MARSHON v. The Fresh Market, Inc., No. 9:2016cv81609 - Document 19 (S.D. Fla. 2017)
Court Description: ORDER AND OPINION DENYING DEFENDANT THE FRESH MARKET. INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS AMENDED COMPLAINT OR ALTERNATIVELY FOR A MORE DEFINITE STATEM ENT denying 10 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim; denying 10 Motion for More Definite Statement. Signed by Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks on 1/5/2017. (lan)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
MARSHON v. The Fresh Market, Inc. Doc. 19 UNI TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA CASE NO.1681609- V- I Cl M DDLEBROOK S PAULA M ARSHON , Pl ntf, ai if THE FRESH M ARKET,N C. l , De e nt f nda . O RDER AND O PI O N DENYI DEFENDANT TH E FRESH M ARKET.I ' NI NG NC.S M O TI N TO DI I AM ENDED COM PLAI OR ALTERNATI O SM SS NT VELY FOR A M ORE DEFI TE STATEM ENT NI THI CAUSE co sbeor t Cour upon Defnda TheFr h M aket I .s(t es S me f e he t e nt es r , nc' 'Fr h Mak f' M oin t Dimis Plitf s Ame d d Co lit o Al r aiey fr a M o e r e ) to o s s an if ne mp an r t n tv l, o e r Dei ie Sae n (i oi n' fld o Oco e 27 2 6 ( 1 ) Plitf Pa l Mas o fnt ttme t $ to ', ie n t b r , 01 . DE 0 . anif ua rh n M ) (Ma s o ' fld a Re po s i o po iin o No mb r1 2 6 ( 1 ) t wh c F e h û rh n' ie i ) s n e n p sto n ve e 4, 01 DE 5 , o ih r s Make r ple t ne day,Nove r t e id he xt mber 1 201 ( 1 . Fort r s sae bel t 5, 6 DE 6) he ea ons ttd ow, he M o i i de e ton s nid. BACKGROUND M a s s cai a iesoutofa si a f lt toc ured on Fr s M a kets pr m ie . r hon' l m rs lp- nd-al ha c r eh r ' e ss M as i a i vi ctz n ofFlrda. ( nde Co ai ,heei fe i mpl nt'or rhon s n ndi dual iie o i Ame d mpl nt r na tr ' Co ai ' i mp . a ! 5 .Frs M ake i ac r rto a d alge l a ctz n o Dea r s ta d e d l' t ) eh r t s opoain, n le dy i e f lwae l h t o s co ' i 'Si e M a s doe notsa e Fr h M a ke ' s ae o i or a i he Compl ntal i nc r hon s t t es r ts t t f nc por ton, r ai one s i ufs i ntt esa ih t Pa tes di st ofciie hi M ac nnii v Hobbs Gr ,LLC, ns tc e o tbls he ri ' veriy tz ns p. Gi te . p. 420F. 1 1 (1 t Ci.2005)(fimi t tac r r toni acii nofb0t issaeof 3d 234, 239 1h r afr ng ha o po ai s tze h t tt i opo ai a prncpa plce ofb i s) Howe r be a e Fr s M ake ' Noi of nc r ton nd i i l a usne s. ve, c us e h r ts tce nd c us t l emovala ton,t r ci he Re movals is t mi sng i or ton,s / #w,a be a e iin a r upple he s i nf ma i ee a . Dockets.Justia.com bu i e si Flrd . (d. t! 3 5 .M as o sCo litalg st to No e e 1 , 4, sn s n o ia 1 a ! , ) rh n' mpan le e ha n v mb r 7 201 s wa a busne s i te a a Fr s M a ketso e l a e a 1 Sout Fe a Hi he s i s nvie t eh r t r oc t d t 727 h der l ghwa i y n Der y Be c ,F o ia (d.a ! 8 . W hi s e wa n a te s o png c rsa t e so e s la a h lrd . 1 t ) l h s e r h h p i at t h t r ' e e r nc M a s a lge y 'si d on a lq d,waerlke s t nc ' c i hert tf l t nta e, rhon le dl ilppe i ui t -i ubsa e, ausng ' o ia l o te g o nd a d s san sv r a d p r n n pes n lij re . (d.a ! 9 . Ma s n a e s h r u n u ti e ee n e ma e t ro a n ui s' l t ) ' rho v r f t rt tt s t nc wa ' r a l a r ntt busne si tes'be us i wasSoc ed urhe ha he ubsa e s k e diy ppa e o i s nvie ' ca e t not ç at l o te g o nd a d be d d i wih c aa trsis oft e to r' (d.a ! 1 ) S e tus n h ru n ln e n t h r ceitc h l o . 1 t 1. h h ' c r trz s t s t e as a i ng ous a ha r haaceie he ubsanc i er da nd zadous c ton. (J.. l a ton, ondii ' / ) n ddii ' M a s saes t t s con to e se f l e rhon t t hat hi dii n xit d or ong nough t t Fr h M a ke kne or s d ha es r t w houl h v k o o ise se c .(d. t 1 ) a e n wn f t xit n e 1 a ! 4 . The Compl i s t f t a sngl c e of a ton a i tFr h M a ke f neglge . ant e s orh i e aus c i gans es r t or i nce Tr c ng t eeme s ofa c a ki he l nt omm on l w ne i nce cli ,M a s alege t tFr h M ar t a glge am r hon l s ha es ke o dh ra d t o c r ,b t t ç iti t e (le ssi ar ao b y s f c n iin a d t we e uy f ae oh o i nan h p rmie n e s na l a e o d t n o ma o wan (e)o c n e ld p rl' o whc i k e o s o l h v k o (d.a ! 1 ) Frs r h r f o c ae e is' f ih t n w r h u d a e n wn. I t 2 , e h M ake s r t uppos dl br c dt sdut by a al ng t lqui s tnc t a umult ont e y ea he hi y ) lowi he i d ubsa e o cc ae he toor b)fii to i tuc ise o st mai ai a cea a s e ara'f c t s c l ; alng i nsr t t mplyee o nt n l r nd af e ' or usomer; ) t f ii t pr t c c t r by t ki r me a se s h a pu tng down m as c eai a lng o o e t usome s a ng e dil t ps uc s ti t, r tng wa ng sgns orcla ngup t lq d;a d)fii t wan c t r aboutt ha r (#. mi i , e ni he iui nd alng o r usome s he zad. f a ! 1 ) M as o camsta b v ru o t i b e c Fr s M ake die ty a d p o i tl t 3 . rh n li h t y ite f hs r a h, e h r t rcl n r x maey c u e h rij re .(d. t!1 ) a s d e nu is 1 a 5 . bud ni o ted fn a t n ttepanif t p e dt eb ssf r u idcin, Fo e v Sae o r e s n h ee d n , o h li tf, o la h a i o j rs ito ' wlr . f c ' I s Co o , 5F.d61 61 ( 1hCi. 9 0 , as n se r ri h r e s n . . fAm.91 2 6, 7 1 t r 1 9 ) M rho ' ro s amls . M as rhon i ta l tld a c pli t a i t Fr h M ake i Fl i sae cou t on niily se om a n gans es r t n orda t t r Septm be 1 , 201 ( 12 a 5- )2 Fr s M a ke fld a tm ey notc ofr m ova t t s e r 2 l o hi 6. DE - t 8 . e h r t ie i l i e e Co r o S p e e 2 2 6. ( 1 . l isn tc ,F e h M ak tsae ta s j c matr u t n e tmb r 0, 01 DE ) n t oie r s r e ttd h t ube t te j rs ito e itd b c u e o d v riy o ctz n hp b t e t Pa t s S e 2 U. C,j u idcin x se e a s f i est f iie s i ewe n he ri . e 8 S. e 1 2. Spec fc l Fr s M a ket c ende t t i, t c por ton, wa i or a e i 33 ii aly, e h r ont d ha t he or a i s nc por t d n Dea r a ha isprnc p plce ofbusne s i No t Car i m a ng i a c tze oft lwa e nd d t i i al a i s n rh olna, ki t ii n he lte . ( 1a 5) M as ont ot rha i a ctz ofFl i a s Fr h Make atr3 DE t . rhon, he he nd, s iien orda, nd o es r t came t tt t parisweedi re. (d.. l a ton,Fr h Mar tmanti t tt li d ha he wo te r ves 1 ) n ddii es ke i ans ha he a mount i con r r y exc eds $75, 00, bas d on a c pa ion bewe n t na ur of n tove s e 000. e om rs t e he t e M as n' alg d ij re a dj y vedcsa r e f rsmi rij re i p e iu tr c s s rho s le e nu is n ur r it wad d o i l nu is n r vo s o t a e . a (d.a 4- . The i tntM oto i ba e on M as sfiu et sat acl m f r ifunde 1 t 5) nsa in s s d rhon' alr o t e ai or ele r Fe R, v.P.12( ( .( 1 at2) d. Ci b)6) DE 0 . LEGAL STANDARD A mo int d s s u de Ru e1 ( )6 c l n e telg l u fce c o ac mpan . to o imis n r l 2 b ( ) hal g s h e a s fiin y f o li t e Se Fe R. v. 1 b ( ) I a s sigt elg ls fiin yo ac mpan ' alg to ,h e d. Ci P. 2()6 . n se sn h e a u fce c f o lits le ains t e Co ti bound t a y t pl a ng sa r ari ult d i Bel Atantc Cor v.Twombl 550 ur s o ppl he e di t nda d tc a e n l l i p. y U. 5 4 (0 7 a dAs c otv l b l 5 6U. 6 2, 78( 0 ) Th ti,h c mplitk s . S. 4 2 0 ) n h rj . q a , 5 S. 6 6 2 09 . a s te o an i t . mu . c ai s fcintf t lma tr a e e a tue t çt t a cli t r ift ti pl usbl on ont n ufi e acua te , cc pt d s r , o sae a m o ele ha s a i e isf c .' Am.De tlAs ' v Cin Cop. 6 5 F,d 1 8 1 8 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ( u t g t a e' ' na sn . g a r , 0 3 2 3, 2 9 1 t r 01 ) q oi n Twombl 550U. a 570) i s sa i t r or pe mitd whenont ba i ofadipostve y, S. t . t misl s heef e r te Di he ss s ii 2The a i wa fld i t Cic t Cour oft Fiten h J c a Ditit i a f Pal cton s ie n he r ui t he fe t udii l src , n nd or m Bea h Count Fl i c y, orda. The c e i syl d M ar hon v The Fr h M ar t f . Ca e No. as s t e s . es ke, nc , s 50 6CA01 201 0329XXXXM B.( l2) DE - . 9Unde t s f ct,Fr s M a ke i a s a cii e ofDeawa e M ac nnii ,420 F, a 1 r he e a s e h r t s lo tz n l r, Gi te 3d t 239, bute s t tf twoul no desr di riy. ven o, ha ac d t toy ve st 3 is ofl w,no co tuc i oft f t la lgato wils s ue a nsr ton he acua le ins l uppor t c e ofa i ' Gl e t he aus cton. ov r ' v LigetGr ,l c,4 9 F.d 1 0 1 08( 1h Ci.2 0 )(ne a q o ai n o te )( hng . g t p. n . 5 3 3 4, 3 1 t r 0 6 itm l u tto s mi d c i t Ma s alCl Bd o c v Ma s a l Ga Dit, 2F. d 1 71 1 7 ( 1hCi, 9 ). rh l y. .fEdu . . rh l C@. s s.99 2 1 , 1 4 1 t r 1 93 ) W hen r vi wi a moton t dimis a co tm us c t e pli tf c e e ng i o s s , ur t onsnl a n ifs ompl i ti t a n n he lght mos f r bl t pli if a tke t f t al al ga i satd t r i as tue. Se i t avo a e o antf nd a he ac u le tons t e he en r e Erc s n v Pa du ,5 U. 8 , 3 ( 0 7 ;Ch itph rv Har u y, 3 U. 4 3 4 6( 0 2 ; ik o . r s 51 S. 9 9 2 0 ) rso e . b r 5 6 S. 0 , 0 2 0 ) Br o s v Ble Cr s t Ble Shed o Fl. l c, 1 6 F.d 1 6 1 6 ( 1h Ci.1 9 ) o k . u o s f u il f a, n . 1 3 3 4, 3 9 1 t r 9 7 . Howe ,pla ngs t ti e no m or t n c usons a e no e ild t t a s pton of ver e di ha b ar e ha oncl i , r t ntte o he s um i t uh. W hie lgal c l i c n p ovi t fa e k of a c pl nt t y mus be rt l e oncusons a r de he r m wor om ai , he t S. t ee s nalr n . a- a s uppore by f c ua alegai . I al 556 U . a 678;s alo Si taialv Coc col td a t l l tons' qb , ' Co. 578F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.2009)(ttng t ta unwarntd deduci offc i not , 3d 252. 