkcdng"qrvkqp."ykvj"ukipkhkecpv"oqpg{"fcocigu" cpf"cvvqtpg{uÓ"hggu"rtqxkfkpi"vjg"kpegpvkxg"vq"nkvkicvg0" " Cf. Herkert v. MRC Receivables Corp.."476" H0T0F0"566."575"*P0F0"Knn0"422:+"*ÐC"encuu"cevkqp"ku"uwrgtkqt"yjgtg"rqvgpvkcn"fcocigu"oc{"dg"vqq" kpukipkhkecpv"vq"rtqxkfg"encuu"ogodgtu"ykvj"kpegpvkxg"vq"rwtuwg"c"encko"kpfkxkfwcnn{0Ñ"*swqvkpi" Jackson v. Nat’l Action Fin. Servs., Inc.."449"H0T0F0"4:6."4;2"*P0F0"Knn0"4227+++0" " Cpf"vjqug"yjq" gpvgtgf"vjg"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"ygtg"wpfgt"pq"qdnkicvkqp"vq"vcmg"vjg"oqpg{"qhhgtgf"kh"vjg{"hgnv" vjg{"eqwnf"fq"dgvvgt"kp"nkvkicvkqp0" Vjcv"ngcxgu"RnckpvkhhuÓ"ugeqpf"ctiwogpv."vjcv"vjg"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"tguwnvgf"kp"vjg"fgpkcn" qh"oqtg"vjcp"qpg/vjktf"qh"vjg"enckou"uwdokvvgf"d{"yqogp0" " Ykvjqwv"oqtg"kphqtocvkqp"tgictfkpi" yj{"vjgug"enckou"ygtg"fgpkgf."vjg"Eqwtv"ku"wpcdng"hwnn{"vq"gxcnwcvg"vjku"ctiwogpv0" " Kp"qvjgt"yqtfu." Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"ujqyp"vjcv"vjg"fcocigu"cxckncdng"vq"cp{"qh"vjg"rwvcvkxg"encuu"ogodgtu"yjqug" 85" enckou"ygtg"fgpkgf"cu"rctv"qh"vjg"GGQE"eqpeknkcvkqp"rtqeguu"ygtg"Ðvqq"kpukipkhkecpvÑ"vq"rtqxkfg" vjgo"vjg"kpegpvkxg"vq"rwtuwg"vjgkt"enckou"kpfkxkfwcnn{0" " " Kp"cp{"gxgpv."ocpcigcdknkv{"eqpegtpu"yjqnn{"kpfgrgpfgpv"qh"vjg"cxckncdknkv{"qh"vjku"qt"cp{" qvjgt"GGQE"tgogf{"eqwpugn"cickpuv"hkpfkpi"c"encuu"cevkqp"vq"dg"uwrgtkqt"vq"kpfkxkfwcn"Vkvng"XKK" enckou"kp"vjku"ecug0" " ÐC"egpvtcn"swguvkqpÑ"hqt"gxcnwcvkpi"Twng"45*d+*5+Óu"uwrgtkqtkv{"tgswktgogpv"ku" vjg"kuuwg"qh"Ðocpcigcdknkv{0Ñ" " Williams v. Chartwell Fin. Servs., Ltd.."426"H05f"96:."982"*9vj"Ekt0" 4222+"*ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+="ugg"cnuq"Hgf0"T0"Ekx0"R0"45*d+*5+*F+"*pqvkpi"vjcv"Ðvjg"nkmgn{"fkhhkewnvkgu"kp" ocpcikpi" c" encuu" cevkqpÑ" ctg" c" rgtvkpgpv" eqpukfgtcvkqp+0" " RnckpvkhhuÓ" rtqrqugf" nkvkicvkqp" rncp" Ðkpxqnxgu" dkhwtecvkqp" ykvj" Rjcug" K" cfftguukpi" ]FghgpfcpvÓu_" Nkcdknkv{" cpf" fghgpugu" cu" vq" ]kvu_" nkcdknkv{"vjtqwij"c"lwt{"vtkcn"cpf"Rjcug"KK"cfftguukpi"vjg"oqtg"uwdlgevkxg"gngogpvu"vjtqwij"jgctkpiu" cpf" chhkfcxkvu0Ñ" " ]5:6." cv" 