Harter v. Bonner County, Idaho, No. 2:2016cv00546 - Document 58 (D. Idaho 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER The County's Motion for Summary Judgment (Dkt 29 ) is Granted in Part and Denied in Part. Signed by Judge David C. Nye. (caused to be mailed to non Registered Participants at the addresses listed on the Notice of Electronic Filing (NEF) by (jp)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Harter v. Bonner County, Idaho " " " Doc. 58 " " " " WPKVGF"UVCVGU"FKUVTKEV"EQWTV" " HQT"VJG"FKUVTKEV"QH"KFCJQ" " " " TQNCPF"JCTVGT." Ecug"Pq0"4<38/ex/22768/FEP" """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" " " Rnckpvkhh." OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF" " QTFGT" """"""""""""x0" " DQPPGT"EQWPV[."KFCJQ."c"rqnkvkecn" uwdfkxkukqp"qh"vjg"Uvcvg"qh"Kfcjq." " " Fghgpfcpv0" " K0"QXGTXKGY" Vjku"ocvvgt"eqogu"dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv"qp"Fghgpfcpv"Dqppgt"Eqwpv{Óu"*Ðvjg"Eqwpv{Ñ+" Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv0"Fmv0"4;0"Rnckpvkhh"Tqncpf"Jctvgt"*ÐJctvgtÑ+"enckou"vjg" Eqwpv{"wpncyhwnn{"fgoqvgf"jko"dgecwug"qh"jku"cig."cpf"ncvgt"hktgf"jko"kp"tgvcnkcvkqp"hqt" hknkpi"c"fkuetkokpcvkqp"encko"ykvj"vjg"Kfcjq"Jwocp"Tkijvu"Eqookuukqp0"Jg"cnuq"cnngigu" xkqncvkqpu"qh"uvcvg"eqpvtcev"ncy."cpf"fgpkcn"qh"jku"fwg"rtqeguu"tkijvu"wpfgt"64"W0U0E0" ¸3;:50"Vjg"Eqwtv"jgctf"qtcn"ctiwogpv"qp"vjku"oqvkqp"qp"Cwiwuv"43."423:0"" Hqt"vjg"tgcuqpu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy."vjg"Eqwtv"ITCPVU"kp"RCTV"cpf"FGPKGU"kp" RCTV"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv0" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"3" Dockets.Justia.com KK0"HCEVU" " Vjg"Eqwpv{"jktgf"Jctvgt"kp"3;;:"vq"yqtm"cu"cp"gswkrogpv"qrgtcvqt"kp"vjgkt"Uqnkf" Ycuvg"Fgrctvogpv0"Jg"ycu"6;"{gctu"qnf"cv"vjg"vkog0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"swkemn{"rtqoqvgf" Jctvgt."cpf"jg"wnvkocvgn{"uwrgtxkugf"qrgtcvkqpu"cv"kvu"uqnkf"ycuvg"ukvgu."yjkej"kpenwfgf" uwrgtxkuqt{"tgurqpukdknkv{"qxgt"crrtqzkocvgn{"3:"gornq{ggu0"Vjtqwijqwv"JctvgtÓu" gornq{ogpv."jku"uwrgtxkuqtu"rgtkqfkecnn{"eqorngvgf"Rgthqtocpeg"Gxcnwcvkqpu"tgictfkpi" jku"yqtm0"Cu"gctn{"cu"4223."qpg"uwej"gxcnwcvkqp"pqvgf"vjcv"Jctvgt"Ðngvu"jku"rgtuqpcn"nkmgu" cpf"fkunkmgu"kphnwgpeg"vjg"yc{"jg"fgcnu"ykvj"gornq{ggu.Ñ"cpf"cnngigf"vjcv"jg"ujqygf" rtghgtgpvkcn"vtgcvogpv"vq"gornq{ggu"vjcv"jg"hgnv"ygtg"gcukgt"vq"ocpcig0"Fmv0"4;/55."cv"50" Dgvyggp"4227"cpf"4237."Ngunkg"Octujcnn"ugtxgf"cu"Fktgevqt"qh"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Uqnkf" Ycuvg"Fgrctvogpv."cpf"cu"JctvgtÓu"koogfkcvg"uwrgtxkuqt0"Vjgkt"tgncvkqpujkr"ycu"kpkvkcnn{" rqukvkxg."cu"ygtg"jgt"kpkvkcn"Rgthqtocpeg"Gxcnwcvkqpu"qh"JctvgtÓu"yqtm0"Jqygxgt."vjgkt" tgncvkqpujkr"dgicp"vq"fgvgtkqtcvg"kp"4234"chvgt"Octujcnn"jktgf"Nceg{"DncemhqtfÏc"ocp" crrtqzkocvgn{"52"{gctu"{qwpigt"vjcp"JctvgtÏvq"yqtm"cnqpiukfg"jko0"" Jctvgt"cpf"Dncemhqtf"koogfkcvgn{"Ðdwvvgf"jgcfu0Ñ"Fmv0"59/3."cv"4/50"Octujcnn"ogv" ykvj"Jctvgt"qp"ownvkrng"qeecukqpu"vq"fkuewuu"jku"itqykpi"vgpukqp"ykvj"Dncemhqtf0" OctujcnnÓu"4236"Rgthqtocpeg"Gxcnwcvkqp"qh"Jctvgt"uvcvgf"vjcv"jg"pggfgf"vq"kortqxg"vjg" yc{"jg"vcnmgf"cdqwv"qvjgt"gornq{ggu."cpf"pqvgf"kv"ku"Ðwprtqhguukqpcn"hqt"]Jctvgt_"vq" eqpvkpwcnn{"dcf"oqwvj"]jku_"uwrgtxkuqt"vq"qvjgt"gornq{ggu0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/33."cv"9="Fmv0"4;/55." cv"50"Jctvgt"tgurqpfgf"vq"vjku"gxcnwcvkqp."enckokpi"OctujcnnÓu"eqoogpvu"uvgoogf"htqo" jgctuc{"tcvjgt"vjcp"rgtuqpcn"qdugtxcvkqpu0"Fmv0"33."cv"90"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"4" Jctvgt"rtqeggfgf"vq"hkng"c"hqtocn"itkgxcpeg"ykvj"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Dqctf"qh" Eqookuukqpgtu"tgictfkpi"Dncemhqtf"cpf"Octujcnn0"Jg"enckogf"Dncemhqtf"tgiwnctn{" cvvgorvgf"vq"cpvciqpk|g"jko."cpf"Octujcnn"cnnqygf"DncemhqtfÓu"dgjcxkqt"vq"eqpvkpwg." yjkng"Ðdgeqokpi"jquvkng"vqyctfu"]Jctvgt_"cpf"fkuokuukpi"]jku_"eqornckpvu"cu"Òrkuu{0ÓÑ" Fmv0"4;/390"Jctvgt"ycu"cnuq"htwuvtcvgf"dgecwug."hqnnqykpi"DncemhqtfÓu"jktg."jku" qrrqtvwpkvkgu"vq"yqtm"qxgtvkog"ygtg"Ðewv"vq"|gtq0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/39."cv"4="Fmv0"4;/3:."cv"9/:." 49/4:0"Octujcnn"tgurqpfgf"ykvj"c"ngvvgt"uvcvkpi"Jctvgt"jcf"Ðc"jkuvqt{"qh"ngvvkpi"]jku_" rgtuqpcn"hggnkpiu"vqyctfu"cp"gornq{gg"enqwf"]jku_"cdknkv{"vq"rtqhguukqpcnn{"rgthqto"]jku_" lqd0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/55."cv"50"Ujg"hwtvjgt"enckogf"vjcv"Dncemhqtf"ycu"c"iqqf"gornq{gg."cpf"vjcv" JctvgtÓu"eqornckpvu"ygtg"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{"fqewogpvgf"gxkfgpeg0"Fmv0"4;/3:."cv"8/;0"" Qp"Hgdtwct{"42."4236."vjg"Dqctf"qh"Eqwpv{"Eqookuukqpgtu"jgnf"c"oggvkpi"vq" fkuewuu"JctvgtÓu"itkgxcpeg0"Dqvj"Jctvgt"cpf"Octujcnn"ygtg"rtgugpv0"Jctvgt"gncdqtcvgf"qp" jku"itkgxcpeg"ngvvgt"cpf"cnngigf"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"jktgf"Dncemhqtf"Ðdgecwug"qh"]JctvgtÓu_" cigÑ"cpf"dgecwug"Octujcnn"kpvgpfgf"hqt"Dncemhqtf"vq"gxgpvwcnn{"tgrnceg"Jctvgt0"Fmv0"4;/ 3:."cv"530"Octujcnn"cfokvvgf"vq"vgnnkpi"Jctvgt"vjcv"ujg"Ðdtqwijv"uqogqpg"qp"vq"ngctp"jku" lqd"0"0"0"dgecwug"vjgtg"eqwnf"dg"c"vkog"yjgp"]Jctvgt_"yknn"pggf"vq"dg"tgrncegf"cpf"]ujg_" pggf]gf_"vq"jcxg"uqogqpg"wpfgtuvcpf"]JctvgtÓu"tgurqpukdknkvkgu_0Ñ"Id."cv"540"Ujg"enctkhkgf" vjcv"kp"ocmkpi"vjgug"eqoogpvu."kv"ycu"pqv"kp"tghgtgpeg"vq"Jctvgt"rqvgpvkcnn{"dgkpi"hktgf." dwv"ogtgn{"c"tghgtgpeg"vq"Jctvgt"gxgpvwcnn{"tgvktkpi0"" Qp"Hgdtwct{"42."4236."vjg"Eqwpv{"Eqookuukqpgtu"ugpv"Jctvgt"pqvkeg"qh"kvu" fgekukqp"tgictfkpi"jku"itkgxcpeg0"Vjg"Eqookuukqpgtu"fkucitggf"ykvj"Octujcnn"vjcv" JctvgtÓu"enckou"ygtg"htkxqnqwu0"Jqygxgt."yjkng"vjg{"hqwpf"jku"eqornckpvu"vq"dg"ugtkqwu." " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"5" vjg{"cnuq"hqwpf"vjgo"vq"dg"Ðwpuwduvcpvkcvgf"cpf"vjgtghqtg"wprtqxcdng0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/3;0"Cu" uwej."vjg"Eqwpv{"vqqm"pq"hwtvjgt"cevkqp0" Octujcnn"tgvktgf"htqo"jgt"rqukvkqp"kp"Crtkn"qh"42370"Ujg"rtqxkfgf"vjg"Eqwpv{"ykvj" pqvkeg"ugxgtcn"oqpvju"rtkqt"vq"jgt"fgrctvwtg."fwtkpi"yjkej"vkog"vjg"Eqwpv{"cfxgtvkugf"vjg" wreqokpi"xcecpe{0"Jctvgt"enckou"vjg"Eqwpv{"pgxgt"rtqxkfgf"jko"ykvj"rgtuqpcn"pqvkeg" tgictfkpi"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp0"Jctvgt"fkf."jqygxgt."jcxg"pqvkeg"qh" OctujcnnÓu"korgpfkpi"tgvktgogpv"dgecwug"ujg"ugpv"c"rgtuqpcn"gockn"kphqtokpi"jgt"eq/ yqtmgtu"qh"jgt"fgekukqp0"Fmv0"4;/33."cv"420"Jctvgt"fkf"pqv"crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp"dgecwug" jg"cuuwogf"vjg"Eqwpv{"jcf"cntgcf{"ugngevgf"c"ocp"pcogf"Dqd"Jqyctf"vq"ugtxg"cu" OctujcnnÓu"tgrncegogpv0"Urgekhkecnn{."Jctvgt"gzrnckpgf<" " Id. K"ycupÓv"uwtg"vjcv"]OctujcnnÓu"rqukvkqp_"ycu"iqkpi"vq"dg"cxckncdng"vq" uqogdqf{"qvjgt"vjcp"Dqd"Jqyctf."dgecwug"Dqd"Jqyctf"jcf"urgpv"c" egtvckp"coqwpv"qh"vkog"ykvj"]Octujcnn_."cpf"K"lwuv"0"0"0"cuuwogf"vjcv"0"0"0"]vjg" Eqwpv{_"jcf"dggp"uqtv"qh"rtgrctkpi"jko"hqt"vjcv"rqukvkqp0"Dwv"kv"vwtpu"qwv."jg" ycu"pqv0"Vjg{"cfxgtvkugf"vjg"lqd"cpf"fkfpÓv"ngv"cp{dqf{"mpqy."qt"cv"ngcuv" vjg{"fkfpÓv"ngv"og"mpqy"vjcv"vjgtg"ycu"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"hqt"og"vq"crrn{"hqt"kv0"" Jctvgt"pgxgt"fkuewuugf"yjgvjgt"jg"eqwnf"crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp"ykvj"Octujcnn."vjg" Eqwpv{Óu"Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"qhhkeg."qt"Dqd"Jqyctf0"Id."Wnvkocvgn{."vjg"Eqwpv{"jktgf"Ocvv" Mnkpingt"vq"hknn"OctujcnnÓu"tqng0"Cv"vjg"vkog"qh"vjku"jktkpi."Mnkpigt"ycu"hkhv{/qpg"{gctu"qnf." cpf"Jctvgt"ycu"ukzv{/ukz0"" Ujqtvn{"chvgt"vcmkpi"qxgt"cu"Fktgevqt."Mnkpingt"urnkv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Uqnkf"Ycuvg" Fgrctvogpv"kpvq"vyq"fkxkukqpu."tghgttgf"vq"cu"ÐGcuvukfgÑ"cpf"ÐYguvukfg0Ñ"Mnkpigt" cuukipgf"c"ocp"pcogf"Mgxkp"Tg{pqnfu."yjq"ycu"hkhv{/vjtgg"{gctu"qnf"cv"vjg"vkog."vq" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"6" qxgtugg"qrgtcvkqpu"qp"vjg"Gcuvukfg."cpf"Jctvgt"ycu"cuukipgf"vq"qxgtugg"qrgtcvkqpu"qp"vjg" Yguvukfg0"Mnkpingt"enckou"vjcv"vjku"fgekukqp"ycu"ocfg"hqt"Ðrwtgn{"ocpcigtkcn"rwtrqugu0Ñ" Fmv0"4;/430"Jctvgt"enckou"vjg"urnkv"ycu"cp"cig/dcugf"fgoqvkqp."cu"Tg{pqnfu"ycu"{qwpigt" vjcp"jko."cpf"JctvgtÏyjq"rtgxkqwun{"uwrgtxkugf"cnn"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Uqnkf"Ycuvg"ukvguÏ pqy"qpn{"uwrgtxkugf"jcnh0""Jg"tckugf"vjgug"eqpegtpu"ykvj"Ekpf{"Dkpmgtgf."vjg"Eqwpv{Óu" Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"Fktgevqt."cpf"tgswguvgf"c"jgctkpi0"Dkpmgtgf"kphqtogf"Jctvgt"vjcv." rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn."Jctvgt"ycu"pqv"gpvkvngf"vq"c" jgctkpi"dgecwug"jg"ycu"pqv"cevwcnn{"fgoqvgf."pqt"ycu"jku"ucnct{"tgfwegf0"" Ykvjkp"jku"hktuv"vyq"oqpvju"cu"Fktgevqt."Mnkpingt"tgegkxgf"eqornckpvu"cdqwv"Jctvgt" htqo"vjtgg"ugrctcvg"gornq{ggu0"Qpg"uwej"eqornckpv"enckogf"Jctvgt"Ðjcu"c"jkuvqt{"qh" vt{kpi"vq"kpvkokfcvg"rgqrng"yjq"jg"fgekfgu"jg"fqgu"pqv"ycpv"yqtmkpi"wpfgt"jko"cp{" nqpigt0"Kp"vjg"rcuv"K"jcxg"uggp"cpf"jgctf"cdqwv"jko"ogpvcn{"]uke_"dwnnkpi"]uke_"cpf" kpvkokfcvkpi"]xctkqwu"eq/yqtmgtu_0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/450"Vjg"eqornckpv"hwtvjgt"cnngigf"vjcv"Jctvgt" ocfg"fgocpfu"vjcv"Ðygtg"wpuchg."dwv"jg"KPUKUVGF"vjcv"yg"hqnnqy"jku"qtfgtu"qt"jg" yqwnf"hkpf"uqogqpg"vjcv"yqwnf0"Jg"vjtgcvgpgf"vq"oqxg"wu"vq"fkhhgtgpv"ukvgu."gve0Ñ"Id." *gorjcuku"kp"qtkikpcn+0"Cpqvjgt"eqornckpv"ceewugf"Jctvgt"qh"{gnnkpi"cv"gornq{ggu0" Mnkpingt"tgrqtvgf"vjgug"eqornckpvu"vq"Dkpmgtgf."yjq"tgswguvgf"vjcv"Dknn"Yknuqp."cp" cvvqtpg{"kp"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rtqugewvqt)u"Qhhkeg."kpxguvkicvg"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"cpf"tgrqtv"jku" hkpfkpiu"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{"Eqookuukqpgtu0"" YknuqpÓu"kpxguvkicvkqp"dgicp"qp"Lwpg":."42370"Jg"kpvgtxkgygf"hkxg"kpfkxkfwcnu" rtkqt"vq"kpvgtxkgykpi"Jctvgt0"Vjgug"kpvgtxkgyu"tgxgcngf"ownvkrng"cnngicvkqpu"qh"Jctvgt" wukpi"uejgfwnkpi"cu"c"ygcrqp"cickpuv"jku"uwdqtfkpcvgu."uetgcokpi."cpf"tgvcnkcvkpi"cickpuv" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"7" eq/yqtmgtu"vjcv"wrugv"jko0"Fmv0"4;/34."cv"3/70"Qpg"kpvgtxkgygg"enckogf"ujg"wnvkocvgn{" tgukipgf"dgecwug"JctvgtÓu"vtgcvogpv"qh"jgt"Ðdgecog"wpdgctcdng0Ñ"Id."cv"4/50"Ujg" gzrnckpgf"vjcv"ujg"ycu"chtckf"qh"Jctvgt"cpf"ftgcfgf"iqkpi"vq"yqtm"ykvj"jko0"Id."" Qp"Lwpg"46."4237."Yknuqp"kpvgtxkgygf"Jctvgt"vq"ikxg"jko"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"tgurqpf"vq" vjg"cnngicvkqpu0"Yjgp"cumgf"cdqwv"c"urgekhke"cnngicvkqp"qh"{gnnkpi"cv"Mgxkp"Tg{pqnfu." Jctvgt"tgurqpfgf"vjcv"Ðyjcv"]Tg{pqnfu_"ku"tghgttkpi"vq"cu"ÒuetgcokpiÓ"uvctvgf"ykvj"jko" dgecwug"jg"ygpv"qhh"cdqwv"jqy"K"ycu"ceewukpi"jko"qh"vjkpiu"0"0"0"vjg"fgekdgnu"ygpv"wr"c" nkvvng"dkv."dwv"vjgtg"ycu"pq"uetgcokpi"cpf"vjgtg"ycu"pq"jquvknkv{"cu"hct"cu"K"co"eqpegtpgf0Ñ" Fmv0"5;/3."cv"9.";0"" Jctvgt"cfokvvgf"vq"wukpi"rtqhcpkv{"fwtkpi"cp"ctiwogpv"ykvj"Dncemhqtf."gzrnckpkpi" vjcv"Ðiw{u"cv"yqtm."vjcvÓu"jqy"vjg{"vcnm"c"nqv"qh"vkogu0Ñ"Fmv0"5;/3."cv"60"Jqygxgt."jg" fgpkgf"wukpi"uejgfwnkpi"cu"c"ygcrqp"cickpuv"jku"eq/yqtmgtu."qt"gxgt"dwnn{kpi"vjgo0"" Hkpcnn{."Yknuqp"cumgf"Jctvgt"vq"uwiiguv"kpfkxkfwcnu"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"Ðurgcm"vq"qp"]JctvgtÓu_" dgjcnh0Ñ"Fmv0"5;/3."cv"60""Jctvgt"tgurqpfgf"ÐKÓnn"lwuv"dncpmgv"gxgt{dqf{0"Gxgt{dqf{"vjcv" jcu"yqtmgf"hqt"og"tkijv"pqy0"0"0"0"KÓo"pqv"iqkpi"vq"gnkokpcvg"cp{dqf{0Ñ"Id. cv"7."Yknuqp" gzrnckpgf"vjcv"jg"fkf"pqv"ycpv"vq"kpvgtxkgy"gxgt{dqf{"vjcv"jcf"gxgt"yqtmgf"hqt"Jctvgt0" Urgekhkecnn{."jg"uvcvgf<" ]L_wuv"ugnhkujn{."K"fqpÓv"ycpv"vq"kpvgtxkgy"c"fq|gp"rgqrng0"K"yqwnf"tcvjgt"nkokv" kv"vq"c"eqwrng"dgecwug"K"jcxg"pqv"kpvgtxkgygf"vjcv"ocp{"rgqrng"ejcnngpikpi" {qw"gkvjgt0"0"0"kp"hcktpguu."kh"vjgtg"ctg"rgqrng"yjq"ctg"iqkpi"vq"dg"ceewukpi" {qw"qh"vjkpiu."K"ycpv"{qw"vq"jcxg"vjg"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"uc{"Òpq."vjku"rgtuqp"ku"kp" vjg"ucog"rqukvkqp"cpf"vjg{"vjkpm"K"co"fqkpi"c"iqqf"lqd0Ó"Uq"c"eqwrng"0"0"0"qh" vjqug"rgqrng0" " " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"8" Fmv0"5;/3."cv"80""Jctvgt"vjgp"uwiiguvgf"hqwt"kpfkxkfwcnu"Yknuqp"eqwnf"kpvgtxkgy0"Yknuqp." jqygxgt."qpn{"kpvgtxkgygf"qpg"qh"vjgo0"See"Fmv0"4;/34."cv"4/7="Fmv0"5;/3."cv"80""" " Cv"vjg"gpf"qh"jku"kpxguvkicvkqp."Yknuqp"rtqxkfgf"c"uwooct{"cpf"tgeqoogpfcvkqp" vq"vjg"Eqwpv{0"Yjkng"Yknuqp"fkf"pqv"eqpukfgt"gxgt{"cnngicvkqp"ocfg"cickpuv"Jctvgt"vq"dg" etgfkdng."jg"hqwpf"ocp{"qh"vjg"cnngicvkqpuÏocfg"d{"fkhhgtgpv"gornq{ggu"cpf"ctkukpi" htqo"xctkqwu"kpvgtcevkqpu"urcppkpi"qxgt"c"fgecfgÏvq"dg"etgfkdng"cpf"Ðtgoctmcdn{" ukoknct0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/34."cv"80"Jg"tgeqoogpfgf"rncekpi"Jctvgt"qp"c"qpg/{gct"rtqdcvkqp0"" " Dkpmgtf"cpf"Mnkpingt"fkuewuugf"vjg"tguwnvu"qh"vjg"kpxguvkicvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Eqwpv{" Eqookuukqpgtu0"Hkpfkpi"vjg"tguwnvu"vq"dg"etgfkdng."vjg"Eqwpv{"fgoqvgf"Jctvgt"vq"vjg"tqng" qh"Uqnkf"Ycuvg"Vgejpkekcp."ykvjqwv"c"tgfwevkqp"kp"rc{."qp"Lwn{"43."42370"Vjg"Eqwpv{"cnuq" rncegf"Jctvgt"qp"c"qpg/{gct"rtqdcvkqp0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"enckou"vjcv."rwtuwcpv"vq"vjku" rtqdcvkqp."JctvgtÓu"gornq{ogpv"uvcvwu"ycu"ejcpigf"htqo"Ðhqt/ecwugÑ"vq"Ðcv/yknn0Ñ"Jctvgt" enckou"vjcv"jg"ycu"pgxgt"ocfg"cyctg"qh"vjku"ejcpig"cpf"ctiwgu"vjcv"jg"tgockpgf"c"hqt/ ecwug"gornq{gg0" Hqnnqykpi"vjku"fgoqvkqp."Jctvgt"uqwijv"vq"crrgcn"vjg"fgekukqp0"Chvgt"ugpfkpi" Dkpmgtf"ownvkrng"gocknu"uggmkpi"kphqtocvkqp"tgictfkpi"vjg"rtqrgt"rtqegfwtgu"hqt" kpkvkcvkpi"cp"crrgcn."ujg"tgurqpfgf"ykvj"c"ngvvgt"vjcv"uckf<"" Eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"rqnke{"iwkfgnkpgu."dgecwug"vjgtg"ycu"pq"ejcpig"vq"{qwt" rc{."{qw"ygtg"mgrv"yjqng"kp"tgictf"vq"dgpghkvu."vjgtg"ctg"pq"crrgcn"tkijvu0" Vjg"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"dg"jgctf"cpf"pcog"engctkpi"tgncvgu"vq"vjqug"gornq{ggu" yjq"ctg"kpfgrgpfgpv"eqpvtcevqtu."ugcuqpcn."vgorqtct{"qt"rtqdcvkqpct{0"Pqpg" qh"yjkej"{qw"ctg0"Vjgtghqtg."{qwt"tgswguv"hqt"cp"crrgcn"jgctkpi"ku"fgpkgf"qp" vjcv"dcuku0" " Fmv0"4;/4;."cv"30"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"9" Jctvgt"vjgp"hkngf"c"eqornckpv"ykvj"vjg"Kfcjq"Jwocp"Tkijvu"Eqookuukqp" *ÐKJTEÑ+0"Urgekhkecnn{."jg"cnngigf"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"fkuetkokpcvgf"cickpuv"jko"dcugf"qp"jku" cig"yjgp"kv"tgcuukipgf"jcnh"qh"jku"uwrgtxkuqt{"tgurqpukdknkvkgu"vq"c"{qwpigt"gornq{gg" *Mgxkp"Tg{pqnfu+."cpf"cickp"yjgp"kv"fgoqvgf"jko"cpf"rncegf"jko"qp"rtqdcvkqp" hqnnqykpi"YknuqpÓu"kpxguvkicvkqp0"Cffkvkqpcnn{."Jctvgt"cnngigf"vjcv"kp"4236"vjg"Eqwpv{" gpicigf"kp"cig/dcugf"fkuetkokpcvkqp"yjgp"kv"jktgf"Mgxkp"Tg{pqnfu"vq"dg"vjg"Ðcnvgtpcvkxg" gogtigpe{"tgurqpug"ocpcigtÑ"ykvjqwv"ikxkpi"Jctvgt"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"crrn{"hqt"vjg" rqukvkqp0"" Qp"Lwn{"36."4238."yjkng"JctvgtÓu"KJTE"eqornckpv"ycu"uvknn"rgpfkpi."jg"tgegkxgf"c" pqvkeg"qh"vgtokpcvkqp"htqo"vjg"Eqwpv{0"Vjg"pqvkeg"fkf"pqv"urgekhkecnn{"gzrnckp"yj{"vjg" Eqwpv{"ycu"vgtokpcvkpi"jko0"Kv"ukorn{"uvcvgf"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"ycu"Ðwpucvkuhkgf"ykvj"]jku_" rgthqtocpeg0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/36."cv"30"Vjg"pqvkeg"cnuq"kpenwfgf"kphqtocvkqp"tgictfkpi"vjg"rtqrgt" rtqegfwtg"hqt"tgswguvkpi"c"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"kh"Jctvgt"dgnkgxgf"jku"vgtokpcvkqp" ycu"vjg"rtqfwev"qh"wpncyhwn"fkuetkokpcvkqp0"Id."cv"3/50"Kv"kphqtogf"Jctvgt"vjcv"hcknwtg"vq" uggm"c"tgxkgy"jgctkpi"yqwnf"eqpuvkvwvg"c"hcknwtg"vq"gzjcwuv"jku"tgogfkgu0"Id."cv"50"Jctvgt" wnvkocvgn{"fkf"pqv"uggm"c"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi0"" Vjg"KJTE"kuuwgf"kvu"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qp"Cwiwuv"48."4238."hkpfkpi"Jctvgt"eqwnf"pqv" rtgxckn"qp"jku"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"enckou0"Jqygxgt."vjg"KJTE"fkf"pqv"eqpukfgt"JctvgtÓu" vgtokpcvkqp"kp"tgcejkpi"vjku"eqpenwukqp"cpf"ocfg"pq"tghgtgpeg"vq"kv0"Rtguwocdn{."kvu" fgvgtokpcvkqp"ycu"eqphkpgf"uqngn{"vq"cnngicvkqpu"ocfg"kp"JctvgtÓu"eqornckpv"hkngf"rtkqt"vq" jku"vgtokpcvkqp0"Qp"Fgegodgt"43."4238."Jctvgt"hkngf"vjg"ncyuwkv"pqy"dghqtg"vjg"Eqwtv0"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î":" KKK0"NGICN"UVCPFCTF" Uwooct{"lwfiogpv"ku"rtqrgt"Ðkh"vjg"oqxcpv"ujqyu"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"pq"igpwkpg"fkurwvg" cu"vq"cp{"ocvgtkcn"hcev"cpf"vjg"oqxcpv"ku"gpvkvngf"vq"lwfiogpv"cu"c"ocvvgt"qh"ncy0Ñ"Hgf0"T0" Ekx0"R0"78*c+0"Vjku"EqwtvÓu"tqng"cv"uwooct{"lwfiogpv"ku"pqv"Ðvq"ygkij"vjg"gxkfgpeg"cpf" fgvgtokpg"vjg"vtwvj"qh"vjg"ocvvgt"dwv"vq"fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"vjgtg"ku"c"igpwkpg"kuuwg"hqt" vtkcn0Ñ"Zetwick v. Cty. of Yolo.":72"H05f"658."663"*;vj"Ekt0"4239+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0"Kp" eqpukfgtkpi"c"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv."vjku"Eqwtv"owuv"Ðxkgy]_"vjg"hcevu"kp"vjg" pqp/oqxkpi"rctv{Óu"hcxqt0Ñ"Id."Vq"fghgcv"c"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv."vjg"tgurqpfgpv" pggf"qpn{"rtgugpv"gxkfgpeg"wrqp"yjkej"Ðc"tgcuqpcdng"lwtqt"ftcykpi"cnn"kphgtgpegu"kp" hcxqt"qh"vjg"tgurqpfgpv"eqwnf"tgvwtp"c"xgtfkev"kp"]jku"qt"jgt_"hcxqt0Ñ"Id."