The Key West Tourist Development Association v. Zazzle, Inc., No. 4:2010cv10100 - Document 40 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: FINAL JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF PERMANENT INJUNCTION in favor of the plaintiff against the defendant. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 2/13/2012. (jw)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
The Key West Tourist Development Association v. Zazzle, Inc. Doc. 40 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA KEY W EST DI SI VI ON THE KEY W EST TOURI ST DEVELOPM ENT ASSOCI ON,a ATI Fl i c po aton, orda or r i Pli if antf, CASE NO. 1 1 00- V- KI : 0- 01 C1 NG VS. ZAZZLE,NC, Ca f r a I a l o ni co por i W I AM D.KW ZEY, R. r aton, LLI J a k a W iD . n e // l Kis y Def nda s. e nt / FI NAL JUDGM ENT AND ORDER O F PERM ANENT I NJUNCTI ON THI CAUSE c esbe or t c ton Pl itf M oton f Enty ofFi lJ S om f e he our an ifs i or r na udgme nt a dOr e o Pema n lj n to ( #3 ) fldFe r a y6 201 . n d r f r ne t n u ci n DE 9 ,ie b u r , 2 A. Bas d o t Cou ts Or rr lng i Pli ifsf voron t oner mai ng is of1w e n he r' de ui n a ntf a he e ni s ue a ( # )a dt siuae fcsf u di teJ itPr- ilS iu ai n ( # 3 , fn a ts DE 38 n he tp ltd a t o n n h on eTra tp lto DE 3 ) Dee d n ' An wes t Plitf l tro ao is ( # 7 1 ,a d t e a miso s f u d i Dee d n ' s r o anifs ner g t re DE 3 - ) n h d si n o n n fn a ts An we t Co lit( #2 ) t Co r fn steflo n fcs s r o mpan DE 2 ,he u t id h o lwig a t: 1 . Th Ke W e tTo rs De eo me t Aso ito ,I .( TDA) i a e y s u it v lp n s cai n nc KW s Fl rda c or ton ha ng isprnci lpl c ofbusnes at1111 1 h Ste t Suie 211 o i om a i vi t i pa a e i s 2t r e , t , Ke W es, orda 33040; y t Fl i , 2. De e d n , i im D. nz y J.( NS , o n No e r2 ,1 7 , fn a t W l a l Ki e , r KI EY) b r v mbe 5 9 3 i a r sde ofKey W es,Fl i an r i sa 71 Emm a Ste t#2,Ke W es,Fl i s e i nt t orda d esde t 4 re y t orda 33 0403282; 3. Attme mae ilDee ntKi e was doi busne s i Ke W e t l s tra fnda ns y ng i s n y s, Fl rdaa on t i e ne we ieknown a ww w.a zl c ; o i nd he nt r t bst s z z e.om 4. De e ntK i e us d a i e a tve webst t tofe ed goodsf s e f nda ns y e n nt r c i ie ha f r or al i Ke W es Fl i n y t orda; 1 Dockets.Justia.com i r oa o p 5. Pl n if i a non- of cor r ton t t has a prm a y g l t hel aitf s pr h po ai ha e onomi gr w t a de opme i Ke W es,Fl rda; c c o h nd vel nt n y t oi 6. Si a l s 1 Pl ntf ha c i usy pr o e a m akeed is nce t ea t 979 ai if s ontnuo l om t d nd r t t an l f tvals nic a cot ng t nua esi e es nd l hi mder t U. Regitr d ta m a k,FANTASY he S. se e r de r FEST; 7. FANTASY FEST i a c pe ai efo t t en Pli tf , heCiy ofK e s oo r tve f r be we a n if t t y W e t Fl i a prva ebusne s i Ke W e t Fl i s , orda nd i t i s es n y s , orda; 8. The FANTASY FEST f si atr t m a hundr ds of t a of e tval tacs ny e hous nds viior ea h ye t Ke W es, orda; st s c ar o y t Fl i 9. I or r t co n de o nduc t Fa t s Fes Fe tval Pli if has t r ie t he n a y t si , a ntf o as s fc e mone t c r t coss of pl nni a r ngi a c uf i nt y o ove he t a ng, ra ng, nd onduc i t a tng he nnua l wee l f si l k-ong e tva ; 1 0. Pli ifr le o m a l alvolmt r buta s hass antf ei s n ny oc t ee s lo ome pai sa ft t d t f ha doe s tntalwo k t yea r s ubsa i r he r ound pl nni t ne f si ; a ng he xt e tval 11. Pli if r s s money t c r t c t of t f tva by s