Bennett v. Public Law Board No. 7694 et al, No. 4:2017cv00130 - Document 37 (S.D. Ga. 2020)
Court Description: ORDER denying 30 Motion for Leave to Appear ; terminating 33 Motion for Leave to Appear ; denying 36 Motion. Plaintiff is directed to file any supplement he desires to his responses to defendant's motion for summary judgment within 30 days from the date of this Order. Signed by Magistrate Judge Christopher L. Ray on 9/22/20. (wwp)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Bennett v. Public Law Board No. 7694 et al Doc. 37 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA SAVANNAH DIVISION " ,1*0"2 "$'00'66 " " ©" 2Ø ÆºßÆ " " " " %5:"64#052146#6+10 " " " & º¸ ºß " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " %8 " ORDER $ æø " ß " %æøß" Æœ" )ø æø " ' " $ ºº ßß œ" ø œ 溜 " ßæ" ß " %æøß œ" 5 æ¬" % œ "1ø¸ ø "¸æ " " º¸"/æßÆæº" æø"#¸ŒÆœœÆæº"pro hac vice "¸æ " " œ"¬ ØØ" œ " Ø ÆºßÆ œ" /æßÆæº" æø" 4Øƺ " ¸æ " " " (æø" ß " æø æƺ " ø œæºœ " æß " ŒæßÆ溜" ø "DENIED ""Pro se" Ø ÆºßÆ ",æ º"2 "$ ºº ß "Æœ"DIRECTED"ßæ" ÆØ " º " œ Ø Œ ºß" " ¸ œÆø œ" ßæ" Æœ" ø œ 溜 œ" ßæ" ¸ º¸ ºß œ" ŒæßÆæº" æø" œŒŒ ø " ª¸ Œ ºß"¬Æß Æº"thirty days" øæŒ"ß "¸ ß "æ "ß Æœ"1ø¸ ø """ 6 Æœ"%æøß" ø ©ÆæœØ " ºß ø ¸" º"æø¸ ø"ºæßƺ "ß ß")ø æø "$ ºº ßß" /ø " $ ºº ßß " ¸" ¸ø ß ¸" œ © ø Ø" ¸æ Œ ºßœ" æø" pro se Ø ÆºßÆ " ,æ º" $ ºº ßß" 2Ø ÆºßÆ "" &æ " "" 6 " %æøß"¸Æø ß ¸" /ø "$ ºº ß"ßæ"œ æ¬" œ " ¬ " Æœ" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" " "/ø "$ ºº ßß" œ" ÆØ ¸" "œ Ø Œ ºß"ßæ" Æœ"/æßÆæº" æø". © "ßæ"# ø"Pro Hac Vice" ß"¸æ " ""6 ß"ŒæßÆæº"œ æظ" "TERMINATED" "ß "%Ø ø "" Dockets.Justia.com º¸" " œœæ Æ ßÆæº" Ø ÆºßÆ œ " 溸 ß" ¸" ºæß" ©ÆæØ ß ¸" 4Ø " " " Id." " /ø " $ ºº ßß"ø œ 溸 ¸ "¸æ " " º¸" ÆØ ¸" "ŒæßÆæº"ßæ" ø"pro hac vice "¸æ " """ +º" Æœ" ø œ 溜 " /ø " $ ºº ßß" ºæ¬Ø ¸ ¸" ß ß" © øÆæœ" œß ß " ø" œœæ Æ ßÆ溜" º¸"ß "#Œ øÆ º"$ ø"#œœæ Æ ßÆæº" © " º"Œæø "œ æøßÆ© "ßæ" ß " º ø Ø" æº ß"æ "Ø Ø" æœß¬øÆßƺ "ß º" " " "ß " æøßœ ""&æ " " ß" ""/ø " $ ºº ßß" ø ¸" ß ß" " ø ©Æ ¬" æ " ß " Ø Ø" ØÆß ø ßø " º¸" © øÆæœ" œß ß " øæ œœÆæº Ø" ß Æ œ"øØ œ"ƺ¸Æ ß œ"ß ß" æœß¬øÆßƺ "¸æ œ"ºæß"©ÆæØ ß "ß " ß Æ œ" øØ œ ""Id." ß" ""/æø æ© ø " " ø ¸"ß ß"4Ø " "¬æظ"ºæß" Ø "ßæ" Æœ" ßÆ溜" œ "Æß"ø Æø œ" º" ßßæøº "¬ æ" øœ"ƺ" " œ "æø" øæ ¸Æº "æø"¬ æ" ø ø œ ºßœ" " øß "ƺ"Æºß ø œß"ƺ" " œ "æø" øæ ¸Æº "" Id." ß" "5 & ") ". 4 " """ 9 ÆØ "ß "%æøß"ø Œ ƺœ"œ ßÆ Ø"ß ß"ß Æœ" æøœ "æ " ßÆæº"Æœ"æº "¬ Æ " should" "ß º "ß "%æøß"Æœ"œ ßÆœ Æ ¸"ß ß"/ø "$ ºº ßß"¸Æ¸"ºæß"ß " Æœ" ßÆæº" ¬Æß " ß " Æºß ºß" ßæ" ©ÆæØ ß " 4Ø " " " # æø¸Æº Ø " ß " %æøß" ¸ Øƺ œ" ßæ" ø 挌 º¸" ÆŒ" æø" œ º ßÆ溜" Æß ø" ƺ" ß Æœ" %æøß" æø" ßæ" ß " © øÆæœ" ø" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" " " " $ ºº ßß œ" ø Œ ºß" ß ß" " Æœ" ºæß" œ ª ß" ßæ" ß " œßøÆ ßø œ" æ " 4Ø " " ® æœ œ" ß " º¸ Œ ºß Ø" øæ Ø Œ"¬Æß " æœß¬øÆßƺ ""$ ºº ßß œ" ø Œ ºß"¬æظ" ø ß " "œ "¬ ø " º" ßßæøº " ŒÆ ß" ø " ß " º Æß" æ " Æœ" øæ œœÆæº Ø" œ ø©Æ œ " i.e. ø " " " ¬ ÆØ " ©æƸƺ " º" ÆŒ æøß ºß" æŒ æº ºß" æ " Æœ" øæ œœÆæº Ø" ø œ æºœÆ ÆØÆß " i.e. Æœ" øæ œœÆæº Ø" æ ØÆ ßÆ溜"ßæ"ß "%æøß ""6 ø "Æœ"ºæ"ƺ¸Æ ßÆæº" ø "ß ß"/ø "$ ºº ßß" œ" ß ¸" Œ ºß" æø"¸ø ßƺ " Ø ¸Æº œ"ƺ"ß Æœ" œ " º¸ " œ"¸Æœ œœ ¸" Øæ¬ "ß "%æøß" ø œ"ß ß"ºæ"œ º ßÆæº" Æœ" øæ øÆ ß ""*æ¬ © ø "ß " ø ßÆ "æ " æœß¬øÆßƺ "Æ " øŒÆßß ¸" "ß "%æøß"ƺ"ß Æœ" ºÆ º" æøŒ "¬æظ"º ß Ø "æ º"ß "¸ææø"ßæ" œ " "Ø œœ"œ ø Øæœ" ø ßÆßÆæº øœ"ß º"/ø " $ ºº ßß" øœ"ßæ" " " œœæ Æ ßÆ溜"æ "¬ Æ " "Æœ" "Œ Œ ø ""0 © øß Ø œœ "/ø "$ ºº ßß"Æœ" ßÆæº ¸" ƺœß" º ƺ "ƺ"ß Æœ" æœß¬øÆßƺ " ©Ææø"ƺ"ß Æœ"%æøß"ƺ"ß " ßø "and he should not continue to do so" ©Æº " º"Œ ¸ " ¬ ø "æ "ß Æœ"%æøß œ" æœÆßÆæº" æº" æœß¬øÆßƺ ""&æ " " Ø ÆºßÆ "ŒæßÆæº" ø ø ¸" "/ø "$ ºº ßß" º¸"¸ ß ¸" ( ø ø " " " " 4 ø¸Ø œœ" æ " ¬ ß ø" Æœ" ßÆ溜" ø " œ æøß ¸" " ¸ ŒÆ " ØÆß ø ßø " ƺ" æß ø" ¸ÆœßøÆ ßœ" æø" ø" œœæ Æ ßÆ溜 " ß Æœ" %æøß" ¬ÆØØ" ºæß" æº¸æº "Æß"œ æظ"Æß" æŒ " ¬ ø "æ "Æß" ƺ "" /ø "$ ºº ßß" œ"ø œß ¸"ßæ" ø"pro hac vice"ƺ" º" æøß"ßæ" æøø ß" ß " øøæøœ"Ƹ ºßÆ Æ ¸" æ© ""&æ " ""# æø¸Æº "ßæ" Æœ"œ Ø Œ ºß"ßæ" Æœ"ŒæßÆæº" æø" ¸ŒÆœœÆæº "$ ºº ßß"Æœ"º Ø "ßæ"ø Œ Œ ø"ß " œ œ" æø"¬ Æ " " ø ¸" œ" 溜 Ø"ƺ"ß Æœ"¸ÆœßøÆ ß"¬ ÆØ " "¬ œ" "Œ Œ ø " ß" " œ" ß"Ø œß"Œ ¸ " º" æøß" ßæ" ØÆœß" ß æœ " œ œ" ƺ" ¬ Æ " " œ" ø ¸" ƺ" ß " ' œß øº" &ÆœßøÆ ß" æ " 6 ºº œœ " ¬ ø " " øø ºßØ " is" ¸ŒÆßß ¸ " " &æ " " " * " œ" Øœæ" øæ©Æ¸ ¸" " øßÆ Æ ß "æ " ææ¸"œß º¸Æº " øæŒ"ß ß"¸ÆœßøÆ ß " º¸" œ" Ƹ"ß " ÆØƺ " ""See ¸æ œ " " " " *æ¬ © ø " ß " %æøß" ººæß" ß" /ø " $ ºº ßß œ" pro hac vice ØÆ ßÆæº" œ" Æß" øø ºßØ " œß º¸œ" œ " Æß" ¸æ œ" ºæß" ¸ œÆ º ß " " ¬ÆØØƺ " Œ Œ ø"æ "ß Æœ"%æøß œ" ø" æº"¬ æŒ"ŒæßÆ溜" º¸" øœ"Œ " "œ ø© ¸" º¸" ¬ æ"œ ØØ" "ø œ æºœÆ Ø " æø" º¸" © " ØØ" ß æøÆß "ßæ" ß" æø" º¸"æº" Ø "æ " ß " ØÆ ºß" ƺ" ØØ" øæ ¸Æº œ" " ø Ø ß ¸" ßæ" ß " œ " ƺ ظƺ " øƺ œ " ø ßøÆ Ø" æº ø º œ " º¸"ßøÆ Øœ "œ æظ"ß " ßÆßÆæº ø" ÆØ"ßæ"ø œ 溸"ßæ" º " æøß"æø¸ ø" " æø" ø º "æø"æß ø¬Æœ ""5 & ") ". "4 " ""# æø¸Æº Ø "/ø "$ ºº ßß œ" ØÆ ßÆæº" æø"Ø © "ßæ" øæ ¸"pro hac vice "Æœ"DENIED ""&æ " " 6 "%æøß"Æœ" 溜 Ææœ"ß ß"ß Æœ"¸ ß øŒÆº ßÆæº" ØØœ"ƺßæ" œßÆæº" ØØ"æ " ß " ÆØƺ œ" ø ßæ æø "Œ ¸ " " Ø ÆºßÆ "ƺ" Æœ"欺"º Œ " º¸"Œæœß" øßÆ Ø øØ " ß æœ " ÆØ ¸"ƺ"ø œ 溜 "ßæ"¸ º¸ ºß œ"ŒæßÆæº" æø"œŒŒ ø "ª¸ Œ ºß ""*æ¬ © ø " ¬ ÆØ "ß æœ " ÆØƺ œ"¬ ø "¸ø ß ¸" "/ø "$ ºº ßß "ß "¬ ø "œÆ º ¸" " Ø ÆºßÆ "" /ø "$ ºº ßß" æºß º¸œ"ß ß" Æœ" æœß¬øÆßƺ "¸æ œ"ºæß"©ÆæØ ß "4Ø " "¸æ " " ß" " º¸"¸ º¸ ºß" ø œ"ß ß"at most ß "¸æ Œ ºßœ" ø "©æƸ Ø "¸æ " " ß" "" & º¸ ºß" ØÆ © œ" ß ß" º " øøæø" º" ØÆ ¬Æœ " " ø ßÆ Æ ¸" " /ø " $ ºº ßß" øƺ "pro hac vice" º¸"œ ŒÆßßƺ "ß " Ø ¸Æº œ"º¸ ø" Æœ"欺"œÆ º ßø " º¸" øßÆ Æº " ß ß" ß ø " ø " øæ ø" ø溸œ" æø" ß " Ø ¸Æº œ " " Id. " #œ" /ø " $ ºº ßß œ"pro hac"vice