Hargett v. Board of Trustees of Florida Atlantic University, No. 9:2015cv80349 - Document 193 (S.D. Fla. 2016)

Court Description: ORDER AND OPINION GRANTING DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT granting 113 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks on 11/8/2016. (lan)
Download PDF
Hargett v. Board of Trustees of Florida Atlantic University Doc. 193 UNI TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI O F FLORI CT DA CASE NO :1 c 80 5- v- 349- l M DDLEBROO KS& M NNON HOLLY HARGETT, Pli if antf, FLORI ATLAN TI LJ I DA C N VERSI TY BOARD OF TRUSTEES, De enda . f nt / ORDER AND O PI NION GRANTI DEFENDANT' M OTION FOR SUM M ARY NG S JUDGM ENT THI CAUSE comesbef et Cou ton Def ntFl rdaAta i Uni r iy Boa d of S or he r enda oi lntc ve st r Tr t s'(i ' Moton f Summa yJ usee $FAU' ) i or r udgme (i oton',fld J ne23, 201 DE 11 , nt i i ' ie u M ) 6.( 3) Plitf Ho l Ha g t (tlr ef)fld aRepo s o J y 2 ,2 6 ( 1 4 ,o whc FAU an if ly r et d- g t ' ie la s n e n ul 8 01 DE 3 ) t i, h rpl do Au u t2 , 01 ( 1 2 .F rter a o ssae b lw, e i n g s 6 2 6 DE 6 ) o h e s n ttd eo FAU' M oi ni g a td e S to s rn e . 1 . Bac ound kgr Hag t h sb e a e o e o F sn e 1 881 ( OF! 5 . h b g nwo kn a a r et a e n n mply e f AU ic 9 . DS ) S e e a r ig s l rra a F Sltrirr Lo n (LL)De a t n i 2 00 (d al 6 . Sic c i ho , i a in t AU' n e l ay a I b b p rme t n 0 . I . t ) n e hl od d Ha gethass f r d fom epieps a c ton t tc us s z es (d. t! l. De pt tkn r t ufe e r l ys ondii ha a es eiur . I a ) s i a ig e media i t c r t m ,Ha g tcon i c ton o ontol ht r et tnuest e renc s i e . Ld.a I2 . Th s o c r o xpe i e ezur s l t J ) e e c u i t e f m s e ch of whi pr es dif r nt degr e of s tt r de ltton. n hr e or , a ch oduc fe e es hor-e m biia i M os t l s ntt Loca Rul 5 1a,FAU fld aSttme ofUndiputd Fa t t s meda a t Purua o l e 6.() ie ae nt s e cs he a y s he i tntM oton.( 11 .Hagetfl aSttme ofM ae i Facsi opposton( 1 ,o nsa i DE 2) r t ied ae nt tral t n ii DE 32)t whih FAU fld afcualrpl ( 1 ) Exc ptwher Ha geti r e a tona f t or c ie a t e y DE 61. e e r t ntoduc s ddii l acs diput t e r s by FAU,t Cour wilr f r s ey t FAU' St t me , whih i syl s es hos aied he t l e e ol l o S a e nt c s t ed C ' DSOF. Ha gets St e e i opposton,whe e r f r nce , i l be e ( ' ' r t' atm nt n ii r e e e d s a l d S F. FAU ' PSO ' ' S f cua r pl whe er f r nce i lbe e E a t l e y, r e e e d, s a l d A DFR. ' ' Dockets.Justia.com fe nty,t y m a f s a pei m a s i ur s (d. 1 ,d ig whc s tmp rrl l e r que l he nie t s tt 1 e z e , 1 ! ) urn ih he e o a i os s y c cous s ,( r etDe 31:-1 .Le sofe butno i r que l Ha getex renc a ons i ne s Ha g t po. 5 4) s tn, t nfe nty, r t pei es vaintt tc us shert brel l ef a prve she fom s a ng (hough s c sil ra ha a e o ity os ocus nd e nt r r pe ki t he an tl h a) ( e r, DSOF ! 1 Hag t De o.3114,21 2 - 5:) Th la tc mmo tp o s iu e ; r et p :- 4:4 21 7 . e e s o n y e f ez r ti g r Ha g t' b d t ma es d n u c nr la l j r s ( OF ! 1 Hag t De o 3 1 rg es r ets o y o k u de , n o to lb e ek . DS ; r et p . 2:3 l ) S mei s t es iu e ' rw o ta ltofg r e eg ' ( r t De o 21 1 1 ) Bu 7 . o tme , h ez rs s a u o hel n r y' Haget p . 6:0- 1 . t d ot rtmes s r nst wor i t a ey a tr ad. (d. t1 - 2) nno c edoe asiur he i , he dur o k mm dit l fe w r I a 1 1 .I as s ez e s b e u nl afd h rmoo ( r etDe o. 89 1 )o h ra ii t c n e tae( u s q e ty fe e d Ha g t p 21 :- 6 r e b ly o o c n rt DSOF !4 t ) . I t cal t ke Har t bewe n t t s ve m i es t r ove fom a s z e and up t t ypi ly a s get t e wo o e n nut o ec r r eiur , o t nt mi e on t r r oc asonan a we y nuts he a e c i mbul nc i c l , ( a e s aled DSOF!4 PS !4 . ; OF ) Ase ry a 2008 Har t i or al s , get nf med FAU of i st s wase l ptc t the s z es fcal hat he pie i, ha r eiur we e br hton by hi t e i a sr s' a t ts c i r d he de rme t be a r oug gh s nson nd tes , nd ha he onsde e r pa t nt o t ' sr s f wor e r e t tcoul pr te sul k nvionm nt ha d oduce s h a r a on. ( uc e di DSOF ! 7- HagetDe ! 9; r t po. 274: 275: & Ex.8 .Har t' ps hol s,Dr Gl Ros Caddy,contr dt thersrs 20- 7 ) gets yc ogit . enn s ime ha te s a a e y a e die ty as ocit wih he per e i ofwor a eve s ( OF!9 . nd nxit r r c l s aed t r c pton kplce nt . DS ) Stri o M a 30, 2011 Tr Chrsens (ç it on' be me Ha gets a tng n y , oy it on çchrsens ' ca ) r t' s p r io . ( u e vs r DSOF ! 1 ) Hag t fl ta fo te sa tof h r rlto s i wih hm, 1. r et et h t r m h tr e eain hp t i Ch itn o c mmu iae h se e to sp o l ( rse s n o nc td i xp dain o ry. DSOF ! 1 ) W i n sx mo ts Ha g t 2 . t i nh , r et hi d l ped t i pr s i t Chrse o wa be m i uni l tr eve o he m e son hat itns n s co ng quey iough' ortha s 'i hi ' i r h' n s te t n o h r ( r ame t f e. DSOF! 1 PS !3 Ha g t De o 3 :0 3 2:) S e iial,s ea e s 2; OF 0; r et p . 012 - 0 8 . p cfc ly h v r t Chitns ( )s hat rse on 1 poke a iy onl t r Hageti fo ofot r ( ngrl y owads r t n r nt hes PSOF ! 30. ;( b) 2) r us t e gewihhe onafindl ba i (d.;()pemitdc wor st ea l h a t i ef ed o nga t r re y ss i ) 3 r te o- ker o t unc t her d s sb tp e e tdh rfo d i s (d. t! 3 ,) ( )q e to d h rwo k i d ti (d. t! e k u r v ne e r m ong o i a 0c ; 4 u sine e r n eal i a ( 3 .) ( )b re h rfo e trn te sa flu g b f r wo k (d a ! 30. ( )t ok wor 0e ; 5 ard e r m n eig h tf o n e eo e r i t 9; 6 o k . a y fo h ra d r f s d t p o iehe tann (d. t! 3 . ;a d ( )rjce h rofe st wa r m e n e u e o r vd r r iig i a 0j n 7 ee td e fr o ) pefr a di o a ts (d a ! 4 ) On o Hag t' c re tc wo k r, Lynn G hannoum ro m d t n l a ks i. t 3 . e f r ets u rn o- r e s i (d a n u ' a d o e f r rc - r e ,Kwe iTr s (Tr s ', t tGed atdeposii t t i n o m', n n o me o wo k r Gh ) s os $ o s' esi $ ) ton ha Chrsens es ci l s r i ze a m ir na Ha get ( it on pe aly c utni d nd c oma ged r t. PSOF! 3 ) Hag tcamsta 0 . r et li h t pro t s r ng unde Chrsens , s wa a knowl d by pr vi s r s s as a ir o e vi r it on he s c edge e ous upe vior n exc le e oye 2 ( elnt mpl e. PSOF!24) . The Pa tes dipu e whet r Chrsens te t d f mal s di t s dipa a el fom ri s t he it on r a e e e ubor na e s r t y r me . ( OF! 1 ;PS ! 1 ) Hag t camst a Clitn o ( )a p id worplc p lce n DS 2 OF 2 . r et li h t u se s n 1 p le k a e oiis on s i i ton i onsse l alowi me t dic s pe s l m at r and s t but ocalzai nc it nty, l ng n o s us r ona te s pors rg r u l poiig wo n' c nv rai n ( OF ! 3 .) ( )j k d wi a d a td fin l io o sy l n me s o es to s PS c 0a ; 2 o e t n ce re d y h t wadsme (d. t 3 b ; 3 p c e o wo nmo eo tn(#) a ( )c iiie Ha g t a d o r n i a ! 0.) ( ) ik d n me r fe / .; nd 4 rtcz d r et n Gha nnoum ' wor pac de pie t i beng mor ef e e oye t a m ae c s k e, s t he r i e scint mpl es han l ompa a or rt (d. t$ 3 d . F c u tr ta Hag t h refp rev d Ch itns n t a mo e lnin l i a 0.) AU o n es h t r et e s l ec ie rse o o d r e e ty t wa d s meo Ch itns n' fmaes b r iae .( o r s o f rse o s e l u o dn ts DSOF! 1 ) 2. Ha get a s cai s a FAU diput ,t t Chrse on osr cied herbe a e ofhe r t lo l m , nd s es ha itns ta z c us r dia lt She al ge s ci ly t td i he s z e ,Chrse on woul sa ove herbut s biiy. le s pe fcal ha urng r eiur s it ns d t nd r woul notas ithe ,a t thewoul i tuc Ha g t' c wor r a pa s sby nott hel d ss r nd ha d nsr t r e ts o- ke s nd s er o p h rete , ( OF ! 3 h) Ahe h rs iurswee o e ,Ch itn o a la to c alg dl e i r PS h 0. . r e ez e r v r rse s n t e s n e l e y c lughe a i r f r nc t t br s s s t ne commen e $I s how you'e r ly, a d nd, n e e e e o he uies he usai d, t d, ç ee r eal 2 The Pa te de t t f a lt of Ha ge ts ol e ua i and t cic sa es ri s ba e he avor biiy r t' d val tons he r um t nc s r uroundi s ver l pr - it ns ng e a e chr s e on i i nt . One i i nc de s nc dent i ve H a g t ' r c nvol d r e ts a e dici nai c antagans he f r rs r s r Dawn Smih (d t ',i 20 ( srmi ton ompli i t r ome upevio , t $Smih' n 08. PSOF ) ! 2 ) Hag t c n e t t sc mpan t alg d rt l t r a to s e ltrs fe e whl 7 . r et o n c s hi o lit o le e eai o y cins h ae u frd i a e wor ng unde Chrse on. lwilnota es m os oft e e s ast a e notr e ntt ki r it ns l ddr s t hes vent, hey r elva o h pr s tc am s er e en l i . r al h rig y u s l. (d a ! 3 . . I a dto ,Ch itn o p mo tdy be a i ey e ly u t o ref' 1 . t 0i n d iin rse s n u re l c me k r n ' ) v ups t'whe a a bulnc was c l t as it Ha get ahe s s f r a s z e-elt d e' n n m a e aled o ss r t, r he ufe ed eiur r a e ij r (d. t 3 .) S ec ne d t a atrt a icd n , rse o o d rdhe t g h me nu y. l a ! 0k , h o tn s h t fe h t n ie t Ch itns n r ee r o o o , i s t ofhe i it nce a t tm e t ts was a e t c i wor ng. n pie r nsse t he i ha he bl o ontnue ki (d.. Smial, 1 ) i lry ac or ng t Ha get Chrse on doc he sc orva to l a tm e bas d on t tm e s c di o r t, it ns ked r ik cai n e ve i e he i he s ntr cov i fom as z e3- e n t ough healowe a he empl e t say on t cock pe e erng r eiur ve h l d not r oye o t he l whie e gi i no wor r a e a i te . (d.a ! 3 . . Fial,Hag t man an t t l nga ng n n- k-elt d ctvii s 1 t 01 ) n ly r et itis ha, duet t sr sfom Chrse o sb l ng a ha a s e , he s z esa wor bec o he tes r it ns n' ulyi nd r s m nt r eiur t k ome mor e fe nt4 (d,a ! 31. Du ig a u ds l e p ro u d rCh itns n Ha gets i s rque , I t ) rn n n icos d ei d n e rse o , r t ometme s f r d b t e f and sx pe i m a s i ur spe day. (d.. ufe e e we n our i tt I e z e r 1) On J nuay 1 201 Ha getsphyscin,Dr Adra Rodrguez s nta l t t FAU , a r 8, 2, r t' ia . ina i ,e eter o c utoni t tHa g t wa dignos d wih e l ptc s z e , whih we e irgge e by sr s'' a i ng ha r e t s a e t pie i eiur s c r k i rd t tes . ( OF! 1 ; d iu zDe o, 2 .Dr Ro rg e wrt t a iwa d d c l n c s ay' o DS 3 Ro rg e p Ex. ) . d iu z oe h t t s i ial e e s r 'f r me y Ha get: o be al d t se a y fom t sr s f e r nm e t r i c r ti t lowe o tp wa r he te sul nvio nt o egan ompos e t a d ur o voi g ig it Eplpi Sez rs' ( on no i tc iu e . DSOF ! 1 Ro rg t De o. 2 .W h n p e e td wihhe e ' ( 3; d iu z p Ex. ) e r sn e t r physca slter Chrse o - a co di t Ha g t - r ple t he di no lket i aofhe i in' et , itns n c r ng o r e t e i d hat d t i he de x se pn a y fo he d s ( tp ig wa r m r e k. PSOF ! 3 Ha g t De o 3 2: 1 ) At hs d p iin 4; r et p . 3 7-6 . i e osto , Cl se on c e d t the di no bele t sm e s e wa medi ly ne es ar be us of ui tns onc de ha d t ive hi a ur s cal c s y ca e t lte ' f l et defne wha consiut d ' te s' ( OF! 3 Ch itn o De o. 2 ) By he et rs aiur o i t tt e t r s . ' PS s ( 4; rse s n p 4-5 . Feb uar 201 Ha g tha de de nott pur uea ac m moda i . ( r y 2, r et d ci d o s n co ton DSOF ! 