li antf aie o ove he oss he esi l e lng s or hi a by s li goodswih T- hit bei t bi s s le ; pons s ps nd e lng t s rs ng he gge t e lr 1 2. ''e s e of T- hit a o he ie s c rbut t t f ndi of t I als h s rs nd t r t m onti e o he u ng he pr uci n ofFa a y Fes; od to nt s t 1 3. Fan a y Fes brngsi m ilonso dola st t busne s sa m e c n s ts t i n li f l r o he i s e nd r ha t i Ke W es a i a i pora c n y t nd s n m tnt ompone oft Ke W e te nt he y s conomy; 14. ta m a k; r de r Eac ye rFa as Fes c eaesa ne t me f r isf tva a gi i a h a nt y t r t w he o t esi l nd ves t Theta ma kf t 201 Fa t y Fe ti HABI r de r or he 0 n as s s TAT FOR I SANI N TY; 1 6. Pl i if ha a quied common 1 w tade k rght i is FANTA SY antf s c r a r mar i s n t FEST a HABI nd TAT FOR I NSAN I na e a m a ks TY m s nd r ; 1 7. Pli if r se e is FANTA SY FEST ma k wih t Unie Stt s a ntf egit r d t r t he td a e Pa e a Tr de a k Ofi e o J y 28,1 i I ena i lCl s41f c t nt nd a m r fc n ul 992 n nt r tona as or onduc i a tng f si ,a Pli tf wasi s d U. Se v c M a k Re sr to No.1, 811; e tval nd a n if s ue S. r i e r gitai n 703, 1 8. The r git r FANTA SY FEST m a k, Re sr ton N o. 1703, 1 e se ed r gita i , 81 , r mai i f 1 f r eand e f c a i vai t ough J y 28, 2; e ns n u1 o c fe t nd s ld hr ul 201 1 9. The r gitr FAN TASY FEST ma k,Reg sr ton N o. 1703, 1 ha e se ed r ita i , 81 , s be comei ont tbl nc esa e; 2 20. Pl i ifr se ed isFANTASY FEST tade k wih t Unie St t s antf egit r t r mar t he t d a e Pae a Tr ma k Ofi e on J y 1 1 tnt nd ade r fc ul 6, 999 i I e na i n nt r tonalCl s 25 f c ot ng, as or l hi nn ey, shit,a Pl i ifwa i s d U . Tr dema k Regita i No.2, 1 m l T- rs nd antf s s ue S. a r sr ton 272, 77; 21. The r git r d FAN TASY FEST ta m a k,Re sr ton No.2, 1 e se e r de r gita i 272, 77, r ma nsi f lf cea e f ta i vai t o h J y 1 201 e i n ul or nd fec nd s ld hr ug ul 6, 9; 22. The r se e FANTASY FEST m mk,Re sr i No.2, 1 ha egit r d gitaton 272,77, s be m ei o e tbl co nc nt sa e; 23. Pli tf r git e isFANTASY FEST tade k wih t Unie Stt s a n if e ser d t r mar t he td a e Pa e a Tr ema k Ofke on Sep e b 2,2003 i l e na i lCl s 1 f Prnt d t nt nd ad r f t m er n ntr tona as 6 or i e ma tr na ey pos e s a Pli if wa is te , m l t r , nd antf s s ued U . Tr m ak Re srton No. S. ade r gitai 2, 951 758, ; 24. The r git r d FANTASY FEST ta m a k,Re sr ton No.2, 951 e se e r de r gitai 758, , r m ansi f l f c and e f ta i va i t o Se e r2,201 e i n u l or e fec nd s ld hr ugh pt mbe 3; 25. The r git e FANTASY FEST ma k,Regita i No.2, 951 has e ser d r sr ton 758, , be om ei ont sa e c nc e t bl ; 26. FANTASY FEST i r git r d wih t sae ofFl i Reg sr to N o. s e se e t he tt orda, itai n 925, a ofJ n r 5,1 i c a s 35a 42; 823, s a ua y 982 n l s es nd 27. FANTASY FEST i r git e wih t sa e ofFlrda,Re sr ton No. s e ser d t he t t oi gita i $03000000 246,on Fe u r 26,2003 i cl s25 a Regita i No.T1 br a y n as nd sr ton 00000011 as 32 ofOc obe 26,201 f c o hi ts rsandhas; t r 0 or l t ng, -hit t 28. FANTASY FEST i r git r wih t sa e ofFl i ,Re sr to No. s e se ed t he tt orda gitai n T03000000247 on Fe ua y 26,2003 i cls 1 a Re sr ton No.T1 0000011 a , br r n a s 6 nd gita i 0 31 s ofOc o 26,201 f pose sa d prn e m at r t ber 0 or t r n i t d te ; 29. FANTASY FEST i r git e wih t sa e ofFl i Re sr ton No. s e ser d t he t t orda, gita i T03000000248,a ofFe ua y 26,2003 i