*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0" Ceeqtfkpin{."vjku"Eqwtv"owuv"gpvgt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv"kh"c"rctv{"Ðhcknu"vq"ocmg"c"ujqykpi" uwhhkekgpv"vq"guvcdnkuj"vjg"gzkuvgpeg"qh"cp"gngogpv"guugpvkcn"vq"vjcv"rctv{Óu"ecug."cpf"qp" yjkej"vjcv"rctv{"yknn"dgct"vjg"dwtfgp"qh"rtqqh"cv"vtkcn0Ñ"Celotex Corp. v. Catrett."699"W0U0" 539."544"*3;:8+0"Vjg"tgurqpfgpv"ecppqv"ukorn{"tgn{"qp"cp"wpuyqtp"chhkfcxkv"qt"vjg" rngcfkpiu"vq"fghgcv"c"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv="tcvjgt"vjg"tgurqpfgpv"owuv"ugv"hqtvj" vjg"Ðurgekhke"hcevu.Ñ"uwrrqtvgf"d{"gxkfgpeg."ykvj"Ðtgcuqpcdng"rctvkewnctkv{Ñ"vjcv"rtgenwfgu" uwooct{"lwfiogpv0"Far Out Productions, Inc. v. Oskar."469"H05f";:8.";;9"*;vj"Ekt0" 4223+0""" KX0"CPCN[UKU" JctvgtÓu"cogpfgf"eqornckpv"kpenwfgu"vjg"hqnnqykpi"ecwugu"qh"cevkqp<"*3+"cig" fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"xkqncvkqp"qh"Vkvng"XKK"qh"vjg"Ekxkn"Tkijvu"Cev"qh"3;86"*ÐVkvng"XKKÑ+"cpf" vjg"Cig"Fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"Gornq{ogpv"Cev"*ÐCFGCÑ+="*4+"tgvcnkcvqt{"fkuejctig"kp" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î";" xkqncvkqp"qh"Vkvng"XKK"cpf"vjg"CFGC="*5+"uvcvg"ncy"dtgcej"qh"eqpvtcev"cpf"vjg"eqxgpcpv"qh" iqqf"hckvj"cpf"hckt"fgcnkpi="cpf"*6+"fgpkcn"qh"rtqegfwtcn"fwg"rtqeguu"kp"xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg" Hkhvj"cpf"Hqwtvggpvj"Cogpfogpvu"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Eqpuvkvwvkqp0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"jcu" oqxgf"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv"qp"cnn"enckou0" C0" Cig"Fkuetkokpcvkqp"Enckou" 1. Applicable Law Kv"ku"ygnn"guvcdnkujgf"vjcv"vjg"Ðeqortgjgpukxg"tgogfkcn"uejgog"qh"vjg"CFGC" fgoqpuvtcvgu"vjcv"Eqpitguu"kpvgpfgf"vjg"CFGC"vq"ugtxg"cu"vjg"gzenwukxg"ogcpu"hqt" rwtuwkpi"enckou"qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"gornq{ogpv0Ñ"Ahlmeyer v. Nev. Sys. of Higher Educ.."777"H05f"3273."327:"*;vj"Ekt0"422;+0"Cu"uwej."qpn{"JctvgtÓu"encko"qh"cig" fkuetkokpcvkqp"wpfgt"vjg"CFGC"ku"rtqrgt."cpf"jku"encko"qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"xkqncvkqp" qh"Vkvng"XKK"ku"FKUOKUUGF0"" Vjg"CFGC"ocmgu"kv"Ðwpncyhwn"hqt"cp"gornq{gt"0"0"0"vq"fkuejctig"cp{"kpfkxkfwcn.Ñ" qt"qvjgtykug"fkuetkokpcvg"cickpuv"cp"gornq{gg"dgecwug"qh"vjgkt"cig0"4;"W0U0E0"¸"845*c+0" ÐVq"rtqxg"fkuetkokpcvkqp"dgecwug"qh"cig."]Jctvgt_"owuv"kpvtqfweg"gxkfgpeg"htqo"yjkej"c" tgcuqpcdng"lwt{"eqwnf"eqpenwfg."kp"nkijv"qh"eqooqp"gzrgtkgpeg."vjcv"kv"ycu"oqtg"nkmgn{" vjcp"pqv"vjcv"vjg"gornq{gtÓu"cfxgtug"cevkqp"ycu"oqvkxcvgf"d{"eqpukfgtcvkqp"qh"jku"cig0Ñ" Maxfield v. Brigham Young Univ.–Idaho."49"H0"Uwrr0"5f"3299."32:8"*F0"Kfcjq"4236+" *ekvkpi"Furnco Construction Corp. v. Waters."65:"W0U0"789."79;Î:2"*3;9:++0"ÐCig" fkuetkokpcvkqp"ecp"dg"guvcdnkujgf"vjtqwij"gkvjgt"fktgev"qt"kpfktgev"gxkfgpeg0Ñ"Mousaw v. Teton Outfitters."NNE."Pq0"6/36/EX/2272:/GLN/TGD."4238"YN"7968566."cv",6"*F0" Kfcjq"Ugrv0"52."4238+"*ekvkpi"Coghlan v. Am. Seafoods Co.."NNE."635"H05f"32;2."32;7" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"32" *;vj"Ekt0"4227++0"Jqygxgt."ukorn{"rtqxkpi"cig"Ðrnc{gf"c"tqngÑ"kp"vjg"fgekukqp"vq" fkuejctig"cp"gornq{gg"ku"pqv"gpqwij="tcvjgt."Ðc"rnckpvkhh"owuv"rtqxg"vjcv"cig"ycu"vjg" Òdwv/hqtÓ"ecwug"qh"vjg"gornq{gtÓu"cfxgtug"cevkqp0Ñ"Gross v. FBL Fin. Servs., Inc.."779" W0U0"389."398"*422;+"*jqnfkpi"vjcv"okzgf/oqvkxg"vjgqt{"crrnkecdng"vq"Vkvng"XKK"enckou"ku" pqv"cxckncdng"kp"CFGC"enckou+0" " Vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"wvknk|gu"vjg"vjtgg/uvgr"McDonnell Douglas"dwtfgp/ujkhvkpi" htcogyqtm"vq"cpcn{|g"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"ecugu0"Id.="see also Wallis v. J.R. Simplot Co.." 48"H05f"::7."::;"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;6+0"Wpfgt"vjku"htcogyqtm."vjg"gornq{gg"owuv"hktuv" guvcdnkuj"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ecug"qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp0"Qpeg"vjg"gornq{gg"jcu"fqpg"uq."vjg" dwtfgp"ujkhvu"vq"vjg"gornq{gt"vq"ctvkewncvg"c"ngikvkocvg."pqp/fkuetkokpcvqt{"tgcuqp"hqt"kvu" cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqp0"Kh"vjg"gornq{gt"ucvkuhkgu"kvu"dwtfgp."vjg"gornq{gg"owuv"vjgp" rtqxg"vjcv"vjg"tgcuqp"cfxcpegf"d{"vjg"gornq{gt"eqpuvkvwvgu"ogtg"rtgvgzv"hqt"wpncyhwn" fkuetkokpcvkqp0"Diaz v. Eagle Produce Ltd. P’ship."743"H05f"3423."3429"*;vj"Ekt0"422:+" *kpvgtpcn"ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0"" Rnckpvkhhu"ecp"guvcdnkuj"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ecug"dcugf"qp"ektewouvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"d{" ujqykpi"vjg"hqnnqykpi<"*3+"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"ogodgtu"qh"c"rtqvgevgf"encuu="*4+"vjcv"vjg{"ygtg" swcnkhkgf"hqt"vjgkt"rqukvkqpu"cpf"rgthqtokpi"vjgkt"lqdu"ucvkuhcevqtkn{="*5+"vjcv"vjg{" gzrgtkgpegf"cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqpu="cpf"*6+"vjcv"ukoknctn{"ukvwcvgf"kpfkxkfwcnu" qwvukfg"qh"vjgkt"rtqvgevgf"encuu"ygtg"vtgcvgf"oqtg"hcxqtcdn{."qt"qvjgt"ektewouvcpegu" uwttqwpfkpi"vjg"cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqp"ikxg"tkug"vq"cp"kphgtgpeg"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp0" See"Hawn v. Exec. Jet Mgmt., Inc.."837"H05f"3373."3377"*;vj"Ekt0"4232+"*swqvkpi" Peterson v. Hewlett-Packard Co.."57:"H05f"7;;."825"*;vj"Ekt0"4226++0"ÐVjg"tgswkukvg" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"33" fgitgg"qh"rtqqh"pgeguuct{"vq"guvcdnkuj"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ecug"hqt"0"0"0"CFGC"enckou"qp" uwooct{"lwfiogpv"ku"okpkocn"cpf"fqgu"pqv"gxgp"pggf"vq"tkug"vq"vjg"ngxgn"qh"c" rtgrqpfgtcpeg"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg0Ñ"Wallis."48"H05f"cv"::;="see also Chuang v. Univ. of Cal. Davis, Bd. of Trs.."447"H05f"3337."3346"*;vj"Ekt0"4222+"*ÐCu"c"igpgtcn"ocvvgt."vjg" rnckpvkhh"kp"cp"gornq{ogpv"fkuetkokpcvkqp"cevkqp"pggf"rtqfweg"xgt{"nkvvng"gxkfgpeg"kp" qtfgt"vq"qxgteqog"cp"gornq{gtÓu"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv0Ñ+0"" 2. Application " Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"ogoqtcpfwo"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"kvu"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv" Ðikxg]u_"Jctvgt"vjg"dgpghkv"qh"vjg"fqwdvÑ"cpf"eqpegfgu"vjcv"jg"ecp"guvcdnkuj"c"rtkoc"hcekg" ecug"qp"jku"CFGC"encko0"Fmv0"4;/3."cv"80"Cu"uwej."vjg"dwtfgp"ujkhvu"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{"vq" Ðctvkewncvg"uqog"ngikvkocvg."pqpfkuetkokpcvqt{"tgcuqp"hqt"vjg"ejcnngpigf"cevkqp0Ñ"Hawn." 837"H05f"cv"33770"" Vjg"Eqwpv{"jcu"engctn{"ogv"vjku"dwtfgp0"Rtkqt"vq"JctvgtÓu"fgoqvkqp."vjg"Eqwpv{" tgegkxgf"ownvkrng"eqornckpvu"cdqwv"jko"htqo"jku"eq/yqtmgtu."kpenwfkpi"cnngicvkqpu"qh" {gnnkpi."xgtdcn"cdwug."cpf"tgvcnkcvkqp"cickpuv"uwdqtfkpcvgu0"Cp"kpvgtpcn"kpxguvkicvkqp" eqttqdqtcvgf"vjgug"enckou"cpf"tgxgcngf"cffkvkqpcn"cnngicvkqpu"qh"okueqpfwevÏkpenwfkpi" vjg"uvcvgogpv"qh"c"hqtogt"uwdqtfkpcvg"yjq"gxgpvwcnn{"tgukipgf"fwg"vq"JctvgtÓu" okuvtgcvogpv"qh"jgt0"Jctvgt"jkougnh."cnvjqwij"ujkhvkpi"vjg"dncog"vq"jku"eq/yqtmgtu." cfokvvgf"vq"tckukpi"jku"xqkeg"cpf"ewtukpi"cv"qvjgt"gornq{ggu0"Vjku"kpvgtpcn"kpxguvkicvkqp." yjkej"hqwpf"ocp{"qh"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"cickpuv"Jctvgt"vq"dg"etgfkdng."ucvkuhkgu"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu" dwtfgp"jgtg0"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"34" " Vjg"dwtfgp"vjgp"ujkhvu"dcem"vq"Jctvgt"vq"Ðtckug"c"vtkcdng"kuuwg"qh"ocvgtkcn"hcev"cu"vq" yjgvjgt"vjg"]Eqwpv{Óu_"rtqhhgtgf"tgcuqpu"hqt"]vjg"cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqp"ctg_"ogtg" rtgvgzv"hqt"wpncyhwn"fkuetkokpcvkqp0Ñ"Id.""