Magielski v. Mascara et al, No. 2:2011cv14235 - Document 25 (S.D. Fla. 2012)
Court Description: ORDER GRANTING 24 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. CASE CLOSED. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 1/27/2012. (rg1)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Magielski v. Mascara et al Doc. 25 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA Cas No. 11- v- 4235- M e 2; c 1 KM KENNETH W I LSON M AGI ELSKI , Pli if antf, VS. SHERI OF ST.LUCI COUNTY, FF E KEN J. ASCARA,aPoltca Subdi son M ii l vii oft Stt ofFl i RI he ae orda; GOBERTO I GLESI S, A i viual a CLI ndi d ly; nd NTON W I AM S, LLI i viual ndi d ly, Def nt. enda s / ORDER GM NTI DEFENDANTS'M OTI FO R SUM M ARY JUDG M ENT NG ON THI CAUSE c m e be or t Cour upon De e S a f e he t f ndant M oton f Summ a y J m e s' i or r udg nt e ( ) r vd s h t G ll ( No. 4 . Pli tf h sf i d t fl a Re p n e1 LocalRul 7 5d p o ie t a ç al ECF 2 ) anif m al o ie e so s. l . m ae ilf c s s tf t i t m ova ' saeme fl a s tra a t e orh n he nts t t nt ied nd uppored a r uie t s eq r d . . . wilbe l de d a te unl scon r re by t opposng pa t ssa e e ,pr de t tt Cour eme dmitd es tove td he i ry' t t m nt ovi d ha he t fndst tt m o ntssa e nti s i ha he va ' t t me s uppore by evi ncei t r or .' M i ulofLoc lRul td de n he ec d ' ndf a e 7.( ) a d u o c n i eain o Dee d n s M o in tepet n p rin o t er c r ,a d 5 d , n p n o sd rto f fn a t' to , h ri t o t s f h e o d n ne o be ngot r s f l a s d i t pr m ie , hi Cour e e st f l ng Or r i he wie uly dvie n he e s s t s t ntr he olowi de . 1. BACKGROUND 2 On Aprl30,2007,Pli if Ke t W is M agilki a of- ut polce ofs e , w as i a ntf nneh lon e s , n fd y i tc r wa c ng a St Luce M e smi l ue ba e l ga e a Di t lDom ai St di i Por Sant t hi . i t nor eag s bal m t gia n a um n t i 1 Plitf fie t fl aRe p ns t De e d n s M o in t Dimis( No 11,1 and an if ald o ie s o e o fn a t' to s o s s ECF s 2) 2 fn a t' to f raM o eDei t S ae n ( No. 0 . Dee d ns Mo in o r fni ttme t ECF 2 ) e n e fcsh r i a e tk n fo Plitf S c n Ame e Co an ( No 1 )a d a t e en r a e r m an ifs e o d nd d mplit ECF . 9 n Dee d ns M o in frSl r J d me t( No. 4 . A1 fcsae c nsr e i te l h fn a t' to o l mmay u g n ECF 2 ) 1 a t r o tu d n h i t g . mos f vor bl t Pli if t a a e o antf . Dockets.Justia.com Luct,Fl rda. W hitwa c ngt gn M a e s ha be n d i ng aco o ofac t t i oi l t hi he me, gi lki d e rnki l hol ut up ha he br ug t t ga e. At s e poi ,m a e e of t sad um r pore t Def nda o ht o he m om nt nag m nt he t i e td o e nt Ri obe t I esm ,a f l of- y polce ofi e who was wor ng a de a lf t St Luci g ro gl i s elow fdut i fc r ki t i or he . e M e s t t M a e s wa s r a i obs eniis I r pons t ma ge e ' compl nt t , ha gilki s c e m ng c te . n es e o na m nts ai , Ofk e I e i a a he of - y ofi ra oa he M a e s a a ke hi t l a t t r glsas nd not r fdut fce ppr c d gi lki nd s d m o e ve he sa um . M a es r a e y que to d t ofk er ast t r a on he was beng a ke t t di gi lki epe t dl si ne he t s o he e s i s d o l ve a us d obs ne lnguag whie tl ng wih t ofi r . M a e s fnaly l f t ea , nd e ce a e l a ki t he fce s gi lki i l e t he sa lm . Furhe c r t ton wih t ofke s e ued i t pa ki l , and M a elkiwa t dil t r onf on a i t he f r ns n he r ng ot gi s s s e nty a r t a c r d wih Dior ry I oxi a i ubs que l resed nd ha ge t s de l nt c ton. M a e s was ta pored t t St Luc e Count J l whe e he was pr e s d by gilki r ns t o he . i y ai, r oc s e Dee da tClno W iims ac re to so tc r Up n b ig tl b W ila t e traj i fn n i tn ln , o r ci n fi e . o en o d y lims o ne al l c l M a elki us d pr a lngu el, gi s e of ne a age a t e hi wor boot t t gr nd hr w s k s o he ound i t cel n he l. W ila st n r tanedM ag e s t mai an or ra s c hy wihi St Luci Co y J i. lim he esr i i lki o nt i de nd e ur t n . e unt al On Aug s 2 , 01 , a ilk fldh sFis Ame d dCo lit( No. 0 a ans u t 5 2 1 M ges i ie i rt n e mpan ECF 1 ) g i t De e nt I e i and W iln s a De e ntSherf Ke J. M a c a a Poltca Subdi son f nda s glsms li m , nd f nda if n s ar , ii l vii o t Sae o F o ia Afe te Co litwa d s s e wi o tp eu iept s a tt ti f he tt f l rd . tr h mp an s imis d t u rj dc l u n o h s h r Co r' Or es( No .1 ,1 ) Ma ilk fldaSe o dAme d d Co an ( No.1 ) u t d r ECF s 6 7 , ges i ie s cn n e mplit ECF 9. 0n De embe 29,2011De e t fl d aM o i f Slm ma yJ m e . c r f ndan s ie ton or l r udg nt I I. LEGAL STANDARD Sl r j dg n ma b e tr do l wh r t r i n g n itis eo maeil a t l mmay u me t y e n ee ny e e hee s o e un su f tra fc . Tw i s v. Kur , 25 F. 1 , 1 5 ( 1h Ci.1 9 ) Th mo n p ry h st e b r e o s y 3d 551 5 4 1 t r 9 4 . e vig a t a h u d n f m e tng t s e c i sa r Adike v.S. Krs & Co. 398 U. 1 1 ( 970) e i hi xa tng tnda d. c s H. e s , S. 44, 57 1 . M or ove ,t pa t m us s e r ç ry A t uppo tisas e ton t tt r i no ge ne is ofma e i lf c b r t s ri ha he e s nui s ue t ra a t y t tng t pa tc a pa t of m ae i l i t r cor i udi de ii , doc nt , cii o ri ulr rs t ras n he e d, ncl ng postons ume s eecr cal sor d i or ton, afda t or deca a i , si a i . l toni ly t e nf mai fi vis lr tons tpultons . , a isons dm s i , i e r a o y a we s o ot rm a e i s''Ric v v.S. l rOpe a i Co., No.1 11 nt rog t r ns r , r he t ral.' the Nucea r tnc 0- 962, 2 1W L 1 9 3 8 a # ( 1h Ci. r 2 , 01 )( u tn Fe . Ci P.5 () 1) An is 01 4 0 5 , t 1 1 t r Ap . 0 2 1 q o ig d R. v. 6 c (). sue of f c i d t ra' i i i a lgalelm e of t cli unde t a i a e s t ntve lw a t s % e il' f t s e ma e nt he a m r he pplc bl ubsa i a whih mi afe tt out om eoft c e. Ale v.Tys Foods I ,1 F.3d 6 6 ( 1 c ght f c he c he as ln on . nc. 21 42, 46 1 1 Ci.1 9 ) Anis eoffc i ç e uie'ft er c r tk na awh l c ul la arto a tir r 9 7 . su a t s t n n 'i h e o d a e s o e o d e d ain l re g offc t fndf t nonmovi pa t J . a t o i or he ng ry. #z I a yi t s sn r t ditit co tmus viw t evi e a a l f t a n ppl ng hi t nda d, he src ur t e he denc nd l ac u l i ernc t er i t lghtmos fvorbl t t pat opposngt moton.J çlhemee nf e es herfom n he i t a a e o he ry i he i #= t' ' r e itn eo as itl o e i e c i s p r o t ( o mo a ts p iin wilb i u t e t xse c f cnil f v d n e n u po t f he n n v n 'l osto l e ns fkin ; a t eemu tb e d n eo whc tej r c u dra o a yfndf rt (o mo a t. An e s n h r s e vie c n ih h u y o l e s n bl i o he n n v n l' d ro ' v. b ryLo b I .4 7U. 