Cl s 41; s br r n as 30. FANTASY FEST i r git r d wih t sa e ofFl i Reg sr to No. s e se e t he tt orda, itai n 703000000249,asofFe ua y26,2003 i cls 9; br r n as 31. The FAN TASY FEST m a k i af r s amousma k; r 3 2. Thit one ye r afe Pl i if sa td usng, a ye r a t Pli tf rya s tr antf trt i nd a s fer a n if r gitr d is FANTASY FEST m a k, De e e se e t r f ndan Ki e sa td s lng goods a t ns y t re eli nd a rii t rt na ef a a y e t'on t Zaz l web st dve tsng mde he m ç nt s f s' he ze f ie; 33. Se nt e yea s a tr Pl i ifr git r d is FANTASY FEST ma k,a ve e n r fe antf e se e t r nd t n mont afe Pl ntf bega usng is HABI e hs tr ai if n i t TAT FOR I NSANI ma k,De e nt TY r f nda Ki e be n ad tsng HABI ns y ga verii TAT FOR I NSANI a ff nt yf s' goods on t TY nd la as e t' he 3 Za zl we st usng a va ito of Pl ntf FANTA SY FEST a HABI z e b ie i rai n ai ifs nd TAT FOR I NSAN I m a ks TY r . 34. The font pa of t Ke W e t Cii n ne pa r publs d o r ge he y s tze ws pe ihe n No m be 1 2009 n ve r , nnounc HABI ed TAT FOR I NSANI a t Fa a y Fes t m e f TY s he nt s t he or 201 0; 35. Zaz l ope a esza zl c asa onlner t lpl tor de i d t e bl ze r t z e.om n i e ai a f m sgne o na e idvd as p o e so a a tss a d mao b a dst ce t a o f rpr d csb a ig n iiu l, r fs in l rit, n j r rn o r ae nd fe o u t e rn ta m a ks r de r ; 36. Zaz e ofe s a wi r zl f r de ange of bl n pr a k oducs, s h as ts rs mug , t uc -hit, s butons e c,t tus r c n c t ie; t , t . ha e s a usom z 37. Za zl pr t ca bepur ha e onlne a z z e. ; z e oduc s n c s d i t a zl com 38. W he a c ume s a c f r FANTASY FEST a HABI n ons r e r hes o nd TAT FOR I NSAN I on a i e e s a c e i lke t Googl s a c e ne,Zaz l swe ie TY n nt m t e r h ng ne i he e e r h ngi z e' bst i a t t oft ba r a ne t ori c os pr m iy t Pli if sFa a y Fes s t he op he nne ds xt o n l e oxi t o antf nt s t we ie; bst 39. Ki e ha us d Fa as Fe tsta m a ks i a rii is s r c and ns y s e nt y s ' r de r n dve tsng t e vies g oodst t publc; o he i 40. Ki e hasi ntte hi goodsa fofi i 'pr ns y de ii d s s ç fcal' oduc sofC t C HABI TAT FOR W SA N I ;' TY ' 41. Ki e ha us m a ks i ntc l a c usngl sm ia t Pl n ifs ns y s ed r de ia nd onf i y i l r o aitf ta m a ksi a rii hi s r i sa goodst t publc; r de r n dve tsng s e vce nd o he i 42. De e nt Ki e s goods ha be n ofer d i a m a r t die ty f nda ns y' ve e fe n nne o r c l a s a ehi goodswih t FANTASY FEST f tva ,i udi t us ofavmi ton of s ocit s t he esi l ncl ng he e ai Pli ifsma ksFANTASY FEST a i ntc lt HABI antf' r nd de i a o TAT FOR I NSANI TY; 43. De e ntKi e ha pr i nty dipl d am i vara ofPl i ifs f nda ns y s om ne l s aye nor int antf FANTASY FEST mar a HABI k nd TAT FOR I SANI m a k on t Zaz l we st N TY r he z e b ie wih t lke i t he i lhood t t Pli ifs c t ha antf usomer woul t nk t r i a as oc ai s d hi he e s n s i ton, c onne i n, s orhi wih Fant y Fe t cto or pons s p t as s; 44. De e f ndanta Pl i if smula nd antf i tneousy a rie pr l dve ts d oducs on we ie t bsts be i t wor HABI arng he ds TAT FOR W SANI on isme c ndie,i l ng ts rs a TY t r ha s nc udi -hit, nd i Oc obe 201 bot we iesa a e ne t ori cos pr m iy t e h o he on n t r 0, h bst ppe r d xt o, n l e oxi t o ac t r t i e ne ; he nt r t 45. De e f ndan Ki e ha us d a col a e i ia i of t r git r d t ns y s e or bl m t ton he e s e e FAN TA SY FEST na e a t H ABI T FOR W SAN I m a k on t Za l w