260 1 t r sai ha n ra e ton a t s c sdee tu f pur eofdeer ni whehe acam i l alys fcent. on i rd r e or pos t mi ng t r li s eg l ufii ) Ge r l a pli tf i notr uie t de a la1t f c supon whih he ba e hi cai . ne aly, a n if s eq r d o t i 1 he a t c ss s l m Fe R. v.P,8( ( .Rahe,Rul 8()2)rquie as ta pli saeme oft cam t t d. Ci a)2) t r e a( e rs hor nd an tt nt he li ha f il notfest def ntofbot t ca m a t s a ry i he enda h he li nd he uppori g ounds Twomby,550U . a tng r . l S. t 5 55 Ho ve,t l 8a () silrq ie a %h wi g'rt e t a abln e a s ri ,o 5 - 6. we r i e ( )2 tl e ur s s o n , ah r h n a k t se t Ru on f e ilm e t r lef' / a 556 n. Pli ifs 'o i ton t pr de t i ounds of hi ntte nt o ei . J. t ' 3. a ntf kblga i o ovi he gr ' s f tte e t r le r r sm or t n lbel a co l i , af m uli r iai oft en ilm nt o ei f equie e ha a s nd ncusons and or a c ect ton he ee nt ofaca e ofa i wilnotdo. I a 555 ( tton omit . i cua algai lme s us cton l ' d. t ' ciai ted) s t l le tons Fa mu t e ou ht r ie(litf )rg t or l fa o etes e u ai elv lo t ea s mp in s be n g o as p an ifs ih t ei b v h p c ltv e e, n h su to e t ta1 oft a l ga i i t c pl i a e t ue. I ha l he le tons n he om a nt r r ' d. ' 4 DI SCUSSI ON Rul 8()() e a2 r hon' le tons e he ea ng Fr h M a ke prm a iy a gue t t M a s s al gai do not m e t t pl di es r t i rl r s ha rquieme sofFe R.Ci P.8()2) l ctst s rlS y detce is'i t Compli . e r nt d. v. a( . t ie o evea i ke s ince ' n he ant ( 1 a 6) Fis,Fr h M ake i it t M as n' de ci i oft lqui s tncea DE 0 t . rt es r t nsss hat rho s s rpton he i d ubsa nd t cr he icumsa s of he f lwe e nots fcenty pr ie. Sec t nce r al r ufi i l ec s ond,i f t M a s n f not t auls r ho or s an t de t y lbe i t s t nc S once e 'o i dden. Thid, tcli st tM arhon c no a quael a lng he ubs a e i c ald' r k hi ' ' r i am ha a lge Fr s M a ke ' consr tve k le e h r ts tuc i nowl dgeoft s t ncewiho ofe i s es pori e he ubsa t ut f rng om up tng f ct las e tonsabou how i woul ha be n on notc s h a by s iyi t amountof a ua s ri t t d ve e ie, uc s pecf ng he tme t da e o c ton e se be or M a s si i he ng r us ondii xit d f e r hon lpped o i. M a s r ponds t the n t r hon es ha r f cua a lga i s f e t r ie a r a ona e i e e e t t Fr h M a ke i la e f a t l le tons u ic o a s e s bl nf r nc ha es r t s i bl or ne i nc unde Fl i lw .Shea s adva st t r t twhe e a c pl ntss glge e r orda a lo nce he heo y ha r om ai ' uppori tng f c s a e a las as de al d a t f m alegai pr ded i 1 Fl i Ruls of Ci l at r t e t t ie s he or l tons ovi n he orda e vi Pr e e s Fl R. Ci P, For 1. 951 ($ 1oc dur , ee a. v. m $ 1Down Neglgenc Co ai ) t Fa i e mpl nf', he c ompl ntsa lga i a e e ai ' le tons r nough t pr dea o ovi dequae notc oft cli . t i e he am M a s sa la y a gumen r a i t Fl i pr edu a r esi i onsse wih t r hon' ncilr r t eltng o orda oc r l ul s nc itnt t he sa d g ni t r lto hi be we n f de a a d sae 1w i di r iy c s s l i tndar over ng he ea i ns p t e e r l n t t a n ve st a e . t s ee nay ta wh n fd r lj rs ito aie tr u h te p ris dv riy ofct e s i lme tr h t e e e a u idcin rs s h o g h a t ' ie st e ii n hp, z s bsan i is s a e contole by sa e 1 w and pr dur lis s by f de a l w. Br u t tve s ue r r ld tt a oce a s ue e rl a own v . Nihos,8F. 770,773( 1h Ci.1 ;s egen aly Han v,Pl r,380U. 460 ( 965) c l 3d 1 t r 993) e er l na ume S. 1 . Pla ng r quie e di e r ment a e pr e a i naur a s a e de e m i d by t Fede a Rul of s r oc dur l n t e nd o r t r ne he r l es Ci lPr e e,notby t r e oft sae whe e t f de alc tst . Br vi oc dur he uls he t t r he e r our is own,8 F. a 773 3d t (ke r lw gove nspla ng rquie nt') ac d.F D.. v Da k deal a f r e di e r me s'; cor IC. . wson,4 F. 1 1 3d 303, 308 5 ( h Ci.1 5t r 993)(i pla ng rquie nt i fdealc ta e govened by Fe a Rul of the e di e r me s n e r our r t r derl e Ci lPr e e8rt rt nbysaelw' ; u iows iv Par vi oc dur ahe ha tt a ' M zk k . amountPit e Cor ,322 F. ) curs p. 3d 91 92 ( t Ci.2003)(li s pla ng r l ' coure doe notappl i fdealc t'; 8, 6 7h r llnoi e di ue i of s s y n e r our' ) Ri y v.For De e Comput Se v,l . 