2 2, 2( 9 6 . Liet b y.nc, 7 S. 4 25 1 8 ) 11 1. A NA LY SI S M a elkis Sec gi s ' ond Am e nded Compl nt alege f le are t and f le i ionmen ai l s a s r s a s mprs t t t I;û o ain o Co si in lm g t b a I dv d a' ( l t 1-11;ç gie t comt ) ' lto f n tmto a Vi hs y n n ii u l Col s 1 1) ç l n ' n Ne g Hiig a d S p r iin o Dee a tDe u y W i ims b De e d n S e if't un l ; rn n u e vso f fnd n p t l a l y fn a t h rf co t V) ç gie t Su r iin a ans S .Lu i Co t S eif Ke J M a c r' t u tV) a d ç lg n pevso g i t t ce uny h rf n . s aa' co n ; n Ne t i t She f bec us i has a Polc a Cuso ofEnc a ng,Tol r tng,Pe m itng, ç ns Aga ni f a e t i y nd tm our gi eai r ti a Raiyi a Pa tr ofI o r Co nd tf ng te n mpr pe nduc of is Ofk e' Empl es of W hi h i Kne or t t t s oye c t w S o l Ha eKn wn'Co n VI.Th sCo r tk su a a ay i o e c Co n i tr h u d v o '( u t ) i u ta e p n n lss f a h u t n un. As CountI Co mt I of M a elkis Se ond Am e t gi s ' c nded Com pl nt saes t t C ai t t ha TLAI FF s NTI ues She rf of St Luce Count f f s a r s a f f le i i o nt' Pl' Se ond Am . r if . i y or ale re t nd or a s mprs nme .' .s c Co l,a 4 ( No 1 ) As te Co liti c nf sngy d a td,i i t la wh te mp . t ECF . 9 . h mp an s o u i l r fe t s mce r eh r 3 M a es ' cli f rf s a r tand f s i ionme i m a pur ua t 42 U .S. j 1 8 gi lkis am o ale res ale mprs nt s de s nt o C. 9 3 o sae lw. To s c e d o a j1 8 cam f r fle a rs,t e plitf h s te b r e of r tt a uce n 9 3 li o as re t h an if a h u d n pr ng t tt e wm no pr bl c us f t a r s . See Rn n v.Eva ,1 F.d 1 ovi ha her s oba e a e or he re t nki ns 33 3 425, 1 3 ( 1h Ci., et d n e ,5 5 U..8 (9 ) Th e se c o pr b b ec u e h we e , 4 6 1 t r) c r. e id 2 S 23 1 98 . e xitn e f o a l a s , o v r o r t a a a fr a i def et ac am off s a r tt rFl i s ae lw . Ja Pr bl pe aes s n fim tve ens o l i ale res mde orda t t a #. oba e c u ee sswh n çç e fcsa d cru tn e wi i teo c rsk o e ge o whc h o a s xit e çh a t n ic mss c s t n h y e ' n wld , f ih e r t h s hasr a ona y tusworhy i or ton,woul c us a pr ntperon t be ive, t rt he e s bl r t t nf ma i d a e ude s o le mde he cr um sa es s ic t nc hown,t tt s pec ha c ha he us t s omm itd,i c mitng, ori aboutt c te s om ti s o omm i a t n o fns .' I .a 1 5 ( u tn W i ims n v.Mil,6 F.d 1 5 1 8 ( 1h Ci.9 5 ) fe e' d t 43 q o ig l n o ' l ls 5 3 5 , 5 1 t r1 9 ) he s n s e (mp ai a d d . çW hen t fact are not i diput , wh t r p o a e c u e e se i a e h ss d e )3 G ehe r b bl a s xitd s q e to o lw,a d s mmayj dg n i a p o rae' Ma x v. mbi r 9 5 F.d 1 0 , u sin f a n u r u me t s p r p it. ' r Gu r , 0 2 5 3 me 1 0 ( 1hCi. 9 0 . 5 7 1t r19 ) Hee Mages was ar td fr diodel i o cai Fl i Stmt j856. r, ilki rese o s r ry ntxi ton. orda a es 011 govt nst c i ofdior l i oxi to a pr dest t r he rme s dery nt cai n, nd ovi ha : ( )Nop ro i t sae s al itxiae a d e d ng rt es ft o a oh r 1 e s n n he tt h l be no c td n n a e h aey f n te pe s orpr pe t a no pe s i t sa e s lbe i oxia e ordrnk any r on o ry, nd r on n he t t hal nt c t d i acoholc be r e i a publc pl c or i or u l i ve ag n i ae n pon a publc c ny i onve nc a ya e nd ca eapublcdit ba e. us i sur nc J I i t onto red fc t t M a elki wa co umi lr e qua ttes of ac #= t s mc r vet a t ha gi s s ns ng a g nii lohol i e a ey pro t hi a r t De s M ot f r Summ .J,Ex. 4 a 3 1 - 0 ( mm dit l i r o s res. f ' .o . , t , 9 2 ECF No 2 - ) . 