e m nd he TA TY r he zz e b st ie; 4 46. De e ntss i a t ha t e f tofr pr en i t t publct o h f nda ' ad c s ve he fec e es tng o he i hr ug Za zl s we ie t hi goods we e r lt d a t s ce o i n,or s z e' bst hat s r ea e s o our , rgi pons s p wih orhi t Pl i ifsg nui FANTASY FEST a HABI antf e ne nd TAT FOR I NSANI f tva cot ng; TY esi l l hi 47. De e nt Ki e wihout a t i ton fom Pl ntf, ha us d f nda ns y, t u horzai r ai if s e desgna i t t a e i ntca t or s t i l i si s bl fom Fants Fes' i tons ha r de i l o, ubsantaly nditnguiha e r a y ts ta mar ; r de ks 48. Fa as Fes i a ann l e ntwhi t s pl e t l t tn da of nt y ts n ua ve ch nke ac he as e ys Oc obe , a i t mont of Oc o r 201 a a pa t o t r gitaton pr s , t r nd n he h t be , 0 nd s r f he e sr i oce s Ki e c e t us na S a a yf s' and c e nty co ns y hos he er me s nt s e t' f ons que l nduc e m mke i on t td tng he Zaz e we ie,whih i ntfe t s lrasç a a y es.' zl bst c de i d he ele t nt s f t' f 49. Pro t s i m a ke i of pr t t r i r o ad r tng oducs h ough Za e be rng t wor zzl a i he ds ç l bia f rI a t 'Ki eykne t tt e ntknown a Fa as Fes t pl c e c i a t t o ns niy,' ns l w ha he ve s nt y t ook a e a h a e r ye rt l s 1 da ofOct ra K i e kne t tt Fan as Fes t nd ve y a he a t 0 ys obe nd ns y w ha he t y t heme f 201 wasç-a t f l a t ' or 0 fl biat or ns niy. l ' B. TheCour f rhe fndst tDe e nts tup a ç a a y f s' sor on t Zaz l we st t u t r i ha f nda e f nt s e t' t e he z e b ie f i co tton wih Pl i if n mpeii t antf . The Cou tûndst t t rhi çf nt y f s' sor De e ntus d Pl i ifsM a ksa r ha , mde s ça as e t' t e, f nda e antf r nd ic n onne ton wih Pl n if sM a ksofe e f s l ci t aitf r f r d or a e: 1. ba ts rs by -hit; 2. ki sts rs d' -hit; 3. ldi sts rs; a e -hit 4. m e sts rs n' - hi t ; 5. pe s rs t hit; 6. bags ; 7. hoode s athit; d we s rs 8. has t; bumpe sike s r tc r ; 1 0. D. m ugs . The Co tfndst tDef nda di notha a lc ns t us Pli ifsM ar . ur i ha e nt d ve ny i e e o e antf ks 5 E. i nd nf ce bl r de r eg sr i , The Cour fnds t t Pli if owns vald a e or a e ta m a k r itatons ti ha antf ta mar , nd s r i m a ksf rFANTASY FEST a HABI r de ks a e vce r o nd TAT FOR I NSANI . TY F. The Co t fnds t t t f lowi Pl ntf s ta mar a s r i m a ks a ur i ha he o l ng ai if r de ks nd e vce r nd tad m a k r gita i a eva i a e or ea eand i rnge by Def nda : r e r e sr tons r ld nd nf c bl nfi d e nt U . Tr de ak Reg sr to N o. 1, 811, FAN TASY FEST i S. a m r itai n 703, n l t m a i lCl s41f c n e tona as or onduc i af si l tng e tva ; U. Tr de mk Regita i No. 2, 1 S. a m sr ton 272, 77, FANTASY FEST i n I e na i lCls 25 f cl hi nnme yts rs; nt r tona a s or ot ng, l -hit U . Tr de k Re sr ton N o. 2, 951, FAN TASY FEST i S. a mar gitai 758, n I t m a i Cl s 1 f prnt m a tr nn ey pose s n e tonal as 6 or i ed te , m l tr ; 4. Fl i Tr de a k Re sr ton No.T03000000246,FANTA SY FEST i orda a m r gita i n Cl s25; as 5. Fl i Tr dema k Regita i N o.103000000247,FANTASY FEST i orda a r sr ton n Cl s 1 a s 6; 6. Fl i Tr de ak Re sr ton N o.103000000248,FANTA SY FEST i orda a m r gita i n Cl s41 a as ; nd Fl i Tr dema k Reg sr ton N o.103 orda a r itai 000000249,FANTASY FEST i n Cl s 9. as G. The Cour fndst tDe e t i ha f ndan ha e ge i ta mar c e f ii oft t e U. t s nga d n r de k ount retng he hr e S. ta m mk r gita i ofPl n iff FANTASY FEST. r de e sr tons aitf or H. Th Co r fn st