320_" " Dwv" vjku" rtqrqugf" nkvkicvkqp" rncp" rtguwogu" vjcv" nkcdknkv{" ecp" dg" cfftguugf"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku0" " Cu"cntgcf{"fkuewuugf."jqygxgt."vjcv"ku"pqv"vjg"ecug"jgtg0" " Gxgp" cuuwokpi"vjcv"nkcdknkv{"eqwnf"dg"guvcdnkujgf"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku"kp"Rjcug"K"*c"eqpenwukqp"vjg"Eqwtv" cntgcf{"jcu"tglgevgf+."RnckpvkhhuÓ"rtqrqugf"nkvkicvkqp"rncp"uvknn"yqwnf"dg"wpocpcigcdng"dgecwug"kv" yqwnf"pgeguukvcvg"jwpftgfu"qh"ugrctcvg"jgctkpiu0" " Cnvjqwij"Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"rtqrqugf"fkxkfkpi"vjg" encuu"kpvq"hkxg"fcocigu"itqwru"kp"Rjcug"KK."vjcv"rtqrqucn"uvknn"yqwnf"pqv"gnkokpcvg"vjg"pggf"hqt" ugrctcvg"jgctkpiu0" " Hqt"gzcorng."kv"yqwnf"dg"fkhhkewnv"vq"fgvgtokpg"vjg"rtqrgt"coqwpv"qh"fcocigu" hqt" cnn" kpfkxkfwcnu" yjq" gzrgtkgpegf" wpycpvgf" vqwejkpi" ykvjqwv" eqpfwevkpi" kpfkxkfwcnk|gf" kpswktkgu0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."cu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg."kv"ku"pqv"engct"vq"vjg"Eqwtv"vjcv"vjg"kpswktkgu"pgeguuct{" kp"vjku"ecug"ecp"dg"tguqnxgf"vjtqwij"uvtgconkpgf"ogvjqfu"uwej"cu"chhkfcxkvu0" " RnckpvkhhuÓ"hcknwtg"vq" uwdokv"c"xkcdng"nkvkicvkqp"rncp"*cu"vjg"Eqwtv"tgswguvgf"kp"kvu"fgpkcn"qh"RnckpvkhhuÓ"kpkvkcn"oqvkqp"hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp+" vjgtghqtg" ku" cp" cffkvkqpcn" itqwpf" hqt" fgp{kpi" vjgkt" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp0" " Ugg."e.g., Espenscheid v. DirectSat USA, LLC."927"H05f"992."998"*9vj"Ekt0"4235+" 86" *Ð]K_h"encuu"eqwpugn"ku"kpecrcdng"qh"rtqrqukpi"c"hgcukdng"nkvkicvkqp"rncp"vjqwij"cumgf"vq"fq"uq."vjg" lwfigÓu"fwv{"ku"cv"cp"gpf0Ñ+="ugg"cnuq"Radmanovich v. Combined Ins. Co. of Am.."438"H0T0F0"646." 65;"*P0F0"Knn0"4225+"*fgp{kpi"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"dgecwug"vjg"pggf"vq"eqpfwev"vjqwucpfu" qh"kpfkxkfwcn"fgvgtokpcvkqpu"Ðyqwnf"tgpfgt"]vjg_"ecug"vqvcnn{"wpocpcigcdng"cu"c"encuu"cevkqpÑ+0" " Ceeqtfkpin{."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"ogv"vjgkt"dwtfgp"qh"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"Ðc"encuu"cevkqp"ku"uwrgtkqt" vq"qvjgt"cxckncdng"ogvjqfu"hqt"hcktn{"cpf"ghhkekgpvn{"cflwfkecvkpi"vjg"eqpvtqxgtu{Ñ"cu"tgswktgf"vq" egtvkh{"c"encuu"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*5+0" " " ii. Rule 23(b)(2) Rnckpvkhhu" oqxg" hqt" egtvkhkecvkqp" qh" c" Twng" 