1 . 4) 3 i e us o e get a k o m eve zur PSOF ! 3Hesometmesr f ed t ltHar t t ke a wal t cal down and pr nta sei e ( 4) . . 4At de ii Ha g t t tfe t t s bei d Cl s e o c ii i d a piked on he poston, r et esii d ha he leve ui t ns n rtcze nd c r i e i lyt pr ntntonal o ovokehers z e ,( r etDe 437: 4) eiur s Ha g t po. 2- . 4 The ea tr Ha ge tr ce ve s a c r prma fom Chrse on r a i t he ofi e r fe , r t e i d por di e i nds r it ns eltng o r fc de or m a br k ha t . On M a 2 , 20l Chrse on r prmande he f ralege y c li c u nd ea bis y 4 2, it ns e i d r o l dl a lng Fl i gove norRi Sco ta l s hol,' s yi s ha e hi ,a expr s i t wih t t orda r ck t n s s e ' a ng he t d m nd a e sng he s ha s me n wo l s o thm. ( o o e ud h o i DSOF ! 1 ;Hag t De .Ex 1 ) Th Pate ds ue wheh r 6 r et po . 0 . e ris ip t te 6; R 6 Ha getacualy s i t s t ngs5 ( r t t l ad he e hi . PSOF ! 1 DF ! 1 ) Thr e days lt r,on M ay 27, e ae , Hagetand Ghan um ha ameei wih Dr W ila M ilr($ ilr',t dea oft FAU r t no d tng t . lim le $ 1e') he n he M lbrre ,t c i a is o ompl i a an boutChrse on' be or ( OF ! 3 ) W he te rt r e t te itns s havi . PS 5. n h y eu n d o h ofi e,Chrse on wa ne t m vi ema lt tt y f e t ie- ' i t y di nota e t fc it ns r d he a i ha he ac d ' t ups' f he d wr dher o b e k polcis (d.. On Septmbe 1 201 Ha g twa a n rprma ra i e. 1 ) e r 3, 3, r et s gai e i nded,t stme f hi i or ga a ' el l i k DSOF! 1 & Ex M) usng1c udeand vul rl nguage' on at ephonecal durngwor 6 ( i 1r 7 . . . Ha g t' fr tdia lt a commoda i r que tc m e on Oc ober 1 , 201 f l ng a r e ts is s biiy c ton e s a t 7 3, olowi S p e t 1 me tn wi o fc asi t eEq a Op o tnt P o rm ( e tmb r 7 eig t f il n h u l p ru i r g a EOP)o tc . ( h y f e PSOF ! s 3 . The r s s 6) equet oughta tona daiy la tme i o de t c ddii l l e ve i n r r o ompos he sl t a d a e ref o voi s iu eort rcove f l ng o DSOF! 1 .FAU g a t he t nt mi espe dayf ez r o e r olowi ne.( 5) r ned r we y nut r or te e p r o c . ( SOF ! 1 ;DS Ex.F a 3 . Att e S p e r1 me tn ,Hag t as h s up ss P 5 OF t) h e tmbe 7 eig r et lo c ompl i d a utChrse on' ha as me ,dici i a he r s tng sr s. ( OF ! 3 ) ane bo it ns s r s nt s plne, nd r e uli tes PS 6. l r pons FAU i or e he t t dici i r polc a e n ts e, nf m d r ha s plna y i es nd xpec ai of pr es i im ttons of sonals a pl d t ale ly e ,r g r ls o ds bit sau . ( R ! 3 ;DSOF Ex.F a 3 . p i o l mp o e s e ade s f ia l y tt s DF ( 6 e i t ) 5 Ha ge t r f e t sgn her r prma whi woul have a knowl d Ch it ns s r t e us d o i e i nd, ch d c edge rse on' c rctrz tonoft i de , ( r t De Ex.1 ,Ho ve,t ofHagetsc wor r haa e iai he nci nt Haget po. 0) we r wo r t' o- kes sgne t doc nt (d.. Afe rcevi t rprma Hagetd atd amo ei uous i d he ume . I ) tr e i ng he e i nd, r t r fe r nnoc a oun oft e s whih t difr ntc wor r sgne i s cc t he piode, c wo fe e o- ke s i d n uppor. ( getDe Ex. t Har t po. 11. ) 6A cc di t H a ge t t c l r l e t pot n i li ntt t t ove w hi H a g tr a l s or ng o r t, he a l e at d o e t a de iy hef , r ch r et ec ls he wa aSnevouswrc ' ( r t De 353:) Thest tonpr s ir e k. Haget po. 5 . ' iuai ovoke he t us ai g t d d r o e i h-one hi v c '( not i herveri t cus . ( r et De 359:7- 9) Agai Haget rf e t oie' but , n son,o re) Ha g t po. 1 1 . n, r t eus d o sgnt rprma ( i he e i nd DSOF Ex.M)a dipueswhehe he beha o wa i ppr it ( nd s t t r r vir s na oprae. PSOF !1) 7. Howe ,Ro n Ka t(ç ba') AsocaeDiecorofHuma Re oures t d Chrsens t ver bi ba kKa t', s it r t n s c , ol it on o ke t I De rment i sr sfe a pos i e' t ep he LL pa t i tes -r e s s bl, ' hough Cl sens s own s r ior as ui t on' upe vs , Da Smih (dmi ' ,dr ce hm t d o tn eo rto sa n r l' ( rse on De wn t i t ' ie td i o i ni u peain s o ma ' Ch itns S h) c po, . 1 0 12 ; PS ! 3 ) Hag t alg s ta a r ti a d o h r me tng wi FAU 2 :- 4 OF 7. r et le e h t he h s n t e ei s t h ad i sr t s Ch it ns e c a e hi bulyi a ha a s e . ( m nita or , rse on s alt d s l ng nd r s m nt PSOF!32) . On Aprl29,201 Ha getha a ve ba e ha wih a he de rmente oye , i 4, r t d r l xc nge t not r pa t mpl e Jlin Borot C: t ') whih se d fom Boro ' t ila t Borot', c tmme r tts emporr asumpton of s ay s i ome of Hagets dutes? ( r t De 374:2- 8 . Latr t t da Borot c ai d t r t' i . Haget po 1 382:) e ha y, t ompl ne o . Ch it ns t tHa getha t eae d a ver ly a e he . ( rse on ha r t d hr tne nd ba l bus d r DFR Ex. . Thene day, F) xt Aprl 30. Chrse on wr e Har t an e al c di her f i lng' a Borot i a i it ns ot get m i, hi ng or i i ' t yel t n n S bur t'and r m i ng he oft ne t ' c pr e sona l .' ( s out ss' e ndi r he ed o i t of s i ly ' DSOF ! 1 HagetDe . a 8; r t po Ex.1 , Afe Hagetrceved t e i,s confontd Cl se o a Borota t r 3) tr r t e i he mal he r e uitns n nd t bout hei c r ce ia i of he be vi t da bef e. ( ha a trz ton r ha or he y or DSOF ! 1 ) FAU c e ontnds t t Ha get ha r t 8. be a e l ud a belge en wih Cl sens n a Borot a t the c c m o nd li r t t ui t o nd t , nd ha r onduc dir e t t supt d he wo k lc .( OF! 1 ; r etDe o. .1 ) Ha g t rc lst a i wa Ch itn o wh g t r pa e DS 8 Hag t p Ex 4 . r et e al h t t s rse s n o o a y a t ts wa me el defndi he s l and s i tng a c r a i ac ount fom ngr nd ha he s r y e ng r e f olcii orobor tng c r Ghmmoum.( r t De 383:8- 4: .Ha g t, n iiaigt eo s to as iu e( Haget po. 1 38 23) reta tcp tn h n e f ez r PSOF! 20)t n lf t of ewihoutChrse on' a t iai ( r t De 385: 10& Ex 1 . ,he ethe sc t itns s uhorz ton. Haget po, 34) . On M a 29, 201 Ga y Pe r I e i Pr vos, notfed Ha get t t he a M ilr we e y 4, r ry, nt rm o t ii r t ha nd le r pr i a t ee da s pe i f he be vi on Aprl 30 a t a c oposng hr - y us nson or r ha or i nd he c umul td ea ler ae ri 7Asa r s l o Hag t h v n r c n l s tie a s iu e id c d a ke ij r , Chrsens e ut f r et a i g e e ty usan d ez r -n u e n l nu y i t on die t d Bo t t compl e s e ofHa getsm or physc l dema ng daiy t s . H a ge t rce rot o et om r t' e ialy ndi l a ks r t cli t tChrse on ha cea e he a t be nni oft da t pe f m t e t ks a a ms ha it ns d l r d r t he gi ng he y o r or hos as nd t s wa diconc re when s la e fom Bo t t tCl se on had r as i hat he s s e td he e m d r rot ha ui tns e sgned t m . he ( r tDe 37 1 378:) Shede e a tngr l twadsBorot ( Haget po. 4:2- 8 . nis ci udey o r t . PSOF! 1 . 8) rp i nd .( OF! 1 Ha g t De o Ex.1 .Th s s e in wa i osd o J n 1 a tr e rma s DS ( 8; r tt p . 4) e u p nso s mp e n u e 6, fe ah ai .( e rng DSOF !2 ) 0. On Ju 1 201 bewe t da e oft notc a t de ii , Har t' couns ne 2, 4, t en he t he ie nd he c son gets el dr fe a lte t FAU diputng t ba i f s pe i and r qutsi t tFAU a omm odae a t d tt r o s i he s s or us nson e tng ha cc t h rds b ly. ( OF ! 1 & Ex.O) Hag t' a c mmo ai n r q e twa tr ef l ( ) e ia ii DS t 9 . r ets c o d to e u s s l e -od: 1 z f rmagll' t tCh itns n i e s hi h sie c n r nain wih'Hag t,wh c c u s l i i ri , ha rse o f a e s o tl o fo tto s t ' r et ih, o n e p y ' c al d,rs td i i i t tn' s z e a wor ( t tFAU û e iie' Chrse on it lege eule n i ght o e ' eiurs t k; 2) ha e ' nstz ' itns io s de ln wih wom e i ge r ,and wome wih e lps i pa tculr o ( mo ehm o to ( ai g t n n ne al n t pie y n ri a , r ) v i u f 1 Hagetsc i ofcomma ' a ( s t Hagetswor sain t a e y c cet be r t' han nd'; nd 3) wich r t' k tto o n mpt ubil o iu s e wih o j cslc i g s a c r e s't ee y rd cn t ers o ij yfo s iu e i mih d t be t a k n h m o n r, h rb e u ig h ik f nur r m ez r . f ' ( OF Ex O a 2- ; DS . t 3 PSOF I 3 ) Ha g t' c un e fx dtelte t Ka a o J n 2 , 01 J 8 . r ets o s l a e h etr o b t n u e 3 2 4. The e i no e denc t tFAU r ponde t t frtt ofHa getsr ss bu i di i t l r s vi e ha es d o he is wo r t' tque t , t t d nsal p d i gt Hag t' d s t mii z h rij r rs ( a d n o r ets e k o nmie e nu y ik. DSOF ! 1 & Ex. a 4 . 5 Ft) The s m e d t Ha gets lte was fxe t Ka t Cl se on pr par d an a ay hat r t' et r a d o ba , ui t ns e e a ndum t Ha g t' 201 pe f manc e l ton,whih putheron a sx- ont Pe f r a e dde o r e ts 4 ror e vaua i c i m h r o m nc I r v me tPln ( P) ( mp o e n a Pl , PSOF ! 3 ) Amo g oh rt ig , h a d n u ciiie Ha g t 8. n te hn s t e d e d m rtcz d r et frS y a sig t ec i o c mma d o mo tt a o e o c so d et ds aifdin wi o s p s gn ) h han f o n n r h n n c a in u o is tsa o t b h c n e i p lce o p o e u e . ( SOF ! 3 & Ex.1 a 5 .Th pa siultd i e ai ha g s n oiis r r c d r s' P ' 8 8 t ) e ln tp ae ,ntr l a, t tHaget()' l ve t ofie f pe s r s nsat t sa tofhe she e tme ha r t 1 t ea he fc or ronal ea o fer he tr not r c duld i e eptt us t r toom';( %manan a pr esi de nori t wor e r me , xc o e he esr ' 2) i iti of sonal mea n he k nvion nt bot i a outoft ofie' a ( S r on t boad a vebal noiy cowokeswhe h n nd he fc '; nd 3) t k he r nd r ly tf ma r r n s i la ngt ofie. PSOF!38& Ex.1 a 5 . he s e vi he fc ' '( 8 t) Bewe n Ap i a d Au us o 2 4 tr e i u p r Paa r f sin l ( P)p iin i t e rl n g t f 01 , h e s p o t rp o e so a ' S osto s n s ' t I De rme wee rcls iid a ' a mi Paa ofsi l'( he LL pa t nt r e a sfe s d de c rpr e sonas' AMP) ( Ac PSOF ! 40) . . The r cls iid poston e aie a hi r pa s a e t n t SP poston. (#.. Ha g ta e a sfe ii nt ld ghe y c l ha he ii / ) r et nd Gha nnoum ( pr s who eumabl weecl s a SPs weenots lctd f rcls i ai , t y r ased s ) r ee e or e a ssc ton hough Hag t a miss edd n ta py ( OF!22 b c u e i lg o h rn g tver lto s i wih r et d t h i o p l DS ) e a s , n iht f e e ai eain hp t Chrse on, s be ived doi s woul ha b n a t se.' ( r et De o 41 4 8 . itns he le ng o d ve ee ' t ' Ha g t p . 8:- ) wa Ha g t i is howe r t ts me t mi m um qua ii tonsf r lssfc ton. ( OF ! r e t mple , ve , ha he t he ni lfcai or eca ii a i PS 21,FAU c est t AM P postonc ane a tonalc iei t Hagetdi notme t ) ountr hat he ii onti d ddii rtra hat r t d e - na ey,hol ng a ba hel ' de e a ha ng u r m l di c ors gr e nd vi nde gone s i i d vocai ltani . pecalze tona r i ng ( OF ! 212 DFR ! 