a De e d n ha o fr df rs l ee e ( 1 t p so c u tretg o s e u ti d h t fn a t s fe e o ae lv n 1 ) y e f o n ef i o d antf or a s r i s t t i rng t tlee U . ta m a k r gitai of Pli if f FANTASY nd e vce ha nfi e he ir S. r de r e sr tons FEST. 6 The Cour fnds t t De e nt wiluly, i entonaly, a fa e ty us t t i ha f nda lf l nt i l nd r udul n l ed he Pli tf' r gitr FANTASY FEST m mks knowi s h m a ks wer c e f tma ks as a n ifs e se ed , ng uc r e ount rei r , d fn d i 1 U. C.j 1 1 ,i c n e to wih te s l,o f rn f rs l,o d srb to o ei e n 5 S. 1 6 n o n cin t h ae fe ig o ae r itiuin f g oodsa s r ce by Defnda t nd e vi s e n. J . The Cour ûndst tDe e da twiluly,i t ntonal a fa e l pr de goods t ha f n n lf l n e i ly, nd r udulnty ovi d a s r i e ne e s r t t c nd e v c s c s a y o he omm ison ofavi ai s ii d i c e f tm a ks a de i d si ol ton pecfe n ount rei r , s fne i 1 U. C.j 111 wiht i e tt tt rcpintoft Deenda ' g n 5 S. 6, t he ntn ha he e i e he f nts oodso sr c woul r e vies d p t goodsors r i est us i c ut he e v c o e n ommitng t vi a i ti he olton. K. The Cour fnds t t De e nthas wilu l i e i l a fa e l i rnge t ha f nda lf ly, nt ntonaly nd r udul nty nfi d Pli tf f de a l r it r ta m aksand s r c m a ks a n ifs e r ly eg se ed r de r e vie r . The Co tfnds t t Def nda has wilul i en i ly,a fa enty i rng ur i ha e nt lf ly, nt tonal nd r udul l nfi ed Pl i ifsFl i r se ed ta m a ksa s r cema ksf rFANTASY FEST a HABI antf orda egit r r de r nd e vi r o nd TAT FOR I NSANI TY. M. antf omm o l w n a The Cour fnds t t Def nda has wilul i fi d Pli if s c t i ha e nt lf ly n rnge ta m a ksa s r i e ma ksf FANTASY FEST a HABI r de r nd e v c r or nd TAT FOR W SANI , TY N. The Cour fndst tDe enda ha us d a f s de i ton oforgi ors lc unde 1 t i ha f nt s e ale sgna i in otr e r 5 U. C. 1 2 S. j 1 5. The Cour fnds t tDe e n ha diut d Pl ntf f mous FAN TASY FEST m aks t i ha f nda t s l e ai ifs a r unde 1 U. C.j1125. r 5 S. P. The Cour snds t t De e ntha e t ha f nda s ngage i pam i of by usng t FANTASY d n l ng f i he FEST a HA BI T FO R I SAN I m a ks nd TA N TY r . Q. The Cour fnds t De enda ha diut d Pl i ifs f m ous FANTASY FEST m a ks ti hat f nt s l e antf' a r u d rF a S a. 4 .5 . n e l . tt j 951 1 7 R. The Cour fnds t t Pli ifs ma ks S t i ha antf r TANTASY FEST' a C ' nd C HABI TAT FOR I NSANI 'a ef mousa sr m aks TY' r a nd tong r . APPLI CABLE LAW S. 1 U. C. 1 1 ( )1( ()d fn saç o n efi mak' s 5 S. j 1 6 d ( )B)i eie t u tret r 'a : c ( c unefi o amakt a i r gsee o t ep i ia rg se i te A! o tret f r h t s e itrd n h rncp l e itr n h Unie Stt s Paent a Tr mmk Ofk: f s ch goods or s r i e td a e t nd ade f or u e vc s s d,ofe e f r s l orditi e a t ti i us whehe ornott ol f r d o a e, srbut d nd ha s n e, t r he pe s ag ns who r le i s ug kne s h ma k wass r se e r on ai t m ei f s o ht w uc r o egit r d. T. 1 U. C. 1 1 ()()p o ie teflo n rme isfrta e r c u tret : 5 S. j 1 7b -c r vd s h o lwig e de o rd mak o ne fing i ( )Trb ed ma e f ru eo c u tret r b e l n g s o s f o ne fimak I a s sig d ma e u e s b e to ()f ra y voain o s cin 1 1 ( )a o ti n se sn a g s nd r u s cin a o n ilto f e to 1 4 1() f h s tte or s ton 220506 of tte 36, i a ca e i vi us of a c e f i ma k or il eci il n s nvol ng e ount ret r d sg ain ( sd fn d i s cin 1 1 ( )o t i tt ) tec u ts al u ls t ec u t e in t a eie n e to 1 6 d f hs il , h o r h l, ne s h o r