45*d+*4+" encuu" hqt" kplwpevkxg" tgnkgh0" " ÐTwng"45*d+*4+"fgenctgu"vjcv"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"vjcv"uwdugevkqp"ku"crrtqrtkcvg"yjgp"Òvjg"rctv{" qrrqukpi"vjg"encuu"jcu"cevgf"qt"tghwugf"vq"cev"qp"itqwpfu"igpgtcnn{"crrnkecdng"vq"vjg"encuu."vjgtgd{" ocmkpi"crrtqrtkcvg"hkpcn"kplwpevkxg"tgnkgh"qt"eqttgurqpfkpi"fgenctcvqt{"tgnkgh"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"vjg" encuu"cu"c"yjqng0ÓÑ" " Lemon v. Int’l Union of Operating Engineers, Local No. 139, AFL-CIO."438" H05f"799."7:2"*9vj"Ekt0"4222+"*swqvkpi"Hgf0"T0"Ekx0"R0"45*d+*4++0" " ÐD{"xktvwg"qh"kvu"tgswktgogpv" vjcv"vjg"rnckpvkhhu"uggm"vq"tgftguu"c"eqooqp"kplwt{"rtqrgtn{"cfftguugf"d{"c"encuu/ykfg"kplwpevkxg"qt" fgenctcvqt{"tgogf{."Twng"45*d+*4+"qrgtcvgu"wpfgt"vjg"rtguworvkqp"vjcv"vjg"kpvgtguvu"qh"vjg"encuu" ogodgtu"ctg"eqjgukxg"cpf"jqoqigpgqwu"uwej"vjcv"vjg"ecug"yknn"pqv"fgrgpf"qp"cflwfkecvkqp"qh" hcevu"rctvkewnct"vq"cp{"uwdugv"qh"vjg"encuu"pqt"tgswktg"c"tgogf{"vjcv"fkhhgtgpvkcvgu"ocvgtkcnn{"coqpi" encuu" ogodgtu0Ñ" " Id0" " Dgecwug" ÐTwng" 45*d+*4+" rtqxkfgu" hqt" dkpfkpi" nkvkicvkqp" qp" cnn" encuu" ogodgtu"ykvjqwv"iwctcpvggu"qh"rgtuqpcn"pqvkeg"cpf"vjg"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"qrv"qwv"qh"vjg"uwkv.Ñ"vjcv" uwdugevkqp"Ðfqgu"pqv"gzvgpf"vq"ecugu"kp"yjkej"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"hkpcn"tgnkgh"tgncvgu"gzenwukxgn{"qt" rtgfqokpcpvn{"vq"oqpg{"fcocigu0Ñ" " Id0"*swqvkpi"Hgf0"T0"Ekx0"R0"45*d+*4+"cfxkuqt{"eqookvvggÓu" pqvg+"*kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0" " " 87" Kp"vjgkt"qrgpkpi"dtkgh."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*4+"ku"crrtqrtkcvg" Ðdgecwug" vjg" tgswguvgf" tgnkgh" ku" rtkoctkn{" kplwpevkxg0Ñ" " ]545." cv" 3260_" " Jqygxgt." Ð]c_" uwkv" hqt" oqpg{" fcocigu." gxgp" kh" vjg" rnckpvkhhu" uggm" wpkhqto." encuu/ykfg" gswkvcdng" tgnkgh" cu" ygnn." lgqrctfk|gu" vjcv" rtguworvkqp" qh" eqjgukqp" cpf" jqoqigpgkv{" dgecwug" kpfkxkfwcn" enckou" hqt" eqorgpucvqt{"qt"rwpkvkxg"fcocigu"v{rkecnn{"tgswktg"lwfkekcn"kpswkt{"kpvq"vjg"rctvkewnctk|gf"ogtkvu" qh" gcej" kpfkxkfwcn" rnckpvkhhÓu" encko0Ñ" " Lemon." 