11 F.d 94,98,n. ( t Ci.1 dgwa d alr . r . nc, 4 3 5 6h r 997) ( tng cii Da o ) Th ,u ta $ saesh ihe e pe dn sa d r sd no a p yt k)(lan ifs ws n . us j s s i tt ' eg tn d la ig tn a d o t p l o a p litf a sae 1w cams'Pam Be c Gt Cf, c ,l c v J h G.Sa rs D, S. P. ,7 1F.d tt a li ' l a h l r- a n . . o n , #- Bo r i, D. , A. 8 3 1 1 n. ( 1h Ci.201 ;s ealo Ca trv.Hen se 781F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci. 245, 250, 4 1 t r 5) e s se nesy, 2d 569, 570 1 t r 1 ) s t woul asaesmoeper si pla ngsa r - i or ae t oug amode 986 , o oo d tt' r misve e di tndad nc port d hr h l f m - notus r t pl di sanda d a tc at i t f r lr l s I i t r or ir e nt or u p he ea ng t r ri ul ed n he ede a u e . t s he ef e relva f t pum os of e ua i t s M oto t M arhon has s tsi or e e ded t or he es val tng hi i n hat s a ifed xc e he r r m e t ofFl i smodelf r f f ldown cai I t ad,1mus l onl t Fe R. equie n s orda' o m or all ms. nse t ook y o d. Ci .P.8()2)t decdewhehe M a s hassae acli uponwhih rle ma begane 4 a( o i t r rhon ttd am c eif y r td. v Neve t es ,evc a yi t pot taly m o ergor r r m e sofRul 8,lfnd rhel s n ppl ng he en i l r i ous equie nt e i t t M a s ha ma s fcint f cua alega i fom whi h la lt f neglge e c n ha r hon s de ufi e a t l l tons r c ibiiy or i nc a r s bl be i e r Iha not d elewher t t ea ona y nf red. ve e s e ha : a m or elef Rul 8 s ysme ey,i r e e a r l n elvantpa t t taçpl di t tsaesa cli f r i r, ha ' ea ng ha t t mus c ai ..a s ta pli satm e oft c am s t ont n hor nd an t e nt he l i howi t tt pla r ng ha he e de i e ild t r if' Fe R.Ci P.8()2) The Supr Cour i e est s s ntte o ele . d. ' v. a( . eme t ntprt hi r e lbeal Gimourv.Gats M c al & Co. 382 F. 1 2,1 1 ( 1h ul i rly. l e , Don d , 3d 31 3 4 1 t Ci,2004) Thepoi i t ' vet dee r . nt s o i he fndantfi notc ofwha t cam i a gi ar ie t he li s nd t gounds upon whi i rss. Twombl 550 U. 544,555 (nt l he r ch t et ' ' y, S. i ema quottons a atr i omitd) Noi pl di e n a modiid by ai nd leatons te . tce ea ng, ve s fe T mbya Ib ld sn tle ur t hy e-e h ia c d pla n ofa e wo l nd q a, oe o i q ie he p rtc nc l o e edigs g s r pa t'a i notmea tt ti up ltga swih f ma itcditnc i . Re nik v s' nd s n o rp li nt t or lsi si tons s c . 4Ia s no e t t M a s n ca lo t ha r ho nnotr l on t f r mode f neglge e cli s - f ey he ede al l or i nc am ound i n For 11 of t Appe x of For - t e t bls t s fcenc of her c e of aci m he ndi ms o sa ih he uf i y aus ton. Alhough Rul 84 pr ousy a id agl st a la ndi f m st tm a t m i ufi e t t e evi l pple os o l ppe x or ha de he i fcint o s wihsa atc 'whe usd asapladi tmplt Fed.R.Ci P.84 ( 946Amendme ) t t tnd ta k' n e e ng e ae, v. 1 nt,he De e r 1 201 a ndme s t t r e a ogae t s gl s Fed.R.Ci P.8 ( 5 c mbe , 5 me nt o he ul br td hi os . v. 4 201 Ame ndment;Lydav CBSCor ,8 F. 1 ,1 n. ( d.Ci, 6) ) . p. 38 3d 331 337, 2 Fe r 201 . 6 Av ,l . 693 F. 1 7,13 ( 1h Ci.201 . Asar ul,courswildrw Med nc, 3d 31 24 1 t r 2) es t t l a ie s n be if rn e s' to n fo t Sa t a c ne t pe . I b l 5 6 t ao a l n ee c rl l wig r m he i cu l o tn' ld q a , 5 r ' f ' U . a 678. S. t De ri i .F wno lste m, ta.9:6-v- 3 - M , 7 a 1 ( D. a De . , Ma tn v o fGuf r a e l 1 c 81 71DM DE 9, t 2 S. Fl. c 23 , 2 6 ( ide r o s J) s ealo Le a Sa d r s cin, u a I o d rt ma eo tacam, 01 ) M d lb o k , .; e s g l tn a d e to spr . n r e o k u li i i notne s a y f t pli ift ts ciialy pl d e r elm e ofa c e ofaci ' Roe ts ce s r or he a ntf o tpe fc l ea ve y e nt aus ton. ' v zwc e Wo Ct. rCh c ,I c, 5 F,d 6 8, 8 ( 1h Ci. 0 ) Att es metme .l r man r Fo oie n . 2 3 3 7 6 3 1 t r 2 01 . h a i , 'i i silne es a y t ta c tt s tl c s r ha ompl i c an et rdiec ori e e ila l atonsr peci a l ant ont i ihe r t nf r nta leg i es tng 1 t ma e i lel nt ne s a y t s t i a r c r unde s he t ra eme s ce s r o usan e ove y r ome vi e l ga t or ' 1 abl e l he y. d. ' ( tngl r Pl quoi n e ywoodAnttu tLii i 655F. 627,641(t Ci. tA Se .8 1 1) ir s tgaton, 2d 5h rUni pt , 98 ). Unde t ssan r i i en iel pl i e t tM a s s f c ua alega i a r hi t da d, t s tr y ausbl ha r hon' a t l l tons mountt o Fr s M a ke ' la lt f ne i nce I Fl i t r a e f e e nt t a ne i ncecli : e h r ts ibiiy or glge . n orda, he e r our l me s o glge am t 1 a lg ld t o te d fn n t p oe t t p an if fo p riu a ij is ( t e i ) e a u y n h ee da t o r tc he litf r m a t lr nure ; 2) h ( c d fn a tsb e c o ta d t ( )t epanifsij r benga tal a d p o i tl c us d ee d n ' ra h f h t uy; 3 h litf nu y i cu ly n r xmaey a e b t b e c a d ( t plitf s fei g a t lh r fo t e ij r ' Zio io ih v y he r a h; n 4) he an if u frn cua a m rm