21 4 ) The tre e o e swho sl d t e AMP p iin wee DS ! -2) ! , 0. h e mply e l h e osto s r wome ( n. DSOF !22) Har tr mai t hihetpade oy i t l De rme ,(#,. . get e ns he g s i mpl ee n he LL pat nt f ) Ha get fld a dic i i ton cha ge a i t FAU wih t EEOC on J y 1 , 2014, r t ie s rm na i r ga ns t ht ul 7 a lgi g t ts e ince dic i nai ba ed on s x and dia lt , asw el asret i ton for le n ha he xpere d s rmi ton s e s biiy l ala i c mpli n a u ta d s rmiain ( OF!3 ) o anig bo th t ic i n to . PS 9. Hageti tae t saci on Mach 1 201 ( 1, She a nded he c ant r t niitd hi ton r 6, 5, DE ) me r ompli onc on Fe u r 1 201 ( 79,heei tr$ mpl') TheAme d Complitc ans e, br ay , 6. DE r nafe t Co . . ' nde an onti ni c s whih,f t pup os of t i t nt M oton,a e c i r a t e c us s of nt ount , c or he es he nsa i r onsde ed s hr e a e a to ( )ds blt d s rmi ain u d rTilsIa d 1 o t eAme ia wih Dia ii e Ac cin: 1 ia ii ic i n to n e te n 1 f h y rc ns t s blt s t i o 19 ( f 9 0 ADA)a d t e Re bitto Ac o 1 7 ( mp .! 3173 )( )sx d srmi ton n h ha l ain t f 9 3 Co l ! - ) 2 e ic i nai i u d rTil VI o t eCii Rih sAc o 1 6 ( teVI)(#. t! 8 - 5 ;a ( )rtlain n e te I f h v l g t t f 9 4 Til l f a 1 8 ) nd 3 eaito unde t ADA a Til V1 (#.a !!74- 8 92) I he Res e,Hagetas atmpt t r he nd te I / t 80, 6- . n r pons r t lo te s o r iea cai bas o a hosiewor e r e . as l m ed n tl k nvionm nt 8 I. I Le St ndar gal a d E c u ts alg a ts mmayj d me ti t emo n s o ta te e i n g n ie i o r h l r n u r u g n f h va t h ws h t h r s o e un The ds uea t a ymae ilfc a t mo a ti e tte t j d me ta amatroflw ' Fed. ip t s o n tra a t nd he v n s n ild o u g n s te a ' , R.Ci P.56a) The mova Sawa be st i ta r s nsbiiy ofi or ng t ditit v. (. nt %l ys ar he niil epo i lt nf mi he src c toft bass f is m o i n,a i ntf ng t e po tonsof çhe pl di , de ii , our he i or t to nd de iyi hos ri t ea ngs postons a we st i e r t i ,a admisonson tl , t t wih t afi t,i any,'whi h i ns r o nt roga ores nd si se ogeher t he fdavis f c t beleve de onsr t t a e e ofa ge ne is ofm ae i lf t' Ce otx Co p.v.Catet, i s m tae he bs nc nui s ue tra ac . ' l e r r t 4 7 U. 3 7 3 3 ( 9 6 ( u t F d R.Ci P.5 ( )1( ) W h r t n n mo n p ry 7 S, 1 , 2 1 8 ) q oi e . ng v. 6 c ( )A). e e he o - vig a t be r t bur n ofpr on a is a ti , t emo a tma smpl lp it ou t t edsrc a s he de oof n s ue t ral h v n y i y s on l t o h itit g c u t( ta t eei a a s n eo e ie c t s p r t en n vngp ry' c s , 1 at325, o r ) h t h r s n b e c f vd n e o u po t h o mo i a t s ae' d ' . Afe t mova ha me isbude unde Rul 56() t b de s hst t non- ngpa t tr he nt s t t r n r e c, he ur n hi o he movi ry t e tbls t tt e i a ge ne is of ma e i lf t M atus t Elc.l s Co. Lt v o sa ih ha her s nui s ue t ra ac . s hia e ndu . , d . Ze t Radi Cor s U. 574,585( 986) nih o p.475 S, 1 . Alhough a 1r as t l e onabl i er nce a e t be dr wn i f r of t non- ovi pa t , e nf e s r o a n avo he m ng ry Ande s n v fi ry Lobb I ,477 U. 242, 2 5( 98 ) t en n- vn pat d s d mo e r o . be t y, nc. S, 5 1 6 , h o mo ig ry l t o r mu t n sm pl s ha i y how t tt e i s ha her s ome me a t physc doubtast t m a e i lf c s' M atus t ial o he t ra a t . ' s hia, 475U . a 58 The nonS. t 6. movi pary may notr s upon t me ealega i orde al oft ng t et he r l tons ni s he a r epa t spl a ngs buti t d mus c dve s ry' e di , nsta t ome f war wih S pe ii f t s or d t i c fc acs howi t tt r s ng ha he e i ag nun is e o til'l a 5 7(iigFe R. v P. 6 e) é h r t er c r tk na s e ie s u f r ra . d t 8 ctn d, Ci. 5 (). i e e h e o d a e s ' W a whol c d not lad a rto ltir of f c t fnd f t non- ovi pa t , t e i no e oul e ai na re a t o i or he m ng ry her s ' ui i s f t i .' I i m e e Sc ntla'of e de e s gen ne s ue or ral'' d 1 A r s i il vi nc uppori t opposng pary' tng he i t s posto wilnots tce;t emus bee h ofas ngt tt j y c d r s na y fnd iin l ufi her t noug howi ha he ur oul ea o bl i f t tpat ' Wale p Dar y,911F. 1 3,1 77( 1hCi.1 .I t non- ngpa t or ha ry. ' kr . b 2d 57 5 1 t r 990) f he movi ry 9 f l t ma a s fc e s ais o ke ufi i nt howi on a es e i elm e of he c e on whih s ha t ng n s ntal e nt r as c he s he b r e o p o f temo i gpa t i e tte t aj d me ta a matro lw, Ceoe Cop. u d n f r o , h v n ry s n ild o u g n s te f a ltx r , 477 U. a 3 S. t 23. 11 1. D ie so s us i n 4. D iabiiy D i c i i i n s lt s r m nato z Har t fr t cl m s t tFAU dic i nat agans he on t ba i of a dia lt . get is ai ha s rmi t d i t r he ss s biiy ( mp . ! 3 - 3 .He c us o a to aie u e teADA, 2U. C. j1 01 1 1 , n Co l!I 17 ) r a e f cin rs s nd r h 4 S. j 21 - 21 7 a d be a e FAU i acove e e iy t tr ei f de a f c us s r d ntt ha ec ves e r l unds- t Re biia i Ac , Pub.L. he ha lt ton t No. 93- 1 87 Stt 355( ftd a 29 U. C.j79 . Cou t c 1 2, a . codii t S. 4) rs onduc aunia yanayssofcams t tr l i li unde t e sa ut bec e t s me sa dsg r ng ADA cli sa y t cli sunde t r hes tt es aus he a t ndar oveni am ppl o am r he Re biiai Ac. 2 U. , .j7 4() l lh! Smih, F. 1 ,1 ( 1hCi. ha ltton t8 9 SC 9 d ; ks ' t 231 3d 301 305 1 t r 2000) . . W her , a he t, a pli if it nds t pr e s r antf n e o ove dic i nai t ough cic t n i s rmi ton hr r ums a tal evi nc t cl m i a s s d a c di t t M c de e, he ai s s es e c or ng o he DonnellDougl famewor . Cl ean v as r k ev l d . Home Sho ng Net k,I . 369 F. 11 11 (1 t Ci. 2004) Purua t t t ppi wor nc, 3d 89, 93 1h r . s nt o ha fa wor t pl ntf be r t i talbur of pr ton t e tbls t elm e s of a r me k, he ai if a s he nii den oduc i o sa ih he e nt prma f c e ca e. I Sa if ng t e elm e s c eaes d pr umpton of dic i i ton,'' i ai s d. ts yi hos e nt r t t es a i s rm na i s fi t bu de t t empl erde e ntt ofe a lgii a e non- s rm i t y r a on f hitng he r n o he oy f nda o f r e tm t , dic i naor e s or t a r e a to 1 l t emplyer me s t s bur n,t t onus s fs ba k t t he dve s c i n. d. f he o et hi de hen he hit c o he e oy t r itar s bl i e e et tt empl r sr s i pr t xual I mpl tt o as ea ona e nf r nc ha he oye ' ea on s e e . d. 8The e i one as t of t Re biia i Ac t t i exc ptonal Because t A ct s st ut y r s pec he ha lt ton t ha s e i . he ' at or lngua r f r t dic i nai n is el by r as of'a dia lt , 29 U. C. 794( ) is a ge e e s o s rmi to iol y e on s biiy S. a, t c alt sa di mo ergor t nt ADA' ( chper t a fndi oflabiiy a ns aus iy tndar s r i ous ha he S whi mis i ng i lt gai t e oyeswihmuli emotves.Mc y v Oc a St mpl r t tpl i ) Nel , al arBannerCor ,9 F,d 1 p. 9 3 068,1 74 073- ( 1h Ci.1 9 ) Soe a v US.De ' o T e s r 3 4 F.d 5 0 5 - 0 (t Ci.20 2 1 t r 9 6 ; ld d . p t f r a uy 0 3 0 . 03 5 5 5h r 0 ) (xpli ng t tj d) t pr son i tn t ADA' i epr tve sa r ,doe not e ani ha 794( , he ovii mporig he S ntr ei tndads s o erd t epanln ua eo j 9 (),Th i o t f hsd sicini d suse if a n 1 . v rie h li a g g f 7 4 a) e mp r o t i itn to s ic s d nr s .3 To esa ih aprm af ci c s u ertt rt ADA ort Reha lt ton Ac , apl i if t bls i a e a c nd ihe he he biia i t antf mu ts o ta ()s e h sads b l y ( )s ei ai u lfe idviu l'i ta s ei i b et s h w h t 1 h a ia ii ; 2 h s i aiid n i d a, n h t h s i l o t q ' a p ro m te e s n ilf n to o g rpo iin wi o wi o tr a o a l a c mmo ain' ef r h se ta u cins f he sto ) t r t u e s n b e c o d to ' h h ; a d( )ted fn a ti na ul d s rmiae a an t( e)b c u eo tedia i t ' Re d v n 3 h ee d n t lwf l ici n td g is h r e a s f h s bl y. e . u y i ' HelCo, 0 F.d 1 5, 0 1( 1hCi. 0 0 . i .2 6 3 05 1 6 1 t r 2 0 ) Unlwf dic i n to icu t n tj s dip rt tt t n ,b tas f iig t ma e a ul s rmiain n ld s o u t s aae r ame t u lo aln o k r as bl r que t a commodai nst tdo no i pos a undue ha ds p on t empl r s e ona e e sed c to ha tm e n r hi he oye ' b ie so eain . 4 U. C. 1 1 ( )5 ( ;D 'n eo v Co Agr Fo d ,I c, 2 F.d usn s p rto s 2 S. j 21 2 b ( )A) A g l . n a o s n . 4 2 3 1 220, 1 ( 1h Ci.2005) Be us Haret pr e s t unlwf dici nai as t 236 1 t r . ca e g t esnt he a ul srmi ton wo ditnc t re - dipa ae te t e a f l e t a c si t heo i s s r t r am nt nd aiur o c omm oda e t wil a es t m l ddr s he s pa a e y. e rtl 1. Dipa a eTr a me s r t e t nt FAU ar s Ha g t f l t esa ih a prm a f i c e ofdiabiiy dic i nai . l gue r et ais o tbls i ace as s lt s rmi ton e mi e c dip e elm e o he prm af c ec e i t n. xa ne a h s ut d e nt f r i a i as n ur a. Diabiiy:Ther ar t e wa a ADA ( t rf eRe biiai Ac)pl ntf s lt e e hre ys n and heeor ha ltton t ai if c demonsr t he diabiiy.Ac r ng t t saut an tae r s lt co di o he t t e: Thet r l s lt m e ns wih r pe tt an i vi le m diabiiy' a , t es c o ndi dua - ( A) Ph sc l rme tli ar n ta s b tn ilylmiso eor y ia o n a mp ime t h t u sa tal i t n mo emao lf a t te o s c idviu l r j r ie ci is f u h n i d a; vi ( B) arc dofs hani r nt or e or uc mpaime ; ( C) bengr ar dasha ngs ha i ime ... i eg de vi uc n mpar nt 42 U. C.j 1 02( ) Ha getc tndst ts i dia e bec us he e lps s tntal S. 21 1 . r t one ha he s sbld a e r pie y ubsa ily lmiste mao l e a tvte o t p a i g (n )itr ci wi oh r' o i te atr aie i t h j r i ciiis f i e k n a d n ea t f s ng t te , r n h l n t , h ' e v be us FAU rgar herasbei i ied. ( ca e e ds ng mpar Compl !32) FAU rs . . e pondst tHa geti not ha r t s d sb e wihn teme nn o teADA b c u e whl i ard s ei n tl td i amao ia ld t i h a ig f h e a s , i mp ie , h s o i e n e mi jr 11 lf a tviy.N o a y,FAU do notc lt e Ha g t' i ie c i t t bl es halng r e ts nvocai n oft ç ega de as'br nc to he s r d ' a h r t s tsy t eds bit p o g Se Fi parc v Ci o l na 2 F.d 11 2,1 1 ( lh Ci. o aif h ia l y r n . e t tik , t fAta t, 3 1 1 6 1 t r i z y 1 3) (xpli ng t t movi pat mus ct t i enc of e de e t s ppor t non99 e ani ha ng ry t ie o i abs e vi nc o u t he movi pa t s c e' o ofer l fi tve e de e d ng ry' as ' r f i fnna i vi nc emonsr tng t t nona ta i hat he movi pary ng t wilbeuna et pr iscaea ti ' .On t tba i al ,t Cou tco dtndt ts l bl o ove t s t ral' ) ha ss one he r ul i ha ummay r j d me ta t t eds b l ypr n i u war ne . u g n s o h ia ii o g s n ra td t The e i a s e r s lo noug e de e i t r c d fom whi a r a onabl f dtnde v d h vi nc n ht e or r ch e s e a s r oul c u t tHa ge ts e lps s t taly lmis he a lt t s a t ot s whih i a onclde ha r t' pie y ubsan i l i t r biiy o pe k o her , c s mao lf a tvt u d rte ADA. 4 U. C.j 1 0 ( )A) $T1 e q e to ofwh t e a j r ie ciiy n e h 2 S. 21 2 2 ( . i h u si n ( eh r n i i i lsi i nti a dia lt und t ADA s d notde a e e i a l i .' nd v dua ' mpanne s s biiy er he g houl m nd xt nsve na yss ' Maz ov Col Re ol i I ',LLC,746F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci, ze . or s uton nt1 . 3d 264, 268 1 t r 2014)( tngj2( ( , quoi b)5) Pu L.11 25,S.3406) Themee e se e ofan i r nt s h ase lps doe not b. 0-3 , r xitnc mpaime , uc pie y, s a tmaial l ta mao lf a tvt Si o v Al.De ' o Hu n Re o r e ,31 F. uo tc ly i mi j r i ci i e y. mps n . a p t f ma s u c s 1 Ap x 2 4 2 7 6 ( 1h Ci. 0 9 ( e c ra , Ho v r Hag t tsiidt a h rt mos p' 6 , 6 - 8 1 t r 2 0 ) p r u im) we e , r et e tfe h t e wo t c ommon t s of s i es c us he t et r l e c c ous s e ie y or pr ve he fom ype ezur a e r o ihe os ons i nes ntr l e nt r r s a ng whieco ci . ( pe ki l ns ous DSOF ! 