o e fn se tn ai gcru tn e , ne j dg n f rt ret ss c p osso d ma e , i d x e u tn ic msa c s e t r u me t o he i u h r tt r n g s me whihe r a c ve mounti g e t ,t t r wih a r s bl a t ney' f e,i t vi a i s r aer ogehe t ea ona e tor s e f he olton c it of onsss - () 1 itninal u igamako d sg ain, n wig s c mak o d sg ain i a ne to l sn y r r e in t k o n u h r r e i n to s o c u tretmak (sd tn d i s cin 11 6 d ofti t l) i c l cin wih o ne fi r a ei e n e to 1 ( ) h s i e , n ome to t t t s l o f rng f s l o diti i ofgoo ors r i es or he a e, fe i or ae, r srbuton ds e v c ; () 2 p o ii g g o o sr ie n c say t t ec mmiso o avolto s e iid r vd n o ds r e vc s e e sr o h o s in f i ain p cfe i p rg a h ( ) wiht eitn t a t er cpin o teg o so sr ie wo l n aa rp 1, t h ne t h t h e i e t f h o d r e vc s ud pu t g t he oodsors viest us i c er c o e n omm itng t vi a i n. ti he olto I s c a c s , h c u tma a r p eu g n itr s o s c n u ta a a nu l n u h a e t e o r y wad rj d me t nee t n u h mo n t n n a itrs rt e tbih dt e s ci n6 21a( )o tte2 , e i ngo ted t o te nee t ae sa ls e md r e to 6 ()2 f il 6 b gr mi n h ae f h s r ieo t ecama tsp e dng s tigf rht cam f rs c e ty o j d me ta d evc f h li n ' la i s et o t he li o u h nr f u g n n n en ng on t da e s e r i ma or f s h s tr tm e ast c tc i r di he t uch nty s de, or uc hore i he our onsde s a o it ppr prae. ()S au o yda g s o u eo c u tretmaks c ttt r ma e f r s f o n efi r I ac s iv vn t eus o ac u tretmak (sd fn d i s ci n 1 1 ()o t s n a e n olig h e f o nef i r a eie n e to 1 6d f hi t l)i c n e to wi t es l, feigf rs l, rdsrb to o g o o s r ie ,h i e n o n cin t h ae o frn o ae o itiu in f o ds r e vc s te t h pan ifma ee t a a y tme b fr fna j d me ti rnd rd b t etilc u q t litf y lc, t n i eo e i l u g n s e ee y h ra o r o rc v r i se d o a t a d ma e a d p o isu d r s b e to ()o ti s cin,a e o e , n ta f c u l n g s n r ft n e u s cin a f h s e t o n a r ofsa ut y damag f a s h us i c wa d tt or es or ny uc e n onne i wih t s l o f i f s l , cton t he a e, ferng or a e orditiuton ofgoodsors r c i t a oun of srb i e vies n he m t - () 1 n tls t a $ ,0 o mo et a $ 0 ,0 p rc nef imakp rt p o g o s o e s h n 10 0 r r h n 2 00 0 e ou tret r e y e f o d o sr ie s d o fr dfrsl, rd srb td a t c u t o sd r j s; r r e vc s ol, fee o ae o itiu e , s he o r c n ie s u t o 8 () 2 i t ec u tfn ta teus o t ec u tretmak wa wi f l n tmo et a f h o r ids h t h e f h o n e fi r s l u , o r h n l $ 000,00 pe c eretmak pe t ofgoodsors r ce s d,ofee f 2, 0 r ount fi r r ype evi s ol frd or s l, rd srb td, stec u t o ies u t' ae o iti ue a h o r c nsd r j s. ' FURTHER FI NGS NDI U. The Cour fnds t t De e ti ha f ndan has diut Pl ntf' f t l ed ai ifs amous and sr FANTA SY tong FEST f r land saer s e e ma ks ede a tt egit r d r . The Cour fnds t tDe e n has wiluly,i e i ly,a faudulnty i rnge t i ha f nda t lf l nt ntona l nd r e l nfi d Pli tf Fl i ta m a k r gita i a i e il t t f l ng r m e es of m a ks a n ifs orda r de r e sr tons nd s ntted o he olowi e di r u rFl St .j495.41: nde a. at 1 ()An o e o amak rgse e t e ti c pe ma r c e b s i t e j i t e 1 y wn r f r e itr d md r h s ha tr yp o e d y ut o non h mia i he e nd ny manuf cur ,us diply or s e of a c t reis or i t tons t r of a a a t e e, s a al ny oun e f t c u to c mpee t u idcinma g a tij n to t r sri s c mamfcu e o r f o tn j rs ito y r n nu