h nu y. vjn vc . ' Ba n r 5 F.d 1 5 ,1 6 ( 1h Ci, 0 8 ( i n Cly Elc Co p.I c v J h s n 8 S r e , 25 3 0 9 0 7 1 t r 2 0 ) ct g a e . o , n . . o n o , 73 o. i 2d 118 1l ( a. 2, 95 Fl 2003). ) ii ui As t t cr umsa s of M a s s f l s ale t t s si o he ic tnce r hon' al, he lges ha he lpped on a Slq d, wae-ies b tn en a t es o p n c rsa tefo to teP e s s' Co . t 9 ,h tte trlk u sa c e r h h p i g a t t h r n f h r mie '( mpla ! ) ta h s t nc wasi r a l a r ntt busne si t es' t ti f e ubsa e i e diy ppa e o i s nvie , ha t t nded i 'wih t foor a not ' bl n' t he l , nd t a i tee o ec nsiu e aS a g r usa d h z r o c n ii n'(d.a ! l ) F eh M ake h t t h rf r o tttd t n eo n a ad us o dto ' i t 1. r s r t d a a s t c l nge w he he t s ale tons ar enough t de ons r t a dut and s a r of ppe r o hale t r he e l ga i e o m ta e y t nda d c r , bra h, n c usto b t e M as o sf l a d ij r Frt Frs M ake' d t a d ae a e c a d a ain ewe n rh n' al n nu y. is, e h r ts u y n sa r ofc r a e e t ihed ele r i t Com pli . The do nott n on t pos i lt tnda d a e r sabls s whe e n he a nt y ur he sbiiy oft rha ng bee br a d. M a s n c a t rz s he s fas a i i s i t e'a Fr s hei vi n e che r ho har c e i e r el t nes nvie ' t e h bus M ak tsd tr . ( mp .a ! 8 . S e t e rctst e lg lc n lso t a,ba e o t i r e' k o e' Co l t ) h h n e i h e a o cu in h t s d n h s s ' e r a i hi Fr h M a ke o d he ai y ofc r t m ant i t Pr m ie i a r as bl s f eltons p, es r t we r s dut a e o i an he e s s n e ona y a e c n iin a dt wan ge jo c n e ld p rl whc a eo s o l b k o t 'Fr s M ak t o dto n o r h r f o c ae eis ih r r h u d e n wn o' e h r e. (d.a ! 1 . W hie s l-e vng l lc l i t amo rs ue'a ot r s ifcual I t 2) l efsr i ega oncusons i r t e c ' n hewie la t ly c de i intc pl nt' Fau k r Adv r .As oc,I .v Nis M ot Cor ,9 F. 69 695 fce om ai ', l ne e t s . nc . s an or p. 45 2d 4, ( hCi.1 ) M as sc l i i butrsedby he alge sausasani tea Fr h 4t r 991, rhon' oncuson s te s r le d tt nvie nd es M ake' sa us as a 'sor ' Unde Fl i l w,ç l pr mi e owne s owe a dut t t i r ts tt ût e. ' r orda a i al e s s r y o her i t est exe c s r as nvie o r ie e onabl c r t mai ai t i pr m ies i a s e c ton. Owe v e ae o nt n her e s n af ondii ' ' ns . Pubi Su r kes l ,802So.2d31 320( a. ) Thepur t r lto hi heef l lx pe mar t, nc. 5, Fl 2001 . pored eains p r als wihi t s ope ofpr s owne dut M or br dl a lga dut i i t n he c emie r y. e oa y, e l y s mput d t a e o nyone who u d ra e a ' n e v r r ajce ts a g n r l e a fr s e b e rs o h r n oh r. n etk s n t d a o t t rae e e ai d nd o e e a l ik f amig te s' e h z ' Mc n v Fl Powe Cor ,593 So,2d 500,5 ( a.1 . I i pos i e,a las a t s cai , a. r p. 03 F1 992) t s sbl t e t t hi sag t tt we s bsa e wa t pr tofs t e, ha he t u t nc s he oduc omt e ndea by Fr h M a ke ' a nt a vor es r ts ge s nd t ti c eaed a' or ee bl zoneofrs 'o par ha t r t k es a e f ik't tons.1 d. Se cond,M a s s ii ly pl dsf wa i whih Fr h M ar t t ough is a t rhon pec fcal ea our ys n c es ke , hr t cs a d o sins b e c e i d t o ra o a l c r . ( mp . t! 1 ) F e h M ak td e no n miso , ra h d t uy f e s n be ae Co l a 3 . r s r e o s t s diput t ta of t e aci or i c i m i lad t is la lt l t a i es e ily s e ha ny hes tons na tons ght e o t ibiiy. nse d, t s nta l a gue t tunl s M a s r s ha e s rhon c n pr is la lt t a l lc ti t a ei i t a 1ot r a ove t ibiiy o ega era n y, nd lm na e l he e a to f he f l,s ha nots fcen l pl a br a ofis dut ButFr s M a ke xplna i ns or r a l he s ufi i ty ed e ch t y. eh r t c t t no ca es f t pr ies o s or he opos ton t t a t pl a ng s a a pl i i fm us e t bls t w e ii ha , t he e di t ge, a ntf t s a i h he t s t nc s i ecs l ton,' c poston, tsze or c r cers is' orgi ca e or t ubsa e' i ie oca i ' om ii pr ii ha a t itc ,' i n, us , he me ha c oft vitm' fl,( 1 a 6) Norc di.Se I alStelSu y Cor v An a, c nis he ci s al DE 0 t . oul t e de e ppl p. . z 8 6 2F,d 3 0, 2 - 4( Ci. 01 )( ititc ur d ma de lv lo pt digi o j siidby 5 3 1 3 3 2 2d r 2 1 d src o t e n d e e f la n i t u tfe n Twombl 'whe i f ule pli ifa s ri RI cli f om itng pr c s m e hani ofhow y' n t a t d antf s e tng CO am or ti e ie c cs she opeae ; eealo Vi onv Ve milon C/ , F. 924,930( hCi. 5 ( antf c me rtd) s s ns . r li y.776 3d 7t r 201 ) pli if alegngilgalpolc s rhofhomenotrquiedt i ntf i owhi wi l i le ie eac e r o de iy nt ch ndow ofie peee . fc r rd) Thi i e c l t t pe ofi or ton t tc n onl be il na e t ough dic y. k ie