1 Ha g t De 3 1 311 21 24- 5:) Durngt ) r et po. 0:4- :4, 4: 21 7 . i he pe i wh s wa e rod tn he s xpos d t hi h sr s s e re ed up t sx pe i mals i ur pe da . e o g tes , he xpe i nc o i tt e z es r y ( OF ! 3 ) Th tkid o r g lr itru to t h r v r a a d me t lf c lis ag a l PS ( 1 . a n f e ua ne rp in o e eb l n na a ute r u b y rsrce h ra ii t c mmu iae e fciey wih oh r. S e eg. Mac a v Fr nf r etitd e b ly o o n c t fe tv l t t es e , . , tz k . a ko d t 9EEOC rgulto e t t i e rtt ADA Ame e ains naced o ntm e he ndme sAc of2008 ( nt t ADAAA) Pub.L. , 1 0 3 5 1 2Stt 3 5 ( 0 8 , r vieta ith tr iu sa tal l t's alb c n tu d 1 - 2 , 2 a. 5 3 2 0 ) p o d h t ' l e em s b tn il i s h l e o sr e l y mi br adl i f vor ofe nsve c r ,t t ma mum e e t pe te by t tr s oft o y n a xpa i ove age o he xi xt n nnit d he e m he ADA. i tntal lmis' i no me nt t be a de subsa ily i t s t a o mandi sa r ' 29 C. R. j ng tndad. ' F. 1 3 2 ' 1() Sinfcnl,t lgsaie hsoy o te ADAAA rv as ta Co ges 6 0.t) )i. g iia ty he e iltv itr f h ( e e l h t n rs s e iial dee te q'd cso t a h d f n s o t e s dc s iu e ç o s fi in l p cfc l i j cld ' e lins h t a ou d h r, pio i ez r s ' t u fce ty y r n lmii ' 2008 Hous J c a y Comm ite Repor a 1 -20. i tng. ' e udii r te tt 9 Ca d t Ch c lt Co,1 6 F.d 9 3 93 3 ( d Ci.1 9 )tu y q si n wh te panif n y t o oa e . 3 3 3 , 7- 8 3 r 9 7 'r ueto eh r litf wih s iu e o s o tdu ain a l td rsrcin s b tn il lmie i mao lf t ez r s f h r rto nd i e e tito s u sa tal i td n j r ie mi y a tviy) Otig v .C,Pe y Co, 223 F. 704,71 11(t Ci.2000)(pie i s z esof ci t ; tn ., 1 nne , 3d 0- 8h r e lptc eiur vayi s vert l tng bet en t ry s ondsa t mi t sbu whi h i pa tt d s e r ng e iy asi we hit ec nd wo nu e t c nca cia e pe ch a dmo e n poe tal l tdmao lf a tvt o s a i , mo o h r) n v me t tn ily i e j r ie ciiy f pe kng a ng t e s, mi FAU , c tng t a snc r peae EEOC r a i , 2 C. R. j 1 0. j( )i-ii ii o i e-e ld egulton 9 F. 63 2()2 ()(i ) (fe tv u tlM a 2 ,201 ) isss t a Ha g t' e i p y c n o s b tn ily lmi a y efcie n i y 4 1, n it h t r ets pl s a n t u sa tal i t n e mao lf a tvt b c u e te d rto o e c siu e i b if a d s e c n rc v r wi i j r ie cii e a s h u ain f a h ez r s re n h a e o e t n y h miue . Ho v r te c re tieain o te rg lto sae ta lan i anne tta i n ts we e , h u rn trto f h e u ains tts h t i j mp i n h t s l e s dco i rmison i adia ii i i wo l s b tnil lmi a mao lf a tvt wh n pio i r n e si s s bl y f t ud u sa tal i t j r ie cii e t y y a t eb 2 C. R.j 1 3 .()1( i)(mp a i a d d .Asds u s d Ha g t' s iu e ma c i . 9 F. v ' 6 02j( )vi e h ss d e ) ic se , r ets ez r s y l tamao l ea tvt wh n a tv . Ac o d n l,F ha n td mo srtd ta Hag t i mi j r i cii e cit c r i gy AU s o e n tae h t r et f y c otpr s i dia e ann ove he s s bld. b Quaiid I di d l FAU a g st a Ha g t i n tq ai d frh rj b b c u e . lfe n viua : r ue h t r et s o u lse o e o e a s s e i u a l t h n l ia ks( a)aepato te n r lworplc ti uainsa e s nil h s n be o a de k s t t r r f h o ma k a e rb lto nd se ta t h f tons of he poston, whih i ude r c vi i t ci , unde go ng pe f r a unc i r ii ' ' c ncl e ei ng nsm tons r i r o m nce rviws a a ce i i or lcii fom he s r ior ( 11 a 6 . Asevi nce e e , nd c ptng nf ma rtquts r r upe vs . DE 3 t ) de , FAU rfr t Hagetss fde ci r ssa e t Chrse on' ciiims( ees o r t' el- s rbed e itnc o itns s rtcs Compl! 20()& . a ( )and t t pope iy f he atr tons wih Ch itns t i e s zurs Har t b) o he r nst or r lecai t rse on o nduc ei e . get de e f nds he qualfc tons bas d on postve r vi ws s r c ve bef r wor ng f r ii ai e ii e e he e ei d oe ki or Chrs e on. it ns A 'qua ii d i vi l'i one who c n pe f m t çes e i lf tons 'oft pos ton d lfe ndi dua ' s a r or he i s nta unc i ' he ii iwih orwihoutras bl a ommodai . Re d,206 F.d a 1 . l i tue t til n it t e ona e cc tons' e ' 3 t 061 t s r ha ial 13 e o s a lt t ha e r s bl n es a y sr sand wo k r s bl wel wih ot r mpl yee' biiy o ndl ea ona y tc s r tes r ea ona y l t he s a ee s nta f tonsofan pos ton.Abs nc ofs h s lspr ve st e pl e fom bei r s e i l unc i y îi e e uc kil e nt he m oye r ng . . . ( lfed.' Wilamsv Mot ol I . 3 F. 1 4,1 91( 1hCi.2002)(mpha i quaii '' li . or a, nc, 03 3d 28 290- 1 t r e ss a d) But eve a ce i ar ndo FAU' c rdeiai of Ha get as a difc t ddt . n c ptng gue S haa rz ton r t f ul s di t Chrse on' own ad ndum t t pe f ma ubor nae, itns s de o he ror nce r ew unde m i FAU' evi r nes S poston t ts wasuna e t pe f m he posto se s nta f tons Alhoug Chrse on ii ha he bl o ror r ii n' s e i l unci . t h it ns hi i td ar asi whih Har dtne d t i pr ghlght e n c g ede o m ovt,he wr t,a t he dl Knowldg l ot s o r tob e e/ob S il/ aiyo W o k't a Hag t is ul c pa l o ro mig t e ed te .' ( OF Ex klsou l f r y h t r eti f l a be fpef r n h s u is' o Ps t ' i y b . 1 a 1 (mphass a d) Chrse on alo t tfed t tf t ye r 201 Hageti t 8 t)e i dde . itns s esii ha or he a 5, r t ' l meg e cai i alaras' ( itns De 1 22- .' Si et r i mor t n s sce xpe ttons n l e . Chrse on po. 28: 25)1 nc hee s e ha uf int ' e de vi nce t Ha gdt i q i d f he poston wiho an ac omm oda i s hat r s ualse or r ii t ut c ton, umm a y r j d me to teq aiidi iiu l r n i ia p o rae u g n n h u l e ndvd a p o g s n p r p it. f c Dicrm i i FAU a s c e t t t r pr of Ha gets prma f i c s . s i naton: lo ont ss he hid ong r t' i ac e a e, whc rq ie a ADA plitf t d mo srt ta s e wa s be td t u lwf ih e u rs n anif o e n tae h t h s u j ce o na ul d srmiaini e au el h ds blt ' Re d 2 6F.da 1 61(mp ssa de ) F frt ici n to i c s /t e ia ii ' e s 0 3 t 0 e ha i d d . AU is b y. a g t tHa gethasnots f r d a adve s aci r ues ha r t ufe e n re ton.Ne ,i ur st tHa gethasnots xt t ge ha r t hown t ta ale a r e a ton wa t ke b a eofadia lt ha ny lged dve s c i s a n ec us s biiy. Hagetrleso t e a re a tons:( )t wr uls penson,whih de i he r t ei n hre dves ci 1 he ongf us i c prved r oftr eda 'pa ( t f l et rcl sf heri o t hihe payi AM P posto and( h e ys y; 2) he aiur o e asiy nt he g r ng iin; 3) 1 Co eni louaiy of W or or niai - me Mana 0 nc r ng i lt k/ ga z ton/ ri geme , Chrse on s i s 's nt' itns ad he k ' i g n rly k o e j a l a o t h w t p o es maeil. (d.a 3. On h r i r e eal n wld ebe b u o o r c s tras' 1 t ) ' e d k Wo Pr tce / pe bliy,' f ac i s De nda lt ' he ound t tH a ge ti ide ndabl a s ha r t s i pe e nd hows u f a he a s g d p or t r s i ne tme' (d. a 4) Fi l wih r r t lcusome Sevi / a i ,' 1 t . naly, t egad o % t r r ceTe mwor ne s rltmeronal Skil/ ve st ' Chrsens wr t t tHa getksrve t pr degood c t e s r i et al lsDi r iy, ' it on o e ha r t 'ti s o ovi usom r e v c o l FAU c tt nt outi t de rme .'(d. t6) onsiue s sde he pa t nt' 1 a . 1 Anot r r s i i difc t t beleve t t FAU does not c i r Ha ge t qua ii d a a 1 he ea on t s fi ul o i ha ons de r t lfe s lbr ra i t tFAU contnue t e pl he - asalbr in. i a i n s ha i s o m oy r i ara 14 Chrsens n' l r tngs o Har t' a it o s ow ai n gets nnua pe f m a e e ua i ,whi ca ed he t l ror nc val tons ch us r o m isouton bonus .The ADA lsss s es it omepos i ea ea ofwo k ont whih dic i i ton m a sbl r s r o c s rm na i y i tu e s e iyn io a piain p o e u e , te hrn , a v n e n , o dic ag o nr d , p cf ig j b p lc to r c d r s h ii g d a c me t r s h r e f e ly e ,e lye c mp nsto j btan n , a dtec th l S t e tr , o dto , n mpo e s mpo e o e ain,o rii g' n h ac a ll h r ems c n iins a d ' o P iie e o e o me t' 4 U. C.j 1 1 a. l itmr t t e etr , on iin , nd rv lg s f mply n . 2 S. ' 21 2() n ne ei h s ems c dto s a ng prvie s c t a y t s m e pr ce nt us d t a l t a r e a tons of Til VI i lge , ours ppl he a e de s e o nayze he dve s ci te I cli . Doe v.De b C@,Sc Di . 1 F. 1 , 1 48 (11h Ci,1 . Thos ams Kal h. st, 45 3d 441 447t r 998) e pr ce nt hol t twhie Til Vl i sno r quie pr ofdie te e de s d ha l te l d doe t e r oof r c conom i c e nc s i c ons que e n a lc s s t a s re i pa tca l a e , he s e td m c nnotbe s c ai a mus a l a tha a t ngi e a r e pe ul tve nd t t e s ve a bl dve s efc o t epanifse ly n . Da i v F o a ePa k 2 5 F.d 1 2,1 3 ( 1h fe t n h litf mpo me t' vs . own fL k r , 4 3 23 2 9 1 t ' Ci.2001. Neg i c nges i t tr ,c tons orprvie s of e oymen mus, r ) atve ha n he e ms ondii , i lge mpl t t tee o e b o j cieyû eiusa dmaeil t c u .1 h r fr , e be tv l i ro n tra' o o nt d. s ' The Elvent Cicui has hed i s e cr e h r t l n om icumsa s t t a unpa d s penson tnce ha n i us i t e e e sa a s empl m e a ton. M c il v Fulon C@.Go ' 349 F.App' 440, ç pr s nt n dvere r oy nt c i ' M lan . t ' vt , x 442 ( 1h Ci.2009)( rcura (hit da s penson wihoutpa maeily a re ;s e 1t r pe im) t ry y us i t y tral dves ) e as Ru s l v Bd o r se so i.fll a Chc go 2 3F.d 3 6 3 (t Ci. 01 ( v lo sel . . fT u te fun v o l. t ia , 4 3 3 , 41 7h r 20 ) t e i da s; a sv Al De 'o r 41 F. p . d 1 71 1 7 - 7( . Al. 0 5 (e d ys. y ) Ev n . a. p t fco n, 8 Su p 2 2 , 2 6 7 M D. a 2 0 ) tn a ) The Se n h Cic t i Ru s l r as ve t r ui n s e l e oned t t a pe a y l s c bi ha cunir os om ned wih a f t onna l modii a i t one' e oyme r cor i a l vowe y dici i r 'c e nc t t i fc ton o s mpl nt e d s n i a dl s plna y' ons que e ha s mor t n 'ti a . Ru s l,243 F. a 3 - Buts pe i as s tasone day m a not e ha irvil' s e l ' 3d t 4142. us nsons hor y be m a e i lbe a e,i s e i t nce ,t ey r tec onl de m i m i l s . Em br v Calahan t ra c us n om ns a s h el t y ni s os es y . l Eye Found.Hop. 1 F.App' 81 8 ( 1h Ci.2005 ( c im)( da s pe i s , 47 x 9, 29 1 t r ) per ura one y us nson, wh r S s ( o sbe c mp n ai n ls wa $ 8.3'dd n tr a h tr s l) Hee Hag t ee i t p si ll o e s to o t s 8 7 , i o e c h e hod . r , r et mo 9 1 5 was s pe d wiho pa f t e days Beca e t Elve h Cic thas notde e nt us nde t ut y or hr e . us he e nt r ui t nni d pr ciey whe an unpa d s penso be omesm a e i ,Iwilas ume,wihoutde i ng, ha t s e sl n i us i n c t ral l s t c di t t hi qualfe a anadve s aci ii s s r e ton. Chrse on' f l e t r l sf Ha gets poston c d a s ha bee a m a e i ly itns s aiur o ecas iy r t' ii oul lo ve n t ral a r e aci n. l i wel esa ihe t t f ii t pr o e a e o e i a sgnii nt dve s to t s l t bls d ha a lng o om t n mplye s i fca o sin Bu ln o l d s,I c v El rh 5 4 U. 7 2 7 ( 9 8 . Re lsiyn