ÐC"rnckpvkhh"ecp"ujqy"rtgvgzv"fktgevn{."d{" ujqykpi"vjcv"fkuetkokpcvkqp"oqtg"nkmgn{"oqvkxcvgf"vjg"gornq{gt."qt"kpfktgevn{."d{" ujqykpi"vjcv"vjg"gornq{gtÓu"gzrncpcvkqp"ku"wpyqtvj{"qh"etgfgpeg0Ñ"Vasquez v. Cty. of Los Angeles."56;"H05f"856."863"*;vj"Ekt0"4225+."cu"cogpfgf"*Lcp0"4."4226+0"Kh"vjg"rnckpvkhh" rtqxgu"rtgvgzv"kpfktgevn{."ektewouvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"qh"rtgvgzv"owuv"dg"Ðurgekhke"cpf" uwduvcpvkcnÑ"vq"uwtxkxg"c"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv0"Lyons v. England."529"H05f" 32;4."3334"*;vj"Ekt0"4224+0" " Jctvgt"tckugu"vyq"vjgqtkgu"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"jku"cnngicvkqp"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"uvcvgf" tgcuqpu"hqt"jku"fgoqvkqp"ctg"ogtg"rtgvgzv0"Hktuv."jg"enckou"Yknuqp"fkf"pqv"eqorngvg"c" vjqtqwij"cpf"ectghwn"kpxguvkicvkqp"kpvq"vjg"eqornckpvu"tckugf"d{"JctvgtÓu"eq/yqtmgtu."cpf" ugeqpf."jg"enckou"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"jko"vq"OctujcnnÓu"xcecvgf"rqukvkqp"kp" 4237"ku"hwtvjgt"rtqqh"qh"rtgvgzv0"" a. Wilson’s Investigation " Kp"uwrrqtv"qh"jku"hktuv"vjgqt{."Jctvgt"ekvgu"vq"Mastro v. Potomac Elec. Power Co.." 669."H05f":65"*W0U0"Crr0"F0E0."4228+."c"ecug"vjcv"kpxqnxgu"c"rtg/vgtokpcvkqp" kpxguvkicvkqp0"Vjgtg."vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Eqwtv"qh"Crrgcnu"hqt"vjg"Fkuvtkev"qh"Eqnwodkc" fgpkgf"cp"gornq{gtÓu"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpv"qp"c"tceg/dcugf"fkuetkokpcvkqp" encko."hkpfkpi"Ðvjg"kpxguvkicvkqp"0"0"0"ncemgf"vjg"ectghwn."u{uvgocvke"cuuguuogpvu"qh" etgfkdknkv{"qpg"yqwnf"gzrgev"kp"cp"kpswkt{"qp"yjkej"cp"gornq{ggÓu"tgrwvcvkqp"cpf" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"35" nkxgnkjqqf"fgrgpfgf0Ñ"Mastro."669"H05f"cv":770"Vjg"eqwtv"eqpukfgtgf"cp"kpeqorngvg."rtg/ vgtokpcvkqp"kpxguvkicvkqp"uwej"cu"vjcv"vq"dg"ogtg"rtgvgzv"hqt"tcekcn"fkuetkokpcvkqp0"See id."" Vjg"kpxguvkicvkqp"cv"kuuwg"kp"Mastro."jqygxgt. fkhhgtgf"octmgfn{"htqo"vjg" kpxguvkicvkqp"jgtg0"Kp"Mastro."vjg"kpxguvkicvqt"hckngf"vq"kpvgtxkgy"vjg"ceewugf"gornq{gg" dghqtg"uwdokvvkpi"jku"tgrqtv"vq"ocpcigogpv0"Id."Vjg"eqwtv"dgnkgxgf"vjku"rwv"vjg"gornq{gg" Ðqp"vjg"fghgpukxgÑ"yjgp"jg"ycu"hkpcnn{"cnnqygf"vq"ujctg"jku"xgtukqp"qh"gxgpvu"ykvj" ocpcigogpv0"Id."Jgtg."Yknuqp"kpvgtxkgygf"Jctvgt"rtkqt"vq"uwdokvvkpi"jku" tgeqoogpfcvkqp"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{."rtqxkfkpi"jko"ykvj"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"tgurqpf"vq"vjg" cnngicvkqpu"cpf"vq"tgeqoogpf"hwtvjgt"kpvgtxkgyggu0"" Cffkvkqpcnn{."Ðkp"eqpfwevkpi"cp"kpxguvkicvkqp"vjcv"tguvgf"gpvktgn{"qp"vjg"swguvkqp"qh" etgfkdknkv{."]vjg"Mastro kpxguvkicvqt_"guejgygf"eqpukfgtcvkqp"qh"cp{"kpfkekc"qh" etgfkdknkv{0Ñ"Id."cv":780"Kpuvgcf."vjg"kpxguvkicvqt"uggogf"vq"dcug"Ðjku"fgvgtokpcvkqp"qp" ujggt"ygkijv"qh"pwodgtu0Ñ"Id."Jgtg."Yknuqp"pqv"qpn{"eqpukfgtgf"vjg"etgfkdknkv{"qh"vjg" xctkqwu"kpvgtxkgyggu."dwv"jku"tgrqtv"urgekhkecnn{"kpfkecvgf"vjqug"kpvgtxkgyggu"jg"hqwpf"vq" dg"etgfkdng"cpf"vjqugÏkpenwfkpi"cp"kpvgtxkgygg"cfxgtug"vq"JctvgtÏjg"dgnkgxgf"ncemgf" etgfkdknkv{0"" Cfokvvgfn{."Yknuqp"qpn{"kpvgtxkgygf"qpg"kpfkxkfwcn"Jctvgt"uwiiguvgf0"Jqygxgt."c" vjqtqwij"kpxguvkicvkqp"fqgu"pqv"pgeguuctkn{"tgswktg"vjcv"cp"kpxguvkicvqt"kpvgtxkgy"gxgt{" rquukdng"ykvpguu0"Yjkng"vgnnkpi"Jctvgt"Ðlwuv"ugnhkujn{."K"fqpÓv"ycpv"vq"kpvgtxkgy"c"fq|gp" rgqrngÑ"oc{"jcxg"dggp"c"rqqt"ejqkeg"qh"yqtfu."pqvjkpi"cdqwv"YknuqpÓu"cevwcn" kpxguvkicvkqp"uggou"kortqrgt"qt"ewtuqt{0"Jku"kpxguvkicvkqp"kpenwfgf"kpvgtxkgyu"ykvj" ugxgp"kpfkxkfwcnu."kpenwfkpi"Jctvgt"jkougnh."cpf"c"jcpfhwn"qh"JctvgtÓu"eq/yqtmgtuÏdqvj" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"36" ewttgpv"cpf"hqtogt0"Jku"tgrqtv"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{"fgvckngf"vjg"kphqtocvkqp"ingcpgf"htqo"gcej" kpvgtxkgy"cpf"fkuewuugf"vjg"etgfkdknkv{"qh"ocp{"qh"vjg"enckou"ocfg"vjgtgkp0"Uwej"cp" kpxguvkicvkqp"fqgu"pqv"tckug"eqpegtpu"qh"kpeqorngvgpguu"nkmg"vjqug"fkuewuugf"kp"Mastro0" Nkmgykug."pqvjkpi"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"Ðecnn]u_"kpvq"swguvkqp"yjgvjgt"]vjg"Eqwpv{Óu_" kpxguvkicvkqp"ycu"c"tgcuqpcdn{"qdlgevkxg"cuuguuogpv"qh"vjg"ektewouvcpegu0Ñ"Id."cv":790" Yjkng"Jctvgt"enckou"Yknuqp."cu"c"Eqwpv{"gornq{gg."ycu"Ðpqv"c"pgwvtcn"kpxguvkicvqt"cu" tgswktgfÑ"d{"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"4237"Rqnke{"Ocpwcn."vjg"ocpwcn"kvugnh"fqgu"pqv"fghkpg"Ðpgwvtcn" kpxguvkicvqt.Ñ"pqt"fqgu"Jctvgt"rtqxkfg"cp{"rgtuwcukxg"uwrrqtv"hqt"vjg"pqvkqp"vjcv"c"Eqwpv{" gornq{gg"eqwnf"pqv"dg"c"pgwvtcn"rctv{0"Cf. Miller v. Lemhi County."Pq0"6/37/EX/22378/ GLN/EYF."4239"YN"47;255:."cv",37"*F0"Kfcjq"Lwpg"35."4239+ *ÐQp"vjg"qpg"jcpf."vjg" rtqugewvqt"gpicigf"kp"cp"kpxguvkicvkqp0"Qp"vjg"qvjgt."jg"ugtxgf"cu"cp"cigpv"qh"vjg" Eqookuukqpgtu"hqt"vjg"rwtrqug"qh"cfxkukpi"vjgo"qp"vjgkt"fgekukqp0"Vjgug"hcevu"cnqpg"ctg" pqv"uwhhkekgpv"vq"fgoqpuvtcvg"vjg"crrgctcpeg"qh"qt"cevwcn"dkcu0Ñ+0"Pqvjkpi"kp"vjg"tgeqtf" kpfkecvgu."pqt"jcu"Jctvgt"guvcdnkujgf."cp{"kortqrgt"eqppgevkqp"dgvyggp"Yknuqp"cpf" qvjgtu"kpxqnxgf"kp"vjg"Jctvgt"kpxguvkicvkqp0" Jctvgt"fqgu."jqygxgt."cnngig"vjcv"d{"ejqqukpi"Yknuqp"vq"kpxguvkicvg"vjg" eqornckpvu."Ðvjg"Eqwpv{"eqwnf"jkfg"hcevu"rgtvckpkpi"vq"vjg"hwnn"ueqrg"cpf"cfgswce{"qh"vjg" kpxguvkicvkqp"dgjkpf"vjg"ewtvckp"qh"cvvqtpg{/enkgpv"eqphkfgpvkcnkv{0Ñ"Fmv0"69."cv"5/60"Vjku" encko"crrgctu"vq"dg"dcugf"qp"urgewncvkqp0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"jcu"rtgugpvgf"YknuqpÓu"gpvktg" ytkvvgp"tgrqtv"qh"vjg"kpxguvkicvkqp"*vjcv"Yknuqp"rtqxkfgf"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{"rtkqt"vq"kvu" fgekukqp"vq"fgoqvg"Jctvgt+."cpf"Jctvgt"jcu"pqv"ujqyp"vjcv"jg"ycu"rtglwfkegf"d{"YknuqpÓu" uvcvwu"cu"cp"cvvqtpg{0"Uwej"dcugnguu"cuugtvkqpu"ctg"pqv"gpqwij"vq"ucvkuh{"jku"dwtfgp"jgtg0" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"37" Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"Eqwtv"hkpfu"vjcv"vjg"pcvwtg"qh"YknuqpÓu"kpxguvkicvkqp"fqgu"pqv"uwrrqtv" JctvgtÓu"enckou"qh"rtgvgzv0"" b. Failure to Promote Jctvgt"pgzv"ctiwgu"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"jko"vq"tgrnceg"Octujcnn"kp" 4237"uwrrqtvu"cp"kphgtgpeg"qh"fkuetkokpcvqt{"oqvkxg"cpf"ugtxgu"cu"hwtvjgt"rtqqh"qh" rtgvgzv0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"eqpvgpfu"vjcv"vjg"Eqwtv"ecppqv"gpvgtvckp"vjku"encko"dgecwug"Jctvgt" hckngf"vq"gzjcwuv"jku"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgogfkgu0""Yjkng"vjg"Eqwpv{"ku"pqv"eqttgev"kp" cuugtvkpi"Jctvgt"owuv"gzjcwuv"jku"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgogfkgu"wpfgt"cp"CFGC"encko."Jctvgt" ku"tgswktgf"vq"cv"ngcuv"hkng"c"ejctig"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Gswcn"Gornq{ogpv" Qrrqtvwpkv{"Eqookuukqp"]GGQE_"qt"ykvj"cp"crrtqrtkcvg"uvcvg"cigpe{"*kp"vjku"ecug."vjg" KJTE+0"See Sproul v. Washoe Barton Med. Clinic."Pq0"5/32/EX/22:23/TEL/XRE."4235" YN"39;43:9."cv",33/35"*F0"Pgx0"Crt0"48."4235+"*ÐCnvjqwij"cp"CFGC"rnckpvkhh"pggf"pqv" gzjcwuv"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgogfkgu"cu"c"rtgtgswkukvg"vq"uwkv."ujg"owuv"hkng"c"ejctig"qh" fkuetkokpcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"GGQE"qt"vjg"gswkxcngpv"uvcvg"cigpe{"0"0"0Ñ+"*ekvkpi"Sanchez v. Pac. Power Co.."369"H05f"32;9."32;;"*;vj"Ekt03;;:++0"" Jgtg."Jctvgt"hkngf"cp"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"encko"ykvj"vjg"KJTE"kp"42370"Jqygxgt." vjcv"encko"ycu"rtkoctkn{"dcugf"qp"JctvgtÓu"fgoqvkqp"ykvjqwv"c"tgfwevkqp"kp"rc{"cpf"ocfg" pq"tghgtgpeg"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"jko"vq"OctujcnnÓu"xcecvgf"rqukvkqp0"Cu" uwej."JctvgtÓu"4237"KJTE"encko"yqwnf"pqtocnn{"pqv"ucvkuh{"vjg"tgswktgogpv"vjcv"jg"hkng"c" ejctig"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp"tgictfkpi"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"jko"vq"OctujcnnÓu" xcecvgf"rqukvkqp"kp"42370" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"38" Jqygxgt."vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"Ðkpekfgpvu"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp"pqv" kpenwfgf"kp"cp"GGQE"ejctigÑ"oc{"uvknn"dg"eqpukfgtgf"d{"c"hgfgtcn"eqwtv"kh"Ðvjg"pgy" enckou"ctg"nkmg"qt"tgcuqpcdn{"tgncvgf"vq"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"eqpvckpgf"kp"vjg"GGQE"ejctig0Ñ" Green v. Los Angeles County Superintendent of Sch.."::5"H04f"3694."3697/98"*;vj"Ekt0" 3;:;+"*kpvgtpcn"swqvcvkqp"octmu"qokvvgf+0"Vq"ocmg"vjku"fgvgtokpcvkqp."vjg"Eqwtv" Ðkpswktgu"yjgvjgt"vjg"qtkikpcn"GGQE"kpxguvkicvkqp"yqwnf"jcxg"gpeqorcuugf"vjg" cffkvkqpcn"ejctigu0Ñ"Id."Cfokvvgfn{."vjgug"ecugu"kpxqnxgf"Vkvng"XKK"enckou"tcvjgt"vjcp" CFGC"enckou0"Jqygxgt."vjg"Eqwtv"hkpfu"uwej"cp"crrtqcej"gswcnn{"crrnkecdng"kp"vjg" CFGC"eqpvgzv0"See"Williams v. Lorenz."Pq0"37/ex/266;6/DNH."423:"YN"6225677"cv",8/ 9 *P0F0"Ecn0"Cwi0"44."423:+"*cfqrvkpi"c"ukoknct"crrtqcej+0"" Jgtg."JctvgtÓu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"encko"ku"uwhhkekgpvn{"tgncvgf"vq"vjg"cnngicvkqpu" ocfg"kp"jku"4237"ejctig"qh"fkuetkokpcvkqp"hkngf"ykvj"vjg"KJTE"vq"cnnqy"kv"vq"rtqeggf0"Jku" cevwcn"ejctig"cnngigf"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"fgekukqp"vq"fgoqvg"jko."cu"ygnn"cu" fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"jktkpi"qh"Tg{pqnfuÏc"ocp"{qwpigt"vjcp"JctvgtÏvq"ugtxg" cu"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Cnvgtpcvkxg"Gogtigpe{"Tgurqpug"Ocpcigt."ykvjqwv"rtqxkfkpi"Jctvgt"cp" qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp0"Vjku"encko"ku"gzvtgogn{"ukoknct"vq"JctvgtÓu" cnngicvkqp"qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"jko"vq"hknn"OctujcnnÓu" rqukvkqp0"Dgecwug"vjku"encko"ku"Ðnkmg"]cpf_"tgcuqpcdn{"tgncvgf"vq"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"eqpvckpgf" kp"vjg"]KJTE_"ejctig.