s s xa ty he y nf ma i ha a y lumi t d hr s over i c Not pe dn wo d b c mean l y i g rh n , t o tteb n fto ds o r ,we ef re t la ig ul e o ult f Ma s o l wih u h e ei f ic vey r o c d o i al e'wih pr ii t physca a ca a ati e oft a ci nti herc leg ' t ec son he i l nd us l trbut s he c de n ompl nt Lez ai . ter v RadintCr atonsGr ,l ,2:6-v- 4349. a e i p. nc. 1 c 1 DMM ,201 W L 7388357,a * ( D.Fl Dec. 6 t 4 S, a. 1 201 ( i e ooks J) 9, 6) M ddlbr , .. Thid,fom M arhon' de c i i of he si and-a l on ca r as r r s s s rpton r lp- f l, e n e onabl i e t t y nf r ha Fr s M a ke wa t a t l - as i c us -n f c - a pr m a e - as i V -or' or eh r t s he c ua n a ei a t nd oxi t n i f ' but ' u tnilfco'- c us o h rij re .S eSa lv Mer Da eCr.43 So. d 1 ,1 - 8 s bsa t a tr' a e f e n u is e th . to. d y , 8 2 4 7 1 s a ( 1 . r DCA 1 8 )(x ann t ebiu c td c n e to c usto g n rly .l i r a o a l F a 3d 9 3 e pli ig h f rae o c p f a ain e e al) t s e s n be t as o s ume t tt f lwoul notha oc r d a e t we s t nc a t tShe e wasa ha he al d ve cure bs nt he t ubsa e nd ha i r t n tr ld rc, n c n iuo ssq e e' ewe nt f la dt eij r .Sah, 8S 2 a 1 au a, ie t a d o tn u e u nc 'b t e he al n h nu y t l43 o. d t 7 ( tngPo v Pi e t la Lumbe Co. 1 So.24227,230( a.1s DCA 1 0).Tot quoi pe . nk ron-i ys r , 20 Fl t 96 ) he e e Fr s M a ke r le on t s xtnt e h r t e is he uppos vag ed uene s of t f l' cic sa s as t t s s he a ls r um t nce o hi elm e t t ta gume i f ec os d f t s m e r a ons saed a e n , ha r nt s or l e or he a es t t bove. Ac or ngl dim is c di y, s s al i notwa r ntd ba e on t i ufi i y ofM a s sa lgatonsconc r ng t na ur o t s ra e s d he ns fcenc r hon' le i e ni he t e f he ha a d an t cic sa esofherf l. z r d he r um t nc al Fr h M ake ne a gue t tisdut t wam c d notbe ti r d wihouta e es es r t xt r s ha t y o oul rgge e t n xpr s ale ton t tt we s tnce was t onc l d' orç dde ' I i no enough,ac or ng t lga i ha he t ubsa i ea e ' i c hi n. t s t ' c di o Fr s M a ke , f M a s eh r t or r hon t de c i t s t nc as lno r diy a e t busnes o s rbe he ubsa e i t ea l ppar nt o i s 9 ivte . ( mpla ! 1 ) Bu F e hM ak td e n tp it oa a tort wh c sae ta a n ie s' Co . t 1, t rs r e o s o on t ny uh i ih tts h t ' y ne i enc cli wil 1e onl whe a c glg e am l i y n ompl nt us c ran m a c wor . Agan,notc ai es e ti gi ds i ie pl a ng ha d a e di s one way wih ihe hype -e hni c pl di of a pas. Re nik,693 t s t rt c cal ode ea ngs ges t' s c ' F. a 1 3d t 324. l i tue t tal ndowne i o i td t wa n i t esonl oft e ûlt pe is t s r ha a r s blgae o r nvie y hos iaent rl whih a e known ors d be known t 'hi butnott i t s c r houl o' m he nviee .Shoe v Gibe t 436 So, n . l rs 2d 75,77( a.1 ) s eJ/' StJo e 'Hos v Cowar,891So.2d 1 1 ( a.2ndDCA Fl 983 ; e ) . sph s p. . t t 039, 042 F1 200 (f dut t wa na ie onl whe t lndowne ' knowl oft da ri s rort 4) i y o r rs s y n he a a rs edge he nge s upe i o he he i s a e o e r or ni s ton t busne si te'' .Butwhet rt perli so lt ntast r quie f ew ar ng i aquesi he i s nvie s' ) off c ,Shoen,436 So.2d a 77,no nome aur He e M arhon des i t we s t ce at t t nclt e. r , s crbes he t ubsan a i r a l appa e t busnes i iee ' be us i i sl a e o t g ound a blnde s i e diy not r nt o i s nv t s' ca e t i wa oc t d n he r nd e d i wih c r t itcsoft tooroft Prmie .' ( mpl a ! 1l . l rquie noextnsve n t haacersi he l he e s s' Co . t g ) t e rs e i pa sng t r a ona y i er e t e t r as ale tons t t t s t e was thi n' r i o e s bl nt pr t hes e ms l gai ha he ubsanc i dde ' , $ o c aC ' Sae t, û a ul g d' o a a j ci ewi asmia c n o ai ns M as o ' $ n e ld' ' tn ' ' mo ta e ' r ny de tv t i lr o n tto . rh n s C l ' c h , , tr nol i de crbi t ha a dousc toni t r f e no a g ound f dimi s . e mi ogy n s i ng he z r ondii s he e or t r or s s al Fi l Fr h M a ke a gu t t t Com pl nt f l t pr de s naly, es r t r es ha he ai ais o ovi uppo tng f c s f ri a t or M a s s c am t t Fr h M a ke ha c tuc i notc of t we s t nc Ye t rhon' l i ha es r t d onsr tve ie he t ubs a e. t he Co pli tsaest tt ç m a n t t ha he i dange ous a ha r r nd za dous c ton e sed f s h a l t oftm e ondii xit or uc eng h i t a g e h Ma k t k e o i t e e e cs ofr a o a l c r ,is e ton a d mane n e h t Fr s r e) n w, r n h x rie e s n be ae n p ci n itna c , 5 I is Re y, Fr s M a ke bal a t noton t t t Cour m i m a ç ea ona e n t pl eh r t ks t he i ha he t ght ke t s bl r i ernc s'onM a s sbehaf ( 1 a 4) Buts l asa i e e e i