44 . Ofi rI e is wa i or d by m a e e t tM a e s wa s r a i obs e tes4 and fce gl sa s nf me nag m nt ha gilki s c e m ng c nii , M agelkipr ee d t us pr a tes whe s ki wih Ofi e l e is. De s'M o . f is oc de o e of nii n pea ng t fc r gl sm f t or S mm.J,Ex.2 a 2 ( No. -) Ad iin l M a ilk E ce me 'p o a iisi t u . , t ECF 242 . dto al y, ges i t ra d' r fnte n he s 3 ç'he sanda d f deer ni whehe pr i r f r or t mi ng t r obabl c us e ss i t s e a e xit s he nme unde Fl rda a r o i nd f d rllw. Ra kn v Ev ns 1 3 F.d 1 2 ,1 5 ( 1h Ci.,c r.d ne ,5 U..8 3 e ea a ' n i . a , 3 3 4 5 43 1 t r) e t e id 25 S 2 ' ( 998 . 1 ) 4W he he M a elkiwa ac u ly s r a i obs eniispro t Ofi e l esa a rva i ofno t r gi s s t a l c e m ng c te i r o fc r gl is' r i l s r e ncet t i t ntanayss elva o he nsn l i. 4 p e e e of S n,wom e a c lr n' a tndi t game. L. I lg o t s fcs no r s nc ç me n, nd hid e ' te ng he ( n iht f he e a t, r tonaltiroff c co d fnd t tt ew a notpr bl c us t a r s M a elkipurua t ai re a t ul i ha her s oba e a e o re t gi s s nt o Flrd S aue j 8 6. 1 u ,sl r j d me ti a r e i fvo o De e d n sa t o ia ttts 5 01 .Th s l mma y u g n s wad d n a r f f n a t s o ComtlofM a e s ' Se ond Ame d Compl i . l gi lkis c nde ant p. . s Cot 1 mt 1 Cot 1 ofM a elkis Se ndAm e d Co pl nti tte Gvi a i ofConsiu i l mt 1 gi s ' co nde m ai s ild ç olton tt tona Ri sby a I vi . P1' Se ond Am .Compl a 6. The s t ght n ndi dual' .s c ' ubsmnce ofCol l,howe r mt I ve , ., t i i ntca t Count1 o Pl i ifs Am e d Co ai , whih wa dimisd wi prju c s de i l o 1 f antf nde mpl nt c s s se t e die h e nty he l i s red nd hi by t s Cour i an Or rdaed Ocobe 26,20115 Cons que l , t c am i ba r a t s hi tn de t t r . Cour wildevot no f rhertm et ana y ng t cai . t l e u t i o l zi he l m fa . CountII l Count II of M agilkis Se I es ' cond Amende Compli i tted ç olton of d a nt s il i a i vi Consiu i lRi ht by a l vi ua' a a tt tona g s n ndi d l' nd ppea st aler t be we a cai f f le a r t r o t na e t en l m or a s res a f s i pr s en pm s ntt 42 U . .C. 1983, ndacli f e e sveus of o c as nd ale m ionm t ua o S j a am or xc s i e f r e, lo ma epzs n t 4 U. C. 1 3 P1' S c n Am . mpl, t8 t e tn t a Co n II d l ua t o 2 S. j 98 . .s e o d r Co .a .To he x t t h t u t I alg sa j1 8 cam frf lea rs a f lei rs n n , t r j d me ti a r e i le e 9 3 li o as ret nd as mp io me t st y u g n s wad d n mma f vorofDef nt f t r as a tc atd i t sCour ' a l i ofCo 1 a enda s or he e ons ri ul e n hi ts nayss unt . As f M ag e s ' c am ofexc sve f c çGove n e a to i l ng t us of or i lkis l i es i or e, ç r m nt c i n, ncudi he e f r by prs gua ds w il o y vi ae s t ntve due pr s rg s unde t Fo t nt o ce ion r , l nl olt ubsa i oce s i ht r he uree h Ame e whe i i s e egi t ti s kst c c e e.' Coc el v. Spa ks 51 F. ndm nt n t s o gr ous ha t hoc he ons i nc ' kr l r , 0 3d 1307,1 ( 1h Ci.2007) Thi sa r l tmael t r o t t rf c wa a id i a 311 1 t r . s tndad t i t y uns n whehe ore s pple n ul good f ih efo tt ma nt n orr sor dicplne or m a ii l a s si aly f t ve y at f r o i ai et e s i i lcousy nd aditc l or he r 5See Or rGr ntng De e ntsM oton t Dimi sPli ifsAmende Compl i de a i f nda ' i o s s antf d ant , a 4( t ECF No 1 )( od n ta s v r in i mi b r i tn in lntito o e to a dite scams . 