aj b t miso . rigtn n u . n . . l t, 2 S, 4 , 61 1 9 ) ca sf ig o o e i r as ispay s l i a ogo t afor ng t opporuniy f rpr nc e e t ca e s nal us o f di he t t o omoton. Se M c i ik v i e clntc . Le t,Ci No.RDB 05288 2007 W L 92761 a *5 ( Md.Ma .26,2007)(mpl rs avit v. - 0, 6, t D. r e oye ' f l e t nomi t pli tf f r pe mane i r as i pay s ae c d be m a e i l a r e aiur o nae a n if o r nt nc e e n c l oul t raly dve s aci . Har t pr e sevi ncet tt AM P cl shad ahi rpa s al t n t SP cas . ton) get esnt de ha he as ghe y c e ha he l s Tha mea s may ha l tt c nce t at i a hi hers lr Howe r Ha g t wasnot t ns he ve os he ha o tan g aa y. ve , r e t qua iid f t AM P poston be aus s doe notdiput t ts di notha a ba hel ' lfe or he ii c e he s s e ha he d ve c ors d g e . Al o g Hag t issst a t j b dd n tr q r ti a dion lce e t l te e r e t u h r et n it h t he o i o e uie h s d t a r d ni , h h i a ce de e- s c fc l t i ii f ms' cla l con r di t he .2 See Ri e Lamarv Cj vi nc pe ii aly, he s ton or '- e ry ta c s rl pos @ . o Ft L d r al,23 F.d 8 6,8 2 4 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ) ( te VI p i fce s owi f , au e d e 2 3 3 4 - 3 1 t r 0 0 Til I rma a i h ng i mplt wihoutpr t templ wa qualfe f poston a is ) Furhemor,s nco ee t oof ha oyee s iid or ii t sue . t r e he di no e n a y f t r c a sfcai As a r ul,t r cls ii ton i nota ma e i l d t ve ppl or he e l s ii ton. es t he e a sfca i s t raly a r ea ton. dve s c i La ty,Chrse on' ne tve 201 pe f manc r vi s e e ed by t evaua i sl it ns s ga i 4 ror e e ew, upplm nt he l ton a ndum a PI doesnotqua iy asa m ae i ly a r e a ton. The El nt Cicui hol dde nd P, lf tra l dve s c i eve h r t ds 1 The i ii f m s'f t r cls i d e oye sat t i i m u qualfca i ' a 2 ' ton or ' or he e a sûe mpl es t e he s ni m pos m ii tons' s Hag t u desa d t e b t sp rtl ls i e ur lb t u ain Tr ii#Ex ein e' r et n rtn s h m. u e aaey it b q ie d c to / ann p re c . r Ed ' ( DSOF Ex.Q) One oft qualfc tonsundert thea ng i a S hel ' degre. (#.. . he iiai ha di s t bac ors e' /) ' Ha ge t of e s no e denc c l ng w he her t w om e who be m e A M PS f fle t r t fr vi e halengi t he n ca ul il d he addii ale atona r r m e . ton duc i l equie nt 16 t tapero ma r vi whih icl ha f r nce e ew c n udesi l dl unf ' ege y ounde c ii s 't tha S t ngi e al d rtcim' ha s ç a bl no i c on t t ms c tons orp i l soft pl mpa t he er , ondii , rviege m oymtnt'i nota tona e. Davi,245 F. 's ci bl s 3d a 1 t 242. l i tue t t whe a evaua i i pos i e s d s r so a aler a t s r ha n n l ton m es ncr a e upe vii n nd t s n e oye s pa - i l ng wihhol ng a dier tona y bonus - t a ton may be m ae ily mpl e' y ncudi t di s ei r he c i tra l a e s Be rv Mi Shor s Vilge,578F.App' 8 824 ( 1h Ci.201 ( c im) dv re. nde . ami e la x 22, 1 t r 4) per ura ( oye de i ng t g a t bonus ca i t or be maei l a re a tonl Smih v. empl r clni o r n n, n he y, traly dve s ci ; t Qun i sT an n in lCop. 5 F.S p 2 1 93 1 0 ( . F a 2 0 )(i dngP1 t b itl r s at a r . 09 u p. d 1 , 2 3 M D. l . 0 7 fn i P o e e o ma e i l a r e,i pa tbe us i de a d i r as s r son a t mpo arl de i d t raly dve s n r ca e t m nde nc e ed upe vi i nd e r iy prve pl nifofpa r s sorbonus s. aitf y aie e) Ne rhees ,a pl n if who cam s t l a l rpe f ma e r tng de i d he of a ve t l s aitf li ha owe r or nc a i prve r b n smus ito uc mo e ta i e o s l-e vn alg to s)t a s wo l h veb e ou t nr d e r h n s r wn efsr ig le ain l h t he u d a e n h g r nted'onebutf t qualt oft r e Cai v Ge e 261F.App' 215 21 ( 1h ua a e ' or he iy he eviw. n . r n, x , 7 1t Ci.2 0 )( rc ra ( litf d ca ai n ta hih rrtn wo d h ve1d t b n swa r 0 8 pe u im) panips e lrto h t g e aig ul a e o o u s c us r ;Br v Snow,440 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.2006)( oncl o y) own . 3d 259, 265 1 t r downgrde o pe fr nc a n roma e e l ton no a tona e unl s pli tf c n Ge t ih t t t l r s or l d t a mor vaua i t c i bl es a n if a ësabls ha he owe c e e o e tngi ef m ofa s a ton')(mphassa d) r Hagett tfe a de ii t ta a bl or dvere ci ' e i dde .Hee, r t esiid t poston ha lbr r empl i ay oyee' pe f m a e r tng nee d t r ac a ce t n t e hol t qualf t peron s ror nc a i de o e h rai hr s d o iy he s f a a lbonus ( r t De 498:2- 4,20- . She sae f t rt Chrse on' or n nnua . Haget po, 1 1 22) ttd urhe hat itns s rviw di nihedhe r tngr ai t prore uai t tha l t bonus (d.a 498:0e e mi s r ai eltve o i val tons ha d ed o es 1 t 1 499:)a s t a ex bisas resofa le lato s ngt dipart bewee he 1 nd ubmis s hi t ei nnua vau ins howi he s iy t n r e ri r s r ior a Chrse on' a s s m e s ( a le upe v s s' nd itns s s e s nt PSOF Ex, 1 N) She c am s t t s 6E- . l i ha he s d ha r c ve abonusfra l s 201 ( r etDepo. 6- 2325,499:) Butt s houl ve e ei d o t eat 4. Ha g t 498: 8, 1. hi t si ony doe notesabls t FAU ha a dic e i r bonuspolc ort ti i di Ha get e tm s t ih hat d s r tona y iy, ha f t d, r t 17 ob ai d bonus s f t y r c r pondi t he m or postve r viws whie mi sng t m t ne e or he ea s ores ng o r e ii e e l s i he f t ye r s r ceve m o eneg tve one . Be us t c nec i bewe n t pe f ma e or he a s he e i d r ai s ca e he on ton t e he ror nc r viw and an lbonus s i s e e nua e s uppore by no m or t n Ha gets k efs r ng alega i ,' td e ha r t' i l- e vi s l tons' Cai 261F. n, App' a 21 t 201 r vi w i no a ma e i l a re e pl e ac i x t 7, he 4 e e s t t raly dve s m oym nt ton. Al o g Ha g t h sito u e e d n efo wh c aj r c ul r a o by fn s t u h r et a nr d c d vie c r m ih u y o d e s na l i d he h s f r d a a r e ac i duet he t e - s pe i wihou pa s ha f l t cie t ufe e n dve s ton o r hr e day us nson t t y, he s aied o t o a y e ie c fo whc aj r c u d ra o a y fn t e s p nso wa i s d d e t he n vd n e r m ih u y o l e s n bl id h us e in s mpo e u o r dia lt Tha i be a e a pli if as pa tof he prma f i ca e,m us pr s nt s s biiy. t s c us a ntf, r r i ace s t e e ome cr umsa i levi nce ofan e oye ' dic i naor i e ,be ic t nta de mpl rs s rmi t y nt nt yond t m e e oc ure e of he r c r nc a a re a ton. JA. v NovaSout ase n Uni. I . 646 F,App' 921,927 ( 1h Ci. n dve s ci M . he tr v, nc, x 1t r 201 ( r c im) ( antf s prma fce c s fie be a e he i l d no ot r fcs 6) pe ura pli if i a i a e ald c us i ege al he a t s ggesi t t(mpl r dimis d hi be us ofhi me a dia lt '.3 Alhough FAU u tng ha e oyej s se m ca e s ntl s biiy' 1 t ) bu e t de c i i ofHa getsbur n- a g ng t tt t r pr oft prm a f c eca e ngls he s rpton r t' de r ui ha he hid ong he i a i s r uie Ha gett S eq r s r t o s demonsr t t tt r s gi n by FAU was a pr txt f a saut rl ta e ha he ea on ve ee or tt o iy- pr ece p pos '( 113a 9 - ie e sychalngest s fcinc ofhe prmafci c e ot td ur e' DE t ) t xpr sl le he ufi e y r i a e as and t c r um sa i e de e as oc ae wih t dic i nai pr ng, 1 I hast r f e me he ic tntal vi nc s it d t he s rmi ton o 4 t he e or t .JA. wasaRe biia i n Ac ca ea r f r nc d t ditnc i ma i n. 646 F.Ap x 3 M ha ltto t s nd e e e e he si ton de n 8. p' a 926- The opi on hi e t taca eofa ton undert ssa ut r quied,eve a t prma t 27. ni nt d ha us ci hi tt e e r n t he i fcesa evi ncet tadia lt wa t 'ol r a onf dimis .'1 a 927 (mphassi a i tge, de ha s biiy s he ' e e s or s sal' d. t s e in orgi ) Si Ha get does not mee t ADA' l r t es d,t r i no ne d t i nal, nce r t t he S owe hr hol hee s e o dif r nta ehe bur n a cor ng t ea h sat e. fe e it r de c di o c t ut 1FAU a e s st is i t s pa a es c i ofisM o i o e ild SDici i oft 4 ddr s e he s ues n wo e r t e tons t ton, ne ntte i s plne he Pli ifwa notDic i na i butwa Ta Due t a Le tm ae Rea on',( 11 a 9- 0) antf s s rmi ton s ken o gii t s ' DE 3 t 1 , t o he l be e Spl i ips D i c i i ton Cl i s Fa l as She Suf e ed N o A dve s he t r a l d i a ntf s rm na i am i fr re Empl ntActon'(d.a 1 4) FAU' unde sandi oft prmafcec e' t r pr oyme i ' l t 0-1 . S rt ng he i a i as s hid ong i pl i y i cor e t i lght of t M c s a nl n r c n i he Donnel- ou as bur n- hi ng f am e or lD gl de s hi r w k. FAU c ompoundsiserorby i t r nvoki a s r e sa r f pr ng pr t xt whih woul r uie ng upe s ded t nda d or ovi ee , c d eq r Ha gett s r t o how b0t t tisr as n f dici i wasf le a t tdic i i ton wast r al h ha t e o or s plne a s nd ha s rm na i he e r a o ,Se ih' n 1 . Afe d lig it p ee t FAU d u lsb c a dr tr st itn a d e s n e n a, .5 tr evn n o rtx , o be a k n eu n o ne t n 18 is bur n unde Ceotx of S n i out t t ditit cour ( ta t ee i a a s n e o t de r le s tng poi o he src t ) h t hr s n bec f e d et s vienc o uppor t non ovi pa t s ca e. Cel e 477 U . a 325, Des t t s t he m ng ry' s ' ' otx, S. t pie hi, Ha get smpl a e s s FAU' pr t xt a gum e , c e ng s ne not pr r t i y ddr s e S ee r nt ontndi he ed ove t t ha dic i nai n wast r a r as f he d s plne. l i e s rmi to he e l e on or r ici i t s nough,s mait i ,f hert ofe he n ans or o fr t tmony - whih s doe i pas i - c r ditng t f dua bass f t s penson. esi c he s n sng onta c i he a l i or he us i Hageti cor t t onc t bur n yli bac t he att ssa aplitf c n us ly r t s red ha, e he de /f , k o r hi tge, anif a ual /& e tbls pr t i one of t wa :: 1 by s sa ih eext n wo ys $ ) ( howi t tt lgii t nondic i naor ng ha he e tmae srmi t y r s ea ons s d not be be ive or ( by s wi t t i lght of al of t e de , houl le d; 2) ho ng ha, n i l he vi nce dic i i t y r s m or lke y m o i t d t decson t n t pr f r d r as .' St s rm na or ea ons e i l tva e he ii ha he of e e e ons ' andar d v A. E. .Sev.l . 1 F. 1318,1 ( 1h Ci.1 )Combsv.Pl atonPate n 1 . B. L r , nc, 61 3d 332 1 t r 998) ant i tr s, 06 F,d l 9,15 Le te v.Good ar Tie ( Rubbe Co., I c.421F.d 1 69,1 85- ( 1h 3 51 29) dbe tr ye r f r n, 3 1 1 86 1 t Ci.2005)( er ng t ta i ee eoft r s sfliy i s icinti t Gus cae' r obs vi ha n nfrnc he eaon' ast s uf e n he * ual s ' ) (mphai i orgi l.5 Butt tdoe no me n t ta ADA orTil Vl pli ifc n e iel e ss n i na)1 ha s t a ha n te I antf a ntr y i nor t que ton ofdic i i t y a mus. SeeFl r v Tr p C/ SchoolDit,803 F. g e he s i s rm na or ni owe s ou y. s 3d . 1 2 ,1 7 3 ( 1h Ci,2 5 (xpann t a i vd n e (h t a mo tmih s p r a 3 7 33 - 8 1 t r 0l ) e li ig h t s ie c t al t s g t up o t n e c a i con e ng t tHa getf al t pr d a e denc ofa conduc by FAU t t aus ton, t ndi ha r t i is o ovi e ny vi e f ny t ha s cfc lylnkst dici i r aci t he diabiiy.'(d.a 1 . I iss ci o a re pe iial i he s plnay tons o r s lt ' 1 t 0) n t e ton n dve s a tons FAU e ai a i t tû c ci , xpl ns gan ha s onne ton ha bee e t bls d be we t s a tons. . . no ci s n sa ihe t en he e c i a adici naor motve.'