438" H05f" cv" 7:20" " ÐVjcv" ]Rnckpvkhhu_" jcxg" uwrgthkekcnn{"uvtwevwtgf"vjgkt"ecug"ctqwpf"c"encko"hqt"encuu/ykfg"kplwpevkxg"cpf"fgenctcvqt{"tgnkgh" fqgu"pqv"ucvkuh{"Twng"45*d+*4+"kh"cu"c"uwduvcpvkxg"ocvvgt"vjg"tgnkgh"uqwijv"yqwnf"ogtgn{"kpkvkcvg"c" rtqeguu"vjtqwij"yjkej"jkijn{"kpfkxkfwcnk|gf"fgvgtokpcvkqpu"qh"nkcdknkv{"cpf"tgogf{"ctg"ocfg="vjku" mkpf"qh"tgnkgh"yqwnf"dg"encuu/ykfg"kp"pcog"qpn{."cpf"kv"yqwnf"egtvckpn{"pqv"dg"hkpcn0Ñ" " Jamie S.." 88:"H05f"cv"6;;0" " " Vjg" Eqwtv" eqpenwfgu" vjcv" RnckpvkhhuÓ" rwtuwkv" qh" oqpgvct{" tgnkgh" ku" pqv" kpekfgpvcn" vq" vjgkt" rwtuwkv" qh" kplwpevkxg" tgnkgh0" " RnckpvkhhuÓ" qyp" nkvkicvkqp" rncp" kpfkecvgu" vjcv" vjg" kplwpevkxg" tgnkgh" uqwijv" yqwnf" ogtgn{" kpkvkcvg" c" rtqeguu" vjtqwij" yjkej" jkijn{" kpfkxkfwcnk|gf" fgvgtokpcvkqpu" qh" nkcdknkv{"cpf"tgogf{"yknn"dg"ocfg0" " Vjwu."kplwpevkxg"tgnkgh"jgtg"Ðyqwnf"pqv"rtqxkfg"ÒhkpcnÓ"tgnkgh"cu" tgswktgf" d{" Twng" 45*d+*4+0Ñ" " Randall v. Rolls-Royce Corp.." 859" H05f" :3:." :48" *9vj" Ekt0" 4233+" *swqvkpi"Kartman v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.."856"H05f"::5.":;5"*9vj"Ekt0"4233++0" " Kp"uwej" ektewouvcpegu."Ð]v_jg"oqpgvct{"vckn"yqwnf"dg"yciikpi"vjg"kplwpevkqp"fqi0Ñ" " Id0"*swqvkpi"Kartman." 856"H05f"cv":;5+0" " " Kpfggf."RnckpvkhhuÓ"eqpvgpvkqp"vjcv"vjgkt"Ðtgswguvgf"tgnkgh"ku"rtkoctkn{"kplwpevkxgÑ"ku"dgnkgf" d{" vjg" hcev" vjcv" vjg{" fgxqvg" oqtg" vjcp" 32" rcigu" qh" vjgkt" tgrn{"dtkgh" vq" cfftguukpi" FghgpfcpvÓu" ctiwogpvu"tgictfkpi"Twng"45*d+*5+Óu"tgswktgogpvu"dwv"qpn{"ogpvkqp"Twng"45*d+*4+"kp"vjg"qrgpkpi" cpf"eqpenwfkpi"ugpvgpegu"qh"vjgkt"tgrn{"dtkgh0" " Rnckpvkhhu"fq"pqv"gxgp"cvvgorv"vq"tgurqpf"vq"vjg" 88" ctiwogpvu"tckugf"d{"Fghgpfcpv"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"Twng"45*d+*4+0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."cu"fkuewuugf"dgnqy." Rnckpvkhhu" tgswguv" vjcv" egtvckp" kuuwgu" dg" egtvkhkgf" wpfgt" Twng" 45*e+*6+" kh" vjg" Eqwtv" fgpkgu" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*5+0" " Dwv"Rnckpvkhhu"fq"pqv"tgswguv"uwej"cnvgtpcvkxg"tgnkgh"ykvj"tgurgev" vq"vjgkt"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*4+0" " Ukoknctn{."kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjgkt"ctiwogpv" vjcv"Twng"45*c+"vqngtcvgu"c"fgitgg"qh"xctkcpeg"coqpi"enckou."Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv"vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv" vjg"Eqwtv"jcu"Ðeqpegtpu"tgictfkpi"vjgug"enckou."Rnckpvkhhu"uwdokv"vjcv"vjgug"encuu"ogodgtu."ujqwnf" RnckpvkhhuÓ"rtqrqugf"encuu"dg"egtvkhkgf"rwtuwcpv"vq"Hgf0"T0"Ekx0"R0"45*d+*5+."oc{"htggn{"qrv"qwv"qh"vjg" encuu" wrqp" tgegkrv" qh" pqvkeg" cpf" rwtuwg" vjgkt" qyp" kpfkxkfwcnk|gf" enckou0Ñ" " ]545." cv" 950_" " Kh" RnckpvkhhuÓ"tgswguvgf"tgnkgh"ku"rtkoctkn{"kplwpevkxg."kv"ku"swguvkqpcdng"yj{"Rnckpvkhhu"yqwnf"ocmg"vjku" ctiwogpv."cu"Ðvjgtg"ku"pq"qrv/qwv"tkijvÑ"hqt"encuugu"egtvkhkgf"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*4+0" " Gray v. Hardy." :48" H05f" 3222." 322;" *9vj" Ekt0" 4238+0" " Vjg" Eqwtv" vjgtghqtg" fgpkgu" RnckpvkhhuÓ" oqvkqp" hqt" encuu" egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*4+0" " " " iii. Hybrid Certification Rnckpvkhhu" cnuq" oqxg" hqt" j{dtkf" egtvkhkecvkqp" rwtuwcpv" vq" dqvj"Twng" 45*d+*4+" cpf" *5+0" " C" j{dtkf"encuu"cevkqp"ku"qpg"kp"yjkej"vjg"eqwtv"egtvkhkgu"Ðc"Twng"45*d+*4+"encuu"hqt"vjg"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg" ecug"cfftguukpi"gswkvcdng"tgnkgh"cpf"c"Twng"45*d+*5+"encuu"hqt"vjg"rqtvkqp"qh"vjg"ecug"cfftguukpi" fcocigu0Ñ" " Lemon."438"H05f"cv"7:30" " Fghgpfcpv"ctiwgu"vjcv"uwej"c"encuu"cevkqp"ku"kortqrgt"jgtg" dgecwug"egtvkh{kpi"c"j{dtkf"encuu"cevkqp"fqgu"pqv"tgnkgxg"Rnckpvkhhu"qh"ucvkuh{kpi"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh" Twng"45*d+*4+"cpf"*5+0" " Rnckpvkhhu"fq"pqv"tgurqpf"vq"vjcv"ctiwogpv"cpf"vjgtghqtg"jcxg"yckxgf"cp{" ctiwogpv"kp"qrrqukvkqp0" " Bonte v. U.S. Bank, N.A.."846"H05f"683."688"*9vj"Ekt0"4232+0" " Kp"cp{" gxgpv."vjg"Eqwtv"citggu"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"owuv"ucvkuh{"dqvj"Twng"45*d+*4+"cpf"*d+*5+"kp"qtfgt"vq"egtvkh{" c"j{dtkf"encuu"wpfgt"dqvj"rtqxkukqpu0" " Ugg"Puffer v. Allstate Ins. Co.."477"H0T0F0"672."692"*P0F0" Knn0"422;+."chhÓf."897"H05f"92;"*9vj"Ekt0"4234+0" " Cnvjqwij"vjg"Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"nghv"qrgp"vjg" 89" rquukdknkv{"qh"ÐfkxkfgfÑ"qt"Ðj{dtkfÑ"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*4+"cpf"*5+."Lemon."438"H05f"cv" 7:3."vjg"Ugxgpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"pgxgt"uwiiguvgf"vjcv"ÐfkxkfgfÑ"qt"Ðj{dtkfÑ"egtvkhkecvkqp"yqwnf"gzewug" rnckpvkhhu" htqo" ucvkuh{kpi" Twng" 