7 h li g h t o eeg mmt t as ne to a i lci n f mo in l srs li y a i tt saeofFl i o iss vii ) gans he tt orda r t ubdi sons. p r o e o c usng h r ''I ( u tng W hilv v.Al r,4 U. 31 ,3 0 21 ( 9 6 u p s f a i a m. d. q oi ' te bes 75 S. 2 2 - 1 8 :. Prs ofk i l a e t be a f ded a g e t de lof de e e e,a t es i a a s t tt ion t as r o for ra a f r nc nd G unl s t ppe r ha he e de ,viwe i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pli if wils vi nce e d n he i t a a e o he antf , l uppo ta r la e i e e e of r e ibl nf r nc wa o mes i t i lc i ofpan undert sa r we ha des rbe , t ca es d notgo nt r s n he nfiton i he t nda d ve c i d he s houl t t ej r . n ily 4 U. a 3 2 o h u y' te , 75 S. t 2 . ' Ht e,i i undiput t tM a elkiwa beng de aned f r dior ry i oxi ton a r ts s td ha gi s s i ti o s de l nt cai nd t a u nbengt l b W ila t e traji c l, a ilki e p o a eln a e a d trw h t po i od y lims o ne al el M g es us d r f n a gu g , n h e hi wo k boot t t gr md i t c l.De s M o .f Sum m . J,Ex.4,a 23. l i cea t t s r s o he ot n he e l f ' t or . t t s l r ha W iln s us off c wa nota bir r m a ii us or s ditc,a wa e oye Gi or rt lim ' e or e s r ta y, lc o , a si nd s mpl d tn de o g i c nr l' De s M o .frSl an o to . f ' t o l J,Ex. a 2 ( No. 4 3 . n us t t ee tn ta ' mm. . 3, t ECF 2 -) , o h xe t h t Co n IIalg sa j 1 3 cam f re c sie u e o f re s mmayj d me ti a r e i utI l e e 98 li o x e sv s f o c , u r u g n s wad d n f vorofDe e nt . a f nda s Da Comt I t s V-V Co t I un s V-V ofM agilkisSe ond Ame d Co pl nta e f rt es ' c nde m ai r o G i ntSupe v so Neglge r ii n a d Hiig't u tl a d t gie tS p r iin't u tV) Th Re o d r v asta al n rn ' co n V) n ç lg n u e vso ' co n . e c r e e l h t l Ne ofk e se oyed by t St Luc eCot y She rf Ofk e a e s n c rii d 1w e or e e t r mpl he . i mt r ifs t r wor e tfe a nf c m nt ofi e si ac or ncewih a i a eFl i lw,a t ta1 ofi e sr ei i s vieta ni fc r n c da t pplc bl orda a nd ha l fc r ec ve n-er c r i ng e e yy a i e c s o sauo yr q ie n s De s Mo . o Sl J, . , t1 3 ( No. v r e r n x e s f tt tr e urme t. f' t f r l mm. .Ex 5 a - ECF 2 - ) Al o fc r aetane i t en e f xp o a e c u et ef cuae alwf lars. J. 4 5 . l f es r r i d n h e d o r b bl a s o fe t t a u re t /S . . A1 ofie sa e a s tai d t tt y t r o y a horze t us t tnmountoff ce whih i l fc r r lo r ne ha he t e nl ut i d o e ha a or c s r a o e a ne es a y under t c r lm s a s a a e ot w i e not a hor z d t us e s nabl nd c s r he ic l t nce nd r her s ut i e o e e es i orunne e s r f ce' l a 2. M a e s doe notdiput t e f c s M or ove , he xc sve c s a y or .' d. t gi lki s s e hes a t . e rt onl ba i f M ag e s ' cli sf ne i nthii a s pe v so a e r ed i hi cl msf y ss or i lkis am or glge rng nd u r ii n r oot n s ai or u lwf la rs a e e sv u e o f re f rwhih s mmayj g n h sbe n g a td i n a u re t nd xc s ie s f o c , o c u r ud me t