cins o etan u h r a t r , us , ipa o s l a ma b b t es i c ur d e dj ta r ao a l, n ma e ds ly r ae s y e y h ad o t e me us nd e s n be a d y r quie t def nda s t pa t s h owne a 1 pr ks de i d fom a / a 1 e r he e nt o y o uc r 1 ot rve r nd or 1 da ess f r by r as n ofs h wr ngf lma acur us diply ors ea t mag ufe ed e o uc o u nuf t e, e, s a al nd o pa t cossoft a ton;a s h c tm a as o de t ta s h c e f is y he t he ci nd uc our y lo r r ha ny uc ount ret ori t tonsi t pos es i o unde t c r ofa de e mia i n he s son r r he ontol ny f ndan i s h c s be t n uc a e de i r d t an ofk e of t c t or t t c lve e o t r he our, o he ompli nt t be desr d. l ana , o toye n as e sng pr ks t pl i if s l be r quie t pr s si ot he antf hal e r d o ove def nts s l onl enda ' aes y; def nda m us pr a1 ee e nt t ove 1 lment ofc to deduci c am e I as e sng da a s os r ton l i d. n s s i m ges t c u t ye tr ud me ta c r i t tecru t so tec s , o a y s m he o r ma n e j g n , c o dng o h ic msmwe f h a e f r n u a bovet n omtf he m t ound asa t lda c ua mage , e e ng 3 tme s h n ount I t s not xce di i s uc m . f he cour s lfnd t tt a t hal i ha he mounto t r c r ba ed o pr isi et ri de t f he e ove y s n oft s ihe na qua e o e c s iete c u t y i isds rto e trj g n f rs h s m a t ec u t r x e sv h o r ma n t icein ne ud me t o uc u s h o r s alfn t bej t a c r igt t ecrl tn e o tec s . c s m i ete o h l i d o us, c o dn o h icl a c s f h a e Su h u n i r f ms h t a he bovec r um sanc s l consiut c ic t es hal tt e ompe ai a notapenat ns ton nd ly. The Co tfndst tDe enda hasenga d i unf i co pe ii i vi ai n oft lws ur i ha f nt ge n ar m tton n ol to he a oft Stt ofFl i he ae orda. l i t r f e ORDERED ,ADJUDGED,a DECREED t t purua t t U. t s he e or nd ha s nt o he S. Tr de a k La a t c a m r ws nd he omm on a saut y l wsoft St t ofFl i ,De e ntW ila nd t t or a he a e orda f nda lim D .Ki e J .a k a W i D .Ki e hi ofi e s ag t ,e oye ,a t ne ,s ce s s s l ns y, r / / 1 ns y, s fc r , en s mpl es tor ys uc s or , aes r es t tve ,ag s c c pia or a a sgns a a 1ot r i prviy ora tng i c e t epr en a i s ent , o- ons r t s nd s i , nd l he s n i t ci n onc r o a tv p riiainwi Kisy, r p r n n l e j n dfo r ci e atcp to t n e ae e ma e ty noie r m: h 9 I rngi t Pli tf s f l ng ta nn e a ma ks r f red t he en a nfi ng he a n if olowi r de m s nd r e e r o r i s ç a ntf M a kse t i ifs r .' pl ' ()U. Trd makRe itainNo. ,0 8 1 a S. a e r gsrto 17 3,1 ; ()U. Trd makRe itainNo. 2 2,7 b S. a e r gsrto 2,7 1 7; ()U. Tr d mak Re itainNo. ,5 ,51 c S. a e r gsrto 27 89 ; ( )Fo iaTrd makRe itainNo. 2 8 3 d lrd a e r gsrto 9 5,2 ; ()Flrd Tr d makRe itai nNo. 3 0 0 0 4 ; e o i a a e r gsrto T0 0 0 0 2 6 ( Flrd Tr d makRe itainNo. 3 0 0 0 4 ; 9 o ia a e r gsrto 10 0 0 0 2 7 ()Fl i Tr de kRe itai No. g orda a mar gsrton 103000000248; ()Flrd Tr d ma kRe itainNo. 3 0 0 0 4 ; h o ia a e r gsrto 10 0 0 0 2 9 ()F i ANTASY F EST; ()HABI FOR I ANI TAT NS TY. Count f ii t FAN TASY FEST f de a a sa er se ed ma ks eretng he e r l nd tt egit r r . Die ty ori r c l m a ac rng,diti i a rii m a ke i ors li Def nda ' rcl ndie ty nuf m i srbutng, dve tsng, r tng, elng e nts goods a s vc i a f hi whi h woul sa e i y,or s nd er ies n ny as on c d t t , mpl ugge tt t s h pr t s ha uc oduc s org nae fom Pl ntf orar as ocatd wih or c ii t r ai if e s ie t ome fo t s m e s ce ast Pl i ips r m he a our he antf