Ñ"vjg"Eqwtv"oc{"rtqrgtn{"eqpukfgt"kv"pqy0"" Vjg"Eqwpv{"ctiwgu"vjcv."gxgp"kh"Jctvgt"jcu"ucvkuhkgf"vjg"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"tgogfkgu" tgswktgogpv."jg"uvknn"ecppqv"uweeggf"qp"vjku"encko"dgecwug"jg"hckngf"vq"crrn{"hqt"vjg" rqukvkqp0"Yjkng"c"hcknwtg"vq"crrn{"pqtocnn{"rtgxgpvu"c"enckocpv"htqo"uweeggfkpi"qp"c" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"39" hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"encko."c"hcknwtg"vq"crrn{"fwg"vq"fkuetkokpcvkqp"oc{"cnngxkcvg"vjcv" tgswktgogpv0"See Bouman v. Block.";62"H04f"343."3443"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:9+"*gzrnckpkpi"vjcv"Ðc" rgtuqp"oc{"jcxg"uvcpfkpi"kp"c"Vkvng"XKK"cevkqp"vq"ejcnngpig"fkuetkokpcvqt{"rtcevkegu"gxgp" kh"ujg"fkf"pqv"crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp"ujg"enckou"ycu"enqugf"vq"jgt"dgecwug"qh" fkuetkokpcvkqp0Ñ+="Yartzoff v. Thomas.":2;"H04f"3593."3597"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:9+"*ÐKp"wpwuwcn" ektewouvcpegu."hcknwtg"vq"crrn{"hqt"c"rqukvkqp"oc{"pqv"xkvkcvg"c"Vkvng"XKK"cevkqp0Ñ+0" Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"Eqwtv"owuv"fgvgtokpg"yjgvjgt"fkuetkokpcvkqp"ycu"vjg"ecwug"qh"JctvgtÓu" hcknwtg"vq"crrn{"hqt"vjg"Fktgevqt"xcecpe{"kp"42370"Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"4235"Rqnke{"cpf" Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn"uvcvgu<""" Xcecpekgu"hqt"gornq{ogpv"kp"Dqppgt"Eqwpv{"ujcnn"dg"cppqwpegf"d{"vjg" Jwocp"Tguqwteg"Qhhkeg"kp"vjg"hqnnqykpi"ocppgt<" 30" Cp"gockn"vq"cnn"gornq{ggu"hqt"kpvgtpcn"crrnkecvkqpu0" 40" Tgikuvtcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Dqppgt"Eqwpv{"Qhhkeg"qh"vjg"Kfcjq"Fgrctvogpv"qh" Ncdqt" 50" Rquvkpi"qp"vjg"dwnngvkp"dqctf"qwvukfg"vjg"Jwocp"Tguqwtegu"Qhhkeg"cpf" qp"vjg"Dqppgt"Eqwpv{"Ygdukvg0" 60" Qvjgt"ogcpu"fggogf"pgeguuct{"tgictfkpi"hknnkpi"vjg"rqukvkqp0"" " Fmv0"4;/48."cv"350"" Vjg"tgeqtf"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"Octujcnn"pqvkhkgf"vjg"Eqwpv{"qh"jgt"korgpfkpi" tgvktgogpv"ugxgtcn"oqpvju"rtkqt"vq"jgt"fgrctvwtg0"Yjkng"vjg"Eqwpv{"enckou"vq"jcxg" cfxgtvkugf"vjg"qrgp"rqukvkqp."kv"tgockpu"wpengct"yjcv"vjcv"cfxgtvkugogpv"gpvckngf0"Jctvgt" enckou"jg"pgxgt"tgegkxgf"cp"gockn"qt"cp{"qvjgt"hqto"qh"personal"pqvkeg"tgictfkpi"cp" qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp0"Jqygxgt."jg"fqgu"pqv"fkurwvg"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{" cfxgtvkugf"vjg"rqukvkqp."qt"vjcv"jg"ycu"cyctg"qh"OctujcnnÓu"korgpfkpi"tgvktgogpv0"Kp"hcev." Jctvgt"cfokvu"vjcv"jg"tgegkxgf"cp"gockn"htqo"Octujcnn"tgictfkpi"jgt"fgekukqp"vq"tgvktg0""" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"3:" Wnvkocvgn{."vjg"Eqwtv"hkpfu"pq"kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"JctvgtÓu"hcknwtg"vq"crrn{"ycu"ecwugf" d{"fkuetkokpcvkqp0"Jg"ycu"cyctg"qh"OctujcnnÓu"korgpfkpi"tgvktgogpv."cpf"ytqpihwnn{" cuuwogf"Dqd"Jqyctf"yqwnf"tgrnceg"Octujcnn0"Fgurkvg"mpqykpi"vjg"rqukvkqp"yqwnf"dg" xcecvgf."Jctvgt"pgxgt"fkuewuugf"vjg"rquukdknkv{"qh"crrn{kpi"ykvj"Octujcnn."Jqyctf."qt" Jwocp"Tguqwtegu0"JctvgtÓu"ncem"qh"fknkigpeg"crrgctu"vq"dg"vjg"vtwg"ecwug"qh"jku"hcknwtg"vq" crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp."pqv"fkuetkokpcvkqp"d{"vjg"Eqwpv{0"Cu"uwej."Jctvgt"ecppqv"uweeggf" qp"jku"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"encko."dgecwug"jg"hckngfÏfwg"vq"jku"qyp"ncem"qh"fknkigpegÏvq" crrn{"hqt"vjg"rqukvkqp0"" Ceeqtfkpin{."Jctvgt"jcu"pqv"ujqyp"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"rtqhhgtgf"tgcuqpu"hqt" fgoqvkpi"jko"ctg"rtgvgzv"hqt"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp0"Vjgtg"ku"pqvjkpi"vq"uwiiguv"YknuqpÓu" kpxguvkicvkqp"ycu"kortqrgt"qt"kpeqorngvg."cpf"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"cevkqpu"dcugf"wrqp"vjg" kpxguvkicvkqp"ygtg"tgcuqpcdng0"Yjkng"JctvgtÓu"eq/yqtmgtu"eqwnf"jcxg"hcdtkecvgf"vjg" eqornckpvu"cickpuv"jko."vjcv"fqgu"pqv"ogcp"vjg"Eqwpv{"ycu"fkuetkokpcvkpi"cickpuv"Jctvgt" dcugf"qp"jku"cig0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"ycu"tgswktgf"vq"vcmg"vjg"cnngicvkqpu"ugtkqwun{."kpxguvkicvg" vjgo."cpf"vcmg"cevkqp"kh"kv"hqwpf"vjgo"vq"dg"etgfkdng0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"fkf"lwuv"vjcv0"Ownvkrng" gornq{ggu"eqttqdqtcvgf"vjg"cnngicvkqpu."hwtvjgt"uvtgpivjgpkpi"vjgkt"etgfkdknkv{0" Cffkvkqpcnn{."JctvgtÓu"hcknwtg"vq"crrn{"hqt"OctujcnnÓu"rqukvkqp"hqnnqykpi"jgt"cppqwpegf" tgvktgogpv"rtgxgpvu"jko"htqo"uweeggfkpi"qp"jku"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"encko0"Kp"uwo."Jctvgt" jcu"pqv"rtqxkfgf"urgekhke"cpf"uwduvcpvkcn"ektewouvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu" fgekukqp"vq"fgoqvg"jko."cpf"hcknwtg"vq"rtqoqvg"jko"vq"OctujcnnÓu"rqukvkqp"ygtg"ogtg" rtgvgzv"hqt"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp0"Dgecwug"Jctvgt"jcu"hckngf"vq"rtqxg"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"rtqhhgtgf" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"3;" tgcuqpu"hqt"fgoqvkqp"ygtg"rtgvgzvwcn."vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"LwfiogpvÏcu" kv"tgncvgu"vq"JctvgtÓu"CFGC"enckoÏku"ITCPVGF0"" D0"Tgvcnkcvkqp"Enckou" 1. Applicable Law " Jctvgt"pgzv"enckou"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"fgekukqp"vq"vgtokpcvg"jku"gornq{ogpv"ycu"ocfg" kp"tgvcnkcvkqp"hqt"jku"KJTE"eqornckpv0"Jg"dtkpiu"vjku"encko"wpfgt"dqvj"vjg"CFGC"cpf" Vkvng"XKK0"Vq"ocmg"qwv"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ecug"qh"tgvcnkcvkqp"wpfgt"Vkvng"XKK"cpf"vjg"CFGC." Jctvgt"owuv"ujqy"vjcv"*3+"jg"gpicigf"kp"c"rtqvgevgf"cevkxkv{."*4+"jg"uwhhgtgf"cp"cfxgtug" gornq{ogpv"cevkqp."cpf"*5+"vjgtg"ycu"c"ecwucn"nkpm"dgvyggp"jku"cevkxkv{"cpf"vjg" gornq{ogpv"fgekukqp0"O’Day v. McDonnell Douglas Helicopter Co.."9;"H05f"978."985" *;vj"Ekt0"3;;8+"*fkuewuukpi"vjg"uvcpfctf"hqt"cp"CFGC"encko+="Stegall v. Citadel Broad. Co.."572"H05f"3283."3287/88"*;vj"Ekt0"4226+"*fkuewuukpi"vjg"uvcpfctf"hqt"c"Vkvng"XKK" encko+0"Kh"Jctvgt"ecp"ocmg"qwv"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ecug."vjgp"vjg"McDonnell Douglas"dwtfgp" ujkhvkpi"uejgog"crrnkgu0"O’Day."9;"H05f"cv"9850"Vjg"dwtfgp"ujkhvkpi"uejgog."cu"ygnn"cu" JctvgtÓu"cxgpwgu"hqt"ujqykpi"rtgvgzv"kp"c"tgvcnkcvkqp"encko."ctg"pq"fkhhgtgpv"vjcp"cu" fguetkdgf"cdqxg"wpfgt"JctvgtÓu"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"encko0"See Stegall."572"H05f"cv"3288/ 890"" 2. Application Kv"ku"wpfkurwvgf"vjcv"Jctvgt"gpicigf"kp"c"rtqvgevgf"cevkxkv{"*hknkpi"c"ejctig"qh" fkuetkokpcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"KJTE+."cpf"vjcv"jg"uwhhgtgf"cp"cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqp" *vgtokpcvkqp+0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"fkurwvgu"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"ecwucn"nkpm"dgvyggp"JctvgtÓu"KJTE" eqornckpv"cpf"jku"vgtokpcvkqp0"Jctvgt"jcu"pqv"rtqfwegf"cp{"fktgev"gxkfgpeg"vq"ujqy"c" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"42" ecwucn"nkpm"gzkuvu0"Jqygxgt."Ð]e_cwucvkqp"uwhhkekgpv"vq"guvcdnkuj"vjg"vjktf"gngogpv"qh"vjg" rtkoc"hcekg"ecug"oc{"dg"kphgttgf"htqo"ektewouvcpvkcn"gxkfgpeg."uwej"cu"vjg"gornq{gtÓu" mpqyngfig"vjcv"vjg"rnckpvkhh"gpicigf"kp"rtqvgevgf"cevkxkvkgu"cpf"vjg"rtqzkokv{"kp"vkog" dgvyggp"vjg"rtqvgevgf"cevkqp"cpf"vjg"cnngigfn{"tgvcnkcvqt{"gornq{ogpv"fgekukqp0Ñ"Yartzoff v. Thomas.":2;"H04f"3593."3598"*;vj"Ekt0"3;:9+0"" Kp"vjku"ctgc."vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"tglgevgf"Ðcp{"dtkijv/nkpg"twng"cdqwv"vjg"vkokpi"qh" tgvcnkcvkqp0Ñ""Coszalter v. City of Salem."542"H05f";8:.";9:"*4225+0"Kpuvgcf."Ð]y_jgvjgt"cp" cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqp"ku"kpvgpfgf"vq"dg"tgvcnkcvqt{"ku"c"swguvkqp"qh"hcev"vjcv"owuv"dg" fgekfgf"kp"vjg"nkijv"qh"vjg"vkokpi"cpf"vjg"uwttqwpfkpi"ektewouvcpegu0Ñ"Id."Gxgp"cp" Ðgngxgp/oqpvj"icr"kp"vkog"ku"ykvjkp"vjg"tcpig"vjcv"jcu"dggp"hqwpf"vq"uwrrqtv"cp"kphgtgpeg" vjcv"cp"gornq{ogpv"fgekukqp"ycu"tgvcnkcvqt{0Ñ"Id."