(d.a 11 1 . nd srmi t y i ' 1 t -2) 1 lemphaszeS ualy' bec us t Supr me Cour ha a 5 i ' us l ' a e he e t s dded t q lfcai t te de e of he uaii ton ha vi nc f liy aone wils tme notbe e ug t s vve t pr t x i uiy. Re ve v Sande s ast l l ome i s no h o ur i he e e t nq r e s , r on Plmbn Pr d, r . 5 0U. 1 3 1 .i - h r wil eisa e wh r , lh u htepanif u ig o fl , 3 S. 3 , 48 kf ee lb n tnc s ee at o g h litf c gl hasesa ihe a prma f i c e a stf t s fce e de t rj c t dee nts tbls d i ace as nd e orh ufiint vi nce o ee t he fnda ' e a ton,no r tona f c fnde c d co udet tt aci wa dic i i t y.' 1 Thos xplna i ai l a ti r oul ncl ha he ton s s rm na or ' d. e cic sanc exi t w he e t em pl e ' r a ed onl a wea i s of f c as t whet t r um t es s r he oye s e t c y k s ue at o her he e pl rsr as wa untu a t e wasa m oye ' e on s r e nd her bunda a unco r re i pende e de e nt nd ntove td nde nt vi nc t tno dic i nato ha o ured, 1 ;Cha ha s rmi i n d cc r ' d. ' pman v AlTr p., 229 F. 1 2,1 ,n, 1 . ans 3d 01 025 1 ( 1h Ci.2000) (e 1t r rcogni ng Ree es modii ton of Comb l Flwer,803 F. a 1 zi v ' fcai sk o s 3d t 339 (a . s me) 1 9 i ee c ta (e s n o frdlma h v b e prtx o s tig'i n te ie c t a r a o nfrn e h t ra o fee y a e e n ee t f omehn ' s o vd n e h t e s n d sprt ofdic i n i ' e onpr ecedcasiiai (mphassi orgi ) i wa eext s rmiaton'bas d ot t l sfc ton) e i n i nal. To s r ie s mmayj g n , r etmu tito u es me cr u tnile i e c o u vv u r ud me t Ha g t s nr d c o ic msa t v d n e f a Chrse on' a must ca a l lnk t a r e a ton wih he diabiiy. Sm ih v Loc e itns s ni o us ly i he dve s c i t r s lt t . khe d- Mari Cor ,64 F. 1 1 1 28 ( 1h Ci.2011 ( antf mus mas lt ic tnta tn p. 4 3d 32 , 3 1 t r ) pli if t rha i rumsa il c e ie c t a ce t satibeis ec n e ngtee o e ' ds rmiao y itnb (mp a i v d n e h t rae ra l su o c mi h mply rs ic i n tr n e t) e h ss ' a d)1 Smih pr de t outrbound frs tsyi aprma fci Til V1 dici nai dde .6 t ovi s he e o aif ng i a e te l srmi ton cai be a ei pe mise de t tmeest Mc l m c us t r t vi nce ha t he DonnelDou asciei (. ,c l- gl rtra ie. ompaao s rtr) a d k ai u gt eqf r 't a ma e a i o v n ig mo ac' fa e ly rsd srmiao y n ç ro s oh r o ms' h t k ' n i cn v c s i'o n mpo e ' ici n t r e nt r t s t i t t he or vi nc ount t t a mus 1 1 .TheEl ve h Cicui ha no delneaed wha ot rf m sofe de e c , bu i ni .7 d hasclrfe t ,e n unde t S onvi i m os i 'fa e k,an i e enc ofdi en i a ii d hat ve r he t c ncng ac' r m wor nf r e tnt tonal dic i na i 'i no pe tedunls S o ehi lnkst ac i t t e pl e' 'pr eced s rmi ton' s t nnit e s s m t ng i he tons o he m oye s' ot t s cls .Tur rv Fl i Prpai Col.Bd.522F.App' 829,83 ( 1hCi.201 ( rcu im) a s ne . orda e d l , x 3 1 t r 3) pe ra . Cons nty,Ha getmus r s t lnk upon a cha lnge t he prma f ci ca e - ori s eque l r t t aie hat i le o r i a e s f he de lne t do s t n - a las a t prt xt sa ci s o o he t e t t he e e t ge. Pe m itng ot r s woul viit t r ti he wie d ta e he saut y r gi e, Any dia e peron on t r ce vi e ofa a r e empl t t or e m s bld s he e i ng nd n dve s oyme a ton nt c i wo d t n ha gr ul he ve ounds t s he e oye . Nowhe e i he bre does Ha geta t o ue r mpl r r n r if r t tcmptt o 1 Si et evi nta y b de ofa ADA cli a es 6 nc he de ir ur ns n am r uppos d t mir Til Vl ' M c e o ror te ls Donne l l- Dou asfa wor Dure v APAC,lc. 236 F. 651 657 ( 1hCi.2000) Har t' ADA gl r me k, ly . n, 3d , 1t r , gets s i c r a nl c nnotunde s how ng e t i y a r hootSm ih' c ie i t s rt r a. 1 Be us t e Elve h Cic thasnotmade c 7 ca e h e nt r ui ompa aore de a ne s ar pa tofa ADA r t vi nce ce s y r n cli ' prm a f c e s ng,Hai s v.Che oke C@. Ci N o.1: 291 J AJ 201 W L am s i a i howi ne r e , v. 08- 6- OF/ B, 0 28 853,a #26 @ . Ga Fe 1 201 (ompaaorevi nce i onl lone way ofpr ng 21 t D, . b. 6, 0) c rt de s y s ovi dici naor i e ' i ADA cl m) (ntr l quoai omitd) FAU' c eni t t srmi t y ntnt' n ai i e na ttons te , S ont ton ha Hagetfie t pr e acompaaor- ie.a i dia ed,non- r e wor rl't twa r t ald o oduc rt ., s non- sbl deg e d ke l' ha s r ls iid ( 11 a 1 -i notrlva . eca sfe DE 3 t 4) s ee nt 20 m a t r quiie s ke he e st howi .1 Be a e Ha getf l t conne tt pot nta adve s a on of ng 8 c us r t ais o c he t i l r e di he s pe i t a dicrm i t y a musba e on dia lt et raspa tofherprm af ci r us nson o ny s i na or ni sd s biiy, ihe r i a e c s o t de n taep ee t F i e tte t s mmayj d me to h rds b ly d s aae ae r o mo srt rtx , AU s n ild o u r u g n n e ia ii ip r t t te m entc a m . 1 r at li 9 2. Faiur t Acc l eo omm oda e t As t Ha gets s co t or of dia lt dic i i ton, FAU a s rs t i o r t' e nd he y s biiy s rm na i s e t hat t ac c omm odaed s e ofhe r ue t a i ed onl t e t twe e va a unr as bl t om r eq ss nd gnor y hos ha r gue nd e ona e. Ha getr pondst tFAU di note agei a i e a tve pr e st de e m i wheheri c d r t es ha d ng n n nt r c i oc s o t r ne t t oul ac omm odae oneoft r quesss cii i herl c t he e t pe fed n awyersJ 201 l te . d e pl rm us ' une 4 et r i m oye An t pr de r as bl ac ovi e ona e comm o i datons f e oye wih k or mpl es t nown dia ltes unls s h s biii e s uc ac omm o i woul r ul i undue ha ds p t t e pl yer An ac om moda i i c datons d es t n r hi o he m o . c ton s r as bl,a t r r d und t ADA,onl i i al e ona e nd hus equie er he y f t lows t e pl e t pe f r t he m oye o r o m he e s nilfnci so tej b' Ea lv Me v s l c,2 7 F.d 1 ,1 6 ( 1h Ci.2 0 ) se t u t a on f h o . r . ryn , n . 0 3 361 3 5 1 t r 0 0 ' (ntr lctton omitd) The e oye be r t i dit bur ofi ntf ng s h a i e na iai te . mpl e a s he mme ae den de iyi uc n a co moda i a t uli t bur n ofpe s son t tt ac omm oda i i r a ona e.1 c m ton nd he tma e de rua i ha he c ton s e s bl d. 1 S ed e ,h we e,ma e amag n latmp wih r s e tt s x ds rmiai n S e if a, 8 h o s o vr k r i a te t t ep c o e ici n to . e nr Se to B. ci n 1Thi i nota c s ofa non- o ng pary de lni t r ta g ou t the oppone di not 9 ss ae m vi t ci ng o ebu r nd ha r nt d r s Sie e i s h cr aie. lnc n uc icumsanc s i ap o i t Edwar v Hone t e s pr pra e. ds . ywel,; ,960 F.d 673 l nc. 2 , 6 4 ( t Ci.1 9 )(l h n ap ry mo e f rs mmayj d me to g o n A, so p n n i 7 7h r 9 2 i e at v s o u r u g n n r u d hi p o e t s W no r uie t r s nd on gr t eq rd o epo oundB -agr ound t mova mihthaveprs ntdbu di no.' he nt g e e e t d t' ) (ntr quottonsomit . Hee,t i enal ai ted) r hough i misaedt lw,FAU di i iaet ca a t stt he a d mplc t he us l pr ong of Ha get' prma f i c s , l a a l r ts i ac e a e n n na ogous st ton,t Te h Cic t a fr e iuai he nt r ui fim d s mmayj d me ta an t n n mo n pan if S rsRa ig S r . I c v S rsCa Clb u r u g n g is a o - vig litf. po t cn e v, n . . po t r u o fAme ia I c,1 F.d 8 4, 9 - 3( 0h Ci.1 9 ) Th twa b c u etea g me ti t e rc , n . 31 3 7 8 2 9 1 t r 9 7 . a s e a s h r u n n h m ov t s m oton,alhough f an ' i t ounde on an e r ous pr m i e s ilt ge e a es enta e e en d r one e s , tl ar t d n s i l l m t oft pli ifsc am . 1 a 8 The pl ntf,t û l td't t is c d nots tsy is he antf l i d. t 92. ai if hus i ere 'o he s ue, oul a aif t bur n by eng ng onl wih t de e tve p e s 1 S t Racig' r a oni i e ly de agi y t he f c i r mie. d. pors n s e s ng s qua l a i a e he e. H a ge t r ponds onl t FA U ' i or e pr t xt pr m i e but nott is va i pplc bl r r t es y o S nc r ct e e e s, o t ld c ii e oft ca allnk be we di a lt s a us a adve s a t o r tqu he us i t en s biiy t t nd r e c i n. 21 a 1 6 . Att e s mma y j d me t sa e s e mus p o u e e i e c t t a r ao a l t 37 h u r u g n tg , h t r d c v d n e ha e s n be a commodai wa a lbl Wils v Cono o,f 1 F. 28 285 ( 1h Ci.19 . c ton s vaia e, li . pc nc, 08 3d 2, 1 t r 97) W he ar que ti pa e l unr as bl,t e pl rha no dut t ive tgae i orbe n t n e s s t nty e ona e he m oye s y o n si t t gi he itr ci ep o e s 1 . S a sv Cr e,6 7 F. p' 9 3 9 8 ( 1h Ci. 5 ( rc ra . ne a tv r c s. d; pe r . e / 0 Ap x 4 , 4 1 t r 201 ) pe u im) The s me i tue i t r ques d not ma a s fcinty s cii de a a s r f he e t oes ke ufi e l pe fc m nd. Gason v t . Belngr hGa den ( Home l . 1 F.d 1 61 1 ( 1hCi.1 . li at r s f , nc, 67 3 3 , 363 1 t r 999) As um i Ha gets diabiiy saus me s t ADA sa r FAU r s na y s ng r t' s lt t t et he t nda d, ea o bl a c modaed her r ques t t ke c mi wa ks2 I dee , Har t ac c om t e t o a al ng l . 0 n d get knowl s t t FAU edge ha c n e tdt t i rq e t ( OF! 1 ) Ast t of h J n 201 r q e t, r etsRe p n e o s ne o hs e u s. PS 5 . o wo t e u e 4 e u ss Hag t' s o s slnt She f is t r pond t FAU ' a gument t t he r quess f Chrse on t be ie . a l o es o S r s ha r e t or itns o ta f re a t ha Cl se on çs nstze 't i e a i wih women a e lptc a e r ns e r d nd o ve ui t ns ie ii d' o nt r ctng t nd pie is r u ea onabl #e s To t extnt t s a e pa tofher cai ,t s a lga i a e wai d. nr s e r e. he e he e r r l m he e le tons r ve Re ol i Tr tCor v,DunmarCor ,43F. 587,599( 1hCi.1 )(s oundsalge i s uton us p. p. 3d 1 t r 995 s gr le d n t ec mplitb t o r l du o i s mmayj dg n a ed e da a d n d'. h o an u n t e i p n n u r u me t r e me b n o e ' e ) The onl ac om moda i r es t t Ha ge t doe a es i her de a t t y c ton equ t ha r t s ddr s s m nd ha Chrsens ç as hi hosiec r ai wih he'( it on ke e s tl onfonttons t r' DSOF Ex.O a 2)a t FAU pr de t nd hat ovi herS l fi,non-onfonai te t nt'(d.a 3) FAU ague t tar s frnon% m, ar ca c r ttonal rame ' 1 t . r s ha equet o c r a i ltea me i nota die a s c fc de a t two d oblge i t c onfont tona r t nt s r ct nd pe ii m nd ha ul i t o onduc a t n i si a i orbe nt i e a tvepr s . nve tg ton gi he ntr ci oce s A de a f as r s t a m nd or upe vior o dopta l sove bea i m a ge e syl i ge r ly hed es r rng na m nt t e s ne a l l t beunra ona e.Sc z p .Br ns ckCor ,833F.Su 2d 11 11 23( M i o e s bl hwarkofv u wi p. pp. 06, 22- D, nn. 2011 (e s f s r s a ot r t notyel a pli ifnotra ona e .Thati tuee n ) r quet or upe vior nd he s o l t antf e s bl) s r ve 2 Har et doe notdiput t tFAU ac om moda e herr que tt wor i a ha r fe c cl 0 g t s s e ha c td e s o k n za d-r e ubi e s e, i et sfc i a te i he Ame d Complit ( mpl!27) pac snc hi a t s dmitd n r nde an . Co . . 22 it s rs 'c f he upe viors onduc i aci bl as a i pende dic i naton ca m . Ha man p t s tona e n nde nt s rmi i li ys . Fo d Lin l c,8 3 F.S p 1 9 ,1 0 ( D.Ga 1 95 (ile e h r sme ti a to a l o o, n . 9 u p. 0 2 1 6 S. . 