M aks r ; 3. I i or e i ot r t die ty o i r c l ma a t e diti e, nduc ng nablng he s o r c l r ndie ty nuf c ur , srbut a rie mmke,or s l one orm o e i rngi goo a s rvce unde Pl i ips M a ks o dve ts , t el r nfi ng ds nd e i s r antf r r a c u i y sm ia ma k t Pl i ifsM a ks ny onf sngl i lr r o antf r ; 4. M a ng ori i ot st make a f le,m iladi orde p i sae e ki nducng her o ny a s se ng, ce tve t tm nt off c , r pr e a i of f c ,i c a t or e es nt ton a t n onne ton w ih t pr oton,a r i e ent di pl y,s l , ci t he om i dve ts m , s a a e ofe i f s e,manuf cur ,pr uci cic ai orditi i ofo o m or i rngi f rng or al a t e od ton, r ul ton, srbuton ne r e nfi ng s r c o goods i s h f s on as t s e vies r n uc a hi o ugges t t s t ha uch i rngi s vce or goods i nfi ng er i s s c onne t d wih o a s it d wih ors o e b Pli tf ort the i a a horze r eleror c e t r s oca e t pons r d y a n if ha s n ut i d es l diti orofPli tf sgoodsors r c s srbut a n if e vie ; 5. Die ty ori r ty s lng orofe i f s l ts rs o mugs orot rgoods rcl ndiecl eli f rng or ae - hit r he be rng Pl n ifs M a ks na ey CFANTASY FEST' a G ai aitf' r m l S ' nd E HABI TAT FOR I NSANI 'on TY' we ie or t o h ot r busnes es unls t y a e a t i d de e s or diti or of bst s hr ug he i s e s he r u horze alr srbut s Pl ntf goods ai ifs ; 6. Die ty ori r c l f s y desg tng t orgi oft De e ntsgoods a rcl ndie ty alel i nai he i n he f nda ' nd s r i sbyusng f smiesoft Pli ipsM a ks e vce i ac i l he antf r ; I ucng ot r t die ty or i r c l f s y desg t t orgi of t nd i he s o r c l ndie ty alel i nae he i n he Defnda tsg e n ' oodsa s r i e by usng f csm iesoft Pli ifsM a ks nd e v c s i a i l he antf r ; 8. M a ng ori i ot r t m a a f s m iladi orde ptve sae e ki nducng he s o ke ny ale, se ng, ce i t tm nt off c ,o r pr e a i off c ,i c ne ton wih t pr a t r e es nt ton a t n on c i t he omoton,ad rie t diply,s l i ve ts men , s a ae, ofe i f r s e,manuf cur pr ton,cr a i orditi i oft De e f rng o al a t e, oduc i iculton, srbuton he f ndants goods ' a s r i s as t t orgn o s c of t Def nda ' goods a s r i s as t c us nd e vce o he i i r our e he e nts nd e vces o o a e c um e st bele t tPl ntf ge neFANTASY FEST a HABI ons r o ive ha ai ifs nui nd TAT FOR I NSANI TY g oodsa s r i e a t De e ntsg nd e v c s nd he f nda ' oodsa s r c c efom t s nd e vies om r he ame o i n ors c rgi our e, o t tPl itf s or ora ovest Def nda ' g r ha an if pons s ppr he e nts oodsa s r i e ort tPl ntf a t nd e v c s, ha ai if nd he Defnda ta es how afii t c e n r ome flaed, onne t d,oras oc aed wih onea he by usng f csm ie ce s it t not r i a i ls oft Pli ifsM a ks a he antf r ; nd Diutng t ditnc i qualt o Pl i ifsFANTASY FEST mar . l i he si tve iy f antf ks I i f rh r ORDERED t tt e Co r s alr sr e j rs cin u n a p o rae t s u te ha h u t h l e e v u idito , po p r p it moton,f t dee m i ton ofdama ,c t,a a t e 'f s a s l ha c i ng i or he tr na i ges os s nd tom ys ee , nd ha l ve ontnui j rs ito f rtee f r e n o teFn l u g n . u idcin o h n oc me t f h ia J d me t DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r ,a M i mi M i miDa Count , Fl i ,t s n mbe s t a , a - de y orda hi 1 h da ofFe u r 201 3t y br a y 2. A . H N OM BLE J M ES LA W REN CE K I G A N I TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE c Al Cot e ofRec d c: 1 ms l or
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