dei d fom t nf e e ' rhon' l. DE 6 t . o ong n nfr nc s rve r he pla ngs i a t lc t t't si pr c s l wha Rul 8r quies l ,556 U. a 678. Tha e di ' ç c ua on en ,' hi s e iey f t e e r . qbal S. t t ot er r a ngs of t r e nt t nns ar t e i aly pos i e does not pr ve t Cour f om h e di he el va e e heor tc l s bl e nt he tr a c ptng a pa tculr one t fows nat aly fom t t xt An r on ATwJ L. . v.Am. ce i ri a hat l ur l r he e . de s c , L C. Me a,l c.680F. 1 1 85( Ci. 2)(i c eplusbiiy i asa dl rt n di n , 3d 62, 84- 2d r 201 ûBe aus a i lt s tndar owe ha p o blt agv n sto a to sma wel es b e tt diegngitr rtto s e c o whc rba ii y, ie e f ci n y l b u j c o v r i n ep eain , a h f ih i pl usbl The c ce b we or among pl usbl i er nce or s ena i i one f t s a i e. hoi et en a i e nf e s c ros s or he fcfn e . .no f r tec u t naRue1 ( )6 moin.)(ne n lctto somi e ) a tid r g t o ) h o r o l 2 b ( ) t ' itr a iai n o ' t d. t 10 hon s ha ls n oc y s ud h v k o o i e itn e' (#.a ! 1 ) M ars alo averst tspil i gr er ho l a e n wn f t xse c v f t 4 . s ' sors ae s fe tast be f esea e t Frs M ake. (#.. I Frs M ake' viw, t e r o rquen o or e bl o e h r t f ) n e h r ts e M a s mus s cult t a o toftme t s t e ha pool on t foo prort he r hon t pe a e he m un i he ubsanc d ed he l r i o r si o e s a nc s lp, r le dva e ome ot r e de e of c t c i notc Thi t or sr t hes t he vi nc onsm tve ie. s he y te c he pl a ng sa r t f . The El ve h Cic thashe d t ta neglge e ca m pr m ie on a e di t nda d oo ar e nt r ui l ha i nc li e s d dut t wa n - whih i oneoft du i M a s post - mus ale çf c st woul s yo r c s wo tes r hon is t lge ta t hat d uppor t (h d fn a ts a t a o c nsr cie n tc ofd ng r' Mo ee v Ca nv lCo p. 5 3 F. te ee d n'l cu l r o tu tv oie a e. ' s ly . r ia r , 9 App' 8 893 ( 1h Ci.201 (fsmi dititc tsa i tonofZio novchelme s x 90, 1 t r 4) atr ng src our' pplcai vji i e nt t martmene i nc cli . l M o ely,t pl ntf di no pla a fcswhas ve t t o ii glge e am) n s e he ai if d t e d ny a t toe r ha tn e t s o ta t ed fn n cu s o eao s oudha ek o a u ars o ij r . l . e d d o h w h t h ee da t r ie p rtr h l v n wn bo t ik f n u y d a 892. Her , on t ot r ha M a s t e he he nd, rhon do pla a f c ua bass f Fr h M a ke ' es e d a t l i or es r ts consr i knowldge - t lngt of tme fom t s t nce s a a anc untl he f l tuctve e ht e h i r he ubsa ' ppe r e i r al. ( mp . t 1 ) Ia n tp ru d d ta s emu tg frh ra dpip itt ee a titr a. l Co l a ! 4 . m o e s a e h t h s o u te n n on h x c n ev l t woul be s i i i d i a si a f lpli ifc d de e mi t s i or ton wihou d umrsng ndee f lp- nd-al a ntf oul t r ne hi nf ma i t t t ai ofdic r Be aus a pli ifs k ea ng bu de s d be c mens a e wih t he d s ove y. c e antf i di pl r n houl om ur t t he a mount of i or a i a ia e' t he ,St i unr as bl t r uie' he t pl d tmi nf m ton val bl ' o r ' s e ona e o eq r ' r o ea i ng i cicumsa st ts c n l r i y t ough dico y. Olon v Champai C@. 78 F. r t nce ha he a ea n s onl hr s ver ' s . ' gn , 4 3d 1 9 1 0 ( t Ci. 01 )(n en l i to a dq oaino te l6 0 3, 1 0 7h r 2 5 itr a ct in n u tto mi d . a t 5TheFl i ca ectd by Frs Ma k ,Wi Di eSt e,v M a ote 553 So,2d 21 ( a. orda s ie eh r et nn- xi or s . rc t, 3 F1 5h DCA 1 8 ) i n tt t e c nrr Ma c te smpy h l t a,a te s mmay j d me t t 9 9 , s o o h o tay. r ot i l ed h t t h u r u g n sag whe a pli iff ist a t e, n antf al o dduc evi nc oflhe lng h oftme t da r c ton e de e i e t t i he nge ous ondii e itdp irt teij r s t d fnd n wa e tte t j d me ta amatro lw,l a 5 3 xse ro o h nu y ' he ee a l s nild o u g n s te f a d. t 5 ' So.2d a 21 s alo Fl Stt j768. (eq rngpli ifs ng i i sesa il nt' t 5; ee s a. a. 0755 r uii antf ui û nes tblsune ' bus t pr acual or consr tve kno edge of dange ous c ton and pe ti pr of of o ove t tuc i wl r ondii nnitng o c tuci k edge t ough crumsa il evi nc s h a lngt of tme) Bu te onsr tve nowl hr ic tnta de e uc s e h i . th s tntve e dentar sa r f pr ig c tuci notc underFl i lw s ysno hi ubsa i vi i y t nda d or ovn onsr tve i e orda a a t ng 11 I s n um, t l e of s fct i t al ge i e v l be we n t we s tnce' he a k pecii iy n he le d nt r a t e he t ubsa s a ppea a a M arhon' f l i not ft lt herneglg e cai . I inAs a on t s ba i i r nce nd s s al s aa o i enc l m ls is l hi ss s a s de e lo nid. #. Rul 10() e b Se r t l Fr s M ar tm ant i t tpa a a 6 a 1 of t Compli vi a e pa a e y, e h ke i ans ha r gr phs nd 4 he ant olt F d. Ci , 1 ( ) Rue1 ( ) whc i r a i c nun to wihRue8 a( ) Fie p Civo e R. v P. 0 b . l 0 b , ih s e d n o j cin t l ()2 , k s . t f . Da ,7 F.d 1 phne 9 3 079,1 2 ( 1hCi.199 ,dema t tanypaa a s ti f t acam 08 1 t r 6) nds ha rgrph etng orh li be ii td a fra pr cia e t a sngl stofcrumsa s' Fed,R.Ci P.l b) I imie s a s a tc bl o i e e l ic tnce .' v. 0( . t f t r quies t t ex en S ng s wo d pr urher e r , o he t t t doi o ul omot c a iy,'t tl c cai f unde on a e l rt ' ha s h l m o ea d s pa ae ta a ton oroc r e e ...be sae i a s r e c . 