9 ) s lg d aa s n s ci n be a unde t ADA, notu raie s bl a ommodai a l i' ;Rodrgue v JohnMui r he but nde ra ona e cc ton' nayss' ) i z. r A/t C/. Ci No.09e 'f r, v. 00731CW ,201 W L 3448 a *1 ( D.CalAug. 201 (a ; 0 567, t 2 N. . 31, 0) s me) but s e Jo s v Biln on,40 F. Supp.2d 1 1 68 ( D. 2005 ( di t t e hn on . ligt 4 57, 67- D. C. ) hol ng ha haasme bas on dia lt ma rques f ta fr ras e) Alho h is cii r s nt ed s biiy de e t or rnse e onabl . t ug ipe tc sr s r ...m a i s e c esbe lgii ae tr e s ofa omm odai ' a e oye c r tes o s y n om as e tm t a g t cc ton,' n mpl e amot i muni he s l fom sr s a c iiim i ge r l Gonz gowsk v.Wi l 11 F. 744, m ze r e f r te s nd rtc s n ne a . a i dnal, 5 3d 747- ( 0h Ci.1 . By t s me ras ng,a al t wor i a mor nururng wor 48 1 t r 997) he a e oni ppe s o k n e ti k en r e ,not die t d a a pari a pe s vionm nt r c e t ny tculr r on,ar not s fc e l s cii . Canni v, e ufi i nty pe fc ce Nor s Bankl N A. 1 F. 723,7 ( t Ci.199 (l i ton t ma ras e we t owa , 89 3d 28 8h r 9) s gai o ke e onabl obl a c mmo ain (oe n t e tn l t p o dn a a g a ai n fe e vr n n ' ; se a o c o d t d s oj x e d l o r viig n g r v to -r e n io me t' Po tr r o ) v.RBS Ciie ,N A. 1 F.Supp.3d 277,290 ( N. 201 )($ rques f t a f cam tz ns , 59 D. H. 6 $ e t or pe ceul l a en r nme 'i t va t beconsderdar s unde t ADA') vio nt s oo gue o i e eque t r he '. Her ,Ha getdi no pi ntpa tculr sr s or t tChrse on cr a e She m e el e r t d t npoi ri a te s s ha it ns e t d. r y ch r t iedhi ma eme syl asas i oft tl co r ttons' ( aacerz s nag nt t e eres i ie nfonai .' DSOF Ex.O a 2) hos t . Tha doe notta l t t a tr ed de a r a i t a ( pe ii sr s or' I addii exc pt t s r nsae o a get m nd eltng o ç c fc te s .' n s ton, e f ro eioae j k ,te ei n e i e c ,a i Bi igtn, h tCh itn o sk o fo tto s' o n s ltd o e h r s o v d n e s n l n o t a rse s n' i n r n ain ' l c i ve moc ng Ha gets dia lt Quie t oppost Hagets de ii t tmony nvol d ki r t' s biiy. t he ie. r t' poston esi de monsr t s t s was m osl pr oc upi wih wha s per e ve t be t u qua ta e hat he ty e c ed t t he c i d o he ne l di ti uton ofCh i t ns s w or r l e r pr che a ong I D e t ents a f Norc n s srb i r s e on' k- e at d e oa s m LL parm t f. a he r l on he c us r alega i t tChrs e on' crtc s s wer de i ned t i ey r oncl o y l ton ha it ns s ii i m e sg o nduc s i r s e e zu e . Ac or ngl Ha gets r s f r Chrsens t e hi hos ie c r ai c di y, r t' eque t o it on o nd s tl onfont tons i s 23 unr as bl z Har t' r e ona e.l gets eques t û al , f i,non- onfont tona team e ' i sm ia l t br ' m ar c c r ai l r t nt' s i lry unr a o bl a alo uns tc. Canni ,1 F. a 7 Po e ar 1 F,Supp.3d a 290. e s na e nd s peci s ce 89 3d t 28; str o, 59 t Be aus Har et doe not i r ce e de t t her r ques wa r as na e,FAU wa not c e g t s ntodu vi nce ha e t s e o bl s oblgae t t ke ac i on i. Wils 1 F, a 285. FAU i t r f e e il d t s i td o a ton t li, 08 3d t s he e or ntte o ummar y j d me o teAme e Co li tsfiu et a c mmo aec u t. u g nt n h nd d mpan ' al r o c o d t o n s B. Se D i c i i i x s r m naton Ha getss ond cli ale s FAU di c i naed a i the bas d on s x,i vi ato r t' ec am lge s rmi t gans r e e n ol i n o Til VI, 2U. C. 2 0 e2() ( mp . !818 ) FAU a g e t tHa g t ddn ts fe f te 1 4 S. j 0 0 - a . Co l! - 5 . r u s ha r et i o u fr a m a e i l adve s e oymen aci t tt ei no evi nce s ny t raly r e mpl t ton; ha her s de ugge tng a dic i i t y si s rm na or motve;t tt ei no c a lnk b we n a s ch put tvem otve a a a s a i a i ha her s aus l i et e ny u ai i nd n dvere cton; nd ta te c mp r tre d n e i d f ci e b c u e me we e s be tt te alg dy a e s h t h o aao vie c s ee tv e a s n r u j c o h le e l dv re aci whie women we e bene i a i oft al ge y postve o s Har t m a s onl a tons l r fcires he le dl ii ne . get ke y c us y e f tt def nd he cli ,ba ey a oncl or for o e r am r l dvancng f rhe t t de l r t t r i a i a t r han o c a e hat he e s ' nvi i mos i ' ofe denc t Chrse on teaed wome dif r ty. She doe notcie l co ncng a c' vi e hat itns r t n fe en l s t t r or e denc (houghs al t Cl se on' te t ntoft mal compaao s. o ec d vi e t he ludes o uitns s rame wo e rtr) 2 Ha g t ar sherr ques wa r as bl be us Ka tdie t d Cl se on t kee t I 1 r e t gue e t s e ona e ca e ba r c e ui t ns o p he LL De rme a sr s fe a pos i e. Ka tsdie tve wa noti r pons t Ha ge tsJ pa t nt s tes -r e s sbl ba ' r c i s n es e o r t' une 201 lte ,bu r he i r s e t a Oc obe 201 meei The e i no e de Ha get 4 e tr t at r n e pons o n t r 3 tng. r s vi nce r t r ue t d a a com m oda i i t t m e i eq s e ny c ton n ha etng. Tha FAU s pa a e y s ht t i pr t t e r t l oug o m ove he at os r of t l D e rm e i not e de e t t Har t ' s e nt r que t w as m phe e he LL pa t nt s vi nc ha ge t s ubs que e s r a ona e. Se Wood v.Gr n,323 F. 1 e s bl e ee 3d 309,1 4 ( 1h Ci.2003)( ani e oye ' 31 1 t r expli ng mpl rs a qui ce e t e rir a co moda i doe not a t a ia l de c es nc o a le c m ton s u om tc ly em s e nt r ques ubs que e t r aon be ;c Smo el v Un v o Cal a Bek ly 3 8 F.Ap x 6 3 6 4 ( t Ci.2 09 e s a l) f i n li . i. f . t r ee 3 p' 7 , 7 9h r 0 ) (mpl rsofe ofale nai a ommodai notadmison t trqu td ac ommodai e oye ' fr tr tve cc ton si ha e ese c ton r a ona e . e s bl) 24 Th M cDo l- gl s fame k a is t Ha ge ts s dic i i i c1i .2 So e nnelDou a r wor pple o r t' ex s rm naton am 2 tod e t eç o vn igmo ac' l r t e Stv n v Ci o r s Pa k 6 5F. p' 6 0 o o s h i n icn s i'at nai , e e s . t fFo e t r , 3 Ap x 9 , c e v y 697 ( 1h Ci.201 ( rc im) Re r esofwhih meho s s e t,t i talf usi 1 t r 5) pe ura . gadls c t d he elcs he nii oc s silo t e t nt a r lvanc oft e o ' di c i naor ani us Thus t s tsy a tl n he x e nd ee e he mpl yers s rmi t y m . , o a if prma fce c e ofdic i nai unde Til Vl.Hagetmus a eevienc t ti )t i a i as srmi ton r te l r t t dduc d e ha 1 he (1 e ly rs ds rmiao y a i s t wa d t e e o e g s b s d o te e ly e s mp o e ' ici n t r nmu o r s h mply e wa ) a e n h mpo e ' prtce c rce itc;( adichageorot rsgni ntc oe td haa trsi 2) s r he i sca hangei t tr orc tonsof n he ems ondii e ly n gc u rd) a d ( )gh r wa )ac u a ln b t e tet ' Stmps n v Ci o mp o me t o c re ; n 3 t ee s a s l ik ewe n h wo. i o , t f ' y Tus al a,1 F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.1 99 ( rc im) c oos 86 3d 328, 331 1 t r 9 ) pe ura . W ih r pec t t s ond c po nt I have a r a f t es t o he ec om ne , le dy ound one of t t ee aci he hr tons r e d i t dia lt s c i t bem aera l a r e na e y t s penson. Onl t frt eviwe n he s biiy e ton o t ily dve s , m l he us i y he is a t r p o m us be f t re mi d. Eve we e lt r c be nd hid r ngs t urhe xa ne n r o ea h yond Ha getsba e r t' r bones bre a e mi he f c ua r or t gr if nd xa ne r a t l ec d, he ounds f e tbls ng Cl se on' dic i naor or sa ihi ui tns s s rmi t y a m ust ni owar wome a e dubi . I he St t ntofM ae ilFa t ,Ha g tpoi t outt t ds n r ous n r aeme tra c s r et n s ha Chrse o enf ce t ofi e' s i lz ton polc mor lninty t it ns n or d he fc s oc ai a i iy e e e l owar m e t wom e ds n han n. She as ct s t he and Tr s s t tm ony t t Chrse e t nded t m a lo ie o r os ' esi ha itns n e o nage wo e mor m n e a a i l i pa tc a c iii ngHagetandGhannoum' wo kpa (houghTr swa ne r brsvey,n riulr rtczi r t s r ce t os s we 7 Theta tonalM c 2 r dii Donne lDou as fa l- gl r mewor r r s a pli ifa t prm a f c e sage t k equie antf t he i a i t o s t t1 1 (q i ame rofapr e e cas ;( (l wa qualfe f t poston;( how ha 6 ) she s mbe ( otctd l s 2) she s iid or he ii 3) (l e s fr d a a v re e ly n a to ;a d ( ) (q e wa rplc d b ap ro o ti e sh ufee n d es mpo me t cin n 4 sh s e a e y e s n u sd (e)p o e td ca sorwa te td ls fv rb y t a a smi ry st td idviu lo ti e h r r tce ls s r ae e s a o a l h n i l l-i e n i d a u sd a ua (e)p o e td ca s' Ma a d v Bd o ge t o v o Un v .o a De 'o u .3 2 h r r tce ls . yn r . fRe ns fDi. f is fFl. p t fEd c, 4 ' F. 1 ,1 ( 1h Ci.2003) Be us t scai uli t y t ns o t f t f tr3d 281 289 1 t r . ca e hi l m tmael ur n he ourh aco whe he Ha getwaste t d l sf vor bl t n m e - i i notne s ar t i tga et o he t r r t r a e es a a y ha n ts ce s y o nvesi t he t r t e f t si pende l oft d onvi i m os c'sa r hr e acor nde nty he i c ncng ai' t nda d. 25 a ls e re d)2 Fi 1y,Har t t nd e s xpe ince .3 na1 get houghtt tChrsens ge al aced findle ha it on nerly t re ir t r me Conve s y,FAU ct t pori ofHa getst si ony i whi s a ted owa ds n, r el ies o tons r t' e tm n ch he dmit t tot f mal c wor swe e teae be t t n her ha her e e o- ker r r td ter ha , 1 fnd t t t e i i ufi e e de e of Chrse on' hosiiy t ds women. i ha her s ns fcint vi nc it ns s tlt owar Ha getsper e i t tCh it ns wa findle t r me i notpa tc a l pr ba i A r t' c pton ha rse on s re ir owa ds n s riulry o tve. s r iors g r de e nor t ds me be s of a pr e t cls a c pa e t nonupe vs ' ene al m a owar m r ot ced a s s om r d o me e sd sn tn c sa i i l aep eu iet wad ta ca s Ke hed v Coo De 'o mb r oe o e e s rl mpi t rj dc o r s h t ls. n l , l. p t f y c Pu . a t &. v' 8 7 F,S p 2 1 3 1 414 ( Co o 2 1,afd 5 7 F. p' 7 b He lh En t 3 , u p. d 2 2, 2 - 2 D. l . 01 ) f ' 5 Ap x 28 ( 0h Ci. 2 4 (u h ra o n ' sa e l te ts Gre di e s a d k rj ie a 1 t r 01 ) s c e s nig s tk n y ralq fin ln s ' n p eudc ' s mi op ii lsats'.Fu t r mos ofHagetsr or cttons u i pe ton,do nOtasit postona t e ' ) rhe , t r t' ec d iai , pon ns ci ss he a gument The s rr . y how o y t tm a depo nt a e t tCk it ns sngld o Ha get nl ha ny ne s gr ed ha se on i e ut r t f ad or monih e . Tha i is l i nota tona e. See Cl k v S.Br s m nt t n t ef s c i bl ar . owar Hos Dit,601 F. d p. s. App' 886,899- ( 1h Ci.201 ) ( t t mor s vio c r i a yeli a x 900 1 t r 5 wihou e, uper s r onfontng nd lng t fmal s di t i no pr tveofsx- s motvai ) Chav zv URSFe Te .Se v, e e ubor nae s t obai e baed i tons; e . d. ch r . I . 5 F.App' 81 822(11h Ci.201 ( rcura ( na c itntybertngfmae nc, 04 x 9, t r 3) pe im) ma ger onsse l ai e l e oye i fontof co- ker not s baed) Thee i onl one rf rnce i Hagets mpl e n r wor s ex- s . r s y e ee n r t' Stt nt t a ct ton t tdes i s Chrse on' unf r team e of women mor br dl aeme o iai ha crbe itns s ai r t nt e oa y. Th tc me fo Tr s ' d p iin wh ri h rmak d ta ftlo e l ( se o )wa a o s r m o ss e osto , een e e r e h t i o k d i Ckitns n s i ke pi ng on - i wasm or t wo e i t ofi e. He waski oflkebeng agg es i t war cki t e he m n n he fc nd i i r sve o d (ile c p l roj' ( o sDe o.612 6 . Bu Tr s i daey caiid ta t r we e sc x c t Bo tt. Tr s p ' :- ) t o s mme itl lrfe h t hee r onl t e wome Har t i l d,t r whom Chrse on a td mor ta e svelyl' y hre n, get ncude owads itns ce e iggrs i l .' 