*swqvkpi"Allen v. Iranon."4:5"H05f" 3292."329:"*;vj"Ekt0"4224++0"" Jgtg."vjg"Eqwpv{"crrgctu"vq"jcxg"dggp"cyctg"qh"JctvgtÓu"KJTE"eqornckpv"cv"vjg" vkog"qh"jku"vgtokpcvkqp0"Cffkvkqpcnn{."yjkng"JctvgtÓu"vgtokpcvkqp"qeewttgf"crrtqzkocvgn{" gngxgpvj"oqpvju"chvgt"jg"hkngf"jku"KJTE"encko."vjg"KJTE"fkf"pqv"kuuwg"kvu"fgekukqp"wpvkn" qpg"oqpvj"chvgt"jku"vgtokpcvkqp0"Vjg"tgeqtf"fqgu"pqv"kpenwfg"engct"gxkfgpeg"qh"cffkvkqpcn" okueqpfwev"d{"Jctvgt"hqnnqykpi"jku"fgoqvkqp."pqt"fkf"vjg"Eqwpv{"kpenwfg"urgekhke" tgcuqpu"hqt"kvu"fgekukqp"qp"JctvgtÓu"pqvkeg"qh"vgtokpcvkqp0"Vjg"pqvkeg"ukorn{"kphqtogf" jko"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"ycu"Ðwpucvkuhkgf"ykvj"]jku_"rgthqtocpeg0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/360" Fgurkvg"vjg"ncem"qh"fktgev"gxkfgpeg."vjg"ektewouvcpegu"uwttqwpfkpi"jku"vgtokpcvkqp" *g0i0"pq"engct"gxkfgpeg"vjcv"Jctvgt"hckngf"vq"rgthqto"jku"lqd"tgurqpukdknkvkgu"qt"cevgf" kpcrrtqrtkcvgn{"chvgt"jku"fgoqvkqp+"eqpukfgtgf"kp"eqplwpevkqp"ykvj"jku"rgpfkpi"KJTE" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"43" encko."etgcvg"c"tgcuqpcdng"kphgtgpeg"qh"ecwucvkqp0"Cu"uwej."vjg"Eqwtv"hkpfu"vjcv"Jctvgt"jcu" guvcdnkujgf"c"rtkoc"hcekg"ecug0" Vjg"dwtfgp"vjgp"ujkhvu"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{"vq"ctvkewncvg"c"ngikvkocvg."pqp/fkuetkokpcvqt{" tgcuqp"hqt"vjg"cfxgtug"gornq{ogpv"cevkqp0"Vjg"Eqwpv{"jcu"hckngf"vq"oggv"vjku"dwtfgp0" Yjkng"kvu"tgcuqpu"hqt"fgoqvkpi"Jctvgt"cpf"rncekpi"jko"qp"rtqdcvkqp"crrgct"ngikvkocvg" cpf"pqp/fkuetkokpcvqt{."vjg"ucog"ecppqv"dg"uckf"hqt"kvu"fgekukqp"vq"vgtokpcvg"JctvgtÓu" gornq{ogpv0"Kp"hcev."vjg"Eqwpv{"jcu"uckf"cnoquv"pqvjkpi"tgictfkpi"kvu"tgcuqpu"hqt" vgtokpcvkpi"Jctvgt0"Yjkng"vjgtg"ku"Ðpq"ngicn"qdnkicvkqp"vq"kphqto"cp"Òcv"yknnÓ"gornq{gg"qh" cp{."qt"cnn"qh."vjg"tgcuqpu"hqt"vgtokpcvkqpÑ"*Mousaw."4238"YN"7968566."cv",9+."vjg" Eqwpv{"jcu"cnuq"hckngf"vq"gzrnckp"kvu"tgcuqpu"hqt"vgtokpcvkpi"Jctvgt"kp"kvu"Oqvkqp"hqt" Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"cpf"cv"qtcn"ctiwogpv03" Vjg"Eqwpv{"ctiwgu"vjcv"kh"kvu"fgekukqp"vq"vgtokpcvg"Jctvgt"ycu"tgvcnkcvqt{."kv"yqwnf" jcxg"vgtokpcvgf"jko"kp"4237Ïkoogfkcvgn{"chvgt"jg"hkngf"jku"KJTE"eqornckpvÏtcvjgt" vjcp"yckvkpi"wpvkn"pgctn{"qpg"{gct"ncvgt0"Vjku"ctiwogpv."jqygxgt."ku"wpeqpxkpekpi0" Ð]U_qog"tgvcnkcvqtu"rtghgt"vq"vcmg"vjgkt"vkog<"Vjg{"oc{"yckv"wpvkn"vjg"xkevko"ku"gurgekcnn{" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 3 "C"enqug"ugctej"qh"vjg"tgeqtf"fqgu"tgxgcn"c"eqornckpv"tgictfkpi"Jctvgt"vjcv"oc{"jcxg"dggp"ugpv" vq"Mnkpigt"fwtkpi"JctvgtÓu"rtqdcvkqpct{"rgtkqf0"Yjkng"vjg"eqornckpv"kvugnh"ku"pqv"fcvgf."kv"crrgctu" vq"jcxg"dggp"hczgf"vq"Mnkpingt"qp"Crtkn"36."4238."gzcevn{"vyq"oqpvju"rtkqt"vq"JctvgtÓu" vgtokpcvkqp0"Fmv0"4;/530"Cffkvkqpcnn{."c"ÐPqvkeg"qh"Xgtdcn"Yctpkpi"htqo"Itgi"Gfyctfu.Ñ" crrctgpvn{"ikxgp"vq"Jctvgt"qp"Crtkn"42."4238."ku"ogpvkqpgf"kp"JctvgtÓu"Tgswguv"hqt"Cfokuukqp" %580"Fmv0"6;/3."cv"70"Jqygxgt."vjg"pqvkeg"kvugnh"fqgu"pqv"crrgct"vq"dg"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0"Yjkng"vjg" Eqwpv{"eqwnf"jcxg"rgtjcru"gncdqtcvgf"qp"vjgug"kpekfgpvu"vq"ctvkewncvg"c"ngikvkocvg."pqp/ fkuetkokpcvqt{"tgcuqp"hqt"vgtokpcvkpi"Jctvgt"fwtkpi"jku"rtqdcvkqpct{"rgtkqf."vjg"Eqwpv{"pgxgt" ogpvkqpgf"vjgug"fqewogpvu"kp"kvu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv."qt"cv"qtcn"ctiwogpv0"Kpuvgcf." vjg"Eqwtv"ku"nghv"ykvjqwv"cp{"kpfkecvkqp"cu"vq"vjg"ngikvkoce{"qh"vjg"Crtkn"36."4238"eqornckpv." yjgvjgt"vjg"Eqwpv{"kpxguvkicvgf"vjg"eqornckpv."qt"jqy"ugtkqwu"JctvgtÓu"cnngigf"okueqpfwev"ycu0" Vjg"Eqwtv"ecppqv"gxgp"dg"uwtg"yjgp"vjg"eqornckpv"ycu"cevwcnn{"ytkvvgp0"Ykvjqwv"oqtg."ogtgn{" kpenwfkpi"vjg"eqornckpv"kp"vjg"tgeqtf"ku"pqv"gpqwij"vq"ucvkuh{"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"dwtfgp"jgtg0"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"44" xwnpgtcdng"qt"wpvkn"cp"gurgekcnn{"jwtvhwn"cevkqp"dgeqogu"rquukdng0"Qt"vjg{"oc{"yckv"wpvkn" vjg{"vjkpm"vjg"ncrug"qh"vkog"fkuiwkugu"vjgkt"vtwg"oqvkxcvkqp0"]Vjg"Eqwtv_"ujqwnf"dg" rctvkewnctn{"ugpukvkxg"vq"vjku"ncuv"rqkpv0Ñ"Coszlater."542"H05f."cv";9:0"" Dgecwug"vjg"Eqwpv{"jcu"pqv"ctvkewncvgf"c"ngikvkocvg."pqp/fkuetkokpcvqt{"tgcuqp"hqt" JctvgtÓu"vgtokpcvkqp."c"igpwkpg"kuuwg"hqt"vtkcn"gzkuvu."cpf"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt" Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"tgvcnkcvkqp"enckou"ku"FGPKGF0"" " E0"Uvcvg"Ncy"Dtgcej"qh"Eqpvtcev"Enckou" JctvgtÓu"Cogpfgf"Eqornckpv"uvcvgu."Ð]Jctvgt_"jcf"c"xcnkf"gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev" ykvj"Fghgpfcpv"Dqppgt"Eqwpv{"rtqxkfkpi"0"0"0"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"qpn{"dg"vgtokpcvgf"hqt"Òiqqf" ecwug0ÓÑ"Fmv0"7."cv"340"Jqygxgt."kv"ku"wpengct"yjgvjgt"Jctvgt"cevwcnn{"ukipgf"cp"kpkvkcn" gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev."cu"pq"qtkikpcn"eqpvtcev"ku"kp"vjg"tgeqtf0"JctvgtÓu"Cogpfgf" Eqornckpv"fqgu"uvcvg"vjcv"ÐDqppgt"Eqwpv{Óu"rgtuqppgn"twngu."rqnkekgu"cpf"rtqegfwtgu" eqpuvkvwvg"cp"gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev"wpfgt"Kfcjq"ncy"cpf."cevgf"cu"c"eqpvtcev"dgvyggp" Rnckpvkhh"cpf"Fghgpfcpv0Ñ"Fmv0"7."cv"60"Rtguwocdn{."vjku"ku"vjg"cnngigf"eqpvtcev"cv"kuuwg" jgtg0"JctvgtÓu"Cogpfgf"Eqornckpv"hwtvjgt"enckou"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"dtgcejgf"vjku"eqpvtcev." cu"ygnn"cu"kornkgf"eqxgpcpvu"qh"iqqf"hckvj"cpf"hckt"fgcnkpi."d{"vgtokpcvkpi"jko"ykvjqwv" iqqf"ecwug."cpf"ykvjqwv"c"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi0"" Jqygxgt."yjkng"JctvgtÓu"Ogoqtcpfwo"kp"Qrrqukvkqp"vq"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv" kpenwfgu"c"jgcfkpi"vjcv"uvcvgu"ÐJctvgtÓu"Eqpvtcev"Enckou"0"0"0"Ujqwnf"Pqv"Dg"FkuokuugfÑ" *Fmv0"69."cv"37+."jg"fkf"pqv"kpenwfg"cp{"ctiwogpv"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjgug"enckou"kp"jku" qrrqukvkqp"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qt"cv"qtcn"ctiwogpv0"Kpuvgcf." " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"45" Jctvgt"uggou"vq"jcxg"eqphncvgf"jku"eqpvtcev"enckou"ykvj"jku"fwg"rtqeguu"enckou"*fkuewuugf" dgnqy+."cpf"cu"c"tguwnv."hckngf"vq"cfftguu"jku"eqpvtcev"enckou0"" Ceeqtfkpin{."Jctvgt"jcu"cdcpfqpgf"jku"eqpvtcev"enckou0"See Shakur v. Schriro."736" H05f":9:.":;4"*;vj"Ekt0"422;+"*gzrnckpkpi"Ðc"rnckpvkhh"0"0"0"cdcpfqpgf"0"0"0"enckou"d{"pqv" tckukpi"vjgo"kp"qrrqukvkqp"vq"]vjg"fghgpfcpvÓu_"oqvkqp"hqt"uwooct{"lwfiogpvÑ+"*swqvkpi" Jenkins v. Cty. of Riverside."5;:"H05f"32;5."32;7"p06"*;vj"Ekt0"4227++="Knowles v. Hawai’i Pac. Univ.."Ekx0"Pq0"382289:CEMMUE."423:"YN"5592742."cv",9"*F0"Jcy0"Lwn{" 32."423:+"*ÐD{"hcknkpi"vq"ocmg"cp{"ctiwogpv"tgictfkpi"vjg"encko."Rnckpvkhh"jcu" cdcpfqpgf"kv0Ñ+0"Yjkng"Jctvgt"cv"ngcuv"ogpvkqpgf"jku"eqpvtcev"enckou"kp"jku"tgurqpug"vq"vjg" Eqwpv{Óu"oqvkqp."ogtgn{"ogpvkqpkpi"cp"kuuwg"ku"kpuwhhkekgpv0"Cf. Leer v. Murphy.":66" H04f"84:."856"*;vj"Ekt0"3;::+"*ÐKuuwgu"tckugf"kp"c"dtkgh"yjkej"ctg"pqv"uwrrqtvgf"d{" ctiwogpv"ctg"fggogf"cdcpfqpgf0Ñ+0"Cu"uwej."vjgtg"ku"pq"igpwkpg"kuuwg"hqt"vtkcn."cpf"vjg" Eqwtv"ITCPVU"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"eqpvtcev" enckou0"" Gxgp"kh"vjg"Eqwtv"ygtg"vq"cuuwog."arguendo."vjcv"Jctvgt"fkf"pqv"cdcpfqp"jku" eqpvtcev"enckou."uwooct{"lwfiogpv"yqwnf"uvknn"dg"rtqrgt"dgecwug"vjgug"enckou"crrgct"vq" dg"dcugf"qp"c"eqpvtcev"vjcv"fkf"pqv"gzkuv0"Jctvgt"uvcvgu"vjcv"vjg"ÐEqwpv{Óu"rgtuqppgn"twngu." rqnkekgu"cpf"rtqegfwtgu"eqpuvkvwvg"cp"gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev"wpfgt"Kfcjq"ncy0Ñ"Fmv0"7."cv"60" Vjg"Eqwtv"fkucitggu0"Vjg"Kfcjq"Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"jcu"gzrnckpgf<" Yjgvjgt" cp" gornq{gg" ocpwcn" eqpuvkvwvgu" cp" gngogpv" qh" cp" gornq{ogpv" eqpvtcev" ku" igpgtcnn{" c" swguvkqp" qh" hcev" wpnguu" vjg" ]ocpwcn_" urgekhkecnn{" pgicvgu"cp{"kpvgpvkqp"qp"vjg"rctv"qh"vjg"gornq{gt"vq"jcxg"kv"dgeqog"c"rctv"qh" vjg"gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev0"Vjwu"0"0"0"vjku"Eqwtv"owuv"gzcokpg"vjg"]Rqnke{"cpf" Rtqegfwtg" Ocpwcn_" vqigvjgt" ykvj" cp{" ytkvvgp" cpf"qtcn" uvcvgogpvu" ocfg" vq" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"46" ]vjg" gornq{gg_" vq" fgvgtokpg" hktuv." yjgvjgt" vjg{" urgekhkecnn{" pgicvg" cp{" kpvgpvkqp"qh"eqpvtcev"hqtocvkqp0"Kh"pqv."vjku"Eqwtv"owuv"vjgp"fgvgtokpg"kh"vjgtg" ku" c" swguvkqp" qh" hcev" cu" vq" yjgvjgt" vjg" rctvkgu" kpvgpfgf" vjg" ]Rqnke{" cpf" Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn_"vq"gzrtguu"c"vgto"qh"vjg"gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev0"" " Nix v. Elmore