45*d+Óu" tgswktgogpvu0" " Pqt" yqwnf" uwej" c" twng" ocmg" ugpug." cu" rnckpvkhhu"eqwnf"cxqkf"Twng"45*d+Óu"tgswktgogpvu"ukorn{"d{"uggmkpi"dqvj"oqpgvct{"cpf"gswkvcdng" tgnkgh0" " Dgecwug"Rnckpvkhhu"hckn"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh"dqvj"Twng"45*d+*4+"cpf"*5+."RnckpvkhhuÓ" oqvkqp"hqt"j{dtkf"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"vjqug"rtqxkukqpu"ku"fgpkgf0" " " H0" Twng"45*e+*6+" Kp"vjg"cnvgtpcvkxg"vq"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*d+*5+."Rnckpvkhhu"cum"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv" egtvkh{"rctvkewnct"kuuwgu"wpfgt"Twng"45*e+*6+."yjkej"rtqxkfgu"vjcv"Ðcp"cevkqp"oc{"dg"dtqwijv"qt" ockpvckpgf" cu" c" encuu" cevkqp" ykvj" tgurgev" vq" rctvkewnct" kuuwguÑ" yjgp" crrtqrtkcvg0" " ÐVjg" fkuvtkev" eqwtv"ku"pqv"qdnkicvgf"vq"itcpv"rctvkcn"egtvkhkecvkqp"kh"rctvkewnct"kuuwgu"ctg"eqooqp"vq"c"encuu.Ñ"dwv" oc{"fq"uq"kp"kvu"fkuetgvkqp0" " Clark v. Experian Info. Sols., Inc.."478"Hgf0"CrrÓz":3:.":44"*9vj"Ekt0" 4229+0" " Rnckpvkhhu" jcxg" pqv" fgoqpuvtcvgf" vjcv" egtvkhkecvkqp" qh" cp{" kuuwg" wpfgt" Twng"45*e+*6+" ku" crrtqrtkcvg0" Vq"dgikp."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"fgoqpuvtcvgf"vjcv"uwhhkekgpv"Ðghhkekgpe{"yqwnf"dg"ickpgf"d{" egtvkh{kpi"c"encuu"hqt"qpn{"rctvkewnct"kuuwgu0Ñ" " Clark."478"Hgf0"CrrÓz"cv":440" " Rnckpvkhhu"ctiwg"vjcv" vjg"hqnnqykpi"kuuwgu"eqwnf"dg"egtvkhkgf"wpfgt"Twng"45*e+*6+<" 30" Yjgvjgt"Fghgpfcpv"etgcvgf"cpf"eqpfqpgf"c"jquvkng"yqtm"gpxktqpogpv=" " 40" Yjgvjgt"Fghgpfcpv"hckngf"vq"vcmg"rtqorv"tgogfkcn"cevkqp"kp"tgurqpug"vq"etgfkdng" cnngicvkqpu"qh"jctcuuogpv=" " 50" Yjgvjgt"Fghgpfcpv"jcu"cnnqygf"mpqyp"jctcuugtu"vq"tgockp"kp"vjg"yqtmrnceg="cpf" " 60" Yjgvjgt"Fghgpfcpv"jcu"hckngf"vq"fkuekrnkpg"jctcuugtu"fgurkvg"vjg"jctcuuogpv"dgkpi" ykvpguugf"d{"uwrgtxkuqtu0" " 8:" ]545." cv" 3370_" " Jqygxgt." Rnckpvkhhu" hckn" vq" eqppgev" vjgug" kuuwgu" vq" vjg" gngogpvu" qh" vjgkt" enckou0" " Cnvjqwij"Fghgpfcpv"pqvgf"vjku"fghkekgpe{"kp"kvu"tgurqpug"dtkgh."Rnckpvkhhu"cickp"hckngf"vq"cfftguu" vjg" gngogpvu" qh" vjgkt" enckou" kp" vjgkt" tgrn{" dtkgh" ykvj" tgurgev" vq" vjku" kuuwg0" " Kpuvgcf." Rnckpvkhhu" kfgpvkh{"cffkvkqpcn"kuuwgu"cpf"ctiwg"vjcv"egtvkhkecvkqp"qh"vjqug"kuuwgu"wpfgt"Twng"45*e+*6+"yqwnf" Ðqp"c"uocnngt"uecng"guvcdnkuj"cnn"qh"vjg"tgswktgf"gngogpvu"cu"vjg{"yqwnf"dg"rtgfqokpcvgn{"rtqxgp" d{"eqooqp"rtqqh"cpf"iq"vq"vjg"gngogpvu"tgswktgf"vq"gcej"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"encko"qh"c"jquvkng"yqtm" gpxktqpogpv"etgcvgf"d{"ugzwcn"jctcuuogpv0Ñ" " ]5:6."cv"620_" " Vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"Rnckpvkhhu"tckug"pgy" kuuwgu"hqt"egtvkhkecvkqp"wpfgt"Twng"45*e+*6+"kp"vjgkt"tgrn{"dtkgh."vjg{"yckxgf"cp{"ctiwogpv"ykvj" tgurgev" vq" vjqug" kuuwgu04;" " West v. MeadWestvaco Corp.." :3" H0" CrrÓz" 96." 