ØÆ ßÆæº"Æœ"ƺœ Æ Æ ºß "that"øæß "ßæ" æøø ß"ß " øøæøœ" Æœ"ºæß" øø ºßØ " æœœÆ Ø """ *æ¬ © ø " ß ø " Æœ" ºæ" œßÆæº" ß ß" œæŒ " ƺ¸Æ©Æ¸ Ø" Œœß" ß" ØØ" ø œ æºœÆ ÆØÆß " æø"ß " ÆØƺ œ"ƺ"ß Æœ" œ " º¸"œ ª ß"ß Œœ Ø© œ"ßæ"ß "œßøÆ ßø œ" æ " 4Ø " " " 1œß ºœÆ Ø " Ø ÆºßÆ " œ" already" ß º" ø œ æºœÆ ÆØÆß " æø" ß œ " ¸æ Œ ºßœ" "œÆ ºÆº "ß Œ"ƺ" Æœ"欺"º Œ ""See, e.g. "¸æ " " ß" " ºæßƺ "ß ß" øæ"œ "ØÆßÆ ºß" œ" º" ¸©Æœ ¸"ß ß"ß " ßßæøº " ø øƺ "ß "¸æ Œ ºß" œ" ºæß" º¸" ¸æ œ" ºæß" æ ø" º " Ø Ø" æ ƺÆæº" æø" ¸©Æœ " œÆ " æº" ¬ Æ " œ Ƹ" ØÆßÆ ºß" º"æø"œ æظ"ø Ø ""5 Ƹ"ØÆßÆ ºß"Æœ" Øœæ" ¸©Æœ ¸"ß ß"ß " æ© " ßßæøº " " ¸æ œ" ºæß" ø ø œ ºß" œ Ƹ" ØÆßÆ ºß " " *æ¬ © ø " ß " %æøß" ºæ¬Ø ¸ œ" Æœ" ß º " æ " ø œ æºœÆ ÆØÆß " Æœ" ºæß" ºßÆø Ø " Ø ø" øæŒ" ß " ø æø¸" º¸" ß " 溜 º œ"æ "ß œ " ßÆ溜"Œ "ºæß" " ºßÆø Ø " Ø ø"ßæ" "pro se" Ø ÆºßÆ "" # æø¸Æº Ø "ß " æøß"¬ÆØØ" æø¸"pro se" Ø ÆºßÆ " º"æ æøߺÆß "ßæ" ß" ØØ" º¸" ® ؜Ʃ " ø œ æºœÆ ÆØÆß " æø" ß œ " Ø ¸Æº œ" º¸" ÆØ " º " ¸¸ º¸Œ" " ØÆ © œ"Æœ"º œœ ø " Æ© º" Æœ"pro se œß ßœ """ * "Œ "¸æ"œæ"ƺ"æº "æ "߬æ"¬ œ ""2Ø ÆºßÆ "Œ "ø ÆØ " º "ø œ 溜 "ßæ"ß " ŒæßÆæº" æø"œŒŒ ø "ª¸ Œ ºß"¬Æß Æº"ß Æøß "¸ œ" øæŒ"ß "¸ ß "æ "ß Æœ"1ø¸ ø "" 6 Æœ" ø œ 溜 " Œœß" " ø ø ¸" ºßÆø Ø " " Ø ÆºßÆ " º¸" ø ø œ ºß" Æœ" 欺" ƺ¸ º¸ ºß" º¸ øœß º¸Æº " æ " ß " øæ ¸ø " " 2Ø ÆºßÆ " Æœ" ¸©Æœ ¸" ß ß" º " """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" " "+º" øÆ "( ¸ "4 "%Æ© "2 " "œß ß œ"ß ß" " ø œ ºßƺ "ßæ"ß " æøß" " Ø ¸Æº "¬øÆßß º"ŒæßÆæº " æø"æß ø" ø ¬ ß ø" "œÆ ºÆº " ÆØƺ "œ ŒÆßßƺ "æø"Ø ß ø" ¸©æ ßƺ "Æß º" ßßæøº "æø" ºø ø œ ºß ¸" øß " øßÆ Æ œ"ß ß"ßæ"ß " œß"æ "ß " øœæº œ" ºæ¬Ø ¸ "ƺ æøŒ ßÆæº " º¸" ØÆ " æøŒ ¸" ß ø" º"ƺ Æø "ø œæº Ø "º¸ ø"ß " Æø Œœß º œ " Æß" Æœ" ºæß" ƺ " ø œ ºß ¸" æø" º " ÆŒ øæ ø" ø æœ " œ " œ" ßæ" ø œœ " œ " ºº œœ ø "¸ Ø "æø"º ¸Ø œœØ "ƺ ø œ "ß " æœß"æ "ØÆßÆ ßÆæº " ß " Ø ÆŒœ "¸ ºœ œ " º¸"æß ø"Ø Ø" æºß ºßÆ溜" ø "¬ øø ºß ¸" " ®Æœßƺ "Ø ¬"æø" " "ºæº øÆ©æØæœ" ø Œ ºß" æø" ®ß º¸Æº "Œæ¸Æ ƺ "æø"ø © øœÆº " ®Æœßƺ "Ø ¬"æø" æø" œß ØÆœ ƺ "º ¬"Ø ¬ " ß " ß Ø" æºß ºßÆ溜" © " ©Æ¸ ºßÆ ø "œ æøß"æø "Æ "œ Æ Æ ØØ "œæ"Ƹ ºßÆ Æ ¸ " ¬ÆØØ" ØÆ Ø " © " ©Æ¸ ºßÆ ø " œ æøß" ß ø" " ø œæº Ø " æ æøߺÆß " æø" øß ø" ƺ© œßÆ ßÆæº"æø"¸Æœ æ© ø " º¸" ß "¸ ºÆ Øœ"æ " ß Ø" æºß ºßÆ溜" ø "¬ øø ºß ¸"æº"ß " ©Æ¸ º "æø "Æ "œ Æ Æ ØØ " œæ"Ƹ ºßÆ Æ ¸ " ø "ø œæº Ø " œ ¸"æº" ØÆ "æø"Ø "æ "ƺ æøŒ ßÆæº " ( ÆØø "ßæ" æŒ Ø "¬Æß "ß Æœ"øØ "œ ª ßœ" " øß "ßæ"œ º ßÆ溜"ƺ ظƺ " ß"ºæß"ØÆŒÆß ¸"ßæ " Œæº ß ø " º ØßÆ œ " " 2Ø ÆºßÆ " œ ª ßœ" ÆŒœ Ø " øœæº ØØ " ßæ" ß œ " æ ØÆ ßÆ溜" " œÆ ºÆº " ¸æ Œ ºßœ"ƺ" Æœ"º Œ " º¸" øæ ¸Æº "pro se ""See United States v. Barker " "( "5 " ¸" " " 5 & ") " " ƺ¸Æº " © º" øæ"œ "¸ º¸ ºßœ"œ ª ß"ßæ"4Ø " "" " "6 "%æøß"Œ œ"ºæ" ƺ¸Æº " º¸"Æœœ œ"ºæ"æ ƺÆæº"æº"¬ ß ø" º¸"ßæ"¬ ß" ®ß ºß" Ø ÆºßÆ " " ø œ 溜 " " ÆØ œ"¬ÆØØ"œ øœ ¸ "ß "æøÆ Æº Ø"ø œ 溜 " º¸"ß ø æø "Œœß" " æŒ Ø ß "ƺ"Æßœ Ø ""See, e.g., Malowney v. Fed. Collection Deposit Grp. " "( ¸" " " º " ß " %Æø " " #º" Œ º¸ ¸" æŒ Ø Æºß" œ øœ ¸ œ" º" æøÆ Æº Ø" æŒ Ø Æºß ""+º"ß " Øß øº ßÆ© " Ø ÆºßÆ "Œ "ø œß"æº"ß " Ø ¸Æº œ" " œ" Øø ¸ " ÆØ ¸"ƺ" Æœ"º Œ ""+ "ºæ" Œ º¸ ¸"ø œ 溜 "Æœ" ÆØ ¸"¬Æß Æº"ß "ßÆŒ " ø Œ " ØÆœß ¸" æ© " ß " %æøß" ¬ÆØØ" ¸ ß øŒÆº " ß ß" Ø ÆºßÆ " Æºß º¸œ" ßæ" " ø œ æºœÆ Ø " æø" ß " ¸æ Œ ºßœ" ¬ Æ " " œÆ º ßø " ÆØ ¸ " © º" ß æ " ß æœ " ¸æ Œ ºßœ"¬ ø "ºæß"¸ø ß ¸" " Ø ÆºßÆ "" SO ORDERED, ß Æœ" º¸"¸ "æ "5 ß Œ ø " " " *4+5612*'4" %*4 4+5612* *'4 4". "4#; 0+6'&"56#6'5 6#6'5"/#)+564#6' #)+564#6'",7&)'" 70+6'& 5176*'40"&+564+%6"1(")'14)+#" """""""""""""""" º" 溜Øß"¬Æß "Ø Ø"œæø œ"ƺ"ß " ø ø ßÆæº"æ " º "œ Ø Œ ºß Ø"¸æ Œ ºßœ ""5 Æ "Æß" ßæ"œ "ß ß"¬ ß" œ" º ¸"Æœ"œÆŒ Ø " " øƸ "ßææ" ø ""2Ø ÆºßÆ "Œ "ºæß" © " º" ßßæøº " ø ø " "Ø Ø"¸æ Œ ºß" æø" ÆŒ"in toto º¸"ß º"ø ø œ ºß"ß ß" "Æœ" øæ ¸Æº "pro se """" "
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