County."568"R05f"3267."3274"*Kfcjq"4237+"*kpvgtpcn"rwpevwcvkqp"cpf" ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0"" Jgtg."vjg"Eqwtv"pggf"pqv"tgcej"vjg"ugeqpf"rctv"qh"vjku"kpswkt{."dgecwug"vjg" Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn"engctn{"pgicvgu"cp{"kpvgpvkqp"vjcv"kv"dgeqog"rctv" qh."qt"ugtxg"cu."cp"gornq{ogpv"eqpvtcev0"Urgekhkecnn{."vjg"4235"ocpwcn"uvcvgu<" VJKU"RGTUQPPGN"RQNKE["KU"PQV"C"EQPVTCEV0"PQ"EQPVTCEV" QH" GORNQ[OGPV" YKVJ" DQPPGT" EQWPV[" YKNN" DG" XCNKF" WPNGUU" KV" KU" GZRTGUUN[" CRRTQXGF" D[" VJG" DQCTF" QH" EQWPV[" EQOOKUUKQPGTU" CPF" WPNGUU" KV" KU" UKIPGF" D[" CPF" EQPVCKPU"VJG"PCOG"QH"VJG"URGEKHKE"GORNQ[GG"YJQ"YQWNF" DG" DGPGHKVGF1QDNKICVGF" D[" VJG" EQPVTCEV0" PQVYKVJUVCPFKPI" CP[VJKPI" UCKF" D[" C" UWRGTXKUQT." FGRCTVOGPV" JGCF" CPF1QT" GNGEVGF" QHHKEKCN." PQ" EQPVTCEV"QH"EQPVKPWGF"GORNQ[OGPV"UJCNN"DG"KORNKGF0"0" 0" 0" VJG" RQNKEKGU" CPF" DGPGHKVU" QWVNKPGF" KP" VJKU" RQNKE[" OCPWCN" CTG" UWDLGEV" VQ" EJCPIG" CV" CP[" VKOG." YKVJQWV" RTKQT"PQVKEG0" " Fmv0"4;/48."cv"4"*gorjcuku"kp"qtkikpcn+0"" " " Jctvgt"ukipgf"cp"cempqyngfigogpv"hqto"qp"Hgdtwct{"3;."4235."kpfkecvkpi" vjcv"jg"tgegkxgf"vjg"4235"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn."cpf"vjcv"jg"wpfgtuvqqf"kv" ycu"Ðpqv"c"eqpvtcev"cpf"ecppqv"etgcvg"c"eqpvtcev0Ñ"Fmv0"4;/490"Jctvgt"ukipgf"c" ukoknct"cempqyngfigogpv"qp"Oc{";."3;;:."yjkej"uvcvgf"vjcv"vjg"3;;:"Rqnke{"cpf" Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn"ycu"pqv"c"eqpvtcev"qh"gornq{ogpv0""Cu"uwej."JctvgtÓu"eqpvtcev" enckou"crrgct"vq"dg"dcugf"qp"c"eqpvtcev"vjcv."kp"hcev."fkf"pqv"gzkuv0"Ceeqtfkpin{." " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"47" gxgp"kh"Jctvgt"jcf"pqv"yckxgf"vjgug"enckou."uwooct{"lwfiogpv"yqwnf"uvknn"dg" rtqrgt0"" F0"Fwg"Rtqeguu"Enckou" Ncuvn{."Jctvgt"cnngigu"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"fgpkgf"jko"rtqegfwtcn"fwg"rtqeguu"kp" xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg"Hkhvj"cpf"Hqwtvggpvj"Cogpfogpvu"yjgp"kv"fgoqvgf"jko"kp"4237."cpf" cickp"yjgp"kv"vgtokpcvgf"jko"kp"42380"Jg"dtkpiu"vjgug"enckou"wpfgt"64"W0U0E0"¸3;:50"Cu" cp"kpkvkcn"ocvvgt."Ð]v_jcv"vjg"Hkhvj"Cogpfogpv"crrnkgu"qpn{"vq"vjg"cevu"qh"vjg"hgfgtcn" iqxgtpogpv"ku"ugvvngf"dg{qpf"fqwdv0Ñ"Johnston v. Earle."467"H04f"9;5."9;8"p07"*;vj"Ekt0" 3;79+0"Cu"uwej."qpn{"vjg"Hqwtvggpvj"Cogpfogpv"crrnkgu"vq"JctvgtÓu"fwg"rtqeguu"enckou." dgecwug"vjg"Eqwpv{"ku"c"rqnkvkecn"uwdfkxkukqp"qh"vjg"Uvcvg"qh"Kfcjq0"See Dusenbery v. United States."756"W0U0"383."389"*4224+"*ÐVjg"Fwg"Rtqeguu"Encwug"qh"vjg"Hkhvj" Cogpfogpv"rtqjkdkvu"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu."cu"vjg"Fwg"Rtqeguu"Encwug"qh"vjg"Hqwtvggpvj" Cogpfogpv"rtqjkdkvu"vjg"Uvcvgu."htqo"fgrtkxkpi"cp{"rgtuqp"qh"rtqrgtv{"ykvjqwv"fwg" rtqeguu"qh"ncy0Ñ+0"" 1. The 2015 Demotion Vjg"Eqwpv{"hktuv"ctiwgu"vjcv."dgecwug"Jctvgt"ejcnngpigu"jku"4237"fgoqvkqp"cu"c" rtqfwev"qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp."vjg"CFGC"rtgenwfgu"jku"¸"3;:5"cevkqp0"Kv"ku"vtwg."cu"pqvgf" cdqxg."vjcv"vjg"Ðeqortgjgpukxg"tgogfkcn"uejgog"qh"vjg"CFGC"fgoqpuvtcvgu"vjcv" Eqpitguu"kpvgpfgf"vjg"CFGC"vq"ugtxg"cu"vjg"gzenwukxg"ogcpu"hqt"rwtuwkpi"enckou"qh"cig" fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"gornq{ogpv0Ñ"Ahlmeyer."777"H05f"cv"327:0"Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"Pkpvj" Ektewkv"jcu"hqwpf"vjcv"vjg"CFGC"Ðujqwnf"dg"tgcf"cu"rtgenwfkpi"¸"3;:5"cevkqpu"kp"vjg"ctgc" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"48" qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"gornq{ogpv0"0"0"0"gxgp"vjqug"enckou"ykvj"vjgkt"uqwteg"kp"vjg" Eqpuvkvwvkqp0Ñ"Id."cv"3282/830"" Fgurkvg"vjg"dtqcf"ncpiwcig"qh Ahlmeyer."vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"tgcfkpi"qh"vjg"fgekukqp"ku" qxgtdtqcf0""Kp"c"uwdugswgpv"fgekukqp."vjg"Pkpvj"Ektewkv"rtqxkfgf"c"pcttqygt"xkgy"cpf" gzrnckpgf"vjcv"Ahlmeyer"Ðjgnf"vjcv"vjg"CFGC"rtgenwfgu"¸"3;:5"uwkvu"vq"tgogf{"gswcn" rtqvgevkqp"xkqncvkqpu"dcugf"qp"cig0Ñ"Stilwell v. City of Williams.":53"H05f"3456."3473/74" *;vj"Ekt0"4238+"Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgp"tglgevgf"cp"ctiwogpv"vjcv"vjg"CFGC"rtgenwfgu"Hktuv" Cogpfogpv"tgvcnkcvkqp"enckou"cpf"tgocpfgf"vjg"ecug"uq"vjg"nqygt"eqwtv"eqwnf"jgct"vjqug" enckou0"Id."" Jgtg."nkmg"kp"Stilwell."Jctvgt"ku"pqv"dtkpikpi"cp"gswcn"rtqvgevkqp"encko"wpfgt"¸" 3;:50"Jg"ukorn{"enckou"vjcv"jg"ycu"gpvkvngf"vq"fwg"rtqeguu"rtkqt"vq"jku"fgoqvkqp."yjkej" vjg"Eqwpv{"tghwugf"vq"rtqxkfg0"Yjgp"eqpukfgtgf"kp"vjku"nkijv."kv"ku"gxkfgpv"vjcv"JctvgtÓu" fwg"rtqeguu"encko"jcu"pqvjkpi"vq"fq"ykvj"jku"cig."cpf"vjgtghqtg."vjg"CFGC"fqgu"pqv" rtgenwfg"jko"htqo"dtkpikpi"kv"wpfgt"¸"3;:50"" Pgzv."vjg"Eqwpv{"ctiwgu"vjcv."gxgp"kh"vjg"CFGC"fqgu"pqv"rtgenwfg"JctvgtÓu" fgoqvkqp/tgncvgf"fwg"rtqeguu"encko."kv"uvknn"hcknu"dgecwug"Jctvgt"ycu"pqv"gpvkvngf"vq"c" jgctkpi"hqnnqykpi"jku"fgoqvkqp0"Vjg"Eqwtv"citggu0"" C"¸"3;:5"encko"dcugf"wrqp"rtqegfwtcn"fwg"rtqeguu"eqpvckpu"vjtgg"gngogpvu<"*3+"c" nkdgtv{"qt"rtqrgtv{"kpvgtguv"rtqvgevgf"d{"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Eqpuvkvwvkqp="*4+"c"fgrtkxcvkqp" qh"vjcv"kpvgtguv"d{"vjg"iqxgtpogpv="cpf"*5+"c"fgpkcn"qh"cfgswcvg"rtqegfwtcn"rtqvgevkqpu0" See Portman v. County of Santa Clara.";;7"H04f":;:.";26"*;vj"Ekt0"3;;5+0"ÐYjkng"uvcvg" ncy"guvcdnkujgu"vjg"rctcogvgtu"qh"cp"kpfkxkfwcnÓu"uwduvcpvkxg"kpvgtguv."hgfgtcn"ncy"ku"yjcv" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"49" fgvgtokpgu"kh"vjcv"kpvgtguv"ku"c"rtqvgevgf"rtqrgtv{"tkijv0Ñ"Hollist v. Madison Cty.."Pq0" 6<35ÎexÎ2235;ÎDNY."4236"YN"72:;;63."cv",6"*F0"Kfcjq"Qev0";."4236+"*ekvkpi"Lawson v. Umatilla Cty.."35;"H05f"8;2."8;4"*;vj"Ekt03;;:++0"ÐWpfgt"vjg"hgfgtcn"eqpuvkvwvkqp."cv/ yknn"gornq{ggu"rquuguu"pq"rtqvgevgf"rtqrgtv{"tkijvu"cpf"vjgtghqtg"ctg"pqv"gpvkvngf"vq"fwg" rtqeguu"dghqtg"dgkpi"vgtokpcvgf0Ñ"Lawson."35;"H05f"cv"8;3/;40"" ÐGornq{ogpv"kp"Kfcjq"ku"rtguwogf"vq"dg"cv/yknn"wpnguu"vjg"gornq{gg"ku"jktgf" rwtuwcpv"vq"c"eqpvtcev"vjcv"uvcvgu"c"hkzgf"vgto"qt"nkokvu"vjg"tgcuqpu"hqt"fkuejctig0Ñ"Nix." 568"R05f."cv"3274"*kpvgtpcn"ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0"Kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"uwej"nkokvcvkqpu."Ðgkvjgt" rctv{"oc{"vgtokpcvg"]vjg"gornq{ogpv"tgncvkqpujkr_"cv"cp{"vkog"qt"hqt"cp{"tgcuqp"ykvjqwv" kpewttkpi"nkcdknkv{0Ñ"Id."*kpvgtpcn"ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0"Rtguwocdn{."khÏcdugpv"cp"citggogpv" vq"vjg"eqpvtct{Ïcp"gornq{gt"ecp"vgtokpcvg"cp"gornq{gg"hqt"cp{"tgcuqp."cp"gornq{gt"ecp" cnuq"fgoqvg"cp"gornq{gg"hqt"cp{"tgcuqp0"" Jgtg."vjg"Eqwpv{"eqpegfgu"vjcv"kv"gpvgtgf"kpvq"cp"citggogpv"ykvj"Jctvgt"vjcv" nkokvgf"kvu"tkijv"vq"vgtokpcvg"jku"gornq{ogpv0"Ugevkqp"72203"qh"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf" Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn"uvcvgu."Ð]g_zegrv"cu"qvjgtykug"rtqxkfgf"kp"vjku"rqnke{."tgiwnct" gornq{ggu"qh"Dqppgt"Eqwpv{"yknn"pqv"dg"uwurgpfgf"ykvjqwv"rc{."fgoqvgf"with an accompanying change in pay."qt"fkuejctigf"htqo"vjgkt"rqukvkqpu"hqt"fkuekrnkpct{"rwtrqugu" gzegrv"hqt"ecwug"tgncvgf"vq"rgthqtocpeg"qh"vjgkt"lqd"fwvkgu"qt"qvjgt"xkqncvkqpu"qh"vjku" rqnke{0Ñ"*gorjcuku"cffgf+0"Yjkng"vjku"rqnke{"nkokvu"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"cdknkv{"vq"fgoqvg"Jctvgt" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"4:" with"cp"ceeqorcp{kpi"ejcpig"kp"rc{."kv"fqgu"pqv"nkokv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"cdknkv{"vq"fgoqvg" Jctvgt"without"cp"ceeqorcp{kpi"ejcpig"kp"rc{04"" Cfokvvgfn{."vjku"fkuewuukqp"oc{"uggo"vq"eqphnkev"ykvj"vjg"EqwtvÓu"cdqxg"hkpfkpi" vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn"fkf"pqv"eqpuvkvwvg"cp"gornq{ogpv" eqpvtcev"ykvj"Jctvgt0"Kpfggf."qpg"okijv"dg"nghv"vq"yqpfgt"jqy"c"ocpwcn"vjcv"fqgu"pqv" eqpuvkvwvg"c"eqpvtcev"ecp"ukownvcpgqwun{"nkokv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"cdknkv{"vq"vgtokpcvg"qt"fgoqvg" cp"gornq{gg0"Vjg"Kfcjq"Uwrtgog"EqwtvÓu"fgekukqp"kp"Bollinger v. Fall River Rural Elec. Co-op., Inc.."494"R05f"3485."348;"*Kfcjq"4234+."rtqxkfgu"enctkv{0"Vjgtg."vjg"Kfcjq" Uwrtgog"Eqwtv"gzrnckpgf<" Kp"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"cp"gzrtguu"eqpvtcev."c"nkokvcvkqp"vq"vjg"cv/yknn"gornq{ogpv" rtguworvkqp" oc{" dg" kornkgf" yjgtg" vjg" ektewouvcpegu" uwttqwpfkpi" vjg" gornq{ogpv"tgncvkqpujkr"eqwnf"ecwug"c"tgcuqpcdng"rgtuqp"vq"eqpenwfg"vjcv" vjg"rctvkgu"kpvgpfgf"c"nkokvcvkqp"qp"fkuejctig0"Uvcvgogpvu"ocfg"cpf"rqnkekgu" rtqownicvgf" d{" vjg" gornq{gt." yjgvjgt" kp" cp" gornq{ogpv" ocpwcn" qt" qvjgtykug."oc{"ikxg"tkug"vq"uwej"cp"kornkgf/kp/hcev"citggogpv0" Kf0"cv"348;"*kpvgtpcn"ekvcvkqpu"qokvvgf+0"" Vjcv"ku"engctn{"vjg"ecug"jgtg0"Yjkng"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn"ku" pqv"c"eqpvtcev."kvu"rtqxkukqpu"*kp"rnceg"cv"vjg"vkog"Jctvgt"ycu"fgoqvgf+"yqwnf"ecwug"c" tgcuqpcdng"rgtuqp"vq"eqpenwfg"vjcv"vjg"rctvkgu"kpvgpfgf"vq"nkokv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"rqygt"vq" fkuejctig"cp"gornq{gg."cu"ygnn"cu"kvu"rqygt"vq"fgoqvg"cp"gornq{gg"with