2 Tho r t t n hosiiy r l tng t s x,Tr s ati ed Chrse on' dipa a e te t t 3 ugh aher ha tlt e a i o e os trbut it ns s s r t r a men t a dic i na i s ul i t tChrsens n wa ed S o ge s rmi ton, pec atng ha it o nt i young pe e'a i w f c s. er opl' nd i ne a e ' ' ( os De 28:- . Tr s po. 19) 26 (d.. Thee i as no i c in t Chzse o sr por wih t wo n who arve a r l) r s lo ndiato hat itns n' ap t t he me ri d he r t' acua t t e e e s it ns s Tr sde re wa nega i Fi ly,Ha gets own f t lsaementr f r nce Chrse on' os pa td s tve. na l f vorts t r ot rwomen. ( a iim owa ds he PSOF 3 .,) A p cu eo as p r io wh ma h v h da 0g l. itr f u e vs r o y a e a c d r l to hi wih t e s cii women - bu apostve orneuta one wih ot r - ha dl ol e ai ns p t hr e pe fc t ii rl t he s r y p o ie e o g e d n ef rar a o a l u yt ifrs xd s rmiain r vd s n u h vie c o e s n bej r o n e e ic i n to . Ha getss x dicrm i ton cli alo f is b aus s c z o - an doe notty t r t' e s i na i am s a l ec e he am t d s r o esabls a ca a lnk bewe Chrse on' s x- s d a mus i as um e t be r a ,a t t ih us l i t en it ns s e ba e ni , f s d o e l nd he potnta adve s ac i The e i a ol el no evi nce t tHa ge ts s pl ed a r e i he e il r e ton. r s bs ut y de ha r t' ex ay ol n r s pens on. Co s q e ty s mmayj dg n i a r e i F Sfv ro Ha g t' Til Vl us i n e u n l, u r u me t s wad d n AU' a o n r ets te l s x dic i nai c , e s rmi ton ount C: Re alaton t i i Th l tc us ofaci i t Am e d Co pl ntalege r t i i n u rt ADA a e as a e ton n he nde m ai l s ealato nde he nd Til VI.( mp . ! 7 8 , 6 9 ) Til V1 p o ie t a: te 1 C0 1! 4- 0 8 -2 . te I r vd s h t I s l be a unl wf e oyme pr c ie f r a empl r t dicrmi t t hal n a ul mpl nt a tc o n oye o s i na e a i ta ofhi e pl e o a iant f e oyme ...bec us he ha gans ny s m oye s r pplc s or mpl nt a e s op e a pr c ie m a an unlwf e pl pos d ny a tc de a ul m oymentpr c i by t s s ha er a tce hi ubc pt , orbe us he hasm a acha ge,t tfe a sse o pa tcpaed i a ma r ca e de r esii d, s it d, r ri i t n ny nne i a i si ton,pr e di orhe rng unde t ss ha e . n n nve tga i oc e ng, ai r hi ubc pt r 4 U. C. 2 0 - () Th ADA c n ansap r l lp o iiin. 4 U. C,j 1 2 3 a . Th 2 S. j 00 e 3 a. e o ti aal r hbto 2 S. e 2 0 () e r brc f a s sng a r t lai cli i t r f e t s u i or s es i e ai ton am s he e or he ame f bot sat e , Fare p or h t ut s ly , Natonwi Mut l .Co.1 F, 1 i de . ns 97 3d 322, 1 36 ( 1h Ci.1 . FAU c lnge onl t 3 1 t r 999) hale s y he e s he ubs ue t ps n he s tcincy of Ha g ts prm a f ce ca e a doe n addr s t s eq nt se i t ufi e r et' i a i s , nd s ot n r r o ke i a e as e ala i M c onne l ou as f a e k. l o de t m a out a prm a f ci c e of r t i ton, a D lm gl r m wor pli ifmus s t t94)s e edi a aci t pr ece u rTil VI ( t ADAJ antf t how ha $1 he ngag n n tviy ot td nde te l or he ; ( s e s fr a a ree oyme ta in;a ( t r wasa c us c 2) h ufeed n dves mpl n cto nd 3) hee a al onneci bewe n ton t e 27 tep oe td a t iy a d te a v re e l y n a to . a f r v Caro l 5 9F.d 9 , h r tce ci t n h d es mp o me t cin' w o d , r l, 2 3 61 v 'Cr 970( lhCi. ) FAU contssonl t s co a t r prngs 1 t r 2008 . e t y he e nd nd hid o . Ac di t t Amende Compli ,t rt i or a si ude:( )FAU' fiur t cor ng o he d ant he ealat y ct ncl 1 S al e o rca sf Haget' poston;( isrf a t ac ommodaehe ras bl r ss and ()is e lsiy r ts ii 2) t eus l o c t r e ona e eque t; 3 t ie vn h ri a e vr me tta e p e h rt c ni u dh siiya d s iu e . ( mp . ! i a ig e n n n ion n h t x osd e o o tn e o tl n ez r s' Co 1 ! l t ' 7 88) Forras satd eale,FAU ha no dut t ac ommodaet r quet t tar t 6, . e ons t e rir d yo c t he e ss ha e he s be t ft slws i.Asac n e u n e isia to c n ts san tea ves a to p o go u j c o hi a ut o s q e c ,t n ci n a no u ti h d re cin r n f Hagetsrt iton cl m. Gome v Lai aw T anst l . 455 F.Supp.2d 81 90 ( Conn. r t' ealai ai z . dl r i, nc, , D. 2006) Bu v Fres& Fre ,I . 953F.Su 8 908( D.Ohi 1 . He t r alege ; ck . i is nc, pp. 96, S. o 996) r hid l d r ai tor ac i a ba e c uson a cont nsno s ppori f ct lale tons24 l doesnot etlai y t s r oncl i nd ai u tng a ua l ga i . t l d i ha r l s ii ton oul t ily s uppor Ha gets cli . And whie Idi fnd t ta non-ec a sfcai c d be m aera l t r t' am ve r a xpl ne ha r t s t ii d or he a r e i prnci e, 1 ha ale dy e ai d t t Ha get wa no qualfe f t AM P dve s n i pl poston. ii l addii Har t r iess ver lne i i si herRe pons t s i isc n ton, get a s e a w ncdent n s e hat he mple ounta s ma e i l a s empl t raly dvere oyme a tons M os of t s ofe onl va nt c i . t he e f r y gue and c us y oncl or c r t ia i ofChrsens sdeme ha acerz tons it on' anorf l ng heri e nalr t orsat not ng mor olowi ntr epors t e hi e t n i t si ht ' or ' i annoya es't twoul notdee a r a ona e e pl e fom ha i y lg s' ' nor pet m nc ' ha d tr e s bl m oye r r pori u a ulc e tng nl wf onduc ,5 Bu ln on N and Sant Fe Ry.Co.v Whie,548 U. 53,68 t2 ri gt a . t S. 2S ej/w, cinD o t ei s fce c o Hag t' b ltd h si wo ke v rn n cam. 4 e n Se to n h n ufiin y f r ets eae o tl r n io me t li e 7 Ha getsa e g r l t tChrse e woul 'ge ve y m a 'a es aat hi t l ng a 5 r t tt s ene aly ha it ns n dt t r d' nd c l e s i yi nd bul haasme 'f l ng he me tng wih HumanRes c ort E0P Ofle.( 1 at19 . r s nt' olowi r ei s t oures he fc DE 34 ) I t s m e vei s cl m s t t Sm ih, Ch it ns s c r nt and he f m e , s r s , n he a n, he ai ha t r s e on' ur e , r or r upe vi or ac c ompls d a fve y r ol t ea t ûge ba k' a her f ha ng once made a r e ihe i ea d hr t o i t c ' t or vi ac dic i nai co antbyalowi Chrse on t mai ai t sausquo sr s lvel (d.a srmi ton mpli l ng itns o nt n he tt te s e , l t 1 20 .Bohoft eal tonsaeft l va 9- ) t hes legai r aaly gue.Thes c i as e r l rmoei tme e ond s lo xtemey e t n i fo t prorpr e t d c r m he i ot c e onduc a woul t f i t e c us lt t t Fors ii conduc , t nd d hus al h a a iy es . pecfc t Ha getc t Chrse on' M ay 1 201 t e ,a t he a Gham oum ' vii wih M ilr t r t ies it ns s 7, 2 hr at fer r nd l s st t le , o 28 ( 6) Haretas rcyce t 201 pef manc r e whih wa a c 200 . g t lo e ls he 4 ror e eviw, c s ompo ofhe nent r dic i i ton t ores Bu aspr vi l dic s d,t r vi doe notc tt e a ma e i ly s rm na i he i , t e ousy s us e he e ew s onsiut t ral a r e a ton bec us Ha get ha no a qua el de onsr t t t a mor c plm e a y dve s c i a e r t s t de t y m taed ha e om i nt r r vi woul havee ild he t abonus e ew d ntte r o . Si e t a i t whih Ha ge tcies a e notm aera l a s FAU i e ild t nc he ctons o c r t t r t ily dvere, s ntte o s mmayj dg n o Hag t' r tl to c u t. u r u me t n r ets eai in o ns a D. Hos ie Wor Envr tl k ionme nt Ha getsRe po e i it t tFAU if l t addr s whehe t e denc s r t' s ns nss s ha kaied o es t r he vi e upporsa t h si ( r )e io me cam u d rb t ted srmi t a drtlain p o iinso te o tl wo k nvr n nt li n e oh h ici nai n eaito r vso f h e on ADA a Til Vl. ( 1 a 20) nd te I' DE 34 t .Sheciest pargrphsi t Ame d Compli t t ' t o a a n he nde ant ha pur tdl lnds hs pore y e uc uppor.(d.. t I4 The Fe r lRul ofCi lPr edur do notper tapli ifd o r ie new cai a t de a es vi oc e mi antf t a s t l ms t he s mmayj d me tsa e' Gimou v Gae , Do al ( Co,3 2 F.d l 1 1 1 ( 1h Ci. u r u g n tg . l r . ts Mc n d : . 8 3 3 2, 3 4 1 t r ' Q 200 . Pl di r r nt a elbealbutsiloblgaepli if t ditnguih t rcams 4) ea ng equieme s r i r tl i t antfs o si s hei li , snc d e nt a e notexpe t d t io i e a 1pos i e cai st tcoul a ie outoff c ss t i e ef nda s r c e o i nf r 1 t sbl l m ha d rs at e f rh i t c o t n he ompli , 1 a 1 ant' d. t 315. The El ve h Cic t ha hed,under cic sa s ' e nt r ui s l r um t nce vit ly i ntc t t e a is her t ta pl i ifc d notdi t ough f t la lga i rual de ial o hos t s ue e, ha antf oul g hr acua le tons s atrd tr u h u oh rc u t i ac mp an a d,a s mma yj d me t c n oiae te c tee h o g o t te o n s n o lit n t u r u g n , o s l t h m d i t a hosie wor e r e cai . Pal r v Al rs ' LLC,41 F,App' 885,88 90 no tl k nvionm nt l m me . be ton s 8 x 9- S ie't iu 'i t y c i dt vi aebra polci ,(d.a 1 .Butas iaywrt up i t' hem ip' f he ontnue o olt e k i es I t 9) wr oltr iei nota a r eempl s n dve s oyme ac i Dik v PhoneD iecor e Co. fl ,397 F. 1 nt ton, c , r t is , Fc. 3d 256,1 0 27 ( 0t Ci.2005) a her t r wasonl a unf fle t e tofone. l a spaae s ci 1h r , nd e he e y n ulild hra n e rt e ton rs e pondi t t pr t xti s Ha ge ti is t the s penson a t r prm a la ng ng o he e e s ue, r t mple ha r us i nd he e i nds e di upt i we eieait y.'( 1 a 1 .Butt t e en s no i e dst ma t epar o t r i tlaor ' DE 34 t 7) r o he xt t he w ntn o ke hes t ofhe r ala i cli ,s net ra qua e ybref d t s acsasr alai norr s d t m i r et iton a m he ihe de t l i e he e t et i ton aie he n t Ame d Com pli taspa tofhe r t la i c am s he nde an r r e a iton l i . 29 ( 1h Ci. 01 )( e c ra (iigt Da i v Co a- l Botig Co Co s l, 6F,d 9 5 1 t r 2 1 p r u im) ctn o vs . c coa tl n . n o. 51 3 5 , 9 4 ( 1h 2 0 ) a r gae o ohe g o n s b As c otv I b l 5 6 U. 6 2 ( 0 9 ) 7 1 t 0 8 , b o td n t r r u d y h rj . q a , 5 S. 6 2 0 ). Nowhe e i her Am e d Compl nt does Ha ge t g ve notc t t s wa a lgi a r n nde ai r t i i e ha he s le ng n i e nde ca e ofaci f a dic i i ton- e o r t it y hos ie wor e r nd pe nt us ton or s rm na i bas d r eala or tl k nvionme . nt The pa a r phs i t Amen rga n he ded Compl i t whih Ha get a l ant o c r t ludes m e el c ry- c r y he r pik isa c swh r s eusd t ea j ci l o tl't c a a trz a to sr ltdt tecamss e n tn e e e h e h de t i sie'o h r ceie cin eae o h li h ve h a t ly pe ( mp . ! 1 ,2 ,2 ,3 ,41 55 6 7 ,8 ) Ac o dn l t ee i n p o e cual ld. Co l ! 9 0 8 0 , , 9, 6 8 . c r igy, h r s o r p r hosiewo k e r e ca m be or t Co t tl r nvionm nt li f e he ur. l i he e O RDERED and ADJUDGED t t De e t s r by ha f ndan Fl i Ata i Uni r iy t orda lntc ve st Boa dofTr t s M oto f SummayJ r usee ' in or r udgment( 11 i GRANTED.Bys pa aeor r DE 3) s e r t de , s mmayj g n wil ee trdi fv ro FAU o al o n s u r ud me t lb n ee n a o f n l c u t. SO ORDERED i Chambe s a W es Pam Bea h,Fl i ,t s n r t t l c orda hi da ofNove r y mbe , 201 6. D LD M .M I DDLEBROOKS UN I TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE Copist e o: Couns lofRe or e c d 30