a e rne n 6 f vorofDe e nt. Cons quen l , no r tona tiroff c coul fnd f M a elkion Co s a f nda s e ty a i l re at d i or gi s unt I V a ds mmayj d me t sa r e i fv ro De e d n s V- n u r u g n i wad d n a o f f n a t. L CountVI Co VIofM agilkisSe ond Am e d Compl i i tted t gai tShe rf Bec us unt es ' c nde ant s il W ns r if a e l Ha a Polc a Cusom ofEnc ag ng, Tolr tng,Pe mitng a Ra iyi a Pa tr of t s iy nd t om i eai r ti nd tf ng te n l ope Conduc ofisOfi sEm pl sofW hih l Kne orShoul Have Knowm' Pl' mpr r t t fce' oyee c t w d ' .s Se ond Am .Co pl,a 1 l i welesa ihe t ta mt ci lt c nno behel la eunder c m . t 2. t s l tbls d ha mi pa iy a t d ibl 4 U. C.j1 3 o ar s o d a s p ro t e r . Se M o l v. p' o So . r , 6U. 2 S. 98 n e p n e t u e ir h o y e nel De t f c Sev.43 S. 6 8( 9 8 ; o v S t 81 F.d 1 8 ( 1h Ci.1 8 ) t cp l isc n ho v r b 5 1 7 ) Br wn . mi h, 3 2 1 7 1 t r 9 7 .M miiai e a , we e, e t hedla e unde j1 whee çhe a ton t ti alge t beunc ttto li eme so l ibl r 983 r ç ci ha s le d o t onsiuina mpl nt r exe ut s a polcy sa e t or na e, r gulton, o de ii of i l a t d a c e i t t men , di nc e a i r c son fcaly dop e nd pr omulatd by t tbod sofi e s'M one l 436 U .S.a 690. g e ha y' fc r .' l, t The onl s y uppor f M ag es ' c am i a sa e e a l dl m a by Ofi r t or i lkis l i s t t m nt lege y de tce W ila s Ac r ng t M a elki Ofk e W iln s t unt hi by sa i t t t r was a lim . co di o gi s , t r lim a ed m t tng ha he e p lc t a ç o sn talw s u a sEi)t g ta y wi a yhighee' P1' Se o Am. oiy h t E e o lo k mb g sc o e wa t n t n r . .s c nd d h ' Compl,a 1 M a elkisc am f l f s ve alr ms . Fis,t çmde l ng a ton t ti . t 3. gi s ' l i ais or e r e ons rt he t ryi c i ha s t al ge t be unc tt i l' ar a be n de e m i d t be c tt i . See supr PM le d o ons iutona 'has le dy e t r ne o onsiutonal a IIA- . Se I. C cond,W ila s al ge sae e a m os a fr a z r t er nc polc r ltng t lim ' le d t tm nt t t fims e o-ol a e iy ea i o nze br a ngby i t . So l a t unde l ng r esar consiu i l s t ngt thm l - e ki nma es ong s he ryi ul e tt tona- ome hi ha s not be n dipu e t r i not ng unc tmtona a e s t d- he e s hi ons i i l bout a polcy t t r quie Ofke s t i ha e r s f r o e or e t r e a al tme . Thus bec us t e senc of a m e e s i il of e denc i nf c he uls t l i s , a e he xit e r cntla vi e n s ppor ofa cai i i ufk i ntf t tcl m t pr ee t ti l s mmayj d me t sa r e u t l m s ns t e or ha ai o oc d o ra, u r u g n i wad d i f vo ofD e e n s n a r f nda t . I V. CONCLUSI ON Fort f r goi r s ns i i he o e ng ea o ,t s ORDERED AND ADJ UDGED t tDe e d n s M oin f rS mma y J d me t( ha fn a t' to o u r u g n ECF No 2 )i GRANTED.I i frh r .4 s t s u te ORDERED AND ADJ UDGED t t Pl ntT s Se ond Amende Com pl nt i ha ai i c d ai s DI I SM SSED W I PREJ CE.TheCl r oft Cour i i tuced t CLOSE t sc s . A1 TH UDI e k he t s nsr t o hi m e 1 pe ngm otonsa eDEN I A S M OOT. ndi i r ED DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe sa M i mi Fl i t ' n r t a , orda, ay ofJ nua y, 201 a r 2. MI EL OORE UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE . c c: A1 c ms lofr or 1 ov e ec d 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