cp" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 4 "Kp"jku"tgurqpug"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv."Jctvgt"ctiwgu"vjcv"jku"rc{"ycu." kp"hcev."tgfwegf"cu"c"tguwnv"qh"vjg"fgoqvkqp."dgecwug"jku"qrrqtvwpkvkgu"vq"yqtm"qxgtvkog" fkokpkujgf0"Jqygxgt."uwej"cp"ctiwogpv"ku"engctn{"kpeqpukuvgpv"ykvj"JctvgtÓu"rtgxkqwu" uvcvgogpvu."kp"yjkej"jg"gzrnckpgf"vjcv"jku"qrrqtvwpkvkgu"hqt"qxgtvkog"ygtg"Ðewv"vq"|gtqÑ" uqogvkog"ctqwpf"4234Ï{gctu"dghqtg"vjg"Eqwpv{"fgoqvgf"jko0"See"Fmv0"4;/39."cv"4="Fmv0"4;/3:." cv"9/:."49/4:0" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"4;" ceeqorcp{kpi"ejcpig"kp"rc{0"Vjg"OcpwcnÓu"ncpiwcig"fqgu"pqv."jqygxgt."kpenwfg"cp{" kpfkecvkqp"vjcv"vjcv"vjg"rctvkgu"kpvgpfgf"vq"nkokv"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"rqygt"vq"fgoqvg"cp" gornq{gg"without"cp"ceeqorcp{kpi"ejcpig"kp"rc{0"Cu"uwej."vjg"kornkgf/kp/hcev" citggogpv"gzvgpfgf"pq"rtqvgevkqp"vq"fgoqvkqpu"ykvjqwv"cp"ceeqorcp{kpi"ejcpig"kp"rc{0"" Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"fgekukqp"vq"fgoqvg"Jctvgt"ykvjqwv"cp"ceeqorcp{kpi" ejcpig"kp"rc{"fkf"pqv"kphtkpig"wrqp"c"rtqvgevgf"rtqrgtv{"kpvgtguv."cpf"Jctvgt"ycu"pqv" gpvkvngf"vq"fwg"rtqeguu"hqnnqykpi"uwej"c"fgoqvkqp0"Vjg"Eqwtv"vjgtghqtg"ITCPVU"vjg" Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"vjku"encko0"" 2. The 2016 Termination Vjcv"ngcxgu"qpn{"JctvgtÓu"fwg"rtqeguu"encko"cu"kv"tgncvgu"vq"jku"vgtokpcvkqp0" Rwtuwcpv"vq"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn."gornq{ggu"vgtokpcvgf"fwtkpi" vjgkt"rtqdcvkqpct{"rgtkqf"ctg"gpvkvngf"vq"cp"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"dg"jgctf"wpfgt"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu" Wpncyhwn"Fkuetkokpcvkqp"cpf"Pcog/Engctkpi"Rqnke{05"" Vjg"Eqwpv{"ctiwgu"vjcv."dgecwug"Jctvgt"gngevgf"vq"hqtgiq"vjg"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp" jgctkpi"kv"qhhgtgf."jg"ecppqv"pqy"encko"vjcv"vjg"Eqwpv{"fgrtkxgf"jko"qh"fwg"rtqeguu0"Vjg" Pkpvj"Ektewkv"jcu"jgnf"vjcv"Ðyjgtg"cfgswcvg"cfokpkuvtcvkxg"rtqegfwtgu"gzkuv."c"rgtuqp" ecppqv"uvcvg"c"encko"hqt"fgpkcn"qh"rtqegfwtcn"tkijvu"yjgp"jg"jcu"gngevgf"vq"hqtgiq"c" eqorngvg"jgctkpi0Ñ"Correa v. Nampa School Dist. No. 131."867"H04f":36.":39"*3;:3+0" Cpqvjgt"ecug"ctkukpi"qwv"qh"vjku"Fkuvtkev"tgegpvn{"tgcejgf"vjg"ucog"eqpenwukqp0"See Miller." """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 5 "Cnvjqwij"vjg"rctvkgu"fkucitgg"qxgt"yjgvjgt"Jctvgt"ycu"c"hqt/ecwug"qt"cv/yknn"gornq{gg"fwtkpi" jku"rtqdcvkqp."vjku"kuuwg"ku"qh"nkvvng"eqpugswgpeg"jgtg"dgecwug"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg" Ocpwcn"qhhgtgf"Jctvgt"c"jgctkpi"hqnnqykpi"jku"vgtokpcvkqp"tgictfnguu0"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"52" 4239"YN"47;255:."cv",36"*Ð]V_jg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"eqpfwev"c"rquv"vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi" fqgu"pqv"eqpuvkvwvg"c"hcknwtg"qh"fwg"rtqeguu"dgecwug"Rnckpvkhh"fkf"pqv"tgswguv"qpg0Ñ+"Jgtg." vjg"Eqwpv{"pqv"qpn{"kphqtogf"Jctvgt"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"tgswguv"c"jgctkpi."dwv"cnuq"cfxkugf"jko" vjcv"hcknwtg"vq"fq"uq"yqwnf"eqpuvkvwvg"c"hcknwtg"vq"gzjcwuv"jku"tgogfkgu"wpfgt"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu" Rqnke{"cpf"Rtqegfwtg"Ocpwcn0""" Jqygxgt."gxgp"vjqwij"rtqegfwtcn"fwg"rtqeguu"tkijvu"oc{"dg"yckxgf."ÐÒ]e_qwtvu" kpfwnig"gxgt{"rtguworvkqp"cickpuv"vjg"yckxgt"qh"hwpfcogpvcn"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"tkijvu0ÓÑ" Byers v. New Plymouth School Dist. No. 372."Pq0"3<34ÎEXÎ22452ÎGLN."4235"YN" 7;65;5:."cv",32"*F0"Kfcjq"Pqx0"7."4235+"*swqvkpi"Pitts v. Board of Education of School Dist. 205.":8;"H04f"777."779"*32vj"Ekt0"3;:;+"*ekvcvkqp"qokvvgf+0"Yjgvjgt"fwg"rtqeguu" tkijvu"jcxg"dggp"yckxgf"Ðfgrgpfu"wrqp"vjg"hcevu"qh"c"rctvkewnct"ecug.Ñ"cpf"yckxgt"ku"xcnkf" qpn{"Ðkh"kv"ku"fqpg"kp"cp"kphqtogf"ocppgt0Ñ"Pitts.":8;"H04f"cv"779"*ekvkpi"Johnson v. U.S. Dep’t of Agriculture."956"H04f"996."9:6"*33vj"Ekt0"3;:6++0"Cffkvkqpcnn{."c"rnckpvkhh"oc{" yckxg"fwg"rtqeguu"tkijvu"d{"gngevkpi"vq"hqtgiq"c"jgctkpi"qpn{"kh"vjg"uwiiguvgf"jgctkpi" yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"cfgswcvg0"See Bignall v. North Idaho College."75:"H04f"465."469"*;vj" Ekt0"3;98+0"Jctvgt"jcu"enckogf"vjcv"jg"gngevgf"vq"hqtgiq"vjg"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi" dgecwug"kv"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"hwvkng0"Jg"gzrnckpgf<" Wnvkocvgn{" chvgt" fkuewuukqp" ykvj" eqwpugn" K" fgekfgf" vjcv" rwtuwkv" qh" c" rquv" vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"ycu"hwvkng0"K"dcugf"vjku"qp"ektewouvcpegu"uwttqwpfkpi"vjg" rtkqt"kp"vkog"rtg/fgoqvkqp"kpxguvkicvkqp"jgctkpi"yjkej"ycupÓv"hckt"cu"uq"hgy" ]Uqnkf" Ycuvg" Fgrctvogpv_" gornq{ggu" ygtg" kpvgtxkgygf0" Vjku" ngf" og" vq" dgnkgxg"vjcv"fwg"vq"rtglwfiogpv"c"rquv"vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"yqwnf"jcxg"vjg" ucog"tguwnv0"K"fkfpÓv"ycpv"cp{"oqtg"pgicvkxg"pqvgu"vq"iq"kp"vq"o{"gornq{ogpv" hkng0" " Fmv0"59/3."cv"80"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"53" Vjg"Eqwtv"uvtwiingu"vq"wpfgtuvcpf"yj{"YknuqpÓu"kpxguvkicvkqp"yqwnf"chhgev" JctvgtÓu"rgtegrvkqp"qh"vjg"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"cxckncdng"vq"jko0"Cu"fkuewuugf"cdqxg." vjg"Eqwtv"fqgu"pqv"eqpukfgt"YknuqpÓu"kpxguvkicvkqp"kortqrgt"qt"ewtuqt{."cpf"vjcv" kpxguvkicvkqp"rtqxkfgf"Jctvgt"ykvj"cp"gzvgpfgf"qrrqtvwpkv{"vq"tgurqpf"vq"vjg"urgekhke" cnngicvkqpu"ngxgngf"cickpuv"jko0"" Vjcv"uckf."vjg"Eqwtv"owuv"kpfwnig"gxgt{"rtguworvkqp"cickpuv"vjg"yckxgt"qh" eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"tkijvu0"Jgtg."gxgp"vjqwij"Jctvgt"jcu"pqv"rtqxkfgf"vjg"Eqwtv"ykvj"urgekhke" hcevu"vq"uwrrqtv"cp"ctiwogpv"vjcv"c"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"kpcfgswcvg." egtvckp"ektewouvcpegu"kp"vjku"ecug"ikxg"tkug"vq"rtguworvkqpu"vjcv"uwrrqtv"uwej"c"rqukvkqp0" Hqtgoquv"coqpi"vjgug"ku"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"hcknwtg"vq"urgekh{"yj{"kv"ejqug"vq"wnvkocvgn{" vgtokpcvg"Jctvgt0"Kh."cu"Jctvgt"enckou."vjg"Eqwpv{"ocfg"vjcv"fgekukqp"kp"tgvcnkcvkqp"hqt" JctvgtÓu"KJTE"eqornckpv."vjgp"JctvgtÓu"dgnkgh"vjcv"c"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"yqwnf"jcxg" dggp"hwvkng"fwg"vq"ÐrtglwfiogpvÑ"ku"tgcuqpcdng0"Dgecwug"c"igpwkpg"kuuwg"hqt"vtkcn"gzkuvu" tgictfkpi"yjgvjgt"vjg"Eqwpv{"jcf"c"ngikvkocvg."pqp/fkuetkokpcvqt{"tgcuqp"hqt"JctvgtÓu" vgtokpcvkqp."kv"hqnnqyu."vjgp."vjcv"c"igpwkpg"kuuwg"hqt"vtkcn"gzkuvu"cu"vq"yjgvjgt"vjg" Eqwpv{Óu"rquv/vgtokpcvkqp"jgctkpi"yqwnf"jcxg"dggp"cfgswcvg0"Ceeqtfkpin{."vjg"Eqwtv" FGPKGU"vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"cu"kv"tgncvgu"vq"vjku"encko0"" X0"QTFGT" VJG"EQWTV"JGTGD["QTFGTU<" 30" Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"*Fmv0"49+"ku"ITCPVGF"KP"RCTV" cpf"FGPKGF"KP"RCTV"eqpukuvgpv"ykvj"vjg"cdqxg"cpcn{uku."cpf"cu"ugv"hqtvj"dgnqy<" c+" JctvgtÓu"encko"qh"cig"fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"xkqncvkqp"qh"Vkvng"XKK"ku"FKUOKUUGF0"" " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"54" d+" Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"encko"qh"cig" fkuetkokpcvkqp"kp"xkqncvkqp"qh"vjg"CFGC"ku"ITCPVGF0" e+" Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"encko"qh"tgvcnkcvqt{" fkuejctig"kp"xkqncvkqp"qh"Vkvng"XKK"cpf"vjg"CFGC"ku"FGPKGF0" f+" Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"uvcvg"ncy"dtgcej"qh" eqpvtcev"cpf"eqxgpcpv"qh"iqqf"hckvj"cpf"hckt"fgcnkpi"encko"ku"ITCPVGF0" g+" Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"Fwg"Rtqeguu"encko" uvgookpi"htqo"jku"4237"fgoqvkqp"ku"ITCPVGF0"" h+" "Vjg"Eqwpv{Óu"Oqvkqp"hqt"Uwooct{"Lwfiogpv"qp"JctvgtÓu"Fwg"Rtqeguu"encko" uvgookpi"htqo"jku"4238"vgtokpcvkqp"ku"FGPKGF0"" " FCVGF<"Qevqdgt"4."423:" " " " " " " OGOQTCPFWO"FGEKUKQP"CPF"QTFGT"Î"55" " aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa"""""""""""" Fcxkf"E0"P{g" W0U0"Fkuvtkev"Eqwtv"Lwfig"
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