97" *9vj" Ekt0" 4225+" *Ð]C_tiwogpvu" rtgugpvgf" hqt" vjg" hktuv" vkog" kp" c" tgrn{" dtkgh" ctg" yckxgf0Ñ" *ekvcvkqp" qokvvgf++0" " Hwtvjgtoqtg."cu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg."Rnckpvkhhu"jcxg"pqv"ogv"vjgkt"dwtfgp"qh"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"vjgug" swguvkqpu"ecp"dg"cfftguugf"qp"c"encuu/ykfg"dcuku0" " Kp"cp{"gxgpv."ÐTwng"45*e+*6+"fqgu"pqv"gzgorv" encuu" tgrtgugpvcvkxgu" htqo" vjg" vjtgujqnf" tgswktgogpvu" qh" Twng" 45*c+0Ñ" " In re Fluidmaster, Inc., Water Connector Components Prod. Liab. Litig.."4239"YN"33;8;;2."cv",6;"*P0F0"Knn0"Oct0"53." 4239+0" " Dgecwug" Rnckpvkhhu" fq" pqv" ucvkuh{" vjg" tgswktgogpvu" qh" Twng" 45*c+." vjg" Eqwtv" fgpkgu" RnckpvkhhuÓ"tgswguv"vq"egtvkh{"cp{"kuuwg"wpfgt"Twng"45*e+*6+052" " " KKK0" Eqpenwukqp" Hqt"vjg"hqtgiqkpi"tgcuqpu."vjg"Eqwtv"fgpkgu"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp"hqt"encuu"egtvkhkecvkqp"]53:_0" " Vjg"Eqwtv"itcpvu"FghgpfcpvÓu"oqvkqp"vq"gzenwfg"vjg"vguvkoqp{."tgrqtvu."cpf"qrkpkqpu"qh"Ft0"Nqwkug" Hkv|igtcnf"]574_."cpf"itcpvu"kp"rctv"cpf"fgpkgu"kp"rctv"RnckpvkhhuÓ"oqvkqp"vq"dct"vjg"vguvkoqp{"cpf" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 4; " Kp"cffkvkqp."Rnckpvkhhu"cnuq"hckn"vq"eqppgev"vjg"swguvkqpu"tckugf"hqt"vjg"hktuv"vkog"kp"vjgkt"tgrn{"dtkgh"vq"vjg" gngogpvu"qh"vjgkt"enckou0" " " " 52 " Cu" fkuewuugf" cdqxg." vjg" Eqwtv" tglgevu" FghgpfcpvÓu" eqpvgpvkqp" vjcv" Rnckpvkhhu" cnuq" jcxg" vq" ucvkuh{" vjg" rtgfqokpcpeg"tgswktgogpv"qh"Twng"45*d+0" " In re Fluidmaster, Inc., Water Connector Components Prod. Liab. Litig.."4239"YN"33;8;;2."cv",84"*P0F0"Knn0"Oct0"53."4239+0" 8;" gzrgtv"tgrqtv"qh"Ft0"Nk|c"Iqnf"cpf"Ft0"Itgiqt{"Okvejgnn."RjF0"]592_0" " Vjku"ecug"ku"ugv"hqt"hwtvjgt" uvcvwu"jgctkpi"qp"Ugrvgodgt"34."423;"cv"32<52"c0o0" " " " " " Fcvgf<"Cwiwuv"44."423;" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa" Tqdgtv"O0"Fqy."Lt0" Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Fkuvtkev"Lwfig" 92"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