1 Ruls 8 a 1 t k e r t r ns c i cu r nc t td n epa at ount' d. e ' nd 0 i wor t t r t r quie t pl a r t pr e hi c am s dic e e y a s i l s t t hi oge he o e r he e de o es nt s l i s r t l nd uccncty, o ha s a r a y c dic r wha he i ca mi a fa e a r s i pla ng. Fi e 79 F,d dve s r an s e n t s li ng nd r m e ponsve e di ' k s, ' 3 1 7 1 8 ( 1h Ci.1 96 (n en lctto a d q oain o t d . He e t ee i o y o e 0 9, 0 2 1 t r 9 ) itr a iain n u tto mit ) r , h r s nl n e tans to a is a one core pondi c r aci n t s ue nd rs ng ountf ne i nc Fr h M a ke c l s onl or glge e. es r t halenge y whehe t s i pa agr phsa es fce l lmie t asngl s tofcic sa s t r wo pecsc r a r ufi inty i t d o i e e r um t nce . Pa ag a 6 i one s enc l a me ey e t ihest tve i a oprae i t s r r ph s ent e ong nd r l sabls ha nue s ppr i t n hi dsrc b sdo t elc t n o F ehM ak t n t ealg dt ri u a t.( mp . t 6 .ld itit a e n h o ai f r s re a d h le e o to s cs Co l a ! ) o o nots ehow t ss nt nc c n be c tu d t mi cr umsa s e hi e e e a onsr e o x ic t nce . Pa ag a 1 i l rbu i alo notpa tc ary difc tt compr hend. l r a : r r ph 4 s onge t s s riul l fi ul o e t e ds The lqui wae -i s tnce on t toor of t pr s whih i d, tr lke ubsa he l he emies c consiut d adange ousa ha r tt e r nd za dousc ton e se f s h al ngt oftme ondii xit d or uc e h i t t Def nt knew, or i t e r s of r as bl ca e i pec i a ha enda n he xe cie e ona e r , ns ton nd m ant ne s d ha known of is e se e. M or ove s ls a we i ena e, houl ve t xit nc e r, pil nd t s t nc o t toor of a gr e y so e occ wih s h fe ncy t tt ubsa es n he l oc r t r ur t uc r que ha he a t pladi sa r frale n i u rfde a lw. Br bout he e ng tnda d o lgig t nde e r l a own,8 F. a 773 (bsr ng 3d t o evi t t e e a 1w c n r l p e dngrq ie n si die st a to s . ha fd r la o to s la i e ur me t n v ri cin ) y 12 lqui wae -i s t nce o t too i a a e whe e pa r feque l wak i d, tr lke ubsa n he l r n n r a r tons r nty l wasf es ea et De e nt or e bl o f nda . ( mp .a ! 1 ) Asdic s e a o e t i p r g a h a d e s ste e tn ofF e h Ma k ts Co l t 4 . s u s d b v , hs a a rp d r se h xe t rs r e' a ua or c tuc i knowldge c e ni t we s t nce o t foor Fr s M a ke ct l onsr tve e onc r ng he t ubsa n he l . e h r t de lne t c tl uet 'muli ecrumsa /li ' t tt spargrph rie ( 1 a ci s o aaog he i tpl ic tncescams' ha hi a a as s. DE 0 t 9 .Cetil Paa rp 1 i n ti n ta emeeyb c u eio fr t d sic ra o swhy ) rany r g a h 4 s o mpe erbl r l e a s t fe s wo itn t e s n a ij r wo l b f r se bl.Be a s n c aln e a p c o t eCo liti s c n u ig n nu y u d e o e e a e c u e o h le g d s e t f h mp an s o o f sn as t pr ven Fr h M a ke fom unde sa ng t cli a f mul tng a r s e,t o e t es r t r rt ndi he a ms nd or ai e pons he Co ants ul notbedimisdunde Rul 1 b) mpli ho d s se r e 0( . f. Rue1 () ' l 2e Rul 1 ( al apa t t d vef amor defniesae ntofapl di 'whe t t e 2e) lows ry o l mo or e i t ttme ea ng' n ha pla ng i ls va orambi uous t tt pa t c nno r as bl pr pa e a r pons ' Fe e di s io gue g ha he ry a t e ona y e r es e. d. ' R.Ci P.1 e . Frs M ake aguest t s d t Complitnotbe dimisd,a mor v. 2() e h r t r ha, houl he an s se e de i t satm e i nec s r lha ale dyexpl ne t tFr h M a ke hasno i ntfe a fnie t e nt s es a y. ve r a ai d ha es r t t de ii d ny c ompon oft Compli tt ti va or a guous As a c eque e,M arho i not ent he a n ha s gue mbi . ons nc s n s r r d t pr dea mor defniesa e nt Ac or ngl i i equie o ovi e i t t t me . c di y,t s ORDERED a ADJUDG ED t t The Fr s M a ke , I ' M o i n t Dim is nd ha eh r t nc.s to o s s Pli ifs Amende Compl n or Alenai y,fr a Mor Dei t Sttme ( 1 i antf d ait tr tvel o e fnie ae nt DE 0) s DENI . ED DONE AND ORDERE i Chmbr a WetP l Beq .Fl i D n a es t s am ah- or . , i s y-dyo ea f Z/ . . , J nua y,201 a r 7. . . . . -. y gd'a /2 1 ? ' D A LD M . I D LEBR OO K S M D UN I TED STA TES D I STRI J DG E CT U cc: Couns ofRe d el cor 13
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
